Western Standard - March 17, 2022


The Pipeline: Jean machine wins by-election.

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
EXCLUSIVE: CPC leadership candidate Pierre Poilievre. LIVE - Triggered: Upcoming Alberta Technology symposium.

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

183.28

Word count

4,601

Sentence count

193

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Weekly Panel News Roundup with Melanie Rizdinning in for Derek Fildebrand, who is out of town with his family. We discuss the by-election results in Fort McMurray-Lack Labish, Jason Kenney's victory in the Alberta election, and much more!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening and welcome to the pipeline. This is the Western
00:00:22 Standards Weekly Panel News Roundup Show. I'm Cory Morgan in place of Derek Fildebrand,
00:00:29 who's usually here in this role our publisher he was indisposed today so uh rather than having
00:00:35 Derek's presence you're stuck with me hosting and we do have our senior reporter Melanie Rizdin
00:00:41 sitting in for Derek today in a sense yes hello welcome to the pipeline again thank you and as
00:00:47 always our news editor Dave Naylor how's it going good good don't put me through this it's been a
00:00:54 lot of interviews one of those one word answer pulling out the words and come on we're a bunch
00:00:59 you're doing better than your wife i am i don't want to go into that no no we won't go into that
00:01:06 not this time uh i am good at getting in trouble with that either way we do have a good packed
00:01:11 show it's a great political week uh particularly in this last few days and we'll go into some of
00:01:17 that i guess we'll start by getting some of the housekeeping out of the way though this show's
00:01:20 been doing great for wow this is the flagship show it's been over a year we've been doing this one
00:01:24 weekly and we are in our studio so people have watched this regularly might have noticed we've
00:01:31 always been scrunched in quite close knee to knee on those things we've got room now to spread out
00:01:36 you guys don't have to smell the whatever I ate for lunch and things like that we're
00:01:39 much more comfortable and we can focus on the issues so we are expanding and things are doing
00:01:44 great and that is thanks to our sponsors and our subscribers just reminding everybody if you haven't
00:01:50 taken out a subscription for the Western Standard yet, and thousands have. It's been fantastic.
00:01:55 Get on there, westernstandardonline.com. Take out a subscription. This is how we stay independent.
00:02:00 This is how we don't have to be controlled or told by the federal government or anybody else
00:02:05 what we have to cover. We cover what's important. It's a free trial for two weeks. No risk. Take it
00:02:11 on, and after two weeks, you can choose whether or not to continue, and for $10 a month, you will
00:02:15 find it worth it. Almost everybody does. So maybe let's get into the news now and remind people of
00:02:22 that news we write and why you can get those exclusive access to stories such as that. The
00:02:27 big item today is the Gene Machine winning the by-election. Last night, Fort McMurray-Lack
00:02:32 Labish, maybe I'll get you to frame all that up, Dave. Sure, the Gene Machine was in full power
00:02:38 last night. By election up there, Gene ran on a platform opposing Jason Kenney. He said he would
00:02:45 do his best to get rid of him while working from within caucus. Obviously, that resonated with some
00:02:50 of the voters in Fort McMurray, Lackabish, and he won with 64%, I think, of the ballots. NDP
00:02:59 candidate was well back, just about 19%. And Paul Hinman, the leader of the Wild Rose,
00:03:06 distant, distant third, just about 11%. So there's, Brian Jean is now a UCP, or when he's sworn in,
00:03:20 he'll be a UCP MLA, and he's going to be letting the games begin then, if not beforehand,
00:03:27 then we'll talk about those developments. Yeah, well, and it'll be giving our newsroom
00:03:31 some interesting copy to cover. So Melanie, I mean, you can look forward to a new caucus member
00:03:36 coming into the ucp yet at the same time opposing his own party i mean what a you know crazed
00:03:42 dynamic i mean something unique we got going on here yeah i think uh what i found interesting was
00:03:48 a tweet last night from kenny welcoming him and congratulating him uh so uh you know i i guess
00:03:57 one would have to look at that and say is kenny sort of trying to say that uh that the opposition
00:04:04 that's going to be coming at him is not something he's concerned of or is he you know trying to save
00:04:09 face don't know or is he just trying to not seem ungracious that's true that's right yeah
00:04:16 he is technically on the team i see those great thing tweets that come out and i'll go into one
00:04:20 of my own favorite stories anyways of one of my high and low points on twitter when i got blocked
00:04:24 by president trump uh that was back when uh senator mccain had been diagnosed with terminal
00:04:30 brain cancer and everybody they knew that donald and mccain didn't have a good relationship you
00:04:37 figure well he's going to say something he's got to say something it was well into the evening
00:04:40 and he still had said nothing has been dominating the news and suddenly get this little terse tweet
00:04:44 that just says uh sorry to hear about your illness mr senator mccain melania and i have
00:04:51 you in our thoughts get well soon wow i was in shock and i just retweeted quickly i responded
00:04:56 to it and said get well soon so he doesn't have the flu man and i said well better late than never
00:05:01 and then all of a sudden i got blocked like i was like well through the through the entire campaign
00:05:05 quite don't forget that uh kenny never mentioned gene gene once by name no even the day of the
00:05:11 election for the by-election he just referred to it as the ucp candidate didn't mention him at all
00:05:17 and he says well i hope the ucp candidate wins so i mean he probably had less sleep than anybody
00:05:24 in alberta last night tossing and turning about what he's going to do well that's it and that's
00:05:29 what i mean about those grudging you know you got to go through the forms you get we're supposedly
00:05:32 on the same team now we're working together but it's forced i mean it's it's not to be a fly on
00:05:38 the wall in the first caucus meeting when brian gene is there is going to be uh interesting yeah
00:05:43 well and especially when he's uh his hashtag in the tweet is renew the ucp it's sort of telling
00:05:50 which direction he's going right in his victory speech he would made it very clear kenny must go
00:05:57 all right so he's not being conciliatory no anyway it's just what an awkward situation that's got to
00:06:03 be in i mean like us going to a staff meeting and there's one member has been demanding your
00:06:06 resignation all the way through and you still have to try and work cooperatively throughout it
00:06:11 uh boy it's going to be other people have problems too corey what about what do you think the
00:06:17 ndp result will mean for them well that's another one and that was a disappointment i mean the ndp
00:06:23 18.5 they were 30 in 2015 up in there and about 24 so this was a decline i mean a by-election
00:06:30 should be an opportunity even if it wasn't winnable to show we're gaining ground we're
00:06:35 the government waiting we're coming up there and yeah melanie like that that didn't develop at all
00:06:39 yeah i was i was actually quite surprised with um the low votership for the ndp as well considering
00:06:47 what you would have mentioned about what they were pulling out before um and uh you know even
00:06:53 just the support rurally in some of the uh the more rural areas northern alberta uh you would
00:07:00 you would have thought that they would have performed a little bit better in this election
00:07:05 but you know maybe it's uh a foreshadow of where things are going who knows the ndp is pulling very
00:07:12 well in the big cities calgary and edmonton they're they're dominating uh yeah no they're
00:07:18 not dead in the water by any means but this would have been an indication to be able to show some
00:07:22 momentum some forward momentum even if they weren't winning you know if you've gained a
00:07:25 little on the last time it's showing you're moving ahead they're moving back that's not
00:07:29 never a good sign maybe we'll get on to the other person who had a hard time in that by-election
00:07:33 as well but first i'll talk about one of our sponsors one of the other reasons we maintain
00:07:37 ourselves as an independent outlet here uh we got to pay our bills you know like the cbc they've
00:07:43 they pay their bills with our money we don't and uh we've got some great sponsors and one of them
00:07:49 is the canadian shooting sports association and those guys we talk about them every week they are
00:07:54 a great sponsor and they're a great organization if you own firearms if you're looking to own
00:07:58 firearms i mean the name says it all it's an association of firearm owners for the safe
00:08:03 responsible legal use of firearms it's got all sorts of resources whether you want to collect or
00:08:09 target shoot or hunt it's up to you go there they've got videos online they've got links to
00:08:14 things like firearm shows and then again most importantly they are standing up for your rights
00:08:18 they are pushing back they have three different legal challenges against the liberal government
00:08:22 on behalf of firearm owners because the liberals keep re-categorizing firearms and slowly but
00:08:28 surely are illegalizing everything we've got turning legal firearms owners into illegal ones
00:08:33 taking them away these guys are pushing back in the courts because somebody has to and you
00:08:38 got to stand up for yourself so check them out canadian shooting sports association take out
00:08:42 a membership with them help them with these legal challenges so you can keep enjoying and safely
00:08:46 maintaining firearms so after that yes the next person in the race was paul hinman uh
00:08:54 what do you think dave absolutely disastrous for uh for paul uh he had spent months up in the
00:09:00 writing, months and months and months, door knocking, putting up signs. I mean, in fairness,
00:09:04 he put his all into it. But disastrous results, 11%. I talked to him before, earlier last week,
00:09:14 he said he thought might get around 35%. And if he got that number, he was hoping a vote split
00:09:20 between the NDP and the UCP may enable him to, you know, just sort of slip up the middle. But he
00:09:26 But he fell far short and it didn't take long for party brass to get involved.
00:09:33 The president of WIP put out a statement announcing an immediate investigation into Hinman's leadership
00:09:42 and his actions in the election.
00:09:48 Rick Northey, the president, noted that Hinman inserted himself basically into the race.
00:09:55 says i'm the leader i'm going to take it excuse me uh and uh northy said you know perhaps a local
00:10:02 candidate uh would have done better so there's going to be some dissensions in the ranks uh
00:10:08 certainly for the ucp well for the walrus independence yeah so i mean uh again comes
00:10:15 to that unity melanie like there's something with the conservatives that keeps you writing
00:10:18 you must almost get tired of writing infighting stories about conservative leaning parties but
00:10:22 it just is an ongoing issue well i was what i was quite surprised with is seeing uh you know over
00:10:28 the last few weeks there's been a lot of talk of the growing support for the notion of independence
00:10:37 out west and so you know there's been polls that have been done that showed that that interest is
00:10:45 growing and i would have thought you would have seen that in this election personally other polls
00:10:51 have given the whip, you know, 15 to 20%, 18%. And their headman fell far below that. So I think
00:10:59 he's in big trouble, Corey. He could be. I mean, it was a difficult gamble politically. As you said
00:11:04 before too, I don't know how many resources they had up there to begin with. Or I mean, a local
00:11:08 candidate will do better if you've got a strong local candidate, but I don't know who they might
00:11:12 have had. And one thing I do know with Paul is he's a tireless campaigner. I mean, he just hammered
00:11:17 on it. If it had been a weak Wildrose Independence Party candidate, they might have been down in that
00:11:22 5%, 4% level like the Liberals as well. I mean, it's always interpretation after, and that's what
00:11:26 the party's going to be studying, though, whether they could have done better. And that was the
00:11:29 gamble Paul took. I mean, if you're a leader and you don't run in it, you can kind of keep some
00:11:33 distance. And if it does poorly, sort of slough it off and make excuses. But he put his own name
00:11:37 on the line on this. And there were a few other parties that may want to consider just folding
00:11:41 up their tents entirely yeah well the alberta party uh i i do love poking at them uh because
00:11:48 they you know as this is actually derek said earlier today they've always been alberta's
00:11:52 biggest paper tagger you know they make so much news they there's always so much attention given
00:11:57 to them and there's so much rah rah and then when election time comes they invariably fall on their
00:12:01 faces and this was no exception where they came in at a 1.7 support number i don't know mel what
00:12:08 what do you think? Is there much of a future with a party that can draw that 1.7?
00:12:12 Well, I mean, clearly that's indicative of perhaps even an awareness issue, perhaps.
00:12:20 You know, I think too, with Wild Rose, you have to sort of wonder, and perhaps there's been enough
00:12:30 time separating the Wild Rose Independence Party from the original Wild Rose, clearly. But for a
00:12:35 of people you got to wonder if there is still sort of a lingering idea perhaps not realizing
00:12:42 the difference the you know um and and again that falls under the awareness are people really paying
00:12:49 attention are they really hearing are they really understanding what these parties are all about
00:12:54 you know are they hearing enough about the alberta party to to know whether they identify with their
00:13:00 policies. Um, you know, I think that's part of the problem. And especially when you're talking
00:13:05 about media and media coverage, uh, it tends to sort of be much louder and obviously more robust
00:13:13 for the bigger, well-known parties. Yeah. Well, in the Alberta party,
00:13:17 part of their problem is they never really have had solid policies. They've always wrapped
00:13:21 themselves around this notion. We're the middle, we're the middle, we're the center. And they
00:13:24 don't take a strong stance on anything because they, there's always that rhetoric from people
00:13:29 saying, well, there's far left and there's far right, but most people are in the middle. Well,
00:13:33 when you come up with a mushy, no stance policy, as these guys keep doing election after election,
00:13:38 sorry, guys, you don't have to go to the far end of a spectrum, but you got to stand somewhere.
00:13:43 But I guess strategically, they didn't, they've got a new leader, Barry Morishida, and he was the
00:13:47 mayor of Brooks, and he's been involved. He didn't put his name on the line running for the Alberta
00:13:51 party up there, or he'd be probably facing the same fate as Paul. This probably won't land on
00:13:56 him, but the Alberta party didn't make any inroads at all in this. This was kind of embarrassing.
00:14:02 So difficult. The Liberal party, they actually did three and a half percent.
00:14:07 That's a bit high for me. Surprisingly, huh?
00:14:10 Well, yeah, and that speaks to a party that really collapsed, though. I mean, in the 90s,
00:14:14 they came actually close to forming government in Alberta at one point, though they were
00:14:19 campaigning from the right, and it was Klein who stole their thunder. But progressively,
00:14:25 they've just kept declining and declining and declining. They're a total non-entity in this
00:14:29 province now. It's an interesting evolution to watch. Okay. Well, I'm going to speak to our next
00:14:35 sponsor and then we'll talk about the biggest loser in this whole race at a moment after that.
00:14:40 So one more sponsor to get through folks, and that is Bitcoinwell.com. Those guys are
00:14:46 a great service and their name sort of describes them much like the Canada Shooting
00:14:51 sports association, bitcoinwell.com. They are an Alberta company. They're throughout Western
00:14:57 Canada, though. They give one-on-one service, help bring you into the world of digital currencies.
00:15:03 They're the middle man in a sense, I guess you could say. They never handle your Bitcoin. Should
00:15:09 you choose to buy it, they facilitate the process. And that's something they're always clear about.
00:15:13 You know, you, they're non-custodial. You control your funds because people worry about that. Digital
00:15:16 currencies. It's new. It's scary. And it's your money. You worked hard for it. These guys have,
00:15:21 they'll show you step-by-step how to get involved, or maybe it's not for you, but you can learn from
00:15:24 them. They have their Bitcoin Academy online to teach you through it and walk you through it.
00:15:28 And corporate plans like we have around here. You can set it up with your company. It's voluntary.
00:15:33 Employees can opt into the program, have a little bit of your paycheck go into a Bitcoin wallet
00:15:39 every month, and the employer matches it for a bit. I should check mine. I may be rich.
00:15:43 You could be.
00:15:44 I've had it for a couple of weeks now.
00:15:45 It must be.
00:15:46 Maybe you don't even need to be here now.
00:15:48 Yeah, I'm going.
00:15:49 But either way, there are a lot of neat options, you know, and ways to diversify your portfolio,
00:15:55 even if it's a modest one like mine, contrary to those online reports of my wealth that I wish were true.
00:16:02 So BitcoinWell.com, check them out.
00:16:05 They're a great sponsor and they're a great service.
00:16:06 And they're a Western company, which is my favorite kind of company.
00:16:09 now the loser from last night though i don't think there was any scenario where he could win
00:16:16 uh what do you think dave what do we got i think it's uh panic stations uh for jason kenney
00:16:24 things started to deteriorate even further last week when the ucp perhaps ucp brass
00:16:31 disqualified two very qualified candidates uh from uh nomination uh attempts uh in writings
00:16:38 that were controlled by Kenny loyalists. Then they took it a step further this week when an
00:16:45 email was sent out to all of Kenny's staffers and all ministerial staffers that, hey, they need to
00:16:52 give up a couple days of their week this week and go on unpaid leave and do some phoning, phoning
00:17:00 around. That just shows you the level of desperation they're at now when we're only three
00:17:06 weeks away from the April 9th Leadership Review in Red Deer. I had a good story this afternoon,
00:17:16 an exclusive one. I spoke with a senior UCP staffer. I've been there for being with the
00:17:22 party forever. He says it's, you know, morale is lower than a snake's belly in a wagon run.
00:17:30 They've been asked to take a 7% wage rollback. And then they're told this week they have to
00:17:36 give up three days' pay. He says it was a slap in the face, quote, unquote. He says the party was
00:17:44 looking for 100 of these staff to show up on the weekends for 12 hours on the weekend,
00:17:51 working the phones. They expected to get 100 people signed up. Right now, they've only got 30.
00:17:57 So he says that bureaucrats will call them. They just have no faith in the Kennedy government
00:18:04 winning. He also added that he had no faith in Brian Jean's winning. So, but the source did say
00:18:14 there's many qualified candidates that are cabinet ministers. But yeah, he doesn't give away. He said
00:18:22 right now it's a coin toss, 50-50. He expects the panic station action of Kenny, who's also a master
00:18:31 organizer to get to work in the next three weeks and he expects Kenny to squeak by with a 55 percent,
00:18:39 60 percent. And if Kenny decides to stay, the source predicts exodus of floor crossing. People
00:18:48 will sit with as independent party members and I'm sure, you know, Brian Jean will be in caucus
00:18:54 encouraging everybody to uh to uh to do that me it may end up being the shortest serving ucp mla
00:19:03 ever if he decides to cross the floor well yeah that's an interesting aspect like you know kenny
00:19:08 has been on the record of saying 50 plus one would be in that form but we know realistically that
00:19:12 wouldn't maybe mel what number do you think would be high enough that jason kenny could comfortably
00:19:17 stay on as the leader well i i think 50 plus one doesn't give you effective leadership i think
00:19:23 you would want to see probably higher than 60 you know 60 65 percent you know where you can sort of
00:19:32 expect that the majority of the people in the room are with you uh but you know i don't know i i think
00:19:40 from from the ucp agm back in november to now he seemed very confident he seemed very uh sure of
00:19:49 this of the options that he had or the chance that he had to win and you know looking at his
00:19:56 sort of reaction now with you know coming out with all of these policy changes and all of these you
00:20:02 know like it almost seems like he's really working extra hard right now to appease different sectors
00:20:09 and and whatnot so i think you can really tell that he certainly is not as confident as he was
00:20:16 then. But I don't think 50 plus one is at all going to be an
00:20:22 effective way to move forward for the UCP.
00:20:25 And the precedent has been set. Ralph Klein, Ed Stelmack, they
00:20:30 went with the mid 70s.
00:20:34 Like with a functional party at a leadership review, usually it's
00:20:37 like 90%. Like you're just going through the motions in the room
00:20:39 says, yeah, we love our leader. Goodbye. And we'll move on to
00:20:41 the next subject.
00:20:42 Bernie again, like 98%.
00:20:44 Yeah, something like that.
00:20:45 And, you know, to get to what Mel's talking about,
00:20:47 Keddie has benefited from the Russian invasion of the Ukraine
00:20:51 and skyrocketing oil prices.
00:20:53 He's got so much cash coming into the Treasury now,
00:20:56 he doesn't know what to do with it.
00:20:57 That's why he's holding daily press conferences,
00:21:00 giving away millions of dollars.
00:21:01 And he's trying to say, look, okay, we went through a tough two years with COVID,
00:21:07 but we're back, Alberta's back, we're booming.
00:21:10 Here's some money, things are going great.
00:21:12 Do you really want to go back to the NDP?
00:21:14 So, I mean, that's, I think, his strategy for the next three weeks.
00:21:18 Well, that gets on to the question, though.
00:21:20 Let's say he pulls it off.
00:21:21 Let's say he gets 60%.
00:21:23 What happens then, though?
00:21:25 As you said, a mass exodus.
00:21:27 What do you think, Melanie?
00:21:28 I mean, we've talked to a number of some pretty discontented MLAs who've already kind of drawn their lines in the sand.
00:21:32 I think they're already there.
00:21:34 They're still only there because this race is looming. 0.99
00:21:36 But once it's passed, no matter what happens, there's going to be some reckoning.
00:21:39 Yeah, that I would agree with.
00:21:41 I think you're right.
00:21:43 Like when it comes, like there are hardliners, I think, that have really come out and shown so much disapproval.
00:21:50 But I think really the only thing that stopped a lot of people from making decisions right now is the fact that there is this leadership review coming up.
00:21:59 So, again, they're just holding on to see what comes.
00:22:03 But then I think if he does hold on to leadership, I think we're going to see a massive shift.
00:22:08 I think talking to Brian Jean at the AGM last year, he thinks once he gets into caucus, he can be the, you know, the unplugging of the corkscrew, so to speak, where all it'll take is a little bit.
00:22:23 MLAs will see that there's no way Kenny can let them keep their jobs, which obviously is very important to them.
00:22:30 And then all of a sudden, the water in the bottle will overflow.
00:22:35 That's what Jean's hoping.
00:22:36 Again, we just can't count Kenny out of anything.
00:22:39 He's a master politician.
00:22:41 He is, but he's really been failing in this role, hasn't he?
00:22:44 At the AGM, I mean, he lost a pretty critical vote there
00:22:47 that would have avoided even a leadership election in the first place.
00:22:53 He might be a little overestimated on some of these things.
00:22:56 And the other thing to keep in mind after that and say he survives
00:22:59 and Brian Jean is in there and some of these discontented MLAs,
00:23:02 to form official party status in Alberta,
00:23:04 All you need, I believe, is it's three or four sitting MLAs to get together.
00:23:08 And now you've officially got official status if 15 of them, which I think is well within possibility, say we're out and we're forming our own side party and caucus.
00:23:18 Well, they only really need two.
00:23:20 There's already two independents.
00:23:22 Two others get fed up.
00:23:23 They can quickly join the independents and bang.
00:23:26 Official party status.
00:23:27 They get all the research money.
00:23:28 And then others may, you know, it takes one.
00:23:30 Sort of the one goes, others may, if they feel the same way, you know, get the courage and do it.
00:23:36 Yeah, I'm sure there's a lot of kind of behind closed doors conversations that are happening in the next three weeks as to people's...
00:23:44 Oh yeah, and as said, we're going to see some political machinations and we're seeing some panic.
00:23:48 I mean, to tap your staffers like that, to say, come on in and arm twist.
00:23:52 And I talked a little bit about that on the show.
00:23:54 That's very dicey, dangerous territory to get to.
00:23:58 These are a government of Alberta employees, and it seems like you're strong arming them
00:24:03 into political activity. I mean, he's already got enough issues with past legal challenges with a
00:24:10 number of actions in the past. They could really get in the soup if they do not very carefully
00:24:15 cross their T's and dot their I's on utilizing those guys on a partisan endeavor. You know what?
00:24:20 It's going to be a great time to be alive the next three weeks for us. Hey, they are our best friend.
00:24:27 they're not boring politics whatever they might be and i mean nobody's gonna yeah the news never
00:24:31 ends these days no and it's only gonna get more hysteric i think as we get closer to that race 0.97
00:24:36 well i think we've covered what's up for this week thank you guys all for tuning in thank you
00:24:41 melanie and dave for putting up with this substitute host today and you do kind of better
00:24:49 than derek he's ah you know he probably won't watch anyway so if he if he's not on he doesn't
00:24:54 much yeah so thank you all for tuning in and uh we will see you all next week on the pipeline or
00:25:02 if you're uh triggered with cory morgan watcher i'll see you guys tomorrow morning at 11 30