In this episode of The Western Standard, we discuss the UCP's victory in the Alberta by-election, and the province's new sovereignty pact with Saskatchewan. We also discuss the mid-term elections in the United States and the influence of Donald Trump.
00:00:00.000good evening i'm derek phildebrand publisher of the western standard you're watching the pipeline
00:00:24.240Today on November 9th, 2022, I'm joined as always by Western Standard opinion editor,
00:00:31.920Nigel Henniford. Nigel. Good afternoon. And joined by Bear Hunter extraordinaire,
00:00:40.080Western Standard, Alberta senior columnist, Corey Morgan. How are you, Corey? Very good.
00:00:45.120Okay. Well, we've got a great show today. We're going to talk about Danielle Smith's
00:00:49.520by-election win and Brooks Medicine Hat. I think we'll have a little more insight into this than
00:00:54.560some other media. We know that area pretty well, don't we? There's a big win, but there's some
00:01:02.960interesting pieces of the puzzle here to be connected. We're also going to talk about
00:01:07.980Saskatchewan joining the Sovereignty Pact. Now that it's no longer just Alberta, I think we need
00:01:13.320a name for these provinces coming together, resisting enforcement of certain federal laws
00:01:18.380in the provincial jurisdiction, so I'm just going to call it the Sovereignty Pact, Saskatchewan
00:01:22.880introducing the Saskatchewan First Act. Very interesting, we're going to talk about that
00:01:27.700and some of the other, the constellation of other provinces and territories, kind of gathering
00:01:31.960around Alberta and Saskatchewan and joining in this direction. Last night was also the midterms,
00:01:39.280midterm elections in the United States, Republicans, not all of the results are in yet,
00:01:44.760But it appears that Republicans have taken the House of Representatives and might, might maybe take the U.S. Senate as well, although that might not be known for several weeks.
00:01:56.780And we're also going to talk in terms of the U.S. midterms, the influence of Donald Trump.
00:02:00.680Was this a help or a hindrance to Republicans as they gear up for the next set of elections in two years, including a presidential election?
00:02:10.640So we're going to talk about that as well.
00:02:11.700Before we get going, we've got to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association. You've heard it a million times and I'm going to say it again. I've been a member of the CSSA for over a decade because they are Canada's leading and best firearms rights group.
00:02:25.600They are on the front lines defending the rights of firearms owners to legally and justly buy, possess, and use their firearms safely in Canada.
00:02:37.240Without the Canadian Shooting Sports Association, gun rights would be set a long way back by now.
00:02:42.080They'd probably already entirely be gone.
00:02:45.080Thankfully, in Alberta, we might not be enforcing some of those federal laws.
00:02:48.780We're going to see what happens on that front, see how the new Alberta Sovereignty Act is applied,
00:02:53.220how the Saskatchewan First Act is applied. But there is good news for gun owners in Canada,
00:02:59.620that they have an organization like this standing up for their rights. But don't be a freeloader,
00:03:04.180support them. If you're not yet a member of the CSSA, go to cssa-cila.org, sign up as a member
00:03:11.700right now. And while you're at it, if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
00:03:15.860shame on you. Go to westernstandard.news right now and sign up. You'll get unlimited access
00:03:21.220all western standard content one of the only remaining media in Canada that refused to take
00:03:26.980a cent of the federal government's big media bailout okay so let's get into it pretty close
00:03:32.820to here at home uh so disclosure for those don't know um the writing of brooks medicine hat that
00:03:39.700is a redrawn constituency uh before it was redrawn it was strathmore brooks and then
00:03:45.780combinations of writing called Medicine Hat and Cypress Medicine Hat on. So half of this new
00:03:51.460constituency I represented when I was in the political arena in Strathmore, Brooks. I know
00:03:56.260Medicine Hat decently well and Cypress County decently well, but I really know Brooks and Newell
00:04:00.820County, which is half of this constituency, very, very well. So we're going to dive into it. Danielle
00:04:06.100Smith, I think approximately October 6 or so, was elected UCP leaders, sworn in days later as
00:04:11.620as premier, but quickly needed a seat in the legislature.
00:04:15.280Michaela Glasgow, the UCP MLA for the area,
00:04:19.000immediately resigned her seat to open up the spot
00:05:10.620Nigel, do you think there's any, did Smith fail to meet expectations or is there any signs of trouble that she wasn't able to do better than 55?
00:06:54.500It was never at risk of an NDP coming in or anything.
00:06:57.120but it wasn't something where you could pop the champagne quartz and say oh yeah we've got some
00:07:02.300momentum here I can really hit the ground running in this next six months and it's a tentative
00:07:08.160endorsement as Nigel said it's a by-election I mean people who the turnouts are low the people
00:07:13.260who do come out are usually people are ticked off about something they're motivated to come out so
00:07:17.080it's hard to read too much into it but I'm sure she really would have loved it if she could have
00:07:21.120gotten 65% or even something higher than the last one to point at and just say we're on a really
00:07:26.500good course. But I mean, again, it would have been disastrous had she gone even below that 50%
00:07:31.340number, because that's a real psychological difference that you don't have the majority
00:07:34.640in that constituency any longer. But I think they're gonna have to read those tea leaves
00:07:39.240carefully. When you break it down, when you start to see some of those medicine hat poles and things
00:07:42.740like that, there's a lot to read into why that number came to where it is. And the Alberta party
00:07:47.580factor, I mean, that's as strong as they're ever going to be. That's their leader in his home
00:07:51.320riding a popular well-spoken man. Former mayor. Yeah, of Brooks. I mean, it was a fluke of
00:07:56.660circumstances that he happened to get that opportunity in the by-election. But at the
00:08:00.180same time, the Alberta party, it will give them a little bit more new life. And they're always
00:08:04.220there. They just won't go away. They're like, you know, a nagging itch in the back of your mouth.
00:08:08.660We're going to get to the different parties here. Sure. Okay. So either way, we're going to go in.
00:08:14.140I'm really, what I'm trying to do is get you off of saying something that's going to earn you
00:08:17.140Okay, so let's pull up some maps. We've got the UCP map here. It's kind of a heat map by color. So dark blue is where the UCP did very well. Extremely light blue would be where they did poorly. So this is just the UCP result where their strengths and weaknesses are. It's not even relative to other parties. It's relative to their own performance.
00:08:47.140So you'll see on the map here that Smith and the UCP did pretty strongly in Newell County, that's the area, surrounding Brooks on the north side of this constituency map.
00:09:01.960So Newell County, that'll be some villages, Duchess, Patricia, places like that, tiny little hamlets, Tilly, Rolling Hills, places most of you have probably never heard of before.
00:09:13.020But I've spent an enormous amount of time bumping around in a truck.
00:09:17.140She did very strongly in those areas, not surprising. That's cattlemen and oilmen's country. You don't get more conservative than that.
00:09:26.860You've got Brooks. She did pretty strong there. She did strong in Cypress County. That's the rural area surrounding Medicine Hat or the north side of Medicine Hat in this constituency.
00:09:39.460But in Medicine Hat proper, you see her vote drops off quite a bit. So it's a lighter shade of blue.
00:17:21.580As you said, they're always artificially
00:17:22.800have their tires pumped by the media for whatever reason over the years. And they're not going to go
00:17:27.420away. They're not going to be a threat to win seats in the next election. But unfortunately,
00:17:30.600what it is, is there'll be a factor, they will be in Calgary, they'll have some candidates,
00:17:33.940and they'll grab between three and 5% each. But when we look at Calgary being the battleground
00:17:38.120of the next election, that three to 5% is going to be the difference between a lot of UCP and NDP
00:17:43.480candidates. And as Nigel saying, the big question is, where are they pulling their votes from? I
00:17:48.160I mean, if they're really pulling them from the UCP, then it really could be harmful.
00:17:53.660But as Nigel said, I think there's also a factor that kind of, as you said, I mean, last time people wanted to send the conservative parties both of them a message.
00:18:01.000I don't think a lot of them intended to.
00:18:03.040They said, I've had it with these guys.
00:18:04.120I'm throwing one at the NDP, never really thinking the NDP would win.
00:18:07.260And holy cow, now we've got four years of NDP.
00:22:59.040It seems restricted to the purely economic sphere.
00:23:02.040Yes, and it's the economic sphere that's always where things come head to head.
00:23:08.040Go back 40 years to when we were dealing with Mr. Trudeau's father over the National Energy Program.
00:23:15.040What was it that brought that down? It was resources.
00:23:19.040Resources and economic development are huge, but it does seem to be more limited in scope, though,
00:23:24.040Then, again, the kind of the drawing board version of the Sovereignty Act as we're conceiving of it right now, whereas the Sovereignty Act goes beyond just economics and resource development into, you know, how are the police going to be used in enforcing the criminal code?
00:23:41.220Are we going to treat firearms owners like, you know, they're crack dealers or something like that?
00:23:51.600Corey, what do you think the political impact will be first in Saskatchewan and then nationally by Saskatchewan doing something like this, which even if it's got differences from the Alberta Sovereignty Act, I think it's gonna be widely perceived as in the same stream as it.
00:24:06.600Well, I think it'll have some impact nationally, just in the fact that it's in recognition that
00:24:10.560these provinces are outright acknowledging that this is not a benign federal government. They
00:24:15.920have to proactively protect themselves from our federal government. That's why we're seeing
00:24:20.840legislations, whether it's the Sovereignty Act or Saskatchewan's initiative, even if there's
00:24:25.760differences within them, they're both saying, look, we've got a problem in Ottawa and we have
00:24:30.200to set up our barricades because they are going to infringe upon our authority.
00:24:36.100And prior to that, it was always, we wait until the infringement happens and then the
00:25:27.100Danielle Smith was sharing Scott Moe's, like, posts about the Saskatchewan First Act, and she was, like, kind of giving a thumbs up, and she was herself comparing it to the Sovereignty Act, as if she's saying, like, hey, look, I'm not on my own here, Alberta's not even on its own, we have other provinces jumping in near Saskatchewan, Saskatchewan's, at least when the NDP are not in power here, tends to be kind of the brother or sister province of Alberta, they tend to walk at lockstep now as a block.
00:25:57.100The Sovereignty Pact. What impact do you think the Saskatchewan First Act will have on, say, the saleability of the Sovereignty Act in Alberta?
00:26:08.020How significantly does this make it easier to sell the Sovereignty Act? It's not just Alberta kicking up a storm by itself.
00:26:16.180The people who don't like the Sovereignty Act now are who? The NDP? The media.
00:26:22.160And a significant number of more leftwards UCPers, although that was leadership race,
00:26:27.740parties tend to fall in line, but I'm not sure the same will be, I'm sure,
00:26:31.160among the general electorate of UCP orders.
00:29:45.160There's 100 seats, so 50% equals a deadlock, although then the vice president, who is the president of the Senate, gets to cast a tie-breaking vote.
00:29:53.080It's really the only time the vice president has any official constitutional powers, unless the president's dead.
00:31:25.140They certainly could have not taken the House and other things, but it wasn't a sweeping red wave as they hoped.
00:31:33.180Nigel, again, we're going to get to Trump in a moment.
00:31:35.800I know it's impossible to talk about this stuff without Trump, but we're going to do our best to talk about the things that are not Trump before we get to Trump.
00:33:37.460okay well we're going to get on to Trump
00:33:40.140Because it's really hard to discuss this without talking about Trump.
00:33:42.540He is the Republican elephant in the room.
00:33:45.680So Trump is expected to formally announce that he's going to run for the Republican nomination again,
00:33:53.900presidential nomination, within about a week, I think.
00:33:58.220November 14th or so is the date that's been kind of pegged that he's likely to do that.
00:34:03.360He's been playing a pretty active role really since the last presidential election.
00:34:08.200He has not gone away at all. I don't think he's taking a break. I don't know if the guy's taking a vacation. He's just been in political campaign mode the whole time, building up his support in the party. He's the presumptive nominee. Even before it goes, he wants to go, he's going to go.
00:34:22.420Trump is popular among the majority of Republicans. He's extraordinarily unpopular among most Democrats, but even a sizable, very sizable minority of Republicans, not just more left-leaning, say, Rockefeller Republicans, but, you know, some who just don't like his temperament.
00:34:42.980They don't know they think he's too narcissistic things like this. He's not necessarily loved by all even all Republicans alone independence, Corey, with Trump looming large over the background here. Do you think he was a helper hindrance to the Republican cause?
00:35:02.440Oh, he was the hindrance. He's a spent force. I mean, I know he's got some very strong
00:35:07.020supporters within the Republican Party. Absolutely. I mean, and that's part of almost
00:35:12.520who puts people off. It's almost cult-like with some of the people and how they are hung up on
00:35:16.340him. Maybe it's the nature of strongly partisan politics, I guess. But you look at the close
00:35:20.380races where he endorsed. Pennsylvania should have gotten a Republican. And, you know, he went and
00:35:26.440endorsed Oz. And I think that was a kiss of death. The Georgia runoff that's coming, likewise. I
00:35:31.860I mean, when the endorsement of that person isn't actually a boost to the people he endorsed,
00:35:39.540that's a reflection on how the whole party could suffer if he's the leader going into the next
00:35:43.740election. I think they very strongly, and I know it's hard because you could really rip your party
00:35:48.020to shreds going by that. The people within the Republican Party have got to think about the
00:35:53.380swing voters, not the hardcore Republicans in there, because I just don't see, I mean, Trump's
00:35:58.140always Trump. He is just that unique character that he is. And if he couldn't win the last time,
00:36:03.080I just can't see him winning in two years from now. So if they want to give Biden four more
00:36:07.120years on a point of principle, put Trump in there as your candidate. I don't, you might mean the
00:36:11.880Democrats. I cannot imagine if he could live that long with the geriatric guy with his head in a jar
00:36:16.180up for president. I feel like even the Democrats know the guy, but they're going to need another
00:36:21.460candidate. I think they've really got to look with him and see what they're doing.
00:36:24.100It does seem Trump's endorsements are a huge help in Republican primaries getting the nomination to be a Republican candidate somewhere.
00:36:33.100But the nomination, at least in some areas, particularly more purple areas where there's actually a real match with the Democrats.
00:36:42.100many of his endorsed candidates did end up going down.
00:39:19.240But because I'm not an expert in it, I'm going to have to more or less say all of these different courts,
00:39:24.520including Trump appointees are probably right. The way he handled that appeared dangerous to many
00:39:30.920people. So I don't think it's just mannerisms. I think it's concerned. I think even his greatest
00:39:37.080defenders would have to admit he's an extreme narcissist. Maybe that's a good thing in politics.
00:39:42.040You have to be a little bit narcissistic. Maybe it's a good thing in brain surgeons too.
00:39:45.800Maybe. I don't know. So let's kind of talk about the coming presidential primary because it ties
00:39:53.880Last night, one of the really big wins for Republicans is Ron DeSantis in Florida. 2018, he won with 0.4% of the vote, if I'm not mistaken. Razor thin. Florida is considered a pretty purple state. I mean, I don't know how many U.S. presidential elections have hinged on the votes in Florida.
00:40:15.300The last time I checked, it was between 17 and 20 percent, crushing defeat.
00:40:19.540Probably one of the widest margins of victory at state level in Florida in a long time.
00:40:25.560And he was DeSantis was the first significant U.S. public office holder to stick his neck out and break with the consensus around COVID, around lockdowns, around mandatory vaccination, mandatory masking.
00:40:41.460Oh, and just in case you're watching YouTube censors, I endorse all of those things. They're great. I love them. I would never question them. I'm just talking about the madman from Florida who says all these terrible misinformed things.
00:40:54.620He was severely rewarded by voters last night with just a thumping margin of victory. But he also said he's not going to, he's been widely touted as a great candidate for the Republican nomination, presidential nomination.
00:41:08.020But he's not going to run, because it's obvious no one can beat Trump for it.
00:41:12.380Trump has just got to lock on that party.
00:41:16.620What does it say that a guy like DeSantis, who ejects all the boxes and had a crushing win in a swing state that's not reliably Republican, or at least hasn't been until now,
00:41:28.480what does it say that a guy like DeSantis, who would normally be a leading contender for the Republican presidential nomination, isn't even going to try?
00:41:36.340first of all i wouldn't expect him to say he was going to try at this stage but he said he's not
00:41:43.060doing it well he said they always say that but i don't think he well no normally you give a
00:41:47.640political answer well you know i'm focused on my voters in florida right now and i haven't
00:41:53.080consulted with my family and you know i'm not thinking about that right now i'm thinking about
00:41:57.560you know the bullshit lines you've heard it a billion times from politicians before
00:42:08.040I don't think he's going to do it because he probably can't win.
00:42:11.540I don't think anyone else can beat Trump for the Republican nomination this year.
00:42:16.020So what does it say that guys like him, operating on the assumption he met what he said, and I think he does.
00:42:22.340What does it say that guys like him aren't even going to try?
00:42:23.980um well what it's what it says to me is that nobody who was going to try would tip their hand
00:42:31.880right now there's two years there's a year to go and before the things get hot and it would be very
00:42:38.640silly to open that up and uh well the jockeying starts now if you take yourself out of the running
00:42:43.920the reason they give these bullshit answers because you want to still be able to go out and
00:42:47.180quietly raise some money arrange the right campaign organizers if you just take yourself
00:42:51.360completely out of the running you kind of cut yourself off from that you make it harder to
00:42:55.520build that stuff there's going to be a draft DeSantis campaign to be sure of it okay so
00:43:00.060you are just rejecting the premise of my question you think DeSantis actually there's a good chance
00:43:05.520he's actually going to run he's going to do it I think I don't think I don't think he totally
00:43:09.620means what he says no I think that is I I cannot imagine if you put the microphone in the in his
00:43:15.560face as they did and said are you going to run I can't imagine him at this time saying yes I'm
00:43:22.640seriously considering it no they didn't do the political answer which is well I'm not thinking
00:43:26.700about it at this time but you know I will talk to the people of Florida and I'll talk to my family
00:43:31.620they'll always come back but the circumstances change maybe okay so tell you what though if he
00:43:38.380doesn't I don't know who who is going to come forward and say yeah okay let me revise the
00:43:43.960question then, since you would completely reject the premise of my first. Do you think a guy like Ron, do you think a guy like Ron, do you think Ron DeSantis or anyone else in America would stand a prayer's chance of beating Trump for the Republican nomination?
00:44:07.300And he has all the positives that Trump has, and he has significantly fewer negatives.
00:44:17.280Well, I do know, I think it was just yesterday or something, Trump was tweeting some elusive thing that, I don't know if it was tweeting, on his Truth Social or something.
00:44:26.880Something like a tweet saying, you know, good thing DeSantis isn't running because I've got the dirt on him.
00:50:16.120The current Lethbridge feed grain prices are as follows.
00:50:19.180Cash parties at $4.53, feed wheat's at $4.70, and corn's also sitting at $4.70 per metric ton.
00:50:25.760In the milling wheat markets, December Minneapolis futures lost $0.05 at $9.45,
00:50:31.100with local hard red spring bids for December movement at $12 per bushel delivered.
00:50:35.100In the oil seeds, nearby canola futures increased $6.50 at $8.90.70 per ton, with delivered values for December trading at $19.97 per bushel.
00:50:46.640In the pulse markets, nearby red lentils are trading at $0.32.50 a pound, and yellow peas remain at $13.00 per bushel.
00:50:54.740In the cattle markets, December live cattle lost $0.92 at $1.52.12 per 100 weight.
00:51:00.340For information on grain marketing, call me at 403-394-1711.
00:51:06.440I'm Sean Smith of Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.