Western Standard - November 03, 2022


The Pipeline: Ottawa says register rifles not, rapists

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Will Trudeau follow Biden in attacking the oil sector? The inside story of Operation Peacock — a failed, murky plot to entrap Nenshi

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

176.58

Word count

7,905

Sentence count

512

Harmful content

Misogyny

23

sentences flagged

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Henniford and Editor-in-Chief Derek Fildebrandt discuss the Supreme Court's ruling on the use of the notwithstanding clause in Ontario's contract dispute with teachers, and the Canadian Shooting Sports Association's campaign to protect gun rights.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard. You're watching The
00:00:23 pipeline. Today is November 2nd, 2022. I'm joined, as usual, by my friends, Western Standard
00:00:31 Opinion Editor, Nigel Henniford. Nigel, getting to work was beautiful today, eh?
00:00:37 What a peach. I was late. Didn't you notice?
00:00:39 You were a bit late.
00:00:40 Yeah.
00:00:41 Yeah. I think most of us were late. Some people remarkably... The people who don't drive were 1.00
00:00:47 here on time. People who can walk to work mostly, people who take the train, stuff like that.
00:00:52 People with four-wheel drive trucks were on time, too.
00:00:55 I've got a four-by-four.
00:00:56 I was still late.
00:00:59 Not that late, but I was late.
00:01:01 I had to borrow my wife's four-wheel drive, so there you are.
00:01:04 Got that in the end.
00:01:05 One man who made it from way outside town,
00:01:08 Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:01:12 Corey, you took the dog sled in all the way from Pritis.
00:01:15 That's right.
00:01:16 I beat that thing and ran it up McLeod Trail all the way downtown.
00:01:19 You should try to capture the bears that keep on attacking your house.
00:01:22 strap them to a dog sled oh if i could train that frustrating animal that's i don't know 0.83
00:01:27 probably less illegal than if you just shot the thing true it'd be more he may not just give him
00:01:31 a job and get you know let him get that just make him a productive member of society yeah
00:01:34 we've got to tie him up outside when i'm here at work though sled bears yeah tie him up uh you
00:01:39 might have a problem getting parking in downtown calgary for your sled bears but i'll tie him at
00:01:44 city hall excellent idea excellent idea okay uh before we get going i want to thank my favorite
00:01:50 sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. You're probably sick of hearing me say it, but
00:01:55 it's important. I've been a member of the Canadian Shooting Sports Association for over a decade
00:02:00 because they are absolutely vital to protecting our gun rights in Canada. The Canadian Shooting
00:02:06 Sports Association is Canada's leading firearms rights group. These guys are taking the fight to
00:02:10 Ottawa, doing everything that can reasonably be done to talk a modicum of sense into the federal
00:02:17 government when it comes to reasonable firearms legislation and regulation. And importantly,
00:02:22 they're a big part of firearms education in Canada. You ever wonder why the federal government likes
00:02:26 to ban guns because they look scary? Well, it's important that people understand that just because
00:02:31 you put a carbonite stock on a rifle, it doesn't mean that Rambo would use it in the jungles of
00:02:36 Vietnam. So if you're not yet a member of the Canadian Shooting Sports Association, go sign up
00:02:42 right now. Don't pause us. Just open another window. Go to CSSA-CILA.org, click on membership,
00:02:51 and sign up right now. Make it a membership if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard.
00:02:55 Go to westernstandard.news and click on membership. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year
00:03:03 to get you unlimited access to all Western Standard content, giving you one of the only
00:03:08 media sources left in Canada that refuses to take the federal government's media bailout money.
00:03:15 We're the leading media organization in Western Canada right now, the only media organization I'm
00:03:21 aware of west of Mississauga that's got its own reporters on Parliament Hill, for God's sake. So
00:03:26 go sign up right now if you haven't already. Oh, geez, I didn't even get people a preview of what
00:03:31 we're talking about. Well, here's what we're talking about today. Supreme Court of Canada
00:03:35 has ruled that it's unconstitutional to put pedophiles and rapists
00:03:44 mandatorily on the sex offender registry.
00:03:48 Very bad.
00:03:49 Very cruel of us.
00:03:51 So sex offender registry or mandatory sex offender registry, unconstitutional.
00:03:57 Long gun registry, that's okay. 0.98
00:03:59 So we're going to talk about that.
00:04:00 We're going to talk about speaking of Supreme Court and things like that.
00:04:05 We're going to be talking about the federal government's hypocrisy around the use of the notwithstanding clause.
00:04:10 You may have heard the Ontario government invoked it, kind of casually, in dealing with a contract with Ontario government teachers, imposing a contract.
00:04:22 Well, everyone's lost their minds about it.
00:04:26 Trudeau's lost his mind about it.
00:04:28 Jagmeet Singh's lost his mind about it.
00:04:29 Not a big loss.
00:04:31 I don't remember hearing them say anything when it came to persecuting Anglophones, Muslims, Jews, and Sikhs in Quebec.
00:04:40 Maybe I just wasn't reading the news that day. I don't know. So we're going to talk about that.
00:04:45 And speaking of rights, today's a lot about real rights and fake rights.
00:04:49 Here's a right that hasn't had a lot of defenders in government lately.
00:04:53 Alberta Premier Danielle Smith talking about back pay for people who were government workers
00:05:00 in the last two, two and a half years who were fired for the terrible crime of being unvaccinated.
00:05:06 You'd think that makes sense.
00:05:08 But obviously the Alberta government's not been talking about that until very recently
00:05:11 because it was the Alberta government that did it.
00:05:14 So very interesting, and the usual suspects are lighting their hair on fire over it.
00:05:19 Okay, so let's start with the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:05:23 has ruled that putting people, we'll go back a little bit, 2011, Harper government passes a bill
00:05:30 that says that if you have two or more, if you commit a sexual offense, it's mandatory that you
00:05:38 go on the National Sex Offender Registry. And if it's two or more offenses, then it's for life.
00:05:44 It can't come off. There was a case, guy raped two girls in Calgary, or sexually offended them, 0.86
00:05:50 I'm not sure the details of it, but bad things.
00:05:54 And the Supreme Court of Canada just ruled that it was unconstitutional,
00:05:58 very cruel of us, not in keeping with our constitutional values here,
00:06:03 that he be on for life.
00:06:09 Nigel, give us a little background.
00:06:11 What the hell was the reasoning here?
00:06:13 So here's the thing.
00:06:15 The Harbour government took the view that the government was there to protect people.
00:06:19 And so we try to be fair to criminals, we try to be just,
00:06:24 but we are primarily interested in protecting people.
00:06:28 So this does not seem to be the consensus in what we've come to refer to as the Laurentian elites
00:06:36 from which the Supreme Court justices tend to be drawn.
00:06:41 So it was only a matter of time as the liberals have been taking apart everything that the Harper government did.
00:06:48 It was only a matter of time before eventually a case came up where they would have a chance to look at this issue again.
00:06:57 And in fact, it's taken 11 years. I'm surprised it took that long.
00:07:01 So it's a simple valid judgment.
00:07:04 They have decided that the rights of the criminal are more important than the rights of people to know who is moving into their area,
00:07:12 who is a person that they should keep their children away from
00:07:15 and should be kept away from their children.
00:07:18 To put it another way, you don't want these people getting jobs as school bus drivers.
00:07:23 And how else do you patrol this?
00:07:27 It's unfortunate, but then people shouldn't do this kind of thing,
00:07:30 and then it's not a problem for them.
00:07:32 Corey, the federal government – actually, I'll back up.
00:07:36 We'll talk about some provincial examples with the notwithstanding clause in a bit here,
00:07:40 a different segment, but you have the Alberta government has called for the federal government
00:07:47 to invoke the notwithstanding clause here. That would end this, that would strike down that
00:07:52 Supreme Court decision, and it would keep the mandatory rapist registry, as we might call it,
00:07:58 in place. But the federal government's never actually used the notwithstanding clause before.
00:08:04 Do you think that this would be a reasonable use of the notwithstanding clause to begin with? And second, how politically possible would it be? Do you think, because remember, it's not the conservatives who would be doing it. It would be the liberals who would invoke the notwithstanding clause in this case.
00:08:23 it would need the consent of all parliament and they would probably get it from the conservatives
00:08:27 probably maybe the NDP wouldn't or maybe the block I don't know but first how reasonable do
00:08:32 you think it'd be to evoke the notwithstanding clause here do you think the liberals with their
00:08:36 voter groups would actually be able to get away with this politically well we'd have to have the
00:08:40 will to do it I mean I think they have a valid case in saying public safety is at risk and we
00:08:45 need to fix the legislation you can even politically spin it and say hey Harper buggered it up but we 1.00
00:08:50 need to close that door right now, invoke the notwithstanding clause and get in and redraft it
00:08:55 and fix what the justices found wrong. I mean, there's a political way through, but they won't
00:08:58 do it. Particularly with the pissing match they've got with Doug Ford going on right now, they've
00:09:04 really gone on about how apparently extreme the notwithstanding clause is. And I mean, I was
00:09:08 looking up, if you look past too, with Ann McClellan, you might remember there was a case with Sharp,
00:09:13 his name was, he was a pedophile. And he actually, self-representing, got our child porn laws struck
00:09:19 down. Not many people realize that. And we did. He was definitely a pedophile and convicted.
00:09:25 Yes. Yes. No, no, we're not getting in trouble for that. Okay. And he was a noteworthy one. 0.96
00:09:30 It was all Corey. It was all Corey. If that's not true. And Ann McClellan was justice minister
00:09:36 at the time and the reform party was outraged and they did eventually close that and bring
00:09:41 in a new law, but it was a six month lapse of technically not having child porn laws for
00:09:45 possession, at least. It was still illegal to make it and create it and a few other things.
00:09:52 Like when we get to these sex offenders, I was looking it up. There's some really good stats
00:09:55 online with the federal government. And they're some of the worst, most dangerous recidivists 1.00
00:10:00 of any criminal category. And it takes some time. And the stats with a convicted sex offender, I
00:10:06 mean, it varies by the category, but within five years, it's something like only 10% of
00:10:10 re-offended, which is still discouraging. Within 15 years, 24% have re-offended.
00:10:17 And it's even higher with pedophiles.
00:10:19 Yes.
00:10:19 They tend to be much higher.
00:10:21 The worst one is actually pedophiles into boys, and that gets up into the 49% range.
00:10:26 But so we're talking about people, and I understand when you take the whole average,
00:10:30 75% won't re-offend, or at least won't be caught re-offending.
00:10:32 Yeah. I put the public safety first. I mean, 25, one in four of these people is going to reoffend. We have to know who they are. We have to prevent this as much as possible. And it's just ridiculous that they take this ability to track these guys away. It's dangerous.
00:10:52 Nigel, the liberals have kind of, it's odd. The liberals like to own the charter. They like to own the Constitution Act 1982 under Pierre Trudeau, but they don't like to own the notwithstanding clause. It's like they consider it the bastard child of the Constitution.
00:11:10 Now, to be fair to the Liberals, it wasn't in their initial drafts.
00:11:14 It was a part of the negotiations and the backs and forth to get it in,
00:11:17 because a lot of some of the Premiers didn't want a charter period.
00:11:21 They wanted to keep more of the common law British tradition
00:11:23 rather than a more American codified Bill of Rights style.
00:11:28 But it is a part of the Constitution.
00:11:30 And I think the Liberals have tried to make the case over quite a period of time
00:11:33 that it might be there, but it's not ever supposed to be used.
00:11:37 Do you think there's any reasonable political argument for the Liberals to make that, well, it's not generally supposed to be used, but it's a break glass in case of emergency case?
00:11:51 Well, geez, I think keeping pedophiles on a list and rapists on a list might be the case.
00:11:55 Do you think the Liberals could make a case that would not offend their base too much?
00:12:00 I actually don't. I don't think that it's that kind of a party anymore.
00:12:03 The Liberal Party that brought this in, first of all, you're absolutely right.
00:12:07 It was a deal. It was a thing that broke the logjam in the constitutional negotiations that took place in 1982.
00:12:15 It's actually to the credit of an Alberta Premier, Peter Lockheed, that we have this.
00:12:20 He, of course, had just come off the dust-up with the federal government over the national energy policy.
00:12:28 I doubt that he was thinking about pedophilia registries.
00:12:31 he was more thinking about energy legislation, but he said, we need something to stop
00:12:37 when the Supreme Court rules something that is very much against the interests of a province.
00:12:45 So this was the deal. Now, could they do it today? Well, I mean, theoretically they could,
00:12:51 but look who the liberals were back in 1982. Half of them were big-time lawyers,
00:12:57 people who had connections in business,
00:12:59 people who had met payroll,
00:13:01 they actually used to wrap themselves in the flag in those days.
00:13:05 It was a liberal government that gave us the maple leaf
00:13:08 and retired the old red ensign.
00:13:11 So they were the party of patriotism.
00:13:13 The conservatives thought they were,
00:13:15 but the liberals had the opportunity to do it,
00:13:17 and they did do it.
00:13:20 And so people went along with them.
00:13:21 That is not the liberal party of today.
00:13:27 I don't think there are two people in that caucus sitting there in Ottawa now who have ever met
00:13:32 payroll. What are they? They're academics. They're activists. We've got a...
00:13:38 Drama teachers. Part-time drama teachers.
00:13:41 What have you got against drama teachers, I ask?
00:13:44 Nothing. I just don't want to put them to be in charge of my life.
00:13:47 You just don't think they should be acting the main parts. I would agree with that.
00:13:52 All of which is to say that the center of gravity of what everybody reckons is common sense is very different in the Liberal Party today than it was back in 1982.
00:14:07 In 1982, you could have found liberals who would support hanging, you could have found liberals who were pro-life.
00:14:16 You won't find any of that kind of thinking these days.
00:14:19 Some of it is specifically excluded.
00:14:21 Certainly, the general sympathy, they don't think, just don't think about the common man.
00:14:27 They think about the exception, the victimized, the criminal, the marginalized.
00:14:31 Hence all this talk about equity, diversity, and inclusion.
00:14:35 That's where they're comfortable.
00:14:37 I've got a column that came out today titled, Register Rapists, Not Rifles.
00:14:44 And, you know, for me, I just, I felt like I was going nuts that, like, I don't know, I'm in my mid-30s.
00:14:51 I don't think I'm a curmudgeonly old man, but maybe I am. 0.85
00:14:54 Maybe I am the crazy one. 0.97
00:14:56 We're in Canada. 0.99
00:14:57 You register your gun, but we don't register rapists.
00:15:00 And that just, for me, crystallized so much of what's happened with postmodern, postnational Canada.
00:15:08 It just seems so detached from reality that this is where we are.
00:15:14 Some of it's ideology, some of it's political expediency.
00:15:17 So let's take the conversation now into areas where the notwithstanding clause is actually being used.
00:15:24 So over the last few years, the government of Quebec with France Lagos, the CAC, his party, weird name, invoking the notwithstanding clause pretty casually on some issues around taking away the rights of Anglophones to learn and use English in their lives,
00:15:46 taking away the rights of muslims jews sikhs and other uh religious minorities who have a visual 1.00
00:15:53 display of their faith from uh partaking in public life in many ways um and you heard very very little
00:16:02 from you know justin trudeau you'd hear some kind of navel gazing like well you know i'm concerned
00:16:08 by it uh we have to defend the rights of these minorities but wouldn't say anything about what
00:16:15 he would do to do it uh wouldn't commit to challenge did the same thing afraid of offending
00:16:20 quebec nationalists and certain xenophobic corners in that province even jagmeet singh
00:16:28 a sikh man who wears a turban has very visual displays of his faith good on him
00:16:35 was fairly muted, I would say, in his attacks on the Quebec government, afraid that that would
00:16:46 affect Quebec nationalists, which, you know, when the NDV had their one wave, they relied on Quebec
00:16:51 nationalists taking out the bloc. So very little, I'd say, muted criticism of Quebec when it uses
00:16:57 the notwithstanding clause to nakedly strip away real rights. But Ontario, the Ontario Doug Ford
00:17:05 government, just invoked the notwithstanding clause preemptively to impose a contract on
00:17:10 teachers to avert a strike and keep kids in the school. Well, all shit went down. It's raining 0.99
00:17:18 hell. The entire NDP caucus in the Ontario legislature was thrown out for breaking the
00:17:25 rules and being too disruptive during the debate on the bill. Jagmeet Singh has called for an
00:17:31 emergency debate on Ontario using the notwithstanding clause in a union contract and
00:17:35 Justin Trudeau condemning it terribly. I suppose I don't need to ask you both if this is hypocritical, 0.87
00:17:42 but we'll start with you, Nigel. What would drive naked hypocrisy of this level? Like, 0.94
00:17:48 how are they going to try and square this? That one is regrettable and you can muse about how
00:17:55 not great and the other one well we may as well invoke the emergencies act so uh i'll give you
00:18:00 two one would be that as far as the ndp is concerned it's the teachers union that is
00:18:07 one of the protagonists the ndp and the teachers union may as well be joined at the hip
00:18:12 they are best buds so of course they're going to go to bat for the for the union the other
00:18:19 the other reason that may appeal to mr trudeau at the moment is while we are talking about that
00:18:24 we're not talking about what's coming out of the inquiry into the trucker convoy some of which
00:18:30 doesn't make the government look too good at all so better to have a few if there's going to be
00:18:35 stuff in the papers let's have it in something which is we're not the all the bad guys we can
00:18:41 even represent ourselves as the good guys um i don't know corey how does the ndp square this one
00:18:49 Like, you know, they, you know, they're probably the most extreme in this saying Doug Ford is, you know, the new Hitler for imposing a contract on teachers.
00:19:01 But they have to.
00:19:02 That's what they are.
00:19:03 I mean, their money, their driving is from the unions.
00:19:07 If you look in the NDP constitution, I'm the dork who read it up with the provincial one and the federal one.
00:19:11 They have guaranteed seats on their provincial boards for all of the union heads in Canada.
00:19:15 They are a union party.
00:19:17 Most, not every single union, but yeah.
00:19:20 Pretty much, yes.
00:19:21 And Canadian Federation Labour, Alberta Federation Labour have guaranteed spaces, all of that.
00:19:24 So, I mean, they cannot not take a union side.
00:19:28 Likewise with Trudeau, he's got that alliance.
00:19:29 That's what's holding his government together right now.
00:19:32 And this is the only sort of deal breaker that could come with Singh.
00:19:36 They can't push back on a union.
00:19:39 Singh will have to break away from his liberal alliance at that point.
00:19:43 That would be the end of it.
00:19:44 So, Trudeau can't take another side on this one.
00:19:47 And I got a feeling they're getting some pressure.
00:19:48 There's a lot of Toronto parents, liberal voters,
00:19:51 who are not thrilled of having their kids held hostage by the teachers union right now.
00:19:54 But Trudeau is in a rock and a hard space.
00:19:56 And plus, as Nigel said, it's a nice distraction from these emergency act hearings
00:20:01 that they really don't want people focusing on right now.
00:20:07 Well, let's talk about the foreign government.
00:20:10 I don't think any of us are great sympathizers with government unions
00:20:16 that try to establish a monopoly over our kids' educations. 1.00
00:20:20 But I will say I'm a little concerned with how casually the notwithstanding clause is used here.
00:20:26 You know, in my column I was saying today, the notwithstanding clause, if it's going to be used, should be used rarely.
00:20:33 It shouldn't be used flippantly.
00:20:36 And I think the federal government used it pretty casually here.
00:20:39 Now, the federal government, to be fair, has been very casual about violating people's rights over the last few years.
00:20:44 The difference is now with someone else's rights. The NDP cared not when they were violating the rights of vaccine refusenix or people who didn't want to shut down the businesses and go bankrupt.
00:20:55 They didn't care there when rights were flippantly violated. This is being used fairly casually.
00:21:01 Now, I know Howard Englund, he writes for The Hub, you know, he was saying he had an argument. I'm not sure if I agree with it, but I thought it was at least worth thinking about that since the advent of the charter, the courts have been very casual about pushing into the legislative space out of their own spheres as the judicial review and oversight and making themselves effectively alternate legislators.
00:21:26 And so because the judiciary has been casual about butting into legislation, well, perhaps it's appropriate then that we do use the notwithstanding clause casually to push the courts back into their own spaces.
00:21:39 I'm open to the argument, but I'm not sold on it yet.
00:21:43 What do you think, Nigel?
00:21:44 Do you think, first, is this a casual use of the notwithstanding clause?
00:21:47 Is it a little too casual for comfort, first?
00:21:50 And two, do you think it's appropriate to use it casually to try and push the courts back into their own space?
00:21:55 Well, okay, on the last first, I'm all for pushing the courts back into their space.
00:22:00 Not sure that this is what does it, but at any rate, back 40 years ago, it was pretty obvious that if you wanted to get something done, once the charter was in place, you'll find yourself a lawyer, never mind your Member of Parliament.
00:22:15 That's not where the locus of authority is anymore.
00:22:18 um as for whether ford did this casually i don't think anybody drops the notwithstanding clause
00:22:27 casually it is considered to be the nuclear option i should let me rephrase that nobody outside of
00:22:32 quebec the very first thing no no seriously the very first thing that quebec did in 1982 was it
00:22:38 repealed all its legislation you find this on a government of canada website if you really
00:22:43 you know you think this is a surprising thing to learn but they repeal all of
00:22:49 their legislation and immediately replaced it with legislation that had
00:22:53 the notwithstanding clause in it all other language legislation yeah no no
00:22:58 everything oh everything everything oh wow everything then had a five-year
00:23:02 limit on it and it's all explained in the in this federal document so so they've
00:23:10 always just said oh yeah that we don't like that notwithstanding what the courts have said we're
00:23:17 going to ignore it so they did they have they've set the pattern on this if you think that any use
00:23:24 of the uh the notwithstanding clause is too casual go to quebec they've got something there that will
00:23:30 make a case for you so now come back to ontario if this was quick if that was if that whole
00:23:36 situation had unraveled in Quebec they would have done the same thing if they thought it suited their
00:23:41 interests and nobody would use it in language or kind of racist ethnic stuff Quebec supremacy well
00:23:49 they don't tend to use it on this kind of thing at least that I recall only because the situation
00:23:54 hasn't presented itself in quite the same way but I mean here you've been in Ontario
00:23:59 so you have as I understand the situation correctly the two sides can't agree
00:24:03 ends up in court the court says makes a decision the ontario government doesn't like it so well
00:24:09 notwithstanding the court's decision you guys are going back to work and all the parents say hurrah
00:24:14 everybody worries about the rights of the teachers i wonder what the rights of the parents are the
00:24:18 kids or the kids well both actually but you know the kids need their education i mean is this is
00:24:26 Is teaching one of these occupations that you're not allowed, shouldn't be allowed to strike?
00:24:32 I don't think we've had that discussion, but now that we've seen what two years when the kids had very intermittent education,
00:24:40 now we've seen what that looks like.
00:24:42 My introduction to politics was in the fifth grade in Ontario.
00:24:44 I remember Mike Harris was the premier, and the teachers went on strike.
00:24:49 And I was one of those kids who didn't like school.
00:24:51 I didn't necessarily get along with some of my teachers at least.
00:24:54 And I was thinking, like, well, when I don't go to school, I get in trouble.
00:24:58 How come the teachers don't have to go to school?
00:25:00 And I heard the teachers tried to brainwash all the kids with a bunch of union propaganda to go home and tell the parents Mike Harris was this evil man.
00:25:08 He must be stopped.
00:25:09 And I was just thinking, like, something's wrong with that.
00:25:12 That was kind of my first time I became politically aware is when those teachers went on strike and tried to use the children as pawns.
00:25:18 Because they tried to use me as a pawn.
00:25:20 And it was kind of the first time I really started to think, I think someone's using me, and it's not my best interest they have at heart here.
00:25:27 Interesting that you should raise that, the way the teachers were propagandizing the kids.
00:25:34 We have a columnist, and I'm going to give him a shout-out now.
00:25:38 His name is John Hilton O'Brien, and in the last week, he has written two articles about recent school board elections in B.C. and in Ontario.
00:25:48 and how the unions, the teachers' unions, have been running a slate of candidates for school boards.
00:25:57 So the body that is actually supposed to negotiate the school contract
00:26:03 is now being taken over by the people who will benefit from a favorable distribution of that contract.
00:26:11 Not all of their candidates got elected, but a huge number of them did.
00:26:15 And that is now the strategy.
00:26:18 Well, and they're often very successful in those school board elections because they have incredibly low voter turnout.
00:26:22 57 out of 82 in Ontario, I believe is the number that Mr. O'Brien was putting.
00:26:27 It's out there now on our website.
00:26:29 Very few people vote in these things because you don't know who they are.
00:26:32 But the unions get very actively organized because they have a huge interest in it.
00:26:36 I never even know who to vote for.
00:26:38 Like, it's held during municipal elections.
00:26:40 I show up to the polls.
00:26:41 I'm like, I know who I'm voting for for mayor and for my councillor. 1.00
00:26:43 And they're like, shit, school boards. 0.98
00:26:45 What I do is I pull out my phone, I see who the Alberta Peters Association has endorsed, and I vote for the next name on the list. 0.99
00:26:50 All right, I want to come to you.
00:26:53 I'll put the main question to you.
00:26:56 I mean, I doubt you're very sympathetic with the union here.
00:26:59 We probably like the idea of keeping kids in school, but do you think this was perhaps a little too casual use of it, or do you think it was justified?
00:27:07 You know, it's a hard one.
00:27:08 I mean, I am not a fan of unions.
00:27:09 Never have been, that's for sure.
00:27:11 But I do understand the reason for the right to collective bargaining.
00:27:14 And it is a right.
00:27:16 And when a government feels that they can just keep invoking that,
00:27:20 if they don't like the deal they're getting, I think, is an abuse of the clause.
00:27:23 That wasn't supposed to be an escape hatch to get you out of a difficult negotiation with a union.
00:27:28 And you do have to go to court first.
00:27:30 Yes.
00:27:31 You have to lose once first before you can.
00:27:34 Well, no, but they did it preemptively here.
00:27:35 They didn't even go to court to lose.
00:27:37 They probably knew they would.
00:27:40 I suppose some of that is, though, based on some poor Supreme Court rulings that give undue powers to government sector unions.
00:27:48 It's a complicated issue.
00:27:49 I mean, what I'd rather see, that's just me blue-skying, but I'd rather see work towards school choice than give people an option away from the unions.
00:27:56 Hey, you want to go to those schools where they go on strike every few years, you put your kid there.
00:28:00 But if you don't want that, you can put your kid into the good school.
00:28:03 Or sorry, they're not in union school.
00:28:06 But that's a hard task, and that's years of work, and that's fighting the unions.
00:28:09 uh you know pulling the pin on the notwithstanding clause was was easier for the short term it probably
00:28:15 does make more sense in the long term just to build more school choice to break them but not
00:28:19 like ontario's got much more of a we have a semi-monopoly from the government schools here
00:28:24 in alberta but in ontario it's much much stronger uh you don't get the charter schools private
00:28:30 schools are limited do only the genuinely rich because none of the money follows the kids so
00:28:35 you in alberta you've got middle class people who send their kids to private school i mean it's hard
00:28:38 for families, but they can do it because some of that money can follow the kids.
00:28:42 That would probably seem to be a better way to, you know, hey, fine, you know, you want
00:28:46 to keep sending your kids to a school where the teachers are on strike every few years
00:28:49 and they've got poor outcomes and tests.
00:28:52 Yeah, well, fine, but let's make it more available for parents to send their kids to 0.63
00:28:56 real schools, not run by the unions.
00:29:00 Huge number of people homeschooling now, too.
00:29:03 Ten percent or something in Alberta. 0.61
00:29:06 So, okay, we talked about a lot of hypocrisy. I think there's a bit more hypocrisy that we can use to pivot into the next one. Well, you've got the government unions in Alberta here, and then the Alberta Federation of Labor, which is kind of the umbrella, kind of a Marxist umbrella organization of the unions here, that didn't really say boo when the Kenney government started firing people from their jobs for not being vaccinated.
00:29:35 This is one of the few times the ATA seemed to really get along with the Kennedy government.
00:29:39 They probably, I don't think they actually give it any credit, but at least they didn't criticize it.
00:29:43 They were not protecting their own workers.
00:29:46 Their own workers were being let go from their jobs for nothing to do with performance,
00:29:52 nothing to do with not doing the hours, just for their own health care choice.
00:29:56 But we've got a new premier here now, and Danielle Smith, yeah, isn't committed to it, 0.98
00:30:00 But she has mused publicly about the potential of back pay for people who worked for the government or AHS, things like that, who were let go from their jobs for being unvaccinated.
00:30:13 They may have been furloughed or fired, a combination of these things.
00:30:16 But people who suffered financially for their jobs because of government mandates.
00:30:22 Corey, one, I think I know what you're going to say.
00:30:26 It's a good idea.
00:30:27 I'm going to assume you think it's a good idea.
00:30:28 but so let's go something maybe a little stick here do you think it's a good idea politically
00:30:34 because uh smith has you know one of the big groups that put her into the premier's office
00:30:40 in the ucp leadership race where people angry about mandatory vaccination lockdowns things like
00:30:46 this but you know as much as that might animate the three of us here a lot of people just they
00:30:52 don't want to fight about this anymore she's already doing a lot on this front do you think 0.92
00:30:57 it's too politically risky for her to go down this path. I just hope that maybe politically, 0.99
00:31:01 she's trying to get all this out of the way now so that after Christmas, she can focus on policy
00:31:06 and winning the next election. Because if she is going to keep hanging up on mask mandates on
00:31:11 the vaccination, which I know are important. And I know some people were terribly wronged and they
00:31:15 lost their jobs. And she based her leadership on talking to that. But politically, people do want
00:31:20 this behind us. And I know those who were kicked out of their jobs still take it very seriously as
00:31:25 they should, but she can't keep focused on what a lot of people are seeing as being in the rearview
00:31:31 mirror. The NDP are going to rip her to shreds. We are now looking at economic recovery, worried
00:31:35 about inflation. We're worried about cost of living, healthcare. And if we're constantly
00:31:42 seeing the news about vaccination and masking, which aren't really contemporary issues now,
00:31:47 they're still pressing again for the damage they've done. It's going to cost her politically. 0.99
00:31:51 Like I said, I understand why she's doing it. I just hope that maybe she's just getting it
00:31:55 done now then so that she can move on to the other things because uh it's not going to help
00:31:59 her in the long run i think nigel is this um i mean there's kind of a whole there's a lot of 0.52
00:32:05 people still pissed off about this i'm still pissed off about it even though a lot of it
00:32:09 probably affected me a lot less but people have a right to be angry about this but it is
00:32:15 i think the majority of albertans unfortunately not maybe as big a majority as the mainstream
00:32:21 media would say, but I think at least a very large number of Albertans, they don't want to
00:32:26 re-litigate this anymore. And she does have to win over a broader audience. Do you think this is just
00:32:32 not a good idea politically, or it's a good idea politically, but she has to do it now and then
00:32:37 move on? Or is this just a bad idea, or just a great idea, and she should ride this all the way?
00:32:42 I'll take your second option. The time to have the discussion was before you ever opened your
00:32:48 mouth now that that expectation is out there if it is not met it is the people who voted for her
00:32:55 who will be disappointed she's got to go through with it otherwise you know we've seen a lot of
00:33:03 we've seen a number of instances where people who we have voted for and trusted to do what they said
00:33:12 they were going to do, have gone into power, and I guess the fashionable word is pivoted.
00:33:19 We hate that.
00:33:21 And if she sends a message to the people who were voting for her, who were animated by
00:33:30 this issue, that, well, okay, maybe it's politically not so smart after all, there will be disappointment.
00:33:37 can only do that so many times before that disappointment turns into staying away from
00:33:44 the polls. She needs them out there next May. So she's got to go through with it now.
00:33:50 Well, let's talk about, let's say she does this. And also, you know, in her interview with me a few
00:33:55 weeks ago at the ECB convention, she talked about essentially pardoning people who, you know,
00:34:00 pastors or restaurant owners, people who were jailed, arrested, ticketed, fined for the crimes
00:34:06 of going about their lives and doing their jobs.
00:34:09 Let's say she gets all of that done.
00:34:11 I think there's going to be a short session of the legislature
00:34:13 after she's expected to win her by-election next week. 0.64
00:34:17 Then she comes in.
00:34:18 She's going to do Sovereignty Act, Bill 1. 0.70
00:34:20 That's the clearest expectation.
00:34:22 I think that's what we're still expecting.
00:34:25 Let's say she goes boom, boom, boom.
00:34:26 She knocks all this stuff off.
00:34:30 She gets it out of the way.
00:34:32 What do you think she should do then when she comes out of the gate
00:34:35 in January and February, after the Christmas break here.
00:34:41 Is it a pivot that she should undertake or just kind of a focus?
00:34:44 She said, I delivered on these things, now focus on other issues.
00:34:46 What does she do to try and pull the UCP back up from the crappy poll numbers 1.00
00:34:51 that it's suffered from for the last few years?
00:34:53 Well, the thing that everybody, there are a lot of people who care about the things
00:34:57 we've just been talking about.
00:34:58 Get it done by Christmas, yes.
00:35:01 And after that, what are the other things that we all care about?
00:35:04 Inflation.
00:35:04 What's she going to do about that? 0.80
00:35:06 Is she going to drop the provincial tax on gasoline, for example?
00:35:14 That's a relatively easy thing to do.
00:35:17 What else can she do to bring down the cost of living in Alberta? 1.00
00:35:21 Maybe adjust the flat tax.
00:35:24 I don't know what the budget will be.
00:35:25 Well, we don't have a flat tax anymore.
00:35:26 We haven't since Prentice killed it.
00:35:28 10%, isn't it?
00:35:29 Not anymore, not since Jim Prentice.
00:35:31 He made it progressive.
00:35:32 Jim Prentice made it progressive.
00:35:33 Notley made it more progressive, and Kenny made it even more progressive by bringing in bracket cream. 0.99
00:35:40 I was in Ottawa.
00:35:41 Actually, yeah, Jason Kenney had the highest income tax rates of any premier, including Rachel Notley.
00:35:48 So maybe we bring back the flat tax.
00:35:51 Maybe we can bring it back to the 10%. 1.00
00:35:53 That would help a lot of people.
00:35:55 I would say 10% is good enough for God.
00:35:57 It should be good enough for the government.
00:35:59 I would have to agree with you all that.
00:36:02 I would say amen.
00:36:05 Preach.
00:36:05 Okay.
00:36:07 No, that's the next thing.
00:36:08 It's the cost of living.
00:36:09 It's giving people a sense of hope, getting those who want to work back to work.
00:36:14 And let's hope there's some money in the kitty from oil prices because that makes a lot of things possible.
00:36:23 Otherwise, it doesn't matter how good a premier you are.
00:36:26 You just can't do what you know you ought to.
00:36:29 Corey, let's say she does Sovereignty Act. 1.00
00:36:32 She does, you know, a Mensa Human Rights Act to protect unvaccinated people from being fired and things like that. 1.00
00:36:39 She does back pay. 0.98
00:36:40 She pardons the pastors and small business owners.
00:36:43 She gets all these things done.
00:36:45 These are things that people like us like.
00:36:48 That's red meat stuff.
00:36:49 We like it.
00:36:50 But I recognize, you know, the three of us aren't the only voters in the province here.
00:36:54 There's other people who are, you know, not quite so hardcore.
00:36:59 coming into the new year what do you think is the big thing she can do to try and win back some of 0.96
00:37:05 those people who have walked away from the uc because it was not uh it was a combination of
00:37:09 kind of center and center left voters who walked away from the ucp but obviously a lot of people
00:37:14 on the right they walked to the wild rows those people polls are coming back in pretty big numbers
00:37:18 but she's still going to bring back the other side too yeah well like nigel said don't you can't 0.64
00:37:22 turn her back now on these things they're out get them done but that's interesting take a get it 0.99
00:37:26 done, go to the Christmas holidays, people calm down, because we know the media and everybody
00:37:29 going to go wild when she brings these in, they'll cool down, we get into the new year. And it's the
00:37:34 now it's the session before the election. And I think it's going to be economy, economy, economy,
00:37:38 people are worried about their bills, making their mortgages, the interest rates are expected to keep
00:37:43 going up. And as Nigel said, too, she's going to have a good pool of probably energy royalties to
00:37:50 stand upon plus standing up to Ottawa, because as we build up that pool, while the rest of the
00:37:55 countries hurt under high energy prices. I still think, I wrote a column to say such today,
00:38:01 there's going to be a grab soon. They're not going to let us just keep prospering like this.
00:38:04 He's going to seem just like Biden. I'd say more of a grab than there already is.
00:38:08 Yes. So they grab automatically. She's going to have her hands full. But I think, again,
00:38:12 I mean, a lot of it divided and a lot of what really hurt the Kennedy government and the UCP
00:38:15 in general was the pandemic was divisive. There were people, there were very conservative people
00:38:21 who were still very supportive of vaccine mandates. There were very conservative people
00:38:24 who were, you know, supportive of the masking mandates.
00:38:28 It crossed the bounds of political ideology.
00:38:31 But people got, they were deal breakers and they left.
00:38:34 That's why I'm saying she's got to get this pandemic thing off the table 1.00
00:38:37 and bring people back to conservative values
00:38:39 and quit fighting and relitigating the last two years.
00:38:42 The only thing somebody else wrote about that,
00:38:44 that was she's also banking on,
00:38:47 let's hope there's not a big resurgence of COVID
00:38:48 because if that comes along,
00:38:50 then it's going to be the top issue again
00:38:52 and it's just going to be hard.
00:38:53 it's nasty. Yeah. What do you think about school vouchers? I love it. Yeah. Think she should do 1.00
00:38:59 that? I maybe after winning a majority. Actually, so actually, let's put it back in. Let's,
00:39:09 it's a hypothetical, but you're not politicians. So you're allowed to answer a hypothetical.
00:39:15 Let's say, I mean, we're already in the phone stuff. Like we're indoors. I mean,
00:39:19 when we had the last wave, when we saw the vaccine mandates, like mandatory vaccines and
00:39:24 return of masking and all this stuff, that was like end of August, like literally even before
00:39:30 the best summer ever was technically over, it happened. But let's say there was a resurgence
00:39:36 on par with that. Can, would Smith survive more than a few weeks if she reimposed mandates 1.00
00:39:48 of any kind, of any kind.
00:39:51 Do you think she wouldn't survive?
00:39:52 No. Not a chance.
00:39:54 That's why I'm saying resurgence. Well, she might not
00:39:56 survive a resurgence no matter how it goes
00:39:58 because she's in a corner. This is
00:40:00 what she built herself on. She can't. 0.58
00:40:02 Well, that would be assuming that
00:40:03 she couldn't survive
00:40:06 not doing it.
00:40:08 I feel like at least her caucus would probably
00:40:10 stand by her. She'd have to try it. So the model 1.00
00:40:12 for that is Mr. Kenny.
00:40:14 I know we sort of disagree a little bit
00:40:16 about Mr. Kenney, and I'm perhaps a little more sympathetic to him than you are, but there is no
00:40:23 question that COVID was the thing that killed him because he didn't do what we figure is the right
00:40:31 thing on that. So if what Mr. Kenney did, which was to give in to the experts, experts should be
00:40:39 on tap, not on top. And Mr. Kenney allowed them to be on top. Well, certain experts. He did not
00:40:48 have the economic experts. He did not have the social experts. One kind of expert. That is what
00:40:54 Premier Smith cannot afford to do. She does what Jason Kenney did. She'll go the same way that Jason
00:41:01 Kenney did. Let me put it another way. Could she survive going full Ron DeSantis? We have a wave. 0.88
00:41:06 and she says, you know what?
00:41:08 We're not doing what Ottawa's doing.
00:41:10 We're not doing what the rest of the country is doing.
00:41:11 We're going our own way.
00:41:13 We're not shutting down.
00:41:14 We're going to have a bunch of rapid testing
00:41:15 and community health care stuff.
00:41:16 We're going to do all these other things to react to it,
00:41:19 but we're not locking down.
00:41:20 We're not doing forced masking.
00:41:22 We're not doing mandatory vaccination.
00:41:24 Could she survive that?
00:41:26 If things didn't turn worse here
00:41:29 than in other areas where they did in force,
00:41:31 which I think a lot of us believe it's negligible,
00:41:34 the impact that masking mandates had or some of these vaccine passports.
00:41:37 So if she took that approach and the increase, if there was even one,
00:41:42 in Alberta of deaths or infections wasn't perceptively higher than other provinces,
00:41:48 she'll have made her point and I think actually kind of glide in.
00:41:51 But if we're even 5% higher in deaths than other provinces
00:41:54 and she hasn't locked things down, she'll pay the price for it.
00:41:57 Yeah, and you know, one of the things that would drive that,
00:41:59 there would undoubtedly be a federal and provincial response.
00:42:03 you would find that we've already seen the issue of BC keeping RCMP at the border
00:42:09 and saying, do you have a valid reason for driving west, out of Alberta?
00:42:13 I'm going to go and see my property on the island.
00:42:16 Well, no, sir, not today. You're not. Go back.
00:42:19 We've seen that already.
00:42:20 And that was when everybody was playing the official tune.
00:42:25 So step away from that, and who knows what you might see.
00:42:28 But I think she has to try it.
00:42:30 That's the thing. Only a year ago, we had internal borders like we were East Germany.
00:42:34 It's just wild. Okay. Well, we're going to wrap it up there. Nigel, Corey, thank you very much.
00:42:41 Thank all of you for joining us as well. But stay tuned. At the end of this, we have got the
00:42:47 agriculture report from market commodities. Stay tuned. Get the latest prices and the lowdown on
00:42:53 what's going on in the Western Canadian agricultural commodities market. Thank you very much. God bless.
00:42:59 Here's today's ag report from Wintry, Lethbridge. Cash barley is trading at $4.55, feed wheat is off a couple bucks at $4.73, and corn is lower at $4.75 for metric ton.
00:43:09 In the milling wheat markets, December Minneapolis futures dropped 41 cents at $9.48, with local harder at spring bid for November-December movement at $12 per bushel.
00:43:19 In the oilseeds, nearby canola futures are higher $7.70 at $8.91 per ton, with delivered
00:43:26 values for December movement at $20 per bushel. In the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices
00:43:32 are trading at $0.34 per pound and yellow peas remain at $13 per bushel. In the cattle markets,
00:43:39 December live cattle are lower $0.47.5 at $1.51.48 per hundredweight. For more information on Fob
00:43:46 farm options, give me a call at 403-394-1711. I'm Matt Busiekum at Marketplace Commodities,
00:43:53 accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:44:16 We'll be right back.