Western Standard - March 23, 2023


The Pipeline: Trudeau blinks first

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Mar 22, 2023 President Joe Biden arriving in Ottawa

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

154.63

Word count

5,981

Sentence count

219

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A weekly look at what's going on in Canadian politics, but from the Western Standard's angle, in the absence of publisher Derek Philippides, who is hobnobbing in Ottawa at the True North conference with Stephen Harper and Conrad Black.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, I'm Nigel Hannaford, Opinion Editor at the Western Standard.
00:00:28 it's wednesday march the 22nd 2003 you are watching pipeline a weekly look at what's going
00:00:37 on in canadian politics but from the western angle in the absence of publisher derek phildebrand who
00:00:43 is hobnobbing in ottawa at the uh true north i beg your pardon the old uh what is it called dave
00:00:53 strong and canada strong and free strong and free conference he's there with my two old bosses
00:00:57 Stephen Harper and Conrad Black. And Corey Morgan has given us a doctor's note, so you've got me.
00:01:04 And I'm joined here today by our news editor, Dave Naylor, who's obviously well-known to
00:01:10 Western Standard readers. And good afternoon, Dave. Good afternoon, Nigel. I'm a bit intimidated,
00:01:17 I must admit, to be surrounded by such intellectual giants. Dave, just be glad that
00:01:24 You're bringing the average age down.
00:01:26 Yes.
00:01:27 How often do you get a chance to do that?
00:01:28 And lack of gray hair, too.
00:01:30 But it's coming.
00:01:31 Yes.
00:01:32 Anyway, so Dave, well-known, as we say,
00:01:35 and especially warm welcome to special guest,
00:01:39 Professor Tom Flanagan.
00:01:41 Again, somebody no stranger to this audience.
00:01:44 How many years did you teach political science at USC, Tom?
00:01:47 I lost track, but it's about 55.
00:01:50 55 years of political oh boy and uh you also worked for stephen harper i did for a few years
00:01:58 yes and uh i never worked for conrad black but i was interviewed by him by once once
00:02:05 tom you are one of us okay this evening we're going to be talking about some big things that
00:02:10 are happening but uh in order the prime minister has given his chief of staff katie telford
00:02:17 permission to testify to a parliamentary committee about what the PM knew and when the PMO knew
00:02:25 about alleged Chinese electoral interference. Will we learn what we want to know? Also back
00:02:33 in Ottawa, the Supreme Court of Canada will be reviewing the Alberta Court of Appeals decision
00:02:40 which found bill 69 the no pipelines act to be unconstitutional will they agree what does it
00:02:48 mean for alberta if they don't and then we want to talk about the university of calgary and some
00:02:55 rather different messaging that seems to be coming out of the administration these days
00:03:00 seems a bit woke but is it we'll get some opinions going about that first however i would like to
00:03:07 thank our sponsor the cssa that's the canadian shooting sports association canada's leading
00:03:16 spokesman for the gun community these men and women are the best they're our strongest advocates
00:03:23 to this government for our legal right to own purchase and use firearms i don't know
00:03:33 where we would be without them given the government that we are dealing with
00:03:37 so if you are not already a member don't delay pick up the phone send them an email get on their
00:03:45 website it's cssa-cila.org or just do what i did google them send them a note send them your
00:03:55 membership and be part of the part of the ongoing struggle to keep our right to maintain our own
00:04:03 firearms in our own homes we need these good friends and if they're going to keep on working
00:04:08 hard for us they need us standing with them through our membership and our active support
00:04:15 so gentlemen let's get to it item one katie telfer dave what what's been going on it was a
00:04:22 The game of chicken, everybody in the country was watching over the last few weeks.
00:04:28 The Commons Committee has been holding hearings on Chinese interference in Canadian elections,
00:04:32 and they wanted to hear from Trudeau's chief of staff, Katie Telford.
00:04:37 The Liberals appeared not to want her to have to testify.
00:04:41 They did more than 24 hours of filibustering.
00:04:44 That's a lot of fillets to be busted.
00:04:47 At the committee to stop this going to a vote.
00:04:51 The Tories then decided to bring it up for a vote in the House, and they had block support,
00:04:58 and the NDP said they were going to support it too if Telford didn't agree to testify.
00:05:03 Well, lo and behold, a few hours before the vote, PMO issued a statement saying that she was going to be allowed to testify.
00:05:11 So, of course, the NDP quickly switched their vote and voted no against the motion.
00:05:17 So she'll be testifying in the next week or so.
00:05:20 And, you know, I'm betting we get the American version of taking the fifth.
00:05:26 And she will repeatedly say, I can't answer that because of national security.
00:05:31 So where it gets us, I don't know.
00:05:33 Well, that's kind of a pessimistic outlook.
00:05:36 Tom, do you see any hope that we'll get to know what we want to know out of this operation?
00:05:42 Not much.
00:05:42 she will one thing she may have is a bad memory we've seen this from other high civil servants
00:05:50 or political staffers who've been brought to testify parliamentary committees and they just
00:05:58 can't remember it's amazing how their memory has declined you wonder how they can be employed
00:06:03 but that would be my prediction since we don't have a fifth amendment as such
00:06:08 she may say she doesn't remember she may say that she can't answer because of
00:06:13 security implications which is always a you know a hard one to crack
00:06:17 so you know we may learn that be true in fact yeah might even be true yeah and so we may learn
00:06:24 something but uh i doubt that we will learn as much as people hope we will learn this is all
00:06:31 sort of symbolic politics it is important though because you know what it did it demonstrated the
00:06:38 fragility of the ndp liberal coalition the prime minister changed his mind because it became apparent
00:06:44 that the ndp uh was going to vote to call katie telford so that meant that the government would
00:06:54 have been defeated on a motion in the house now that's not automatically a confidence motion so
00:07:00 that doesn't mean that the government needs to fall but it does show that the government can be
00:07:05 defeated i think it's something that you'd like to avoid uh so that's my reading of it
00:07:11 but i as i say i don't expect to learn that much from katie telford's appearance yes that would
00:07:18 have been a really bad story if they'd have lost a vote absolutely yeah it looks but it would look
00:07:23 terrible and uh does as i say it doesn't mean the government falls but it's something they would
00:07:29 like to avoid to keep their coalition together because they've got to keep it together until
00:07:34 2025 you know until the next election they would prefer to keep it going until then tom what do
00:07:40 what do you think of the uh appointment of the trudeau family friend uh former governor general
00:07:47 what is a special reporter anyway david johnson is uh is uh has got this what i assume is a fairly
00:07:54 plung job yeah well i guess it's it's whatever he wants to make it uh that it's not a well-defined
00:08:03 role i mean it doesn't doesn't have any formal legislative um thinking david johnston is uh
00:08:11 i you know i think a very distinguished person he was dean of law at mcgill he was
00:08:18 by everybody agreed that he was a fine governor general um i think he will do his best to be
00:08:24 impartial here it's more the the optics that it's uh johnson's and the trudeaus were old family
00:08:33 friends uh he was on the ward of the uh trudeau foundation for a while just um the optics are
00:08:42 wrong uh but i don't want to say anything critical of david johnson except perhaps he shouldn't have
00:08:49 accepted the appointment, but it's, you know, the old saying, justice must not only be done,
00:08:56 but must be seen to be done. And so no matter what his report is, people will immediately
00:09:02 start to criticize it and say that he wasn't objective, even if he did his best to be objective.
00:09:08 So it's... Does he actually have the powers to do the job in the fullest possible sense?
00:09:16 like can he compel testimony no i don't think so and he's it's not a judicial role no i don't
00:09:20 think he has that kind of power it's it's a you know he can investigate uh he he can talk to
00:09:27 officials uh but beyond that it's not clear to me what he actually it's another delay you know i
00:09:37 think one of the things the liberals are doing here is they're ragging the puck they're just
00:09:42 want to drag this out until something else comes up that makes people forget about it
00:09:46 and they hope that it won't become a serious issue at election time so appointing a special
00:09:52 rapporteur is another way of of ragging the buck so if we could beam you into the um office of the
00:09:59 leader of the loyal opposition and he were to say to you what do you think we should how do
00:10:05 how do we bring this government to bear you've had years of this kind of experience what would
00:10:11 you tell them well i think the the opposition has done a good job on this issue in in the sense that
00:10:17 they have forced a split between the liberals and the ndp and they are bringing miss telford in to
00:10:24 testify so i guess i would say let's wait and see what she says and then um probably we will turn
00:10:33 our attack dogs loose uh on whatever it is that she said or didn't say and we will keep this going
00:10:43 um the danger is that people will lose interest so we have to find a way to uh to keep it alive
00:10:51 and so the liberals want to drag it out so that people do lose interest
00:10:56 sure there'll be another scandal coming right down the road the way this government goes yeah
00:11:00 i'm sure there will be well if you notice how things work dave you you know you there's scandal
00:11:06 and scandal and scandal you must have had a dozen of them and i bet most people couldn't name you
00:11:11 three but what they do remember is that there have been scandals and that's how a government
00:11:17 loses its reputation people just get every bad thing that comes along they're there they go again
00:11:26 And they give themselves a bad name, and I think it's going to have serious consequences.
00:11:32 I believe the polls are starting to show it, aren't they?
00:11:35 Every poll has got the Tories in front.
00:11:37 Well, that's one course that events may take, is the accretion of small scandals until a government gets a reputation for a scandal.
00:11:48 It is, however, possible for the big one to surface.
00:11:51 And that's what happened when the Harper government was first elected.
00:11:56 In 2006, it was in the wake of revelations about the Liberals using public money in Quebec for political purposes.
00:12:05 The ad scam business, employing advertising firms with public money.
00:12:10 So that was the big one.
00:12:13 And of course, you're always hoping that there will be the big one.
00:12:16 But if the big one doesn't surface, then the accretion of many is also good when a government becomes known for scandal.
00:12:23 And I think that's probably where we're headed now.
00:12:27 Is this not the big one, Chinese interference as far as high up as the PMO maybe?
00:12:33 I don't think it is the big one.
00:12:36 I think it's the big one in Ottawa because it involves senior political staff,
00:12:42 maybe the prime minister himself.
00:12:46 I mean, in a way, it obviously involves the prime minister himself.
00:12:49 He's in charge.
00:12:50 And these things happened while he was prime minister.
00:12:53 So clearly he's involved.
00:12:56 What kind of traction it has in the rest of the country,
00:12:59 I mean, it doesn't affect anybody's paycheck.
00:13:01 It's not a bread and butter issue of the kind
00:13:04 that often determine elections.
00:13:07 So it's more, I think, for the political class
00:13:10 that get wrapped up in this kind of thing.
00:13:13 You know, that's a really, if we had more time,
00:13:17 we could go deeper on that point.
00:13:19 I'd like to think that although obviously paycheck policies are the ones that trigger a vote one way or the other,
00:13:28 I get the impression that Canadians are scandalized at the possibility that their election could have been interfered with by anybody,
00:13:38 especially by the People's Republic of China.
00:13:41 Do you not think there's got a little more traction than that?
00:13:46 Well, I haven't seen it that way.
00:13:48 you know i'm old i'm out of touch i don't talk to that many people anymore i'm retired
00:13:53 so maybe i'm just out of the loop so what i know about it comes mainly from what i
00:13:58 what i read in the media um that's my impression of it is that it's a a political class issue
00:14:06 rather than what would turn it into a voters issue is voters are scandalized by dishonesty
00:14:15 some scandals don't touch them when they seem just like a question of who got appointed and
00:14:22 you know it seems like inside baseball but voters uh do get aroused when they sense dishonesty
00:14:30 and so if the conservatives can spin this not and not just the conservatives but other parties
00:14:36 can spin this as liberal dishonesty and liberals are lying to you so that's close to a breakthrough
00:14:44 then what would seal it is evidence of people making off with money, loot, loot.
00:14:53 That's what sealed the ad scam scandal.
00:14:56 That's what made it the big one, is that the liberals were actually taking public money.
00:15:01 Now, we haven't seen that yet, but if it appears that there is some aspect of bribery in this,
00:15:08 some quid pro quo and we're seeing this in the united states with uh in very slow motion the
00:15:15 biden family scandal um it's looking more and more as if they're going to be able to demonstrate
00:15:20 that uh there's money given for special consideration that kind of thing is deadly
00:15:27 so that's what i would the opposition parties will be hoping that they can that they can find that
00:15:34 Great points, Tom.
00:15:37 I guess we'll see what she says, but I think like you, I'm pessimistic, we'll have a real
00:15:43 revelation there, but let's move on to pipelines, because this could easily be kind of a matter
00:15:50 of whether we keep the lights on in Alberta in 10 years' time.
00:15:54 Dave, I get all the bills mixed up, Bill 48, Bill 69, you know.
00:15:59 Well, 69 is the tanker ban, isn't it?
00:16:01 Or is it the pipeline?
00:16:02 48, yeah, see, you're going to like it.
00:16:05 48 was the tanker ban.
00:16:07 69 is, they call it, the no more pipelines ban.
00:16:09 All right.
00:16:10 It's much broader than that, but it's...
00:16:12 Yeah, well, that's in the Supreme Court this week.
00:16:16 Alberta...
00:16:17 Okay, but first it went to the Alberta...
00:16:19 Yeah, Alberta government sued the Liberals.
00:16:23 It went to the Alberta Court of Appeal,
00:16:26 and Alberta won four to one.
00:16:29 Of course, it was taken up to the Supreme Court where their hearings started on Wednesday.
00:16:35 So it won't be, obviously, probably a few months until a verdict is reached.
00:16:42 It can be that quick.
00:16:43 Well, you know, keep in mind there's one of them missing, right?
00:16:48 The Western Justice, Justice Brown, has got himself in an altercation in Arizona
00:16:57 where there was an alleged scuffle. So he is not in his seat at the moment under investigation.
00:17:04 So, you know, I think Premier Smith was mentioning, you know, she hopes his
00:17:09 absence isn't going to be the sway vote that the West would have had.
00:17:14 I want to come back to what Premier Smith was saying yesterday in a few moments, but
00:17:18 before we do that tom um you know later first what are the implications of what the supreme court is
00:17:27 considering what does it mean for alberta yeah well bill c69 is a long complex piece of legislation
00:17:35 many implications but i think what's what's really important is that it extends federal jurisdiction
00:17:43 over impact assessment into projects which are within the boundaries of province now it's it's
00:17:51 clear that the federal government has jurisdiction over things like interprovincial pipelines
00:17:57 which they have used to kill several pipeline proposals but that's always been clear that
00:18:02 things like interprovincial railways hydro corridors pipelines those are
00:18:07 international interprovincial and international those are under federal jurisdiction but
00:18:13 one would have thought reading the constitution that the provinces have jurisdiction within their
00:18:17 own boundaries so if the provinces want to authorize a new pipeline from a gas field in
00:18:24 northern alberta to drive a power plant somewhere else within the province that that would just be
00:18:29 a provincial matter the the new legislation allows the federal commission to override
00:18:37 provincial jurisdiction and to impose a federal environmental review which could include
00:18:47 emissions carbon emissions now the feds may not do this in every case we don't know how widely
00:18:54 they would use this power it's a power that they could use but presumably they had a reason for
00:19:00 passing it and my guess is that anything big would be subject to federal impact assessment
00:19:08 on top of the provincial so it it gums up the word the least it does is it comes up the work
00:19:13 and extends things um at worst become it could become a virtual veto power and this involves
00:19:20 i think this is important to grasp it's not just alberta and the oil industry but this applies
00:19:26 to all industries that have environmental impacts so for example in ontario premier ford
00:19:33 wants to open up parts of northern ontario for mining and he's been working at that and seems
00:19:39 to be getting close perhaps to getting partnership with some of the first nations up there so they
00:19:45 can build the roads and dig the mines but these are big big projects for uh you know relatively
00:19:51 rare metals that require you to move a lot of earth in order to get it right well that would
00:19:55 be that would come under federal control now the feds might like that project because it's for 0.99
00:20:02 batteries um and electric vehicles so you know maybe it would maybe they wouldn't get in the way
00:20:09 but potentially uh provinces province developmental plans will now be under federal jurisdiction
00:20:16 uh quebec hydro quebec um they want to do a new hydro project for power within quebec it would be
00:20:24 subject perhaps to to federal review so that's why eight out of ten provinces are well seven
00:20:31 other provinces are supporting alberta in this hearing um and i i don't think it will end here
00:20:38 even if the supreme court upholds c69 which i think it will based on its past record whether
00:20:46 russell brown is there or not i think it will actually uphold it but when that many and
00:20:52 including all the big provinces are opposed to it there will be political repercussions later on
00:20:57 i can't say exactly what but the provinces will be discussing ways that they can use their
00:21:04 remaining powers to strike back so i don't think the story ends here well that's a
00:21:10 That is a relief that it doesn't end there, but how does it play out?
00:21:17 Well, it's in the short and medium term.
00:21:19 I don't know whether the Sovereignty Act applies in this case, does it?
00:21:22 Who knows?
00:21:24 In the short run, I don't think much has happened.
00:21:27 It doesn't stop business that's ongoing, where it might be involved, let's say,
00:21:32 a big new development in the oil sands, opening up of a new,
00:21:37 whether it was was subterranean with heated steam or whether it's a surface pit that i think you'd
00:21:43 see the feds getting involved there so within a few years there probably would be some kind
00:21:50 of conflict between provincial aspirations and federal regulation um but i think it's
00:21:57 always a mistake to be chicken little because in the meantime there's going to be an election
00:22:01 If a new government comes in, they might amend to relax those powers.
00:22:08 Those powers, they say, are not mandatory.
00:22:11 Ultimately, it's going to depend on who's in power.
00:22:13 If the liberals are still in power, they will appoint the commission.
00:22:18 Then the commission will recommend that an environmental assessment be done.
00:22:22 Ultimately, it's up to the minister to make the final decision.
00:22:25 So if you have different people at the top, you could avert confrontation for, you know, for some period of time, and they might repeal or amend it, just as Brian Mulroney's government repealed the National Energy Program.
00:22:45 Took time.
00:22:47 A lot of things were lost in the meantime, but ultimately it was repealed.
00:22:52 So I think it's a mistake to, you know, to give up hope.
00:22:56 I think the political process may come into play.
00:22:59 But, you know, I can't, my weakness as a pundit was I could never foretell the future.
00:23:05 See, I'm an expert at telling you why the past had to happen as it did.
00:23:11 So bring me out to talk about the history.
00:23:14 I've got an explanation for everything.
00:23:16 Well, the future, I don't know.
00:23:18 Well, for the future, let me just pass it over to Dave here for a moment,
00:23:21 because yesterday premier smith was answering questions after an announcement on a different
00:23:27 matter and somebody asked her about this very very business and what they asked was
00:23:36 the they referenced what she said on a on a radio program and asked what it would mean
00:23:46 for alberta in practical terms i mean tom has just explained the grand theory of the thing the yeah
00:23:53 the court could probably do this and maybe it could be repealed later but you know we want we
00:24:00 want power in this province our population is growing there is a strong urge by the federal
00:24:08 government to electrify everything that moves and even our homes that don't we're going to need more
00:24:14 power one of the easiest places and one of the cleanest places for us to get the power
00:24:22 from gas fire generating plants what did she have to say about that well energy security
00:24:28 seems to be coming more and more uh an issue for her and i know it's one of your uh your
00:24:34 your favorite issues too and it's you know and it's the future is kind of scary without these
00:24:42 these new plants who's going to power the electric vehicles you know oh because it's crazy numbers
00:24:48 that they want to reach only by by 2030 and you know what it's really not just alberta it's what
00:24:55 alberta can offer the world uh you know japan came to ask for natural gas no it's no no business plan
00:25:03 uh you know germany came oh sorry no business plan well if there is a proper business plan
00:25:08 Alberta can supply gas to anyone that needs it, basically, and then the money would flow into Alberta.
00:25:17 And I think Premier Smith was saying today, you know, if we'd have had the ability to do this at the start of the Heritage Savings Trust Fund,
00:25:25 it would now be $300 billion, and we'd be sitting on money like Norway sits on money from their energy reserves.
00:25:34 But, you know, it's got to become common knowledge that Alberta has this ability.
00:25:41 And, you know, let us give us the wings and let us fly and see what we can do.
00:25:46 Tom, do you think that energy security gets any traction as an election issue?
00:25:50 Do people get it?
00:25:52 Well, I think in Alberta they do.
00:25:53 Outside of Alberta, probably not.
00:25:55 Maybe in Saskatchewan.
00:25:58 But in the rest of the country, I don't think so.
00:26:00 I don't think the energy industry is appreciated.
00:26:03 I think until they can't keep the lights on, then it will become appreciated
00:26:09 if they're having energy blackouts and so on.
00:26:13 But until they feel it, it's not appreciated just by talking about it.
00:26:18 It's only appreciated when they begin to feel it.
00:26:20 Well, she made some reference yesterday to there being a, we didn't have a brown,
00:26:26 but we came close to one just before Christmas.
00:26:29 Yes.
00:26:30 That, to me, would seem like a failure on behalf of provincial government.
00:26:35 We ever get to the stage where that could happen.
00:26:37 Yeah, it's pretty scary.
00:26:39 Pretty scary.
00:26:40 We're getting to that point.
00:26:41 And, you know, it probably can happen.
00:26:45 I mean, it has happened in places like Texas that you would think of as bastion of the energy industry.
00:26:52 Weather is very unpredictable.
00:26:56 Crazy things can happen.
00:26:57 Bring on the nukes.
00:26:59 yes we'll bring on the small nuclear uh module reactors yes those would be a big benefit the oil
00:27:06 sand if i i mean i i don't know the price equation but uh if it's if it's uh affordable
00:27:14 that you would have be able to heat the steam that you need for bringing the oil up from the ground
00:27:20 without adding to carbon emissions so you sort of win-win all the way around if it
00:27:25 so we'll have to wait and see whether these things become practical i mean there are many things um
00:27:32 that work in prototype but they can't be scaled up for some reason or other so i guess we're gonna
00:27:37 have to wait and see on that okay all right well the other thing that we've been that's been
00:27:43 occupying us this week we had a very um a column from uh actually the old colleague of yours dr
00:27:49 Barry Cooper, very critical of the way that the administration at the University of Calgary is
00:27:57 thinking. We know they, for example, have got a race-based hiring system that in one job added
00:28:05 actually said white men need not apply. I was devastated. What do you see going on up there
00:28:12 on the hill, Dave? Well, apparently it seems to be becoming one of Canada's most woke universities.
00:28:19 um you know uh full admission i never went to any university so i'm not sure what exactly goes
00:28:27 better journalists because yeah probably but so i'm not exactly sure what goes in those hallowed
00:28:32 hallowed halls of learning but uh and it's not just the ufc there's all sorts of uh of woke
00:28:38 stuff coming on basically every campus uh across the country and uh ufc seems to jump on board
00:28:47 You know, we've done stories on those ads you've talked about, the white men do not apply, and racial-based hiring, and it's all part of the new woke generation, I guess.
00:28:59 And, you know, eminent people like Barry Cooper, and I'm sure Professor Flanagan may have opposing views, let's say.
00:29:10 And change is never easy, but some of the changes seem to be a bit strange.
00:29:15 Well, I think Barry's point was that they're so busy planning
00:29:17 for the future that they're no longer interested
00:29:19 in studying the past.
00:29:20 And just a few moments ago, Tom, you were saying, ask me something.
00:29:24 Okay, so I'm asking you, what do you see going on there?
00:29:27 Tom Hanks Yeah.
00:29:28 Well, you know, to be honest, I'm glad I'm retired.
00:29:32 I'd probably be in constant conflict if I were still a member.
00:29:38 Barry and I are old friends.
00:29:40 We were in graduate school together.
00:29:41 So I've known Barry for almost 60 years, and he likes to stir the pot.
00:29:47 So he may write it up in provocative language, but basically what he says is true.
00:29:54 The university is going in that woke direction, and you pointed to the special hiring plan.
00:30:02 One of the things behind that is that the administration has bulked itself up
00:30:10 by hiring a series of vice presidents to deal with particular woke issues.
00:30:18 Vice president for indigenous affairs or whatever.
00:30:21 I don't have all the exact titles in front of me.
00:30:24 Most recent was a vice president for diversity, inclusion, and equity.
00:30:31 equity, yeah. You know, so these, these, these positions overlap and interlock, but you create
00:30:38 then a number of people who are paid to do something. So they have meetings with each other
00:30:44 and they generate new, new policies. This has been happening at all universities in North America
00:30:54 and United States and Canada. I think it's been worse elsewhere, but maybe the University of
00:31:00 Calgary is going to start to play catch up.
00:31:02 I always felt when I was teaching there that University of Calgary was largely immune to these trends.
00:31:09 They never seemed to wash up on our shore, so to speak.
00:31:12 So I didn't worry about it too much.
00:31:15 But I think that has changed.
00:31:18 So I think the university is going to be going with the pack now.
00:31:21 Well, let me ask you this.
00:31:22 Somebody who was in a position to have a qualified opinion told me that if they didn't do this,
00:31:30 anytime that their researchers were applying for grants through federal programs they would
00:31:37 probably not get the grant because the university didn't follow this whole business of diversity
00:31:43 inclusion equity do you think that's yeah oh i think that's absolutely true and this is this
00:31:48 is something that i ran into so the federal government is actually buying the point of
00:31:52 view they want but i yeah absolutely they in my late years of teaching i started to run into this
00:32:00 um there were all kinds of reviews for research projects that were imposed
00:32:06 because of uh federal involvement in financing in one memorable case i had a grad student who
00:32:12 wanted to go out to the nishka and study their their experiments with private property 1.00
00:32:18 but the nishka said they they wouldn't let her on until um she completed a review on
00:32:25 on campus, the campus wouldn't approve the project
00:32:29 until she had permission from the NSHCA to go there.
00:32:33 So she finally quit graduate school and went back to Ottawa
00:32:38 where she had a job.
00:32:40 But yeah, this kind of presence is pervasive.
00:32:44 And it's hard for administrators
00:32:46 of the university to resist it.
00:32:49 You'd almost have to have a university like,
00:32:53 What's the one in the United States, Hillsdale in Michigan, which is, you know, puts itself completely outside the funding system and relies on private funding.
00:33:02 We haven't had anything like that in Canada yet.
00:33:04 Our big universities are all creatures of, we have some small universities who are perhaps a little bit more independent,
00:33:11 but the big ones are all really dependent on this federal grant money.
00:33:17 So do you think that, let's not make it too easy for the UCP, but if they put money into universities and enveloped it for research, but did not have these kinds of restrictions applied to it, is that a way forward?
00:33:37 Could be. I think it would require the support of the provincial government.
00:33:42 the provincial government is the main funder the funding for research a lot of it comes federally
00:33:48 but the provincial government is still the main funder of the university so if the provincial
00:33:53 government started exerting a little more control I mean for example universities including U of C
00:34:01 always cry poor that they need larger grants now if the province would say look how can you cry
00:34:07 poor when you just added three new vice presidential positions each one is paying
00:34:13 i don't know probably 200 000 plus a year plus each vice president gets um an executive assistant
00:34:21 and a director and you know so you get budgetary implications of close to a million dollars by the
00:34:27 time you're done how can you cry poor when you keep adding these positions i think the province
00:34:33 you know these these are provincial institutions they are chartered by the problems they are
00:34:38 ultimately uh to be controlled by the people of alberta through provincial government and sure
00:34:45 institutional autonomy is important but when it's abused it seems to me the province uh ought to be
00:34:51 stepping in and that's my view of a like the university of calgary asking for more money i mean
00:34:58 I mean, sure, I want to see money for teaching and what's necessary,
00:35:04 but I know that a lot of that money is going for purposes that I think are wasteful.
00:35:09 So I say, come on down, province.
00:35:12 That's why we elected you people.
00:35:14 Let's see what you can do.
00:35:16 Dave, that sounds like an editorial to me.
00:35:18 Better get writing, Nigel.
00:35:20 Well, it also sounds like a news story.
00:35:22 That's the right people, so I'm going to turn that one over to you as well.
00:35:27 We work on that together, Tom.
00:35:28 OK.
00:35:29 Look, this has been great.
00:35:30 Thank you so much, Dave.
00:35:31 Thank you for having me.
00:35:32 I know you love to give up an hour of your Wednesday afternoon.
00:35:36 So it's all those stories waiting to be published for our readers.
00:35:41 And Tom, I hope you'll come back again.
00:35:43 This has been a pleasure.
00:35:44 OK.
00:35:45 Fun to do it.
00:35:46 Great to have your input.
00:35:49 Look, ladies and gentlemen, Western Standard, I have to make this pitch.
00:35:56 And I am glad to make this pitch because we're doing something special here.
00:36:00 This is the kind of journalism that you've been asking for, but we need you to help us do it.
00:36:06 So we refuse to accept government funding, which, by the way, is another way that the federal government uses money through Heritage Canada to control what we read and what we ultimately think.
00:36:21 So we don't take that funding because we don't want to be beholden to Ottawa.
00:36:26 We rely on people like you to support independent journalism by choice.
00:36:32 So please, if you are not already a member of the Western Standard, become a member.
00:36:39 Get unlimited access.
00:36:41 It's a real thief-in-the-night deal.
00:36:43 It's $10 a month.
00:36:44 It's $100 a year.
00:36:46 I think I'm right with the numbers.
00:36:48 But if we're not, we have a charming young woman who will be pleased to receive your call or handle your email.
00:36:55 Take your money.
00:36:56 and make sure she doesn't charge you too much so ladies and gentlemen thank you for being with us
00:37:01 this evening it's been a pleasure to have you watching and you gentlemen talking so that's it
00:37:08 for the western standard i'm nigel hannaford the current lethbridge feed grain prices are as
00:37:14 follows cash barley is flat at 412 feed wheat is lower two dollars at 410 and corn steady at 415
00:37:22 dollars per ton in the milling wheat markets may minneapolis futures are down seven and three
00:37:27 quarter cents at 8.38 with local heart rate spring bid for april movement at ten dollars
00:37:32 forty cents per bushel in the oil seeds nearby canola futures lost eight dollars fifty cents
00:37:38 at seven hundred twenty dollars ninety cents per ton with delivered values for april movement at
00:37:44 sixteen dollars twelve cents per bushel in the pulse markets nearby red lentil prices are steady
00:37:49 at 32 and a half cents per pound yellow peas remain at 12.50 cents per bushel in the cattle
00:37:56 markets april live cattle dipped 75 cents at 161 dollars 67 and a half cents per hundred weight
00:38:04 i'm david lee at marketplace commodities accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options
00:38:11 canadian shooting sports association without the cssa our gun rights would have been taken 0.99
00:38:16 Long, long ago, these guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:38:25 And more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:38:30 To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:38:35 You can become a Western Standard member for just $10 a month or $99 a year for unlimited...