Western Standard - July 15, 2021


The Pipeline: July 14, 2021

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Mountain Standard Time - July 13th, 2021 Mountain Standard Time - July 15, 2021

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

179.42

Word count

6,230

Sentence count

350

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join Western Standard news editor Dave Naylor, editor-in-chief Derek Felderbrandt, and Calgary Stampede columnist Corey Morgan as they discuss the new leader of the Wild Rose Independence Party of Alberta, Paul Hinman. They also discuss Canada's embarrassing loss to Italy in the World Cup, and the lack of a candidate on the party's ballot.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 No.
00:00:01 Yeah, that's it.
00:00:02 I don't know.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Hi, I'm Derek Felderbrandt, publisher of The Western Standard.
00:01:17 You're joining us today on The Pipeline on July 14th, 2021.
00:01:22 Thank you very much for joining us.
00:01:24 I'm with Western Standard news editor Dave Naylor today,
00:01:28 who is still sulking from their humiliating loss to Italy.
00:01:34 Yes, we can't win on penalties.
00:01:37 It's all there is to it.
00:01:38 No, but England made it further than usual.
00:01:41 Further than Germany. 0.76
00:01:42 That's all that matters to England, isn't it?
00:01:44 Sometimes.
00:01:44 It really is just victory for England. 0.85
00:01:47 And France.
00:01:49 See, France was out so early.
00:01:51 They still get to savor the victory.
00:01:54 Yeah, we don't even worry about the French anymore.
00:01:56 And, of course, joined by Corey Morgan, host of The Corey Morgan Show and Alberta political
00:02:02 columnist. Corey, keeping busy?
00:02:04 Oh, yeah. Stampede season.
00:02:06 Amen. Okay. Well, we want to begin by, as usual, thanking all of our members for their
00:02:13 continued generous support. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to
00:02:17 westernstandardonline.com membership. You can try a Western Standard membership free for 15 days,
00:02:24 giving you complete access to all western standard content. This is bailout free media
00:02:29 working for western Canadians so we'd be grateful for your support and we promise to provide you
00:02:34 with great content, large quantities of it on a daily basis from our team here.
00:02:40 As well today's show is sponsored by the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights. The Canadian
00:02:47 Coalition for Firearms Rights works hard to protect your right to own and use firearms.
00:02:53 go to firearmsright.ca and click why join to learn more about how you can join them and add your
00:03:03 voice to the fight for your right to own and use firearms in Canada. As well today's show is also
00:03:10 sponsored by Resistance Coffee. Resistance Coffee is a great company providing great coffee. You know
00:03:16 a lot of coffee companies out there take a portion of their profits and they funnel it to the latest
00:03:21 woke progressive cause resistance coffee is uh not quite doing that they take ten percent uh
00:03:27 actually i'm not sure it's that is it ten percent ten percent of their profits and to support uh
00:03:33 organizations and causes fighting for your constitutional freedoms uh go to resistance
00:03:39 coffee.ca and use promotion code one word western standard again use uh promotion code western
00:03:45 standard all one word to get ten percent off your first order you'd be supporting the western
00:03:50 Standard by supporting one of our important advertisers, and you'll be getting great coffee
00:03:55 supporting great causes. Well, let's jump into what we've got on the show today. We're going to
00:04:02 be talking about Paul Hinman, new leader of the Wild Rose, lots of politics going on around the
00:04:08 Calgary Stampede. We'll be talking about that. And of course, we're going to talk about John
00:04:15 Carpe stepping aside as president of the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights. But we're going to
00:04:19 again with Paul Hinman, leader of the Wild Rose Independence of Alberta, a party of Alberta now
00:04:25 official. Dave, why don't you give us the rundown? Actually, as you know, Derek, this is the second
00:04:29 time Paul has led a Wild Rose party. He was one of the leaders of the old Wild Rose. He was the
00:04:36 first leader of the old Wild Rose. Yeah, back in those days. So he ran as leadership for the Wild
00:04:43 Rose Independence party. And obviously it was one of the most, actually probably one of the most
00:04:48 boring races in history. He was the only candidate. And because of COVID, you know,
00:04:53 he really couldn't get out and campaign much. But, you know, they had the forums and all that
00:04:59 sort of stuff. And the vote was over the last two days. And Tuesday night, it was announced he had
00:05:06 92% of members who voted support. So certainly an overwhelming mandate. I talked to him before
00:05:13 the votes were counted uh he says the plan now is to to hit the road get out and start meeting
00:05:20 albertans and having town halls where people can actually go and see them and talk to them and uh
00:05:26 you know they're doing well in the polls and uh that's really without even doing any social media
00:05:32 or any any campaign whatsoever so i think he's stepping into a good position there do we know
00:05:37 how many people voted in the leadership i want to say 1600 but don't quote me on that i wouldn't
00:05:42 imagine very high turnout when there's one candidate on the ballot um but i think right
00:05:47 now they're sitting around 10 000 members overall so it's a pretty low turnout but i mean it's hard
00:05:52 to motivate yourself to vote uh yes or no to something um i i guess just a few few areas we'll
00:05:59 we'll stab at this before we get into paul itself let's talk about the race or lack thereof uh
00:06:06 corey do you think it was kind of a missed opportunity for the party not to have a more
00:06:09 combative race with you know more than one candidate or do you think this is a better
00:06:14 position that he comes out of it unbruised no i i personally think a race would have been better i
00:06:18 mean races can have pitfalls you get some lunatic candidates you get some infighting they can be
00:06:23 divisive there's totally hazards to come with a leadership race if it's run poorly or you've got
00:06:27 the wrong people but they're also a huge opportunity i mean a good competitive leadership race you get
00:06:32 these candidates pounding the pavement they're selling memberships they're interacting with
00:06:36 people they're making news they're bringing it into the scroll of course that didn't happen as
00:06:40 you said it's the well i'd say the second most boring leadership race in alberta because the
00:06:44 alberta party said theirs going for a month and some they don't they don't have any candidates
00:06:49 so uh you know the wild rose party has one more candidate than the alberta party they have 100
00:06:54 more candidates that's right yeah so i i mean it's it's good that they're coming out of this
00:06:59 they can go straight to work and paul certainly is a ground worker but i i think they would have
00:07:04 have done much better to have a good competitive couple of months of campaigning race, you know.
00:07:09 I think the biggest, I think there probably were going to be a few candidates, but they put this
00:07:13 ridiculously high entry fee to entering the race. It's $30,000. It's not unusual to have an entry
00:07:20 fee into a leadership race, but $30,000, I forget exactly how much it was in 2015, Wildrose race,
00:07:26 but that was when Brian Jean won. The party was in terrible shape, but still it was technically
00:07:30 still the official opposition the media had written it off its opponents had written it off
00:07:34 some of its own members had written it off but at least it still had a couple seats in the
00:07:38 legislature it was official opposition i mean it was it was at least some kind of a prize to be had
00:07:44 and i don't think it was even thirty thousand dollars that thirty thousand dollars is a massive
00:07:47 entry fee and i think that was probably the single biggest barrier to people getting in well that's
00:07:52 obviously to keep the lunatics out and you know look at the calgary merrill merrill race i mean
00:07:58 That's just overrun now, and I think they're up to, what, 15 or 16 candidates, and yeah,
00:08:06 some of them are, shall we say, on the fringe.
00:08:08 So I agree with you, Derek, $30,000 is way too much, but the $100 is ...
00:08:13 Well, I agree.
00:08:15 Where you find the balance of these things, I don't know.
00:08:17 $10,000 will keep a lot of kooks off a ballot, but I think it's probably more reasonable.
00:08:23 And UCP was something like, I don't know, something like that.
00:08:28 It was, but I mean, that was a case of where you pretty much knew the winner of that race
00:08:32 was probably going to be premier.
00:08:33 So people were willing to invest some money and take a gamble.
00:08:37 As you said, even the old Wild Rose Party, they were the official opposition.
00:08:40 They had some seats.
00:08:42 This is a new entity or, you know, in a sense, and there's just, you're not gambling on an
00:08:48 asset here and there's no prize for a second.
00:08:51 Yeah.
00:08:51 There you got to be leader of the official opposition, probably got to be premier, but
00:08:56 I've been involved in the negotiations that between the Wildrose and PCs that had created
00:09:00 the UCP, that those negotiations were structured to have two real candidates on the ballot,
00:09:07 really.
00:09:08 And they had a $50,000 entry fee very specifically, not just to keep kooks out, but to keep everyone
00:09:13 out.
00:09:15 And that pretty much succeeded.
00:09:16 At the end of the day, only one other got on the ballot. 0.71
00:09:18 You know, I understand setting a bar to keep the lunatic. So it's just hard to find that. 0.54
00:09:24 I think 10,000 is reasonable. You know, I mean, your average person that you're not just going
00:09:28 to throw that away on a whim. I mean, maybe some of that case will, but that's where you have a
00:09:31 leadership committee too. I mean, if somebody's spending 10,000 just to troll a party and it's
00:09:36 clear that that's the case, you can still have a leadership committee say, no, you know what?
00:09:39 We don't believe you're in this best interests of the party and we won't let you go.
00:09:43 Yeah. But this was an acclimation, which I say, I feel wasn't, didn't serve the party well in the
00:09:48 i mean i think paul's great he'll do a great job but that just wasn't the it might be the best way
00:09:52 to get there yeah i think it was a missed opportunity yeah i i don't i i know for sure
00:09:57 i know i could say matter of factly there were some other fairly credible candidates looking to
00:10:02 run but um 30 000 remember that's three thousand dollars to get your name on the belt that's not
00:10:06 thirty thousand dollars for campaign funding you have to raise that beyond it so uh and significantly
00:10:12 more expensive if you actually had a contested campaign in this case him then really had to
00:10:16 to raise the $30,000, and that was it, because he was only God. But I guess let's talk about Paul
00:10:21 himself and what this means for the Wild Rose and the broader political landscape. You know,
00:10:26 as you said, Dave, this is the second party with Wild Rose in its name that he's led. He led the
00:10:31 Wild Rose Alliance as its founding leader. Wes created also a merger of two smaller parties on
00:10:38 the right, the Alberta Alliance and the Wild Rose Party. He became the first leader. He eventually
00:10:45 stepped aside for Daniel Smith to become the leader, but he still, even after he was stepping
00:10:50 aside, he won a by-election in Calgary that really shocked Alberta and catapulted the
00:10:55 Wild Rose from not being taken seriously at all right to the forefront. But he's coming
00:11:00 into this at a different, at a time when Wild Rose is starting to get noticed by the mainstream
00:11:06 media. I mean, it's hitting 20% in polls, which is credible. I don't know if it'll continue
00:11:11 to grow or can proceed a bit if people's anger has boiled down a bit from the end of lockdowns.
00:11:18 What do you think polls election means for the party itself in the broader political landscape?
00:11:23 Well, I think a more experienced person, as you said, he's been around the block
00:11:31 several times. Our exclusive Main Street poll has him as high as 20% in the province.
00:11:36 No, no, that was Angus Reid. Ours had him at 17th.
00:11:39 Oh, okay. Well, we'll believe ours over here. But our pollster, Akito Maggie, said there's
00:11:45 more than enough support there to get MLAs. So once he gets his foot into the door, he knows
00:11:52 how things operate. He knows the legislature system and whatever sort of number of seats he
00:12:01 has, he knows how to manipulate them in the best way possible. So what you could see in the future
00:12:07 is uh you know not necessarily beyond the realms of possibility is a you know an ndp minority 0.58
00:12:13 government and then the ucp and the wild rose and the oppositions having to deal with each other
00:12:19 well if it's a minority government even if the ndp has the most people got to understand
00:12:23 the party with the most seats if they don't have a majority are not necessarily the government
00:12:27 that's not the way or so then this is kind of something people don't understand anymore after
00:12:31 the whole you know when steven harper had a minority government and there's this coalition
00:12:35 that came up to try and overtake them uh it may have been dirty but what they were doing was not
00:12:40 unconstitutional by any stretch and so canadians i think that warped the opinions of a lot of
00:12:45 canadians about how our system works uh you could have like look at christy clarkton bc she was one
00:12:51 seat shy of a majority she had the most seats uh but she didn't get to form government because the 1.00
00:12:55 two smaller parties the ndp and the greens got together you could see something conceivably like
00:13:00 that in alberta where uh because right now clearly the ndp would win the most seats in alberta but
00:13:05 I'm not convinced it's a majority government because they're so concentrated in Edmonton and kind of the inner city parts of Calgary.
00:13:16 They've got no support in rural.
00:13:18 They've got no support in rural right now.
00:13:20 So it'd be hard to see them winning seats outside of big cities other than maybe the two Loughbridge seats, maximum one other.
00:13:28 So we could see a minority where Wildrose would hold the balance of power.
00:13:31 But as it is right now, Wildrose is anywhere near 20%.
00:13:35 It seems impossible that the Conservatives can win a majority.
00:13:37 Agreed.
00:13:38 And certainly Jason Kenney is hoping COVID goes away and people forget about it.
00:13:44 And I'm sure one of the things that Paul will be mentioning wherever he goes is, don't forget, Kenney did this to you.
00:13:51 He took away your livelihoods.
00:13:52 He locked you in your houses.
00:13:54 He shut down your business.
00:13:56 He's been advocating against the lockdown since day one.
00:14:00 I'll talk to our producer.
00:14:01 We just don't want to keep the comments up as long, especially if they're long comments
00:14:06 that take up half the screen.
00:14:08 And that's kind of a note to those of you commenting.
00:14:10 If you want your comments to be shown on the screen, please keep them short because if
00:14:13 they're too long, it takes up half the screen.
00:14:15 We can't really display that.
00:14:17 Shout out though to operations manager, James.
00:14:20 This is why we're looking a little better than we normally do, even Corey looks more
00:14:24 handsome.
00:14:25 I thought I looked better when I had a bit of blur.
00:14:28 So we're not disappearing into the green screen anymore and stuff like that.
00:14:32 Your glasses are a little bit.
00:14:35 It's not a green screen.
00:14:36 This is the window of our office.
00:14:37 Yeah, that's true.
00:14:38 We do have the best view in the city.
00:14:40 So thank you to James.
00:14:41 Yeah, I mean, it's where does Paul take the party from here?
00:14:47 So, you know, it's the first step is to get up and the people know who he is because the average, you know, I couldn't pick out of the police on it because he's been away from public sight as, as, as, you know, most of the, most of the people during COVID.
00:15:06 So now we can get out.
00:15:07 Now we can get a space show.
00:15:09 Now we can meet people.
00:15:10 Now we can knock on doors.
00:15:11 Now we can go to community barbecues.
00:15:13 And he's a veteran.
00:15:15 he'll know exactly what to do. It won't take him long to get his name known.
00:15:20 And because of the, you know, we were the only media when we did polling to specifically get
00:15:29 Wildrose support. All the other media just clumped him in with others. And you get this,
00:15:34 you know, this other bar that nobody knew what it was.
00:15:37 Yeah. So I want to ask you about that, Corey. For the longest time, yeah, the other media,
00:15:41 and they would pull they put into other and other would be like almost tied with the ucp i mean
00:15:47 it's growing and growing you think at some point you're gonna say what is this yeah but they didn't
00:15:50 want to look yeah yeah it was bizarre i mean if other gets above five percent you're you're
00:15:57 supposed to look at that okay so above something above five percent that probably got some kind
00:16:02 of significance and you know i mean all the other polls other would be like 20 or 25 something huge
00:16:09 and they would just they refused to look at it and you have to wonder why uh we'd pull and ask
00:16:14 about wild rose and we'd like we know what the other is this is what it is we're pulling all
00:16:18 these other smaller options this is the one that's standing out here um so they're sitting at between
00:16:24 17 and 20 percent right now the polls uh ours and main street at 17 and then about two weeks later
00:16:31 angus breed out of the 20. um but things have you know alberta is pretty much completely reopened
00:16:36 and now borders are still closed and things like that,
00:16:38 but that's under federal.
00:16:40 Do you think that with the reopening
00:16:42 that this is going to really take the steam out of Wild Rose,
00:16:45 or are these voters lost to Kenny at this point?
00:16:48 I don't think the reopening,
00:16:50 I mean, it might stop the bleeding for Kenny,
00:16:52 but getting them back,
00:16:53 I mean, one of the things he's got to keep in mind with Paul, too,
00:16:55 he's a party builder.
00:16:57 He's not one of the ones that you'll see front and center
00:16:59 and firing brimstone and making the great quotes,
00:17:01 but he works the ground,
00:17:03 and he's already saying he's going to hit those constituencies.
00:17:05 He's going to get those organizations going.
00:17:08 He's going to get that campaign machine going, which you need when the time comes.
00:17:11 And that's why he keeps getting underestimated because where did this guy come from?
00:17:14 Well, he built a foundation there that came in and whipped you and you weren't paying attention to it.
00:17:19 And that's what happened to the media. 0.55
00:17:19 He didn't pay attention to these guys and Paul was working it for some time and building that up out there.
00:17:25 But the thing is with Kenny, this is the Wildrose Independence Party.
00:17:28 And we're going into a federal campaign probably this fall that's going to be very divisive.
00:17:34 And from all accounts and all appearances, we might get a liberal majority out of this.
00:17:38 And Kenny has been notoriously weak in dealing with Ottawa.
00:17:41 He won't stand up to him.
00:17:43 He talks big.
00:17:44 He backs down.
00:17:45 And that's a giant hole for Paul to fill.
00:17:47 That's a great area to capture votes.
00:17:51 And, I mean, he's making no bones about where he's going.
00:17:53 He's moving towards Alberta independence.
00:17:54 He's moving towards getting a police force, getting the pension plan.
00:17:58 Not just talk, talk, talk, talk, talk.
00:18:00 We've heard for two years of the UCP.
00:18:01 He's going to move on it.
00:18:03 and that's what's grabbing solid, dedicated supporters.
00:18:06 So Kenny's really got to up his pro-Alberta game.
00:18:09 He's got the COVID thing handled, and it seems to have worked out well,
00:18:12 and that's going to help him. 0.99
00:18:13 But that independent thing is going to bite him in the ass 0.99
00:18:16 if he doesn't figure out how to consolidate it. 0.99
00:18:18 Yeah.
00:18:19 Okay, well, let's move things real local here.
00:18:23 Right now, you can see I'm not my regular suit and tie here.
00:18:29 We've got a stampede party after work today.
00:18:31 It is the Calgary Stampede.
00:18:33 Thank God it's on.
00:18:34 I know some of you don't want to go because it's not perfect.
00:18:38 But I say don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
00:18:43 It's just great to see people out and living, breathing the free air now.
00:18:48 People are sitting on patios, drinking beers.
00:18:52 There's some rodeo going on.
00:18:53 And this rodeo doesn't get you sent to jail.
00:18:55 That's important to note.
00:18:57 It's great to see.
00:18:58 And, you know, this is kind of the place where every politician likes to come to.
00:19:03 Justin Trudeau visited Calgary, but right before Stampede started.
00:19:07 I don't think he's actually going to Stampede because that would not send the right virtues.
00:19:10 It would not signal the right virtues.
00:19:13 I don't think Jake needs – some people can forgive me, correct me if I'm wrong,
00:19:17 but I don't know if Jake Bixian has ever been to Calgary Stampede.
00:19:19 He might be the only national partier who's not from the bloc at a quad to do that.
00:19:23 I'm pretty sure the bloc leaders visit Calgary Stampede more often.
00:19:26 They actually might be welcome.
00:19:28 Yes.
00:19:28 I think the block leaders are welcome here.
00:19:31 I think it's time for Alberta to get right behind those guys. 1.00
00:19:33 Oh, yeah, absolutely.
00:19:35 But at least on the provincial level, it is full campaign season.
00:19:39 It is the greatest campaign event on earth.
00:19:42 Dave, why don't you tell us what's going on with the political groundscape here? 0.62
00:19:47 Oh, a silly season in Calgary.
00:19:49 As you mentioned, Derek, the prime minister touched down for a few hours the day before the kickoff. 0.50
00:19:55 Conservative leader Erin O'Toole popped into town for a press conference before heading west.
00:20:03 Jason Kenney, you'll recognize him.
00:20:05 He's walking around with the biggest grin on his face in Calgary.
00:20:10 He's going to the Premier's Stampede breakfast.
00:20:14 That was packed.
00:20:16 Hey, even NDP leader Rachel Notley, who questioned way back in May,
00:20:22 said the Stampede probably shouldn't go ahead because it's going to be a super spreader event.
00:20:28 She wasted no time in getting down here and holding a big party. She'll be around town
00:20:34 all week, various functions. She is super spreading everywhere. Yes. So it's just an
00:20:42 event that politicians cannot miss. And, you know, the people come to them. The people will go
00:20:49 and to get a free pancake and sausage at the community constituency offices and all that sort
00:20:58 of stuff. So I don't think there's a better time than Stampede Week for politicians to actually
00:21:03 get out and meet Albertans. And of course, there's Albertans from across the province here
00:21:08 coming down for the rodeo and the stampede. So it's a must-tend event for politicians.
00:21:15 Well, this rodeo is just not as fun as Bojan because, you know, just when something's
00:21:19 illegal, it's a lot more fun.
00:21:21 I mean, when I was in high school, I used to smoke pot, it's not fun anymore.
00:21:29 I feel like illegal rodeo is so much more than the legal variety.
00:21:33 Absolutely.
00:21:34 It takes some of the thrill out of the whole thing.
00:21:36 At least we get to see, you know, Rachel getting out there and I bet you she's thrilling in
00:21:41 the thrill of the hypocrisy.
00:21:43 You know, knowing that you went out there and said that anybody going to the Stampede is going to put people at risk. 0.94
00:21:47 Anybody going to the Stampede is going to be a super spreader and is going to kill people.
00:21:51 And now she's out there shaking hands, smiling, talking to people and doing everything that she said two months ago was inhuman. 0.99
00:21:58 So, you know, there's going to be a bit of a thrill in the doing something so out of sorts, I guess.
00:22:05 I could say it's that.
00:22:06 I mean, it's just the hip and the arm.
00:22:07 So yesterday, you know, every politician around is having their stampede breakfasts or barbecues.
00:22:14 Well, not only breakfast, because it's cheaper to put on.
00:22:16 A very interesting one yesterday.
00:22:18 They were not Calgary politicians, but they had their breakfast anyway.
00:22:23 Drew Barnes and Todd Lowen, the two UCP MLAs, originally elected to Wildrose,
00:22:28 who were thrown out of the UCP caucus by Jason Kenney.
00:22:31 Todd Lowen, because he said Kenney should resign, and Drew Barnes, because he doesn't like Drew Barnes.
00:22:37 um they had a they had a stampede breakfast yesterday uh there was quite a fairly pretty
00:22:44 big turnout there um brine gene showing out with kind of a cheshire cat smile on his face
00:22:52 um there were um so you know we we had someone there there were quite a few wild rosers there
00:23:01 from the from the original wild rose they were there fairly large numbers uh what do you think
00:23:06 those two are up to having an event in Calgary so far from their constituencies you know I don't
00:23:12 know if they've got anything formal on the go but they're definitely thinking I mean it's something
00:23:16 that's got to keep Kenny nervous I mean these guys are working together uh Brian Jean whether
00:23:21 he's interested in putting his you know foot back into the ring or not it's hard to say because he
00:23:25 likes poking from the sidelines too uh he likes to just kind of stir things up and troll them but
00:23:30 when you see those three together in one spot and this was definitely predetermined I mean yeah
00:23:34 they're not Calgary MLAs. You know, Todd had to drive from Valley View.
00:23:39 Drew had to come from Medicine Hat.
00:23:40 Brangina had to come from Fort Mac. Like these guys converged.
00:23:43 And that gives you the feeling, well,
00:23:44 you're trying to gain Calgary support for some reason.
00:23:46 If you're trying to gain Calgary support for some reason, what are you up to?
00:23:50 But it leaves it wide open to speculation then.
00:23:52 Are they looking to form their own party in caucus?
00:23:54 Are they looking to join Paul?
00:23:56 Or are they just sitting on the groundwork thinking maybe eventually they go back to UCP?
00:23:59 I don't know, but it gets us all spanking and wondering about it anyways. 0.89
00:24:03 they're not quietly sitting in the background right now and is it showing more you know the
00:24:07 merger that i think everybody thinks is the building between the old wild roses and the old
00:24:12 stories uh and starting to split back up into their own tribes is this uh you know public showing
00:24:19 them and you know there's certainly the barbecue last night was crowded uh and anybody that was
00:24:26 there was probably not a fan of the premier at all. Okay, let's deal with, I guess,
00:24:35 take a little further away from home here. So John Carpe, president of the Justice Centre for
00:24:41 Constitutional Freedoms, they're based in Calgary, but they've been taking on constitutional cases
00:24:46 across Canada, really leading the fight in the courts against lockdowns and other restrictions
00:24:52 that they believe are unreasonable intrusions on constitutional freedoms. They've had some
00:24:58 successes, some failures, but they do seem to have stepped in it recently. It came to light
00:25:05 that John Carpe had hired or authorized the hiring of a private investigator to find out if a judge
00:25:16 judge around Winnipeg who is overseeing the case that they're in right now.
00:25:24 The judge in Winnipeg is dealing with a case where seven churches in the rural parts of
00:25:30 Manitoba are taking the gun to court over the lockdowns.
00:25:35 The judge is overseeing the case, private investigator was hired.
00:25:40 Dave, why don't you fill in the rest, because I'm not telling the story very well.
00:25:45 Why don't you tell us exactly what happened and why John Carpe is at least on a leap of
00:25:51 absence right now, president of the JCCF?
00:25:54 Certainly.
00:25:55 Well, nobody, John Carpe is being a tireless worker, working probably 24-7 for months on
00:26:01 end to defend people's constitutional rights.
00:26:05 His group is swamped, they're desperate for lawyers.
00:26:09 And I think he was probably, in his case, he was sitting there thinking about Jason Kenney
00:26:15 and the Sky Palace and those public photos that showed him breaking COVID regulations.
00:26:21 And I'm just guessing, but probably what went through his mind is if they can catch this
00:26:28 judge or something like that, then, you know, that's going to be a good stick in their arsenal.
00:26:34 So they hired a private investigator to follow this judge, and by all accounts, didn't do
00:26:40 a great job, was easily spotted by the judge the first time.
00:26:45 They followed him out to his cottage, which I don't know where it is, but if it's a longer
00:26:52 rural area, it's kind of tough to follow anybody there and not get noticed, but they were quickly
00:26:58 spotted. The judge obviously realized this is a concern, notified the police, and made
00:27:06 it public. That same day, John Carpe, the sort of fell on the sword, said he'd made
00:27:16 a mistake, and the next day he announced he was stepping away as head of the organization.
00:27:23 The board of directors...
00:27:24 He's on leave, he's not on leave.
00:27:25 No, we're still there.
00:27:27 The board of directors said they had nothing to do with it.
00:27:31 They were not informed about it.
00:27:33 So obviously a decision John took on his own.
00:27:38 He has stepped aside for an unspecified amount of time. 0.98
00:27:44 Yeah, it was a dumb thing to do.
00:27:48 So, Corey, this has obviously got a lot of the lockdowners jumping for joy. 0.83
00:27:55 They're like, ah, we got you.
00:27:58 You know, carpe's bad. 0.94
00:28:00 These people are bad.
00:28:01 They're doing bad things.
00:28:02 I think his critics are fair to say that this was not a good idea.
00:28:09 This is, you know, not the norms of how we deal with things.
00:28:14 It's not right to be hiring PIs and spying on people.
00:28:16 but i gotta we gotta ask is it okay for the government to be spying on people
00:28:22 i mean canadian governments the feds and the provinces every single province have had police
00:28:28 and civilian government officials spying on civilians for a year and a half they set up
00:28:34 snitch lines and encouraged people to spy on their neighbors on people walking down the street their
00:28:41 friends and their family and report it and snitch it to the government for a year and a half
00:28:45 The government is spying on us, and now we spy on the government, or we're just spying on the government.
00:28:53 I don't think two wrongs make a right, but how do you think the JCCF was, how do you think Carpe and the JCCF were squaring this in their minds?
00:29:02 Why did they think this was a good idea?
00:29:04 Yeah, I mean, it was clear, and I think if anybody knows more than anybody right now that that was a terrible lapse of judgment, it's John.
00:29:09 I mean, you know, hindsight, maybe I can't explain.
00:29:13 and we know John's a smart guy, a dedicated guy, and to, of all people to follow, you know,
00:29:18 a judge in an inactive case, I mean, the optics of it and what it sets as a precedent is, you know,
00:29:23 can be read into very terribly. I think what he had in mind, though, as Dave was pointing out
00:29:27 at the Sky Palace, if it had been anybody other than the judge, the stuff you'd get elected
00:29:31 officials who are demonstrating hypocrisy, if you can get health officials demonstrating
00:29:35 hypocrisy, the people who are telling you, because it does help invalidate the law. If
00:29:39 you've got the person saying, this is the law, but it doesn't apply to me, that is something
00:29:43 you'd even almost bring up in a courthouse to say, look, how can we call this a valid law when
00:29:47 the people who implement it aren't following it? Though I think perhaps he should have been
00:29:52 watching legislators rather than the judiciary in that case. And I'm certain he's reevaluating
00:29:57 that decision. And it's too bad because of, as we said, he's done so much great work. That
00:30:01 organization has been so important for government overstepping its boundary. And the government did
00:30:07 create that atmosphere of everybody spotting on each other. I mean, I remember Mayor Nietzsche
00:30:10 going on about call that snitch line if you see your neighbor having you know a strange car parked
00:30:15 in front of their house or three people in the backyard you call up and get them in there and
00:30:19 it's turned us into these these karens as the overused term goes to keep moving on each other 1.00
00:30:26 so i mean it was just an extension of more of that same attitude but it really was it was poorly
00:30:30 conceived and it's really too bad it really is yeah well so he he's not resigned he's not been
00:30:37 fired by the board um i mean he's large i think he's pretty much built the organization from
00:30:42 scratch um and it has really come to the fore as probably the most prominent constitutional
00:30:47 freedoms organization in the country by far i think there's there's also the um canadian
00:30:52 constitution foundation they used to be the most prominent but i think they've they've been a lot
00:30:57 less prominent especially during lockdowns perhaps they're more resident uh want to touch this
00:31:03 There's also things like the BC Civil Liberties Association.
00:31:07 They're more concerned with burning down churches.
00:31:11 If we want to speak about legal organizations that lost credibility, those guys, I'm sorry.
00:31:16 To me, John took the blame for it immediately.
00:31:22 He didn't try to weasel around it.
00:31:24 He said, I did it.
00:31:26 I was wrong.
00:31:27 I'm going to step aside.
00:31:28 And I made a mistake.
00:31:29 And the board admitted that when they put out their statement.
00:31:33 And they said, John immediately owned up.
00:31:35 So, I mean, come on, we've all had brain farts.
00:31:38 We've all made wrong decisions.
00:31:41 As long as we admit them, I think most people are given another chance, right?
00:31:45 And you move on and you learn and you get better.
00:31:47 And he's not letting it distract from him.
00:31:49 I mean, that's an organization with a lot of lawyers with a lot of irons in the fire.
00:31:52 They got a lot of important work to do.
00:31:54 And with this blowing up, at least John's not that distracted and sidetracked from all the rest of the work they're doing.
00:32:00 If he was an NHL player, he'd get a three-game suspension.
00:32:04 Yeah, I think that's, I mean, still my organization.
00:32:08 But, I mean, if I was a member of that board, I think, you know, brief two, three-week suspension, slap on the wrist, put him back on the ice.
00:32:18 Because he's a good player that you don't want to bench for long.
00:32:22 No, he'll come back rested and more focused and with a clear head.
00:32:26 Guy probably needed a vacation anyway.
00:32:28 I think he probably did.
00:32:29 Yeah.
00:32:30 Okay. Well, that's it for today's show. I want to thank, of course, Corey and Dave for being with us and especially all of our Western Standard members. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, please go to westernstandardonline.com slash membership. Try out your membership free for 15 days. You can cancel at any time if you don't like what Corey has to say. If you don't like what I have to say, you have no choice. You've got to keep paying.
00:32:54 And, of course, today's show is sponsored by Resistance Coffee.
00:33:01 Resistance Coffee is a fantastic company that takes 10% of the proceeds of the sales of their coffee
00:33:10 and pass it on to organizations supporting your constitutional freedoms.
00:33:14 I don't know if they're supporting the Canadian Constitutional Freedom.
00:33:16 The Justice Center for Constitutional Freedom.
00:33:18 I don't know.
00:33:19 That is one of the ones they don't.
00:33:21 Apparently, I'm getting the thumbs up.
00:33:22 they do if you support the justice center constitutional freedoms i could use a couple
00:33:27 of limo tears right now yeah it's always refreshing cory drinks it every morning uh so uh support
00:33:33 resistance coffee support good causes that they uh they back with some of their profits so go to
00:33:38 resistancecoffee.ca use promotion code western standard to get 10 off of your first order that's
00:33:45 one word western standard as your promotion code getting 10 off of your uh first order
00:33:52 As well, today's show is sponsored by the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights.
00:33:58 The Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights works tirelessly for your right to own, use, and just have a lot of fun safely with firearms.
00:34:07 They're a fantastic organization that's on guard for you.
00:34:12 I know these guys, they've got an office perched out in Ottawa in a place you don't want to be with people who want to take away your guns.
00:34:20 they're there working the halls of power and doing advocacy on your behalf to be able to keep your
00:34:26 firearms. So go to firearmsright.ca and click why join to find out more about why you should join
00:34:34 the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights. That's it for today's show. We appreciate all of you and
00:34:41 all of your time. God bless.