Western Standard - November 11, 2020


The Pipeline, November 11, 2020

Topics
Mentioned
The Rant with Cory Morgan November 9, 2020 The Rant November 16, 2020

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

165.83

Word count

7,469

Sentence count

130

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, Western Standard editor Dave Naylor and publisher Derek Fildebrandt discuss the latest in the U.S. election, including the possibility that Joe Biden will become the next president of the United States, the impact that could have on the Keystone XL pipeline, and Jason Kenney's challenge to public sector unions with a 4% pay cut.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Welcome to the Pipeline, the Western Standard's weekly current affairs broadcast and podcast.
00:02:35 I am Western Standard publisher, Derek Fildebrandt.
00:02:38 Joining me today is Western Standard News editor, Dave Naylor.
00:02:43 Dave, how are you doing?
00:02:44 I'm well, Derek, how are you?
00:02:47 I'm great, thanks.
00:02:48 Today we're going to be covering a few things.
00:02:50 We will be covering ongoing controversy around the U.S. presidential election.
00:02:56 We'll be discussing if Joe Biden has a lock on things, as has been declared, or if there
00:03:02 is what the possibilities are that Donald Trump will be able to turn things around.
00:03:08 We'll also be talking about the fate of the Keystone XL pipeline if, in fact, Joe Biden
00:03:13 does manage to secure the presidency in the end and what that could mean for Alberta and
00:03:20 the rest of Western Canada, and we're going to be discussing Jason Kenney's challenge to
00:03:26 public sector unions with a 4% pay cut, what that means, what the politics will be, and
00:03:31 how that will impact the budget in Canada.
00:03:35 But before I do that, I want to turn to, I just take note that today, November 11th, is
00:03:44 Remembrance Day, a very important day for many people across Canada, not just Westerners,
00:03:52 people in many countries.
00:03:54 Today we had an editorial board publication on the six fallen Canadian soldiers who have
00:04:03 lost their lives in the line of duty in Canada, for Canada in 2020, written by our defense
00:04:11 columnist, Alex McCall, just a very nice tribute to those fallen.
00:04:18 So just to take note, lost in the line of duty this year was Corporal James Choi, I hope I
00:04:26 pronounced that correctly, Captain Jennifer Casey, and the crew of Stalker 22, that is
00:04:34 Abigail McBurrah, Sub-Lieutenant Abigail McBurrah, Sub-Lieutenant Matthew Pike, Master
00:04:42 Corporal Matthew Cousins, Captain Maxime Miron Morin, Captain Kevin Hagen, and Captain Brendan
00:04:50 Ian MacDonald, all of them, six Canadians, Canadian men and women who have fallen in the
00:04:57 line of duty in the Canadian forces in 2020, quite a large number considering we are in
00:05:04 what is more or less peacetime, no major military combat engagements overseas.
00:05:10 It's quite a few, I think, to be lost in a peace year, isn't it, Dave?
00:05:13 It's a sad number and certainly a day of reflection, and hopefully everybody takes a minute of silence
00:05:21 to, you know, give thanks to what these veterans have done and what we're able to live for and
00:05:28 through today.
00:05:30 Absolutely.
00:05:31 Okay, well, thank you all for watching.
00:05:34 Before we get into the meat of today, we want to thank those of you who are Western Standard
00:05:39 members for your contribution, those of you watching but who support the work we do of
00:05:44 having an independent, non-government-funded or licensed media, please go to westerncenteredonline.com
00:05:50 right now and become a Western Standard member for just a few bucks a month.
00:05:53 You can help us continue our work as the ultimate antidote to the CBC.
00:05:59 So let's start with, I'm kind of driven crazy when I see Canadian media focusing so much on
00:06:06 the U.S. election.
00:06:06 The CBC obsessed with Kamala Harris.
00:06:19 Lost you, Derek.
00:06:21 Oh, have you lost me, Dave?
00:06:23 Oh, no, you're back.
00:06:24 Okay.
00:06:26 You know, the obsession of the Canadian media, particularly the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation,
00:06:30 it's funded to the tune of around $1.3 billion a year because liberals are afraid that there
00:06:38 won't be any coverage of Canadian news without it, yet it spends half of its time covering
00:06:43 American news that is covered on, obviously, the American networks and still quite heavily
00:06:47 on the private or semi-private Canadian networks.
00:06:51 But nonetheless, it's interesting.
00:06:52 We're going to cover it here.
00:06:53 So, Dave, we'll go to you for kind of a rundown.
00:06:59 There's been a lot of controversy in many quarters, at least, and with many of our readers
00:07:04 and viewers, Western Standard, about the media calling the election for Joe Biden.
00:07:09 He is leading in the Electoral College right now.
00:07:12 That is not certified.
00:07:14 It hasn't gone through the courts and it hasn't yet been challenged in many respects.
00:07:18 Let's go to you, Dave, about where things stand, why the media have broadly called things for
00:07:26 Joe Biden and how appropriate that is with everything else that's going on.
00:07:33 Well, you'll have to remember, Derek, that most of the mainstream media in the United States
00:07:38 absolutely hates Trump.
00:07:40 So, any sort of glimmer at the end of the tunnel, they are going to grab.
00:07:44 Now, it certainly looks like Biden will emerge eventually the winner, but he's not now the
00:07:51 winner, but eventually.
00:07:53 He's got enough Electoral College votes that should give him the presidency.
00:07:58 But President Trump is claiming widespread voter fraud and he's not conceding.
00:08:06 There's court challenges going on all over the United States.
00:08:09 An army of Trump lawyers is going and trying to get some election results overturned.
00:08:16 They haven't had any success yet.
00:08:19 Whether they will have success remains to be seen.
00:08:22 And whether or not it ends up in the Supreme Court also remains to be seen.
00:08:28 Certainly, Trump is not conceding.
00:08:31 He went to Arlington National Cemetery today for Veterans Day ceremonies there.
00:08:37 And while world leaders from Justin Trudeau to Boris Johnson to Angela Merkel have all contacted
00:08:47 Biden to congratulate him and say how much they're looking forward to working with him,
00:08:53 such a call has not come from Trump.
00:08:56 He has not conceded, nor does it look like he's going to concede.
00:09:01 As Biden says, though, he's taken a hit in terms of what this will do to his legacy.
00:09:09 If he's eventually removed kicking and screaming from the Oval Office, you know, how is that
00:09:15 going to look in the history books?
00:09:17 But yeah, looking good for Biden, but you cannot declare him the ultimate victor quite yet.
00:09:25 Yeah, I mean, a lot of people are saying the media shouldn't be calling this until it's done.
00:09:33 The fact is the people don't like it when they call it when your side loses and they do like
00:09:36 it when your side wins.
00:09:39 We do, you know, if there was no calling of things, there'd be no point to even watching
00:09:44 election results.
00:09:45 We would just wait for election officials to certify things at the end.
00:09:48 So I don't think there's anything wrong with the media making a judgment call.
00:09:52 I think where the mainstream media goes wrong is in saying that this is a done deal.
00:09:58 I'm not sure I would call him president elect yet.
00:10:02 I'm not sure that's language I would use.
00:10:04 I would say he is the leading candidate for president right now, based on the numbers that
00:10:10 are there, based on the status quo, pre-court challenges and any changes that could take
00:10:18 place around mail-in ballots and potential fraud, he is on track right now to become president.
00:10:25 So I think it'd be fine to call him the presumptive president.
00:10:31 That might be a more appropriate term than president elect until these court challenges
00:10:34 are done.
00:10:35 Remember that Al Gore was the president elect or presumptive president for 32 days plus
00:10:42 before he lost in court and Florida flipped to George W. Bush. 0.51
00:10:50 So this is going to go on for some time.
00:10:53 A lot of people are saying there's mass fraud.
00:10:56 I don't think many people actually can say that matter of factly yet.
00:11:00 I think there is beyond a doubt a lot of big red flags in some key swing states in Pennsylvania,
00:11:08 in Wisconsin, in Michigan, to an extent in Georgia.
00:11:13 There are some major red flags around mail-in votes and the vote dumps.
00:11:18 It's too, I think, presumptuous right now to say that is voter fraud.
00:11:22 There could be perfectly good explanations for that.
00:11:26 But that's going to have to be proven in court, as it should be, for people to have any kind
00:11:31 of confidence in the final result when it comes.
00:11:36 But that's going to require quite a few court battles to be successful.
00:11:42 That's going to require at least Pennsylvania.
00:11:44 It's going to require Georgia.
00:11:46 And I think Trump has held North Carolina, if I'm not mistaken.
00:11:53 But it's going to require overturning enough votes in Georgia and Pennsylvania,
00:11:57 and either one of Nevada, Arizona, Michigan, or Wisconsin.
00:12:04 One of those four would have to flip to give Trump his 270 electoral college votes.
00:12:10 So if he does that, then he remains president.
00:12:13 But that is a steep hill to climb.
00:12:17 The initial results in elections don't often change very much in recounts.
00:12:23 But this is an extraordinary case.
00:12:24 You have massive records for mail-in ballots.
00:12:29 And in some states, they took the bizarre step of sending everyone a mail-in vote
00:12:34 and allowing them to vote in person.
00:12:36 You're just supposed to honor the system and not vote in person if you voted in the mail.
00:12:40 That seems quite bizarre to me.
00:12:41 In Canada, we've got our own problems.
00:12:44 But we seem to have, in provincial elections we've had recently,
00:12:48 there's been no mass mailing of everybody a mail-in vote.
00:12:51 Plus in person election day, it's been you had to request a mail-in vote.
00:12:57 That seems to be a lot less susceptible to voter fraud.
00:12:59 So it is entirely plausible that things are going to turn around and that some of these key swing states will flip over.
00:13:09 But it is a tough hill to climb.
00:13:12 And I can't say, I wouldn't put my money on Trump.
00:13:16 I think he is certainly less than 50% likely to do it.
00:13:21 But I think it's important that these certainly big red flags are resolved in court.
00:13:30 Otherwise, there's no hope whatsoever of the United States American people rallying around Joe Biden.
00:13:36 No, I think the Biden camp would call that kind of thinking, Derek, a bit delusional.
00:13:45 You know, you talked about the number of different states that have to be overturned and whatnot.
00:13:50 But we're not talking about Biden winning these states by a couple thousand votes.
00:13:55 He's got huge leads in these states.
00:13:58 And, you know, are they going to find 40,000, 50,000 ballots that were not counted or illegally counted?
00:14:07 You know, you're right about most ballots are counted pretty closely.
00:14:12 Then you may get a couple of votes one way or the other being changed in a recount.
00:14:17 But certainly not the massive swing that the Trump campaign is hoping for.
00:14:23 So, you know what?
00:14:25 The B.C. election results that was held at the end of October weren't finally announced until this week.
00:14:32 So it does take a while.
00:14:34 And the Biden people are going to have to be patient a little bit longer.
00:14:39 And we'll see where the court system goes. 0.67
00:14:43 Yeah, indeed.
00:14:45 It's a bit rich right now for Democrats to be demanding that Trump concede now.
00:14:52 I think it is certainly not a legal requirement, but it is a, I think, important political convention that the man or woman who loses the election does concede.
00:15:07 Remember that Hillary Clinton did not concede on election night 2016.
00:15:11 She gave a very grudging kind of hissy fit of a concession the next day.
00:15:18 But then it was absolutely clear, no recounts, no court challenges, had any possible math of reversing her defeat to Trump in 2016.
00:15:27 Certainly there's nothing stopping Trump from picking up the phone, calling Biden, saying, hey, good race.
00:15:36 It was close.
00:15:37 You know, good job on what you've done, but I am not going to concede until we get the final polls in.
00:15:44 But to completely ignore Biden, to not even pick up the phone and ludicrous stuff like Secretary of State Pompeo saying that the transition shall run smoothly into the second Trump administration.
00:15:59 And the sort of night of the Pentagon and Trump firing all the top officials, and it seems like he is taking his revenge while he's got time.
00:16:09 yeah uh it he i don't think trump has any um i don't think there's any has any obligation to
00:16:17 concede yet but once these court battles are finished if in the end uh he does not uh manage
00:16:24 to get uh you know if there is no voter fraud found if there is no significant errors or glitches as
00:16:30 they're calling them found and he does in fact lose uh i think while it's not a legal requirement
00:16:35 it is a moral requirement of donald trump to concede at that time he has no he has no obligation
00:16:40 to do so before then i think opening the lines of communication between trump and biden would be
00:16:45 positive getting both men to agree that uh once the courts have settled things uh whoever does not
00:16:51 emerge victorious should um should be clear about trying to get the country to rally behind the
00:16:57 president whoever that might be i don't think that's going to happen regardless but i think
00:17:01 that's what would be best for the uh american people in the united states um but trump uh
00:17:07 it'll be it will he concede if in fact he loses in court uh it is not a given that he's going to win
00:17:13 it's not a given that he's going to lose but if in fact he loses in the end will he concede and will
00:17:19 he leave the white house of his own accord um trying to predict what trump does is a mugs game derrick
00:17:26 yeah yeah we should all know by now there's not even trying yeah we shouldn't even be trying at
00:17:32 this point but we're going to do it anyway uh because it's fun but um you know uh this will be
00:17:38 the big determiner about uh if in fact he loses um you know if he if he still refuses to leave the
00:17:45 white house and has to be removed forcefully uh then his worst critics will have been proven correct
00:17:51 but if after losing in court if in fact he loses um he says fine okay uh we've done our due diligence
00:17:59 and we've done our best we might not agree with the courts but uh they've spoken and that's the rule
00:18:03 of law and he goes uh then i think a lot of these um trump's critics that said this man is an aspiring
00:18:09 dictator uh they'll have been proven wrong it won't be much credit uh comfort to trump uh if he if he
00:18:15 loses and leaves the white house but uh it is very difficult to foresee this man um well it's very
00:18:22 difficult to predict what he's going to do but i i'm not in the camp to believe he's an aspiring
00:18:27 dictator uh that he won't leave the white house under any circumstance uh to not leave the to lose an
00:18:33 election uh at least according to the courts and to refuse to leave the white house would trigger a
00:18:38 civil war and that's just not in the cards it's not going to happen um but i can tell you this
00:18:43 if uh if the if trump wins in court and and he stays uh it'll be interesting to see all the
00:18:49 democrats if they will continue their language about the need to rally around the new president
00:18:53 and come together uh and i have a strong suspicion that uh the peace that has reigned since the
00:19:00 election will be ended uh and we'll see riots in the streets uh very very quickly to an unprecedented
00:19:06 level in american history i don't think there'll be any parallel to the violence we would see
00:19:09 if uh if trump uh emerges victorious in the end i think the united states is on the precipice derek
00:19:16 and uh hopefully they can figure it out indeed well uh let's bring it a little closer to home but
00:19:22 still related to this uh if uh joe biden does manage to emerge uh victorious in the electoral college after
00:19:31 the uh court challenges have been completed uh if he does um there is now a very big question mark
00:19:39 over the future of the keystone xl pipeline uh while he was vice president to president obama obama
00:19:45 uh stretched out uh delayed the approval process for keystone before eventually using an executive order
00:19:51 uh to kill it himself uh trump reversed that and uh and issued an executive order to approve the
00:19:59 construction of keystone xl uh and construction is now underway with a very healthy dose of alberta
00:20:05 taxpayer dollars i was pretty suspicious uh about uh of course we want to see keystone xl built here at
00:20:13 the western standard but uh you know i'm a bit more suspicious about using government money for a
00:20:19 private project that's corporate welfare it normally ends badly if um you know the government's uh jason
00:20:25 kenney's reasoning for using taxpayers money into this was that the private sector wasn't doing that
00:20:30 but a normal conservative would say if the private sector isn't doing something
00:20:34 it's normally for good reason that the private sector sees risk in something and that it's not
00:20:38 economically viable or the risk is too high uh and now it looks like there's a significant
00:20:43 possibility that joe biden will follow through on his promise to cancel uh the construction permit for
00:20:48 keystone and uh that could leave a lot of egg on the face of alberta taxpayers um and obviously the
00:20:55 future of the oil and gas industry here dave um what has uh where does that commitment from joe
00:21:02 biden to cancel keystone xl stand right now with both himself and the democratic party uh do we
00:21:09 expect him to follow through on it if he in fact uh does become the next president united states
00:21:14 well biden was vice president and in the oval office when barack obama signed the order killing
00:21:21 the pipeline uh he made the promise to uh biden made the promise again to kill it during the
00:21:27 the campaign uh of course he also said he wasn't going to ban fran at fracking which he has said
00:21:32 many times he wants to do uh along with uh vice president elect uh kamala harris uh so yeah i you
00:21:41 know if he remembers he made the promise uh he'll he'll follow through and cancel it i think the only hope
00:21:48 is for the the lobbying of justin trudeau on a person-to-person basis with biden uh jason kenny
00:21:57 has said albert is gonna lobby as much as they can and they have a trade envoy in washington but let's
00:22:03 be honest uh joe biden doesn't know kenny from a hole in the ground it's got to come from the prime
00:22:08 minister's office so i guess the question is privately how badly the prime minister wants this
00:22:15 how badly you know trudeau hasn't done much in terms of pipelines so but he says this government
00:22:21 uh or his government it's one of their top priorities is to build the pipeline so i think
00:22:27 the only way that it's going to get done is if trudeau can whisper in biden's ear and say look
00:22:32 these are the jobs that is going to create in the states this is how it's going to give you uh
00:22:38 petroleum uh sustainability uh this is how it's going to help with the environment
00:22:45 and if if trudeau can put forward good arguments in all those sectors then maybe it's got a chance
00:22:51 but uh uh if you're a betting man i don't think the odds are for it at the moment yeah yeah um i i
00:22:59 think there's some um hand wringing in the premier's office right now uh this would be the single largest
00:23:05 corporate welfare boondoggle in alberta history it would uh it would completely blow out of the water
00:23:11 um things like novitel and those big scandals that plagued the getty government when the government
00:23:16 was involved in uh direct funding of private uh investment ventures then and led to ralph klein
00:23:23 cancelling and selling them all off getting the government out of the business of business uh
00:23:28 the in the government uh funding that has gone in from alberta taxpayers into the keystone excel is
00:23:34 quite substantial and would be larger than any of those uh and it would be an absolute political
00:23:39 disaster uh that would compound just how bad it is to have the pipeline itself cancelled it would then
00:23:44 have the blowback of all the taxpayers money that's been sunk into this as well it would be an absolute
00:23:49 uh economic fiscal and political disaster in alberta uh and it is quite concerning as you said that
00:23:54 this might all be now in the hands of justin trudeau justin trudeau has been willing to approve
00:23:59 the keystone excel pipeline because it doesn't cross any other provincial boundaries it goes straight
00:24:04 from alberta into the united states um so he doesn't have to worry about upsetting british colombian
00:24:09 or quebec or ontario voters in that case he has to only deal with albertans because it's it's not
00:24:15 crossing any of our boundaries so so he has agreed to that one um and he does support it publicly and
00:24:20 on paper uh the bigger question will be how deeply do we believe that he supports it in his heart is he
00:24:27 really willing to go to bat for this if justin trudeau genuinely believes that i think he actually can save
00:24:33 it um you know he is uh among progressive liberal left liberals around the world justin trudeau is
00:24:40 still a celebrity icon they love the guy liberals united states love justin trudeau um he is what
00:24:47 they want their people to be and uh and he's very popular with the left of the democratic party
00:24:53 um so upsetting justin trudeau would be a big no for for uh for joe biden if justin trudeau says look
00:25:01 if you do this we are going to hit back there will be uh there will be diplomatic repercussions
00:25:06 there will be economic repercussions if you do this uh justin trudeau i think does have the ability
00:25:10 to save this um now i know a lot of people in the mainstream press have been saying that this is an
00:25:16 opportunity for kenny and uh justin trudeau to hold hands in kumbaya jason kenny should give up their
00:25:21 opposition to the portion of the federal carbon tax that they haven't already implemented in alberta
00:25:26 uh but alberta's already got a carbon tax on the oil and gas industry uh so alberta's already given
00:25:31 in to ottawa on that front canada has a carbon tax um and they're the alberta government's not
00:25:37 actually challenging the federal government's ability to impose a carbon tax on the industrial
00:25:42 side where alberta still kept the ndp's carbon tax they just renamed it uh a fancy less threatening
00:25:47 name than carbon tax so uh yeah but joe biden already the democrats are uh rife with recriminations
00:25:56 about how this election has gone joe biden is currently leading to become president of the
00:26:01 united states but the democrats have shockingly and unexpectedly lost seats in the house of
00:26:05 representatives and they have failed to pick up seats in the senate to give them control there
00:26:11 uh so this is an extraordinary election where at least for now they have won the presidency
00:26:17 but they have lost everything else uh and uh democrats are fighting themselves right now
00:26:23 uh moderate democrats ones that remain are accusing the uh the aocs and bernie sanders of the party
00:26:32 on the on its left flank for putting forward this uh you know green new deal and defund the police
00:26:38 agenda scaring away moderate voters which has cost them seats when the democrats expected to
00:26:44 significantly increase their majority in the house of representatives now they have the smallest
00:26:48 majority in 20 or 22 years of any party and uh and they failed to pick up the senate looks
00:26:53 like republicans are very likely to retain control there uh and so the democrats are kind of falling
00:26:58 into a big fight right now the question is is joe biden going to side uh with the radical wing
00:27:04 which he does not represent he is the establishment uh career politician moderate if you will wing of
00:27:10 the democratic party is he going to side with the the left of the party to keep them under control
00:27:16 and working with him in congress because he needs the house of representatives or is he going to
00:27:20 go to the moderates and try and broker deals with republicans and i think keystone excel will be one
00:27:24 of the big telltales of that if he's going to pick uh working with moderate republicans and democrats to
00:27:30 try and get something done or is he going to uh work with the left of the democratic party uh to try and
00:27:37 keep his party together and i think one uh one angle that we haven't talked about derek is is unions uh the
00:27:44 democratic party has always been the party of unions uh traditionally and how many union jobs will be
00:27:51 lost you know from uh from montana to nebraska to build this thing if biden cancels it so the unions
00:27:59 i think are going to have a powerful say uh as to whether or not he does or not very true although
00:28:06 most of the workers who are going to be building the keystone excel pipeline on the american side are in
00:28:10 red states the democrats are not likely to win anyway we're talking about montana and dakota's
00:28:15 utah and idaho that area that is solidly red and had no chance of going blue no matter what you said
00:28:22 dave montana never goes blue um those are in red states so even if they're uh union voters uh they
00:28:30 uh they're in states where their numbers don't really matter to the democrats so uh i'm not sure if
00:28:35 that how much that'll do but uh i guess this gives us a great time to transition to another
00:28:40 discussion about unions even closer to home here uh jason kenny has uh laid down the gauntlet
00:28:48 uh to public sector unions um dave why don't you uh fill us in on uh what has happened there what is
00:28:56 some of the background leading up to this and uh what is it jason kenny has asked of the unions and
00:29:01 what has the government union's uh response been so far uh kenny is asking government workers to take a
00:29:07 four percent rollback this comes after the uh he took a rollback on uh uh or ucp staff took a rollback
00:29:15 of seven percent so he's asked the unions to do their bit try and help to cut the the the debt and
00:29:21 the deficit by taking a four percent rollback uh you know hundreds of thousands of albertans have lost
00:29:27 their job and and are currently struggling to make ends meet so kenny's asking the uh the unions uh to do
00:29:34 their part the union's uh reaction has been obviously to fall off their chairs laughing uh and uh basically
00:29:41 saying no chance they're starting uh lobbying campaigns petitions uh they want albertans to join
00:29:50 them in the fight against kenny uh interestingly derek a government uh arbitrator gave uh aupe workers
00:30:00 in various colleges uh across the province a one percent raise so i think that's what you know if
00:30:07 the unions are lucky that's what they may end up getting uh which won't please uh kenny's people at
00:30:14 all yeah yeah um you know i've said for some time that uh i i believe that kenny has been wasting his
00:30:22 mandate and uh not being tough enough with the government sector unions uh there is no chance of
00:30:28 balancing the budget even before covet even before the uh russian saudi oil war uh there was no chance
00:30:34 of seriously balancing the budget without major cuts to no kenny said he wasn't going to do this
00:30:42 during the election uh i thought it was a mistake now he says he is going to do it um so it is kind
00:30:48 of breaking an election committed but i think it's a good commitment to break uh if we're going to take
00:30:52 us a given that these guys are going to break their commitments we hope they break them in the wrong
00:30:55 direction rather than we broke break them in the right direction rather than the wrong direction
00:30:59 so i i think this is a win and i think it's bold uh four percent pay cut is not going to do it but it
00:31:04 is a significant step in the right direction um the ucp has already cut mla pay uh for the premier and for
00:31:12 all mlas uh by five percent uh the premier i think took a bit more than that um so they had lead by example
00:31:19 and i thought it was a bad move at the time because they weren't doing it at the exact same time as
00:31:23 asking the rest of the public service rest of the government employees to do it if you're going to
00:31:28 cut mla pay you're going to cut the premier's pay the main point it's not actually going to save much
00:31:33 money it's at the end of the day it's actually it's kind of a it's a very it's a drop of a drop in
00:31:38 a bucket uh in the larger uh sense of uh what government spends every year but uh the point to do
00:31:44 it is to give the politicians the moral authority to get the the pay of the rest of the public service
00:31:50 the bureaucracy and all the other uh employees under control and they should have done it at
00:31:54 the same time it would have given them that moral um that moral gas in the tank to to take them on
00:32:01 and say look we're doing it we're taking a hit uh we all have to do this we're all in it together
00:32:06 they can still say that but politically they should have really done it at the same time
00:32:10 they would have uh i think had much uh greater success with the public i think the public is still
00:32:16 probably on side with them uh the public sector has had massive pay increases uh beginning at the
00:32:22 end of the client era really ramping up over stalemath but continuing through redford and prentice
00:32:30 notly limited their pay increases to relatively modest amounts but because it was so high already
00:32:36 uh it really didn't amount to much in terms of the overall books and can't alberta's government
00:32:42 employees are in most cases wildly overpaid compared to the private sector and even government
00:32:47 employees in other parts of the province these people enjoy uh virtual guaranteed jobs uh if
00:32:52 you're a teacher to lose your job you've got to be caught doing something pretty terrible um
00:32:58 same goes in many other areas of of government employees you just don't lose your jobs when
00:33:02 you're in a government union um they've got pensions they've got benefits and they've had
00:33:09 perfect job security when uh the private sector in alberta has been getting the crap kicked out of it
00:33:15 so it's time for the public sector to do its uh to do its part and i think uh you know uh we have to
00:33:21 give credit where credit's due uh they're actually uh you know to jason kenney and finance minister tapes
00:33:26 they're actually showing some uh some backbone here we wanted to have cory morgan on today but we had uh
00:33:31 technical difficulties getting him to uh getting an internet connection from wherever it is he lives out in the
00:33:36 middle of nowhere and um but corey wrote a piece on this about this is the do or die time for jason
00:33:42 kenney uh reference that got actually picked up in the global mail and some other mainstream outlets
00:33:47 um and uh it looks like uh they're serious now the question is is four percent what the government's
00:33:54 really demanding of the public sector unions or is this kind of just the opening position and they're
00:33:58 hoping to whittle them down to one percent cut or freeze or a modest increase dave in your
00:34:06 in your view do you think this is what they're demanding or do you think this is just an opening
00:34:10 move well as in all negotiations derek i'm sure it's just an opening move they would love to get four
00:34:17 percent and i'm sure they'd settle for anything but a raise but i think the people of alberta you know
00:34:25 they're fed up they're fed up with the economy they're fed up with coronavirus they're just no they're
00:34:31 they're fed up with getting kicked in the groin the last uh the last couple years so i'm not sure
00:34:36 the people of alberta want more union shenanigans i don't think the union will get public support and
00:34:44 i think that's what the uh the kenny government is counting on and i think uh uh corey hit the nail on
00:34:49 the head and on his piece when he says you know this is the the key time in uh kenny's pres or
00:34:55 premiership so you know we'll see whether or not uh that they stick to it indeed uh yeah we'll see
00:35:03 if they do this uh we had uh corey actually uh as i said corey wanted to be on we wanted corey on the
00:35:10 broadcast today but his connection wasn't good enough but it seems he can at least comment uh
00:35:14 corey morgan joining us via the comment section today uh the unions will go crazy on the ucp no matter
00:35:19 what they do little to lose and taking them on now they were never going to support uh never going
00:35:24 to cooperate start cuts uh i think corey's dead right uh the aupe the afl these are partisan uh
00:35:31 organizations directly connected or uh strongly connected in many ways uh to the ndp uh the tories
00:35:38 could give them a five percent pay increase uh when everybody else is losing their jobs and these guys
00:35:43 will still not be happy they will fight them no matter what um but beyond just the politics of it
00:35:49 uh they need to do something about this there is just as without a giant oil boom coming which uh
00:35:55 we can't we can't continue to hope is going to come uh which they did in the last budget they need
00:36:00 to get serious about this and i think um uh you know we know covet is temporary we hope it's not
00:36:06 going to be too long the vaccine is now likely on the way um but uh oil prices uh i i think the the
00:36:14 drop in oil prices really shocked the tories uh out of their complacency and around hoping that boom
00:36:19 times are going to return on this the fact is i mean we we can do certain things to attract investment
00:36:25 but at the end of the day without pipelines on the one side and uh uh peak in oil prices on the other
00:36:31 which is out of government's control uh there's just not much that we can do and we're going to have
00:36:36 to get our own finances under control before this um before we really hit a debt wall and we are
00:36:43 hitting a debt wall our deficit is the largest per capita in canada by a massive margin uh on
00:36:48 a per capita basis we're running deficits bigger than justin trudeau so it's kind of rich for
00:36:52 conservatives to be lecturing justin trudeau when we run even bigger when conservatives run even
00:36:56 bigger deficits on a per capita basis and what is supposed to be the heartland of conservatism in
00:37:00 canada so um i i think that drop in oil prices spurred by um uh spurred by the uh russian saudi oil war
00:37:13 has potentially really shaken them out of their complacency and that's a good thing well any union
00:37:19 that is refusing to work with the ucp as you as you touched on derek the the ucp hasn't really cut
00:37:25 anything since they came to power uh obviously the covert pandemic has had a lot to do with that and
00:37:31 the emergency spending that they've had but these unions better be careful what they what they wish
00:37:36 for and all they have to do is look back to the day days of uh of ralph klein now that was chopping
00:37:42 and uh the alberta go out the alberta people supported ralph klein's cuts by a massive margin there
00:37:49 were still you know the same people ndp supporters who who complained and didn't like it but for the
00:37:55 most part albertans said those cuts are needed and you remember at the end of the day uh uh klein
00:38:02 holding up that big check uh you know debt paid in full and that was because of the cuts he made so
00:38:09 we'll see absolutely uh okay well before we wrap it up we'll just go through some of the comments
00:38:16 uh not a ton today but uh we'll try to answer your questions uh steve uh mugridge says hey guys a
00:38:22 little off topic here but where are we with respect to western independence my view is there's too much
00:38:27 division on the conservative side to pull together and get it done uh and he is from brooks alberta
00:38:33 good people in brooks i'll tell you um well it's not a topic we're covering today but uh you know it's
00:38:39 always uh important to check back on that issue uh as it continues a low boil um uh the conservatives
00:38:47 are divided over this uh polling that we did uh in the early summer i think uh right before uh may
00:38:56 had um support for independence uh between 45 and 48 depending on how we asked that question
00:39:04 um and the way that broke down within parties was interesting uh obviously within the wild
00:39:09 rose independence party voters uh which were i think uh around 10 of the vote in that poll
00:39:15 uh they were uh about 90 in favor of independence that's not surprising that's in the name of the
00:39:22 party uh ndp supporters were uh very strongly federalist uh they were 90 against independence
00:39:29 but uh ucp voters uh was very interesting so they had already lost a lot of votes in current polls to
00:39:35 uh to uh to independence parties like wild rose independence uh and of the remaining voters 52
00:39:41 still supported independence 48 opposed it um that is a very dangerous place for a party to be on any
00:39:48 issue and they are uh dead set on not discussing it to allow those divisions to come into the open
00:39:55 uh their position is that well we are federalists we don't contemplate independence under any circumstance
00:40:01 but unlike the ndp we have respect for people who want independence and want to leave and we'll at
00:40:06 least hear them out uh even if we're not going to do anything about it that's the position they've
00:40:10 tried to take uh and they went to extreme measures uh to keep uh that debate under wraps by uh for the
00:40:16 first time that i'm aware of in alberta history ending private members business uh so that the
00:40:21 legislature couldn't debate uh a motion discussing independence and uh as we had him on last week uh rogue mla
00:40:28 uh drew barnes broke with the ucp to say no uh private members that is non-cabinet members in the
00:40:35 legislature and the opposition have the right to bring forward these private members motions and
00:40:39 private members bills and i want to discuss it uh because i support under certain certain
00:40:45 circumstances independence and uh and i think we should have that debate and the ucp went to
00:40:49 extraordinary lengths to not even have that debate so yeah i think you're right steve conservatives are
00:40:54 very divided on it um but as it is right now uh that party has no interest whatsoever in even
00:41:01 discussing the topic uh their position is that we're federalist we're going to remain federalist under
00:41:06 any circumstance but that we're um we're at least going to be respectful of those who disagree
00:41:12 uh dave what's your what's your take on where things are at i think you're right derek i think it's
00:41:17 on the the pot is on simmer at the moment i think there's a lot of work going on behind the scenes
00:41:23 uh you take the maverick party for example i'm sure jay hill is putting the miles on by
00:41:30 by trying to set up constituencies and get the they were looking at a 39 candidates they want
00:41:37 to get ready to go uh when the next election is called uh hopefully they're going to uh jay says
00:41:44 they hopefully they want to expand on that the longer trudeau uh holds off i think provincially yeah
00:41:50 i think they're just trying to stay below the radar i think what they need is another huge issue
00:41:56 uh that they'll come up and and uh and express their opposition maybe it is a cancellation of the uh
00:42:03 the keystone pipeline and uh whatnot so yeah they're just uh everybody's laying low and uh you know
00:42:09 checking out the territory at the moment uh we'll go to ron hi raf uh regular uh viewer there can't be any
00:42:16 negotiations negotiations with unions four percent rollback is a must my government did five percent
00:42:23 in 94. i think he's referring to ralph klein and you can't balance the budget without doing for a four
00:42:28 percent rollback um so i think taking a very similar position that uh well that we have said here and uh
00:42:35 cory morgan has said uh there just is no balancing the budget without a rollback of uh the government
00:42:40 unions pay um the big thing though is i think the tories have squandered a political opportunity
00:42:46 to cut mla pay and deal with uh this uh government union sector uh rollback at the same time that's
00:42:56 probably because they had no intention of doing it when they cut mla pay that was uh that was an
00:42:59 election promise that people liked to get mla pay brought uh to a more reasonable level and uh and so
00:43:06 they did that as as a standalone uh they knew it would give them some moral authority later on but
00:43:10 i don't think they had any intention of of a rollback at that time i think it was the collapse
00:43:14 in oil prices and the uh continued refusal of the alberta economy to do what they want and uh and turn
00:43:20 around um so but by not doing it right up front although they couldn't have done it up front because
00:43:26 it wasn't in their election platform uh but by not doing it up front at the same time as the mla pay cut
00:43:32 i think they have uh seriously damaged their ability to actually get it done uh so we're
00:43:37 going to see if is this just an opening position for them to try and get some concessions from the
00:43:41 unions who are being wildly unreasonable right now promising or threatening things like uh general
00:43:46 strike uh or is this something that they're intent on getting okay well uh thank you all very much for
00:43:54 watching um remember if you are a western standard member we thank you very much for your support
00:44:00 uh if you're not yet a western standard member please go to westernstandardonline.com right now
00:44:05 become a member support what we're doing if you want there to continue to be an independent free press
00:44:09 in the west that doesn't accept a dollar of government funding or comply with government
00:44:13 media licensing um we we would greatly appreciate your support um again uh you know we uh ask that
00:44:22 even though people aren't going in large numbers to remembrance day ceremonies today
00:44:26 uh take uh just take a few moments to uh remember uh our fallen in particular this year uh the six men
00:44:34 and women who uh gave their lives in the line of duty in the canadian armed forces uh in 2020 and uh
00:44:40 and lost their lives please take a few moments to remember them if uh if you if you can uh thank
00:44:46 you very much for joining us uh dave always a pleasure try to stay warm and uh thank you all very much for
00:44:52 thank you all very much for your time god bless