Western Standard - January 26, 2023


The Pipeline: Smith, prosecutor controversy continues

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The next election will be a fight between Trudeau's status quo and Poilievre's rejection of it Ottawa Exposed: Danielle Smith says no to Trudeau's reckless lockdowns.

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

157.71

Word count

6,785

Sentence count

414

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hanford and Editor-in-Chief Dave Naylor join host Derek Vildebrandt and Managing Editor-In-Chief of the Western Standard, Niki Hanford, to discuss the ongoing saga surrounding Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and her pardons for people facing federal charges.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening. I'm Derek Vildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching
00:00:28 the pipeline. Today is January 25, 2023. And a very good evening to you all. I'm joined as usual
00:00:36 by Western Standard Opinion Editor, Nigel Hanford. How are you, Nigel? Good today. Thank you. I know
00:00:40 you're working on some good projects. I guess we have to keep that hush for now. We can't say
00:00:45 anything right now. Okay. Also joined, not as usual, because the great Cory Morgan is down
00:00:53 somewhere warmer for the time being, but kind of a flashback to one of the founding panel members
00:00:59 of the pipeline, Western Standard News Editor, Dave Naylor. How are you, Dave? I'm great,
00:01:03 Derek. Glad to be here. Beautiful. Yeah, we had a funny moment the other day. I saw on Facebook,
00:01:07 you had this picture up and you had no hair, it was just buzzed. And everyone was in the
00:01:12 comments section saying, you look like Heisenberg. Maybe to make a little money on the side of the
00:01:16 standard, you're running a crystal math lab. You came into work the next day and you didn't have
00:01:21 your hair head shaved it's just a filter i guess you have on yeah it was a snapchat filter a friend
00:01:26 took it and i put it up and i can't believe how many people thought it was real look pretty
00:01:30 realistic yeah it was great yeah yeah so for the record dave is not uh cooking crystal meth in his
00:01:36 basement but i'm afraid what my skull looks like when there's no hair on it at least i don't think
00:01:41 you're cooking no okay definitely not okay um we got an interesting show today um the controversy
00:01:50 around Danielle Smith and seeking pardons and whatnot for people who were persecuted
00:02:00 by the Alberta provincial government while Kenny was in power continues. You know, it's
00:02:08 a combination of a few things. There's around pardons and then there's around alleged interference
00:02:13 with prosecutors. Those are two very different things. And, you know, the CBC has been putting
00:02:19 out stories without evidence, but they're standing by it. So it's in a weird limbo, where they're
00:02:24 claiming that people have claimed to see emails that would lead to interference and prosecution.
00:02:31 CBC hasn't seen the emails. Story continues to evolve and become quite controversial. We're
00:02:36 going to, we're going to dive into that. Less controversial is numbers around fundraising,
00:02:44 preparing for the next provincial election in Alberta. After several years of lagging behind
00:02:48 the NDP, the UCP have now either matched the NDP or arguably, depending on how you're slicing the
00:02:55 numbers, gotten ahead of the NDP, both raising seven million dollars in 2022 in the unofficial
00:03:01 numbers so far. But if you include leadership fundraising from the leadership campaigns for
00:03:06 the UCP, the UCP would have a significant lead at 10.8 million. So we're going to talk about that,
00:03:11 what this means for the United Conservative Party and both of the parties as we go into
00:03:17 the provincial election. Unsurprisingly, subsidizing the federal government subsidizing the media is not doing enough to stem the bleeding post media, the biggest newspaper company in the country by far laying off 11% of their editorial workforce, scrapping a bunch of their print copies, which is probably actually a smart move, and moving to remote offices and virtually every newspaper across the country.
00:03:44 country. So damning stuff, the federal government's media bellows still not enough money for big media, laying off reporters, shutting down newsrooms right across the country. Before we get started, though, we got to thank as usual, my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. I know you're sick of hearing me say it, but I've been a member of the CSSA for more than a decade, because they are Canada's leading firearms rights group. Without the CSSA, the federal government would have likely confiscated
00:04:14 all of our firearms a long time ago by this point. Membership of the CSSA is vital to ensure
00:04:21 that there's an organization speaking for firearms owners in Canada to educate people
00:04:26 and to fight the federal government where necessary against ridiculous and arbitrary
00:04:33 firearm seizures and limitations about what law-abiding people can do with their firearms.
00:04:38 So if you're not yet a member of the CSSA, make sure you go to CSSA-CILA.org or just Google CSSA as I do and become a member today.
00:04:47 It's vital for firearms owners to stand together. That's why I've been a member for so long.
00:04:52 Okay, so we're going to start with the controversy around Alberta Premier Danielle Smith.
00:05:00 Due to our own horn a little bit, this actually started in an interview we did with Danielle Smith during their convention.
00:05:07 uh the party's first convention right after she was elected uh leader of the party and uh
00:05:12 made premier um i was asked i asked her about pardons for people who are facing at least
00:05:20 provincial charges not federal charges provincial charges uh involving covet people who refuse to
00:05:25 shut their restaurants down wouldn't close their churches down people who were charged for uh you 0.78
00:05:31 know calgary police beat the crap out of a kid for playing pond hockey all sorts of ridiculous 0.97
00:05:36 things. And I asked her about pardons for this. And I'll put words in her mouth, but her response 0.66
00:05:43 was along the lines of, yeah, that's something we should absolutely be looking at. She couldn't
00:05:47 speak to the specifics of it, what powers the province has, but it doesn't. Pardons are one
00:05:53 thing because it wouldn't be favoritism. It would just say this was an inappropriate application of
00:05:58 the law. The province overstepped its bounds and shouldn't have been bringing in these restrictions
00:06:02 anyway. And so there'd just be a blanket pardon for people who didn't actually do anything violent
00:06:08 or damage property, that kind of thing. But the story took a bit of a twist. I think last week
00:06:15 when the CBC claimed that people, they had seen, they have talked to people in Smith's office who
00:06:24 have seen emails between the Premier's office and prosecutors that would show some kind of
00:06:31 interference with prosecutorial independence. That'd be an issue. Dave, why don't you fill in
00:06:35 the blanks there? Well, after that CBC story came out, obviously it exploded because if true,
00:06:41 it's a huge, huge problem. It's a huge scandal. You cannot have the premier or politicians
00:06:46 interfering in the judicial system. The UCP or Daniel Smith brought in the public service to
00:06:56 through all their emails over the weekend and they couldn't find any and they said that's it
00:07:02 story done and dusted so that threw the ball back into the cbc's court they put out a they updated
00:07:10 their story to say they stand by it and they didn't take it down so but as of a few minutes
00:07:16 ago cbc appears to have doubled down and brought in another story saying after the election or
00:07:24 sorry after she won the leadership but danielle smith visited the justice minister and spoke
00:07:30 about this stuff uh which to me i think you would do right i mean you just you're looking at it as
00:07:36 an education experience okay what she told me in an interview she would do that i'm not sure how
00:07:41 this is what's going on now but see and then cbc took it from there to say uh uh you know she she
00:07:49 She became, you know, very pushy in wanting to get this stuff done.
00:07:53 We've got a call into the Premier's office, he'll be on the site shortly, that is denying it,
00:08:01 saying that nothing unprofessional happened.
00:08:05 The Justice Minister has put out a similar statement.
00:08:08 And I think the key thing to remember is the statement from the Crown Prosecutor's Office themselves,
00:08:12 who said they had not been in touch.
00:08:14 So, you know, CBC is doubling down, still no proof, still no named sources, which is fine, that's what journalists do, but it's going to be still a bubbling story.
00:08:29 Unnamed sources are one thing. We've used unnamed sources. Sometimes you've got people in a corporation, in a government, some kind of organization, and if they use their name, well, they'd be fired, and therefore they would never talk to you.
00:08:41 So I don't think there's anything wrong with an unnamed source, but you've got to be ready to stand by it.
00:08:46 You've got to do your best to corroborate it from other sources, even if they're unnamed.
00:08:51 You've got to be confident in it.
00:08:52 Now, this CBC story, the CBC says they have not seen the emails themselves.
00:09:00 They have just been told by people in the Premier's office, in the government, that they have seen emails.
00:09:08 I don't know.
00:09:09 So, Dave, if you came in and you presented that story to us and that was our sources, we've talked to people who have seen emails, I'd be pretty nervous about publishing.
00:09:19 I'd want to see a copy of it.
00:09:21 I'd want to see a copy.
00:09:22 One thing to keep in mind is that Signifier is saying CBC hasn't seen the emails, only came in the second day after the story was published.
00:09:33 But that was not in the original.
00:09:34 That was not in the original story.
00:09:35 Yeah.
00:09:36 Yeah. You better trust your sources to be right on this one.
00:09:40 So this, Nigel, is not to say the story is incorrect. We don't know yet. There's an allegation made by the CBC on maybe they're correct, but it's it's definitely not rock solid, at least at this time.
00:09:55 um both the premier's office and the CBC are doubling down both I suppose both could be right
00:10:04 that someone went rogue in the office and the Smith and the higher-ups didn't know maybe I
00:10:09 suppose they could both be right but uh public services investigated say they didn't find
00:10:14 anything the prosecutor's office which is quite independent look they say they didn't find
00:10:19 anything uh how much risk is there for Smith here because the story keeps bubbling even if some of
00:10:24 this stuff isn't very related. They are saying, you know, hey, we have emails, you know, a letter
00:10:30 from Ezra Levant to the rebel to chief of staff to Smith saying, here's ways you could look at
00:10:37 pardoning people. I don't think that's news. I'm not sure how I think they're maybe they smell 0.99
00:10:43 blood in the water, and they're trying to gin things up a bit more. Is there a real story here,
00:10:47 you think? I suspect that in the end there isn't but what I mean what we know is that she you
00:10:55 described how she said yes this is something we should look at it was of interest to people who
00:11:01 were likely to support her so she would ask once she became premier all right what can we do now
00:11:13 At that point, it becomes a matter of interpretation.
00:11:17 If you don't like Danielle Smith, the very fact that you ask that question becomes evidence of interference.
00:11:24 If you do like Danielle Smith, then you would accept what the press secretary for the premier's office said,
00:11:34 which was that after taking office, the premier and her staff had several discussions with the minister of justice
00:11:41 and Justice Department Public Service requesting an explanation of what policy options were.
00:11:49 Happens to be a justice matter.
00:11:51 If you've got a policy on pipelines, you would probably have a similar kind of a discussion
00:11:56 with the officials who have the details.
00:11:59 What are our policy options?
00:12:01 So, for me, so much will depend upon what, if anything, the CBC is ever able to put on the table and say,
00:12:13 well, here is the email that our source saw, and it depends entirely on what it says.
00:12:21 I would be very surprised. I would be extremely surprised if they have anything that comes remotely close in tone or tenor to what was going on in the federal government with SNC-Lavalin, for example.
00:12:37 I have noticed, though, the Premier's office is couching its language, careful not to say no emails exist.
00:12:48 They're saying none could be found and we're not aware of any.
00:12:53 Someone, it is possible someone could have sent something inappropriate.
00:12:57 But again, we've not seen the email.
00:12:58 This is CBC saying we've talked to a guy who says they saw the email.
00:13:04 Again, not to say that that email doesn't exist and the source is incredible.
00:13:07 But it's not very solid. But the premier's office is being careful to say, not that it didn't happen.
00:13:16 Of course, they should be. I mean, it would be very foolish to, but what was it, somebody's private email? We don't know.
00:13:24 You'd be pretty silly as a, you know, a Daniel Smith staffer to use your official email for something like that. 0.97
00:13:31 Yeah. Let's talk about what interference is, because I suppose reasonable people could probably draw different conclusions about this. 0.95
00:13:39 I would see interference as involving yourself in specific cases.
00:13:45 You know, let's say Arthur Pawlowski, he's one of the more prominent cases out there.
00:13:51 You know, if the Premier's office was interfering with the Solicitor General and the prosecutor saying drop charges against Arthur Pawlowski,
00:14:00 That could reasonably be seen as interference. If it was a broader directive to say, OK, well, we think pretty much all of these charges during COVID lockdowns and mandates and all these things were unreasonable.
00:14:15 We don't think that we should be proceeding with this because it was unjust to begin with. And it's a blanket policy and not individuals. I wouldn't see that as interference.
00:14:24 I'd see that is exercising the discretion of the solicitor general to target certain kinds of prosecutions and others. Justice has been done in many jurisdictions before Quebec did it with abortion. They didn't intervene necessarily in specific cases, but they said Quebec Solicitor General in the 60s or 70s said, we're just not prosecuting. We're just not prosecuting on abortion restrictions anymore, even though it's against federal law.
00:14:49 BC did the same thing with small possession of cannabis.
00:14:52 They just didn't do it.
00:14:53 They didn't say, Mark Emery should be lawed off.
00:14:55 They just said, we're not prosecuting anyone.
00:14:57 Although he still got charged because he was not small amounts.
00:15:00 He was selling and paying GST on it.
00:15:04 I think the difference there, Derek, is you're talking about future problems.
00:15:10 What you're saying that you wouldn't consider interference is Daniel Smith saying, okay, let's go back and drop all these past charges.
00:15:18 So I think there's a bit of difference between saying, okay, don't charge anybody with COVID stuff going forward now to saying, let's drop all the COVID stuff that's already before the courts.
00:15:29 There's a difference, but I want your take on if you would think that'd be interference.
00:15:32 I do, yes, absolutely.
00:15:33 You think it'd be interference to say all COVID stuff?
00:15:36 Well, she's clearly has done that.
00:15:40 She's made no secret about that.
00:15:41 That's been open.
00:15:42 She said it with us.
00:15:44 She said it in others with interviews.
00:15:45 There is no secret that she has said she wants, will explore, and I think the implication being she would support dropping existing charges against people from the COVID era.
00:15:56 You'd think that was interference?
00:15:58 Well, she said she'd explore it, and that's appears, according to the CBC story, what she did.
00:16:04 If she actively did it or directed it.
00:16:06 Yeah, I think that's interference.
00:16:09 Okay.
00:16:10 All right.
00:16:10 Nigel, I want to.
00:16:11 Because the charges have already been laid.
00:16:13 If she says, okay, no more charges in the future, then I think you're good.
00:16:19 But those charges were laid under one set of directives under the Solicitor General and the Premier at a former time,
00:16:27 which is funny because the Solicitor General now is the Health Minister during all of this.
00:16:33 It's all very incestuous.
00:16:35 But it was, for all intents and purposes, a different government, even though there's a significant overlap between them.
00:16:40 was a different government and governments are able to set the priorities of prosecutions.
00:16:46 Nigel, I want your take on, do you think that would cause, would it constitute interference
00:16:52 to give a broad directive that these charges and cases be dropped against people who shirked
00:16:59 COVID restrictions and mandates? Yeah, well, I must disagree with you slightly, Dave, on that.
00:17:04 Well, we disagree lots, folks. No, I'm not coming back next week.
00:17:10 But, you know, a lot of people thought that those things were unjust.
00:17:16 So you put somebody in a position where they can address injustices.
00:17:22 I don't have a problem with that.
00:17:25 There are other reasons, by the way, why cases can be dropped.
00:17:29 Sometimes they can just time out.
00:17:31 And we have an incredibly busy court system at the moment where people who I think a lot of us would like to see go through the process
00:17:39 and have the matter resolved just eventually fall off the edge
00:17:43 and the case is dismissed.
00:17:45 That is another way.
00:17:49 If that can happen to somebody who's got a drug charge,
00:17:52 I'm quite happy to see it happen intentionally
00:17:55 with somebody who is charged under a law
00:17:58 that I personally think was obsessive and poorly conceived.
00:18:04 I think we're going to have to ultimately wait
00:18:06 and see if the CBC can produce the email,
00:18:08 between Smith's office and a prosecutor.
00:18:12 If they can provide that,
00:18:13 well, then we'll have to judge it on its merits.
00:18:15 And if it was some fart catcher intern, 0.64
00:18:18 probably not as serious.
00:18:20 If it was the chief of staff, very serious.
00:18:22 So I think we're just gonna have to wait and see,
00:18:26 can CBC produce the email?
00:18:28 And I'm sure they're frantically trying to get it right now
00:18:31 because that'll make their case for them if they do.
00:18:34 If they can't find it,
00:18:35 it's CDC said Smith said. All right. Actually, we're gonna change up the plan order here, we're
00:18:44 gonna go straight to a story around fundraising in Alberta UCP and an NDP. For since not that long
00:18:55 after the last provincial election in spring 2019. The UCP under Kenny has been trailing the NDP and
00:19:02 fundraising sometimes quite badly probably an indication of an upset party membership
00:19:09 and that gap between the parties was pretty big that gap has now well essentially disappeared
00:19:17 now smith has only been the leader of the party more or less for the fourth quarter
00:19:20 of 2022 but the party overall matched the ndp and fundraising for
00:19:27 For 2022, it's 7 million each. If you include money raised for the leadership campaigns, the UCP actually raised 10.8 million. But that money can't be put towards a general election. It's all complicated.
00:19:43 So depending on how you look at it, the UCP has either closed the gap and tied the NDP or exceeded it, depending on which metrics you're looking at.
00:19:50 Dave, break it down a bit further.
00:19:52 I know you've looked at the numbers.
00:19:55 Tell us how this has changed over the last while and how the UCP closed that gap.
00:20:02 Well, I became a journalist, Derek, because I hate math.
00:20:05 So I'm going to have to refer to my cheat sheet here.
00:20:09 You're quite right in saying that ever since the last election,
00:20:13 Rachel Notley has been leading quarterly fundraising,
00:20:18 especially apparent during Jason Kenney when he was in charge.
00:20:24 Basically, they both got $7 million to play with before the May election.
00:20:32 The UCP raised $3.2 million in the last quarter, which is an incredible amount.
00:20:39 you know nearly half of that seven million and that was their best month since the the previous
00:20:44 election in 2019. Interestingly on January 31st both parties raised two hundred and sixty five
00:20:54 thousand dollars. So I guess there's some year-end. Do you have numbers on how the NDP did in that
00:21:04 last quarter of 2022 when the ucp you know had smith new leadership and uh seemingly uh revival
00:21:10 in their fundraising numbers yeah to be honest i don't uh the only one i've got is the ucp 3.2
00:21:16 million in the last quarter uh yeah that's uh that's a large chunk of money so basically for
00:21:25 the campaign uh both uh parties are well funded uh and everything's to play for at the moment the
00:21:33 The latest opinion polls taken mid-December have the NDP at 38%, the UCP at 32%, six points behind, but there's a whopping 25% undecided.
00:21:47 So that's where, obviously, the election will be won and lost, and at this moment, it's all to play for, and money will be no object.
00:21:55 So Nigel, fundraising is not necessarily a good barometer of general public opinion, but it is a pretty reliable barometer of opinion within parties.
00:22:08 And so it wouldn't be, I don't think it's a stretch to say that the unpopularity of Jason Kenney among UCP members, among UCP supporters was, you know, driving the big reason why UCP fundraising was laying so far behind the NDP for almost his entire premiership.
00:22:28 These numbers have come rocketing back now in the fourth quarter of 2022. That's the only quarter for which Smith is leader. And it's also coming after the leadership election, where a lot of the bigger donors are all tapped out, they're not allowed to donate anymore, but they still set a record in that quarter.
00:22:47 do you think this would be a sign then of perhaps the UCP membership the UCP supporter and donor
00:22:57 base maybe showing at least a brief glimmer of being a united united conservative party
00:23:05 I don't think they'll ever be united be united but that certainly is a very strong indication
00:23:10 of support you don't give money to causes or parties that you don't believe in and I think
00:23:17 that's really the, what do these, there's one number that we don't have, and that's what the
00:23:22 average contribution is to each. Yeah, because these were unofficial numbers, self-reported by
00:23:27 the parties. This is not the breakdown from Elections Canada. Breakdowns not till March.
00:23:33 No, when we have that number, admittedly it's going to be getting quite close to the event,
00:23:38 but when we have that number, we really see how that plays out. I do recall, you know,
00:23:44 There was a time when the Liberal Party was raising massive amounts of money,
00:23:50 but it was all, this is the time when corporate donations were allowed.
00:23:54 And so they had kind of 12,000 lawyers in Toronto and Montreal
00:24:00 who were supporting the party.
00:24:02 Meanwhile, this would be in the Canadian Alliance days,
00:24:07 you had 150,000 people all given $100 each.
00:24:11 150,000 votes, 12,000 votes.
00:24:13 what's it going to be here we won't know until march apparently but it just the just the
00:24:20 trajectory of this from disinterest under in the nine months during which uh jason kenney was
00:24:27 leading the party and was thoroughly rejected by the party uh to the last quarter when you have a
00:24:35 new premier everybody gets hopeful and says all right okay if that's how it's going to be here's
00:24:40 my check. And away it goes. So I think if I were in the United Conservative Party, I would take
00:24:47 those numbers and receive them with great enthusiasm and hope. I want to talk about the NDP a bit more
00:24:54 here, because I think they have a lot to be happy about as well. They had a record quarter. It may
00:24:58 have been a record year as well. You know, during their term in government, it was pretty widely
00:25:05 known that if you were a staffer at the legislature the premier's office anything like that you were
00:25:11 expected to max out your donations not everyone did but most people did it was understood that
00:25:16 part of your salary was taxed back to the party because you owe the party your job you were
00:25:21 expected to donate the maximum and that was a significant portion of the ndp's fundraising hall
00:25:27 now they don't have that to rely on anymore they've got some staffers at the legislature
00:25:32 But opposition staffers are paid a pale reflection of what government staffers are junior government staffers clearing over 100 and you'll have like the top opposition staff or chief of staff making 800. So they don't have quite those disposable salaries to go with.
00:25:50 This shows me that the NDP has established a significant fundraising base in Alberta. They're getting, they're raising significant money. And this is outside of the political action committee PACs that both UCP have allied with them and the NDP have allied with them. You know, the unions and businesses find ways to get their money around one way or another. But for the party proper, the NDP is raising substantial sums of cash. What do you think you could chalk that up to, Dave?
00:26:19 Well, if you just look at the polls, 38%. That's a good chunk of support in the province. If you go into the cesspool of Twitter on any night, the hatred is out there for Daniel Smith. Hatred is out there, you know, for the UCP party as a whole.
00:26:39 And it's, you know, the NDP, they were in power.
00:26:44 So they've got a good, solid base of support in the province.
00:26:48 They do.
00:26:48 And those are the people that are donating the money.
00:26:53 As Nigel said, you know, some of them will just be $100 from NDP supporters.
00:26:59 You know, we don't want to see another year, a UCP four years.
00:27:02 Look at the mess they made of the pandemic and health care and all that sort of stuff.
00:27:07 So, yeah, you just can't discount the NDP in any way, shape, or form.
00:27:15 Don't discount it, but there were reasons why people would have stopped supporting the UCP during 2022.
00:27:22 There are also reasons now.
00:27:24 Okay, I still think I prefer the UCP to what I remember of the NDP.
00:27:31 We'll go through a little bit of second thought on this.
00:27:34 The NDP is now consistently raising large amounts of cash, and they're doing so without being in government where they are able to unofficially tax the political staffers in the government, kicking back parts of their salary.
00:27:47 This is going to be overwhelmingly support from people who just support the NDP.
00:27:54 This is pretty well without precedent in Alberta.
00:27:57 The NDP is in election mode. They are. Every single day, Rachel Notley is putting out some press release complaining about something that the UCP has done. Within minutes of every UCP announcement, there's an NDP press conference to follow with their reaction.
00:28:16 So they've already got their election game face on, and they're pushing their agenda proactively, and it's getting in some newspapers, and it's getting more coverage than they normally would.
00:28:26 Well, before we move on, let's just talk quickly about Drew Barnes. He is the independent MLE from Cypress Messed Hat. Now, he was first elected under the Wildrose banner in 2012, reelected Wildrose 2015, and then reelected under the UCP banner in 2019.
00:28:41 Since that time, he became kind of a thorn in the side of Jason Kenney. Never called for him to resign or anything during most of that time. But, you know, would talk about Kenny's fair deal stuff being too limp.
00:28:56 Even talked about possible independence, you know, pretty controversial. If you're a sitting member of a governing party, took issue with a lot of, you know, lockdown and mandate things.
00:29:06 And finally, Kenny just kicked him out when Todd Lowen spoke up and said Kenny should step down as leader. He's been sitting as an independent MLA since Todd Lowen has since returned to the UCP and his transgression was much greater.
00:29:20 He called on the leader, the premier at the time, just Kenny to resign, but Barnes has remained independent.
00:29:27 Now, he issued a statement, I think yesterday, saying he is not seeking the UCP nomination.
00:29:35 Now, I think most people have interpreted that as he's not running in the next election and technically say he's not running the next election says he's not ready for the UCP nomination.
00:29:46 And at the same time, he praised Daniel Smith quite strongly.
00:29:50 So with you, Nigel, why do you think he's not going to run for the UCP nomination?
00:29:56 And do you think there's a chance he takes a crack at this as an independent?
00:30:00 He may well have just had enough of the whole thing.
00:30:04 No, I haven't spoken to him.
00:30:05 I haven't asked him that question.
00:30:08 And how many, he's already, what did you say, independent, Wildrose, UCP, you're running out of parties.
00:30:13 Going back as an independent again, I doubt that that would be a successful venture,
00:30:18 given that there's the momentum of a new leader.
00:30:23 Seems unlikely, but, you know, he's done his time in the legislature.
00:30:31 He may well have other interests that he wants to pursue.
00:30:34 I had a brief chat with Drew today.
00:30:39 He basically said, this isn't what I signed up for 11 years ago.
00:30:43 He's put in a decade in politics.
00:30:46 As you say, Nigel, he's worked his way through many parties.
00:30:50 His only opportunity is to run as an independent.
00:30:53 Alberta doesn't elect independent people. 0.63
00:30:56 I suppose he could run for the Wild Rose Independence Party,
00:31:01 but I don't think he'd have much chance down there.
00:31:04 So I think, you know, Drew will ride off into the sunset
00:31:08 and take care of some other stuff.
00:31:10 There you go.
00:31:11 A newsman who actually picks up the phone and asks the subject, what are you going to do?
00:31:16 We're going to talk about the news in a second.
00:31:17 Dave Naylor, we salute you.
00:31:18 I'd be doubtful.
00:31:19 He goes independent.
00:31:20 The last independent MLA elected in Alberta was circa 1982.
00:31:25 Gordon Kessler.
00:31:27 No, that was a by-election, and he was Western Canada concept.
00:31:31 No, it was Ray Speaker.
00:31:34 Ray Speaker, if I'm not mistaken, was the last independent elected in Alberta.
00:31:38 and this was a time before there were televised leaders debates. You just elected your MLA and
00:31:45 whoever had the most MLAs was the premier. That was the way it was and so the actual MLA counted
00:31:50 for something. It had a bit more of a voice. It wasn't as dominated by the leader and Ray Speaker
00:31:54 had been an MLA for decades before that with the social credit party. He had been the deputy premier.
00:31:59 He had been finance minister. He had been after Ernest Benning, the number two man in Alberta
00:32:04 and was a rural riding, and he got elected in, I think, 1982 or so.
00:32:09 It's not happened since.
00:32:11 Independents do not get elected in Alberta, particularly the provincial level.
00:32:16 There's been a few very rare cases at the federal level.
00:32:20 David, there was a liberal MP from Edmonton who made it as an independent once.
00:32:25 But it's extraordinarily rare.
00:32:28 I can't imagine he'd likely do it.
00:32:31 So that being a safe UCP writing,
00:32:35 whoever wins that UCP nomination is likely to take it on.
00:32:38 And full disclosures, as we're talking about this,
00:32:41 former Vice President of Operations at the Western Center,
00:32:43 James Finkbeiner resigned from his position here
00:32:46 to actually run in that writing, which is in his hometown.
00:32:50 So full disclosure that we know people involved in this.
00:32:54 Maybe that's one reason we know so much about it.
00:32:56 Okay, well, speaking of reporters,
00:33:00 picking up the phone and doing their job.
00:33:04 Post Media, the biggest newspaper company in Canada,
00:33:09 if you can even call it Canada, the biggest in Canada,
00:33:11 but they're not Canadian, they're actually owned
00:33:14 by the Chatham Wealth Management Group out of New Jersey.
00:33:17 It's more or less a New York,
00:33:20 it's owned by money guys in New York.
00:33:23 That's who owns most of the newspapers in Canada.
00:33:26 And that's the National Post, the Calgary Herald,
00:33:28 Vancouver Sun, Regina Leader Post, Winnipeg Free Press, Ottawa Citizen, tons of stuff, and like many, many, many in between.
00:33:41 They're supposed to be the big boy.
00:33:43 Now, they're getting gargantuan piles of money from the federal government every year for the media bailout subsidy.
00:33:50 We don't know the exact amount because they won't tell us.
00:33:53 They classify it as a tax thing, so we don't actually really get to know.
00:33:56 But post media has announced the layoff of 11% of their editorial workforce.
00:34:04 Both of you guys are not mean to date you, but two of you are long standing veterans in the media industry.
00:34:12 industry. How is it possible that subsidies come in from the federal government, which equal between
00:34:19 probably 33 to 44% of how much they spend every year isn't enough to keep these guys propped up
00:34:26 at this point? So you mentioned the New York hedge funds, they want their money, and you've
00:34:32 got to keep shoveling, shoveling the money to them. Postmedia is just a shambles at the moment.
00:34:39 They've canceled their Monday papers for the Vancouver province, Sun, Herald, Journal.
00:34:44 No more Monday product.
00:34:47 Nobody works in the news.
00:34:48 I think we've got the biggest newsroom in the province, certainly.
00:34:52 Actually, among written journalism, although we're on video right now, most of what we do is written.
00:34:56 I could be mistaken.
00:34:57 I believe we are the only newsroom in Alberta.
00:35:01 They're not back in the newsroom because they're selling their buildings.
00:35:06 They need more money.
00:35:08 So, yeah, they announced yesterday, Jerry Knott, one of the top guys there, announced 11% slashbacks, says it's going to affect every paper in the chain.
00:35:21 But I think, quite cruelly, they didn't say who was going to go.
00:35:25 They said, oh, you know, we'll tell you in a couple of days who's going to be laid off.
00:35:30 Which is good. You should ask for volunteers.
00:35:32 And, you know, that sort of Damocles hanging over your head is a bit unfair.
00:35:39 So, you know, lots of post-media people, they're sitting with their heads down at the moment.
00:35:47 Morale, which was already low, plummeted even further.
00:35:53 You know, you just wonder, you know, the Calgary Sun Sports Department has three people in it.
00:36:00 One to cover flames, one for stampeders, and one to do the desking and layout and all that sort of stuff.
00:36:08 How can you cover a city of Calgary with three people?
00:36:12 That's insane.
00:36:13 I don't know how many more former post-media employees we can hire at the Western Standard.
00:36:18 We've taken on a lot.
00:36:20 We're sort of the refuge for former post-media and some employees.
00:36:25 Nigel, you kind of, you know, your time at the Harrow was probably kind of the end of its high times as a big, serious and profitable business.
00:36:38 I don't know. What do you think this is going to do to their to their newsrooms?
00:36:43 It was less people.
00:36:45 We've got 650 staff coast to coast, apparently.
00:36:49 11% of them are going to go.
00:36:50 Well, what's left for those people?
00:36:54 And I noticed, by the way, that people who are earning more than $60,000 are expected to accept the pay cut.
00:37:01 So, you know, that's not huge money.
00:37:06 It's going to be very hard to keep people motivated.
00:37:12 This is a very sad day.
00:37:14 I mean, it would be possible to, because the Western standard is a bustling place,
00:37:22 going somewhere, doing things, getting stories out,
00:37:26 you think, hey, we rock, and those guys have just spoiled their whole credibility
00:37:34 with some bad reporting or some biased reporting, ho, ho, ho.
00:37:38 I don't feel like that because there's a lot of good people in those organizations, people who know how to write a story, people who know how to dig.
00:37:50 And the truth of the matter is that there just is not the budget to let them do what they know how to do.
00:37:57 So for everyone who is a crazy little wokester, there's somebody, some old stager there who has been pulling his weight and more for all these years.
00:38:06 and they're either going to work for less or work not at all.
00:38:10 This is not a victory for anybody.
00:38:15 I feel really sad about it.
00:38:17 And I have noticed it.
00:38:18 I'm sure you guys have seen it too.
00:38:20 Previous rounds of playoffs at Post Media, this is obviously far from the first.
00:38:26 I can't even number it at this point.
00:38:30 Not universally, but generally, they're often letting go a lot of the veterans,
00:38:34 a lot of the best guys in the business.
00:38:36 because they tend to be more expensive, you know, like anywhere, the guys more, the more experienced
00:38:42 guys, the guys disproportionately better at their job, can be more experienced than the kid just
00:38:47 out of J school, not always the case, but often is. And, you know, and it's just leaving these
00:38:53 things as skeletons, you know, here, we try to have a pretty good mix of, you know, seasoned
00:38:58 veterans, like you guys, and kids fresh out of journalism school, or people who don't know
00:39:03 journalism, and we're going to train them up. It's a combination of these things. But you know,
00:39:07 their newsrooms are increasingly filled with recent J school graduates, who are being all
00:39:15 thoughts, all sorts of nonsense about journalism. And I, I feel like if that's the route they go in
00:39:20 this round of layoffs, again, further compounding that problem, they're only going to move further
00:39:25 and further away from a lot of their readerships and continue to lose market share.
00:39:29 Yeah, I mean, obviously, a big part of this, a whole part of this really is the fact that the business model that sustained print newspapers for so many decades has been completely undermined by the Internet.
00:39:43 First thing to go were the real estate ads, followed by the Vodicar ads, followed by the flyers, one by one, all of the big sources of revenue.
00:39:51 Actually, the first one to go was the legal ads, you know, the career placements and so on.
00:39:55 So bit by bit, when I was running newspapers, I simply recall that half of our revenue came
00:40:09 from the local advertising and about 15% of it from what we refer to as national advertising
00:40:18 and 15% from classified advertising.
00:40:22 Well, okay, so the classifieds went to Kijiji and its imitators. 0.99
00:40:27 The legal ads went to the websites, the career websites.
00:40:35 And by and by, people were less than, it compounded.
00:40:38 It was less than the paper, so people were less inclined to buy it.
00:40:41 Subscriptions went down, not the place to choose to advertise anymore,
00:40:45 and somebody else was delivering the flyers.
00:40:47 You know, I mean, it was just a, it just couldn't last.
00:40:50 And now they're reduced, begging Justin Trudeau on their knees for Bill C-18 to shake down Google and Facebook and have them more money.
00:40:58 The Alberta properties, the Edmonton Journal, Sun, Herald, and Calgary Sun, they used to be the jewels of Post Media.
00:41:06 They would make tens of millions of dollars a year.
00:41:09 And the fall, you know, the fall from that, the height of it to what it is now is being staggering.
00:41:16 I don't know what their circulation is now, but it's a fraction of what it would have been.
00:41:20 People just don't buy paper, newspapers anymore.
00:41:23 All right, well, we're going to wrap it up there.
00:41:25 Nigel, Dave, thank you very much, gentlemen.
00:41:26 Thank you.
00:41:27 I thank all of you for joining us today.
00:41:29 Remember, if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, you should be.
00:41:32 Go to westernstandard.news, click on membership.
00:41:35 It's only $10 a year.
00:41:36 Sorry, $10 a month or $100 a year, and that'll give you full access through the paywall to get all Western Standard content.
00:41:42 We're talking right now about the trouble in the media and news business.
00:41:46 Well, the only reason we're able to continue doing what we're doing is because people like you put their money where their mouth is and support independent media.
00:41:53 We refuse to take a penny of the federal government's media bailout.
00:41:56 We can't do it unless you support us.
00:41:58 So become a member today.
00:42:00 Guarantee you're going to love it.
00:42:02 Thank you very much for joining me today.
00:42:04 God bless.
00:42:16 Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:42:34 Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:42:39 These guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:42:46 And more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:42:52 To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:42:56 You can become a Western Center member for just $10 a month or $99 a year.