Western Standard - September 28, 2023


The Pipeline: The Speaker spoke too quick

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Sep 27, 2023 Damage caused by school closures for COVID

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

177.77

Word count

8,681

Sentence count

420

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us this week as we discuss the biggest blunder in Canadian parliamentary history, a 92-year-old member of Parliament is invited to a meeting with a notorious Nazi spy, and the Canadian Shooting Sports Association is fighting the government for trying to take away your right to own guns.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening welcome to the pipeline this is the western standards weekly panel show where we'll
00:00:18 pick out a few of the top issues of the weekend and analyze them give our opinions on them dissect
00:00:24 them and discuss them and boy there's a lot of issues to discuss this week i'll tell you
00:00:30 I'm Corey Morgan.
00:00:31 I'm a regular columnist in Alberta with the Western Standard, and I'm joined today by,
00:00:36 I'm going to start with Nigel Hannaford, our opinion editor.
00:00:39 You're doing week by week, aren't you?
00:00:40 Yes, I like to make sure you're actually listening to me, so if I'm swapping it around.
00:00:44 Oh, we listen to you.
00:00:46 So do thousands of others.
00:00:48 Some do, yes.
00:00:49 They don't all necessarily like it, but they do listen, and that's important.
00:00:52 Yeah.
00:00:52 I see the letters to the editor.
00:00:54 Okay.
00:00:55 As well, we also have our news editor, Dave Naylor, here today.
00:00:59 Great to be on with the Toast of India, the latest India media sensation, Corey Morgan.
00:01:05 I'm going to have to learn to dance the bangra or some of those things.
00:01:10 Trudeau, I mean, he fit in.
00:01:12 You could barely distinguish him from an Indian citizen when he was there that first time.
00:01:15 Well, you know, phone the PML and see where you get that neat stuff.
00:01:20 Soon they don't return my calls.
00:01:21 I think I'm blocked.
00:01:23 All right.
00:01:25 So, yes, we won't talk about India this week.
00:01:27 Well, maybe a little more, but there are big issues from the Prime Minister's office.
00:01:33 I'll start with one of our sponsors before we start digging into all that stuff, though.
00:01:36 And that's an important thing as well is this is how we stay independent, guys,
00:01:41 so we can cover these things that our government doesn't want us to.
00:01:44 And the big one is the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:01:47 They're a great group.
00:01:49 If you enjoy firearms, you want to continue to enjoy firearms, owning them, hunting with them,
00:01:54 collecting them, target shooting, whatever you want to do.
00:01:56 It's your business.
00:01:56 That's the thing.
00:01:57 It's your business, but your business needs to be protected, and the CSSA is standing up for you
00:02:01 because we've got a government that wants to take away your right to do that. 0.90
00:02:05 If you are not a member of the CSSA yet, guys, get on there.
00:02:08 Check them out.
00:02:09 It's affordable.
00:02:09 It's an investment in your own freedoms.
00:02:11 Check them out.
00:02:12 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, cssa-cila.org.
00:02:17 It's very important.
00:02:19 All right.
00:02:20 Well, let's talk about some federal politics.
00:02:23 uh as you see here the speaker spoke too quick and uh well he's not spoken or speaking anymore
00:02:29 whatsoever now uh give us the rundown dave what do we got this week the rundown the debacle uh
00:02:35 pierre polly i've called it the biggest blunder in canadian uh parliamentary history uh this is
00:02:41 when the uh somehow a uh a 92 year old member of the former member 98 i'm sorry of the the waffen
00:02:49 SS was invited to Parliament to witness the speech of Ukraine President Zelensky.
00:02:58 Then parliamentarians gave him two standing ovations when he was introduced.
00:03:03 It wasn't until afterwards, lo and behold, it was found out that he was a member of this notorious
00:03:09 Nazi outfit. And they were really bad boys during the war, no doubt about it. 0.85
00:03:15 So there were calls for resignations and apologies all over the weekend.
00:03:19 On Monday, Speaker did resign, took full responsibility.
00:03:25 On Wednesday, after three days of hiding, the Prime Minister came out and he apologized, not on behalf of himself, on behalf of all parliamentarians.
00:03:36 And shockingly to me, he admitted he has not got in touch with President Zelensky yet to offer his personal apology.
00:03:43 You know, he always sort of seems to come across as he and Zelensky are best buddies,
00:03:48 and they couldn't stop hugging each other during that trip to Ottawa.
00:03:51 So it's been a seismic week in Ottawa politics, the likes of which I don't think we've ever seen.
00:03:58 Have we, Nigel?
00:04:00 Well, yeah, I think we have.
00:04:01 I mean, seismic weeks in politics, boy, how about India just a couple of weeks ago?
00:04:06 Involving the speaker.
00:04:07 And well, this is not since, what is it, 1967 or something?
00:04:12 57.
00:04:12 57, yeah.
00:04:14 There was a speaker resigned.
00:04:15 And I had to look it up just to see if it was anything like it.
00:04:19 His name was John Bosley.
00:04:20 And the reason he gave was he was just tired of the childish antics in the House of Commons.
00:04:27 He couldn't take it anymore.
00:04:28 That was, sorry, that was in the Mulrooney days when it was the Rat Pack, you know, the
00:04:32 Rat, Sheila Copps.
00:04:33 So that was in the 80s.
00:04:34 Yeah, so it was in the 80s.
00:04:36 So we're both wrong, but, you know, Error loves company.
00:04:41 But no, I mean, to your point, Dave, obviously, this is a real bag of nails.
00:04:48 And this is, there's so many things that amaze you out of that.
00:04:52 There's 338 sitting members of Parliament.
00:04:56 Does any of them actually know anything about the war in Eastern Europe?
00:05:02 like I wouldn't expect them to be experts and I wouldn't expect all of them to know anything
00:05:07 but I would have thought that you know those who are representing Ukrainian writings might have
00:05:12 seen this coming and said just exactly what this what was this man doing to be a little bit fair
00:05:18 you know I watched that clip a number of times it was very muted applause for what those you know
00:05:23 if we've attended in the gallery at sessions they introduce a number of guests and everybody
00:05:29 just almost automatically get up and applaud. You almost never refuse to do so.
00:05:34 I think in this case, the applause was because they felt he was fighting the Russians.
00:05:39 Yeah. And I think though, even if I were a member of parliament and I was sitting there,
00:05:43 and if I had clued in, wait a minute, you know, start to do some math. 98 years old,
00:05:47 fighting for the Ukrainians against the Soviets. There's only one unit that was doing that and
00:05:51 they weren't on our side. But what are you going to do? Are you going to stand up and shout it out
00:05:56 in the middle of the parliamentary uh event are you going to you know take your seat uh i think
00:06:02 all of them were still in shock i mean they weren't given a warning this individual was
00:06:07 necessarily you know they didn't know it until it was announced so i think perhaps there were
00:06:11 some out there with a knowledge of history who are already realizing oh wow something's going to
00:06:15 hit the fan here really fast but they weren't going to be the ones to raise their hand and say
00:06:20 it's about yeah well i mean wouldn't they have looked like heroes today if they had oh if one
00:06:24 even had just stood up and said, hey, hey, hey, I'm not giving an ovation to a Nazi,
00:06:29 but you better be, that's part of it. You know, you're on the floor, you just got gobsmacked.
00:06:33 You better be 100% sure you heard what you heard. You don't want to call an innocent man a Nazi.
00:06:39 Still, that's the prime minister's job. I mean, there are some members of parliament
00:06:42 who represent areas where the Ukrainian presence is something they have to acknowledge and work
00:06:48 with. Maybe they are Ukrainian themselves. And of course, the other side of it is the staffers,
00:06:54 in this whole thing, I mean, there's been a lot of talk, well, the speaker's office should
00:07:00 have caught it, or it was the security people who should have caught it.
00:07:04 You know, when I was in the PMO, staffers got involved in this kind of thing, and we
00:07:10 checked out the people that we were going to have in.
00:07:13 The speaker's office has staffers.
00:07:17 Do they not do that sort of thing?
00:07:19 Do they not feed that information to the security agents and say,
00:07:24 have you got anything on any of these people?
00:07:26 Happens to be a Ukrainian this time.
00:07:28 It could easily be somebody else from a completely different context.
00:07:33 Canada having so many contexts.
00:07:35 Somebody didn't do their job.
00:07:38 And what I took offense to with the prime minister's apology was within the space of 15 seconds,
00:07:42 he said, I apologize.
00:07:45 It was the speaker's fault.
00:07:47 That's not an apology.
00:07:48 No, it's throwing under the bus.
00:07:50 And the other thing that you'd know to David, I believe he hasn't, as far as we know, contacted Zelensky.
00:07:56 I mean, there's a victim, if anybody, in this.
00:07:58 I mean, Putin must have been just spitting his vodka and laughing his brains out when he saw his enemy standing there,
00:08:04 when he's been trying to connect him to Nazis for years, applauding a literal Nazi.
00:08:09 I mean, you couldn't have staged a better event for Putin's PR machine.
00:08:13 Maybe Zelensky's not taking his phone calls at the moment.
00:08:15 You know, he may be that angry.
00:08:17 You know, that's not beyond the realm of possibility.
00:08:20 But they gave Polyev two full days in Parliament to just swing for the fences.
00:08:26 And the poor Liberal House Minister Gould was reduced to a quivering mass by the end of it.
00:08:35 I was going to ask you, Nigel, you've worked in PMOs.
00:08:38 What is the strategy behind hiding for three days?
00:08:42 Well, Harvard didn't hide that much.
00:08:45 But I guess when you, there have been times, I think there was a time when, well, Thomas Volcker was just grinding relentlessly on about a certain senator who lived rather well.
00:09:00 There's only so many times you can get up and answer that question.
00:09:04 And so sometimes if an opportunity comes to go elsewhere for the day, you take it.
00:09:09 However, that had not happened in this case.
00:09:11 This was, happened on Friday.
00:09:13 the Prime Minister had a duty to be there on Monday and explain himself.
00:09:18 Not only was he not there on Monday, he was not there on Tuesday.
00:09:21 And this little so-called apology that he issued was intended,
00:09:26 I'm sure he didn't honestly believe it would work,
00:09:29 but it was intended to deflect from what would happen in question period later.
00:09:35 Well, you know, I've already dealt with that kind of thing.
00:09:37 I think, by the way, that Pierre Polliver was relatively restrained
00:09:42 in his attacks on the government yesterday.
00:09:46 I mean, he did save his best for the prime minister when he finally returned.
00:09:51 Yeah, and to be clear, Trudeau was in Ottawa on Monday.
00:09:55 He had private meetings, whatever they are, in the morning.
00:09:58 He was in BC on Monday.
00:09:58 And he met with BC Premier Eby in Ottawa.
00:10:01 He was in Ottawa.
00:10:02 He was in Ottawa.
00:10:03 And then on Tuesday, he took a quick jump to Toronto.
00:10:07 So he was around.
00:10:08 It wasn't a case of he was on a foreign mission somewhere.
00:10:11 He just chose to deliberately not attend Parliament.
00:10:14 I would think part of it, though.
00:10:15 I mean, you know, what everyone might think of Trudeau.
00:10:17 I mean, I know you and I differ on our views of where his intellect may land.
00:10:20 But one thing I think is true is he's not good at thinking on his feet, though.
00:10:24 When it's something this big, he needs coaching.
00:10:26 It's time to, because that's what he does.
00:10:28 He'll stonewall, and he'll give the same answer over, as we saw in question period today.
00:10:31 But if he has to come up with his answer to stonewall like that, he gets in trouble. 0.97
00:10:35 And you could see him in question period, you know, referring to a sheet where he had his notes.
00:10:39 So he needed his day to, okay, how can I just sit and deflect rather than take responsibility or try and, you know, take this as a leader and speak to it.
00:10:49 He's not capable, in my view, of that.
00:10:51 He needs his coached answers.
00:10:53 One thing I'm not seeing come out of this that I thought would come out of it by now is an agreement with all the parties to say, okay, the next time this happens, this is what we're going to do.
00:11:04 Why haven't they come together and formed an all-party committee to work on getting a plan in action?
00:11:09 so the next time a world leader speaks in in the house of commons we know we know what's going to
00:11:14 be investigated and and you know how who's going to do the vetting yeah well that would mean
00:11:21 surrendering a certain amount of control you know if you're if you're the government you probably
00:11:25 don't want to do that and you'd have to listen to the ndp and the green party as well as the
00:11:30 conservatives that might be hard to take look at the alternative what they're dealing with now
00:11:34 Oh, once every 50 years.
00:11:38 But it's, you know, the unfortunate thing is no matter how much they try to just fully lay this on Rody's feet is if he unilaterally did this, which I still find hard to believe.
00:11:48 The timing that he picked a Ukrainian veteran on the day, this was part of a whole staged affair.
00:11:54 I mean, there was an error.
00:11:55 They certainly didn't mean to do this, but there were more minds involved in seeking out this gentleman and bringing him in than just Rody.
00:12:02 In fact, I got a feeling the way he was reading that for him that he didn't know anything about this guy who was coming in, even though he was technically the one reading for it.
00:12:09 But the nuances of whether the speaker is independent or isn't independent or isn't partisan, it doesn't matter.
00:12:16 As far as the world is concerned, when they see an ovation for a Nazi, they don't look at all of that.
00:12:22 See, the average Canadian doesn't look at all of that or understand that the speaker's independence.
00:12:28 This is going to land on Trudeau's support numbers, whether he thinks it's going to or not.
00:12:31 Oh, yeah. Yeah, you can't deflect this to the speaker.
00:12:35 Nigel and I were talking about it yesterday.
00:12:39 You almost, I don't want to say you feel sorry for this old man because he was a Nazi at some point, 0.65
00:12:44 but he had no idea what he was getting himself into either, I'm sure.
00:12:48 You know, he's now could be sent to Poland to face trial.
00:12:53 They're talking about maybe extraditing him and stuff like that.
00:12:56 So, I mean, is there a point, you know, these events happened in the 1940s.
00:13:01 Is there a point where it's okay to forgive and forget, move on?
00:13:06 Well, I think the point at which that comes up is probably for the offended people to decide.
00:13:14 But, you know, let's try and we try to be fair to Mr. Trudeau just now.
00:13:22 Let's try and be fair to this elderly gentleman.
00:13:25 At the time that he joined up, he was 18 years old.
00:13:29 18-year-old boys tend to see things pretty simply.
00:13:33 And what he had witnessed in his life was a deliberate campaign of starvation
00:13:39 by the Stalinist government in the Soviet Union against his people.
00:13:44 It's called the Holodomor.
00:13:45 They actually went and they stole the food from the farms
00:13:48 so they could feed the Russian people and pretend that everything was good. 0.99
00:13:52 Meanwhile, the Ukrainians died. 0.99
00:13:55 that happened and it happened in his lifetime and he saw that so the first person to come along and
00:14:03 say hey you want to go fight the russians join up we'll give you a gun and you're on your way 0.87
00:14:08 probably had his attention and many of the things that we hold against the nazis now were either a
00:14:15 not known at the time in his area like how could he have known and b this was the middle of 1943
00:14:23 a lot of things hadn't happened yet so from you you know a kid let's face it we we all have 18
00:14:32 year olds in our lives at some point and the consensus is that they tend not to know much
00:14:38 but they're very passionate about what they do know i can see how easily anybody in those
00:14:45 circumstances could have said sure sign me up where do i where do i sign i mean there were
00:14:51 were millions of young men in Japan and Canada and the United States and Great
00:14:56 Britain and Germany and all the combatant countries who were making the 0.84
00:15:00 same choice. My country's at war, what do I do? So, you know, there's no specific
00:15:07 incidents laid at his feet that I am aware of. You could have seen that the
00:15:13 Nazis is the lesser of two evils in a, when you're in a rough part of the world
00:15:16 you're choosing between authoritarian dictatorships. The Russians were the 1.00
00:15:21 most recent ones to abuse you. I have little to lose than throwing my hat in the ring with these
00:15:25 guys. Derek made a very good point about that yesterday, actually. And he said, you know,
00:15:29 on the Western Front, there was literally a good guy, bad guy scenario. On the Eastern Front,
00:15:35 you just have two bad guys. Yeah, well, and I remember reading up on it, too, when initially,
00:15:40 actually, when the Eastern Front started, the Nazis came in a lot of Russian villages. So it 0.97
00:15:44 was just one dictator over and over. They weren't too concerned. It didn't matter. They just wanted
00:15:49 It wasn't until the Nazis started brutalizing the local villagers that they built a resistance over in Russia.
00:15:54 Otherwise, they were marching on by and head to Moscow.
00:15:57 I don't care.
00:15:57 But again, that's all sort of moot to the point of, yes, in that case,
00:16:01 the gentleman should have been allowed to rest out the final few years in obscurity.
00:16:06 And as I said on my show earlier, it's between him and if there was any actions in his God or his conscience.
00:16:11 But now it's been brought into the spotlight.
00:16:13 But he just never should have been brought into Parliament in the first place.
00:16:16 That's the thing.
00:16:17 Well, I think everybody's agreed on that.
00:16:21 No, and just my thoughts.
00:16:24 I don't think you look good chasing a 98-year-old man out of the country.
00:16:28 Probably not something that would be good politics.
00:16:31 So this has opened up other stuff, too.
00:16:33 Some of this was covered with the Ukrainian members who had come to Canada in the 50s.
00:16:38 People have been asking.
00:16:39 They say, well, why wasn't that the Nuremberg trials?
00:16:42 Well, for one, they were already full.
00:16:43 They had enough war criminals at their plate as it was who were far worse. 0.95
00:16:45 Caesar death camp operators and other such evil personas.
00:16:50 They basically said, they didn't give them clearance,
00:16:54 but they said, we're not gonna go further with you.
00:16:57 In 2000, at least 2000.
00:16:58 Yeah, a decision, just move on.
00:17:01 We aren't exonerating you,
00:17:04 but we're saying leave it behind.
00:17:06 But now the Benign Breath and others are giving up
00:17:07 and saying, well, why did we do that?
00:17:09 What is the record on that?
00:17:10 And they're re-examining in hindsight.
00:17:11 I don't think anybody's gonna extradite
00:17:13 and find out the few dozen remaining anymore
00:17:15 any of that, but it's opened up a whole new area of Canadian history to re-examine.
00:17:20 Right, and that's another interesting point that you're bringing up there, Corey, that the people
00:17:25 who made those decisions, a lot of them, were probably Canadian veterans. You know, you sort
00:17:31 of transit out of the armed forces and into the government service in some kind or other. People
00:17:36 who had actually been in action and probably had a very much more nuanced view of what other people
00:17:44 had been through and made a made a decision based on what dare i say it'll maybe a little
00:17:50 bit of compassion even i don't know it's hard to say but it's a war time it was 80 years ago
00:17:57 atrocities happen on both sides too it's just you never hear about the ones the victors might have
00:18:01 committed uh aside from dresden yeah and uh it was ugly it's unfortunate we're revisiting this
00:18:08 uh in the way we are right now as i said maybe hopefully though they're examining it and at
00:18:12 least learning we need some degree of vetting with people we don't lose that freedom it's a big
00:18:19 honor for a member of parliament to invite a constituent to be able to stand in the gallery
00:18:22 and get that shout out but you don't necessarily want to be a screaming protester who's going to
00:18:27 throw eggs or you know hang and drape a flag over the edge or any of that either so i got a feeling
00:18:33 it's going to be tougher to get into parliament ironically the speaker had his open tea yesterday
00:18:39 It was supposed to happen last night for all members of the press gallery and MPs.
00:18:45 As a speaker, he gets a government house.
00:18:47 It's called The Farm in Quebec.
00:18:50 And it was supposed to happen there.
00:18:51 And not surprisingly, it got canceled after.
00:18:54 I'm sure his wife's not overly happy.
00:18:55 I don't think they're probably having some nasty conversations at the moment.
00:18:59 Well, this is big.
00:19:00 He's got to move.
00:19:01 He's one of those housed positions.
00:19:03 So your life's been turned upside down.
00:19:05 And you're going to get a pay cut of $90,000 a year.
00:19:08 uh and one of the interim speakers is actually a separatist member of the bloc
00:19:14 just when you think parliament can't get any uh any more chaos
00:19:20 one of the first two words of the national anthem or oh canada
00:19:25 sometimes whoa change the intonation of it maybe they'll ask me for the job you know if you were a
00:19:31 a script writer, they wouldn't let you do this. No, no, no. People won't. Nobody would ever think
00:19:37 that. Well, let's get on to something a little drier, but still a big issue. I mean, it's kind
00:19:43 of gotten overshadowed with this whole event. It's the long-awaited report on the Alberta pension
00:19:49 plan was released last week. It was. Premier Daniel Smith announced it late last week at
00:19:56 the MacDougall Centre, looking at some of their advertising, a very slick campaign.
00:20:02 It's obviously something that's been worked on for months and months.
00:20:06 But the bottom line, I think, for most people is Premier Smith says Alberta is owed $534
00:20:15 billion from the Canada pension pound, which is more than half of the $570 billion in total.
00:20:22 So that shows you how much Alberta has overpaid over the years, and she is promoting, she's saying we may be able to pay less and get more out of it if we go the Alberta way.
00:20:41 But there are going to be a panel chaired by former Treasurer Jim Denning, who, as we know, cleared Alberta's debt at one point.
00:20:52 And he's going to go around the province and listen to what people have to say.
00:20:56 And I expect people will be loud and vocal whichever way they choose to go, Nigel.
00:21:03 Yes, they certainly will.
00:21:05 I mean, the fundamental argument in favor of doing this is pretty sound.
00:21:11 it's a young workforce they're not going on pensions the fact that we have overpaid so much
00:21:21 indicates another one of those systemic inequalities in confederation people have
00:21:28 got a like why do you work hard in order to pay for somebody somewhere else to retire maybe they
00:21:33 maybe there should be well maybe they should be paying a little more to fund their own retirement
00:21:38 that's like you working to pay for your neighbor now so the difficulty I think
00:21:46 and the plan comes in actually making it happen if you lend your deadbeat brother
00:21:52 500 bucks there's no question that he owes it to you but how do you get it out
00:21:59 of him and how even assuming that once the formulas have been examined and
00:22:06 That's going to be the first objection.
00:22:07 Oh, well, you know, your numbers are wrong.
00:22:10 It couldn't possibly be that much.
00:22:12 Let's see that they actually do line up and find a number.
00:22:17 Well, all right, we agree that you've overpaid by this much.
00:22:20 We understand that you want to leave.
00:22:23 You are by law entitled to take that with you,
00:22:26 but we can't afford to give it to you.
00:22:28 So this then becomes a national issue
00:22:32 because the Canada pension plan has only got one place to go.
00:22:36 it's not a government agency but it can only go to the federal government and so you're going to
00:22:42 have let's say that the election result goes the way that i think we all want it to in two years
00:22:49 time and you've got prime minister polyev and you've got premier daniel smith and these two
00:22:56 natural allies have now got this horrible conflict between them how is that going to work out so
00:23:04 So this is a really tough one.
00:23:09 The plan idea is fine, and to the degree that I can tell it would work as advertised by
00:23:15 the government of Alberta.
00:23:17 Getting it over that particular hurdle is going to require some creative thinking by
00:23:22 the people concerned.
00:23:24 I think speaking to what you were talking about with Prime Minister Polioff, it's also
00:23:29 given Trudeau a wedge issue that he can go and say, look, Alberta's trying to rip the 1.00
00:23:33 rest of the country off. And he can certainly use it to his benefit. The idea itself has kind of
00:23:40 gone over like a lead balloon across the country in other provinces, as you would expect it would.
00:23:47 Saskatchewan officials, Newfoundland officials, even the people in charge of the CCP said no.
00:23:56 So it is going to take a lot of persuading and arguing to get it through.
00:24:02 So the rest of the country basically takes the position,
00:24:04 too bad we're gonna go on ripping you off forever?
00:24:06 Exactly, well, because their residents
00:24:09 are gonna have to pay more, right?
00:24:11 Yeah, well, and that's where some of those discussions
00:24:13 maybe will finally get serious in front of some Canadians,
00:24:15 though, why are you vulnerable like that?
00:24:17 This is supposed to be a pension plan,
00:24:18 not a social welfare program.
00:24:21 So I'm expected, I should be expecting,
00:24:23 I put in this much, that's my fund that's building,
00:24:26 that's sitting in there, that's waiting for me to draw from,
00:24:30 And I'm supposed to accept then that it'll be a lesser amount because we're
00:24:34 funding others who put in less elsewhere or we're of any different age
00:24:39 demographic, which is no fault of my own.
00:24:41 I know we'll be painted as selfish for daring to say that, but again,
00:24:44 we're not talking about any other transfer payment.
00:24:48 This is supposedly a pension plan.
00:24:50 No, and I think Nigel wrote about it.
00:24:54 In fact, I know he wrote about it is Canada pension plan has done okay for
00:24:57 itself and was a 10 uh basically which is a lot better than my current investment portfolio so
00:25:05 and one of the big arguments in alberta is going to be okay who gets control of this
00:25:08 who runs it uh you know and i think daniel smith has made it pretty clear it's going to be in our
00:25:13 in our arms length uh organization that runs it uh but that you know that's going to be a worry
00:25:18 for a lot of people is who's going to control the money yeah and that is worth worrying about
00:25:22 with the like we're talking about a pretty substantial difference here like they're they're
00:25:28 quoting for fourteen hundred and twenty five dollars a year less in premiums more than a
00:25:35 hundred dollars a month so we've actually now to support the rest of canada are all paying
00:25:41 a hundred dollars a month more than we need to that's a pretty strong argument and by the way
00:25:48 that goes for the employer as well because they're matched.
00:25:50 It's costing businesses a lot of money.
00:25:52 It's costing, you bet.
00:25:54 I mean, it could open the door too.
00:25:55 So I mean, that's just the first shot.
00:25:58 That's the calculation based on what they wrote up back in 66,
00:26:01 I believe, when it was formed.
00:26:04 That was the exit clause.
00:26:05 It was Ontario actually that insisted on having that within the legislation.
00:26:08 I mean, technically, we're just following the letter of the legislation.
00:26:11 And they didn't anticipate this kind of regional imbalance, I think,
00:26:15 in the fund at that time when when talking about somebody extricating themselves from it but maybe
00:26:21 i'm just throwing it out some different negotiations might come well maybe alberta
00:26:24 can do a phased exit the people who have the investment in the plan will still be entitled to
00:26:29 what will come out for what they put in so far but starting at this point they're going to contribute
00:26:33 to this new one and that way your old funds are protected but we're on to a new one so you don't
00:26:39 keep contributing to that pool because the disparity is only going to get worse or things
00:26:43 like that a lot of people in the uh the alberta separate argument basically saying we just want
00:26:49 what quebec has and guess who's got their own pension plan quebec does so if they can run it
00:26:55 i've heard no problems about it i've heard i think assume it's running smoothly so if they
00:27:00 can do it why can't alberta well alberta can it's just that the rest of the country will have ontario
00:27:07 especially which originally wanted the exit clause because they were a half province in those days
00:27:15 probably figured they might be getting ripped off by the rest of the country now it's working in 0.95
00:27:19 their favor not so keen no i mean the the motivations are with everybody a concern
00:27:25 are very easily understandable uh who who would vote to pay more if you lived in ontario
00:27:32 who would vote to carry on paying as much as we do if you live in alberta
00:27:35 And the timing is very interesting, isn't it, Nigel, that all the reports and the UCP final decision on what they're going to do is just a few months before the next provincial election.
00:27:48 You certainly see the battle lines being drawn, and Rachel Ngo is already screaming from high hell.
00:27:53 Well, Rachel Ngobley and her union followers all have separate pension plans that are very lucrative.
00:27:59 If for those who are solely relying on government pension plans, they're looking at a lean retirement.
00:28:06 Yes, yes, it doesn't take you very far, would it?
00:28:09 I mean, Premier Smith only has to sell it in Alberta.
00:28:12 That's something.
00:28:12 Some people are howling in other parts of the country, but that's not her concern.
00:28:18 As I said, it puts Paul Yevon in a terrible spot if he becomes prime minister.
00:28:21 Like I said, if Trudeau comes out and says he's going to fight to the death for it, and you're a Trump-tonian, and you're going to have to pay $1,400 a year more, maybe enough to swing a vote?
00:28:33 Certainly might. And then on top of that, you also have the emotive argument about
00:28:38 Alberto the renegade on climate change.
00:28:41 Yes.
00:28:42 So I can, you know, people were fantasizing here about what would a future Prime Minister
00:28:47 Polyev do, but it may not be. A future Prime Minister Polyev might be the same old story.
00:28:54 Because that's how the liberals always win, it's by division.
00:28:58 Yep. The next election is still a ways away.
00:29:02 It's never about building a consensus.
00:29:03 That was one of those things that's not done until it's done.
00:29:07 Well, getting on to, I guess, you know, climate change, the bad actor Alberta is, and just in general.
00:29:13 Can anybody afford electricity anymore?
00:29:16 We're starting to see the real costs are starting to come in now, I think.
00:29:20 You know, people are grinding it through, not just by saving the world from evil forms of electrical generation,
00:29:26 but now realizing that it's not cheap to save the world from these other generations.
00:29:30 No, my electricity bill was $200 last month.
00:29:32 I mean, come on.
00:29:34 But the people in Ontario got hit with a sticker shock yesterday,
00:29:40 as reported by Sean Polzer,
00:29:41 that a think tank has come up with a figure of $3,300 a month.
00:29:48 Oh, it's a year, isn't it?
00:29:49 No, I thought it was a month.
00:29:50 I think it was a year.
00:29:51 Was it?
00:29:52 Oh, okay.
00:29:52 Yeah, you're right.
00:29:53 Yearly.
00:29:53 It's still a big buyout.
00:29:54 Yearly.
00:29:54 $3,300 a year by 2030.
00:29:56 Yeah, it was like $300 a month.
00:29:57 The price was $200.
00:29:59 Yeah.
00:29:59 So maybe we should let Sean in on. Why don't we pull him in there? Hey, Sean, how you doing?
00:30:07 Doing all right, guys. How are you? Good, good. So as Dave already sort of self-corrected,
00:30:12 but it was your story there. What do we got going on? It looks like an energy reality check
00:30:17 has kind of landed in Ontario. Well, it was the Canadians for affordable energy and
00:30:24 uh they put out a report and it's basically using the numbers from the independent electric system
00:30:30 operator in ontario we have one too it's which is called the alberta electric system operator
00:30:36 and uh just uh outlined some scenarios of uh what would happen if they had to uh stop using natural
00:30:44 gas which comes from alberta under the uh proposed uh so-called clean electricity uh regulations that
00:30:53 were tabled earlier in the Alberta problem. Alberta politicians have had such a problem.
00:30:59 So yeah, and Ontario only relies on about, unlike Alberta, they use natural gas to back up
00:31:09 basically their nukes and their wind. So it only supplies about 10% of their overall electricity
00:31:15 compared to more than 80% here in Alberta. And what they're saying is that they were forced to
00:31:20 retire these gas fired plants early it would result in about a three and a half percent reduction in
00:31:29 gdp 60 increase in power bills so that's where the 3300 bucks per household per year comes from
00:31:38 and possibly even tip the government into deficit after 2030 i noticed that i think they had about
00:31:46 a two billion dollar surplus this year and this would reduce government revenues anywhere like
00:31:53 four or five billion dollars a year after 2030. So outside of electrical generation does this
00:31:58 apply to household natural gas use as well for heating and cooking and whatnot because that would
00:32:04 impact your electric bill if you had to switch all that over as well did you take that into account
00:32:08 to? As far as I know, it was only with regards to operating the power grid. So whatever other
00:32:18 electrical appliances and things that are used in there, it didn't specifically reference getting
00:32:24 rid of natural gas stoves, for instance, like they're talking about doing in Quebec, I believe
00:32:28 is effective January 1st of this year. Okay, so I just think that's a great irony, guys,
00:32:33 because what you could do then is, well, I want to save money on my electricity, so I'm going to
00:32:37 take out my electric range and take out my electric heating system and bring in natural
00:32:41 gas because it'll be cheaper than my electric bill now that they've gotten rid of gas-fired
00:32:46 electricity. The shoe is about to drop, as Sean will tell you, in Alberta tomorrow. That $3,300
00:32:53 a year increase in Ontario, they only use 10% natural gas. In Alberta, it's 80%.
00:33:02 So can you imagine that figure that's going to come down tomorrow for Alberta?
00:33:05 Well, and the consequences, again, we start getting to the, where do we go with this?
00:33:12 This is due to a national policy and provinces responding to it, but then the electrical generation is provincial policy.
00:33:19 Do you think, Nigel, we might see Ontario finally becoming a bit more of a vocal ally with Alberta on this sort of issue?
00:33:25 You know?
00:33:26 It would be logical, wouldn't it?
00:33:28 Well, yeah, but I mean, I didn't actually expect the Ontario government to be taking a logical point.
00:33:35 a view on some other matters that related to the you know how children are instructed in schools
00:33:41 either but it seems that they actually do react to uh when they don't have an answer they react
00:33:48 to what the public is saying and here we are with a apparently a sound calculation that everybody's
00:33:55 going to be paying 290 a month for for power if they carry on with this that's got to uh that's
00:34:04 got to send people back to the drawing board i mean there's one thing for alberta to object to 1.00
00:34:08 what the federal government is trying to pull but when you've got ontario saying just a minute
00:34:14 maybe we should rethink this maybe we should put this off for a period of time
00:34:20 then that rather undercuts what we were saying just a few moments ago about the
00:34:25 prime minister being able to build a solid block against alberta and saskatchewan
00:34:31 These people are not going to want to pay another $290 a month for their electricity. Lord knows, we certainly don't. So I think we've got a common interest there.
00:34:41 Well, and again, I think it's part of the problem among many that the federal liberals just can't seem to understand and grasp. When they realize there's an affordability issue in Canada, they realize that they're losing in the polls because people can't afford their mortgages, their rent, their utilities, and their food.
00:34:58 but they can't bring themselves to relax their iron grip on their ideology that they have to
00:35:04 stop these sorts of generation. Like Dave, as you're saying, your bill is already, 0.96
00:35:11 and the rest of us in the hundreds of dollars a month, we can't afford it. Like ideology of
00:35:15 the common citizen goes out the window if you're worried about freezing to death or starving. I
00:35:19 mean, or at least, you know, losing weight and living colder. Yeah. And speaking of the liberals,
00:35:24 Sean just finished a story on Wilkinson, announced the sort of the route to oil and gas emissions,
00:35:31 and it didn't quite get up to Alberta's red line, but it looks like it's coming pretty close,
00:35:36 I think Sean can. Yeah, Sean, so I mean, we've been hearing that talk for quite a while too,
00:35:40 they keep nudging around the edges of it and everything, Gilboa's sort of hinting at it as
00:35:45 well, like are we seeing the beginnings of them coming up with a formal emissions cap soon?
00:35:50 Well, people always wanted to put in the emissions cap now for weeks and he's been
00:35:58 delayed and part of the reason is because Premier Smith essentially said that if they
00:36:03 come through with an emissions cap while they're doing this round table talks that they're
00:36:10 off.
00:36:11 It's Oprah though, it sounds to me she's pretty determined that if they do introduce
00:36:17 these caps that uh she'll walk away from these uh so-called consultations which include the 0.92
00:36:23 electricity regulations by the way that are supposed to be going on for the better part of
00:36:28 the year and uh minister zibola has said that he wants to unveil these caps by the time they head
00:36:36 off to the cop 28 summit in dubai in the beginning of december which uh premier smith has also said
00:36:45 that she will attend to uh unveil these um carbon capture incentives which are near and dear to her
00:36:52 heart so part of the package that uh wilkinson introduced today um made mention of carbon
00:36:58 capture but also said that the primary focus of government policy is going to be to remove those
00:37:06 emissions before they even hit the atmosphere which is code word for an emissions cap which
00:37:12 is actually spelled out in in this policy document that he supposedly went to paris to attend a
00:37:17 critical minerals conference but instead dropped a carbon management program you know in the shadow
00:37:23 of the eiffel tower but uh it says right in there uh emissions cap on oil and gas in brackets pending
00:37:32 so it's coming the question that i i'd love you to speculate sean why did the minister make that
00:37:40 announcement in paris if you're talking about policy that you're going to try and organize in
00:37:45 canada wouldn't wouldn't it have been a good thing to put that to the house of commons now
00:37:49 that it's sitting again or at least announce it at a trade or a trade show such as we've had here
00:37:55 in calgary recently why paris well that would have been a brilliant idea uh the reason that
00:38:01 they went to paris is because they're using the numbers in the iea uh road map to net zero that
00:38:07 that was released earlier this spring,
00:38:10 where they're talking about 25 million barrels a day
00:38:13 of oil demand and production by 2045 or whatever it is,
00:38:18 a number that the Saudis flat out said
00:38:21 at the World Petroleum Congress is fantasy.
00:38:24 Not only is it fantasy, it's dangerous.
00:38:27 So he went to Paris ostensibly to talk about critical minerals
00:38:32 and the irony is that about an hour after this,
00:38:36 rather lengthy policy document it's uh you know it's on the interweb so i don't know how many
00:38:41 pages it is but it's got to be about 30 or 40 pages uh you know they issued uh like maybe a
00:38:47 two-page briefing note that uh canada is going to have bilateral discussions with france on
00:38:54 critical mineral supply chains so why maybe they went maybe they went for the food guys you know
00:39:00 I heard that the food in France is pretty decent this time of year.
00:39:06 So it's right across the river from a 15th century wine seller.
00:39:10 Sean, didn't you find it ironic that Wilkinson in Paris making or dropping this announcement
00:39:17 when just across the channel, the Brits are announcing yet another multi-billion dollar
00:39:23 deal to go look for more oil?
00:39:26 Yeah, that's true.
00:39:27 um and i actually haven't got to writing that one up yet it was on my list this morning but
00:39:32 all these other things happen yeah 3.8 billion dollar development in the north sea um prime
00:39:38 minister sumak sunak uh so this one's going to be done from equinor which is norwegian
00:39:46 state oil companies so norway has become the largest supplier of both oil and gas to the eu
00:39:51 since the Russian invasion and they obviously have no intent on slowing down and it comes about
00:39:57 a week after the British Prime Minister announced a plan that they are stepping away from some of
00:40:03 their own net zero goals due to the affordability crisis that they're having in their own country
00:40:09 so it seems that the answer is not less oil and gas and fossil fuels but actually more in the interim
00:40:15 the world goes one way canada goes the other yeah well you know the issue with the speaker
00:40:22 and the the onion the unwanted guest is very easy to understand and it's very easy to say well look
00:40:29 it makes us look bad in the world the issues in india are actually relatively easy to understand
00:40:36 and you can see how it makes us look bad to the rest of the world but this stuff that sean is
00:40:41 talking about is so wrapped up in reports and files and research and organizations that meet
00:40:49 in hot places to talk about the global warming crisis and it isn't so easy to understand but
00:40:57 for my money this is actually one of the most serious issues that we have to face that this
00:41:04 This government apparently does not care that people will freeze to death in the dark if
00:41:13 their policies are fully consummated, because even if they can get electricity, they won't
00:41:19 be able to afford it.
00:41:21 This is like not having enough to eat kind of serious. 0.55
00:41:26 The liberals are dangerous.
00:41:28 Absolutely. 0.83
00:41:29 And it shows as well.
00:41:30 I mean, as you mentioned, it's that different world, though.
00:41:33 It is a different world. Those ones who attend those climate conferences, as Sean pointed out, these are IEA, that's International Energy Agency, I believe, targets, not domestic ones that we're binding ourselves to.
00:41:45 I mean, Trudeau has always wanted to be the star on the foreign stage, and he's done a terrible job of it, ironically, despite that being his priority.
00:41:53 But it sounds like, as we said, other countries like the UK, Norway, they're becoming pragmatic.
00:41:57 They're realizing, hey, we like this stuff, but we can't afford to do this.
00:42:01 we we've got to get back to these fossil fuels but canada is the laggard in this we just insist
00:42:06 on the self-flagellation over this and you know we're trying to do all this with electricity
00:42:11 where billions of people in africa would just like electricity yeah yeah some some great 900
00:42:18 million people do not have electricity yeah i think there's even more than that that's one of
00:42:23 those i find repugnant attitudes from a lot of these these developed world environmentalists
00:42:30 when we've got developing nations that really could use affordable energy to develop their
00:42:35 entire economy because it's so key to everything. And they'll say, here, have a windmill. Thank us
00:42:41 for it. No, no, we won't give you natural gas. No, we won't let you damn that river. We won't let
00:42:46 you have a nuclear facility. But here's some windmills and solar panels. And come on, guys,
00:42:51 you'll be all right, won't you? It's just a disconnect from reality. And it's like the
00:42:56 Liberals are trying to bring us down, bring Canada down to a third world level, because that's what 0.96
00:43:01 will happen, Nigel, when people can't afford the electricity and whatnot. Do you think we have a
00:43:06 problem with 10 cities now? You wait for five years if all this stuff goes through. Third world, we've
00:43:12 already got the colored money. Yes, indeed. There's a lot of irony. I mean, so you briefly mentioned
00:43:18 carbon capture as well, Sean. So, I mean, a part of it just seems that we never get credit for the
00:43:23 effort we've done in our industries on that sort of thing like that's being ignored the progress
00:43:28 that's been made so far it's not considered if we could bring carbon capture to a certain level
00:43:33 that our energy generation would be sustainable well there was a considerable portion of the
00:43:39 document like I said was devoted to carbon capture Canada has the most functioning carbon capturing
00:43:47 facilities uh in the world we've got uh you know the quest up near edmonton there's boundary dam
00:43:53 in saskatchewan uh there was that direct air capture in squamish that just got sold to
00:43:59 occidental for a billion dollars ironically to produce more oil is what they're going to use it 1.00
00:44:04 for but um you know and there there was a note in there you know saline aquifers in western canada
00:44:11 basin so these are associated with oil production you know the conventional oil production that we've
00:44:17 we've had around here for the last 75 years have enough geological storage space to store
00:44:23 I think it was 800 years worth of Canada's emissions up current rates and it and it could
00:44:28 be even higher it could be you know a thousand years but then the policy of the government
00:44:33 is not necessarily to abate the so there's a recognition that these technologies will
00:44:39 be needed to meet the net zero because there's going to be some residual emissions from other
00:44:44 industries like cement for instance like more cement is used in the world than water it is the
00:44:49 absolute most uh used commodity on earth but that the policy of the government is going to be to
00:44:58 basically reduce those emissions before they even get there you know so uh they're they're talking
00:45:04 like uh carbon capture is only going to be about five percent of uh this solution that they have
00:45:09 in mind towards net zero so well keep watching and seeing what they come up with uh thanks for
00:45:16 it is a bit of a head scratcher app today thanks for uh watching and reporting on it while the 0.87
00:45:21 rest of us are distracted with the parliamentary naval gazing and idiocy that they've got going on
00:45:27 the other front because it's easy to forget that the the rest of the world and the policies are 0.79
00:45:31 still happening right now and it's all being overshadowed by just unimaginable uh events
00:45:39 All right. Well, thanks, Sean. Just one quick, I guess, to wrap it up, too. We didn't mention one of the first actions the Liberals did when Parliament first sat was to try and get unanimous consent to have this whole affair stricken from Hansard and from video records. So as if it never happened. That was their first instinct was to cover up rather than apologize or figure out what happened when it went wrong or anything. But let's just get it out of the way.
00:46:05 Yeah, you know, every now and then I get a letter from somebody who darkly suggests that everything that's being done is about control and suppression of thought and this kind of thing.
00:46:18 Yeah, well, you know, we do get those letters and there's something there, but I don't know whether it's what they say is there.
00:46:26 But boy, oh boy, if you wanted to make the case, the actual elimination, like photoshopping people out of the picture, as it were, if I can use that as a metaphor.
00:46:35 just pretend this didn't happen
00:46:36 that actually supports a rather nasty
00:46:39 it feeds it
00:46:40 it feeds it
00:46:41 you know
00:46:43 we don't do ourselves any favors in this country
00:46:46 it seems
00:46:47 alright well I think we've solved a few of the world's
00:46:50 problems hopefully they were all listening
00:46:52 we know our Indian audience is always one of two
00:46:54 so I thank you
00:46:56 very much Dave and Nigel
00:46:58 and Nico for keeping everything running
00:47:01 and Sean who's on his way out
00:47:02 and of course all of you guys for viewing
00:47:04 And make sure, hey, if you haven't got a subscription yet, westernstandard.news slash membership, take one out.
00:47:09 This is how we can keep bringing this stuff to you guys.
00:47:12 So thank you all for tuning in today.
00:47:14 Try to stay warm.
00:47:15 Put in a wood stove.
00:47:15 It's going to get expensive.
00:47:17 And we'll see you all again next week at this time.
00:47:20 Here's an update on commodity prices in Leppard for today.
00:47:23 Cash barter remains at $335.
00:47:25 Feed wheat is steady at $350.
00:47:27 While October corn is unchanged at $350.
00:47:30 And November-December corn is trading at $318.
00:47:31 In the milling wheat markets, December Minneapolis futures dropped $0.135 to $7.53 per bushel, with local hardwood spring bid for October movement at $9.40 per bushel.
00:47:43 Looking at canola, November futures added $11.90 at $7.2610 per ton, with delivered buys for October movement at $16.12 per bushel.
00:47:53 In the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices are holding at $0.365 per pound, and yellow peas are higher $0.25 at $10.75 a bushel.
00:48:01 In the cattle markets, October Live cattle are higher 45 cents at $185.25 per 100 weight.
00:48:08 For more information on pricing or picked up options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:48:15 I'm Matt Buscombe at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:48:21 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:48:28 these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and
00:48:34 legislation in canada and more importantly educating the public about how we keep guns
00:48:39 out of the hands of the wrong people to become a member it's absolutely worth every penny
00:48:46 you can become a western standard member for just ten dollars a month or 99