Western Standard - February 15, 2024


The Pipeline: Guilbeault says no more roads

Topics
Mentioned
The Winter Games bolster local economies in rural Alberta DEI is destroying ideology

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

164.47

Word count

7,735

Sentence count

554

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The usual suspects are back to discuss a variety of news items. Federal Environment Minister Stephen Gilbo says no more roads should be built in Alberta, cities should encourage people to walk more, and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says Canadians do not want Canada to be great again.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day, I'm Derek Fulibrand, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:28 Today is February 14th. Gentlemen, if you haven't already, order your flowers for your lady, because it's Valentine's Day.
00:00:35 If you're already watching this, you're actually probably already up Schitt's Creek at this point.
00:00:40 I'm joined, as usual, by Western Standard Opinion Editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:44 I remembered.
00:00:47 You would. From everything I can tell, Judy is very happy with you.
00:00:53 At least she appears so when she's around here.
00:00:54 She certainly knows the right thing to say.
00:00:57 And so do I.
00:00:59 A man a little less studied, but I think does a decent job.
00:01:04 I like to think so.
00:01:06 And as Dave said, I'll probably hit the 7-Eleven on the way home to grab a chocolate rose or something.
00:01:10 That's normally what I do.
00:01:11 This year, I actually ordered flowers for one of our reporters years ago when a family member passed away.
00:01:20 And that good deed came back to help me, because I got a text from the flower company yesterday.
00:01:27 And I was like, oh, geez.
00:01:29 So hopefully my wife is not watching. 0.97
00:01:31 She just thinks I just did this remembering.
00:01:34 Spontaneous.
00:01:34 I don't remember these things.
00:01:36 I'm not very good.
00:01:36 All right.
00:01:38 Well, we've got really interesting topics today, good headlines.
00:01:42 Federal Environment Minister Stephen Gilbo says, no more roads.
00:01:47 Cities should stop building roads to encourage people to walk more.
00:01:50 Get out of your car and walk from Calgary to Edmonton, because that's good for the environment.
00:01:56 You didn't say that exactly, but more or less saying that the federal government should stop using the gas tax fund to transfer money to municipalities for roads.
00:02:07 And instead, just use it on bike paths and sidewalks, that kind of thing.
00:02:11 The Auditor General's report into the arrived scam app is out. How could the budget balloon from about $80,000 to what it turned out to be? $57 million approximately?
00:02:27 approximately. 59 and change I think the last count. Yeah that's a that's a little over budget.
00:02:33 How did costs given to this liberal aligned firm manage to explode by, I can't even do the math in
00:02:43 my head, how many times is that? The leader of the opposition said it was 750%. I checked his
00:02:50 math, it was actually 746. I think that's more than that. 80,000 to 59.5. We're gonna have to
00:02:59 do the math on that because it's just so many times over I'm having a hard time. Have the operations
00:03:04 manager check it out. Yeah. Justin Trudeau says that Pierre Polyev wants to make Canada great
00:03:11 again and Canadians do not want Canada to be great again. A very interesting and bizarre exchange in
00:03:17 in the House of Commons. I mean, it's one thing
00:03:19 to go after MAGA. You know, liberals
00:03:21 don't like the MAGA thing, and
00:03:23 you know, it's fine. I guess
00:03:25 fair game to go there, but saying
00:03:27 Canadians do not want 0.97
00:03:29 Canada to be great again.
00:03:32 It's an interesting
00:03:33 line of attack. One thing's for sure,
00:03:36 the war room in the Conservative Party
00:03:37 has already got that clipped out, and it's working
00:03:39 on the ad. Oh, it's already done. I'm sure they've
00:03:41 already got five versions of that ad
00:03:43 done. And
00:03:45 And, well, Ed Pierpoliyev says he's going to kill the media subsidies.
00:03:49 We'll see if we have time to get that far.
00:03:51 Before we get into it, Corey, why don't you tell people about my favorite sponsor?
00:03:55 I'm guessing that must be the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:03:57 It must be.
00:03:58 Yes, with Tony Bernardo.
00:04:00 Those guys do a fantastic job.
00:04:01 If you own firearms, plan to own firearms, you're a hunter, you're a target shooter, you're a collector,
00:04:06 you have to be a member of this association.
00:04:08 I mean, these guys stand up for you.
00:04:10 They provide you resources to make sure you can protect your right ability to use those firearms.
00:04:14 And they, like any other association, provide all sorts of resources as well, whether it's for local shows or events and things such as that.
00:04:21 So check them out, Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:04:24 Their website is cssa-cila.org, or you can just Google them, Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:04:31 It's a membership well worth investing in for yourself.
00:04:34 You know, Corey, you probably saw this in our pages just within the last two weeks.
00:04:38 We had an article there from Tony updating our readers on what was going on in the government with regard to firearms.
00:04:46 Oh, yeah, they're on top of it.
00:04:47 Just search Bernardo and it'll come right up.
00:04:50 All right. Well, let's start here.
00:04:53 So Federal Environment Minister Stephen Gilbo, he says all sorts of funny things.
00:04:59 And he gets away with it most of the time, at least outside of Alberta.
00:05:05 But he seems to have really stepped in it on this one.
00:05:07 And he wants the federal government to stop funding.
00:05:13 So the federal government collects billions of dollars every year in the gas tax.
00:05:17 So that is a tax paid on fuel, presumably mostly by drivers.
00:05:23 And it's supposed to be used to be put towards roads for those drivers.
00:05:28 And he says, well, we need to stop that.
00:05:31 We're not going to stop collecting the gas tax.
00:05:33 We're obviously going to keep collecting it.
00:05:35 but that money should be used for things that are explicitly not for drivers paying the gas tax.
00:05:41 This will encourage people to walk more. He's not incorrect about that. No roads means less driving
00:05:46 and presumably we can walk to Lethbridge from Calgary if that's really what he wants.
00:05:56 Nigel, he seems, actually you were just telling me before we started, he held a presser just a few
00:06:01 hours ago and he's trying to back away from that position. Well I would hope he would.
00:06:05 I mean, the trouble with Mr. Gilles Baud, he's one of these very, very sincere people.
00:06:10 Well, you said it right.
00:06:11 I've been practicing in front of the mirror.
00:06:15 He says he's very sincere, and every now and then the problem that sincere people have
00:06:21 is that they tell you what they honestly really think.
00:06:25 And he actually thinks that we should get out of our cars and walk more or ride a bicycle.
00:06:33 Now, to some degree, there is a limited argument in favor of that.
00:06:39 I think we could all afford to take a walk for the sake of our hearts and our constitutions during the lunchtime.
00:06:46 But I live, you know, you live, what, 10 miles from the office?
00:06:50 I live 6.2 miles from the office.
00:06:52 You come in from Prentice, for heaven's sake.
00:06:54 You're dating yourself using miles.
00:06:58 It's all I use.
00:06:59 I have no idea how many miles I am from the office.
00:07:01 well 16 and in my case about nine but anyway however you do the maths it's too far to walk
00:07:08 and it's too far to ride ride a bike unless you're one of these keeners
00:07:13 i have a suspicion and i think i first had that suspicion when it was one of your columns in about
00:07:19 april of last of 2022 when you were speculating this was all about actually getting people to
00:07:28 drive less and making having car a car a luxury and we're all going to be in our 15 minute cities
00:07:36 we weren't going anywhere and sure enough that it is now emerging that the electric cars aren't
00:07:42 suitable for the environment there's never going to be enough of them because people won't buy them
00:07:47 there will be less cars and then he will be happy so it all makes perfect sense but i thought you
00:07:53 you were off on a conspiracy theory about time. Well, sometimes I am. Well, you weren't this
00:07:58 time, were you? Seems to be proving out a bit. Yeah. Well, as usual, today's conspiracy theories
00:08:06 are tomorrow's government policy, something we saw too often during COVID. Corey, is this
00:08:13 did he give any indication about how much he wants federal government to act on this? Is this
00:08:19 going to be federal policy that the gas tax transfer cannot be used towards roads, or was he
00:08:26 just going to enable-gazing? He didn't give specifics, but I mean, he certainly, you know,
00:08:29 the veil dropped for a minute, and we see the kind of direction he wants to go. I don't know if he's
00:08:34 going rogue, or if it's represented in the whole government. It does seem almost as if Justin
00:08:39 Trudeau has just kind of given him free reign and environment, and he's, the thing people have to
00:08:44 realize that Gilboa, he's the real thing. He's a nutter. He's an environmental extremist. If you 0.99
00:08:50 might remember a long time back, I doubt Derek would, but there was a Edmonton experimented with
00:08:55 like a graduated ballot sort of thing for their city council. And this fellow named Tucker Gomberg
00:08:59 managed to actually get a council position, which never normally ever would have happened.
00:09:03 He proposed things like flooding the city streets so people could skate to work. This was an actual
00:09:08 council. I mean, sadly, he was actually quite disturbed. And he took his own life at the
00:09:15 Confederation Bridge some years later. So which was tragic. I don't want to jump on the grave of
00:09:19 the man. But he was an example of when you take a truly extreme activist and put them into a
00:09:24 position with a little bit of authority. But that was still Edmonton City Council.
00:09:28 Gilbo is like the Gomberg of federal politics. And he's in a very position of serious federal
00:09:33 authority. And that gets a little more scary. Because not only would he want to spread the
00:09:38 streets with ice, perhaps, but he's got the ability to force it, and
00:09:41 I think we're seeing a hint of where he'd like to go. 0.99
00:09:46 I mean, the man is nuts. 0.96
00:09:50 He is a true believer, eco-fanatic. 0.99
00:09:54 He's the guy who would scale the CN Tower.
00:09:58 Ralph Klein's house.
00:09:59 He invaded Ralph Klein's private residence.
00:10:02 stuff that would normally make you, put you off into a silo where you can play with your little friends,
00:10:14 but you're regarded as so far outside the mainstream that you're not welcome in a so-called mainstream political party.
00:10:21 But here he is in one of the most senior positions in the federal government,
00:10:25 wants to essentially shut down the electrical grid in Alberta and Saskatchewan.
00:10:30 I know the Premier of Alberta had a pretty robust response to him yesterday.
00:10:37 Well, I think, yeah, about the roads, she said he just wasn't realistic.
00:10:42 She made the same arguments that we're making here now, that the distances are too much,
00:10:47 people have to be mobile, and he's just not accepting the grim realities.
00:10:52 I mean, maybe you could reconstruct some large Canadian city like Toronto
00:10:56 So it was a kind of a place where everybody gets around in public transit,
00:11:01 but it's just plain not going to work in the rest of the country.
00:11:07 Good for the Premier for making that point, for sticking with it,
00:11:12 and for, once again, holding up Mr. Gilbo to derision,
00:11:19 the derision that he so richly deserves.
00:11:24 Bless your heart.
00:11:26 All right. Well, a little less crazy, but a little more traditional liberal corruption era.
00:11:35 I mean, it's rarely a week goes by without some form of liberal corruption coming up, but the Arrive can, dubbed Arrive Scam now.
00:11:45 This is, this has got the sniff of the sponsorship scandal on it.
00:11:50 This one, this one smells like pure old fashioned liberal corruption. So the arrive can app was originally contracted by the federal government to them. What's called GC strategies, GC strategies. Now, fun little fact. If you're following along at home, look up their Twitter account and look at who GC strategies follows. They follow only one person.
00:12:19 Justin Trudeau. They have one person they follow, Justin Trudeau. Now, if I was setting up
00:12:25 a corruption scheme, and I was going to create a Twitter account to try and give the appearance
00:12:30 of being a legitimate business, I don't know, I'd probably follow at least three people.
00:12:35 Three people, maybe. But not just the one guy who butters my bread. So I did the math quickly.
00:12:43 We were talking about in the opening here about how over budget this is. It's not 738% over budget. It's 737 times over budget.
00:12:55 Yes.
00:12:56 Yeah.
00:12:57 Like, if something goes over budget around the office here by 30%, I might get a little pissed. But maybe there's reasoning for it.
00:13:10 Maybe, you know, some things aren't predictable.
00:13:13 Your legal bills, your marketing budget.
00:13:17 You know, if something is more than 20% over budget, I answer to our board of directors over it.
00:13:23 And, you know, if something was double the budget for the year, I'm going to get some hard questions.
00:13:30 And maybe there's a legitimate reason for it.
00:13:32 But 737 times, so 738 if we're running up in the decimal here, 738 times over budget.
00:13:43 I can't think of anything in the history of the world that has been that far over budget.
00:13:48 The entire American space program, the Saturn program, the put a man on the moon was over budget.
00:13:55 But it was not 738 times over budget.
00:14:01 Nigel, what's been the Federal Liberals' response to the Auditor General's report here?
00:14:07 Well, they don't really have one. And I noticed that the response is in question period. Yes,
00:14:13 they were very downbeat. They said what they had to say, but they weren't really trying to defend
00:14:18 it. And in fact, the minister actually got up and said, well, just because there was a national
00:14:23 emergency doesn't mean to say that people get to just throw the rules out. I mean,
00:14:27 things were done wrong here. That's about as complete an admission of guilt and defeat as
00:14:33 you're going to get from the Liberal Party. You know, the problem where I think things went off
00:14:42 the rails there, remember when this was put together. It was put together over a period of
00:14:49 about five weeks in April of 2020. This was the period of time when all levels of government were
00:14:57 speaking the language of war we had to stick together we have your back it's going to take
00:15:04 everybody uh we're all in this together we're all in this together and it was um there there was a
00:15:11 tremendous degree of hype to get people who once the initial two weeks had elapsed during which
00:15:19 we were going to smooth the curve and it was very clear that their the policies were going to extend
00:15:26 and that the lockdowns were coming and the masks were coming,
00:15:30 they needed an atmosphere of intensity and alarm and widespread fear.
00:15:36 And in that atmosphere, this thing was conceived.
00:15:40 And I think that it was just, look, do whatever it takes.
00:15:44 Like, you got it, run with it, get this thing done because we need it.
00:15:49 It's a national emergency.
00:15:51 This would not have happened in more peaceful times.
00:15:55 You mentioned GC strategies.
00:15:57 One of the pieces of evidence that to me seemed indicative of the state of mind
00:16:03 was that the initial news story came out.
00:16:05 It was this plucky little gang of amateurs who put this thing together in their garage
00:16:10 and done it for $80,000, and here we are with a ride-can Canadian genius to the rest of it.
00:16:16 Well, that's not exactly what happened.
00:16:18 They were anything but amateurs.
00:16:19 They were smart operators.
00:16:22 They got the contract, and then they found people who could do it for them,
00:16:25 subbed it out, took a cut.
00:16:28 This is what came out in the Auditor General's report.
00:16:31 And then, I guess, as the whole situation moved forward, well, you know,
00:16:38 you've got to upgrade.
00:16:39 You've got to keep up with the latest upgrades to the phones,
00:16:42 and there's five different kinds of phones that you can do it for,
00:16:45 and they kept on spending money on this app.
00:16:49 And the big thing that went wrong within CBSA was that nobody kept tabs on the expenses.
00:16:57 And the app didn't really work.
00:16:59 It was a disaster the whole time.
00:17:01 Which is amazing because really it was nothing more than a form.
00:17:04 You know, high school students kind of do that sort of stuff just for the yearbook.
00:17:10 So, Corey, how much do we know about who GC Strategies is?
00:17:15 They have a very opaque public profile.
00:17:18 It has the appearance of kind of a shell corporation.
00:17:23 It's got a Twitter account, which follows one person, as I said, just Justin Trudeau.
00:17:28 So it's not really...
00:17:29 It seems to be two people.
00:17:31 There's no history of them being an app development company or those individuals having app development skills.
00:17:37 As I just said, it turned out they farmed it out.
00:17:39 They took... I mean, it reeks. It reeks to high heaven.
00:17:43 heaven. My wife, Jane, is a bookkeeper. When she was hearing this news, you could hear the veins
00:17:48 popping in her head. She gets upset when I mess up with $20 on one of my forms for books or
00:17:53 something, and just something like this to happen in the scope of millions. It reeks. There was no
00:17:59 bid tendered even. These guys were just given it. I mean, they didn't even have to show that they
00:18:04 had a plan. According to the AG, I believe that when they applied for this contract, they cut and
00:18:11 pasted the requirements from the government.
00:18:14 So you can hear the frustration from the Auditor General.
00:18:17 She said this, you know, 59.6 million or whatever.
00:18:21 She says this is just a ballpark estimate because the documents are missing and the emails have all been deleted.
00:18:28 Like now it's reeking of cover up to we're getting into the criminal realm here with some of the stuff that's coming up.
00:18:33 And I think the liberals would be wise to get on this and try to play the victim.
00:18:38 I mean, just get up and say, we're going to clean this up.
00:18:40 They took advantage of Canadians because there's so far, there's no evidence that is tied to the party.
00:18:46 So well, they would if there's no blood on their hands, because, you know, they could say, hey, you know, it was wartime.
00:18:56 Yeah. And, you know, some bad things are going to happen.
00:18:59 Some people are going to take advantage of us.
00:19:02 But they gave this clearly was not a very proper competitive process.
00:19:10 There is a place for some sole source contracting in very limited specific circumstances.
00:19:16 This was not one of those circumstances.
00:19:20 But I think they, is the victim card available to them to play?
00:19:26 I mean, they attempted the victim card with the sponsorship scandal in the early 2000s, we recall.
00:19:31 That didn't work very well.
00:19:34 I mean, Paul Martin tried to essentially blame his liberal predecessor.
00:19:37 The public just saw liberal.
00:19:39 liberal. They didn't really care which faction of liberal within the liberal universe, they're like, well, those are different liberals. Canadians are, yeah, but they're liberals. Is the victim card here available for them to play? Or if they play that card, though, you know,
00:19:56 You can only do it if you're not tied to it.
00:19:59 Exactly.
00:19:59 I mean, even then, as you said, it's under their watch.
00:20:02 They're still going to wear some of this no matter what.
00:20:05 But to date, there's been no evidence tying it to any liberals.
00:20:08 It looks like, you know, some senior bureaucrats and CBSA.
00:20:10 And then again, the buck stops in the prime minister's office.
00:20:14 But yeah, their quiet lack of indignation on this, I guess, may spell it.
00:20:21 Or maybe at least they're scrambling just to make sure they don't have a connection somewhere before they take the offensive.
00:20:26 because this stinks. This stinks bad. So Nigel, we have the Auditor General's report. Where do 0.75
00:20:32 things go from here? You will recall that... No one's been held accountable. No, you will recall
00:20:40 that the Auditor General was asked specifically about corruption, and she deflected the question
00:20:46 by saying that certain things have been referred to the RCMP. That is where it has gone. So we will
00:20:54 see you will see fairly soon i should expect that if anybody gets charged uh and they may well be
00:21:02 the the scapegoats in them in the issue but i come back to my original point once you create an
00:21:09 atmosphere of panic you can get away with anything and that's the serious lesson that this this
00:21:14 incident much more than the money the money's bad but if you want to put something across canadians
00:21:20 you just scare them and you make them afraid. And then you do whatever you want.
00:21:24 And something may illegal may have happened. But the thing is, you know, with these kinds
00:21:28 of arrangements, it might be illegal in any other circumstance, except when the government does it.
00:21:36 Like, you know, for example, it's illegal. I remember so when I was finance critic of the
00:21:41 Wildrose, the provincial NDP broke the law by busting through their artificial debt ceiling.
00:21:49 And the question was, well, what happens when they break the law? The answer was nothing. It's a law, but there is no punishment to it. And so I'm not sure, perhaps something, you know, maybe something illegal happened here.
00:22:05 But when the government does it, it's just almost de facto legal unless someone circumvents very specific areas in criminal law.
00:22:14 So I'm not sure anyone gets held, has held the responsibility here.
00:22:19 We'll see. Yeah, I mean, there's certainly a case to be made if there's fraud that has been committed.
00:22:23 And on the surface, it looks like there's some evidence of it.
00:22:26 But it's a matter, again, of whether there's going to be the government will to go after and scapegoat who's responsible or if they just want to try and make this go away.
00:22:34 And if they go after them, the worry is then, well, then they're going to have to defend themselves.
00:22:39 And if they're going to defend themselves, they're going to speak about what the government said to them.
00:22:44 And I'm not sure that's in...
00:22:45 Do the liberals really want these guys on the stand spilling all the beans?
00:22:52 Not before the next election.
00:22:53 No.
00:22:54 Right about the time that we get some action on the China interference inquiry, we will get some action on this.
00:23:02 Yeah.
00:23:03 All right.
00:23:04 Well, just the other day, there was a very interesting exchange in the House of Commons.
00:23:12 Justin Trudeau and Pierre Polyev.
00:23:15 And, you know, rather than me explain it, why don't we just show the video from that explanation?
00:23:22 Under the previous Conservative government, everything was perfect.
00:23:26 And what he is proposing to do is to make Canada great again.
00:23:31 That is not what Canadians want.
00:23:33 He is pining for a nostalgia that, quite frankly, Canadians do not feel.
00:23:38 They remember what he did as part of Stephen Harper's failed housing minister.
00:23:44 He remembers the rights of Indigenous peoples violated, 1.00
00:23:49 the ignoring of environmental responsibilities
00:23:52 and the lack of an environmental and economic plan for the future.
00:23:56 We're going to continue on.
00:23:57 Canada is and always has been our country.
00:24:05 And we want Canada to be a true north that is as strong and as free as it can be in every
00:24:12 way that matters.
00:24:13 The best country in the world.
00:24:15 That's why we're here.
00:24:16 That's why we strive.
00:24:17 That's why we serve.
00:24:21 Canada must reflect the true character of the Canadian people.
00:24:25 Honourable in our dealings, faithful to our commitments, loyal to our friends
00:24:32 By turns, a courageous warrior and a compassionate neighbour
00:24:36 It is our purpose that Canada must be great
00:24:40 It must be great for all Canadians
00:24:42 It must be a country of hope and an example to the world
00:24:46 And only when it is these things, when Canada is all that it can be
00:24:51 Only then can we say that our work is done
00:24:54 So long before anybody thought of Donald Trump as president of the United States, former Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Canada is great and will be great, etc.
00:25:04 So using the word great and Trudeau says, well, this is clear that Pierre Polyev, who was a junior minister at the time, was aware that Donald Trump would be U.S. president and campaign on a slogan of making America great again.
00:25:22 And Canadians do not want that.
00:25:24 They do not want Canada to be great again.
00:25:28 I mean, you can, I mean, the liberal voting base is generally not very sympathetic to
00:25:33 mega and Donald Trump policy, language, et cetera.
00:25:37 So that's fine.
00:25:38 He can make the argument, I think, against, you know, the conservatives picking up on
00:25:45 mega themes and that.
00:25:47 But to phrase it this way, the Canadians do not want Canada to be great again.
00:25:53 That seems like weird politics to me, Nigel.
00:25:56 It's very weird politics, Derek.
00:25:59 But I do think that in moments like this, Mr. Trudeau is telling you what he really thinks,
00:26:06 just like Mr. Giobot gives away what he really thinks in our earlier segment.
00:26:12 Mr. Trudeau, not six weeks after he was elected in 2015, gave an interview to the New York Times,
00:26:20 which he said that Canada was a post-national country.
00:26:24 And in the eight years that have elapsed since then, we have seen ample evidence
00:26:29 that the symbols of Canada before 2015 that we all responded to,
00:26:37 he's systematically removed and replaced with other symbols more to his liking or simply no
00:26:44 symbols at all he actually does not regard canada as he does not treat canada as a great country
00:26:53 so really when he says canadians don't want canada to be great i think he's telling you what he
00:27:00 thinks he is projecting what he thinks onto a population of about 40 million and he may well
00:27:05 will be very, very wrong in that. I'm actually not sure he's wrong in a sense, not maybe in the way
00:27:12 he thinks, but well, then I hope you're wrong. Yeah. Oh, I wish I was wrong. But I mean, Canada
00:27:17 isn't a nation by most definitions of nation. It is a state. But I mean, if I like the thought
00:27:26 experiment of if the world had amnesia, we woke up tomorrow, and we lost all of the atlases,
00:27:31 we had no idea what the national borders were uh are what how would we draw the the borders around
00:27:36 the world today and i i don't think canada would exist i think quebec would exist as a state um
00:27:43 but i don't think canada would because we'd speak the same language as our southern name
00:27:47 our southern neighbors uh similar cultures canada is the product of old colonial european politics
00:27:56 We were just the part of North America that didn't want to govern itself by the late 18th century.
00:28:02 So in a sense, Canada isn't a traditional nation state, the way, say, France or Germany or Britain is.
00:28:11 But I think he conceives it in another way, that we're not a people in any sense, and we should have no real self-identity.
00:28:20 We should be multicultural entirely.
00:28:23 And that's where he goes.
00:28:26 You know, you go back to the Second World War, and you see what a little nation of 10 million people was able to do in the fight against fascism.
00:28:39 But even then, that was two nations in one state. Quebec is its own nation.
00:28:44 Well, they would certainly tell you that, but the simple fact is in the name of Canada, with Canada on the shoulder patches, 900,000 people out of a population of 10 million put on uniform and came out of the end of the war as one of the significant military.
00:29:01 And they were mostly Anglos. Quebecers, by a large measure, either opposed the war or did not participate until conscription.
00:29:08 When I am in my cups, I do like to say that. But the truth of the matter is that the French-Canadian contribution to that war was significant.
00:29:18 It was, but it was in significantly lower numbers than an Anglo-Canada.
00:29:20 There were significantly less of them to offer their services.
00:29:24 No, I'm not saying proportionally.
00:29:24 Well, it was a national effort, Derek, and I do strongly believe that at that particular time,
00:29:35 a concept of Canadian nationhood had taken hold and was strongly supported by the people who lived here at that time.
00:29:44 Now, the 70 years since, it's been taken apart.
00:29:49 You know, we lost the flag, they changed the Constitution, they increased the...
00:29:56 You've even changed the anthem.
00:29:58 Demographic mix, changed the anthem, you know, these kinds of things.
00:30:02 But in all of those cases, people would still argue, I think, that it was in order to reconstruct a nation, not necessarily to change it.
00:30:12 There's only in the last few years that you've really seen the whole idea of the nation of Canada held as a secondary consideration and treated with contempt.
00:30:24 Corey, I know you and I have maybe different conceptions of Canadian nationhood than Nigel does, but I suppose we've maybe got a little off track.
00:30:35 I think we're kind of, well, yeah, we're a little off track. But to what Trudeau said here, that
00:30:41 Canadians do not want Canada to be great again. Was this him just kind of getting away with his
00:30:48 own rhetoric against Mega? Or was this? We might be reading a bit too much into a simple man.
00:30:54 I mean, he's not good when he goes off script. And he's been told, and we can see that from
00:31:01 the government lately, they've been failing when they try to go after Polyev. So the instructions
00:31:05 have been, whenever you can, go after Trump, campaign against Trump, campaign against Premier
00:31:11 Smith, campaign against others, they feel that there's a weaker spot to go against there.
00:31:15 And the point I think he was just trying to make was a sidelong, unscripted way to try and tie
00:31:21 things to Donald Trump. But he tripped on his own tongue. And of course, it came out sounding
00:31:27 horrific when you're saying Canadians don't want to be great. And, you know, I believe it's I mean,
00:31:34 I agree he's got this warped vision of a post-national state and things like that. But
00:31:39 I think in this particular statement, maybe there was a bit of a Freudian underpinning to that. But
00:31:45 for the most part, I think he just slipped up. But it's a terrible slip up to make when you're
00:31:49 talking about national unity. I think you made an interesting point there about how he wants
00:31:54 to campaign against others because Polyev has turned out to be a hard target to land a punch 0.99
00:31:58 against. And it's not uncommon that liberals will campaign against the U.S. president if that
00:32:04 president is Republican. Republicans are the more nationalistic party in the United States, so
00:32:08 obviously if you're not a national of the United States, you're going to feel less attraction to
00:32:14 American nationalism. You know, Paul Martin would regularly campaign against George Bush, even
00:32:20 though George Bush was not running for Canadian prime minister, he would campaign against Bush.
00:32:24 That was fairly common. So I would I would certainly expect him to campaign against Trump.
00:32:29 So let's talk about maybe how a Trump presidency, second Trump presidency or restoration, Trump restoration, let's call it, could affect the next election.
00:32:39 It's not for sure. But if I'm putting money down, I think Trump is going to be president again.
00:32:44 Biden was the boring, safe candidate in the last election.
00:32:48 maybe a collectocrat establishment democrat but he wasn't seen as crazy but now he is undeniably
00:32:57 heavily senile he cannot operate as commander in chief in the united states he just simply
00:33:04 can't do the job regardless of what you think of his politics uh some people think trump's crazy 0.72
00:33:10 And maybe he is, but he is not senile. And Biden doesn't know what room he's in. You know, if you have like a major car accident or something, they'll ask you three questions like, what year is it? What's your name? And who's president United States? And I'm not sure that Joe Biden can answer any three of those questions at the same time on any given day. So I think there's a very good chance we're going to have another Trump presidency.
00:33:37 Yeah. But something different this time is that Trump's not the unknown boogeyman. He might not have appealed to a lot of Canadians. We also know during the four years he was in power, he didn't do much to harm Canada. I mean, what are you defending us against? I mean, perhaps, you know, people may feel he'd do some damage in the American area, but he's no more protectionist than Biden was or is. And, you know, he's not an expansionist president. He's not going to send the army after us or something.
00:34:02 So I don't think those shots of trying to say we're going to protect you from Trump are really going to land that as well as they think they might.
00:34:10 Not that. But I think the accusation is that Polyev would govern like Trump.
00:34:16 And I think they're there. And the biggest knock against Trump is his own personality.
00:34:21 A lot of people like myself like Trumpism, but we don't I don't like Trump, the man, the individual.
00:34:27 So it was really the individual character and I don't think Polly if there's anything like him as an individual character.
00:34:33 But I think it's the accusation isn't that you'd be supporting Trump Trump is going to hurt Canada.
00:34:39 I think the accusation is that you'll govern Canada like Trump governs America.
00:34:43 How much do you think a Trump restoration for lack of better term will hurt the chances of Polly have in the next election? 1.00
00:34:55 No, I don't think it will.
00:34:57 People are already starting to line up
00:34:59 which side of the political spectrum they're going to land on.
00:35:03 And if you like Poilier now,
00:35:07 you're not going to buy the accusation
00:35:11 that he's really just Trump in waiting for Canada.
00:35:13 And if you do like Poilier, well, whatever.
00:35:16 Things were pretty good with Trump for four years,
00:35:19 so let's hope they're pretty good with Mr. Poilier.
00:35:22 I can't see that.
00:35:23 I can see them trying but I can't see them I can't see it working as I think it's probability it's not guaranteed but I think probability wise it's a pretty good bet to bet on Trump coming back to the presidency in the United States it's looking that way yeah I can't for the life of me figure out why the Democrats can't say let's get someone else who's not entirely off the rocker
00:35:53 senile to be their candidate for president, but this seems to be what they've decided. They're
00:35:59 putting great grandpa up again, not letting him retire. To be fair, I can't see why the Republicans
00:36:04 can't find somebody sane either. Well, the difference is the Republicans like Trump. The
00:36:09 Democrats don't even really like Biden. He's just their guy. No Democrat is a thwalled about him.
00:36:16 The radical left of the Democrats don't like him because he's an establishment
00:36:19 I think it's just the Democratic establishment is afraid that the radical woke and socialist left of the Democrats will have their chance for a candidate this time if they put up someone who's not as old as Bernie Sanders.
00:36:33 But in any case, I think Trump is a pretty good bet.
00:36:36 that yes but it's but that's actually kind of dangerous because what happens when you've got
00:36:42 a candidate who is destined to lose is that you find a distraction and you have a national
00:36:49 emergency and you say well this guy is monica missiles something like that well no american
00:36:56 president's ever lost while at war i mean it's it's a good incentive for having wars and donald
00:37:01 Trump is the first president since Herbert Hoover to not have a significant war during his presidency.
00:37:08 I mean, Trump would have stood a very good chance of getting reelected if he had have had a war,
00:37:13 or if he would have leaned into COVID using wartime language the way other world leaders did.
00:37:17 Which war are you associating with Hoover?
00:37:19 I said he's the last president who didn't get America into a significant war.
00:37:22 Oh, I see. Yes. Too busy getting them into a depression.
00:37:26 No, generally speaking, if you want to get into a war, elect a Democrat.
00:37:31 You've got Woodrow Wilson in the First World War.
00:37:33 You have FDR in the Second World War.
00:37:36 You have Harry Truman for Korea.
00:37:39 You have Kennedy and Johnson for Vietnam. 0.57
00:37:42 Well, the Republicans were the war party, though, for some time.
00:37:47 By Nixon, they became the war party.
00:37:50 But didn't have to actually fight one.
00:37:52 Nixon was the guy that got them out of Vietnam.
00:37:54 Largely so, yeah.
00:37:55 And without Watergate, probably would have gone about a much better. But certainly through through Reagan. I mean, I love Reagan as much as the next guy. But Reagan was a hawk. Bush first, Bush the second. They were both hawks.
00:38:08 It's the old thing. If you don't want if you want peace, prepare for war. And that's what the Republicans have done. That's what the Democrats.
00:38:15 But Trump returned the Republicans to their traditional position as the peace party.
00:38:21 But for a long time, I'd say from Reagan on through the second Bush, they were the war party. 0.53
00:38:28 But it switched back to the way it was pre-Reagan.
00:38:32 I mean, just to head off the guys who are already reaching for their phones, I will concede that George Bush took the United States into the war in Afghanistan and the war against terror.
00:38:42 On the other hand, what else was he going to do after the trade center?
00:38:47 We're way off track, but I'm liking this off track today.
00:38:49 Afghanistan, I totally had to do, but Iraq was a pretty, that was an optional. 0.99
00:38:54 That was not a mandatory question on the...
00:38:57 It did backfire on them once things were investigated and realized.
00:39:00 And I think the result of that is one thing that propelled the return of the Republicans,
00:39:04 the position of the, not anti-war party, but the less imperialist of the two parties.
00:39:09 Yes, certainly.
00:39:10 Okay, well, we're going off a lot of tangents today, but I'm liking these tangents. But let's bring it back closer to home again here. So Pierre Polyev, when he ran for Conservative leader, promised to defund the CBC. Very popular. He's been very clear on that.
00:39:30 He gives these great speeches about, you know, he looks forward to the day when they can close down the headquarters of the CBC in Toronto,
00:39:39 when a family pulls up a U-Haul and moves into the C-suite.
00:39:44 But he has, until now, not committed to ending the government subsidies to the so-called private sector media,
00:39:54 the bailouts, essentially, that the Western Standard painfully has not taken.
00:40:00 Which is why you need to support us by becoming a member at westernstandard.news.
00:40:04 $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:40:07 But he has not yet committed until now to end the private sector subsidies.
00:40:12 And I've suspected it's because, well, it's pretty hard for a journalist to cover you fairly if you're promising to end subsidies that are paying for their jobs.
00:40:25 I mean, if I'm a reporter and 35%, 40% plus of my salary is directly dependent on keeping the liberals in power, I can't cover the other guys fairly.
00:40:40 I can't cover the liberals fairly.
00:40:42 And so I think he's been afraid of provoking the media against him by saying he'd get rid of these subsidies.
00:40:49 I suspect, Corey, that the reason he has just this week promised to do away with the subsidies to Toronto Star, National Post, Golden Mail, all these guys, is because he's finally realized that they're not going to give him a fair shake no matter what.
00:41:12 So he may as well promise to ax their jobs.
00:41:15 Yeah, I mean, I think there's two reasons.
00:41:17 That's one of them.
00:41:17 It's a big one.
00:41:18 They're not going to give them a fair shake. They're on them like fleas on a dog. I've never
00:41:22 seen media so eager to keep the leader of the opposition accountable as I have in this last
00:41:27 year while giving a pass to the prime minister who prances out of the country or out of the
00:41:32 House of Commons every time a scandal comes up. The other part too, though, is I think it's
00:41:36 becoming evident to Canadians in general that the subsidies aren't working. The newspapers are
00:41:41 still contracting. The CTV and Bell are still doing layoffs. The subsidies aren't working.
00:41:46 They're trying to save outlets, you know, and I've got a column coming out in a little while on that from an inevitable despise, despise, I despise some of them.
00:41:58 And he's realizing that, you know, Canadians are also realizing this is just throwing good money after bad.
00:42:04 Something needs to change, but subsidizing isn't working.
00:42:07 So he's not afraid to go after it.
00:42:08 Nigel, why do you think he's declined until now to say he would get rid of the subsidies to the so-called private sector media, and has just now said he'll do it?
00:42:22 Well, timing is everything, and one thing is you don't want to put all your policies out there at the moment, but it just seemed like the right time to point out that the media,
00:42:32 Bell has just laid off, what was it, 5,000 people to get rid of a massive operating debt
00:42:42 that was piling up to what was basically a telephone company.
00:42:46 So he has no friends.
00:42:51 It's like Corey says, he has no friends in the media.
00:42:54 Why are we keeping this up?
00:42:56 Put it out there.
00:42:57 The base actually will love it, and they do.
00:43:00 and you can see that from the response that we've been getting.
00:43:07 20 months to an election.
00:43:10 What he is doing is taking them on.
00:43:13 Have you noticed this?
00:43:15 I mean, you kind of not noticed it.
00:43:16 Like, he doesn't just, Harper would go to the press conference,
00:43:21 take two questions, they would always be hostile.
00:43:24 They were never simply a request for information.
00:43:27 They'd leave and they went off and did what they did.
00:43:30 And Kaleev is not doing that.
00:43:33 He is going.
00:43:33 He'll take as many questions as he likes.
00:43:35 But, boy, if you were a reporter, you had better have your questions in order 0.94
00:43:40 and be based on solid fact or he will make a fool of you.
00:43:44 And I don't know why, but they keep coming up unprepared, 0.51
00:43:47 and he eats his apple or he mocks the toque or whatever it is, you know,
00:43:52 and they go off with their tails between their legs.
00:43:55 And now he has finally given them the kick in the rear as they leave.
00:43:59 By the way, I'm dropping this and you'll get a, you know, getting a job, make toast for old people or something. 1.00
00:44:07 Yeah, that's that's the end game here to actually diminish their their influence and the respect that people have for the media by just showing them up working.
00:44:19 You know, I've had meetings with politicians and, you know, not infrequently.
00:44:23 They'll ask me, I'll put it this way.
00:44:25 When I was testifying at the Senate last year on Bill C-18, the Online News Act, I was, I think by a liberal or technically an independent, but a liberal senator, what can the government do to help the independent media like the Western Standard?
00:44:43 And what I said was, leave us alone, and stop subsidizing our competitors. Stop subsidizing the legacy media, and stop trying to help us. Just leave us alone. And that's it. So if Pierre Polyev can end these subsidies.
00:45:00 more national advertising might have been. Well, yeah, I suppose so. Don't you think?
00:45:06 You know what, that's a good idea. But, you know, stop subsidizing our competitors, and stop trying
00:45:13 to pass things like the Online News Act to help us because all the Online News Act did was get us
00:45:16 kicked off Facebook. It costed us a lot of money. So what do you think it costs the mainstream media
00:45:23 because they were Facebook was paperboy for them to? Yeah, but not not in the same percentages. It
00:45:28 It was, because conservatives are more likely to be on Facebook, leftists are more likely to be on Twitter.
00:45:33 Twitter is still there, Facebook is not for us.
00:45:36 So it hurt everybody, but it proportionally hurt more conservative and right-leaning publications more.
00:45:42 Interesting. Okay.
00:45:43 Yeah.
00:45:44 And as a source of revenue, it hurt them a lot less because they're taking the federal government subsidies.
00:45:50 So, and they're not really in the business of growing.
00:45:52 We are.
00:45:52 But nobody won.
00:45:54 No, nobody came out of this looking good.
00:45:56 All right. Well, we're going to wrap it up there. Corey, Nigel, thank you very much.
00:46:02 I thank all of you for joining us today on the pipeline. Remember, the Western Standard is
00:46:06 federal government bailout free. We rely on advertising and memberships from people like
00:46:12 you. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to Western Standard News right now
00:46:17 and become a member. It's only $10 a month or $100 for an entire year to get all access to all
00:46:22 Western Standard content. Without that kind of thing, well, we'd have to shut down or take the
00:46:27 subsidies like the other guys. So please do it. Thank you very much for joining us today, and God
00:46:32 bless. Canadian Shooting Sports Association. Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken
00:46:38 long, long ago. These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms
00:46:44 regulations and legislation in Canada, and more importantly, educating the public about how we
00:46:50 keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people to become a member it's absolutely worth every penny
00:46:56 you can become a western center member for just ten dollars a month or 99