Western Standard - April 06, 2023


The Pipeline: Slippery slope of the Trump indictment

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Apr 5, 2023 Twitter CEO Elon Musk slams BBC reporter in surprise interview

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

176.18

Word count

8,105

Sentence count

656

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan join host Derek Fildebrand to talk about the Trump Indictment, a proposed bike lane on the Trans-Canada Highway, and much, much more!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching
00:00:16 The Pipeline. Today is April 5th, 2023. We've got a great show for you today. I'm joined,
00:00:25 as always, by Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford. How are you, Nigel?
00:00:28 Great, thanks. Pretty good to go. Actually, I realized we're having a blue suit convention today.
00:00:34 Yep. Well, I thought you were the one who sent the memo. Just so everyone's watching at home,
00:00:40 we do not coordinate what we're wearing, besides basic office dress codes. We've also got Western
00:00:45 Standard senior Alberta columnist Corey Morgan and host of The Corey Morgan Show with us. Mr. Corey
00:00:51 Morgan, how are you doing? Very good, Mr. Fildebrand. Did you get a new haircut or new glasses or
00:00:55 something? You look cool. Both, actually. Yes, I've tried a whole revamping. I'm glad you noticed.
00:01:00 The Botox was great. Thanks. Great. I'm going to do the lips next. Yeah. It's April 5th, so I'd be
00:01:06 remiss if I didn't note that on April 1st, we like to engage in a little bit of fake news on April 1st,
00:01:15 April Fool's Day. We've been doing this since we founded the Western Standard. We try to trick
00:01:21 the readers, especially those early morning readers. You're laying in bed, groggy, looking
00:01:25 at your phone, scrolling through the stories. And we had a great one. We'll pull it up on the
00:01:31 screen here, actually. It was that the federal government, federal budget was funding $100
00:01:37 billion to repurpose one lane of the Trans-Canada Highway to be repurposed as bike lanes.
00:01:44 Now, we had an unofficial vote on this in the newsroom here. And we came to that because
00:01:50 it sounded so damn plausible. And boy, we fooled a lot of people. It was pretty high-profile
00:01:56 people, too. We got them on the April Fool's. Because I don't think it was that... It is
00:02:01 outrageous, but it seems like something the federal government would do, which is why I
00:02:04 think it was so effective. I don't know whether you've looked at the stats, but we're still fooling
00:02:09 people on that. There's been 2,000 hits on that since April the 1st. I just hope these
00:02:16 guys actually do read to the end.
00:02:18 Because it's not April 1st anymore. They might be thinking this is just real. And you don't
00:02:23 know it's for sure until you get to the very last line, it says April Fool's. But I mean,
00:02:28 you should by the time... It's pretty outrageous by the time... It gets worse and worse as you
00:02:32 go through the article.
00:02:32 As you scroll through the article, it starts pretty serious at the top. By the time at the
00:02:36 bottom. You really should...
00:02:38 Daniel Spetz is going to invoke the Sovereignty Act and so forth.
00:02:41 Maybe not too bad, but Quebec Premier Francois Legault says he'll only allow it through Quebec
00:02:48 if Alberta pays for it. And Muslim women are not allowed to wear head coverings with their 1.00
00:02:54 bicycle helmets. That sounds entirely plausible as well.
00:02:58 To some people.
00:02:59 It's something Quebec would do. Something they would do. Okay, well, let's get onto it.
00:03:05 We've got a good show today. We're going to talk about... You all know that Donald, former
00:03:10 US President Donald Trump has been indicted on some kind of campaign finance charges related
00:03:17 to alleged hush money paid to former porn star Stormy Daniels. We're not going to talk about
00:03:25 that itself. But we're going to talk about the kind of the bigger term ramifications of
00:03:30 that because this is... It's not unprecedented that... Oh, let's say for instance, Donald
00:03:35 Trump did do this. He's guilty of a crime. He would be very far from the first US President
00:03:41 to commit a crime. I think you'd have a hard time mentioning a single US President who hasn't
00:03:46 committed a crime. But they don't seem to prosecute him. So this is changing a lot of precedent.
00:03:51 And it would... It has the potential to radically alter the nature of the American Republican
00:03:57 presidential system. So we're going to talk about kind of the slippery slope that couldn't
00:04:01 come with the Trump indictment. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she's going to sue the CBC.
00:04:08 Maybe. You've probably been following along the story where the Smith government in Alberta
00:04:15 has been accused of attempting metal with Crown prosecutors involving some of these kind
00:04:23 of crazy COVID cases where people have been facing charges for not obeying lockdown orders
00:04:29 and mandates and things like that. And a lot of what they've come up with, they've not provided
00:04:35 proof for. And Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she's going to sue the CBC. But they have
00:04:40 a month to correct the record and apologize. That's a bit unusual. And we're going to talk
00:04:46 about why. And defunding the police. Remember defunding the police, guys? Remember that?
00:04:52 That was all the rage, what, roughly two years ago? Defund the police. And we had it right
00:04:56 across Canada. Politicians, largely the municipal level, some of the provincial and federal level
00:05:01 with, you know, NDP types creeping a little towards the liberals. Liberals weren't that dumb 0.99
00:05:07 to do it. But they would not pay homage to some of the rhetoric around it. Well, defunding 0.99
00:05:12 the police. We've had, no one's, no one in Canada's gone full Seattle and totally defunded
00:05:18 the police, which, oh boy, Seattle worked out well. We're going to have to talk about the
00:05:21 Seattle example. That lasted a hot minute before it ended up in a Mad Max hellscape. But some
00:05:28 politicians did act on reducing police budgets. People like Alberta Mayor, Calgary Mayor Jody
00:05:34 Gondek, who it's kind of put in a tight spot now as we have this epidemic of urban violence,
00:05:41 particularly but not exclusively centered around areas of mass transit. We've got stabbing sprees,
00:05:46 people just being killed in random acts of violence. And I'm sure more social workers is
00:05:52 exactly what's going to fix this. Before we get into it, though, I want to thank my favorite
00:05:56 sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. I've been a member of the Canadian Shooting Sports
00:06:00 Association for well over a decade, because I trust them as Canada's leading firearms rights
00:06:05 groups. Without the CSSA fighting for firearms owners, the federal government would have likely
00:06:10 seized virtually all of our firearms by now. They are leading the fight to, at the very least,
00:06:17 try to slow down the pace of gun confiscations and persecution of gun owners in Canada and doing
00:06:24 absolutely great work. And so if you're a firearms owner or just licensed for firearms,
00:06:28 you don't be getting the free ride on this. You need to support the fight and join the Canadian
00:06:34 Shooting Sports Association. Go to cssa-cila.org or do what I do, Google them, click on membership,
00:06:41 and join up. It's worth absolutely every penny. While you're at it, you should sign up for the
00:06:46 Western Standard too, eh? I think so. Good idea. Yeah. We're one of the only media in all of Canada
00:06:52 refused to take the federal government's bailout money. Go to westernstandard.news and click on
00:06:56 membership. It's only $100 a year or $10 a month for unlimited access, supporting independent
00:07:02 journalism, and you'll have total access through our paywall to all of our content.
00:07:06 All right, let's get into it. We don't talk much American politics on the pipeline or the
00:07:12 Western Standard in general. There's enough going on north of the border, and we tend to focus more
00:07:18 on the West than elsewhere and federal issues affecting the West. But we just can't avoid it this
00:07:23 week. Former U.S. President Donald Trump has been indicted on, I think, 35 counts of technically
00:07:32 falsifying tax documents to- Business records. Business records to cover up the alleged-
00:07:40 34 counts. Yeah. All involving hush money to- alleged hush money paid to former porn star Stormy Daniels.
00:07:49 It's- we're not going to get into- I don't want to get into too much about if it's true or not. I've read
00:07:56 some stuff that this is bunk, you know, but there's always going to be two sides on this. It's very
00:08:01 political. I don't want to get into how legitimate the charges are or not. But we just have to keep in
00:08:07 mind, in the United States, in many places, the prosecution or district attorneys are elected positions.
00:08:13 This is something we're not really familiar with in Canada. These are elected positions, and it's not
00:08:19 all- they're partisan. You run as a Republican, and you run as a Democrat. In this case, it was a
00:08:26 Democrat, and he ran on a platform of indicting Trump. It's something kind of beyond the way we
00:08:33 think about these things, and I think we should probably elect more positions in Canada, but
00:08:37 electing prosecutors seems really dodgy to me, and this- seeing the consequence of it. We're seeing
00:08:43 the consequence of this. Now, I want to focus on not- first we'll talk- we know it's political. There's no
00:08:55 sense in getting into that. We know it's political. I don't think any side would deny that. Question is,
00:09:01 is this a good idea? And I- the way I see it, there's- let's just- so we can talk in- in the
00:09:09 abstract on this. Let's- let's take as a granted- which is not true. We'll take as a granted- Trump
00:09:14 is guilty. He has done something illegal. Okay. Well, there's almost certainly never been a president,
00:09:20 even a choir boy like George Washington, minus owning slaves, who's ever broken the law, and that
00:09:27 wasn't against the law at that time. Well, he was guilty of treason. Well, well, he was guilty of
00:09:33 treason against the British crown. That's entirely true. Yeah, so anyway. So virtually every president
00:09:39 has broken the law at some point, but none of them have ever been charged, let alone convicted of
00:09:44 anything. So there's- I think there's kind of two schools of thought. One is, well, they should be held
00:09:51 accountable. Presidents break the law. They should be held accountable like anyone else. Ben, that's a fair
00:09:57 argument to be made. But that means we would have to indict probably every living U.S. president,
00:10:04 a former U.S. president, except for maybe Jimmy Carter. He's probably a bad president, but he was
00:10:08 a choir boy. I'm not aware of any laws that he's broken. But Obama ordered targeted drone strikes on
00:10:15 American citizens, guys who did deserve to die, but were killed illegally. These were extrajudicial killings.
00:10:22 Obama could be brought up on first-degree murder. You know, Bill Clinton could be brought up on many
00:10:31 counts of perjury. But you don't do this in America. And I think the idea is that you don't- a lot of
00:10:37 these banana republics in parts of the other parts of the world, the former president is always thrown in 0.71
00:10:42 prison for corruption, abuse of power of some kind. Tax rule. Yes, something. And it kind of denigrates
00:10:51 the kind of people you're going to attract to the office. So I know there's been a long rambling
00:10:55 setup here. I apologize, but it's a big topic. If we just take for instance, as a granted, which is
00:11:03 not fair, but we take as granted, say Trump did break the law here, would it still be right
00:11:08 to charge him in this case? Depends what you think of the offense in question. I mean,
00:11:16 if a former president is arrested for drunk driving, yeah, he should probably face the charge.
00:11:22 However, in this case, it is so clearly aimed at the 2024 election and setting up the situation for
00:11:31 that. He's arraigned today. It's yesterday. So what are we talking about? April the 4th, 2023. Nothing
00:11:40 happens until January 2024, which is right when the next election starts. First with the primaries and
00:11:48 then with everything else. This case, I am told, now keep in mind, I am not an expert on American law.
00:11:57 However, those who I regard as credible in this matter, say that these charges are misdemeanors,
00:12:09 that the statute of limitations has run out on them, and that the only way that they could be brought
00:12:14 together is to say, ah, well, we're pursuing them because they were done to conceal a greater crime,
00:12:23 which would be a felony. Therefore, they can stand. Well, what's the greater crime? Well,
00:12:28 we're not going to tell you. So this is, I believe, on the basis of what I've heard, that this will not
00:12:36 stand up. It will fold. But meanwhile, the whole Republican Party, and Trump in particular,
00:12:45 has been put on an eight-month distraction. Just like so much of the rest of his presidency was
00:12:52 subjected to distractions, which seemed legitimate at the time. You know, the Russia investigation,
00:12:59 the Ukraine investigation, all turned out to be nothing there. But while he had to address that,
00:13:08 he was prevented from paying attention to other things that would have been better occupied at
00:13:14 the president's time. So the whole thing is political. That's not unusual, I guess, for things to be
00:13:20 political at the national level in any country. But the United States has always traded on being a
00:13:29 democratic superpower. The Second World War, massive production, arsenal of democracy. Democracy was
00:13:35 the fundamental virtue. In Iraq, what were they trying to do? Bring democracy. In Afghanistan...
00:13:41 No, that was the excuse after they couldn't find weapons of mass destruction.
00:13:43 Well, sure, but in Afghanistan...
00:13:45 It became their reason.
00:13:46 So, you know, if you're going to hold yourself up as a model of democracy,
00:13:51 you can't have a system where governments change and the new government prosecutes the old government.
00:13:58 That's how it happens in many Third World countries, some South American countries,
00:14:04 places where nobody pretends that they're truly democratic. The United States has to operate to a
00:14:11 higher standard. And this kind of political prosecution, boy, it can go both ways. You know,
00:14:17 in the saddle today, under the horses, hooves tomorrow. Right now, is Trump under the gun? Could be a
00:14:24 Democrat president when the power changes. This was a foolish, foolish move by the Democrats. 1.00
00:14:30 So, Corey, it's what I want to get into. This is with precedent. My reading of it, which is entirely 1.00
00:14:38 amateur, it looks pretty weak. They don't seem to have some smoking gun that he did anything wrong.
00:14:43 It looks more like when they got Al Capone on tax evasion. Yeah.
00:14:48 You know, like, maybe he did something. Maybe. I don't know. But it looks pretty minor. But, you know,
00:14:56 you look at, you know, even good presidents like Reagan. Reagan and George H.W. Bush, they had a Rand
00:15:01 contract. Clearly broke the law. But, like, nothing happened to them. Bill Clinton clearly broke the law.
00:15:12 Nothing happened to him. Obama clearly broke the law to kill some guys who deserve to be killed, 1.00
00:15:19 but clearly broke the law in doing so. And it's kind of just, it's been an unsaid thing that presidents 0.96
00:15:27 don't get charged. It was maybe epitomized by Nixon. We said, if the president does it,
00:15:32 it's not against the law. Something to that effect you said in his famous Frost interview,
00:15:36 which is kind of a maximalist view of presidential powers and a very dangerous view, I think. But it's
00:15:44 largely been accepted. Do you think this is win, lose or draw, whatever happens legally?
00:15:52 I think the the seals, the seals broken here. Republicans, there's also elected Republican
00:15:59 prosecutors in America do a lot of them. Do you think this is going to just start a huge round of
00:16:04 legal political recriminations where the legal system is now used to go after Biden, Obama?
00:16:10 Absolutely. I mean, you've opened that up. And it's, unfortunately, it's a reflection of how
00:16:14 vitriolic and divided the country has become. I know, you know, the listeners always get on my case
00:16:19 when I put it, I don't like Trump. I want to see that man in the rearview mirror. I'm sick of hearing
00:16:23 about Trump. I want to see a good Republican come up and have Trump in the history books. Now, this is,
00:16:28 this action has done two things. It's let him play victim. It's going to keep him in the news for the next six
00:16:33 months. And yes, the Republicans are going to be scrambling and distracted and won't be able to
00:16:37 deal with their primaries correctly. And as you said, it's unprecedented. I mean, we, you have to
00:16:43 use some judgment. A president isn't above the law. If a former president went out and stabbed somebody,
00:16:48 you take them in and you will be host being president. But presidents have killed people illegally
00:16:53 in office all the time. Like all, every president's killed people. Yes. Sometimes outside the law.
00:17:00 It's a case by case thing. This wasn't the pressing thing that they needed to turn the nation upside down
00:17:04 on and go after. It's pure vindictive approach. Going after a man that the Democrat establishment
00:17:12 despises is an unfortunate sign of what happens when you elect prosecutors. Yeah, they're gonna follow on
00:17:18 partisan lines when they really should, you know, be following that blind justice. It's a,
00:17:22 it's a disturbing precedent on all levels. And I'm saying this is somebody who again,
00:17:26 who has has no love of Trump, but this is not good for the United States at all.
00:17:31 Well, you hinted into this, Corey. Will this actually help Trump? So Trump, as a former
00:17:41 US president, obviously comes into the Republican primary or Republican nomination with a huge lead.
00:17:47 But Ron DeSantis has been making pretty good inroads. He wasn't in spitting distance,
00:17:52 but he was, he was in throwing distance, which is impressive. You know, Ron DeSantis really
00:17:59 distinguished himself during COVID as really one of the first leaders in the world. And first,
00:18:04 I'm aware of, at least in the Western world, to break the consensus around lockdowns and mandates.
00:18:09 And he threw it completely out the window. And he set off a chain reaction that kind of ended here in
00:18:15 Alberta, actually, in, in no small way, probably helped result in actually, Daniel Smith winning
00:18:23 the UCP leadership, quite the domino effect he started. And so he had, he's had a chance,
00:18:29 an outside chance, but a legitimate chance for the Republican nomination, offering some who said
00:18:34 Trumpism without Trump, that you can have a lot of the policies and things that he stands for without
00:18:39 kind of a narcissism that comes with Donald Trump. But a poll that came out that kind of did a kind
00:18:46 of an overnight poll after the indictment. And Trump's now just got a huge lead. Maybe that's
00:18:53 just short term here. We'll start with you, Nigel, is this going to help Donald Trump, I guess, maybe in
00:18:58 two parts, with the primary election, to get the Republican nomination, and then two, possibly with
00:19:04 the general election. Okay, if you want to be deeply conspiratorial about this, yes, it will help him in
00:19:10 the primary, because there's a huge sympathy factor. People who voted for Trump, people who like Trump,
00:19:16 are scandalized by the fact that the old convention, once you're out of office, they leave you alone,
00:19:22 with your conscience, you know, they're going to rally to his cause. He will probably sweep away
00:19:30 with the nomination. The second part of it is what you referred to about the actual election itself.
00:19:38 Now, the margins are incredibly, without getting into the whole, you know, January the 6th thing,
00:19:45 it was a close run election. You didn't need to move a lot of people from one side to the
00:19:51 other side, to bring about a different result. So, what do the Democrats do? They create this
00:20:00 massive paintbrush of a spear. It ensures that he gets the nomination. They, perhaps foolishly,
00:20:09 but they regard him as the weaker candidate, the one that they could more easily destroy.
00:20:14 Well, most of the data, most of the data supports that, that, you know, DeSantis would
00:20:19 wipe the floor with Biden. Many Republicans would, but Trump has got his hardcore base,
00:20:24 but he, a lot of Republicans have soured on Trump in the last couple of years.
00:20:30 So, you know, maybe they, maybe this is their, one of their, one of the spin-offs
00:20:34 of this would be get the candidate that they want. They better be careful what they wish for,
00:20:40 because I know there was a time when I personally, I can't speak for the conservative party,
00:20:45 when I say, oh yeah, let it, let it be Justin Trudeau. What a lightweight, you know, all hair
00:20:50 and teeth. And of course, now we've had seven and a half years of, of Justin Trudeau. It's been
00:20:56 a very, very bad thing for the country. So you can, you can call these things wrong. And I certainly did.
00:21:02 Maybe the Democrats would call that wrong too. You just don't know how these, like 10 months away,
00:21:06 man, that's a long time to, sorry, 18 months away for the, for the general, for the general election,
00:21:13 19 months. It's, who knows what can happen. For him to say he could have a heart attack and die.
00:21:18 So could Biden. You just don't know how these things are going to break. But the, the, I'm sure
00:21:24 that that's in the back of their minds. They'd rather face Trump the second time than DeSantis for
00:21:29 the first time. Corey, do you think this helps Trump, I guess, I guess, kind of two part,
00:21:33 win the Republican nomination? Is DeSantis got no hope now at this point? Or, and then second,
00:21:41 if Trump does get the nomination, is this going to help or hurt him? I won't go as far as saying
00:21:45 that DeSantis has no hope, but this is, this plays right into what Trump likes to do. He's
00:21:48 a victim of the establishment. They're coming to get me and they're rigging the game. They are
00:21:52 playing into the narrative he's building here. And that's how he loves to play. And that galvanizes
00:21:57 his supporters and it brings them out. And he campaigned in a sense as an anti-establishment
00:22:02 person, the time he won. I mean, Pennsylvania, areas like that, working class people say,
00:22:07 I'm going to stand up to the machine, the system. And right now the machine, the system does seem to
00:22:12 be coming after him and it gives him an ability to play that. Now that may or may not, if he wins the
00:22:18 nomination, I think it strengthens him for it, for sure. And if he does win it,
00:22:24 as we said, you know, it's hard to predict. As Nigel said, there could be an unintended consequence.
00:22:27 If he plays that right, markets it right, he could suddenly end up becoming president again.
00:22:32 And boy, what a wild four years we're in for then. And what do you want to bet that there's
00:22:36 going to be some Republican prosecutor somewhere who's now going to go look at those Democrat
00:22:41 prosecutor and try to find some grain to get him for malicious prosecution? I just, I think we're
00:22:50 entering a really dangerous period here. And I'm not sure what the right answer is.
00:22:55 Political recriminations and throwing all your ex-presidents in jail does not work for countries
00:23:01 to do that. But at the same time, you break the law, you should be held accountable. I'm not really
00:23:04 sure what the right way is to go. All I do know is if you're going to charge presidents, you have to
00:23:11 charge all of them for which we know they've broken crimes. And boy, it could get pretty crowded and sell
00:23:18 block P. Okay. We're going to move on now, bring it a little closer to home. Alberta Premier Daniel
00:23:26 Smith started as kind of a CBC story here trying to gin up a scandal. It goes back a while. Those of you
00:23:35 have watched the pipeline know the background of the story that Daniel Smith was accused by the CBC of
00:23:42 interfering with prosecutors who are going after people who were charged for violating lockdowns and
00:23:50 mandates and all this silly stuff that happened under the Kennedy government.
00:23:52 Prosecutors who weren't even elected.
00:23:54 Yes. Yes. We're still dealing with prosecutors here. Quite the segue. I didn't even put that
00:24:00 together. The CBC's whole story was based on emails from the Smith's Premier's office to the
00:24:09 prosecutors. After that story came out, the CBC was forced to admit they actually never saw the emails.
00:24:14 They just talked to someone who says the emails exist.
00:24:17 Okay. Well, I mean, that's not quite the solid story they were saying. I'm not saying the emails
00:24:24 don't exist. But it was an important detail the CBC left out of the original story. CBC's continued
00:24:30 on this. There was a call we talked about last week with Calgary Street Feature, Arthur Pulaski.
00:24:38 She says she doesn't have the power to pardon him and stuff. So I'm not really sure what the problem was.
00:24:41 But either way, the Smith now has come out and said, CBC retract the story or I'm going to sue you.
00:24:49 Okay, that sort of made sense. But what got me was, and you have until the end of April to do it,
00:24:55 a month. Now, if you've ever gotten a defamation notice before, you're normally given 24 hours.
00:25:04 That's pretty standard. You got 24 hours to meet this condition, this condition, and this condition.
00:25:08 Otherwise, we're going to sue your pants wire anymore. We're on cable. Crap. We're not we're
00:25:13 going to sue your behind. But they gave them a month. What's up with you, Corey? Why? Does that
00:25:19 look fishy to you? Like, is that weird? It's something I don't like saying very often, but I
00:25:22 don't know. It is weird that I'll grant. I mean, as you said, if there's something untrue, there's
00:25:28 something that's damaging, then you as the victim of it, you want that gone as soon as possible. You want
00:25:33 the retraction as quickly as possible, if you're going to get one. Or, you know, move forward,
00:25:39 you don't say, you know, that's really damaging and unfair and hurtful and wrong. And I'm going to
00:25:43 put up with it for another month until you reconsider it. So it's, it's unusual. And I can't see the
00:25:50 benefit in giving such an extended notice on this. I'm not drawing a line in the sand. Well, there is
00:25:56 another line in the sand that takes place around that exact same time, the writ drops for the official
00:26:01 election period to begin. Maybe it's because they want a story of like, okay, he gave the CBC all
00:26:07 this time, and we're going to sue him now. I don't know. Well, that's kind of the way I was thinking
00:26:13 about it. I was, I was, you know, that's brave of you to say, I don't know, because I was getting
00:26:18 ready to mouth those words. And then suddenly, I thought, wait a minute, this gives her a good story,
00:26:23 right as the election starts, right as the writ drops. Because this whole story, as it has played out
00:26:30 so far, and we don't know the end of it. But as it has played out, so far is a classic smear.
00:26:40 You put something out there. The other side denies it. The denial is never as persuasive as the original
00:26:47 allegation. And now there will be people who go to their grave, if they still care about this, saying,
00:26:55 they never could prove it, you know. Well, there was something there, or the CBC wouldn't have said it.
00:27:00 Well, look, it is possible the CBC is right. Well, it is. I don't think, I don't think it's
00:27:04 likely, but it's possible they are. I can't imagine why they would put themselves out there so far.
00:27:10 I don't have something. Some of, I know some of you are going to get angry, because I'm going to say,
00:27:15 there are some good journalists at the CBC. And I know some of the ones who worked on this story.
00:27:20 And, you know, they're serious people, serious journalists. But I kind of raised my eyebrow when
00:27:27 they published the original story saying, you know, emails show blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then
00:27:31 they had to correct their own story and say, well, we haven't seen the emails. We talked to a guy who
00:27:36 says he saw emails. So I don't have two minds on this. And also just, I don't know, I'm pretty confident
00:27:44 those emails don't exist. I mean, I think perhaps, you know, obviously, the CBC reporters were confident
00:27:49 that they did. But at this point, with the amount of grief, with the amount of stuff that's gone on,
00:27:54 I mean, if somebody could even take screen snaps of them and have forwarded them to the CBC or
00:27:58 something, you just hold the phone out for the CBC reporter. Yes. And that hasn't happened. They
00:28:04 never even could admit that they even saw them. So that's reporting on a rumor. And there's a lot
00:28:09 of danger in that, you know, so I suspect those don't exist.
00:28:13 No, I mean, it looks like a smear job that backfired. And it could, the best explanation
00:28:21 for the 30 days is just, it makes a better story as she goes into the election. 0.99
00:28:25 But is it a good story? Because, I mean, CBC backs down under threat of suit. I mean,
00:28:31 that's not a bad story. If the CBC backs down. But here's the thing about the CBC. They're not a real,
00:28:36 they're not a private company like the Western Standard. We get a defamation notice, even if we're
00:28:42 pretty confident in the story. I mean, there's a huge financial incentive to retract it anyway,
00:28:46 because we don't have a bottomless pit of money. But you know who does have a bottomless pit of
00:28:51 money? The federal government and the CBC. The CBC gets more than a billion dollars a year.
00:28:56 And do you want to bet for a minute that if Danielle Smith beat the CBC and got maximum damages,
00:29:04 that Justin Trudeau wouldn't turn around and just make them whole and cut a check?
00:29:07 They don't have any shareholders to answer to. They have no economic incentives to answer to.
00:29:12 The federal government would just turn around and say,
00:29:14 okay, Danielle Smith won $5 million. Here's a check for $5 million.
00:29:18 That's true. But boy, the reputational damage would be quite large.
00:29:22 Yes, it would.
00:29:23 If I were the CBC, I wouldn't want that.
00:29:25 No, but they have the ability to fight it in court to its maximum extent.
00:29:30 So if they think they've got any change, like, if you're, you know, if a big guy comes at you and
00:29:35 threatens to sue you, you've got to be pretty confident you're going to win. Because the
00:29:41 financial resources of going to court are so enormous. But you know, if a big guy is threatening
00:29:47 to sue a big guy, those things do go to trial, because they both got limitless resources to do
00:29:52 it. The CBC has limitless resources to pursue this. So if the CBC thinks they've got better than
00:30:01 a 25% chance of winning, they probably go to court. And the very least, it punts the issue out for
00:30:07 years before this thing would actually get solved. It'll go for years and years and years long after
00:30:12 the provincial election.
00:30:13 So somewhere down in the CBC office, there is a conversation that has either taken place or has
00:30:18 to take place at some point, where the people working on that story get pulled into the office
00:30:25 and say, who actually saw these emails? Did you see them? Well, actually, no.
00:30:33 Oh, they admit they didn't see them.
00:30:34 They didn't. That's right. So who was it who said that they had seen them? Well, I can't tell you that.
00:30:41 Look, we're all in the room together. This is serious stuff. Are we confident?
00:30:49 And there'll be a kind of a shakedown of who is, who is visibly sweating? Okay. You know, so
00:31:01 all of what you say is true about the limitless resource. But on a year to year basis, they still
00:31:05 have budgets to meet. And there's some, you know, I think the only damage would be reputational for the
00:31:10 CBC. Huge. As long as Trudeau is still prime minister, he would simply write them a check.
00:31:15 And also, you know, $5 million would be considered like record damages for defamation in Canada.
00:31:22 $5 million. The CBC doesn't sweat $5 million. It's nothing. They can afford even to pay,
00:31:30 even after legal fees, they can afford to pay maximum damages and not really have a significant
00:31:34 financial impact to the bottom line. Their only impact would be reputationally.
00:31:40 Well, that would be big.
00:31:43 I don't know, but is there a win for Smith in this? Because
00:31:47 I'm sure she just wants this issue to disappear though. I mean, this is one where they,
00:31:50 you could see they're trying to widen the crack. They're trying to build mistrust. I'm not talking
00:31:55 just about the CBC, but opponents politically. This is a case of mistrust. It's he said, she said,
00:32:00 or whatnot. And that was the intention of the smear in the first place. It's just,
00:32:05 even if there's nothing there, you create the, you create that a little bit of smoke.
00:32:08 Well, that's again, if it's a smear.
00:32:10 And that's what recently happened though, is they kind of brought it all up again and threw it in.
00:32:14 And that turns out there was no new revelations in this. You just regurgitated the story with a
00:32:20 video clip attached to it. I mean, Smith just wants this story out of the scroll, which again,
00:32:25 this is why I have surprises dragging out. Yeah. But, and I think there's a lot of parallel,
00:32:32 some, I don't take it as granted that this is a smear and that there is nothing here. I,
00:32:38 I will accept there's a possibility that it happened. I mean, it was a new government that
00:32:43 came in. They had like no staff. They kind of stumbled into the office because they had to get
00:32:48 Kenny out in 24 hours after she became Smith, after Smith became premier, because he was continuing to
00:32:54 govern in his own right, not act as an interim premier. So they kind of stumbled into the
00:32:58 premier's office. They expected to go in, but there was no transition that you didn't
00:33:02 traditionally have. We've talked about this before. It's possible an accident happened.
00:33:07 I don't know. On balance of things, it doesn't look like it was likely true, but
00:33:13 I think there's a possibility it is. Well, you'd have to ask yourself, well,
00:33:16 what's the CBC hanging onto it for if it's all true and they've got the proof? What did that mean?
00:33:21 Oh, are we holding it for the election? No, not necessarily. They, it is possible. CBC is telling
00:33:30 the truth, but they can't burn their source. And, and, and that's, that's a really dicey thing because
00:33:35 to defend yourself in court. You should be able to expose the emails without burning the source,
00:33:39 even a screen snap of them. Yeah. Or as Nigel said, just have one of the reporters say, yes,
00:33:44 the source showed me and I saw the email and they can't even do that. So yeah, no,
00:33:51 they haven't even seen an email held on a screen up to them. They can't even say that. And that's
00:33:57 pretty flimsy. Yeah. Yeah. I don't think we'd go for that in our newsroom, would we?
00:34:04 No, I want to float something really creepy past you. But I can see that. I've seen the email, Derek,
00:34:08 but I can, I can see the temptation, especially if, if the source is someone we trust. Like,
00:34:14 let's say it's someone we all know. This is a good guy. It's a friend. He wouldn't screw us.
00:34:19 And he comes and says, Nigel, I saw an email that says, I'm not even a joke. He'll get me sued.
00:34:28 I saw an email from Justin Trudeau to a guy admitting to murder. I'd be like, oh, that's a
00:34:36 big story. That's a big story. I want us to break that story. And we trust this guy,
00:34:42 but he won't even show you the email. I'm taking him on his word. I can see the temptation's there.
00:34:49 You're going to break a huge story, make a career out of it.
00:34:52 Or end one. Or end one. But like, you can see the temptation for a journalist to do that.
00:35:01 And, but that's part of our jobs is resisting that temptation as much as possible. Okay.
00:35:09 They say on cable news, time will tell. Yeah. Time will tell. All right. We're going to keep it,
00:35:17 uh, well, kind of go nationwide, but a little bit, some relevant here in Alberta. Um,
00:35:24 there were two years ago, uh, following the murder of, uh, George Floyd. This was,
00:35:29 um, he was a criminal, uh, being rightfully arrested in the United States, it seems,
00:35:34 but the police officer used bizarrely excessive force and put him in essentially a chokehold with his
00:35:42 knee guy saying, I can't breathe and he dies. And, uh, the police officer, Derek Chauvin convicted of
00:35:50 murder. And I think rightfully so, uh, but this sparked the black lives matter thing, which initially 1.00
00:35:55 I was like, oh, okay, well, you know, I think police brutality is a important issue and
00:36:00 some of this is relevant. And then it kind of spun way out of control and it became, uh, kind of a
00:36:06 racial social justice warrior woke mob and they started getting into defund the police. Um, and
00:36:17 defund the police became real, uh, really in vogue saying with a lot of lefty politicians and activists
00:36:23 for a while. We saw it right across, uh, Canada to different extents. You know, you saw Justin Trudeau,
00:36:29 uh, take a knee and bow to BLM. You had a lot of mayors or municipal politicians sort of adopt the
00:36:37 language around to fund the police. Here in Calgary, we had Jodi Gondek. Now she was a city 0.73
00:36:42 counselor at the time, not yet the mayor, but she, uh, advocated for and voted for measures
00:36:48 to as much as possible defund the police. They didn't, there was no proposal I'm aware of to go as
00:36:54 far as Seattle did, which was to defund the police, which resulted in, um, ganglords seizing power
00:37:03 within 24 hours, going around executing people. It was like a scene from Mad Max. Uh,
00:37:09 you know, uh, I think they had like what they're like vegan collectives and stuff in the streets
00:37:14 until they all starved and ran out of food. It was pretty funny. Um, we didn't go that far,
00:37:19 but they definitely, you know, they cut the police budget,
00:37:21 try to reallocate it to some squishier things. Uh, you saw this in Edmonton too. And, uh,
00:37:28 well now it's been, it's been two years and we've got lower police budgets. Uh, we've had an epidemic
00:37:34 of violence. We're now going through a stabbing spree across Canada, including right here in Calgary.
00:37:40 Uh, you just hop onto the LRT lines and you'll see just those LRTs become, uh, hold up that, uh,
00:37:47 you know, Corey's got a map here, just to kind of the crime, the crime, uh, I see that. Yeah.
00:37:54 So the, the crime lines, the heat map with the, the darker orange zones are actually coincidentally
00:37:59 all right along the LRT lines throughout the city. So it appears there's quite a correlation
00:38:04 between crime and, and, and the, uh, no, no one wants to go on this. You know, uh, city Congress says,
00:38:10 we're gonna spend billions of dollars for, uh, for the green lines, but more people use transit.
00:38:15 Maybe get the stabby meth heads off. That'll get people back on. Start there. Yeah. Let's start with
00:38:21 the stabby meth heads. Um, but no. So anyway, uh, this, this kind of came to what had yesterday, uh,
00:38:28 Alberta premier Danielle Smith stood with, uh, some police chiefs and, uh, Calgary mayor Jody Gondack,
00:38:35 who, um, has previously called for defunding the police. Uh, and she was asked a question.
00:38:41 I think it was a bit of a loaded question. It was the overall intent of the question,
00:38:45 I think was fair and relevant. It was a bit loaded, but, um, she didn't really like getting
00:38:49 asked tough questions. Uh, let's, uh, let's roll that question for mayor Gondack key in with the
00:38:55 counter signal. Uh, just a few months ago, a handful of months ago, you were fighting tooth and nail
00:39:00 again, against increasing the police budget and you were actively supporting defund the police
00:39:07 rhetoric. I'm just wondering when you realized that police forces were not optional, did it take,
00:39:13 you know, the random stabbings, wives getting stabbed, police officers getting killed to realize
00:39:18 that it was important to fund police departments and how can Calgarians trust you when you flip-flop
00:39:24 on basic issues like public safety? So, uh, yeah, you saw there that, uh, Calgary mayor Jody Gondack,
00:39:35 not very happy about getting asked this question. Again, it was a bit of a loaded question.
00:39:40 Overall, the intent of it was quite fair and relevant. Uh, just no response. I'll start with
00:39:45 you, Corey. What would have been the appropriate way for Jody Gondack, who had very clearly supported
00:39:51 the defund the police movement before she was mayor, but when she was a city councilor now 0.93
00:39:55 standing there, uh, beside, uh, provincial politicians and chiefs accepting more, more money
00:40:01 for the police? Well, I mean, a good, smart political answer would say circumstances have
00:40:06 changed from that time until today. And then we reevaluated things, but with the addiction epidemic
00:40:11 and other changing factors, the lockdowns have really, you know, shaken things up and clearly crime
00:40:16 has just become more acute. We obviously have to get some more boots on the ground to protect
00:40:20 Calgary is there. I could have written that and given it to her. It would look a lot better than
00:40:24 a blank stare for three seconds and storming away from the microphone. Be a BS political answer, 0.99
00:40:28 but at least be, I mean, as a mayor, she should be good enough to come up with that. Yeah. Any 0.99
00:40:32 politician could pull that out of the back pocket. Um, you know, Jody Gondack is, again, I don't want to
00:40:39 get too into the weeds for Calgary. We've got a national audience here. Um, but she's, you know, kind of a
00:40:44 symbol for that BLM and defund the police movement. Uh, where have these guys gone? I know, I know in
00:40:52 Seattle, they were murdered by their own gang lords who seized power and a few square blocks in their
00:40:57 vegan collective, but, uh, where have these advocates gone? Well, they very wisely stayed silent because
00:41:04 there really isn't the whole message of defund the police was misinterpreted by the criminal element.
00:41:10 It came out of the incident that you described with, uh, with the George Floyd murder and people
00:41:19 could get that an aggressive police force needed to be restrained if in fact it was aggressive.
00:41:26 And there has been a militarization of the police. Like you look at some of these guys,
00:41:29 they look like they're seal team six. There was, there was the video evidence of it. Uh, however,
00:41:35 what the criminal element heard is that defund the police, great. Anything goes. So if we got a
00:41:42 problem, we can work it out on the LRT. We can either go someplace and lift some property, call some,
00:41:49 call some damage, do some crime, whatever is advantageous. We can shoot up on the LRT. We can
00:41:56 make it shag on the LRT. Apparently so that's a well-watched video. Uh, so if you haven't seen it,
00:42:03 yeah, we've got the video up on the Edmonton LRT of a, of a couple, um, engaging in, uh,
00:42:10 they're having it away under a blanket right there on the LRT. And meanwhile, there's somebody
00:42:14 sitting back there thinking, I can't believe what I'm seeing. I got to film this. And we ended up
00:42:19 with the video. So, you know, defunding the police sends a message that nobody is paying attention to
00:42:26 what's going on around them anymore. Nobody cares. You can trace it all the way back to the broken window
00:42:32 theory that, uh, Rudy Giuliani brought in in New York. Once you start showing that you care,
00:42:39 the crime goes down. When you show that you don't care, that's what defund the police says
00:42:43 to the criminal mind. Well, then guess what? Up goes criminal, criminal elements,
00:42:50 criminal acts. So that's what's happened here. And I, you asked the question, where are these people gone?
00:42:55 They are stupid, but they're not so stupid as to stand by that original recommendation when 1.00
00:43:03 manifestly it doesn't work. They've just shut up. They shut up and let's hope they stay that way. 1.00
00:43:09 You know, when the defund the police thing happened, there was originally some interesting
00:43:14 writing that I thought was actually worth paying attention to. And these weren't people saying defund
00:43:18 the police, but it was like demilitarize the police said, you know, like you could talk about
00:43:22 reforming them. I mean, I think people would agree there were cultural problems. There were
00:43:27 structural problems and that's what's leading to police officers acting out. I mean, look to that,
00:43:33 but we're on earth with anything else. We say this system is failing. So the best thing we could do for
00:43:37 is to take the money away from it. You know, the healthcare system says we should defund it and make it
00:43:40 a little better. Education was defund the teachers and our children all get A's. I mean, it's,
00:43:45 it's absurd, but the trend went and the wave went and some politicians actually followed through with
00:43:50 it and we're seeing the fruit of it. What it did was demoralize police. And that also led to,
00:43:56 I think, further acting out on officers that weren't acting properly. It was an unintended consequence,
00:44:01 but I think as Nigel said, they realize how naive and how much this backfired and the wiser ones are
00:44:06 just, well, we'll just kind of slip into the background on this one and wait for the next issue.
00:44:10 I mean, there, there are instances, you get, you got a person with mental illness,
00:44:18 they're having problems, they have a bad day, they become suicidal and they want the police to shoot.
00:44:24 So they run out of the house with a dagger and threaten people and so forth.
00:44:32 The argument is, well, we need less police and more social workers, but you know,
00:44:35 the social worker who wants to jump into that situation is going to be a rare find. 1.00
00:44:40 Yeah. All right. Well, we're going to have to wrap it up there.
00:44:43 Nigel, Corey, thank you for joining me today. And thank all of you for joining us on the pipeline
00:44:48 and the Western Standard. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, please go to
00:44:51 westernstandard.news, click on membership. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year to join us to get
00:44:57 full access to all Western Standard content past that pesky paywall that I know you keep on hitting
00:45:02 against. You'll be supporting independent media. We are one of probably about three,
00:45:10 maybe four media in the entire country that refuse to accept the federal government's media bailout.
00:45:16 And we rely on advertisers like the Canadian Shooting Sports Association and direct support
00:45:22 from members like you. So sign up today. Thank you very much for joining us. God bless.
00:45:28 Canadian Shooting Sports Association. Without the CSSA,
00:45:31 our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago. These guys are on the front lines helping
00:45:37 to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada. And more importantly,
00:45:43 educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people. We've become a
00:45:48 member. It's absolutely worth every penny. You can become a Western Standard member for
00:45:54 just $10 a month or $99 a year for unlimited access.