Western Standard - June 07, 2025


To win, the Conservatives must take back the culture

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Gear up for the Global Energy Show Canada! Carney says Muslim values are Canadian values

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

111.99

Word count

2,748

Sentence count

127

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Why did the Conservative Party of Prime Minister Stephen Harper lose to the Liberal Party of Canada in the 2019 election? With us today is scholar Brock Eldon, who is in the middle of moving back to Canada from his post-university life in Vietnam.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to this special edition of
00:00:20 Hannaford, a weekly politics show of the Western Standard. I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:24 One of the puzzles of Canadian politics is why, after the spectacular successes of the years when Stephen Harper led Canada, the party he led has been shut out in three following consecutive elections in 2019, 2021, and most recently in April this year.
00:00:45 In fact, Canada's Conservatives, under Pierre Pellier, won more than 8 million votes, a party record.
00:00:53 But it still wasn't enough.
00:00:55 They ended up with 144 seats to the Liberals, 169.
00:00:59 So the question today is, why, how does this happen?
00:01:02 With us today is scholar Brock Eldon, who is in the middle of moving back to Canada from Hanoi, where he's been teaching university.
00:01:10 Good to see you, Brock.
00:01:11 Thanks for taking the time.
00:01:13 Absolutely.
00:01:14 Great to see you, Nigel.
00:01:15 Good to see you again.
00:01:17 Brock, I think everybody who cares know that the NDP vote collapsed and their vote went to the Liberals.
00:01:23 So in one sense, it's obvious what happened.
00:01:25 But in a recent article in the Western Standard, you said there was something else going on.
00:01:30 What would that be?
00:01:33 Let me start by addressing what you've just said.
00:01:38 The NDP collapse has been a reality for how many years now? Long enough that I don't think that played as large a role as people think.
00:01:55 we can go back to polls from November, even December, and it appeared to be quite an obvious
00:02:06 victory for the Conservatives. I think that for many, many people, the NDP and the Liberal Party
00:02:15 have been synonymous for a very long time. So I don't think it was a matter of vote splitting.
00:02:21 I think that the public perception of those parties is just that they've muted into one another.
00:02:32 But there's other factors that I bring up in my article that I'm surprised are not being discussed in Canada.
00:02:42 First, I think the conservative election ran too narrowly on economics and failed to address the culture.
00:02:57 And I think that this is a trend in conservatism and youth imagination about conservatism. 0.99
00:03:06 um we have a second isn't it isn't the cliche it's the economy stupid 0.98
00:03:14 um you know people care about their pocketbooks why would that be a wrong thing to focus on 0.99
00:03:21 why would the economy be a wrong thing to focus on because it loses people who are not
00:03:28 economically literate who care about other things that they want a political direction
00:03:35 to stand behind i mean it seemed that there was a whole generation of young people who were
00:03:42 voting for pierre poliev for no other reason that he caught their imagination and showed them that
00:03:48 there could be a way that they could buy their own house start their own family do think you know
00:03:53 live the canadian dream the american dream uh have what their parents had now that's very much
00:03:59 an economic issue uh what why why would that be a wrong thing because i think i i think that the
00:04:08 anger that is certainly true and as a as an ex as an expat moving back to canada i thought that was a
00:04:16 part of a very very important strategy that would result in a conservative election
00:04:25 however i think that this was not an election between the conservatives and the liberals i
00:04:32 think it was an election between the conservatives the media the conservatives versus the liberals
00:04:41 plus the media plus the schools plus all captured federal institutions um and i didn't think and
00:04:52 And as the election grew closer and closer, it seemed like the conservatives were not
00:05:01 fighting seriously for that terrain, which would mean for many voters that even a conservative
00:05:07 victory isn't covering what they want.
00:05:11 Let me read back to you something you put in your article here, which seems to be to
00:05:16 that point.
00:05:18 You said Poirier's message of economic freedom resonated with younger voters.
00:05:25 We just talked about that.
00:05:27 Younger voters who were disillusioned by ever-worsening housing costs,
00:05:31 declining services, and a sense that the opportunity was slipping away
00:05:36 or pulled beyond their grasp.
00:05:39 And then comes the but.
00:05:43 But his campaign lacked cultural courage.
00:05:47 He avoided the questions that animate national life.
00:05:52 What does it mean to be Canadian?
00:05:54 How do we live together?
00:05:56 What should we preserve?
00:05:57 And in bypassing these questions, he forfeited the deeper contest.
00:06:03 What is cultural courage?
00:06:05 What is cultural courage?
00:06:07 I think it was C.K. Chesterton who said that traditionalism, those are different words, but it's close enough, is the democracy of the dead.
00:06:23 So I think that as large an admirer of Pauliev as I've been, I think that the vision lacked depth when it came to the most important moments.
00:06:41 Many young Canadians are very confused about our national identity.
00:06:46 Most of the media they consume is American.
00:06:49 A lot of cultural courage. I mean, before I get to cultural courage, moreover, I also mentioned that the conservatives turned down podcast opportunities with people including Joe Rogan, where they could have a three-hour discussion talking about anything.
00:07:12 And Pierre Polyev has the most compelling story of any politician in my lifetime. That is a story of how freedom in Canada exists and why it needs to be preserved.
00:07:31 The ideas that I had seen Pauliev explore before about, when I speak of the democracy of the dead, about things that matter to families, the immigration debate, the gender debate, he had a massive, massive forum for that.
00:07:56 And I think that for many young Canadians, it was a massive disappointment that while over the course of his tenure as the conservative leader, he had demonstrated courage.
00:08:13 He did not in the final moments.
00:08:18 Well, what would it look like if we had?
00:08:20 Let me let me quote back another thing that you stated here.
00:08:23 you said the pattern is clear
00:08:26 actually you said that from John Diefenbaker to Stephen Harper
00:08:30 the Conservatives governed as economic custodians
00:08:34 rarely touching the cultural assumptions
00:08:38 underpinning Canadian society
00:08:40 and then you went on that Conservatives
00:08:43 passed tax reforms while the left
00:08:46 rewrites the national story
00:08:50 through the schools, the media, the bureaucracy, and the courts.
00:08:54 And it's interesting that just a moment ago,
00:08:57 when you described who the conservatives were actually running against,
00:09:03 you used those very terms, the bureaucracy, the courts, the schools.
00:09:07 You had the liberals, the NDP, and the whole federal state, I guess.
00:09:12 um so is it is it your contention then that the conservatives while they need to do a good job on
00:09:24 economics because nobody else does at the same time they have to be fighting a cultural battle
00:09:31 that uh and and dealing with the issues that all the smart people tell them to stay away from
00:09:37 because they're divisive and they're not going to win votes.
00:09:40 Right.
00:09:42 Yeah.
00:09:44 Well, I mean, freedom from housing inflation
00:09:51 is not the same as freedom for freedom of expression,
00:10:00 freedom of the press, and...
00:10:06 Freedom of assembly.
00:10:07 all freedom of assembly it's not the same and i think that that was a mistake that's that's
00:10:19 honestly that's half of conservatism missing um i think that it's great that
00:10:28 The other thing about economic promises
00:10:31 is that they often don't manifest.
00:10:38 I think people can get behind someone
00:10:42 who promises those things,
00:10:45 and when there are enough punches pulled
00:10:51 in important battles,
00:10:55 like the battle against progressive orthodoxy
00:10:59 with the media landscape we have
00:11:03 where financial literacy is in massive decline,
00:11:10 I think the freedom to
00:11:13 was the bit missing.
00:11:19 Myself,
00:11:20 this
00:11:23 did not affect my vote
00:11:26 I know
00:11:28 that these were promises made earlier
00:11:30 but they did not come up on the campaign
00:11:32 trail so
00:11:34 a restored
00:11:35 conservatism must
00:11:38 recover
00:11:40 virtue
00:11:41 balance
00:11:44 order
00:11:45 and rootedness
00:11:48 okay now
00:11:49 All right. I think I see where you're going with this. What you're describing is a situation where financially-minded conservatives contest an election. A lot of people understand, yeah, we need to do something about the national debt. We need to do something about the high taxes. They get all that.
00:12:08 But against that background, you've got that dichotomy where people will say, look, I'm a fiscal conservative, but I'm socially liberal.
00:12:20 And that's that.
00:12:23 That's a problem.
00:12:24 Yes.
00:12:24 That is a problem because it is that is the social liberalism that actually, in the end, determines what kind of a society we're going to live in.
00:12:34 And that's a function of the media, the embedded bureaucracies, the education system, all the high points in national life are occupied by people who have what we might call a broadly progressive view.
00:12:50 And while conservatives are busy saving us money, they're teaching us our kids that all the money belongs to the state, that sort of dichotomy.
00:13:01 So how did that set of affairs come about?
00:13:04 in the second world war that's not what canadians were about now that's 80 years ago but
00:13:09 obviously things changed um how did they change who changed them
00:13:15 hmm the the answer um how do we change i guess it's really what matters i give two answers to
00:13:26 this, but the simple answer is academic institutions, which prioritized and almost completely
00:13:36 neglected. When I was in school, so about 15 or between 15 and 20 years, statistics
00:13:48 became
00:13:49 dropped as a mandatory
00:13:52 course for political science students
00:13:54 and
00:13:56 we had
00:13:58 critical theory
00:14:00 developed by the Frankfurt School
00:14:02 and postmodern
00:14:04 postmodern ideas
00:14:07 Very quickly, where are the
00:14:09 Frankfurt School? Because that sounds like it's
00:14:10 an important jumping off point
00:14:12 The Frankfurt
00:14:14 School
00:14:15 there's
00:14:18 And let's start with, yeah, the Frankfurt School, group of German theorists who came to America inspired by, you know, we had the Russian Revolution, the cultural forces working in Eastern Europe, the rise of fascism.
00:14:44 and America developing as this free market,
00:14:51 rather traditionalist state.
00:14:54 I mean, there's nowhere else in the world.
00:14:56 So they came in the 1930s, I think, did they not? 0.64
00:14:59 Yes.
00:14:59 And ended up in Columbia University?
00:15:02 Yes.
00:15:03 Yes.
00:15:03 So what was it that they did that set in motion
00:15:07 the other things that we're complaining about?
00:15:09 the frankfurt school writings are a usurping of traditionalist ideals they came to america
00:15:23 infiltrated massive universities much like the post-modernists and 0.99
00:15:30 took these ideas to deconstruct
00:15:36 conventional Western wisdom built up over centuries.
00:15:46 Right.
00:15:47 So, okay, so they took out,
00:15:49 there's a group of people with a very specific idea
00:15:51 and highly motivated,
00:15:53 took over the universities.
00:15:55 The universities taught the teachers to be,
00:15:58 you know, the theories and principles.
00:16:00 Not necessarily identifying them as radical, but teaching them as a matter of fact.
00:16:06 So that goes out into the schools, and the teachers then teach the kids, and the kids end up voting liberal.
00:16:14 Is that kind of how I'm simplifying it?
00:16:17 Well, with my generation, I would argue that that's the case.
00:16:23 Yes.
00:16:24 It's very simple.
00:16:25 they are the dominant theorists and that change came in about 2010 um because people around my
00:16:34 age noticed that that this was now being taught as fact and we're not we live in a country where
00:16:43 whole seminars are offered on the critical theorists with nothing to counter it and
00:16:50 And that's to undergraduates who do not have the balance to counter those ideas in a classroom setting and working under the tutelage of instructors who are married to these ideas.
00:17:12 So how do we turn this thing around?
00:17:16 Let's say the conservatives win the next election.
00:17:20 What should they do? They probably won't, because that's not where their heads are at. But if you could guide them, what would they do to try and bring balance back into public sentiments?
00:17:37 If I could advise the Conservative Party on the next election cycle and movement going forward, I think that the answer is that avoiding culture is riskier.
00:17:57 I'm not at all saying that we abandon economics, but the left is not avoiding culture. And I believe that cost the Canadian Conservatives the election.
00:18:10 The left is remaking culture, as conservatives seem to be struggling to figure out how to talk about it, figure out what's going on.
00:18:26 And this is very important because culture connects to how we think about everything. Justice, identity, belonging, truth. And if the conservatives surrender that ground as they did before, we've already lost the next cycle.
00:18:53 And one more thing I would advise is that the Conservatives bypass any and all traditional media in Canada and take those chances on those independent media outlets that are not bound to incentives.
00:19:19 and embrace the – there's a lot of ways of viewing the word counterculture,
00:19:30 but an online counterculture has emerged who the conservatives let down.
00:19:40 So I think those are two starting points.
00:19:44 Okay.
00:19:44 now just on that last point obviously you would expect me to as a as part of that media counter
00:19:50 culture to bite on that right away and i am um you mentioned before that the that the conservatives
00:19:58 took a pass on the opportunity to go on probably one of the most influential new media that there
00:20:05 is and that's the joe rogan show now um first of all it's american second uh it worked very well
00:20:13 for donald trump and that would have fed the the media uh line that uh well mr polyarab is just a
00:20:20 sort of a pint-sized canadian uh donald trump you know it's just a model now there's some there's
00:20:28 something to that argument but on the other hand what do you think it could have done for him if
00:20:34 had gone for it i i've heard that i i've watched joe rogan oh oh millions millions yes in three
00:20:45 days joe rogan uh got 38 million views for his interview with donald trump now
00:20:53 he wasn't going to get those numbers but it would have been he that that is not
00:20:59 an irregular
00:21:02 Do you think Canadians would have 0.92
00:21:04 flipped over to Joe Rogan
00:21:06 if they don't watch him normally
00:21:07 they would have made a point of
00:21:09 They would have heard about it
00:21:10 They would have seen clips on the news
00:21:13 They would have heard
00:21:14 Polyev
00:21:16 hopefully tell his
00:21:19 life story
00:21:20 express his vision
00:21:22 in extremely articulate terms
00:21:25 and
00:21:26 this
00:21:28 And I don't know the data for the demographics that watched Joe Rogan, but I think he would have restored a lot of the just plain hurt to disillusioned workers, blue-collar workers, and male voters.
00:21:47 yep okay well look that that certainly uh i actually agree with you on that one but a lot
00:21:55 of conservatives would tell both of us that we were we were risking a lot if we had done all that
00:22:01 yes but they're the joe rogan it's not just the podcast i've heard this criticism so many times
00:22:10 joe rogan is in the news every day that would have been
00:22:13 it wouldn't have been a matter of uh would people tune in it would be a matter of could people
00:22:21 escape could the liberals escape it because the joe rogan and the podcast world is so influential
00:22:32 and so discussed and yet when you come right back to it you have that huge uh liberal electorate
00:22:38 doesn't think about these things very much, and they're just reassured by having a mature
00:22:44 individual such as Carney as opposed to Justin Trudeau, uttering soothing words and saying he's
00:22:52 going to stick up for Canada. And of course, he doesn't threaten what they already believe to be
00:23:00 true, whereas conservatives now, or funny really when you think of the name conservative means
00:23:07 looking after things but conservatives actually are now in the situation of threatening things
00:23:13 that so many people believe to be true thanks to the efforts of these of these academics who
00:23:19 barnstormed their way into columbia university 100 years ago we are out of time unfortunately brock 0.64
00:23:28 but this has been a great discussion and i actually think that this is something that
00:23:32 or the conservative movement in Canada has to take on,
00:23:36 or simply, you know, all that will be left to be conserved
00:23:39 will be left-wing ideas that lead us to nowhere good.
00:23:43 So, thanks for coming on.
00:23:46 Great to see you, and you're moving back to Canada.
00:23:49 We wish you easy travels.
00:23:54 Thank you very much, Nigel. It was a pleasure.
00:23:56 For The Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:24:02 Thank you.