Western Standard - April 06, 2026


THE PIPELINE: The NDP convention goes off the rails as Alberta independence hits 177,000 signatures

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ex-Alberta emergency chief says Ottawa destroying national security agencies - as a matter of policy Western Standard News Update | Citizenship guide rewrite spotlights Liberal appointees | 7 Apr 2026

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

172.49

Word count

7,791

Sentence count

277

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

21

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard editor-in-chief Dave Naylor, senior editor Cory Morgan, and senior editor-at-large Jordan Peterson join host Derek Vildebrandt to discuss the latest news out of the Alberta independence movement and the new leadership of the New Democratic Party of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day! Today is April 1st, 2026. I am Derek Vildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard,
00:00:29 and you're watching the pipeline i've got the usual crew here today western standards former
00:00:34 opinion editor nigel hannaford all again senior alberta columnist cory morgan news editor dave 0.76
00:00:41 naylor good evening great show great show uh first the ndp go full retard by not only elect 0.84
00:00:49 a trotskyite as their leader uh the convention itself descended into pure madness woke doesn't 0.87
00:00:57 do justice to how i and i i apologize for the term retardant to the older people who don't 0.78
00:01:03 get it we would never use that term for a person with actual disabilities 0.71
00:01:06 well i use it in the turret way in which i used it in the fifth grade very liberally for just 0.96
00:01:13 people who are cognitively functional but somehow still very stupid and uh we're gonna get into that 0.71
00:01:20 you've seen i'm sure a bunch of the viral clips of it but we're gonna get into it talk about what it 0.99
00:01:24 means for the NDP going forward. The Alberta independence campaign says that it has the
00:01:31 177,000 signatures necessary to force a citizens initiated referendum on independence. All signs
00:01:41 point towards go for a vote on October 19th. We're going to talk about where the independence
00:01:46 movement goes from there. But first, news out of Ottawa. The federal liberal government is
00:01:53 quietly considering modernizing Canada's national anthem, senior officials saying that they will
00:02:01 remove some or all references to God and replace the words with something more inclusive.
00:02:09 According to the documents we obtained in Access to Information,
00:02:14 Department of Canadian Heritage has been revealing it, specifically the line,
00:02:19 god keep our land glorious and free the idea is to change it and bring it in line with the successful
00:02:24 2018 change to the national anthem to make it gender neutral when they removed in all thy
00:02:30 son's command replaced it with all of us command uh some of the secularist groups in quebec have
00:02:37 have praised this uh one group in quebec though uh says in addition to removing god they want to
00:02:42 remove the word Canada, because Canada, as they see it, is a colonial and oppressive construct,
00:02:49 so remove Canada from old Canada. The new NDP leader, Avi Lewis, says, I'll quote him here,
00:02:54 I think we should explore whether God should be updated to something that better resonates with
00:02:59 all Canadians, and express a solidarity with Palestine, perhaps something like Allah keep
00:03:06 our land glorious and free uh others have talked about taking elizabeth may said it should take
00:03:12 on our first nations that uh we should replace god with great spirit uh or creator and potentially
00:03:19 even change canada to turtle island in the national anthem alberta premier danielle smith
00:03:24 uh was fiercely opposed to it but she said uh it's hard for her to get worked up about it
00:03:29 because canada could have its own anthem by november 1st and she guarantees it will have
00:03:33 many, many references to God.
00:03:36 Pierre Polyev
00:03:37 says, this is the same
00:03:39 government that can't axe the tax, build the homes
00:03:41 or stop the crime, and wants to
00:03:43 distract from issues by finishing another job
00:03:45 Justin Trudeau couldn't, wrecking our anthem,
00:03:47 sissifying our country, and atheizing
00:03:49 the people. But since the 0.93
00:03:51 Conservative Party values the votes of newcomers,
00:03:53 they'll be abstaining. And of course, PPC
00:03:55 leader Maxime Bernier, he took a harder position, 0.99
00:03:57 says, these atheist cucks are ruining 1.00
00:03:59 our country, deport them all, or burn them 1.00
00:04:01 at the stake. 0.99
00:04:03 well for those of you who still haven't got it yet i already mentioned the top of the show it's
00:04:08 april fool uh april 1st what's if you didn't get it i mean shame on you don't trust any of the news
00:04:14 even us even us sometimes we're trying to pull one in on you uh dave our alex zoltan uh our bc 0.96
00:04:22 reporter did this story you oversaw it uh it was top shelf it's kind of our standard practice for
00:04:28 our annual april fool's day story we always want to do something that's outrageous and crazy
00:04:32 but believable something close enough to reality and we sure tricked a lot of people this year
00:04:38 certainly did you just read the comments and it was uh you know the liberals could the people
00:04:45 bought it because it could happen it's not something that you would put past the liberals
00:04:49 to do it and uh and that's the that's the key to making a good joke uh was it the year before
00:04:54 the year before that we had the the federal government getting rid of a lane on the trans
00:04:59 canada and doing a trans bike lane uh you know across country painted with colors and
00:05:07 got a lot of people with that one including jordan peterson and we've got a lot of people
00:05:12 on this one too it's uh it's always a good uh good fun day of the year to be a journalist
00:05:17 yeah yeah we always try to start as believable and straight face as possible at the top and then we
00:05:22 get into uh maxime bernier calling for burning people at the stake at the bottom we shouldn't
00:05:27 to put the caveat though i mean when the conversation evolves into the ndp as bizarro
00:05:31 and surreal as it is believable none of it is april 1st stuff guys this is real that's that
00:05:36 that is why i think of all the news outlets we have the best april fools stories because we
00:05:41 it's not true it is a trick it we are fooling you but it's something totally plausible it's
00:05:47 not true but it's plausible we're lying by telling a greater truth i think that uh most people don't
00:05:54 read very far into it but if you ran into it uh quite a bit and you got to a guy called frenchy
00:05:59 mcfrench i didn't i didn't quote him saying tabernac i think that's when most people probably
00:06:12 all right um anyway the the risk of what we're doing is we actually give uh the federal government
00:06:18 ideas because this is something they would do they would do it okay all right the next part i
00:06:25 swear to god this is true news we are not making this up uh you probably know it because you've
00:06:32 probably seen a bunch of the clips on it these clips first went viral when uh again our bc
00:06:35 reporter alex zoltan he was uh monitoring the ndp convention most of what the media watch and
00:06:42 what the public watch if the public most of the public watch none of this but they'll watch like
00:06:47 speech from you know the winner and stuff like that of the leadership they don't watch the the
00:06:52 nuts and bolts of the convention itself oh they were nuts uh i'm not sure which of them had nuts
00:06:59 we're not allowed to say nuts there some bolts too i'm sure yeah missing some nuts and bolts
00:07:08 oh god i'm having evisions from silence of the lambs um okay uh so we're just
00:07:15 many of you have already seen it we're just going to play a quick little montage of some of the
00:07:19 the best of moments from canada's democratic socialist parties convention the point of
00:07:24 privilege on microphone one then we'll go to microphone three go ahead delegate yes hello i
00:07:30 i was standing here with my gender equity card before you called on the previous speaker
00:07:34 this card was used in an inappropriate matter i see that we are one minute ahead of schedule
00:07:42 and so i'm going to get out of here these are my rights being directly under attack
00:07:48 right now in alberta and that a cisgender woman had spoken uh over me i will invite delegates to
00:07:56 assist me in better using the card by forming a straight straight line behind the microphone
00:08:05 um with a prominently displayed equity card and we thank delegates not to call me
00:08:09 Madam Chair or Madame la Présidence.
00:08:11 I'm a non-binary person.
00:08:12 My pronouns are they, them, and their.
00:08:14 Chair is sufficient.
00:08:19 And with regret, you've spoken to the resolution.
00:08:23 It's not open to you to also call the question.
00:08:25 Okay.
00:08:29 The state rests its case.
00:08:32 They're certifiable.
00:08:35 I mean, this stuff is...
00:08:38 I don't know, Dave.
00:08:39 you start I don't know I don't even know what to say well I think it goes down as the you know
00:08:45 Nigel's been around a lot longer than I have but certainly the most bizarre political convention
00:08:49 and in Canadian history uh some of the most bizarre attendees uh you know you've seen it by 0.78
00:08:56 the uh the little clips that John just played the gender cards and cis cards and cards coming here
00:09:03 cards come in there and it was it was it was a little ridicule uh and unfortunately it is
00:09:10 it's brought shame on the country out of canada uh it's being mocked around the world sky news
00:09:16 had a segment in australia where they're saying canada is not a real country greg gutfeld on fox
00:09:23 last night was saying they got to build a wall northern canada to keep out the wackos you know
00:09:28 he gave out about 20 minutes which is a lot they gave a lot of material yeah they gave him
00:09:33 two hours worth of material to work with so yeah i've certainly never seen anything like it uh
00:09:38 i feel sorry for the the average real ndp person who goes to these pays their money and then goes
00:09:45 to the convention and is probably sitting in row 12 just wondering what the hell have i got myself
00:09:50 into and it's uh you know by uh electing uh uh avi lewis they've moved so they are now left of
00:10:00 elizabeth may okay we'll get to avi lewis uh i want to focus on uh yeah it was crazy everything
00:10:06 but yeah um i'm not positive it was john john k may have been him or someone else uh dubbed uh
00:10:15 We'll put a picture of him, her, they back up.
00:10:20 Pronoun Hitler. 0.86
00:10:21 Put pronoun Hitler back up. 0.73
00:10:23 Let's juxtapose it with old school OG Hitler. 0.62
00:10:27 You could see where they, them is going with this. 0.71
00:10:34 There was one segment where she, they had to use the word straight
00:10:41 in some very non-obviously gender-related things. 0.81
00:10:43 just straight like she choked on it yeah like it showed on the word the word itself was too much 0.99
00:10:50 for her yeah it's um not even in sexual context can't talk about us god damn it cory oh my god 0.98
00:10:57 what what did you read into that i wasn't even heard that time 0.94
00:11:01 you guys picked up what cory said right no no okay okay it's just me okay i don't know i know
00:11:09 normally i'm going to see something true this time i missed it let me know what i was getting
00:11:13 let us know in the comments if you guys took cory what i said maybe i'm just over sensitive
00:11:16 kind of things he says now probably after the show okay um so to dave's point cory uh
00:11:25 you know what are the regular members thinking sitting there i'm not sure how many are there
00:11:29 because you know at the core and i'm speaking in very broad strokes here but you know at the core
00:11:37 of the left in general is a sense of a lack of self-esteem of victimhood of and of moral
00:11:45 superiority to compensate fear a lack of success and so if there i'm sure there were a handful of
00:11:53 like white straight cisgendered males there and they're they're not allowed to speak because they
00:12:01 all have they're literally playing race cards they're literally playing gender cards and
00:12:05 they have a whole bunch of categories.
00:12:09 So if you're a white, straight,
00:12:11 so-called cisgendered
00:12:12 Christian guy, and you're just like
00:12:14 an old-school labor guy who's there 0.87
00:12:16 somehow,
00:12:18 do they enjoy...
00:12:22 It's a humiliation ritual.
00:12:23 Could you imagine Gil McGowan sitting in that crowd?
00:12:25 Yeah! He's super privileged!
00:12:27 His white privilege is off the chart!
00:12:29 So, like, how do you think 0.99
00:12:31 a white... I don't know. How do you think a Gil McGowan, 0.75
00:12:33 say, would feel there?
00:12:34 that he's literally not allowed to speak.
00:12:39 Are they kind of enjoying this humiliation ritual
00:12:42 or are they actually upset like what happened to my party?
00:12:45 Well, I think most of them are already gone.
00:12:47 That's what happened here is that Jagmeet Singh and so on
00:12:51 and this party is atrophied and it's shrunken
00:12:53 and it's gotten smaller.
00:12:55 And what we saw was a display of what the husk of it is.
00:12:57 You know, the pragmatic labor types have moved on
00:13:01 or at least they won't show up for these meetings.
00:13:02 they've allowed the fringe to dominate now i mean they're down to they're just a a fringe party in
00:13:08 the house of commons and you know we we know from even established parties if you've got a small
00:13:14 room the nuts can take the committee pretty fast and that's what happened there somebody referred
00:13:18 to it as the victimhood olympics you know because they had a point system you know you started at
00:13:23 a straight white man okay you're down at zero and everything you can come up with whether it's a
00:13:28 a handicap or racial or sexual identity and you just added all those points
00:13:34 until you got to jump the line I mean it was absurdity so how does the the last 0.53
00:13:38 of the stalwart NDP members feel about this I don't know you've got your green
00:13:45 card you've got your yellow card you've got your white card they're still need
00:13:50 to guys with the credit card yeah and that's the old school that you're
00:13:55 talking about now i you know this was hilarious in a sad kind of way and of course you have to
00:14:01 remember we've got people who think like that and do that kind of thing and speak like that
00:14:06 right here in alberta as well so you know we can't we can't afford to be too too snooty about it but
00:14:13 you know um most people don't take that much notice of politics when it's not an election on
00:14:20 this will be over and done with in a day or two everybody had a good laugh meanwhile you're a new
00:14:26 leader he'll make his presence felt in the in the commons no he won't well he's got to get a seat
00:14:33 but he's not going to run for one he goes no real seats available he's safe to win but uh you know
00:14:38 he's going to have his uh he's going to have his say and when the election does come around remember
00:14:43 there are 3 million people who normally vote NDP that's the pattern over the last several elections
00:14:51 only 1.25 million voted for Jagmeet Singh that is there's going to be a bounce back up and it's
00:14:59 going to come from people to whom all of what we are talking about meant nothing they were born NDP
00:15:06 they will die NDP they will vote NDP and it's going to be interesting see what that you know
00:15:12 when one and a half million people come back to the NDP at the next election,
00:15:17 which I think they will, what difference does that make to the outcome?
00:15:22 You don't think there could be a 1.25 million leave?
00:15:25 I mean, you look at the autoworker.
00:15:27 Well, they should, but no.
00:15:29 The autoworker whose dad was a member of the union in Windsor, and you're a member of the
00:15:35 union, and you've always been an NDP and you're looking at this.
00:15:39 Well, it's an interesting point because when the Reform Party got started,
00:15:42 There was a lot of people who walked over from the NDP to join the people who they would never have thought they would ever have any agreement with, and the Reform Party was born.
00:15:51 Well, this is a broader trend across the whole Western world right now, where traditional Labour versus Bourgeois Party politics of Europe have faded down.
00:16:04 It was never as strong in the United States and Canada as it was in Europe, but it's breaking down even in Europe, where social democratic parties have lost basic blue-collar unionized support.
00:16:16 It's now much more cultural.
00:16:18 People vote along the lines of, how do you feel about mass migration?
00:16:21 Much more than they feel about, you know, what do you think policy should be on open versus closed shop for unions?
00:16:28 Like, that's happening everywhere.
00:16:29 I think this is just accelerating, though, the NDP.
00:16:32 So this is a good way for us, I think, to pivot into the party more broadly under the direction of Abbey Lewis.
00:16:38 So Abbey Lewis, I mean, his predecessors, and he comes from NDP aristocracy.
00:16:44 His grandfather...
00:16:46 Just died, I believe.
00:16:48 Yeah, no, his grandfather was already dead.
00:16:50 His grandfather was the leader, I believe, of something called the Waffle,
00:16:54 which was a radical Marxist and Trotskyite faction within the federal NDP.
00:17:00 was eventually kind of purged as it
00:17:02 was trying to not be seen as too
00:17:04 tied to the Soviet Union.
00:17:06 Or it was by purge, it was kind of
00:17:08 pushed down, suppressed.
00:17:10 His father,
00:17:13 Stephen Lewis,
00:17:14 he was leader of the federal NDP and leader
00:17:16 of the NDP in Ontario.
00:17:18 So he comes from NDP
00:17:20 aristocracy. I mean, just as a family thing,
00:17:22 I mean, probably was nice for his father
00:17:24 if he was cogent at the
00:17:26 time. I don't know what his last days were like, but
00:17:28 it's good to see, you know, to see your son go on a
00:17:31 sixth season. So within the family,
00:17:32 that's nice.
00:17:34 So he comes from NDP aristocracy, he's married
00:17:36 to Naomi Klein, who is also
00:17:39 very well regarded
00:17:40 in the radical left in Canada.
00:17:44 I'm
00:17:44 always hesitant to
00:17:46 tell the left what's good for the left.
00:17:48 You know, the way I see, like, you know,
00:17:51 Gary Mason
00:17:52 of the Globe and Mail in Vancouver likes
00:17:54 to say, tell Albertans what's good for Alberta.
00:17:57 You know, or you see lefties always say, oh, if the conservatives have this leader, they're going to be too right wing and they'll never get elected or something.
00:18:08 I mean, they all said that about Danielle Smith.
00:18:11 You know, so I'm always hesitant of leftist advice for rightists.
00:18:16 So I'm cautious of committing the same sin in reverse.
00:18:19 What do I think the left should do? 0.98
00:18:22 I think there is a market for the crazy left. 0.96
00:18:24 but he is without a doubt 0.98
00:18:26 the most radical leftist
00:18:29 to ever lead the NDP
00:18:30 I don't think he would deny that characterization
00:18:32 I think he's
00:18:35 I'm not sure if it's openly or not
00:18:37 but he's a Trotskyite essentially
00:18:38 Trotsky's big thing
00:18:41 was that Stalin was too right-wing
00:18:43 that's kind of
00:18:45 when we say Trotskyism
00:18:48 we're talking about the schism that developed
00:18:50 within the extreme left between Stalinism
00:18:52 and Trotskyism
00:18:53 Of course, Trotsky says, and I would have been nicer, I wouldn't have murdered all those people.
00:18:57 Too bad he led the Cheka, oh no, he didn't lead the Cheka, he led the Red Army and murdered hundreds of thousands or millions of people himself.
00:19:05 So I think, you know, a bit of historical digression, but yeah, he comes from a Trotskyite position that thought Stalin was too conservative.
00:19:16 I'll put it to you, Nigel.
00:19:18 Is there a market for this in Canada in 2026?
00:19:21 Not seriously.
00:19:22 Not to win, but to have a crescent supply line. 1.00
00:19:24 Well, people would be able to like to, there are the kind of crazy pinkard people out there that we saw. 1.00
00:19:32 They will be, the spotlight will not be on them. 1.00
00:19:37 The party will take its case to the people and saying that Mr. Carney has betrayed the Green Movement,
00:19:46 that we need less oil or more solar power.
00:19:50 They'll say all those things.
00:19:52 they'll say they're in solidarity with the palestinians which is kind of odd given that i
00:19:56 believe the family the lewis family is jewish isn't it well i want to talk about that that
00:20:02 is a weird thing that also comes back to trotskyism but uh we'll go down that path a little bit yeah
00:20:08 yeah but anyway that no i mean these people know how to know how to run an election campaign
00:20:13 now they've got people out of the way who don't and like everything else they play out their
00:20:17 strengths and certain people will be told to just sit still and be quiet over there don't rock the
00:20:22 boat you'll get your you'll get what you want but let the big people who know how to do politics
00:20:28 win this election or win the seats and that's that's what they have is the possibility to take
00:20:34 power away from mr carney mr carney's right sitting on the edge of a of a majority with the
00:20:41 next three by-elections are supposed to go his way um they have the power to take that
00:20:46 away from him when it's that when it's that uh thin companies are hanging on less than 300 votes
00:20:52 dave this said is it what jade meet singh would say when i am prime minister blah blah blah blah
00:20:59 and everyone would laugh it was so self-evidently ridiculous but we'd humor him in that like well
00:21:06 you know they've got a you know respectable chunk of seats in parliament they build some power he's
00:21:11 He's not going to be a prime minister, but he says it, whatever.
00:21:15 The NDP briefly contested for power, sort of, before Jack Layton died and early Thomas Mulcair.
00:21:21 They were the up-and-coming party that could challenge the Conservatives in a two-party system.
00:21:27 I think this is the NDP explicitly just adopting its more traditional role of,
00:21:33 we're not contending for power, we're the conscience of Parliament,
00:21:36 and we are going to move the Overton window
00:21:39 far to the left, create space
00:21:41 and try to drag the Liberals there
00:21:43 when they don't adopt our policies 0.91
00:21:44 we create a political price for them to pay
00:21:46 that is a perfectly respectable
00:21:49 thing to do on the left and the right
00:21:51 in different circumstances
00:21:52 it's very often
00:21:55 done, the Green Party does it
00:21:56 the Green Party doesn't make claims to run for power
00:21:58 but they make claims to try to change the conversation
00:22:01 move things in their direction
00:22:03 I think this is the NDP
00:22:05 explicitly saying we have no interest
00:22:08 in actually governing anymore.
00:22:09 We don't even want, we saw how disastrous
00:22:11 the de facto coalition was with J.B. Singh.
00:22:13 J.B. Singh was too moderate.
00:22:15 We had to give up too much
00:22:16 to get those kinds of things done.
00:22:17 But we are going to try to radicalize
00:22:20 the conversation here
00:22:21 and try to win in meta-politics
00:22:24 and not worry about trying to win too many seats
00:22:27 and certainly not worry about
00:22:28 trying to win government anymore.
00:22:29 That's what I think,
00:22:30 that's the big message, I think,
00:22:32 that the NDP is explicitly
00:22:33 making that decision right now.
00:22:35 You may be, or you may be reduced to a rump party and end up just having one or two seats next to Elizabeth May.
00:22:41 Well, they're already essentially clear. 0.79
00:22:42 And having no influence whatsoever.
00:22:45 Their big problem right now is money, right?
00:22:49 They've got to find, as Nigel says, they've got to find some money men who are willing to put up big bucks to help them, you know, get some money in the bank.
00:22:57 They were massive, yeah.
00:22:57 Yeah, massive, massive.
00:22:59 But this could, by going really hardcore here, you could get some lefties who have, you know, some of them have jobs.
00:23:06 You know, they're white-collared, unionized government employees and professors.
00:23:10 By going this radical, you might convince the faculty lounge at whatever Ryerson University is called now to open up their wallets.
00:23:18 This could help them financially.
00:23:19 Yeah, maybe.
00:23:20 I mean, Lewis's family himself is worth $28 million, according to reports.
00:23:25 That would take a good chunk of their debt.
00:23:27 They didn't get that rich by giving it all to the party.
00:23:30 No, no, that is charity.
00:23:31 Also, remember, there's donation caps.
00:23:33 There's some moderate workarounds.
00:23:36 You know, I'm going to give the donation cap, maximum donation limit.
00:23:39 My wife will, my children's.
00:23:41 But, you know, you can't come in and just lay down millions of dollars.
00:23:46 It doesn't really.
00:23:47 You could put up a secure line of credit for the party to keep it afloat.
00:23:51 Private wealth can do that.
00:23:52 It's already happening, actually.
00:23:54 Yeah, that kind of thing can happen.
00:23:55 um but you know you can't come in just by your way like that super straightforward anymore
00:24:01 when you are positioning yourself to the left of elizabeth may a lot of most people most sane
00:24:08 canadians will not take you seriously uh you're right about some university professors and uh
00:24:15 and uh some of the uh david suzuki's of the world but for for most people no um i would think for
00:24:22 most NDP voters know. I don't think most people joined the NDP five, six years ago for it to be
00:24:30 run by the freaks that are running it today. For me, the question is where does the NDP
00:24:37 vote go to? Do they go to the Liberals or does it go to the Tories?
00:24:41 Well, you see there, Dave, that's where I think we're on slightly different tracks.
00:24:46 I think that the NDP will play down the freaks when it gets close to an election.
00:24:52 They won't be seen.
00:24:53 They won't be heard.
00:24:55 And they'll play on the old sentiment of, you know, we're the revolutionary left-wing party.
00:25:01 But the Tories and the liberals can just put out what their policies are.
00:25:05 They will.
00:25:06 And that's, you know, we don't want any more.
00:25:08 I think he's going to run as an, to his credit, I think he's going to run as a radical leftist.
00:25:14 The guy who's come out of the gate saying he wants to nationalize grocery stores, nationalize housing construction, nationalize.
00:25:20 he's gone way and beyond
00:25:22 I think he's in on this, I don't think he's going to
00:25:24 temper it a bit, but he certainly
00:25:26 is not starting to, now he's won the leadership
00:25:28 even, he's
00:25:29 you know, it's interesting, Corey, because
00:25:32 Mandani won on that platform
00:25:34 so maybe there's a
00:25:35 not-buyer
00:25:37 Canadians who have booked for free groceries
00:25:39 21 out of 23 council members
00:25:42 in Toronto voted to have 0.90
00:25:43 government-run grocery stores, as ridiculous 0.88
00:25:46 as it is, so it's true 0.95
00:25:47 there is a constituency for it, if you can
00:25:50 concentrate them, you can win some seats.
00:25:52 So, Nigel brought this up.
00:25:54 What do you guys take on this?
00:25:56 It's a difficult and very complicated
00:25:58 subject,
00:25:59 but his ancestry is curious
00:26:02 in this case.
00:26:03 He's Jewish. He's married to a Jewish
00:26:06 woman. 1.00
00:26:08 So, obviously, he keeps
00:26:10 his Jewish identity, but he's a secular
00:26:12 Jewish person. I'm not sure if he's
00:26:14 atheist or not, but he's certainly
00:26:16 not orthodox.
00:26:17 He's certainly not orthodox, and he is explicitly, and in very no uncertain terms, anti-Zionist.
00:26:26 He was asked about this at a press conference just the other day, and he says he comes from a long line of anti-Zionist Jews.
00:26:37 He was a part of the Bund, which was kind of a Jewish communist group in the former, what became the Soviet Union, pre-revolutionary Russia before 1917.
00:26:51 And I mean, I think that's a head scratcher to a lot of people that he would be not just not a Zionist himself, but explicitly anti-Zionist.
00:27:00 I don't understand it terribly well, but I mean, there is a tradition on the radical left of that, like Trotsky.
00:27:07 And I think this guy is a Trotskyite.
00:27:09 Trotsky was Jewish and he came from the radical, radical left in the Bolshevik Party.
00:27:17 And he was anti-Zionist.
00:27:20 And so there was kind of historically, if we're going back over 100 years here, 100 years, 100 years plus,
00:27:26 conflict within the community about where you're going to be nationalist,
00:27:30 so a Jewish nationalist being a Zionist, or internationalist being the extreme communists.
00:27:37 And so I think that's the best sense I can make of it, is he comes from the other tradition, and it's the minority tradition, certainly, within the world Jewish population today.
00:27:48 But it is a tradition that I think he comes from, and he says his father and his grandfather always come from.
00:27:55 I don't think that we need to be too puzzled about that, Derek. 0.99
00:27:59 I mean, we tend to think of the Jewish people as being united by their sufferings and therefore all thinking the same thing, but they don't. 0.97
00:28:08 And there are some who will cheerfully sell out their, you know, their race, if you want to put it that way, for their own advantage. 0.96
00:28:15 Here we have one.
00:28:18 It's not a surprise to me because there are lots of people who look like you and I who sell out people like us all the time. 0.51
00:28:28 Well, it's much more common among white people. 0.59
00:28:30 And it is. There's a number of different sects.
00:28:34 There's a Messianic Jewish congregation that believes actually,
00:28:38 they've created this hybrid of believing in Jesus being the Messiah,
00:28:42 yet claiming to still be Jewish. They've got a church down in West Calgary.
00:28:45 Well, they would be ethnically Jewish, but religiously Christian.
00:28:48 Exactly. But they deviate from the other things. 0.82
00:28:51 I mean, part of it too, with the Israel connection, 0.55
00:28:54 it's a pretty good indication
00:28:57 there's going to be some secularism going on
00:28:58 because those who are the true believers believe that
00:29:01 they have to be in possession of the temple map
00:29:02 for the coming of the Messiah
00:29:03 that's a lot of where that tie comes
00:29:06 well that's another one subsect
00:29:08 and then you get some Orthodox Jews
00:29:11 within New York who oppose
00:29:12 the Zionist cause
00:29:14 and that's more I think on a 0.82
00:29:16 idealized
00:29:19 thing that they feel it's going to come 0.96
00:29:20 the Messiah must come before
00:29:22 so I mean it's all over the map 0.82
00:29:24 But the bottom line is, as far as ideologies go, his extreme socialist ideology has overwhelmed any of the Jewish identity when it comes to the Zionism part.
00:29:34 In a lot of the debates online and as vitriolic as they get, I certainly wade into them on X, you know, because I really take pleasure in the nuanced discussion I get. 0.67
00:29:42 And some of the lunatics who really come after me on that one, though, you'll see they have the Palestine Plague and a shocking amount, honestly shocking, of the hammer and sickle.
00:29:50 Like, there's a battle going on, too. 0.93
00:29:52 There really is some people trying to make a resurgence,
00:29:54 not just of communism, but of Sovietism. 0.93
00:29:57 And they're tied into that whole Palestinian thing. 0.98
00:30:01 And I don't fully comprehend why, 0.94
00:30:03 because I don't see how a new Soviet system
00:30:08 is going to help the Middle Eastern countries.
00:30:10 But there's a lot of bizarro stuff going on.
00:30:11 All I can say is, look what happened to Trotsky.
00:30:14 Yeah, it didn't end well.
00:30:15 Yeah.
00:30:16 Dave, I feel kind of like we're crawling around,
00:30:18 I'm feeling our way through an unlit cave in this discussion of that.
00:30:23 It's, it's, it's, it's an odd one.
00:30:25 I don't fully understand it, but I don't think it'd be fair to call him an anti-Semite.
00:30:33 He is a radical anti-Zionist, like hard.
00:30:36 He is a hardline anti-Zionist, but I don't think it's not plausible.
00:30:41 I'm not sure he is self-hating because there is a, maybe he is, maybe he's not.
00:30:46 it's all blurry
00:30:48 I can't see into this man's heart but he does
00:30:51 come from a tradition that's like this
00:30:52 within secular Jewish
00:30:54 community
00:30:55 you know because are a lot
00:30:59 of anti-Zionist anti-Semitic
00:31:01 yes but not all
00:31:02 there's different groups
00:31:04 I mean I haven't seen Lewis trying to
00:31:06 soft sell or apologize and hopefully that doesn't happen
00:31:08 say for the ones who've been targeting a Jewish
00:31:10 community repeatedly in Toronto
00:31:12 that's anti-Jew
00:31:14 that is uh but there are the people who are just critical of the concept of israel at all together
00:31:19 not necessarily the jew aspect it's very hard to untangle those two things but that is where
00:31:23 they're coming from i think i i'm gonna guess that lewis is landing where they haven't seen it
00:31:28 but again the interesting thing i mean the only one and only flag waving on the stage when he did
00:31:32 the big money shot at the end of the convention was a palestinian flag no canadian flags no manitoba
00:31:37 flags no not even a trans flag just a palestinian well okay so that is the most baffling part of all
00:31:44 that i just don't get like why why like why would you have okay i guess
00:31:52 you guys like palestine good for you you like trans but you didn't have the fan
00:31:56 they didn't have a canadian flag does anyone want to attempt to that and i know we're really
00:32:03 deep into the dark cave at this point you know we're trying to get inside their minds and i'm
00:32:09 sure we're not doing a great job crazy place to get it it's a terrifying dark cave any idea of
00:32:14 why they would choose to have a only palestinian flag on a stage and not even a canadian flag
00:32:21 not even alongside it just a way of giving the finger to everybody who doesn't agree with them
00:32:25 don't forget you've got a most disagreeable bunch of people there we were talking earlier about the
00:32:31 there they were with their cards and their pink hair and their shrapnel in their ears and so forth
00:32:37 Well, by their appearance and by the positions they take,
00:32:43 they're just saying, screw you to the rest of Canada.
00:32:45 Well, they don't care about electability.
00:32:47 And I mean, maybe he's saying the same thing.
00:32:50 Do we think they did it deliberately or do we think they were just an organ?
00:32:53 Those things are stage organ.
00:32:54 Those are stage managed events.
00:32:55 You're careful about who brings which flag onto a stage for a shot like that.
00:32:59 And I mean, the conservatives, you know,
00:33:00 Paliyev is typically, and Shuv and others,
00:33:04 but pretty supportive of Israel and so on.
00:33:05 But you know darn well they're not going to have a conservative event where one flag in the background is the Star of David waving around there. 0.92
00:33:11 That would be ridiculous.
00:33:12 As you're pigeonholing and causing division, you don't need to embrace. 0.91
00:33:16 These guys chose to.
00:33:17 The conservatives would be rightfully ripped if they had any foreign flag on stage besides...
00:33:24 If it's alongside the Canadian flag, even that's a bit weird if you're supposed to be the Canadian party.
00:33:30 But you have only one, and it's a foreign flag.
00:33:33 of a nation that this question of whether it exists or not
00:33:36 I don't understand
00:33:39 we need a translator 0.99
00:33:41 I don't think we're gonna, this is the wrong room
00:33:42 to try and get into the mind of NDP
00:33:44 we need to talk to someone
00:33:45 they don't talk to me, they throw stuff at me
00:33:48 I like talking to them, I mean it's crazy
00:33:50 but sometimes it's a bit more interesting
00:33:52 just talking to you guys who are mostly sane
00:33:54 okay
00:33:56 mostly sane
00:33:58 well, let's face it, we have seen a lot of our old 0.51
00:34:00 kind betray us 1.00
00:34:01 this man is a Jew 0.79
00:34:03 but he's not taking the Jewish part
00:34:06 so
00:34:07 I'm not sure I think he sees it
00:34:10 probably just as a different
00:34:12 tradition it's like a different way of doing
00:34:14 it as they would see it
00:34:16 well what would be the it
00:34:18 then
00:34:19 I mean
00:34:20 what does success look like for him
00:34:24 having taken that position
00:34:26 world communism
00:34:27 that's what I mean that's where you get to the bottom
00:34:29 That's what I was saying, the hammer and sickles.
00:34:31 Starting in Winnipeg?
00:34:32 Ooh, yes.
00:34:34 Yeah.
00:34:35 Okay.
00:34:38 Okay.
00:34:38 Anyway, that's...
00:34:40 I'm not polishing the turd.
00:34:42 We're trying to dissect the turd here.
00:34:44 Anyway, yeah, I guess when the segment's called NDP Go Full Retard,
00:34:47 it's difficult for us to empathize.
00:34:51 We've done our best.
00:34:53 Okay.
00:34:54 Alberta goes full independence.
00:34:56 um so cory uh the alberta prosperity project says that it has reached 177 000 signature threshold
00:35:06 they're obviously going to try to get more than that because some signatures will get disqualified
00:35:10 for different reasons uh there was one setup uh you know i live out in county i there was a
00:35:17 new location set up just on the side of uh township road i was driving home to yesterday and
00:35:21 I stopped by and chatted with them, so they're still going strong at this, but it seems extremely likely now they're going to get the signatures, and we're going to be having a referendum alongside nine other questions on referenda in October.
00:35:37 Yeah, and yeah, Stay Free Alberta, they did their thing.
00:35:40 I'm a little perplexed as to why, I mean, if there was a successful petitioning thing,
00:35:45 to give a little credit where it's due, you know,
00:35:48 Lukasik didn't let a peep about his numbers out until the very end.
00:35:52 And then floored everybody with a massive number.
00:35:54 And that way he kept his volunteers constantly pushing and going and going.
00:35:58 Yeah, this is not a good idea.
00:35:59 I know that Stay Free Alberta is saying, but don't stop, guys.
00:36:02 Keep going.
00:36:03 We need to make an example.
00:36:04 look these are volunteers who have been sitting out on cold highways they've been getting the
00:36:09 finger from people they've been taking time out of their lives and some will continue to do so
00:36:14 but that's hard work and it's going to be a little harder when the weather's bad you get up in the
00:36:18 morning geez do I want to go set up at a table outside or go knocking on doors or maybe I should
00:36:22 you know clean the bathroom or something it's going to slow down the collection but they were
00:36:27 feeling some pressure I mean it seemed like every week another story was coming out saying that
00:36:31 they're not going to make it. And it's freaking people out and freaking supporters. There was
00:36:35 another one saying, oh, that was hitting the headlines just two days ago. Oh, there's problems
00:36:38 with rural addresses and they might not make the bar. And I think they were getting frustrated with
00:36:42 that and just wanted to say, look, we're getting it done. And then there's that potential injunction
00:36:47 coming on the South, which isn't stopping a referendum. It's stopping the petitioning,
00:36:51 which is really bizarre. And for most legal people I've talked to, though, you can never
00:36:56 predict a judge saying it's really, it's junk. It's not going to go through, but they're feeling,
00:37:00 well we want to establish we crossed the line there's going to be a referendum injunction and
00:37:05 no referendum we did what we had to do and they'll have that moral ability to push for one this fall
00:37:10 so i think that's the rationale on releasing that but it's clear there's going to be a referendum
00:37:14 this fall people had better accept that and move on to the campaign mode now um yeah and so campaign
00:37:21 mode is i think where this they need to start start thinking about things um jason kenny is
00:37:28 I guess positioned himself as
00:37:30 the de facto leader of the Federalist side
00:37:32 which is wonderful
00:37:33 but he's got the easier job
00:37:36 they've got the high ground here
00:37:38 he's defending high ground
00:37:39 but I think
00:37:42 this is trying to position himself to
00:37:44 take Pierre Polyev's job
00:37:46 if Polyev loses the next election
00:37:48 I think that's what he's trying to position himself for
00:37:49 he probably won't get much support in Alberta
00:37:52 when that happens but he could say to the rest
00:37:54 of Canada, I kept Alberta
00:37:56 in Canada
00:37:58 The pro-independence side, though, that's got no clear leader at all.
00:38:05 You know, there's a number of names around.
00:38:09 I know Kenny's going to be debating with Keith Wilson of the Alberta Prosperity Project.
00:38:15 He's a pretty well-spoken guy.
00:38:18 But, Dave, there does not appear to be any real major figure yet on the independent side.
00:38:25 And to me, that looks like that is the single biggest thing that's got to get fixed.
00:38:30 Absolutely.
00:38:30 But they seem quite happy at the moment.
00:38:33 We talked to Mitch Sylvester yesterday.
00:38:35 He's one of the leaders.
00:38:37 He says, look, we've gotten this far.
00:38:40 We've got several leaders.
00:38:43 Jeff Rath is one of our leaders.
00:38:45 But he doesn't want to be a politician.
00:38:48 I don't want to be a politician.
00:38:49 So he's quite happy to let things grow from the ground level up.
00:38:56 So I don't – I'm like you, Derek.
00:38:59 I think that they need to have somebody, and they need to have somebody in place quick if they want any chance of winning this thing.
00:39:07 But they don't seem to be in any rush to appoint a leader unless they're keeping something up their sleeve.
00:39:14 Well, I know when, Nigel, one of the things, you know, Alberta Prosperity Project says is, well, you know, this is nonpartisan, it's decentralized, you know, Corey and I have been around this movement a long time, we know that by its very nature, the movement attracts very independent minded people that sometimes have a hard time working together.
00:39:35 So it might be very difficult for you to get literally everyone else to stand down, essentially become lieutenants and have one guy up front and everybody agree to do that.
00:39:44 A lot of that is being independent minded. Some of it, no one will admit it, but some of it is going to be ego.
00:39:52 So I don't know. Is this just is it just kind of an excuse?
00:39:56 The reason we have no leaders because everyone's a leader and it's organic and everyone goes out.
00:40:00 is that legitimate or do you think it's
00:40:05 I see it as a bit of an excuse for the independent side not able
00:40:08 to organize itself appropriately for even a short term
00:40:13 campaign like this. Well no disrespects to many of the people who work very hard
00:40:17 on this project but nobody has actually
00:40:20 by their words and actions distinguished themselves
00:40:24 as the leader. It ought to be pretty obvious by now who the guy
00:40:29 as well it would be a guy uh but it's not just uh it's it's not obvious from the words and actions
00:40:40 so far so i think what you're going to get is uh you're assuming everything goes according to plan
00:40:47 you will get a referendum it doesn't have to be in october there's a number of things that could
00:40:53 delay it including the legislature itself that could schedule it later than october
00:40:58 or the legislature is within the legislature's gift to amend the question or just defeat the
00:41:04 bill there is actually no legal requirement for it to go ahead even if they get the signatures
00:41:10 so there's a lot of things that could interrupt the flow of this thing but until somebody comes
00:41:15 along who actually has the credo and the clout to challenge the federal government personally
00:41:22 and thereby draw to himself or herself all the bad words
00:41:30 that make other people want to rally around them and help them.
00:41:34 We've not got our Sam Adams.
00:41:36 We've not got our George Washington.
00:41:38 We've not got the people who you're going to send to the Constitutional Convention
00:41:43 to write the new book for Alberta.
00:41:47 So it doesn't mean it won't happen.
00:41:49 it just may take a little longer than the
00:41:52 enthusiasm hope. The thing is
00:41:54 they have the signatures, they know
00:41:56 that there is the feeling there
00:41:58 Well, we don't have our Washington
00:42:00 we don't have our Jefferson, but
00:42:02 well, some of us can fashion ourselves
00:42:04 at least the Thomas Paine writing our
00:42:06 pamphlets, trying to spread
00:42:08 the news for now. Somebody has to inform the
00:42:10 Washingtons. René Levesque could be something
00:42:12 they could use. Yeah, okay
00:42:14 we are out of time, I don't even
00:42:16 get a party shot, we have such little time, so we're going to go 0.96
00:42:18 quick firing line of parting shots starting with nigel all right so my my thing is about air canada
00:42:24 you know they'll they'll reroute you they'll start you early in the morning and deliver you
00:42:29 at late at night they'll lose your bags they will cancel the flight that you booked and put you on
00:42:36 at a time and then that you don't want to go and then as for the flight itself sometimes it goes
00:42:42 well and sometimes it's exciting none of that matters life goes on but when the chairman of
00:42:49 air canada gets up and delivers his heartfelt condolences for the two pilots who were killed
00:42:55 in new york in that accident and he only does it in english well then the bloody roof comes down
00:43:01 and oh well this can't be tolerated you're down the road and we're going to get somebody who can
00:43:05 speak both languages that's the problem you know like this is the problem i see in so many areas
00:43:11 of our life is that people are focused on the wrong things and that's just a beautiful
00:43:17 example and he was effectively fired by parliament the committee voted to recommend he be fired he
00:43:23 was essentially forced to retire and it wasn't just the liberals and the bloc it was the
00:43:27 conservatives too yeah well we got shame on the cash you know we've got it we've got to start
00:43:32 focusing what it is that matters to make this country work yeah corey i'll go quick i just
00:43:37 think since the condolences weren't properly delivered in french we should have the highest
00:43:41 office in the land do so and our governor general should give those condolences in an extended
00:43:45 french speech that's cruel you mean hey have corporate heads got to speak french shouldn't
00:43:53 our governor general dave uh the good ward good lord willing uh the uh manned mission to the moon
00:44:02 is underway as we speak uh for the first time in half a century uh godspeed artemis 2. amen it's
00:44:10 fake they're filming it in northern ontario all right nigel cory dave thank you thank you
00:44:18 john on production and all of you who joined us today and are supporting our work uh go to
00:44:24 western standard dot news click on subscribe it's only ten dollars a month or a hundred dollars a
00:44:28 year to get unlimited access to all western standard content and support the work that
00:44:32 we are doing thank you very much and godspeed
00:44:40 We'll be right back.