Western Standard - September 01, 2022


The Pipeline - Kenney reverses his own tax hike

Hosted by
Mentioned
UCP Leadership Debate HANNAFORD Sovereignty Act is all politics, nothing about law

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

178.18

Word count

9,855

Sentence count

681

Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The United Conservative Party leadership debate is over, and the dust has settled on the candidates for the leadership race. This week, Derek Fildebrandt and Nigel Hannaford join the show to discuss the debate, the media's reaction to it, and whether or not there's a double standard when it comes to harassment of public officials.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:22 You're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:25 Today is August 31st, 2022.
00:00:28 We've got a great show coming up, but first I want to introduce our regular co-hosts, or semi-regular co-hosts, Western Standard Opinion Editor, Nigel Hannaford. How are you feeling, Nigel?
00:00:42 Great today. The debate is over.
00:00:44 Top of the morning.
00:00:45 And joining us again is former Western Standard Opinion Editor and now Western Standard Senior Alberta Political Columnist, Corey Morgan. Good to see you again, Corey.
00:00:56 Oh, it's good to be back in the office. It's good to be away for a week to do this.
00:01:00 Well, you're not supposed to say that part. I never like to leave. I sleep here.
00:01:04 Yeah, I know.
00:01:05 Okay, we've got a great show. We're going to be talking about the final United Conservative Party leadership debate,
00:01:12 the second of the official debates, the third or fourth, depending on how you're counting it,
00:01:18 or the 15th, if there's a bunch of tiny little regional ones as well,
00:01:22 But probably the third or fourth major debate and the final one. And boy, did it disappoint. But I think largely, we're going to get into that. Not too good.
00:01:34 All right. Kenny has reversed his giant tax hike. One of the first things he did as premier
00:01:44 was to de-index income taxes, bracket creep as they call it. And on his way out the door,
00:01:52 he, I think it might be one of the greatest things he's done as premier is to undo one
00:01:56 of the worst things he did as premier. We're going to talk about that. Also, we're going
00:02:01 talk about the media double standard around harassment of public officials. I'm sure you've
00:02:07 read and listened and watched all sorts of breathless media coverage of the guy who made
00:02:14 some rather impolite, I think he seemed like an unpleasant character, but the guy who made some,
00:02:19 who was screaming obscenities at federal deputy prime minister, Chris Gia Freeland,
00:02:25 And expressing the way I think a lot of Albertans feel, but doing so in very, I think, un-Albertan welcoming language.
00:02:35 We're going to talk about the breathless media coverage of that versus other times where there's been verbal assaults, or in fact, physical assaults, but against conservatives.
00:02:45 We're going to talk about the difference in the media coverage of that.
00:02:49 We're going to do so on the federal level and on the provincial level.
00:02:52 You might not be that surprised that there might be a double standard involved.
00:02:57 Before we get started, though, I want to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:03:02 CSSA has been standing on guard for your right to legally own and use firearms in Canada.
00:03:09 Without the CSSA, the Trudeau government would have taken away our right to bear any kind of firearms in Canada long ago.
00:03:15 They're on the front lines helping any politician who will listen to craft smart firearms legislation and regulation.
00:03:21 And very importantly, doing yeoman's work on firearms education in Canada, helping Canadians at large understand what is smart firearms legislation, if that's not a contradiction in terms to begin with.
00:03:38 I've been a member of the CSSA for well over a decade because I trust them as Canada's leading gun rights organization to defend my right to own a gun in Canada.
00:03:47 If you're not yet a member, you should be.
00:03:49 Go to cssa-clia.org.
00:03:53 Corey, you're proud of me for getting that right?
00:03:55 You didn't get it right.
00:03:56 It says cssa-cila.org.
00:04:00 What did I say?
00:04:02 CLIA.
00:04:03 The best thing is to Google.
00:04:05 Sorry, it's CL...
00:04:06 C-I-L-A. 1.00
00:04:09 For F's thing. 0.95
00:04:11 CSSA, I love you, but you got to change the French acronym on your name
00:04:15 or at least your website. Okay, go to where, Corey?
00:04:20 CSSA-CILA.org. I have the advantage of a lot of repetition on that.
00:04:27 I love you, CSSA, but not that part. Sorry. Okay, let's get into it. The last UCP leadership
00:04:36 debate was last night. It was an official party debate. We're going to get into more specific
00:04:42 areas, but Nigel, give us your general high-level thoughts first.
00:04:46 High-level thoughts.
00:04:48 High-level.
00:04:48 Given the choice between watching that and a long drink of warm water, they're about
00:04:53 the same.
00:04:54 It was not what you'd call exciting stuff.
00:04:58 The only time I saw any real slapdown was when Trevor Taves challenged one of his opponents
00:05:07 that you should have read.
00:05:09 What should they have read?
00:05:11 The government financial statements, which is that thick,
00:05:14 and it's not something you'd ever pick up unless you really need it to.
00:05:18 I think it should be Travis Taves, yeah.
00:05:20 Yeah, Travis Taves.
00:05:21 What did I say?
00:05:22 Trevor Taves.
00:05:23 Trevor.
00:05:24 Well, okay.
00:05:25 There's a lot of Taves in this part of the world.
00:05:27 Yes, yeah.
00:05:28 But Travis Taves is certainly unmistakable.
00:05:31 Thought-level thoughts?
00:05:32 I mean, everybody won.
00:05:33 At the end of every debate, well, who won?
00:05:35 Every team claimed to.
00:05:37 We'll hold off on that part.
00:05:38 Sure.
00:05:39 We will get to that.
00:05:41 Okay, so let's talk kind of, before we get into how the candidates did, let's talk about the debate in general.
00:05:46 It's format, questions.
00:05:48 Well, look, you've got two hours, you've got seven candidates, you've got seven questions,
00:05:54 and everybody has to get a fair kick at the can, otherwise it doesn't look like it was done.
00:06:00 But you also have a party that is focused on unity and civility.
00:06:05 And so from the spectator point of view, it's kind of hard to make a big thing out of a pot bowl question.
00:06:13 Tell me what you would do to improve life for farmers.
00:06:17 Well, that's important to farmers. 0.99
00:06:19 But it's a bullshit question. 0.97
00:06:20 But it still doesn't really, you know, there's not much room to get into controversy there. 0.99
00:06:25 Yeah.
00:06:26 So, you know, Corey, it's an official party debate, so it had to include all seven.
00:06:33 I think most of us could agree that from previous experience, less than seven makes for more interaction.
00:06:40 But it's an official party debate, and because it's official, they have to have all seven there.
00:06:44 There was no way around that.
00:06:46 But, you know, I want your thoughts on the format.
00:06:50 We'll get into, you know, this idea that they had these vague, very puffball questions, as Nigel was saying.
00:06:58 you know uh it wasn't um you know what will you do to um you know increase market access for farmers
00:07:07 uh it would be you know some long preamble about how great the ucp is followed by and what will
00:07:12 you do to make agricultural policy even better that's not the exact question specifically and
00:07:17 then they would say specifically yeah they would ask a general vague question and then always say
00:07:22 and specifically um what are your thoughts on how like you know the questioning well it's probably
00:07:27 where the candidates almost want it to be too and this tail end i mean they're all actually now
00:07:31 courting second place votes is what they're doing their strategy has changed they've they've you
00:07:34 know people don't switch allegiance this late in the race very much unless there's been a
00:07:38 catastrophe of some kind so they don't want much for fireworks anyways they want to look congenial
00:07:43 to the other candidates uh strategically something that changed i guess you know with the format as
00:07:47 well i mean the first one they really messed up when they had that opportunity to okay choose who
00:07:52 you're going to debate well yeah so just before you get there explain for those who didn't watch
00:07:57 this painful debate experience, they'd be asked this BS vague question. And then the candidate
00:08:03 who got the question, and you could tell, I think they were given the questions in advance. They
00:08:08 had these scripts they're reading from. It looked like it. And then the candidate could ask anyone
00:08:13 else a question they want. And that was BS too. It's kind of interesting that they didn't ask
00:08:19 Daniel Smith very often, did they? Well, I think that's where Corey is going, is because it was
00:08:23 the same format as their first official debate. And they screwed that up because they were all
00:08:27 asking Danielle questions. I don't think they did that this time. No, they did realize their
00:08:30 mistake because Danielle is a smart orator. She doesn't get shaken. She doesn't get rattled. 1.00
00:08:35 And every time you give her another two minutes to speak, she's just gaining more support. And I
00:08:39 watched that first appearance. You're calling out the strongest one here. I mean, if she was a 0.96
00:08:44 terrible speaker, if she had bad points to make, then fine, keep going to her. But they just gave 0.99
00:08:48 her more airtime. She had, I mean, and when you're trying to grab oxygen amongst seven candidates,
00:08:53 it's hard to stand out. But when they're all turning to her the first time, she was actually
00:08:57 leave the face you saw half of the time for the entire debate. This time around, they figured
00:09:00 that out. Let's not give her more oxygen than you need to. Yeah. And again, I just don't think
00:09:05 anybody was eager to have any sparks at this point. They're all trying to hold the line.
00:09:09 As you said about the second place stuff. So instead of most of the questions being,
00:09:13 Danielle, why are you trying to destroy Canada with the Sovereignty Act? It was,
00:09:19 Travis, why is your tie so nice? It was trying to ingratiate one another for second ballot
00:09:26 of choices or to or maybe if you're a lower candidate you're hoping maybe Travis wins that
00:09:32 you know you'll be treated nicely when cabinet picks come along um yeah I think it's a really
00:09:37 good one I remember you wrote a column on it at the time and then you did a show um that
00:09:41 all those questions focused on Smith in the first debate they made at the Smith show
00:09:45 this time they um they talked about Smith and slammed her all the time but they didn't do it
00:09:52 questions to her they would they would debate each other and say nice things about each other
00:09:57 and be like what do you share with us why you think the sovereignty act is the worst thing
00:10:01 since the atomic bomb they'd figured that out and and again yeah they there's no doubt too that 0.79
00:10:08 she's still the front runner at least as far as they're concerned their internals have got to be
00:10:11 telling them that i mean if she was lagging you're not going to be turning your guns at her then and
00:10:15 they're still all focused on her uh things haven't changed much i think from that first debate it's
00:10:21 just as far as the progression of the race, you're in the latter half. So the tactics are going to
00:10:26 change. But the policies, there's not much new coming out. They're all just trying to hold on
00:10:31 to what they got. And as I said, try to get those second place votes. Because if somebody doesn't
00:10:34 win it in the first ballot, it's going to be really critical in this system to try and pick
00:10:38 up a lot of those second place choices. The debate in general, do you think UCP members got anything
00:10:48 out of it i wonder how many actually watched it to the end to be honest with you um so the answer
00:10:54 is no i i can't imagine that anybody changed their mind as a result of anything they heard there
00:11:01 last night uh it's very hard to be prescriptive about what a perfect setup for a leadership
00:11:08 debate is because on the one hand you don't want to stromash in the in the uh on the stage or
00:11:16 chaos it makes for good entertainment well it's entertaining but i encourage chaos in our debate
00:11:21 and i think it went great we intentionally courted chaos but you know i mean i mean
00:11:26 josh davidson did an excellent job of hosting the event but he was so anxious to make sure that
00:11:33 people didn't cut into candidates time by applauding when really they should be quiet
00:11:38 i think he spent more time scolding people about don't applaud don't applaud uh than people actually
00:11:44 She's been applauding, you know, and you sort of want it like that.
00:11:47 Well, it accepts the energy in the room.
00:11:48 Yeah.
00:11:49 Like, in our debate, there was lots of applause.
00:11:53 Every once in a while, it was just a bit excessive.
00:11:56 But we liked it because it adds the energy.
00:11:59 It makes the candidates, puts the candidates more in the ring.
00:12:02 You know, can you imagine, you know, if you've ever done mixed martial arts
00:12:07 or any kind of boxing, it's not very fun to fight without a crowd.
00:12:11 Right.
00:12:11 I think of those NFL games during the COVID when they had the cutout fake audiences in the background in an empty arena.
00:12:16 Yeah, it's not the same if you're not hearing thousands of screenings.
00:12:19 You want that, and it materially changes the debate.
00:12:23 Well, you know, sometimes the speaker actually draws energy from the crowd.
00:12:27 That's where you know that you're a politician.
00:12:31 Former.
00:12:31 Former politician.
00:12:33 So, you asked me what I thought.
00:12:37 I watched it through, but it was hard work.
00:12:39 We had a fair number of people watching on our own stream of it. I got a weird message about halfway through the debate from an NDP staffer in Edmonton and said, no, I can't actually say if the UCP stream was not good or not, but the person claimed at least that the official UCP stream is not very good.
00:13:02 So the NDP were all hate watching it on the Western Standard stream.
00:13:08 I don't know if that's true or not, but that's that's what the NDP person told me.
00:13:13 And truth is not an objective thing.
00:13:16 The NDP has no reason to flatter us.
00:13:19 The NDP doesn't have much interest in flattering us.
00:13:21 So I'll take it for what it is.
00:13:24 OK, let's we'll talk maybe more focused on the bigger and medium candidates, winners and losers.
00:13:30 Do you think anyone came on top?
00:13:33 Probably not.
00:13:34 I mean, it was more just maintaining the line.
00:13:36 Nobody made a knockout blow.
00:13:37 Nobody stepped in it ankle deep.
00:13:39 We're not seeing headlines this morning of, you know,
00:13:42 nobody made any broad new announcements or anything either.
00:13:45 It was just a steady-as-she-goes event.
00:13:47 And as Nigel said, that's where the challenges of staying awake through it were.
00:13:50 Well, Nigel, maybe I used the wrong term, winners and losers.
00:13:53 Well, that can be contextual, I guess, based on where you're coming from.
00:13:57 I'm not saying that the last place candidate landed a blow that catapults them to first or first fell to last, but who do you think, relatively speaking, relative to where they went coming into this debate, who do you think rose the most, who do you think fell the most?
00:14:15 Well, you know, Derek, something very interesting has happened over this entire campaign that
00:14:20 was cemented last night. And that is that when the campaign started, the general assumption was
00:14:27 that it was between the two former party leaders, Daniel Smith and Brian Jean. And Brian Jean,
00:14:33 without actually ever, as you put it, putting his foot in it ankle deep, has just sort of
00:14:39 not kept up
00:14:41 and Mr. Taves
00:14:43 has come
00:14:45 from behind
00:14:47 and mounted a very
00:14:49 effective
00:14:50 with all the provisos that we've said
00:14:53 that this was not theatre
00:14:55 but within the context of that
00:14:57 debate, he did well
00:14:59 he was very effective, very articulate
00:15:01 knew his files, spoke
00:15:03 firmly
00:15:04 you had the sense that if it was a
00:15:07 follow-up question he would have had the answer to it and so winners and losers I wouldn't be
00:15:14 prepared to say that there was an outright winner but it seemed to me very clear that he and Danielle
00:15:21 Smith were the two who at the end of the day you had to say it's going to be one of these or it
00:15:26 better be one of these if it's not this is not to say that people like Mr. Lewin I thought I thought
00:15:34 you know, they said sensible things. But on top, those two, yes.
00:15:44 Okay. You know, my thoughts were, I think Todd Lowen did well. You know, I don't think he came
00:15:54 out of it catapulting anywhere near frontrunner status. But I think, you know, he, I think,
00:15:59 endeared himself a lot with his comment around, you know, it was an agriculture, I think it was
00:16:03 on the bs agriculture question and he talked about uh fertilizer and he talked about uh you know if
00:16:08 we just uh you know trudeau trudeau's mouth is fertilizer and we can use that uh something to
00:16:15 that effect and it got a good rouse out of the crowd brian gene tried to jump onto that it took
00:16:20 the metaphor i think a bit too far to the point where it did definitely i'm not implying he made
00:16:25 it inappropriate or gross but it would just kind of the point where the the joke was pretty old
00:16:30 and stale and ran with it
00:16:32 too far. But I think Lowen did well
00:16:34 to endear himself there.
00:16:36 The Right to Farm Act, I think that was
00:16:37 the Right to Farm Act.
00:16:41 Largely symbolic,
00:16:42 I'm sure, but it sounds good to
00:16:44 a farmer.
00:16:45 It was more
00:16:48 or less an agriculture section of a
00:16:50 sovereignty act, more or less
00:16:52 saying, we're going to tell
00:16:54 Ottawa where to stick at any time they
00:16:56 tell our farmers what to do.
00:16:57 Right, exactly. So more or less it's a agriculture restricted section of a Sovereignty Act.
00:17:03 It's become a live issue of late with the plan to reduce nitrogen emissions. I mean,
00:17:07 there may be a case for that, certainly. So I want to talk about the two candidates who've
00:17:12 consistently pulled in by far the bottom two. And they pulled the bottom two possibly because
00:17:21 last night they came across as if they were at an NDP debate. You had Lila here and Rajan Sani
00:17:29 used a lot of rhetoric that sounded like they're trying to channel their inner Alice in Redford
00:17:34 and when you get the Alberta Teachers Union to sign up on mass. I don't think that's a strategy
00:17:38 that will work anymore because now you have the NDP. You don't need to elect a Liberal or New
00:17:43 Democrat as a PC. So I don't think that play will will work. But you had here and Sani saying things
00:17:50 like you know we're balancing the budget on the backs of our public schools you
00:17:55 know asked if they support choice in education they say I support choice and
00:17:59 then immediately say but I support our public education that is like the
00:18:03 Alberta Teachers Association they would and that's a shout out to all the
00:18:06 teachers yeah and they would organize there's a union organizers yeah and they
00:18:10 would use buzzwords around curriculum more or less implying it should be they
00:18:14 should go back to what the NDP did which is give the ATA control over the
00:18:17 curriculum, that kind of thing. I guess we'll talk about these two candidates here, Ahir and
00:18:24 Sani. Do you think they had any kind of pickup from this debate? I can't imagine who they would 0.99
00:18:31 come from, who is also a member of the United Conservative Party. That is a very, very minority
00:18:38 point of view. And you'll notice that probably the biggest round of applause that came during
00:18:43 the entire evening, came for Mr. Taves after he said, look, first principle, parents are
00:18:53 primarily responsible for the education of their children, and the whole place went wild.
00:18:58 This was right after the remarks you just quoted had been made. So I don't think there's any
00:19:04 doubt of where the party membership stands. So in terms of putting that out there at the debate,
00:19:11 I don't see what the point was
00:19:13 because that was not going to pick up votes
00:19:15 whether there is some other
00:19:16 whether that is going to be useful
00:19:19 in some other context
00:19:20 I don't know
00:19:21 but in terms of picking up last night
00:19:23 no, definitely not
00:19:24 Corey, so when Redford tried this kind of play successfully
00:19:28 it was under very different leadership rules
00:19:30 you could become a member of the PC party
00:19:33 right up until the first ballot vote
00:19:35 and if there was a second ballot vote
00:19:36 which there was, you know, to the final three
00:19:38 you could continue to sell memberships
00:19:41 right up until that last ballot vote.
00:19:44 And that's what Redford did, and she got the ATE to come in. 0.98
00:19:47 The membership cutoff has already happened,
00:19:49 so there won't be any more teachers signing up.
00:19:53 What do you think was kind of the play of here
00:19:55 and to a lesser extent, Sonny here?
00:19:58 To be honest, I don't even know why they ran.
00:20:00 I mean, it's this point in the race.
00:20:02 I mean, they're also rands, but they aren't even...
00:20:04 It's fine, you get those in every race,
00:20:05 but they aren't endearing themselves to the other candidates
00:20:08 if you're looking for a cabinet spot later
00:20:10 or a longer period.
00:20:11 I mean, it looks like Leila should have been paying better attention 1.00
00:20:13 to her constituency because chances are she's not going to win her nomination. 0.99
00:20:17 Yeah, they just lost the vote of their board there by 75% in their own writing.
00:20:21 Yeah, and strategically, I guess, Sonny, you know, you're getting some profile.
00:20:26 You got a little more known within the party.
00:20:28 You're carving out a pretty left edge over there,
00:20:31 and then you don't have that teacher's union to be able to pad those votes. 0.87
00:20:35 I'm not sure what her rationale was
00:20:39 even for running in the first place, to be honest,
00:20:41 unless she really misread what the membership of that party is.
00:20:44 But I guess maybe it'll help show balance.
00:20:47 I mean, you know, a good congenial leader afterwards
00:20:50 might say, well, we'll put you in cabinet social services
00:20:53 or something just to pacify that wing of the party.
00:20:56 Or perhaps they're going to be looking at something
00:20:57 like Alberta party in the next election or something.
00:21:02 I want to do, I'm going to get you,
00:21:04 I'm going to get us all on the record. We're going to predict, and we've had an office pool
00:21:09 going on the other side of the door in the hallway on how the federal conservative leadership is
00:21:14 going to break down. We haven't really gotten on the record for Alberta yet. So, you know,
00:21:21 we've got Smith, Taves, Gene, Schultz, Lowen, Sonny, Aheer. I want predictions. I'll put,
00:21:29 I'd say a case of beer, but a case of beer. A beer would be very satisfactory.
00:21:34 Okay. I'm willing to go in on a case of beer. I'm going to bet here. For you, cash equivalent.
00:21:41 Put a case in the fridge for guests.
00:21:43 Okay. There we go. I'm going to bet a case of beer here, but you got to rank them in the right order in which they're going to place on first ballot.
00:21:51 Your predictions, Corey. Let's start with last and work your way up, or from first and work your way down.
00:21:57 Last, we're looking at the top three, or are you looking at all seven?
00:22:00 All seven. All seven from first to last.
00:22:03 I think here is going to come in in seventh.
00:22:06 Very recently so.
00:22:08 Okay.
00:22:10 Sonny will come in sixth.
00:22:12 She's got a solid base of support in Northeast Calgary,
00:22:15 and she's courting that, and it'll get some numbers in. 0.97
00:22:17 But it'll still be a far, far distance.
00:22:19 I won't try to go for percentages.
00:22:20 You don't need percentage.
00:22:21 Just ranking.
00:22:22 Yeah, and then Todd Lowen.
00:22:24 Fifth, yeah.
00:22:25 Brian Jean.
00:22:26 Okay.
00:22:28 Oh, wait a minute.
00:22:28 For Schultz.
00:22:30 Schultz and Jean, yeah, no, I think I'd go for Schultz
00:22:32 and then Gene.
00:22:34 I'm sorry.
00:22:35 Who's higher, who's lower?
00:22:36 Gene higher than Schultz.
00:22:38 Okay, so Schultz in fourth,
00:22:39 Gene in third.
00:22:40 Yep.
00:22:41 And Taves and Smith.
00:22:44 That's the exact order
00:22:45 I wrote mine in.
00:22:49 What are your predictions?
00:22:49 Well, I agree
00:22:52 that
00:22:53 Mesa here will
00:22:55 trail.
00:22:57 Like in dead last?
00:22:59 Seventh place.
00:22:59 Yeah.
00:22:59 And Sony will be six.
00:23:05 I actually am predicting a late rally for Rebecca Schultz.
00:23:10 It will put her into fourth place, pushing Brian Jean down to fifth.
00:23:15 So Brian Jean, five.
00:23:18 Rebecca Schultz, fourth.
00:23:20 Sorry, and where's Lohan?
00:23:22 Lohan is three.
00:23:23 Lohan in third.
00:23:26 Schultz in fourth.
00:23:27 Oh, sorry.
00:23:28 Oh, Schultz in fourth.
00:23:29 Gene in fifth and second first. Well, Smith first and Tave second. Okay, bold. I could see it
00:23:37 happening. But it is bold, yes. It's a bold one? Yeah. Okay. I shall have reserved beer. I think
00:23:43 you'll probably, you should actually get odds for it because you're breaking food. I'm going to stick
00:23:48 with the conventional wisdom. We've been good at being wrong before too though, so there's still
00:23:53 room. I mean, this is an easy call. I have never been wrong. I've never been wrong,
00:23:58 particularly about anything in politics. Yeah. Okay. And just for the record, from first to last,
00:24:04 Smith, Taves, Gene, Schultz, Lowen, Sonny, Aheer. I think that's probably the conventional wisdom,
00:24:11 at least the more objective observers. Okay. Well, it's on the record. We're going to come back to it
00:24:19 on United Conservative Party election night. Speaking of which, we're going to have live
00:24:23 broadcast on the night of the federal conservative leadership vote, which is what September
00:24:28 10th? Yes. September 10th, we're going to have live wall-to-wall coverage. I think it'll be a
00:24:33 lot better than the last time we covered a federal conservative leadership. God, it has to be.
00:24:38 We have better than like a phone camera taped to a wall. We need to have good tape.
00:24:45 We're obviously going to have a live full night coverage of the United Conservative Party race
00:24:49 as well. Okay, let's move on. Speaking of why they're having a United Conservative Party
00:24:55 leadership race. Jason Kinney on the way out. He's trying to check some things off. I think he's
00:25:01 trying to leave himself. It's very interesting. You wouldn't think that the man who founded and
00:25:09 led a party and is turfed by that party three years after forming a majority government,
00:25:13 you wouldn't think that that's, you wouldn't think he's actually been thrown out. He seems to be
00:25:18 going around acting like he's served like three terms. He's done a long time as premier and he is
00:25:23 just kind of on his long way out. He's doing legacy building. And one of these
00:25:28 things he's done, maybe you want to challenge me on that. But one of the things he's done is
00:25:34 reverse. One of the first things he did as premier, which was reversing the indexation
00:25:40 of income taxes. Now that's called bracket cream. And just for a little history for people,
00:25:46 Jason Kenney became known in Alberta and across Canada before entering formal politics as the
00:25:52 head of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, first then Alberta, then nationally. And he made his
00:25:56 name beating the hell out of Ralph Klein and then Paul Martin over bracket cream, saying it was 0.99
00:26:03 damn criminal. It's the government effectively raising taxes every year because inflation goes 0.88
00:26:08 up, but the tax brackets stay the same. So people are pushed into higher and higher tax brackets,
00:26:14 even though their real income is effectively the same. I think he used the term pernicious.
00:26:18 He said it was a pernicious and stealth tax hike. 0.96
00:26:22 And one of the first damn things he did when he came to office was to do exactly that. 0.60
00:26:28 Yesterday, he announced the reversal of that. 0.96
00:26:32 And I suppose that's a good thing.
00:26:36 Nigel, do you think he deserves a pat on the back for it?
00:26:40 The thing with Jason Kenney is that he has significant accomplishments behind him.
00:26:47 And when the leadership review gave him 51%, he won technically, 51%.
00:26:55 After changing the rules half a dozen times to get him 51%.
00:26:58 Don't leave me down that rabbit trail because I don't know where it ends.
00:27:02 But it gets pretty dark down there.
00:27:06 But I can try and put myself in his head and think, you know, I drove all over Alberta in an old blue Dodge truck.
00:27:13 I've done all this.
00:27:14 COVID hit me. 0.70
00:27:15 then I just as the financial situation is turning around I get thrown out darn it I'm going to have
00:27:23 my say and I'm going to leave my leave a bit of a personal legacy is that a selfless thing to do
00:27:30 when you have you know the next people coming along might be very nice to make a make that
00:27:35 gesture make these gestures maybe not but I can see how he gets there and as for the as for does
00:27:42 he deserve a pat on the back? Probably not, because he let it happen in the first place.
00:27:49 He didn't need to do that. I mean, it's never too late to do the right thing, and he's done the
00:27:56 right thing, but he's done the right thing, technically reducing the tax revenue of his
00:28:01 successor, never himself. And I get that he wants to leave the legacy. He wants to go out with
00:28:09 something positive on his name not just being chased out by his own party for arresting pastors
00:28:15 and shutting down businesses and things like that that's not how most conservatives want to be
00:28:20 remembered by history uh but he's taken away an easy win from his successor i think it goes without
00:28:25 saying we've seen in the leadership debates every single candidate has said that they would reverse
00:28:28 back at creep probably something they would do on the first day in office jason kenny just took away
00:28:34 the ability of his successor to get an easy win.
00:28:36 Do you think he's, or do you think he's, you know,
00:28:42 do you think he's being,
00:28:45 does he have the best interest of his party success
00:28:48 after him and his successor at heart here?
00:28:50 Or is it just fine, like, ah, whatever, you know, let him have it?
00:28:54 It's hard to get into his mind.
00:28:56 I mean, he wants just to go positive in the end, I guess, for himself.
00:29:00 There's no doubt about that.
00:29:01 I mean, if you were playing, and he's a political guy.
00:29:03 I mean, he's as political as they get.
00:29:04 He knows what he's doing when he does these things.
00:29:07 And you're stealing some thunder from whoever's coming in next,
00:29:09 whoever that might be, because you want them to hit the ground running.
00:29:12 They've got a general election six months after getting in.
00:29:16 They need a legislative session with a whole bunch of good,
00:29:18 popping policies that make Albertans happy.
00:29:21 Well, they can't announce the bracket creep.
00:29:22 They won't be able to do a darn thing with the surplus
00:29:24 because he's already dedicated it, which was great.
00:29:27 I thought that was another thing.
00:29:28 It's good that they put it towards debt repayment.
00:29:30 That's a very positive thing.
00:29:31 But, like, that would have been a nice little announcement for his successor to me.
00:29:36 If you're looking for a legacy, you know, pick a capital project.
00:29:39 Take a little chunk of that surplus and go cut a ribbon on something you know.
00:29:42 This was the one that Jason Kenney initiated and brought up.
00:29:45 Let Jason Kenney build the Jason Kenney Memorial Park, for all I care.
00:29:49 Yeah, nuts.
00:29:50 But, like, whatever.
00:29:52 This has some undertones.
00:29:53 Most legacies are much more expensive.
00:29:54 A little bit of spite, I think, still on.
00:29:56 You know, no, no.
00:29:57 I'm not giving you guys gifts, whoever you are replacing me.
00:29:59 You're going to work for it.
00:30:00 I'm taking the credit for this stuff.
00:30:02 I think it's because he thinks Danielle Smith is going to win.
00:30:05 Because I'm not even convinced he wants her to win the next election.
00:30:10 Because I think it's, I think he would like to be, I think when the history books are written about this, he'd like it to be, well, I could have won.
00:30:20 But these yokels kicked me out of my job.
00:30:23 And I could have won that election, but they didn't know it was good for themselves. 0.99
00:30:27 And they lost because they picked a crazy person like Danielle Smith. 1.00
00:30:30 If he has gone out of his way to attack her and her platform,
00:30:33 I'm not convinced that he actually wants her to win
00:30:37 because he'll look better in history if she doesn't.
00:30:39 That's in the back of his mind in our own little petty personal place,
00:30:43 but I still think he's a decent enough person.
00:30:44 He doesn't want to see Notley in for another term.
00:30:47 Maybe have Danielle win with three-seat majority on top of it, 1.00
00:30:51 but get a spanking, but I just don't think he's quite that vindictive.
00:30:54 I don't think he wants to see the NDP win,
00:30:56 but I don't think he also wants to see Danielle.
00:30:58 I think he might be a bit incongruent in his thinking here.
00:31:04 But everything's so bizarre with this whole year and how this has all landed.
00:31:07 So to try and guess where he's going to go and why, I think he can answer.
00:31:12 Okay, so we kind of come back maybe more to the, I kind of moneyed the first question about, do you think he deserves credit for it?
00:31:18 I mean, it's never too late to do the right thing, but does he deserve any credit for this?
00:31:24 when he, Kenny, Jason Kenney imposed one of the largest tax hikes in Alberta history. The only
00:31:31 one that was potentially larger was the NDP carbon tax, which we still have because we're willing to
00:31:36 do what Ottawa says. Do you think Kenny deserves any credit whatsoever for this?
00:31:42 As Nigel said, he never had to bring it in in the first place or the numbers were already there too
00:31:47 that he could have dropped this months ago if it was such a rush then to do it, to do it just before
00:31:51 the end of the leadership race? I don't know. There's stuff at play. Nigel? If any, whoever wins
00:31:59 the race, if they want an idea from this desk, they can do more on gas taxes. 0.61
00:32:07 Well, there's only a bit they can do, I think, because, well, as Kenny punted the date of his
00:32:15 leadership vote several times there and change the rules. He also announced they were temporarily
00:32:22 getting rid of the provincial portion of the gas tax. That was very nice. Probably extremely
00:32:26 politically motivated as he was trying to save his job, obviously was not enough. But some of
00:32:32 the candidates, I know Travis Taves, I'm not sure about Daniel Smith, but at least Taves has said
00:32:37 he would make that permanent, no provincial gas tax. I think that'll last at least as long as
00:32:41 gases, as long as oil revenue keeps coming in. But then there was Jean's proposal. So right now,
00:32:48 there is no provincial gas tax, which is nice, because it kind of more or less neutralizes
00:32:51 the federal carbon tax just means the money goes to Ottawa, though. But what can be done was Jean's
00:32:57 interesting proposal of... Actually, is that doesn't it? Now, is that actually so? Because
00:33:01 we pay GST on the price of a liter. So if you take 15 cents a liter off, that means less GST.
00:33:08 Less GST goes to Ottawa.
00:33:09 Yes, a little bit less.
00:33:11 Taves pointed that out yesterday.
00:33:13 When I was at a previous life, when I was at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation,
00:33:17 I wrote the gas tax report every single year.
00:33:20 And it's incredible how much money goes to Ottawa
00:33:23 because the GST doesn't apply to just the price of the gasoline.
00:33:27 It applies to even the gas taxes on it.
00:33:31 So if you cut the gas tax, that means actually the amount of GST going to Ottawa goes down.
00:33:36 A lot of people don't know that, you know.
00:33:37 Yeah, it's a tax on taxes. In Quebec, they have a tax on a tax on a tax. The QST, buckle up, folks, this one's wild. The QST in Quebec, it doesn't just tax the gas and the regular excise taxes on gas, it taxes the GST.
00:33:57 Because the GST is a tax on a tax.
00:33:59 The QST is a tax on a tax on a tax.
00:34:03 Now, that is some meta-tax for you there.
00:34:05 You still following me, everyone?
00:34:07 Let us know in the comments section if we're just complete.
00:34:09 We sound totally out to lunch.
00:34:11 It makes sense, I swear.
00:34:12 That's why the tax freedom day comes at the end of August in Quebec, isn't it?
00:34:15 Yeah.
00:34:17 Okay.
00:34:20 Before we move on, just on the gas tax part,
00:34:22 Jean's proposal was interesting, saying that because Albertans are the owners of the resource, we should not be paying the royalty portion at the pump.
00:34:32 So I don't know exactly how it works, but I've read it. It seems to actually make some sense.
00:34:38 You know, thoughts on that? Jean's kind of royalty tax?
00:34:41 That's actually what I had in mind. The next leader can do something, do more on gas taxes.
00:34:45 That's I just didn't remember it was Mr. Jean who said that.
00:34:49 Yeah, absolutely. Let's at least look at that.
00:34:52 It's an idea.
00:34:55 That might be an easy one.
00:34:56 It's not as easy as bracket creep, which everyone...
00:35:00 Well, no, it's not an easy thing.
00:35:02 But when you think how far people will drive to save two cents a liter,
00:35:06 whatever that royalty is worth, that is going to be appealing to some people.
00:35:12 It's a very visible thing to people on their budget.
00:35:13 Yeah.
00:35:14 Maybe what we need is...
00:35:16 They used to do this.
00:35:17 They used to put it on the side of the gas pump and say,
00:35:19 your gas cost you 50 cents and then this tax and this tax and this tax and people could actually
00:35:25 see well you know those stickers came from the canadian taxpayers federation i used to i used
00:35:29 to make those well there you go yeah and people are still talking about it derrick i've actually
00:35:33 i've got a giant version of it blown up for a press conference still on the wall in my garage
00:35:37 right now there we go okay do it again uh clearly politicians would never be hypocritical and 0.95
00:35:44 Speaking of hypocrites, let's talk about the mainstream media's harassment double standard.
00:35:52 So I think late last week or something along the lines, there was some fella in Grand Prairie, 0.90
00:36:00 and he saw that Deputy Prairie Minister Chrystia Freeland was there.
00:36:05 Apparently, she's originally from the region.
00:36:07 She does not consider herself an Albertan, but when she's here, she calls herself a daughter of Alberta or something.
00:36:12 But she's not an Albertan. She's a Torontonian.
00:36:14 But, you know, I don't think most Albertans think very highly of her.
00:36:19 But I don't think most Albertans would scream and swear the way this guy did.
00:36:23 It was, we should have actually included the video in this.
00:36:27 But I think most people have seen the video.
00:36:29 I think everyone's seen the video by now.
00:36:32 It wasn't a very good way to express oneself.
00:36:34 The media have called this an assault, or sometimes they've slightly backed up their language to say a verbal assault.
00:36:41 Maybe. But the media has made a pretty big deal of this, haven't they, Nigel?
00:36:48 Well, they have. And also, they've tried to pin it to this province. Like, you know,
00:36:52 come to Alberta, and these are the kind of people you're going to meet. It's sort of a subtext to
00:36:58 the whole thing. Because we were having this discussion, I was looking through the files,
00:37:03 and I see that they've had some pretty nasty incidents down east as well. I don't think it's
00:37:07 peculiar to Alberta or any other province. There's a general diminishment of people's standards of
00:37:15 behavior. It's been coming on for decades. This kind of thing tended not to happen so much in the
00:37:20 1950s and the 1960s, saying it didn't, but not so much. Now it's pretty common.
00:37:26 You're dating yourself a bit.
00:37:29 People look, I mean, with the cameras you're using, everybody's going to see the wrinkles.
00:37:33 i don't have to date myself it's just being done for me but um no so that you you can speculate on
00:37:41 why standards are coming down but uh the idea of a of a man sort of seeing a woman whether she's
00:37:48 in politics or not and hurling obscenities at her was absolutely outrageous at an earlier time now
00:37:57 we're talking about it on a talk show you know examining it to see whether this was definitely
00:38:01 not the best foot forward of Alberta. I don't think it's the best way to express anger.
00:38:05 Absolutely not. I have a lot of anger at the federal government and Christia Freeland, but
00:38:10 I wouldn't deign to strip down to a tank top and get up to her and start screaming obscenities. It 0.60
00:38:20 was not very nice. I think we can all agree it was not a nice thing to do. But the media,
00:38:27 I'm going to talk about the media reaction to this, though.
00:38:29 The media, Corey, have bit on this hook, line, and sinker, I think,
00:38:36 and have tried to portray this as outright violence.
00:38:41 Tried to portray it, I think, as Nigel said, in the subtext very gently as it's Albertans, you know, Albertans, 0.68
00:38:48 and that he's a racist and misogynist. 0.53
00:38:52 He could be those things, but I don't know. 0.95
00:38:54 I just take him to be an angry, uncouth, and ungentlemanly figure.
00:39:01 I don't know.
00:39:02 Your take on how the media has framed this.
00:39:04 Yeah, well, I mean, again, everybody has condemned it, and they should.
00:39:07 I mean, look, she's a small woman who, you know, even myself,
00:39:12 I had that lunatic running at me with a wife, beat her around, screaming. 1.00
00:39:14 I'm going to feel intimidated. 0.99
00:39:16 And intimidating of elected figures is unacceptable.
00:39:19 There's no getting around that.
00:39:20 And just before I get after the media, who I love getting after,
00:39:24 Some of our own typical social media supporters, it's always, it wasn't right, but, no, wait a
00:39:28 second, there's no but, you got, no, but it's but, oh, they did this, they did that, no, no, and that's
00:39:33 what feeds the media too, and you see a bunch of, and then they start pulling it up, oh, this tweeter
00:39:36 from Alberta said, well, but in her case, she's a this, and there's some really ugly discussion
00:39:42 going on out there, and it does feed a biased media, gives them the opportunity to say, this is
00:39:47 the Albertan thing, or this is what Polyev fostered, and as you said, it's in a subtext, they won't say
00:39:51 it directly, but they are doing that. What they will say directly is that Pierre Polyev, Daniel
00:39:58 Smith, the Western Standard, other non-government funded media, we're responsible for this.
00:40:06 You know, to paraphrase Thomas Sowell, the world is moving in a direction where no one's responsible
00:40:13 for anything they did, and everyone is responsible for something that other people did. This is where
00:40:19 they're going. So I think we've got some headlines that we're going to bring up here covering this.
00:40:25 So, you know, first we had some of the mainstream media coverage of, you know, the accosting of
00:40:33 Chrystia Freeland here. It's assault. It's verbal battery, all these things. It's very serious.
00:40:41 We're now like in approaching the second week of talking about this almost. This is leading the
00:40:48 editorials of all the big legacy government-funded newspapers, all the legacy government-funded
00:40:53 television stations. But I don't remember quite the same outrage when there was not very long ago
00:41:00 a physical assault on a politician in Canada. Maxime Bernier had eggs thrown at him. That is
00:41:06 physical assault. That's serious. Obviously, he was not injured in any great way. There was no
00:41:14 grenade inside the egg, but that was assault. I can't remember, Nigel, there being anywhere
00:41:20 near the outcry. Well, again, in the process of looking up the old issues, I couldn't find
00:41:28 anything where anybody said, this, of course, we deplore the egging of Mr. Bernier, but,
00:41:36 and then all the reasons why it actually was perfectly all right, barely got a mention.
00:41:41 if it did it was usually it was almost ignored well it was almost ignored except when it was
00:41:45 mocked you know couldn't have happened to a nicer guy that sort of comment yeah so you're totally
00:41:51 correct there is a double standard uh in the medium and but we knew that going in we know the
00:41:58 media tends to have a point of view there are exceptions there are people who don't fall into
00:42:04 a neat log step but generally speaking they are going to they're going to love a victim story
00:42:10 because it's a process story.
00:42:14 Ideas are not interesting to write about,
00:42:17 but people fighting with each other
00:42:19 or a woman being verbally assaulted,
00:42:23 oh, well, everybody has an opinion about that
00:42:25 and they get into it and know what the opinion is going to be.
00:42:27 So it's like catnip for the media.
00:42:33 You didn't see the denouncement swarm.
00:42:36 No.
00:42:36 And that's what we get now, right?
00:42:38 Everybody's accepted.
00:42:39 If everyone hasn't proactively come up and issued some official statement from on high,
00:42:45 well, then you condone it.
00:42:46 You're practically beating women. 1.00
00:42:48 Nobody was getting on Trudeau's case, so you had to denounce what happened to Bernier.
00:42:51 I mean, you shouldn't have to.
00:42:52 It's a given.
00:42:52 Everybody rational knows.
00:42:54 Rational.
00:42:54 There's not enough rationality.
00:42:56 I understand that.
00:42:57 But rational people know you don't throw eggs at people.
00:42:59 You don't come running, screaming at them, spouting obscenities.
00:43:02 You just don't.
00:43:02 You don't have to constantly make people reiterate that and say over and over that they don't
00:43:06 support that.
00:43:07 But that's what the media is doing and cornering, and it's getting annoying.
00:43:11 You know, it was interesting that Mr. Trudeau did make that statement the following day.
00:43:16 Oh, let's talk about that.
00:43:17 Well, that was incredible.
00:43:20 It was at an event, and he just got out of his speaking notes to draw attention to this situation with Ms. Freeland.
00:43:31 Let's talk about what he said.
00:43:32 Well, just for the viewers' benefits, I don't remember, I'll have to paraphrase here, but Trudeau said something along the lines of, you know, politicians, public figures need to stop doing things that divide people.
00:43:48 You need to stop saying things that get people angry and get people divided and all these things.
00:43:53 And I was watching this, and my jaw was just dropped that the man who said that many of the unvaccinated in Canada were racists and misogynists, bigots, and all these nasty things.
00:44:09 Had unacceptable views.
00:44:10 Unacceptable views.
00:44:11 The man who invoked martial law and seized the bank accounts of people protesting against his policies.
00:44:16 And this twerp has the nerve to say that everyone else is responsible for dividing Canadians.
00:44:27 He has no responsibility for any of this.
00:44:30 Well, what he actually said was that it was not, he also said it wasn't an isolated incident that women generally face this.
00:44:38 Got to tell you, men face it as well.
00:44:40 Two of the people we were talking about earlier, Travis Staves and Ryan Jean, both had death threats during this leadership race.
00:44:50 They seem to be pretty calm about it.
00:44:54 But I didn't recall hearing a lot of other people being uncalm about it.
00:44:58 You know, I've never talked about this publicly because I don't want to.
00:45:01 I think a lot of politicians use this kind of thing to score, oh, poor me points.
00:45:06 But I'll just briefly say a guy was just convicted the other week for making death threats against myself.
00:45:12 The whole trial revolved around his political inquisition.
00:45:16 It was actually quite political.
00:45:18 Most media didn't bother reporting on that.
00:45:21 But a guy made the whole thing about politics and was convicted of making death threats against myself.
00:45:28 And all the comments I saw from lefties and all these stories on the Herald or the Suns was like,
00:45:36 of course, someone threatened to kill Phil DeBrand. 1.00
00:45:39 He deserves to be killed. 1.00
00:45:40 This was unanimously the left-wing comments. 1.00
00:45:43 And I took it as a compliment.
00:45:45 But I don't talk about this thing, and I'm not very comfortable talking about it,
00:45:47 because people like to use this and saying, well, someone made a threat against me,
00:45:51 so everyone should feel bad for me, and that should somehow score me some political points.
00:45:55 and well our own mayor yeah let's talk about her yeah jody conduct tweeted i have been asked by
00:46:03 some people why i haven't made a public statement about the assault on our deputy the assault by
00:46:09 the way not the verbal assault she says right here on twitter on our deputy prime minister 0.80
00:46:14 she continues to be blunt i had to sit with my thoughts for a couple of days because this
00:46:19 incident is not isolated
00:46:21 and it brings up too much
00:46:23 pain and fear.
00:46:26 Yes.
00:46:28 Yeah, whatever.
00:46:29 I just am not in the mood for Gondek myself.
00:46:32 You know, but
00:46:32 there has been stuff happening too. People showed up at her
00:46:35 house and that is an
00:46:37 intimidation. That's not cool.
00:46:39 And it is wrong. And I went
00:46:41 on about that at the show because I mean, I rip
00:46:43 Gondek all the time and I had a lot of my own show commenters
00:46:45 saying, yeah, she deserves it.
00:46:47 Guys, you're not helping.
00:46:49 it's just as wrong if our our side people we agree with do these things it is wrong even if
00:46:58 they're doing it out of anger that we share just as if the other side does it it's just as bloody
00:47:04 wrong and you give her more opportunity to play oral me like she did with that yeah so you're 0.98
00:47:09 only helping them guys you know you're not so let's talk another example of uh you know this
00:47:15 kind of double standard, very close to home here, involving the USP leadership race. So you have
00:47:23 the kind of lefty-ish Leela here. Someone apparently hacked her Facebook, she claims,
00:47:32 and started posting some nasty things. And she very successfully played the victim card
00:47:40 in the media. I think we may even have some of the headlines. The media very much bought onto
00:47:46 that narrative. She's a victim for her. Now, I think like the exact same, maybe even the same
00:47:53 day, if not, it was plus or minus one day, someone was going around making fake phone calls and
00:48:02 recording them, pretending to be the Danielle Smith campaign, saying very nasty things,
00:48:08 pretending to be on behalf of Danielle Smith. The media on that one, damn near silence. They 0.96
00:48:16 barely even reported it happened. You had Dwayne Bratt, apparently the only political science
00:48:24 professor who could be quoted in Alberta politics in the media. With a here, he said these people
00:48:29 should face jail time, call the police. And with Danielle Smith, he, I believe, said,
00:48:36 Like, call the police against Danielle Smith.
00:48:38 You know, I've noticed that so many people are really anxious about the ability of Facebook and the telephone companies to trace them.
00:48:47 Why are we not able to find the people who made the fake phone calls to Danielle Smith's campaign?
00:48:54 Why are we not able to find the people who hacked, you know, how much of a grip has Big Brother got on us?
00:49:02 look
00:49:05 there's nothing you can say in defense
00:49:08 of people who do that kind of thing
00:49:10 there really isn't
00:49:11 I don't even know whether there's awfully much
00:49:14 you can say to understand but I do
00:49:16 suppose that there are some folks who are so deeply
00:49:18 invested in the
00:49:20 politics that they believe in that they feel
00:49:22 that they are doing something useful
00:49:24 for their person if they
00:49:26 screw up the other guys
00:49:27 this is not the first time you've heard about this kind of thing
00:49:30 it happens all the time
00:49:31 but
00:49:33 I wish they wouldn't
00:49:35 but I do wish that
00:49:37 if you're going to make a big fuss
00:49:40 for one person
00:49:40 can you make a big fuss for the other person
00:49:43 and if not then neither
00:49:45 let's be fair about this
00:49:47 Corey I think there's kind of two key
00:49:50 points about why the media make a big
00:49:52 difference about one person
00:49:54 or group of people and not about another
00:49:56 I think the first
00:49:58 is their politics, are they on the left
00:50:00 In the case of Freeland and Ahir, they're on the left, but they're also willing to, actually, oh, I hate to do this. Freeland's credit, she didn't play the victim card. The media definitely played it for her. She didn't go out there pleading for me. Ahir definitely did this teary-eyed press conference and very much actively tried to play the victim card.
00:50:25 So in that case, actually, Freeland was less bad.
00:50:30 But, you know, when you see this with conservatives, you know, there are tons of death threats against Harper.
00:50:37 I remember when I was in politics, I got a ton of death threats.
00:50:41 But you know how I handled it.
00:50:42 I never went out and talked about it at all.
00:50:44 What I did is I applied for a concealed carry permit.
00:50:49 I made the argument that, look, I'm an elected official.
00:50:52 I'm getting death threats and it'll cost the taxpayer almost a million dollars a year to give
00:50:56 me a security detail. How about I'll do it for free? You just let me carry my Glock.
00:51:01 They said no, but I had to try. I had to try. The extent of some of this, and I mean, yeah,
00:51:08 what they made with what they hear, there hasn't been enough critical, at least examination before
00:51:12 they reported on these things. And this was reported as if it was a political attack on
00:51:15 here. Yeah. Well, I don't know. Facebook's not the easiest thing in the world actually to hack
00:51:19 unless you went and downloaded that darned app 0.98
00:51:22 and didn't read the small print 0.98
00:51:23 and put some cute little bunny ears on your picture
00:51:24 when you're Instagramming.
00:51:26 And holy cow, you downloaded something
00:51:27 and made a crack into your own page.
00:51:30 So a little critique here
00:51:31 because there's lots of people
00:51:32 who would love to hack all sorts of political pages,
00:51:34 but they don't manage to
00:51:35 because they're being responsibly run.
00:51:38 I've never heard, I'm sure it happens.
00:51:41 I want to victim blame here.
00:51:42 But I've never seen another Albertans Facebook page
00:51:45 ever hacked.
00:51:47 Like it's pretty, I really shouldn't say this
00:51:49 because now someone's going to try and hack me.
00:51:50 But in general, it's pretty tough to hack these things.
00:51:55 There's a lot of security measures in place.
00:51:57 Some discussion, just some critical discussion on some of the things.
00:51:59 And the same with Smith's episode with the fake calls that were made.
00:52:02 Those little calls were taken at face value right off the bat.
00:52:04 Look at that.
00:52:05 The Smith campaign's been doing these belligerent calls.
00:52:07 Well, wait a minute.
00:52:08 Look at the source of the recording and just look at her Twitter thread.
00:52:11 Coincidentally, the person that this supposed calls went to
00:52:14 is a haywire left-wing online activist.
00:52:17 wow what a four and a half million people in the province that's the one the belligerent caller from
00:52:22 the smith campaign phoned up yeah amazing coincidence just some i mean critical look
00:52:28 before you report but they didn't it was straight to and you're not going to get a call from any of
00:52:32 the ucp leadership campaign or at least any of the big ones that know what they're doing unless you
00:52:37 are one a current ucp member to a former ucp member possibly a legacy wild rose or pc member
00:52:45 or you're on some list that got into their hands that has overlapping interests.
00:52:50 You're a part of a gun group or you're a pro-life group or a screw Ottawa group.
00:52:55 But you have to be on some kind of right-wing list.
00:52:58 Otherwise, you're not going to get a random call.
00:53:01 You have to have had some interaction either with the UCP
00:53:04 or with UCP-adjacent organizations to get on those lists.
00:53:08 So this person who cried that they got this call, I'm not convinced.
00:53:14 But the media reported it as fact, and then did remarkably little to walk down when it turned out Smith campaign were actually the victims.
00:53:21 Or that person really got the call unsolicited, but somebody who was faking it says,
00:53:24 who's the person who's going to make the most racket if they get calls like this?
00:53:27 Well, here's a haywire social media person.
00:53:29 It'd be like if I got a bunch of belligerent NDP calls.
00:53:32 I mean, I'm not on NDP lists, or at least not positive ones.
00:53:37 You know, come on.
00:53:38 I mean, you know I'm going to make up.
00:53:39 I think you are on a block list somewhere.
00:53:40 Yeah, some sort of list.
00:53:41 It's just the odds are getting pretty long with some of this stuff happening.
00:53:44 But there wasn't critical examination.
00:53:46 It was just reported as is.
00:53:47 And that's questionable.
00:53:49 Yeah.
00:53:49 Well, that's so often the case.
00:53:52 Okay.
00:53:52 Well, we've had a great chat today.
00:53:54 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, what the hell's wrong with you?
00:53:59 You really should be.
00:54:00 The Western Standard, we are actually now the only media organization in all of Canada,
00:54:05 west of Mississauga, that has a bureau on Parliament Hill.
00:54:10 While everyone else is shrinking and going bankrupt,
00:54:12 The Western Standard is growing and we're growing because of people like you who are becoming members of the Western Standard.
00:54:18 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content, no paywall.
00:54:25 And, you know, we've got dozens of reporters and columnists now providing some of the best news and commentary you're going to get in Canada.
00:54:33 If you're following any of the stuff that we're talking about today, you know, the federal conservative leadership race,
00:54:38 the United Conservative Party leadership race in Alberta, the corrupt state of the Canadian media,
00:54:44 you need to be following this. The Western Standard very proudly refuses to take a cent
00:54:48 of the federal government's media bailout. We are 100% funded by advertising and people like you
00:54:56 who sign up as members. So if you're not yet a member, go to westernstandard.news slash membership,
00:55:01 sign up, sign up. It'll make me, Corey, and Nigel very, very happy. It sure will. Speaking of happy,
00:55:09 I think it's time to get a beer.
00:55:10 I think it is.
00:55:10 Yeah.
00:55:11 Gentlemen, it's been a slice.
00:55:13 Thank you for joining us today.
00:55:15 You're welcome.
00:55:16 It was a pleasure.
00:55:16 Thank all of you, and God bless.