Western Standard - May 16, 2026


THE PIPELINE: When the ethnic vote votes ethnic

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Once, we did immigration right – and we can do it right again HANNAFORD: Once, we did immigration right – and we can do it right again

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

161.33

Word count

7,885

Sentence count

346

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

32

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, we discuss Alberta's carbon tax deal with the federal government, the rise of the far-right in Canada, and the growing problem of ethnic politics in Canadian politics. Plus, a look at how ethnic politics is playing a key role in Canada's political system.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:27 Today is May 13th, 2026, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:31 I've got our normal crew of misfits here, our former opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:37 Former because I'm a misfit, I guess.
00:00:40 Nah, you retire. 0.99
00:00:41 I'm still here because you're a misfit. 0.99
00:00:43 Yeah, that's too fit. 0.98
00:00:46 Senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:47 And news editor, Dave Naylor. 0.86
00:00:51 Head misfit. 1.00
00:00:52 Head mistress.
00:00:53 all right you know sometimes it kind of fits with the business right uh we are going to talk
00:01:00 about uh alberta's big carbon tax sellout uh confirmed today that uh the alberta ucp government
00:01:10 has agreed to pay a carbon tax of 130 per metric time getting to that by 2040 in exchange for well
00:01:21 We'll get the details of it tomorrow, unless it leaks out earlier,
00:01:24 but we'll get the details at least officially tomorrow.
00:01:26 Friday.
00:01:28 Oh, yes, Friday, not tomorrow.
00:01:29 I'm ahead of myself.
00:01:31 But Friday at a press conference between Daniel Smith,
00:01:34 Premier Daniel Smith and Prime Minister Mark Carney,
00:01:37 where I guess there'll be some kind of announcements of a pipeline
00:01:41 or towards pipelines.
00:01:42 We'll see.
00:01:44 But either way, Alberta has had to sell the farm to get this.
00:01:47 So we'll talk about it.
00:01:48 um the canada haters are rallying to save canada from alberta the only uh the only thing that
00:01:58 canada haters hate more than canada it seems is alberta uh efforts by some in the foreign-owned
00:02:07 and eastern-owned uh mainstream media press to paint every every alberta independent supporter
00:02:15 as a hater of Canada while conveniently overlooking the people who genuinely hate Canada, people who
00:02:21 topple statues of our founders, people who change the lyrics of O Canada, people who denigrate the
00:02:27 military, that kind of thing. So we're going to get into kind of the hypocrisy around that.
00:02:31 But first, what happens when the ethnic vote votes ethnic? We've had, it's a thing not just
00:02:42 in Canada or Alberta. It's really
00:02:44 everywhere in the Western world that has
00:02:45 mass migration. You get
00:02:47 kind of balkanized
00:02:49 pockets of
00:02:51 people from different ethnicities
00:02:54 and they'll
00:02:56 often vote, normally vote
00:02:58 for someone of their own ethnicity
00:02:59 once they reach a critical mass
00:03:02 of the voting public.
00:03:05 But there's a very interesting
00:03:06 case we want to zero in on
00:03:08 from Ontario, I think Scarborough
00:03:10 in the GTA
00:03:11 where Nate Erskine-Smith, he is a Liberal member of Parliament,
00:03:17 and he's trying to become a Liberal member of the Ontario Parliament
00:03:19 because he's seeking the leadership of the Ontario Liberal Party.
00:03:23 He has spent his entire political career supporting open border,
00:03:27 virtually unlimited mass migration, Dave.
00:03:30 There's video clips of him going back a decade
00:03:33 and a mile long of him pandering to that local ethnic community,
00:03:38 which is Bangladeshi primarily.
00:03:41 And I guess he was expecting a little gratitude for the support he's given them.
00:03:47 And it didn't pan out so well when he was running for the Liberal nomination, which is kind of a precursor for him to become Ontario Liberal leader, right? 0.99
00:03:53 Yeah, be careful what you do in case it comes back and bites you on the ass, I guess is the way to look at it. 0.96
00:03:59 But yeah, he, in the nomination race for Scarborough, he lost to a gentleman called Ashanal Hafiz, who is a local Bangladeshi businessman, owns 15 Domino's pizza outlets. 0.99
00:04:15 And he lost, Erskine Smith lost by 19 votes.
00:04:21 And it was just, it looked like a mess.
00:04:24 I mean, it looked like Northeast Calgary politics at its worst. 0.78
00:04:28 They were handing out Bangladeshi voting cards and telling them, you know, basically having these people.
00:04:35 I don't mean these people like that, but not in a Don Cherry way.
00:04:40 But, you know, he got the Bangladeshi community motivated and they came out and supported their Bangladeshi client, you know, or candidate.
00:04:52 So, yeah, Liberals all for mass migration, but now it's turning into, you know, 0.98
00:04:57 hey, we can't even get elected in Toronto right now because of the ethnic group. 0.94
00:05:02 And apparently he doesn't speak very good English.
00:05:04 So I'm sure he'll be a worthwhile member of the Ontario Parliament.
00:05:10 I think there's a good headline in there about the dominoes falling or something along those lines. 0.74
00:05:17 Corey, you know how ethnic politics works.
00:05:23 We've got our pockets here in Alberta.
00:05:25 Northeast Calgary is one spot.
00:05:27 Southwest Edmonton is another.
00:05:30 And those enclaves continue to grow into other quadrants of both cities,
00:05:34 even areas outside of both cities increasingly.
00:05:38 And all parties play this game.
00:05:41 The Conservatives are absolutely no better on this.
00:05:45 you know conservatives
00:05:48 often
00:05:49 Doug Ford just the other week saying
00:05:52 hey I wish I could snap my fingers
00:05:53 and you could all stay and then become
00:05:56 citizens. Everyone plays
00:05:58 this game. I think the liberals probably play
00:06:00 it. They probably lean into it the hardest
00:06:02 but the conservatives do it
00:06:04 pretty well. They don't get any pass
00:06:06 on this kind of thing
00:06:07 but the assumption
00:06:10 has generally been
00:06:11 you're
00:06:14 going to support the politician
00:06:16 that lets you in. Our party
00:06:18 has been in power for 10 years.
00:06:20 We let you guys in. We let your cousins
00:06:22 and your uncles and your grandparents
00:06:24 and all of these people in, and we've
00:06:26 provided generous benefits.
00:06:28 I'm such a good guy. I show up to
00:06:30 the cultural events. I put on the costume.
00:06:32 I do the dance. I eat the food.
00:06:35 And they expect an electoral reward
00:06:38 for that. Well, they might still be willing to vote for the party,
00:06:40 but they still want their
00:06:42 guy in.
00:06:44 And that seems to be the lesson of Nadir Smith here.
00:06:50 His campaign put out a video detailing what it sounds pretty fraudulent,
00:06:54 but none of it sounds surprising.
00:06:55 You know, they got people voting without proper ID.
00:06:59 They're like the flimsiest of stuff that they're allowing to take place.
00:07:03 Sounds like people got to vote more than once.
00:07:05 It sounds totally fraudulent.
00:07:07 But it's kind of a, what else did you expect when you're playing? 0.53
00:07:12 This is Tammany Hall politics.
00:07:14 just in 2026. What else did you expect?
00:07:17 Yeah, well, the ethnic 1.00
00:07:19 game is totally different, as we've all 1.00
00:07:21 suffered through it. I'll just kind of quickly go back
00:07:22 to a past story. We had a nomination
00:07:24 in Northeast Calgary with the Wildrose Party
00:07:26 when it was up and coming. We had five people,
00:07:29 four people running in it. Three were
00:07:31 of ethnic minorities and one wasn't.
00:07:33 The three who were running
00:07:34 immediately submitted thousands
00:07:36 and thousands of brand new memberships, and
00:07:38 we quickly determined that
00:07:40 actually all three had sold to the exact same
00:07:42 group members over and over the duplicates were out of control so our executive director actually
00:07:49 went door knocking and documenting and checking on these we had households with supposedly 20
00:07:52 people in them uh things like that and we disqualified all three of the others and kept
00:07:57 the white guy i tell you the backlash looked awful but what are you supposed to do they play politics
00:08:02 differently in blocks and they play the nomination game heavily so on the liberals what looks good
00:08:08 on you. You backer towards it. You didn't put in the controls and you learned another hard lesson.
00:08:15 It's also a symptom though, I think of not having good policies of multiculturalism. But when these
00:08:20 blocks and these enclaves are starting to turn so predominant for one group or another group or
00:08:25 another, we're going to see more of that, whether it's conservative or liberal, because you don't
00:08:28 play based on policy any longer. You've got to play based on finding community leadership and
00:08:33 whatever that particular ethnicity that dominates a riding is. And I don't think it's healthy for
00:08:38 Canada democracy, but we're just
00:08:40 seeing it starkly with the Liberals now, having it
00:08:42 happen to them, and we're going to see
00:08:44 more. So, a ton of
00:08:46 people voting in this,
00:08:48 it's claimed, were not citizens,
00:08:50 which is allowed under the Liberal Party, but
00:08:52 many of them were even temporary foreign workers,
00:08:54 like they're not even permanent residents.
00:08:57 But the Conservatives really
00:08:58 can't get on their high horse here. The Conservatives
00:09:00 don't, at least officially, allow temporary
00:09:02 foreign workers to vote, but
00:09:04 the Conservative Party voted against
00:09:06 limiting membership and therefore voting in the Conservative Party federally
00:09:10 to Canadian citizens at their most recent convention here in Calgary. The Conservatives
00:09:14 voted against it. So they've got, they don't really have any
00:09:18 horse to stand on here themselves. But I think
00:09:22 one of the lessons here is, I don't know how to put it,
00:09:26 in a way that's not going to get me in trouble, so I'm just going to get in at least some trouble
00:09:30 here. I'll have to discipline myself. You know, regular
00:09:34 Proviso, not all migrants are cheats and engage in Tammany Hall-style dirty politics, but a lot do. 1.00
00:09:43 If you import people from the third world, you cannot act surprised and shocked when you get third world politics. 0.99
00:09:52 Some people do leave that behind, and they want nothing to do with it here, but a lot don't. 0.90
00:09:58 These are multi-generational habits.
00:10:00 Democracy is not just the flip of the switch.
00:10:03 You know, everyone sounds nice on paper, but it's a culture. It's a practice. It's something that often takes generations to be truly inculcated with.
00:10:14 And then there's the other side, which is where I probably get in more trouble for saying that every other group in the world plays tribal politics.
00:10:26 In the West, white people, we've generally been told that's a bad thing. We don't play tribal politics.
00:10:33 we're colorblind you know a brown guy could represent a white riding an asian guy could
00:10:38 represent a black riding and none of it should matter because it's you know we're not playing
00:10:44 tribal politics but the fact is that is a uniquely european idea among european descended peoples 0.89
00:10:53 that we don't do that the rest of the world didn't get the memo so nader skin smith uh you know
00:11:02 Now, color him surprise, no pun intended, that his opponent showed up playing tribal politics. 0.78
00:11:12 I don't know where this leads.
00:11:14 I don't know how we get other groups to stop playing tribal politics without eventually everybody playing tribal politics.
00:11:21 And when we get to that, that's a bad spot to meet.
00:11:23 look this this is the triumph of everything that the liberals have done since pierre trudeau
00:11:28 uh father of the father of the unfortunate justin trudeau's first started opening
00:11:36 immigration offices in non-traditional areas back in 1967. they have always tried to play the race
00:11:44 card play the cultural card in order to weaken conservative holdings we go back to the 1970s
00:11:50 when joe volpe prominent liberal mp at the time uh basically stole the the uh ridings along the
00:11:59 the shore of the lake there by importing portuguese immigrants and eventually they managed
00:12:05 to get the the the majorities that they needed he was italian okay well he was but if they use the
00:12:13 portuguese immigrants so uh you know like everything they have done has been to expand
00:12:19 the influence of immigrants at the expense of the conservatives. Lord knows Jason Kenney did a 0.99
00:12:26 hell of a fine job trying to reverse that for the time that he was in office. You know,
00:12:31 Mr. Curry in a hurry was the joke around the hill, but, you know, it didn't stick.
00:12:37 So what do we got? We are now seeing the start of the full flowering of all of those policies
00:12:44 over a period of some 60 years and you get somebody like erskine smith who by the way
00:12:50 is not a particularly sympathetic character for people like us i'd say no more and i went through
00:12:57 the how many stages of grief is it five i you know three seconds i was done and so uh so there you are
00:13:06 the thing is this is a little bit unique in the sense that after the war we had a lot of ethnic
00:13:13 communities from europe displaced dps displaced persons uh coming here germans austrians italians
00:13:22 they didn't get into politics they showed up they got the job they did it uh took the paycheck went
00:13:29 home to their families what's different is that the uh this particular group of uh immigrants from
00:13:36 bangladesh and others like them do get into uh into politics because they have actually bought
00:13:43 the package they think that this is a good thing this is how you get influence this is how you make 0.99
00:13:47 things happen so let's play the game it's just that they play dirty uh you know i i forgot we
00:13:54 should have shown it earlier let's we got to show that picture uh someone captured this picture was
00:13:58 on social media and it really just it captioned both nade erskine smith's and perhaps the liberal
00:14:04 party maybe even western civilizations uh predicament here perfectly it's uh you'll see
00:14:11 it's it's nate walking out of the hall the building where the nomination was held there's
00:14:16 trash all over the ground it doesn't look like a first world country it's gloomy out in the
00:14:23 distance that he's walking to and there is a with the canadian flag flying there's the weird uh 0.99
00:14:30 trans pride
00:14:32 progress flag
00:14:35 flying at the same time.
00:14:36 Whoever captured that photo, I don't know
00:14:38 if that was intentionally meant, but
00:14:40 it's almost like a
00:14:42 renaissance painting in its significance
00:14:45 and the symbolism
00:14:47 captured right there.
00:14:49 I'll tell you one thing, Derek, I bet it wasn't 1.00
00:14:50 the Bangladeshi community 1.00
00:14:53 who put the trans flag there.
00:14:55 No! 1.00
00:14:57 I think that's a fair...
00:14:59 uh you might be prejudging things here but i think it's probably a fair prejudgment uh yeah you know
00:15:06 the thing is i would actually maybe i'm just being very very british about this but i would rather
00:15:12 have somebody like shoach majunder or javan divani who are respectively of salvation origin and
00:15:20 jamaican origin who are true conservatives i would rather have them representing me in ottawa
00:15:28 then i would have somebody uh who is of the same persuasion as mr eskin smith who has totally
00:15:36 on conservative ideas and is actually part of the problem of how this country is going down
00:15:43 to the point we can come out of a nomination meet and seal trash on the ground on a trans flag 0.86
00:15:48 that's give me the give me the guy with the right ideas every time yeah but as we're quickly 0.64
00:15:56 discovering though uh the rest of the world didn't stop playing tribal politics just because
00:16:02 you know we kind of collectively decided as european societies some did break out i guess
00:16:07 you could see like shoo he's in calgary heritage i think isn't it i mean he's not going to get a
00:16:11 block of south asian voters that's not an ethnic right he's he's won it based on his own merit and
00:16:16 campaigning and uh he's a very popular member of parliament down there so we can we can break out
00:16:20 of that that that thing and to be fair i think if shoo ran in northeast calgary he would probably
00:16:25 collect some of your support based on your your ethnic community but but you've won a non non-ethnic
00:16:32 writing yes i said you want to oh he's actually harper's right yeah it was harper's old writing
00:16:36 preston manning's writing at one point um for lack of a better term he wanted a white rotting
00:16:41 based on values you know people like what he stood for he won the nomination he won the general
00:16:45 bunch of people like us voted for him yeah yeah uh but i don't think uh even if we shared the values
00:16:53 I think it's highly improbable
00:16:54 any one of the four of us at this table
00:16:56 would get elected in Northeast Calgary.
00:17:00 I'm willing to say that
00:17:01 with a fair bit of confidence.
00:17:02 Well, part of the way that game works is if we did,
00:17:04 it would mean we would have had to get some endorsement
00:17:06 from some community leaders in those ethnic...
00:17:09 It gets into that whole intricacy
00:17:11 of Northeast Calgary politics.
00:17:12 Yeah, we would owe them a favor.
00:17:14 It would have been the last one.
00:17:17 And you know, I know some people
00:17:19 are going to watch this and they're going to try
00:17:20 and play it back to us at some point,
00:17:21 and lord it over us, and I'm not going to say
00:17:23 this is so awful, how can you be saying it?
00:17:27 Maybe some know
00:17:27 nothings will not know better, but
00:17:29 political operatives in left-wing
00:17:32 parties, you might condemn us
00:17:34 for saying this, but you know what we're
00:17:35 saying is true. You play
00:17:38 these games, you know it's true,
00:17:40 you know that this is just
00:17:42 the way it works. So,
00:17:44 save us the
00:17:45 self-righteous condemnation
00:17:47 when it comes for saying the truth
00:17:50 out loud that
00:17:50 You know, until very recently, people only said in hushed tones.
00:17:57 Okay, well, I mean, that's a sort of...
00:18:00 Derek's never said anything in hushed tones, has he?
00:18:03 Never.
00:18:05 Touche.
00:18:07 All right.
00:18:08 Fairly decent segue then, I think, into our next segment here.
00:18:16 The Canada haters rallying to save Canada against Alberta.
00:18:19 so I don't mean to pick on him
00:18:21 he's actually a decent writer
00:18:22 I don't often agree with him
00:18:24 but the Calgary Herald's Don Braid
00:18:26 wrote in his column
00:18:29 the Alberta independence people
00:18:31 hate Canada
00:18:32 they have to show hatred and contempt for Canada
00:18:35 he quotes some people
00:18:36 saying
00:18:38 I don't think anything really hate
00:18:40 I don't know how in front of me
00:18:41 an independent Alberta would probably seek
00:18:44 American recognition
00:18:45 which I don't know any country in the world
00:18:47 seeking independence, seeks American
00:18:49 recognition, all the more so one that
00:18:51 borders it. I don't know
00:18:53 how that's a newsy thing, but he says,
00:18:55 you know, these people hate Canada.
00:18:57 They have hatred and contempt for Canada.
00:19:02 Okay.
00:19:03 Oh, no. Anyway.
00:19:05 And that got me thinking,
00:19:07 Nigel.
00:19:09 The Canada haters.
00:19:11 I'm sure there are a few, but
00:19:13 it's a vanishingly small number.
00:19:15 When I think of Canada haters,
00:19:17 I think of people who toppled the statues of Sir John M. Macdonald.
00:19:20 I think of the people who changed the lyrics of Old Canada to make it gender-neutral and politically correct.
00:19:25 I think of the people who either cheered or stood by as 112 churches were burned to the ground or significantly vandalized. 0.54
00:19:32 I think of the people who kneel ritualistically for Black Lives Matter,
00:19:37 people who lowered the flag on Parliament Hill for five months, 0.66
00:19:40 people who put down the history of Canada as a genocidal state founded on stolen native land.
00:19:48 When I think of Canada haters, those are the people I'm thinking of,
00:19:52 not people who, for the most part, have been patriotic Canadians their whole life.
00:19:58 They might be born in Alberta or born elsewhere, love Canada, love what it stood for.
00:20:04 They don't hate Canada, at least as they were born into,
00:20:07 but they might hate what canada has become and what canada is becoming well i've had 50 years
00:20:12 plus to observe the difference between canada that was and the canada that it has become and so i can
00:20:19 100 uh see where you're coming from that on uh derek and actually agree with you um you know
00:20:27 people are always going to put the best go into a back room well what are we going to say now
00:20:32 obviously somebody like mr nenshi a one-time mayor of calvary now a leader of the oppositions well
00:20:39 how are we going to fight daniel smith on this one well we'll be very pro-canadian well this is
00:20:43 the same guy who tried to take one of the canada day celebrations and then turn it into a provincial
00:20:49 lament for all the sins of racism colonialism i don't know there was a long list i mean he didn't
00:20:57 want to do canada day he wanted to he wanted to make it a day of protest so when you got people
00:21:01 like that you have to wonder about the sincerity of it and you know because this came up i ended up
00:21:08 looking around uh to see where where we were going with this and um you know there's something
00:21:16 on facebook i'm sorry instagram from one court ellingson he's a an mla and this is the kind of
00:21:25 ndp oh yeah very ndp so he says a few weeks ago this would be last week a few weeks ago
00:21:31 the Alberta NDP organized a day of action to fight against the Alberta separation.
00:21:36 Here's what they got. 75 people in Calgary and 200 people across our province showed up on a
00:21:45 snowy April day to talk to neighbors about why Alberta is better leading Canada than leaving it.
00:21:52 After all the sound and fury and all, frankly, the BS, they managed to get, according to this
00:22:00 individual 275 people out so i don't think the tide is flowing their way because i think the
00:22:07 what derek has just said about who it is who actually really hates canada and the kind of
00:22:14 things that the ways that they choose to express it don't fit well in alberta um yeah sure go on
00:22:25 take it from there but dave um you know i i uh i wrote a column on this and you know i kind of
00:22:33 very broadly try to put alberta nationalists in two camps one is probably disproportionately
00:22:39 alberta born uh that understands the very long history of alberta struggle with ottawa
00:22:45 structural constitutional issues going back forever um all of these things and that's one
00:22:53 group and the other one i called redoubt uh canadians they're and my guess is they probably
00:23:00 come disproportionately from other provinces uh because those other provinces are going to hell
00:23:04 and they came to alberta for an opportunity they come to alberta because of what it stands for um
00:23:11 and they're they're not anti-canadian at all they they're patriotic canadians but they see that
00:23:17 canada has gone to hell and it's continuing to go further down into hell and there does not appear to
00:23:23 be any real sign that that is being reversed right now. And so the idea is that you're actually able
00:23:32 to save a slice of Canada by leaving it, essentially. The rest of Canada is irreversibly,
00:23:40 I think it's roughly 125, 127% debt to GDP, $4 trillion of debt. These things are never,
00:23:48 ever getting paid by us, our children
00:23:50 or even our grandchildren
00:23:51 context, we're still literally
00:23:54 paying debt taken out by
00:23:56 Pierre Trudeau before I was
00:23:58 even born
00:23:59 the idea is to save a piece
00:24:02 of Canada, save Canada
00:24:04 by saving at least a little piece of it
00:24:06 I don't see this being
00:24:10 a deeply anti-Canadian movement
00:24:12 the way they say that even Quebec would be
00:24:14 I'm not even sure Quebec is necessarily anti-Canadian
00:24:16 it just wants to be its own thing
00:24:17 um i don't know you used used to work with these guys uh what plan are they living on thinking that
00:24:24 this somehow canada hate fest well you gotta you gotta remember dawn who like consider a friend
00:24:31 is very left-wing very left-wing uh uh writer has been for for decades but but just look i mean the
00:24:38 facts tell the story people are moving to alberta en masse uh people thousands of people from bc
00:24:44 are fleeing the wacky government of david eby uh thousands of people are leaving uh ontario
00:24:50 uh wacky government of uh doug ford and where are they going to go into alberta which is causing
00:24:56 stresses for us in terms of education and school building and getting enough teachers and stuff
00:25:01 like that but i don't think all the people coming here are coming here as okay albert is going to
00:25:07 separate let's go to alberta you know they're coming here you know to try and get the best
00:25:13 quality of life for their families and uh you know i'm sure some of them would probably vote
00:25:19 for independence but i think most of them would still be happily canadian or happily say they're
00:25:24 canadian um all right okay uh corey um the um it makes for i mean neither the the nationalist
00:25:39 camp or the Federalist camp are homogenous,
00:25:41 as you and I well know.
00:25:44 We can't agree on much really often,
00:25:47 even within the Nationalist camp.
00:25:49 But the Federalists,
00:25:51 there's odd
00:25:53 bedfellows. I mean,
00:25:55 give the devil
00:25:57 his due here.
00:25:59 Jay Zkenny, I don't consider to be a
00:26:01 Canada hater. He's Canada first,
00:26:03 not Alberta first. 0.88
00:26:04 And that's a legitimate position to take.
00:26:06 That's fine. That's his choice.
00:26:09 But he's not a Canada hater, but he has to share a campaign and a stage, essentially, here with people who do hate Canada or at least demonstrate contempt for it.
00:26:21 Yeah. You know, you've got, you know, depending on the poll we look at, we'll say 35% of Albertans support independence, 30% at the low end, 38% at the high end, depending on the polls you're looking at.
00:26:34 We'll say 35% split the difference here.
00:26:39 So among the roughly two-thirds that are currently opposed to independence, a majority of those are on the left, and they're backing parties that stood by as churches were burned down.
00:26:50 They vote for politicians that wanted to change Canada Day from a celebration of Canada into a ritualistic self-flagellation of national guilt, voted for politicians that kept the flag at half-mast for five months for a genocidal hoax.
00:27:09 I don't know, maybe I'd like your thoughts on how can those people now drape themselves in the flag as the patriotic defenders of Canada when two, three years ago, they were calling Canada an illegitimate settler colonial slave state founded on stolen native land.
00:27:33 It's hypocrisy and a purposeful cognitive dissonance.
00:27:37 You know, I like stirring things up.
00:27:39 When I'd get bored on X, if I just wanted to get things worked up,
00:27:41 and that still works now.
00:27:43 I've posted that about five times over the years.
00:27:45 I just, a simple, Canada is not a genocidal country.
00:27:49 And the hornet's nest is poked.
00:27:51 I'm a racist. 0.93
00:27:52 I'm a denier.
00:27:54 I am, you name it, this and that.
00:27:56 The people who get so upset for me daring just to say that the country isn't genocidal.
00:28:02 their idea of where we're supposed to be sitting and where we're supposed to be thinking is we're
00:28:05 always staring at our shoes. Canada is an awful place that did terrible things that probably
00:28:09 shouldn't exist. It's a post-national state. We're settlers, we're colonialists. And then when we see 0.84
00:28:15 independence movements blossoming on each side of the country, all I had tried to ask these guys,
00:28:21 what the hell did you think was going to happen? You've been undercutting any sense of pride or
00:28:26 identity or unity in this country for years. And lo and behold, some people said, well,
00:28:31 I'm not about to stand up and hand it all off to the indigenous bands, 0.98
00:28:34 but I don't feel any connection to this god awful state. So yes, 1.00
00:28:37 I won't feel bad for a second saying, you know what?
00:28:39 I might embrace an independence movement because you guys told me this country
00:28:42 is not worth saving anyways. So yes,
00:28:45 it's not helping them when they suddenly have cloaked themselves in this flag
00:28:47 that they were so recently burning and pissing on. And I got no use for them.
00:28:51 As Samuel Johnson said two centuries ago,
00:28:54 patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.
00:28:57 He was of course speaking of the Americans, but it applies equally.
00:29:01 today? Well, I think it's contextual. I think the scoundrel can rely on patriotism to cloak
00:29:10 his actions. But I would reject that patriotism is a negative thing to begin with. I believe in
00:29:18 nationalism. I believe patriotism. It is often a force for good. But people doing bad, you can
00:29:24 fall back and you use it as a cloak. That's exactly what Johnson was talking about. People
00:29:29 with dishonest or selfish motives
00:29:31 will often use patriotic fervor
00:29:34 to cover their tracks.
00:29:35 It's a tried and true method.
00:29:37 Yeah, you know, I guess
00:29:39 it doesn't need to be said,
00:29:41 but I'll say it anyway, to be fair.
00:29:43 Not everyone in the Federalist camp 0.97
00:29:45 is a hypocrite here. 0.71
00:29:47 Not everyone in the Federalist camp is a hater. 1.00
00:29:49 That would be less ridiculous
00:29:51 than I think what Don Braid was arguing 0.82
00:29:54 that the Alberta nationalists hate Canada.
00:29:56 There's just not particularly
00:29:58 much evidence to support that.
00:29:59 You know, there are plenty of people in the federalist camp who are not self-loathing, self-flagellating, who think Canada is an illegitimate state.
00:30:10 But what I am saying is it makes for awkward bedfellows when your goal is to save Canada.
00:30:18 I'm not sure what Canada they're trying to save.
00:30:20 It seems to me that the Canada I was born into was just long gone.
00:30:23 Let me just say this. What I notice about the people who I encounter in the Alberta independence
00:30:31 movement is that there isn't some culture or language that binds them together, as would be
00:30:37 the case with Quebec. It is a set of values that they hold and all seem to hold, which is
00:30:47 where we entered this discussion, talking about the people who say they're patriots
00:30:53 for Canada are the ones who have said everything about Canada is wrong, but those things that they
00:30:58 say about Canada being wrong are the things that Alberta patriots, if I can use that expression,
00:31:05 they're the ones they're trying to hold on to. Fair play, decency, parliamentary democracy.
00:31:13 They're rejecting the socialists.
00:31:16 Okay. We got a nice flow. One topic's actually going to another fairly well today.
00:31:23 We're going to talk about Alberta's carbon tax sell-out.
00:31:29 So in November, I think it was the day before the UCP convention,
00:31:33 Daniel Smith and Mark Carney signed an MOU,
00:31:36 Memorandum of Understanding,
00:31:38 about working together if some give and take on environmental policy
00:31:42 in exchange for fixing the situation around pipelines
00:31:46 and possibly tanker access on the West Coast and things like that.
00:31:50 um i had a pretty open mind to it cory um i was actually shocked when we you know we all showed
00:31:58 up to the ucp convention covering that there and i uh in a very awkward moment found myself to be
00:32:04 the squishy moderate in the room most people were were very much opposed to it but i said
00:32:09 you know i mean we should encourage the premier to make a good faith effort
00:32:15 on these files
00:32:18 I mean it's just an MOU
00:32:19 let's see how it goes
00:32:21 negotiating good faith
00:32:23 maybe she can make some progress 0.99
00:32:24 but I mean she can't sell the farm to do it 0.98
00:32:27 this Friday 0.99
00:32:30 there's going to be a press conference
00:32:33 I believe here in Calgary
00:32:34 that's what we understand
00:32:35 we'll be covering that live
00:32:38 where I guess
00:32:40 the results of this will be put forward
00:32:42 we don't yet know
00:32:44 is there going to be a pipeline built
00:32:45 Is it just fixing the process to potentially get to a pipeline? I don't know.
00:32:50 One thing we do know that's come out early is that the Alberta government has now signed on the dotted line.
00:32:57 It's agreed firm that Alberta will agree to increasing the industrial carbon tax to $130 per metric ton, elevating up to into 2040.
00:33:08 Corey, I went into this with an open mind
00:33:15 I took some guff for being too soft
00:33:18 which is a pretty rare thing for me to have to take
00:33:21 but I don't think it was wrong to keep an open mind
00:33:26 but I think we know enough now
00:33:29 Alberta has now agreed to completely capitulate
00:33:32 on the carbon tax and we are going to accept the legitimacy
00:33:35 policy, Ottawa dictating our own internal environmental policies. To me, this looks
00:33:41 like a total salad. Yeah, I'm not going to celebrate this. I understand in the role of
00:33:46 Premier, your job isn't to walk right into a room with the Prime Minister and just give him the
00:33:50 finger right off the bat. You know, okay, well, let's see what we can do to potentially find
00:33:54 mutually beneficial agreements for the country and for the province. But the carbon tax, I mean,
00:33:59 come on, we've talked about this for a decade. It doesn't do a damn thing to save the environment.
00:34:04 it never will, it's a tax. That's all it is, is something Premier Smith has always been very
00:34:08 clear about, whether it's the consumer one or the industrial one, and it puts Canada at a
00:34:14 disadvantage around the world in trying to sell its products. Now, it puts Alberta at a disadvantage.
00:34:21 The baloney we're seeing from guys like Corey Hogan, you know, that lone liberal MP, 0.99
00:34:26 talking like the rest of the world is demanding decarbonized oil, this fictional imaginary crap. 0.99
00:34:34 No, they aren't. And in fact, Canada isn't demanding it as they get Venezuelan, Russian, 0.85
00:34:38 Saudi Arabian, and every other tanker to the East Coast they could possibly can get. But Alberta is
00:34:43 the one and only beacon that apparently has to decarbonize its oil. She capitulated. I think she
00:34:50 should have told him to go to hell. It'll be interesting to see on Friday. I imagine they got 0.99
00:34:54 something else, but let's see where this proponent is then. Do you have a proponent? Have you got
00:34:58 rid of the tanker ban? Have you said that the indigenous don't have a veto? There's a whole
00:35:02 lot more things i expect out of this if you're going to call it a victory so maybe she's letting
00:35:07 something out and has a big announcement coming i don't know but i gotta see there there is
00:35:11 reporting now coming out of ottawa that uh prime minister carney will declare this a project of
00:35:16 national interest which basically means the indigenous lose all their rights to complain
00:35:21 and bitch and block it but that's what in theory is going to happen but what's going to it's going 0.82
00:35:26 unleash a tidal wave of protests uh and we're going to have uh highways blocked and uh railways 0.98
00:35:33 blocked and uh but but you know hopefully at the same time it's getting built but uh you know
00:35:39 obviously still years away from uh uh being constructed and and and completed so the whole
00:35:47 thing about the uh you know the shipping bans and and whatnot can be dealt with at a bit of a later
00:35:53 time because because nobody's going to invest a nickel that's true unless they know what's gone
00:35:58 that's that's that chicken and egg game that's been great though now that would be a relatively
00:36:02 easy thing for him to do now and say look we're making progress you know we've got rid of the
00:36:06 plankton there are no pipelines we've eliminated that legislation yeah you've still got the
00:36:12 promises you have hinted at to the indigenous peoples to deal with but the things that we could 0.93
00:36:17 do now that we could do easily we're doing so this is the way it's gonna we don't see that 0.98
00:36:22 Yeah, well, Nigel, even if, let's say it's, there's a bunch of victories on those fronts, the West Coast thinker band gone, it's a project of national importance, all of these things.
00:36:37 I know, and it looks likely, okay, we could get a pipeline of this. I don't care if we get a dozen pipelines or if they build them to the moon. Alberta will have signed away its sovereignty.
00:36:47 What happened to, you know, Premier Danielle Smith has said she's not backing independence for Alberta.
00:36:54 She's backing a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada.
00:36:57 This doesn't sound like a sovereign Alberta.
00:37:00 The carbon tax is a matter for Alberta to decide.
00:37:04 This is an Alberta carbon tax, yet it's being dictated in terms of these negotiations to buy Ottawa.
00:37:10 That doesn't sound like a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada to me.
00:37:13 No, and you know, if I were Danielle, I don't know whether I'd be doing that.
00:37:17 But I have to go back to where Corey started in this segment
00:37:22 when he said she can't go in there with boxing gloves
00:37:26 and you've got to try to make it look like you're working along.
00:37:31 But she really has the world against her on this one
00:37:34 for all the reasons we've just talked about.
00:37:36 The cost of burying carbon dioxide to make decarbonized oil
00:37:41 is going to put $50 a ton or two onto oil.
00:37:45 this is what they tell me about people who know more than I do $50 a ton and
00:37:50 you're gonna go out and try and sell this overseas what exactly you know how
00:37:54 long do you think the round war is gonna last it's this is not gonna work but she
00:37:59 goes in and says what she has to say I got a feeling that the thought may be by
00:38:04 2040 Carney will be gone somebody else will be in charge it is
00:38:11 inconceivable that the liberals should govern for another you know 14 years they've done it before
00:38:18 we'll get well that would be a 24-year run you're starting to get back into mckenzie king territory
00:38:23 but anyway you know this can't possibly last we've even what al gore saying like global warming which
00:38:29 is the foundation of all this is going to be replaced by global freezing i mean i don't know
00:38:35 who takes al gore seriously anymore but al gore is prepared to stake his reputation on being wrong
00:38:41 This, I think, is going to go away.
00:38:45 Meanwhile, as long as she's talking, the Western, you know, the Alberta independence crowd cannot use that as a wedge against her.
00:38:54 I don't know.
00:38:55 I do agree that she, you know, can't walk into a meeting with Carney and just punch him in the nose.
00:39:01 As good as that would all make us feel that is not what she should do, she should be negotiating in good faith.
00:39:10 The problem is she's negotiated us $130 a ton carbon tax.
00:39:16 And maybe Carney has gone by then.
00:39:18 Maybe he is replaced by a more radical liberal. 0.99
00:39:22 Maybe he's replaced by a crappy conservative. 0.75
00:39:26 Because many conservatives won't take a standing even against the industrial carbon tax. 0.94
00:39:31 They're going to hem and haw.
00:39:32 They don't want to rock the boat too much to win votes in central Canada.
00:39:37 So can we, I don't think we can rely one bit necessarily on the conservatives being committed to repealing the carbon tax.
00:39:43 Conservatives changed their mind about a bunch of things in the last two weeks of that last campaign when they thought it would maybe save the election for them.
00:39:49 Didn't.
00:39:51 So she has then agreed to the principle that Ottawa has legitimacy in dictating this to us.
00:40:02 That is a moral loss.
00:40:05 That is a loss on an important principle.
00:40:09 So, you know, yeah, it's 2040 is, I guess, a ways off.
00:40:16 Maybe Carney's gone by then.
00:40:17 Maybe things change, but I wouldn't bet on it.
00:40:20 I mean, we're still dealing with the disastrous policies of Justin Trudeau 10 years ago.
00:40:26 You can't really bet on this.
00:40:28 I think this is a strategic mistake.
00:40:31 I don't think it's going to appear.
00:40:32 I think this is,
00:40:34 Carney needs this to keep the Stephen Gilboa wing
00:40:36 of the Liberal Party in the tent,
00:40:40 keep the NDP down, keep the Greens down.
00:40:44 But this is, in Alberta,
00:40:47 I have a feeling that there's going to be a lot of people
00:40:50 on our side who are upset about this.
00:40:54 I think this should be on the ballot in October.
00:40:57 There should be a referendum question at this point.
00:40:59 We have five questions on constitutional reform,
00:41:03 which I generally more or less agree with,
00:41:06 but that are never going to go anywhere
00:41:07 because the rest of Canada will not say yes to it.
00:41:10 We've got, I think, four questions on immigration.
00:41:12 One's four, one's five.
00:41:14 That's fine.
00:41:15 And then probably independence as well.
00:41:18 Let's put this one on.
00:41:19 Let's see where Albertans stand on this.
00:41:22 Maybe I'm wrong,
00:41:24 but this is not a deal I think I would vote for.
00:41:27 so look i think that mr carney has an incentive to to at least appear to offer a pipeline because
00:41:37 if enough people believe that it's a real prospect that is going to subtract from the independence
00:41:45 movement so he is not totally unmotivated to do something good or at least appear to do
00:41:51 something good for daniel smith on friday that would have an impact now whether it's real
00:41:58 that's a whole different discussion for next week but um i wouldn't write it off just yet
00:42:05 all right all right uh party shots dave uh very disturbing video this week of uh gang of girls
00:42:14 and uh yeah we'll show some the video very disturbing uh uh poor girl in red deer beaten
00:42:22 senseless swarmed kicked in the head repeatedly elbowed in the face repeatedly and then when she 0.95
00:42:28 was unconscious she was dragged to a group of nearby trees and and dumped um disgusting behavior 1.00
00:42:36 our linda slobodian wrote about it today you know nothing's stopping these miscreant teens
00:42:41 uh nothing will stop because there's no justice no justice for them so uh rcmp under great
00:42:49 pressure to make some arrests i think it'll be quick but uh yeah go go and check out the video
00:42:54 because it really is really is disturbing you know i got to my share of scraps as a teenager
00:43:00 and uh we fought one-on-one and when someone lost it was over and if someone didn't stop
00:43:09 Your own friends dragged you off.
00:43:12 I forget even the law here.
00:43:15 Maybe there's just no code of how to have a proper scrap in high school anymore.
00:43:20 There's always going to be people fighting in high school.
00:43:22 It happens.
00:43:22 It's never going to go away.
00:43:24 But, yeah, there seems to be no common sense about how to have a proper scrap now.
00:43:29 No.
00:43:31 Corey?
00:43:32 So, I guess, due to good marketing and good branding,
00:43:35 Tim Horton's got practically a monopoly in the donut and coffee industry in Canada.
00:43:39 and then devolved into what I think was one of the most overrated institutions in the country.
00:43:44 So we're seeing that getting withered away with Dunkin' Donuts moving in
00:43:47 and some others moving into the country.
00:43:50 I'm just enjoying seeing competition come back.
00:43:52 And I just want to say, I miss Robin's Donuts.
00:43:54 I guess they still exist in other parts of the country,
00:43:57 but they aren't in Alberta anymore because they just couldn't compete against Tim Hortons.
00:44:02 Really? Just kind of took everything by wave.
00:44:03 But maybe we were reversing things.
00:44:05 I want to see some competition in the donut and coffee world.
00:44:07 so come on back Robbins
00:44:09 we missed you
00:44:10 so more work for temporary foreign workers
00:44:13 well you know
00:44:15 if you guys have a donut shop actually hired Canadians
00:44:17 that's a bigger debate
00:44:19 but I tell you as a serious industry owner
00:44:21 put out an ad and see how many show up for it
00:44:24 yeah fair enough
00:44:24 but yeah Tim Hortons really is
00:44:26 the Canadian healthcare of
00:44:29 food service delivery in Canada
00:44:31 it's something where we have no right
00:44:33 to be very proud of at this point
00:44:35 Nigel
00:44:36 Yeah, so I couldn't help noticing that story that we picked up out of Black Locks.
00:44:42 Black Locks does the research and puts it out, and we're happy to pass it on to everybody else.
00:44:48 But on World Press Freedom Day, Prime Minister Carney praised a strong, independent press.
00:44:55 What Black Locks revealed was that just about 10 days before,
00:44:59 officials in all of the most powerful ministries had got together,
00:45:03 and we're trying what they were trying to do is work out who's a real journalist who should be
00:45:07 allowed to go into it and i i'm just touting ahead i think we're going to put this out on
00:45:13 friday uh i did a little rap this morning because i was kind of mad so watch out for it on friday
00:45:19 talking about the hypocrisy of uh somebody who will stand up and say on one day that uh press
00:45:26 matters and freedom press freedom matters and meanwhile is trying to sort of ways find ways to
00:45:31 exclude people like us people like rebel news juno from being able to ask questions at government
00:45:38 meetings all right uh mine i've got uh call them up now uh we don't report on rumor here
00:45:47 but we ended up in a weird kind of twilight zone of information uh i've had some very good sources
00:45:54 tell me that alberta finance minister nate horner uh not sure the reasons around it but he'll be
00:46:01 stepping down or something to that effect
00:46:03 in the coming weeks
00:46:05 and he will be replaced as Alberta's
00:46:07 finance minister by Jason Nixon.
00:46:10 So I've got
00:46:11 pretty good sources telling me that.
00:46:13 But there's also pretty good sources in the government
00:46:15 who deny it to me.
00:46:17 And I've got other sources in the government who
00:46:19 deny it, but unconvincingly.
00:46:22 So
00:46:22 You read it here
00:46:25 first. You read it here first.
00:46:27 The column,
00:46:29 if you read it, you'll see. 0.97
00:46:30 i i i make i unambiguously hedge and try to cover my ass because i you can't this is not gospel you 0.57
00:46:37 can't take it to the bank because i've got official government sources denying it but i've also got 0.87
00:46:43 some pretty good sources in the government confirming it and then others who denied it
00:46:48 as i said very unconvincingly so uh take it for what it is if uh if you're put if this is on poly
00:46:57 bet. It's a good bet that
00:46:59 this is happening. Jason Nixon's going to be the next
00:47:01 finance minister of Alberta, and Nate Horner
00:47:03 is either retiring or moving out of a portfolio or
00:47:05 something. I don't know what's happening on that side.
00:47:09 It's probably a good bet
00:47:10 to roll the dice on, but
00:47:13 it's a roll of the dice. I hate
00:47:15 to have an unconfirmed story. We don't do
00:47:17 rumor, but in this case,
00:47:18 we're reporting what some
00:47:21 people confirm, and we're reporting
00:47:23 at the exact same time that others are denying it.
00:47:25 Such as it is.
00:47:27 so we'll see uh i think i'm right but we could have it i can have egg in my face time will tell
00:47:35 such is the world of political sometimes there it is yes okay dave cory nigel thank you thank you
00:47:42 john run in the studio and all of you who joined us uh give us your precious time today thank you
00:47:48 for your support if you're not yet a subscriber to the west standard and by subscriber i don't
00:47:52 me just getting our emails. I mean, you have a paid subscription for all access to Western
00:47:57 Standard content. Please go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe. It's $10 a month or $100 a
00:48:02 year to get unlimited access to Western Standard content and support the work we do. Thank you
00:48:08 very much for joining us today and God bless.
00:48:22 We'll be right back.