Western Standard - January 11, 2024


The Pipeline: MLI calls Guilbeault policymaker of the year

Topics
Mentioned
Conservatives blast Liberals for allowing David Menzies arrest That was close‼️ ‘U S Pilot Narrowly Avoids Decapitation’

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

180.59

Word count

8,956

Sentence count

503

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Corey and Dave return to discuss the latest in Canadian politics, including the latest assault charges against the Prime Minister's security guard, David Menzies, for questioning Chrystia Freeland at a public event.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, welcome to The Pipeline.
00:00:26 I am Western Standard columnist and show host, Corey Morgan.
00:00:30 This is our weekly news and affairs show, a panel show, where we get a few of us turning your ear and dissecting what's been happening and leading the news at the Western Standard through the course of this week.
00:00:43 I'm going to start, though, before I get to who's joining me today.
00:00:46 We've been rotating the crowd a lot over the holiday season and talk about our sponsor, though.
00:00:50 and that that's how we pay the bills that's how we keep these shows going and they are a fantastic
00:00:56 sponsor it's the canadian shooting sports association guys if you're firearms owners
00:01:00 collectors whatever you may want to do with them you've got to be a member of this association
00:01:05 it's important there's all sorts of resources access to gun shows uh shooting sports things
00:01:11 like that but as well they lobby on your behalf because you have a government that's trying to
00:01:15 take away your right ability to have those firearms and if you don't stand up for yourself
00:01:18 They're going to win in their safety in numbers.
00:01:20 You've got to join an association to protect your rights together.
00:01:23 So check it out, CSSA-CILA.org.
00:01:27 It's the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:01:30 And take out a membership, guys.
00:01:32 It's well worth it.
00:01:33 All right.
00:01:33 I'm joined today.
00:01:34 I'll start on the end.
00:01:35 It's been a while since we've seen them here on the end seat there.
00:01:38 Our news editor, Dave Naylor.
00:01:40 How's it going, Dave?
00:01:41 Good.
00:01:41 Thrilled to be back with this weather.
00:01:43 I'm thinking it's going to be minus 36 in the morning.
00:01:46 Going to feel like minus 36.
00:01:48 Derek's off today, so I'm thinking of declaring the rest of the week work from home week.
00:01:53 All right, I would second that.
00:01:56 What a great idea.
00:01:57 Just be happy that we have indoor jobs anyway.
00:01:59 Yeah, that's true.
00:02:00 That is true.
00:02:01 There is that.
00:02:02 Okay, well, we'll see how that goes.
00:02:05 I'm sure he's probably not watching the show anyway.
00:02:07 And, of course, as we're always joined by opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:02:12 Hi, Nigel.
00:02:12 How are you doing?
00:02:13 Tanned, rested, and ready.
00:02:14 Oh, good.
00:02:15 Yeah, everybody's kind of had a break.
00:02:16 I'm escaping from mine pretty soon here.
00:02:19 Coward?
00:02:20 Yes. 0.57
00:02:21 Well, I don't know.
00:02:21 The drive he's got ahead of him, you know, maybe we should have a little more sympathy for him.
00:02:26 I don't know.
00:02:27 We'll see.
00:02:27 See, you know, normally when I drive, if I'm in a hurry, I'm looking at the kilometers ticking down to my destination.
00:02:32 But what I'll be looking at this time is the thermometer ticking up as I get southward.
00:02:36 So it'll motivate me to carry on despite the howls of my life.
00:02:40 Send us a postcard.
00:02:42 Yeah, will do.
00:02:43 All right.
00:02:43 Well, let's get on to some of the more pressing things, I guess.
00:02:48 This is kind of a deep subject, a big one.
00:02:49 It's been hitting the news a lot.
00:02:51 This video has gone out.
00:02:52 It's with a rebel media reporter.
00:02:55 David Menzies tried questioning Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland when she was walking
00:03:01 into an event, and he had quite an altercation with one of her security members.
00:03:06 It was an RCMP member, and he was pretty roughed up and charged with assaulting a police officer.
00:03:12 we'll play that video because there's so many people arguing about the context on social media
00:03:16 what happened well we'll let you watch the full video for yourselves so you can determine what
00:03:20 we're talking about and uh then we'll talk a little more about this so the freeland how come
00:03:25 the irdc is not a terrorist group why is your government supporting islamo now 0.99
00:03:31 me you're under arrest for assault police you're under arrest how am i under you bumped into me
00:03:48 you pushed into you but i was just scrubbing here i got my credentials here and you just
00:03:52 bump into me so please you're under what is your name in your bag
00:03:57 what is your name in your badge you've been told you're under arrest why am i under arrest
00:04:02 he brought my way
00:04:06 i was just swimming uh christian freeland i'm a police officer you're under arrest
00:04:13 what is your name in your badge you've been assaulting a police officer how is that possible
00:04:16 okay because you assaulted me three years ago when blackmail contracted
00:04:20 you mean i was asking questions aggressively no no your actions were you were almost pushing
00:04:28 everybody over lincoln you got this on video right he's saying i'm pushing people over
00:04:34 that's an absolute falsehood there were people so now it appeared that way that's what you're
00:04:39 saying officer that's what i saw i wasn't i didn't touch a single person that was a little
00:04:43 bit aggressive for what was happening get that you get it you're under arrest please take the
00:04:47 microphone out of my face. Well, I'd like an ongoing record of this. Can I have the microphone?
00:04:51 Can I have the microphone? Can I have the microphone? Can you give me a microphone?
00:04:56 Take your hand out. Why am I? Why am I? I'm just doing my mom. I'm resisting. You don't need to
00:05:04 resist. I don't have to say anything. You know the truth. I have nothing to hide, sir.
00:05:10 Welcome to Black Faces Canada. This is what they do to journalists. I was merely scrumming 1.00
00:05:17 minister freeland and a rcmp officer blocked me and evidently this is now a trumped up charge of
00:05:24 assault folks i didn't come here to cause any trouble i came here to do my job and now i'm
00:05:31 handcuffed this this is your candidate now folks you know this is the gestapo taking black faces 0.61
00:05:39 orders outrageous and meanwhile the islamic revolutionary guard corps is not a terrorist 0.86
00:05:47 organization is not a terrorist organization and these liberals have the audacity to show up at a
00:05:54 vigil for for a plane in which almost 200 people were killed 57 canadians one unborn child by the
00:06:02 way and look at this they don't want it is against the law in black faces canada to ask insensitive 0.76
00:06:10 questions impolite questions so a government canadian government that props up an islamo 1.00
00:06:18 fascist regime that's okay but if you ask questions about that uh that's not okay
00:06:25 this is an absolute outrage i didn't come here to cause trouble folks i just came here to ask
00:06:31 All right. So, I mean, that was pretty striking anyways. I mean, you know, we can get into a bit
00:06:47 of a, and I'd like to get into a little more about the discussion of who's a journalist,
00:06:50 who's not, cause it's really opened a whole bunch of discussions on this whole thing.
00:06:54 But I'll start with Dave.
00:06:56 I mean, I think anybody can agree that was probably, it was an overreach by the security officer and the police.
00:07:03 I mean, it really didn't seem to be justified for anything we could see in that video.
00:07:06 Oh, no doubt about it.
00:07:08 Look, Corey, I'm not a big fan of David Menzies and his antics.
00:07:13 You know, he's been arrested more times than I've had hot dinners.
00:07:16 But this RCMP officer completely out of line, completely provoked him and, you know, and caused the entire incident, roughed him up, took four cops to arrest him.
00:07:29 You know, at least Menzies had the good sense to keep talking during his arrest and got some good video.
00:07:35 And I'm sure his boss Ezra probably gave him a little bit of a bonus and videos being viewed more than 10 million times now.
00:07:43 And surely the rebels doing some top fundraising off it.
00:07:49 But yeah, clearly in the wrong.
00:07:51 And you could just tell Chrystia Freeland smirking away as she avoids a legitimate question about an Iranian group on the anniversary of the day when the Iranians shot down an airliner with a whole bunch of Canadians on it.
00:08:05 Yeah, well, and as a veteran of many arrests, Mr. Menzies composed himself fairly quickly.
00:08:10 But, you know, at first, one of the things, I mean, I've watched that video multiple times because I've seen the arguments and dispute.
00:08:15 The first part of it, you can see he was scared.
00:08:17 And who wouldn't be?
00:08:18 I mean, this is a big officer has you by the lapels and is slamming you against a wall.
00:08:23 Like he was playing clothes, right?
00:08:25 So instantly Menzies wouldn't have known it was a call. 0.68
00:08:29 And this is an act, I mean, of intimidation.
00:08:30 If you were another reporter, a small person, considering, you know, scrumming or going after public figures, this would have a pretty chilling effect, I think, Nigel.
00:08:38 You know, in seeing that, you might reconsider doing your job. 0.94
00:08:42 Well, I hope I wouldn't, but darn it all, I believe I would. 0.60
00:08:47 You know, you're absolutely right. 0.94
00:08:51 Part of that, I think, the look on Mr. Menzies' face was occasioned by the fact that he just plain didn't see it coming.
00:08:58 He was concentrating on the minister, and then from the cover of the lamppost out steps this tank,
00:09:06 bumps into him this is what i see when i look at the video bumps into him when he's looking the
00:09:12 other way well he was surprised apart from anything else so uh and and rightly so you know
00:09:20 uh there's a there's a lot of people and you made reference to this a moment ago
00:09:26 who have no sympathy with menzies because they don't like the rebel and they don't like what
00:09:33 the rebel does or stands for. Okay, we've said it. Now, does anybody deserve to get
00:09:45 bumped like that by the RCMP while they're in the act of trying to speak to a politician?
00:09:53 I say, no. We operate as journalists. We have no special journalist rights. We operate under the same right that every other Canadian citizen has of free speech, free expression, and the right to address a politician.
00:10:16 Now, there is a time and a place for everything, and you can expect that if you make your move
00:10:26 at the wrong time, you probably will be rebuffed, but not necessarily out of spite, merely out
00:10:33 of the fact that, well, we can't really talk right now, but it was noticeable.
00:10:37 I mean, we all know that they don't like the rebel.
00:10:39 They don't like us, but my word, they really don't like the rebel.
00:10:42 um can't even get recognized as a as a newspaper they don't get admitted to liberal party events
00:10:51 it goes on and on and on so there's clearly the rcmp knew who menzies was here comes the minister
00:10:57 menzies is going to make his move whether it was a misplaced act of gallantry or some more sinister
00:11:04 explanation that I that I hesitate to even speak about on the air what happened happened and it
00:11:12 shouldn't happen because that if you have been walking by or as a person who is not involved
00:11:19 with the media at any time see Minister Freeland and just mind who that is Minister Freeland when
00:11:26 are you going to recognize when are you going to condemn the IRGC you shouldn't expect to get
00:11:31 slammed against the wall by the RCMP. But you have as much right to ask that question as the
00:11:36 journalist has, we're operating under the same code. Absolutely. And I mean, again, that's why
00:11:43 it was so important to play this video, because I've seen a lot of apologists or people making
00:11:46 excuses. I mean, had Mr. Menzies been aggressively approaching, if he'd been sprinting towards her as
00:11:52 if he was going to make contact, or if he hadn't even been with a camera person, I mean, it would
00:11:56 be clear to anybody saying this is a person doing a report. If this was a run of the mill
00:12:02 civilian making a run at a minister, I expect the RCMP to get in and make a block and say,
00:12:08 excuse me. But even then, you know, you block them off, you don't grab them and slam. And again,
00:12:14 that absurd charge, which was dropped, you know, some hours later of assaulting a police officer.
00:12:21 I mean, really?
00:12:23 Obviously, the RCMP officer obviously made it up on the spot.
00:12:27 Okay, how can I get this guy out of the way?
00:12:29 Oh, he bumped into me.
00:12:30 That's assault.
00:12:32 You know, it's, and as you say, they took four hours before somebody came to their senses
00:12:36 and said, you know, we better let this guy go.
00:12:39 The process is the punishment by that point.
00:12:42 I mean, you've shaken a person up, you've scared them, you've locked them up.
00:12:45 And it's going to cost them a lot of money.
00:12:48 Because, you know, Ezra is going to unleash the lawyers and he's going to win.
00:12:51 he's got the case and he's got the video evidence. So it's just a matter of how much he'll settle
00:12:57 for. That's the other journalism school takeaway here is if you're going to talk to a liberal
00:13:02 cabinet minister, you better have a camera running while you're doing it. Well, if one of my reporters
00:13:07 saw Christopher Freeland walking down the street, first of all, they would think, my, she's not in
00:13:12 a limo. Isn't she always in a limo? And then I would expect them to go and engage and talk to
00:13:17 and try and get a story out of them.
00:13:19 And as you say, you know, what if it was a constituent, you know, on Freeland's writing
00:13:25 and has got a problem and, you know, barking dog or something like that and wants to complain?
00:13:30 Do they get tackled by RCMP?
00:13:34 Scary.
00:13:34 And we've got police as well where it's a tough job.
00:13:38 And, you know, they get questioned on a lot of arrests.
00:13:40 They get questioned in a lot of circumstances.
00:13:42 When we do see on video a clear example of an officer making up a charge against somebody, that adds to mistrust of police in general.
00:13:53 When people see that, you know, quite often when you hear some criminals say, I was falsely accused, this and that, people roll their eyes.
00:13:59 Well, you start to see more of this.
00:14:01 And you can't make this up in Canada.
00:14:02 You know, one day where cops delivering coffee to Hamas, protesters, and the next day they're busting reporters.
00:14:10 Like, what is going on with police in this country?
00:14:13 And there was many officers there, too.
00:14:15 I mean, if there was one officer going rogue and getting out of control,
00:14:18 I'm going to guess perhaps this gentleman was the senior officer on the scene.
00:14:21 I don't know.
00:14:22 But none of the others raised their hand and said,
00:14:25 maybe this is settled now, we can stop.
00:14:27 I mean, I think there's a pecking order in police services generally,
00:14:32 like the state troopers give way to the FBI.
00:14:35 And in Canada, somebody comes along from the prime minister's personal details
00:14:39 and seems to take control of the situation
00:14:41 because that's where this fellow is from.
00:14:45 The provincial police are going to say,
00:14:47 oh, I guess they've got it there, haven't they?
00:14:49 So we're not going to interfere.
00:14:51 And it looked like City of Toronto officers.
00:14:54 No, it was in Peterborough.
00:14:56 So whoever it was,
00:14:57 they are not going to call out their senior colleagues
00:15:01 and say, hey, look, we've got a problem here,
00:15:03 especially when they know it's being filmed.
00:15:05 They're going to keep their mouths closed
00:15:06 and maybe behind closed doors.
00:15:08 Even if they're right,
00:15:09 They're not going to say a thing.
00:15:11 They're not going to win that one.
00:15:14 So, I mean, and that goes further into some of the discussion I saw online.
00:15:18 And, of course, it's not always the most nuanced and bright discussion, but it's something a lot of people throw out when they're the tribalistic nature.
00:15:24 I like these media outlets.
00:15:25 I don't like those.
00:15:26 But when people keep throwing in and it annoys that crap out of me, journalist in quotes, reporter in quotes, or saying they're not real ones.
00:15:32 I mean, just to clarify, for one, there is no actual certification for who is or isn't a journalist in Canada.
00:15:41 It's a definition of a rule.
00:15:42 Long may that continue.
00:15:43 I certainly don't want the government saying, well, you're a journalist and you can do this and you're not a journalist, so go away.
00:15:48 Exactly.
00:15:49 I don't want to see that.
00:15:50 That would be shocking.
00:15:52 But it's a discussion worth having.
00:15:54 People better realize.
00:15:55 It's not up to you.
00:15:56 It's not up to the government.
00:15:57 So if anybody can define who is or isn't a journalist, you can say it's a bad journalist, an incredible journalist, a tasteless journalist, fine.
00:16:05 But they're still technically, if they're reporting on something, a journalist.
00:16:08 I mean, I had a conversation with Mr. Menzies yesterday, and he tells me that he spent three years at Ryerson University when it was called Ryerson, came out of there with a journalism degree.
00:16:21 even if there was a professional designation of journalists, I would hope that three years at
00:16:27 Ryerson would satisfy the critics, plus 25 years since working in the industry. I mean, like you
00:16:33 said, good journalist, bad journalist, journalist anyway. Yeah, you may not like their style or how
00:16:39 they go about being a journalist, but you can't argue who's a journalist and who's not. Well,
00:16:43 people try, and it's just frustrating. I mean, if we get into regulation, this was kind of
00:16:48 unexpected. It was something that came up earlier, and you've written on it, Nigel, with CRTC is
00:16:53 hinting at coming up with codes of conduct. I mean, that's quite a regulatory step towards
00:16:59 actually saying who's a journalist or who isn't, and what you're even allowed to do as a journalist
00:17:03 or not. That's kind of distressing. I mean, I, you know, honestly, Corey and David, we're not a
00:17:12 long-lived breed but I expect nevertheless to live to see the day that we have that kind of 1.00
00:17:20 licensing for journalists. I am told anecdotally that they already have it in Great Britain. I
00:17:26 find that hard to believe and I haven't checked it out but the person who told me had been at a
00:17:32 press conference where it's all right boys let's see your licenses and we go here we go again sort
00:17:37 of thing you know and he came to the Canadian he said well we don't actually have a license to be
00:17:41 Oh, don't you? Oh, okay. Well, fair enough. Carry on. Really? Is that how far things have fallen?
00:17:48 I relate it as an unattributed anecdote that I have not checked the truth on yet. I only heard
00:17:55 it very recently. But certainly there are many places in the world where you don't just get up
00:18:02 and start writing. You have to have permission. And Canada at the moment is not one of those
00:18:08 places and may that continue i just don't have a very happy expectation that it will
00:18:14 well anything the crtc does they mess it up yeah you know they couldn't organize their
00:18:19 booze up in a brewery but uh it is it is scary to think of you know the code is going to say
00:18:24 you must stay 10 10 feet back from any politician and you know it's uh i'm not sure it will get far
00:18:31 peace david i don't know i mean the only thing i can think of that would be worse than an
00:18:35 inefficient crtc was an efficient crtc yes yes good point you know maybe maybe we should just
00:18:43 hope for at least a little incompetence in the administration of this should it ever come about
00:18:48 well their middle name is incompetence so i'm sure it'll be there it'll be the one thing they
00:18:53 get right you mark my words well and i just always like to remind folks in situations like this when
00:18:57 you're talking about empowering a government further and even if you like the current government
00:19:02 just remember it's not always going to be a government you like and if you've empowered
00:19:07 them to step on those sorts of rights when the government comes in that you don't like
00:19:12 the journalists that you enjoyed before suddenly might find themselves being shut out from
00:19:17 communications or the ability to report and everybody again has done a disservice all over
00:19:22 again well nigel you worked in the pmo with harper for for 10 years now that was a guy journalists 0.74
00:19:28 hated. Journalists did not like Harper, but he wasn't blacklisting anybody or sending his RCMP
00:19:34 thugs to arrest anybody, was he? No, he did not. And I actually, I was thinking about this very
00:19:42 thing and wondering whether something had changed in the years since I was voted out of office,
00:19:49 so to speak. I was, for the benefit of those who don't know the Hannaford story, I was a staffer,
00:19:55 I wasn't an elected person, but I was looking after the Prime Minister's speeches for about six years.
00:20:02 And in all of that six years, I had the opportunity to hang out, I guess you would say,
00:20:10 with a lot of these RCMP officers, because they were the only people on a trip who were close to my age.
00:20:15 And, you know, it's either that or join the young staffers while they sit there on their phones, you know,
00:20:21 and sort of trying to hit on each other. That's what they would do.
00:20:24 Anyway, so I ended up gracious enough to make room at the table for me, and a pretty good bunch of guys.
00:20:32 And the men that I and a couple of women who were on the PMPD, who I knew between 2009 and 2015,
00:20:42 I would not expect this kind of thing from any of them.
00:20:47 There was not one that I thought, well, you know, good job he's on our side, but he is a bit of a thug, you know.
00:20:54 No, there was none of that.
00:20:56 This took me completely by surprise.
00:20:58 So they're getting their marching orders from somewhere, aren't they?
00:21:02 That's a conspiracy theory, Dave.
00:21:06 Perhaps.
00:21:06 So just that attitude, though,
00:21:07 thinking that it's within their rights to do that,
00:21:10 and you've got to wonder where that's come.
00:21:12 Again, it might be a rogue one, but we've seen a lot of...
00:21:14 I mean, Prime Ministers chafe at media often.
00:21:17 Mr. Polyev, if he becomes the Prime Minister,
00:21:20 I suspect it's going to be a prickly relationship,
00:21:22 but I haven't seen indications that he wants them muscled out.
00:21:25 He'll just munch an apple and ignore them, which drives people wild.
00:21:29 Some people might say it's an inappropriate thing, too.
00:21:31 That's fine, but it's better than sending the thugs after them.
00:21:35 That's for sure.
00:21:36 Mind you, I mean, we have another.
00:21:39 People probably forget about this, but it must be about 25, 26 years ago.
00:21:43 But one day, Mr. Chrétien was irritated by somebody who was being abusive.
00:21:48 Yes, the Schoenigan handshake.
00:21:50 That was, I guess that guy probably didn't do that again.
00:21:56 No, probably not.
00:21:57 You know, that was one of the few times I sort of applauded Prime Minister Chrétien.
00:22:00 I mean, it was an inappropriate case.
00:22:02 This was a person coming out of nowhere, approaching a prime minister.
00:22:06 He'd gotten past security and within arm's reach of Prime Minister Chrétien.
00:22:10 Younger people might not know or remember. 0.58
00:22:12 If you Google the image, you'll see he grabbed hold of him by the neck and he muzzled him aside.
00:22:17 It was great.
00:22:17 That's one case where the Prime Minister's personal detail was there for the protection of the crowd.
00:22:24 From the Sherwinigan back streets.
00:22:29 Don't forget the Inuit sculpture to the head. Remember when the guy broke in? 1.00
00:22:35 Oh, his wife Eileen.
00:22:37 Yeah, his wife clubbed the guy with Inuit sculpture.
00:22:40 I don't know. You say you didn't used to care much for Mr. Kretzian, and I guess I would say the same, but I'm sure missing him now.
00:22:49 Absolutely. I mean, he was still, even if he didn't like him, he was respectable.
00:22:52 Yeah, you've got to have a liberal prime minister.
00:22:55 He was smart, and he had a degree of dignity. His treatment of the West, again, is as typical of liberals, drove me bananas.
00:23:01 But I wasn't cringing in fear whenever he'd go overseas representing the country versus today when, I just wish Trudeau would extend his vacations year-round, to be honest,
00:23:10 because he just can't seem to get through one
00:23:11 without a problem.
00:23:14 You should check it out with Mr. Biden.
00:23:16 Apparently, Mr. Biden knows some good spots
00:23:18 and spends a lot of time there.
00:23:20 That's a different show.
00:23:21 World Revolution together.
00:23:23 Yeah, they're sitting with those tropical islands.
00:23:26 God.
00:23:27 All right, well, let's move on.
00:23:30 Only crossing the line.
00:23:31 It's usually that's my job in here.
00:23:32 Well, approaching the line.
00:23:34 Whatever line that might be.
00:23:36 Let's talk about a policymaker
00:23:38 who seems to have won an award.
00:23:40 a liberal policymaker one of trudeau's uh top ministers uh dave uh yes this is a well-deserved
00:23:48 award cory uh from the uh mcdonald laurier institute a think tank they have named gilbo
00:23:54 policymaker of the year uh for basically doing uh everything that he can to destroy the economy
00:24:01 from straws to plastics registries to electricity regulations to clean fuel
00:24:07 environments. He has done more to screw up the Canadian economy than anybody else,
00:24:13 and the McDonnell-Laurie Institute gave him this award, and I'm sure he proudly accepted it.
00:24:20 He's got quite a generous amount of contenders for economic dingbats over the years.
00:24:25 They said nobody came close to him in this current batch of Liberal cabinet ministers.
00:24:31 They put it beautifully, Dave. They said, this is intended as criticism, but I expect you'll boo.
00:24:37 would be pleased with the acknowledgement. Yes, I'm sure he would. Maybe he'll accept it wearing
00:24:45 his orange jumpsuit from his old days. I mean, the thing with, there's actually an excellent
00:24:55 analysis. This isn't just like an organization putting up its new year's credits or anything
00:25:02 like that. It's not like the Taxpayers Federation and their teddies, even the McDonald-Lorean
00:25:05 institute actually does a lot of nuanced uh policy discussion and i think the ctf would say that it
00:25:10 did too but uh you know i'm not knocking them i love them as well yeah but look uh there's a
00:25:17 three-page article in their in their january report and they actually lay out four things
00:25:24 that they put to mr gilbo's account which any one of us who live here work here try to make a living
00:25:32 here uh so yeah that's exactly what's what's going wrong so the you know the the first one of course
00:25:39 is the carbon pricing scheme the second one is the clean fuel regulations and clean fuel regulations
00:25:45 does not mean clean in the sense that you normally use the word clean it means uh fuel which has not
00:25:54 burned other fuel to produce so if you're pumping heat into a sag-d set up in fort mcmurray well
00:26:01 Well, that's burning fuel.
00:26:04 The less fuel you burn, the cleaner the fuel that you ultimately produce.
00:26:08 I mean, it's economically efficient to a degree,
00:26:12 but when the requirement takes you past the point of an economic return,
00:26:16 then it's serious and damaging.
00:26:19 So carbon pricing, clean fuel rigs,
00:26:23 and it's interesting that just as they make this point in this document
00:26:30 that even as they are asking producers to produce cleaner fuel,
00:26:35 they are, by other regulations, destroying the market for that fuel
00:26:41 by announcing that by 2035 you won't be able to buy a gasoline-powered car
00:26:49 to put your clean fuel into.
00:26:50 So they're hitting both sides.
00:26:55 And, you know, you go through the whole thing here,
00:26:59 And it is so obvious that the minister has been given a blank check.
00:27:09 Go do it. Do whatever you can.
00:27:12 We're going to save the earth? No.
00:27:15 But we're certainly going to screw the West.
00:27:17 And that's a good thing.
00:27:18 Because there's just that kind of disaffection for anything to do with Alberta,
00:27:24 anything to do with Western Canada, which we have, we don't have to assume it.
00:27:31 We don't have to conjecture that it must be so because of the actions, which is one way of looking at it.
00:27:37 We can just go back over the prime minister's past comments, both when he was in office
00:27:43 and when he was just another backbench MP.
00:27:47 These things like, problem with Canada, there's too many Albertans running it. 0.99
00:27:50 You know, that was during the Harper years, obviously, but I mean, there's a long list of these comments that he's made.
00:27:56 He clearly doesn't like this part of the country and the values that it has.
00:28:01 So, I mean, is it sloth on the part of the prime minister just saying, you know, here, I'm going to give it to this crazed ideologue?
00:28:07 And that's what he is.
00:28:08 I mean, as you mentioned, the picture of him with his manic eyes and that grin in an orange jumpsuit while he's being led away in chains.
00:28:14 Like, this is a guy who climbed on the roof of Premier Ralph Klein's house to protest in the past.
00:28:21 He crossed all sorts of lines.
00:28:22 Now he's one of the most powerful people in the country.
00:28:25 Does Trudeau agree with this ideological agenda of Gilbo, or does he just not care?
00:28:29 He's not paying attention, just saying, go for it.
00:28:31 Well, I think he's sitting on the beach in Jamaica and basically saying to Gilbo, go for it, 0.99
00:28:37 because I think this is what he wants his legacy to be.
00:28:39 Yes.
00:28:39 You know, when people look back in 30 years, he's going to say, well, I started the Green Revolution in Canada, and we ended up saving the world.
00:28:47 You know, despite the fact Poliev, when he gets in, is going to change everything back to normal, hopefully.
00:28:53 I think it's his legacy plan.
00:28:58 Well, it is his legacy plan, and he's been very faithful to it over a long period of time.
00:29:02 back when Gerald Butts was actually in the prime minister's office and in the years leading up to
00:29:09 when he had to leave the there was a there was a public occasion I think it might have been in
00:29:16 it was in Ontario somewhere a small town meeting and he said well we've got to phase out the oil
00:29:20 sands you know now sometimes when people make these kinds of statements you think well that's 0.96
00:29:28 That's ridiculous.
00:29:29 Nobody's going to phase out the oil sands, it's making too much money, it's carrying 0.93
00:29:32 the country, it's this, this, this, and this, and you just write him off as a flake.
00:29:39 Then he was challenged on it.
00:29:40 He came back a little later and said, well, I kind of maybe overstated my case, something
00:29:45 like that.
00:29:46 But actually, you're right.
00:29:49 This is a long-standing goal and it's taken them 10 years and they are getting there.
00:29:56 if we don't have a change of policy, which I think is going to require a change of government,
00:30:03 they may end up achieving their ends. Well, that's it. I mean, as the headlining
00:30:08 on the standard said, ruthless, reckless, and damaging. Like he is just a wrecking ball coming
00:30:12 in there. I mean, the courts have tried to rein him in. There's been a couple of
00:30:15 pretty landmark rulings saying, you guys have overstepped the constitution. Your
00:30:20 plans, your regulations are going too far. You're going outside of your jurisdiction. In both cases,
00:30:26 they're just kind of like well yeah he doesn't seem to care you know we'll take another look at
00:30:30 the rules and maybe we're ready you know and uh it's going to be interesting 2024 what the
00:30:36 relationship is with Gilbo and Premier Smith of Alberta she's called for him to be fired and
00:30:42 removed uh which obviously is not going to happen because Trudeau would have done that a long time
00:30:47 ago if he thought he was uh not the right guy so you know when you've when you've called for
00:30:52 somebody to be fired it's not a good way to go into a negotiation session is it sorry there's
00:30:59 one other thing that's in this article that i think is worth repeating because one doesn't like to
00:31:04 sort of conclude on a on a note of despair and the author i don't know her personally but i
00:31:11 have had some dealings with heather exner pedo and she just says it is often said that if you
00:31:16 you want to go fast, go alone. But if you want to go far, go together. And she makes the point
00:31:22 that Gilbo is very far ahead from industry and the provinces. He's out there on his own.
00:31:31 And in fact, most Canadians are trailing in the dust somewhere, and certainly the provinces are,
00:31:39 as you were just saying. He is alienating voters. This is what she writes. He is alienating voters
00:31:46 who are concerned more about affordability and housing.
00:31:52 They've got an election within 21 months.
00:31:58 I don't know what they're going to do to get around this,
00:32:00 but at the moment, he is a serious drag
00:32:04 on the election chances of the Liberals in 2025.
00:32:09 And the thing he's doing right now is probably...
00:32:12 What he's probably doing right now
00:32:13 is getting his resume ready for a job at the UN.
00:32:16 Oh, yeah.
00:32:16 Right, because if you're an environmental WACO, there's your place to go for employment.
00:32:20 Yeah, seeking a reference from Mr. Schwab.
00:32:23 Yes, no doubt.
00:32:24 And part of the problem, and that's what they're listing, is the damage he's doing, and that will hang over.
00:32:28 Even if Trudeau suddenly said, you know what, I've had enough of this guy.
00:32:32 I've got to refocus if I've got any hope in being reelected.
00:32:36 The chill he's put on investment, as you said, it's a long game.
00:32:40 Who in their right mind would invest in a gas generating facility in Alberta when they're talking about capping you off on that in a few years?
00:32:47 Who's going to invest in an auto dealership or, you know, any number of things when you know that these guys have already, I mean, the damage is done.
00:32:57 I mean, we can undo some of it, but it's going to hang over.
00:33:00 Well, you know, Corey, who would you even want to invest in manufacturing electric vehicles
00:33:09 if you can't be sure that people are going to, A, want to buy them, and B, if there's nothing else
00:33:14 left to buy and they have to, that they'll be able to plug them in and charge them up. Because right
00:33:19 now, that is not by any means a certain thing. No, our grid, there's a lot of big question marks
00:33:25 So he's well out past any rational people with his policies, and we've got this mess.
00:33:31 I just came back from Vancouver, and I'll let you know, every second car seems to be a Tesla.
00:33:35 Yeah, really?
00:33:36 They're all over the place.
00:33:37 Well, when's the last time I went to minus 30 in Vancouver?
00:33:39 Yeah, exactly.
00:33:43 Well, we'll see.
00:33:45 Interesting to keep watching that crazed man.
00:33:47 I mean, I got sent running out, I don't know if you remember, to take pictures of him when he came across the Hall of Fame with Premier Kenny, actually.
00:33:54 and he got out with his entourage from a minivan from the airport parked and idling over off to
00:34:01 the side that he was warm while he was having his meetings for him. I was frozen because they kept
00:34:05 running me in circles trying to find him, Derek phoning me and texting me and so on, but
00:34:08 he's a character, quite indifferent he seemed to me anyway, so at least I didn't get arrested or
00:34:14 beaten up for my troubles. You obviously weren't trying hard enough, were you? I guess I needed a
00:34:19 rebel mike they didn't know what this western standard thing was all right well armed and
00:34:26 freezing we've got you know the weather's changing and it's going to make i mean a problem that's
00:34:32 been building for a while now is going to hit critical level really fast what's going on dave
00:34:36 yeah as i mentioned earlier we're going to be minus 36 like it feels like in the morning
00:34:41 um they've had some major problems in edmonton with homeless homeless camps and they shut one
00:34:47 down and they gave the media sort of a behind scenes look and they called him in and on a table
00:34:53 there were all sorts of weapons laid out from from firearms to machetes to brass knuckles
00:34:59 and they showed a really what was called a horrific film of what what happens in these tents
00:35:04 and you could see one guy trying to light a propane tank to get some heat coming off it and
00:35:10 he blows off his hand he eventually dies uh from his injuries and other people die in fires because
00:35:17 are too intoxicated to to save themselves and it's it's it's a real mess uh and
00:35:26 this week the government announced in alberta opening up another 150 emergency shelter spaces
00:35:33 in edmonton so you know what if people want to go there's room for them uh but a lot of these the
00:35:41 homeless don't want to go they don't like the shelters it's dangerous for them they can't do
00:35:46 their drugs uh in the shelters a lot of them are also mentally ill um so yeah it's it's a tough
00:35:53 job for all the social workers and the police officers and it's it's not just edmonton it's
00:35:58 calgary it's basically every major city in canada now has homeless camera almost camps uh set up in
00:36:07 them so major problem this is the first cold wave of the winter and let's hope everybody makes it
00:36:12 it through. These cities are in a rock and a hard place. I mean, if they don't enforce, if they don't
00:36:17 take down these tents, we know how the activists will react when the fires happen, not if and when
00:36:23 the people are, you know, overdose or intoxicated to the point where they freeze to death and not
00:36:28 realize it. The city and authorities will get the blame for not having gone in there. But right now,
00:36:34 of course, they're getting the blame and being called heartless for going in and tearing down.
00:36:38 Like, is there ever going to be an acceptable answer to this?
00:36:41 Actually, as Dave was speaking, I was just thinking, if you had all the money and all the power in the world, what would a solution be that could work?
00:36:50 I could not think of one that does not require the active participation of the person that you're trying to help.
00:36:59 That is the challenge.
00:37:01 I remember an article that you wrote, Corey, probably three or four months ago, in which you mentioned the dilemma posed by encountering a person passed out on, I think it was on a park bench, laying there in stark misery.
00:37:20 and is it the right thing to walk on by
00:37:25 or should you intervene?
00:37:30 And there are people saying, I'll just leave them alone.
00:37:33 And yet that seems the cruelest outcome
00:37:36 to just leave somebody in misery.
00:37:40 And yet, if you take care of them today,
00:37:44 you will find them there again tomorrow.
00:37:47 so what exactly is
00:37:50 it is an incredible dilemma
00:37:52 because I think in this city
00:37:53 and I bet it's the same in Edmonton
00:37:56 this is not a Calgary Edmonton thing
00:37:58 there is enormous reservoir
00:38:00 of goodwill
00:38:02 of people who
00:38:04 want to help other people
00:38:06 the homeless center down there at the end of
00:38:10 4th Avenue was built
00:38:12 on the basis of private
00:38:14 donations mostly
00:38:16 I have to say, from the oil patch.
00:38:19 I remember, you know, back in the Calgary Herald editorial board,
00:38:23 these guys coming in and talking about how they were,
00:38:26 this is what we need to do, and it's going to be like this,
00:38:28 and it's going to be like that,
00:38:29 and we're really going to make a difference,
00:38:30 and there's a thousand homeless people,
00:38:32 and there will be a thousand less by the time we've finished.
00:38:35 Well, good, how do you not support that?
00:38:38 We did, we supported it wholeheartedly, but, you know,
00:38:41 it hasn't worked out that way.
00:38:44 to me you have to you have to spend real money in the mental health area and i think it's been
00:38:50 criminally underfunded forever in canada and that's what these people need the most is some
00:38:56 mental mental health get their mental well-being that addictions treatment and the two are tied
00:39:01 closely together i i mean a person who's addicted often has underlying mental health issues and it
00:39:05 takes the same sort of treatment to try and get them functional or safe again but that's the
00:39:10 elephant in the room. A lot of people just still refuse to discuss when it comes to the homelessness
00:39:15 encampments. They start running out, well, what about the single mom with three kids or the person
00:39:19 who got displaced because his job got laid off? That's not who's in those camps. Quit pretending
00:39:24 it is. They're at the shelters. They're availing the services that are there and they should.
00:39:29 The ones in the camps typically, most of them are addicted. They're often dangerous. It's something
00:39:35 else, you know, people don't like talking about, but there's truth in this. We're seeing with the
00:39:38 weapons in Calgary. It was firearms, not just pellet guns and machetes and samurai swords.
00:39:43 And they're often very addicted. You can't put, how can you put with a single mom and three kids, 0.99
00:39:48 the guy who's gone psychotic on methamphetamines in the same room? You can't do that. It's not
00:39:53 an appropriate place for them. We need to talk about warehousing them somewhere. Nobody wants
00:39:58 to say it, but I don't see any other. You look at a case in Calgary before Christmas,
00:40:04 uh three homeless guys it was in an outskirts neighborhood i think it was country hall so they
00:40:10 obviously took the lrt to get there they broke into one of the the um cabins not cabins uh garden
00:40:17 at the home depot and they they went in there to get out of the cold and uh set a fire and all
00:40:24 three of them ended up burning to death so it's you know it's not just an encampment down here
00:40:29 at this far reaches of this every city that's going to have to deal with it you know if you
00:40:35 think about where when this started you start to see a suggestion of the only answer this started
00:40:44 when our attitude to keeping people in mental institutions changed the deinstitutionalization
00:40:53 everybody was going to go out and look i mean well intentions there was well intentioned everybody
00:40:59 was going to go out into a halfway house become part of the community they'd be supervised they 0.96
00:41:04 would take their meds and you know this this sort of grim victorian institution would be no longer
00:41:11 necessary well unfortunately it didn't work out just as the optimists hoped it has been in fact
00:41:19 worse than the pessimists predicted yes and uh again people aren't ready to face that reality
00:41:26 when i'm talking about warehousing actually i'm kind of talking about just the immediate thing
00:41:29 like we got people who are going to freeze to death we we need to do something it's going to
00:41:33 hit minus 40 they're intense they're impaired we can't stick them in conventional centers
00:41:38 what the heck do we do with them i mean i'm just saying an emergency shelter a true one a heated
00:41:43 spot with concrete floors that we can just get them into to mitigate the immediate damage longer
00:41:48 term yeah we need specialized treatment facilities for mental health long term uh i've written on
00:41:54 on that at length, you know, it's always been a thing with the deinstitutionalization. I mean,
00:41:57 it was quite a trend. Those were first, the middle institutions were all built in the Victorian
00:42:01 times. It was supposed to be merciful for people who were in horrible conditions. Unfortunately,
00:42:06 they turned into warehouses to dump people and forget about them. Thorazine gave them a way to
00:42:10 say, Oh, look at that. We can medicate these people and they're perfectly fine. Yes. Seemed
00:42:16 like this Edmonton camp was basically organized crime. They had a chop shop set up in a tent
00:42:21 for bicycles they would bring in a stolen bike they would put a you know some new idea on it
00:42:28 get it out again sell it and get their drugs out of it so and with all the weapons and and
00:42:33 that's in there the the hardcore hardcore homeless what i'm talking about they rely on crime to pay
00:42:42 for their drugs and the denialism from people and i won't mention which radio show i drive a lot and
00:42:47 I listened to talk radio and there was a host at Edmonton who spoke of that very bicycle chop shop.
00:42:53 And a caller had said, he's chopping up stolen bicycles.
00:42:56 And the host got very upset, cut off the caller and said, that's unfair.
00:43:00 We don't know if those bicycles were stolen.
00:43:02 He could be repurposing abandoned bicycles.
00:43:05 What sort of BS, naivety, sidetracking?
00:43:09 I mean, you see my veins starting to pulse.
00:43:10 I was screaming at my car radio at the time.
00:43:13 How are we going to solve the problem if you're not going to face the reality?
00:43:16 right you know and if you're going to try and divert people away from what reality
00:43:20 dave do you have any like that was an astonishing array of weapons i mean i wouldn't have been a
00:43:25 surprise to see a few that seems fairly normal but when you look at the pictures yeah what were
00:43:31 they preparing for it's incredible armageddon and the same thing happened in calgary too as
00:43:36 cory said earlier they recovered a whole mess of weapons uh you know i'm sure some of it is just
00:43:41 for self-protection because there's a lot of it's a rough world they're in right and they're they're
00:43:46 often the victim of crime themselves perpetrated by other homeless people. So yeah, I mean,
00:43:53 it's not a tent city, it's an armed encampment is what it is.
00:43:58 Well, I'm getting back to, I mean, I went last summer and I took those pictures last fall when
00:44:02 the police dismantled that one off of Deerfoot, for people who don't know Calgary, there was a
00:44:05 big bushed area, multiple times they cleaned out sort of long-term entrenched encampments in there.
00:44:12 And the waste I saw, I mean, we published a bunch of pictures of it.
00:44:15 Hundreds, hundreds of propane tanks, truckload after truckload after truckload of garbage.
00:44:21 And they burned about half an acre because of a fire that got out of control.
00:44:24 And, of course, there were old syringes and pipes and all sorts of things.
00:44:27 There were drug paraphernalia.
00:44:29 This isn't harmless.
00:44:31 That's what people, you know, you can't turn your back and let these people settle in in a spot like that.
00:44:36 They got all of those materials because they'd been spreading out and robbing the industrial area nearby.
00:44:41 businesses trying to function coming in the morning and their gates have been cut and
00:44:46 metals have been stolen like just we don't like the reality i bet your weeks pay i bet you a
00:44:52 week's pay they're back probably probably it's an isolated spot to watch yeah i mean it's and it's
00:44:59 you know it's a tough tough crowd to police too right i mean when you think of regular organized
00:45:04 crime you think of you know some people in suits and hell's angels which you can uh investigate
00:45:09 and perhaps infiltrate and wiretap
00:45:11 and do all that sort of good police work.
00:45:14 But you can't do that with these guys, can't you?
00:45:16 No.
00:45:16 And it's a valid question when people ask.
00:45:18 When you say, dismantle that camp, dismantle that camp.
00:45:20 And people say, well, where are you going to put them?
00:45:22 It's a fair question.
00:45:25 Because, I mean, when press interviews the dentists
00:45:27 at these camp, usually they say, well,
00:45:29 I'm going to go set up my tent down the road a half a mile.
00:45:31 And then they'll kick me out of there
00:45:33 and I'll sit it up over there.
00:45:34 And I don't have an easy answer.
00:45:37 Nobody does.
00:45:37 That's the hard part with this issue.
00:45:38 Exactly.
00:45:39 But they do have to go somewhere because they're going to die.
00:45:43 I guess, you know, I like to, when I talk about this subject, I talk about it a lot.
00:45:47 And people will accuse me, you're heartless and you're cold.
00:45:49 No, I'm never for a second forgetting that those people in those camps are somebody's children,
00:45:53 they're cousins, they're brothers, they're mothers.
00:45:56 I mean, you don't know.
00:45:58 But it frustrates me, too, with those saying it's inhumane not to,
00:46:02 we can't intervene for the sake of their dignity.
00:46:04 That's another one that gets to me.
00:46:06 If it was my daughter down there servicing men to get a fix, 1.00
00:46:09 She has no dignity left, and I'm fine if the state tries to intervene to save her.
00:46:13 If it's my son who's sleeping behind a dumpster who's lost bowel control, there's no dignity left.
00:46:19 And the UCP, Daniel Smith, promised to do this sort of involuntary treatment.
00:46:24 I haven't seen any movement on that yet.
00:46:27 It's a tough one to try and do, but it's the route we have to go.
00:46:30 They're not going to help themselves.
00:46:31 I would think under the Mental Health Act, I mean, it does say if a person's at risk of hurting themselves or others,
00:46:39 the state has the right and the ability
00:46:40 to intervene, to protect them.
00:46:42 Well, I would think that applies to people
00:46:43 that heavily into addiction
00:46:44 when they're sleeping in these cold conditions,
00:46:47 but nobody's got the courage to make that move yet.
00:46:49 You know, how many people would they have to round up
00:46:53 and accommodate and put into-
00:46:55 It's a huge endeavor.
00:46:58 There may be a reason why they just,
00:47:00 well, you know, we'll take the ones who want to be helped.
00:47:03 Yeah.
00:47:04 We'll start with them.
00:47:04 It would take some planning.
00:47:05 You certainly can't do something like that overnight.
00:47:07 Yeah, there's several thousand in Calgary, and I'm assuming it's the same number in Edmonton.
00:47:11 Well, there's nothing we can do for the weather, but hope for the best and hope they've arranged as well as they can.
00:47:17 I mean, we know there are emergency heating shelters in Calgary and in Edmonton,
00:47:20 and they're shuttling people from transit stations to get them to them if they're willing and they can.
00:47:25 So I guess we just hope and pray we don't hear too many reports.
00:47:29 You could offer to take a couple on holiday with you, get them warm down there.
00:47:33 Keep that in mind.
00:47:34 I mean, maybe next year.
00:47:35 I don't know if I've left room
00:47:36 in the back of the truck for that yet,
00:47:38 but well, I guess we'll hope for the best
00:47:41 and to eventually find somebody with the courage.
00:47:43 And I really do have a lot of hope for Premier Smith.
00:47:45 Actually, she seems not to be afraid
00:47:46 of taking on the tough tasks.
00:47:48 Well, at least she is looking in the right direction.
00:47:53 When you go look to British Columbia
00:47:55 and all they're trying to do is make it easier
00:47:58 for people to, now at a younger age,
00:48:01 at least she wants to fight it.
00:48:03 BC is now giving fentanyl to kids without their parents' consent.
00:48:09 That's where BC is going.
00:48:11 I saw that headline.
00:48:11 It just floored me.
00:48:13 Yeah, I looked that one up.
00:48:14 I think it was Adam Zeevo, is it?
00:48:15 Yeah, we're going to be doing a follow-on.
00:48:19 Watch the Western Standard with that story.
00:48:20 It'll be up there and we'll be following up.
00:48:21 Well, we're out of time for this week, guys,
00:48:23 and I'm going to be sneaking off and escaping for a while,
00:48:26 true enough, somewhere warmer.
00:48:28 So have fun.
00:48:29 and
00:48:30 well, we will see you when I get back
00:48:34 and I'm sure there will be lots more to rant and rave on
00:48:36 and discuss. Have a great trip
00:48:37 Have a great trip and come back full of fire
00:48:40 Oh, yeah, you're too calm
00:48:42 I'll be a little more piss and vinegar 0.99
00:48:44 when I get back
00:48:45 This is new laid back Corey Morgan for 2024
00:48:48 Have your rest
00:48:50 and go for it
00:48:51 Should make it clear your show is still going to be on next week
00:48:54 with a special guest host
00:48:55 I hope I don't get outplayed too much
00:48:58 by the backup quarterback.
00:48:59 I might find myself out of a job.
00:49:00 We'll see.
00:49:01 But tune in.
00:49:02 I'm sure it'll be great.
00:49:03 And thank you all for tuning in today, guys.
00:49:05 And we'll see you all when I get back.
00:49:08 Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:49:10 Without the CSSA,
00:49:11 our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:49:14 These guys are on the front lines
00:49:16 helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms,
00:49:20 regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:49:22 And more importantly, educating the public
00:49:24 about how we keep guns out of the hands
00:49:26 of the wrong people.
00:49:27 To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:49:32 You can become a Western Standard member for just $10 a month.