Western Standard - February 01, 2024


The Pipeline: Repealing Calgary’s insane anti-bag, straw, napkin policy

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Winning the battle against red tape Alberta New Policies: Preserving choices for children and youth

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

158.43

Word count

7,526

Sentence count

450

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Calgary voted to repeal its anti-bag bylaw, and now the question is, will the rest of the province get on board with it? And Vancouver has a new bike lane policy. Also, the city of Vancouver has abandoned a policy on paper cups.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening this is the pipeline i'm your host this evening james finkbeiner i'm joined by
00:00:29 Nigel Hannaford our opinion editor. Great to see you here doing this James. Thanks for joining me
00:00:35 I like doing this with friends and not by myself and our copy editor and reporter Mike Thomas. Hello
00:00:41 thank you guys very much for joining me tonight. On tonight's show first up we have
00:00:48 Repealing Calgary's insane anti-bag bylaw. Well Mike why don't you explain this one to me. It's
00:00:56 ridiculous oh um basically what happened in council on uh tuesday afternoon was it was taken
00:01:05 to a vote to consider repealing the uh bylaw and it was a 10 to 5 voted yes we will uh repeal it
00:01:18 so what happens now is that it will go to council again on march 31st for a public hearing
00:01:25 which the public can participate in and you do need to register you go to calgary.ca if you want
00:01:32 to be in council chambers and give them your thoughts on on the bylaw and at the end of the
00:01:42 public hearing it will be voted on and I'm assuming if if this vote is correct it will be
00:01:47 voted down and it will disappear oh that would be nice yes it's uh it's interesting so a couple of
00:01:53 councillors had to switch their votes here. Nigel, what do you think got them to change their minds?
00:02:00 Oh, I think a massive public rejection of the whole concept. I mean, Mike here is talking about
00:02:08 if you want to be there in the council chambers, you'd better register. How about
00:02:13 if you want to be there in the TELUS Convention Centre, you'd better register because that's the
00:02:19 level of discontent and dismay about this and i think that people just well they perceive two
00:02:27 things one is that uh here's somebody else interfering in my life over something that's 0.97
00:02:34 pretty both petty and important at the same thing like there's not a big deal in itself but darn it 0.68
00:02:40 you know you can't even you can't even have a plastic bag for your past steps right so you take
00:02:48 one out of your pocket that's still still usable from three weeks ago when they were legal you
00:02:53 know people don't want to be reduced to doing that and the other thing and i heartily concur
00:02:57 with this is this is just not something that any city council this one especially should be
00:03:05 concerning themselves with i mean this is just aren't we good peoples caring about the earth
00:03:11 i'm glad you care about the earth but this is not the way to do it fix the roads get that done right
00:03:18 take care of the sewers, look after the parks,
00:03:21 make sure there's somebody to cut the grass,
00:03:24 and, you know, handle police and fire.
00:03:27 Well, totally.
00:03:28 And then leave it alone.
00:03:29 It's just more bureaucratic bungling.
00:03:31 Yes.
00:03:33 It makes no sense to drive up to a McDonald's or wherever
00:03:38 and ask for your order, and then you ask for a bag,
00:03:41 and they charge you 15 cents for that.
00:03:43 And I think the thinking is, well, if you're going to pay for the bag,
00:03:47 you won't throw it in the garbage or it won't end up on the street or something like that.
00:03:51 Of course, that's not true. Not true. But we were talking in the newsroom yesterday and
00:03:55 we have a very efficient bottle return system that nobody complains about. You get your bottles,
00:04:04 you take them back, you get your money and off you go. And so why can't we set up something like
00:04:09 that in terms of the ketchup packets or bags? How it would be structured? I don't know.
00:04:16 that takes some thought but why not just add an extra nickel or whatever it is to the bag the
00:04:22 ketchup pallet and then you take them to the we have the depots in place uh take them to the
00:04:29 depot they weigh them or count them or whatever they do and they give you some money back and
00:04:34 now they've got these uh bags and things like that that they can engineer to put into uh waste
00:04:41 removal properly. But you know, I don't usually give a shout out to other groups, but I've got
00:04:49 to say the Canadian Taxpayers Federation made a very good point in their comment on this
00:04:55 when they just said, look, it starts small and it gets bigger. It's
00:05:04 strap this tax before it balloons into wackier items,
00:05:11 wackier plans like the city of Vancouver had to abandon.
00:05:16 Well, this I did not know.
00:05:17 I missed this completely when it happened,
00:05:21 but the city of Vancouver had a policy on paper cups.
00:05:27 Yes.
00:05:28 Do you know about it?
00:05:28 I do.
00:05:29 Yeah, well, they've abandoned it.
00:05:30 Anyway, sometimes reality and practicality just runs smack into ideology, and as this is an ideology that it's somebody's job, but it's not city council's, then I'm very glad to see this development.
00:05:45 Well, like Dave and I were talking about earlier on the Corgan Morgan show this afternoon, we were talking about the bike lanes and how the bike lanes are immediately cleared of snow.
00:05:56 But we have bylaw officers and essentially the sidewalk enforcement for sidewalk shoveling is done by bylaw, but it's done when they are requested to enforce.
00:06:06 So how would this law have even been enforceable?
00:06:09 Are we going to put Calgary bylaw officers in McDonald's and make sure they're charging 15 cents for a bag?
00:06:15 So it's only been in place for, I think, a week, maybe a week and a half. But I will tell you that there has been very few times I've actually been charged for a bag. And I know that because after the order has been completed and I have paid, I have then been offered a bag.
00:06:32 Now, I'm not going to rat those businesses out. They're awesome people. They're great places. I go there frequently, but I have not had to ask for a napkin, ask for a fork, or pay for a bag outside of the grocery store.
00:06:46 but you know james i'll tell you how these things get out of hand there will be some person who has
00:06:52 decided that this is their cause all the things on god's green earth that they're going to care
00:06:58 about they're going to care about paper bags and plastic forks and they will go to fast food
00:07:04 restaurants and they will be given one and then they will turn around and rat out the and then
00:07:10 the bylaw officer will show up and you get two or three prosecutions and then suddenly everybody
00:07:14 starts to do it. That's how these things get. And that's actually a really vicious
00:07:18 anti-citizenry, just a real bad form thing to do, but that's what happens.
00:07:24 Well, and if the goal is to...
00:07:26 What happened during COVID, by the way?
00:07:27 Oh, exactly.
00:07:28 If somebody sees somebody having a good time in their front room, call the police.
00:07:31 Call the police. Bastards. 1.00
00:07:33 If the overall goal is to actually reduce waste and reduce what's going into the landfill and 0.99
00:07:39 deal with the plastic crisis, which I have a hard time with this plastic crisis, I don't
00:07:43 believe there is a crisis. You know, we have plastic pollution. I think it's dirty. I think
00:07:48 we could all clean up our act a little bit. But why would they go after the compostable bags for
00:07:54 one? And why wouldn't they be encouraging that? These bags go into the municipal compost facility.
00:08:01 They were designed with the municipal compost facility. This could be a solution to the plastic
00:08:07 problem completely because not only do they work in the environment as compost, but they work in
00:08:13 the municipal facilities.
00:08:15 Now they're saying they were trying to stop the compost
00:08:19 or the waste from getting to the facility in the first place.
00:08:21 Well, what's the point of having a compost facility
00:08:23 if we're not gonna compost?
00:08:26 Fair point, and if it's not gonna go,
00:08:28 the waste is going to be generated anyway,
00:08:31 so if it's not gonna go in a compostable bag,
00:08:33 what is it gonna go in?
00:08:35 Interesting point.
00:08:37 So, yes.
00:08:39 Like, we're not gonna stop using bags for our convenience.
00:08:42 And the paper bags are one thing, but the cloth reusable bags or the reusable bags that they call them, they only last for so long.
00:08:50 They're not recyclable.
00:08:51 They're not compostable.
00:08:52 So why wouldn't be, they're going to become part of the plastic problem or they're going to be part of the waste problem.
00:08:59 So why wouldn't we be encouraging compost and building up that compost facility to be able to handle the additional compost if we're moving away from plastic and paper and other type stuff?
00:09:09 you know, it's definitely been frustrating. It's one of those things where, you know,
00:09:14 it probably looked great on paper. And when they've seen it in practice, or they got handed
00:09:19 their McDonald's burger and their fries and whatever just through the window, and all of a
00:09:23 sudden there's kids with dumping pop all over the vehicle, and there's fries in the cup holder.
00:09:28 You know, I bet these counselors got a lot of very angry phone calls. But, you know, more to that,
00:09:33 it's affordability. And right now, no one in Canada is having a great time. Groceries, gas,
00:09:40 home heating, absolutely every aspect of our life. The costs have gone up. I actually did
00:09:45 some quick math. So I've been using HelloFresh for a while. That is seven meal kits delivered
00:09:51 to my house once a week. That would be 15 cents per bag. Essentially, that's going to work out
00:09:56 to $50 a year. $50 a year in the grand scheme of things isn't a ton of money, but realistically,
00:10:03 if I have kids, a family, a mortgage, fuel,
00:10:07 and everything else has gone up,
00:10:09 that $50 for some people comes down to being able to eat
00:10:13 or being able to heat their homes.
00:10:15 50 bucks a year, you spend 50 bucks a week on cigars, come on.
00:10:19 I actually spend about $116 a week,
00:10:22 actually I think it's 160 now.
00:10:25 I don't let them tell me how much I'm actually paying
00:10:28 because it's 75 or 80% taxes
00:10:33 on those as well.
00:10:34 So I just feel so frustrated that my weakness
00:10:38 is just giving Trudeau more money to blow.
00:10:41 Yeah, so I'm glad to see that-
00:10:43 You need counseling for them.
00:10:45 Well, yeah, actually the Alberta government is actually,
00:10:49 well, all of the governments in Canada
00:10:51 are actually stepping up their addictions treatment
00:10:54 for smoking, which is good.
00:10:56 I wish they would treat meth and crack the same way though.
00:10:58 Yes.
00:10:59 Especially with the warning labels
00:11:00 that they put on cigarettes.
00:11:02 Um, but that actually brings us to, uh, to our next point here. They are going to delay MAID for the mentally ill. Now, I, this, this, this to me has been disgusting. Um, I, I, I support the MAID program. I do. 0.91
00:11:20 I don't think somebody who has ALS, cancer, where their death is imminent and there's no way out of it, they should be able to die with dignity.
00:11:31 But that's not what this is.
00:11:32 People with mental health and addictions issues, those can be treated.
00:11:36 So how did we get here?
00:11:39 Very good question.
00:11:41 Yeah, really.
00:11:41 And I think that we got to this point the same way we got to quite a lot of other issues that divide us these days in society.
00:11:50 There's a certain worldview, a certain mindset that makes human beings expendables.
00:11:58 And when you remove the certainties, certainties, for instance, that come from religious belief,
00:12:05 Well, when anything goes, and if you're going to argue that human beings are essentially commodities or they're like animals, just a sort of a more intelligent animal, that in itself is perhaps a debatable point.
00:12:18 But anyway, you know, you ask how we get here?
00:12:22 That's how we get there.
00:12:23 I actually like the way that you put it just then, that people who are in an extremity, I think that is their choice.
00:12:35 I hope that I would not make it myself because that doesn't square with who I say I am.
00:12:43 But also, I've never experienced the kind of pain that somebody who is a week away from dying with ALS, for example, will experience or the worst forms of cancer.
00:12:54 where the problem comes in and you you said this is that when we expand it
00:13:02 to people who aren't just about to die but who are going to die at some time in the next year
00:13:12 which is where we have got to at the moment and the plan was to make it possible for people who
00:13:17 are just not having a good time they're mentally ill 0.93
00:13:21 somebody who is so mentally ill that they can't even drive their car should probably not be 1.00
00:13:29 making a life and death decision about themselves so is the government looking at them as a burden 0.99
00:13:35 on society and let's just get rid of them and i hate to use that language um you know mike
00:13:40 a lot of people say that and it's like a lot of these things there is some truth to it 0.98
00:13:45 There was a report put out two years ago that made at that particular point
00:13:51 was saving, I think, the province of Ontario about $90 million a year.
00:13:57 Well, $90 million is a lot of money to the ordinary citizen,
00:14:03 but for a health system, for a province, it's peanuts.
00:14:07 So I don't really think that's what's driving it.
00:14:09 I honestly think that it's a misguided sense of human rights.
00:14:14 but it is misguided
00:14:16 and let me tell you a story
00:14:17 we have a columnist, Linda Slobodian
00:14:20 very popular, very well read
00:14:22 and about a year ago
00:14:25 she got tipped off
00:14:26 about a young man
00:14:27 and this by the way is before these
00:14:29 laws that have now just been delayed
00:14:32 were even being
00:14:34 talked about
00:14:35 a young man, 23 years old
00:14:38 had diabetes
00:14:40 he was losing his sight
00:14:42 and we think he was depressed.
00:14:47 He found a doctor in Ontario
00:14:51 who agreed to give him medical assistance in dying.
00:14:54 The date was set.
00:14:56 Linda researched the story.
00:14:59 She had plenty of help from the anguished mother 1.00
00:15:01 and created enough of a stink about it
00:15:05 that the operation didn't go through.
00:15:09 This was all in our back files
00:15:11 for anybody who's really interested.
00:15:12 a second story about three months later talked about how this young man was now
00:15:18 living with his grandparents which was I guess a for him you know a good good
00:15:23 place to be he was busy and he had a girlfriend he wasn't talking about made 0.89
00:15:30 anymore so you know people who are mentally ill it can change oh yes yes
00:15:38 People have been in deep depressions, and then they've come out of them.
00:15:43 Sometimes it's with medication.
00:15:45 Sometimes it's with the gospel.
00:15:47 Sometimes it's just, you know, good medical treatment.
00:15:50 Whatever it is, mental illness is not the end.
00:15:53 And to have somebody take their own lives while they're in that condition is just unconscionable.
00:15:58 It shouldn't happen.
00:15:59 I think one of the most detrimental things you can do to somebody who's struggling with mental illness, depression, anxiety,
00:16:06 is to say you've given up on them.
00:16:09 And I think that the message this sends by saying,
00:16:13 oh, well, you can get made,
00:16:14 is that society has given up on them,
00:16:17 that there is no treatment for mental illness,
00:16:19 that the way you feel right now
00:16:21 is the way you're going to feel forever.
00:16:23 And that's not true.
00:16:24 We have decades of science that says mental illness can be treated.
00:16:29 And like you said, there's many different ways to treat it.
00:16:31 It can be a doctor.
00:16:32 It can be medication.
00:16:33 It can be talk therapy.
00:16:34 It can be religion.
00:16:35 It could be a new job. You can ask your barber, you can ask your hairdresser. A haircut can cure depression, at least for a few hours. But it's shocking to me that the medical community, and especially this is being driven by people on the left, that, you know, they're the ones that say we need to do a better job of protecting the vulnerable in society.
00:16:56 We need to have better social supports. We need to have better social security and we need better health care and treatment for these people.
00:17:03 And then at the same time saying, but if that doesn't work, you know, just die. 0.87
00:17:08 Yeah. And I I I can't I can't square that circle. 0.96
00:17:12 No, and that's because you're a sane individual. There were 13,421 people, according to the Public Health Agency of Canada, who received medical assistance in dying during the year 2022.
00:17:29 That's about a third more than it was in 2021, which is about half as much again as it was in 2020.
00:17:35 And it is going up exponentially.
00:17:37 So much for the idea that we're waiting for people in extremis to do this.
00:17:42 It is becoming a choice.
00:17:44 Now, they don't actually list medical assistance in dying as a cause of death in Statistics Canada.
00:17:52 But you can find the numbers with the Public Health Agency of Canada,
00:17:57 which does have a silo office dealing with this and nothing else.
00:18:02 So there's the number.
00:18:03 Let me take that 13,421 and move it over to the Statistics Canada table,
00:18:11 and it works out as the seventh largest cause of death in Canada.
00:18:18 You'll never see it in Statistics Canada.
00:18:20 If you had cancer and you took MAID, you're just a cancer victim.
00:18:23 But over here in PHAC, they know who you are, and they list it separately.
00:18:28 But that's how prevalent this is becoming.
00:18:31 Ordinary suicides, when people just finish themselves off, less than 4,000.
00:18:36 Medical, 13,000.
00:18:39 It's astonishing how it's growing.
00:18:41 Yeah, that's a shocking number.
00:18:44 There's been exponential growth on this, but we've even seen stories.
00:18:48 I think the one story came out of Ontario where someone was experiencing homelessness,
00:18:52 or their rent had gone up, they were going to become homeless.
00:18:56 And one of the options that was presented to them was MAID.
00:18:59 And it feels like this has become the backup default of we don't know.
00:19:04 And they throw their hands up in the air and it's tough.
00:19:08 It's a hard problem to solve.
00:19:10 And they say, well, how about MAID? 0.99
00:19:12 Yeah.
00:19:13 Well, you'll never get anybody in officials to confirm this,
00:19:16 but the anecdotal experience of people who are in hospital,
00:19:21 if they're in tough shape and, you know, things are not looking good,
00:19:26 they're very quick to mention that made is a possibility.
00:19:29 Like, they really market this.
00:19:31 Why? Why?
00:19:34 Well, I honestly think that some people believe they're doing a good thing.
00:19:40 You know, most people actually do think that they're doing what's right in their own eyes.
00:19:45 They don't do what's wrong in their own eyes.
00:19:47 It might be what's wrong in your eyes and my eyes and Mike's eyes.
00:19:51 But they honestly think they're doing a good thing.
00:19:54 I think as a society, maybe we should take a little bit
00:19:57 of time to reflect, take a look in the mirror
00:19:59 and really ask ourselves what we should be doing
00:20:02 to help people and how we should help people.
00:20:04 But let's move on to something less depressing
00:20:08 and equally as tragic.
00:20:10 The CBC bosses say that they are protecting us
00:20:15 from misinformation.
00:20:18 Yes, they are.
00:20:19 Look at that here.
00:20:20 This is, I got this from Nigel's, 10 pages of corrections that the CBC has made on its own
00:20:29 broadcast, right here. This is off its website, Mike. Right off the CBC website. So people,
00:20:34 you can go have a look at it. It's just, it's unbelievable. We said this, whoops,
00:20:39 that was wrong. We said this, whoops, that was wrong. And so they're the defenders of
00:20:45 misinformation? I mean, they're the providers of misinformation. I hate that everything goes
00:20:54 back to COVID all the time, but we have to with this one, we go back to COVID and first we talk
00:21:00 about the fear. And the fear that was propelled out of the mainstream media was crazy. And we go
00:21:06 all the way down to the trucker protest and then look at story after story after story of the
00:21:12 misinformation and the fear that they drove around the convoy. So. Those things aren't in here.
00:21:19 No? No, this is, these are kind of reporter errors where it's a, mostly it's a reporter
00:21:25 error as a matter of fact. I mean, look, let's be fair. Let's give the CBC their due. This is what
00:21:31 they say. This is on their website. As part of their commitment to transparency, they're publicly
00:21:37 tracking significant corrections. So these are the, you know, these are the multiple significant
00:21:43 corrections or clarifications. At least they do that. I will give them that. But when you go
00:21:49 through it, you do get a little weary sometimes. And there are some things which, you know,
00:21:59 you mentioned the trucker's convoy. I don't see that in here. I don't see them saying, well,
00:22:03 Well, actually, we kind of got that wrong.
00:22:06 And if we're going to be talking about misinformation and disinformation,
00:22:10 what about the CBC's refusal to call people who murder and brutalize other people terrorists?
00:22:22 You know, obviously, I'm talking about the Gaza situation and the incident that stopped it.
00:22:26 I mean, I don't want to even talk about some of the things they did
00:22:29 when they jumped the border and started killing people at that rave.
00:22:32 And it goes far, far beyond a quick bullet in the head or anything like that.
00:22:38 And that's plenty bad enough.
00:22:41 They won't call that terrorism.
00:22:44 Now, to me, that is an act of disinformation in itself, not misinformation.
00:22:49 This is an attempt to deceive.
00:22:51 Yeah, absolutely.
00:22:52 Absolutely.
00:22:54 They want to control the narrative.
00:22:57 And they think that their job is to control the narrative countrywide.
00:23:04 And that's just simply not true.
00:23:06 That's why we have so many different independent news agencies popping up.
00:23:09 Most of them, like, well, The Rebel, for example, part of their mission statement, they say, is to counteract the CBC.
00:23:17 And, you know, you see the CBC take activist stances on things all the time, particularly around the terrorist attacks in Israel and the ongoing war there now.
00:23:27 And, like, they're sending everything to the managers to approve before it goes out.
00:23:34 And, you know, it'll take you three seconds to Google CBC Alberta,
00:23:38 and you can find Kaylin Ford and the outright lies that they published about her.
00:23:43 That case is still ongoing.
00:23:45 But even our own premier had to settle with the CBC just not long ago
00:23:49 over a lawsuit, over their misinformation.
00:23:53 Well, actually, they do make reference to this here.
00:23:56 They do.
00:23:56 They're kind to themselves.
00:23:57 So is that internal policy or is that coming from outside the organization, do you think?
00:24:06 I think it's coming from inside the organization.
00:24:09 I think it's coming straight from the top.
00:24:10 You look at the CEO and the bonuses right now, and she has been on a media tour being absolutely unapologetic about laying people off and taking her $100,000 bonus. 1.00
00:24:22 I could not imagine how they measure success in their business then, because if you look, I actually looked at this. So when I was looking at an article that you guys sent me, the articles that come up referencing CBC, CTF calls for CBC head to cut executive bonuses after layoffs.
00:24:41 CBC CEO misled with Indigenous language services claim.
00:24:46 CBC faces TV ad revenue crash.
00:24:49 Heritage Minister tells CBC to justify executive bonuses.
00:24:52 So where's the good job?
00:24:56 There was two misinformation articles right there, and then followed up with, well, you take a billion dollars of tax dollars.
00:25:05 You make an aggressive salary to start with.
00:25:08 Your ad revenue is crashing.
00:25:09 You had to lay off employees, but you did such a good job.
00:25:13 You're going to get a $100,000 bonus.
00:25:16 I think the bonus structure around here, Derek, and I are going to have to have a talk.
00:25:20 I was going to bring that up.
00:25:21 Yeah.
00:25:22 Apparently, I need to nosedive the advertising department, and then I'll get a bonus.
00:25:28 You know, this business is about where does the direction come from.
00:25:33 I know a lot of people who are very concerned about the CBC think that it flows from the top.
00:25:44 I don't. I'm with you on this.
00:25:46 I am convinced that within the CBC, there is a hiring method that excludes people who don't follow the basic prescription.
00:25:58 There may be some difference of points of view at the margins, and some people are a little more conservatively inclined than others.
00:26:08 But fundamentally, if you don't fit the left-wing progressive mold, you're not going to get hired.
00:26:17 And the other thing, many people like to imagine a situation where there's a call from the PMO to the CBC.
00:26:25 okay we'll take care of it. I don't believe that happens. Nobody needs to be told because they're
00:26:32 all those kinds of people in the first place. They wouldn't have got the damn job if they 0.98
00:26:36 weren't that kind of person. That's a very good point. That's a very good point. So when it comes 0.99
00:26:43 to defunding the CBC, fine if that's what it takes. What it really is going to take is a
00:26:51 wholesale sacking day in the upper echelons where these decisions are made and a new cadre of people
00:26:58 who have a different approach to journalism where they go back to the old way which is what we
00:27:03 practice here by the way whereas you take both sides and let the reader make up their own mind
00:27:09 or the viewer make up their own mind you don't adopt the new ethic in journalism and this is
00:27:15 what they're teaching in journalism schools today whereas you the journalist have an obligation
00:27:20 to place a certain point of view in front of the public
00:27:23 so that the public understands what's right.
00:27:26 And everything else is misinformation and disinformation. 1.00
00:27:28 People are too stupid to be able to figure it out. 1.00
00:27:31 Oh, exactly. 1.00
00:27:31 A great example of this is just in the last week.
00:27:35 I believe the CBC article that came out that said
00:27:38 taking the GST off the carbon tax would cost the tax dollars a billion dollars.
00:27:44 But I believe our headline was taking the GST off the carbon tax
00:27:48 would save taxpayers a billion dollars so neither one is misinformation or disinformation but
00:27:55 obviously they're trying to push a narrative which i don't understand why a media organization
00:28:00 would ever purposely push the government's narrative the whole way there's there's some
00:28:05 critical things here that that they need to like take a look at uh but you know they they do it
00:28:11 and they do it unapologetically and i i agree with you i don't think there's a phone call coming from
00:28:15 the PMO to the CEO of the CBC, but that doesn't need to happen. She knows her job. She knows where
00:28:23 who cuts the checks, who writes the dollars, who pays her paycheck. And when you are taking those
00:28:28 government dollars, you're suddenly accountable to where those government dollars come from,
00:28:32 which is why we don't take government dollars. And, you know, that's why we're accountable to
00:28:38 our membership. And, you know, we've made mistakes. We've definitely made mistakes.
00:28:42 And when our subscribers, our members, our editors, anybody catches them, we fix them.
00:28:48 We apologize.
00:28:49 That happens.
00:28:50 Anytime you're trying to record what's happening and get all the facts, you know, it's possible to make mistakes.
00:28:57 But, you know, some of this goes well beyond that.
00:28:59 Some of it is just flat out PR for the Liberal Party, the NDP Liberal Coalition in Ottawa.
00:29:07 Thank God for our sponsors, eh?
00:29:09 Absolutely.
00:29:10 Which reminds me, while we're talking about it, you should become a member of the CSSA.
00:29:15 They are fighting for your gun rights, they're fighting for your property rights, and they're taking on the Trudeau Liberals on their gun grabs and their gun buyback plans and absolutely everything.
00:29:25 If you're not a member of the CSSA, you can become a member of the CSSA at cssa-cila.org.
00:29:32 Now, while we're talking about Trudeau, bad laws, gun grabs, buybacks, let's talk about Trudeau's legal reverses.
00:29:42 There has been no shortage of these.
00:29:44 Actually, they're just falling out at this point.
00:29:47 So, Nigel, why don't you, let's talk about which one should we start with?
00:29:55 So, look, here's what we've had.
00:29:58 This is just in the last six months.
00:30:00 In January, just last week, the federal court ruled that the Trudeau liberals had proceeded in an unreasonable and unjustifiable way when they applied the Emergencies Act to the convoy situation.
00:30:22 And the truth of the matter is that existing laws could certainly have taken care of the issue.
00:30:29 Here in Alberta, it did not take the Emergencies Act and the powers thereof to clear up the situation.
00:30:35 Of course, things could have been done that way in Ottawa.
00:30:39 The judge, Judge Wagner, sorry, Judge Mosley, said that when he began the case,
00:30:46 he had some reservations about the movement.
00:30:49 He says he still has reservations about the movement, but when he heard the quality of the arguments that were presented to defend what they did as opposed to who they were, he had no option but to declare that the government had acted illegally.
00:31:08 That takes you back then to, well, let's not go into the plastics ban again, but again, the federal court in November of last year struck down the single-use plastics ban.
00:31:19 In October, the Supreme Court of Canada, on a reference case, said that the federal government had proceeded out of their lane, to use Daniel Smith's expression, but at any rate, that Bill C-69, the No Pipelines Act, the Impact Assessment Act, as it's properly known, was unconstitutional in part because the federal government was moving into the provincial area.
00:31:47 That's three. In July, it was determined, unfortunately, this is not a binding decision, but there is an organization that reviews military cases, and it decided that Canadian Armed Forces members who had refused the vaccine had actually had their rights violated when they were consequently fired.
00:32:11 This is about 400 people, nearly 400 people, who were either fired or quit because they wouldn't take the vaccine.
00:32:19 Never mind the, I mean, don't have the vaccine debate, because otherwise you'll keep me here all afternoon.
00:32:26 The fact of the matter is they, it is a very personal thing to accept medical treatment or refuse it.
00:32:32 And therefore, to say, well, you're in uniform, therefore you've got to do whatever they say,
00:32:39 as opposed to whatever we order you to do in the line of duty, three different things.
00:32:46 So they lost on that.
00:32:47 Then, you know, as you go back through the files, you see SNC-Lavalin, you see the ethics violations,
00:32:55 and there is a picture that emerges here of a government that doesn't give a damn about what the law says.
00:33:04 If they have something in mind to do, well, let's do it.
00:33:08 By the time it's done, it'll be two years before it gets through the courts,
00:33:12 and after that, we've achieved our objective, and they have.
00:33:17 I mean, with Bill C-69, how many pipelines have we built?
00:33:20 Exactly.
00:33:21 You know?
00:33:21 Even with the plastics ban, that's where all of these things are coming from 0.91
00:33:25 at the municipal level now is it was building off of the original plastics ban,
00:33:29 and how many restaurants have you seen plastic straws back at?
00:33:32 I'll tell you, last night, my favorite bar, my favorite pub, they have plastic straws.
00:33:36 I was ecstatic.
00:33:37 It's amazing.
00:33:39 But let's talk about the former attorney general.
00:33:44 Now, he's gone to private industry.
00:33:46 He's been hired at a law firm.
00:33:48 Mr. Lametti, you must.
00:33:50 Yes.
00:33:50 So I wonder, if you're an attorney, and we've seen what happened when an attorney general stood up to Justin Trudeau in the past,
00:34:01 Jody Wilson-Raybould stood up, said, SNC-Lavalin, this is the Department of Public Prosecutions, there should be no political interference, she wouldn't do what Trudeau said, she was gone.
00:34:12 Now, Lamedi was overwhelmingly responsible for these laws, obviously, it would have been his advice that they would have wrote these on.
00:34:21 Do we actually think that it was coming off of David Lamedi's advice, or was this directly coming from Trudeau?
00:34:26 I would guess Trudeau. I think that he is in a situation where he feels very comfortable with his coalition with the NDP. He basically gives him the majority and dictatorial powers that he is not afraid to use. I think a lot of stuff comes out of the PMO that generates all this stuff.
00:34:53 Yeah, it would surprise me that, I mean, there's a few attorneys sitting around at the cabinet table, but it would surprise me that the government's lawyers are wrong this much.
00:35:06 To me, it feels like this is coming from somebody who, A, doesn't care about the law, doesn't care about the letter of the law, doesn't care about the Constitution, and is saying, I don't care what it says, I want it like this.
00:35:17 And that's what it feels like to me. Like, especially the invocation of the Emergencies Act.
00:35:24 War Measures Act.
00:35:25 Well, yeah, the War Measures Act. Coots was done. There was no more protest at the Ambassador Bridge.
00:35:30 And the protesters in Ottawa had begun moving into the areas, working with police for days at that point.
00:35:36 And it wasn't needed. And part of it says no other law in the country was available to stop it, except we know that there was.
00:35:46 And to me, it feels like Trudeau said, I don't care what the law says.
00:35:52 We're going to do this.
00:35:54 It's hard to get inside anybody else's head and understand why they do certain things.
00:36:01 But there is something about the prime minister's repetitive behavior,
00:36:07 which, when put together with things that he has said, makes me think this is just an opinion.
00:36:15 Again, this is not a diagnosis, but that he enjoys the feeling of being regarded as a tough, determined prime minister who will make things happen.
00:36:26 He said something along those lines 10 years ago, talking about how much he admired the Chinese way of government.
00:36:35 And he also has a father who invoked the War Measures Act, who I think overall was applauded for doing so. 0.81
00:36:44 There was, not without its controversy back in the 1970s, but generally speaking, people felt, all right, well, there's somebody who takes charge when charge needs to be taken.
00:36:55 Did Mr. Trudeau want that kind of talk about him?
00:37:01 Perhaps so.
00:37:03 Certainly, if that was his idea, it has seriously backfired because this string of, you know, I only went back six months.
00:37:12 But this string of government actions that have been declared illegal by various levels of courts and authorities speaks of a government that just says, you know what, we're going to do whatever we want to do, and people can object, but we'll have our way.
00:37:34 Yeah, absolutely.
00:37:35 I've seen it done in management union situations. Get the person out of here. Yeah, they'll grieve it. But, well, 18 months later, meanwhile, we don't have to work with them. It's a tactic. It's very commonly used. So, doesn't look good on them, frankly.
00:37:52 No, I mean, just the amount of investment that they've chased out of Canada, as it is, is mind boggling, mind boggling.
00:38:00 You know, like we have a tanker ban off of the West Coast, but we're shipping in dictator oil into Quebec and we can't build pipelines.
00:38:09 And like they're they're applying like the Tech Frontier mine was a death that was caused by this Bill C-69.
00:38:18 and 50 billion dollars I believe yeah and could you imagine right now without the oil and gas
00:38:25 industry Canada would be in a recession for sure and then on top of it we have these shovel ready
00:38:32 projects but even after uh because of the way Trudeau has written laws applied the laws and
00:38:38 then the courts have struck them down who's going to invest in that market who who's going to go
00:38:43 and say you know what let's put tech back on the table but we're got to do it quick before Trudeau
00:38:48 notices. You bet. But this is, you know, when we have these discussions, I think there is a
00:38:55 tendency to think, well, he didn't know what they were doing. I mean, look at the investment we've
00:38:59 lost. They must be so sorry. No, they're not. No, that was the investment they wanted to chase.
00:39:05 Exactly. They didn't have to win the court case. They've chased away the investment. 0.70
00:39:10 Oh, exactly. Tech's not going to put the money on the table to build that mine, 0.87
00:39:14 And even though they're not required to go through that assessment, the original approval from Alberta would still stand.
00:39:21 But could you imagine going back to your shareholders and saying, well, we're going to take this extremely risky investment.
00:39:28 We're going to invest billions and they could change the law, write a new one or whatever before you even get a shovel in the ground and get started.
00:39:35 You know, it takes decades to build up a reputation as a solid place to do business.
00:39:42 You can ruin it.
00:39:43 in months. Oh, absolutely. That is their single biggest achievement. They've killed
00:39:50 investment. And I find it fascinating that Minister Gilbeau, the environment
00:39:54 minister, is talking about a federal or a plastics registry, while at the same
00:39:59 time coming to Edmonton to announce a new plastics facility. Does the cabinet
00:40:05 table sit, do they meet in the same room? Do they know what they're doing? Because
00:40:09 here they're investing like hundreds of millions, if not millions of dollars. And on the other side,
00:40:14 they're trying to make these exact same businesses struggle. You know, it's, I don't
00:40:20 understand. Do they want a good economy or do they want to do useless things to pretend to save the
00:40:25 environment? I think the latter. I think there's, you know, to get into conspiracy, the Thomas
00:40:32 conspiracy they want to keep fossil fuels in the ground so that at some point in time
00:40:41 they own them all and then they can start bringing them out because they go well you know that
00:40:46 electric thing didn't work out so well or we don't have enough people but don't worry about it we
00:40:51 we have real we control the oil and the gas now and we'll look after getting it out to you and
00:40:57 and the power and the wealth that will generate for them for that and again this is the thomas
00:41:03 conspiracy uh i think that's their long-term goal um well certainly there are many people
00:41:13 who would agree with you and they would they would wonder who uh mr trudeau and the gang were taking
00:41:20 their orders from yes and you may be right but i will tell you you it doesn't have to be that
00:41:26 in order to explain their behavior now it is possible for these people to be genuinely and
00:41:33 sincerely mind-blowingly wrong and to have totally bought into a system of belief
00:41:41 that makes all of these things thoroughly logical and if it hurts people well you know all right
00:41:49 that's the price we have they have to pay not necessarily us but they will have to pay yeah
00:41:55 Well, even, you know, one of the talking points Trudeau always uses is that he's trying to support the middle class and those working hard to join it.
00:42:01 But almost every piece of economic policy that has come out since he's been the prime minister would be contrary to that.
00:42:10 And a lot of these laws have made it worse.
00:42:13 You know, if you're trying to get indigenous communities, and I spoke to Robbie Picard, an oil and gas activist from Fort McMurray on the Cory Morgan show this afternoon.
00:42:22 Well, how many indigenous communities would have been uplifted from the tech frontier mine? How many jobs? What does that mean for reconciliation? So, you know, I'm glad that the courts are finally saying, okay, that's enough. That's unconstitutional. That's illegal. What you're doing is wrong.
00:42:43 But how do we get that changed? Is there a way to, you know, I don't think the Liberals are ever going to start following the law. They're going to keep inventing it. But, you know, what we've seen, Calgarians picked up the phone, they called their city councillors, the bylaws gone.
00:43:02 do we think this liberal government would listen to the constituents because we've seen on the east
00:43:09 coast that when the pressure got applied to those mps they said all right carbon taxes off home
00:43:14 heating oil what can albertans what can saskatchewan what can bc what can manitoba do
00:43:20 well vote liberal they would probably tell you maybe that would make a difference i don't know
00:43:25 I don't think I could live with myself, but it's, what it's going to take, I'm afraid, is a change of government.
00:43:34 Yes.
00:43:34 And obviously, you know, that means obviously we're saying it's going to take a conservative government
00:43:41 because there isn't anybody else who might do things differently.
00:43:45 But, you know, Reeder contacted me recently and said,
00:43:48 why do you always refer to the Trudeau liberals as opposed to the government?
00:43:52 Well, I think it's important that we recognize that this liberal government is not a typical liberal government.
00:44:02 The governments led by Paul Martin and Jean Chrétien, you know, didn't have to agree with everything they thought.
00:44:11 But they were sensible enough not to do the kinds of things that this liberal government is.
00:44:19 And I think the Liberal Party has been hijacked by a faction.
00:44:25 It's a faction that's in control that just thinks that what it's doing is necessary and good.
00:44:32 And therefore, it will be done over the objections of everybody.
00:44:37 I agree. I actually, I'm wondering when...
00:44:41 So I stopped short of calling them commies. 0.56
00:44:43 Well, I think Trudeau's cabinet is a very tight group, and I think they control everything.
00:44:49 And I don't think any of the MPs outside of that circle get a lot of input.
00:44:56 I don't think they're listening to them.
00:44:58 But I also think some of them are just happy to be there and don't care.
00:45:03 I think, you know, I think they're well over getting paid well over $200,000 a year now.
00:45:08 You know, they've got the pension.
00:45:10 They've got all of these benefits.
00:45:12 So what's the point of rocking your own economic boat to go to war with the ideologues that are running your party just to get tossed out?
00:45:19 which by the way is a lot smaller than the cabinet i pass on what i've been told
00:45:26 with the warning that people sometimes exaggerate but my information is that the decision making
00:45:34 in this government is the prime minister his closest non-elected senior officials in other
00:45:41 words chief of staff principal secretary and a handful of politicians who do have his confidence
00:45:48 but that even quite senior cabinet ministers struggle to get an appointment with the Prime Minister.
00:45:55 I would agree with that.
00:45:55 Yeah.
00:45:56 And when you see people like Mr. Morneau, who actually, again,
00:46:02 I don't say that I agree with his politics,
00:46:06 but I will admit that the man understood money,
00:46:10 couldn't take it any longer,
00:46:12 bailed out before his own reputation was brought down amongst the people that he left behind.
00:46:20 So I think, actually, James, with all due respect, it's quite possible that the orbit of decision
00:46:28 making in that government is very much smaller than the whole cabinet.
00:46:32 Well, like you said earlier, Trudeau does admire the basic dictatorship in China,
00:46:36 and there's nothing more dictatorship-like than having all of the decisions for an entire nation
00:46:41 be made in one room by a very small group of people but that is all the time that we have
00:46:46 for this week I'd like to thank Mike and Nigel for joining me Corey will be back next week Derek
00:46:53 might be back next week but thank you very much for joining us this evening and we'll catch you
00:46:58 later Canadian Shooting Sports Association without the CSSA our gun rights would have been taken
00:47:04 long long ago these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms
00:47:11 regulations and legislation in Canada and more importantly educating the
00:47:15 public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people to become a
00:47:19 member it's absolutely worth every penny you can become a Western Center member
00:47:25 for just $10 a month or $99 a year