Western Standard - September 07, 2023


The Pipeline: Polls point to national Conservative majority

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Sep 6, 2023 MPC Daily Market Update Sep 8, 2023

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

168.24

Word count

8,746

Sentence count

423

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us as we discuss the events of the Freedom Convoy trial, immigration, and much, much more! - The Pipeline is a weekly panel show hosted by Corey Morgan, Nigel Hannaford, and Chris Oldcorn.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to The Pipeline. I'm Corey Morgan, the Alberta columnist with the Western Standard.
00:00:18 This is our weekly panel show covering the top stories and issues and dissecting what's been
00:00:24 going on in Canada over the last week. So the folks joining me today, well, one of the regulars
00:00:30 on the pipeline, of course, is our opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford. How's it going, Nigel?
00:00:34 So far, so good, Corey. Great show today, I think.
00:00:37 Oh, I think we got a lot to talk about.
00:00:40 Oh, there's never a shortage.
00:00:41 No, there certainly isn't. And yeah, we will certainly be getting into it right away. Oh,
00:00:46 the glasses are coming off, so we know.
00:00:48 This is serious stuff.
00:00:48 This is serious. Okay, as well, from Saskatchewan, we've got Chris Oldcorn on.
00:00:54 I'm not so regular on the show, but always welcome and lots to add.
00:00:58 A very prolific writer for the Western Standard.
00:01:00 How are you doing, Chris?
00:01:01 I'm doing fantastic.
00:01:02 Thanks for having me on.
00:01:04 Oh, much appreciated.
00:01:05 And yes, Derek's indisposed.
00:01:07 There will be a story coming on about that.
00:01:09 I should bring it up just on a lighter note.
00:01:12 The video went out to Derek's precious new motorcycle.
00:01:16 And I understand why he'd be upset.
00:01:18 You know, it's a big purchase.
00:01:18 but a rough-looking fellow went out in the back and tipped it over just randomly out of the blue
00:01:24 there and did some damage to it and uh derek rounded somebody up from the newsroom and they
00:01:28 managed to catch this fella and that somebody was sean pulser yes when not reporting energy shows
00:01:35 remarkable industries and there's a gumshoe yes the western standard justice team 0.97
00:01:44 and there'll be a don't mess with me i got friends in the western standard that's right
00:01:48 there'll be a story pending on that one. Well, aside from our local crime and justice issues,
00:01:54 we got a few other things to talk about today. Of course, the trial for a couple of the organizers
00:02:00 of the Freedom Convoy last year in Ottawa has gotten underway. It did the other day with Tamara
00:02:06 Leach and Chris Barber. And of course, there'll be a lot to discuss and what that trial means,
00:02:10 where it might be going, and how people are going to receive it. As well, in Manitoba,
00:02:15 out in the West, the provincial election has kicked off over there. And it looks like they
00:02:19 got a pretty tight race building up between the PCs and the NDP out there. So we'll talk a bit
00:02:23 about that and what's going on. Then that's a big story. It's been a big one with the standard
00:02:29 leaked memo saying that record numbers of immigration have been fueling the housing
00:02:34 crisis within Canada as much as the Liberals have been denying it. It sounds like they kind of
00:02:38 always knew that was the case out there. So yes, that will be an interesting conversation as well.
00:02:47 Let's start things out though with talking about Tamara Leach and Chris Barber.
00:02:54 Nigel, yeah, I mean, where do we start with this? You know, we've talked about it a long time.
00:02:58 It's been building, but it's kind of like we're revisiting the whole
00:03:02 the Emergencies Act and lockdown and the protests and everything all over again.
00:03:08 Well, you know, Corey, I think people who are expecting a rerun of Perry Mason with dramatic incidents and people pointing at each other and shouting each other down are probably in for a disappointment.
00:03:23 So far, it's been like watching paint dry.
00:03:26 it almost has to be that way as lawyers make their case
00:03:34 and put the evidence out in front of the jury.
00:03:38 But, you know, it strikes me, Corey,
00:03:42 that in the end, whatever the decision of the court,
00:03:46 and obviously we have our ideas about what that ought to be,
00:03:51 you can't get away from the fact that this is a political event.
00:03:56 But it was a political protest, and the protesters are now on trial.
00:04:04 So where does this thing land in the end?
00:04:11 There's going to be, it is probably in the liberal government's interest
00:04:15 to get this out of the way now, two years before the next election,
00:04:19 because as a political event, I think everybody is going to have an opinion,
00:04:23 and they're going to have a strongly held opinion.
00:04:26 Well, this is a good point, Nigel. And this is very divided with people. I've been watching,
00:04:32 of course, the social media buzz and so on. There's not many people looking at a gray area
00:04:36 in this. They feel either these organizers are guilty of a high crime and should have the full
00:04:41 force of the law imposed upon them or people feeling that they should be just, you know,
00:04:44 that it should be let free. They never did anything wrong. They expressed their free protest
00:04:49 and should let it go. Chris, you, of course, have been watching this closely as well. All of us have
00:04:56 over the last year and some now.
00:04:59 What are your interpretation of this trial
00:05:02 as it gets underway?
00:05:03 So far, yes, it's been pretty just procedural so far.
00:05:07 The first main witness came up today,
00:05:11 which was the incident commander for the Ottawa police.
00:05:16 And basically what he said was they were overwhelmed.
00:05:19 They didn't expect as many people to show up
00:05:22 in terms of like the trucks and so on.
00:05:24 they vastly underestimated the size of the convoy and that caused them problems because
00:05:30 they were stretched so thin, which just showed that there was plenty of people in Canada
00:05:36 who were upset with the lockdowns that were persistent and mandates and so on for vaccine
00:05:42 and all the masking and everything else that went on. And of course, rightly so, people went
00:05:49 and they protested which in a free country you are allowed to do um which begs the question if
00:05:55 you uh don't follow what the government is saying in this country do you still have the ability to
00:06:01 go out there and say what you think uh without fear of being arrested and prosecuted um and
00:06:09 possibly i mean they're both looking at you know possibly you know 10 years in jail or more which
00:06:14 is for a protest organizer. Not to mention there was all kinds of leaks that came out
00:06:23 that shouldn't have been leaked to the media in terms of communication between both of them that's
00:06:28 now out there in the public. So there's all kinds of questionable things that have happened
00:06:32 even before this trial started yesterday. Well yeah and that's something that I think
00:06:38 there's a lot of symbolism going on right now. Something that the courts will have to prove and
00:06:42 indicate is malintent on the part of the organizers. They weren't looking to commit a high
00:06:49 crime or harm anybody with this protest. There's no evidence of such. I mean, things really took
00:06:55 off in a way that I think nobody saw coming, whether it was the Tamara Leach and Chris Barber
00:06:59 or the Ottawa police force. And I think the prosecution, I mean, they're going to have to
00:07:05 try and indicate that these are potentially dangerous people if they really want a strong
00:07:10 sentence, because otherwise you're really just being vindictive and trying to go after them.
00:07:14 Yeah, and the right to protest has got to be more than the right to write a letter to your MP.
00:07:22 You know, and unfortunately, protests are inconvenient for people around them.
00:07:29 Forget about this one for a moment.
00:07:31 If you happen to live near the legislature in Edmonton, and there's a group of people,
00:07:37 thousands of them perhaps who were making a noise one afternoon well that's inconvenient now that
00:07:43 they will say well this went on for weeks and it did but in in in principle it's the same thing
00:07:51 and the point was a valid one and how do you nobody went around breaking property
00:08:01 quite the reverse in fact nobody made a mess of the streets quite the reverse in fact
00:08:10 and i understand from reports at the time that even petty crime was down in that area
00:08:16 while uh while the convoy was there uh so i don't know how the courts will measure
00:08:24 the proportionality of an occupation.
00:08:29 They will want to call it an occupation.
00:08:32 They already have tried to call it an occupation.
00:08:34 And of course, the lawyer for Ms. Leach and Mr. Barber said,
00:08:40 no, no, no, it's not an occupation, it's a protest, is it?
00:08:43 But the proportionality of it may be what the thing turns on,
00:08:48 that they go too far for too long.
00:08:50 David Plylariouf Leach If I could just hop on what Nigel just said
00:08:52 there a second ago about the crime. A couple of months ago, I was on a Twitter space with
00:08:57 Sockwell Day. And he was in Ottawa at the time. And he said he felt the safest walking from where
00:09:03 he lived to his office during the convoy than at any other time in Ottawa. And he has spent a long
00:09:09 time in Ottawa. So that's just one example of, you know, crime was down. I mean, you don't show up
00:09:16 bouncy castles when you're trying to commit crimes. Yeah, well, and the proportion, as Nigel
00:09:22 was saying, and the extent of the prosecution on this, I mean, we've seen past large protests. It's
00:09:28 quite a while for some people. If you remember the Occupy movement that happened and in city parks
00:09:33 all across North America, there were protesters setting up camp literally for months before the
00:09:37 police even moved on them. And I never remembered any of those protest leaders ever having such a
00:09:44 force of the law coming down i think there were some fines issued and a few minor things but
00:09:48 not a case where they're held without bail for for 50 some days at a time and and now relentlessly
00:09:53 pursued through the court system like this well you know if the government is going to prevail
00:09:58 in this prosecution and i'll say it again this is a political prosecution they are going to have to
00:10:05 show that the convoy leaders wanted to bring down the government i think they will not be able to
00:10:13 do that because that was never the intent and nothing like that was ever proposed they will
00:10:22 also have to explain why the prime minister would not even meet with leaders of the convoy right at
00:10:29 the start uh that was an option and in the first hours and days of the of the arrival of those
00:10:41 trucks if the prime minister had said all right you know send me to bring the leaders in let's
00:10:49 let's meet in a neutral ground you know there's plenty of hotels around there with large ballrooms
00:10:58 maybe everybody would have been satisfied if they'd been able to give a thorough airing of
00:11:04 their grievances to the prime minister himself there was never a sense in which if we don't get
00:11:13 what we want if we don't bring the government down we're staying here forever well and again
00:11:20 it would have gathered the prime even if a senior minister had gone or just somebody to show an
00:11:25 indication of listening even if it wasn't well intentioned but just to go through the motions
00:11:30 go down and say, we sat with them. They're intractable. They're extreme. Now we can no
00:11:35 longer negotiate. We have to work on getting out. But they never even did that first step of
00:11:39 talking with them. And that says a lot. And it stole, I think, the moral high ground from their
00:11:45 ability to move in and prosecute any protesters or remove them. Well, it was never a violent crowd.
00:11:50 I mean, there are certainly some protests that we've all witnessed over the years where you
00:11:55 probably wouldn't want to go down there and talk to the and talk to the crowd uh or even have them 0.76
00:12:02 into a hotel room it would just turn into a circus but this was one like these are these are basically
00:12:08 law-abiding people yeah and it was there was no believe in the system you'd need some degree of
00:12:15 security fair enough but i remember i believe it was before he was the prime minister but
00:12:20 uh trudeau sat down with justice or justice chief theresa spence when she had her uh amazing weight 0.98
00:12:27 gaining hunger strike uh on uh parliament hill and uh yes again you know nothing changed but he
00:12:35 gave the time to speak to her but i mean i'll go down and i'll start with chris though i guess
00:12:39 on this though and that was what we do is we speculate and guess like chris
00:12:43 or i'll start with myself as well uh in guessing how this court case is going to end up and how
00:12:47 how people are going to react to it. And I think that the justice is going to head to the mushy
00:12:53 middle. They're going to convict them on a couple of charges. They're going to throw out a few others
00:12:56 and probably won't give them any jail time. They'll say you've put in enough time served with
00:13:01 your time in remand. And nobody's going to be happy about it, though, because the people who
00:13:06 want blood are going to want them to do more time in jail. And the people, of course, supportive of
00:13:10 Leach and Barber are going to say, hey, no, they should be exonerated on this. And they'll probably
00:13:15 go to appeals, but that's where I feel things are going to be going. But where do you think
00:13:20 they are, Chris? Well, this is a judge-only trial. There's no jury. I think that the judge will have
00:13:28 to look at it based on the merits of the case. I don't think there's anything that suggests they
00:13:33 were trying to overthrow the government. I mean, no one said that. You can't find either of these
00:13:40 people, or for that matter, the organizers of the Freedom Convoy and the people who are there,
00:13:44 no one was saying we're here to overthrow the government. And that's going to be a hard case
00:13:49 to make when you have all those communications between the organizers and no one ever said it,
00:13:56 or even for that matter, inferred it. So at the end, I think you're right. I think it'll come
00:14:01 down to they'll get a slap on the wrist, maybe some community service hours at best, or maybe
00:14:06 I don't think you're going to see them doing any jail time at all for it. I think this 16-day
00:14:12 trial is really just more for show than anything else. But at the end of the day, I think you're
00:14:19 right, Corey, I don't see them spending much time in jail, if any, and it'll be basically a slap on
00:14:25 the wrist. I think, Chris, that the charges are mischief and encouraging others to commit mischief.
00:14:30 Is that not correct? Yeah, there's mischief, intimidation, obstructing police officer,
00:14:35 counseling others to do the same thing. Chris has an additional charge about obstructing a highway
00:14:41 because of his vehicle, but other than that, like, these are not charges that make you
00:14:50 be like, wow, these are dangerous criminals, we better lock them up for a decade.
00:14:54 Yeah.
00:14:55 Depends what point the government really wants to make, and I know that people who believe
00:15:00 in the judicial system would be quick to say, well, it's not the government that's going
00:15:04 to make the decision, it's going to be the judge, but I think we all know that...
00:15:09 Judges are appointed by the government.
00:15:16 We will have our own expectations, yes.
00:15:23 Anyway, are we allowed to wish Tamara Leach luck? 1.00
00:15:27 I believe so.
00:15:28 This is an opinion broadcast.
00:15:30 We're putting out our point of view on this,
00:15:33 and that's why I'm saying we'll even go down the speculation road,
00:15:35 and we have the right to be completely wrong in guessing
00:15:37 how the rulings may come in this, but I think most of us are wishing Tamara and Chris the best
00:15:42 of this. I mean, we know that they're not odious, dangerous criminals that are going to go out and
00:15:47 cause harm should they not be locked up. This is very much a show trial.
00:15:53 No, it's sad. I think a lot of it comes down to points of pride, too, though. You know,
00:15:58 the government was embarrassed. The government was, the prime minister himself was embarrassed.
00:16:03 He appeared on international circles to have lost control of his own country, his own people.
00:16:08 And now they're vindictive.
00:16:10 They want to slap back.
00:16:12 And that's not the proper reason for justice.
00:16:14 Vengeance should never be a part of justice.
00:16:17 You said it.
00:16:18 That's exactly right.
00:16:20 Well, we'll keep watching and waiting.
00:16:21 And as I said, I share it.
00:16:23 I wish Tamara the best and Chris as well.
00:16:26 And I can't speak for yourself, Chris, but I imagine your sentiment's similar.
00:16:31 Yes, it is.
00:16:31 And just to clarify, the Chris on trial isn't me, it's Chris Barber.
00:16:35 Yes.
00:16:36 Yeah.
00:16:37 Okay.
00:16:37 No, you're not.
00:16:38 They want to put you on trial for something else.
00:16:40 Yeah, I'm just covering it.
00:16:42 Okay.
00:16:43 So I should turn to and speak to guys who are standing up for our rights as well
00:16:47 and not on the streets in a protest sort of way, but as, I guess you could say,
00:16:53 an advocacy group.
00:16:54 And that's the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:16:56 They've been a fantastic sponsor for us at the Western Standard for quite some time.
00:17:00 And they've been a fantastic advocate and resource for firearm owners, of course, for a long, long time as well.
00:17:07 We've got, I mean, among the many, many issues that are coming from the federal government infringing on our rights,
00:17:12 a government that ideologically wants to take away your right to use and enjoy and own firearms safely and responsibly.
00:17:20 So the CSSA, they push back, they stand up for you.
00:17:23 Plus, they have all sorts of resources on their site, as any association would.
00:17:27 If you own firearms and want to maintain your right to own them, you've got to be a member of the CSSA.
00:17:33 It's an investment in your own rights.
00:17:35 Check them out.
00:17:36 Its website is cssa-cila.org.
00:17:40 It's the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:17:42 Just Google them.
00:17:43 Take out a membership.
00:17:44 It's not that much.
00:17:45 And they will help continue to make sure that you can enjoy those firearms.
00:17:49 Because it's just, again, as we're seeing with these trials, we've got a government that's not looking out for our rights.
00:17:54 And if we don't stand up for ourselves, nobody else will.
00:17:57 All right. Well, let's go to the federal front. It might tie in a little bit indirectly with this trial. I mean, it's one of those things that actually has put our federal conservatives in a rock and a hard place on a divisive sort of issue. But right now, polls are certainly turning. I mean, we're seeing a big change.
00:18:14 It's not just an outlier. A lot of polls have been coming out now federally, and they've been pretty clear that the Liberal Party of Canada is in a polling freefall, as far as that goes, and the Conservatives are really gaining ground.
00:18:26 For the first time, we're starting to see some pretty clear evidence of a Conservative majority, potentially, with the polling as things sit today, of course.
00:18:36 we understand it's a snapshot but boy you know that's that's been a turn around this last few
00:18:41 months nigel i mean we've really seen just such a shift where they seem to have been kind of 1.00
00:18:45 locked in the in this you know static spot for so long and now they are just on the move but what
00:18:50 do you think is really behind this change well just to add some specific details to what you've
00:18:56 just said there they we're talking about a a poll released by 338 uh that is an aggregator or that
00:19:04 looks at everybody's polls and certain other considerations as well, like records and history
00:19:09 and so forth. And they come up with a projection. And what they're projecting is 170, I mean,
00:19:16 this is if the election had happened yesterday, 179 seats for the Conservatives out of 338.
00:19:27 And the Liberals cut way back down to 101. So that is, that's their projection.
00:19:34 Now, you know, if I were a liberal strategist and I had been asked by a friendly television station to comment,
00:19:44 I would tell the CBC that polls are for dogs and that in two years' time, who knows what the situation will be.
00:19:55 But our sheep always come back to the fold when there's a stark choice.
00:20:00 And certainly for the last two elections, that has been the case.
00:20:05 But you'll notice that the vote turnout for the Liberals has declined with every election since 2015.
00:20:14 You know, they got a handsome majority in 2015.
00:20:17 They didn't get a handsome majority in 2019, and they polled even less in 2021,
00:20:23 to the point that they actually had to have this hand-holding agreement with the NDP,
00:20:28 which has not served the NDP, well, not that I care, but the liberals have actually been trending downwards now
00:20:39 ever since they were elected in 2015.
00:20:43 And what this poll is showing is that since the last election in 2021, the trending down is continuing.
00:20:52 So this is a long-term movement.
00:20:56 who knows whether the numbers will be just exactly as they are today in two years time
00:21:05 but the liberals have got a serious problem of losing public enthusiasm public trust
00:21:12 and credibility and you know if i can just say one last thing cory there is there's a way that
00:21:21 these things work the first time you screw up everybody talks about it for a while and then
00:21:28 life goes on and then comes a second time and the third time and people start to forget what the
00:21:35 original ones were but you know what they do remember there was something this guy is always
00:21:43 screwing up. And when the media gets hold of that idea, suddenly things start to change and you no
00:21:55 longer get the benefit of the doubt. It happens to every government and it is happening to this one
00:22:02 and their problem is that they can't get a handle on it, they keep fueling it. And so I would say
00:22:09 that this this this whatever the whatever the spinmeisters say this is not going to be uh not
00:22:16 going to be happy day in the pmo no i mean there's no doubt i mean if you live and die by the polls
00:22:23 when you're in politics whether you want to admit it or not yeah and they do their own internals and
00:22:27 it's true it hey if it could get this low after two years it can climb back up within two years
00:22:31 this doesn't necessarily uh you know mean something but it bodes terribly as you said
00:22:36 it's a trend. This isn't an outlier. This isn't a spike. It just continues to drift down. And as
00:22:42 you said, it's one scandal or problem or misstep after another. Chris, what do you see as standing
00:22:50 out? I mean, it is a cumulative problem that's going on, but it does seem to be accelerating
00:22:53 lately too. What is it that's causing a more recent loss in confidence and support for the
00:23:01 Liberals in your view? Well, we can go to actually another poll that we had last week
00:23:06 about young voters, voters in their 20s, between 20 and 29. Predominantly, they were, you know,
00:23:14 liberal supporters, and it has just been, once again, a downward trend. So just from the beginning
00:23:20 of August to the last week of August, they went from 26% support with people in their 20s
00:23:28 All the way down to 16% in one month. And voters, those young liberal voters have been going both directions. The NDP has about 31% support now in people in their 20s. But here's an astounding number. The conservatives are only almost at 40%. They're like 39.7% I believe it was in the poll support among voters in their 20s.
00:23:54 And I think it's because Pierre has been hammering on affordability issues, and that is playing well with them because, you know, their incomes are lower than people in their 40s and 50s.
00:24:06 So things are hitting them harder and they're trying to get in the housing market and they can't because we're just not straight up, not building enough houses for the amount of people that we're bringing into the country and that are already here.
00:24:19 We have been not building enough for a long, long time.
00:24:22 And it's a cumulative effect. And I honestly think it's it's going to the grocery store and the dream of buying a home is making a lot of voters in their 20s really disillusioned with the Liberal Party, particularly the one led by Justin Trudeau.
00:24:38 I don't think they feel that they can relate to him in any way, shape or form presently.
00:24:42 Yeah, and that's got to be making them sweat when a key component of your base support is losing again, they're not losing support, you know, or further among people who are already strong conservative demographics, it's the youth that should make them sweat like that was their stronghold. And yeah, I'm well past my 20s. But I remember it well, and you're, you're full of ideals at that age, you know, and that's where you could vote based on those. But you're also your wallet tends to be pretty empty. My 20s, I mean, times were tight, you got the young kids in the house, you
00:25:12 you're still building up your fortune, whatever it may be, furniture, and paying off a car and so on.
00:25:18 You're very sensitive to cost of living issues.
00:25:22 And you often don't necessarily have a big buffer to get you through spikes or times when it's going high.
00:25:27 So, you know, they don't, they're not feeling, I think, that the Trudeau government can turn this around.
00:25:33 I think that's part of what's really changing that for the youth right now.
00:25:35 Well, I'm sure it is.
00:25:37 And you know, the question that that raises is,
00:25:40 will the old liberal tactics work?
00:25:45 In the past, in past elections, they have trotted
00:25:50 out the purple dinosaur arguments.
00:25:52 You know what I'm talking about.
00:25:54 Stephen Winick Jr.: I remember it well, yes.
00:25:55 Stephen Winick Jr.: Okay.
00:25:56 And they would want, they would love to be able to say
00:26:01 that the conservative leader is, you know, he's a closet pro-choice, pro-life advocate,
00:26:10 and that, you know, gay marriage will be under attack if he's elected prime minister. Well,
00:26:18 you know, Pierre Polliver, I mean, not the social conservatives like him for this, but
00:26:22 Pierre Polliver has made it very clear that he is pro-choice. He went out and actually said he is.
00:26:29 He didn't kind of beat around the bush and say, well, I, you know, I personally am pro-life,
00:26:34 but I wouldn't legislate, which is what conservative leaders tend to say.
00:26:39 He said he's pro-choice.
00:26:41 Well, there goes that issue.
00:26:42 You're not going to be able to run a campaign of innuendo based on that.
00:26:47 So what about other aspects of social conservatism?
00:26:50 Well, you know, he has a very diverse caucus.
00:26:54 Let's put it that way.
00:26:55 And again, you know, if that, if the liberals try
00:26:59 to make that an issue, he can just put certain people
00:27:03 on center stage and they don't have to say whether they,
00:27:07 you know, what particular aspect of diversity they represent,
00:27:11 they just, everybody knows what they stand for.
00:27:14 So there goes that.
00:27:15 So, you know, what are they going to do?
00:27:17 Are they going to try and claim he's actually a Russian agent?
00:27:20 You know, it worked on Trump, I guess, but, you know,
00:27:24 Could it work on pure polymer?
00:27:25 Where do these people go?
00:27:26 Well, yeah, they're guns running out of bullets.
00:27:28 I mean, you brought up, it's funny,
00:27:29 you just talked about Day came up recently
00:27:31 and that's where the purple dinosaur thing came from.
00:27:33 That was from Warren Kinsella when he pulled that stunt.
00:27:36 And Kinsella has been very critical of the Trudeau liberals.
00:27:39 Like the pragmatic liberals of the nineties though,
00:27:43 don't seem to be there anymore.
00:27:44 It's a government populated by ideologues.
00:27:47 And I would think if they could regain confidence
00:27:50 in the fiscal thing,
00:27:51 they need to pull up some people right now to say,
00:27:54 These are strong financial managers.
00:27:55 These are things we can do to make your life more affordable.
00:27:59 And they don't seem to have them around anywhere.
00:28:01 There's no more Paul Martins.
00:28:03 There's no, you know, responsible liberals that they can bring forth.
00:28:08 So they're in a tough position.
00:28:11 And Jagmeet Singh a couple of years ago even said that the liberals are taking his best policies.
00:28:16 Well, that's because the Liberal Party just kept shifting to the left and took over a lot of the things that the NDP was pushing.
00:28:26 And they've almost become the NDP.
00:28:28 And unfortunately for them, most Canadians don't line up with a lot of the NDP policies.
00:28:34 That's why they don't get that many seats.
00:28:36 And the Liberals have tried to move into that territory, and it hasn't worked.
00:28:41 And, yeah.
00:28:42 That's a very good point.
00:28:44 I mean, this partnership with Jagmeet Singh, they can't help but then start wearing some
00:28:48 of the NDP policies, which, again, if the majority of Canadians wanted to go as far
00:28:53 left as the NDP, we would have had an NDP government by now.
00:28:56 Yes.
00:28:56 And the thing with this poll is that it is so overwhelmingly in favor of the conservatives,
00:29:03 it excludes the possibility of a continuation of a liberal NDP alliance, because 179 is
00:29:12 It's an absolute majority out of 338 seats.
00:29:19 This has got to be deeply concerning to the prime minister and to the people around him.
00:29:25 They'll smile and make light of it, make all the, you know, the dog comments, but things
00:29:32 are not going their way.
00:29:33 And frankly, you know what it is, Corey, ultimately, it's the hypocrisy that gets you.
00:29:39 always the is when you say you stand for this and then do that and that's the record of this
00:29:47 government and people can't remember the details but they know it when they see it and that's what's
00:29:53 forming their opinions now imagine if i was a struggling young parent and i see a prime
00:29:58 minister in six thousand dollar a night hotel rooms in a governor general jet setting i start
00:30:02 to get a little tired of it eventually just to chime in one other thing there too um picking
00:30:09 piggybacking on something that Nigel said there. It's no longer the conservative party. When you
00:30:14 see a picture of all of their MPs, it's no longer a conservative party. You can't use the argument
00:30:20 that it's just a bunch of old white guys because it's not. It's very diverse. It looks very much
00:30:25 like Canada does. And it shows that conservatives can come from any part of Canadian society and
00:30:32 have those conservative values. And it used to be that they would just pull out that old sort of
00:30:39 boogeyman, bunch of boogeyman arguments, like Nigel was saying. But that's getting harder and
00:30:43 harder to do when you look at the conservative party and who are their voters, who are their
00:30:50 MPs, who are their candidates. It's quite a diverse party. You know, Chris, that's a very
00:30:57 good point and i i think the uh the the old liberal assumption that anybody who is anything
00:31:03 other than white is a natural liberal rests on the assumption that if you're not white you must
00:31:10 be a victim and they've played to that but you know look at the kind of people who are getting
00:31:19 elected as conservatives. They are people who have conservative ideas, and they may come
00:31:26 from somewhere else, or they may come from a non-white. We've just elected here in Calvary 0.99
00:31:33 Heritage, we've elected Chivalry Magender. He is not a white guy. He is, but he is an 0.79
00:31:39 out-and-out conservative. I know the man very well. He is not, he never was or ever could have been
00:31:48 a liberal voter and yet the liberal party behaves as though they think well if you are anything but
00:31:54 white then you properly belong with us yeah well and she was an excellent example and i mean yeah
00:32:00 i've known him a while too and he's fantastic and he's an example too of the next generation
00:32:05 of immigrants that i i'm not sure if she was born in canada or not he's been he grew up in calgary
00:32:10 his english is better than mine i believe if we talk one-on-one well i wasn't going to bring that
00:32:14 But since you mentioned it.
00:32:16 He's certainly more classy than I am when he speaks anyways.
00:32:19 And that changes that demographic as well.
00:32:22 There's a lot of great conservatives from all cultures and walks, and they're capitalizing on it.
00:32:28 That's not a recent thing, by the way.
00:32:29 I mean, it was the same under the Harvard government.
00:32:31 It was just never particularly recognized as such.
00:32:34 All right.
00:32:35 Well, let's turn the page to some provincial politics for a bit here.
00:32:38 We'll get back to some federal stuff when we cap off the show here.
00:32:41 But an election has just been called in Manitoba, a general election, and it's a competitive one from all indications right now.
00:32:49 This is the first campaign that Heather Stephenson is going to be going into as premier.
00:32:55 And she's had a tough time.
00:32:57 She never had that honeymoon after winning the leadership, becoming premier.
00:33:01 She's consistently been considered the least popular premier in Canada, at least as the personal indication when measuring the premier.
00:33:08 The party has had its ups and downs.
00:33:11 So, I mean, it's a progressive conservative government in Manitoba right now with, I'll just break it down there. There's 57 seats in their legislature. There's 35 progressive conservatives, 18 NDP, three liberals, and one vacancy.
00:33:26 again as far as polls go I was looking at 338 kind of their aggregator is looking at it with
00:33:32 maybe a slight NDP lead or almost neck and neck but of course this is right in the very beginning
00:33:38 of this campaign right now in Manitoba so it could really go either way I know you've been
00:33:43 doing some background on this Nigel what are you seeing coming up here in Manitoba
00:33:47 well okay if you're asking me to put my money on the table and make my bet now I say the
00:33:53 conservatives go back in again, that is because some of the NDP policies are so far out there
00:34:05 that people eventually come to theirs, it's like the liberal strategist, you know, the
00:34:12 flock comes home.
00:34:13 It works both ways.
00:34:15 I mean, Juan Canu is the NDP leader and he signed
00:34:22 on to the Leap Manifesto, a more left-wing progressive piece
00:34:30 of literature you wouldn't find since the year 2000.
00:34:33 All the progressives and all the people
00:34:36 who had big ideas signed on to this.
00:34:38 It's highly environmental.
00:34:40 It's no more resource extraction.
00:34:43 Well, you know, in the end, people understand that you can't live like that.
00:34:49 And if you want a job, you are going to have to have some economic development.
00:34:55 And these things are aspirational, but they're not practical policy.
00:34:59 So you put that together with a promise to, well, you know,
00:35:09 So he promises not to raise taxes, or at least to only raise them by linking them with inflation.
00:35:19 But then there's the credibility thing.
00:35:22 When a conservative says they won't raise taxes, you know they're speaking from the
00:35:27 heart.
00:35:28 When a socialist promises not to raise taxes, you tend to suspect that they might, if they
00:35:39 felt it was in their interest to do so certainly we here in alberta know all about that from the
00:35:46 four years of um this is not lee's uh time as premier and i think the manitobans probably
00:35:53 suspect the same thing so if you're asking me to go out all of them i say that heather stephenson
00:35:58 goes back but it won't be because everybody admires how she handled the covert crisis
00:36:05 and the lockdowns and jailing pastors and crackdowns on churches and so forth that is a thing
00:36:12 the thing that might help her and maybe i know i know uh chris is very following this very very
00:36:18 closely not only in manitoba but in other provinces chris um what is she doing about restoring
00:36:26 parental rights well this is huge um she did come out and say that you know parents have rights to
00:36:33 their kids surprise surprise they should know if they're changing their pronouns or wanting to
00:36:40 transition so she's weighed in on that and it looks like that that policy obviously if they 1.00
00:36:48 get elected will will will continue um i do think that gave her a bump in the polls uh it was very
00:36:55 those stories were very popular when they came out um and on top of that they're doing a bunch
00:37:01 of things that are are hitting people in their 20s and 30s so you have parents with young kids
00:37:06 who are worried about like what's going on in their kids schools and so they're going from the
00:37:11 parental rights aspect of it but they're also going after the economic aspect of it
00:37:16 the lowest tax bracket over the next four years the amount of taxes someone will pay in that will
00:37:21 be cut in half that's on top of the tax cut they put in for the lowest tax bracket in their 2023
00:37:27 budget. And then if you are a first-time home buyer, they are going to eliminate the land
00:37:33 transfer tax, which is the highest in the country and put in by the NDP back in 1987.
00:37:39 And just to give you an example, the tax cut will put about $1,900 back into people's pockets
00:37:45 per month. And then the land transfer tax, let's say you're buying an average home in Winnipeg,
00:37:52 That's going to save you a little under $6,000 in the land transfer tax and registration fees.
00:37:57 So between the parental rights and the economic stuff for people in the lower income brackets, they're really going after voters in their 20s and 30s.
00:38:05 And maybe they're seeing what's happening federally with a lot of people leaving from the liberals into the conservatives in that age bracket and kind of piggybacking on some of that.
00:38:14 But she is definitely behind the parental rights thing. 0.96
00:38:17 she didn't go as far as Moe did but with the banning of third parties like Planned Parenthood
00:38:21 but she went all the way up to that line Moe was the only one that went over the line with the
00:38:27 banning third parties New Brunswick and Manitoba Ontario didn't ban things like Planned Parenthood
00:38:31 even though they did here in Saskatchewan. Chris not every province has a land transfer tax.
00:38:40 Of the ones that do theirs is the highest like percentage-wise. Well just just how bad is it?
00:38:45 Well, if you're buying an average home in Winnipeg, it's $5,700 for the land transfer tax.
00:38:51 So just to buy a house, and you paid the realtor, and now you have to find $5,700 for the government?
00:38:59 Yes. And a small registration fee on top of that as well.
00:39:05 So she has promised to get rid of that?
00:39:07 For first time home buyers, yes. So if you are renting right now and you're going to buy a home,
00:39:13 uh then you qualify well and that saves a huge amount of money particularly when you're
00:39:21 younger and in a lower tax bracket than say somebody in their 40s or 50s oh yeah it takes
00:39:26 a bite out of you know what you're trying to save for your down payment that first time i mean it's
00:39:29 a tough hurdle everywhere as it is it always has been so uh that that's always that'll certainly
00:39:35 be set in the back i can see that being popular uh the other part too we talked a bit before the
00:39:40 show about that, Chris, about, you know, and Nigel mentioned with credibility, is Kenu's been
00:39:44 promising some things as well. I mean, you know, that's nothing new out of politicians. They will
00:39:49 promise the moon and the stars to get elected, but whether or not you believe them when they're
00:39:53 saying those or whether it could actually happen. And he's made some health promises that they've
00:39:57 got to be making even progressive voters thinking, hey, you know, I love what you're saying, but I
00:40:00 just can't see that happening in the health system. Yes, that I'm not sure where he thinks
00:40:09 he's going to be able to do this or find these people. But he said that if he's elected, he's
00:40:14 going to hire 400 new doctors, 300 new nurses, and reopen three ERs in the Winnipeg area.
00:40:23 I think every single premier across this province, across the country, every province and territory
00:40:29 would love to be able to go out and hire 400 doctors and 300 nurses. They just don't exist. 0.95
00:40:35 that's the problem so it's one thing to get up and say these promises for health care and stuff
00:40:40 like that but if there's nothing like if it's not based in reality i'm sure the conservatives
00:40:47 right now in manitoba would hire 400 doctors and 300 nurses if they existed they have programs in
00:40:54 place trying to recruit health care workers incentivizing them to come to manitoba just
00:41:00 like there is in other provinces in Canada. And for that matter, everybody's fighting for healthcare
00:41:06 workers across the globe right now because there's just a global shortage. And the other thing that
00:41:10 the PCs did that actually was incredibly smart was they have what they're calling a favorable
00:41:16 legal opinion that if they're reelected, they're going to take the carbon tax off your hydro bill
00:41:23 and then fight the government in court if they come to try and get the money. So they're going
00:41:27 going to tell manitoba hydro to scrap the carbon tax on the bills and see what happens uh they
00:41:36 haven't really been too specific on what they mean by favorable legal opinion um but that's also one
00:41:42 of their platforms as well is to go after the carbon taxes too you know and i just asked chris
00:41:50 one more thing here in in alberta there is a huge interest in using part of saskatchewan
00:42:02 and part of manitoba as an energy corridor which you would export natural gas and move electricity
00:42:11 maybe allow manitoba to sell hydro power in a westerly direction this energy corridor has been
00:42:21 proposed for years and i think the idea is that if it could be put together on indigenous land
00:42:27 then it would make the whole process of approval very much easier by being that one step removed
00:42:34 from federal oversight.
00:42:36 Now, we are under the impression that Heather Stephenson has not
00:42:42 been particularly receptive to that proposal.
00:42:46 Do you know why, and do you think
00:42:48 that this election might change her tune?
00:42:54 Stephen Winick- I think as she tries to play more,
00:42:56 she tries to play a little bit happier with Ottawa
00:43:00 than Saskatchewan and Alberta do.
00:43:03 I mean, Mo and Smith obviously are very outspoken
00:43:06 against policies coming from Ottawa
00:43:09 and also how we have a lot of our energy
00:43:12 that's a bit landlocked,
00:43:14 where we could be exporting a lot more and so on.
00:43:17 But I think that if it was put on the table
00:43:21 and there was a actual real plan
00:43:24 that would bring tons of jobs to Manitoba,
00:43:27 I don't see why she would not be full steam ahead on that
00:43:31 because she is like, for example,
00:43:33 the Manitoba hydro thing,
00:43:35 standing up to the government on energy issues.
00:43:38 And so of Alberta and Saskatchewan,
00:43:41 I mean, renewable energy is not going to heat our homes
00:43:45 in the middle of the Saskatchewan winter
00:43:46 when it's minus 40.
00:43:49 And whether we like it or not,
00:43:53 we're gonna be reliant on oil and gas
00:43:57 and natural gas for the foreseeable future.
00:44:01 regardless of what policies Trudeau and his buddies in Ottawa want to put in place
00:44:07 with regard to the environment.
00:44:10 So do you think it's going to be an election issue at all?
00:44:14 I think it might be something they bring up very close to the election if they do
00:44:19 as sort of a cherry on top of we're going to bring more high-paying jobs to Manitoba
00:44:25 because those jobs are going to be very good middle-class jobs
00:44:29 and they would last for a long time.
00:44:32 Well, we'll be watching this election pretty closely.
00:44:34 It sounds like the issues are very similar, actually,
00:44:36 to what we're looking at on the federal front,
00:44:38 and it could be a bit of a snapshot of those issues as they hit the polls there.
00:44:41 So we're getting close for time here.
00:44:44 We want to touch on that final subject quickly.
00:44:46 So I'll go to Ichi.
00:44:47 I'll start with Chris, because this is something that kind of recently came out
00:44:50 and really dominated our story scrolls.
00:44:53 Credit where due.
00:44:54 It was Key and Bexty with his counter signal who got that memo on that,
00:44:57 And it was a memo saying, I mean, something that's contrary to what the Liberals have been claiming all along, that immigration is causing or certainly is exacerbating the housing crisis across the country.
00:45:11 Justin Trudeau now is clear, was aware of that being a problem and he has done nothing about it.
00:45:17 Chris, how do you think that's going to impact him?
00:45:20 I mean, this hasn't had time to really resonate yet and hit him in the polls, but I think
00:45:23 it's probably the worst possible timing on an issue that's pressuring a lot of people and
00:45:27 it's really going to make it worse.
00:45:31 Absolutely. He found out about this information. And a couple of months later, back in November of
00:45:38 2022, the Liberals increased the amount of immigration coming into the country,
00:45:44 knowing full well that immigration was fueling the housing crisis. 0.77
00:45:47 We simply are only building about a third of the homes that we need to every year to over the next seven or eight years just to get back to a point where it's easy to find a home to buy.
00:46:02 I mean, it's crazy in the home markets now.
00:46:04 You put your home up and there's 27 bids in 24 hours because there just is a lack of supply.
00:46:10 And we're not building anywhere near where we need to.
00:46:13 And then on top of that, Trudeau just keeps increasing immigration.
00:46:16 So this year, there's going to be 465,000.
00:46:20 It's going to be another 20,000 next year, which takes it to 485.
00:46:24 And by 2025, we're bringing in half a million immigrants a year.
00:46:27 However, we're only building 223,000 homes on average per year.
00:46:32 Well, that doesn't take into account people that are already here that need homes, people that are coming in immigration. 0.94
00:46:39 And then the other thorn here in Trudeau side is the fact that there's a lot of international students that also need places to live, even if it's only temporary for a couple of years.
00:46:50 They still have to go somewhere. And so between like immigration and then also international students coming, there's a massive housing crunch, particularly in cities that have colleges and universities.
00:47:04 And this should not be a surprise to anyone that if you're bringing in X amount of people
00:47:10 and you don't have X amount of places to put them in, you would cause a housing crisis.
00:47:15 I mean, it's common sense.
00:47:19 You know, it's like having the whole family visit from Saskatchewan when you only live
00:47:23 in a one-bedroom apartment.
00:47:24 It just isn't going to work.
00:47:25 You know, the, I wouldn't want anybody to take away the idea that we blame the government's
00:47:35 immigration policy in its entirety for the problem with accommodation.
00:47:42 There are other factors.
00:47:44 And, you know, Pierre Polliver within the last year was talking about gatekeepers and
00:47:49 He was referring to the municipal councils that often make new development difficult in a number of ways.
00:47:59 He was talking about the CMHC and some of their stipulations.
00:48:06 You know, there are other factors, not to mention the fact that, you know, the construction industry, like every other industry, has got an aging workforce, and eventually people give up.
00:48:16 they've had enough of it and they're not and it's not something that's attracting the new blood in
00:48:21 so there are other factors yes to knowingly to knowingly bring in more and more people to cram
00:48:32 and jam in more people into an existing housing supply just goes beyond negligence and you have
00:48:42 to ask for why are you doing it and so far we have not had an answer from the government on why they
00:48:51 do that he's hiding overseas now so that kind of brings us to a close though we filled it up so
00:48:56 much to talk about when jay came on earlier that was the question we had on my show earlier too
00:49:00 there's just so many issues burning right now it's hard to cover them all so uh we've covered
00:49:06 a good chunk of them though and got our views out there so nigel chris thank you very much for
00:49:12 another great show today and we should have him back we should actually can i just piggyback on
00:49:18 something nigel said there uh about uh the fees on houses we had a story a couple months ago in
00:49:23 vancouver and that a million dollar condo has about three hundred thousand dollars worth of
00:49:27 fees on it yes i saw that story like like think about that like that's 30 of the cost of a condo
00:49:35 in vancouver right now is just simply fees that the builder has to pay before he even starts he
00:49:41 or she starts building, buying what they need, getting the workforce, it's 300,000 bucks out the 0.99
00:49:48 door. That's absolutely absurd. Well, we'll keep working on things and keep hammering on things. So
00:49:54 thank you again, guys. And if you want to catch those stories from Nigel Hannaford, Chris Old
00:49:59 Corn, you got to subscribe, get on to westernstandard.news, take it out $9.99 a month,
00:50:04 $100 a year. And those who have subscribed already, thank you very much. We really do
00:50:07 appreciate it keeps us independent so thank you for tuning in this week guys and we will see you
00:50:13 all again with a whole new set of issues to dissect next week at this time
00:50:17 the current lethbridge feed grain prices are as follows cash barley remains at 345
00:50:25 feed wheat added four dollars sitting at 364 while corn is holding at 360
00:50:31 in the milling wheat markets december minneapolis futures jumped 20 cents at 782 per bushel
00:50:37 with local hard red spring bid for September movement at $9.25 per bushel delivered.
00:50:44 Over to the oilseeds, nearby canola futures are down $2.90 at $794.60 per ton,
00:50:51 with delivered values for September movement at $17.68 per bushel.
00:50:56 The pulse markets are unchanged, with red lentils trading at $0.35 a pound
00:51:00 and yellow peas at $11 per bushel.
00:51:05 Looking at the cattle markets, October live cattle spiked 77.5 cents at $180.72 per hundredweight.
00:51:12 For more information on pricing and picked up on-farm options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:51:20 I'm Vera Buziak at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:51:29 Canadian Shooting Sports Association. Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken.
00:51:34 Long, long ago, these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:51:43 And more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:51:49 If you become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:51:53 You can become a Western Standard member for just $10 a month or $99 a year for unlimited access.