Western Standard - January 12, 2023


The Pipeline: Just(in’s) transition

Topics
Mentioned
Alberta man shows food prices gone higher than stated numbers Michelle Stirling of Friends of Science on the "Just Transition"

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

178.75

Word count

7,244

Sentence count

474

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Federal Government's gun grab is now slated to begin with a pilot project in Prince Edward Island. We also talk about Justin Trudeau's announcement of the Just Transition, starting to lay things out on how the federal government plans to take control of firearms in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening i'm derek phildebrandt publisher of the western standard you're watching the pipeline
00:00:29 Today is January 11th, 2023. Thank you very much for joining me today. I'm here as usual with the
00:00:37 Western Standards opinion editor, Nigel Henniford. How are you, Nigel? I'm good. How are you? So far
00:00:43 so good? I was going to say pissing vinegar, but maybe not quite pissing vinegar today. We'll see
00:00:48 by the end of the show. I'll get work. Let's take a vote on it. Yeah. And also joined by the Western
00:00:52 Standards senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan. Corey, always pissing vinegar with you. Oh,
00:00:57 nothing but. You had a good show today, eh? It was. I got some good rants out. Good. Right on. Okay,
00:01:02 well, we got some good topics to go through today. The federal government's gun grab is now slated
00:01:08 to begin with a pilot project in Prince Edward Island. They're targeting gun owners, the law
00:01:13 abiding gun owners at least, on the poor island because they just don't have as many guns per
00:01:19 capita and they're small. And the idea is to test out the government's gun theft program there,
00:01:25 learn some lessons, use it as a pilot program, and then roll it out across the country. I'm
00:01:32 sure the RCP are really looking forward to knocking on doors of these criminal hunters in Alberta.
00:01:41 We're also going to talk about Justin Trudeau's announcement of the Just Transition,
00:01:47 starting to lay things out. This has been coming for some time, but the Just Transition, if you're
00:01:52 in one of these evil jobs in oil and gas or or anything that extracts anything out of the ground
00:01:57 like this your job is slated to be eliminated by fiat by the federal government but don't worry
00:02:03 uh you can get a job putting up some solar panels so we'll be talking about the just transition
00:02:09 also um uh one ndp candidate here in alberta says daniel smith has no mandate
00:02:15 um in fact rachel not only has been saying that but not on a variety of issues the ndp have been
00:02:21 saying it. Does the premier of Alberta have no mandate? I don't know. We're actually going to
00:02:25 talk about it. Might be a case to be made. There's been no election yet. We'll see. Before we get in
00:02:30 though, I want to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. Very relevant
00:02:35 having the CSSA sponsoring today's show talking about the federal gun grab starting in Prince
00:02:40 Edward Island. I've been a member of the Canadian Shooting Sports Association for more than a
00:02:44 decade because I trust them with my membership dues to protect my rights as a law-abiding or
00:02:50 otherwise law-abiding firearms owner in Canada from confiscations and restrictions by the federal
00:02:56 government. The CSSA is doing the work that is necessary to make sure that Canadians are as well
00:03:02 informed as they possibly can be about what is reasonable for controlling firearms in the country,
00:03:08 standing athwart efforts by the federal government to seize all of your guns. If you're not yet a
00:03:13 member of the Canadian Shooting Sports Association, you should be. Go to cssa-cila.org or just do what
00:03:19 I do and Google them, sign up, become a member today. It's worth absolutely every penny. Okay,
00:03:25 so excellent segue into our first topic, the gun grab starting in Prince Edward Island. So this
00:03:32 goes way back, geez, about two and a half years ago, federal government introduced, didn't do by
00:03:41 bill, but they did it by what's called an order in council. That's essentially a cabinet decree. 0.88
00:03:46 So no vote in the House of Commons, just the cabinet decides this.
00:03:49 They were to ban 1,500 different firearms.
00:03:51 Now, not as bad as that sounds, because they were banning a bunch of things that have always been illegal in Canada.
00:03:57 They had some rocket anti-aircraft missiles in there.
00:04:02 They had some German Panzerfaust anti-tank guns.
00:04:07 They had some very interesting things that I was very saddened to learn were made illegal,
00:04:12 Because if I knew that I could buy a Panzerfaust or Russian anti-tank missiles, anti-aircraft missiles, I'd have totally gone in on them.
00:04:19 I just hadn't seen them around the Calgary gun show when it comes to town.
00:04:23 But it began there. Now there's a bill before Parliament right now where they're going to expand upon that list.
00:04:29 That's kind of the latest controversy with it, where they're now just they're expanding what is assault style firearms that include very basic, simple hunting rifles.
00:04:37 If they just happen to be semi-automatic with a detachable magazine.
00:04:39 So this is all now starting to get real. This is not based on the bill. This is based on the order and counsel. Federal government through the RCMP say that they're going to pilot this.
00:04:54 So here's their reasons. Islanders own a few guns and represent a, quote, low risk assessment before the RCMP expand the program nationwide. 0.77
00:05:05 That was first broken by Black Locks Reporter, which we contract doing a lot of our work on Pirroland Hill.
00:05:11 They say Prince Edward Island will be used as a pilot and will be the first point of collection.
00:05:15 That's the term they use, collection. They don't say theft.
00:05:17 collection based on the small number of firearms set in August 31st transition book for the
00:05:23 Minister of Public Works. As a result of lessons learned, gaps analysis and risk assessment would
00:05:28 inform the second phase of national rollout. Now, phase two of the national rollout is planned for
00:05:33 spring of 2023. Once IT case management system is in place, said the memo, the department acknowledged
00:05:41 quote, very limited interest from the industry and supporting the quote, buyback program proposed
00:05:47 three years ago. Now I refuse to call it a buyback because back implies the federal government had it
00:05:53 to begin with. Second, it implies the federal government is buying something. They're stealing
00:05:57 something and handing money to someone that they have determined. We'll start with you, Nigel. You
00:06:05 seem to have something to say. Do you think it makes sense for them starting in Prince Edward
00:06:11 Island to kind of pilot this before they get to a more troublesome area like Alberta?
00:06:15 right up until the moment that they describe Prince Edward Islanders as low risk. What is
00:06:20 that? If you're from BEI, if you live there, and they say, oh, they're just low risk. Wait a minute.
00:06:27 Maybe I'm not such a low risk as you think. Like, maybe the buyback will get some pushback there
00:06:32 that we didn't anticipate. I could be wrong. We have to read into what they mean by low risk,
00:06:37 but I would guess that low risk means it's less likely there. It's a different culture. It's less
00:06:42 likely that people are going to refuse entry of police into houses to confiscate their property.
00:06:48 It's less likely that someone will physically resist arrest. I mean, they might have those
00:06:54 issues out there, but I would imagine culturally Prince Edward Island is different than Alberta.
00:07:01 Guns are not as deeply ingrained as a part of the culture there. So perhaps that's what they 1.00
00:07:04 mean by lower risk, that the police are just going to have less guff from trying to steal
00:07:08 people's property. I would imagine that's what they thought, yes. I wish they had started
00:07:15 with their pilot project somewhere where they actually do have a gun problem. Where would that be?
00:07:22 Downtown Toronto. I mean if you're going to go house to house and asking for firearms,
00:07:28 try and pick up a few illegal ones at the same time. They're only going to go house to house
00:07:33 who registered firearms owners. They're not going to go house to house where they suspect
00:07:37 there are criminals with crime guns. They're only going to go to houses, I imagine,
00:07:43 where they suspect someone had the firearm legally.
00:07:46 How do they know that? I mean, there's no gun registry, right?
00:07:51 Yes and no. There's kind of two ways they can do this. One is if they had a restricted firearm
00:07:58 to begin with, and that restricted firearm was then made prohibited. So if you have a handgun,
00:08:03 AR-15, something like that, those were registered. If you have handguns, you have restricted
00:08:10 long guns like AR-15, et cetera, or now the Ruger Mini, it's a freaking hunting rifle, I don't know
00:08:17 why, but you had to have them, oh, Ruger Mini wasn't actually restricted, but you had an AR-15,
00:08:25 you had a pistol, they were registered. The government knows, at least at some point,
00:08:30 that you had it and so they'll know you so those will probably be the very first places to target
00:08:34 the second place is the target will be people who might not have uh restricted guns but they
00:08:39 have non-restricted guns so they don't know what the guns are but they know you have a license
00:08:45 for them so they'll probably just go to licensed houses i i'll bet you dollars to donuts the only
00:08:50 places they're not going are uh houses with people who do not have a license who have not registered 0.96
00:08:56 their guns and use their guns for nefarious purposes. They're not getting a knock from the
00:09:00 RCMP on the door. I return you to my basic point. Start in Toronto. You never know what you might
00:09:05 find. Corey, what do you think they're starting with a gun grab in PEI, not downtown Toronto or
00:09:11 Alberta? Yeah, well, Toronto would be, that would indeed be dangerous. And, you know, because then
00:09:16 you will encounter the real criminals are there. Very few of the guns they're actually looking for
00:09:21 in the places with. Yeah, it's ridiculous. But I mean, hey, you know what, maybe we'll see that 0.92
00:09:27 on the ground and see the failure of this whole initiative in action. I looked it up. PEI has
00:09:32 6,444 people with PALs, which is a firearms license. Doesn't even mean necessarily they
00:09:38 own even a non-restricted firearm. I mean, you can get the license. It doesn't mean you have a
00:09:42 firearm. So are they going to go to 6,400 doors and ask, do you now have firearms that weren't
00:09:49 on the restricted list, but now have been illegalized due to the arbitrary changes in the
00:09:54 laws. And I suspect of those 6,400 people, even if the culture is different over there, most of
00:09:59 them are going to say no. Somebody comes to my door and asks what I've got in my house. I'll say
00:10:03 come back with a warrant. It's none of your business. What they're going to tell you though
00:10:08 is because under the Firearms Act, police do not need a warrant to enter your home if it's a
00:10:14 firearms inspection. They can knock and you legally have to grant them entry. Now I'd still
00:10:19 recommend people refuse entry to police into your home without a warrant. There's only two
00:10:24 legitimate reasons for police to enter a house. One is they have a warrant approved by a judge
00:10:29 or two they have they meet the legal definition of they have reasonable grounds to believe
00:10:35 a people are in imminent danger or a crime is underway. That's it not just hey we think you
00:10:42 you vaguely think you might have something
00:10:45 that Justin Trudeau doesn't think you should have.
00:10:47 So, you know, if they come legally, yeah,
00:10:50 they might say they don't need a warrant,
00:10:52 but I wouldn't allow them in without them.
00:10:55 No, and I'd be intransigent.
00:10:57 I'm going to make them work it all the way to the end then.
00:10:59 And I suspect a number of these people would too.
00:11:01 The resources, even for this 6,400 people,
00:11:04 they would have to dedicate from officers
00:11:05 who have not expressed interest in wanting to do this.
00:11:09 I see a pending failure on the small experiment with this.
00:11:13 Just to let them know, just imagine, once you get to Toronto,
00:11:16 where there are law-abiding firearm owners as well, lots of them,
00:11:19 or Alberta and Saskatchewan, where you get crabby law-abiding firearm owners
00:11:23 who really are not going to cooperate.
00:11:25 But isn't this the thing, Corey?
00:11:26 The stated objective of this is what?
00:11:30 Firearm safety, less gun crime.
00:11:32 These are not the guns to go after, if that's the objective.
00:11:36 It's the opposite.
00:11:37 These are the rule-abiding people. They follow the rules, and that's why I think they're going to be twice as crowded.
00:11:42 These people pay their parking tickets, for heaven's sake.
00:11:44 You know, licensed firearms owners are statistically less likely to commit a crime with a gun in Canada than non-firearms licensed owners.
00:11:54 Even though licensed gun owners are a fairly small minority overall in Canada,
00:11:59 I mean, a big minority in Alberta, but a fairly small minority overall in Canada,
00:12:05 you're statistically more likely to commit a crime if you're not a legal gun owner.
00:12:08 You're more likely to commit a gun crime if you're not a legal gun owner than if you are a legal gun owner.
00:12:15 So I think there could be several unintended consequences of this.
00:12:19 So you remember, at some point this spring or late spring or early summer,
00:12:24 the federal government announced they're going to ban the purchase and sale of handguns.
00:12:28 And the federal government assumed, well, that means that'll more or less put a stop to handgun sales right away.
00:12:33 everyone will get the message because we're hinting we're obviously going to
00:12:36 ban them the federal government was shocked shocked when handgun sales hit
00:12:42 sky-high new records everybody went out and bought handguns not everybody I
00:12:47 certainly don't own any I don't know any handguns if you're watching RCMP but the
00:12:54 so that was the unintended consequence of it it fueled gun sales now if they
00:12:59 start because they're piloting on the opposite end of the country and in a
00:13:03 small little area this is gonna start raising a lot of attention of gun owners
00:13:08 in the rest of the country maybe who haven't been paying as much attention
00:13:10 and we're gonna start seeing what happens I have a feeling this is gonna
00:13:14 make it even more difficult for them to go house-to-house and seize people's
00:13:18 firearms if they're piloting at Prince Edward Island first we're gonna see what 0.96
00:13:22 happens there and and the likely shit show that ensues so by the time they 0.95
00:13:27 get around to, say, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Manitoba, BC, Ontario, I have a feeling that a lot of people 0.96
00:13:36 have just had boating accidents. The cops come to their door and say, I don't know what happened,
00:13:43 officer, geez. So by the time they get around to the rest of the country, everyone's been well
00:13:47 warned. We've known they're doing this for some time, but, you know, they offered, they asked
00:13:51 people to hand in the guns. Almost zero guns were handed in from this, but now they're going to get
00:13:57 more active in enforcement so people have held on to the gun so far but once they start actively
00:14:01 trying to confiscate and steal from people i'm feeling a lot of guns are just going to have
00:14:05 boating accidents um do you think this is going to what are there any other unintended
00:14:12 consequences either of you think are going to come from piloting this in pei yeah well
00:14:19 obviously if it looks like it's going well in pei from the federal point of view people are going
00:14:24 to take notice and they are going to take whatever avoidance action they think they can get away with.
00:14:31 I mean it's the best thing that we've got going for us here in Alberta and in Saskatchewan though
00:14:36 is two provincial governments that are very ready to say no to this and make as little accommodation
00:14:43 to the to the RCMP as they themselves can get away with. So that's where I want to go with this now
00:14:49 is Alberta and Saskatchewan. Both governments, the Smith government, the Mo government,
00:14:56 respectively have said, we will not comply. Saskatchewan passed, I think called the Saskatchewan
00:15:02 Firearms Act. It's a little complicated, but essentially it puts up this, this is the only
00:15:08 time I've ever liked bureaucracy. They put up this intentionally hugely bureaucratic piece of
00:15:12 legislation that just makes it very, very, very difficult for the RCMP to practically seize
00:15:19 people's firearms and still follow provincial law. In Alberta, they've just said, we're not
00:15:25 enforcing it. The RCMP and prosecutors have other priorities. Go to you, Corey.
00:15:32 How effective do you think that'll be though? Because the federal law of the land is still
00:15:36 going to say, you're not allowed to have this property, you have to hand it into the government.
00:15:39 how effective do you think this can really be as a tool since we don't have our own provincial
00:15:44 police forces in Alberta Saskatchewan? I think it'll still be fairly effective because they
00:15:48 don't it gives them an out not to bother with it I think some of the seizures or charges you might
00:15:53 see happening would be coincidental you know if there was another crime that had happened they're
00:15:58 searching a household now they found that this person's non-compliant they'll add that to the
00:16:02 charges and they'll do it but to the point of dedicating the resources to try to go house to
00:16:07 house to the, what, tens of thousands of homes in Alberta, hundreds of thousands of homes that may
00:16:12 potentially, there's just, it's logistically impossible. And I mean, with the unintended
00:16:17 consequences you spoke of as well, law-abiding firearm owners are using the firearms safe for
00:16:22 a good secure location. Well, how many now are going to move them somewhere else because they
00:16:26 feel that'd be where it'd be targeted? Now you've got a firearm that moves into an unsafe stored
00:16:31 location because it's hidden. They're going to make things worse. Well, let's talk about the
00:16:36 reaction or perhaps lack of reaction from the Alberta NDP on this. This is a big issue.
00:16:44 But, you know, correct me if I'm right, Nigel, but I haven't heard a peep from the Alberta NDP
00:16:48 about this, other than that they say there shouldn't be an Alberta Provincial Police Force,
00:16:54 that Alberta should not control its own policing in Alberta, should be controlled from
00:16:57 Ottawa. Has the NDP spoken up about this at all that you've seen?
00:17:02 Not that I have seen. And, you know, it stands to reason that they wouldn't. First of all, it's not a vote winner in Alberta. So nobody is.
00:17:11 Well, not among their pool of voters, I'd say.
00:17:14 Well, certainly. They're not going to enlarge their pool by making a strong case for supporting the government in its efforts to collect legal guns.
00:17:26 You know, like that's not going to help them.
00:17:28 The other thing is, don't forget who runs the provincial NDP.
00:17:32 It's not Rachel Knottley, it's Jagmeet Singh.
00:17:35 Jagmeet Singh is in lockstep with Trudeau on this as part of the deal that they have between them
00:17:40 to maintain the federal government's time in office.
00:17:46 So it sort of stands to reason that the NDP would not be taking a strong pro-Alberta, pro-gun owner position.
00:17:58 on this, because that's not what their federal party is saying. In fact, quite the reverse.
00:18:05 Well, okay. So I know Corey's done quite a bit on this before the, you know, how the federal
00:18:10 provincial NDP are actually one organization within their constitution. There is, it's the
00:18:16 only federated party in Canada, whereas, you know, conservatives, liberals, et cetera, have,
00:18:22 they might be allied parties between federal and provincial levels, but they are quite separate.
00:18:26 They are connected, but I wouldn't say this is necessarily just because Jagmeet Singh favors this. I think Rachel Notley and the NDP favor this. Within their voter universe, I mean, if you were a gun owner in Canada or the United States, the chances of you voting for a left-wing party are now statistically nil.
00:18:47 There are very, very few, at least legal gun owners who vote for left-wing parties anymore.
00:18:54 It's now become a very partisan issue.
00:18:56 If you have a gun, you almost universally don't vote or vote for right-leaning parties.
00:19:01 So I think it's just that there's not a lot of votes for the NDP to pick up by doing this.
00:19:06 They alienate their hardcore, more progressive left urban base by doing this.
00:19:13 Corey, do you think there's any point in the NDP standing up opposing this?
00:19:20 Or are they just going to?
00:19:22 They're doing what's most politically expedient for them is just stay silent on it.
00:19:26 Because their own base does want to see a gun grab.
00:19:29 And as Nigel said, they are running contrary to where Jagmeet has been outspoken on it.
00:19:36 And I mean, typically they'll allow some degree of independence at the parties.
00:19:39 unless a fight comes between the provincial leader and a federal, they'd rather not have that even
00:19:43 come out. Because in the end, with their party structure, if it came to such a standoff,
00:19:49 Singh would be able to override a provincial leader technically. It's unlikely. But there's
00:19:55 no real way to enforce it. Jagmeet Singh is... Well, he could pull her party status, but that's...
00:19:59 Yeah, but what would happen instantly is the Alberta NDP would say, fine, now we're
00:20:03 our own separate provincial NDP. Yeah, it's a very unlikely eventuality. It would never,
00:20:07 I don't think would ever really come to that. I mean, and there have been disagreements.
00:20:11 Notley was not the friendliest towards energy and pipelines, but relative to Thomas Mulcair,
00:20:17 she was practically a rig pick. So, you know, there has been daylight on some issues. There's
00:20:22 not really an enforcement mechanism. It's just, it is a very bizarre and I think unhealthy thing
00:20:27 to have federated political parties like the NDP where it really is one and by supporting one,
00:20:32 are obliged to support another I've often split my votes federally and provincially I've I voted
00:20:38 while rose provincially and at least sometimes conservative federally or I voted or I vote
00:20:45 provincially conservative I voted federally libertarian or PPC but you know whereas with
00:20:50 the NDP your money goes to both it's bizarre stuff okay let's move on to Justin's transition
00:20:59 And that's right, Justin is transitioning the oil and gas workers into new green eco-friendly jobs.
00:21:09 So the federal government, Justin Trudeau has been talking about this for some time, using the term just transition that, yes, I'm sorry, we're going to have to eliminate your industry.
00:21:19 We're going to have to eliminate these high-paying, mortgage-paying jobs that, you know, some of which you have to be highly educated for, some of which are just kind of the only way for a lot of blue-collar people to make their way up in the world.
00:21:35 We're sorry we're going to have to eliminate these jobs, but we're going to provide new jobs in their place.
00:21:40 We saw this with coal in Alberta. The Alberta NDP did kind of a just transition thing in their eyes at least. Eliminated the coal jobs and offered people jobs screwing in eco-friendly light bulbs and putting up solar panels or something to that effect.
00:21:57 Trudeau is now saying this is where we're going federally. And I don't think we've seen much in the way of detail yet. But I don't know. How serious a package would you expect this to be, Nigel?
00:22:10 Well, not terribly. And whatever it is, I don't see how there's anything that the federal government can do to replace this particular industry.
00:22:19 This industry employs about 140,000 Canadians. It was 165,000 in 2014, so they've already been successful in whittling it down.
00:22:30 But those Canadians who are working in the energy industry are earning, on average, $125,000 a year compared to the national average in the year that that was taken, which was 2019, $57,000, double the national average wages.
00:22:51 One third of those workers are women.
00:22:54 55% of them are immigrants.
00:22:56 There's a tradition.
00:22:57 That was the first job I had when I came to this country.
00:22:58 And immigrants didn't even include in the new fees.
00:23:01 Yeah, they're always welcome.
00:23:04 For the record, immigrants speak better English than the Newfies. 0.97
00:23:07 Sorry, Arthur.
00:23:08 Yeah, Arthur's...
00:23:10 I should say more intelligible English.
00:23:12 So, just transition.
00:23:16 Transition to what?
00:23:17 To another $125,000 top-level job?
00:23:22 I mean, let's not be patronizing, but a lot of the guys who are on the rigs
00:23:26 are not going to roll over seamlessly into computer programming.
00:23:30 In fact, I've seen how that worked.
00:23:31 30 years ago, I ran a paper on Vancouver Island that was a big mill town.
00:23:35 And that's what they wanted to do.
00:23:37 They wanted to get, well, they lost their contracts.
00:23:41 They had no option.
00:23:42 And so there was this transition from being a forestry worker to what?
00:23:48 And they decided computers.
00:23:50 And so right by my office, there was another office where these guys were the grade 8, grade 9 education.
00:23:57 who'd come out of school early, gone into the forestry industry, made big money,
00:24:02 and now they were being shown how to use a 386.
00:24:06 It didn't go well.
00:24:09 And I suspect that just transition is a label for a BS program
00:24:16 was going to take people out of the oil and gas industry,
00:24:20 where they did earn very high wages,
00:24:21 some of them earn a lot more than $125,000,
00:24:24 and put them into something where they can't earn a third of that.
00:24:30 I mean, let's face it, putting in solar panels and working on windmills,
00:24:36 these are not jobs where you make that kind of money.
00:24:39 So I think the whole thing is a hoax.
00:24:41 Or put it this way, it's a public relations exercise
00:24:45 to put the best possible face on something that is going to be deeply wounding
00:24:50 to a hell of a lot of people, and not only in Alberta.
00:24:52 This is right across the country. Our industry here in Alberta affects something like 168,000 jobs in B.C., Ontario, Quebec, Atlantic, Canada, people who earn something from the Alberta and Saskatchewan energy industries.
00:25:12 It's like about $30 billion that's earned here that's spread out across the country. So this is huge.
00:25:18 Corey, you've got quite a bit of history in the patch.
00:25:21 I think you were a landman?
00:25:23 Surveyor.
00:25:23 Surveyor.
00:25:24 Surveyor.
00:25:25 You've worked in the patch.
00:25:27 I don't think you've – did you ever work the rigs themselves?
00:25:29 No.
00:25:30 No.
00:25:30 I was an advanced man.
00:25:31 Yeah.
00:25:32 Okay, but you've spent a lot of time in the industry.
00:25:36 You know, I remember a speech from Rex Murphy once he came to Calgary,
00:25:39 and it was just – he could make drilling for oil emotional.
00:25:45 He's just – he's the poet laureate.
00:25:47 of Alberta, and he's a new fee. So many of our greatest Albertans are new fees. But,
00:25:55 you know, he talked about how this was the greatest welfare program in the history of Canada,
00:25:59 you had, you know, provided a place where, you know, young, unemployed or underemployed young
00:26:06 men and women could come from Newfoundland, or rural Alberta people could come with, you know,
00:26:11 high school or sometimes even less education you know oil patches is not just that there's a lot
00:26:17 of really highly educated people there's engineers all sorts of crazy stuff but you know you can work
00:26:22 the rigs uh with not a lot of background you can come from poor families poor backgrounds
00:26:29 and this was the the greatest place by far for opportunity unless you got lucky with
00:26:34 the business or something. You know, is there any way that Trudeau could structure this program
00:26:43 to provide anything comparable? If money's not an object? Is there any way like if Trudeau just
00:26:49 opens up the checkbook? Is there any way to structure something that can provide anything
00:26:52 comparable to you? Oh, and there's no industry growing like that. You know, people talk about
00:26:55 tech. Well, look at it. Look at all the layoffs. Shopify is laying off. Amazon's laying off.
00:26:59 Twitter is laying off. It's not a growth industry. And the presumption of this whole
00:27:04 just transition is that this industry is in decline. But that is contrary to what's happening
00:27:08 everywhere else in the world. You know, petrochemical production demand is projected
00:27:15 to go up for decades. And we have it here, we should be increasing. In fact, there is a labor
00:27:21 shortage in the field right now. So it's ludicrous when we're sitting in this situation to say we
00:27:26 we want to transition people out of this and you don't have somewhere to send them to. And as you
00:27:30 said, it's a broad industry. I mean, we always think of the rigs and the guys work in there,
00:27:34 but there is a whole lot more to it. Everything from the campies cleaning the rooms and the cooks
00:27:39 to truckers to production accountants in the city. And these are all, again, major roles that
00:27:47 are paying very well that we need. And there's no easy place to transition them to it. As Nigel
00:27:52 said, it is a farce, but pursuing this farce can do a lot of damage. And the thing that worries me
00:27:57 is that if the markets are left alone, it'll continue to grow out there and there will be
00:28:02 no need to transition, at least for a few decades. Is the government anticipating interfering in that
00:28:07 market, thus causing the need for the transition? Well, I think that's the whole point. And I
00:28:10 suspect that, yes, and that's where the real fear comes in. They already are. I mean, I suppose they
00:28:16 could go further. No tankers, you know, bragging, bragging pipelines. They haven't flipped up the
00:28:24 switch, but they've, they've just turned down the power supply. They can get worse. There's
00:28:29 always room to get worse. Okay, well, let's switch it up. You know, we started all the way out east
00:28:34 that we kind of worked towards just transition for the broader west. But let's now finish it
00:28:39 with Alberta, does Danielle Smith have a mandate? So the 1.00
00:28:45 nominated NDP candidate in Red Deer, North Alberta, from
00:28:50 getting her name right, Jaylene Tweedle, says that Danielle 0.97
00:28:54 has Daniel Smith has no mandate to govern Alberta. But we've
00:28:59 also seen this from the NDP all over, including Rachel Notley
00:29:02 back in November said that Daniel Smith has no right to act
00:29:06 on some of these policies like an Alberta pension plan
00:29:10 as opposed to the Canadian pension plan,
00:29:12 Alberta Provincial Police Force, Sovereignty Act.
00:29:17 I don't know, these might be good things,
00:29:21 but I think it actually raises an interesting point.
00:29:24 Daniel Smith has not had a general election.
00:29:27 She has not faced the voters at large.
00:29:30 So the UCP has a mandate broadly to govern,
00:29:34 maybe not for some of these individual policy items, but broadly to govern.
00:29:39 But, you know, Daniel Smith was not elected in the last election.
00:29:42 She has a mandate from United Conservative Party members, but not Albertans at large.
00:29:48 We'll start with you, Corey.
00:29:49 Do you think the NDP has a point in saying Daniel Smith doesn't have a mandate to do these things?
00:29:54 It's kind of where you are. It's yes and no.
00:29:56 I mean, it's unreasonable when they were first coming out, call an election, call an election, call an election.
00:30:00 When you've been elected the leader, you don't have a mandate.
00:30:01 Look, that's not how our system works.
00:30:02 And we know that I need a mandate. He didn't say that until he was high in the polls, the wild rose he thought was destroyed.
00:30:08 But well, speaking of NDP silence, E.B. is out in B.C.
00:30:11 He didn't even have to defeat a single person in the leadership race to become premier as an NDP premier.
00:30:16 And I don't hear Notley saying, you know, David, you should call an election over there.
00:30:20 So there's their standard as usual is double, if not triple when it comes to things.
00:30:24 But that said, Danielle Smith has proposed some some pretty serious policy changes.
00:30:30 And when you are only six months from a scheduled election, I think it would be more responsible to campaign on those platform things rather than starting to implement them.
00:30:40 And I don't think there's any indication there's going to be a provincial police force, a provincial pension plan or any of those things in place or even moving towards being in place by May of this year.
00:30:50 So those will be questions coming up.
00:30:52 And, you know, if Danielle Smith was trying to ram those through before the election, then I think maybe there's some questions to be asked.
00:30:59 But at this point, I think it's just posturing. And, you know, Albertans will decide whether or not Premier Smith has a mandate in May.
00:31:07 So, Nigel, there's I hate to equivocate, but there's kind of two. There's a lot of several points on both sides of this.
00:31:15 I take Corey's point that maybe she should wait till she has a mandate. But people also want to see action.
00:31:21 They want to see governing. And many Albertans want to see how she's different than Jason Kenney.
00:31:25 So at the same time, you know, I don't think she could sit around and kind of do nothing and just kind of mine the house for six months, then get to it after. 0.99
00:31:33 But a lot of these things, it seems they're putting in place the pieces to be able to implement if they get a mandate in the next election.
00:31:40 They're putting in place the pieces to move towards an Alberta police force, move towards an Alberta pension plan.
00:31:47 Sovereignty Act, they did just, they outright passed it.
00:31:50 They haven't invoked it on anything yet.
00:31:52 But, you know, the Sovereignty Act doesn't affect you on a daily basis the way, say, Canada Pension Plan or police will.
00:32:00 It's just sort of there.
00:32:02 And a future government can repeal it with a simple bill in the legislature.
00:32:06 Do you think the NDP has got a point here that she doesn't have a mandate and she should either call an election or not really do all that much until the next election?
00:32:14 So if the NDP did have a point, then they would have to be ruled by their own narrow stretchers here.
00:32:22 And I don't recall the NDP being in any way restrained by a lack of a mandate.
00:32:28 Surely you wouldn't imply that politicians could be inconsistent.
00:32:33 I certainly would.
00:32:34 And I think that the NDP, you know, nobody, I mean, just to take one,
00:32:38 nobody asked to have their children educated to wonder whether they were boys or girls.
00:32:43 And that all got started off with the NDP.
00:32:46 Carbon tax.
00:32:47 They never mentioned a single word about the 2015 election.
00:32:50 so let's not get too hung up on the ndp making a pious face and saying which he has no mandate
00:32:56 tell you what danielle smith premier of alberta ran has paid the most attention to health care
00:33:04 reform the sovereignty act and to relieving the distress of a rising inflation on the the economy
00:33:12 just have the details of that one you always have a mandate it doesn't matter who you are or how
00:33:17 long you've been premier, you always have a mandate to relieve the distress of ordinary
00:33:23 Albertans who are going to benefit from that program of tax relief. That's number one. You
00:33:30 don't need to fight an election to know that as premier, that's your job. Number two, you always
00:33:36 have, if you are premier, however you got there, you always have a mandate to make healthcare work
00:33:43 better. You don't need to go to an election to say, this is what we need to do, and here's how
00:33:48 we're going to do it. She can be judged at the election if it doesn't go well, but she certainly
00:33:55 has a mandate to make improvements if she can see how to do it. And then the third thing, you want 1.00
00:34:00 a mandate for the Sovereignty Act? Look, Jason Kenney won his position on the basis of taking
00:34:10 it to Ottawa. And he lost his position. I think we're all agreed around this table anyway. He
00:34:16 lost his position when he didn't adequately take the fight to Ottawa. So, does the UCP
00:34:25 government have a mandate to take a tough line with Ottawa? Yes, it does. Has Danielle Smith 0.96
00:34:31 been consistent with that? Yes, she has so far. We'll see how it goes. But I would say that she
00:34:38 has not stepped outside the narrow lanes in which the NDP would like to confine her.
00:34:45 There's also, you know, I don't think the NDP are responsible for this, but
00:34:49 I don't think most people understand how our system of government works.
00:34:53 People act like they're electing a premier. You know, you were never elected premier,
00:34:58 your members made you a party leader. Technically only one in 87 Albertans vote for the premier.
00:35:05 the premier is merely an MLA only people in a single constituency vote for the premier
00:35:10 or you know or conceivably maybe two people uh people in two constituencies or maybe three or
00:35:17 four i don't know how many parties are around uh vote for someone who could potentially be premier
00:35:24 technically there's only 87 people in alberta who vote for the premier and that are those are
00:35:29 MLAs. MLAs vote for premier. MPs vote for prime minister. It's essentially a glorified electoral
00:35:36 college, similar to the American system. Most Americans don't technically vote for president.
00:35:42 They effectively do. But, you know, we don't elect premiers. We don't elect prime ministers. You
00:35:48 elect MLAs and you elect MPs and they select who it is. Now, you normally have a good idea because
00:35:53 there's a leader of a party. But I mean, geez, 19, some point in the 30s, Albertans elected a
00:36:00 government with no premier. When the social, when social credit swept away the United Farmers of
00:36:05 Alberta. To the surprise of everyone, including the social credit, social credit, which is barely
00:36:11 even a political party, didn't even call them social party, social credit league, they just
00:36:15 won a majority of seats, and they had no leader. And so what did they do? Well, they elected one
00:36:20 of their own. And that guy wasn't even an MLA. It was Bill Eberhardt, and he had to run the
00:36:24 by-election to come in. So I just don't, I know I'm getting a little too into the weeds with this
00:36:29 stuff, but I think there's a misunderstanding of the system. That being said, the only real way
00:36:35 to determine, does someone have a mandate to do something, I have to admit, boils down to,
00:36:39 do I like that person and what they're doing? I mean, we're going to say they have a mandate.
00:36:44 If we like what they're doing, we like the person. And if we don't like the person,
00:36:48 and we don't like what they're doing, we say they don't have a mandate. That's more or less what it
00:36:53 boils down to. I think the only real time you can make a very clear case someone has no mandate is
00:36:57 they get elected on one thing and they do something completely different or something
00:37:02 that was out of left field. Rachel Notley in the carbon tax was one such thing. It was, 0.52
00:37:07 it didn't even get fine print. They didn't even allude to it. And they got elected. And one of
00:37:12 the first things they do is carbon tax. That was a pretty clear case of no mandate.
00:37:18 Bill 6, the farm bill they did, they had a little something for it. It was a bad idea. But I'd say much more terrifying than doing things without a mandate is when the NDP do things that they do have a mandate for. Most of the worst things the NDP did when they came to power in Alberta were things that they had a mandate for because many, many Albertans didn't pay attention to their platform.
00:37:39 They just wanted to get rid of the PCs and Richard Motley seemed nice.
00:37:42 No one reads a platform. So I don't know. What do you think, Corey?
00:37:46 Is it more dangerous when governments do have a mandate?
00:37:48 When they're NDP, that's for sure. And ironically, I mean, it's a good point to make.
00:37:53 That was something I remember Daniel Smith saying in the past when she was a radio host.
00:37:57 A leader is lost if you lose your caucus. That's the point.
00:38:00 That's the tip. She learned that lesson herself quite in the hardest of ways, as have many other leaders.
00:38:06 if you don't have a mandate among those other MLAs, you are not going to stay in there for
00:38:11 terribly long. One of the things the NDP were really hoping for, actually, because they were
00:38:14 trying to foster those post-leadership divisions, was that there was going to be a split party or
00:38:17 some floor crossers or people stomping out the door. And that didn't happen. And they've been 1.00
00:38:22 pretty distressed about that. And I think that's part of why they're moving on to this mandate
00:38:25 canard as well. Yeah. All right. Well, we're going to wrap it up there. Thank you gentlemen
00:38:30 for joining me today. I thank all of you for being with us. If you're not yet a member of
00:38:33 Western Standard, please do. The Western Standard is bailout free. We refuse to accept a penny of
00:38:39 the federal government's media bailout. We rely on sponsors and of course, memberships from people
00:38:45 like you. Becoming a member gets you full access to all Western Standard content. You get past that
00:38:50 pesky paywall that I know you hate if you don't have a membership. Go to westernstandard.news,
00:38:54 click on membership, sign up. It's going to be money well spent, I promise you. Thank you very
00:39:00 much for joining us today and God bless. Here's a quick look at what commodity prices are doing
00:39:04 in Lethbridge today. Cash barley is down $4 at $4.37, feed wheat is down $3 at $4.42, and corn
00:39:11 is down $2 at $4.40 per ton. In the milling wheat markets, March Minneapolis futures at 1.5 cents
00:39:17 at $8.96 per bushel, with local hardwood spring bid for Jan Feb movement at $11.55 per bushel.
00:39:25 Looking at canola, nearby futures slipped $3.90 at $8.3770 per tonne, with delivered
00:39:31 buys for February movement at $18.55 per bushel. In the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices
00:39:37 are higher half a cent at $0.33 per pound, and yellow peas are trading at $13.25 per bushel.
00:39:43 And in the cattle markets, February live cattle are lower $7.50 at $1.5768 per 100 weight.
00:39:49 For more information on pricing or picked up options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:39:56 I'm Matt Busiekum at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:40:02 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:40:09 These guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms, regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:40:16 and more importantly educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong
00:40:21 people. To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny. You can become a Western 0.90
00:40:28 Center member for just $10 a month or $99 a year.