Western Standard - December 23, 2022


The Pipeline - The Top Stories from 2022

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Dec 22, 2022 Ottawa Exposed: Trudeau's worst moments of 2022 and how Poilevre can win in 2023

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

181.49

Word count

9,311

Sentence count

526

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Columnist Corey Morgan discuss the biggest news stories of the year, including the Freedom Convoy, the fall of Jason Kenney, the return of Danielle Smith, and the great gun grab of this year.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:22 Today is December 20, 21st 2022. Our last episode of the pipeline for the year. So thank you all
00:00:31 very much for joining us. As usual, I've got with us Western Standard opinion editor,
00:00:37 Nigel Hannaford. All ready for Christmas, Nigel? You bet. Shortest day of the year too.
00:00:41 Just gets better from here. Yeah, 21st. Oh, it's all better from here. Perfect.
00:00:47 Also gone with us, everyone's second favorite, Western Standard Senior Columnist and host of Untied with Corey Morgan.
00:00:55 Corey Morgan, I love a number two.
00:00:58 Always thrilled to be here, even if I'm a number two.
00:01:02 Remember, you're demoted.
00:01:05 I'm going to call you number two like a Picard except.
00:01:08 It's better than the number two reference in South Park I thought you were going for.
00:01:10 No, no, no, I was going for the old naval term, second officer.
00:01:14 Number two. Or Dr. Evil. Number two. Yeah. Okay. For those of you who got it. It was mildly amusing.
00:01:23 Okay. Today is going to be a bit of a change. We're going to be talking about the top stories of 2022, or the biggest stories.
00:01:32 A mixture of the two. Some of the ones that were the biggest and most important, which are obvious, like the Freedom Convoy,
00:01:39 and others that maybe didn't get as much media attention as they should have,
00:01:43 but were very significant and important for 2022,
00:01:46 like a huge new federal regulation over the media and the internet in Canada
00:01:51 that just really didn't get the attention they should have.
00:01:53 But we'll be talking about things like the fall of Jason Kenney,
00:01:56 the comeback of Danielle Smith, the great gun grab of this year,
00:02:00 and, of course, new federal controls over the media and internet in Canada.
00:02:03 Before we get going, though, Corey's going to tell you all about my favorite sponsor,
00:02:07 the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:02:08 Ah, yes. Well, the name says it all. They're an association for people who enjoy shooting sports, whether you're a hunter, target shooter, or gun collector. It doesn't matter. It's nobody's business what you do with them anyways if you're law-abiding. But you need an association to stand up for your rights, plus to share resources. They've got stuff like links to sporting events and upcoming gun shows. And most importantly of all, they're standing up for your right to own, possess, transfer firearms.
00:02:32 So if you own firearms, you are doing yourself a disservice if you are not a member of the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:02:38 Their website is cssa-cila.org, or just Google them out, Canadian Shooting Sports Association, easiest way.
00:02:46 Beauty. All right, thanks a lot, Corey.
00:02:48 Also, you've got to get your Western Standard membership if you don't have it yet.
00:02:51 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, shame on you.
00:02:54 In fact, you can actually now buy the Western Standard as a gift. 0.99
00:02:58 You got your dipshit niece, nephew, son, daughter going to university, getting all sorts of silly ideas about Marxism and being woke in their heads. 0.99
00:03:08 Maybe expose them to some hard news and straight opinion. 0.99
00:03:12 Get your kid, get your nephew, anyone who really needs a slap upside the head, a Western Standards membership for one year.
00:03:19 You get it at westernstandard.news, and I believe, just click on membership and you'll find an option in there.
00:03:25 All right, so we're going to start off with what was probably the biggest story of the year, quite possibly the most important story of the year, and frankly, the first really big news story of the year.
00:03:38 So we're just going to have to start with it, the Freedom Convoy.
00:03:43 You know, we all know where this came from.
00:03:45 We had on and off again lockdowns in every province in the country.
00:03:49 We had vaccine mandates discriminating against people in ways none of us had seen in our lifetimes.
00:03:56 And then I guess the spark that really set it off was make the federal government making it illegal for Canadian truckers to reasonably reenter Canada when doing long hauls to the states and back.
00:04:11 essentially putting a lot of these truckers out of work because they were so dangerously spreading COVID driving around trucks by themselves for weeks on end. And that that finally set it off and it came as one would hope from Alberta. This was this was an Alberta grown movement comes out of here, goes to Ottawa and and the rest is history. Nigel, why do you think what was the big impact?
00:04:41 of this? Why do you think this deserves to be one of the biggest stories of 2022?
00:04:46 First, it is the big story because it tied up the downtown of the Capitol for several weeks.
00:04:54 That in itself makes it the big story. The other part of it though, is that it was a genuine,
00:05:00 decent, relatively well organized and peaceful demonstration where citizens came together to
00:05:08 tell the government what was on their minds that the government was wrong and then first the
00:05:15 government wouldn't meet them to be more specific the prime minister would not receive any
00:05:21 communications from them have them over to the have the representatives over there to
00:05:27 to the good lord they were parked right outside the laundry block i think they heard far to walk
00:05:31 i think they heard them and uh you know he wouldn't talk to them and then they brought in
00:05:36 And then, as it is pretty clear from the inquiry,
00:05:40 they brought in the Emergencies Act, which, of course,
00:05:42 is the old War Measures Act by another name.
00:05:45 And so it was a massive government overreach that sparked it
00:05:51 in the first place, and a tone-deaf government wouldn't hear
00:05:55 them when they got there, and finally,
00:05:57 a massive government overreaction that brought it to a close.
00:06:02 Of course, it's the top story.
00:06:04 and you know this has been brewing for a long time we've had we've had mr trudeau in office
00:06:12 now since 2015 and although he puts a sunny face on it you keep seeing legislation walking along
00:06:22 that is intended to limit people in so many ways i know we're going to get to some of those other
00:06:27 ways later but you know there has been a feeling brewing in this country and you could really
00:06:33 feel it here in Alberta. I'm saying, okay, it's time to take a stand, it's time to fight back,
00:06:40 it's time to say no to all this. I think that was the feeling that put Pierre Polyave into the OLO.
00:06:46 So that's where I want to pick up a curry here. Okay.
00:06:49 Let's talk about the political fallout of this. The most tangible political fallout was the end
00:06:55 of Aaron O'Toole as leader of the Conservative Party of Canada. That was a very direct result.
00:07:00 He equivocated, opposed it, mildly supported it.
00:07:05 Most people don't know this, but there's a lot of background stuff where he was going to try and use this to oust Polyev from the conservatives.
00:07:12 That backfired on him.
00:07:14 O'Toole's gone.
00:07:15 And then you get Polyev as leader.
00:07:18 I think that's a pretty direct result that came from it.
00:07:21 More indirectly, but I still think related was I think it at least contributed to the end of Jason Kenney.
00:07:25 because it really just, it mobilized the anti-lockdown, anti-mandate, kind of pro-freedom movement to a whole new level.
00:07:33 And it elevated it to the center stage.
00:07:36 And you had Kenny kind of equivocating again.
00:07:39 You saw him kind of in a panic trying to get rid of some of the mandates he had so he didn't look like Trudeau.
00:07:45 But, you know, at the Coutts blockade and in Ottawa, people were coming at Kenny just as hard as they were coming at Trudeau.
00:07:52 So I think a bit more indirectly, but still related.
00:07:55 This probably also helped to take down Kenny and eventually, again, leads to Smith.
00:08:02 How fair do you think, the O'Toole one is obviously fair, 1.00
00:08:05 but how fair do you think it is kind of linking the Kenny and Smith part in,
00:08:08 and what do you think were the other big political ramifications that came from the Freedom Convoy?
00:08:13 Yeah, well, I mean, with Kenny, I think maybe it might have been the final thing,
00:08:16 but this was kind of already happening.
00:08:18 I mean, he just he tried to play both sides of the fence with the COVID restrictions and he burned and he just basically infuriated both sides.
00:08:26 He had no base of support left anymore when the time came.
00:08:29 And when things were brought to such a head, it was it certainly fed the finale.
00:08:35 I mean, it fed people in realizing they can oppose something.
00:08:38 I think a large part of what this story was, was a segment of people shed off the Canadian attitude of, well, I'm pretty upset with that, but I'll just let it go and shrug.
00:08:47 No, they got up and they did something and they pushed back and they sent the government into panic.
00:08:53 They were powerful, whether you agree with the convoy or not.
00:08:56 They made an impression and it changed the political atmosphere.
00:09:01 And the long run still has to be measured out in that.
00:09:04 I think that Daniel Smith and Pierre Polyev both rode into their leaderships by playing to that segment of the base to win that.
00:09:11 But that segment also is a minority within the electorate at large.
00:09:15 So they've got to watch that they don't corner themselves too far into that.
00:09:19 But the convoy changed the face of politics in Canada without doubt.
00:09:22 I mean, the Sovereignty Act, the Saskatchewan First Act, again, we're both responses to a federal government that's viewed as overreaching and getting too much into our face.
00:09:30 I don't think we would have seen those kind of acts three years ago, no matter who the premiers were.
00:09:35 So it's had an impact and we're still seeing what's going to come from this.
00:09:38 You know, Corey, you can just see the strength of feeling that was behind there when the truckers said, yes, by all means, send us money.
00:09:46 They raised more money in a week than the Liberal Party raised in three months.
00:09:50 I already read my column. I got the numbers down.
00:09:54 You left it on the screen.
00:09:55 You know, we should we should we should freeze the bank accounts of anyone who's ever donated to the Liberal Party.
00:10:01 Far more dangerous to Canada than a couple of truckers.
00:10:03 Okay, well, segues in nicely. The I think one of the definitely in Alberta, and it was a national story was the fall of Jason Kenney. A year ago, today, very few people I think would have predicted that Jason Kenney wouldn't even make it to the end of his first term.
00:10:24 You know, when he was driving around Alberta in the blue truck, trying to drum together the UCP and then his leadership race, he always would say about Rachel Notley, one and done.
00:10:34 We're going to make the NDP the first one-term government in Alberta history.
00:10:38 Well, Jason Kenney was also one and done.
00:10:41 In fact, Rachel Notley lasted almost a year longer than Jason Kenney did.
00:10:47 He's gone.
00:10:48 A lot of the country has a hard time wrapping their minds around it.
00:10:51 There's a lot of conservatives elsewhere. They remember the older Jason Kennedy, the one that was elected UCP leader, the cerebral smart guy, staunch conservative.
00:11:01 They didn't really see the Kenny that Albertan saw over the last two and three years that, you know, was locking down, was kind of dealing with Ottawa very technically.
00:11:10 Lots of furrowed brows and news releases, but not actually doing very much.
00:11:17 We'll kind of kick off with you, Corey.
00:11:19 What were the big reasons you think that fueled the fall of Jason Kenney that few outside of probably the Western Standard offices here would have predicted was even in the cards a year ago?
00:11:34 Well, I guess maybe two years ago wouldn't have been in the cards.
00:11:39 You could kind of see it coming a year ago now.
00:11:41 Most of the media a year ago, I don't think we're taking it.
00:11:44 Watch it.
00:11:44 A year ago, they were starting to recognize that at least a few people were upset.
00:11:48 starting to bubble up. I don't think anyone would have predicted he'd be gone. No, no, I think people
00:11:52 would have thought he'd weather this storm there. The discontent within the party was definitely
00:11:56 just too much for him to manage to turn around. I think that the slow burning part that was,
00:12:03 as you put it, his tepid approach with Ottawa. I mean, he talked very big getting in to voters in
00:12:08 Alberta and to his members on, we're going to do the fair deal panel. We're going to bring a pension
00:12:11 plan. We're going to bring Alberta police force. We're going to do all of these measures. And he
00:12:16 hadn't done a single thing and barely started the process towards
00:12:18 it after two and a half years, three years in office, people
00:12:20 when are you going to get on with this because Trudeau is
00:12:22 getting ever more intrusive with us and Jason Kenney still
00:12:27 spinning his wheel. So that frustrated a lot of people. And
00:12:30 again, the burning on the pandemic, I mean, he brought in
00:12:34 the restrictions, but he would talk out of both sides of his
00:12:36 mouths, you keep promising, I'm not going to do we will never
00:12:38 have a vaccine passport. That's a direct quote. And he brought 0.72
00:12:42 in a vaccine passport. About a week after he said, we're
00:12:44 going to have the best summer ever. We're never locking down again. He locked down again. He just
00:12:49 expended his political capital on when he would take firm stands. They were stands he had to back
00:12:55 off on or felt he had to back off on in short order. He just lost the trust and support of
00:13:02 people on all sides of the issue. Nigel, I want to talk about the media on this because I it's one
00:13:07 of the biggest stories of 2022, but I think it wasn't until February that the media realized
00:13:17 that he was in trouble. Jason Kenney didn't seem to realize he was in trouble until they were a
00:13:21 couple days out from what was supposed to be the big in-person vote in Red Deer, and they realized
00:13:25 people registered to vote were three to one against him, and that's when they changed the
00:13:30 rules to try and even the playing field a bit. But it wasn't until I think early February,
00:13:38 maybe January that the media said, the media kind of collectively said, okay, it seems his
00:13:45 leadership is in trouble. But here we had been, we had seen this for a long, long time coming.
00:13:54 Why do you think the kind of the big legacy media just totally missed the boat on this story until it was, like, happening?
00:14:03 Because the signs were all there.
00:14:05 Well, there are quite a few reasons why that could be so.
00:14:09 One of them is that the legacy media gets its idea, gets a narrative in its head.
00:14:16 Not just about this, but about anything.
00:14:18 and it makes it once once the idea is firmly there it takes quite a lot to dislodge that idea
00:14:25 so all right the narrative was that uh premier kenny had been a very successful federal cabinet
00:14:31 minister he'd come back to alberta he bought the blue truck he'd driven all over the problems he'd
00:14:36 organized the party put the two together now we have the united conservative party and he'd gone
00:14:41 out in one very very convincing electoral victory over over um rachel notley what sort of trouble
00:14:49 could he possibly be in and it wasn't until you kept getting these stories about uh nomination
00:14:56 meetings that where a kenny candidate had been not only chosen but others have been disqualified
00:15:04 disqualified for one reason or another and often the reasons weren't particularly good now the
00:15:09 first time you first time a reporter gets a story like that well it's an outlier when you get enough
00:15:15 of them they start to think oh what is going on there so it took a while to change the narrative
00:15:21 that's that i think is the first one the other thing and this sort of leads directly back to the
00:15:28 government's response to covet is that somewhere along the line the media forgot that their job
00:15:35 was to question and to challenge what the government was saying not to necessarily come
00:15:41 out in gross opposition to it but say if you're doing this why are you doing that they forgot that
00:15:47 and instead they lined up got the press release if it comes from the government if it comes from
00:15:52 alberta health then this must be the right thing to do we're doing a public service by making sure
00:15:57 you have accurate information except half the time it wasn't accurate information it was the
00:16:02 the very opposite. It was deceptive, and I would go so far as to say manipulative, but anyway,
00:16:07 that's a different argument. So it wasn't a long stretch from not getting the narrative about
00:16:17 Kenny, but then seeing him as the official spokesman for the authorized point of view.
00:16:25 And so he doesn't think the media gave him a break, but in a lot of ways they did.
00:16:34 I think the biggest one has still been missed here.
00:16:37 I think it's that most people who work in journalism simply didn't know who any of these people were who were so angry.
00:16:44 Those people, they tend to live not where journalists live.
00:16:47 journalists tend to live in the downtown major urban centers of the country, mostly in the Ottawa,
00:16:53 Montreal, Toronto, triangle, but, you know, even media here, they live in downtown Calgary,
00:16:59 downtown Edmonton. These people came from rural or they came from suburbs, not all but
00:17:05 disproportionately. And they had very different worldviews, different political views. And,
00:17:12 you know, just as we might say, well, I can't, it's impossible that the NDP could ever win
00:17:16 in Alberta because I don't know anyone who votes any people maybe because we don't roll in those
00:17:19 circles because we have our bubbles and the media live in their own social bubbles they just simply
00:17:24 didn't know these people the media people who work in the media for the most part didn't know anyone
00:17:30 who was really angry about mandatory vaccination mandatory masking lockdowns and and so this
00:17:36 their worldview was unable to to touch it that these people don't really exist they are a small
00:17:41 fringe minority you know you're on to something there derek and it reminds me if i can tell you
00:17:46 a 20 second little little anecdote to that point it was 2006 stephen harper's election victory had
00:17:53 just been announced and there were some of us in the editorial board who were still there waiting
00:17:59 to comment on this you're talking about the calgary yeah this is the calgary herald in 2006
00:18:03 and somebody from the newsroom comes down this is not a not a result they were expecting now they've
00:18:09 got to get comments from conservatives and i won't name this individual because he's still active in
00:18:14 the in the business but he said any of you guys listen we need some contacts anybody we need a
00:18:20 conservative you know all they knew were liberals so there is a certain amount of what you're saying
00:18:26 there that they probably didn't know who to ask or who to go and see they didn't know about corey
00:18:32 Yeah. Yeah, I think it's kind of a, it's the symptom of just a broader issue that helps. It's not always that the media have an agenda. It's just, they just might not know people outside of these circles who don't live where they do and think like they do.
00:18:51 That's right. Biggest source of media bias is just, I don't see the point of this, and choosing to report something else when actually it's quite an important story.
00:18:59 Well, our tangents are working great today, because I think this rolls over nicely into the comeback of Danielle Smith.
00:19:07 I don't think a lot of people a year ago would have said, I think Danielle Smith is going to be premier.
00:19:13 Now, I remember it was just over a year ago, November 2021, me and Corey, before you joined us,
00:19:21 we were at the UCP convention at the Gray Eagle Casino just outside Calgary here at the Suitsino Reserve.
00:19:26 and uh danielle smith was she was doing some freelance work with us and so she was on the show
00:19:32 and uh jason kenny's behind her on the stage and she just kind of says uh you know if jason kenny
00:19:39 wasn't the leader anymore i'd run to replace him and we all just kind of fell out of our chairs
00:19:43 danielle smith announced on the western standard in the same room with jason kenny that she wanted 0.58
00:19:49 his job i hope we've got a clip of that oh we do you know what we should make a note of that because
00:19:53 that's a highlight. That was a real highlight. That was the first solid hint that, holy crap,
00:19:59 she's making another go of it. But most, well, it wasn't a hint. She said she would if he's gone. 0.95
00:20:05 It was a pretty frontal shot. But still, at that time, it was like, eh, could she really win?
00:20:12 Because she had just so much baggage from kind of the disastrous end of her time as Wild Rose
00:20:19 leader. She had a tremendous start to it, but then totally melted down the most spectacular fashion 1.00
00:20:23 in December of 2014. Oh, geez, actually, we're on the anniversary date. I think it was the 21st.
00:20:31 I'll never forget. It was like Pearl Harbor for me when that went down. But again, I don't think,
00:20:38 I was skeptical at first that she could do it, but I thought she had a real chance. Most of the
00:20:43 legacy media think didn't really give her chance though it's they had just seen Kenny defeated by
00:20:50 what they saw is a redneck rabble but of course it's going to be Kenny's chosen success or or 1.00
00:20:55 if not hit Travis Taves it was going to be Brian G because he's the big name
00:21:01 Daniel Smith was just too radical too out there and but then she just dominated um
00:21:06 We'll start with you, Nigel. Why do you think the comeback of Danielle Smith deserves to be one of the big stories of the year? And why would it be different than most ordinary leadership campaigns to stand out this way?
00:21:22 You know, because BC had a leadership campaign.
00:21:25 Sorry, I just asked you a question, then go right back to myself.
00:21:27 I threw it back to myself.
00:21:29 I didn't mean to do that.
00:21:30 But BC had a leadership race to replace an incumbent premier, John Horgan.
00:21:36 I can't even remember the new guy's name.
00:21:37 Davey.
00:21:38 Davey.
00:21:39 Mm-hmm.
00:21:40 Davey.
00:21:40 We can make one name.
00:21:45 Almost no press.
00:21:46 Like, it was just quiet and was boring.
00:21:48 And then in Alberta, it was just this raucous Royal Rumble affair from start to finish, wall-to-wall coverage.
00:21:56 The country was talking about it, and we're a smaller province than B.C.
00:21:59 So why do you think that this story should be in the top stories of 2022 and not Dave Eby or whoever his name is in B.C.?
00:22:10 So you're talking about the October Revolution here.
00:22:12 The October Revolution.
00:22:13 Okay.
00:22:14 In 1916, they didn't see that coming the next year either.
00:22:17 1917. Well, 1917 was the revolution, but before it happened, they didn't see it coming. And just the same, a lot of people last year didn't see this coming.
00:22:26 But like 1917, everyone should have seen it coming in 16.
00:22:30 It's hindsight, eh? 2020. Well, I think there's a number of reasons why that, again, there's a number of reasons why this one dominated.
00:22:39 for the first thing in the bc if you want to compare it to the bc leadership succession
00:22:44 uh i mean mr horgan was diagnosed with cancer otherwise he'd still be there yeah so you know
00:22:52 it was very sad it wasn't the worst ndp premier that you could possibly imagine and i think a lot
00:22:58 of people felt genuinely sorry about it when he announced his intention to uh to retire but you
00:23:03 know it had to be done and somebody had to take the job and they went through the motions there
00:23:08 There was no palace coup to take them down.
00:23:10 No, there was no, you know, nothing personal about anybody.
00:23:14 It was just business.
00:23:15 So that explains a relatively low key of the B.C. leadership race, whereas, of course, I mean, just a few moments ago, you outlined the different factions that were operating within Alberta.
00:23:32 You know, that mad as hell not going to take it anymore crowd out in the country.
00:23:37 who we love, by the way.
00:23:38 When I say they're a crowd, I'm not saying that they're rabble.
00:23:41 We mean them the best possible.
00:23:43 Absolutely.
00:23:44 These people have got the right idea.
00:23:47 So, but on the other hand, there were people who would lead the mainstream media,
00:23:52 get the information from Alberta Health Services,
00:23:55 instinctively trusted that source, even when they didn't understand.
00:24:00 They said, well, it must be right because it comes from Alberta Health Services,
00:24:03 very compliant. And you know the biggest thing about Danielle Smith? This is why she attracts 0.96
00:24:13 the bad press that she gets. She actually wants to change something. She has ideas. 0.97
00:24:22 And she's already put into the practice a rather large number of them. But the thing is,
00:24:28 people say they want change, but they actually don't. They just want a change of caretaker.
00:24:33 And this would have been, if Travis Taves had won the leadership,
00:24:40 well, things would probably just go on the way they've been going on.
00:24:44 No disrespects to Mr. Taves, he's an actual finance minister,
00:24:47 but he wasn't out to change the world.
00:24:50 Daniel Smith is out to change Alberta, but anyway.
00:24:53 And much of the opposition he runs into is that people either don't understand
00:25:00 what it is that she's trying to do, or alternatively would react badly to any kind of change.
00:25:08 So that makes this whole process extremely, is vitally important for Alberta. It's also
00:25:16 fascinating to watch as a political story unfolding. I did not ever think that we would
00:25:21 see, for example, an Alberta Sovereignty Act. I didn't think we would see a provincial government
00:25:25 and say, you know what, we're not going to collect firearms
00:25:29 just because Mr. Trudeau says so.
00:25:33 Now we've got Saskatchewan doing the same thing. 0.95
00:25:36 So many things that are just complete disconnects
00:25:40 from anything that's gone before.
00:25:42 So we'll see what kind of appetite Alberta has 1.00
00:25:45 to get behind the strong leader.
00:25:48 Gary, actually I should not be phrasing it as,
00:25:51 why do you think it's the biggest story of the year?
00:25:54 You weren't in the room because you were doing something else.
00:25:57 But why do you think this is one of the biggest stories of the year?
00:26:00 If not, or you could say, well, you don't think it should be.
00:26:02 That's fine.
00:26:04 And when do you think the media realized this was a big deal with her, that she can win? 0.50
00:26:10 She dominated most of the race. 0.98
00:26:12 She came to dominate fairly early, but, you know, when she launched, I don't think it was taken that seriously.
00:26:18 It was definitely not taken very seriously when, you know, she was on a Western Standard program November last year at the UCP convention.
00:26:25 It says, Kenny's gone. I think I'm going to run.
00:26:29 People chuckled at it, but I don't think most people took it that seriously.
00:26:32 So, you know, why do you think this is one of the biggest stories of the year, if you do think it is?
00:26:38 And when do you think the media started to realize she could actually do this?
00:26:43 She might win.
00:26:44 Yeah, well, and it is the biggest story of the year
00:26:46 because basically a lot of people just didn't see it coming.
00:26:50 She said that Phoenix rose from the ashes.
00:26:52 Last November, I was among those who laughed it off.
00:26:55 Okay, I mean, I still respect Danielle and, you know, a powerful person,
00:26:58 but to be able to take the leadership and become the premier of this province
00:27:01 after your history, I mean, I've gotten over it, but I just can't see it.
00:27:04 I would never have believed it at that point.
00:27:06 By the time the leadership campaign was going full bore,
00:27:08 I was along the lines of she's going to win this thing.
00:27:11 I mean, just remember from our bets from it,
00:27:13 But it took till then before I could see it.
00:27:15 So the media was just as gobsmacked.
00:27:17 I mean, they had dismissed her initially.
00:27:19 And again, kind of just to reiterate what Nigel has been saying, she represents change.
00:27:24 And it's not just here.
00:27:25 Other premiers are watching her.
00:27:27 And that's what's really got the establishment afraid.
00:27:30 I mean, you notice it's not just the domestic legacy media local that's been lined up against her.
00:27:35 When have we ever seen a premier so consistently attacked from central Canadian press?
00:27:41 I mean, their focus is on this little province of Alberta, almost four times as much as you would
00:27:46 see, their focus on Ontario with Doug Ford, which is their own turf. Because if she succeeds in
00:27:51 these changes, she's going to inspire others. And Mo is definitely already following along those
00:27:59 lines. Even Manitoba has been showing things. And it undercuts the establishment in general.
00:28:04 People who are afraid of change realize she will bring it. She's actually,
00:28:08 She's quite different from Kenny, who talked big and did little.
00:28:12 Smith is going to follow through what she says she's doing, for better or for worse.
00:28:16 And that's really got some people terrified.
00:28:18 And it's really got me excited.
00:28:19 So I think it's a great, yeah, it's a top story,
00:28:21 because we haven't seen a revolutionary-type premier like that in a long, long time.
00:28:26 But you'll notice what they're doing.
00:28:27 They're treating it as a process story.
00:28:30 In eastern Canada, there's not a lot of analysis of what this really represents, 0.94
00:28:34 the Sovereignty Act, other than, oh, well, it must be rubbish, 0.88
00:28:37 because it comes from Alberta. 0.76
00:28:39 But the personalities involved, that's what media likes.
00:28:43 Always has, like, look for the fight between people.
00:28:46 That's part of why it's getting so much attention back there
00:28:50 and being treated the way that it is.
00:28:53 Maybe it makes for good copy.
00:28:55 Well, it makes good copy.
00:28:56 I don't think I'm speaking out of turn,
00:28:57 but, you know, when we were over at the Premier Southern office,
00:29:02 just around the corner from our office here last Friday for the year-end interview,
00:29:06 She said before the interview started, and I think this is probably not out of turn to repeat.
00:29:14 You know, she was talking about incrementalism versus big, bold change.
00:29:19 And she says, I'm along the lines of, I don't want to be an incrementalist of managing Rachel Notley's socialism.
00:29:26 I want to destroy Rachel Notley's socialism and then incrementally bring in conservative policy.
00:29:33 And to get it back to where it should be and then run that.
00:29:36 get us back to kind of a get to a year zero of some kind here get to get to a point and then
00:29:42 make some incremental changes but that we've got to have a much more revolutionary wiping of the
00:29:47 slate of uh and i think she would probably mean more than just not like we're going back through
00:29:52 pretty badly managed years of jim prentice allison redford ed stomach and unfortunately probably the
00:29:58 last term of ralph klein you know the guy quit drinking and just went to hell so like we we've 0.75
00:30:04 had a combination of bad or mediocre government for a long time in this province. And she does
00:30:11 not appear to be said to be an incrementalist premier. And it's a roll of the dice. But I think
00:30:16 it's fair to say she will be at the very least, I think she's probably more revolutionary than
00:30:20 Klein was. I think you're right there. I mean, one of the reasons why we had such a lot of bad
00:30:26 government for so long is that we had such a lot of money. And it was always easier to just buy
00:30:31 off the problem you know give this group more money give that group more money when the when the
00:30:37 negotiations came up and so we ended up with a very high cost government and then of course when
00:30:42 the money stopped all these problems suddenly became very sharpie and focused and you find
00:30:49 can't afford socialism which is how we ended up with what is it 100 billion dollars in debt
00:30:53 But when she says things like, I want to build up the heritage fund, I believe her.
00:31:02 That is the kind of conservative policy that she would do. 0.92
00:31:06 But let's remember, every single premier since, what was this, Nuts, after Lougheed?
00:31:12 Getty.
00:31:13 Getty.
00:31:14 Everyone since Getty has said that and hasn't really, now, Klein did put away savings.
00:31:19 It wasn't into the heritage fund, but it was into other savings pots.
00:31:22 I think it was called the Rainy Day Fund.
00:31:26 Or certainly it was referred to as that.
00:31:28 It was referred to as the Rainy Day Fund.
00:31:30 So Klein did save, but everyone's talked about saving, and it hasn't really happened.
00:31:36 I'll believe it when I see it, but I think she's genuine in her desire to do it,
00:31:40 but actually doing it's going to be a lot tougher.
00:31:42 You know what I reckon that she may do on the Heritage Fund?
00:31:45 Instead of withdrawing the interest on it every year to pay for ongoing programs,
00:31:49 she'll start letting some of that build up. 0.99
00:31:51 At least not withdraw the interest.
00:31:55 That's what's been going on ever since the Heritage Fund was established.
00:31:58 Yeah.
00:31:59 Okay, well, God, our segues are perfect because we were talking about, you know,
00:32:03 Smith saying she's not going to comply, you know,
00:32:06 force the Alberta government, police and prosecutors to comply with federal gun grabs.
00:32:11 Well, we're going to talk now about the great gun grab of 2022.
00:32:15 It's maybe a bit of a misnomer because it's been happening for a long time,
00:32:18 But I think it's fair to say 2022, the gun grab coming from Ottawa reached a whole new level.
00:32:26 We had in the spring, the federal government announced that they will ban the sale, gifting, and transfer of handguns in Canada.
00:32:36 And they thought that, well, that means everyone's going to stop buying guns right now because they know that we're going to be banning it and they're going to be worthless.
00:32:43 Much to the shock and horror of Ottawa and the Toronto Star, handgun sales went absolutely freaking crazy.
00:32:56 Remember we announced it? I told everyone at the Western Standard, everyone's like, oh my god, we got to get our handguns.
00:33:01 So I said, the Western Standard will loan any employee up to $500 to buy handguns.
00:33:06 We called it the Western Standard, I think we called it something along the lines of the Western Standard Employee Armament Loan Program.
00:33:12 And I guess this got out the Toronto Star saw it. They ran a big story saying, my God, look at these absolute nuts out west. They haven't got the message. You're not supposed to have handguns anymore.
00:33:24 And then we had wholesalers contact us and say, we're going to sell any Western and standard employee handguns at wholesale prices.
00:33:36 And so I, it was a great deal.
00:33:39 It was great.
00:33:41 It was great.
00:33:41 I kind of liked it because I had all the excuse I needed at home to go out gun shopping.
00:33:46 Sorry, honey, we have to buy it now.
00:33:47 We'd be crazy not to.
00:33:48 I'll literally, it will be illegal very soon from now.
00:33:51 So handgun sales went through the frigging roof.
00:33:53 record handgun sales this summer. Eventually, then the federal government was panicking because they
00:33:58 didn't have a bill to ban it, so they had to find some weird, bizarre regulatory workarounds. I think
00:34:03 they did something involving like dairy import bans, some obscure powers the government had to
00:34:09 try and regulate the stop of it. So there's that on handguns. Now, I know handgun owners, we don't
00:34:15 get as much sympathy as regular hunting rifle and shotgun owners. People say, oh, what do you need a
00:34:21 handgun for? Well, this is still a free country, isn't it? I don't have to answer your stupid questions. I can have a handgun because I want a handgun. That's all the reason I need. But either way, handgun owners have less public sympathy than, say, hunting rifle and shotgun owners. So then fast forward to this fall and the liberals bring in a new bill. And it's to do put in legislation what they said they were going to do and that's ban the sale of handguns. And then just a few weeks ago, we get an amendment.
00:34:51 to the bill at the committee level. And it's more or less the liberals are just going to ban a shit ton of regular hunting rifles, all sorts of basic stuff.
00:35:00 If you've got a detachable, you've got a semi-automatic rifle with a detachable magazine. Well, surprise, surprise, that's now an assault style rifle.
00:35:08 Absolutely not stuff. And it seems to have blown up in their faces. We'll start with you, Nigel.
00:35:18 you think this deserves to be one of the big stories of 2022? And at what point do you think
00:35:24 the media started to catch on that this was not a story that's just going to anger the hardcore gun
00:35:31 enthusiasts? Well, they started to get that when they suddenly realized, well, if it's a hunting
00:35:36 rifle and it's used for hunting, that probably isn't what the crime problem is on the bad streets
00:35:42 of major cities in canada so you know not that we like guns they said but there seems to be a
00:35:51 logical disconnect in what the federal government is trying to do and even some of the you know the
00:35:56 people that we criticize here for the way they attack things well that actually doesn't make
00:36:02 any sense does it how is this going to help so that was the first that was the first thing um
00:36:08 The thing with the reason why a lot of people are exercised about this,
00:36:17 and tell me if this is another of these fortuitous segues,
00:36:21 but you can't take this in isolation from some of the other things that the federal government has done.
00:36:29 If it was just a firearms issue, maybe you could.
00:36:32 But this is also, and I know you want to talk about this later,
00:36:35 This is coming from a government that wants to restrict press freedom.
00:36:39 This is coming from a government that spent two and a half years
00:36:42 telling people what to do about a pandemic
00:36:45 without really knowing themselves what was the right answer.
00:36:49 You could go on.
00:36:50 There's a whole culture of control that this is just one part of.
00:36:58 People are starting to catch on that there is this culture of control.
00:37:01 They're not liking it.
00:37:01 and it starts to put issues like firearms ownership in a slightly different light.
00:37:07 Well, I should mention, this segment in particular is sponsored by the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:37:13 Yes. All right.
00:37:14 Our favorite guys, you guys all know I've been a member of the CSSA for well over a decade. 0.98
00:37:20 These guys kick ass. 0.92
00:37:21 If you want to keep your guns, you better be a member of the CSSA now. 0.98
00:37:26 So we'll go to you, Corey.
00:37:27 I think this story has kind of taken on a new life. When it was just handgun owners, we're a fairly small part of the population. People seem to think that, you know, legally purchased handguns. People go, they purchase a handgun on Monday and they go knock off a 7-Eleven on Tuesday. That's not happening. Handguns used in the Commission of Crimes in Canada are more than 99%, 98, 99% are smuggled from the United States.
00:37:57 but the amendment to this bill when I started ensnaring regular bonafide
00:38:03 hunting rifles that people could not deny these are legitimate hunting rifles
00:38:07 I think there is sort of an agrarian romanticism in Canada still of the
00:38:12 hunter the hunter is you know there might not be a lot of sympathy for the
00:38:16 oilfield worker but there there is a romanticization of the farmer and if
00:38:21 most people aren't farmers we kind of idolize it kind of agrarian way same
00:38:24 And with the hunter, we, most people don't have much sympathy with someone who goes down to the gun club and fires off a nine mil for the afternoon.
00:38:32 But, you know, the guy who goes out, shoots deer, shoots a moose, it's a very Canadian thing to do.
00:38:39 Why do you think the media itself actually started to pay more attention to this and actually put at least some critical light on the new gun grab stuff?
00:38:50 Well, part of it is because of they threw their own fart catchers under the bus. 0.97
00:38:54 We've had this debate going on for months and months, say, on social media with the other blue checks and legacy media find.
00:39:02 And people like me say they're coming after legitimately on fire.
00:39:04 No, they aren't. No, they aren't. They're never going after hunting firearms.
00:39:08 They're never doing it. And they said it a dozen times, a dozen ways.
00:39:11 Yeah.
00:39:11 And now suddenly there's no denying they have just gone after a whole large amount of hunting firearms that were never a problem.
00:39:19 So these defenders of that act now have an egg on their faces, and not all of them are as shameless with their lies as Minister Mendicino, who would just lie and forget about it the day after.
00:39:27 They're embarrassed.
00:39:28 I know the same feeling back when I was still somewhat supportive of Premier Kenney when I was saying, look, he said he's never bringing a vaccine passport.
00:39:36 He's obviously never going to bring in a vaccine passport.
00:39:38 And then later on, people were rubbing my face.
00:39:41 And geez, Corey, I thought you said, I guess I was wrong.
00:39:44 I was not very supportive.
00:39:46 And even I didn't think he would go that far.
00:39:48 I was like oh so but the media feels that way I mean they were carrying water for this for quite a while and suddenly now they don't have a defense for this anymore either so I mean elements of the media anyways and the vocal people within it so I think that's part of it they're like okay that's enough I can't do this for you guys anymore if you're going to keep moving the goalposts this isn't worth it you're obviously not going after criminals you're going after guns well our it's funny the biggest stories of the year I've put in more or less as much as
00:40:18 could chronological order of when they took place. They all segue so perfectly to each other. And this segues us perfectly to our last one, federal control over the press and the internet segueing from what you said Nigel about
00:40:33 there seems to be all of these strange attempts by government, particularly the federal government to assert new levels of control scope and size and scope of control over people's lives, particularly from the federal government.
00:40:46 federal government. And they seem to be kind of siloed on their own. But when you kind of zoom out at the bigger picture, it's much more worrisome. And one of the most worrisome has got to be federal control over the press and the internet in Canada. Now, this is going back some time, but not that long before we return the Western Standard to publication, the federal government announced a $600 million bailout package for the media.
00:41:14 And people watch here, no, we don't take that. But then we've started to see other bills, the online harms bill, which would heavily censor social media for offensive content.
00:41:27 Sometimes stuff that's probably genuinely bad and should probably not be there. But also, we know the way this would go.
00:41:34 It would just be offensive stuff, stuff that challenges the federal government and the official narratives of things.
00:41:40 or then we saw, or you call it misinformation or disinformation, you just label it misinformation, disinformation, and you're gone.
00:41:47 They should ban that one, yes. Yeah. Of course. That kind of thing. 0.79
00:41:51 And then the most recent one, something called the Online News Act, which sounds fairly innocuous,
00:41:59 but I'd always be cautious when the government has news in an act.
00:42:04 That means you have some kind of regulation of the news and of the press.
00:42:08 And so we've got the Online News Act, which is the one that's really gone below the radar right now because the legacy media don't want to talk about it too much because they lobbied for it.
00:42:18 You've got something called Newspapers Canada, which is the lobby organization representing the big corporate press conglomerates in Canada, Post Media, Globe Media, Tor Star Corp, all these things.
00:42:28 And the idea is more or less put a gun to the head of Facebook and Google and say, you owe these guys money because you did them the favor of distributing their content.
00:42:40 Tons of you guys are watching this on Facebook right now.
00:42:44 And if you're watching this on Facebook right now and this bill passes as it is, we will be banned from Facebook at some point in the new year.
00:42:51 As Facebook has said, if this bill passes, we're not handing money off to companies that haven't earned it from us in a regular commercial agreement.
00:42:58 We're just going to kick the news off of Facebook.
00:43:01 And the legislators have put this bill together in such a way as it makes it illegal for the Western standard to say, we want no part of this.
00:43:09 We don't think Facebook owes us any money, and we don't owe Facebook any money, and we just want to put our content on Facebook.
00:43:16 And that's what's happening now.
00:43:17 So you've got now federal control over social media platforms and the media itself together, trying to really go after the distribution of media.
00:43:27 So with you, Nigel, why do you think it's come to this?
00:43:32 Why do you think the legacy media lobbies so strongly for it?
00:43:37 And do you think this is one of the it's definitely not gotten the top five, six press stories of the year by coverage.
00:43:44 But why do you think it deserves to be in here?
00:43:45 yeah why would the media report on them trying to fleece uh companies using the power of the
00:43:52 government i think you just the way you ask the question is to suggest the answer look i mean
00:43:58 what this is the long game here what this is going to do is going to put us back to the days when
00:44:04 you you the only place you got your news was from a newspaper you're not going to be able to just
00:44:10 login while you have your coffee at your kitchen table check the news before you
00:44:15 head off to work because it won't be there if Facebook does indeed say what
00:44:20 do what it says it's going to do let's face it well you'd be limited to going
00:44:23 to westernstandard.news that's the only place you'll be able to find or
00:44:27 nationalpost.com or whatever yeah but it won't show up in your feeds anymore
00:44:31 isn't going to show up in your feeds and so you know if you can sort of
00:44:35 picture picture the days when things got passed around by fax and the only way
00:44:39 could get a hold of somebody was by a landline you know the days before the internet that's the
00:44:46 that's kind of the the technology that you're going to be dealing with you'll hear things on
00:44:51 the radio you you want to see it on tv you can turn on but you're not going to be able to get
00:44:56 the the feeds on your phone that you can read while you're on the c train going to going to
00:45:02 the office and that's really going to hurt now that works for the um this works in two ways one
00:45:10 is that uh the the media the old media when they're the only game in town will of course
00:45:20 have some stay of execution i don't know whether it's possible to drive people back to newsprint by
00:45:25 taking away electronics but there'll be some upside to them but if they do it goes the other
00:45:31 way and they do get they do decide to and Facebook relents on this the old media gets paid
00:45:41 and they're also getting paid by the government how fair impartial and unbiased do you think
00:45:50 you could possibly be to ask the question is to imply the answer exactly um
00:45:56 So, Corey, I want to talk.
00:45:59 What's the problem now?
00:46:00 Yeah.
00:46:01 Let's talk in particular about why this wasn't one of the biggest stories in terms of how much coverage it got in the year.
00:46:07 When it's an absolutely earth-shattering bill, it will change the nature of media in Canada.
00:46:14 I mean, yeah, if Facebook just flips off the news, says no more news on Facebook in Canada, that'll mean everyone's readership goes down.
00:46:21 Now, it's already happened.
00:46:22 And Facebook has been throttling how much news shows up in your algorithms for some time.
00:46:27 Like we've seen our proportion on Facebook go down.
00:46:30 All the other publishers I've talked to all see the same thing.
00:46:32 So they've been kind of putting their thumbs on the scales of how much news shows in your feeds now.
00:46:37 But it's still a big portion of what we get.
00:46:40 But it's a relatively smaller portion of what the big guys, the old print media and the broadcast media rely on.
00:46:48 They can always go back to, you know, so if they lose Facebook, well, they can always just last for more subsidies to make up the difference.
00:46:57 Ah, geez, Facebook's so mean. Give us more cash, Papa Trudeau.
00:47:00 But I want your take on why do you think it hasn't been one of the biggest stories of the year in terms of coverage?
00:47:09 One, it is probably one of the most substantial federal bills in decades.
00:47:14 Well, I would bet there's probably been countless columns that have been spiked by perhaps some
00:47:18 guys who thought they could write up on this and they submitted it and somewhere in the editorial
00:47:22 level, they said, no, we're just not going to talk about that right now. I mean, the self-interest
00:47:26 is evident. They don't want to highlight something that is protecting a dinosaur. And that's what it
00:47:31 is. And they're going. And it's the story of the year. I guess it'll be more of the story I told
00:47:37 you so when this collapses, I think, though, because, yeah, I mean, it'd be nice to think
00:47:42 that perhaps people can go back to the days of paper and
00:47:44 print, but they won't. But things will change. And the
00:47:46 internet is it's living, they're going to be playing
00:47:50 whack a mole. I mean, if Facebook isn't covering it,
00:47:51 you gotta remember, Google is a big factor in this too. So
00:47:54 you got to get direct URLs, what you'll see is a boom in
00:47:57 secondary advertising, because now you're gonna have to
00:47:58 advertise elsewhere to reach people, let them know, come here
00:48:02 to read our content, and people aren't gonna like that. I think
00:48:06 it'll help with in the long run with Maverick publications like
00:48:09 hours, if you even want to call it that, an alternative and new media. And this is the last
00:48:16 gasp. So I mean, you can subsidize and keep that dying institution alive for a while, but their
00:48:21 business model is broken. And they'd rather chase subsidies and forcing people to take part in their
00:48:27 old model rather than adjust themselves. Like I'll just throw in a quick analogy from my past career
00:48:32 when I was a surveyor. It frustrated me. I spent my first three years out there getting abused by
00:48:36 surveyor as a rodman yelled at freezing cold and holding the rod and pounding laugh before they
00:48:41 would even let me touch a transit. And then I had to learn my formulas and I had to learn how to
00:48:45 calculate area and elevations. And then GPS came along and completely wiped out my trade.
00:48:51 You know, nowadays, a person could pull out a smartphone and learn doing seconds without any
00:48:56 training what took me years to get to. And some surveyors got lost with that they couldn't adapt
00:49:01 themselves to GPS, I learned how to do digital mapping and other things and adapted and got
00:49:05 another 15 years out of that career. But some of the older surveyors, they couldn't, and they got
00:49:10 left behind. And what we've got right now with a lot of the legacy media members are those older
00:49:15 surveyors, they're fighting it with all they've got. But unless they can change themselves,
00:49:20 they're going to get left behind, they're going to lose this in the long run.
00:49:24 I think you're right. And I mean, this bill passes, it's going to be very tough on us,
00:49:29 even though we want absolutely nothing to do with it. But we will endure. Actually, that's,
00:49:33 that's a really important reason why y'all need to be on our newsletter because if we get shut
00:49:38 off of facebook if this bill passes and facebook gets shut down for us you're going to need to get
00:49:42 your morning blast in the morning that's uh that's how you're gonna have to find us it's gonna it's
00:49:46 gonna be tough so make sure you remember make sure you're on our newsletter go to westernstandard.news
00:49:52 well gentlemen it's been a hell of a year it's been a very good year i think um
00:49:58 Catch our big. We are running, it's now over 20 long columns by people who know what they're
00:50:12 talking about. You're a fanatic editor, right? Fanaticism is in the DNA. Look, we've got a lot
00:50:20 of really smart people who are delivering their thoughts, not only about what has happened in
00:50:25 2022, but also in 2023. After this, after this program, you'll see the trailer for it. So watch
00:50:32 it and come to our website and take a look. These people know what they're talking about.
00:50:38 Yeah, it's a great series that Nigel set up from a lot of our best columnists across Canada,
00:50:44 retrospective on 2022 and looking forward into 2023. Nigel, Corey, it's been a great 2022 with
00:50:53 with you guys. Merry Christmas. Merry Christmas to all our readers. And Merry Christmas and
00:50:59 New Year very soon to all of you, our loyal Western-centered readers, watchers,
00:51:06 and listeners. It's been such an honor to be with you this year in this
00:51:09 tremendous year of growth. Just, I had a great 2022. So thank all of you for that great year.
00:51:16 And Merry Christmas.