Western Standard - November 25, 2020


The Pipeline November 25, 2020

Topics
Mentioned
Franco Terrazzano of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation on a possible Alberta sales tax Franco Terrazzano of the Canadian Taxpayer's Federation on our fiscal condition.

Episode Stats


Length

57 minutes

Words per minute

147.08

Word count

8,469

Sentence count

572

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Calgary schools have been shut down for the rest of the month of December as a result of the Spanish flu outbreak. The government is trying to crack down on the spread of the virus, but there are a lot of new rules and regulations in place that will affect businesses and restaurants.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:29 Thank you.
00:02:59 Thank you.
00:03:29 Thank you.
00:03:59 Thank you.
00:04:01 Thank you.
00:04:31 Thank you.
00:04:33 Thank you.
00:04:35 Thank you.
00:04:37 Thank you.
00:04:38 Thank you.
00:04:40 Thank you.
00:04:42 Thank you.
00:04:44 Thank you.
00:04:46 Thank you.
00:04:48 Thank you.
00:04:50 Thank you.
00:04:52 Thank you.
00:04:54 Thank you.
00:04:56 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:02 30th. Kids in the younger classes will still be allowed to attend school in person. The
00:05:09 Premier says, you know, the younger kids are being good. It's just the teenagers who think
00:05:14 they're immortal who are going around spreading the virus. And as mentioned, the winter break
00:05:20 is being extended for a week and classes won't resume until January 11th. Restaurants and bars,
00:05:28 they can stay open, but a whole bunch of new rules and regulations that will affect their
00:05:34 operations. Only six people are allowed from the same family to sit at a table. You're not allowed
00:05:40 to sit with other families. So a couple of couples cannot go out on a double date. Myself, I'm single,
00:05:49 so I'm not going to go sit by myself, but apparently I'm allowed to have two named cohorts that I'm
00:05:57 allowed to go to pubs with. Who collects these names? Who do I give them to? How do I make that
00:06:04 selection? Nobody knows. Amateur sports banned. Nine outbreaks recently linked to recreation hockey
00:06:12 games in the province. Churches allowed to stay open, but only one third capacity. Kenny said some
00:06:20 churches have been flagrantly violating the rules. Businesses, some have to shut. Some are only
00:06:27 allowed to operate on a per appointment basis. Banquet halls, conference rooms, they're closed.
00:06:33 Personal services are closed. Retail stores can only operate at 25% capacity. So that's going to put
00:06:41 a large dent in their Christmas shopping budgets and estimates. Kenny did say one interesting thing.
00:06:48 He said during the first lockdown, the UCP, quote, made a grave mistake in allowing places like Walmart
00:06:56 to stay open because they sell groceries, but they shut down thousands of other businesses. And Kenny
00:07:03 actually apologized for that yesterday. You can go get your hair cut, but you have to have an appointment.
00:07:09 All workers are being asked to work from home and they're going to increase enforcement. You can get
00:07:16 up to a $1,000 fine if you have somebody over to your house and they're going to try and enable peace
00:07:23 officers to legally be able to hand out tickets. I guess the good thing is, Kenny says there's no plan
00:07:30 to set up a snitch line for Albertans to call their neighbors or to call police on their neighbors who
00:07:35 may have a Christmas gathering. But as I said, Derek, this is sure ruined plans for the Western
00:07:42 Standard annual Christmas party.
00:07:43 Shame that Dave, you and I won't have to blow a bunch of our huge bank account on a lavish Christmas
00:07:53 party this year. Thank you for the update. Reaction to this is being very mixed. We'll discuss reaction,
00:08:02 I think, pretty soon. But some of this is quite bizarre. Some of it was encouraging. I think it
00:08:08 was encouraging that the Premier apologized for the earlier move to shut down most small businesses
00:08:14 and retailers while the big box stores, the Costcos, the Walmarts could remain open. I thought that was,
00:08:23 I'm not sure I can ever recall Jason Kenny apologizing for anything, actually.
00:08:26 Absolutely. That was actually a refreshing move, I think, on the Premier's part. It showed a bit of
00:08:33 maturity. I think they received, you know, small business owners are really one of the bedrock
00:08:37 constituencies of the UCP's base in Alberta. I think they received a ton of blowback from a lot of their
00:08:44 core supporters on that. So in addition to it being probably a bad policy move, I think it was also a bad
00:08:50 political move on their part. And they recognized it and made sure not to shut down those small
00:08:56 businesses right now. So I think that was a positive move. But it was, I think he's, a lot of these
00:09:04 measures, it seems impossible to enforce. When the original lockdown took place, the full lockdown,
00:09:10 that was in roughly March last year or so. And there was nearly universal buy-in for it. The,
00:09:17 you know, there hadn't been enough time to test the data. The reports being given to people were
00:09:23 showing that this is going to be as bad as the Spanish flu, that we're going to have massive 1.00
00:09:27 death tolls, that the healthcare system was going to be swamped. We didn't have the capacity for it.
00:09:32 We had to flatten the curve, two weeks to flatten the curve. We all remember that.
00:09:34 And, but that was required universal buy-in or near universal. Now, I think you're at best 50-50. It's
00:09:44 going to be, I don't think there is the, to boil over a term from the left, the social license to do
00:09:50 this kind of thing. I don't think there is the public buy-in for a mass shutdown of the economy.
00:09:57 I don't know how the government's going to enforce not allowing you to have,
00:10:00 your kid to have a sleepover at your house. The government requires a warrant to enter your house
00:10:06 unless there's a crime in progress. These are, fall under provincial statute. These are not crimes.
00:10:12 If you're having, if you're having, if you're having your best friend over for dinner at your house,
00:10:16 that's not a crime. That's a provincial fine and statute. It's not in the Criminal Code of Canada.
00:10:22 So I don't think the police have the right to enter your house without a warrant. I'm not sure many
00:10:26 people will, I'm considering printing off a copy of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and taping it
00:10:31 to my front door with a little subheading on it, get a warrant. But it'll be very difficult to enforce
00:10:41 this kind of thing and also have requirements of, are we going to now require identification of
00:10:47 people sitting down for dinner to make sure you're living in the same household? Again, quite bizarre.
00:10:51 I know in my case, I keep a very small social bubble, just three other couples and, you know,
00:10:59 we've had them over for dinner. I go hunting with the guys, the girls get together for drinks at a
00:11:04 house or something. We keep ourselves pretty close, but that's now even potentially illegal.
00:11:09 I don't know how the government intends to enforce this. I think a lot of this is going to be virtue
00:11:12 signaling. We'll see how rigorously they enforce this kind of thing, particularly when it comes to
00:11:18 people's homes. I think it's pretty bad press for a conservative government to have the police
00:11:23 barging, knocking down doors to people's houses without warrants. I don't think that's going to
00:11:27 fly very well. Corey, do you think that the government's going to have any ability to enforce this
00:11:34 on the one hand? And then second of all, maybe you can speak to the political pressures here.
00:11:40 We've discussed this before. I think to Kenny's credit, he has not seen lockdowns and masks as the
00:11:45 kind of virtue signaling, civic religious virtue signaling that most liberal politicians have,
00:11:52 or in the case of Doug Ford and Brian Palliser on the conservative side, if you can call them that.
00:11:58 I don't think he's seen this as a virtuous kind of civic religion, but he has been under tremendous
00:12:05 pressure in the media and from other political sources in Alberta to bring in a full lockdown.
00:12:10 So if you can speak maybe to, how do you think, how well do you think the enforcement's going to
00:12:15 work first and then maybe speak to the political pressures that are kind of shaping what's happening
00:12:19 right now? Yeah. Well, he's trying to be surgical. I mean, rather than doing a full lockdown
00:12:23 or appearing to do nothing, he's going by, well, this is where we have identified transmission.
00:12:28 So we're going to target those areas and try to reduce that. So they feel it's been happening more
00:12:33 in households, whether through school associations, bringing that home and then spreading it further,
00:12:39 or social gatherings. A lot of people think a lot of this spike might've come from a lot of
00:12:43 Thanksgiving dinners where you had outside household people coming into close quarters,
00:12:46 drinking, laughing, potentially spreading it. I don't think he's eager to, and I doubt again,
00:12:53 especially when we're talking about the political pressures that he's going to have
00:12:58 police coming in and cracking down on people at least anymore than they have to. The optics and
00:13:02 everything are just horrible. I mean, all of us are tired. I've been one of the ones most
00:13:07 reluctant and pushing back against restrictions, but you know, some of it all grudgingly tick.
00:13:11 You know, we were going to have Christmas at our place this year. We're going to have the family
00:13:14 members come over and everything. We've decided, you know what, we'll defer. Maybe if things are
00:13:18 sane in February, we'll have the family all come by and we'll do something then. It's not for fear of
00:13:24 the police coming in. You know, when I want to make a standout, I'll give them the middle finger and go
00:13:27 for it, but fine. If this is potentially going to help, it's a small sacrifice because I don't want to see the full
00:13:35 lockdown and people are pushing for it. People really want to do this. What'll be kind of interesting
00:13:42 is watching Ontario, Manitoba, where they have cracked down to see whether it helps. That's the
00:13:47 big question as well. Is it going to do a bloody bit of good? Is it going to be any better than with
00:13:52 this partial thing? I mean, yeah, the enforceability in restaurants is going to be very difficult.
00:13:56 Again, I think a lot of people will voluntarily not do it though. I mean, are you going to call a friend
00:13:59 and say, Hey, do you want to bring your wife out? Let's go have supper. You know, do you want to get those 0.66
00:14:03 side long stairs from the other people or whatnot? So I think a degree of it will
00:14:09 reduce contact, whether that makes a difference in the case numbers. I don't know, but he's under
00:14:16 pressure. He's trying to walk in the middle. He's getting it from both sides. So it tells me
00:14:20 he found balance. It seems whether it's a good balance or not, it remains to be seen.
00:14:25 Yeah. We've seen in the media, I mean, you know, Don Braid writes a smart column most of the time,
00:14:29 and he gets wrong sometimes, but he writes an interesting column that people on the left and
00:14:33 the right can take. But, you know, even Don Braid took a very specific ideological position on this.
00:14:40 The media have been broadly saying if Jason Kenney doesn't impose a full lockdown,
00:14:45 he is responsible for these deaths, that blood will be on his hands. And so there's been tremendous
00:14:51 political pressure from the media. The media have been singing, at least the mainstream media have been
00:14:55 singing almost uniformly from the same songbook with a few skeptical exceptions. And, you know,
00:15:06 so I think it's been largely political pressure. I think most UCP voters are a combination of either
00:15:14 believing that this is all bullshit, and I don't think we fall into that camp. But, oh, I think we're 0.99
00:15:21 frozen. Great. You know, we don't fall into the, this is all a hoax camp. But I think many people,
00:15:30 especially on the right side of the spectrum, are skeptical of the effectiveness of these things.
00:15:35 They're very skeptical of government period right now, because what they were told at the beginning
00:15:40 of this has turned out to be so wildly wrong with the modeling. We are so many times below,
00:15:47 even the least worst case scenario of COVID. It's bad. But, you know, and then we've got funny,
00:15:54 funny statistical anomalies, if we can call it that, of there are zero influenza cases this year.
00:16:01 I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure this is the first year in the history of Alberta that there are
00:16:05 zero influenza cases. So, I mean, it's, I suppose it's technically possible, but I'm willing to give
00:16:11 people pretty good odds on a bet that that's not correct, that there are influenza cases,
00:16:16 and they're just being misclassified as something else now. So, I think he's between a rock and a
00:16:21 hard place politically. I don't think they actually want to be doing this in the way that other
00:16:25 governments across Canada have gleefully done it. I don't, I think in their heart of hearts,
00:16:31 they might even think that this is kind of nonsense and won't really do very much in the long term.
00:16:36 But I think it's politically, they're giving into pressure on one side, at least partially giving
00:16:44 into pressure on one side that wants draconian measures. And they're trying to have the best of
00:16:48 both worlds here. But from everything I've seen, the lockdown Karen crowd, they're not satisfied with
00:16:54 this. And then the anti-lockdown crowd, they're not satisfied with this. And that's often a very
00:17:01 dangerous place to be politically. And don't forget, Kenny left us all with a dire warning yesterday
00:17:11 that these restrictions will be reviewed in three weeks. And if things aren't any better, he says,
00:17:16 it's going to get worse and the harsher lockdown will come.
00:17:20 Yeah. So speaking of dangerous places politically, maybe we'll talk about the reaction to this,
00:17:30 or I guess we've already been talking a bit about the reaction. Just this morning on Danielle Smith's
00:17:36 show on 770 CHQR, she was interviewing Rachel Notley. It was a very interesting way she opened up
00:17:44 her show today saying she's there's a bit of a movement to get her off the air. And she's not
00:17:51 even going to give any of her own perspectives today. She's just going to host and not not say
00:17:55 any of her own views. And to start that off, she had Rachel Notley on NDP leader and opposition leader.
00:18:02 And Rachel, she was asked, asked Rachel Notley point blank, because she was kind of beating around
00:18:08 the bushes about what she wants to see. She says, do you believe that all bars and restaurants should be
00:18:13 closed? And Rachel Notley said, and at least she gave a straight answer. Yes. Period. Said a bit after
00:18:21 that, but nothing to alter it. I can't give an exact quote. But Rachel Notley says she wants all bars
00:18:26 and restaurants closed in Alberta. Now, even if you think that this, you know, that we should have
00:18:33 extreme lockdown measures, if you close all bars and restaurants, and you make it illegal to gather in
00:18:38 people's homes, you know what's going to happen? People are just going to gather in homes.
00:18:42 So, you know, this is kind of like, like a water balloon, you're going to squeeze one side, it's
00:18:47 going to come out somewhere else. Humans are social creatures. We don't, most of us are not hermits
00:18:52 living in the woods, we want to see other human beings, even if it's just Cory. And, you know, we,
00:19:00 you have to do something. I think the trick should be how do we do it in the most responsible and
00:19:06 cautious manner, we reasonably can. And closing down bars and restaurants. So when, you know,
00:19:12 bars and restaurants were closed down in the first lockdown, the first full lockdown,
00:19:17 people gathered in homes. And if you're saying you can't gather in homes, and you can't gather in
00:19:22 restaurants, well, restaurants will just be closed. Most of them are not going to be like
00:19:25 that barbecue joint in Ontario that openly defy the law. These places don't want to receive fines for
00:19:30 doing it. It's just not profitable. So then people will just gather in their homes. But that's the
00:19:35 position of Rachel Notley. I'm not sure if it's because everybody working in these places is
00:19:40 ununionized or not. But it does seem to be that the only people who don't, who are protected from
00:19:47 losing their jobs and lockdowns are unionized workers, primarily public sector, but even private
00:19:53 sector are tend to be more protected from this kind of thing. Everybody in the private sector,
00:19:57 not in a union is much more susceptible to this kind of thing, particularly small business owners.
00:20:04 Well, yeah, as a former restaurant owner, I mean, that's a tough business at the best of times. And
00:20:08 then the people working there, I mean, they're very reliant on its servers and cooks, people in the
00:20:15 kitchen, and then places servicing these restaurants. I mean, there's a lot downstream,
00:20:19 there's truckers supplying us, there's tradesmen keeping that place going, like they are a big part of
00:20:23 the economy, the hospitality sector, in general. And the transmissions, again, she's making a giant
00:20:30 leap that these transmissions are happening in restaurants, and there isn't any evidence of it.
00:20:34 And you can see why I can actually see, you know, when you think about it, why it's happening more in
00:20:38 households than restaurants. In a restaurant, they are following rules, they are getting people to
00:20:43 sanitize their hands on the way in, they aren't socializing from table to table, they're staying
00:20:48 limited to their small group, they are masked when in transit, I mean, you got to wear a mask to go to
00:20:53 the bathroom, you're not as much measures as we could do to prevent transmission are happening in
00:20:59 restaurants where they aren't happening. As you said, when you squeeze that balloon, and suddenly
00:21:03 you've got 20 people in a household, who all hug and kiss each other on the cheek on the way in,
00:21:08 who perhaps share the odd wine glass, who have absolutely no controls going on, then transmission is
00:21:15 going to be higher. So when we're looking logically, it's not coming out of restaurants, so don't shut
00:21:20 them down. But Notley, again, she's a socialist, there's no economic reality in her mind. I mean,
00:21:25 there isn't, members will face that, they aren't looking at that, they just feel we can borrow,
00:21:29 borrow, borrow until everything gets better. And it's not realistic. So for her to whimsically say,
00:21:34 just close restaurants and bars, it means nothing to her. And it shows.
00:21:38 There's no doubt that a full lockdown, that will be the end, that will be the death knell for
00:21:43 for many establishment that are just sort of barely holding on at the moment. I don't know about you
00:21:48 guys, but I feel quite safe when I go to my neighborhood bar. They've had more visits from
00:21:53 health inspectors than than any place I know. They're in there at least once a week. I only sit with
00:22:00 my group of friends that I know are all practicing, you know, being safe. And as Corey said, masks on when
00:22:08 you go to the bathroom, masks on when you get up to leave. And the staffer, if you accidentally
00:22:14 forget the staffer, are always reminding you. And they're in a tough position this time of season
00:22:20 anyways, they're going to lose all of their Christmas party business. That's a devastating blow for some
00:22:28 some places that they will not recover from. And while still being able to operate,
00:22:34 these new restrictions are certainly going to put a lot of people off from even going there because
00:22:39 they can't socialize the way they even can now.
00:22:43 Yeah. Well, I guess this takes us to Manitoba. Maybe, Dave, why don't you bring us up to speed on
00:22:55 great sins committed by churches in Manitoba? It's a weird COVID world we live in, isn't it, Derek?
00:23:03 This is a case involving an organization called The Church of God. And they had a service on the weekend
00:23:12 that it was just southeast of Winnipeg in a place called Hanover. And they had more than 100 worshipers,
00:23:20 sorry, 100 worshipers show up for the service. And people saw all the cars in the parking lot
00:23:28 and saw all the activities and notified the proper authorities in Manitoba. Churches are only allowed to
00:23:36 hold services for five people maximum. So obviously, this church was flagrantly violating the law,
00:23:44 they knew it, and they didn't care. In fact, Tobias Thiessen, the minister of the Church of God seems
00:23:54 somewhat proud that he got $2,600 worth of tickets. He said, quote, I feel honored to get these and
00:24:01 receive them for doing something God wants me to do. So he doesn't sound repentant for his sins.
00:24:09 And I imagine coming Sunday, his parking lot will be full again.
00:24:13 Yeah, well, I guess I mentioned it in passing earlier. You're seeing more and more open,
00:24:21 almost civil disobedience type actions taking place against lockdowns in Ontario, where Doug Ford
00:24:30 has kind of bought into the religion of this thing. You know, you've got this barbecue joint owner,
00:24:35 I think he's kind of north of Toronto somewhere, or on the northern side of Toronto,
00:24:40 something in that area. He owns a barbecue shop. He's not allowed to open at all. And
00:24:48 and he did anyway. He said, too bad. So that wasn't COVID. Probably not. No guarantees.
00:24:59 You know, he opened anyway, and the place was so full that the police couldn't even stop it. And
00:25:03 and he's going to do it again. And it's not just it's not just people kind of scoff lying. This is
00:25:11 very open and in your face. It's publicized. And and they're taking it on almost as an act of civil
00:25:17 disobedience. You didn't see that in the March lockdown. But I think at that time, what else could
00:25:23 we do? I'm not a virologist. None of almost nobody is, except for a very select number of people,
00:25:30 a select number of even doctors. And we were told that this is how serious this is. And virtually
00:25:36 everybody bought in and went with it. That consensus has been smashed since March. That does not exist
00:25:44 anymore. So you just don't have the mass social buy in. So I just don't think these these lockdowns
00:25:50 are going to be are going to be particularly effective. Especially as you know, we squeeze
00:25:57 the balloon, it's going to come out somewhere else. You know, I bet you, you know, my church
00:26:03 attendance has been poor in recent years. But, you know, I can tell you when I used to be a very
00:26:09 more regular church church goer, if we were told we couldn't meet in church, we would just have a
00:26:14 service in somebody's home. You do that already for Bible studies. So this stuff is going to happen.
00:26:20 I think the the smarter thing to do would be where we were a couple of weeks ago, is just have
00:26:26 reasonable measures in place, asking people to be responsible, and be truthful about the data. And
00:26:33 in Alberta, at least, actually, the data has been relatively truthful. I think they're still over
00:26:38 reporting COVID cases, because if there are zero influenza, I got a feeling some people are getting
00:26:42 in there. What they're calling COVID deaths is often not a COVID death. These are people who are already
00:26:47 had very serious conditions, but they happen to have COVID. But at least Alberta is publishing
00:26:54 the data regularly, it's fairly verifiable, you can go through it, and you can parse the data.
00:27:00 And I think that's the best things people can do, because governments that have been more secretive
00:27:04 than, say, Alberta's. People lose faith in it. People don't trust it. And then that consensus
00:27:11 around reasonable measures we can take breaks down still further.
00:27:15 A bit of a side note, but still on the religious angle, gentlemen. I did a story this morning on the
00:27:21 website about the Archbishop of Vancouver, our Archbishop Miller. And he is, you know, confused,
00:27:29 he's baffled about BC's provincial laws when it comes to houses of worship. They have to close
00:27:36 as of November 19th. They're shut, no services allowed. And the Archbishop says that's unfair.
00:27:43 He's got a flock of 475,000 Catholics in Vancouver that he's in charge of, and he's no longer allowed
00:27:51 to minister to them. One of the puzzling things is his church is allowed to remain open for
00:28:00 Alcoholics Anonymous meetings in the basement, which he says is a good thing, but he's not allowed
00:28:05 to have worshippers inside. Very confusing for churches and worshippers across Western Canada.
00:28:13 Every province has their own individual rules.
00:28:17 Well, and if you close down the bars, then the alcoholics have to drink at home. That's a great
00:28:21 idea. We, as usual, we go through all your questions and comments.
00:28:28 Pardon? Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, just since you're starting, I was just wondering what Calvin brought
00:28:32 something up. Does the state of emergency put Hinshaw in charge? Because Notley this morning
00:28:37 actually was, and I know that Premier Kenny has been playing a bit of a lot of politics over a while.
00:28:43 They kind of bat it back and forth. Well, we're listening to the medical experts, and then at times
00:28:46 when the medical experts don't say what they want, then they're kind of quiet. But is
00:28:51 Dr. Hinshaw now in charge due to the state of emergency?
00:28:55 No, this doesn't put Hinshaw in charge as if she becomes the Premier. The government didn't 0.56
00:29:02 break a glass on the wall and Hinshaw comes out with an axe. It's not like that. But I think she
00:29:09 is given greater measures. The big thing is that Cabinet is given greater control and it suspends,
00:29:17 at least in theory, some of the rules around habeas corpus and the right of government to
00:29:25 search your property without a warrant. Again, I'd still say anybody, just for disclosure,
00:29:31 don't have large gatherings at your home. That's probably a bad idea. But if you're going to have,
00:29:39 you know, one or two people over and you're having a responsible gathering, despite what the government
00:29:43 says, and the police come to your door, demand a warrant, they'll say they don't need a warrant,
00:29:48 but they do. If they enter your property without a warrant, it is unconstitutional,
00:29:53 because these are not crimes. These are provincial statute. And that does not qualify as criminal
00:29:57 activity, even if it's breaking a law. There is a significant difference in that,
00:30:01 that a lot of people, I don't think, understand. So if men in boots come to your house and demand to
00:30:09 be let in, you demand a warrant and do not allow them in under any circumstances. You don't have to
00:30:14 answer questions about what you're doing in your house if it's not criminal activity taking place
00:30:19 at that time. So the big thing is that the cabinet has more, more power. Hinshaw does have, Hinshaw,
00:30:26 so Kelvin Gula Jones says, yes, Hinshaw can do things without legislation. It's true. But generally,
00:30:33 these things happen with the consent of the cabinet. The cabinet, the executive council can order,
00:30:40 can make essentially laws through something called order and cancel, which is essentially a cabinet decree.
00:30:45 And now the government has greater latitude to do just that without passing legislation. So it is
00:30:51 significantly more authoritarian, but it isn't all the power necessarily in the hands of just
00:30:57 Dr. Hina Hinshaw. As I was saying earlier, we will come through your comments and questions
00:31:03 at the end normally, but every once in a while, if we're on the topic as we see it, we'll go to it.
00:31:08 Justin Coleman says, one wonders if all the politicians lost their wages, if this all of a sudden went poof.
00:31:15 Yes, the ECP took wage cuts, and rightly so, the feds gave themselves raises.
00:31:20 Yeah, I mean, it's no wonder that you got, you know, Gil McGowan and the Alberta Federation of Labor
00:31:25 representing unionized employees, many in the government. They're calling for total complete
00:31:32 lockdowns. Well, what's that going to do? It's going to bleed the private sector and increase the relative
00:31:36 strength of the public sector and unions. Politicians have, in many ways, actually, their job is easier.
00:31:44 I could tell you, serving the legislature for four years, going up, no events to Edmonton, 0.99
00:31:49 but leaving your family and going to Edmonton is a real pain in the ass when you can, and I imagine 0.99
00:31:53 all the more pain in the ass if you're going all the way to Ottawa. If you can be a legislator and 0.99
00:31:57 work from your living room, certainly it's not as prestigious and nice, but no one pays attention to
00:32:01 you anyway unless you're a senior cabinet minister or the leader of the opposition. So there really has been
00:32:06 no hit to the politicians. If they were feeling the pinch even half as much as people in the private
00:32:11 sector or small business owners, I have a feeling we'd be taking a very different approach right now.
00:32:16 Oh, absolutely. You know, Gil can sit in the comfort
00:32:19 of his place and tell other people to sit at home and go bankrupt. That's an easy luxury to have when
00:32:24 you siphon your money off of the other workers to pay your bills, but for people in the real world,
00:32:29 it's devastating, and I'm getting sick, actually, of people who were financially secure telling other
00:32:34 people to sacrifice on their behalf. Cut your own wages first. Western Standard, we mostly work from
00:32:39 home most of the week right now. We come into the office on Wednesdays and the other day for meetings,
00:32:45 but this is, for lack of a better term, a white-collar job. We can do this from computers, from the comfort
00:32:51 of our living room, unless you open for us where you have no internet, but most of these kinds of jobs,
00:32:58 we are fortunate. We are privileged that we can work from home. We don't have to go to a storefront,
00:33:04 bricks and mortar, and actually be there on the job. So for us, you know, we've taken an advertising
00:33:09 hit, but we're still able to continue doing our job, largely because our members have stepped up.
00:33:13 We've had a lot of new members join the Western Standard actually during this time. People make
00:33:18 donations that have helped keep us float. That's made up for a large part of our advertising hit that
00:33:23 we've taken, but a lot of people are not in this position. You're out in the oil field. You're flipping
00:33:27 burgers. You're waiting tables. You own a retail store. These people are losing their livelihoods.
00:33:35 And, you know, as terrible as this all, as the virus is, I would rather take a 0.02% chance with
00:33:42 my life than a 100% chance of potentially losing my house and my business on that kind of trade-off.
00:33:48 And economics is all about trade-offs, but we're not talking about trade-offs enough right now.
00:33:53 In the trade-off, I mean, a very small chance of contracting and then potentially dying from COVID,
00:34:02 which is terrible, but contrast with a near certainty of losing your business or your house,
00:34:07 I'm going to take the risk on COVID if that's the binary choice I'm faced with. We're not faced with it
00:34:14 in this job in media. We can work from home. And I can tell you, all the other media that are out there,
00:34:19 calling for lockdowns, they're working from home right now. Their jobs are safe. They're fine. And
00:34:24 they're taking checks from Ottawa to pay for it in most cases. But they're working from home. Their
00:34:29 jobs are not at risk. But they're lecturing everybody about the need to put other people
00:34:34 out of work whose jobs are at risk. End of rant. Well, let's go to something of a smellier variety.
00:34:43 Frenchman. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. This is a family show. We're going to talk about the
00:34:51 fromage. The Bloc Québécois, arch defender of the supply management system, which artificially requires
00:34:58 the rest of Canada to buy disproportionately Quebec dairy in particular, but also other supply managed
00:35:06 goods. The Bloc Québécois has introduced a bill in the House of Commons that would require, which would
00:35:14 essentially ban the federal government from allowing any more importation of supply managed goods,
00:35:19 primarily cheese, but others as well in trade agreements. A little bit of background. Canada has
00:35:26 a Soviet style supply management system that has government quotas for how much you can produce
00:35:33 in a range of agricultural goods. When we have trade agreements, this is the biggest thing stopping us
00:35:38 from getting great free trade agreements across the world is everybody wants to buy and sell with Canada,
00:35:42 but we won't allow their dairy farmers or their egg farmers, et cetera, poultry to import in Canada
00:35:48 without massive, massive tariffs. There's a very small proportion of imported cheeses already allowed
00:35:54 without those super tariffs. But the Bloc still thinks that's too much. Dave, why don't you tell us
00:36:00 about this Bloc bill, what it is they're proposing, and anything we've heard from any of the other parties
00:36:06 in reaction to it? Well, you summed it up very nicely, Derek, calling it a Soviet-style
00:36:12 supply management system. But the Bloc has said you've given away too much already. They're obviously
00:36:19 defending their base, the Quebec farmers. They say that concessions have been made in the last three
00:36:32 free trade deals that Canada has signed, including the withdrawn NAFTA agreement. And they say that
00:36:41 things are taken away from their dairy farmers, and there's no compensation given back.
00:36:46 So they're bringing in this law, private member's bill, to ban any more concessions. And they're
00:36:54 demanding that money owed to the Quebec farmers be paid immediately. They're still waiting for
00:37:02 concessions from, or payment because of concessions from the last round. And Bloc leader Blanchet is
00:37:09 demanding Finance Minister Christina Freeland bring in immediate measures to give the farmers money.
00:37:17 And he's demanding that happen in the economic statement that's coming up on November 30th from
00:37:25 Freeland. So, you know, it's the Bloc defending their base, and I'm not sure how much support it's
00:37:31 going to get. As with all private members' bills, it will be very rare to see it pass. But we'll see
00:37:38 what happens.
00:37:39 Well, it is a minority government, so there actually is a chance to pass private members' bills in that
00:37:44 case. And, I mean, every single party currently represented in the House of Commons, the Bloc,
00:37:50 the Greens, the NDP, the Liberals, and the Conservatives, are all religiously in support of
00:37:56 supply management. You know, that was one of the big reasons, the key reason that Maxime Bernier
00:38:04 lost the Conservative leadership by a hair and led to a falling out there. And since his departure,
00:38:09 there's been no voice really in the Conservatives against supply management. It always just kind of
00:38:17 makes me chuggle, half chuckle, half cry, that the party in defense of free markets is defending
00:38:23 one of the most draconianly Soviet economic policies. It's even bad almost by many Soviet
00:38:28 standards. The Soviets allowed for some free trade in certain goods, so this would actually fall on
00:38:33 the more draconian side, even within the Soviet Union's economic policy. But I think there's actually
00:38:39 an excellent chance of it passing. If it doesn't pass, the Conservatives' base is very divided on this.
00:38:45 The caucus might be almost unanimously in favor of it, at least publicly. The Conservatives might be able
00:38:52 to oppose it on the sense that, oh, we support supply management, but we should, you know, we're gonna
00:38:56 have to make some concessions in trade deals. The Liberals might even have wiggle room on that. 0.95
00:39:01 So it's hard to say, but all it's going to require is the support of the NDP, which will support it,
00:39:07 almost certainly. And either the Conservatives or the Liberals, I think, would be enough to pass it.
00:39:14 The Greens will probably support it anyway, but their numbers don't add up to a decisive number.
00:39:18 So it's potential this thing could pass. Corey, I know you've got some feelings on supply management.
00:39:28 How do you think this is going to play out? Do you think there's a chance of the bill passing?
00:39:32 In particular, how do you think the Conservatives are going to react to it?
00:39:35 Well, I've long railed against supply management. I mean, it is an odious policy. It is.
00:39:40 It's Soviet style. It's repugnant. It's market control. It's been in for decades. 0.99
00:39:45 You know, I wrote recently just even on the animal welfare aspect of it, because also what supply
00:39:51 management does is it forces everything into large-
00:39:53 Corey writes animal rights crusader.
00:39:55 Yeah. And you can't get small market dairy products or poultry products because it's
00:40:00 unfeasible with the quota system. An analogy I like using is my wife, Jane, she grew up on a dairy farm, 0.92
00:40:05 a small one, and her father had a quota to sell cream, but he didn't have a quota to sell milk.
00:40:10 So literally they'd skim the cream, family consume as much milk as they can,
00:40:15 maybe feed some to the pigs. Even the rest goes into the ditch. It's illegal to sell it. Illegal.
00:40:20 I mean, that's, it's ridiculous, but the control that the cartels have on the politicians, 0.79
00:40:26 they've got them by the short and curlies. I don't know if the Conservatives will support this bill,
00:40:30 but you can be sure that they'll be silent in their opposition of it at the most, you know,
00:40:34 and I, as far as private member bills go, this one may very well get through because it's
00:40:40 following up with that very strong dairy cartel who basically has every political party in their
00:40:45 pocket. And I've seen that, seen that as the Achilles heel of the Conservatives. Every one of
00:40:51 them should look at their feet in shame when they try to claim to be a Conservative and then claim to
00:40:55 support supply management in the same sentence because they, they are complete polar opposite
00:40:59 policies and there's no excuse to keep supporting it.
00:41:01 Excellent. Well, uh, let's, um, uh, we're going to go to our remaining questions and comments. We'll
00:41:08 go to, uh, Eldon Siemens asks, does the Alberta Emergency Measures Act remove our constitutional
00:41:15 protections, uh, like, uh, freedom of association? Uh, Dave, do you want to take a crack at it?
00:41:23 Uh, that's a good question. Uh, does the constitution, does the charter of rights and freedoms,
00:41:30 uh, oversee everything? Um, you know, the short answer is to be blunt. I, I don't
00:41:38 really know. Uh, certainly when the elder Trudeau brought in, uh, the war measures act that over,
00:41:46 that, uh, you know, uh, overtook everything. It's now called something different, less ominous,
00:41:52 but it's still a federal thing. Uh, so yeah, I'm not sure the province is allowed to go, uh, uh,
00:41:59 that far. Even, even Kenny yesterday said, uh, you know, some of the restrictions that people want
00:42:04 would be against the charter of rights and freedoms and they have to be, uh, they have to be very careful.
00:42:09 Uh, yeah, I mean, it, it certainly does, um, it's a very constitutionally sticky issue or, or legally
00:42:19 sticky issue here. Uh, the Supreme Court has, I'm not actually sure if the emergency, at least the
00:42:26 National Emergencies Act, which is the renamed War Measures Act, uh, I don't think it's been actually
00:42:31 used since, uh, pure, uh, Trudeau the first used it, uh, with the FLQ crisis in Quebec. Yeah,
00:42:38 the October crisis with the FLQ terrorists in Quebec. Uh, I'm not sure if it's been used by the,
00:42:42 uh, since then. And we didn't even have the charter then. So I'm not actually sure this thing has been
00:42:46 tested in the courts. Uh, but generally go to courts tend to be sympathetic towards government
00:42:52 using powers in this sense. If it can just, as they would say reasonably justified in a free and
00:42:58 democratic society, uh, it'd be interesting to see, uh, uh, John Carpe of the Canadian Constitution
00:43:05 Foundation has vowed, uh, legal challenges, uh, if Alberta went into a lockdown, uh, I received a
00:43:11 call from him this morning. Uh, I expect it to be up, uh, probably sometime this afternoon. Uh, it sounds
00:43:19 to me, uh, like John is not satisfied with the, uh, not quite full lockdown measures in Alberta. Uh, it
00:43:25 sounds like he'll be making a challenge. So we actually couldn't see constitutional challenges
00:43:29 against this, but those things take a very, very long time, unless you're talking about an injunction.
00:43:34 Uh, and I think the courts would be loath to grant injunctions against governments at times like this.
00:43:39 Uh, but I, I think we could see court challenges about if the, if these emergency powers acts are in
00:43:45 fact, uh, constitutional or not. Certainly parts of them are constitutional, uh, the parts that grant
00:43:51 power to the executive at the expense of the legislature, essentially allowing the executive to make
00:43:55 laws without, uh, without passing an act of a legislature or without passing an act of parliament.
00:44:02 Uh, the courts are not going to strike that down. They should, but they're not going to, uh, they've
00:44:08 got a long history of upholding that. The bigger issue will be, uh, can violations of things like
00:44:14 habeas corpus be, uh, justified to the courts. Uh, you know, the, the ability of the government to enter
00:44:22 your home without a warrant, that kind of thing. Uh, that is to be determined. Uh, I think they
00:44:27 certainly violate the, the, the spirit and principles of the constitution. Uh, but it's
00:44:33 not yet determined if, uh, the courts will support the government in doing that.
00:44:37 Well, and the charter gives a huge out right on the beginning with kind of throws it into within
00:44:41 reason, you know, the government can infringe on these if they can come up.
00:44:45 The Canadian charter is so Canadian. There's no absolute principles in it. It's like, here's our
00:44:49 principles, but these are nice to have. But if the government can, uh, can justify taking them
00:44:53 away from you, well then. So it leaves a huge hole right off the bat. And then even then,
00:44:57 if you found a judge who said, no, you know what? That hole's not big enough. Uh, I'm ruling against
00:45:03 you. Well, the next thing down is the notwithstanding clause. Cause this, if this is a provincial thing
00:45:07 and it's a charter issue, the province can say, well, the court disagrees with us, but we're invoking
00:45:13 the notwithstanding clause. So we're exempt from it anyways. So I'm afraid that we don't have a
00:45:18 lot of charter protection if the government wants to go down the road. I mean, we'll see. Carpe is
00:45:23 going to give it a crack, but we'll see what happens. The only provincial government or the
00:45:26 only government in Canada period, federally and provincially, it's ever used the notwithstanding
00:45:29 clauses Quebec. Uh, you know, they use it like it's the morning after pill. Uh, they, they're free. Uh,
00:45:39 that might be a too accurate of a night, uh, but like, you know, they'll use it. They're like,
00:45:42 Oh, too bad. Uh, we're, uh, we don't really care. They use it generally on French language,
00:45:49 culture, ethnic issues. Uh, but I wouldn't be surprised if they use it in something like this. 0.76
00:45:55 Uh, but you know, the notwithstanding clause is very much taboo for governments to use. There's
00:46:00 a reason no one's used it across Canada, outside of Quebec. Um, so I, I think, you know, if the courts
00:46:06 did rule that these things were unconstitutional, I think that the government's would be very hesitant
00:46:11 to invoke the notwithstanding clause because it, uh, it is very much the political judicial nuclear
00:46:17 option. Okay. Uh, and we've got, uh, Ron Pike covering up the entire screen with his long, uh,
00:46:24 comments here. Just, uh, just before we get to Ron, uh, please, uh, keep your comments relatively
00:46:31 short. Try not to put URLs in a comment that you would like us to go to, uh, if it covers up the
00:46:36 whole screen, we're much less likely to get to it. If it's too wordy, try to keep your questions short
00:46:40 and concise. I know you got a lot to say, but please just, uh, try your best, but we're going
00:46:44 to go to Ron Pike. Uh, we kind of deal with the gist of it. Why do people not trust their health
00:46:48 officials? My opinion is that they are not being transparent with all of us, uh, giving us the case,
00:46:54 case, case speech, and then being inundated by Tam on every second commercial. Uh, I haven't,
00:46:59 I don't really watch TV, so I haven't seen these Tam commercials, but I'm, I'm told, uh, that they're terrible.
00:47:04 Uh, but I, I suppose we shouldn't judge it based on how well they come off, but, uh, I, I think
00:47:10 I'm not convinced that governments were lying to, uh, at least the Canadian governments were lying to
00:47:15 people when this all became an issue. I think they were just wrong. I think they were mistaken,
00:47:20 uh, and that in most cases they did not adequately atone for that. People make mistakes and governments
00:47:25 are human. Government's going to make their fair share of mistakes, uh, but they need to atone for them.
00:47:30 They need to admit to them and own up to them. And Canadian governments have not really apologized
00:47:35 for how wrong the modeling was. Uh, I think their reasoning as well, if we apologize, that means
00:47:40 we are wrong and then people won't trust us in the future. I take an opposite perspective. Uh,
00:47:44 if you're wrong, people will be more likely to trust you in the future if you fess up to it.
00:47:48 So I think Ron's got a, got a good point there that people are not trusting public health officials
00:47:53 because they have not fessed up to mistakes that they made. Uh, Tam herself said masks are essentially
00:47:58 useless. Don't use them. Uh, we've never heard an apology and retraction for that. They just simply
00:48:05 flip positions, uh, like, like she was a politician and said, uh, here's what we think now. And don't 0.98
00:48:11 ask questions about why we had 180 degrees different position in the past. Uh, Dave, uh, how do you think,
00:48:20 you know, have public health officials, uh, damaged their trust with the public? And, uh, and if you
00:48:28 think so, should they, um, uh, how do you think they should best go about, uh, atoning for that to
00:48:34 restore trust? Well, the two hardest words in English language seem to be, I'm sorry. Uh, you know,
00:48:42 we talked earlier about, uh, Premier Kenny apologizing yesterday, and that was the first time I think,
00:48:48 you know, has discussed that we've ever heard, heard him apologize. Uh, Tam, Tam, uh, as you,
00:48:56 as you said, has, has flip-flopped and, uh, and not apologized. The, uh, Ontario Auditor General came
00:49:05 out with a report today slamming the Ontario government's handling of the, the, the pandemic,
00:49:11 and the government's response was, well, you know, we tried our best with the information that we have.
00:49:16 So all stuff like that leads to the conspiracy theories, leads to people saying, you know,
00:49:22 I don't trust what Hinshaw is telling us. I don't believe what Tam is telling us now because she's
00:49:28 changed positions. And it is that sort of flip-flopping and, uh, that, that, that causes these people,
00:49:36 or causes conspiracy theories in people's minds. Um, unlike you, Derek, I think the Alberta government
00:49:42 has been fairly open and, and transparent with, with their numbers. Uh, there have been some
00:49:49 problems in the last week or so with, uh, with testing numbers, but, uh, I think overall they've
00:49:54 been, uh, uh, coming pretty clean. Uh, you know, it seems to me to, when, when new information breaks,
00:50:03 governments and, and health authorities are slow to react to it. And it's almost like the people get
00:50:08 the information and they're reacting to it quicker than the government health authorities
00:50:13 are. And I think the mask flip-flop was a perfect example of that.
00:50:17 Yeah. Indeed. Uh, well, let's go to one last curious comment from, uh, Calvin, uh,
00:50:24 Goulet Jones. I apologize. Uh, Calvin, tell us in the comments, if I'm masquerading your name,
00:50:29 it might be French, uh, Goulet or something. I think it's Goulet, but I, I don't know. There's no
00:50:35 TTE, but, uh, just let us know if I'm masquerading your name. I can, uh, as a Phil de Brandt, I can
00:50:40 appreciate people getting it wrong. Um, but he says, hire Danielle Smith. Uh, as far as I know,
00:50:45 she's already got a job, but, uh, if, uh, if she finds herself out of one for expressing
00:50:51 controversial opinions, we'll certainly be making a call to her. Uh, I think she'd make,
00:50:55 uh, certainly, uh, an interesting addition to the Western standard team, but I, I think she's got, 0.99
00:51:01 uh, I think she's got it right. Oh, and, uh, apparently I was wrong. Corey was right. It is Goulet.
00:51:08 So my apportion, my apologies, Calvin Goulet Jones. All right. Well, uh, thank you all very much,
00:51:15 uh, for joining us today, uh, sharing your time with us, your questions and your comments.
00:51:20 Uh, as usual, I want to remind you, if you're not yet a Western standard member,
00:51:23 please go to Western standard online.com right now, sign up to become a member for just a few
00:51:28 bucks a month. Uh, we do not accept government funding. We do not comply with government media
00:51:33 licensing. We're one of the very few, uh, independent media organizations in Canada that do that. And we are the
00:51:38 only one in the West, at least that I'm aware of, of, uh, of any kind of size and scope. Uh,
00:51:44 but, and if you are a Western standard member, thank you very much for your support. We really
00:51:47 appreciate it. Uh, if you thought that this was, uh, an interesting, uh, or at the very least
00:51:53 entertaining video you saw today, uh, please share this on your social media networks to, uh, to get
00:51:58 the word out and encourage others to become Western standard members. But, uh, thank you very much for
00:52:02 your time. Uh, we, uh, we appreciate, uh, you joining us today.
00:52:32 Thank you.
00:53:02 Thank you.
00:53:32 Thank you.
00:54:02 Thank you.
00:54:32 Thank you.
00:55:02 Thank you.
00:55:32 Thank you.
00:56:02 Thank you.
00:56:32 Thank you.
00:57:02 Thank you.
00:57:32 Thank you.