Western Standard - September 15, 2022


The Pipeline: Poilievre's landslide win

Topics
Mentioned
HANNAFORD Poilievre and the many hypocrisies of Justin Trudeau The Great Sovereignty Act Debate clip

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

181.16

Word count

7,312

Sentence count

525

Harmful content

Misogyny

22

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Western Standard Opinion Editor and Publisher Derek P. DeBrandt and Editor-in-Chief Nigel Henniford discuss Tory Leader Jason Kenney's landslide victory in the United Conservative Party leadership race. They also talk about what the victory means for the future of the party and what it could mean for Alberta's next leader and premier.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Phil DeBrandt, publisher of the Western Standard. You're watching The
00:00:23 Pipeline today on September 14th, 2022. And boy, it has been a beautiful day. We've got a great
00:00:31 show today. Let me introduce my co-belligerents, Western Standard Opinion Editor, Nigel Henniford.
00:00:38 How are you? I'm great. How's everybody? It's good. Octoberfest is coming. I'm stockpiling beer,
00:00:45 polishing lederhosen. Glad to hear that. Yeah. We'll help you. You're not a big fan of leather
00:00:51 the pants, Corey? I just didn't like thinking of polishing your lederhosen. I don't actually polish
00:00:54 the lederhosen. Actually, the way you do it is when I was in Munich for Oktoberfest, there was
00:00:58 this old, old guy I was drinking beer with. He had these beat up old lederhosen and I said, wow,
00:01:04 they've taken a lot. You know, mine are getting kind of worn out too and I can't find a place
00:01:08 with dry cleaners. You never dry clean the lederhosen. You take the oil on your hands from
00:01:13 like chicken or sausages or something. You take the oil and you rub it through the lederhosen.
00:01:17 and it gives it good protection.
00:01:19 I've known more of a Russian accent, I guess it sounds like.
00:01:22 But, yeah, that's how you polish it,
00:01:24 because you just take grease from food and rub it into it, and it protects it.
00:01:28 Greasy, my greasy leather pants.
00:01:30 That's an amazing heritage you're preserving.
00:01:34 It's our proudest moment.
00:01:37 Okay, well, we've got an interesting story today,
00:01:39 a set of discussion topics today.
00:01:43 Polyeb's landslide win, absolutely killing it,
00:01:46 crushing, annihilating, I don't know how many adjectives I can use to describe
00:01:50 Polyev's win. We're going to talk about what the hell happened, reality, expectation versus reality.
00:01:58 Also, the Western Standard has commissioned Main Street Poll to conduct a series of scientific
00:02:04 polls across Alberta, some very interesting data. We have a real, we did on a number of topics,
00:02:09 real focus on the UCP leadership race, but a few other things as well. Danielle Smith leading the
00:02:14 race, unsurprisingly, but we've got a breakdown of where that's at and what it could mean for
00:02:19 the selection of Alberta's next UCP leader and premier. Also, we pulled Albertans of where they
00:02:25 stand on the Sovereignty Act. In particular, how does it break down within the United Conservative
00:02:31 Party? Very interesting numbers coming up. The numbers certainly don't support a lot of the
00:02:36 strategies that are being pursued by at least some of the camps. Also polling, who Albertans
00:02:42 trust more mainstream media or independent and alternative media sources? Well, I know how you,
00:02:49 I know what you guys trust more. Of course you should watch the CBC, the schmucks. Yeah, no, 1.00
00:02:54 I'm just joking. We've done some polling on what kind of media Albertans like to go to.
00:02:59 Before we get into it, though, we got to thank my favorite sponsor. Oh, they're just wonderful,
00:03:04 the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. I've been a member of the CSSA for well over a decade
00:03:09 because I trust them as Canada's leading gun rights organization, defending our right to buy
00:03:15 and use firearms safely and legally in Canada against the federal government's constant attempts
00:03:20 to take those rights away. Without the CSSA, they would have taken our guns long, long ago. And yes,
00:03:26 they try, but whatever rights we have got left are thanks to groups like the Canadian Shooting
00:03:30 Sports Association. If you're not yet a member of the CSSA, go join right now. Go to cssa-cila.org.
00:03:39 And yes, I asked Corey before the show started so I could write it down.
00:03:43 That's the first time I got it right, isn't it, Corey?
00:03:45 It's a rare occasion, yeah.
00:03:47 Rare occasion.
00:03:48 And I always just remind everybody, just kind of Google it anyways.
00:03:50 You'll find it pretty fast.
00:03:51 Yeah.
00:03:52 It's easier.
00:03:53 If my CSSA friends are watching, please change the URL.
00:03:56 It's terrible. 0.99
00:03:56 But just Google the damn thing. 0.99
00:03:58 Google it. 0.98
00:03:59 Okay, so let's jump right into this, guys.
00:04:03 Crushing.
00:04:05 Massive.
00:04:06 Destroying.
00:04:07 I don't know how many more adjectives we can use to describe this.
00:04:13 Anything?
00:04:13 I know we had our own predictions down.
00:04:15 Corey actually, just for those of you who didn't watch our live broadcast Saturday,
00:04:19 Corey actually won the office pool on it.
00:04:21 He was entitled to quite a few six-packs of beer.
00:04:23 He very generously declined a lot of good, expensive beer.
00:04:29 I could have used it.
00:04:30 Oktoberfest coming.
00:04:31 I could have really used that beer.
00:04:32 I did not win.
00:04:33 Corey edged me out for the top spot.
00:04:37 Instead, he took his prize in the form of a pizza party for all the staff in the Calgary headquarters.
00:04:41 Very nice.
00:04:42 I'm getting bloated now, thanks to us.
00:04:43 Yeah.
00:04:45 So the win was not really unexpected.
00:04:48 It was actually even higher than both our predictions.
00:04:50 It was about 68% in points, 70% in terms of popular vote.
00:04:56 So let's not talk about expectations versus reality, actually.
00:04:58 We all expected this to be huge, maybe a little bit bigger, some of us were thinking.
00:05:02 But I want your thoughts.
00:05:03 What does this mean for the Conservative Party?
00:05:05 Polyev has won with the biggest mandate of any leader in the history of that party,
00:05:09 obviously more than Scheer and O'Toole, but even more than Stephen Harper did,
00:05:13 both in terms of points percentage and in terms of number of votes and popular vote percentage.
00:05:18 What do you think this means for Polyev coming in as the new leader?
00:05:22 Nothing bad, that's for sure.
00:05:24 I mean, one of the grim predictions leveled against Polyev from the beginning was,
00:05:31 well, he'll do well in Alberta, but he won't do so well back east.
00:05:34 well what happened out of 338 riding associations he carried 330 of them so that means that at least
00:05:43 70 of them in Quebec voted for everything but six in Quebec and two in Ontario so first of all the
00:05:52 there's something going on across the country I think it's particularly strong here in Alberta
00:05:57 but if you look at the way people are engaging with politics at the moment the number of people
00:06:02 for example who went to red who wanted to go to red deer last year for the leadership or in fact
00:06:07 it was march of this year for the leadership review i mean not only those events get about a
00:06:12 thousand two hundred twelve hundred people there were uh are near twenty thousand people who wanted
00:06:17 to go like wanting to go to a leadership review like that means paying a hundred dollars and
00:06:22 driving halfway across the province to get there because whether you're starting from calvary or
00:06:27 edmonton you know red deer's in the middle so there was a tremendous commitment to making a
00:06:32 statement whether it was for the premier or against a lot of people wanted to do that you
00:06:39 look at the turnout that you get in some of the uh some of the constituency association meetings now
00:06:45 to put in the new board that's going to go in that was 450 i think came out to leela here's
00:06:51 board meeting.
00:06:54 A local AGM.
00:06:55 I've never heard of a local AGM
00:06:56 with anything approaching that.
00:06:57 A hundred would be a lot.
00:06:58 Yeah, 50, 60 is kind of normal.
00:07:01 So something was obviously going on there.
00:07:05 Something was obviously going on
00:07:07 that thousands of truckers
00:07:09 converged on Ottawa
00:07:11 and thousands more people
00:07:13 joined them either on the streets
00:07:15 or in echo events around the country.
00:07:17 So something has happened in this country
00:07:19 that is causing people who normally wouldn't even write a letter to the editor
00:07:25 to get on their bike, get in their truck, get on the plane,
00:07:30 go somewhere and do something and make a statement.
00:07:33 Now, that is the wave of unrest that I think has helped Pierre Oliver
00:07:41 move into such a commanding position.
00:07:44 Like right now, if there was an election tomorrow,
00:07:46 So that particular campaign is already on a war footing.
00:07:51 I would be surprised if Mr. Trudeau would even want to dare risk it.
00:07:55 He's surfing it.
00:07:58 Corey, I think, you know,
00:08:01 Nigel's essentially arguing that he's captured lightning in a bottle.
00:08:04 There is this big tsunami coming right now,
00:08:07 and you could see Polyev on his surfboard wearing a nice Hawaiian shirt,
00:08:12 riding it to a crushing victory.
00:08:13 but the magnitude of his victory you know it's not these little piecemeal down ballot things
00:08:21 Andrew Sheard I think took 13 ballots to win and he didn't win a single one of them until the very
00:08:25 last one and there were even questions about that last ballot and then you have O'Toole I think it
00:08:32 took a good number of ballots for him to win and he needed the clear support of social conservative
00:08:36 king makers to get there before he threw them overboard he threw Leslie Lewis overboard he
00:08:41 through Derek Sloan overboard. Polyev doesn't seem to owe anyone anything here. It's his party.
00:08:49 What do you think that means for the ability of Polyev to maybe remake the conservative party 0.89
00:08:57 in his mold? Well, I don't know if he's looking to remake things, but the bottom line is he's got
00:09:01 the mandate. He's got the authority. He can move. I mean, nobody can question where he's going to go
00:09:06 right now he just got 68 percent in a hard walk you know fought race within that party and the
00:09:11 closest was charay at 16 so it's not like there was even a close second contender so it gives him
00:09:17 a lot of leeway to stay on message people can't keep saying to him you have to tone it down now
00:09:22 you have to lighten up i mean there's a degree of looking at the federal picture now but he's in
00:09:27 charge i mean he he's been proven right on where he's gone and the way he's done it and i imagine
00:09:32 he's going to continue to. And it's not, it's as Nigel says, people are looking for change.
00:09:36 They're getting off their butts and they're doing something. And, you know, it's not like he had
00:09:41 pretty hair and was of a rockstar quality. He's a bit of a geeky looking guy, you know,
00:09:47 and, but it's the messaging people came on to him. And that's a stronger base of support than
00:09:53 somebody looking for, you know, something fluffy. He could do some great things here.
00:09:56 So we talked about this on Saturday evening when he gave his acceptance speech, which I think he was pretty confident he was going to be allowed to give, about potential pivot.
00:10:09 He definitely didn't throw any of his policies and signature ideas off, but there were some things that he talked about regularly, his biggest applause lines during campaign events that were not in that speech.
00:10:22 you didn't hear talk about digital currencies like Bitcoin. You didn't hear talk about defunding
00:10:27 the CBC and ending media subsidies. Still talked about, in general, about freedom and things like
00:10:34 that. You know, a lot of the punditry has speculated, is he going to pivot? Is he going
00:10:40 to pivot? Do you think this was a pivot of any kind? And if so, was it a pivot of substance or
00:10:47 just rhetoric. What do you think? Maybe a pivot of rhetoric. I mean, first of all, the regular
00:10:53 mainstream media, the state-supported media, as we refer to them, are not going to give this man
00:11:01 a break in any sense. So if he does well, well, he could have done better. If he says this, well,
00:11:07 he could have said that. So the fact that he did not make further reference to defunding the CBC
00:11:14 does not mean the idea has gone away.
00:11:17 It just means come back another day
00:11:19 when the time is right.
00:11:21 Didn't talk about, I don't think you mentioned
00:11:23 firing the governor of the Bank of Canada either.
00:11:27 But, you know, do you think that,
00:11:29 I don't think that that matter is at rest.
00:11:32 Whether the governor stays or the governor goes,
00:11:34 it's the policy that has to change.
00:11:36 And that is what, that is,
00:11:38 every indication that Mr. Poliver means
00:11:41 to cut back on the inflationary spending that has brought about the situation we're all
00:11:48 struggling with now are the gas pumps in the grocery stores. So I don't see a pivot there.
00:11:53 So, Corey, we're not going to know if he actually jettisons any of the... I mean,
00:11:56 it's not uncommon for a political leader, you know, a conservative leader to run on the right
00:12:00 in the leadership, pivot to the center for the general, or, you know, often, you know,
00:12:06 liberals and Democrats run on the hard left in the leadership and they come to the center
00:12:11 afterwards. We're not going to know until we really see the platform. If we don't see anything
00:12:15 about the CBC in there or the Bank of Governor, Governor of the Bank of Canada, well, then we'll
00:12:20 know for sure. So we're an election platform. Yeah, we're not going to know until we see that
00:12:24 for sure. Right now. I mean, it's as Nigel said with the CBC, though, it does resonate with some
00:12:29 people, but you're keeping your powder dry. I mean, maybe the right opportunity comes. We've
00:12:32 got a while to the next election. So suddenly some pictures get leaked of Rosie Barton's Justin
00:12:36 Trudeau hope chest. Well, that's going to bring everybody up and show just how slanted they
00:12:40 They are the CBC, and that's a good time to take another shot and fire out of that.
00:12:45 But there's no sense going into shooting every barrel you got just after you've won.
00:12:49 The economy is the big thing, and he's really focusing on that right now.
00:12:53 And I suspect he's going to come back to the others if they rise in the interest of Canadians.
00:12:57 The other thing is, if and when an election comes around, you're not going to go out.
00:13:02 You've published a full policy book, but you're not going to campaign on 100 things.
00:13:06 You're going to do like Stephen Harper did, I would guess, in the 2006 election.
00:13:11 Pick out five things that actually resonate and dribble them out,
00:13:15 one a week through the election campaign.
00:13:17 Well, when Harper did that, it was five big items,
00:13:20 but they still had a full platform, costed out.
00:13:22 Yes, they did.
00:13:23 It's expected that you're going to have a full platform,
00:13:26 but Harper had five big things.
00:13:29 And I remember, you know, I was like, I was barely in university.
00:13:34 or no, I don't even know if I was in university.
00:13:37 Yeah, I think I was in university or high school.
00:13:39 I was in high school, that's what it is.
00:13:41 And every Canadian could say what those five things were.
00:13:46 They didn't know the rest of the platform,
00:13:47 but those five things were it, and everyone got it.
00:13:50 So you'll probably see something like that.
00:13:52 I want to talk about the runner-runner-up, Leslyn Lewis.
00:13:57 Now, I'm not positive, but her campaign, I think,
00:14:00 has claimed she actually got more votes this time 0.79
00:14:02 than last time.
00:14:03 but her impact on the race was undeniably smaller. Last time, you know, the time O'Toole was elected,
00:14:10 she was probably the only real, arguably Derek Sloan, but her and Derek Sloan were the only
00:14:16 actual real conservatives in that race. Aaron O'Toole, you know, people who were cheering for
00:14:20 him, he was running for true blue, and I said, guys, he's clearly lying to you. He's clearly full
00:14:25 of it. But Lewis was the most genuine of those candidates. She did very strongly. She arguably
00:14:31 won the popular vote and could have won except for the points system. But she was pretty far
00:14:35 back this time. But she was
00:14:39 closer to Jean Charest in points than Charest was
00:14:42 to Polly F. Much, much closer. In fact, in popular vote
00:14:47 she was only a hair behind Charest. In popular vote she was almost
00:14:51 the second place candidate. What's next for her? 0.97
00:14:55 She had a really strong showing in the time O'Toole
00:14:59 one, but O'Toole put her straight to the back benches, didn't care that she represented a more
00:15:03 conservative wing of the party, was angry at her that she was on, or that she refused to disclose
00:15:07 her vaccination status. We'll start with you, Coria, maybe. What do you think the future holds
00:15:14 for her? Where's Leslie Lewis going to settle, go when the dust settles here? I think Paul Yev
00:15:20 will give her a good critic's portfolio and keep her front center. I don't think he's going to make
00:15:23 the same error as O'Toole. I mean, he's got a good unified party. Let's keep it. Sure, she'll
00:15:29 came in at what around 10% this time around but that's a significant number is when you're looking
00:15:33 at 600 and some thousand members as you said that that number of votes still grew and and these are
00:15:38 motivated voters I mean the ones she represents are the door knockers they're the donors they're 0.98
00:15:44 you know that that's part of why people always wonder why traditional conservatives or social
00:15:48 conservatives tend to punch above their weight well it's because their base gets out and helps
00:15:52 they're much more potent in a party than others so I think Polly is wise enough to take that
00:15:56 seriously respect her as we talked about before uh put her somewhere and probably i would imagine
00:16:02 if he forms a government some sort of cabinet portfolio he's going to keep her prominent maybe 1.00
00:16:06 not right next to him all the time but she's going to be well captain uh sandy nigel what 0.98
00:16:11 what do you think happens with lewis oh i think cory has nailed it i mean i noticed she didn't
00:16:16 make the first cut when he announced his uh leadership team she was not one of the one of
00:16:21 of the eight. But she absolutely represents an important constituency. And Corey was making a
00:16:28 reference to that they work hard, they turn out, they pound the signs into the hard packed earth
00:16:34 and 20 below. They also write the checks. They strongly believe in putting their money where
00:16:41 their mouth is. If he were to lose that, lose the respect of that component, it would cost them
00:16:47 literally money. And, you know, she wasn't a part of that leadership team, but the way caucus works,
00:16:53 there's some of that leadership team who are genuinely in positions of leadership,
00:16:57 like house leader, which is Andrew Scheer and the whip. Some of the positions like caucus chair
00:17:01 and things like that are actually a bit more junior because then you've got your critic
00:17:04 portfolios. Generally, the finance critic job, which Polly have had before, a job I used to
00:17:09 have as well provincially, that's considered a very high level one. So, you know, you'd rather be
00:17:15 finance critic, probably, and not be on the leadership team in most cases. You're going to
00:17:20 get airtime there. The question is, is he going to be as scared of his finance critic as O'Toole
00:17:24 was of his finance critic? I suspect not. I suspect that there is enough people who think
00:17:30 the same way that it will not be an issue to choice. Just, you know, who's going to, who's
00:17:36 absolutely. Okay, so let's, I'm going to bring it back here, closer to home here. The Western
00:17:41 Standard commissioned Main Street research to do a scientific poll. This is not like
00:17:45 a website poll. You know, the Western Standard, we put up a poll, we're asking readers what they
00:17:49 think. But it's kind of self-selecting. Those are Western Standard readers. This is not self-selecting.
00:17:56 This is demographically weighted across Alberta. It gets a pretty good sense of where Albertans
00:18:00 are at. So we paid Main Street to do this, ask them a number of questions. One of the ones we
00:18:06 asked was, of course, how people intend to vote in the next election. The UCP in this has pulled
00:18:12 ahead. UCP has been languishing in the polls. It's not that long after they were elected and
00:18:17 it continued to go down and down and down, often at the expense of the Wild Rose, sorry, to the
00:18:24 benefit of the Wild Rose. In this, the Wild Rose had really fallen back down to earth at 5%. 5%
00:18:30 has still got a heartbeat of something, but it's much lower than the 14% they were getting this
00:18:36 time last year, right before Kenny was kind of showed the door by his party's members in
00:18:41 leadership review. But among those who say that they're voting UCP, the poll had Danielle Smith
00:18:48 at 44%. Second place at less than half of that was Brian Jean at 20. And then in a statistical
00:18:55 tie, but technically a point behind him was Travis Taves, 19. And then after that, you had
00:19:02 Somewhere in the neighborhood of 5% for Rebecca Schultz, roughly another 5% or so for Todd Lowen, and then nil for the last two.
00:19:16 What's your think of this number? Do you think this is reflecting what you're seeing?
00:19:20 Well, first of all, you know, that huge support for Danielle Smith is the same kind of spirit that drives it as this huge support for Polly Herve.
00:19:32 People are looking for change, and they find somebody who articulates that need to change very clearly,
00:19:39 very definitely knows what they think, and is good at putting it across.
00:19:43 They're not playing around at the edges.
00:19:45 But what I find interesting about that particular race
00:19:50 is that Smith raised more than a million dollars,
00:19:54 something like a million and 40,000.
00:19:57 And she got that from something like 4,500 people.
00:20:03 And she has 44% of the party's...
00:20:08 It was a large number of small donations.
00:20:10 A large number of small donations.
00:20:12 Mr. Taves also raised over a million dollars
00:20:17 not quite as much as
00:20:18 They're about tied, yeah
00:20:19 They're about tied
00:20:20 but his support is down there at 19%
00:20:22 so what does that tell you?
00:20:24 It suggests to me that there's
00:20:25 a smaller number of larger donations
00:20:28 So who is backing?
00:20:29 Well, Taves' campaign
00:20:30 our reporter in Edmonton, Arthur Green
00:20:33 asked the Taves' campaign
00:20:35 he gave the Western Standard
00:20:37 the amount that the Taves' campaign has raised
00:20:40 but they refused to disclose the number
00:20:41 of donors, which was very strange.
00:20:45 One could surmise that probably means
00:20:47 it's a smaller number of large donations.
00:20:50 Strangely, though, the Gene campaign refused to say anything.
00:20:53 They refused to say how much has been raised,
00:20:55 let alone from how many people.
00:21:00 But yeah, it's an interesting point.
00:21:01 You've got both campaigns raising pretty much the same amount of money,
00:21:05 but one campaign with more than twice the support of the other.
00:21:07 So what I'm thinking, there are some people
00:21:10 who are deeply invested in Alberta politics
00:21:14 who really want Mr. Toews to win
00:21:17 and they're digging deep in their pockets,
00:21:19 which is their right.
00:21:22 But it's interesting that Smith's appeal
00:21:25 seems to be wider, much wider.
00:21:28 Of course, back to the polling numbers.
00:21:32 We've got all of the other candidates
00:21:36 whose name is not Daniel Smith, save Todd Lowen,
00:21:38 have been very clear it's anybody but Danielle.
00:21:42 They had their, as Linda Silbodian put it,
00:21:44 their Mean Girls press conference getting together saying,
00:21:48 Sovereignty Act is terrible.
00:21:50 It's the worst thing ever.
00:21:51 Danielle must be stopped. 1.00
00:21:53 Vote for anyone but her. 1.00
00:21:54 Rank your ballot all the way with everyone whose name is not Danielle Smith.
00:22:00 She's sitting at 44 here.
00:22:01 And that's, I think, lining up with most other polls.
00:22:04 It's got her just shy of winning on a first ballot. 0.99
00:22:06 But I think the smart money here is that she's not going to grow as much on subsequent ballots as probably Travis Taves and possibly Brian Jean will.
00:22:19 How much risk is she in of Alberta conservative frontrunner syndrome here where she has a strong first ballot but can't grow her way to a win on the subsequent ballots? 0.91
00:22:28 I don't think it's that high a risk. If you look at the numbers, even if he's held, and of course, you know, we pulled with people who say they would vote UCP, but it's not necessarily members. So that's a different category altogether. And a 44% and then it was seven, I believe, for Lowen. And I would almost think when Lowen drops off, if the balance could, if those numbers held, almost all of those 7% would go towards Smith.
00:22:50 her bar to reach and that creep. And we know that she might only get a small percentage of 0.99
00:22:55 the second votes for the other candidates if when they drop off, but it would be enough by that
00:23:00 point to push her over the edge. But I think realistically among members, I mean, it's
00:23:04 indicative as well. When you look at the way those fundraising numbers matched out, she's doing good
00:23:09 traditional ground organization. She's selling a lot of membership. She's getting people on the 0.58
00:23:13 ground. She's galvanizing them. I mean, you could get a millionaire to give a hundred thousand to a 1.00
00:23:18 campaign, but his vote's still only one vote when it comes to the membership voting. Technically
00:23:22 that would be illegal. Well, you know what I'm seeing. There's ways. So, you know, she's doing 0.96
00:23:28 it the traditional get them out there. And I suspect when you're looking at percentages of
00:23:31 actual members sold plus members that are engaged ones that are going to get out and vote, I still
00:23:37 think she's going to win it comfortably on the first ballot. You think she's going to get first
00:23:40 ballot? I do. Have you got that on the bet? I don't know. Might have changed by this point.
00:23:44 You got to get on the board. Oh, I'm up there. I just, that might, I haven't looked at it.
00:23:48 Well, it's going to cost you another six-pack to update your – if you want to get on again.
00:23:51 You're going to get that back out of me one way or another.
00:23:53 I'm going to get paid back here.
00:23:55 You can add another one, but it costs you another six-pack.
00:23:58 It's essentially you're placing a second back.
00:23:59 I don't even remember what I did.
00:24:01 You're going double or nothing.
00:24:02 I was going to have a look, so I'll have a look.
00:24:04 But at this point –
00:24:05 You're saying first ballot.
00:24:05 I think she's going to win at first ballot. 1.00
00:24:07 I'll throw my number out right now at 55.
00:24:10 Okay.
00:24:12 Have you got a guess?
00:24:13 I would actually say very much the same as Corey.
00:24:16 Just to make it more fun, I'll say 60%, but, you know.
00:24:19 60?
00:24:20 First ballot.
00:24:21 Okay.
00:24:22 Well, you know, think about it.
00:24:24 You take all the votes that aren't already committed to Taves and Gene,
00:24:31 they've got to go somewhere.
00:24:34 Yeah, but other than Lohan, they're all strongly, strongly anti-Smith.
00:24:39 And Taves' status quo support.
00:24:41 Like, he's been selling to people who are saying,
00:24:42 I'm okay with things as they are. 0.91
00:24:43 Those are the hardest ones to get off their butt, fill out their thing, seal the envelope, and put it in the mail. 0.94
00:24:48 I agree. 0.99
00:24:48 It's the angry one of those.
00:24:50 I think the reason she's not, she has semi-captured lightning in a bottle here, but I think a little less so than Polyev.
00:24:58 And the reason for that is that federally, the liberals are in power.
00:25:03 Right now, the conservatives are in power.
00:25:05 And so you have a large segment of the UCP, the more kind of establishment PC Tory side that says, well, things can't be that bad.
00:25:13 We're in power. So they're not as angry for them.
00:25:17 The last few years have been on balance, probably fine.
00:25:21 You know, all mistakes were made, but on balance, they're fine.
00:25:25 I think she's captured the bigger part of the party.
00:25:27 But I think because, you know, it's not like federally we're Trudeau's in power.
00:25:32 So I'd be surprised if she captures that much of a thundering win, but let's go to the one way maybe she can.
00:25:42 So what we're going to talk now about is another part of the poll we did, which is on the Sovereignty Act.
00:25:48 So I don't have the exact numbers. Overall, a plurality of Albertans were opposed to it.
00:25:53 Now, we asked the question differently than other media have.
00:25:55 Other media, upholsters went out and they said, do you support the Freedom Convoy, which was a movement that went to Ottawa to blockade borders, occupy the city, and end public health measures?
00:26:08 Well, that's pretty leading.
00:26:09 I didn't want to lead it any other way and say, did you support the Freedom Convoy, which went to overturn the tyrannical government in Ottawa, which has been oppressing us?
00:26:18 That would have been leading as well, even though it might be kind of my view.
00:26:21 We just asked simply, do you support the proposed Alberta Sovereignty Act?
00:26:24 simply. So there was a plurality, not a majority, but a plurality of Albertans
00:26:29 were opposed, but a very, very strong minority were supportive. And then roughly 23, 25 percent
00:26:38 didn't know or didn't have an opinion. But I had the pollster ask that question for a different
00:26:46 reason. I want to know how UCP voters feel about that. So then you segment, you know, that first
00:26:51 question we had. How are you going to vote? And you match it up, take the UCP people, and then ask for
00:26:55 their answers on the Sovereignty Act. And that was an interesting number. 67% of likely UCP voters
00:27:03 in Alberta say that they support the Sovereignty Act. Second place was not opposition to the
00:27:10 Sovereignty Act. Second place, by far, was about 25% who said that they don't know or don't have
00:27:18 an opinion. Among UCP voters, the opposition to it was about, correct me if I'm wrong,
00:27:25 we have the numbers on the site, but it was about only 17% of UCP voters oppose the Sovereignty Act.
00:27:33 So let's talk about what this means just for raw politics. I don't know about you, Nigel,
00:27:39 But I would like to be on the side with 67%, not 17%. 0.80
00:27:45 Right now, you've got one big candidate and one small candidate, Smith and Lowen, on the 67% side.
00:27:52 And then you've got all five other candidates, two of which are big, sharing 17%.
00:27:58 If you're advising Travis Taves or Brian Jean, and you look at these numbers, what do you advise them to do?
00:28:09 change the channel. Don't talk about the Sovereignty Act if you can get away with it.
00:28:15 They've tried. They can't. This has become a referendum on it. It's too late.
00:28:18 Smith has obviously laid out the terms of this thing, but they're on the wrong side of the people
00:28:24 who are going to make the decision. It's as simple as that. If you've got 10 people in the room and
00:28:30 six of them want one thing, two of them don't know and two of them all wants completely different,
00:28:36 it's the sixth that's going to make the decision. Those are roughly the percentages that you're
00:28:40 talking about here. There's not really an awful lot that you can do about it. They can...
00:28:44 It's actually like six, three, and one almost. They're in third place beyond don't know.
00:28:52 So they're not in a good spot. If it's a referendum on the Sovereignty Act,
00:29:00 there's the result. So Corey, I'm going to ask you this from a different perspective.
00:29:04 You look at this, and you're on the Smith campaign.
00:29:07 This would tell me that the Sovereignty Act is more popular than Danielle Smith. 1.00
00:29:13 Danielle Smith is actually below where she should be. 0.93
00:29:15 If this is a referendum on the Sovereignty Act, she's underperforming.
00:29:20 Sovereignty Act's at 67 among UCP voters.
00:29:23 She's at 44.
00:29:25 If I was her, if I'm advising her, I'm telling her, double down on it.
00:29:30 Talk Sovereignty Act all day, every day.
00:29:34 What would you advise her?
00:29:35 I don't know if I'd go with that.
00:29:37 Like, it's at this point, if you're starting to feel pretty confident, you're going to pull this off.
00:29:41 Because that's going to be the harder sell if and when she does win the win. 1.00
00:29:44 She probably wants a first ballot win, though. 0.99
00:29:46 Well, if the 44 turns out to be true, that's not a first ballot.
00:29:50 It's still at least up in the air.
00:29:51 I think broadening some of her policy, I think with the tactics she did recently, now she's gone into health care. 1.00
00:29:56 And she's, you know, that's a big issue with a lot of people.
00:29:59 And when you've got some of that 67%, they might have still been supporting one of the other candidates because, well, I don't know where she stands in health care.
00:30:05 I like the Sovereignty Act, but I don't know where she is there.
00:30:07 Well, she's now stepped in that. 0.57
00:30:09 I mean, there's a risk because her health stance could drop people off of her. 1.00
00:30:12 You know, when you start changing, you start losing some of your base as quickly as you gain it.
00:30:16 So you better watch which battles you take.
00:30:18 But I don't know about hammering further on the Sovereignty Act.
00:30:20 I mean, you don't back down from it by any means, but I think at this phase.
00:30:24 Smith is less popular among UCB voters than the Sovereignty Act.
00:30:27 I mean, so on the other side, just politically, I mean, Taves and Jean might genuinely believe that the Sovereignty Act is a bad idea.
00:30:35 But, I mean, I've never met a politician who's above flip-flopping when it makes good sense to.
00:30:41 And for me, if I'm looking at them, it looks like this is a time to flip-flop.
00:30:45 Well, she can twist the knife a little more. 0.99
00:30:47 She has been trying to be very conciliatory and nice.
00:30:50 The reality is, you know, at least when you're looking at Taves, look, you guys did nothing for three years. 0.99
00:30:54 That's why your leader got kicked out on his butt. 0.99
00:30:57 I'm proposing to do something. 0.99
00:30:59 That's what's drawing people.
00:31:01 You guys should get on board with this,
00:31:02 even if you're going to twist that knife a little more.
00:31:04 But I mean, I think everybody's already well aware
00:31:06 that that's her act as far as that goes. 0.95
00:31:08 I mean, if that's why they're going to support her,
00:31:10 then they will.
00:31:11 So I just don't know if doubling down
00:31:13 is going to give her much benefit at this point.
00:31:19 Yeah, well, I don't know.
00:31:21 I'll put it to you.
00:31:22 So Smith, 44 is definitely leading the pack by a wide margin, but she is still well behind support for the act that she's associated with. If you were advising her, would you tell her, you need to do more? You need to continue to bust away in support of the Sovereignty Act? Or are you trying to broaden appeal? Or are you just trying to max out Sovereignty Act support?
00:31:47 So people like the Sovereignty Act, the people who are going to make this decision, some of them are still unsure about Danielle Smith because of the floor crossing.
00:31:59 That is probably a big part of the difference between the 44% that she supports, that she enjoys, and the 67% that supports.
00:32:09 A big albatross.
00:32:10 How does she cross that? There's only one way to do it, and that's out there doing what she's doing, out there talking to people. She is very persuasive. When you meet her, you want to believe her. So the more people she meets, the more hands she shakes, the more she puts it out there, the better her chances of reaching out to the low-end supporters as well.
00:32:34 The single biggest cause that leads me to think that she's going to win this is not that she is at 44%.
00:32:41 It's that the keystone policy that this has become a referendum on the Sovereignty Act is at 67%.
00:32:47 And that other than Todd Lohan, all of the others have not just said that they're against it.
00:32:51 They have cried chicken little about it.
00:32:55 They're calling this apocalyptic.
00:32:56 Now, you've got to be careful with polling on issues, though, because not every issue is weighted the same to every voter.
00:33:05 Every voter says health care is important, but not every voter makes their decision based on health care.
00:33:11 67% say they support the Sovereignty Act.
00:33:13 That doesn't mean that 67% of the UCP voters are going to make their decision based on the Sovereignty Act either, because people have different priorities.
00:33:22 You are correct.
00:33:24 Right. That is the theory. But you said it yourself just now. Sovereignty Act has become the referendum. This election is a referendum on the Sovereignty Act. That's the trigger issue this time. I think your analysis is correct.
00:33:45 Speaking of a referendum, we had a little one in this poll on how Albertans feel about the media.
00:33:51 Now, I don't want to toot our own horn too much, but I got to do it a bit.
00:33:56 I don't have, geez, I should have written down the details of the numbers here, but the numbers were great.
00:34:01 So this is Albertans at large, not just UCP voters.
00:34:04 This is Albertans at large with a demographically weighted proper poll.
00:34:08 And there was a strong plurality, I think, in the 40s, around 42% of Albertans.
00:34:13 honestly more than I thought. We asked Albertans, or our pollster asked Albertans,
00:34:19 which source of news do you trust more? Independent and alternative sources or
00:34:26 mainstream sources of news? And it was, I think, a win of about 10% for independent and alternative
00:34:33 media, which is incredible. I know we're at strong risk of tooting our own horn here too much,
00:34:42 but whatever, let's take a victory lap. But it's not just the Western standard. There are other
00:34:47 independent media here, some on the left, mostly not on the left, but there are some.
00:34:53 Corey, go to you first. What do you think would be behind that? Why would, you know,
00:35:00 why are at least Albertans, we didn't ask Canadians at large, but we asked Albertans,
00:35:05 why do you think Albertans would be leaning so strongly towards independent
00:35:09 media outlets and away from the mainstream?
00:35:12 I think a lot of it still hangs over from the truckers' convoy.
00:35:15 I mean, the legacy media in Canada embarrassed itself
00:35:18 with its coverage of that, the way they portrayed things,
00:35:21 they spun things, they fabricated some things.
00:35:24 I mean, the amount of retractions that Mother Corp
00:35:26 had to put out during the convoy was an embarrassment in itself,
00:35:29 and Albertans haven't forgotten that.
00:35:31 And a lot of that, too, is, again, we've seen that
00:35:34 definitely a fawning towards Justin Trudeau
00:35:37 and Justin Trudeau's hostility towards Alberta.
00:35:39 So you're getting quite a recipe for people to say,
00:35:42 I've had it with that established media
00:35:43 and I'm looking for alternatives.
00:35:45 So I think it's happening across the country,
00:35:47 but probably more so than other areas than in Alberta.
00:35:49 And then some of it, I like to think,
00:35:51 as pattern on backs, we're doing a good job.
00:35:53 We've been putting stuff out there.
00:35:54 It's been some years of Dave with some solid news copy
00:35:57 and some great columnists and reporters
00:35:59 and people realizing we can go to other sources.
00:36:02 You can pat yourself on the back.
00:36:03 We have good opinion from you too.
00:36:05 But they're finding out that these alternatives are more than blogs.
00:36:08 They are real news alternatives, and they're coming up, too.
00:36:11 I think it also really went downhill for mainstream media during the last two years with the COVID coverage.
00:36:17 Yeah.
00:36:17 Because it was so obvious that they were, in their own minds, they were good corporate citizens doing a public service by taking whatever the government said
00:36:29 and putting it out there with a bullhorn
00:36:32 and making sure people did the right thing.
00:36:35 And often it wasn't the right thing.
00:36:38 And often they found themselves saying one thing here
00:36:41 and something else completely different there.
00:36:44 And people eventually said,
00:36:46 well, I don't know whether I believe any of them anymore.
00:36:49 And their behavior during COVID really hurt them.
00:36:53 I would take it from both of you.
00:36:55 I think those two years were absolutely devastating to it.
00:36:59 were, in their minds, they were being good corporate citizens, but they stopped seeing
00:37:03 themselves as watchdogs of the powerful and started seeing themselves as the bullhorn of
00:37:08 the public good. And they have a different view than perhaps some of we do on what is public
00:37:12 good. And I think their coverage of the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa, that was just kind of, that was
00:37:19 the piece de resistance. That was just kind of accumulation of it where you've just got some
00:37:24 truckers with bouncy castles and hot tubs, and they're saying, well, good God, it's like London
00:37:29 in the Blitz. We're under siege from the Nazis, and we're facing imminent evasion at any time.
00:37:34 Democracy is going to be overthrown. And I think a lot of people saw through that. I would suspect
00:37:40 that if we conducted this poll in other provinces, particularly in the East,
00:37:44 you'd probably see mainstream with an edge over the independent and alternative sides. I think
00:37:49 you'd still see a lot of support for independent and alternative, but I think you'd see less so
00:37:53 because there's less independent and alternative media there.
00:37:57 Alberta is, we're the laboratory of it in Canada.
00:38:02 The influence of independent media, I think, in Alberta is much greater than elsewhere.
00:38:07 I mean, that's where the Western standard will cross all four Western provinces,
00:38:10 but it's no secret.
00:38:12 Careful, Derek, they're listening.
00:38:14 We're broadcasting.
00:38:17 But it's no secret that the, you know, we're most read in Alberta over other provinces.
00:38:22 We've got good readerships in the other three Western, but definitely biggest in Alberta.
00:38:26 And you've also got significant numbers of people here who are going to listen to other non-government sources of media, left and right.
00:38:35 I think it's just bigger here, so there's more experience with it.
00:38:39 And, you know, yes, the last two years, then finished off with the Freedom Convoy.
00:38:46 But this has been coming for a long time.
00:38:49 It's been coming for a long time, trust going down in the mainstream media.
00:38:52 But what was more interesting to me was trust in the independent and alternative media.
00:38:59 Distrust in the mainstream media has been building for some time.
00:39:01 But trust in the alternatives to it, that was heartening that 40-odd percent of Albertans were,
00:39:08 they put their trust in organizations like us and other independents.
00:39:13 Okay, well, that's enough tooting of our own horn for a day.
00:39:17 I like the Freedom Convoy.
00:39:18 All right, gentlemen, thank you very much for joining.
00:39:22 If you are not yet a member of the Western Standard, shame on you.
00:39:26 Shame. 0.99
00:39:26 Hang your head in shame. 0.94
00:39:28 But open your computer right now if it's not already open. 0.97
00:39:30 Go to westernstandard.news and click on membership.
00:39:32 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:39:36 And that will give you unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
00:39:39 And you'll be supporting independent, bailout-free Western media.
00:39:44 Apparently, your neighbors trust us.
00:39:46 So if you trust us, if you trust the Western Standard to provide you the straight goods,
00:39:51 well, then you should support it
00:39:52 because the Western Standard refuses
00:39:53 to accept the penny of the federal government's media bailout
00:39:55 and we can't do it without the support of you.
00:39:58 Well, that's it for today.
00:39:59 Nigel, Corey, thank you very much as usual.
00:40:02 Thank you. Always a pleasure.
00:40:04 And all of you, thank you very much.
00:40:06 Auf Wiedersehen.
00:40:20 Thank you.