Western Standard - October 20, 2022


The Pipeline - Smith’s apology tour

Topics
Mentioned
Smith apologizes for past comments on the Russian invasion of Ukraine Question Period with Premier Danielle Smith

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

180.55

Word count

8,424

Sentence count

496

Harmful content

Misogyny

34

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Western Standard, we discuss Alberta's new premier, Danielle Smith, and her controversial comments about the unvaccinated. We also talk about the new government, the new cabinet, and much, much more!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening i'm derek phil the brand publisher of the western standard and you're watching the
00:00:23 pipeline. Today is October 19th, 2022. I'm joined as usual by the always dapper Western Standard
00:00:32 opinion editor, Mr. Nigel Henniford. How are you, Nigel? I'm good. Looking forward to getting into
00:00:38 it. Yeah. I know you got a lot to get off your chest today. And a guy who's always got a lot
00:00:42 to get off his chest, Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan. How are you,
00:00:46 Corey? Good. I'm still sweating those ribs a bit, but we'll see. I was saying before we got on the
00:00:53 air, you eat some bad pork. It might turn you kosher. We'll see if it brings me to it. Take a
00:01:00 lot. Take a lot. Okay. Well, we've got a lot to talk about today. Danielle Smith,
00:01:09 been premier now, sworn in as premier for about a week and a half or so now,
00:01:13 But making a lot of apologies. Should Danielle Smith be apologizing for her comments, some controversial older statements in some cases surrounding the Russia-Ukraine war, newer statements surrounding discrimination against the unvaccinated?
00:01:31 It seems like quite an apology to her. We're going to talk about why she's doing this. Should she be doing this or should she maybe be not?
00:01:38 uh but speaking of the new government here in alberta the uh premier smith is going to announce
00:01:46 her new cabinet on friday it'll be sworn in a few days after that uh not normally the way it's done
00:01:51 normally these things are announced and sworn in simultaneously but we're going to find out who the
00:01:55 new cabinet is we're going to talk we'll speculate about who we think will be in and who we think
00:02:00 will be out but also who should be in and who should be out what kind of message is she going 1.00
00:02:05 be sending here. And the National Inquiry going on in Ottawa, the big circus. Is Trudeau on trial
00:02:13 here for the appropriateness of invoking the Emergencies or War Measures Act? Or is the
00:02:20 Freedom Convoy on trial for its attempt to overthrow democracy and pledge us into a new 0.87
00:02:29 dark age? So we're going to deal with the three of those. Before we get going, though, 0.98
00:02:33 We've got to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:02:37 I've been a member of the CSSA for well over a decade because I trust them with my membership dues to defend my rights as a lawful firearms owner in Canada.
00:02:47 Without the CSSA, our basic rights to own, purchase, and use firearms Canada would already be almost entirely gone.
00:02:56 You know that that's where the federal government wants to go with your gun rights, and it takes organizations like the Canadian Shooting Sports Association that are the leading firearms organization in Canada defending your rights against the federal government that are trying to take things that many of us will not give up except from our cold, dead hands.
00:03:19 So if you're not yet a member of the CSSA, go to cssa-clia.org, or just Google them like I do whenever I want to go to them, and become a member today.
00:03:38 It's money very, very, very well spent.
00:03:41 Speaking of money well spent, if you're also not yet a member of the Western Standard, you need to be.
00:03:46 The Western Standard is one of the only bailout-free media left in all of Canada.
00:03:51 It's a very, very small number of media that refused to take Justin Trudeau's media bailout money.
00:03:59 The Western Standard, we're now actually coming up to our third anniversary in just a few days here.
00:04:04 Three years, and we've built something absolutely incredible.
00:04:08 I'm very proud of, and we could not have done without the support of each and every one of you.
00:04:12 If you're not yet a member, go to westernstandard.news, click on membership.
00:04:15 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all of our content.
00:04:20 You're going to love it.
00:04:21 All right, so let's get into it.
00:04:25 Right out of the gate, Danielle Smith sworn in as premier, and she gives a press conference afterwards.
00:04:32 And she says something to the effect of, you know, the unvaccinated are the most...
00:04:38 In all her short life.
00:04:40 Yes.
00:04:40 She had never seen a group of people.
00:04:42 More discriminated against than the unvaccinated. 0.63
00:04:48 Well, there has been certainly discrimination in her life.
00:04:51 I don't recall any other group that was not allowed to go to a restaurant, that was not allowed to travel,
00:04:58 that was not allowed to engage in very basic functions that people in a nominally free country are allowed to.
00:05:05 But I think as could probably be expected, some people took issue with this and it kind of blew up.
00:05:11 And they said, well, what about group X?
00:05:13 What about group Y?
00:05:14 And, you know, the unvaccinated don't deserve this sympathy.
00:05:19 She apologized.
00:05:21 Do you think she has anything to apologize for in those comments?
00:05:24 Not at all.
00:05:25 I was sitting right there when she said them.
00:05:26 And my first reaction was, thank goodness, somebody's out and said it.
00:05:30 They had a rough time, those of us who were unvaccinated.
00:05:33 It was a very clear case of discrimination.
00:05:37 That's not to say nobody else ever got discriminated against.
00:05:41 in the 50 or so years that she's talking about but this was us and this was last year and the
00:05:48 year before and in my view there was nothing in that to apologize for she spoke no more than the
00:05:56 truth what's going on here and watch how this plays out she's been a radio host for seven years 0.84
00:06:02 and she's been an opinion columnist in the calgary herald for six years and the ndp have got their
00:06:08 team of researchers going through everything she's ever said or everything she's ever done
00:06:14 and everything she's written and they will drop one of these out every week in order to contrive
00:06:22 a narrative that first of all she's been wrong wrong wrong all these years and secondly that
00:06:27 she's now apologizing um it's pretty obvious she needs to stop apologizing she needs to say
00:06:35 this is what she needs to say. She needs to say, once I was a writer for an editorial page,
00:06:41 once I was a columnist, I was a talk show host, and you know, I said things to get discussion going.
00:06:50 Now I'm the premier. I'm gonna be saying things in a different way. I'm not apologizing anymore.
00:06:55 Some of this is new, like her comments around the unvaccinated being discriminated against.
00:07:01 Some of this is older, some much, much older, but some are just a little bit old.
00:07:06 Smith in her newsletter wrote some comments around, really around the beginning of the
00:07:12 Russian invasion of Ukraine, that I think it's fair to say part from the party line that is
00:07:19 supposed to be accepted that this conflict, like every conflict Canada has ever had a side in,
00:07:24 is always black and white and there is always 100% good guys and 100% bad guys
00:07:30 And there's no, there's never any nuance to how these things start.
00:07:36 You know, I certainly didn't read her comments as anti-Ukraine or pro-Russian or pro-Putin, but certainly became spun that way.
00:07:45 And she apologized for that.
00:07:47 Now, I guess with the unvaccinated one, she issued a clarification, not technically an apology, but it came across as an apology.
00:07:54 Ukraine, I think it was outright pretty much more of an apology.
00:07:59 Some of these things that NDP are digging up are much, much older.
00:08:03 I think the one thing from the 90s where she talked about,
00:08:06 it was a rather curious comment that moderate smoking might actually be good for you.
00:08:10 I would be hard-pressed to think that she would believe that today.
00:08:15 I think it requires more research.
00:08:17 Yeah.
00:08:19 But, Corey, it's kind of become really from the first day now
00:08:24 where she's either said something and is apologizing
00:08:27 or something else has been dug up from the past, and she's apologizing.
00:08:33 Is this, do you think, the right way for her to move on from these things?
00:08:36 You know, say, I'm sorry, let's move on.
00:08:39 Or do you think she needs to dig in her heels a bit here? 1.00
00:08:41 You won't stop the wolves by throwing meat at them.
00:08:44 They've seen her reverse lights, and they're going to keep coming.
00:08:46 You only inflame them when you apologize to them.
00:08:49 These are people that despise her.
00:08:51 The ones who are most inflamed about her comments, nothing is going to pacify them.
00:08:55 And once they've beaten one to death, as Nigel said, they're going to have a long list.
00:08:58 They'll start the next one.
00:09:00 And maybe she's got to come out, I think, with a blanket statement just to clarify that.
00:09:04 Look, I'm in a new role.
00:09:06 She's got to learn a bit herself.
00:09:08 To be fair, that first statement, she spoke like a talk to a show host rather than a premier.
00:09:11 And that's why she got into the soup. 0.91
00:09:13 She's a premier now.
00:09:14 She's got to learn how to parse her own words to make sure they can't be taken out of context
00:09:18 or used against her.
00:09:19 She's in a different role, but she's smart.
00:09:20 She'll figure that out fast.
00:09:21 but she's got to stop this or they will bleed her a death of a thousand cuts all the way to the next 1.00
00:09:26 election. She's got to say, I'm not going to address those things any longer. That was stuff
00:09:31 in the context of exploring ideas, being a talk show host, being a columnist. Some of my views
00:09:36 might've changed. Some of them might've been just exploratory at the time, but I can't sit and
00:09:40 address every little one of these things. That discussion's closed. We're working on, and then
00:09:45 just say, that's it. We're working on AHS. We're working on the sovereignty act. We're working on
00:09:49 reducing the cost of living. I'm a premier now. I don't have time for that petty stuff. She's 1.00
00:09:53 got to stop it. This is only going to get worse every time they get another apology out of her. 1.00
00:09:57 So let's talk kind of apology strategy. Jason Kinney, I think, was on the other side where
00:10:02 he could run someone over and he would not apologize. He just generally,
00:10:07 with extraordinarily few exceptions, did not apologize, including cases where it was
00:10:11 pretty clearly warranted an apology was required. Smith seems to be now apologizing,
00:10:17 I think much too liberally. Perhaps this might be a symptom of the
00:10:24 seven-year apology tour she's been on for her actions with the floor crossing that were 0.94
00:10:31 so clearly warranting of an apology and groveling and sackcloth and ashes and anything she could
00:10:37 possibly do to show contrition. Nigel, do you think it's possible that, you know, her being
00:10:45 stuck in this apology limbo, which was probably necessary for seven years, has maybe just
00:10:51 preconditioned her to the point where anything goes wrong, she feels the need to just kind of
00:10:56 apologize? Well, I don't think so, no. I mean, when she was on the campaign trail in search of the
00:11:01 leadership, I didn't pick that up from her in anything she said. I mean, people would put her
00:11:06 on the spot, and she'd, yeah, well, that's what I did. Well, those were generally attacks on,
00:11:09 But other than, well, she did apologize during the leadership campaign on the, you know, her floor crossing ordeal, but on everything else she did, because those are generally, oh, no, well, she apologized on the kind of the cancer and things you can do to prevent cancer comments.
00:11:26 But she generally didn't apologize much, but there was some, but she certainly wasn't all over.
00:11:31 But now that she's premier, the attacks are different.
00:11:34 These are different kind of attacks, and it's a different tempo.
00:11:37 She's no longer just a candidate.
00:11:38 She's the premier.
00:11:39 So when one of these attacks come at her, it's front page of all the legacy media right away.
00:11:45 And it's a lot more heat.
00:11:47 So I guess I'll kind of just reframe the question that way,
00:11:50 that is the heat so great now that she's conditioned that when that heat comes on her
00:11:54 that she feels the need to just apologize?
00:11:56 Well, I don't think so, and I certainly hope not.
00:11:59 Things you apologize for are when it's like bad manners.
00:12:05 I remember a time back when Ralph Klein was premier.
00:12:07 He went out, probably had a little more to drink than he should.
00:12:12 He ended up outside a homeless center and was throwing money on the sidewalk to the people there.
00:12:19 That was not nice.
00:12:22 And he apologized for it.
00:12:25 And Rolf did a number of things during the time that he was premier, which were like that and worth apologizing for.
00:12:33 And he had that gift of saying, ah, gee, shucks, you know, there I go.
00:12:37 I did it again.
00:12:37 And people sort of smiled and said, oh, that's Ralph, you know, but at least he apologizes.
00:12:42 This kind of things that she's being taken to task for now are not of that nature.
00:12:49 They are ideological.
00:12:51 They are, do you apologize for what you think and who you are?
00:12:55 And she can't say, I apologize for those things because we voted for Daniel Smith on what we saw.
00:13:02 Well, used to be members that Albertans haven't had a chance.
00:13:05 Yeah, that's true. But I mean, you know, let's see. That's the party membership chose her for what she was, not what she's apologizing for.
00:13:15 What do you think the risk is if if this continues? Surely some of it is, you know, as you both said, she is the pundit premier.
00:13:27 She is still sort of working her way out of being a talk show host and a columnist.
00:13:32 um you know she went from talk radio to some business advocacy and then she was here for 0.93
00:13:40 about two months uh with a show and a bit of writing and then straight into a campaign
00:13:45 um and you know she kind of did get and step in a bit with her comments around cancer whatnot i
00:13:51 don't think she meant anything bad by it but came across very poorly during the campaign
00:13:55 um i don't think she was wrong at all with her comments about the unvaccinated being
00:14:01 discriminated against. But I could, as soon as she said it, I was like, oh, I know some people
00:14:05 who are going to lose their minds here. Do you think she has to be a lot more careful about what
00:14:11 she's saying? Or does she then risk losing that authenticity, that kind of aw shucksness that she
00:14:17 has that makes her charming and an attractive leader to many people? She has to change how 0.98
00:14:23 she's speaking because she's the premier now. It's different. It's not the same as when you're a radio
00:14:27 host speculating on something, or when you're a columnist speculating on something, now you are
00:14:31 in a position of authority, a position with some power. So you do have to watch what you're saying
00:14:36 now, because it holds a lot more weight to it. But she can't keep apologizing for the past. The
00:14:42 risk there is letting her opponents own the narrative for the next seven months. And the 0.57
00:14:46 biggest risk will be Premier Rachel Notley. She can't have that. She's got a big plan. She's got
00:14:51 a big agenda. And if she's constantly having to address things she said in the past over the next 0.81
00:14:57 few months. And hey, if I was a strategist at the NDP, that's exactly what I'd be getting ready to
00:15:00 do. Let's keep owning the agenda. Keep her reactive all the time. She'll lose. She will lose. So this
00:15:07 was a bad sign with this recent one. I understand the pressures are coming on. She's got a million
00:15:11 things to think of at once. She's probably got 10 voices in her ears, all have the best idea on
00:15:15 earth and how to win the next election. But she can't let them grab this and own her because they 0.99
00:15:20 will and it's a mob and you can't pacify them so uh hopefully she'll have no apologies to make
00:15:27 about her cabinet yeah uh if she's in office too just to add further yeah as nigel was saying if
00:15:32 she makes a big mistake a policy mistake or something while premier that's when i want to
00:15:36 see an apology if she's truly contrite and feels she did something wrong i know that's better to
00:15:41 see that than as you said with kenny's digging in his heels and just refusing it's just this going
00:15:45 over the past that can't be done anymore. Yeah. Okay, well, let's talk about Smith's new cabinet
00:15:50 coming in. We're going to see, she's taken some time. It was very unusual or unconventional
00:15:58 transition. She almost immediately was sworn in as premier. Normally, when a leader succeeds a
00:16:06 leader that's already in government, you're, you know, a prime minister succeeding prime minister
00:16:10 in the same party or premier succeeding premier in the same party um usually there's a fairly
00:16:16 cordial handing over of power and there's two at least you know two weeks or so that's that's
00:16:23 usual if it's a new party taking over sometimes up to even three you know there's a big transition
00:16:28 here smith more or less uh walked off the stage at the leadership convention and went straight to
00:16:35 to the lieutenant governor's house and said, swear me in. It was a matter of days. It was the fastest
00:16:40 I've ever seen. And very unusually, she did not swear in her cabinet at the same time. Normally,
00:16:44 the premier or the prime minister is sworn in at the same ceremony as the cabinet. She hadn't even,
00:16:50 I think, put a ton of thought into the cabinet at that time, other than her transition team's
00:16:54 general ideas. She'd just come through a caucus retreat where she sat down with every single
00:17:00 member, I think 60 or so members of their caucus, interviewed them all. And on Friday, she's going
00:17:06 to announce her cabinet. Also unusually, as she's then going to wait a few more days to swear them
00:17:11 in early in the next week, I think the Monday or the Tuesday. But we're finally going to get to see
00:17:18 it. What are the big things, Corey, that you want to see in this? Not what you think you're going to
00:17:27 see, but that you want to see in Smith's new cabinet? I want to see some ministers with an
00:17:34 appetite for reform. This is a new leader. I want to see a new flavor in this government.
00:17:39 At the same time, I know she has to juggle party unity. She doesn't want to shun the Kenny loyalists.
00:17:44 That's how you get a party rift. So some of the past cabinet ministers should remain in, but I do
00:17:49 want to see in those senior positions. I want to see somebody in health who is then willing to say,
00:17:53 yes, we're gonna shake up AHS,
00:17:55 we're gonna change some stuff.
00:17:58 Intergovernmental affairs,
00:17:58 I don't know if we have a provincial cabinet posting,
00:18:01 but I think people in that role
00:18:03 then have it reflect her platform and saying,
00:18:05 yes, we're not gonna take a soft stance
00:18:07 with Ottawa, justice, minister,
00:18:10 let's strongly look at the police.
00:18:13 You know, I guess not a rebellious cabinet,
00:18:15 but I wanna see ones that are reflecting the new leadership
00:18:18 and pushing that agenda,
00:18:19 not just built to pacify people within caucus.
00:18:23 Well, before I go to you, Nigel, is there any individuals you want to see in and want to see out?
00:18:31 You know, I don't see too many. I really want to see that. That's part of the problem we've had with with the Kennedy government. You haven't heard from anybody else. I'm not sure what rising stars are in that caucus and aren't. They've been so quiet. I'm sure there's some very talented people and I can't really write a good list of who would be better.
00:18:47 There's ones that carry a lot of past baggage, though.
00:18:50 Tyler Shandro is an example of it.
00:18:51 I don't know if he could sit there without Danielle having to wear some of Jason Kenney's past luggage, you know.
00:19:00 Taves, on the other hand, though, he didn't, you know, even though he was part of the inner circle, didn't seem to carry as much of that.
00:19:07 And maybe, again, for the sake of unity, giving him a senior position would be good.
00:19:10 He's got a lot to think about.
00:19:11 Well, he was not directly, well, he was a part of the inner cabinet that made a lot of these COVID lockdowns.
00:19:16 He was in the sky, pal.
00:19:18 Yeah, he was a part of these things, but it doesn't quite stick to him the same way he does with Chandra, or even Nixon.
00:19:24 Or Nixon, and that was interesting.
00:19:26 I saw an interview with him this morning, actually, outside of the caucus retreat,
00:19:30 and speaking very positively, anyways, but perhaps that's when you're on your way in to see if you can't save your cabinet position or not.
00:19:37 I don't know.
00:19:37 It's hard to tell how it's going within caucus, but Nixon, I mean, definitely is known to be closely tied with Kenny,
00:19:43 and he could be a problem for Smith if he's in cabinet.
00:19:47 So she's got to think very carefully on that.
00:19:49 But he could be a problem if she shuns him too.
00:19:53 So, Nigel, before we get to what we're expecting,
00:19:55 we're going to come to that in a bit.
00:19:58 What is it you want to see in this?
00:20:00 Who do you want in?
00:20:01 Who do you want out? 0.79
00:20:02 Who do you think should stay?
00:20:04 Who do you think should be some new additions? 0.99
00:20:06 If you're advising Danielle Smith and she says,
00:20:10 write me up a memo who you think should be in,
00:20:13 who should be out who should stay what are the big names that come to mind well first of all i'm a
00:20:17 great believer in that old saying that you keep your friends close but you keep your enemies
00:20:22 closer so if there is anybody that she feels maybe part of a kind of a shadow shadow group of people
00:20:30 within the party but who are not actually in government she'd be best to pull them out of
00:20:35 there give them an incentive to that's most of the current cabinet well it could be like most of that
00:20:40 I think she had only one cabinet minister, Casey Maddow, supporting her.
00:20:44 The rest of the cabinet either publicly or quietly opposed her.
00:20:51 The biggest problem, let's just say that she wins the next election, which we all hope and pray she does. 0.97
00:21:00 The time when this shadow group would come into their own would be after that.
00:21:05 I cannot believe and I dare not believe that those MLAs, cabinet ministers, members of the UCP
00:21:13 who presently sit there in the legislature would rather undermine her now to make a point 1.00
00:21:19 and get elected in May next year. So I think she can actually count on the overt support at least
00:21:28 of just about anybody that she's likely to pick. And the person that I would to address your point
00:21:35 The person that I would be looking for first is finance, whom I would pick Trevor Taves.
00:21:43 I, unlike Gorey, I would leave Tyler Shandro as attorney general because I don't know.
00:21:51 I had a quick look to see who else was available.
00:21:55 They have a fair number of lawyers.
00:21:56 They have seven. But of the seven, I think he is the preferred, he's the one I would prefer.
00:22:06 The Ariana Lagrange in education. And in health, I kind of like what Copping's doing.
00:22:16 So I think there's quite a lot to be said for not making major changes in the cabinet at this point.
00:22:21 What about Nixon? So Nixon is currently the finance minister. He also might be the environment
00:22:28 minister at the same time. I'm not sure if that was shoved off, but he stepped into finance when
00:22:32 tapes came out. And he was house leader under Kenny. He was really his right-hand man. I think
00:22:39 there'd also be incredible tensions. I cannot imagine Brian Jean, who we have not really talked
00:22:45 much about here, but Brian Jean sitting at the same cabinet table as Jason Nixon. It's not known
00:22:50 a lot of people, but Jason Nixon stabbed Gene straight in the back during the last UCP, the
00:22:56 previous UCP leadership race. He was part of Kenny's inner circle up until the very morning
00:23:00 that he sent out a news release endorsing Jason Kenney. So he was sitting around privy to all his
00:23:05 inside stuff. There is, it's beyond bad blood. In fact, I think the relationship between Gene and
00:23:11 Nixon is probably worse between Gene and Kenny. This was so personal, it was a betrayal.
00:23:15 um and you know and there's a lot of hard feelings in the ucp caucus currently surrounding nixon the
00:23:24 way he's kind of put the elbows up enforcing kenny's discipline on the caucus um do you think
00:23:31 it's do you think smith would be advised to keep him in you've generally advised keeping that team
00:23:36 there you think should be advised to keep him in or maybe show him the door i am not uh privy to
00:23:43 all of the things that you've just explained.
00:23:45 On the basis of what you just
00:23:47 said, probably not.
00:23:49 I don't know that story well enough
00:23:51 to offer
00:23:52 an erudite comment on it.
00:23:55 But as a general principle,
00:23:57 most of the
00:23:57 leadership contenders
00:24:00 come forward and either put out
00:24:03 a statement saying that they will
00:24:05 support Smith
00:24:06 and that they are working for party
00:24:09 unity and looking forward to the election.
00:24:12 If that's the attitude, then keep them busy.
00:24:16 Give them some reason, a personal reason to stay loyal
00:24:19 and not be on the outside of the fence looking in and plotting, waiting for their chance.
00:24:25 Gene's an interesting one to continue.
00:24:27 Let's take a moment to talk about Gene.
00:24:29 Everyone kind of forgot about Gene.
00:24:30 If I could, and I could be wrong, I don't want to be too unfair to Brian on it,
00:24:35 but if I can think of one person who would potentially try to raise a caucus revolt
00:24:40 and cross the floor with a handful of members, I could think of Gene potentially doing it.
00:24:45 And I don't, maybe he wouldn't, I could be way off pace, but he's a person who's going to have
00:24:50 to be carefully managed within there. And he, it's not just Nixon he bristled with in caucus.
00:24:56 There's a few folks, but still the only way to quiet him perhaps is to bring him into cabinet.
00:25:00 Where do you put Gene? That's a, she's got some tough decisions. I mean, you can see why they 1.00
00:25:05 get that temptation just to make a giant cabinet there. We can just stick everybody in there.
00:25:08 Well, that's why, it's one of the reasons Canada has the largest cabinets on the planet. Our cabinet is something like three to four times the size of the American cabinet that runs the most powerful government on the planet. Little Canada has a cabinet four times the size. It's obviously for very political reasons, multifaceted political reasons, going back to Confederation and before.
00:25:29 um but brian gene i want to come i want to ask you nigel he i mean bringing them in giving them 0.99
00:25:38 mistaken something is one way to ensure loyalty but if it doesn't ensure loyalty it makes them
00:25:45 a bigger threat down the road if they do become uh problematic you think smith would be wise uh
00:25:51 i also have a feeling he's not going to take just any cabinet post he probably feels uh you know
00:25:58 Brian Jean has the deserves one of the big ones. Do you think she'd be smart to do that or to
00:26:05 more or less offer him something he might not necessarily take and quietly encourage his
00:26:12 third retirement? Well, if I were her, I would, as I say, keep the people who are likely to give
00:26:22 the most trouble close and he is certainly somebody who may not you know he put out again
00:26:29 he's one of the ones who put out a very conciliatory statement after it was after it was all done
00:26:36 you should do that don't make more than that than one should but you know there are there are
00:26:44 ministries where he could set out seven months and see how the voters think about it in May
00:26:49 I would say perhaps, you know, environment or even, even energy.
00:26:59 All right.
00:26:59 Fort McMurray, you know, he's got a, got an interest there. He knows a bit about it.
00:27:04 Well, we've talked about who should more or less, Gene's the only one we've talked about
00:27:09 potentially coming in. I do think Smith would be wise to make this her cabinet, not just
00:27:15 the kenny government plus smith i don't think that would send really the right message who
00:27:21 currently not in cabinet other than gene since we've talked about him now who currently not in
00:27:24 the cabinet but sitting in that caucus do you think she should consider promoting well tot
00:27:30 lowen for a start mm-hmm i uh just that uh well and i do count rachel schultz as part of the 0.85
00:27:41 No, no, I mean, everybody who was before they had to resign to run.
00:27:45 So I think Scholz effectively would consider still there, even though she's not technically there.
00:27:50 Scholz is definitely cabinet minister material.
00:27:53 She already was a cabinet minister for Children's Ministries.
00:27:57 She fought a very clean campaign. 0.96
00:27:59 That's been noticed.
00:28:01 It's also been publicly commented on.
00:28:04 She'd be a very easy one for Danielle to bring in and probably give a good job to her. 1.00
00:28:08 Better one than the one that she had before.
00:28:12 Corey, no one's talked about these two.
00:28:15 Sonny and Ahir.
00:28:17 Yeah, I was waiting for that.
00:28:18 The 1% club. 0.98
00:28:19 I think together they got rid of this.
00:28:21 I don't see how they serve any good purpose to keep them within.
00:28:26 They ran nasty negative campaigns.
00:28:28 They don't draw much support of the party membership whatsoever.
00:28:32 You know, since they get rid of them all together,
00:28:33 let the constituencies,
00:28:35 which Ahir already has quite a hornet's nest going on in her own. 1.00
00:28:39 I think Sonny's probably comfortable within hers, but they don't belong in cabinet.
00:28:43 There's no sense bringing them in.
00:28:44 Speaking of it here, we know she's on track to lose her nomination now. 1.00
00:28:48 It seems almost impossible that she keeps it unless she's protected for a third time.
00:28:53 You heard it here.
00:28:54 There is a movement afoot to move her to Calgary Elbow.
00:28:57 You heard it here.
00:28:59 That doesn't mean it's going to happen, but there are some players in the party who know she's going down.
00:29:05 She cannot get re-nominated.
00:29:06 didn't just miss draft more. And rather that because if she gets defeated, there should probably 0.80
00:29:11 cross the floor to the NDP or the Alberta Party or the Liberals or something to the left of the
00:29:16 UCP. It's the Alberta Party. They're the catchment of those discards. Yeah, they're due for another
00:29:22 floor crossing that survives a few months again. But a way to stop her from doing that would be 1.00
00:29:27 to put her an elbow where she might have a prayer of holding that seat for the UCP. It's currently 0.89
00:29:32 open. Doug Schweitzer's resigned. And they haven't held a by-election, which is very odd. This is
00:29:38 very odd because normally if there's vacant seats and you have a by-election, you have a by-election
00:29:43 for all of the vacant seats. And we talked about this last week. I don't think it looks good on
00:29:48 Smith to not hold the by-election in Elbow. It looks like they're afraid. And I know why they're
00:29:54 afraid. They might lose that seat to the NDP. It's a downtown urban seat. And there's a lot of,
00:29:58 There's some hoity-toity types in the area who might not like a populist party very much.
00:30:02 They prefer the NDP.
00:30:04 But it's another sign that maybe that there's a game of foot here
00:30:07 because you couldn't have held that by-election if you were moving a sitting MLA to it
00:30:10 because it would look ridiculous for someone to resign a seat in one riding
00:30:15 to run in a by-election in another and then essentially have three by-elections.
00:30:19 That would look comical.
00:30:21 But you heard it here.
00:30:22 There's a movement of foot in the UCP as a way to keep her from crossing the floor 0.82
00:30:26 even though she's going to lose that riding?
00:30:29 I think that would be terrible.
00:30:30 I mean, you're parachuting one who just got rejected
00:30:33 from her rural constituency on the outside of the city
00:30:35 into a swing riding within Calgary.
00:30:38 And let's face it, I mean, I like Lila.
00:30:39 I really actually do.
00:30:40 But she's not a strong campaigner. 1.00
00:30:44 You need somebody who's a workhorse and personable and good
00:30:50 and preferably local if you're going to hope to win Elbow in May.
00:30:55 and here I think it would be an insult to a second insult to the voters of elbow if
00:31:01 you deferred their by-election already for seven months and then for just
00:31:04 political purely political partisan reasons you flip somebody like it here
00:31:07 over there to be the candidate the idea of that strategy and I'm not saying it's
00:31:12 happening there's a very good chance it's not in fact if they actually unless
00:31:16 she got appointed to that writing I don't think she'd win the nomination in
00:31:18 elbow either but it would be a way to get her to not cross the floor to the 0.99
00:31:24 NDP or the Alberta Party or the Liberals. Because she probably will end up with someone other than
00:31:29 the UCP if she loses the nomination there. Take your losses. What a mess. What a mess. Okay, now
00:31:35 quickly, start with you, Nigel. What are you expecting from the new cabinet? What are you
00:31:40 expecting to see when this is announced Friday? Well, I'm expecting to see what I pretty much
00:31:45 laid out there is a lot of people we know very well occupying very similar positions. So that's
00:31:52 not really that exciting.
00:31:56 Right?
00:31:56 Any big changes you're expecting in there?
00:31:58 Not big ones. Like I said, you know, with the back
00:32:00 bench, I don't see any names aside from, say, Todd
00:32:02 and some others who are standing out.
00:32:04 The only thing I'd expect from the cabin is I think they're
00:32:06 going to be tasked, though, to really hit the ground running.
00:32:08 I don't think she's going to want to move slowly. She's got 0.88
00:32:10 seven months to say, this is the new government
00:32:12 and we're going to get stuff done.
00:32:15 Not a lot of time to measure the drapes.
00:32:17 The one thing I would hope
00:32:19 is that Danielle, as she has
00:32:21 won her place on the basis of the Sovereignty Act that she would take the lead on intergovernmental
00:32:27 relations. She would be the obvious. She is the premier. First minister, right? You know, that's
00:32:33 what Kenny did. At first, I thought when Kenny did, it might be good. But the premier, if you're an
00:32:38 active premier, you're taking the lead in all the ministries. The idea of having a minister is
00:32:41 someone to mind that file while you're distracted with something else. So because Kenny was
00:32:46 intergovernmental affairs minister, well, intergovernmental affairs got completely forgot
00:32:50 as soon as covid happened there was no minister stick handling that now i think you could
00:32:53 consolidate a bunch of these ministries i don't think you need 30 cabinet ministers in the
00:32:57 legislature of 87 people you could have a not that i expect the cabinet to get significantly shrunk
00:33:03 but you could probably get away with a cabinet of 10. but i i don't know i think that portfolio
00:33:07 probably should get with another minister that's the idea of having ministers is so that when the
00:33:12 premier or the prime minister's attention is drawn elsewhere by events as inevitably happens
00:33:17 there's still someone moving that file forward and it doesn't get forgotten the way
00:33:21 intergovernmental failures has been completely forgotten over the last two years well that's a
00:33:25 pretty fair argument yet so she has invested so much in the relationship between alberta and 0.55
00:33:32 ottoman that it almost behooves her to go out and uh and show how it's done well she would
00:33:39 definitely take the lead on it but you know what she's going to be judged on ralph klein 0.99
00:33:42 ran in 93 it was about getting the budget under control but he wasn't also simultaneously
00:33:46 the finance minister still had a finance minister to do that even though that was the overwhelming
00:33:50 focus of the government stopping the debt crisis but yeah i think one way or another if she's the
00:33:55 intergovernmental affairs minister or not she's going to be the face of it she's going to be the
00:33:59 face no one's going to care about whatever minister they put in there as intergovernmental affairs
00:34:03 minister they'll probably do a lot of the work but it's it's the premier's face you're going
00:34:07 going to see on these things. And it needs to be. Yeah. Yeah. Other than Lohan going in,
00:34:15 I think Nixon's going in. I think she knows that there's just too much politics there. 0.99
00:34:23 I could be very wrong, but I'm giving a 51% chance Nixon's out. I'm giving a 99% chance
00:34:30 Lowen is in. And I look for a few other MLAs that supported Smith coming in. Jason Stephan,
00:34:38 he's a lawyer. I could see Savage being out. Well, actually, I think Savage said she's not
00:34:43 running again, right? I would bet every minister who's not running again is out.
00:34:50 It's an easy out there. Because being a minister helps you get reelected. You've
00:34:54 got more profile, bigger office budget for communications. Being in cabinet helps you,
00:34:59 gives you a marginal edge if you're in a close race. So I don't think anyone, I think Savage
00:35:04 said she's not running. I don't expect Savage to be in that cabinet then. Definitely not if she 0.99
00:35:09 said she's not running. Prediction, 100% chance Jason Kenney's out of cabinet. I asked, I actually
00:35:16 asked Danielle about that when I had her on the show. Oh, what'd she say? She said it would be
00:35:21 very awkward and inappropriate. I even just asked what role he might have in the government, like
00:35:25 even in an associate minister or statesman sort of place.
00:35:28 And she made it pretty clear that he's not going to have much of anything.
00:35:32 So that would have been quite a surprise.
00:35:35 Jason Stephan, I think you can see in...
00:35:38 Guthrie.
00:35:40 Guthrie.
00:35:40 Actually, I think there's a good chance you could see Guthrie in.
00:35:43 And those are guys who are a bit rebellious too, though.
00:35:48 Well, they were rebels, but they were...
00:35:50 And this is an interesting thing.
00:35:52 They were on Smith's side of the rebellion against Kenny.
00:35:55 but they were rebels. Yes. And rebels are... They can get prickly on the next one just as easily.
00:36:00 Yeah, we'll see. Okay, so let's move on to the whole other end of the political mess here in
00:36:07 Ottawa. The national inquiry that's taking place into the federal government's invocation of the
00:36:15 Emergencies or War Measures Act. We're now a few days into this, or about a... How long are we
00:36:22 into this, at least a few days. Yeah, well, Thursday last week, wasn't it? Yeah, started last
00:36:26 week. Okay, so better part of a work week. They're starting, they seem to be starting with the small
00:36:33 fish and working their way up. They're starting with like municipal officials, and I saw on the
00:36:38 TV, it said Ottawa resident. I was like, oh, how did that guy get in there? Just Ottawa resident.
00:36:45 I don't know who elected him, but okay, sure, Ottawa resident. They're starting with small
00:36:48 fish and working their way up. It's kind of a mess right now, just different officials in the
00:36:53 municipal and policing level pointing the finger at each other saying, well, I did my job. This
00:36:57 guy screwed up. But we've got also sense of from the opening statements about where this is going
00:37:04 to go. And that's why we're calling this segment Trudeau or the convoy on trial. And I think that's
00:37:10 that is how the Canadian public is going to see this, how well that's borne out by the process
00:37:18 and the testimony is to be seen, but from the sense you're getting, even though we're still
00:37:24 pretty early days in this, Nigel, are we seeing this as more of a trial of Trudeau or of the
00:37:30 convoy? The intention will definitely be to show the convoy in a bad light. It's an interesting
00:37:39 thing that we've got something called an Emergencies Act. You could never have invoked
00:37:43 war measures act now that's old news the name of the change but calling it an emergencies act
00:37:49 yeah you could a lot of people would forgive you for thinking this was an emergency so who
00:37:54 are the emergency well there's all these trucks parked there uh and they they have a different
00:37:59 idea to the government so very much as the democrat party is trying to run a a narrative
00:38:06 around january the 6th so so i think this government is is using this inquiry as a
00:38:16 narrative building exercise to portray the truckers as who they say they are deplorable people
00:38:22 misogynistic racist unacceptable opinions we've all been through that list of all the ugly things
00:38:28 summarize it as unvaccinated on summarize it well yeah but then if you just say unvaccinated means
00:38:33 all of that's to be that is considered to be unacceptable and some people say well you know
00:38:38 actually i'm not vaccinated i'm happy with that the way you are i don't ask you to be unvaccinated
00:38:46 if that's your so what we've got is a is a very definite narrative building there and you bet
00:38:52 the whole idea is to present the truckers and everybody who supported them as being sinister
00:38:59 uneducated anti-establishment and on the basis of that they hope they get a
00:39:07 verdict that will enable them to get elected again sometime in the future
00:39:12 they have to win the public relations exercise that's why you're seeing you
00:39:18 know the sort of the humble people and then the slightly less humble people and
00:39:21 then the downright arrogant ones and then the ones who twist the truth I mean
00:39:26 what do we have Mendocino saying that Ottawa was ungovernable? Good Lord. When they were served
00:39:36 an injunction to stop honking their horns, they stopped honking their horns. Obviously,
00:39:40 there was some government going on there. And in actual fact, you were safer walking up and down
00:39:44 among the trucks than you were working, than you would have been walking two blocks down on Spark
00:39:49 Street, you know, this is a PR exercise from beginning to end.
00:39:54 Corey, from what you've seen of the testimony and the way the
00:39:58 inquiries been conducted so far, do you expect the government to, I
00:40:03 think there's two kind of two broad strategies, not necessarily
00:40:05 mutually exclusive, but in terms of the way they're going to try
00:40:11 and tee this up, is it primarily to defend their use, make the
00:40:16 case that well uh here was a problem and this was the way the only way to address it or do you expect
00:40:24 it to be less of a focus on defending its use uh or actually i should say defend its use
00:40:32 by purely talking about the freedom convoy and the the great danger to civilization it 0.97
00:40:40 the lazy way is just to keep shooting at the convoy and talk about how crazy they are what
00:40:43 what was wrong. And, you know, even if you concluded that they were dead wrong and that
00:40:48 you conclude they overstate their welcome and they should be removed, that still doesn't mean
00:40:53 you needed the emergencies act. No, but that's the point they should be trying to make. But the
00:40:58 lazy, easier point to make is just to keep throwing mud and demonizing the convoy and hoping people
00:41:03 don't even pay attention to what the basis of this inquiry is. But will they get away with that
00:41:06 is the question is do you know to convince a majority of left and center-left voters in
00:41:13 canada that um that they were in the right on this issue do they need to convince the public
00:41:21 that the emergencies act was necessary or do they just need to make the case that these were bad
00:41:28 people and we did tough things to bad people uh similar to what pierre trudeau did with using the
00:41:35 the war measures act uh during the flq crisis i mean it was obviously a bad thing but uh people
00:41:41 were getting killed i mean not that if two people were killed murdering people i would support the
00:41:46 emergencies act against them too well i i don't know uh like we've kind of we kind of at least
00:41:51 in english kind of we've just kind of accepted that over time like it was much more serious
00:41:55 two people were assassinated and there was some minor bombings that didn't have people killed but
00:42:00 it was bad, but sending the troops in, warrantless searches of homes and arrests without habeas
00:42:07 corpus, it probably was a giant overreaction. But Pierre Trudeau didn't need to convince people that
00:42:14 the War Measures Act was necessary. He just needed to convince people that the Quebec separatists
00:42:20 were really bad guys. And then people more or less didn't care about was the War Measures Act
00:42:26 an appropriate tool, the necessary, needed tool to deal with it. People didn't care about it after
00:42:34 there because the argument was made. It was a pretty easy argument to make that the FLQ and
00:42:38 anyone who supported them were just bad guys. So what I'm getting at now is, is this the same
00:42:44 strategy? Does Trudeau not need to make the case that the Emergencies Act was necessary and required
00:42:51 and instead just has to make the argument that the Freedom Convoy were a threat to democracy?
00:42:55 Well, that's what I'm, that's what I'm arguing.
00:42:58 I agree.
00:42:59 I think that's what they get away with it.
00:43:00 Yeah, I think the public doesn't think that nuanced.
00:43:03 Unfortunately, there's policy weenies and people like ourselves who look at historical
00:43:07 authoritarian regimes and see the tools they use and understand the, the significance of
00:43:12 suspending civil rights to deal with an emergency.
00:43:17 They're talking about press gangs, essentially to force truckers into forced labor.
00:43:21 But your average citizen doesn't.
00:43:22 That's exactly what that was.
00:43:23 I hate to, you know, but unfortunately the Kardashians dominate the news.
00:43:28 They're not going to think that deeply on the policy.
00:43:30 And that's part of the reason you're going to see,
00:43:32 you want to see one of the biggest things that would be covered is when King
00:43:35 takes the stand, Pat King, because he's one of the ones on the list.
00:43:39 He sort of personifies a lot of the fringe aspect that was a part of the movie.
00:43:43 He will help the liberals' case in that.
00:43:47 I think they will try to prod the crazy out of him.
00:43:50 He is amongst the least sympathetic figures involved.
00:43:52 Tamera Leach probably went on and off to stand fast. 1.00
00:43:55 She's sympathetic, she's smart, she's controlled.
00:43:58 Pat King could potentially go off on that tangent.
00:44:01 You see, you see, you see, did you want that man taking over Ottawa?
00:44:04 Again, it's irrational, but that's how you win the points.
00:44:06 We've got a very complicit legacy media who will more than happily feed that pablum to the masses as this comes up.
00:44:13 You know, there's an awful lot of people who say they value freedom,
00:44:15 but when somebody actually does something a little unusual to stand for freedom,
00:44:21 well oh well I don't know that I would go that far and they back off and they're the ones who
00:44:28 will probably find this whole theater to support their view that the truckers were
00:44:34 kind of a little bit working class for their tastes and therefore they don't back them well 1.00
00:44:39 everyone's on the right side of history when you're reading it in the books oh yeah well and
00:44:42 I like to keep mentioning and I like to keep mentioning to the war measures act because that
00:44:46 really drove home how serious this act is and the sort of circumstances where something like
00:44:51 this should be imposed. An emergencies act could mean any flutter or a heat wave. And this should
00:44:57 be of the most serious of last resorts. The aliens should be landing before you think about it.
00:45:02 Outside of the first and second world wars, the war measures or its successor, the emergencies
00:45:07 act has only been used twice. And it's been used by the same family. That should say something.
00:45:15 outside of world wars.
00:45:18 It's only been used by two guys with the same last name.
00:45:23 All right.
00:45:24 Well, let's wrap it up there.
00:45:25 Thank you very much, gentlemen.
00:45:26 And thank you all for joining us today.
00:45:29 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
00:45:31 good God, you need to be.
00:45:32 Go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:45:34 Click on membership.
00:45:35 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access,
00:45:39 and you'll be supporting independent,
00:45:41 bailout-free Western media like the Western Standard.
00:45:44 Cory, Nigel
00:45:46 Always a pleasure
00:45:48 I love it, thank you very much
00:45:50 and thank all of you and God bless
00:45:52 Alberta Prosperity Project is dedicated to protecting Alberta's world-class energy sector
00:46:16 and has invited Alex Epstein, American author of the best-selling new book, Fossil Future,
00:46:21 to speak on the importance of fossil fuels and the vital role they play in our economy.
00:46:26 Join us on Friday, October 28th at the Westin Calgary Airport for beef and beer with Alex
00:46:32 Epstein.
00:46:33 You will not want to miss this.
00:46:35 Buy your tickets at www.albertaprosperityevents.com today.