Western Standard - August 10, 2023


The Pipeline: Hostage exchange - Windmills for oil

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Cory Morgan Show. Canada’s ticking immigration time bomb Are oil & gas companies subsidized?

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

174.21

Word count

8,327

Sentence count

510

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

25

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan join me to talk about the latest hostage crisis in Alberta, Justin Trudeau's strange privacy tour, and the Canadian Shooting Sports Association's new attack ads.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching
00:00:17 The Pipeline. Today is August 9th, 2023. I'm joined as usual by Western Standard opinion
00:00:25 editor, Nigel Hannaford. Great to be back. Gonna be back here too. We've also got, as always,
00:00:31 Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan. How you doing, Corey? Very good, thanks.
00:00:38 Okay, well, we've got a fun show today. First, a hostage crisis.
00:00:46 Ottawa has been taking hostages from Alberta for quite some time. The tech oil sands mine,
00:00:52 pipeline approvals, natural gas exports to Germany. They've taken a lot of hostages. But
00:00:57 all of a sudden, new twist in the story. Alberta's taken some hostages. The Alberta government has
00:01:04 put in place a six-month moratorium on so-called green energy products. That's windmills,
00:01:11 solar panels, hipsters on exercise bikes, different things like this.
00:01:17 ostensibly so that they can do a review around land use stuff, which makes some sense.
00:01:26 But I'm actually hoping that there's a bigger agenda at play here.
00:01:30 And that's that, well, if Ottawa is going to be shooting our prisoners, 0.97
00:01:36 then perhaps we should start shooting some of their dear green prisoners as well. 0.99
00:01:41 Just for the Facebook, YouTube, and Facebook, mostly Facebook and YouTube censors. 0.99
00:01:47 we're not actually talking about shooting people, metaphorical projects. We're going to be talking about housing prices, housing, housing, or house building and immigration, immigration levels already at massive record levels continued to be planned to go to even higher new record levels. And whatever else you might think about immigration, good thing, bad thing.
00:02:14 It's definitely far, far outpacing new home construction in Canada.
00:02:19 So we're going to be talking about that, particularly comes from a column that Corey wrote.
00:02:24 We're going to talk about Justin Trudeau's privacy tour.
00:02:27 Of course, I'm sure you've all seen the news.
00:02:29 Justin Trudeau and Sophie Gregor Trudeau have split, and they both issued a very, I think, reasonable plea for privacy to leave their family out of this.
00:02:41 This is a private matter.
00:02:42 And I think most reasonable people among us said, that seems reasonable to me.
00:02:48 And about two days later, Justin Trudeau trots out his Barbie son on social media,
00:02:54 doing anything but keeping his family life private from what's going on.
00:03:02 So I'm going to talk about Justin Trudeau's kind of very strange privacy tour here.
00:03:07 A little on the nose, but trying to contrast himself.
00:03:10 uh uh conservative leader peer poly of the conservative leaders new clothes a new set of
00:03:17 positive advertisements about the conservative leader uh released about how he is a great family
00:03:24 man and the regular guy and wink wink nudge nudge his family's together i think that part was a you
00:03:32 know a little maybe a little on the nose but uh we're going to talk about these new attack uh it's
00:03:37 not attack ads, the opposite of attack ads, positive, flowery, nice ads, meant to perhaps humanize Pierre Polyev as he continues to climb in the polls here.
00:03:48 Before we get started, though, we've got to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:03:53 I was actually just talking to these guys this morning.
00:03:56 I've been a member of the CSSA for more than a decade because we need the Canadian Shooting Sports Association there to defend our rights as free firearm owners
00:04:06 In Canada, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association is kind of leading firearms rights organization and is absolutely necessary.
00:04:15 If we are to retain any right to own and use firearms legally in this country without the CSSA.
00:04:22 By this point, I'm sure we'd all still be gun owners.
00:04:25 We'd just be criminals for doing it at the same time.
00:04:28 So if you're not yet a member of the CSSA, you need to stop free riding and join up with them.
00:04:33 Go to CSSA-CILA.org.
00:04:37 I'll also make an unscheduled but I think important plug here.
00:04:42 Many of you have probably noticed we're pretty much banned from Facebook at this point.
00:04:47 Some of you with a VPN or watching from outside of Canada or maybe there's been some trickery going on where they haven't got you yet.
00:04:54 We're banned from Facebook.
00:04:55 were about to be banned from Google. And this is all because of federal legislation meant to help
00:05:01 us. You know, we've talked about Bill C-18 before, the latest media bailout bill imposed by the
00:05:08 federal government designed to bail out legacy publishers and broadcasters by making Google
00:05:14 and Facebook give them money for helping them find readers and viewers. A strange crime. Well,
00:05:21 So this is obviously blown up in their faces. And the Western Standard, we've been at left holding the bag. We don't take the bailout money, but we have to deal with being banned on Facebook and Google because of federal government legislation.
00:05:36 So two things. If you're already a member of the Western Standard, thank you very much. But if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, sign up right now at westernstandard.news.
00:05:44 It's only we've got a special promotion on right now. You can sign up for a trial membership and only five dollars a month.
00:05:49 It's a great deal. And if that's too much, just sign up for the free newsletter so you can at least stay in contact with us.
00:05:55 See the news that we're sending out every morning in the newsletter, because very soon it's going to be very hard to discover us organically on Google or on Facebook where most people get their news.
00:06:05 Okay, let's jump into it. Hostage exchange. For a very long time now, at least since the Trudeau government came to power in 2015, they have been outright cancelling energy product, generally fossil fuel based energy products in Canada.
00:06:24 And, you know, we remember just a few years ago, the Tech Frontier Mine, a massive oil sands project, billions and billions of dollars of investment, tens of billions of dollars in economic activity and royalties over the projected life of the oil sands mine, just canceled by the Trudeau government.
00:06:46 No good reason other than we don't like it.
00:06:48 Too bad.
00:06:49 It's Alberta.
00:06:49 It's oil.
00:06:50 That's a double negative.
00:06:51 Can't do it.
00:06:52 All sorts of, you know, the no more pipelines bill, the no more tank, the West Coast tanker ban, all of these things designed to kill the oil and gas industry in Alberta.
00:07:01 So they've been taking hostages and shooting them to boot.
00:07:05 Well, all of a sudden, just a few days ago, a very interesting announcement in Alberta here.
00:07:12 The government's put in place a six month moratorium on wind and solar projects.
00:07:19 projects. Now, a lot of people who actually live near where they build these things don't like
00:07:24 them. They make the landscape look like crap. A lot of people live in the country because it's 0.98
00:07:28 beautiful and it's natural. It's a big reason to live in the country. Well, it doesn't look so
00:07:33 beautiful and natural when you've got giant mirrors for solar farms and wind farms polluting the
00:07:39 landscape. People who want them tend to live where these things aren't. So it disrupts landowners.
00:07:46 just helps their way of life. So they put in place a six month moratorium on that.
00:07:50 But I think there could be, I mean, critics of this are saying, well, maybe they're trying to strike back at Ottawa.
00:07:57 And I thought, oh, that's a great idea if it's true. I don't know.
00:08:01 Let's start with you, Corey. Is this a bit of column A, part of column B?
00:08:07 It is partially concerned of landowners having their landscapes polluted by these projects without any consultation with them.
00:08:14 Or is this primarily Alberta taking some hostages now and saying, geez, you killed our projects. 0.99
00:08:21 It'd be a shame if this wind farm was killed too.
00:08:24 Well, I think there's a bit of both going on.
00:08:26 It's the government saying, you know what, we're not part of this almost craze for renewable energies.
00:08:33 We actually want to start appraising these and treating them as we do with other conventional energy projects for feasibility, environmental impact, things like that.
00:08:40 The icing on the cake, though, is telling Ottawa, well, yeah, we're not going to play your game with this.
00:08:47 We're going to develop our industry, as is our provincial, right, how we see fit.
00:08:51 We can debate whether it's a good idea or a bad idea to develop that way.
00:08:55 But she's, I think, sticking out the line, too, though, saying it's our choice whether it's good or bad.
00:09:00 This is our turf.
00:09:01 And what are you going to do about it?
00:09:03 And as you said, the hostage exchange might be pending.
00:09:06 Yeah, Nigel, the idea of the hostage exchange, you know, Alberta taking hostages to come back at Ottawa, didn't really strike me too much until this morning.
00:09:17 The discussion was mostly around, you know, on one side, while they're protecting landowners in rural areas from polluting their landscapes with, you know, wind and solar farms everywhere.
00:09:28 On the other side saying, oh, how dare you? This is a thriving industry.
00:09:32 You know, it's subsidized up the wazoo.
00:09:35 But, you know, they are being built.
00:09:37 They're just doing this because they don't like green energy.
00:09:39 I'm not convinced that they don't like so-called green energy.
00:09:43 But it struck me that this could be a hostage exchange.
00:09:45 When I was walking by in the hallway, we've got some kind of covers of our older issues here.
00:09:51 And headline, one of our earlier issues was, you know, if Trudeau kills the tech frontier mine, it's war.
00:09:57 And I thought, maybe there's a bigger, higher level politics to this, that this is Alberta frustrated that, okay, we can't do, this can't seem to do anything to force Ottawa to allow us to develop our industries as we see fit.
00:10:14 So perhaps we'll strike at them on our own soil, because we've got these little green, you know, these little solar and energy farms that Ottawa likes.
00:10:23 they're on our soil, and we can stop new ones from being built. We can play the
00:10:28 same game. I don't know, am I reading too much into this, that this is a hostage
00:10:32 exchange, or is this just more or less what it is on its face, that it's just
00:10:36 maybe they just don't like them, or maybe it is just a review for landowners?
00:10:41 So, I would say that the conversation that went, you know, we should start
00:10:47 stopping new green developments until they start allowing some new oil
00:10:53 developments was probably never that explicit because there are enough good
00:10:58 reasons which I may come to just to put a lid on the amount of new green
00:11:06 whether it's solar or wind development in this province. However I think everybody
00:11:13 sat back once they made the decision and said something along the lines of what
00:11:17 you saying that's kind of interesting actually we can do it too can't we it's sort of like the
00:11:22 sovereignty act only it's proactive instead of reactive but i i do strongly believe that
00:11:30 that this government would have been motivated by genuine reasons of of public concern they nearly
00:11:39 had a blackout before christmas we came that close and they are very aware that you cannot summon up
00:11:48 renewable energy on demand if the wind doesn't blow or if it's dark if it's cloudy whatever the
00:11:53 problem is you can't just say all right turn on the turbulence because nothing happens they also
00:11:58 articulated a number of other reasons that these things have got like a 20-year lifespan
00:12:02 and they're not recyclable so what do you what's the exit plan going to be and they say well this
00:12:07 is something we're not going to have any more of these things until we've developed that in six
00:12:10 months gives us a reasonable amount of time to do it but this is a province which lives four months
00:12:18 of the year below zero and tough you know it's it's you need power all the time and the idea that
00:12:27 the power could ever go off in the middle of the winter is something that provincial government
00:12:31 that allowed it to happen should be crucified for they're not going to lay themselves open to that
00:12:36 charge. I think it's kind of interesting that they've actually picked up and run with this
00:12:41 when so many previous provincial governments have not brought us this close to the brink.
00:12:47 Yeah, it's sort of Ottawa's, Ottawa doesn't really care how reliable this stuff is because it feels
00:12:52 good. They're happy to let the western bastards freeze in the dark. They don't care if this stuff 1.00
00:12:55 is reliable or not. And it was, you know, most of this stuff began in a really big way under the NDP.
00:13:02 They completely changed the way they did the power grid, introduced massive new subsidies in addition to subsidies that were already there federally and from the previous Allison Redford and Stelmack governments.
00:13:15 But the Kennedy government didn't really change anything on it.
00:13:18 They more or less just kind of left it in place.
00:13:22 And so far, this is early days for this UCP government.
00:13:25 Smith has only been premier in her own right since the elections, you know, May 31st, really.
00:13:32 They haven't had even a city of the legislature since the election, but it'll be telling if they start pulling the subsidies on these things.
00:13:40 Now, the old ones, there's old contracts signed to be very, pretty much impossible to get rid of the old contracts.
00:13:45 We're going to be stuck paying those for generations, just as Ontario is stuck paying them for generations back from the McGinty government.
00:13:51 But it'll be telling if Alberta does.
00:13:56 Corey, what do you think?
00:13:58 Do you think this would be the next move?
00:13:59 Is that Alberta starts pulling the subsidies out on these developments?
00:14:03 Well, it might.
00:14:03 If you don't like something, you probably don't subsidize it.
00:14:05 I mean, the whole case of whether they're viable or not is whether they could exist with just private investment.
00:14:09 I mean, you know, we would agree in this room anyways.
00:14:11 So I could say, yeah, the thumbs up is going on, but we're yanking our portion of it.
00:14:15 If you can bring in the private capital and follow the proper environmental hoops, go to town.
00:14:20 But in the meantime, we're done backstopping this because we have to bring more reliable things onto our grid, such as gas or, you know, dare I say, who knows?
00:14:29 Maybe, you know, modular nuclear and a lot of other options out there.
00:14:32 Ottawa killed the subsidies for oil and gas, which was precisely zero dollars.
00:14:38 So in response, we have to kill the subsidies for Ottawa's green projects, which is a lot more than zero dollars.
00:14:45 And there's a reason to, just for cost-benefit analysis, like I did a comparison, that Traverse Solar Project, it's already generating, it's in the grid, it's, the numbers offhand, I think it's 340 megawatts it generates, which is sizable, but it takes up 3,200 acres of land down there.
00:15:03 Now there's the Calgary Energy Project, it's a newer energy plant that was built, it's natural gas fired outside of Calgary, which generates about 320 megawatts, a little bit less than that one.
00:15:13 But it only takes up about 10 acres. So when you're talking environmental footprint too, I mean now the gas one has emissions, the solar doesn't, but there's more to be discussed.
00:15:22 There's not a lot of emissions in natural gas.
00:15:24 No, relative to a lot of other forms. So tapping the brakes, because there's 50, if you go to the
00:15:32 Alberta website, it's very good for the government, 50 large renewable energy projects in the
00:15:37 application or pending construction stage right now. Like there's a lot and that's ones that are
00:15:42 five million dollars or more. They're usually in the hundreds of millions. It's a good time to
00:15:46 rethink those things. Of course, this will be totally misrepresented to the Central Canadian
00:15:51 Oh, of course, we're Alberta.
00:15:55 Well, let's talk about how effective a strategy this might be.
00:15:58 If it is, in fact, a strategy.
00:15:59 Maybe we're reading way too much into it.
00:16:01 Nigel, you've said maybe it wasn't an explicit discussion.
00:16:05 I hope it was, actually.
00:16:07 Like, I hope that the Greenies' worst fears here is actually true, 1.00
00:16:10 that this was a very intentional and strategic move to retaliate against Ottawa.
00:16:16 And maybe if it wasn't intentional to begin with,
00:16:20 Maybe it was just, oh, we just need to, you know, for land development stuff, we need to look at that.
00:16:25 It seems to actually be a potentially great move for the province to make if they want to strong-arm Ottawa,
00:16:31 because Ottawa seems to have held all the cards, the Supreme Court stacked.
00:16:34 It's chosen exclusively by federal politicians, which is Trudeau and before them Harper.
00:16:41 Do you think this is an effective strategy, if in fact it is a strategy, to strong-arm Ottawa and to relenting on canceling Alberta projects?
00:16:49 Hard to say. On the surface, yes, it is. We can play that game, too. Under the surface,
00:16:59 what will the federal government do? What will the Liberal Party, more to the point,
00:17:04 do with this narrative of an obstreperous, obstructive Alberta government?
00:17:08 Will that be a bit rich? Oh, Alberta's stopping energy projects.
00:17:12 Well, stopping green energy projects.
00:17:14 I would love to see them say that. It'd be hilarious.
00:17:17 Well, it would, but it would sell very well to the central Canadian electorate,
00:17:23 which doesn't believe the best of Alberta in the first place, and would probably react quite
00:17:27 strongly to an emotional pitch from the prime minister. And Lord knows he's going to need some
00:17:33 effective emotional pitches in the two years' time.
00:17:36 Well, let them hit on Alberta. Who cares? 0.84
00:17:38 whether that will actually force them to relent the thing that we need to be building more natural
00:17:49 gas generators now that's what we know how to do that's what we know works and we have
00:17:54 the natural gas to do it with it is the nuclear nothing against nuclear but i think there's a
00:18:01 little bit more of a time lag between saying yes we'll do it and actually turning it on it also
00:18:07 happens to be that we have all hell for a basement of natural gas we have virtually infinite natural
00:18:14 gas under us and it's cheap but you made a point about the ndp a few minutes ago about how this
00:18:20 started they were the ones who actually started decommissioning the coal fire generating plants
00:18:23 which is the by far the cheapest way to generate electricity and all that had happened is that
00:18:31 they have completely bought the program unthinking unquestioning an emotional appeal oh we must do 1.00
00:18:38 our part too so let's get you know more harm is done by stupid people than evil people i don't 1.00
00:18:46 think the ndp were evil but they certainly were stupid on this whole file and now we've got a 1.00
00:18:53 government that is i think trying to pick up the beat well not think it is manifestly obvious 1.00
00:18:57 they're trying to pick up the pieces and make sure that the lights don't go off. 1.00
00:19:01 Well, I think we've got Nigel's slogan, more harm is done by stupid people than even evil people. 0.99
00:19:06 Well, it's not original. I'm sure observed it. 1.00
00:19:09 Yeah. All right. Well, we're going to switch it up to another federal provincial issue here.
00:19:18 That housing, the relationship between housing and immigration.
00:19:23 People watching are probably gonna have different views on immigration.
00:19:26 But, you know, Canada was populated, other than the very first people here, by immigrants.
00:19:31 We've, you know, and our birth rates are low that probably can't be forced that much higher through whatever incentives.
00:19:38 Immigration is a pretty important part of the economy here, especially as we have this upside down pyramid scheme of the welfare state between health care and pensions and things like that.
00:19:48 But whatever you level you think immigration should be at. We have to agree that I would think that if you know housing prices are already so stratospheric that it's your only way if you're a young person today to get a house is that your parents give or lend you the money or you win the lottery that at a minimum we should at least be building enough new homes in Canada so that it stays roughly equivalent with with availability.
00:20:18 relative to immigration. Well, that's very much not the case. Corey, you had a column on this.
00:20:24 Yeah, I did, or the column is coming out soon anyways, and I did talk about that on the show,
00:20:29 I did. Yeah, I mean, the numbers, it's just straight math. The Trudeau government is
00:20:34 stubbornly sticking to their 500,000 a year target for immigration of people to come into Canada.
00:20:39 That was one of the first things asked of the new immigration minister. Will you, even progressive
00:20:43 outlets are starting to question, would you start considering slowing it down? We've got a problem.
00:20:46 We said no.
00:20:47 Not cutting it, but just slowing it down the growth.
00:20:49 If anything, we might even increase it, he said, actually.
00:20:52 So we have $500,000 planned to come in every year.
00:20:55 Our housing units right now, and that's housing, it's apartments, that's houses, it's everything, is roughly about $230,000.
00:21:01 So, I mean, this is a...
00:21:02 And not every immigrant needs their own unit, because there's a lot of families coming.
00:21:05 That's right.
00:21:06 It's not straight across, but it's certainly not enough.
00:21:09 Plus, if they're coming in, either whether the immigrant can't find a new home or they get into the bidding and the costs go up.
00:21:16 because we're having difficulty with citizens here now, affording to get into either buying
00:21:20 a home, as you said, or even renting. It's eating a larger and larger part of people's incomes.
00:21:25 This is a collision course going on, and it's going to lead to some very, very big challenges.
00:21:30 I looked up some of the numbers because we were talking a bit earlier, you know,
00:21:33 what's the incentive? Why is the government so stuck on this? Well, it's according to the IMF.
00:21:37 So if Canada sticks to its immigration targets, we will see our GDP increase by 1.5% because 0.61
00:21:43 in incoming immigration does generate activity and GDP. But of course, when you break it down
00:21:49 to per capita GDP, that's where the difference lies, because that will drop not by 15.5%. But
00:21:57 they're predicting 0.2% to 0.5%. Because sure, you've increased the economy by one and a half
00:22:02 percent, but you're spreading it amongst 500,000 extra people every year. And so let's, you know,
00:22:08 more people will have less, but it helps them balance the books, it helps them avoid the R word,
00:22:13 there's no recession as long as the GDP is ostensibly growing. But this again, as you said,
00:22:18 it's a pyramid scheme, and it's going to crash eventually. We can't just keep maintaining this
00:22:23 by pumping people into support to the population demographic changes we have, we've got to get the
00:22:28 housing. Nigel, you don't have to be anti-immigration to have legitimate concerns about
00:22:35 this stuff. I mean, you can be very pro-immigration, say, well, first of all, I'm not sure any society
00:22:41 in the world can absorb this proportion of people. I mean, I think reasonable people would agree
00:22:47 that a society can absorb a certain number of newcomers from foreign languages, foreign
00:22:56 religions, foreign cultures. We can absorb a certain proportion every year. What is the
00:23:01 proportion we can absorb and what point does it tip over that we can't? I don't know. I mean,
00:23:07 There's a lot of examples in Europe that they have absorbed a lot more than they can handle. Canada's been relatively successful-ish in absorbing people, but at some point it's going to tip over.
00:23:21 But now it's getting into a very beyond the traditional cultural arguments, which dominate discussions of immigration. It's now getting into basic economics of it.
00:23:30 And that is much more difficult for the liberals to argue with, saying, yeah, housing is a problem, but we're going to continue to bring in many more people every year than we're actually building the necessary homes for.
00:23:44 Do you think, you know, if the government continues on this, and the conservatives haven't, the conservatives have been so shy around this because they don't want to get painted as anti-immigrant.
00:23:55 I mean, saying, well, we're not going to bring in half a million a year.
00:23:58 We're going to bring in 4.5, you know, 450,000 a year.
00:24:02 The liberals are saying, well, you're racists.
00:24:04 Even if Canada still had the highest immigration levels in the world, it's less than the liberals. 0.89
00:24:08 Therefore, you're racist.
00:24:08 The conservatives have been very tepid around this.
00:24:11 I don't know where they're going to go with it.
00:24:12 But do you think, regardless of what parties in power, this housing issue with immigration poses a risk of causing an anti-immigration backlash
00:24:23 that could maybe turn to a naster form of xenophobia?
00:24:27 I hope it doesn't come to that, Derek.
00:24:29 I really hope it doesn't come to that.
00:24:32 But you are going to be seeing more stories
00:24:34 about immigrants living in tense cities.
00:24:37 Because if there literally is no place for them to go,
00:24:42 what are they going to do?
00:24:43 They will do what they can,
00:24:45 and they will find temporary accommodation.
00:24:49 And it's going to be a terrible story for the liberals.
00:24:52 We've already got that.
00:24:53 Look, that just happened in Toronto.
00:24:54 Now Toronto's screaming for money to house these poor people 1.00
00:24:58 who we invite to our shores, and we have got to work for them to stay.
00:25:01 That's right.
00:25:02 So, I mean, keep this up, and that's only going to be a growing problem.
00:25:08 That, I think, is going to be a backlash against the government 1.00
00:25:11 that once more was stupid as opposed to manifestly evil 1.00
00:25:16 for just not getting it right. 1.00
00:25:19 I mean, you can have different ideological ideas,
00:25:21 whether it's about green energy or climate change
00:25:25 or about the level of immigration.
00:25:27 But whatever your ideological idea is,
00:25:30 you've at least got to do it properly
00:25:32 and according to the mathematics.
00:25:34 I thought Corey was off on an interesting point there,
00:25:37 but you didn't go very far into it.
00:25:39 And that was, is the impetus to bring in more immigrants,
00:25:43 to bring in more taxpayers,
00:25:46 because the whole social benefit scheme in Canada
00:25:48 is actually a massive Ponzi scheme.
00:25:51 And we could not depend, like this generation could not depend on the generation that's following to, frankly, pay the bills, to pay the CPP, to pay the OAS, to pay the GIS, to pay the cost of health care.
00:26:06 You know, so you bring in more immigrants, you have more taxpayers, and now we've got enough money, and I'll be somewhere else by the time that all this comes home to roost. 1.00
00:26:18 I have to wonder whether that's really what it's all about.
00:26:22 Well, that's maybe where I want to go next.
00:26:25 And this one's going to be a bit more politically sensitive by its nature.
00:26:29 Immigration, the politics of immigration in a lot of countries is sometimes set by ideology,
00:26:36 but often it's more just practical politics, stacking the deck one way or another to favor one political party or another.
00:26:44 And some of that will overlap to an extent. But like you look in the United States, generally Democrats favor immigration more than Republicans do. Both are generally fairly pro-immigration, but, you know, Democrats more so.
00:26:59 But one of the big reasons for that is that recent immigrants and visible minorities vote in significantly larger numbers, proportionally Democrat.
00:27:09 So the Democrats have a political incentive for higher immigration, whereas Republicans have a political incentive for lower immigration.
00:27:19 And there's a similar, although maybe not as strong, correlation in Canada that, you know, how many, you've all heard it before with some older immigrants.
00:27:28 Well, I, my family came here under Trudeau, senior Trudeau, so I feel obliged to vote liberal. The liberals have painted themselves very effectively as the party of immigrants, rightly or wrongly, they have.
00:27:42 You know, Mulroney opened Canada up to record levels of immigration. He passed the official multiculturalism act, but somehow did not steal the political star as the party of immigration from the liberals.
00:27:52 The Liberals have retained it. The Conservatives closed the gap quite a bit when with the Harper majority victory in 2011, you know, with Jason Kenney's work and things like that.
00:28:02 But that was fleeting. That seemed to have been largely a one-off kind of thing.
00:28:07 The Liberals do seem to have a strong partisan interest in higher immigration because there are people who are more likely to vote Liberal once they can get their citizenship than not.
00:28:21 Is that what's driving this and the consequences of these kind of insane levels of immigration be damned? 1.00
00:28:28 Or is it just that they think it's the right thing to do?
00:28:31 Well, I go back to what I just said.
00:28:33 I do think that the incentive, the economic incentive is very strong.
00:28:38 Bring in more people, pay more bills, worry about the consequences in the end when they have to be worried about.
00:28:46 But for now, we need more taxpayers.
00:28:48 That, I think, is the driving thing.
00:28:50 Because the bringing in more people also brings in more carbon dioxide emitters.
00:28:58 It's not going to make the net zero any easier to meet by 2035 if between now and then you bring in, what, another 6 million people?
00:29:10 That's counterproductive in a lot of ways.
00:29:13 Carbon dioxide emitters, that is what we should just call humans now.
00:29:16 Well, consumers and carbon dioxide emitters, that's right.
00:29:20 Corey, same thing to you. Do you think this is driven by, rightly or wrongly, this is driven by the partisan political incentive for the liberals that, you know, immigrate, at least more recent immigrants, it's less of a withholder, more established immigrants, but this, that they're more likely to vote liberal and that's why they want to bring these people in in such numbers?
00:29:41 I think secondary to the economic case, that could be part of it for sure, because traditionally, demographically, that's a better area.
00:29:46 But those who came in and felt gratitude towards, say, Trudeau Sr. didn't come in and have to spend their two first years in a tent camp,
00:29:53 waiting for a year to find a doctor for a checkup, and having an increasingly hostile citizenry,
00:30:00 which is going to happen if, again, we don't properly integrate new Canadians.
00:30:05 I don't know if they're going to feel such a sense of gratitude to the existing government for the situation they got put in
00:30:10 as past immigrant, you know, immigrants may have had. So I wouldn't count on their support later. 0.72
00:30:14 Okay. Well, we're going to change from kind of federal government to Trudeau more personally.
00:30:21 So everyone knows Justin Trudeau and Sophie Gregor Trudeau split. They put out kind of
00:30:29 at the same time, simultaneous statements that I think were very, you could tell there was a lot
00:30:35 of communication strategists behind this. The deal was already arranged to make it as neat as possible. And in there, they included a very reasonable and humane plea for privacy for their families that we try to, you know, keep
00:30:52 try not to make the personal political here. And the media more or less do normally respect that, at least for liberals, liberals, private lives are generally considered more or less off limits.
00:31:03 But then, and we're going to have to bring the picture up here. I think it was about two days later, Justin Trudeau posts this picture of him and his son. I didn't even know what his son looks like. He has appeared in photos. It's not like they've been totally sequestered and hidden, but haven't really been trotted out too much.
00:31:22 To Trudeau's credit, you know, he hasn't used his kids' props too much, at least that I've seen.
00:31:27 But then he trots out his son as a prop here, and they're both dressed in pink, and, you know, it's labeled Team Barbie.
00:31:35 And, I mean, it's fine, go to see Barbie.
00:31:37 I'm disappointed I couldn't take my daughter to see Barbie here.
00:31:40 My wife took her instead, because I had to watch the baby. 1.00
00:31:44 But, you know, it's fine.
00:31:48 You really want to see Barbie?
00:31:50 Out of all movies I could watch with my daughter in a theater, it looked like a funny one.
00:31:54 It probably had its moments.
00:31:55 Like, if you're going to go to a movie theater with a six-year-old girl, I mean, you could probably see worse. 0.98
00:32:01 You could probably see worse.
00:32:03 It sounded kind of funny with some jokes that go over the heads of kids, but we'll meet in an adult.
00:32:09 So, no problem with that.
00:32:12 But just, I can't put my finger on it, but it was just the look of them.
00:32:17 I've used this term for Trudeau before we have a word in German for it it's very hard to pronounce
00:32:23 which translates roughly a punchable face and he just had such a punchable face in it
00:32:34 it's smug it's that smug little but did whatever else you think it was very clearly
00:32:40 sending some kind of message using his son as a prop like less than 48 hours after he makes a plea
00:32:47 for privacy and it just reminded me of you know uh harry and megan merkel touring around the media
00:32:55 going on oprah screaming please respect our privacy you know just kind of like that uh that
00:33:01 that south park episode and harry and megan's privacy tour gory well yeah i mean you know stop
00:33:09 You know, give us our privacy. And they're holding signs and marching in front of the cameras. And within two days, there he is. And it wasn't a case of he'd gone to the theater and some individual had taken a picture with their camera and posted it. This was a staged, posed, hey, look at me. But you know, it's pure Trudeau. It's pure, it has to be about him. It's that shallow, you know, all eyes on me. Look at me. I'm the dad going through a separation.
00:33:37 You know, somebody on social media pointed out an interesting thing.
00:33:39 You know, maybe his messaging was actually more petty than that.
00:33:41 Even it was actually directed towards Sophie.
00:33:43 Hey, I got him for the weekend.
00:33:45 Look what I'm doing.
00:33:46 That's speculation.
00:33:47 But you see, when you're going to play that game and you're inviting that speculation.
00:33:50 Well, that's the problem.
00:33:50 Yeah, you invite it.
00:33:51 Just, you know, you have your personal pictures.
00:33:53 I have pictures with my kids.
00:33:55 I do my political stuff on Twitter.
00:33:57 And boy, I invite the backlash and the headaches.
00:33:59 But I don't post my family pictures on there.
00:34:01 I post them in other areas where I'm sharing with family.
00:34:05 He's choosing to expose that.
00:34:07 It doesn't mean it justifies hostile reactions or attacks against his kids,
00:34:11 but it also says, dude, your request for privacy was more than a little overblown.
00:34:15 Yeah.
00:34:16 You know, last week I wrote something right after the news came down.
00:34:22 I said, you know what, I disagree with Mr. Trudeau on just about everything,
00:34:25 but on this, I understand the situation.
00:34:29 And I'm happy to just say, go take the space you need, you and Sophie.
00:34:36 And then the first thing that comes up is this.
00:34:38 I kind of wish I hadn't written it.
00:34:39 I feel like I've been deceived, you know.
00:34:42 Surely.
00:34:42 Wouldn't be the first time.
00:34:44 But the guy just can't help himself.
00:34:47 He's a publicity hound.
00:34:49 If the cameras are not pointing in his direction, he's over here, you know.
00:34:54 It's sad.
00:34:55 It actually is kind of sad that a fellow with that mentality is leading the country.
00:35:01 And it does make it hard, I think, for other politicians to make the same plea who actually mean it.
00:35:07 Like, hey, I'm going through something personal here.
00:35:11 Please leave my family out of this.
00:35:13 This is our personal life.
00:35:15 We shouldn't get chewed up at home for this.
00:35:18 You know, they're human beings.
00:35:19 And people have respected it.
00:35:20 I mean, there haven't been paparazzi climbing the walls, trying to get pictures of the Trudeau family or tailing Sophie to see if she has a new date yet or anything like that.
00:35:30 But again, at the same time, it would be more like, OK, I'm going to leave the family thing here and we're going to have the political thing here.
00:35:35 But no, he's still got them quite well immersed in the public eye.
00:35:39 Yeah. And I have a feeling that Sophie Grigor, you still call her Trudeau?
00:35:44 Maybe she keeps the name because it's got some cachet.
00:35:46 I don't think the court settlement is rich yet, so legally she's probably... 1.00
00:35:51 But who knows, maybe she keeps it because it's got some cachet, who knows.
00:35:56 But I have a feeling she's not going to just quietly ride into the sunset.
00:36:00 I mean, most people still remember Margaret Trudeau, and she used that platform into some kind of career.
00:36:10 Sophie Trudeau is probably going to do something similar. 1.00
00:36:14 I doubt she's going to ride into the sunset.
00:36:16 She doesn't seem to have that craving of attention that we see out of Justin, which I think he inherited from Margaret.
00:36:23 Sophie likes the spotlight a bit, but she doesn't seem to be quite as obsessed with it.
00:36:28 So I don't know if a comparison to Margaret is fair.
00:36:31 But if she reinvents herself as a public figure, then... 0.98
00:36:33 The name's an asset.
00:36:35 Yeah, yeah. And Jen Gerson, the line, I think, had a... 1.00
00:36:38 I'm guessing it was her who wrote it, which is the editors.
00:36:41 But the line, they had a good column on this about, okay, well, she's off limits for now. 0.71
00:36:47 But if she tries to reinvent herself as a public figure, she becomes fair game again.
00:36:51 And I have a hard time believing she's just going to totally go away and live like the Unabomber. 1.00
00:36:58 We'll see.
00:37:00 Probably not like the Unabomber, no.
00:37:04 Well, the last few years, he was really mailing it in.
00:37:06 It's usually me who pulls these stunts on.
00:37:12 James, who's operating the camera today, got that one.
00:37:17 Okay.
00:37:19 Okay, the Conservative leader's new clothes.
00:37:23 So, Pierre Paulyab has been undergoing some of an image makeover lately.
00:37:28 He's gotten rid of the glasses.
00:37:29 I'm guessing he either got laser eye or contacts.
00:37:32 I find it looks a bit weird because I feel like he feels like he looks he looks almost naked with
00:37:38 it and now that night might just be I remember my dad had a mustache for a time while I was a kid
00:37:41 and for a few years and he shaved it and I was like who the hell is this guy maybe just get so
00:37:46 used to someone and he's just always had glasses I think since he was born but you know he's been
00:37:53 shown less in his pinstripe suits and more you know in athletic gear and doing stuff he's been
00:38:00 working out uh but now there's um now these these new uh these new ads that have come out
00:38:06 not attack ads they're positive ads and positive ads are so much less cool than attack ads i like
00:38:13 attack ads even bad attack actually especially bad attack ads but these ones are they're kind
00:38:18 of corny it's got his wife talking about how uh he's a good guy cares about where you're going
00:38:25 not where you're from uh he's got one with uh one of his kids i think his boy um they're nice
00:38:32 and fluffy uh Nigel do you think these are gonna have i don't know any real effect of trying to
00:38:38 rebrand him from being kind of the i hate to say this but the millhouse poindextery political nerd 0.63
00:38:45 attack dog who's always going for the throat to be you know the nicer dad husband you think this
00:38:51 is these might be effective or his image makeover in general effective? Well look women vote and 1.00
00:38:59 women like Trudeau or have in the past so there's no good saying well I don't care about all that 1.00
00:39:06 sort of thing I'm just going to have to you know change the carry on and get the message right
00:39:12 and we'll see see where it goes on the election because it may not go well. So you know about
00:39:20 Two months ago, we ran something about how women didn't like Bolivar.
00:39:24 And a lot of the things that were claimed by various people working for the Toronto Star, the Globe, and Mail, the CBC,
00:39:34 were that he was harsh, that he always seemed to be ready to fight, he was aggressive, he was nice.
00:39:43 All right, well, if that's an issue for women, it's not an issue for men. 0.84
00:39:48 But if it's an issue for women, what are you going to do about that? 0.72
00:39:52 Why don't we do a blue pullover?
00:39:53 No, that didn't work for Harper. 1.00
00:39:56 Let's not do blue pullovers.
00:39:59 You know?
00:40:00 So we go, how about laser eye surgery?
00:40:04 Yes, we could do that.
00:40:05 And look, I know a really good hairdresser.
00:40:08 We could tweak it a bit.
00:40:10 And so the thing starts to go. 0.98
00:40:12 And it's horrible to have to admit the politics comes down to this kind of trash. 0.98
00:40:19 But it does. 0.99
00:40:20 Well, I don't think it is just women as well.
00:40:23 Image matters to both male and female voters.
00:40:27 Yeah, but his male image was fine.
00:40:29 I think it was better than it was with women. 1.00
00:40:33 But I think even a lot of men thought, he looks like a bit of a nerd.
00:40:37 Not sure I could have a beer with him kind of thing.
00:40:39 So I think, you know, he might be actually even, it's probably geared primarily at women, but I think also at men. You want to appear, you know, one of the famous, I think they started polling this in the 2000 US presidential election. Who would you rather have a beer with? George Bush or Al Gore? George Bush beat the hell out of Al Gore, which was funny because George Bush had quit drinking at that time and somehow seemed to become dumber when he was sober.
00:41:06 but uh that really wasn't a fair fight come on like go to my way to avoid love to drape have a
00:41:17 beer with george bush like that would be a good time yeah um but that was a that was an interesting
00:41:23 kind of poll it's not saying how you're gonna vote but it said a lot about relatability and
00:41:27 likability and i think this might also be a bit with the men that you know he's gonna seem a
00:41:34 little less nerdy, you know, like, not doesn't look like a guy who's like, you know, a conservative
00:41:39 intern and just worked just from there. Somebody's been a bit more in the real world.
00:41:44 So what we've actually got to find out is who is advising him? Like, who's the wizard who is
00:41:48 taking charge of the external profile and is making these decisions on behalf of him and the
00:41:56 party? RuPaul. Oh, God. But I mean, popular, you know, as shallow as it is, it is a popularity
00:42:03 contest. And if anything's been nagging them or hanging over them in the polls, the party's
00:42:09 growing and growing and doing better. But personal popularity, he's people don't like him. He's been
00:42:15 doing okay. Yeah, but he's not been matching the party. So I mean, they've maxed out what they can
00:42:20 do with policy. Now let's soften the person. I think it's a good tactic. It's unfortunate that
00:42:27 policy alone isn't necessarily enough, whether it's male or female, though, they feel with the
00:42:31 person. We saw that with Preston Manning too, when he softened things up in the 90s, suddenly the
00:42:35 glasses were gone, the hair was a little better. So he got rid of that, hi, Preston Manning voice.
00:42:40 And he never became prime minister. But to be honest, as a younger Canadian voter at that time,
00:42:44 I was already a reformer, but I found that more appealing. I was just a little more, a little less
00:42:48 dorky, a little more human. So I think we're going to see more of it. The big question,
00:42:53 like you're asking those, whether or not it's going to work, that we'll see.
00:42:56 You know, Corey, it depends a lot at the election time as to what kind of a mess we're in.
00:43:01 Like, if you've got a serious medical condition, you want a good doctor, and it won't necessarily be the personality doctor.
00:43:11 It might be somebody who's a miserable sub to work with, but he knows where to put the knife, and he has a perfect record.
00:43:17 So if farms are good, then the voters may well choose somebody who's likable and wears odd socks.
00:43:25 But image matters, and it does say a lot.
00:43:27 Like, when someone comes for a job interview with me, I'll admit it.
00:43:33 Come in with a face tattoo, I'm going to have a really hard time getting over that, even if you've got great qualifications.
00:43:41 I'm going to get sued now by everyone with a face tattoo who's applied for a job here and not getting more.
00:43:44 Well, there's been a lot of those.
00:43:46 But, I mean, like, your presentation matters.
00:43:48 Are you dressed for the job? 0.97
00:43:50 Did you dress like a slob? 1.00
00:43:52 Did you comb your hair? 0.99
00:43:54 Do you care about how you present yourself?
00:43:56 So it's not just that. And, you know, we all don't think so, but we've, you know, there's ample studies to show how a politician looks matters. How someone applying for a job, men and women matters. Even men are more likely to hire handsome looking other men.
00:44:14 just because maybe
00:44:17 it's been almost a year now
00:44:20 that's why I hired you two
00:44:21 bring up the levels around here
00:44:24 or maybe it's a proof that I'm just
00:44:26 so much less shallow that you two are here
00:44:28 but I mean
00:44:30 image matters and it's
00:44:32 unfortunate we all like to pretend
00:44:34 well it does to everybody else but not us but
00:44:36 even subconsciously it's hard
00:44:38 to get over and the way
00:44:40 we were just talking about
00:44:42 Justin Trudeau and his
00:44:44 punchable face, the way 0.79
00:44:46 he looks. I mean, just for some,
00:44:48 some people love that stuff, but
00:44:50 others of us, I don't really know what was wrong
00:44:52 with the substance of it, other than I looked at it
00:44:54 and said, hmm, I really don't
00:44:56 like him today. Oh, it's just so visibly fake.
00:44:59 That's the right thing.
00:45:00 But, you know, this stuff,
00:45:03 I don't know, I think it
00:45:04 sinks in and it matters on some level.
00:45:07 You're going to work that
00:45:08 word, how many syllables in it? Ten was it?
00:45:10 I am almost surely mispronouncing
00:45:12 it because it's the last part of it sounds like history, Geschichte, but I pronounce it
00:45:18 Bekfeifen Geschichte. And any Germans watching right now, feel free to very much correct me on 0.97
00:45:26 it because I feel like it's wrong. Bekfeifen Geschichte. Bekfeifen Geschichte. Give me the
00:45:33 spelling. A punchable face or a face in need of punching or a slappable face, all acceptable 0.84
00:45:38 translations. And all things I feel. Okay, Cory, Nigel, thank you very much for joining. I thank
00:45:46 all of you for joining us today. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to
00:45:50 westernstandard.news right now. If you're not a member, sign up at least for the free newsletter
00:45:55 to stay in contact as federal legislation is now having us banned from Facebook and Google.
00:46:01 If you want to stay in touch with the roughly 50 news articles and opinion columns we're publishing
00:46:08 a day our video content podcasts and things like that you need to stay in touch with us because
00:46:12 ottawa has done its best to make sure that you can so go up sign up right now and if you can
00:46:18 please support us by becoming a member we've got a special promotion on it of only five dollars a
00:46:22 month right now thank you very much for joining us and god bless here's an update on commodity
00:46:27 prices in lethbridge for today cash barley is down three dollars at 385 feed wheat is also down three
00:46:34 at $3.87 and corn is steady at $3.86 per metric ton. In the milling wheat markets, September
00:46:41 Minneapolis futures are lower 7.5 cents at $8.23 per bushel, with local hard red spring
00:46:46 bid for August movement at $10.20 per bushel. Looking at canola, November futures are down
00:46:52 $6.40 at $7.84.50 per ton, with delivered values for August-September movement at $17.44
00:46:59 per bushel. In the Pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices are trading at $0.32 per pound
00:47:05 and yellow peas are at $10.70 per bushel. And in the livestock markets, October live cattle
00:47:11 added $0.70 at $1.80.40 per hundredweight. For more information on pricing or picked up options,
00:47:17 give me a call. I'm Matt Buscombe at Marketplace Commodities. Accurate real-time marketing
00:47:22 information and pricing options. Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA,
00:47:28 our gun rights would have been taken long long ago these guys are on the front lines
00:47:33 helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in canada and more
00:47:40 importantly educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people
00:47:44 We've become a member. It's absolutely worth every penny.