Western Standard - June 22, 2023


The Pipeline: Smith, Trudeau clash on Just Transition

Mentioned
Cory Morgan Show. Where are the bodies? The 1867 Project - Why Canada should be cherished

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

160.66

Word count

7,567

Sentence count

383

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's show, we're joined by our business and energy writer Sean Paulsard to discuss all things energy related in Alberta. The premier of Alberta, Danielle Smith, is trying to get her party on board with a plan to reduce Alberta's dependence on oil and gas, and the federal government wants to get Canada on track to be net zero by the end of the 2035s, but what exactly does that mean for Alberta's energy supply?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening welcome to the pipeline i'm corey morgan this is our western standards weekly news
00:00:20 and issues panel where we'll break things down discuss them and uh sometimes you can solve
00:00:26 of questions and problems, but not always.
00:00:29 I'm joined, it's a little bit of a different shakeup today
00:00:31 by our business and energy writer, Sean Paulsard
00:00:34 here on the far right.
00:00:35 I think it's your first time on the pipeline, isn't it?
00:00:37 Yeah, I think so.
00:00:38 Okay, well, welcome to the show.
00:00:40 Thank you very much.
00:00:41 And of course our opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford,
00:00:44 stalwart regular on this show.
00:00:45 Good to be back.
00:00:46 Ah, good.
00:00:47 And yes, we've got a lot to come into today.
00:00:50 So before we start into the issues though,
00:00:53 we do have to talk about those people who help pay our bills
00:00:56 keep this show on the air one of which is the canadian shooting sports association a fantastic
00:01:01 organization if you are a person who enjoys firearms whether you're collecting or target
00:01:07 shooting hunting any of those things you need to be a member of the cssa it's essential you 0.96
00:01:12 want to protect your rights to be able to continue to enjoy those and have your kids enjoy those so
00:01:16 check them out it's at canadian shooting sports association cssa-cila.org and as well just one
00:01:25 nagging reminder for you guys we do not take any government funding but we do rely on you to
00:01:30 subscribe so if you haven't subscribed yet go there westernstandard.news slash uh slash membership
00:01:38 take out a membership 9.99 a month or a hundred dollars a year and you'll get full unfettered
00:01:44 access to all of our news stories columns and all that good stuff so yes we will have
00:01:52 a few things to chat about today uh where to begin with though and that's part of why we've
00:01:58 got sean in here is we've got some energy issues going on we've been waiting for a while on this
00:02:03 and uh maybe i'll get you to begin with that sean uh bill c50 finally came out they've renamed it
00:02:11 it doesn't seem to quite have the teeth in it necessarily i thought it might but i mean perhaps
00:02:15 you could explain a little more what's going on there i mean is it a tension point with with
00:02:19 premier smith or uh what's the how did that bill land with things well it's a little bit like
00:02:25 putting lipstick on a pig there corey they called it the sustainable jobs bill but really what it
00:02:31 is is the just transition bill and it was part of a flurry of developments that kind of came fast
00:02:39 and quick almost too much to keep up with um so the bill itself was released a day ahead of a
00:02:45 meeting with Daniel Smith and Energy Minister Brian Jean and other representatives of the
00:02:51 province that had been promised apparently before the election. Hours before the meeting,
00:02:59 Jonathan Wilkinson came with Intergovernmental Affairs Minister Dominic LeBanc and they handed
00:03:05 out $325 million to the city of Calgary for electric buses on top of another $150 million from the
00:03:12 Canadian Infrastructure Bank and then proceeded into the meeting, made lots of comments about
00:03:20 having no lines in the scion. I think the quote that he made to the Canadian press was,
00:03:28 I would never take extremist positions on issues and hardline positions. And then the very next
00:03:35 day we get a report from the Canadian energy regulator for the pathways to net zero, which
00:03:41 which basically calls for 70% elimination of oil and gas,
00:03:46 83% reduction in oil sands, 60% reduction in natural gas.
00:03:51 Basically all our worst fears
00:03:54 that Premier Smith has been saying all this time.
00:03:57 Well, that's it.
00:03:58 I mean, the bill kind of in their talk
00:04:00 reiterates what they'd like to do.
00:04:02 I mean, what they want to see with this reduction
00:04:05 in petrochemical production and sales,
00:04:08 but they haven't quite gotten into the how, have they?
00:04:11 I mean, there's only so many ways they could make this happen, Nigel, but where do you think it's going?
00:04:15 Well, you know, it is a, nominally, both parties want the same thing.
00:04:22 Premier Smith has outlined her government support for the overall gas, overall goal of eliminating carbon emissions, bringing it to net zero by 2050.
00:04:36 the federal government wants to do the same thing by 2035 so you think there might be room there to
00:04:43 come together but it doesn't seem to work out that way because the feds want to do it their way
00:04:50 which is by capping emissions whereas our premier wants to do it the alberto way which is by
00:04:57 producing more efficiently and reduce and reducing the emissions that way and just
00:05:02 taking a little longer to do it. By the way, not jeopardizing electricity supplies while we're
00:05:08 doing it. So I think it's a sort of a, and as a matter of fact, one of our columnists, Ken Green
00:05:15 from the Fraser Institute, hell of a good writer, a fellow I've known for years, and I kind of trust
00:05:20 his judgment on these things. He too is sort of saying it's a discussion over means rather than
00:05:26 ends on the surface. What's really going on? Well, that's where we get into speculating about what's
00:05:37 going on in the back of people's minds. And we probably shouldn't do that because we don't know
00:05:41 for sure. But I'm wondering if this is actually something that Ottawa really has a position where
00:05:48 Alberta could win as well as they do. Well, I don't know if they're even taking Alberta into
00:05:54 consideration when they do these things.
00:05:56 This is all aimed at Alberta.
00:05:57 Oh, I understand.
00:05:58 They're not taking our good interest
00:06:00 on their part.
00:06:04 So here's one of the weird things.
00:06:07 Like China, 1.00
00:06:08 as we know, what was the figure that you
00:06:10 trotted out yesterday?
00:06:12 Sean, about how much
00:06:14 of the, what's the fraction of
00:06:16 the world's CO2 transmissions
00:06:18 that China is 0.73
00:06:20 responsible for? About a third.
00:06:22 About a third. Okay, it's a third.
00:06:24 All right. So why is it so large? They're a large country, but they burn a hell of a lot of coal.
00:06:33 All right. Natural gas is cleaner. If cleanliness is measured by the amount of carbon dioxide,
00:06:40 well, then natural gas is clean fuel. Why don't we sell them natural gas? 0.73
00:06:48 Federal government doesn't want us to do that. Now, that's not a funny thing. This is where
00:06:52 you start to wonder why people make the decisions they do.
00:06:58 You've got two provinces side by side.
00:07:02 Each has, it thinks, the constitutional jurisdiction
00:07:06 over its energy, its environment, and Ottawa comes along and says,
00:07:12 no, it's one atmosphere, so we're going to dictate what both provinces do.
00:07:18 One atmosphere. You can't have it all to yourself.
00:07:21 Then we come to the China issue, and the one atmosphere argument falls down dead.
00:07:29 Oh, no, we've got to, Canada has to meet its own emissions targets.
00:07:34 Doesn't matter about China, we're just doing it here. 0.99
00:07:36 Well, what about the one atmosphere?
00:07:37 No, no, no, don't, you know.
00:07:39 So there's something really strange about the way Ottawa thinks of these things in relation to the provinces.
00:07:45 Well, it's more ideological than pragmatic, really.
00:07:48 I mean, they won't accept mitigation.
00:07:49 And, you know, natural gas, certainly it emits, but it's a heck of a lot less than coal.
00:07:54 But they won't go for that middle ground.
00:07:56 No, they won't.
00:07:56 I mean, the Paris Accord, which is what they say they're trying to meet the terms of, actually has a provisional, is it Article 6, that says if you sell natural gas to somebody else, you can count that against your own emissions.
00:08:09 Well, if you help other countries reduce their own emissions, then yes, you can claim those credits as well.
00:08:15 And apparently there's enough potential in Western Canada anyway, so over to northeast
00:08:22 BC with LNG to basically offset the country's entire emissions profile by exporting natural
00:08:28 gas to Asia.
00:08:29 So do we know why they don't want to go for that?
00:08:31 I'm not exactly sure.
00:08:33 And I did put that question to the chief economist of the Canadian Energy Regulator, and they
00:08:40 had not factored that into their calculations.
00:08:42 So, and to their credit, basically the only assumption that they made was that Canada
00:08:47 reaches net zero.
00:08:49 So they worked backwards from there.
00:08:51 Normally when you're trying to work out a hypothesis, you try to work through the facts
00:08:55 and then you come up to the, you know, the hypothesis at the end.
00:08:59 Well, in this case, they started with the hypothesis that we are going to reach net
00:09:04 zero by 2050 and then work backwards and said, this is how they're going to do it.
00:09:07 But there was no provision for exports or reducing other countries' emissions.
00:09:14 And then also, there was no provision for increases in population.
00:09:19 Canada hit 40 million people last week, and we're expected to be pretty close to 50 million by 2050.
00:09:25 All of whom, of course, exhaled carbon dioxide and burned it in their cars and are eating their homes.
00:09:32 Absolutely.
00:09:32 Well, then getting back to assumptions, you know, that the whole premise of this, at least when they named it as well, the transition was that energy jobs are going to disappear.
00:09:42 They're not going to be around anymore.
00:09:44 Demand apparently is going to disappear for our hydrocarbons and they're going to have to train these, you know, energy workers into a new career environment or something of the sort.
00:09:57 But I mean, for most economists, there's no indication that demand, world demand for petrochemical products is going to be dropping anytime soon.
00:10:05 So that leaves the fear that that just means that they plan on shutting it in here, despite what world demand might be.
00:10:10 Is that sort of my interpreting that right?
00:10:12 Yeah, I think so.
00:10:13 The U.S. government's Energy Information Agency, in fact, protects U.S. oil consumption to rise by 2050, partly due to things like population increases to about 19 million barrels a day from 16.
00:10:29 So it was previously at about 20. It's gone down to about 16, and they see it climbing back up to 19 by 2050 and essentially just staying there.
00:10:37 I had a piece on the weekend about Brazil.
00:10:41 Brazil wants to pretty much double their oil production and overtake Canada as the world's
00:10:45 fourth largest producer.
00:10:47 So governments around the world are still increasing investments in oil and gas.
00:10:52 Shell is increasing its oil production 1 to 2, 3 percent a year.
00:10:57 It came out of their annual meeting.
00:10:59 ExxonMobil, these 2050 net zero targets, they're supposed to disclose them under these new
00:11:04 reporting standards and they basically said that they're not material because
00:11:07 it's not going to happen by 2050 and it's gonna have like zero financial
00:11:12 impact on their business and if Exxon is saying that you know I think they
00:11:18 probably know a little bit more than the International Energy Agency absolutely
00:11:23 I mean in Norway as well I think they were in Norway as well North Sea
00:11:27 operations it's just we seem to be the only Boy Scouts out there saying we're
00:11:31 going to contract. I guess we'll just have to settle for being better people. Hungry and cold
00:11:36 people. Hungry and cold and not going anywhere, but my word. Well, and the way that they're going
00:11:41 to do it is very interesting as well, because they're proposing to essentially more than double
00:11:47 the carbon tax, about $380 a ton, because the idea here is that if we keep it at $170 to $2050,
00:11:54 that inflation erodes the effectiveness of the tax at essentially setting in oil and
00:12:01 gas, 3% production caps per year.
00:12:05 So the aim of these policies is to make oil and gas unprofitable and to force companies
00:12:12 to essentially shut it into the ground.
00:12:14 It's an interesting light on what they expect inflation to be in the years to come.
00:12:23 you go to the grocery again keep that in mind that seven dollar pound of butter when did you
00:12:31 save three eight three hundred and eighty dollars a ton for carbon prices that's here um by 2050
00:12:39 that was uh i think it was actually after 2040 they uh they assumed it coming in because 170 is
00:12:44 is what, 2030?
00:12:46 Well, I guess it'll be your guys' problem then.
00:12:49 Well, you never know how long you might make it.
00:12:53 I mean, part of the challenge too, though,
00:12:54 is these guys keep moving the goalposts.
00:12:57 I mean, it was only a few years ago,
00:12:58 the environment minister was saying,
00:12:59 there's no way we're gonna go past 50 per ton,
00:13:03 and they've blown that right out of the water.
00:13:06 That's gonna cause an investment chill.
00:13:08 I mean, why would you wanna put money into a country
00:13:11 when the government just seems obsessed
00:13:13 with shutting down.
00:13:14 Well, they wouldn't want that, would they?
00:13:16 Imagine the government of Canada
00:13:18 wanting an investment chill
00:13:19 in natural resource extraction in Canada.
00:13:22 Yeah.
00:13:23 Well, and that was another point
00:13:24 that the chief economist made
00:13:25 was that the government might have to use
00:13:28 these policy levers to accelerate that transition
00:13:33 to zero by 2050 if some of these other measures don't work.
00:13:36 So in other words, moving the goalpost
00:13:39 is perfectly within the rules in this scenario as well.
00:13:43 Yeah, we can't trust them to stop there. Well, we'll see. I mean, there's certainly going to be some, I think, some battles coming up. I mean, Premier Smith, though, has been pretty clear that she wants to, she's not going to put up with it, or at least she's taken on the most defensive stance we've seen on this from a Premier in Alberta in quite some time. She'll follow through on that.
00:14:05 Yeah, and I think she absolutely means what she says.
00:14:12 It's a strong team that's facing Ottawa, you know, Rebecca Schultz and Brian Jean and Danielle Smith,
00:14:19 and they've got the rest of the cabinet behind them on this.
00:14:23 If this is going to work for them, it's going to work like Ottawa says do this, they say we won't,
00:14:31 Ottawa tries to sue, and they drag it out in court, hopefully past the next election date,
00:14:37 and then with what many expect will be a different government,
00:14:42 there'll be a different dynamic between the federal government and the provinces.
00:14:46 Only hope.
00:14:48 It can just, yeah, it's never looked more likely.
00:14:54 Well, that segues into, you know, wondering about the next government or what it may be.
00:15:00 So we just had four by-elections that were just held the other day, and two liberal ridings and two conservative ridings, and pretty much it looks like the status quo won the day.
00:15:13 There was no significant movement compared to past polling and, you know.
00:15:21 Well, you know, one of the ones that is worth talking about is Portage-Lisgar, where Max Bernier, of course, had high hopes of claiming a seat in Parliament, but he didn't.
00:15:36 In fact, he didn't even come close.
00:15:38 And I don't say this with a great sense of satisfaction, but the numbers are that the Conservative candidate got 20,000 votes and Bernier got 5,000.
00:15:48 So what does that mean for the future of the People's Party
00:15:52 if they can't make significant headway in a riding like that?
00:15:59 I mean, the other place that they tried out was in Winnipeg South Centre,
00:16:04 and they got 300 votes, like 1% of the votes.
00:16:10 So it looks to me as if the PPC idea has had its chance
00:16:17 and doesn't seem to be going anywhere.
00:16:21 Now, that actually could be a good thing for the Conservative Party of Canada
00:16:28 because in the last election, the people who go through the results
00:16:34 and the spreadsheets reckon that the loss of votes from the Conservatives
00:16:39 to the People's Party probably cost them about 15 seats.
00:16:43 It's disputed, but there was certainly an outflow of the more conservatively minded people who went to vote for the People's Party, didn't vote for the conservatives, split the vote, and the liberals slipped by.
00:17:02 So I think that's what those by-election results tell me, is that PPC is probably a spent force.
00:17:11 I'm not saying it's going to disappear, but I don't think it's going to be a factor in the next general election.
00:17:17 I could be completely wrong, but that's my quick take on the election results.
00:17:23 Well, I mean, yeah, I think it's a fair take.
00:17:27 and the conservatives are going to need that extra
00:17:31 a little bit though because they also aren't gaining ground right now. I mean it just seems
00:17:34 astounding with the, I mean you understand a couple were safe liberal seats
00:17:38 so they weren't going to switch. We were hoping maybe to see some progress or some
00:17:42 increases and it's not looking like anything's moving. I mean
00:17:46 no matter how many scandals, no matter how many cover-ups, no matter how much
00:17:50 ineptitude we're seeing from this federal government, the partisan lines are
00:17:54 drawn in the sand, I think,
00:17:55 and nobody seems to be ready to move.
00:17:57 Well, to be fair, these are low turnouts.
00:18:01 And that's the way-
00:18:02 It's hard to read too much into a by-election.
00:18:04 Yeah, the by-elections are never big turnouts,
00:18:07 but we've got 36%, 45%, 38%, you know.
00:18:12 It's a strong sample if you were a polling company,
00:18:15 but it's not really giving you the picture
00:18:18 for a future battle, whether it's next year
00:18:21 or the year after.
00:18:23 And I think that that helped Premier Smith here with the election here in Alberta was that she had managed to consolidate that kind of far right vote and bring it back into the fold.
00:18:35 And I mean, when you think about it, the margin between a majority and being turfed out of office was like, what, 2,600 votes across the province?
00:18:45 Yes.
00:18:45 So I think in that sense…
00:18:46 I think there were 2,600 votes here in Calvary, really.
00:18:50 Pretty much.
00:18:50 It's very tight, and that's not an unusual thing to have elections turn on a relatively
00:18:58 small number of seats where the voters are evenly divided.
00:19:05 In the 2011, the famous 2011 election, which led to Harper's strong, stable National Majority
00:19:12 Conservative government, I still say it after all these years, I mean, that all came down
00:19:17 to about 5,000 votes coast to coast.
00:19:19 We've won one riding up by two votes
00:19:21 with those kinds of, with that kind of division
00:19:25 in certain areas.
00:19:27 It's critical that if you want a conservative government,
00:19:32 you better vote for a conservative government,
00:19:35 not make a protest vote to another party.
00:19:37 And by the same time, if you want a liberal government,
00:19:40 it's important you turn out.
00:19:42 Well, that's the nature of our system as well.
00:19:44 Some stuff's almost beyond your own control,
00:19:46 But it seems to be whether conservative or liberal, it depends on who the peripheral parties are splitting the vote at any given time.
00:19:53 With a strong NDP, which we don't really have too much right now, with a strong NDP biting into the liberal support, conservatives have a much better chance of moving ahead.
00:20:03 But when the NDP is weak, the liberals can pull it off.
00:20:06 I said in Alberta, of course, we saw the extreme example of it when the Wildrose Party split with the conservatives.
00:20:12 And had there been even a 10% bite out of the vote last time around, we'd have another NDP government here.
00:20:19 Yeah, they told me you were giving money to the NDP, Corey, just for that great reason.
00:20:22 Yeah, that's right. I don't have enough money. Just rumors.
00:20:29 But it's a frustrating state. So where does Bernier go from here?
00:20:34 I mean, he still has the support of a significant amount of people,
00:20:38 I mean, enough to sustain a little party,
00:20:40 but it doesn't really, they've got to find themselves
00:20:43 and figure out what they want to do and where they're going.
00:20:46 Look, I actually have got a lot of time for the things that Mr. Bernier says.
00:20:52 He happens to, he and I are in sync on a lot of things.
00:20:57 However, I am prepared to vote for the person who can actually give me a fraction of that as long as I at least get that.
00:21:10 Because another four years of a liberal government, I think, would see all of the things that we've just been talking about in terms of the destruction of the energy industry here in Alberta come about.
00:21:25 I can think of a number of other things that wouldn't go very well,
00:21:28 but just to stay on topic,
00:21:31 everything we talked about in the first 20 minutes of this show
00:21:34 is on the line if the Liberals form another government in 2025
00:21:40 because that's their policy.
00:21:42 So if you want to stop that,
00:21:45 you've got to vote for the person who's most likely to do that.
00:21:48 But in my judgment, that's going to be the Conservative Party with Pierre Polymer.
00:21:57 I mean, much as I like Mr. Bernier, look, I also like the people in the Christian Heritage Party,
00:22:04 but there's no way that they're ever going to win a seat, never mind former government.
00:22:07 So what's the point of putting your vote there?
00:22:12 Go with somebody who can do something for you.
00:22:13 So, and then likewise, so the other by-election was Oxford, and the Conservatives took that seat.
00:22:20 But that was, the winner came in at 43% of the vote when the last election was 47%.
00:22:27 It said, you can't read too much into a by-election, but still, I mean, you need to see some forward momentum.
00:22:32 I mean, this can't be blamed on the PPC.
00:22:34 This can't be, you know, Mr. Polly has to grasp the interest, I think, of Canadians somehow.
00:22:40 and he's had a difficulty doing it, I think, so far, or at least non-conservative, you know,
00:22:44 the swing voters out there that are there, they don't seem to be swinging to the Conservatives yet.
00:22:50 They haven't heard enough. There's always room to hurt more, isn't there?
00:22:55 I think he's having a hard time capturing the imagination of people. He's a very good speaker.
00:23:01 When you see him in question period, you know, he's sharp and he's quick on his feet,
00:23:05 But I don't think he's managed to find an issue or a platform that really captures the imagination of not just people here out west in the prairies, but across the country.
00:23:19 You see, you're making the assumption that people are judging candidates by their policies.
00:23:25 Right.
00:23:26 I'm not sure that they do.
00:23:27 Certainly, Paul has been talking about things that people care about a lot, which is affording a house, buying a home.
00:23:39 This is especially strong among young people fresh out of college, in their first, second jobs, and looking to build what their parents had.
00:23:48 And so when he talks about gatekeepers and the things
00:23:52 that make it difficult for younger people to get started
00:23:55 on this very basic aspiration of owning the place
00:23:58 that you live in, he is talking to an eager audience.
00:24:03 So then, well, all right, well, what's not working then?
00:24:06 And what I get back is that, well, women don't like him
00:24:10 because he's too strong, he's too sharp, you know.
00:24:14 That poor Mr. Trudeau gets savaged every day and it's not fair.
00:24:19 And some of these kind of non-political considerations can really affect how people perceive a politician.
00:24:28 Take Stephen Harper.
00:24:30 Easily, without question, the most competent and able prime minister that this country has had since the Second World War.
00:24:39 if you're just going by pure efficiency in governing.
00:24:43 That's all that Harper was interested in before he went in.
00:24:47 Good governance.
00:24:48 That's what he delivered.
00:24:49 What was the knock on Harper?
00:24:52 Oh, he's a cold fish.
00:24:53 Look at those blue eyes.
00:24:54 They just go right through you.
00:24:56 Like, what's that got to do with anything?
00:24:58 You know, it's like saying,
00:24:59 well, I don't want that guy to be my surgeon. 0.99
00:25:01 He seems like a miserable soul, 0.95
00:25:03 when in actual fact, 0.91
00:25:04 he's the most competent surgeon in the hospital
00:25:06 and the guy who has the wonderful bedside manner
00:25:09 has been known to make mistakes i'm going with the i'm going with the surgeon who can fix my
00:25:13 brain and i'm going to go with the pilot in the airline who's going to put it down on the numbers
00:25:17 not the fellow with the big mustache who talks a good game so you know we judge politicians by
00:25:23 the wrong standards they really do and that's what's working against i remember when uh preston
00:25:28 manning got laser eye surgery yeah you know and started uh fix his hair up a bit yeah and started
00:25:34 appealing to kind of to young people talking you know that kind of language and you know it was a
00:25:39 real shift for him because you know preston was you know kind of like dr nerd i think it kind of
00:25:45 helped so too i mean as you said you know that presentation i mean mr manning's policies were
00:25:50 solid for what they were with the reform and that was like he was always a policy focused man
00:25:55 and uh but yeah often the critique was oh that old-fashioned hair and those glasses and that
00:25:59 voice. And when he did start swinging that a little bit anyways, it did expand. And it was
00:26:06 just frustrating because it should be a matter of making a better sale of your policies rather than
00:26:10 having better hair. But it's a reality that has to be faced. You know, Corey, I didn't live in
00:26:16 Alberta back in the 1950s and the 1960s. But people who did tell me this province was never
00:26:23 governed better than it was in the hands of a bunch of old men in dry suits. 1.00
00:26:29 You know, boring old guys, but he had ethics, and they did the right thing, and they did their best.
00:26:36 Wouldn't mind a bit of that.
00:26:37 No, you think of the old ones, it's, you know, people, liberal-leaning ones, like Grant McEwen,
00:26:42 and there was a different type of honor, I think, is the term that you don't see.
00:26:48 I think you're right.
00:26:49 Who resigns on a point of principle these days or resigns after they've made a royal screw-up?
00:26:56 And the screw-ups are building up.
00:26:59 Well, let's talk about our screw-upper-in-chief, Justin Trudeau.
00:27:04 And the latest, which is kind of a bizarre story that broke this week or didn't break or happened or didn't happen,
00:27:12 word got out that the RCMP are investigating Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on the SNC-Lavalin matter.
00:27:21 And then they correct said, no, they aren't.
00:27:23 Like, what the hell is going on?
00:27:25 Well, let me just be Dave Naylor for a moment, because normally speaking, when we do this,
00:27:29 Derek's there, and Naylor is there, and Dave just sort of says, well, what is the actual news here?
00:27:34 So this is our story.
00:27:37 Reviewing the readout issued by the government of Alberta after...
00:27:41 Oh, I'm sorry, that's the one.
00:27:42 You're reading the wrong line.
00:27:44 Good story, obviously.
00:27:45 Yeah, it's a great story.
00:27:47 I think you've got it on the bottom.
00:27:49 Ah, there it goes.
00:27:50 The RCMP denied it was investigating SNC-Lavalin.
00:27:54 just hours after the publication of an access to information request where the police force
00:28:01 said the exact opposite. The claim was made in a RCMP tweet and they said this just two days ago
00:28:09 in response to numerous media reports the RCMP can confirm it is not investigating allegations
00:28:17 of political interference in the trial of SNC-Lavalin.
00:28:22 So, look, that, I guess, is their position.
00:28:26 That's the fact.
00:28:27 They're not investigating.
00:28:28 But why did we think they might be?
00:28:30 Well, the tweet runs contrary to a May 25th letter,
00:28:34 and that's not even a month ago,
00:28:36 that the RCMP sent to Duff Conacher,
00:28:40 the co-founder of Democracy Watch.
00:28:42 And that was published in conjunction
00:28:44 with a media release on Monday morning.
00:28:47 And the only thing I can say is that they were actually responding to an old inquiry 10 months ago.
00:28:55 So perhaps there was a, Conacher is the person to speak on this,
00:29:02 but he put in his original FOIP back in last July.
00:29:09 Freedom of information for people who don't get into the journalistic jargon.
00:29:15 And it's taken all this time to come back to them, which is pretty typical, unfortunately.
00:29:21 And so in the meantime, evidently, the RCMP have changed their minds.
00:29:25 So that's what I make of it.
00:29:27 Do you see more?
00:29:29 I don't see more, but it certainly stirred a lot of things up.
00:29:33 There are some people who feel that, you know, if indeed there was interference, that there should be charges.
00:29:37 I've seen others turning it around, fair enough, that a similar parallel, not quite as, I think, as extreme.
00:29:42 They're saying, well, Daniel Smith, Premier Smith, was found by the ethics commissioner to have been inappropriately lobbying on behalf of somebody in there, and that the charges should follow there.
00:29:53 I guess some of the questions people start asking, even if this has been resolved with the RCP, should we be pursuing politicians with criminal-type charges in these situations or not?
00:30:04 Well, you know, if it's criminal, it's criminal.
00:30:07 but let's be honest about it the nexus between government agencies and the government itself
00:30:14 whether we're talking about the energy regulator or whether we're talking about the
00:30:23 regulators that look after the airline industry or in this case the rcmp
00:30:30 statistics calendar the list goes on and on the people who are at the top of these agencies
00:30:38 are not stupid they know what the government wants and what it doesn't want and they don't
00:30:48 always need to be told what is a what to do sometimes they just recognize that something 0.97
00:30:54 is politically hot.
00:30:57 Maybe it's not a good idea to go after it.
00:30:59 Now, this sounds pretty like,
00:31:01 this sounds like tin hat stuff
00:31:03 as if it was one vast conspiracy,
00:31:06 but, you know,
00:31:07 look at the courts.
00:31:11 We have got a court system
00:31:13 which is very responsive
00:31:15 to what it believes
00:31:18 is going on in government.
00:31:21 You think, well, how can you even
00:31:22 begin to say that?
00:31:23 the law is the law, and the answer is that the law is not the law when a government, when a court
00:31:30 thinks otherwise. We have a thing called a living tree interpretation of the Canadian Constitution.
00:31:37 In fact, it is explicit that the court system is supposed to be responsive to the public mood.
00:31:45 And so if everybody thought this in the 1950s, well, fair enough, but these days we think this,
00:31:50 therefore we interpret the law that way so right there at the highest levels we have a perfect
00:31:57 illustration of the responsiveness of government agencies to public opinion and government
00:32:05 sensitivities i have no evidence that the rcmp were unduly influenced in this this may well
00:32:13 have come as a consequence of a thorough and exhaustive investigation and they found no
00:32:18 evidence worth pursuing but it doesn't surprise me yeah well and i mean some of it is when it
00:32:25 comes to at least following through on a prosecution that you got to think of the whole picture i mean
00:32:29 is it the pursuit of this warfare the looking into the public interest the disruption of actually
00:32:36 criminally charging a sitting prime minister would be massive and you you know even if
00:32:42 unconsciously have to be thinking about the consequences of what will come about if you
00:32:46 decided to try to do something like that well and there's a certain amount of fatigue i think that
00:32:50 set in as well um given you know some of the past um i guess they aren't even allegations
00:32:56 they're actually findings of fact that you know conflicts of interest against prime minister and
00:33:01 and the things that he's done and they range from potentially quite serious to you know banal you
00:33:08 You know, the blackface and, you know, drinking too much beer at a music fest in Kelowna. 1.00
00:33:15 And so after a while, it seems to be you just don't really know what to believe anymore
00:33:22 or how serious these things really are.
00:33:25 And it's like you said, you know, I would hope that if the RCMP found something
00:33:29 that was serious enough, you know, to warrant following up with criminal charges
00:33:33 that they would actually do it.
00:33:36 You know, I have a hard time believing that they wouldn't.
00:33:38 But I don't know.
00:33:40 Yeah, well, listen, I just said, everything we've seen, there's no indication that there's been any political pressure or anything in this particular case.
00:33:45 No evidence at all.
00:33:47 But the RCMP has come under question in the last few years over a number of things.
00:33:52 So Brenda Luckey, we never really did hear resolution on that so much with, for example, with the Nova Scotia massacre, the shooting that happened out there.
00:34:02 and the prime minister's office hadn't pressuring the RCMP
00:34:05 and the head of the primary RCMP was pressuring
00:34:09 investigating officers to release information prematurely
00:34:12 on that.
00:34:12 That's distressing stuff.
00:34:15 And then to have seen, at least from what I can tell,
00:34:17 never really signed a resolution over what happened there.
00:34:21 There's some mistrust in at least the leadership
00:34:24 of the RCMP and that's not a good place to be.
00:34:27 Yeah.
00:34:28 I think there's always been a certain amount of mistrust
00:34:30 in the leadership of the RCMP.
00:34:31 It seems to me it goes way back into the Trudeau days, you know, that there's always been,
00:34:36 and it's usually up at the top, and it's in Ottawa, because where the politically based
00:34:42 things are happening, I'd have a harder time seeing it happen out in any of the provinces
00:34:47 where they would be investigating, you know, the Premier of Saskatchewan or something like that,
00:34:55 except for maybe Colin Thatcher.
00:34:56 well i guess we'll see who comes calling when the federal government tells the government of
00:35:04 alberta exactly what to do and they don't do it when they break the criminal code for violating
00:35:09 the environmental statute i don't think that would be in the criminal code would it i don't
00:35:13 know jibble seems to think it is he threatened uh scott moll yeah yeah there's some bizarre
00:35:22 posturing between those two that's for sure and uh yeah it's just it's it's our our main uh law
00:35:28 enforcement and and i think part of the rcmp they've always been a very tight organization
00:35:34 with information like sometimes they don't do themselves any favors when you you do have to
00:35:39 fight and i mean we understand ongoing investigations they can't just leave it to the
00:35:42 public and everything but they they also aren't very you know communicative when when something
00:35:48 happens or things like that and that fosters mistrust or at least animosity between the rcmp
00:35:52 and media quite often yeah i mean that is so typical though of any government agency we happen
00:35:58 to be talking about the rcmp and they certainly supply us with examples but you know the the
00:36:06 agencies that try and get information out of public health canada you know they will give it
00:36:11 to you eventually when it's no longer relevant try and get a call back from statistics canada
00:36:16 you know it's it it's difficult and i think the reason is that whenever whenever an agency
00:36:24 has a reporter asking they think what are they going to do with this like what's the story going
00:36:30 to be is this going to be a pr problem for us so there is a an incentive to be minimal with
00:36:37 information what the public doesn't know the public can't ask questions about so when we get
00:36:43 into the high level or sensitive areas of law enforcement or things of misdeeds. Who is the
00:36:53 body though that has to take care of this or how can I'm thinking more with the allegations of
00:36:59 Chinese Communist Party interference on a number of levels or even intimidation of members of
00:37:04 parliament, you know, inserting themselves into nominations by election. Some of them may
00:37:11 potentially have a criminal element. I mean, if you're threatening or intimidating a member
00:37:15 of parliament, that that could have criminal sanction. But at what point does a law enforcement
00:37:23 agency get involved in that or, you know, it seems CSIS is being sidelined. So who does?
00:37:31 Well, certainly not a retired governor general with close ties to the, you know,
00:37:38 it's a very good question that you ask such is the distrust for institutions in canada at the moment
00:37:47 that it is very hard to identify a person or an office an institution you say well look
00:37:55 put it in their hands and we know it'll be done right
00:38:00 you might say well why don't we take a retired supreme court judge again you have to know 0.66
00:38:06 So what are their ties? What are their backgrounds? The short house, of course, is I really don't know where you would go to find a person who everybody would trust.
00:38:21 Well, and trust is sort of essential if we're going to try and dig into something as entrenched
00:38:28 as possible, electoral interference or intimidation of our elected officials.
00:38:34 But we're kind of hitting the end of the road with this.
00:38:36 I mean, where are we going anyways?
00:38:38 Are we going to get another special rapporteur, whatever the heck that is, anyways?
00:38:42 Even if we do, would that person be able to do anything?
00:38:45 Well, a special rapporteur as conceived by the Prime Minister, no.
00:38:50 But what Johnson could not do and what Johnson needed to be able to do if he was ever going to succeed in that task was to subpoena witnesses and require testimony under oath.
00:39:03 So I have to hope that in 40 million Canadians,
00:39:07 there is one person, maybe a few to choose from,
00:39:11 who, if put in the position of saying get to the bottom of this,
00:39:14 you have the powers you need, go to it,
00:39:18 that would actually get that done.
00:39:20 I said just now I don't know who that would be.
00:39:24 I don't have a list in my pocket.
00:39:26 But surely to goodness there must be maybe a former CSIS director
00:39:31 are now living in comfortable retirement
00:39:33 like George Smiley, who can go and be grabbed
00:39:36 and brought to center stage again?
00:39:39 Well, there should be a large amount of, you know,
00:39:41 retired justices or people.
00:39:42 I mean, it doesn't even have to be at a top-level individual.
00:39:45 They've had some well-qualified history.
00:39:48 And, I mean, it...
00:39:50 Somebody who's not too worried about their reputation.
00:39:54 Someone who could stand up there and take a beating
00:39:56 and not really care.
00:39:58 They'll take the beating, I guess, of it in the way in.
00:40:04 But, I mean, it's still nothing compared to, say, if you want to sit for an American Supreme Court spot.
00:40:08 Why is his name eluding me?
00:40:09 The man who they just crucified a couple of years ago.
00:40:13 Robert Bork.
00:40:15 Kavanaugh.
00:40:16 Kavanaugh.
00:40:16 There's another one.
00:40:17 Actually, there's a list, isn't there?
00:40:18 And, boy, I mean, who would want to apply for that job when you have to run that horrific conflict?
00:40:24 And, you know, somebody investigating this shouldn't, but now that the precedent's been set with the last one,
00:40:30 it's just so compromised in appearance anyways.
00:40:34 Well, his problem was he was appointed by the prime minister.
00:40:37 I mean, there would be some hope if you get parliament itself to report, to appoint the person and have that person reporting to parliament.
00:40:48 Well, let's say if you had an all party committee, I mean, it's not the first, all party committees exist, they've been around.
00:40:54 And if they do, you know, with a lot of fighting and burning the midnight oil and putting names forward and back, forward and back, if they do settle on somebody, I mean, it reduces the chances that any of those parties are going to suddenly come against this person because they voted yay when the time came to bring them in.
00:41:11 Well, they get the opportunity to pick that.
00:41:13 No indication at the moment.
00:41:16 And we still have Mr. Johnston in that role for another nine days, I think, though what he's doing.
00:41:24 don't know at this point to strange state of affairs we are in so yes I mean
00:41:39 it's it's I guess it's bringing back to just the main question people ask is
00:41:44 Canada broken you know a big wide open question but we've got some very very
00:41:50 serious things that keep happening and we just can't seem to get resolution we we can't clear
00:41:57 these up we can't stop them it's is the system flawed inherently you don't i don't think the
00:42:06 system is inherently flawed but i do think that the system was designed when there were higher
00:42:16 expectations not merely of people in office but of people generally
00:42:25 uh we referred earlier to how you never hear of anybody residing on a point of principle
00:42:33 anymore or when caught in some flagrant misdeed saying all right well that's i i can no longer
00:42:41 continue in my office and we criticize the politicians for that but then look at the society
00:42:49 in from whom we are drawing from from which we are drawing our elected representatives how ethical
00:42:59 are canadians generally do people cheat on their taxes do people lie on their resumes do people
00:43:10 People keep their word in simple transactions.
00:43:15 Is a handshake deal still a deal in Calgary and the oil patch?
00:43:20 I'd like to think it is. I don't know.
00:43:23 But I think there's been a general decline in the moral standards.
00:43:29 What people think is the right thing to do.
00:43:32 And so you are going to have politicians working the system with those ideas in mind, and it's not always going to look good.
00:43:43 That's even more depressing than thinking that the system is broken because the system can be fixed with legislative tinkering or even rewriting.
00:43:51 But if you've got an ingrained cynicism among the populace that ensures that you don't bring people with an honorable mindset into the profession of politics or senior bureaucratic roles, that's a lot harder to fix than that.
00:44:07 Well, it is.
00:44:09 But it doesn't mean that it can't be fixed.
00:44:12 No.
00:44:12 Can't give up.
00:44:12 We could go back into the schools and start teaching young people a sense of honor
00:44:19 rather than a sense of entitlement.
00:44:22 We could talk about success instead of victimization.
00:44:28 We could get rid of the participation trophy and reward merit.
00:44:34 We could build a culture based on a different set of values.
00:44:39 The place to start is in the schools.
00:44:42 Yeah, and boy, that's a topic for an entirely different show and a huge one.
00:44:46 But that's absolutely right.
00:44:47 Like I said, I want to end on a note anyways of hopelessness because that's how I kind of felt at the end there.
00:44:51 No, actually, it could be done, but you would have to want to do it.
00:44:55 Yes.
00:44:55 And political forces don't always want those things to happen.
00:44:58 If we work hard enough, we can make them do things they don't want to do, whether they like it or not.
00:45:03 Sometimes.
00:45:04 All right, we'll stay on their case.
00:45:06 That's our job.
00:45:07 And try to keep them as honest as we can, I guess.
00:45:10 Well, that's about as much as we can do in this role.
00:45:14 All right. Well, that's all the time we have for today, guys.
00:45:18 So thank you very much for joining today, Sean.
00:45:22 And as always, Nigel.
00:45:24 And to all the rest of you out there, I appreciate the viewership.
00:45:28 We've almost solved a couple of the world's problems today,
00:45:31 and we'll be back again next week to solve the rest of them.
00:45:35 Here's an update on commodity prices in Lethbridge for today.
00:45:41 Cash barley is up $3 at $4.23, feed wheat increased $2 at $4.21, and corn moved higher
00:45:48 $5 at $4.24 per metric ton.
00:45:51 In the milling wheat markets, July Minneapolis futures jumped 19.75 cents to $8.68.75, with
00:45:57 local hard red spring bid for July movement at $10.75 per bushel.
00:46:02 Looking at canola, nearby futures are lower a dollar at $7.44.50 per tonne, with delivered
00:46:07 values for June movement at $17.10 per bushel.
00:46:11 And in the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices are holding at $0.33.5 per pound, and
00:46:15 yellow peas are trading at $1.125 per bushel.
00:46:19 In the cattle markets, August live cattle slip $0.12.5 to $1.77 per hundredweight.
00:46:25 For more information on pricing, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:46:31 I'm Matt Musicum at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:46:37 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:46:43 These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:46:51 And more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:46:56 To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:47:01 You can become a Western Standard member for just $10 a month or $99 a month.