Western Standard - October 09, 2025


Time to SMASH the Alberta teachers’ strike

Topics
Mentioned
Alberta teachers get nothing from union during strike CORY MORGAN SHOW: Alberta needs less talk and more action from Premier Smith

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

166.62

Word count

7,889

Sentence count

394

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

24

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The usual suspects are back in studio to discuss a variety of topics, including: Ben Bankus' Canadian tour being cancelled for a joke, the Alberta Teachers Association's strike, and the UCP's deal with the teachers union.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day!
00:00:27 Today is October 8th, 2025.
00:00:29 I'm Derek Phil, the publisher of the Western Standard
00:00:31 And you're watching The Pipeline
00:00:33 I've got our usual
00:00:35 Crew of malcontents
00:00:37 On today, former Western Standard
00:00:39 Opinion Editor, Nigel Hannaford
00:00:41 Good evening
00:00:42 Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan
00:00:45 Always a pleasure
00:00:46 And Western Standard, British Columbia Columnist
00:00:49 Elise Mills
00:00:50 Thank you very much, it's a pleasure
00:00:53 Yes
00:00:54 Alright, well we got
00:00:58 It was a week where we didn't have any trouble figuring out what to talk about today.
00:01:04 Hasn't made a lot of news other than on our pages, but Canadian comedian Ben Bankus,
00:01:11 who's actually kind of made it semi-big time.
00:01:14 He's gotten all over the states and whatnot.
00:01:16 He's doing a Canadian tour, coming through.
00:01:19 I had booked some tickets, I think eight tickets for Western Standard Calgary staff
00:01:24 to go and see him when he came
00:01:25 and would perform at the
00:01:28 Grey Eagle Casino, and he got cancelled
00:01:30 for a joke. He posted
00:01:32 on Instagram and Twitter
00:01:34 to X on
00:01:36 National Shame Day,
00:01:39 which
00:01:40 Western Standard employees do not get off 1.00
00:01:42 unless they're caught surfing.
00:01:45 But, yeah,
00:01:46 a comedy show
00:01:48 cancelled for being offensive.
00:01:50 Remember when we talk about that?
00:01:51 um alberta premier daniel smith uh making a very interesting power play um kind of colin
00:02:01 mark carney's maybe bluff probably bluff but we're gonna find out if it's a bluff um so colin
00:02:07 a bluff is maybe a bit presumptive but that's my guess uh well he's been trying to have it both
00:02:11 ways on pipelines he's formed he's against them everyone can vote for carney uh he's he's a
00:02:17 rorschach test of uh how up your elbows are and uh she her plan is uh getting him off the fence 1.00
00:02:26 and it's getting a lot of the right people very angry about this uh tamara leach and uh barber
00:02:34 have been sentenced i'm sure you've all seen the news uh and they have gotten very stiff
00:02:39 sentences stiffer than uh some pretty damn serious criminals including rapists thieves robbers
00:02:47 people who commit very serious 0.88
00:02:49 assaults
00:02:50 we know what's really important
00:02:53 what the government takes seriously in Canada
00:02:56 you can give people
00:02:57 fentanyl on the streets 1.00
00:02:59 that you know will kill them and kill them 1.00
00:03:01 which I think should be classified as murder 1.00
00:03:03 and you're going to get in many cases
00:03:06 a lighter sentence than organizing
00:03:08 a peaceful protest with bouncy castles
00:03:09 to demand your freedom back
00:03:12 but we're going to start
00:03:14 something a bit closer to home
00:03:15 here in Alberta
00:03:17 uh the teachers for the public schools are on strike um lucky me i don't send my children
00:03:25 to a government uh alberta teachers association run school i sent my kid to a charter school
00:03:32 so my kid is still going to uh to school that should be all you alberta parents watching who
00:03:37 i don't yet send your kids to a charter school you should charter schools
00:03:41 they're kind of like a private school except there's no tuition they're like a not-for-profit
00:03:46 school and it's fully funded doesn't i don't pay any tuition for my kids to go and uh they're just
00:03:52 there's all sorts of benefits like my kids not having propaganda shoved down their throats uh
00:03:58 every uh hour of the school day what's the waiting list to get into the school that your kid goes to
00:04:04 i'm not sure how it is right now but they keep on expanding spaces they've got they open up a
00:04:07 second campus because demand is so great it's a growing business it's booming it's a booming
00:04:12 industry and um it's just a fantastic program and uh our teachers don't seem to strike now i think
00:04:21 we're only uh i guess the school's on fourth year i think we haven't had a strike yet and the teacher
00:04:27 the teachers are very invested it's really great so if you're not yet going uh sending your kid to
00:04:31 a charter school you should be check them out wherever you are if you're in calgary look at
00:04:34 calgary classical academy there's other options uh i think they're even looking at studying at
00:04:38 at Edmonton Classical Academy because they're so successful.
00:04:41 Yeah.
00:04:44 But the teachers are on strike.
00:04:46 Now, I'm actually kind of angry at the UCP here
00:04:49 for making such a generous offer
00:04:52 to the Alberta Teachers Association.
00:04:55 12% raise over, is it three or four years?
00:04:57 Four years.
00:04:58 Yeah, 12% raise over four years.
00:05:00 That's more than most people are going to get.
00:05:02 And that's just increasing all the grids. 0.93
00:05:04 You might, you know, with how long you've been there,
00:05:07 you might move into a higher grid so you might get
00:05:09 more there's a good chance you're going to get more than
00:05:11 12% over four years but the whole grid moves
00:05:13 up 12% over four years all
00:05:15 sorts of other things they
00:05:16 negotiate more teachers more teaching assistants
00:05:19 giving them all this stuff
00:05:21 and of course
00:05:23 and the union
00:05:25 recommended the deal to the membership didn't they
00:05:27 yeah you know to be fair to the union boss
00:05:29 they actually recommended the deal
00:05:30 and the teachers voted overwhelmingly
00:05:33 to reject it
00:05:35 um
00:05:36 I don't know. I'm not very sympathetic to the union bosses, but in this case, they recommended
00:05:41 the deal. I'm actually upset with the UCP for putting forward such a generous deal, considering
00:05:47 how little in the school year teachers have to work. And teachers, you know, during the school
00:05:51 year, you know, they work hard and they deal with a lot of crap. I mean, there's kids like me that 0.92
00:05:58 are difficult to deal with. I understand it, but they get more time off than anybody and virtually
00:06:04 any job that's gainfully employed
00:06:06 and they reject this
00:06:09 deal.
00:06:11 I've got an idea
00:06:12 for ending the teacher strike.
00:06:15 I don't really have a very good analogy.
00:06:17 Corey told me I shouldn't use this analogy
00:06:18 but I'm gonna...
00:06:20 I don't think I said anything you shouldn't use.
00:06:23 Oh, no, no.
00:06:24 Maybe it was someone else I was talking about today.
00:06:26 Someone else in the office thought
00:06:28 I shouldn't use this analogy because it's bad.
00:06:30 But I really don't know how else to demonstrate the point.
00:06:32 This is a hostage negotiation.
00:06:34 The teachers are holding our kids hostage.
00:06:38 We're holding their contract hostage.
00:06:40 And here's what I think we should do.
00:06:41 We've got to figuratively, purely figuratively, 0.98
00:06:44 start shooting some hostages to let them know that we are serious. 0.95
00:06:48 Every single day that the strike goes on, 0.96
00:06:52 the Alberta government should convert a government ATA public school
00:06:56 into a charter school.
00:06:58 So, okay, it's Monday.
00:07:00 If you won't have a deal by the end of today, that's one school.
00:07:04 Tuesday, we're doing another school.
00:07:06 You do that throughout the first week.
00:07:07 Every single day, we're shooting a figurative hostage.
00:07:10 We're turning a government ATA school into a charter school.
00:07:14 And if you get to the second week, fine, we're going to do two a day.
00:07:17 And this is a threat I think the teachers would have to know that they're serious about. 0.99
00:07:22 You've got to know that you're crazy. 1.00
00:07:23 You're going to shoot the hostages. 1.00
00:07:24 Again, terrible analogy, but this is the only way I could really get my point across here.
00:07:29 that charter schools are better for kids.
00:07:34 They're better for everyone
00:07:35 besides the power of the unions.
00:07:38 And the unions are not there
00:07:39 to look out for the interests of the kids.
00:07:41 They are there legally mandated
00:07:42 to look out for the interests of the teachers.
00:07:45 Fine, but that's not what's important to me.
00:07:47 What's important to me
00:07:47 is my kids getting a good quality education
00:07:49 and being able to be good, productive,
00:07:52 free citizens in the world
00:07:53 when they come out of it.
00:07:55 So that's what I think we should do.
00:07:56 The Alberta government,
00:07:57 I'm already angry at you
00:07:59 for offering them such a generous deal. 1.00
00:08:02 These guys are just too stupid to realize it. 1.00
00:08:05 And they waited until kids were back in class. 1.00
00:08:08 They didn't struggle for the summer when they could have.
00:08:10 They waited until kids were back in class
00:08:11 before doing this, holding our kids hostage.
00:08:14 But charter schools massively outperform
00:08:16 the ATA government schools.
00:08:19 This is how you do it.
00:08:20 And frankly, it becomes then a good thing every day
00:08:22 that the teachers drag their heels
00:08:24 and refuse to sign on to a very generous deal.
00:08:27 We get more charter schools out of it in the end.
00:08:29 I think if you start doing this,
00:08:31 the teachers are going to come to the table pretty damn soon.
00:08:35 But I hope not too soon,
00:08:36 because I want more charter schools for kids in Alberta.
00:08:40 You do. I do, too.
00:08:42 You know, we're already getting our wish
00:08:45 because that whole area of education
00:08:49 that is outside the public system
00:08:51 has grown substantially in the last five years.
00:08:55 You know, it varies around the province, but I'm told that in Calvary,
00:09:00 certainly kind of the western end of Calvary,
00:09:03 there's something like 30% of kids are being educated outside the public system.
00:09:09 And it would be in schools such as you were referring to, the classical academy,
00:09:15 but also Christian schools.
00:09:16 Some people just homeschool their children and find it works out better for them that way.
00:09:21 the thing that i am uh i have a sort of a horrible theory about but this is more than about the money
00:09:30 the education industry for that is what it is and by that i'm talking about not only the
00:09:37 civil servants who work in education in the ministry but also the teachers themselves
00:09:44 the ata there is a critical mass within that you know john hilton brian calls it the blob
00:09:51 whatever you call it it's it's an industry and it's not just the money they actually want control
00:09:58 they don't like the idea that parents elect mlas mlas find themselves an education minister and
00:10:06 they set the curriculum because these people have got ideas of the right yeah the idea wants to be
00:10:11 certain yeah and so this is a this is one of the uh one of the things that's driving this
00:10:16 and I hope the government toughs it out.
00:10:22 Well, it's sounding like it.
00:10:24 I mean, that's interesting.
00:10:24 Chris Sims from the Taxpayers Federation also wrote a piece
00:10:27 and was saying it, look, you know, she's saying get winter boots,
00:10:30 teachers, because it looks like Smith's settling in
00:10:32 for the long haul with this one.
00:10:34 The attitude from the government so far is, okay, you know what,
00:10:37 we're going to help parents with a few bucks
00:10:38 so that they can get alternative care for their children
00:10:40 during the strike.
00:10:41 They're saying we're going to help you weather the storm,
00:10:43 like we aren't rolling over for this demands right now.
00:10:46 So that's a different take than governments who often capitulate pretty darn quick when it comes to something like this.
00:10:52 So I think this one's just warming up.
00:10:53 Yeah, at least I know maybe it's a bit insider Alberta here for you coming from B.C.
00:10:59 But we had that Corey alluded to this.
00:11:02 The government is taking the revenue that's essentially being saved by not paying these teachers while they're on strike.
00:11:07 And it's using it to at least partially offset the cost of parents who have to put them in child care or do extra driving around.
00:11:16 They're giving it to kids.
00:11:19 Incredibly to me, you know, Nahid Nenshi, the NDP leader.
00:11:25 Incredibly came out against that.
00:11:29 Like, I mean, he was supposed to be the moderate.
00:11:32 He's not supposed to be from the old government union, old school NDP.
00:11:38 You know, he's purple.
00:11:38 He's not red.
00:11:39 He's not blue.
00:11:40 Not orange.
00:11:40 um but i i'm i'm trying to figure out his politics on this move where you know he just says i i know
00:11:48 is he proposing to continue to pay them are we just going to pay the teachers while they strike
00:11:54 uh i mean they'll then strike for all time i'm not i'm not really sure where he's coming at this
00:11:58 from um i've been trying to figure out what the where the ata is coming from um i i know i talked
00:12:05 to some uh some kids who live in the area near me and they've been given the propaganda i i remember
00:12:10 I first became politically active in the fifth grade
00:12:12 as a kid growing up in a small town
00:12:15 Ontario. There was a teacher strike when Mike
00:12:16 Harris was the premier and
00:12:18 it politically activated me because
00:12:20 the teachers were pushing a bunch of propaganda
00:12:22 on us and it was
00:12:25 the first time I had authority figures
00:12:26 that I thought were not being truthful
00:12:29 with me. I was like this
00:12:30 this seems like 0.99
00:12:32 bullshit and they were telling us to 1.00
00:12:34 come out and give them 1.00
00:12:36 hot chocolate and sandwiches on the picket
00:12:38 lines i actually uh i had little glass vials stink bombs and i'd walk in for 10 time my shoes
00:12:44 i dropped stink bombs on the picket line not because i really care about politics but because
00:12:48 i didn't like my teacher for lying to me but uh that was my first act of uh of terrorism so um
00:12:55 anyway i just i the politics of this are bizarre i think it's it's somewhat uh what cory's saying
00:13:02 is the ata is used to having a lot more control they were given a huge amount of control uh over
00:13:07 things under Alison Redford, and that
00:13:09 persisted on. It doubled down a bit more
00:13:11 with Rachel Notley,
00:13:13 but it really began with
00:13:14 in earnest with
00:13:17 Alison Redford as Premier, who owed
00:13:19 her job as Premier into PC leadership to the
00:13:21 Teachers Association here.
00:13:23 But also, I just think of this, the
00:13:25 ATA is just kind of spoiling for a political
00:13:27 fight. I think they just want to fight
00:13:29 the UCP, and they've kind of boxed
00:13:31 themselves in now, where
00:13:33 the UCP
00:13:35 can't give them any more. The government's running a
00:13:37 deficit. It has not controlled its spending. That's on the UCP, but part of controlling its
00:13:40 spending is dealing with maniacs like the ATA. I'm not really sure what their game is here. They
00:13:45 seem to have boxed themselves in. Well, let's just start with, you've mentioned two politicians
00:13:51 manufactured by Stephen Carter. So Nenshi is the made-up politician, and Redford, as we know,
00:14:00 was involved with Stephen Carter. So well done. That's the contribution to Alberta by Mr. Carter.
00:14:06 you're talking to
00:14:08 a
00:14:09 he picks up really well
00:14:12 yeah
00:14:13 one day
00:14:16 we'll have to get into the mistakes
00:14:18 of political consultants and how it's
00:14:20 determined Alberta State
00:14:22 and the millions they make
00:14:24 along the way on the pathway
00:14:26 of our tiers
00:14:27 you're talking to somebody that
00:14:30 my earliest memory of school
00:14:32 was my teacher
00:14:34 striking in grade one
00:14:36 and my parents and other parents getting involved and saying, listen, we're going to teach these
00:14:42 classes. So back in the 80s, that's something parents could do in British Columbia, but
00:14:47 obviously things have changed. Out here in BC, we're watching you with a smirk, because
00:14:53 as you know, we had rolling teacher strikes. There were some terrible years there. And it was a
00:15:00 collection of about six years where my child was going through elementary school, and she didn't
00:15:05 have a year that wasn't interrupted at least once. I really regret not sending her to a charter or
00:15:11 private school. And this is, you know, I felt guilty about pulling her out away from her friends.
00:15:18 I would suggest every parent just go through the fire, just move them out to a private or charter
00:15:25 school. This is, as we learned in BC, because what you've done in providing some sort of, I think,
00:15:31 stipend i guess to parents um or voucher um to help them a long way is something we have done
00:15:38 in bc everything that is uh on the stage in in alberta with this art with this fight with the
00:15:44 ata is really reflective of every choice and decision that my former colleagues and my former
00:15:52 bosses made in british columbia we tried every trick in the book we have held firm we had a very
00:15:59 long strike um and when we realized that this was no longer about money but was about our effort to
00:16:06 take control back of the teachers college things started to change um and my suggestion as sort of
00:16:14 looking at this and i am surprised that your teachers did not vote with the recommendations
00:16:19 with the offer that was recommended uh by the union uh bosses that's something i haven't seen
00:16:25 in british columbia before but i think this is revenge tactics revenge politics it's over an
00:16:31 ideology and um nigel you wrote a great piece about this today and referred back to a interview
00:16:39 that you had i think roughly a year ago now um where you spoke to a young woman who was talking
00:16:47 about charter schools and yes thank you i remembered her last name and unfortunately
00:16:53 I couldn't remember her first name. But I found that to be intriguing because that's what we
00:16:59 found out. And, you know, I came from a coalition party, blue liberals, red Tories, fiscal
00:17:07 conservatives, and my ministers of education were predominantly liberals, and they turned out to be
00:17:13 the hardest on these unions. But I will say it is about revenge politics. It is not about the money
00:17:20 that you're offering. It's about also capping class sizes. The problem that Daniel Smith's
00:17:26 going to have is most parents in Alberta do not want to be sending their kids to a classroom
00:17:32 that's heaving at 37, 38, or 40 students per class. Nobody does. And not every parent,
00:17:39 especially as we're looking at the economy today, can afford, even Alberta, even in prosperous
00:17:45 Alberta, can afford to look at a charter or private school. Actually, charter schools in
00:17:50 Alberta have no tuition. There's no tuition in charter schools in Alberta. The only question
00:17:55 is, do we have enough charter schools? Which is why I think we should start converting public
00:17:59 schools into charter schools. All we need is really the buildings for it. There's the demand
00:18:04 for it. Everyone wants to send their kids to there and there's no tuition. You're missing 1,200 spots
00:18:09 in charter schools right now. And you might as well just double that by the time, because by summer,
00:18:14 that's probably going to double as well. So you're right to look at that. And I think that's a
00:18:18 fantastic thing. I wish that was something that was offered in British Columbia. But I would say
00:18:22 that I think if you can look at the cap, I think easing the cap without giving them control
00:18:28 would be some amazing political judo. But what they're looking for is control. Control over
00:18:36 what they're teaching, what they're talking about. They refuse, all teachers in this country
00:18:41 and their unions or federations refuse to get back to traditional teachings.
00:18:48 okay like what about financial literacy just a real a real quick point elise when we talk about
00:18:56 the teachers wanting control let's distinguish between the teachers organizations and some of
00:19:02 the great teachers that we all know personally who really aren't into this they're not the ones
00:19:07 who want to put the dirty books in the in the school library that comes from up the up the scale
00:19:13 So those are the people that we're fighting with.
00:19:16 So, Tamara Leach and Barber, we already knew some time ago,
00:19:21 they were found guilty in the biggest mischief trial in the history of the world.
00:19:27 They were sentenced just the other day.
00:19:32 Well, Derek, I think our editorial had it about right.
00:19:35 Yeah.
00:19:36 You know, Leach and Barber got hammered worse than people who do truly horrible things.
00:19:41 And why?
00:19:42 Because they challenged the legitimacy of what the liberal government was doing with COVID regulations in 2022.
00:19:49 Governments just hate that.
00:19:51 So this was a political prosecution, and the government wanted to deter other people.
00:19:57 I mean, Tamara Leach and Chris Barber were handed conditional sentences for leading one of the most peaceful, heartfelt protests that this country has ever seen.
00:20:07 Their only crime was refusing to stay silent when government power ran roughshod over ordinary Canadians.
00:20:16 I mean, we quoted Alan Borovoy, the late Alan Borovoy, great defender of civil liberty.
00:20:26 And he was once asked, he actually stated this.
00:20:31 He said, what else do people have than peaceful protests when government power runs roughshod over them and they don't listen?
00:20:41 And that's the question that's at the very heart of this moment.
00:20:45 Tamara and Chris stood for freedom, our freedom.
00:20:48 And for that, they were vilified.
00:20:50 They had the bank accounts frozen.
00:20:52 They had their trucks confiscated.
00:20:54 Years of their lives stolen by endless, you know, three-week protests and three years in the legal process.
00:21:00 yet they never called for violence
00:21:02 never broke faith with Canada's
00:21:04 democratic ideals
00:21:05 and you know peaceful dissent
00:21:08 is not a crime
00:21:09 it's the lifeblood of a free nation
00:21:12 I beg to differ it is a crime here
00:21:14 well it is because of crime
00:21:16 no question
00:21:16 you know did they break some laws
00:21:19 yeah you're not allowed to just set up
00:21:21 in a street for a prolonged period of time
00:21:23 but
00:21:24 people have been doing this for quite some time
00:21:27 in Canada without ever getting charged
00:21:29 Let's remember the so-called Idle No More, very weirdly titled, but Idle No More, when Harper was in power.
00:21:37 A conservative government in power, and these guys were blocking rail lines, highways, they set up encampments, and they did not have bouncy castles.
00:21:46 They had the distinct vibe of violence in the air that if you came to break them up, they would violently resist.
00:21:54 here. There was no violent resistance even when
00:21:56 they sent mounted troops in
00:21:58 to break these guys up, riding over
00:22:00 Granny. We will remember that video.
00:22:03 So, did they break the
00:22:04 law and commit mischief? Yeah.
00:22:07 I think they did.
00:22:08 But they did much less than
00:22:10 many, many other protests that have taken
00:22:12 place over the last
00:22:14 10 to 15 years, where there were
00:22:16 no prosecutions at all.
00:22:18 And then, they've now been sentenced.
00:22:21 And they've, you know, we note this
00:22:22 in our editorial. We cite
00:22:24 quite a few examples uh cory where um sorry i'll go to uh elise uh they cite quite a few examples
00:22:32 elise where uh rapists uh people who have attempted murder um people who have committed
00:22:41 major acts of physical violence have received significantly less severe uh sentences uh than
00:22:49 Leach and Barber
00:22:51 and it's such a sacred cow
00:22:54 in Canada, you're not allowed to question
00:22:55 the objectivity and fairness
00:22:58 of the justice system. If you question
00:23:00 it, you're questioning the constitutional
00:23:02 foundation of Canada. You're
00:23:03 somehow beyond the pale to question it.
00:23:06 I think at this
00:23:08 point, we don't even have to question it. We
00:23:10 know it's bullshit. 1.00
00:23:12 Bingo. So 1.00
00:23:13 a good example would be the story I think that
00:23:16 we discussed while
00:23:18 it was still warm and sunny
00:23:19 outside was the gentleman that went before court he had paid to for child rape he was a permanent
00:23:28 resident in the process of his application to be a full-fledged Canadian citizen and there were 0.88
00:23:35 several he was arrested for the paid rape or the attempt to rape school-age girls and I mean
00:23:41 elementary school-age girls and the judge intervened and said I don't want to give you a 0.68
00:23:46 long sentence. I want to be careful because I think it's going to hurt your citizenship. I'm
00:23:51 sure you all remember this. It wasn't that long ago. He ended up with a lesser sentence
00:23:55 and less conditions than both Tamara and Chris. Another good example would be over the weekend
00:24:02 where Samajoon, a terrorist entity, a designated terrorist entity, held a massive event outside
00:24:13 the vancouver art gallery the vancouver police the rcmp and the city of vancouver stood didn't even
00:24:19 stand by they didn't even show up they were allowed to propagate hate anti-semitic slogans
00:24:27 and encourage violence this country is broken it's not just the repeat bail offenders it my issue
00:24:35 with all of this is that the ottawa police uh for a capital city have are not used to being
00:24:44 challenged are not used to large events uh it's shocking to me as somebody from vancouver and i
00:24:49 think it would be shopping shocking to somebody from toronto as well where we're in constant
00:24:53 protest mode uh the city and and the city is made up of decision makers in high profile places
00:25:00 I also think some of this, well, not some of it, but a lot of it had to do with the crawlback from the illegal use of the emergency that I believe it was illegal.
00:25:12 I do not believe there was a justification for that.
00:25:14 And when you look at that massive Hamas rally that was on Capitol or was on Parliament Hill, sorry, not Capitol Hill, Parliament Hill last year, last fall, where ISIS flagged for being flown and streets were being shut down.
00:25:30 and threats of violence were going back and forth
00:25:33 and the cops were dragging people out,
00:25:35 nobody was arrested and, well, nobody was charged
00:25:39 and nobody's gone through the criminal courts in Ottawa
00:25:42 based upon that event.
00:25:43 So we have two tiers or maybe even three tiers
00:25:47 of justice in this country.
00:25:48 The third tier would be for First Nations people 0.96
00:25:51 and we know what the second and first tier is in Canada.
00:25:55 Yeah.
00:25:56 Corey, I'm going to skip you on this one
00:25:58 because we're short on time.
00:25:59 uh yeah it's okay uh oh uh elise is gonna get double here uh she come to you uh because we're 0.96
00:26:07 gonna talk pipelines here whenever there's a problem it's always you too bc and quebec it's
00:26:15 always you too whenever there's an issue we know it's you too um so uh we have the national
00:26:23 priorities office
00:26:25 created by
00:26:27 Carney. This is supposed to cut through the
00:26:29 red tape, get big things moving.
00:26:31 Get Canada building again.
00:26:33 Very noble, good idea. At least
00:26:35 in theory, you know, is it just another layer
00:26:37 of bureaucracy? Maybe. Or maybe it does help cut
00:26:39 through it. But, okay, this is what
00:26:41 we got, so let's try it.
00:26:43 And no surprise
00:26:45 when the initial list
00:26:46 for the national priorities came out, it did
00:26:49 not include any pipelines, because no one in their right
00:26:51 mind right now wants to build
00:26:53 a pipeline
00:26:54 when you have the No More Pipelines Act
00:26:57 the Impact Assessment Act
00:26:58 and you certainly don't want to build it
00:27:01 to BC's north coast
00:27:03 because there's a tanker band
00:27:04 so you've got a pipeline there
00:27:06 well it's not allowed to go anywhere
00:27:08 you just put it in barrels and buried underground essentially
00:27:11 so
00:27:12 Carney was able to say
00:27:14 I can't say yes or no to a pipeline because
00:27:17 there's
00:27:18 no proponent
00:27:20 so the Alberta government says alright
00:27:22 I want to see your cards
00:27:24 and they put some money on the table. The Alberta government
00:27:26 is going forward as the proponent
00:27:27 to get this ball rolling
00:27:30 to see if it gets approved
00:27:32 through the National Priorities Office here
00:27:34 and if so, then it's going to seek
00:27:36 someone in the private sector
00:27:38 to pick it up.
00:27:39 I think it's
00:27:41 it was a good way, I guess
00:27:43 at least, in my view
00:27:46 to force Carney to put his
00:27:48 cards on the table, show us his cards.
00:27:49 i'm sure that daniel smith and kudos to daniel smith because she has managed to do something
00:27:55 that very few politicians in the last almost three decades have been able to do which is called the
00:28:00 federal government's bluff but i'm very confused so we have this office which by the way is the
00:28:05 second incarnation of this office uh people forget but there was uh mr harper um had a
00:28:11 infrastructure office um and that didn't work either because things got voted down the other
00:28:19 thing is so you're you you have that infrastructure office or that national products office but then
00:28:24 you also have bill c5 which is sort of like the fast track to improve a lot of different things
00:28:29 um and then but you're holding on to specific legislation that impedes not just oil tankers
00:28:37 uh off the coast are off of the west coast but actually impedes a lot of other economic activity
00:28:43 that we desperately need.
00:28:46 British Columbia is a great example
00:28:49 of a jurisdiction that might as well
00:28:53 just be allergic to prosperity.
00:28:55 It has done everything in its power
00:28:57 to put a closed-to-a-dismas sign on its doors.
00:29:01 We don't have really any energy companies left,
00:29:05 and those guys left a long time ago.
00:29:09 We're also facing down
00:29:11 one of the nastiest uh recessions uh about to hit our shores uh so i'm not sure what's going on in
00:29:18 david eddie's mind uh but kudos to miss smith for for pushing um to recalling carney's bluff
00:29:25 um but carney i i'm very unclear as to what carney's doing uh i'm completely confused because
00:29:33 he's also now put keystone xl back on the table with trump as a way to toss those tariffs off
00:29:38 the table so you know i know we're short on time i could go on but you know apologies from british 0.59
00:29:44 columbia not all of us are as ridiculous as david eb and by the way can we just note that his voice 0.67
00:29:49 was cracking yesterday he looked he was about to start crying because daniel smith called him 0.98
00:29:55 un-canadian and mo and scott mo piled on i mean how embarrassing for me uh so okay cory so we
00:30:02 have an official apology from British 0.97
00:30:04 Columbia now.
00:30:07 That apology
00:30:09 is not accepted.
00:30:12 Not accepted.
00:30:15 But then we saw
00:30:17 yesterday, Carney meets with
00:30:19 Trump at the White House.
00:30:22 Wasn't a lot of elbows up.
00:30:23 It was actually very chummy. It was actually probably
00:30:25 the way, if you're being smart with a guy
00:30:27 like Trump, you know,
00:30:29 Oh, you're just fantastic.
00:30:31 You're transformative.
00:30:32 He used the word transformative a lot.
00:30:34 And Trump was very nice back.
00:30:36 You know, if you're willing to blow some smoke up Trump,
00:30:38 it seems to go a long way.
00:30:40 He likes that.
00:30:41 And it was actually pretty cheery.
00:30:44 At least the public part of me was very cheery and nice.
00:30:46 We don't know about pie and closed doors,
00:30:47 but it seemed to go well.
00:30:50 Didn't come back with a trade deal,
00:30:52 but the CBC reported at least
00:30:54 that Carney put Keystone on the table.
00:30:57 that might be
00:30:59 okay, so Smith has
00:31:01 you know, she's called
00:31:05 I'm gonna beleaguer this
00:31:07 analogy, but she's called 0.97
00:31:09 Cardi has to show his
00:31:11 cards now on a pipeline
00:31:13 but maybe this is his way
00:31:15 of not
00:31:17 completely melting down the whole thing
00:31:19 that he'll say no for British 0.98
00:31:21 Columbia, because there's voters
00:31:23 he needs in British Columbia
00:31:25 but he's not going to lose
00:31:27 terribly many votes, probably
00:31:29 if he allows Kistan to go, because where is it passing 0.59
00:31:31 through? Eastern and
00:31:33 Southern Alberta, which is about the least
00:31:35 liberal places on the surface of the
00:31:37 earth
00:31:38 and then, you know, so all he has
00:31:41 to do is sign off on the international side
00:31:43 so Alberta gets a pipeline
00:31:44 but it's going to go south instead
00:31:47 of west
00:31:48 although it's argued, I think, pretty strongly
00:31:51 that the west pipeline is more important
00:31:53 because that takes us to international markets
00:31:55 because by being so capped up to the American market,
00:31:57 we're continuing to sell at such a discount.
00:31:59 So that's why we're actually probably better off
00:32:01 getting to Asian markets on the West Coast.
00:32:05 Do you think that's it that, you know,
00:32:08 he's maybe setting it up for Keystone
00:32:10 as a way to soften the blow
00:32:12 for saying no to a West Coast pipeline?
00:32:14 Well, he sure shows himself as weak then.
00:32:16 I mean, everybody came to that conclusion.
00:32:17 Canada, for the first time in recent history,
00:32:20 where the whole country polled,
00:32:21 was in support of a pipeline to the coast.
00:32:23 for the sole reason of realizing we're hyper dependent on the United States for this industry.
00:32:28 And it has us over a barrel when we get a trade dispute. So it means Kearney's completely given
00:32:32 up on the only way to ease that is to broaden your customer market. The only way to do that
00:32:37 is to get a pipe to the coast. So he's given up on that. And then when we start that discussion
00:32:42 about lacking a proponent, nobody's raising their hand to have Lucy pull the football away again,
00:32:47 heading down Keystone. TC Energy said to hell with you. I mean, they took Canada out of it.
00:32:52 they're basically uh well to be fair their their final pullout was when biden killed it yes but
00:32:59 they're still tired of losing you know there's no companies eager to lay it on the line anymore
00:33:04 so that would have to be some talks i mean yeah biden killed it trump would have to make it quite
00:33:09 clear and then there's the whole battles of everything through nebraska and everything
00:33:12 else that went as that expired are they starting again with it they're pipeline shy so uh yeah
00:33:18 Yeah, Kearney might be going that route, but boy, what a pathetically weak route to go then.
00:33:22 You know, the thing that I haven't heard is whether he wants Keystone to carry decarbonized oil.
00:33:29 You know, this idea that you bury an equivalent amount of carbon dioxide to the oil that you're carrying through the pipeline.
00:33:37 And that's the trouble with Kearney.
00:33:38 You never really know what he's put on the table and what he hasn't.
00:33:42 And Keystone gets my vote, but what exactly is the deal going to look like?
00:33:48 Is there something you can make believe?
00:33:51 I know lots of Republicans, and I know lots of people, you know, a few feet from Trump's office.
00:33:57 And I spoke to them this morning because my mouth was agape.
00:34:01 Obviously, I felt it was, you know, a shell game that was going on.
00:34:05 It was to test to see if he could wiggle out some of those tariffs.
00:34:09 And my former colleagues down there felt the same way.
00:34:13 You know, my understanding of how this really went was Mr. Carney acquiesced often.
00:34:18 as we've seen before uh but there is something that's going to get done but the auto sector
00:34:25 is a no-go for trump so far so kari's got to deal with that and he has this deadline in november
00:34:32 coming up with you know danielle smith uh where we will really understand what that how big that 1.00
00:34:38 bluff is um but keystone is cory points out the expired licenses through nebraska uh lack of
00:34:46 of social license but i do think some of that sentiment has changed since trump has come back
00:34:51 into office and i think trump thinks he might be able to win it problem is he's he is and i will
00:34:57 say the best guy to talk to the energy ceos uh he's the best guy to say come on i need you guys
00:35:03 to build something i need you guys to build a keystone but that's not going to be uh enough
00:35:09 for for daniel smith and it is so far down the track no pun intended uh but we have we already
00:35:16 have a beautiful project called northern gateway we just need to take it to prince rupert versus
00:35:21 kittimat so when david eby says oh this is just some sort of pie in the sky and it's a government
00:35:27 project and hey where's british columbia's money because that guy's is part of eb's ranch
00:35:33 his hysterical tantrum yesterday he's like i want some money if they're going to get this
00:35:38 he literally says if they get this
00:35:40 I want a project too
00:35:41 yeah
00:35:43 it's all become so
00:35:46 nonsensical and quite frankly
00:35:48 embarrassing
00:35:48 okay speaking of
00:35:52 nonsensical we're going to segue
00:35:53 to our last segment here and we've got to keep a tiny
00:35:56 bit of time for parting shots
00:35:57 so
00:35:59 I think he's from
00:36:02 Toronto or Toronto area originally Ben
00:36:03 Bankus
00:36:04 you scroll through Instagram
00:36:07 or Twitter, there's a good chance
00:36:10 you've seen him. He does
00:36:12 some racy comedy.
00:36:14 He does, some would
00:36:16 say racist, others would say
00:36:17 racist and hilarious impressions
00:36:19 of Olivia Chow.
00:36:22 You know, he's
00:36:24 controversial. He is
00:36:25 not afraid
00:36:28 of what people call him.
00:36:29 He's very funny.
00:36:32 Some would say inappropriate.
00:36:34 That's fine. But guess what?
00:36:36 That's free speech.
00:36:37 And it's comedy.
00:36:39 And you can't have one without the other.
00:36:43 So I decided, you know, this guy's pretty outside the ordinary lineup of comedians.
00:36:52 So I decided to buy eight tickets for some of the Western Standards Calgary staff to go down and see them.
00:36:59 It's the Grey Eagle Casino.
00:37:00 Grey Eagle Casino's got a great venue.
00:37:02 I've gone to concerts there and shows.
00:37:04 There's even been political conventions there.
00:37:06 It's a great place.
00:37:07 um but it is on a reserve and ben bankus um uh curry made uh uh he he posts i i don't think it
00:37:19 was shot that day but he posted a video on uh i guess it's called truth and reconciliation day
00:37:23 uh national surfing day uh uh making a joke that involved residential schools and whatnot
00:37:30 not, you know, I watched it, I was like, ooh, spicy, but I, you know, certainly didn't think
00:37:37 he was not advocating hurting anyone, killing anyone, harming anyone, but it was definitely
00:37:42 spicy, and then I guess he says there were two complaints to Grey Eagle, Grey Eagle pulled it,
00:37:49 and he's now rebooked. Well, yeah, so I'm kind of mixed on this. Comedy is the front line of
00:37:53 free speech, though. I'm a big George Carlin fan. He made it pretty clear you can joke about
00:37:58 anything. And then that routine,
00:38:01 he goes into a joke about rape. Some people
00:38:03 might be offended in the works,
00:38:05 but that's his point making.
00:38:06 It's a joke. You don't like it.
00:38:08 Don't come to my show. And
00:38:10 he fought. He got charged. This was a big
00:38:12 battle. And Bankus
00:38:14 is sort of trying to do the same thing. And I think he was
00:38:16 being purposely provocative, though.
00:38:18 When you put out that particular joke
00:38:20 on there on Truth and Reconciliation Day,
00:38:22 knowing you're going to do a show
00:38:24 at a casino that's on
00:38:26 reserve land. One of the complaints might have come from him for all I know.
00:38:31 I mean, you know, publicity stunts aren't new from
00:38:33 comedians. As well, it is a private place.
00:38:38 They do have the right to say no to whoever's going to perform, and they're not. It'll be
00:38:42 interesting to see, though, because he's stirred things up. He's got in the scroll. It's when we start
00:38:46 to see human rights charges, things like that, where they say
00:38:50 you can't say that joke, no matter what venue you're in. And I've got a feeling he's
00:38:54 looking to try those waters and he'll probably
00:38:56 find them pretty soon with the nature of some of his jokes
00:38:58 yeah
00:38:59 Nigel, I'd agree
00:39:02 it's a private venue, they have a right to not
00:39:04 have him, but
00:39:05 it's not a good, like I generally like
00:39:08 the Soutina, like they're relatively
00:39:10 well run
00:39:11 you know, their band members
00:39:14 tend to be
00:39:16 better off than a lot of other band members in Canada
00:39:18 you know, they don't get everything
00:39:20 right, but they, relative
00:39:22 to some others they're getting some things right uh but this just i think it shows a thin skin
00:39:27 especially right now you know they've already banned media from going around there kind of
00:39:31 conveniently after the chief was charged with rape uh not yet convicted not tested in court
00:39:36 but he's been charged with rape but then some other thing happened and then they all of a sudden
00:39:40 ban the media from being there this is the reserve you said was reasonably well run uh yeah it's a
00:39:45 a little bit. I said relatively.
00:39:48 Relatively. It's
00:39:49 less medieval than some others.
00:39:52 But yeah, I've
00:39:53 generally had a lot of respect
00:39:55 for where they do things. Anyway,
00:39:57 it looks thin-skinned,
00:39:59 and I think all it did is raise
00:40:01 his profile. Well,
00:40:03 so it did.
00:40:05 I think I'm with Corey on this one.
00:40:07 There's no obligation if you think that somebody
00:40:09 is going to insult you that you have to rend them
00:40:11 your church hall to do it in.
00:40:13 So he went to Yuck Yucks,
00:40:15 and there they go you know um he sold out several nights in a row now yeah yeah i mean uh if this
00:40:22 was just a way to publicize his show then it certainly worked very well well he already had
00:40:27 a show at a big venue he was gonna be able to do one show and one big show on one day now he has
00:40:32 to do a couple of small see where i where i start to get anxious is when publicly owned places start
00:40:39 to ban people because it's like you've had sean foyte going through the canada in the summer
00:40:44 anytime great eagle is semi-publicly owned it's owned by a reserve which is a a quasi order of
00:40:51 government so but you know but it's a great thing i can make the distinction for them to their
00:40:57 benefit but uh you know when you get parks camera they're getting into the act and saying well you
00:41:01 can't be on your show here then uh i mean maybe that's what he should have done book the parks
00:41:06 Canada spot in the...
00:41:08 Wouldn't that have been a story?
00:41:10 Send him a note.
00:41:11 When is the show?
00:41:15 I think it's in
00:41:16 November, or is it October?
00:41:18 It's pretty soon. It's coming up.
00:41:20 Send him a note. Tell him the book Parks Canada.
00:41:23 Anyway, that's it.
00:41:24 And he's got a lot of tour dates.
00:41:26 We're going to go to Parting Shots now, but
00:41:28 for everyone watching,
00:41:30 look up his clips.
00:41:32 You will probably be offended,
00:41:34 but that's okay
00:41:36 but if you laugh while you're being offended
00:41:39 that's a good time
00:41:40 that's a great time
00:41:42 we call that Dave Chappelle
00:41:45 we call that Dave Chappelle
00:41:46 yeah exactly
00:41:49 my favorite people
00:41:51 are both funny and offensive
00:41:53 at the same time
00:41:54 they go really well together
00:41:56 look him up
00:41:57 he's got a bunch of tour dates
00:42:00 he's got obviously Calgary
00:42:01 he's probably got Edmonton
00:42:03 a number of others.
00:42:05 You'd be surprised if you didn't have a Saskatchewan and BC
00:42:07 stuff as well.
00:42:09 Yeah, you should check it out. It's
00:42:11 a lot spicier than anything you're going to see on CBC.
00:42:15 Okay.
00:42:17 We'll go
00:42:17 to our parting shots. We'll start with you, Elise.
00:42:20 So, my parting
00:42:21 shot is to Premier EB
00:42:23 and the
00:42:25 embarrassment, the embarrassing presser
00:42:27 that he held yesterday.
00:42:29 I would like to remind
00:42:31 Mr. Eby that he's part of Confederation and part of that agreement is our mutual
00:42:36 contribution to the success of Canada. I would prefer him to stop crying at these press conferences,
00:42:45 floundering through them, stop spreading misinformation, stop intentionally twisting
00:42:51 what Confederation is and what the individual rights of each province is. I would like him
00:42:58 to sit down with both Premier Moe and Premier Scott
00:43:01 and have an adult conversation.
00:43:03 I would like him to recognize that his political future,
00:43:07 the end is very near,
00:43:09 and it will have nothing to do with the pipelines.
00:43:12 It will have everything to do with his lost offices,
00:43:16 not only within his caucus per se, but within his party.
00:43:21 But Canada, Canadians have woken up. 0.94
00:43:23 There is a political revolution happening in this country
00:43:26 where they have realized that this type of incompetence, ideology over confidence,
00:43:34 has cost us billions and billions in investment,
00:43:37 and therefore good-paying jobs that have a future.
00:43:41 And I would remind Mr. Eby and anyone of his ilk that your days are numbered.
00:43:45 All right.
00:43:46 Corey, I'll go quickly.
00:43:48 Frances Whittowson was assaulted in Winnipeg by a violent protest last week,
00:43:52 not a nonviolent one.
00:43:54 She's posted the videos online.
00:43:55 and she's trying to get police action. 1.00
00:43:57 There's obviously been charges, right?
00:43:59 Not yet.
00:43:59 So maybe view those videos
00:44:01 and perhaps send a note to the Winnipeg police
00:44:03 saying you don't want to tolerate seeing women assaulted
00:44:05 for trying to speak in public places.
00:44:06 Yeah, we've got the story up at the Western Standard.
00:44:08 Share that story, folks.
00:44:09 Get that story in the Western Standard.
00:44:11 Share it and tag the Winnipeg police.
00:44:14 Let's see if people committing assault against her 1.00
00:44:17 get half the sentence that Tamara Leach and Chris Barber got.
00:44:22 Which brings me to my parting shop.
00:44:24 There are two people who should be on a conservative ticket somewhere in the country.
00:44:29 That's the kind of people we want in Parliament, not in jail.
00:44:34 All right.
00:44:35 Mine is for the illustrious Alberta Senator Chris Wells.
00:44:40 This is the creepy dude who Trudeau appointed to the Senate.
00:44:45 Very well known in some circles for, leads, I don't know, some LGTBQ alphabet soup department. 0.83
00:44:54 I think at the University of Alberta, where he just talked about gay stuff all day.
00:44:59 I really don't know any other way to describe it.
00:45:02 He just talked about how awesome it is and how persecuted he is when he's very much not.
00:45:09 Not going to get into it, but dude's got serious, serious, creepy vibes.
00:45:14 And I guess, you know, maybe they were paying him a quarter million dollars a year or something at the University of Alberta.
00:45:21 I don't know, because he's complaining about how hard done by he is, make it $180,000 a year as a senator for life, plus benefits, plus pension, plus travel.
00:45:35 Yeah, look, being a politician has got some downsides.
00:45:39 I had to drive all the way up the road to Edmonton every week.
00:45:42 That sucked.
00:45:43 I had to drive all over creation.
00:45:45 But it comes with a job.
00:45:45 You don't like it?
00:45:47 Resign.
00:45:47 Someone else will do it.
00:45:49 It's a job for life.
00:45:50 It's the greatest gig in politics
00:45:52 in the Democratic world because it's not
00:45:54 Democratic. It's awesome.
00:45:57 It'd be great to be appointed
00:45:58 for life to a position of power
00:46:00 and never have to face election
00:46:02 again. That is awesome.
00:46:04 And the guy's complaining about $180K.
00:46:06 So, that's that.
00:46:09 Well, if he gives it up, maybe
00:46:10 you know, if they're
00:46:12 looking for a liberal appointment,
00:46:14 maybe it's time for Corey tonight to
00:46:16 finally get what he's been looking for.
00:46:18 Oh, that's a parting shot.
00:46:20 There we go.
00:46:20 Shots fired.
00:46:22 Okay.
00:46:22 Corey, Nigel, Elise, thank you very much.
00:46:26 And thank you, John, for producing today's show and all of you for joining us today.
00:46:32 Remember, the Western Standard relies on people becoming members, paying for the independent journalism that we do.
00:46:40 We need you to support our work.
00:46:42 Go to westernstandard.news.
00:46:43 Click on subscribe.
00:46:44 It is $10 a month or $100 a year, and that gets you unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
00:46:52 You're going to love it. It's just the best.
00:46:54 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:47:14 We'll be right back.