Western Standard - June 15, 2023


The Pipeline: Mendicino caught in another big lie

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update June 14, 2023 MPC Daily Market Update June 16, 2023

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

176.79

Word count

8,405

Sentence count

615

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, Western Standard editor Nigel Henniford and editor-in-chief Derek Fildebrand are joined by Western Standard columnist Corey Morgan to discuss the controversial move of Paul Bernardo from a maximum security prison to a medium security prison, and the fallout from it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day, I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard. Today is June 14th,
00:00:18 2023, and you're watching The Pipeline. I'm joined, as always, by Western Standard opinion
00:00:23 editor, Nigel Henniford. How are you, Nigel? I'm good, thank you. We've also got, as usual,
00:00:28 Western-centered senior Alberta columnist Corey Morgan on a reduced, less furious column writing
00:00:36 job, I guess, since the campaign. Yeah, I'm not going to be pumping them out quite as much
00:00:41 as during campaign period. I'll still have plenty of rants to get out there though. Good, good.
00:00:45 All right, well today we're going to be talking about the Federal Public Safety Minister,
00:00:50 Mr. Mendicino, what's his first name again? Marco Mendicino. Dubbed by some as the Minister of Lies,
00:00:59 while caught in another probably, I suppose it's not 100%, but oh boy she looks like a big lie,
00:01:07 this time about his role with moving of Paul Bernardo from a maximum security prison to a
00:01:15 medium security prison, doing his best impression of Sergeant Schultz. I see nothing. I see nothing.
00:01:22 I hear nothing. We're going to be talking about that. The Liberals also on the ropes, though,
00:01:28 following the resignation of David Johnson as Justin Trudeau's special rapporteur,
00:01:35 bending to what seems like the inevitable, resigning from the job, putting this all back
00:01:42 in the lap of Justin Trudeau. We're going to talk not so much about the resignation itself,
00:01:46 but the fallout from it. What are the consequences, the political damage, and where's the potential
00:01:51 inquiry going to go from here? I'm going to talk about the new Alberta cabinet sworn in on Friday.
00:01:59 Smith putting her stamp on things as she swears in her first cabinet after receiving a mandate 1.00
00:02:07 from Alberta voters. Before we get started, though, I want to thank my favorite sponsor,
00:02:10 the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. I've been a member of the CSSA for more than a decade
00:02:15 because I trust them as Canada's leading firearm owner rights group. Without the Canadian Shooting
00:02:20 Sports Association, the federal government would have an open target on your guns. It's important
00:02:27 for law-abiding firearms owners in Canada to stand together against government, particularly federal
00:02:33 government, attempts to not let you use your guns for anything, and more importantly, to take them
00:02:39 away. So if you're not yet a member of the CSSA, go to CSSA-CILA.org or do what I do, just Google them
00:02:46 and click on membership and join today. Okay, Mr. Marco Mendicino, already dubbed by some,
00:02:57 you know, probably not his family and friends, but dubbed by some as the Minister of Lies
00:03:00 for a whole very long list of statements he's given that have been probably lies.
00:03:13 Now we find out, I think it was just yesterday that, was it yesterday or the day before?
00:03:18 The day before.
00:03:19 The day before, that Paul Bernardo, one of the most notorious mass murderers,
00:03:25 I don't know if mass murder is the right word, because he's not a serial killer either.
00:03:29 No, free for a serial killer, I believe, so that would be easy.
00:03:32 But it has to be like a pattern, not kind of all at once.
00:03:34 I don't know.
00:03:35 Killed a lot of people.
00:03:37 Something I want to know a lot about.
00:03:39 Brutally raped, tortured, and murdered teenage girls along with now a parent volunteer at her school, Karloch Molka. 0.71
00:03:50 He has been denied, justice was denied in that he wasn't burned alive or filleted like the animal he is,
00:04:00 but he was given a life sentence in a maximum security prison, and that's, well, he's not there anymore.
00:04:08 The powers that be have moved him to a medium security prison.
00:04:12 This morning I kind of flippantly called it a club fed.
00:04:15 Medium security prisons are not club feds, I guess.
00:04:17 They're not easy. They're not the minimum securities. They're probably not playing golf on their breaks.
00:04:22 But they are markedly less severe and less unpleasant than a maximum security prison.
00:04:30 Marco Mendicino says, I knew nothing about this. I am outraged, positively outraged, that this monster would be moved to a medium security prison.
00:04:41 Well, then the news came out last night or this morning that, in fact, his office was notified.
00:04:52 I guess really now Pierre Polyev conservatives are demanding his resignation, saying he lied.
00:04:58 He did know about it.
00:04:59 I suppose, Nigel, there is a technical small possibility that this note came through his office
00:05:07 and one of his staffers looked at this as Paul Bernardo being sent to a significantly less unpleasant prison.
00:05:16 That's not news. Let's just pass it on.
00:05:20 What are the chances that one of the staffers in this office just did not think this was noteworthy
00:05:25 to pass up the chain of command versus what the Conservatives are alleging that,
00:05:31 no, obviously someone in his office did tell him he did know about it and therefore lied to Canadians in Parliament?
00:05:36 So there are two possibilities out there. One is that the staff are concerned was born less than 30 years ago and didn't actually live through that particular period of Canadian history when this was the hottest topic.
00:05:53 Or if he lived through it, it didn't mean anything to him because he was in grade school.
00:05:57 Actually, it's taught to every kid in grade nine social studies or legal because of his accomplice, Carla Homolka, and the double jeopardy things.
00:06:05 So even people born long after this, they're taught this in high school.
00:06:09 And I'm guessing that everybody in the minister's office has probably taught them high school.
00:06:13 Why would you teach that in high school?
00:06:16 Have they got a course on killers?
00:06:19 I don't know.
00:06:19 But anyway, maybe he should have known.
00:06:22 I'm saying there is a strong possibility that the person, you know, working in these ministerial offices are often very young and just didn't recognize the significance of it.
00:06:34 The other possibility, which I lean to, actually, is that somebody said, oh, that is something for which the minister should have plausible deniability.
00:06:46 Just don't tell him so that he can get up and say, I had no knowledge.
00:06:49 If we find that somebody gets fired, dismissed, moved on to something else, that will tell you something about whether it was how deeply Mr. Mandacino feels about the fact that he wasn't told.
00:07:03 So that's excellent segue to my next question, Corey.
00:07:07 Melissa Lassman, one of the two deputy leaders of the conservative opposition, question period today.
00:07:14 She said, asked Mendocino something to the effect of, you know, she said, you're throwing your staff under the bus.
00:07:22 You're saying your staff, because we now know your staff knew.
00:07:24 You didn't say earlier your staff knew.
00:07:26 She said, we had no idea.
00:07:27 I had no idea.
00:07:27 We had no idea.
00:07:28 Now it turns out your staff knew.
00:07:29 So, if you're going to throw your staff under the bus, which staff have you already fired for this?
00:07:36 Because clearly, if there's ever a fireable offense, it's not passing that one of the most notorious murderers in Canadian history has been moved to a significantly comfier prison.
00:07:49 So, yeah, her question was, okay, fine, if this was your staffer, who was a staffer, and have they been fired yet?
00:07:57 And he's got no answer for that yet.
00:08:00 I mean, you would think if there was a clear person to point to, I mean, the Liberals.
00:08:03 The fact that no one has been fired leaves me to think that, no, he was told.
00:08:07 Yeah, to throw them under the bus.
00:08:08 And if you can't find somebody, then you're going to be stuck with it.
00:08:11 And as he said, he's known to just get out of situations by just speaking to the contrary and letting it blow over.
00:08:18 But now he's been caught in what is very probably a lie.
00:08:23 No staffer has been fired.
00:08:24 Clearly, they would know who this is because you sign off on these things.
00:08:28 There's a clear paper trail of all this kind of stuff.
00:08:32 No staffer has been fired, which leads me, Nigel, to believe that this was not a staffer issue.
00:08:39 That, no, this was the minister.
00:08:41 Yeah, and let's say it was a staffer issue.
00:08:45 We have a thing in this country called ministerial responsibility.
00:08:48 Oh, how quaint and burnish of you.
00:08:50 I know, I know.
00:08:51 It's very charming.
00:08:54 But the fact is that if one of his staff made a mistake, then it's his problem.
00:09:00 He is the one who takes the fall, not the unfortunate 25-year-old staff member
00:09:05 who's three years out of university.
00:09:07 You know, there, his judgment is supposed to be the one that counts.
00:09:13 And it's not like this is a first offense.
00:09:15 It really is time for Mr. Mendicino to step aside.
00:09:18 I don't know whether they've got anybody better, but that's the state of the Liberal Party today.
00:09:25 The other aspect was just the bad political judgment.
00:09:28 I mean, if that came up the lines, you know, his ministry doesn't deal with every prisoner transfer that's going on out there.
00:09:33 Somebody in Correction Services Canada realized this is something so significant.
00:09:36 We better get a heads up to the others because we know there's going to be some blowback on this.
00:09:41 It's not just an unknown name.
00:09:44 They don't typically send those memos up, and that nobody caught on to them, that, boy, we got a firestorm coming, we better prepare for it.
00:09:52 It just defies belief.
00:09:57 You talked, this is not his first offense here, both for, I guess, screw-ups and lies.
00:10:06 We had almost a little mix-up when we were talking about our topics for today.
00:10:10 you're talking about Mendicino and Bernardo. And I was a little confused at first because our sponsor, Canadian Shooting Sports Association, its executive director is Tony Bernardo. And I know Mendicino and that Bernardo are fighting all the time. And then it got me thinking, which Bernardo does Mendicino have the bigger problem with? The one that's fighting for gun rights or the one who seems to, well, at least privately not have a big problem with moving to a medium security prison.
00:10:40 I mean, it's probably a little over the top to say he has a bigger problem with gun owners than Paul Bernardo, but I think it's kind of insightful into the liberal mind that, you know, they're so focused, and Mendicino in particular is so focused on pre-crime.
00:10:59 So people who have done absolutely nothing wrong, but we need to punish them, confiscate their otherwise illegal and lawful property.
00:11:06 But this guy, one of the most terrible murderers in Canadian history, well, maybe we should ease up a little on him.
00:11:13 Well, you know, Derek, it all depends what the ultimate goal of government is.
00:11:17 And if it is to provide good governments, then everything you have said is absolutely correct.
00:11:23 The guy should go.
00:11:23 However, if the role, if the object of this government is to totally change the nature of Canada, part of which would be the removal of firearms from private ownership, then the man is actually doing what he has been instructed to do and I guess doing it quite effectively.
00:11:45 So really, he would be in Mr. Trudeau's good books for things that we sit here and say, how can he get away with this?
00:11:52 The fact is, he's doing what he's there to do.
00:11:55 So, again, you're just setting up perfect segues.
00:11:58 Well, we talked about this before.
00:12:00 I'll throw it to you.
00:12:01 But, you know, most ministers don't resign in the sense of just, oh, I think David Johnson resigned.
00:12:10 I don't think he was told to resign by Trudeau because it was not good for Trudeau.
00:12:13 I think David Johnson came to the conclusion. This is not tenable. I'm not serving any public good here. I think it's time for me to go. And he resigned. Ministers don't resign that way. They get resigned. They don't resign. They get resigned.
00:12:30 The prime minister sits down and says, you've become a liability to the party and to the government.
00:12:36 I need you to resign.
00:12:39 That's what happens.
00:12:40 I can't, has there ever been a fired minister?
00:12:42 I can't remember.
00:12:43 There has been, but in my life, I can't think of one in my lifetime, but they have generally just resigned.
00:12:52 Is this guy going to be finally up to get resigned?
00:12:56 because Trudeau has stood by him through a lot of less than ministerial actions.
00:13:06 And I'm not aware of Trudeau forcing any minister to resign since he's been prime minister.
00:13:11 Well, Jody Wilson-Raybould may...
00:13:13 Well, he shuffled her out. 0.91
00:13:15 Yeah, that's...
00:13:16 He didn't outright fire her.
00:13:18 That would have looked too bad, but he shuffled her out to some... 0.99
00:13:22 If you make the chair uncomfortable enough, it amounts to the same thing.
00:13:25 No, I come back to what I just said, that as far as Mr. Trudeau is concerned,
00:13:31 Mr. Mendicino has demonstrated his ability and his willingness to say anything
00:13:37 to protect the government, even if it is not true.
00:13:41 He will take the calumny and the criticism.
00:13:45 That's fine.
00:13:46 Government goes on and does what it wants to do.
00:13:49 And for Mr. Trudeau, that makes him a pretty valuable minister.
00:13:52 So I don't think he's going to get fired.
00:13:55 Do you think he, is he in a tenable position here? Because he, I mean, technically there might be plausible deniability that it went to his office.
00:14:05 It's not normally known if it's shown to the minister, but I see a very small chance that he did not see this.
00:14:12 It seems very, very likely that he was clearly lying.
00:14:15 It just doesn't seem to matter, though, and he's a good foil.
00:14:18 Well, as Nigel said, he serves his purpose in the House.
00:14:22 He'll just lie again, and people will forget about it.
00:14:26 The consequences don't seem to land on the Prime Minister's office anyways when it comes to this,
00:14:31 even though he is the one who appoints these ministers.
00:14:33 I think at worst, Mendocino might not make it through the next shuffle in that role.
00:14:37 But as for going outright, as you said, and pushing him out of there,
00:14:41 I don't see the government ever admitting error that clearly.
00:14:44 Just give him a different podium from which to utter doublespeak.
00:14:48 Yes.
00:14:48 He's like one of those guys in the Mafia movies.
00:14:51 It doesn't matter what you ask them to do,
00:14:52 they go and do it, and they come back and kiss the rain.
00:14:56 They're more than a man in Medellino.
00:14:57 Oh, when did I get that from?
00:15:00 That was racist.
00:15:03 Anyway, Italian and Irish racism is still allowed on the Western standard, 0.94
00:15:07 because they're just too damn fun.
00:15:10 I guess the last part would be about Bernard himself.
00:15:15 I'm actually not sure what the process is here,
00:15:16 But generally, what prison you're serving in is not a directly political decision.
00:15:22 The minister doesn't get to say, well, you're going to go to this prison and you're going to that prison.
00:15:26 And that's a good thing.
00:15:27 I don't think we want the politicians deciding that.
00:15:30 That'd be obviously too much direct involvement in the justice system.
00:15:33 But they get to set the rules under which these things are decided.
00:15:40 What do you think the chances are, Nigel, that Bernardo actually ends up back in a maximum security predatory?
00:15:46 Well, if I were him, I certainly wouldn't be sleeping easily at night with that prospect
00:15:52 in mind.
00:15:53 In the end, part of letting the whole thing go away is not keeping the story alive.
00:15:58 So if you move him back to either they're going to do it right away and get it over
00:16:03 with, but they're not going to come back in a week's time or two weeks time and make
00:16:07 the story go live again by moving him.
00:16:10 So I would say...
00:16:11 Well, they said, oh, I've asked for a review.
00:16:12 Yeah.
00:16:13 He's just kind of kicking the can a bit.
00:16:14 We can get it through the next couple of days. He's probably going to stay where he is.
00:16:19 You think Mr. Bernardo is going to get to stay long term in his comfier new dicks?
00:16:25 I'm with Nigel in that if they're going to do it, they're going to do it soon.
00:16:28 I think they might do it soon, though.
00:16:29 This is something that this gets to the core of Canadians, though.
00:16:32 This ticks them off.
00:16:33 And I know the system isn't supposed to be based so much on revenge or punishment.
00:16:37 But when it comes to somebody in such a singular profile like Bernardo, that's an exceptional case.
00:16:43 And they may put the pressure on to say, let's just bump him back into there and let people forget about it over time.
00:16:48 I don't know how many people I've talked to who oppose the death penalty, but then they're like, but I'd be okay if you got a prison shake. 0.99
00:16:56 This guy deserves to die. 0.87
00:16:59 Are we allowed to say that on YouTube, that anyone deserves it? 1.00
00:17:02 Well, I'm going to say it right now. 0.99
00:17:03 Paul Bernardo deserves to die. 1.00
00:17:05 And if we get banned for that. 0.99
00:17:06 I mean, I've always been opposed to capital punishment because, I mean, I don't trust the government to get my taxes right, much less to execute people.
00:17:12 but I wouldn't we got him on film though like we I wouldn't we know that he was left in his cell
00:17:16 with his shoelaces and happened to tie himself up or something I mean so be it but you know uh
00:17:22 we should just put him in the same uh prison jail that Epstein in yeah that could that could work
00:17:29 let's Epstein the guy it's too bad we ever have to hear about that guy again you know what that'll
00:17:33 probably get me in trouble yeah because Epstein did not kill him so the Clintons will be at your
00:17:37 house next week. Do any of you actually believe Epstein killed himself? I wouldn't bet my paycheck
00:17:43 on it. No. I don't think anyone actually believes that. I'm surprised that Ghislaine is still making
00:17:49 it, to be honest. That was a tangent. Isn't that justice? There's only one woman involved in the 1.00
00:17:55 entire massive racket, and it's the woman who goes to jail, not the men. Jeez. Okay, that was
00:18:01 tangents I'm taking this on there. I'm going to pull it back. So I kind of alluded into this
00:18:07 earlier about David Johnson. He resigned last Friday as Trudeau's special rapporteur, special
00:18:14 rapper. He, I think, was a rare resignation in any kind of political role in it. I think he
00:18:22 actually did resign on his own. I think, I feel kind of half bad for the guy. I think he did
00:18:29 accept with the best of intentions. He just should have known it was inappropriate for him to accept
00:18:34 that the role shouldn't have existed to begin with. It was clear an inquiry was necessary,
00:18:38 and that if you were going to have this silly special rapporteur role, it had to be someone who
00:18:42 was impeccably objective and distant from any political connection or personal connection to
00:18:48 the local party or to the prime minister or any of the subjects involved, which he was clearly not.
00:18:54 we'll start with you Corey was it inevitable that David Johnson was going to end up kind of eating
00:19:04 it like this or or at any point down on the way from his appointment until Friday was was there
00:19:12 a way for him to steer a different way perhaps by actually recommending the inquiry I don't think it
00:19:17 was inevitable or even if he was going to recommend against the inquiry he could have made a much
00:19:22 better case for it then. He could have had a better report. It was a half-assed, terrible
00:19:27 report that he'd done. He hadn't thoroughly investigated things. If he had, even though
00:19:32 there's still, of course, the opposition would be yelling, he's too connected to Trudeau and this
00:19:36 and that. But they'd say, look, he's doing his job. He's been interviewing this. He's concluded
00:19:39 that. He's suggested this. You know, you guys are just smearing a good man who's doing a good job.
00:19:45 But because he'd done such a terrible job, nothing was going to save that position, I think.
00:19:50 I don't know, Nigel. It was a terrible job, and that certainly compounded things, but I think just his very presence from the beginning, not having the buy-in from the main opposition parties, made it untenable from the beginning.
00:20:05 I think the only way he could have walked out of this with his reputation intact would have been to recommend an inquiry, but he clearly was not going to recommend an inquiry.
00:20:15 His mandate came from the Prime Minister. He reported to the Prime Minister. He made amply clear he was not working for Parliament of the people.
00:20:22 He was working for the Prime Minister in his own words. Was it inevitable that it had to end in tears this way?
00:20:29 Yes, I think it was, because the job as he originally took it was not able to be done on the terms that he accepted it.
00:20:36 He had no power to subpoena people.
00:20:38 That meant he was never going to get terribly close to the truth.
00:20:42 All it was ever going to be was conversations and a sort of a general feeling of, well, things weren't really done right, and we should have more talks.
00:20:52 It never was going to be anything else.
00:20:55 There was one other thing about Mr. Johnson that I was not aware of when this first came up,
00:21:00 and that was his own deep personal connection with China
00:21:03 that has since been revealed in a number of articles.
00:21:07 He's a distinguished academic.
00:21:10 He's a fairly frequent visitor over there.
00:21:12 There's one particular university.
00:21:14 I can't pronounce it, but there's one place that he feels very close to,
00:21:17 calls it a second home.
00:21:19 Three of his children have been over there to study.
00:21:22 So he is sort of a friendly for China.
00:21:26 So between being a friendly for China, I actually believe he was a friendly to China.
00:21:31 I'm not so sure he was actually that friendly with Trudeau.
00:21:34 I think he probably was telling the truth when he said he had very little connection to Trudeau in the years since Trudeau became prime minister.
00:21:44 And one of the reasons that I think that is that if he had actually had a closer connection to Mr. Trudeau, he would have known what a flake he was.
00:21:54 And then he would have never got involved with a job in the first place.
00:21:57 Possibly.
00:21:57 So you have to believe him on that.
00:21:59 I'll tell you what, there's no close connection between Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Johnson now.
00:22:02 What?
00:22:03 No more cozy little Thanksgiving dinners, a ski holiday.
00:22:07 I would agree with that.
00:22:08 In the future.
00:22:09 Although, even if he knew Trudeau was a flake, I'm still not sure he would say no because he saw this as a public service. He's been doing things for the public good in his whole life. He's, you know, previous to now been wildly respected for his public service and selflessness. And, you know, the way he put it was, well, you know, when you're asked to serve your country, you say yes.
00:22:32 That's not a West Wing. Nobody does that in the world.
00:22:34 I know, I know, but I could, well, he's old, so he might be old school.
00:22:42 I mean, he's not a spring chicken.
00:22:44 He might have a very old-fashioned view of things, and you're asked by your country to serve, so you serve.
00:22:49 And even if your general is Sergeant Schultz, you go into battle.
00:22:55 Well, I would love to think that, because I actually still have a soft spot for him from the time that he was governor general.
00:23:02 He did a wonderful job in that role.
00:23:04 And he was very, very carefully chosen.
00:23:07 And I think any significant skeletons
00:23:09 in his closet would have been uncovered in the process
00:23:13 that led him to be appointed.
00:23:14 So I stole.
00:23:17 But, you know, he's just got that Central Canadian sense
00:23:21 of what could possibly be wrong
00:23:25 with having another liberal fundraiser as my lawyer.
00:23:30 They're good people.
00:23:31 They know how to do the right thing.
00:23:33 Well, yeah, but most people don't actually see it that way.
00:23:37 They think there could be a conflict, and the fact that you're very friendly with China doesn't make it any better.
00:23:41 So he would have been good to stay out of it.
00:23:43 So this is clearly damaging to the Liberal government, the Liberal Party.
00:23:48 However, those two can be possibly distinguished.
00:23:51 There's no question it's damaging.
00:23:53 But I guess the question is, how damaging?
00:23:55 Is it recoverable?
00:23:56 Is it such a muck on them at this point, Corey, that they're not going to be able to wipe it off?
00:24:03 Because I think Trudeau is, he has walked out of some doozies.
00:24:07 He has cleaned blackface off of himself. 1.00
00:24:10 He has gotten through SNC-Lavalin.
00:24:15 The Wee scandal.
00:24:16 I mean, like, it's too many.
00:24:17 I don't know what it takes.
00:24:19 I mean, you know, if it hadn't been for all those prior ones that he's managed to slide out of,
00:24:23 I would have said, yes, this is it.
00:24:24 He's done.
00:24:24 But you know what?
00:24:26 I won't believe it until I see it now.
00:24:28 I don't know what it takes.
00:24:30 But, I mean, it's really looking dire, though.
00:24:32 I mean, the polls are dipping, and that's when things, I think, start to change a little bit.
00:24:37 I was talking to Jay Hill earlier on my show today, and you talked about that.
00:24:41 You know, not every Liberal member of Parliament is unprincipled.
00:24:44 I mean, a lot of them are getting tired of having to wear this odious mess themselves,
00:24:48 and some of them have ambitions as well, or they're worried about their own positions,
00:24:52 and they've got to be starting to grumble a little inside.
00:24:55 The Liberals are very good at keeping it tight.
00:24:56 They're fantastic.
00:24:58 Conservatives are their own worst enemies, but the Liberals hold the fort.
00:25:01 But you know behind closed doors, it's got to be getting tense, particularly when the polls go down.
00:25:06 That's when self-interest starts kicking in.
00:25:07 I don't see any chance of the Liberals turfing Trudeau.
00:25:10 He owns that party.
00:25:12 He has fashioned that party in his own image.
00:25:15 I guess if he wants to fight the next election, he's going to be the Liberal leader in the next election.
00:25:19 I have a very hard time.
00:25:21 I mean, he's not an Alberta Conservative leader, for God's sakes.
00:25:23 He is a federal Liberal leader.
00:25:26 I can only recall one who was truly turfed, and that was Kretchen with the Paul Martin wars.
00:25:31 They hate Ignatiev and Dionne, but those weren't well established like Trudeau or anything.
00:25:38 And they weren't in government, they weren't the prime minister.
00:25:40 I guess it's you Nigel, is this the one?
00:25:46 I mean, there's been so many big scandals and Trudeau has gotten through all of them.
00:25:51 But this one seems to rise to another level of seriousness and liberal actions to date.
00:25:56 just doing the most wild gymnastics. It's like Cirque du Soleil watching them bob and weave and
00:26:07 dodge around having an inquiry, even if they weren't guilty. Boy, they sure look guilty now.
00:26:14 So you're asking me, is this the one where they'd miss the trapeze and go
00:26:17 right into that yeah okay probably not and the reason is that people aren't necessarily going
00:26:27 to make their voting decision on this or on any of the scandals they know about it they can't
00:26:33 actually name them all where you can but there's not i can't name them well there's too many run
00:26:38 out of fingers but the uh they're going to look back and they say okay we know he's you know he's
00:26:44 a shady character we know he's on principle but you know what i sure do love it when he stands up
00:26:49 for my lbgtq to in and out son or daughter and i sure do like it when he uh when when when he rails
00:26:58 against because i don't like poliver and i just i just don't like him i i agree with everything he
00:27:02 says i just don't like him but i'd like it when mr trudeau goes after him and they're going to be
00:27:07 making their decisions on everything except the things which we think sensible canadians should
00:27:14 make their voting decisions on is what are you going to do with the economy what are you going
00:27:18 to do with the armed services what are you going to do with the health system that is failing how
00:27:22 are you going to relate to the problem that's hardcore partisan voters i mean because yeah
00:27:26 no party goes down to zero okay but you know there's uh i mean you know the conservative 1.00
00:27:33 say there was a conservative there's a reason the bible calls us sheep we vote for stupid people 0.99
00:27:37 and follow them okay but just imagine the conservatives are in power and they're doing 0.99
00:27:42 a bunch of things that we like on a policy level but uh it turns out the prime minister or a prime
00:27:48 minister was a serial killer well i probably would definitely want a new conservative leader
00:27:52 but would never make me vote liberal there's just nothing ever that can just as there are a bunch of
00:27:58 liberals who will always vote liberal, maybe they'll go MVP, who knows, but let's follow,
00:28:03 let's follow. But then there's a bunch of people in the middle who vote for a variety of reasons,
00:28:07 some of which are political policy, some of which are more ethical, nebulous political. 0.79
00:28:16 You know, you don't need every liberal voter to say, I'm done with the liberals, they're crooked.
00:28:21 You just need, I don't know, 25% of them.
00:28:24 Are these the people who, even if it turned out that the Prime Minister was a serial killer,
00:28:30 would still vote for him anyway? Not the 25%. They'll probably be 25% at the bottom end who
00:28:36 will stay with them, maybe even if he's a serial killer, but the furthest 25%, you know, they,
00:28:41 they could move around. Well, it might go to the NDP, and that certainly would have the desired
00:28:44 effect. Yeah. Well, let's talk inquiry. It seemed almost inevitable since the beginning that there
00:28:52 was gonna be an inquiry because this is what they're for this is a textbook definition and
00:28:58 the liberals have done everything on the face of the earth that they could possibly do they have
00:29:04 exhausted the playbook they've done everything and it's failed at every single point as i was just
00:29:09 saying a few minutes ago if they weren't guilty well they sure found a way to look guilty you
00:29:15 know it's like if you uh you know the police come talk to you about robbery of the local 7-eleven
00:29:20 and you didn't do it but you happen to pull out a pistol with the file number uh with you know
00:29:26 the serial number fired filed off and you're holding a bag of 7-eleven stuff and you run away
00:29:32 uh and you got no receipt i mean they certainly made themselves look guilty
00:29:39 this has led me to think that they're probably more guilty than i even assumed they were which
00:29:44 wasn't particularly i try to be a bit charitable but now i'm i'm increasingly not very charitable
00:29:50 towards them on this. Corey, is an inquiry now inevitable? Are we getting one? I don't know.
00:29:57 Suddenly, I don't like saying that. I don't want to cop out from you.
00:30:00 Your best instinct. Do you think we're getting one or not? I think we're getting one, but I think
00:30:04 it might be a year or so before we do. Before it starts? Yes, before they get that cornered,
00:30:10 before it really gets pushed to that point. You need Jagmeet Singh to play ball, and he's just
00:30:15 not. Oh, if it doesn't start for a year, then there is no inquiry. I can tell you that. If
00:30:19 There's going to be an inquiry.
00:30:20 It's going to be the issue.
00:30:21 It's going to disappear.
00:30:22 I mean, whoever's been leaking this, I think, still has a Trump sized pile of file boxes in this house somewhere.
00:30:29 And he's just going to keep putting it out there.
00:30:31 This issue isn't going to go away.
00:30:33 That's the thing.
00:30:34 So, I mean, that's where I agree.
00:30:35 It's inevitable.
00:30:36 It's just how long.
00:30:37 What is it going to take?
00:30:38 Where's the tipping point going to hit?
00:30:41 And, yeah, maybe it'll be in a few months.
00:30:43 But I got a feeling, I mean, look how long they've dragged it out this time.
00:30:46 Nigel, they've tried everything possible, far more than I thought they would attempt to.
00:30:53 And all they've done is hurt themselves more and more.
00:30:57 They didn't come right out and say, okay, you know what?
00:30:59 We're going to get to the bottom of this.
00:31:00 This is about national security and our democracy.
00:31:02 We're going to get to the bottom of this.
00:31:04 They now look guilty.
00:31:06 The only reason the only reason to not hold it now is that they're far guiltier than even their least charitable critics have accused them of being.
00:31:18 So that you know, an inquiry is going to lead to jail time or the absolute devastation of the government's reputation.
00:31:26 Otherwise, there's just doesn't seem to be any way out of the hole they're in right now short of an inquiry.
00:31:31 what's your better we get one yes but again it'll have its wings clipped
00:31:37 there'll be something that makes it less effective than it ought to be either
00:31:42 they the person doing it will not be able to subpoena witnesses I think all I
00:31:48 think all inquiries can well I mean the inquiry that mr. Johnson conducted could
00:31:54 not no but he wasn't an inquiry he was a special rapporteur but it was an
00:31:59 inquiry by. I'm adding that to my job title by the way. I'm a special rapporteur. I think that's
00:32:04 French. I identify a special rapporteur. I mean or another possibility is that yes we'll have a
00:32:11 full inquiry but it will report to the prime minister or it will report to the cabinet and
00:32:18 it won't never be unless there's a leaker. Yeah. We'll never get to see it. There is an opportunity
00:32:24 to really push this past the point when the next election is going to be. There is a lot of
00:32:30 opportunities to play funny with this, because it's dealing with largely confidential documents.
00:32:36 And so you know, even a legitimate inquiry might just be able to say, well, you know,
00:32:41 speak only in vagaries, I looked at things and there was maybe something over here, but we can't
00:32:47 really say what so i think that astonishes me is that they with all the resources they have
00:32:54 and all the motivation they have they've not actually outed the leaker which makes me think
00:33:00 that what corey is thinking but they may know who this guy is but he says listen if you put if you
00:33:06 pull me in i can tell you that there's going to be a lot of stuff coming out from the secret we're
00:33:11 dealing with the clandestine services they may have shot him by now he could be dead for all we
00:33:16 know. Oh, this is Canada. They can't afford the bullets for that. Oh, when you're dealing with
00:33:21 clandestine services, they will shoot. They'll shoot spies and leakers. They'll do it. So who 0.98
00:33:27 knows? It's a test. We'll leave if anything else comes up. Okay. Well, let's move to something a
00:33:32 little lighter. We're going to bring it back home here to Alberta. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith,
00:33:37 fresh off of her election victory, has sworn in her new cabinet. Some of the big jobs. Nate
00:33:46 Horner gets finance. He represents Drumheller-Stetler. Big, big sprawling Eastern Alberta
00:33:52 riding. Ariana LaGrange formerly the education minister. She moves from education to health.
00:33:59 So she moves from the second biggest budget department to the first biggest budget department. 0.83
00:34:06 Lots of squawking from the left on that one. They hated her in education. Funny enough, even 0.94
00:34:12 I was a pretty tough critic of the Kennedy government, but education was the one area
00:34:15 where I was like, they're doing pretty good here. I'm liking a lot of this. So a lot of lefties not
00:34:23 happy about her going there. Brian Jean takes the very senior portfolio of energy. I mean,
00:34:31 normally that's considered a Calgary job. For some reason, a Calgary minister gets it.
00:34:35 You can see where Fort McMurray might fit into it.
00:34:38 Fort McMurray plays in.
00:34:39 Yeah.
00:34:40 Yeah.
00:34:41 Rebecca Schultz gets environment, and Demetrio Nicolaitis moves from advanced education to education.
00:34:49 So a fairly vertical move for him there.
00:34:53 What are the big ones that stand out for you among the ones I've named and the ones I haven't named as the real appointments that stood out?
00:35:01 Well, the ones that, first of all, I'm thinking about it like a rugby match, and you've got your scrum, and you've got some heavy-hitting people in the front line.
00:35:16 We are going to have a confrontation with Ottawa over pipelines and over the use of natural gas for generating electricity for home heat and power.
00:35:25 It's coming.
00:35:26 I mean, this is what this Bill C-69 is all about.
00:35:29 So who do you want out front?
00:35:30 well who you've got out front is danielle smith in whom i have every confidence brian gene and
00:35:36 energy in whom i have every confidence and rebecca schultz who i have learned to have confidence in
00:35:43 in the leadership campaign and in the months since that is a strong team to stand at the border
00:35:50 and say no that was my first and overwhelming impression when she rolled out her cabinet now
00:35:57 you also mentioned Adriana LaGrange. As a self-declared unrepentant social conservative, 0.98
00:36:04 I admire what she tried to do in education and I thought bring that perspective to health,
00:36:11 she'd probably do all right. And then yesterday I was listening to Rachel Notley condemning her
00:36:16 and I knew then that Daniel Smith had made the right appointment.
00:36:22 What are the big ones instead of to you, ones I've named or not named?
00:36:26 Yeah, well, seeing LaGrange in health, it's showing that Premier Smith isn't looking to just
00:36:32 put somebody in then to smooth the waters and maintain the status quo. She knew that was going
00:36:35 to draw fire. So she's ready to fight a bit on the health front and with those labor unions. And 0.99
00:36:41 I'm heartened with that. As I just said, the way they're responding tells me she's over the target.
00:36:46 I think that's really good. Justice, you didn't mention with Mickey Amory. I don't know a lot
00:36:52 about him. I know Moe Amory. Yeah, his father who is the MLA player. And Moe is an interesting
00:36:59 character as an MLA. I just don't know. He's a big variable in a big position. Justice is not a
00:37:05 minor portfolio. And he wasn't in cabinet at all before, right? No. That's a major elevation. So
00:37:10 that's kind of an unexpected. But there was only three lawyers. Yeah. So he had a really good chance.
00:37:14 You got Brian Jean going to energy. We were talking about this last week and I think you guys
00:37:18 I was like, three lawyers, all three are serving.
00:37:24 Yeah, so I mean, he's a big question mark
00:37:25 sitting in there anyways,
00:37:26 because Justice is, you know,
00:37:27 well, Shando certainly learned 1.00
00:37:29 that you can get in trouble in there,
00:37:30 or more so Casey Maddow.
00:37:33 Hopefully Mr. Amory is just going to manage it confidently.
00:37:36 I don't think Justice is a big area
00:37:38 where Smith is looking for battles in the near future,
00:37:40 but, you know, health, education, and the Ottawa front,
00:37:43 I mean, they're certainly huge.
00:37:44 It's interesting that United front,
00:37:46 as Nigel laid it out,
00:37:47 When you can see the signaling coming from Premier Smith that that's where she wants to go with a big main task of the government to begin with. 1.00
00:37:54 And they're all three leader contenders in the last race lined up in those key positions.
00:37:59 So I'm just impatiently looking forward to fall to seeing, you know, what sort of direction she's going to put that cabinet in.
00:38:06 And I saw Rick McIver was put into transportation or no municipal affairs again.
00:38:10 A job which he has been in before.
00:38:13 Possibly.
00:38:14 I guess he might go finance, but I was wrong.
00:38:16 But yeah. So that's actually where I want to go next is the ins and the outs. Inns first, and then notable ins and notable outs.
00:38:25 Notable ins, Rick McIver, who I very much expected to return.
00:38:32 You know, he's very, actually, he's easily the most experienced minister in the government.
00:38:36 He, you know, he was on Calgary City Council for a long time.
00:38:40 Then he was a minister under Redford, Prentice, Kenny.
00:38:44 He's been a minister for a long time.
00:38:46 And I was surprised not to see him in Smith's first cabinet.
00:38:52 But back in now, I mean, nine of 12 UCP MLAs in Calgary are in cabinet.
00:38:58 So MacIver.
00:38:59 And then Nixon.
00:39:01 That was one of the ones we were talking about.
00:39:05 Very controversial choice, Corey.
00:39:07 It was.
00:39:08 I mean, it was the one we kind of agreed to.
00:39:10 She wouldn't put him back in, or at least not in his first run.
00:39:13 But he's back in cabinet.
00:39:16 And as we talked about, though, if there was going to be a flashpoint of caucus discontent or somebody who's going to be problematic, Jason Nixon potentially could have been that.
00:39:25 And there's some of the old, you know, keep your enemies closer, keep them in cabinet, keep them calm, keep them contained, and it's one less thing to sweat.
00:39:33 But there's also the possibility, Corey, that there could have been a serious conversation.
00:39:38 So I'm Premier, you're not.
00:39:40 What's it going to be?
00:39:41 I mean, you can do this.
00:39:42 You can be out on your own and make it hard for me.
00:39:46 I know you can do that, but she could actually be doing something very good.
00:39:50 I don't think she wants an adversarial minister in there.
00:39:52 I mean, you still want a functional one.
00:39:55 A cabinet generally buys you a fair degree of loyalty.
00:39:59 Probably should.
00:40:01 Yeah, I suppose time will tell.
00:40:03 I mean, it's generally been assumed that he was kind of the focal point of caucus discontent against Smith.
00:40:10 I mean, he could potentially be, but it would be considered a whole new level of treasonous to do it while in cabinet.
00:40:17 Well, in cabinet, there's cabinet solidarity.
00:40:20 When the cabinet speaks to caucus, the cabinet is supposed to speak with one voice, never dissenting, even in a caucus meeting.
00:40:28 So, I mean, it could go either way, but it definitely appears to be an attempt to buy some peace.
00:40:34 Well, I certainly can't imagine that the appointment was made without some kind of explicit understanding.
00:40:40 Yeah, it wasn't frivolous.
00:40:42 No, there's no doubt about that.
00:40:43 So some notable outs, not huge, not really big ones, but notable outs, you know, when I went through the list.
00:40:51 Shane Getson, he is just north of Edmonton, so vaguely Edmonton area-ish, which generally puts you on a short list of cabinet now, since there's no UCP MLAs in Edmonton.
00:41:03 But he, I mean, I don't think he was, no, he wasn't anti-vax, but he made a bunch of news when first reported by the Western Standard that he had some very serious adverse reactions to vaccines.
00:41:16 His face blew up.
00:41:17 Most of that picture, yeah.
00:41:18 I mean, it was shocking.
00:41:20 Stop. 0.99
00:41:20 Holy crap. 0.99
00:41:21 And I think that angered Kenny and some of the cabinet ministers that, hey, you're not making life easy on us here. 0.97
00:41:32 I want you to keep this quiet.
00:41:35 So, I mean, he's not in cabinet.
00:41:38 Bouchard, he replaced Jason Kenney in Calgary Law Heat, was backed by Take Back Alberta.
00:41:48 seems a fairly competent guy and you know nine of 12 Calgary MLAs are in cabinet
00:41:53 to be a Calgary MLA and not be in cabinet you got to be wondering now
00:41:58 what the hell did I do um and the one that stands out most to me is Grant Hunter uh Grant Hunter
00:42:05 is one of the longer serving MLAs there he was elected first as Wildroser in 2015 very very
00:42:11 competent, solid conservative. He served as an associate minister and Kenny's first cabinet
00:42:19 minister for red tape reduction, so very minor role, but seems to excel at it. Kenny booted him
00:42:24 out once the COVID rumbling started because he was a bit of a dissenter, but he ended up in the end
00:42:30 backing Travis Tate for the leadership, so it seems like he would have been actually a pretty good fit
00:42:33 coming in anyone else from either of you who stands out as huh surprise I'm
00:42:41 surprised they're not in cabinet oh really of the people that you've
00:42:46 mentioned most of them you know I wish these things fairly carefully but they
00:42:51 didn't create such a high profile for themselves but when the announcement
00:42:56 came out I was thinking well just a second word did I miss ground hunter
00:43:00 here somewhere. You know, it just didn't take me that way. And that's no reflection on the
00:43:05 competence or the personalities of these men and women. But she had a set of priorities. I think
00:43:13 that this message, you know, there's messaging in the appointment of cabinet ministers, either
00:43:18 look, we're favoring this group or favoring that group, or we've not got enough women or something 1.00
00:43:23 like that, you know, and that I suppose would be a... Yeah, we haven't even talked about the
00:43:28 The whole diversity thing. The rest of the media can talk about the diversity bingo card game.
00:43:32 I think it can get away with less women. 1.00
00:43:34 I didn't even think about it.
00:43:37 I forgot one notable in. Devin Grishan returns to Cabinet now.
00:43:42 He was the Minister of Agriculture.
00:43:45 There was a kerfuffle in the last year of Kenny involving alcohol in the legislature.
00:43:55 Everyone's so surprised there's alcohol in the legislature.
00:43:58 Come on, I spent four years around there. Other than the Mormons, everyone is, everyone's imbibing quite liberally from time to time. Although some of this stuff, none of it was proven. 0.91
00:44:10 It's a matter of responsibly.
00:44:11 Yeah, you got to do it responsibly. Anyway, he returns as Minister of Transportation and Economic Corridors. The Economic Corridors is a new sort of portfolio attached to it, which I know you're going to have more to say on possibly next week. We've got some columns coming up on it.
00:44:25 Not cabinet, but actually is a very notable out, but there's a very good reason probably for it, and that is Nathan Cooper.
00:44:33 Nathan Cooper is technically, I guess, still the speaker of the legislature.
00:44:39 He was the speaker from 2019 until now, and he was house leader of the Wildrose opposition from four and actually interim leader of the UCP after the merger before Kenny was elected leader of the UCP.
00:44:54 the single biggest nerd within a few kilometers of the legislature. The guy just, so you had Jay
00:45:04 Hillen on your show earlier, a parliamentary procedure and stuff. Nathan Eats policy. Jay
00:45:10 Hill is like Michael Jackson cool compared to how much of a nerd Nathan Cooper is on this stuff.
00:45:17 The guy's life ambition is to be the speaker of the Alberta legislature. He loves everything.
00:45:22 Nothing else. So he is a guy who would have, I think, been on a very short list for cabinet. If he's not in cabinet, it's almost certainly that he said, no, Madam Premier, I, I want to be speaker. So, and I, and I spent a good one. He's actually been a very good speaker. Yeah.
00:45:38 So does the speaker in the legislature have the same kind of entertainment budget and privileges as the speaker in the House of Commons?
00:45:45 No, no.
00:45:46 Then why would you want the job?
00:45:49 Well, I guess he's just maybe not quite the drinker, because the Speaker of the House of Commons has this big cottage in the Gatineau site with this massive scotch collection.
00:45:59 It's like a scotch library.
00:46:00 I mean, I think any one of us, maybe not you, but if Nigel and I became Speaker, we had this unlimited library of world-class scotches that never ran out, we'd never get to work again.
00:46:14 It would kill us.
00:46:16 But it is something, you know, whether Nathan Coober, if you've watched him in there, I mean, he just, he thrives on it.
00:46:21 He loves it.
00:46:21 He does stuff outside of there.
00:46:23 He educates on procedure and things.
00:46:25 Yeah.
00:46:26 See, it's good to see, actually.
00:46:27 He's kind of a brighter...
00:46:28 Honorable member for Lethbridge East.
00:46:30 Yes.
00:46:30 It's nothing but fun.
00:46:32 All right, dear.
00:46:33 Well, perfect timing.
00:46:35 We're going to wrap it up there.
00:46:36 We're going to wrap a tour it up.
00:46:40 Come on, please, please.
00:46:42 Oh, come on. 0.87
00:46:43 I have to work for the rest of the afternoon without ringing in my ears.
00:46:45 It was a very special joke to me.
00:46:47 Okay.
00:46:49 It was special.
00:46:50 Yes.
00:46:51 All right, Nigel, Corey, thank you very much for joining.
00:46:54 And thank all of you for joining us today.
00:46:56 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to westernstandard.news, click on membership.
00:47:01 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
00:47:07 Thank you very much for joining us, and God bless.
00:47:09 The Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:47:16 These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:47:24 And more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:47:29 We've become a member. It's absolutely worth every penny.