Western Standard - March 10, 2026


Travis Dhanraj breaks silence

Topics
Mentioned
Should temporary workers pay for social programs? Western Standard News Update | CBC refusing to release names banned from network | 11 Mar 2026

Episode Stats


Length

4 hours and 13 minutes

Words per minute

163.51

Word count

41,513

Sentence count

842

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Travis Dhanraj is testifying before the Canada Human Rights Commission in a case that centres around his removal from the air on Canada's public broadcaster, the CBC. Today's episode is brought to you by Cuff and Mocha, a Toronto-based podcast that focuses on Canadian politics and culture.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 We'll be right back.
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 Travis and I are returning to our breaking news routes because this is the type of story
00:01:57 that we're going to have to cover today.
00:01:59 And the reason we're all here is because Travis is testifying before.
00:02:04 Now, Can't Be Censored was born out of Travis's very public dispute with the CBC.
00:02:10 It's centered on editorial freedom, on discrimination and inside Canada's public broadcaster.
00:02:17 That particular case is before the Canada Human Rights Commission.
00:02:20 And this morning, it's also before Parliament.
00:02:23 And so in just a short while, Travis will appear before a parliamentary committee in
00:02:27 ottawa to testify inside uh inside and tell us what happened at the cbc and the events that led
00:02:33 to his removal from the air and over the next several hours i'm going to stay with you we're
00:02:38 going to take you through the lead up to that testimony we're going to bring you inside the
00:02:41 hearing live as it unfolds we'll return here for reaction once it's over as well just you want to
00:02:46 stay tuned for this travis is going to be joining us right after but first we have travis himself a
00:02:51 A lot of Travis, Travis, Travis, Travis is joining us from Ottawa.
00:02:56 Travis, how are you feeling this morning?
00:02:58 You know what, Carmen, I am glad that we're streaming this.
00:03:01 We made the decision, you know, a couple of days ago that we were going to stream this.
00:03:06 And I was disappointed to see this morning in the Toronto Star.
00:03:10 You know, I made that challenge to Brody Fenlon, the editor-in-chief of CBC and the broadcaster to stream this.
00:03:17 And to have some transparency around exactly what went on.
00:03:20 And it's disappointing that they told the star this morning that they're not going to do that, that there are other places to stream it.
00:03:25 Well, if we have to be that place, then that is what it is going to be in terms of how I'm feeling.
00:03:31 You know, you know what you know, you're my co-host, but you're also my friend.
00:03:36 You know what this has been like for me, what a struggle this has been emotionally, mentally, in terms of my reputation as well.
00:03:46 But really, Carmen, this is about something much bigger than me.
00:03:52 It really is.
00:03:53 It's about whether or not employees should be subjected to a toxic work environment.
00:03:59 I know that you are going to be speaking with another former CBC employee in the next little while about her experience, which dates back well before my time on Canada tonight.
00:04:11 And I think, you know, really over the past several days since I put out that video and even before that, people started contacting me that were either at the CBC and say that their careers were completely destroyed or people that are still there that have raised concerns repeatedly to management about the environment, about the fact that they have a double standard when it comes to certain employees, about political bias, about all of these concerns.
00:04:41 And nothing has been done.
00:04:43 You know, there are tongue lashings that the president of CBC gets here at Parliament.
00:04:49 But really, the time for that is over.
00:04:52 It's time for action.
00:04:53 We really need to see some accountability in some of these, in terms of some of these really important issues when it comes to public trust and employee safety.
00:05:03 You know, before we get to that conversation, which we will, we want to show viewers some of those key moments that brought us to this day.
00:05:10 Sure.
00:05:10 And we've got to put together for you for, you know, how the story has unfolded and why today's testimony matters.
00:05:16 Take a look. Madam Chair, and thank you for being here today.
00:05:25 One of the CBC shows that I will admit as a conservative I'd like to watch is Canada Tonight Show.
00:05:33 And of course, this features Travis Dhanraj. And I'm wondering, do you watch that show?
00:05:39 All right. And then I'm a little bit curious as to why Mr. Donrush had this exchange with you, Ms. Tate.
00:05:51 He tweeted on April 19th, 2024,
00:05:55 at the time when the public broadcaster is under increasing scrutiny and when transparency is needed,
00:06:01 Candace and I request an interview with Catherine Tate.
00:06:06 We wanted to discuss the new budget funding.
00:06:09 what it means for jobs and the corporation's strategic priorities ahead.
00:06:13 Our request was declined.
00:06:15 This is unfortunate.
00:06:16 Why did you decline, Mr. Donraj's?
00:06:19 I was on annual leave.
00:06:21 I wasn't available.
00:06:22 Okay.
00:06:23 And then Mr. Donraj curiously tweeted on April 19th, 2020,
00:06:28 or sorry, after this tweet, he tweeted on May 2nd, my apologies,
00:06:32 on May 2nd, 2024, he tweeted he was back on Canada tonight,
00:06:35 Meaning he went into, he disappeared from the air for a week or ten days there.
00:06:44 Was this because of any type of repercussions?
00:06:46 Because he asked, he was calling out to you publicly missed it?
00:06:49 I'm not aware of any repercussions, no.
00:06:52 Because just on the heels of my colleague, Ms. Ashton's comments, I find it a little
00:06:57 bit strange that one of your stars, Mr. Donrush, calls you out publicly, and then he disappears
00:07:04 from the air for for a week or ten days and I would just like to point you to
00:07:09 your own conflict of interest policy that says our standards do not change
00:07:13 when the CBC or a partner of CBC becomes the public interest becomes the story
00:07:19 public interest guides our choices do you still stand by this statement of
00:07:24 course and I just to be clear I don't get involved in the programming and
00:07:28 scheduling decisions in the newsroom so I have to assume that that there's a
00:07:33 reason that occurred for Travis Danraj, but I'm not, again, involved in any of those discussions.
00:07:41 Okay, well, I mean, I'm not a booking agent for Mr. Danraj, but I would assume that he would
00:07:47 probably like to have you on the show again. If Mr. Danraj reached out to you, would you commit
00:07:52 to going on to a show? I will look at all invitations. As you can imagine, we have many,
00:07:57 many shows and that's just at CBC Hydro Canada so where I try to make myself
00:08:02 available to as many as I can given whatever is on the schedule at the time.
00:08:08 And just to finish up, you did give me a complete I guess rejection of my
00:08:16 premise that perhaps there was something off the fact that Mr. Damaraj was taken
00:08:20 off the air shortly after calling out you publicly. Can you confirm right
00:08:24 unequivocally to the committee that there were no reprisals or no negative outcomes to Mr. Donaraj
00:08:30 for his calling you out publicly for not appearing on his show. I'm not aware of any.
00:08:37 Okay, just to bring some context to that for people who are just watching, that was a past
00:08:41 committee hearing. This is the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage that Travis is appearing
00:08:46 before today. That was a past hearing with past President Catherine Tate. What this committee
00:08:52 specifically looking into is the broader health of mainstream media it's got a particular focus
00:08:57 on cbc which you're going to be bringing that's why they brought catherine tate um to um to test
00:09:02 to testify and what she was saying which is one of the almost it wasn't the starting point for you
00:09:08 but it was one of the big things that happened where you had approached uh catherine at the time
00:09:14 when you know there's a story about executive bonuses and you wanted her to appear on your show
00:09:18 and because of that public call out you were disciplined for it well you know we had an
00:09:24 editorial meeting and i and i didn't make the request but it was one of the chase producers
00:09:29 that made the request to miss kate's office because there was this conversation going on
00:09:33 about executive bonuses and we wanted to ask her about that we wanted to ask her about broader
00:09:38 issues with the public broadcaster so i'm going into the studio on that day and i i i get a and
00:09:45 I know that, you know, the request has been declined.
00:09:48 And I thought to myself, well, that's unfortunate that, you know, we're talking about public trust here.
00:09:53 There should be transparency around some of these issues.
00:09:55 And the president, the then president, because she's not the president anymore of CBC, doesn't want to do an interview.
00:10:02 That's unfortunate.
00:10:03 So I tweeted two facts that we requested a interview with her and that it was declined.
00:10:09 It's unfortunate.
00:10:11 You know, what followed after that was just shocking to me.
00:10:15 As I am a former journalist now, but I was a journalist when this all happened, it was absolutely shocking that I was pulled into a disciplinary hearing.
00:10:24 There needs to be a separation between those that govern the corporation, has the corporation's interests in mind, and the news division.
00:10:33 That is sacrosanct. The news division should have separation.
00:10:37 So while I was going through all of this, my head was spinning because I'm like, am I in a twilight zone here?
00:10:42 what kind of message does this send to other journalists in the newsroom that simply want
00:10:49 to do their job and report the news and miss tate you know her testimony it it was surprising to me
00:10:55 as well because i brought to ottawa the receipts and so we will be discussing uh this morning in
00:11:02 my opening statement that you know example there but that really was kind of a bit of a breaking
00:11:08 point there were so many things that happened prior to that and after that but it really was
00:11:14 a shocking moment now there is a new president of cbc and i thought with the new president coming in
00:11:19 there would be some accountability around some of these issues but there does not seem to be
00:11:25 any change when it comes to really some of these fundamental issues that are core to
00:11:30 to be people being able to do their jobs without fear of reprisal uh travis we're gonna let you
00:11:39 go in a few minutes because i know you have to head in but i do what to expect today what you're
00:11:45 you know preview what you're saying sure yeah let me just let me just say this before before i take
00:11:50 off because i do have to head into the hearing i this i and i said this in in the video that that i
00:11:56 did the other day you know some people will say this is a partisan issue that you want to destroy
00:12:01 the public broadcaster i have said you know the story carmen i i grew up watching the cbc that i
00:12:08 worked there when i was 19 years old on jonavision i used to walk around the cbc broadcast center in
00:12:15 awe and the heart of this organization i would use to sneak into the newsroom when i was 19 years
00:12:20 just to look around because it was this place that brought canadians together so this is not
00:12:27 about whether or not you're a conservative or you're a liberal or ndp or green or bloc it's
00:12:32 about whether you're a canadian and you want an institution in this country that has been around
00:12:39 for 60 years to be able to you know have trust when it comes to taxpayer dollars it's 1.4 billion
00:12:48 dollars we're talking about here and some of these issues around workplace culture some of these
00:12:53 issues around bias that exists some of these issues about double standards that should not happen in
00:12:59 any workplace let alone a public institution so that's what i'll say i'll have more to say coming
00:13:05 up inside but and i'll talk to you as soon as uh we wrap up as well okay there we'll be watching
00:13:12 uh in the meantime as travis heads in uh i did have a conversation yesterday with someone else
00:13:18 um we've been getting a lot of you know um emails and uh messages from people who've had similar
00:13:25 types of experiences as travis and wanting to share their experience uh with the cbc at the cbc
00:13:31 with us uh one of those people her name is karen johnson now she's never met travis
00:13:37 I've never met her either. She reached out to us after hearing the story and for the first time
00:13:43 she's so I want to show you that conversation I had with her a little bit earlier. Our next guest
00:13:50 spent more than 25 years in television and radio including more than a decade at the weather
00:13:55 network and appearances on national programs like Canada AM. In 2017 she joined CBC as a weather
00:14:03 specialists in toronto but after raising concerns about what she called a toxic workplace less than
00:14:09 a year later she was dismissed and after exhausting efforts through her union and internal management
00:14:16 to raise the concerns she made a direct appeal in 2018 to cbc president catherine tate now she
00:14:24 describes systemic problems inside the newsroom including harassment bullying workplace culture
00:14:29 and management practices she ultimately left the industry altogether now she has never spoken with
00:14:36 travis before this week but reached out just days ago saying she wanted to share her experience
00:14:42 after seeing news of his story i want to welcome karen johnson into this program now karen thank
00:14:49 you so much for being here i told a little bit about your story where you say you joined cbc
00:14:54 it was a dream but then within days starting something happened tell us a little bit about that
00:14:59 I think it was probably my first week. I think I saw a lot of red flags. I guess starting with,
00:15:08 I actually had a friend who was doing traffic on the radio side of CBC, and she was having,
00:15:15 going into those sort of labor pains, and no one was going to take her to the hospital. 0.53
00:15:20 And so I'm only there maybe in my second day. So I said, I'll take her. So I took her in a cab.
00:15:28 and when i came back i was asked where where have you been like what are you doing where'd you go
00:15:33 and i said well i told you and you told me to go take her to the hospital and i did um so right
00:15:38 from there i just thought things were not normal and then my first week on the radio side just it
00:15:45 was probably icier than any sort of uh uh an ice box you could feel people were not friendly not
00:15:52 welcoming uh they were upset i got the job over i guess another employee that they considered um
00:15:59 probably a lot more credit to their name and who's doing the job previous so there were a lot of red
00:16:06 flags but i thought you know what be a team player you're new to the newsroom make friends just go
00:16:12 with the flow don't cause issues you know you later described what you experienced as part of
00:16:17 like a broader workplace culture problem not just those specific incidents that you mentioned what
00:16:23 led you to to believe that and what was happening behind the scenes so um you're when you're hired
00:16:30 if i don't know if anybody knows this when you're hired at cbc or any other sort of newsroom you
00:16:34 have a nine month probation uh during that nine months things should be brought up to you if
00:16:40 there's concerns or what have you that usually what happens i was actually days to my probation
00:16:47 being over when i got called in um to say that i wasn't standing in the right place of a weather
00:16:57 green screen which i've been doing for 25 years i wasn't giving accurate information but i've never
00:17:03 had a complaint about my my um my information so um all this started to tag on i was humiliated
00:17:12 in the newsroom when i was told to not go into studio told to wait i was berated i was screamed
00:17:18 at um and then told what am i going to make things better to improve the situation a situation that i
00:17:26 didn't even cause i was just doing what i was told to do uh things like that um i got written up for
00:17:33 having a thick eyeliner on my on my makeup on my my face and we had makeup artists who did our makeup
00:17:39 so that was a comment i had gotten from an executive producer she's nice but she wears too 1.00
00:17:44 much eyeliner out of my hands um i was called a bimbo uh um on day 10 that i sounded like a bimbo
00:17:53 uh on the air that was one of the criticisms that i had received i'd never been called that in my
00:17:58 life uh even a brown uh barbie which was um not great was that from someone who supervised you
00:18:06 yes that was actually my producer in day day 10 on the job and that led you eventually to
00:18:12 write to the president tell us about that yes so i went through the union i went through the
00:18:18 president i had a case i even hired an external lawyer um i was getting nowhere and i thought you
00:18:24 I have to bring it to somebody's attention because honestly, I felt like I was an Alice in Wonderland
00:18:30 and you have all those mirrors and you see these doors and you think that there's an opening and
00:18:34 there's a crack there and you can get through and it's not, it's fake. It doesn't exist.
00:18:39 And I was honestly, I was losing it. I was losing myself. I was yelling at my kids. I was taking it
00:18:47 out of my family. I was spiraling. And I thought, what better thing to do? Let me just try and reach
00:18:53 out and see if i can connect with someone show them my proof show them my evidence because i
00:18:58 kept detail account of everything and the door just got slammed in my face no one listened to
00:19:05 me no one heard me i feel like i just got failed i had a case we were in in arbitration um it was
00:19:14 our turn it was my turn to testify and our union lawyer bailed i mean it's been so many years and
00:19:21 i can still hear how this has affected you to this day um you know would you talk a bit maybe about
00:19:29 how this has taken a toll on your mental health what it was like emotionally i know you're talking
00:19:34 a bit about like how it affected your home life but talk to us a bit more about the impact
00:19:41 there's nothing like i just didn't know what to do i was at work i got called in and before i
00:19:47 knew it i didn't even have my belongings i was showed the door the side door to cbc on front
00:19:52 street i didn't even know what hit me i i'll be very honest with you i didn't understand
00:20:01 just reading everything going to the union i didn't understand the cause for dismissal
00:20:07 the same things that they were trying to reprimand me on i'd be looking and watching
00:20:12 looking at the social feeds looking at the show people were doing the worst or probably the exact
00:20:18 same thing and i just i couldn't put two together i really couldn't there's a lot of pretty pictures
00:20:25 on the outside and then when you get inside you know what the real story is and how people are
00:20:29 treated there's a two-tier system and people who work hard who are respectful who want to be team
00:20:37 players, they don't get recognized. And it's really sad because the CBC has really taken the flame
00:20:49 and extinguished so many great careers of journalists out there from reporters to anchors
00:20:55 to weather people for no reason at all. And it's like a little high school. It's favorites. It's,
00:21:02 oh, if you go out for drinks with this one, you know, they have that clique. I'm sorry. I'm past
00:21:07 high school. I'm there to do a job, do it well, inform the Canadian people. The CBC needs to be
00:21:15 just pivoting and understand what they're doing is wrong. And in some companies, illegal what they
00:21:24 do to people and the fact that they are protected is just absolutely mind-blowing just mind-blowing
00:21:32 and we're not talking just simple black and white things like these are things that are
00:21:38 you look and go am I crazy you question everything about yourself you question your credibility you
00:21:46 question your skills you question your talent you you question everything about yourself who you are
00:21:53 what you do and no person should be put through that nobody okay karen johnson we appreciate you
00:22:00 sharing your story for the first time on can't be censored thank you thank you
00:22:08 okay that was taped a little bit earlier uh earlier with karen johnson she is a former cbc
00:22:14 employee and those are really um tough things to hear uh i like travis was a former journalist
00:22:21 working inside newsrooms um if you miss karen what she said this is the first time she's spoken out
00:22:26 publicly she talked about being called a brown barbie um being called a bimbo being berated
00:22:33 in the newsroom in front of all her colleagues and the impact that that had on her in her career
00:22:39 which ultimately led her to quit journalism altogether um and uh you know in that interview
00:22:47 to this day she still sort of questions herself she um and it's the same thing with travis where
00:22:52 it's it's like you know am i seeing things the right way is it just me or does is does anyone
00:22:57 else see that um that's kind of like the common thread that i've kind of seen through this but
00:23:02 both have come to the realization that what they experienced was real and they want to
00:23:08 share their experiences and that's what travis is doing today uh in ottawa so for all of you that
00:23:14 are joining us i think we've got about a thousand people with us good morning my name is carmen
00:23:18 wong i am one of the co-host can't be censored travis as you know is the other co-host and he
00:23:24 is in ottawa today we spoke a little bit earlier uh what he's doing is at 11 o'clock we'll bring
00:23:29 this to you live he is inside of a parliamentary committee uh it is called the standing committee
00:23:36 on canadian heritage and what these committees do is they look at particular issues related to their
00:23:42 uh to their topics so this committee the heritage committee uh this step in
00:23:49 health of mainstream media in canada so that encompasses print broadcasts digital news
00:23:57 and there's a special focus on cbc's funding and mandate given that they're funded by taxpayers
00:24:04 by the government to the tune of over a billion dollars so that is what we are looking forward to
00:24:11 at 11 o'clock we've got a lot of um great interviews set up for you we've got catherine
00:24:17 marshall who is travis's lawyer coming up i also have brian lily who you might know as a sun
00:24:24 columnist speaking to us we've got colby hall who is the founding
00:24:32 of mediaite in the u.s and he talks about the intersection of politics
00:24:41 So we've got Travis right after the right after his testimony talking to us as well about what that was like.
00:24:50 And, you know, there's been a lot said publicly. Travis has put a lot out there publicly on our podcast in particular.
00:24:59 He's not done any interviews. And I know that he had said, well, I'm going to be speaking in front of committee under parliamentary privilege.
00:25:08 And a lot of people took issue with that. So they said, people are saying, why did you have to wait
00:25:16 for parliamentary privilege to talk about this? And the reason why, Travis will explain, is because
00:25:22 he wants to actually name names. And when you do that against someone who may work at a bigger
00:25:28 corporation, you expose yourself to the possibility of legal action. And so when you testify before
00:25:36 parliament you're protected under this parliamentary privilege supposedly and so uh what you say there
00:25:42 can't be used against you in a legal way um so that is what he meant by it i know some people
00:25:48 had questions of that um part of what he was fighting for um and his dispute with the cbc
00:25:53 had to do with not only workplace culture but um you know he says discrimination editorial control
00:26:00 and we've got some clips of uh of you know some of the things that he did on air
00:26:09 um with his show because he tried to bring a
00:26:12 Laura, listen, you know, I appreciate you doing this interview.
00:26:28 I think, you know, it's interesting to hear your perspective from being in the inner circle.
00:26:32 But a lot of people in this country and yours would not agree with that view.
00:26:38 They think that, you know, another potential Trump presidency would be disastrous.
00:26:42 What do you say to people, not only in the United States, but here in Canada, that have that view of the situation?
00:26:49 Well, I would ask them, what is it that they thought was such a disaster the first time around?
00:26:53 Was it that, you know, people were prospering here in America, unlike we'd seen in many decades?
00:26:58 You had things like manufacturing coming back, historic trade agreements with, you know, Canada and Mexico,
00:27:03 historic trade agreements with China, as I just alluded to, the Abraham Accords in the Middle East,
00:27:09 meetings with kim jong-un to denuclearize the korean peninsula how about an energy policy that made us
00:27:15 energy independent and gave us strength on the world stage those were very important things so
00:27:21 i think my question would be how was life for you as an american citizen or perhaps as a canadian
00:27:27 citizen when donald trump was in office and if you take the tweets that people didn't like out
00:27:32 of it and perhaps his personality out of it and people are very honest i don't think travis there's
00:27:37 a whole lot that people could say negative in fact i think you're going to see a lot of people
00:27:41 who voted for joe biden in this country in 2020 coming over to vote for donald trump in 2024 i
00:27:48 can't let you go without asking about the upcoming trials uh and the court cases do you think that
00:27:53 those are going to have a negative impact and do you know if your father-in-law is going to testify
00:27:58 on the defamation trial uh well i'll leave all the specifics of course to the lawyers but what
00:28:03 I can tell you is that people in this country have had what I believe is probably an inverse
00:28:08 reaction to the intention of all of these indictments. The reality is Donald Trump is
00:28:13 going to be the Republican nominee. It is time for Joe Biden and his Department of Justice to do away
00:28:18 with all of these indictments. I think a lot of people in this country feel like the goal of them
00:28:23 was to deter Donald Trump to perhaps throw mud his way and tell anyone who might potentially
00:28:28 support him, this might not be the guy for you. And it's actually Travis had the inverse effect
00:28:34 of that. He, every single indictment has gone up with his poll numbers, especially after that mug
00:28:40 shot in Georgia, poll numbers through the roof. I think the people of this country who feel that
00:28:45 this system here is not working for them understands that that same system is working
00:28:50 against Donald Trump. Why all of the effort against one man? Why the attempt to keep one guy
00:28:56 so much out of the White House. I think it only rallies support behind him.
00:29:01 And I think you're going to see proof of that tomorrow in New Hampshire. You'll see it in
00:29:04 Nevada, South Carolina, and I believe you'll see it on November 5th when he's elected as the 47th
00:29:09 president. Well, we shall see about that. No doubt who you are backing, Laura Trump.
00:29:14 Appreciate the time tonight. That is Laura Trump joining us from Palm Beach, Florida.
00:29:20 Okay. So that was a old clip of Travis's show, Canada Tonight. He had Laura Trump on. That was
00:29:25 one of the people he was permitted to have on, but he will tell you in his testimony today,
00:29:30 there was a lot of pushback when it came to having a diversity of voices, different perspectives of
00:29:35 political leadings on his program. So that's what we wanted to show you from that clip. Again,
00:29:43 just if you're joining us, I want to remind you, you're watching Can't Be Censored. This is a live
00:29:47 stream, a live broadcast leading up to the testimony 11 o'clock, which we will stream
00:29:52 live here on our channel. There's a comments button for you. If you want to send a comment,
00:30:00 if you want to send a question for me or for Travis, I will make sure we read that and get
00:30:03 back to you either on the broadcast or afterwards. But right now, I want to bring in someone who is
00:30:11 very experienced in these sorts of issues. Catherine Marshall is an employment and human
00:30:16 rights lawyer. She's the founding partner of Marshall Law, and she also happens to be
00:30:20 Travis's lawyer. Catherine, good morning. Thanks for being here.
00:30:24 Thanks for having me.
00:30:29 Okay, so Travis has his case before the Human Rights Commission. But in the meantime, he's also testifying in front of this parliamentary committee. So how do those two things, you know, work together?
00:30:43 Well, today is going to be a huge day because Travis is able to speak freely about the case
00:30:49 and the evidence and name names under the protection of parliamentary privilege. So,
00:30:55 the case, the Human Rights Commission case is continuing to proceed and that will
00:31:02 keep going and we'll see what the CBC has to say after today.
00:31:07 i mean they're what their line has been catherine is just you know they um they deny everything they
00:31:21 don't agree with his accounting of things that you know they stand behind their news and their
00:31:25 employees and so they kind of they're already giving us a sense that they're going to dispute
00:31:31 um most of what he's claiming um but maybe you can take us because you've been through
00:31:37 this process before take us through like kind of what a committee hearing might look like for
00:31:42 Travis like does he you know do an opening statement what happens for the committee hearing
00:31:48 or the human rights hearing oh okay yeah yeah the committee hearing um he'll get to do an opening
00:31:57 statement and then he'll be asked questions by the parliamentarians who are there and then the
00:32:03 members of parliament will be able to ask him really anything that they want and this committee
00:32:11 hearing is about a study that's going on and to the CBC so it will be the first of numerous
00:32:18 committee meetings but I think we can expect that Travis is going to be very uncensored and
00:32:26 look there's a lot of intimidation that happens in these kinds of cases
00:32:30 oftentimes people get threatened with lawsuits for defamation and they get intimidated and we
00:32:37 know in travis's case the cbc desperately wanted him to sign a gig order they wanted to muzzle him
00:32:44 today is their worst nightmare the idea that he gets to sit there in parliament really saying
00:32:49 exactly what happened to him and telling the truth i think is the the last thing they wanted
00:32:55 to see happen. So if there's power in today and being able to just tell the truth and not
00:33:03 be sued for it or not be intimidated for it. So I'm very looking forward to today.
00:33:12 And maybe you can just bring us up to speed on some of the key points in Travis's claim that's
00:33:20 going to go before the Human Rights Commission without going in too much detail, but the broad
00:33:24 strokes in terms of what you'll be arguing yeah so his claim is for discrimination um we're going
00:33:33 to be arguing that the cbc um created a very toxic and discriminatory work environment for travis
00:33:41 that they recruited him as a token they expected him to espouse a certain point of view as a
00:33:49 a racialized person. And when he did it, they retaliated against him. And they didn't allow
00:33:55 him to have freedom of speech or voice or thought or opinion. And then they essentially drove him
00:34:02 out on a leave and tried to force him to sign an NDA and tried to force him to basically give in
00:34:11 to whatever they wanted. And those are going to be the core issues of the claim. And we do expect
00:34:17 is going to go to a hearing and there'll be a lot of witnesses we plan on subpoenaing
00:34:23 many people from the cbc to come speak and we have a lot of former cbc employees who want to
00:34:30 speak out as well so it's going to be a significant hearing okay katherine marshall i appreciate your
00:34:39 time katherine is travis's lawyer she's a founding partner at marshall law and an employment human 1.00
00:34:44 rights lawyer right now i want to bring in um colby hall colby is the founding editor of media
00:34:49 it is a top u.s based website covering the intersection of media and politics
00:34:53 colby appreciate you being here hi
00:35:02 okay i think
00:35:07 okay i don't know i can't hear colby but maybe that's on my end
00:35:11 and he's our producer. He'll send me a quick note to let me know. But while we're trying to get that
00:35:18 up and going, I'll just say, you know, Colby doesn't know the ins and outs of what's about
00:35:23 to happen here at Parliament. But my co-host, Travis Danraj, is testifying before a parliamentary
00:35:32 committee. And this parliamentary committee, it is called the Standing Committee on Canadian
00:35:37 heritage we just shortened that to the heritage committee they're looking at the broader um health
00:35:43 of mainstream media in canada uh that can include print and broadcast and digital news and um a
00:35:49 specific look at you know public funding of the broadcaster and i think we have colby back with
00:35:55 colby can you hear me now i can how are you good sorry about that i don't know what happened i just
00:36:01 magically worked um so i thought we'd chat with you about so travis and i were both come from
00:36:07 mainstream media uh earlier travis left a short time ago and today we're doing this special
00:36:14 live coverage because he's testifying before a parliamentary committee about um his experiences
00:36:19 at the public broadcaster it's called the cbc uh which the government funds this tune of over a
00:36:24 billion dollars here and so at issue is um you know trust in traditional journalism um and also
00:36:31 kind of you know where audiences are going is what i want to cover with you because
00:36:35 we're we're we're podcasting we're on youtube we're doing all sorts of things that aren't
00:36:39 um you know mainstream media and that seems to be the direction of of most things now where
00:36:44 people are heading and tuning into a hundred percent um you know it's a really sort of
00:36:50 disruptive and confusing time for media in general and you know the travis uh story is a fascinating
00:36:56 one um there are parallels to what happened in the united states with uri milliner and um npr
00:37:02 and allegations of sort of bias but a lack of diversity of voices i think the situation in
00:37:09 canada is different of course because cbc plays such a more central role in the media landscape
00:37:13 whereas npr is more sort of um that created more of a broader conversation about sort of media bias
00:37:20 in general but what all this does is it sort of we've entered this weird sort of um through the
00:37:27 looking glass where we are assessing how stories are reported and not just the stories that are
00:37:32 being reported and there is a real crisis of trust with legacy media um some of it is earned some of
00:37:39 it is as a result of like long-term or really effective rhetorical attacks on outlets that
00:37:46 aren't are pretty specious those attacks but in that kind of ugly milieu has been this sort of
00:37:52 wonderful rise of independent outlets um and the independent outlets like this and many others
00:37:59 you know is a dual-edged sword what's great about it is you can find reliable outlets that are well
00:38:04 informed and smart and have a strong point of view of course there's also the sort of more pernicious
00:38:09 side of it of independent outlets that just go for kind of zazzy click bait and may not
00:38:17 you know they sort of pollute the the reservoir of information in a toxic way
00:38:22 so it's a good news bad news thing but i think you know big picture we're going through this
00:38:26 massive massive transformation in a very short period of time it's as if the you know sort of
00:38:31 the printing press was you know invented and they had five years to create guardrails we we don't
00:38:37 right like we've between the rise of independent media social media ai algorithms like we all feel
00:38:46 pretty untethered and it's what makes travis's testimony so fascinating because it's getting to
00:38:51 the essence of what are facts and what is truth yeah and you know i think travis and i take great
00:39:00 pains to say that we're not journalists anymore like we don't there is a need for journalism
00:39:04 there is a need for people who gather facts and report them in an objective way that's not what
00:39:09 we're doing um but there's also you know a lot of local news deserts in the country in us and in
00:39:15 America and Canada, where people don't have access to what's happening inside their community. So
00:39:20 there is a need for journalism, for local news. And that's why the CBC, the argument Travis is
00:39:27 making is not that we need to defund it, that we need to get rid of it, but we need to make sure
00:39:31 we improve the workplace culture, but also any sort of perceived bias. And part of that, I want
00:39:38 to ask you about whether people have an issue with CBC being funded by the government, but is it any
00:39:44 better when things are funded by big corporations you know it's like what's what's the trade-off
00:39:49 there well they're similar honestly like if you watch you know i cover uh us media and so as a
00:39:56 result like the vacuum of sort of political leadership has been filled with sort of loud
00:40:01 voices on cable news and so i mean to our previous conversation i think we're sort of seeing the end
00:40:07 of the golden era of cable news which is probably good but cable news for example is largely funded
00:40:14 if you watch any cable news for any extended period of time all you're just washed over with
00:40:19 just sort of a raft of pharmaceutical commercials in the united us that's that's okay and that's
00:40:24 legal and guess what is never really covered on cable news anything critical about sort of
00:40:31 pharmaceutical industry and so to your point like when big corporations who who aren't necessarily
00:40:39 committed to journalistic standards are are looking to sort of make money and fuel their big
00:40:47 corporations they are dispassionate about that they don't really care necessarily they should
00:40:52 be fact-based and often are fact-based but often turn into analysis and um you know so and the
00:40:59 decisions getting to culture the decisions of bias aren't necessarily saying someone on the left is
00:41:05 bad and someone on the right is bad or anything like that it's more about choosing what not to
00:41:09 cover right you see it on conservative media in the united states well they'll never say anything
00:41:14 critical about president trump he wore a cap during the sort of service at dover when fallen
00:41:21 soldiers arrived had that happened under a democratic president that would have been 0.87
00:41:25 outraged for a week non-stop so to your question i think when the government funds something like cbc
00:41:32 or or npr like i think it raises a different set of questions and i think it it what it what it's
00:41:39 what makes travis's sort of complaint so interesting and what i thought was really
00:41:43 smart about his complaint is that it's a cultural thing that there is a tendency for newsrooms and
00:41:52 networks to have a level of groupthink that they're not even aware of and as our audience
00:41:58 becomes really balkanized with like sort of more you know across the spectrum you know it becomes
00:42:04 increasingly important to be fact-based and truth oriented but also share voices that you may not
00:42:11 agree it's a it's sort of what the heterodox is like make it a marketplace of ideas where you
00:42:16 can hear other people as long again as it's responsible and it's fact-based then that's i
00:42:21 think responsible journalism the other thing i have to say and i hate to even bring it up but
00:42:25 but we're in this weird kind of post-truth world.
00:42:28 Journalism is a fact-based, purely objective thing.
00:42:33 And I'm not sure in a postmodern world
00:42:35 that exists to the degree that we'd like for it to believe,
00:42:37 that you can always find bias in anything.
00:42:40 And I think we are really struggling
00:42:42 with some navel-gazing obsession
00:42:44 of people wanting to find problems when there aren't.
00:42:49 You can't please all the people all the time.
00:42:51 So this testimony today,
00:42:54 I'm not fluent necessarily in Canadian media landscape, but it's fascinating because it's
00:42:59 really about how media, how we consume media in general, internationally.
00:43:05 Okay, Colby Hall, appreciate your time today. Thank you so much.
00:43:07 Thanks for having me.
00:43:10 Okay, next up, we want to bring in conservative MP, Phil Lawrence. Phil, good morning to you.
00:43:17 How are you?
00:43:18 Good morning. How are you, Carmen?
00:43:20 good and we actually played a clip of you uh earlier this morning on our um on our broadcast
00:43:27 it was you questioning catherine tate uh in a previous session of this um of this committee
00:43:35 and uh so that was you we'll just tell people that that clip that we played um and today you're
00:43:40 taking part in the committee again so uh let us know kind of what you'll be talking about and what
00:43:46 you expect today and and how it's been going in terms of this uh this study yeah so so first off
00:43:53 i remember that testimony that exchange changed with katherine tate about travis and it really
00:44:00 goes to i think some of the heart of what know what mr donrush has been talking about on can't
00:44:04 be censored in other places is to um if you're going to hold yourself out as a journalist if
00:44:09 you're going to hold yourself out as a national broadcaster one who is responsible for telling
00:44:15 truth to canadians you have to hold yourself accountable and the look on kathleen tate's
00:44:20 face uh when i asked her uh about what was going on with travis donraj at the time of course he
00:44:25 had asked her to appear on his show uh and uh i don't know if the video really captured but being
00:44:31 in the room there um you're you're an interviewer so you would you would realize this but there's
00:44:36 when when you have someone there who's completely flat-footed you can just sort of read it in their
00:44:41 face, right? And she was completely, it appeared to me, I don't want to cast aspersions, but it
00:44:47 appeared to me that there was something not right, I guess I'll put it that way. And so I'm really
00:44:51 looking forward to Travis's testimony. I won't ask, I want to be candid, I won't actually be
00:44:56 asking Travis any questions today, but I am very much looking forward to him, Mr. Don Raj, telling
00:45:02 his story. And of my six-year career, that interaction with Ms. Tate, it is one of those
00:45:09 vivid memories I have in those six years of her sort of being completely flat-footed and me
00:45:14 thinking something is definitely not right here. Yeah and you know through all this I mean I think
00:45:20 Travis and I are both you know we're not necessarily proponents of like defund the CBC get rid of it
00:45:26 all of it's bad but there are problems within it that need to be addressed for having you know
00:45:31 the risk being the recipient of over a billion dollars worth of government funding so I'm
00:45:36 wondering from you know conservative party's perspective or do where do you stand in terms of
00:45:40 uh you know how things go forward the cbc their funding and what what are your expectations from
00:45:45 them yeah so number one what and uh we of course campaigned in the last test and the last campaign
00:45:52 about defunding the cbc but i would tell folks that my problem with the cbc i didn't know i don't
00:45:58 didn't want to end it either um but if they are going to be receiving over a billion dollars i
00:46:04 they're up to almost 1.5 billion dollars in taxpayer dollars just like any other organization
00:46:09 that receives funding uh from a hospital to a child care they have to be accountable to the
00:46:15 people of canadians to the canadian people and quite frankly miss tate's answers were extremely
00:46:20 evasive and cbc continues to not uh not be fully forthright about what's going on and that's what
00:46:27 like every other canadian should be i'm very interested in hearing uh what mr donrush has
00:46:31 to say at heritage committee so yeah and i think with my previous guest we're talking a little bit
00:46:36 about um the decline of traditional media the decline of traditional journalism but also the
00:46:42 need to have like journalism to have local news to have some and uh at the committee today the
00:46:48 witnesses also include uniform includes news media canada it's got two digital news um startups and
00:46:55 you know you represent a rural Ontario writing and so where do you kind of see um where do you
00:47:01 kind of see the future of journalism of mainstream media of that sort of thing uh from someone who
00:47:07 represents a rural writing who may not have access to to you know coverage like we do in big cities
00:47:14 yeah my my own belief is that no one has a monopoly on the truth and that often the best
00:47:19 way of sort of filtering out the truth is to get it through multiple different sources and so
00:47:24 uh i heard your last interview it was excellent about uh the gentleman was talking about the
00:47:28 vulcanization uh of of our media and the fact that we're that what's going on now is that many
00:47:34 people across the country are just hearing from select sources i would encourage everyone to step
00:47:39 out of their echo chamber um and and hear from multiple you shouldn't be just listening to cbc
00:47:45 you shouldn't just be listening to a one particular podcaster you need to get a variety of sources so
00:47:51 that you can get a full picture of what's what's been going on um and so like i said i mean it's
00:47:56 trite to say at this point that the echo chambers sort of put us all uh so we all think we only know
00:48:02 that bit of the truth uh we really need that wide variety and once again for for uh news outlets
00:48:09 like the cbc and many others quite frankly who are receiving government money there must be
00:48:12 accountability there must be transparency okay i'm not going to keep you i know you're trying
00:48:19 to get into committee as well um so i've got a vote actually to get to speaking to maybe some
00:48:24 other point in time anytime thanks very much okay take care okay next uh next up i have i want to
00:48:32 bring in brian lily um brian is a veteran of canadian media he is currently part of the sun
00:48:37 news network he's built one of the most followed independent conservative media presences here in
00:48:43 this country through his sub stack and through his youtube channel lily unleashed and a friend of the
00:48:47 show brian hi how are you good to see you and a long time ago wrote a book all about cbc and the
00:48:54 problems with it that how old is that book 2012 it came out is there anything in there that's
00:49:02 changed or is that different different from what you wrote well you know the um listening to you
00:49:10 uh speak with colby and then with phil um you know and phil was talking about catherine
00:49:17 not disturb um talking about catherine tate showing up a committee and being dismissive
00:49:26 there's whole chapters in there at one point the the largest libel settlement in canadian history
00:49:33 was with cbc and a doctor out of ottawa who they smeared his reputation claimed he was taking uh
00:49:40 his his findings were because he uh was taking trips from a pharmaceutical company uh was proven
00:49:47 that wasn't true he asked for a simple apology they refused to admit they did anything wrong
00:49:52 uh and so um they ended up having to pay a million dollars because they wouldn't say sorry
00:49:58 when i first started with the sun in 2010 cbc had just become um uh subject to the access to
00:50:06 information act and you know there were limits you can't find out about their journalism or
00:50:10 sources or things like that but how the business is run they were supposed to be like any government
00:50:14 department and there was a stack of uh a tips that our company had filed paid for filed but
00:50:22 it was all nothing they wouldn't admit to anything and so i made that the story at one point carmen
00:50:27 um hubert la croix the then head of cbc was hauled before committee and asked why
00:50:35 uh they were claiming that they ran the entire network with one uh ford sedan and one truck
00:50:42 because we just asked a simple question how many vehicles does CBC own or lease for their network
00:50:50 everything was redacted except they admitted to one sedan it was like a Ford Taurus or something
00:50:56 and one truck yeah they just wouldn't admit to basic things that everyone else is supposed to
00:51:04 do and and I remember writing at the time if CBC is allowed to get away with this
00:51:09 then every other department will learn and the access to information program will become worse
00:51:15 well guess what cbc wasn't held to account that was under a conservative government definitely
00:51:20 not under the true to liberals and the access to information system that journalists rely on
00:51:25 has become worse you find out less information it takes you longer they charge you more
00:51:30 um everyone learned from cbc you can get away with ignoring the public ignoring those pesky
00:51:36 journalists why do you think why do you think that they operate like that like you know without
00:51:44 transparency they you know they do receive so much government money um is it like a culture thing is
00:51:50 it systemic is it like sometimes maybe there's nothing even to hide like why why would it be a
00:51:55 big deal to tell people people expect businesses to run with vehicles it's it's not something that
00:52:01 you may necessarily need to hide why do you think there is this culture of secrecy
00:52:05 um there's an arrogance with cbc that you don't find elsewhere now look i've never been employed
00:52:14 by cbc but i have worked for uh bell media the old chum uh set up um you know i think the only
00:52:24 major private one i haven't worked for is rogers and and each major corporation has their own way
00:52:32 doing things their own views through but cbc just operates on a different level and you know so over
00:52:40 the years a lot of their journalists have been frustrated with the the secrecy and long before
00:52:45 we're not just talking about travis uh some of my best sources for cbc stories over the years have
00:52:50 been people inside cbc i remember um talking to one outside of the uh uh ottawa headquarters
00:52:59 and they just pointed at the building and said you've got 12 floors of uh paper pushers in there
00:53:06 no one knows what they're doing uh compared to the the folks that are actually on the air
00:53:11 whether on radio or tv but yeah it's a systemic culture of arrogance um they don't owe the public
00:53:17 anything um you know think of how many times cbc has done stories about uh misdoing uh bad treatment
00:53:28 of employees um sexual harassment of employees and they are holier than thou and yet we know
00:53:37 these things have happened inside cbc one of the access to information requests that i got
00:53:43 was almost entirely redacted um i believe it was 14 we asked for in a very specific time frame
00:53:51 just the cases of uh sexual harassment um in ottawa toronto and montreal got back 1400 pages
00:54:01 almost all redacted there was one email that they didn't take everything out of and it was
00:54:05 two of the hr people that have to deal with this uh saying oh sorry i got confused too many cases
00:54:12 um that they are holier than thou if it's the mounties or somebody else and look all of this
00:54:20 stuff should be called out, but they deny that it exists in their own environment when we know
00:54:25 it absolutely does. And I got to tell you, it's 1053, and I'm looking forward to Travis testifying
00:54:32 soon and seeing what he spills the beans on. You and I have heard the stories elsewhere.
00:54:50 I don't know if I'm frozen or you're frozen.
00:55:17 madam chair okay i think we're having a bit of issue with the connection with brian so i want
00:55:23 to thank brian for joining us um he has been a guest on travis's show when he had it on the cbc
00:55:31 um brian you saw him holding up that book uh he had written about the problems with the cbc
00:55:36 uh long long long before we started talking about them he said he wrote that book in 2012 i think
00:55:41 it was oh we got brian back um sorry about that brian can hear me yep uh yeah it might be my
00:55:48 connection actually sorry about that uh so i want to take you back to um travis a bit and what's
00:55:53 happening with him because you were a guest on his program when he was on the cbc and that was
00:55:59 that came as a surprise to you to be um allowed to be on the cbc at that time so um i he called
00:56:08 me to tell me about the show and um i guess it would have been december 2023 and um i was driving
00:56:18 around california with my wife and he's so he's on speaker and he knows her as well and he says
00:56:24 i've got the show and i want you to come on and i started laughing out loud and he said no i'm
00:56:29 serious i said travis they will never let me on cbc television i think i've been on once or twice
00:56:35 when I was part of a story that was central to being able to tell the story.
00:56:41 But, you know, CBC, over the years, they have all kinds of different journalists
00:56:48 and opinion makers and columnists on, but they don't have me on.
00:56:53 And I've done pre-interviews, and the pre-pre-interview that they do,
00:56:58 folks that don't know this, they will interview you ahead of time
00:57:01 to find out what you're going to say, and then if they don't like it, they cut you.
00:57:03 And I've always cut before broadcast.
00:57:06 Travis's show did not do the pre-interviews.
00:57:08 I love that.
00:57:10 But he said, I'm serious.
00:57:12 They told me I could have you on.
00:57:14 And I said, if you can get me on, I will show up just for you.
00:57:18 And I was maybe four times on the show around there.
00:57:24 And it created so much controversy for people that didn't like to hear other points of view.
00:57:29 i was on there with people that i disagreed with but we're all cordial and we are all respectful
00:57:35 i mean you watch the show if you would have discussions real discussions and you know i
00:57:42 remember um mixing it up real good with gara's hands saying on the couch one day uh whatever we
00:57:49 were debating we yeah we had a real debate about it and then at the end it was like oh good to see
00:57:56 shook hands we walked to the subway together um and chatted about life and our families you know
00:58:02 so it they allowed me on and then and others that were irritating to uh part of the cbc audience
00:58:11 because talking about silos they really just like to have a silo mentality very narrow band of
00:58:19 what's allowed um the audience complained a lot and travis would show me the text messages the
00:58:25 the tweets, everything that he would get for daring to have not just me, but other people
00:58:30 with views that don't neatly match up with CBC.
00:58:34 And Brian, I'll just read. We got this from a current employee, a message to us today. It says,
00:58:39 the CBC's political bias is an open secret. No honest person can deny to start speaking to all
00:58:48 Canadians and end the sanctimonious march towards irrelevance. And by the way, I just
00:58:54 got a message from Travis as well that CBC has sent a camera to his testimony to
00:59:00 cover it so I wonder what you think about this idea so from this employee
00:59:05 their political bias is no oh are we do we have Travis okay Travis does he know
00:59:13 he's on yeah I can hear you guys it's very low I'm getting my ear pods but I
00:59:18 just wanted to update you hey Brian how's it going I'm excited on what is
00:59:23 going on there's a vote in the house right now so there's a bit of a delay uh and so the chair
00:59:30 is happening from liberals is in the room right now and uh some of the other panelists that will
00:59:35 be on it's quite a large panel today but they're just waiting for some of the other members that
00:59:38 are still in the house so i heard i just heard like a little bit of a snippet of your commentary
00:59:44 but you know brian you have been on the show before you know that this was not something that
00:59:48 was just about getting conservatives on it was about having a diversity of opinion and i love
00:59:53 that really was a shame that they they decided to cancel the panel i got my airpods now so
00:59:58 i'll probably be able to hear you guys better there you go technology it's wonderful
01:00:06 are you connected yes is this the first day with your iphone i'm watching you guys now yeah so i
01:00:11 can hear you i'm sorry i'm used to having a network brian so i i'm a network orphan now my friend
01:00:20 but no I mean listen yeah as I was saying right that this was about having a diversity of
01:00:26 perspectives it was about actually reflecting uh the the true Canadian conversation and not in an
01:00:33 Ottawa bubble way a lot of these you know panels that we see are in the Ottawa bubble it's insiders
01:00:39 talking to insiders I wanted to pop that bubble and actually have the real conversation so you
01:00:44 know some of the things that happen behind the scenes which I'm going to get into when we get
01:00:48 into the committee here were very problematic in terms of some of the decisions that were made
01:00:53 around that panel which I have actually never revealed before but I mean I guess I would ask
01:00:59 you what was your experience on the panel I had you on time with Sheila Copps and Faye Johnstone
01:01:05 that's a pretty I don't know if you can get further on the ideological spectrum than Brian
01:01:10 Lilly and Faye Johnstone. Look it was a respectful conversation we all said our pieces we debated
01:01:18 You know, I can tell you from my experience with Sheila Copps on X, not always respectful.
01:01:26 And that's from her end.
01:01:27 And I've known her a long time because I'm from Hamilton.
01:01:29 She's a Hamilton MP.
01:01:31 And I covered her when she was still in cabinet.
01:01:33 So we've known each other a long time.
01:01:37 She can get really pointy elbows on X. 1.00
01:01:41 We had a respectful discussion on your show.
01:01:45 Yeah.
01:01:46 and i mean i think that that is also something you make a good point because i think
01:01:50 that was things can things can get very heated on social media you know people can be keyboard
01:01:56 warriors i'm sure she would say the same thing about you sometimes she would have criticism
01:02:00 yeah i sometimes have elbows up yeah but it's a it's a different thing when you're there in
01:02:05 personal work where you're in a format where everybody is there together having a conversation
01:02:10 and i think it was a very canadian panel because you get you can have it out and then you could
01:02:16 leave maybe hearing even a bit of what the other person said and changing the perspective that you
01:02:22 might have a little bit and that's what we need we are in silos right now right so i i mean it
01:02:30 it was a shame and i think that you know there were several panelists that put an op-ed out after
01:02:34 uh saying that it was unfortunate that cbc did that that's just one of the many issues
01:02:40 there's a canadian human rights uh complaint with the commission right now those who go to systemic
01:02:46 issues of tokenism right i i mean essentially this is what the case argues that that i
01:02:54 if you're going to give somebody a show with their face and their name don't make them just
01:02:59 a teleprompter reader and that's essentially what i became and i'm like i'm not here i'm not here to
01:03:04 be a teleprompter reader if you're elevating somebody to this level they should they should
01:03:08 have a voice well that that was my experience is when i've had shows and on radio and television
01:03:16 hosted shows where it's built around you and your personality you have to let your personality show
01:03:21 and um you know every outlet um you know you're playing in someone else's sandbox so every outlet
01:03:30 has you know the the measurements or the uh the sides of the sandbox you play in that sandbox
01:03:38 but it's it shouldn't be as constraining as what you were dealing with uh you know you were talking
01:03:42 about getting voices on that you don't hear elsewhere i had a really popular um uh video
01:03:49 chat i don't call mine podcast because i don't i don't have a schedule and i don't do it regularly
01:03:54 like you guys do so i just invite people on for chats and i post them and on my sub stack ad on
01:03:59 keith wilson who's from alberta he's a leader in the separatist movement we've talked to each other
01:04:05 before smart guide we completely disagree but i had him on to say okay you tell your point of
01:04:11 view i'm going to explain why i disagree with you it was incredibly popular and people liked hearing
01:04:16 the different viewpoints you don't really get that you get people denouncing alberta separatism or 0.96
01:04:23 diminishing it they're all yahoos idiots rednecks keith's a king's council lawyer very smart guy 1.00
01:04:31 wrong but smart um so uh you know but it's important it's it's very important what you're 1.00
01:04:37 saying to have uh to have folks that disagree with you to have conversation to them even when
01:04:42 we were figuring out the lineup for this show you know i was talking to our producer and what about
01:04:47 this person they disagree with you i said that's great excellent let's have another perspective on
01:04:52 the show i am not you know fragile in terms of hearing uh what other people think uh if they if
01:04:58 they don't agree with what's going on we have to engage with folks that we disagree with to get
01:05:04 to a conversation where there can be a consensus uh in terms of just what what's fact what's
01:05:11 fiction and i just think that that it's lacking right now because the way the algorithm works
01:05:16 you're just fed the same kind of news over and over again so anyway i gotta get back in there
01:05:24 carmen oh you're hi carmen hi no i just my my skills no good okay i'll see you later um okay
01:05:31 it could be a while you guys yeah it's gonna be a little while um it's okay bye but uh
01:05:39 it's the brain i see people kind of like tuning in more we're getting our numbers are
01:05:43 are ticking up because they're expecting this um this committee to get started at 11 o'clock
01:05:49 but we're hearing uh from travis that there is some sort of vote going on so that's why it's
01:05:54 been delayed a bit uh brian are you okay to to hang out a bit longer or do you i can stay for
01:06:00 a little bit um oh the votes uh isn't being called for another 20 minutes so this is going to be
01:06:07 a bit i'm just pulling up parlview um as we talk on our feed as well um and i'm checking it out
01:06:15 and uh so yeah the uh committee hearing hasn't started and um for those uh who know parliament
01:06:23 um they're ringing the bells they call it um there's a fun tradition they do it over at queen's
01:06:29 park where my office is now um but when they're calling people to vote they ring bells and lights
01:06:36 flash uh so that mps or mpps know that they have to go to the chamber uh even though a lot of them
01:06:42 are just going to vote on their phones but you uh were both on both sides you worked in politics
01:06:48 and you uh covered it do you like this voting on your phone thing i mean listen if you're gonna
01:06:56 vote you should be able to vote in person i think like it's not too much to ask and votes don't
01:07:00 happen all the time right like it's like if there's like a super big exception like you're
01:07:05 having you're in labor you're gonna have a baby okay let's have you vote by proxy but otherwise 0.71
01:07:12 maybe show up to vote um i i forget if it was a justin trudeau news conference i think it was
01:07:19 a trudeau one before he left and of course they brought it in for the pandemic but it stuck around
01:07:25 we're at a news conference and the vote came up and they had to pause the news conference
01:07:30 and they all stepped aside from the microphone just like two steps aside and they're on their
01:07:35 phones and swiping and hitting a button and this is the most bizarre thing i've ever seen
01:07:41 uh go to the chamber being that if it's an important vote be there and you can figure it out
01:07:47 yeah with with some small exceptions um okay let's just i want to get this um this this heritage
01:07:57 committee because it's like they're talking about other things it's not just the cbc but um and
01:08:02 they're talking about kind of the health of mainstream media and they're talking about like
01:08:06 you know cbc's funding which has become the flashpoint and i wonder if like
01:08:12 like do conservatives want to see the cbc go like is that kind of the end goal like what is well
01:08:20 you know you heard from phil there and if you listen to pierre pauliev they've kind of backed
01:08:26 away from some of that yeah um because of the uh uh well they lost the last election but i'll say
01:08:38 this during the uh the election in the lead up to the election and during the election
01:08:46 every time pierre poly have stood up and said and we'll define the cbc it would be the loudest
01:08:52 applause line. It is very popular with a large part of the base. And the reason for that is the
01:09:00 inherent bias. It's not just a soft liberal bias. It's a hard capital L liberal bias. The first
01:09:12 person that I ever heard complain about media bias on the Hill, by the way, when I got there
01:09:19 21 years ago,
01:09:21 was he on NDP Staffer,
01:09:23 who said,
01:09:24 it's ridiculous the way we get treated,
01:09:27 and the whole gallery 0.64
01:09:29 just loves the liberals.
01:09:31 When I was in the gallery,
01:09:32 there were 308 people there,
01:09:34 I believe is the number.
01:09:35 A third of them were from CBC.
01:09:37 Wow, really?
01:09:38 Yeah.
01:09:38 But that includes producers,
01:09:40 camera techs,
01:09:41 reporters.
01:09:42 You've got an office
01:09:43 inside Ottawa.
01:09:46 Yeah.
01:09:46 So there's a lot of people
01:09:48 that cover the hill or used to be a lot of people that cover the hill um about a third of them were
01:09:55 CBC or Radcan and uh you know you you get to know each other uh over years of standing around in
01:10:03 scrums waiting for things to happen as you know uh what do journalists do hurry up and wait for
01:10:08 politicians and and so you know you can you can kind of guess or judge what people's politics are
01:10:15 And in the gallery, it was rare to find conservatives or people that would be open to the conservative ideas, far more likely to find a new Democrat inside CBC.
01:10:28 That's even more concentrated. And so the conservative voting base, a lot of them just look at it and say, this thing is is too biased.
01:10:37 If they took it seriously and tried to fix it, I think people would be less angry and demanding that it be shut down.
01:10:45 But, you know, there's a couple of decent conservatives that go on CBC on power and politics, but they try and keep the ban pretty narrow.
01:10:57 And David Cochran argues with everything that the person representing the conservative side says and amplifies everything the liberal person says.
01:11:07 yeah people notice that uh you know if david wants to just admit that he really likes liberals
01:11:15 and liberal policies he'd be a more interesting host but if you're going to be neutral because
01:11:19 that's the type of host i've been before carmen like i've been people know that i lean conservative
01:11:25 way but doesn't mean i don't pick on the other side just ask you know doug ford um had his
01:11:31 government on the front page of the sun yesterday morning uh beating them up over the lcbo stuff
01:11:35 uh and you know i'm gonna see peter bethlin fall be the minister i was picking on uh he's speaking
01:11:43 at the empire club that's the thing i've got to go to in a little bit um you know i'm gonna see
01:11:49 him after giving him bruises on his shins that i was kicking yesterday but you've got to be calling
01:11:55 out both sides they don't do that there um i don't find that uh there are two main
01:12:00 sorry and the hosts the difference between you and the hosts on the cbc like you are like it's
01:12:09 been a many media literally here right like you're so you're allowed to have an opinion yeah right
01:12:19 um they're supposed to be more objective right so there there's a difference okay so let me pick on
01:12:25 someone that used to work at cbc then worked with me at bell media always claimed to be neutral
01:12:31 was anyone surprised when evan solomon the former host of power and politics
01:12:37 announced he was running for the carny liberals
01:12:42 no um so we we know their politics but they won't admit it pretend they're neutral
01:12:49 and but then you know it's it's how they interact and if you are constantly fact-checking the
01:12:58 opposition but not the government because well the government's liberal and the opposition's
01:13:04 conservative then the people that support the conservators are going to be saying hey wait a
01:13:08 minute i'm fine with you fact-checking all right is what they're saying correct but what about
01:13:12 doing it to the other guys the guys that are actually in power um and they don't have that
01:13:18 balance you know i i would say that fashion capelos who is hosts the power play over at ctv
01:13:26 pushes back against all sides she annoys an awful lot of politicians because she does that 1.00
01:13:33 but that's her job and um you know to the politicians to get angry at me when i cause 1.00
01:13:40 them headaches i'm not your friend and i'm not here to be your friend i'm here to do a job and
01:13:47 and so do that job and i think you know you can look at uh uh vashi at ctv you can look at mercedes
01:13:56 stevenson uh at um global she's way on that leave right now they do that um the folks at cbc
01:14:05 do not they're not fair and balanced to use the fox news term
01:14:10 I want to read another comment we got in from a former CBC employee. In my view, the problems at
01:14:22 the CBC are about ideology, not about partisanship. During my years at CBC, I observed that the
01:14:27 majority of its workforce came from the same demographic, urban, university-educated, secular,
01:14:34 and politically progressive. Hiring practices and other internal policies from CBC leadership
01:14:40 reinforces uniformity of worldview, contributing to an unhelpful form of group thing in terms
01:14:47 that ignored or dismissed other views and distracted from the CBC mandate to all Canadians
01:14:53 forge so i would say that's like travis well he has he has said in the past that when they hired
01:15:05 him they thought they would be getting that right oh they thought they were as he said to me they
01:15:11 thought they were getting a specific type of brown guy hey he's a brown guy he's got to be you know
01:15:16 just like us oh you have different thoughts you don't line up neatly um i i think they were shocked
01:15:25 when they hired him and you know travis's uh views on all kinds of things are all over the map
01:15:33 it's what makes them interesting um but what you described i've heard it put this way cbc likes to
01:15:40 broadcast to the deepest darkest parts of the annex in toronto which for people that don't
01:15:46 know that aren't from toronto it's a is a leafy wealthy neighborhood near the university of
01:15:51 toronto is that where you live is that where you know i i am yorkville adjacent um i must that's
01:15:59 much better i i live right near queen's park everyone that follows me on social media knows
01:16:08 that because i i post videos walking around with my dog talking about politics uh the dog doesn't
01:16:13 talk about politics that then i'd be very wealthy because that that would be something um you know
01:16:19 so there's a clip that you can find on um cbc's archives it's on their own website and it dates
01:16:26 back to i think 1960 and there was a young mp from uh thunder bay before it was even called
01:16:35 thunder bay named doug fisher doug fisher went on to become a uh columnist for the toronto telegram
01:16:43 And then the Toronto Sun. And a bunch of his sons worked in political journalism as well. But back then, Doug was a CCF MP. So it's before the NDP ever got in.
01:16:58 And he's doing an interview with CBC on the Hill, and he's been complaining about them.
01:17:06 And he described something very similar to what your viewer had written in.
01:17:14 And they said, well, what's your problem with CBC?
01:17:16 And he said, it's a metropolitanism.
01:17:18 And they said, well, what do you mean by that?
01:17:20 He said, they only broadcast to that triangle, the one I mentioned earlier, Toronto, Ottawa, Montreal.
01:17:25 all and and they don't uh think about the rest of the country i would say that on cbc radio they do
01:17:31 a better job of that of touching into uh smaller communities across the country uh but look this
01:17:39 this is a problem and it's not just cbc it is a problem with a lot of our uh legacy media is that
01:17:46 they don't think about that uh you know yeah this is a big country and you've got to get around and
01:17:52 and see it i am a downtown toronto urban elitist latte sip or sushi eater sure but i get out across
01:18:00 the country and you know visiting small town uh saskatchewan not always by choice got to go where
01:18:09 family is but you know get out there um i've been on both coasts in the last little while um i'm
01:18:17 fortunate enough to be able to travel some people can't but the media the media is too focused and
01:18:24 i think that's what your your writer was saying there is that uh it it broadcasts to a smaller
01:18:30 version of canada than we should be seeing if you can hear me that's fine i i see you twice now
01:18:47 you're um you're the new host of can't be censored apparently apparently you're you're
01:18:52 well i i do have to run shortly um so i i won't be able to continue
01:18:57 continue hosting but happy to help out here when i i know what it's like to have to dance on a live
01:19:02 show um okay in the interest brian i'm gonna i'm gonna thank you and let you go in the interest of
01:19:16 um you know saving our viewers from my glitching i want to thank you brian i want to play you um
01:19:24 air this morning um it was an exclusive uh interview with someone who has never spoken
01:19:29 out before uh she is from the uh she worked at the cbc and she wanted to tell us a bit about
01:19:37 her experiences working gone a lot of um people talking to us about their experiences inside the
01:19:44 cbc they've been encouraged by hearing travis's story also i want to let you know that our
01:19:50 comments uh section is open if you have any questions or if you have any comments i'd be
01:19:56 happy to share them here on our live stream um and uh and you know we're in a bit of a delay
01:20:03 because there's a vote happening inside of parliament right now and um committee was
01:20:10 supposed to start at 11 o'clock and this was a parliamentary committee it's called the heritage
01:20:16 committee that was going to look at a number of things they're going to hear from travis they're
01:20:21 going to hear from a number of people and it's going to be about you know the the health of of media
01:20:31 the cbc
01:20:32 the Canadian government to the $2 billion. That number is being adjusted slightly as we lead up
01:20:43 to the budget period. It looks like previous funding that they got will be cut by a little.
01:20:53 So he's going to testify before this committee today. It is made up
01:20:57 of mps from all three parties uh he does an open statement um they get to ask him questions uh
01:21:06 in this committee before catherine tate who is a previous president of cbc has appeared she's
01:21:14 been questioned we showed you this clip earlier of mp philip lawrence questioning her over what
01:21:20 happened with travis and if she had any knowledge of it so uh we know that this is an issue um
01:21:27 that has been brought up in this committee before it's something that has been brought to the
01:21:31 attention of Travis's former employer of the CBC. I understand from Travis that the CBC is
01:21:37 sending a camera to cover it today. Before his appearance, Travis had issued a challenge to the
01:21:45 CBC to broadcast its proceedings live so people could see the discussions for themselves unedited
01:21:51 firsthand. They're not going to do that, but we are going to do that, which is what we're waiting
01:21:56 for. I've had a lot of interesting people come through our live stream today. We talked to
01:22:02 Catherine Marshall, who is Travis's lawyer, when he makes his case before the Human Rights
01:22:08 Commission. Catherine is the founding partner of Marshall Law. She has represented a lot of people
01:22:13 on employment issues and human rights. And I've got, have I got Amrit here? Yeah. Hi. Hi. What's
01:22:22 going on there? Are they going to start soon? Yes, so we should be starting shortly. We're
01:22:27 just waiting on a vote in the House to clear, and then we'll be on our way.
01:22:34 Okay, so Amrit, introduce yourself to folks here.
01:22:38 So I am a lawyer at Marshall Law. I have been working alongside Catherine on Travis's case
01:22:44 from the beginning and deciding to go forward with a human rights complaint and really advocating
01:22:50 for Travis and all of the other CBC employees
01:22:53 who are being discriminated against
01:22:55 within a toxic workplace environment.
01:23:01 Yeah, and as Travis is running co-host,
01:23:03 I've kind of seen him through this process
01:23:04 and I've seen all the work that you guys have put in.
01:23:07 And people think it might be easy
01:23:10 to just say, you know, make a complaint and make a claim.
01:23:14 But there is so much documentation,
01:23:16 so much thought and so much work
01:23:18 that goes into putting all those things together and I noticed today Travis is carrying two binders
01:23:26 to his personality it says the receipts on it and so he's got a lot of evidence to support what he
01:23:35 is saying and the claims he's making about you know workplace culture about discrimination about
01:23:40 tokenism about editorial bias and editorial control and those are some of the central issues
01:23:46 that he'll be covering today and i i suspect that's you know the crux of what's going to be
01:23:51 before the commission as well yes so what the commission is looking at really is the state of
01:23:57 journalism in canada and what travis's complaint really demonstrates is that there there's issues
01:24:03 there's systemic issues in place and what's happening is there is so much centralized control
01:24:10 over media outlets right now for example the cdc that we're not actually seeing the diversity
01:24:16 in news reporting we're only seeing diversity on the screens and what travis is here to do
01:24:21 essentially is shed light on that issue within major organizations such as the cdc he's really
01:24:27 advocating for true diversity from within the system not just externally and that's what we're
01:24:34 here to do today um and how like you've worked on these sort of complaints before uh these
01:24:42 issues that you know employees have had with really big corporations like the cbc like bell
01:24:49 media uh where you are just one person going up against a giant corporation who has a team of
01:24:57 lawyers uh you know lots of money yeah they spend as much time and money as they want on something
01:25:04 like this and so it's like it it's pretty challenging to go up against that as you know
01:25:10 just one person like travis like people that represented and you guys do a lot of that work
01:25:16 yeah so it it can be challenging when you're going up against large corporations but it's not as
01:25:24 challenging when you have the truth on your side for example travis's folders of receipts right like
01:25:29 he has the truth on his side the facts on his side and it only really takes one person like
01:25:35 Travis to start making a wave within the system for example you guys recently had a CBC employee
01:25:42 who discussed the same issues similar to what Travis faced right like long before he was on
01:25:47 Canada tonight it takes one person to start a motion and once that motion is started it's
01:25:52 really hard for these larger organizations to to continue taking the stances that they take
01:25:58 yeah and i wonder if that like so we went since travis has spoken out like we've gotten a lot
01:26:03 people coming to us and telling their stories i think that's the case for you as a law firm as
01:26:09 well like once you've represented some of these folks who have uh issues people all of a sudden
01:26:13 come out of the woodwork and it's a little easier for them to try to approach this process and try
01:26:19 to you know talk about what happened to them so have do you see more of that like once these cases
01:26:23 become a little bit more public yeah so that's that's the one thing our firm really specializes
01:26:28 on is helping the the the individual where we don't represent employers and that's for a reason
01:26:35 right the people need to see that they have advocates on their side willing to fight for them
01:26:40 and that's what we're here to do it once somebody sees that a individual is able to speak up and
01:26:46 use their voice usually they will start taking follow yeah okay so i hear that the bells have
01:26:54 stopped so that means that they are we do not go inside but it was really good to speak for you
01:27:00 today thank you thank you amrit okay if you're just tuning in that was uh one of travis's lawyers
01:27:05 who's joining him in ottawa today he is on parliament hill testifying before the heritage
01:27:11 committee. We are waiting for that to start. It was supposed to start at 11 o'clock, and that was
01:27:17 delayed because of a vote. And you would have heard when I was talking to Amrit that those bells
01:27:23 going off, that signals for people to get ready for the vote. Once those bells stop, then the MPs
01:27:30 actually have to vote. So I think we still might be a little while away if I'm remembering
01:27:35 parliamentary procedure properly. So they'll have to vote to actually vote, then they'll have to get
01:27:40 into a committee and so i hope you'll stay with us because we are like one of the only people that
01:27:47 are going to be live streaming the whole testimony unedited um travis had issued a challenge to his
01:27:54 former colleagues at the cbc to the managing editor there to to stream it as well and they
01:27:59 have politely declined uh to do that but we do know that they have sent a camera to cover this
01:28:05 story um inside of parliament inside of heritage committee and i could tell you a little bit more
01:28:11 about what's going to happen in there uh travis is not by himself they've kind of stuck him in
01:28:17 with a with a group of people to present to this committee uh along with him there will be the um
01:28:24 digital news uh there will be someone from quebec community broadcasters there will be someone from
01:28:39 the friends of canadian media uh the director of uniform which is canada's largest private
01:28:45 union sector that represents journalists they'll have someone there the director of
01:28:50 media from uniform honest reporting canada is there their pro israel media watchdog that
01:28:57 monitors and critiques canadian media coverage they'll be a part of that panel as well they'll
01:29:02 have someone that is focused on technology ai and new funding models for journalism presenting to
01:29:10 this committee today they'll also have someone from news media canada they are a newspaper
01:29:17 digital news industry lobby group in canada and so we have a particular interest of course in
01:29:24 watching what travis does but the reason why he's been grouped with all these people is because this
01:29:30 is a meeting a committee that is taking a look at the health of mainstream media as a whole but
01:29:37 what is particularly special and important is cbc's funding their mandate and their future
01:29:44 as uh as the public broadcaster and oh i'm so happy my friend sarjit kor is going to be joining
01:29:51 us i see that she's uh entered she's not quite ready yet she's gonna she's gonna be here soon
01:29:57 but i see her getting ready in my little window sarjit is the co-founder of kapow communications
01:30:05 she and i have worked together before she is often called on to be a commentator on media
01:30:11 and she specifically has been on CBC's Power and Politics, which is their flagship political show.
01:30:19 So she's got a pretty interesting perspective. I think Sarbjee, I'm not putting words in her mouth,
01:30:24 she'll say this herself, but she probably considers herself a progressive voice in politics.
01:30:30 And I know we've had a lot of conservative voices here on the program, on the live stream this
01:30:37 morning but i you know i really don't think this is a super partisan issue that we're talking about
01:30:43 uh there are concerns legitimate concerns from both people who lean right and lean left
01:30:49 um and so that's why i wanted to bring sergeant on i'll give her a moment just to get ready
01:30:54 and i'll hear from my producer when she is ready and we can bring her in otherwise i'll just let
01:31:00 you know again my name is carven wong good morning it's 11 30. we're expecting the test
01:31:05 the committee to get started at 11 o'clock and it is delayed because there was a vote i'm hoping
01:31:10 that that committee will start pretty soon but in the meantime yay sarjit is here thank you sarjit
01:31:17 hi hi good morning hey thank you so much for jumping on i know we were expecting to talk to
01:31:23 later on but the committee got delayed it's um the mps had a vote so they they pushed the committee
01:31:29 back a bit by 30 minutes but you know all morning i've been talking to people who have you know
01:31:37 have had issues um we see or their former employers or they have a perspective and a lot of that has
01:31:45 been conservative views right and so i know that you yourself would probably say you are more
01:31:51 progressive in your political leanings um you were asked to be a contributor on power and politics
01:31:58 for a few more time but then you weren't so tell us about your experience there and what you think
01:32:03 happened um so i i was for a time very frequently on cbc power and politics before that i was on
01:32:11 many other channels as well global ctv over the years just being someone who was uh pretty
01:32:17 outspoken and had many years of experience in politics working in provincial politics many
01:32:23 campaigns. Oh, did I lose Sarbjit? No, there she is. Okay. We're having a problem with Sarbjit's
01:32:41 Wi-Fi. She's like me. Wi-Fi is working against us today. So I apologize for that. We'll try to
01:32:47 bring her back in as soon as she's ready. And I think I might have her back, but I have
01:32:52 no volume, maybe. Sergi, can we hear you?
01:32:59 She can hear us, but we can't hear her. It's okay. Listen, we are not CTV News. We are not
01:33:05 CBC. We are not global. We are not a big media conglomerate who's got like six cameras pointed
01:33:11 at me um and the technology to live broadcast we are um we are a uh live stream so we are
01:33:21 live on the internet and so we sometimes have some technical difficulties here and i apologize
01:33:28 for that but i'm seeing all your comments thank you for engaging with us um can't be censored
01:33:33 is a podcast that was born out of travis leaving mainstream media uh talking about his issues at
01:33:39 the cbc and his issues with uh editorial content editorial direction with workplace culture with
01:33:49 the idea of tokenism and so when he decided to leave cbc i had already left mainstream media
01:33:57 about six years ago and uh we decided we wanted to do this program uh it's called can't be censored
01:34:03 And normally, if you watch our podcast, we do long form interviews with people and on our terms who we want to talk to the way we want to talk to them.
01:34:13 And even though we don't consider ourselves journalists anymore, we try to have a balance of perspectives, a balance of people on our podcast.
01:34:23 And so you can see that I'm tap dancing a bit here because I'm hopeful that committee will get started very soon.
01:34:30 If you're tuning in, you'll know that the Heritage Committee was supposed to start at 11 o'clock this morning.
01:34:36 It has been delayed because of a vote.
01:34:38 This is a committee.
01:34:39 It's called the Standing Committee of Canadian Heritage.
01:34:42 It's made up of a number of MPs who sit on this committee.
01:34:47 They get to talk to people.
01:34:48 They get to listen.
01:34:50 I get to talk to Sarah Jean again.
01:34:51 Hi.
01:34:52 I'm trying really hard to join you guys.
01:34:56 Okay.
01:34:56 So you were telling us about being on Power & Politics.
01:35:00 Yeah, so I was on Power & Politics amongst many, many other media outlets.
01:35:04 But there came a time where my profile was so high that it clearly started getting under certain people's skin.
01:35:10 And they would start these online attacks against me and start tagging CBC or whoever
01:35:16 and claiming that I was their journalist and I was their employee and that I was getting rich, rich off of CBC tax dollars.
01:35:23 And I think the funniest one was I posted something about me at a restaurant.
01:35:28 I took a selfie in the washroom and, you know, it was a very organized campaign, organized and orchestrated campaign by conservatives and those right wing little online people to say that I was Marie Antoinette of Canada, living high off CBC tax dollars.
01:35:46 And they just kept tagging CBC, CBC, CBC.
01:35:49 Other times, you know, I would speak very, very bluntly.
01:35:53 i'm not a person who's kind of afraid to say what i think needs to be said i used words like calling
01:35:59 what was happening in gaza a genocide uh later i learned that cbtc doesn't use that term but
01:36:06 in the long story short um i was suddenly asked to stop coming on wasn't really given any proper
01:36:12 explanation um i went from going on very frequently to weekly to not at all even during the election
01:36:21 and when I asked questions about why it was I was just given kind of nonsensical non-answers and you
01:36:27 know at least Travis knows what happened or why he wasn't allowed to come on but I know for sure
01:36:32 that you know saying things like genocide again now you have these outfits like honest reporting
01:36:37 and whatnot that have targeted people like myself and many other people that as soon as you say
01:36:43 something that is pro-Palestine or what they perceive to be against their cause they start
01:36:49 flooding those newsrooms with emails and we know this from people who work in those newsrooms
01:36:54 that it's become very very difficult and there's a chill around uh those kind of conversations
01:36:59 it's just unfortunate that the media kind of caves into this and lets those tactics actually succeed
01:37:06 yeah because they've gone so far with you as to give you a contract right to give you
01:37:12 you'll be on our program is to signal there's an arrangement between you and
01:37:23 that program so that you appear there and that you know that will be a regular
01:37:26 contributor so that was like roughly pulled away yeah and it's like you know
01:37:34 a contract but it's not like a job job you get a small honorarium for every
01:37:39 appearance it might cover you know your time your hair your makeup whatever so you're not you're not
01:37:43 getting rich off of this but it still is a slot that you get every week with the same panelists
01:37:49 and it was all formalized and quite frankly i always got really really good feedback um that my
01:37:55 my contributions were were good and valued and uh people really liked it and i think that's why
01:38:01 i went from being um a very regular contributor to being somebody that was contracted to have a
01:38:06 regular slot okay so there's some issues with my wi-fi still um but i i wanted to ask you use the
01:38:29 idea of cbc being nervous that they got all this like the negative things about you sent into them
01:38:39 use language that uh you know they didn't they didn't um necessarily accept themselves and i
01:38:47 wonder like you're kind of making the same arguments as conservatives will make in terms
01:38:52 of being censored right in terms of a public broadcaster not allowing a diversity of thought
01:38:59 and that's something that not only happens on the right side but what we're hearing from you
01:39:03 is that something that happens on the left yeah i actually think the standard and the bar is much
01:39:10 higher for the left because on the right side when we say you know there should be some level
01:39:16 of standards or filtration we're talking about you know people who are on should have some background
01:39:21 in politics they should have some experience in journalism they should have some credentials but
01:39:26 some of the people that um i would say the right wing wants to present and platform are people who
01:39:33 don't have any of those things they just have an online large following some of them have very
01:39:37 problematic views whether they be associated with um you know uh racist organizations or you know
01:39:44 there's somebody who goes on tv who called me a see you next tuesday on twitter and uh you know
01:39:49 he had a little time out and then he was back on. So I think there's actually a double standard
01:39:54 where the conservatives do a really good job of causing a fuss and claiming that they're being
01:40:00 censored, whereas actually there's a ton of people on the left or who are progressives
01:40:05 who are quietly being sidelined. And I don't really know what to make of it, except that
01:40:12 there should be similar typical credential standards to look at and people tagging or
01:40:19 just claiming and complaining about people should not be enough it should be a decision made by those
01:40:25 producers and again they never told me they never gave me a reason which is also annoying to me so
01:40:31 I can only speculate as to why I wasn't on but I've heard this from many many people whether it's
01:40:37 CBC or other broadcasters that, you know, they, when they say something that is a little bit out
01:40:43 of the kind of safety box, they, they are not invited on again. Yeah. Okay. I might check in
01:40:52 with you later, but I've got to run right now. Thank you so much for jumping in. I know that
01:40:57 we're supposed to talk this afternoon, but I really appreciate you coming on a bit earlier.
01:41:01 So if you're just tuning in, please stick with us. We are still waiting for the
01:41:06 a way the Heritage Committee it started 11 so I haven't seen signs that that
01:41:15 might be starting yet but hopefully soon the reason why we're broadcasting live
01:41:21 today it's special can be censored
01:41:26 that he will name names, that he will talk about his experience inside the CBC a little bit about,
01:41:43 but he's going to go into way more details. He is more comfortable, according to his lawyers,
01:41:49 to name names in this sort of situation because of parliamentary privilege.
01:41:53 And that is, if people don't know what that is, that is the idea that what you say inside of a parliamentary committee is protected speech.
01:42:02 It can't be used against you to sue you for defamation or libel or whatnot if it's said within the Confidence Committee for the purposes of their meeting.
01:42:11 It would be different than if you were to say it maybe on this platform or maybe in front of a microphone in the media.
01:42:18 So that's why we are listening very closely to what Travis has to say this morning, pretty soon to be this afternoon if they don't get started.
01:42:26 It's 1141 right now and this committee still hasn't gotten underway.
01:42:31 We know there was a vote that delayed things.
01:42:33 So it seems like my signal is pretty stable, Wyatt, when it's just me.
01:42:39 It's just when we have other people that it sometimes gets a little glitchy.
01:42:43 so maybe i'll just keep talking for a little bit until i see that um i see that it's problematic
01:42:49 and then i i do have something i want to show you guys again it was a story that we got exclusively
01:42:56 from someone who used to work at the cbc she was called a brown barbie she was berated in
01:43:02 front of the newsroom yelled at she was called um and you know that's just sort of the tip of uh 1.00
01:43:16 the tip of what we've received and you know i'm getting i'm getting a message that my wi-fi is
01:43:21 not good so i'm going to spare you all for a few minutes i'm going to run that package uh that
01:43:26 is a former employer, employee of the CBC. Our next guest spent more than 25 years in television
01:43:36 and radio, including more than a decade at the Weather Network and appearances on national
01:43:41 programs like Canada AM. In 2017, she joined CBC as a weather specialist in Toronto. But after
01:43:49 raising concerns about what she called a toxic workplace, less than a year later, she was
01:43:54 dismissed. And after exhausting efforts through her union and internal management to raise the 0.99
01:44:01 concerns, she made a direct appeal in 2018 to CBC President Catherine Tate. Now, she described
01:44:08 systemic problems inside the newsroom, including harassment, bullying, workplace culture,
01:44:13 and management practices. She ultimately left the industry altogether. Now, she has never spoken
01:44:19 with Travis before this week, but reached out just days ago saying she wanted to share her experience
01:44:26 after seeing news of his story. I want to welcome Karen Johnson into this program now. Karen,
01:44:33 thank you so much for being here. I told a little bit about your story where you say you joined CBC.
01:44:38 It was a dream, but then within days starting, something happened. Tell us a little bit about
01:44:42 that? I think it was probably my first week. I think I saw a lot of red flags. I guess starting
01:44:51 with, I actually had a friend who was doing traffic on the radio side of CBC and she was
01:44:58 going into sort of labor pains and no one was going to take her to the hospital. And so I'm
01:45:05 only there maybe in my second day. So I said, I'll take her. So I took her in a cab and when I came
01:45:12 back i was asked where where have you been like what are you doing where'd you go and i said well
01:45:17 i told you and you told me to go take her to the hospital and i did um so right from there i just
01:45:23 thought things were not normal and then my first week on the radio side just it was probably icier
01:45:31 than any sort of uh an ice box you could feel people were not friendly not welcoming uh they
01:45:37 they were upset I got the job over, I guess, another employee that they considered. Probably
01:45:43 a lot more credit to their name and who's doing the job previous. So there were a lot of red flags,
01:45:50 but I thought, you know what? Be a team player. You're new to the newsroom. Make friends. Just
01:45:56 go with the flow. Don't cause issues. You know, you later described what you experienced as part
01:46:00 of like a broader workplace culture problem, not just those specific incidents that you mentioned.
01:46:06 what led you to to believe that and what was happening behind the scenes so um you're when
01:46:14 you're hired if i don't know if anybody knows this when you're hired at cbc or any other sort
01:46:17 of newsroom you have a nine-month probation uh during that nine months things should be brought
01:46:22 up to you if there's concerns or what have you that usually what happens i was actually days
01:46:30 to my probation being over when i got called in um to say that i wasn't standing in the right
01:46:39 place of a weather green screen which i've been doing for 25 years i wasn't giving accurate
01:46:45 information but i've never had a complaint about my my um my information so um all this started
01:46:53 to tag on i was humiliated in the newsroom when i was told to not go into studio told to wait
01:47:00 I was berated. I was screamed at and then told, what am I going to make things better to improve
01:47:07 the situation? A situation that I didn't even cause. I was just doing what I was told to do.
01:47:13 Things like that. I got written up for having a thick eyeliner on my makeup, on my face. And
01:47:21 we had makeup artists who did our makeup. So that was a comment I had gotten from an executive
01:47:26 producer she's nice but she wears too much eyeliner out of my hands um i was called a bimbo 1.00
01:47:32 uh um on day 10 that i sounded like a bimbo uh on the air that was one of the criticisms i had
01:47:39 received i'd never been called that in my life uh even a brown uh barbie which was um not great
01:47:46 was that from someone who supervised you yes that was actually my producer in day day 10 on the job
01:47:54 and that led you eventually to write to the president tell us about that yes so i went
01:48:01 through the union i went through the president i had a case i even hired an external lawyer
01:48:06 um i was getting nowhere and i thought you know i have to bring it to somebody's attention because
01:48:11 honestly i felt like i was an alice in wonderland and you have all those mirrors and you see these
01:48:15 doors and you think that there's an opening and there's a crack there and you can get through
01:48:19 and it's not it's fake it doesn't exist and i was honestly i was losing it i was losing myself
01:48:27 i was yelling at my kids i was taking it out of my family okay we want to interrupt right now to
01:48:34 take you live to parliament hill where the heritage committee is getting underway we're
01:48:37 going to listen in live our code on that card that links to a short awareness video if you
01:48:46 need more information pursuant to the routine motion adopted by this committee i can confirm
01:48:51 that all the witnesses have completed the required connection tests in advance of this meeting
01:48:57 please wait until i recognize you by name before you speak and all comments should be through the
01:49:04 chair pursuant to standing order 108 and the motion adopted by the committee on monday september 22nd
01:49:10 2025 this committee is meeting to study the state of the journalism and media sectors so
01:49:17 quite a broad study and with us today we have travis danrash former journalist association
01:49:26 de radio diffuser communautaire du quebec angela carrero executive director welcome freshnet news
01:49:34 janet clo and mario bartell with friends of canadian media we have raj shown and randy kit
01:49:43 honest reporting canada we have mike fagelman amanda eskenazi and dr haran shani narcus
01:49:52 please forgive me if i've butchered your name and paul deacon from news media canada good to see
01:49:58 you again sir so everyone or your organization will have five minutes for an opening statement
01:50:04 and then we'll open up the floor to members for questions we'll start with mr danrush you have
01:50:12 the floor now for five minutes sir that's precious there we go appreciate it good morning uh madam
01:50:19 chair and members of the committee as a kid growing up in alberta i wasn't like most of my
01:50:25 friends every night i watched the national with knowlton nash he represented a public broadcaster
01:50:31 that belonged to canadians not the power not to party but to the public and that is the cbc that
01:50:39 i believed in now many canadians know the story about one of my tweets in april 2024 i publicly
01:50:46 stated that canada tonight had requested an interview with then cbc president catherine tate
01:50:52 and the request was declined facts shortly after i was removed from the air now on may 7th 2024
01:51:01 tate told this very committee she was quote not aware of any repercussions yet 24 hours earlier
01:51:08 a tip records show her vice president barb williams briefed her directly about my situation
01:51:14 and that matters because trust matters the tweet was not the beginning it was the breaking point
01:51:22 for months prior tensions had been building not over performance but over control while I was
01:51:28 publicly held up as a bold diverse host my ability to lead the very program carrying my face and name
01:51:35 was quietly being stripped away CBC's stated commitment to diversity contrasted with realities
01:51:42 of tokenism still I pushed forward creating a nightly panel to showcase real
01:51:48 diversity including of thought I questioned unequal pay why for example
01:51:53 one contributor who was indigenous always needed to be paid while others
01:51:58 worked when a prominent black journalist requested compensation after appearing
01:52:02 doing the exact same job I was told to reconsider booking him moving forward I
01:52:07 I attempted to end this discriminatory practice.
01:52:11 Instead, the panel was cancelled.
01:52:14 When it came to politics, interviews were blocked under guardrails,
01:52:18 governed by an internal document never made public,
01:52:21 titled Parameters for Political Guests.
01:52:23 Political access was centralized.
01:52:25 Booking decisions controlled elsewhere.
01:52:28 It did not happen once.
01:52:29 It became a pattern.
01:52:31 It became the standard.
01:52:33 Power and Politics, hosted by David Cochran,
01:52:35 was given gatekeeping authority over which politicians could appear on canada tonight
01:52:40 when i questioned that control and who was in control i was viewed as disruptive at the same
01:52:47 time i raised concerns about a toxic environment after i sat down with speaker greg fergus for a
01:52:53 conversation on black history month chief political correspondent rosemary barton circulated internal
01:52:59 communications questioning my program copying senior leadership insinuating she or Mr Cochran
01:53:07 should have done the interview it was an intimidation tactic which management ignored
01:53:13 I and others raised concerns about bullying behavior by senior figures including Mr Cochran
01:53:18 but while he remained on air I faced discipline and marginalization now the transcripts of these
01:53:24 meetings show the issue was not about my journalism but about reputational risk to the corporation
01:53:29 I received a written warning carrying the threat of termination.
01:53:33 I was placed under confidentiality restrictions that prevented me from correcting public and internal narratives.
01:53:40 CBC silenced and intimidated me simply for trying to do my job and fulfill my public service role to Canadians.
01:53:47 Now, this is not about left or right.
01:53:50 It's not about one tweet or one career.
01:53:54 it's about systemic control tokenism selective enforcement and a toxic culture where intimidation
01:54:00 went unchecked when i refused to waive my rights under the canadian human rights act in a proposed
01:54:06 confidentiality agreement right here and gag order essentially my role was not renewed my union
01:54:14 tasked with protecting my rights as an employee told me explicitly quote it's very much a normal
01:54:20 thing that we use. After 25 years in journalism, my career ended. That dream I had as a kid of
01:54:26 working at CBC shattered along with my trust in it. Now inside the newsroom, the message was
01:54:32 unmistakable and did not need to be spoken. I raised concerns. I challenged centralized control
01:54:38 and bias. I fought for real diversity and equal standards. I tried to do my job as a journalist.
01:54:44 Within months, I was pulled off the air, disciplined, restricted from speaking,
01:54:48 stripped of my primetime program and eventually out altogether now if you were still working there
01:54:54 would you feel safe raising similar concerns this is how silence becomes culture it's how whistle
01:55:01 blowers are intimidated public institutions do not weaken from scrutiny they weaken when they avoid
01:55:08 it the cbc that i believed in was strong enough to withstand accountability if it is to endure
01:55:14 as a public broadcaster worthy of canadians trust and over 1.4 billion dollars of their money
01:55:21 it must be strong enough to withstand it again accountability is not destruction
01:55:26 it is survival thank you for your time
01:55:31 thank you and next we go to angelica carrera
01:55:35 I don't know if I said your name correctly but you have five minutes starting now thank you
01:55:51 madam chair members of the committee thank you for giving me the opportunity to share
01:55:56 some observations as part of the study on journalism and the media in Canada and Quebec
01:56:02 I would also like to commend the work of the committee, which made accurate and relevant
01:56:07 recommendations in its third report.
01:56:10 As the Executive Director of the Association of Community Radio Broadcasters of Quebec,
01:56:14 I have the privilege of observing the work accomplished by these stations.
01:56:19 We have 37 radio stations spread across the province, from Montreal to Matagami and the
01:56:25 Île de la Madeleine, for example.
01:56:28 are francophone but some are bilingual or anglophone such as the station in blanc sablon
01:56:35 they therefore cover a huge geographical area sometimes with only meager revenues per year
01:56:42 the work they do is creative tireless and sometimes miraculous there are also media outlets
01:56:49 that have been around for many years which have stood the test of time despite the difficulties
01:56:55 the vast majority of stations employ at least one journalist sometimes two or three or four
01:57:03 for a total of about 50 journalists who work to provide local news coverage rooted in the reality
01:57:11 of their respective communities community radio stations have always enjoyed the public's trust
01:57:18 and this was confirmed by a study conducted by our association in 2024.
01:57:24 Furthermore, it is not enough to simply say that you are doing local journalism,
01:57:28 you have to actually do it. The physical presence of journalists in community stations is to be
01:57:35 distinguished from cases where news is generated by means other than humans or where broadcasts
01:57:40 merely relay information from the largest nearby urban center. But in addition to the physical
01:57:47 presence of journalists and all their volunteers because there are many volunteers it is their
01:57:51 mission and raison d'etre that make them excellent ambassadors for the local community
01:57:58 their mission is to serve the community in which they are rooted in fact it is the community that
01:58:03 creates and manages the radio station that has the community's interests at heart it is important to
01:58:08 remember that these are non-profit media outlets and they play an essential role in protecting
01:58:16 freedom of the press and defending the public's right to quality information their content is
01:58:23 diverse non-partisan comprehensive and reliable we therefore provide the kind of local journalism
01:58:30 that the committee refers to in its second recommendation and it is true to say that it
01:58:36 needs support a lot of support indeed as i said at the beginning community radio stations operate
01:58:42 on meager revenues that are dwindling year after year and when people seem to say they are heavily
01:58:47 subsidized that is very unfortunate because the only provincial subsidy they receive for
01:58:53 their operations does not even cover the normal salary of one of the company's employees or barely
01:58:59 these subsidies are difficult to renew even after many years for the federal government we have the
01:59:04 local journalism initiative which we really appreciate and a little project funding is
01:59:09 offered for those who managed to qualify but it is not enough fortunately we are stepping up our
01:59:14 efforts to promote the community radio initiative which could be managed by the community radio fund
01:59:21 of canada in an attempt to increase the funds available to all community radio stations in the
01:59:27 country we are asking the government for annual operating funding of approximately 30 million
01:59:33 dollars to provide around eighty five thousand dollars per station which is still very modest
01:59:38 compared to the funding provided or needed by other broadcasters this assistance would help
01:59:46 ensure basic financial visit viability otherwise radio stations must rely on advertising revenue
01:59:53 to try to make up for this shortfall but as several experts have already pointed out this
01:59:58 advertising revenue has clearly shifted to foreign platforms which are gobbling up almost everything
02:00:03 this is not new canadian government money being used to grow the financial assets of large
02:00:08 american companies multinationals this goes against the bi-local policy promoted by this
02:00:15 same government i would also like to highlight the work we are doing along with our two sister
02:00:20 associations the ncra the national campus and community radio association and the alliance of
02:00:28 community radio broadcasters of canada to try to issue a clear directive on local advertising
02:00:35 a specific portion would be systematically allocated to community advertising together
02:00:42 our three associations represent independent non-profit community radio stations across canada
02:00:50 we believe that this directive would encourage governments to allocate more of the funds that
02:00:55 are already there but used elsewhere to local media it is a reallocation of existing funds it's
02:01:02 not a new request but above all we believe that advertising broadcast in this way would have a
02:01:09 much greater and more lasting impact on canadians as the government of canada continues to invest
02:01:16 in public communications to raise awareness of its programs and services it is increasingly
02:01:22 important to ensure that these messages are delivered through channels that truly reach
02:01:28 the intended audiences rather than through digital giants that have no roots or support in canada
02:01:34 advertising that does not take into account geographic linguistic or digital barriers
02:01:39 risks leaving some communities confused and misinformed in short the general idea is to
02:01:45 help the government fulfill its mission of informing the country's entire population
02:01:51 and having a more significant impact on it thank you very much thank you hello and mario bartell
02:01:59 from freshnet news collectively you have five minutes i'm not sure how you want to share that
02:02:06 thank you for the opportunity to speak at this committee my name is mariel bartell
02:02:10 and my name is janice clue and along with teresa mcmanus and cornelia nailer we are the co-founders
02:02:16 of fresh at news the first non-profit news cooperative in western canada that's union
02:02:20 supported we are veteran community news reporters editors paginators with more than 100 years of
02:02:27 combined experience covering new westminster burnaby and the tri-cities in british columbia
02:02:32 approximately 600 000 people outside of the city of vancouver last april glacier media now called
02:02:39 low star media closed our three online publications the new westminster record
02:02:44 burnaby now and tri-city news in the middle of the federal election it meant we couldn't cover
02:02:50 the all candidates meetings our candidates couldn't get their messaging out and our
02:02:54 readers were lost about who to vote for this is dangerous to democracy
02:03:00 when i originally landed at the tri-city news in 1991 virtually every community in
02:03:05 the lower mainland was served by at least two local papers consolidation and closures
02:03:11 winnowed that down to one in most communities by 2015 then in august 2023 the same month our meta
02:03:18 social medias shut down glacier media stopped printing our newspapers altogether the company
02:03:24 said online was the only way forward it wasn't less than two years later five rapidly growing
02:03:31 cities and two villages immediately east of vancouver were left with little or no local news
02:03:36 source that meant decisions made at city halls and school boards got no independent coverage
02:03:42 there were no stories about young athletes and emerging artists no coverage of local events
02:03:47 festivals parades what may have been no longer economically viable to glacier media was
02:03:54 untenable to the journalists who have dedicated their careers to sharing those stories after all
02:03:59 we live in those communities too so the four of us got together with the co-op developer
02:04:04 and with the support of our union unifor local 2000 we put together a plan to keep our communities
02:04:09 informed we spent the summer and early fall of 2025 learning about co-op structures and
02:04:16 governance fundraising and doing community outreach people told us they didn't know what
02:04:21 was happening in their hometowns anymore on october 15th we launched fresh news online
02:04:29 a single title covering all our communities it's named for the annual spring runoff from the
02:04:33 northern snows that washed down the fraser river past our cities it symbolizes renewal a fresh
02:04:40 start two months later we revived a print edition we're monthly for now but we plan to increase to
02:04:47 twice a month in april with our ultimate goal to return to weekly publication we're four journalists
02:04:53 who never had to give much thought to the business side of our craft the ads that ran between our
02:04:57 stories and the distribution network that got those stories to readers the learning curve has been
02:05:03 steep but our journalism skill set has made us adept to changing gears when needed the communities
02:05:09 are responding our website traffic grows every week as do subscriptions to our weekly email
02:05:14 newsletter advertisers are eager to get into our newspaper and readers are scooping up the
02:05:19 newspapers 20 000 of them from our distribution points at city halls community and cultural
02:05:26 recreation hubs grocery stores coffee shops and barber shops senior residences we even
02:05:32 get calls to replenish we truly we truly feel our model of non-profit locally rooted journalism
02:05:39 that's accountable to the communities we serve is a way forward as corporate media gives up
02:05:45 but what we're doing is not new in fact across the united states as corporate media abandons
02:05:50 communities due to lack of profits reporter-led news organizations and collectives are filling
02:05:55 the gap still supports are lacking for journalism startups in canada we've come this far mostly on
02:06:01 a volunteer basis as we continue looking for jobs our severance and ei benefits have dried up our
02:06:08 fundraising at community events and through online through an online crowdfunding platform
02:06:13 has comprised mostly small individual donations 10 25 100 at a time we don't have charitable
02:06:21 status so we can't issue tax receipts that might shake loose transformative big money support
02:06:27 foundation funding frequently looks for a proven history something that's difficult for a startup
02:06:31 to provide grant opportunities are often like fitting a square peg into a round hole and the
02:06:37 few that are journalism specific like the local journalism initiative are already over subscribed
02:06:42 and don't provide funding for critical supports like hiring ad reps who can bring in ad revenue
02:06:48 or covering costs like software subscriptions insurance printing and distribution make no
02:06:55 mistake many of the media's industry's wounds are self-inflicted too much growth too quickly back
02:07:01 when times were flush too much consolidation too many resources expended chasing bad ideas
02:07:07 too many owners that are investors rather than people who believe in the mission of news
02:07:12 those owners would have would have us believe the news business is dead but our from our experience
02:07:18 in the past few months since we started fresh at news has been quite the opposite people want to
02:07:23 be connected to each other and their communities free from algorithms businesses want to share
02:07:28 their stories with local customers and journalists want to be able to write and keep sharing the
02:07:33 stories putting community back into community news is the way forward thank you thank you
02:07:41 it's a very effective use of sharing your time and as a former community reporter i really
02:07:46 appreciate your efforts thank you for all you're doing next we have the friends of canadian media
02:07:52 rash shown and randy kit i expect an equally engaging back and forth between the two of you
02:07:59 yeah the floor for five minutes thank you madam chair members of the committee friends is a
02:08:04 non-partisan public interest organization dedicated to ensuring that canadians have access to strong
02:08:10 independent canadian journalism and storytelling we advocate for citizens not for corporations
02:08:15 because a healthy media system is essential to a healthy democracy let me begin plainly the state
02:08:21 of journalism in canada is poor and in most communities is deteriorating further over the
02:08:27 the past decade and a half, hundreds of local news outlets have closed across the country.
02:08:31 Millions of Canadians now live in communities with little or no local news coverage. Newsrooms
02:08:37 have shrunk. Journalists have been laid off. Entire beats have disappeared. This is not simply an
02:08:43 industry transition. It's a democratic deficit. Local journalism scrutinizes municipal councils.
02:08:49 It covers courts. It informs citizens about public health, education, and emergencies.
02:08:56 when journalism disappears civic participation declines polarization increases and misinformation
02:09:02 fills the vacuum governments have taken important steps including the journalism labor tax credit
02:09:08 the local journalism initiative the online news act the online streaming act and support for cbc
02:09:14 these measures matter they demonstrate recognition that journalism is not just another sector
02:09:20 its democratic infrastructure but the structural disruption facing canadian journalism
02:09:26 remains profound the economic model that sustained local news has been destabilized
02:09:31 by global digital platforms that capture advertising revenue while investing
02:09:36 minimally in canadian news production that brings me to five areas where federal leadership is
02:09:41 essential first the online news act and the online streaming act are critical to creating a
02:09:47 sustainable funding framework for local news these laws must not be weakened traded away
02:09:53 or hollowed out through exemptions or side deals regulatory certainty and enforcement
02:09:58 are essential second eligibility for the journalism labor tax credit should be expanded to include
02:10:04 broadcasters broadcast newsrooms particularly local television radio face financial pressures
02:10:10 similar to print the they too are pillars of local accountability third parliament should
02:10:16 close the loophole in section 19 of the income tax act that allows full deductibility of
02:10:21 advertising on foreign digital platforms canadian advertising dollars should not receive preferential
02:10:27 tax treatment when they're directed to foreign platforms rather than canadian outlets fourth
02:10:33 the federal government should commit to directing at least 25 of its advertising budget to trusted
02:10:38 domestic news organizations both publishers and broadcasters big and small this would strengthen
02:10:45 local journalism while ensuring canadians receive critical public information through reliable
02:10:50 channels fifth canadian news creators must be protected from having their content used by
02:10:55 artificial intelligence companies without permission or compensation copyright protections
02:11:01 licensing frameworks and transparency requirements must ensure journalism is not harvested without
02:11:07 value flowing back to those who produce it finally a vibrant cbc is part of a strong ecosystem alongside
02:11:14 successful private and independent media as the national public broadcaster it plays a foundational
02:11:20 role in connecting regions serving official language minority communities and maintaining
02:11:25 news capacity where commercial models are under strain i will now turn to my colleague randy kit
02:11:31 thank you raj chair members of the committee uniform represents approximately 9 000 media
02:11:36 workers across canada in the last several years alone hundreds of journalists and media employees
02:11:41 have lost their jobs when newsrooms shrink the consequences are immediate fewer reporters at
02:11:47 city hall fewer investigative projects fewer rural correspondence and more reliance on centralized
02:11:53 news content and yet the demand for reliable information has never been greater as fresh
02:11:59 at news can tell you we are living through a period of geopolitical instability rising information
02:12:06 and increased public cynicism journalism is one of the few professions capable of grounding public
02:12:11 debate in verified fact failing to stabilize canadian journalism means surrendering not just
02:12:18 jobs but our sovereignty losing our local accountability shared facts and democratic
02:12:24 resilience that safeguard our nation's independence journalism is essential to a functioning
02:12:30 democracy and the canadian government should treat it like a national park something that
02:12:35 must be nurtured protected and properly funded for future generations a strong journalism sector is
02:12:42 not a luxury it's infrastructure for democracy and it's imperative that we sustain it we thank
02:12:48 the committee for undertaking the study and stand ready to assist
02:12:53 thank you very much uh we'll now turn to honest reporting canada i have mike fegelman in the
02:12:59 the room. Do you have colleagues online? I don't. Oh, they are. Here we go. Are you all joining in
02:13:05 the five minute opening? Joining in the Q&A component. Okay. Very good. Very good. You have
02:13:10 the floor now for five minutes. Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning. My name is Mike Fagelman,
02:13:13 and I'm the executive director of Honest Reporting Canada. We're a nonprofit organization that
02:13:18 ensures fair and accurate Canadian media coverage of Israel. We started more than 20 years ago,
02:13:23 but the overt media bias that we have experienced and seen over the last two and a half years
02:13:28 has made that era look quaint by comparison.
02:13:31 Just hours after thousands of Palestinian terrorists invaded Israel on October 7th,
02:13:36 carrying out an orgy of murder, rape, torture, and kidnappings,
02:13:39 our taxpayer-funded broadcaster leapt into action.
02:13:42 In a letter to editorial staff, George Ahe,
02:13:45 CBC's former director of journalistic standards and practices,
02:13:48 warned journalists not to use the word terrorist when referring to Hamas,
02:13:52 not to admit that 2005 was the end of Israel's permanent presence in Gaza,
02:13:57 which it was, and even when Canadian officials refer to Hamas as terrorists.
02:14:02 Ehi wrote that reporters, quote, should add context to ensure that audiences understand this is opinion, not fact, end quote.
02:14:09 Hamas is, of course, a listed terrorist organization.
02:14:12 It soon became clear for the CBC and for wide swaths of the Canadian media landscape,
02:14:18 their role was not to report the facts to Canadians,
02:14:21 but to use their immense influence in society to promote a narrow ideological agenda.
02:14:27 Present day, news outlets parrot talking points from pro-Palestinian activists, and overwhelmingly feature guests with a predictable anti-Israel worldview, presenting them as credible, while choosing not to include opposing voices.
02:14:40 When anti-Israel groups sneeze, it achieves wall-to-wall news coverage.
02:14:44 When Amnesty International accuses Israel of committing a genocide, going so far as to make up a new definition in order to do so, or when a discredited group of non-experts make such claims, they get widespread coverage.
02:14:56 Yet when scholars documented Hamas's fabricated death toll or penned a comprehensive report demonstrating that no genocide took place, they were ignored by our media.
02:15:07 The unfounded claims of genocide and starvation were promoted ad nauseum by our media.
02:15:12 And as it soon became clear that those allegations were false, reporters didn't apologize.
02:15:17 They simply moved on.
02:15:18 Now, like a cat chasing a laser dot on the wall, the worst offenders in anti-Israel media bias in Canada, whether the CBC, the Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star, or others, take their cues not from what's newsworthy, but rather what complaints are being made by pro-Palestinian activists.
02:15:35 When reporters document the worrying rise of Islamic radicalism in Canada, the presence of Iranian regime officials in our nation, or the impact of Qatari dark money in Canadian universities, they are treated as persona non grata.
02:15:49 When a Canadian mosque recently honoured Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Khamenei and glorified him as a martyr, our journalists ignored this brazen support for terrorism.
02:15:59 Our journalists have a solemn duty to hold the powerful to account, to not act as their water carriers.
02:16:06 But that's what they've done, promoting hardline anti-Israel disinformation and acting as unpaid publicists for immense web of extremist actors in Canada.
02:16:17 This media coverage directly contributes to a spike in anti-Jewish hate crimes.
02:16:22 When Israel is painted as a genocidal and pariah state, and opponents are widely silenced,
02:16:28 a target is drawn on the back of Canadian Jews.
02:16:31 The incessant demonization of Israel, and by extension Jews, has led to an unprecedented
02:16:36 attack on the Jewish community, with terrorist rallies now a regular occurrence on Canadian
02:16:41 streets, and Jewish schools and synagogues, as we saw this past week, shot at. While far too many
02:16:47 elected leaders and law enforcement ignore this cancer that is in our midst. Over the past two
02:16:53 years, our media promoted ideology over facts, and in the case of the CBC, did so at the taxpayer's
02:17:00 expense. I'm happy to recount numerous examples of Canadian media bias that we have confronted.
02:17:05 When our media act as stenographers for a regressive and hateful worldview, it's not reporting the news, it is creating it.
02:17:13 And when our leaders stay silent, they let it happen.
02:17:17 Our elected leaders must take the lead to remedy the situation.
02:17:21 In my written testimony and submission to this committee, I've offered three concrete courses of action that you can take directly to counter these critical issues, and I would be happy to elucidate them today for anyone interested.
02:17:33 As well, I've brought with me here today two colleagues, Dr. Haran Shani-Narkas, CEO of InnoHives, and Amanda Eskenazi, Director of Education at HR Canada Charitable Organization.
02:17:45 They conducted a comprehensive review of the CBC's coverage of the Israel-Hamas war and have provided real scientific evidence of asymmetric coverage.
02:17:54 It isn't an opinion that the CBC is one-sided.
02:17:58 We now have scientific, irrefutable proof.
02:18:01 Canadian taxpayers fund public broadcasters to provide accurate, impartial, and reliable information.
02:18:08 When media outlets choose ideology over facts, they fail in this fundamental duty,
02:18:13 leaving Canadians misinformed on issues of national security, on issues of terrorism and international conflict.
02:18:19 This is not merely a concern for one community.
02:18:23 It affects every Canadian's right to understand the world as it truly is. 0.69
02:18:27 restoring trust in our media is not a partisan issue but a national imperative
02:18:34 parliament must act now to ensure that our media serve canadians with facts
02:18:37 with fairness and with integrity because an informed public depends on it and our democracy
02:18:43 requires it thank you thank you and finally we have paul deegan with news media canada
02:18:51 welcome sir you have five minutes starting now bonjour media can media d'info canada
02:18:56 represents media canada represents about 550 news titles across canada from independent weekly
02:19:06 community newspapers to large urban and national dailies the advertising market in canada continues
02:19:12 to remain very challenging simply put too many ad dollars are being scooped up by google last year
02:19:19 a u.s federal court judge ruled that google which operates in all three areas of the market
02:19:24 the buying the selling and the ad exchange itself illegally monopolize the ad tech market through
02:19:30 anti-competitive conduct news publishers fully embrace and support the responsible
02:19:36 and ethical use of artificial intelligence at the same time despite deploying bot blockers we are
02:19:43 seeing the theft of our intellectual property on an industrial scale companies like google
02:19:49 microsoft open ai which is familiar to all of you in terms of the role their employees didn't play
02:19:55 in alerting authorities to the tumblr ridge incident perplexity and even canada's cohere
02:20:01 are ingesting repackaging and distributing copyright protected content directly from
02:20:07 published news articles these companies aren't just providing snippets that one would find through a
02:20:13 traditional search. They're providing very detailed summaries and passing it off as their
02:20:17 own creation. They're depriving news publishers of audience, subscriptions, and advertising,
02:20:23 capturing the value journalism depends on for its survival. Moreover, Google, which is dominant in
02:20:30 search, has embedded AI-generated summaries directly into their search interface without
02:20:36 providing publishers with an effective opt-out mechanism. If publishers want to block Google's
02:20:42 ai crawler they find themselves de-indexed or unable to attract traffic to their sites
02:20:48 news is an essential input to the knowledge economy it helps people businesses and investors
02:20:53 make better more informed real-time decisions it's also a necessary input for the output of
02:21:00 the ai companies but the value transfer cannot be asymmetric the user needs to pay the creator
02:21:06 the content theft by a com ai companies must stop and government can help first public services and
02:21:14 procurement canada and treasury board can work together to ensure that those on the government's
02:21:19 list of artificial intelligence suppliers there's a hundred and some odd companies on that list
02:21:23 sign a supplier agreement that states that they will use a our material ethically with a commitment
02:21:30 to the principles of transparency consent and attribution with respect to all copyright protected
02:21:36 source content second the industry minister can ask the comp bureau to look into the state of
02:21:41 competition with respect to search and ai google bot should be split into two crawlers one for ai
02:21:49 and one for search that would help level the playing field between publishers in google
02:21:54 and between other ai companies in google those companies have no incentive to sign commercial
02:21:59 agreements with publishers when google's ai services are getting the content for free
02:22:05 Third, the Copyright Act should not be amended to include a text and data mining exception
02:22:10 or be weakened in any way. Rights holders must be protected, no exceptions. On the positive side,
02:22:17 the Online News Act, well imperfect, is working for Canadian news publishers. Prior to the Act,
02:22:23 and in an effort to thwart it, Google and Meta did content licensing deals with a number of
02:22:28 news publishers. Most of our members, however, were left out in the cold, without assent.
02:22:33 Today, whether you're a large publisher or a smaller independent, you're getting about $16,400 per year per full-time journalist.
02:22:41 For example, The World Spectator from Moosem in Saskatchewan received almost $80,000 last year.
02:22:49 Prior to the Online News Act, most of our members never saw a dime in content licensing from these American big tech firms.
02:22:56 Between the Online News Act and the Canadian Journalism Labor Tax Credit, which rewards those who maintain and grow journalism jobs,
02:23:03 there's finally a level of predictability for business planning which is
02:23:07 translating into a level of stability and many newsrooms where we are seeing
02:23:11 investment after years of cost cutting both these measures should be maintained
02:23:15 let me turn briefly to government advertising despite the government
02:23:19 stated by Canadian policy changing its agency of record and spending tens of
02:23:24 millions of dollars each year news publishers are not seeing any
02:23:27 meaningful federal government ad dollars yet when a bank a retailer or a
02:23:32 car company runs a national or regional campaign news publishers do okay that's because their chief
02:23:38 marketing officers know we are a great way to reach and engage canadians so why are we only
02:23:43 seeing micro pennies on the dollar when it comes to the federal campaigns it's simple the government's
02:23:48 agency of record is doing what is easiest and most profitable for them and that's programmatic
02:23:54 advertising through american big tech firms we hope the committee will recommend an advertising
02:23:59 set aside that you heard about earlier an ad set aside done right with with on the publishing side
02:24:05 we for example reach 86 percent of canadians who engage with reach newspaper content each week
02:24:11 it's time for the government to think more like a marketer who cares about reach
02:24:15 and efficacy we can help you reach engaged audiences better than anyone for advertisers
02:24:21 whether governments or the private sector credible journalism strengthens trust while
02:24:26 delivering better business results in a brand safe environment there's absolutely no reason
02:24:31 the federal government shouldn't use canadian news brands to inform canadians in an age of
02:24:42 misinformation and disinformation amplified by algorithms facts are essential quality information
02:24:51 created by real people who have fact-gathering, fact-checking, editorial and legal review and
02:24:59 being accountable costs real money. Thank you. Thank you. Questions from members starting with
02:25:07 Mrs. Thomas for six minutes. You have the floor. Awesome, thank you so much. Thank you to each of
02:25:12 you for being here today. My first set of questions is going to go to Mr. Danrash. Mr. Danrash, I'm
02:25:17 just curious there was a document that you talked about in your opening remarks
02:25:21 called parameters for political guests would you be willing to table that with
02:25:24 the committee I would perfect thank you very much appreciated um now I just want
02:25:30 to get to the bottom of this can you talk a little bit about any pressure
02:25:33 that you experienced at the CBC to shape stories in a particular fashion sure I
02:25:40 can but I do want to spend part of my time because I am here speaking and this
02:25:46 is my story but over the past several days and even when this story initially came out
02:25:50 there have been other cbc employees current and former that have come forward to me that are
02:25:57 afraid to speak out publicly and they have sent me some statements so i'd like to if i can read
02:26:02 into the record some of what i have been getting from current and former employees uh this is a
02:26:08 current employee at the cbc i've been with cbc for 10 years and i have witnessed and experienced
02:26:13 multiple incidents of the misuse of taxpayer dollars racism favoritism nepotism sexual
02:26:18 harassment and verbal abuse and then she goes on to outline specific examples this uh next
02:26:25 individual was someone that you would all know if i said their name they left the cbc after a 10-year
02:26:32 career uh the end of their statement says without exaggeration i experienced toxicity every single
02:26:39 day and it was almost always from the same people it was not subtle it was not hidden it was part
02:26:44 of the daily reality of working there she goes on to say that uh she was set to interview uh
02:26:51 catherine tate on air i introduced myself to her in the makeup room as the host in front of others
02:26:56 she responded i didn't know i'd be interviewed by somebody who looks like she is 14. that moment
02:27:02 stayed with me it was dismissive inappropriate and reflected a broader culture in which respect
02:27:08 was not always equally extended to everyone uh on on mr cochran this is one of his former
02:27:15 producers his toxic behavior extended beyond editorial matters and was more often than not
02:27:19 deeply hypocritical while he publicly presented himself as a supporter of diversity he actively
02:27:25 undermined the contributions of colleagues who were minorities this is somebody who left the 0.72
02:27:31 industry and had to go to another country. After about a year of working there as an anchor, this
02:27:39 is in Vancouver, I was suddenly removed from the anchor desk. I was told the decision was related
02:27:45 to the color of my skin, that as a white person I did not fit the diversity targets they were
02:27:50 trying to meet. No concerns about my performance had ever been raised. My concern was the system
02:27:57 and the reasoning behind the decision. My frustration was never directed at the individual
02:28:02 who stepped into the role. She was also said that she was forced to check a box if somebody of a
02:28:08 diverse background appeared on the air, and she said that that was concerning to her. I believe
02:28:13 it's important to include a broad range of voices and perspectives, but reducing interview subjects
02:28:17 to a checkbox felt like an overly simplistic way of approaching something that deserves much more
02:28:24 care and thought and i can go on there are a number of these stories and it is shocking these
02:28:29 people have been traumatized they are scared to come out they are scared of the professional
02:28:35 repercussions and management like laundry lao like chris carter they are concerned about
02:28:42 protecting the reputation of the organization as opposed to dealing with these issues when it comes
02:28:50 to employees. So, Mr. Danraj, during your time there, which, sorry, can you just outline what
02:28:55 years were you there? I was there. I finished at Global, I think, in 2020, 2021. It's in the bio
02:29:04 that I provided. And then I came to Ottawa. I was a parliamentary reporter. I flew around with the
02:29:09 Prime Minister. I covered Parliament Hill. You know, I was, then I went back to Toronto. I was
02:29:16 on marketplace i covered the queen's funeral and then i got my own show which i thought you know
02:29:21 i'd have some say in terms of how that show went and on the the intersection panel uh you know this
02:29:27 is a this is a picture here of all the folks that we had on the panel you know we've got here one
02:29:32 with raheem mohammed and rachel gilmore i don't know if you can get two people very uh far apart
02:29:38 on the ideological spectrum is that sheila copps brian lily and faye johnston right we were having
02:29:44 the canadian conversation and this panel was cancelled and you also have issues of pay equity
02:29:50 when it comes to all these folks so so okay so obviously your point here was to create a panel
02:29:56 that was full of diversity not just in skin color or ethnicity or religious background perhaps but
02:30:01 you wanted diversity of thought correct were you given the journalistic freedom then
02:30:06 to move forward and do that
02:30:09 for the sake of the Canadian public?
02:30:11 No, I mean, the issue became with the panelists,
02:30:16 we had a list of 43 people or 45 people
02:30:20 that Power and Politics gave us
02:30:23 that said, do not go near these people, right?
02:30:27 And some of these folks were like reporters,
02:30:29 like Robert Benzie.
02:30:30 There's a story breaking at Queen's Park
02:30:32 and we're on at seven o'clock.
02:30:34 We should be able to call, you know,
02:30:35 somebody who covers queen's park and talk to them but there were these continued hurdles and road
02:30:41 blocks that were set up to really have a certain group of folks in ottawa in control of who was
02:30:50 allowed on on programs particularly mine was a concern and there were repeated episodes of
02:30:57 conservatives being blocked i mean i have the the g chats right here i i said uh you know in terms of
02:31:05 getting folks on that we we need to have balance this is not about just having a show with
02:31:10 conservatives or just with liberals but if power and politics is going to have liberals talking
02:31:16 points on all the time we should have balance as a network and i said we are in contravention of
02:31:22 section 11 of i told brodie finland this and also andre lau repeatedly we are in contravention of
02:31:29 the broadcasting act if we are not providing equitable time for all perspectives so i don't
02:31:34 to flood the show with conservatives but i do want to have balance and there are you know there and
02:31:40 this is all i can talk to my legal team because some of this is before the human rights commission
02:31:45 in terms of how this happened but there were repeated attempts over and over and over again
02:31:50 at one point i heard okay well maybe you can have ndp folks on but conservatives are a no
02:31:58 it i mean it should blow the canadian public's mind that this was the stuff that was going on
02:32:04 Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you all for those opening remarks.
02:32:13 My first question is for Ms. Klu and Mr. Bartel.
02:32:15 Firstly, it's a pleasure to meet you both.
02:32:17 Ms. Royer speaks very fondly of you.
02:32:19 I'd like to focus on a highlight of your opening remarks.
02:32:22 You noted a lack of support.
02:32:24 I quoted this because I thought it was interesting and well said.
02:32:27 Grant opportunities are like fitting a square peg into a round hole.
02:32:30 From your experience in building a new outlet, what are the biggest barriers facing independent
02:32:34 journalism startups in Canada and what do you believe would best help address those barriers
02:32:42 well I you know we we're journalists and and you know we we've become we've run head-on and into
02:32:49 into some of the challenges of of creating a viable business and and some of the costs of that
02:32:54 um you know the the local journalism initiative has stepped up with some funding for us so that
02:32:59 helps cover uh some wage for for for our crew uh but you know that doesn't deal with we need to
02:33:07 hire someone who can sell ads we don't know how to do that we shouldn't be doing that we're
02:33:10 journalists um so we need to have we want to maintain that that separation between between
02:33:16 the ad side and the journalism side uh so luckily we have found some people who are willing to help
02:33:21 us and off the side of their desks and get us going and uh but you know to go forward to to
02:33:27 ramp up we have to become professional at every level of this and and so you know some of that
02:33:33 infrastructure support is is critical to this you know we ran in headlong into just how expensive
02:33:38 some of these things are software uh licenses to to get uh to allow us to produce a newspaper
02:33:44 uh web web hosting fees uh insurance all these things that we were completely oblivious to in
02:33:51 our role in the newsroom have have uh have come home to roost and and you know luckily our crowd
02:33:56 funding gave us a good foundation to to start tackling some of these things but again as we
02:34:01 move forward uh becoming a viable business will will mean backfilling a lot of those things with
02:34:06 with support fantastic over the past few years certainly we've seen a significant number of
02:34:13 community newspapers close or reduce their reporting capacity you highlighted this in
02:34:17 your opening remarks from your perspective as a long-time local journalist reporter
02:34:22 could you speak to what happens to community accountability and civic engagement when local
02:34:25 news coverage disappears i believe you highlighted that it was dangerous to local democracy but
02:34:30 i'm keen to see you expand on that if possible we became a news desert we have news deserts and news
02:34:38 news poor jurisdictions and uh glacier media closing us in the middle of the federal election
02:34:43 was was quite bad so we've had people pretending to be reporters sit at the media desk in council
02:34:52 meetings and uh they're reporting when we're not so that's dangerous
02:35:04 perfect thank you your association has represents 37 different radio stations as you know many
02:35:13 community radio stations depend on volunteers and limited funding what are the biggest
02:35:18 operational challenges that community radio is facing today i'm thinking of lower advertising
02:35:25 revenue digital disruptions with foreign platforms well you stated it well
02:35:34 there are all the operations done by volunteers which isn't ideal because even though those
02:35:41 volunteers give their time dedicate themselves make these radio stations work any operation that
02:35:50 is based on that model is hard to keep up over the years but it's the case they they manage
02:35:57 but funding for operations that's the basic need that's what they need and it's what they don't
02:36:05 have and then advertising revenue as i said and others have said advertising revenue aren't there
02:36:13 anymore it's gone to foreign platforms so it would be very good to have a clear government directive
02:36:22 and then radio stations could contribute to getting the government's message through
02:36:28 And then you mentioned the digital transition. That's another element that's a major challenge.
02:36:36 Radio stations are cornerstones for their community. They're on the FM station, but also
02:36:46 on the web. They can be listened to. There are podcasts, news. So these are really
02:36:53 complete media outlets, but we need to help them with the digital transition.
02:36:58 It can be harder depending on the station.
02:37:02 Parfait.
02:37:03 Mr. Schultz, Canada's broadcasting and media regulatory framework was designed at a time when traditional television and radio dominated the landscape.
02:37:10 Given the rapid rise of global streaming platforms and digital media companies,
02:37:15 do you believe Canada's existing regulatory tools are still adequate for protecting Canadian journalism and cultural sovereignty in the digital age?
02:37:23 um i believe the tools are there i think perhaps the crtc has been a little bit slow in terms of
02:37:28 taking action the crtc has done some some good things and certainly the government canada has
02:37:33 done some good things the online streaming act the online news act has been enormously helpful
02:37:38 the tax credit has been helpful the local journalism initiative the crtc made a very
02:37:42 important decision last year to ask streamers to contribute a base contribution of 1.5 of its
02:37:49 annual revenue to support local news um that's being challenged in court right now but we feel
02:37:53 confident it will go the the crtc's way um those are all important steps but more needs to be done
02:38:00 especially given the the canadian center for policy alternatives uh um uh conclusion that
02:38:08 um a significant portion of the canadian population i believe it's 2.5 percent have access to no local
02:38:14 news or only one local news outlet so that's really a problem that needs to be corrected
02:38:18 the tools are there and the regulator needs to be encouraged to use them
02:38:28 now we go to mr shampoo for six minutes thank you madam chair i'd like to thank
02:38:35 our witnesses today we have a great panel who represent the importance of the topic
02:38:41 we are covering with the study madam chair before speaking to the witnesses i'd like to table a
02:38:45 motion i've discussed it with a few members around the table it's a motion that i will read
02:38:52 and i'd like us to keep a little time at the end of the meeting to debate it i will read it
02:38:58 and then we can discuss it a little later to not interrupt questions to witnesses
02:39:04 it is a motion being tabled in relation to radio canada's decision to offer its programming
02:39:12 its news on the prime video platform owned by amazon we find that this is a decision
02:39:19 that needs to be explained and questioned so the motion is that pursuant to standing order
02:39:26 108-2 the committee invite the ceo of cbc radio canada marie philippe bouchard to appear before
02:39:33 the committee for a minimum of two hours to explain the decision to make ec abdee's programming
02:39:40 available on the prime video platform owned by the american multinational amazon even before it is
02:39:46 made available to quebecers and francophones in canada on two point tv or on a canadian-owned
02:39:51 platform madam chair i've prepared this in french and english it's available to committee members
02:40:02 if i may i'd like to ask us to reserve time at the end of the meeting today to discuss this motion
02:40:07 so we can explain the spirit of this request from the Bloc Cubicua.
02:40:14 I think everyone agrees.
02:40:17 Thank you.
02:40:19 Thank you, Madam Chair.
02:40:21 Once again, thank you to all of the witnesses for joining us today.
02:40:25 I think this is an extremely important study.
02:40:28 It's a very concerning topic.
02:40:31 and the variety of media perspectives here are a testament to that.
02:40:38 I'll start with Ms. Carrero because we've heard a lot about community media
02:40:45 and we know that times are tough.
02:40:49 Support isn't what is needed.
02:40:54 I also want to ask a question to Mr. Deegan who represents written media
02:40:59 But you talked about the local journalism initiative. Have you noticed a decrease in support through that program for your members? Is the support still what your members need it to be? Because I know it's essential for local coverage in Quebec and elsewhere.
02:41:23 So what is the state on the ground for your members with the Local Journalism Initiative?
02:41:29 Yes, the LJI is something we appreciate.
02:41:32 It's funding that's there for stations.
02:41:36 We haven't noticed a specific decrease as such.
02:41:40 Stations request it and they hope to obtain it.
02:41:44 However, we always hope it will be renewed in time for budget 2026.
02:41:52 that's what we are hoping for and sometimes even if a station has that LJI
02:42:02 it needs to be possible to hire someone it's not just getting the subsidy but
02:42:08 being able to use it but that's another kettle of fish but I just wanted to
02:42:12 mention it the LJI is something we really appreciate and we really hope to
02:42:17 to see it renewed in budget 2026 i'd like to ask a question to paul deegan as well i know your members
02:42:25 often
02:42:29 use that very important program the local journalism initiative for written media it's
02:42:33 very important andrean laroche the member for shefford received from the val west newspaper
02:42:41 in her area she was told that the funding had decreased by 30 this year which has a huge impact
02:42:50 on small written media in the regions and community outlets is this a concern you've seen
02:42:58 at news media canada we uh pull uh yes for newspapers it's about 37 000 per journalist this
02:43:09 year but we have about 200 journalists under this program it's very important for weeklies
02:43:23 and other independent community media have you heard from your members that the program was less
02:43:29 generous with them this year yes yes so there's still the expectation that this program would be
02:43:36 increased which is necessary to address media deserts media deserts news deserts are everywhere
02:43:43 thank you very much back to you miss carrito we heard earlier about artificial intelligence
02:43:50 and this will be coming up often in the study surely as community media i imagine you don't use
02:43:58 ai to prepare the news and broadcast it but some media are using that technology
02:44:03 for due to economic reality but often they use programs that you don't have
02:44:11 access to so what is your perspective on that distortion and the equity of the
02:44:15 rules I imagine it wouldn't be a cause for celebration correct I think you are
02:44:26 correct community radio is based on principles that they try to keep up and if there are people
02:44:40 who could use ai it would be community radio stations because they don't have staff they
02:44:45 don't have the necessary funds but it doesn't it's not consistent when we see that others can
02:44:53 benefit from subsidies so this is a real issue we need to maintain our mission those tools are
02:45:01 there we can't deny it but we would like to have assistance in that regard a question to everyone
02:45:10 for advertising from the federal government
02:45:15 the transfer of advertising from traditional media towards digital media since 2019 i've
02:45:22 been in this role since 2019 the same thing has been asked that the government spend less on
02:45:29 foreign digital media and more on traditional media the friends of canadian media have been
02:45:35 talking about that for years i'm sorry mr shampoo but we your time is up there's no time for an
02:45:42 answer you can answer a little later thank you the next time perhaps do you now have the floor for
02:45:49 five minutes thank you madam chair uh mr dunraj i uh found your testimony quite uh fascinating
02:45:57 i was a journalist for myself for 30 years i was also a national director of the canadian
02:46:04 association of journalists journalism has indeed changed you noted that you used to sit down and
02:46:10 watch um norton nash as the voice of you know a trusted voice i i also remember lloyd robertson
02:46:20 as a kid watching him peter kent stanley burke ironically peter kent stepped down in 1978
02:46:29 after criticizing um political interference from the liberal prime minister so um the the cbc
02:46:38 does talk about being diverse inclusive uh fair and balanced yet one of the cbc's premier
02:46:46 segments is something called at issue which features toronto star journalist chantal hibert
02:46:54 athila raj and globe and mail journalist uh andrew coin in what universe is this diverse
02:47:03 fair or balanced as a news panel well i i mean the the national uh makes their own decisions
02:47:12 i suppose in terms of uh who who they put on that that panel uh you know and it's rosie's panel so
02:47:20 uh miss barton's panel so i i guess you know you can have to you know you can have to talk to her
02:47:25 about the editorial decisions but you know what i was attempting to do on this program was have
02:47:30 that diversity of opinion and you know when they cancelled the panel i sent in a note to panelists
02:47:36 asking for feedback um and i was disciplined for that and i just want to talk about this
02:47:42 nda that i got because it's important uh because i was raising concerns about editorial and and i
02:47:50 was slapped with and this nda here which is a practice that the cbc uh is using frequently
02:47:58 which was raised by dave seglins and you guys all have the paper dan rash has considered whether he
02:48:04 has a human rights complaint with respect to the issues in dispute and by his signature below
02:48:09 confirms that he does not further he confirms that he seeks no right or remedy under the canadian
02:48:16 human rights act as amended with respect to the issues in dispute and any such claim is barred
02:48:21 by this agreement that should be shocking to every member on this committee and i and i hope
02:48:28 that other members on the committee take an interest in terms of the the issues that i'm
02:48:34 outlining here because it is very important we should not have a public institution silencing
02:48:40 their own employees and having them waive their rights under the canadian human rights act that
02:48:45 should be shocking um getting back to the the bigger issue of the fairness and and balance in
02:48:54 news um you mentioned at one point that uh cbc management actually prevented you from interviewing
02:49:02 conservative conservative leader pierre paulia on your show can you describe what happened there
02:49:08 yeah well we i i mean i basically wasn't allowed to pick up the phone and and talk to uh conservatives
02:49:15 I have some G-chats here, which I just want to, you know, read you part of this.
02:49:20 I'm talking to my senior producer.
02:49:22 I'm saying, okay, you know, this is an editorial discussion.
02:49:26 Can we get a conservative perspective on this is essentially what I'm saying.
02:49:30 It is a no to the conservatives, I'm told.
02:49:32 We can't chase anyone from the entire party.
02:49:35 The chase is with PNP.
02:49:37 so if power and politics is not able to secure a conservative uh or you know somebody that
02:49:44 presents an alternate perspective then we are not allowed to i'm told at one point we're sure that
02:49:50 there's a myriad of other types of interesting guests that you can chase outside of the
02:49:54 conservatives uh can i be included on conversations with power and politics that's not how we work
02:50:00 I say to management, by playing petty office politics, we feed into conservative narratives that we have a bias against them.
02:50:10 Canada Tonight is a melting pot of news of the day, and politics and decisions from it largely impact Canadians.
02:50:18 So we need flexibility to respond to emerging stories.
02:50:22 So yes, I wasn't even allowed to pick up the phone and call to request Pierre Polyev.
02:50:28 look at what happened when i had melissa lanceman on my show right i was threatened to be pulled
02:50:33 off the air which cbc then said in a news statement they didn't threaten to do that there are recordings
02:50:38 of them trying to do this why do you think they were doing that i mean there there's an effort
02:50:45 to essentially uh protect those in ottawa uh in in terms of their perspectives on these things uh
02:50:55 in terms of who they want on the show it should be about you know we did an interview with karen 0.85
02:51:00 johnson uh my co-host on the new podcast i'm doing it is out right now she's another former cbc
02:51:06 employee that is talking about the toxic culture she said that she alleges that she was called a
02:51:12 brown barbie a bimbo but she says that it's it's a very high school culture and these are things
02:51:19 that that this is fine if you if you have hosts doing that it's not fine but it okay but management
02:51:27 you are responsible for dealing with it and so if management is not going to do anything if the
02:51:34 president of the CBC is going to come here and expect a tongue lashing and then be able to go 0.59
02:51:40 back to the CBC and continue to get funding without accountability these practices will continue
02:51:47 so shame is clearly not enough to get the cbc to a place where they will hold themselves accountable
02:51:55 so it's incumbent upon this committee to do that ms roy you have the floor now for five minutes
02:52:02 go ahead merci madame chair i'd like to begin by welcoming witnesses from
02:52:08 my community janice clue and mario bartell of freshet news thank you both for your decades of
02:52:16 service when glacier meteors media's tri-city news closed last year it was a devastating loss for our
02:52:24 riding of port moody coquitlam and i'm extremely grateful that veteran reporters like yourselves
02:52:30 step forward i'm sorry ms royer your audio is a little low for the interpreters i'm hearing that
02:52:37 they are having trouble hearing you can you try moving your boom closer to your mouth and see if
02:52:42 that's any better. Is that better? Madam Chair is that better? Yeah I think it's better. A little
02:52:56 bit better? Okay. Just keep that boom close to your mouth. It just sounded that you were a bit
02:53:01 far away. I'll keep it close and is that um are we going to start the clock from the day? No you
02:53:10 can have your time back okay great thank you thank you thank you okay merci madam chair i'd like to
02:53:15 begin by welcoming witnesses from my community janice clue and mario bartel a fresh no i'm sorry
02:53:22 ms roy the audio is not getting it oh no okay
02:53:31 let me just check the connection i'm going to suspend for a minute while we try and work this
02:53:38 Okay. Merci.
02:53:58 All right, if you're just tuning in, you are watching
02:54:03 Travis appear before a parliamentary committee in Ottawa. This is the heritage committee. He
02:54:06 started with opening statements um and as promised he did name names in terms of uh the people who
02:54:15 were roadblocks to um what he perceived as fair coverage and uh and fair treatment
02:54:23 during his time at the cbc he is being asked questions at this point now he's part of a panel
02:54:29 of a number of people so um everyone had their opportunity to make opening statements and now
02:54:34 members of the committee which are uh made up of all three three of the parties um all different
02:54:40 parties rather i should say not just three um they will have their chance to ask panelists
02:54:45 some questions and you can see that the majority of the questions being directed
02:54:50 at least by the conservative side are to travis about his experience in his time at the cbc so
02:54:56 we're on a brief pause right now inside of the hearing because uh one of the panelists is having
02:55:02 some audio difficulty but i want to cover a few things that travis talked about one of them was
02:55:11 he has two binders with him and they've got cbc's logo on them and it says the receipts
02:55:18 and he's reading from those some correspondence that he had kept audio recordings
02:55:25 um emails that went back and forth between himself his editorial leadership um between
02:55:33 different people within the newsroom uh either you know about rules about protocols about discipline
02:55:41 and so those are the sorts of pieces of evidence that he's presenting in front of parliament right
02:55:46 now he's not doing it all he's not dropping everything because there is a case being made
02:55:52 for the human rights commission uh which we spoke to katherine marshall who's his lawyer about a
02:55:57 little bit earlier and some of that evidence is being well all of that evidence is being submitted
02:56:02 to the human rights commission and so some of that is being um is being held but he has disclosed a
02:56:10 lot uh for example he has this email that he's submitting into committee it's called the parameters
02:56:15 for political guests so travis has talked about how he was prohibited from contacting certain
02:56:22 people um he was uh not allowed to have conservative voices not even allowed to pick up the phone
02:56:30 and to call them to ask them to be on a show and so there were guidelines procedures protocols
02:56:37 that cbc put out for that and travis has submitted what that is to committee
02:56:41 we're going to head back inside live to parliament uh mr tumba the floor goes to mr tumba
02:56:49 for five minutes starting now
02:56:55 thank you very much madam chair
02:57:00 excuse me
02:57:03 it won't be long
02:57:04 I'll start with Ms. Carrero. Thank you for your presentation. I think my colleague Therese
02:57:21 raised the point earlier. I'd like to hear you tell us
02:57:25 about well community media outlets ask for advertising how much can that help radio
02:57:35 stations can survive well in fact as i was saying earlier there's a subsidy that's received but it
02:57:46 doesn't cover this the salary or barely of one employee for a radio station
02:57:51 so community radio stations have to be creative and find other ways and advertising revenue are
02:57:59 one of those ways to make up for that shortfall there are also other ways of proceeding community
02:58:08 radio stations have bingos for example that helps with funding as well so these are ways
02:58:16 to address a need that isn't covered by subsidies so it's something very
02:58:23 important and has always served the model of these media outlets that's how
02:58:30 they operated for a long time it's nothing new so it's a loss from recent
02:58:37 years and that's why we're really calling for a return of that advertising
02:58:41 revenue. Thank you, Ms. Carrero. Mr. Bartel, Ms. Cleo, what you experienced last year,
02:58:52 I don't know how to describe it, but you are a model of resilience in the face of challenges,
02:59:00 because despite what you went through, you came back, and we can tell you love media,
02:59:07 love your work my question is when you talk about having bigger donations do you have like a number
02:59:16 in mind in terms of funding well we did we did launch a founders club that allowed people to
02:59:26 donate a thousand dollars a minimum thousand dollars um and we recognize them in in ads in
02:59:32 our newspaper house ads in our newspaper and and uh we're we that the campaign didn't really get
02:59:39 going as well strongly as we wanted to because we kept running into roadblocks with trying to issue
02:59:43 tax receipts we're not a charity um and a few efforts we did try would have run afoul of cra
02:59:49 and we didn't want to do that we didn't want to run run do anything illegal or or that would come
02:59:53 back and bite us um so we don't know i mean we you know we we we got some support from from our union
02:59:59 and and uh some other groups that did step up selflessly and say you know that we we believe
03:00:05 in this too this is this is important this is important for our community um but you know we
03:00:09 don't know what kind of potential is out there if if we don't have some of these tools available to
03:00:15 us like being able to issue tax receipts and that and uh you know we spend a lot of time trying to
03:00:20 investigate things my colleague here janice has spent a lot of time writing grant applications and
03:00:25 and as we said it's it's often fitting a square peg into a round hole where we're trying to get
03:00:30 grants as as cultural or as uh institutions things like that that that we kind of fit into
03:00:36 but it all depends on how you look at it uh so it's it's it's a lot of a lot of effort to to
03:00:43 find money wherever we can to try and to try and give us that foundation that we can build upon
03:00:48 you want canadian media you want the government of canada to consider them do you think some media
03:01:06 outlets are not taken into account by the government of canada what would be your proposal to move
03:01:11 forward last year i think the government spent about okay we want to just um pause for a second
03:01:26 because i have tony clement with us and i want to make sure tony gets some time on here and um
03:01:31 tony i will interrupt if travis comes back on so we can listen in uh but thank you for joining us
03:01:36 of course people will know tony clement he's been both the federal provincial cabinet minister after
03:01:40 leaving politics. You do all sorts of things, including independent media. So thank you for
03:01:46 spending some of your time with us this afternoon. I'll just say to you, I want to ask you a bit
03:01:51 about this because it seems like most governments, with the exception of the Trudeau Liberal government,
03:01:58 were at a constant state of warfare with the CBC, right? Like when you were part of the
03:02:03 Hartford government, it certainly wasn't a very friendly environment. Do you think,
03:02:08 When the Conservatives talk about the CBC, the money that they're giving to the CBC, the government, is it ideological? Is it accountability? What is behind that?
03:02:17 I think it's a combination of a number of things, and particularly because the CBC, by virtue of its structure and mandate, has a leg up on private sector media.
03:02:33 They get government funding. They are still allowed to get private sector funding through sponsorships and commercials. And then they continually were expanding their mandate to, you know, podcasts or, you know, news blogs, all of these things that the independent media were doing, and it was all being state subsidized.
03:02:59 So I think from a fairness perspective, that was a big problem.
03:03:06 And, of course, overlaid on that is a general perception by conservatives that there's not a lot of conservative voices in the CBC.
03:03:16 For an institution, a state-backed institution that claims to represent Canada, there wasn't a lot of representation of a particular point of view.
03:03:26 Let's put it that way.
03:03:27 Yeah. You know, and you kind of started your own independent podcast platform. You talk to you speak to audience just like we do directly. Do you think that's kind of the direction that we're heading to with journalism? Like, where do you kind of see things going here?
03:03:44 I'm actually very optimistic about journalism. I think that this whole move to continually state-subsidize journalism is bound to failure.
03:03:57 People are judging the old media as found wanting and are gravitating towards new media and independent media, whether it's podcasts or independent broadcasting, you name it, YouTube videos.
03:04:19 There's not a diminution of people acquiring and consuming news.
03:04:27 i believe canadians consume a lot of news they're just not getting it in the same place that their
03:04:33 parents or their grandparents did so i think that that is actually a good trend i think that that
03:04:39 means that there is still competition and different viewpoints and even more varied viewpoints than
03:04:46 had been available before so uh i'm not one of these people that is doing a requiem for old
03:04:54 media i just think things are transforming to new versions of consumption of media yeah and while
03:05:01 that audience gets redirected elsewhere the government still continues to fund the cbc at
03:05:07 you know over a billion dollars um and do you think that that sort of funding should continue
03:05:13 like should they be uh should they be a place that still survives because there is you know a need
03:05:19 for local news and no one's doing that like what are your thoughts on like kind of the viability
03:05:23 of the CBC and where that goes? Yeah, I think it's, you have to sort of split up the CBC into
03:05:28 different segments. I think CBC radio performs a function in rural communities and other
03:05:34 remote communities that cannot be replicated. I think that with some reform, Radio Canada
03:05:42 in Quebec can perform a useful function. Then you've got CBC television, English television,
03:05:48 And I just think that what it's providing has already been replicated. There's no need for state funding of that. And so I think there has to be a new model for that, quite frankly.
03:06:03 I think sticking with a model that's been around for almost 100 years isn't good statecraft, it isn't new thinking, and just because it's the way it was done since 1935 doesn't make it the way it should be done for the rest of the 21st century.
03:06:22 Okay, Tony, thank you. I'm going to have to leave you here and go back to Travis. Thanks so much, Tony.
03:06:26 professional reprisal but i also know that this was raised repeatedly and whether or not there
03:06:34 was influence from the former prime minister's office in terms of editorial decisions that were
03:06:40 being made on power and politics or not even the allegation of that on its face needs to be
03:06:47 investigated and from my understanding and cbc can put out a statement correcting uh me if i'm wrong
03:06:54 on this, I don't think that there was ever an investigation. That is a serious concern,
03:07:02 right? I mean, if there are repeated, you know, allegations made about perhaps there's too much
03:07:10 influence here. Now, let me just say this as well. I was a reporter in Ottawa. I've been at
03:07:15 Queen's Park. I was the Queen's Park Bureau Chief for Global. Reporters have sources.
03:07:18 we all know that but there's there's a line where that leads into editorial decision making
03:07:27 and you have to make sure that that is clear and if there's even an allegation that that
03:07:33 may have been crossed you have to look deeper I guess to that end then we we know that public
03:07:41 trust toward the media in general is on the decline we know that that is true with the
03:07:46 CBC. There's no exception there. In your mind, then, you know, is that lack of trust justified?
03:07:53 I think that right now, the CBC, by continuing to put out statements and to come to these
03:08:00 committees and say, yeah, you know, we might have a little bit of a problem. But, you know,
03:08:05 overall, we're not biased. That's gaslighting Canadians. Canadians can see that this is an 1.00
03:08:11 issue right and and this is you know folks have accused me of coming here being a cheerleader
03:08:19 for the conservatives i am not a cheerleader for the conservatives i'm sorry i'm not a cheerleader
03:08:25 for the liberals either i was trying to do my job as a journalist and part of that is being
03:08:30 balanced and so when you have i you know when i was pulled into these disciplinary meetings
03:08:35 i was told that it was editorializing because i put that katherine kate wouldn't come on the program
03:08:39 and it's unfortunate this is unfortunate was editorializing right and was perceived bias
03:08:46 there's a lot of perceived bias going on that i don't see any uh discipline around so i think cbc
03:08:55 needs to have a you know a wake-up call here in terms of accountability uh and really that's
03:09:02 incumbent upon this committee i have made recommendations there are 11 recommendations
03:09:07 in terms of how to uh you know move some of this forward when it came to mr cochran you know this
03:09:13 is during the convoy for example we were talking about tamara litch who was an individual who was
03:09:20 involved in the convoy having that we were doing a story around that uh and you know off the hand
03:09:25 marks remarks can be made at times uh and i said i think that she has a couple of different last
03:09:31 names people who live in trailers usually do you know okay off color remark but if this is a pattern
03:09:40 right you have to if your staff on your own show are raising this if people are leaving the program
03:09:49 you have to look a little bit deeper into it as opposed to pulling me off the air for saying
03:09:54 it's unfortunate the president didn't come on the show so the canadian public is paying for this to
03:10:00 the tune of about 1.4 billion dollars and then of course the government also increased that by an
03:10:04 additional 150 million dollars at the end of the day then the public is the shareholder and also
03:10:10 the ones that are supposed to be benefiting from this news coverage in your estimation
03:10:14 what changes are needed to actually restore that trust i i think that there needs to be
03:10:18 an overhaul when it comes to management i've you know you have my specific recommendations but i
03:10:23 will also say this i am not here as somebody who does not believe in public broadcasting
03:10:28 I was on Jonovision. I started as an audience coordinator when I was 19 years old at the CBC.
03:10:34 I worked on the Air Force. I worked on the Red Green show. I then left. I came back. I worked
03:10:39 at CBC Edmonton. I worked at CBC Toronto. Left. Came back again. I took a pay cut to come back
03:10:45 to the CBC. I used to walk around the CBC broadcast center when I was 19 years old and sneak into the
03:10:51 newsroom. And I thought, this is this. I want to be at this place at some point. This is the heart
03:10:56 of this building the news organization and and it has gotten so far away from what it was
03:11:04 the cbc should not be a polarizing force it needs to bring canadians together and it has the
03:11:12 infrastructure to be able to do that but until there's a recognition of the problem from
03:11:18 management nothing will happen and they fail to recognize this i i am willing i would be willing
03:11:25 to sit down tomorrow with the new president to talk about some of this stuff right but good
03:11:30 people are leaving they're being forced out and and their concerns are being dismissed because
03:11:36 it's about protecting reputation well here's you know some news i don't have to be wanting to
03:11:44 destroy the cbc because management and executives are doing a great job of that on their own
03:11:48 thank you uh we're gonna try one more time with ms roy to see if we have sound now that you have a
03:11:56 new headset you have the floor for five minutes fingers crossed okay excellent excellent so i'd
03:12:02 like to begin by welcoming witnesses from my community and that is janice clue and mario
03:12:07 bartell of freshet news and i want to thank you both for your decades of service and of course
03:12:14 when glacier media's tri-city news closed last year it was a devastating loss for our riding
03:12:20 of port moody coquitlam and why is this because democracy only works when citizens can see the
03:12:28 truth clearly and that requires strong independent journalism so that voters can make informed choices
03:12:34 and hold leaders accountable janice in your own words you actually said that this is dangerous
03:12:40 so this brings me to the matter of journalistic integrity and the journalist code of ethics and
03:12:45 i'd like to really drill down if i could with uh with you and mario so with the advent of
03:12:51 podcasts and online news there's a great deal of misinformation how refreshing journalists trained
03:12:56 and is that the norm i was trained in britain under a program called the nctj
03:13:05 national council training of journalists there's a standardized curriculum in colleges and
03:13:11 universities in britain you do a year program and take legal courses municipal government courses
03:13:21 shorthand you then go out in the field for 18 months and then we all write a national exam in
03:13:26 the end we don't have this in canada we need this in canada it's similar to a trade like red seal
03:13:33 and it would help with municipalities that are struggling with reporters who call themselves
03:13:39 reporters and they're not professionally trained. It would help the municipalities figure out
03:13:46 who should be at the table, who should be at the media table.
03:13:50 Okay, got it. Can we drill down a little bit further and speak to the core principles? So
03:13:57 what really are the core principles of the code of ethics for journalists what are the what are the
03:14:02 pillars well you try to be balanced you try to give both sides of an issue you you try to
03:14:11 give a fair representation of you know when we cover city council you you try to give a fair
03:14:16 representation of the concerns that were raised and and and how they were raised so that when
03:14:21 readers read how a decision came to be they they have some knowledge as to what what uh what some
03:14:28 of the downfalls might be what some of the advantages might be and you just sort of you
03:14:33 report you don't interpret you report i'm i'm actually understanding that um yeah just just
03:14:41 what you said mario that accuracy and verification are absolutely key multiple sources um that there
03:14:50 needs to be um journalists themselves need to be free from conflicts of interest and there can't
03:14:56 be any exchange of gifts or favors um there is a a high level of accountability and transparency
03:15:04 can you speak to uh some of these these principles and how you report um and and also avoiding bias
03:15:12 how you bring that into Fresh It News.
03:15:17 Well, I think we do as we've always done. We stand apart. We don't try and cultivate
03:15:25 friendships or favor with anybody. We go in there and we go in with a fresh mind as to
03:15:32 what is being discussed, what the issues are. And you give a fair ear to all sides and report
03:15:41 accordingly i know that there was a gap between the closure of tri-city news glacier media and
03:15:50 freshet opening and of course the closure happened just ahead of the election what do you feel the
03:15:57 impact was on the electorate in making decisions in in the lead up to the election what what
03:16:04 actually happened it said in the opening as we had said in the opening um we couldn't cover
03:16:11 um candidates and the readers were lost they didn't know who to vote for they didn't know
03:16:17 where to go and again it was very dangerous to democracy so having um corporate media pull out
03:16:27 uh in the middle of the federal election was devastating to our readers and to the advertisers
03:16:31 and to the candidates well in a normal news cycle too we would be there covering all candidates
03:16:37 meetings and and uh bringing you know bringing readers who you know we're there we're kind of
03:16:42 the proxy for people who don't go but still may be interested but they may not be interested in
03:16:46 sitting around for two hours and at a meeting or they just weren't able to go so we're the proxy
03:16:50 that's how we see ourselves same city council anything we cover we're kind of the proxy for
03:16:54 the public so when you uh are able to give a flavor for for a candidate and and what they
03:17:00 said and the the issues that were raised by by people at all candidates meetings that's that's
03:17:05 bringing information to to the larger public as well and and uh hopefully that then informs
03:17:11 everybody a little bit better about when it when it comes to marking their ballot which
03:17:15 which way they're going to go we also cover a very large we also cover when i noticed that there was
03:17:20 a prevalence of other um sort of freelancers journalists that we've never heard of before
03:17:26 that were sort of taking up the space in the news desert and i think people were then tuning into
03:17:31 that because they were hungry i think the electorate is particularly hungry for um this is all the time
03:17:37 we have for this question i'm sorry but i really appreciate that you make the point that journalists
03:17:44 have to be in the room at the school board meetings and at the city halls and in the courtrooms and
03:17:49 when people say ai can take over the job of journalism i think they don't understand what
03:17:55 journalism has done because ai can't be in those rooms um mrs thomas you now have the floor for
03:18:01 five minutes. Awesome. I'm going to ask one quick question and pass it off to my colleague. My
03:18:05 question is for Mike, Mr. Coleman, or your colleagues. And my question is this. You made
03:18:12 a statement with regards to linking the safety and security of the Jewish community here in Canada
03:18:17 to biased coverage from the news media. And I would like you to take a moment and just expand
03:18:22 on that in terms of the consequences that are there. Sorry, you cut out there for a second.
03:18:26 I'll speak to a bit of a portion that I'm going to hand off to my colleagues on Zoom as well.
03:18:31 The first thing is what's reported today becomes domestic and foreign policy tomorrow.
03:18:36 And I echo Mr. Danraj's comments about a very, let's call it a jaundiced marketplace of ideas.
03:18:43 What we have seen in the past couple of years, most certainly as it relates to the CBC, is the elevation of radical voices, giving them a platform, giving them undue legitimacy,
03:18:54 which we feel really does serve to elevate the fringe and marginal voices who are traditionally
03:19:03 you know again on the fringe trying to work their way into the mainstream and then it serves
03:19:07 fundamentally to fan the flames of hatred against Israel and the Jewish community. More specifically
03:19:12 HR Canada Charitable Organization and InnoHives did a long-term two-year study on the Hamas-Israel
03:19:20 War, which found that there was this asymmetry in the CBC's coverage, most specifically that it
03:19:27 elevated radical voices like Independent Jewish Voices, which is a radical anti-Zionist hate
03:19:33 group, and giving them this platform, again, it bestows this kind of credibility, which they
03:19:39 don't deserve, but I'll allow Dr. Haran Shani-Narkis and Amanda Eskenazi to speak in more detail about
03:19:46 their work um so i'll just say briefly first of all thank you and thank you mike can you hear me
03:19:58 right hopefully okay um so i'm here as a scientist um and if there are any questions about the
03:20:06 research we conducted i'm happy to answer i'll just say that taking into account the asymmetry
03:20:13 that's already inherited in the israeli gaza war um we found some very troubling evidence showing
03:20:19 for example how the cbc is using headlines in order to promote one side of the story um
03:20:27 such that even when you compare that to the actual reporting by the cbc
03:20:35 madam chair there's an issue with the audio the interpreters are struggling to interpret
03:20:39 okay I'm sorry we don't have good sound for your intervention there is that
03:20:46 better right now or if not maybe Amanda can take that is it I'm sorry no okay
03:21:09 all right if you are just joining us uh the committee is on a bit of a pause because they've
03:21:16 got audio issues too um they are uh gonna wrap pretty soon i think right now they're getting
03:21:24 through a a bunch of panelists uh on the health of mainstream media in canada um and a lot of
03:21:33 the focus today though is on cbc's funding their mandate um on travis's testimony of editorial bias
03:21:43 of um discrimination and tokenism and i just want to remind folks to stay tuned uh after the this
03:21:51 committee wraps up travis and i will speak we'll go over some of his testimony um and we'll we'll
03:21:58 recap all that for you in case you missed any of it uh but i want to thank you for for tuning in
03:22:03 so far and we'll join the broadcast once again real honest news about what's going on in the
03:22:11 world and they are beating a very one-sided drum a very one-sided narrative and that's what's being
03:22:18 offered to canadians of course canadians are going to be angry they're going to be upset
03:22:24 because what they're being told the reality is is upsetting and angering and when you only present
03:22:31 one side of what is going on you end up with a very ideologically um you end up with an ideology
03:22:41 you don't end up with reality and with um the facts and so i think when you are feeding
03:22:49 canadians um the cbc is not is not telling canadians um how to think about an issue
03:22:57 they're they're showing Canadians what to think about the issue and that should not be the role 0.61
03:23:03 of our public broadcaster and as you know the to just return it to your question Mrs Thomas that
03:23:10 if you have consistently one-sided narratives like this of course you are going to have people who
03:23:16 feel that they need to do something about it and when we have one-sided narratives that demonize
03:23:22 an entire group of people because that's what's happening then of course you are going to have
03:23:26 people who are angry about that and feel that they need to do something about that and that
03:23:30 unfortunately is what we're seeing on the streets in canada right now and what we saw this weekend
03:23:36 in toronto thank you mr miles do you now have the floor for five minutes great thank you very much
03:23:46 and thank you to everybody for being here today and getting this study started off in a very lively
03:23:52 way um i want to talk i think we're all very interested in making sure that there's a diversity
03:23:57 of voices in journalism that's what makes great journalism one thing i'm curious about is the
03:24:02 right balance between you know well how we can create an ecosystem where the private broadcasters
03:24:07 and and journalists thrive as well as a public broadcaster like what the balance looks like
03:24:13 especially in rural communities i find that one thing and i think it speaks to what's been
03:24:17 mentioned is that often rural voices are not actually particularly as more and more newspapers
03:24:23 in small towns close more and more radio stations in small towns close how do we make sure that
03:24:30 things aren't centralized just in the cities of canada but the voices of of rural canadians
03:24:35 are also part of all the conversations we're having maybe i'll start with paul to speak about
03:24:41 that if you get some thoughts so much i i think one of the programs that's that's important for
03:24:47 rural voices is the local journalism initiative um you know many of our members um would be
03:24:54 a couple let's say perhaps in their mid-70s they own the local community newspaper their kids have
03:25:01 moved to the city or or doing something else and the lji is a way of getting a reporter 0.99
03:25:07 into that community invested in that community you know covering cops courts city hall that kind
03:25:14 of stuff so i i think the lji in terms of the uh rural coverage is absolutely uh critical one thing
03:25:22 i will say about the cbc and this is an issue in particular in rural communities cbc has been
03:25:29 poaching journalists from community newspapers and this is a problem there's a terrific uh
03:25:35 column uh written by tim schultz of the saint albert gazette and i think you should all read
03:25:40 it it's in his own paper and it's also in the national post but take a take a look at that i
03:25:45 mean we're losing journalists to the cbc they're getting more money better benefits and listen we
03:25:52 don't begrudge the cbc but i'll give you just one example jeff lg who's an entrepreneur who owns
03:25:57 village media jeff trained a journalist the journalist was hired by the cbc went to toronto
03:26:03 jeff sort of felt okay about that the journalist is in toronto for a while then they move that same
03:26:09 journalist back to the sioux competing with him and he trained that journalist and that's a real
03:26:15 issue it's an issue you know in franco manitoban communities for example this is this is an issue
03:26:21 that you know we're very concerned about is is the poaching of talent and again you know it's
03:26:25 a free labor market but to actually go after and pick off people from community newspapers
03:26:31 in communities like banff it's just not fair i think that's it's uh you know part of what i'm
03:26:38 looking to get at too is some of those those places of like that you know conflict or whatever
03:26:43 between the two sectors and how we can actually uh seek to support both in the ideal world and
03:26:49 to make sure that those voices are not particularly in the rural communities not uh dismissed um are
03:26:55 are there others
03:26:58 i mean i i think you know one of the challenges that we've got
03:27:02 is uh canada post um and and just in terms of sort of you know distribution so
03:27:07 a lot of our members there these are a printed product
03:27:10 a community newspaper canada post has made a decision
03:27:15 that if you have a canadian tire flyer in your newspaper
03:27:20 it falls under something called the consumer's choice program so if
03:27:23 a community says for example i don't want junk mail essentially then you're not able to deliver
03:27:29 that you know newspaper to the community with a canadian tire flyer and the canadian tire flyer
03:27:35 you know that might be for that particular publisher 75 000 a year in revenue that's two
03:27:40 reporters so i think there's lots that the federal government can do to ensure that um that you know
03:27:47 rural community news outlets uh thrive and you know the cbc is one avenue canada post is another
03:27:55 um are you encouraged at all by the idea of cbc moving into rural communities and broadening the
03:28:01 base of of some of their stations look our our view is cbc should be complementary not competitive
03:28:07 and and if they move into communities they're already well served you know that's an issue
03:28:13 they should move to areas that aren't served and when you look at the list that the cbc put forward
03:28:19 in the editor's blog uh they've done it twice in the last sort of year or so many of these
03:28:25 communities are are already well served by you know community newspapers community radio stations
03:28:32 and so i think that's something we have to look at they shouldn't be sort of predatory in the
03:28:36 marketplace if you will very very good um i had just one quick question on ad if i have a couple
03:28:41 a little bit of time just uh just speaking with the ad thing when you're saying i'm curious to
03:28:46 know when you say private enterprises actually kind of bought into local advertising even more
03:28:52 than the government what motivates that because we're a great way of reaching canada right
03:28:57 six percent of canadians read newspaper content each week uh you know when you advertise in a
03:29:02 community newspaper you know it's in a brand safe environment some of these digital ads you do you
03:29:07 you have no idea where your ad is going to wind up on you know some porn site or something or other
03:29:11 right so it's we're a great way to reach canadians we're cost effective and um you know we would
03:29:19 if we're getting ads from you know the banks the airlines the telcos etc how come we're not getting
03:29:25 ads from our own government all of the federally regulated industries the grocery stores they all
03:29:30 advertise with newspapers and yet we don't really see a dime from the federal government that's
03:29:35 that's a problem sector thank you thank you I gave you a bit of leeway there but
03:29:44 there's a there's a limit I will give you the floor for two and a half minutes
03:29:51 thank you madam chair mr. Fegelman you surprised me earlier when you talked
03:29:58 about radical comments that distort media coverage you have an
03:30:04 organization honest reporting that looks at the accuracy of reporting with the conflict
03:30:14 in israel against hamas and now the conflict with iran and i think that's quite fine to have 0.61
03:30:21 groups that look at the quality of journalistic coverage with a conflict situation it's even more
03:30:26 delicate i think that's good i think it's important but your methods are unacceptable
03:30:33 mr fegelman you have a website where you directly attack journalists who have coverage work that
03:30:42 does not please you and that to me i don't understand how you call yourself someone who
03:30:49 looks at the quality of coverage when you use methods that look like harassment laura julie
03:30:55 pero magdalene butras are targeted on your website rather than calling out the coverage that you find
03:31:02 not good enough you attack the work of the journalists and you encourage your supporters
03:31:07 to write directly to them and you give them a template to write directly to them thousands
03:31:13 of emails have been sent to those journalists and maybe to others do you think that harassment
03:31:20 method of journalists is a constructive way to ensure that coverage of these very important and
03:31:28 sensitive issues do you think that harassment method of journalists is the right one do you
03:31:32 stand by that for your question mr shampoo if i may answer your question with a question to you
03:31:39 when your constituents contact you with concerns and complaints would you characterize that as
03:31:44 harassment not at all my constituents expect that i do the work and they elected me and they have
03:31:54 the right to contact me directly you could contact the media that hires these people
03:31:59 you could be in touch with the cbc ombudsman that's how it works you don't directly contact
03:32:06 the journalist it becomes personal it becomes an attack on the work and often the integrity
03:32:12 of the person because you are going after someone who shouldn't be receiving thousands of nonsense
03:32:19 emails as politicians we expect this it's part of the job journalists shouldn't be undergoing this
03:32:26 so go after elected officials those who manage cbc radio canada but let journalists do
03:32:35 their work and have comments from their bosses don't you think that would be the right way to
03:32:40 proceed ourselves as an added layer of editorial oversight um in a world where we're hearing
03:32:47 of massive cutbacks in the Canadian journalism landscape where there's less verification,
03:32:55 we found that actually most journalists value the work that we do because we're, that may
03:33:00 surprise you because we're pointing out the unfairness.
03:33:03 In that case, because I have very little time, I'm sorry, are you able, because I have
03:33:12 very little time left, are you able to provide the names of journalists who support your
03:33:15 work journalists and media not commentators credible ones which journalists support the style
03:33:24 of approach you have with journalists regarding the quality of their work we could have this
03:33:28 conversation for a long time i think the chair will interrupt me soon but if you want to respond
03:33:33 to what i've just said i would be pleased to read your comments you could write to the committee
03:33:37 send all of the documents you wish and we can even pick up this conversation you and i afterwards
03:33:44 because i think this is a very important issue it's about the credibility of your comments which
03:33:48 could be very good in this debate perhaps they can provide that information to the committee
03:33:54 if you can come back with those names that mr shampoo has asked for that would be later that
03:34:02 we would accept that information because we're out of time quest to go two minutes for each
03:34:08 party before we finish this conversation before we get to mr shampoo is that okay everybody okay
03:34:12 with that? Okay. Mrs. Thomas you have two minutes. I'll be taking this two minutes. Yeah Mr. Fegelman
03:34:24 it was very interesting when you said that you indicated that the CDC executive said that the
03:34:31 network shouldn't refer to Hamas as a terrorist group even though the government of Canada has
03:34:38 recognized them as a terrorist group since 2002 why should the public be alarmed at this well
03:34:47 in the canada gazette it is publicly listed that they are a terrorist group their day job is to
03:34:52 strap a suicide vest on themselves and with the intent of maiming and murdering innocence when
03:34:59 our media sanitized language it effectively legitimizes the actions or at least it distorts
03:35:06 people aren't fully aware that what these people do what their intentions are is to wipe israel
03:35:12 and jews off the map so it is it is really misrepresenting the facts on the ground language 0.63
03:35:19 matters diction matters now your organization did do a deep dive into the coverage that
03:35:28 uh happened um throughout cbc since october the 7th can you just uh reiterate some of that coverage
03:35:37 and and you you allege it was uh highly biased well i'd like to recount a couple of examples of
03:35:43 cbc bias that we've come across the first on on february 16th cbc radio canada's correspondent
03:35:49 elisa serrett who was later suspended uttered an anti-semitic trope on air when claiming that and
03:35:55 and I quote the Israelis. In fact, the Jews finance a lot of American politics and control 0.99
03:36:01 a big machine. It's a clear-cut anti-Semitic trope. CBC continues to use reporters who've
03:36:09 expressed radical anti-Israel views. They have a journalist named Sarah Jabakanji, who in 2021
03:36:15 signed an open letter boldly proclaiming that there should be more pro-Palestinian coverage.
03:36:20 uh that's just at the CBC um I I would refer you to my colleague Amanda Eskenazi who can talk in
03:36:28 specifics about uh some of the results of the study that they did about about the CBC's bias
03:36:35 thank you um I'm sorry we just have two minutes for everybody it's a really quick it's like we
03:36:42 call it the lightning round kind of like a game show uh Mr. Miles you have two minutes
03:36:46 sure you know i i think i'll just go right back to paul because we get a little interrupted i'm
03:36:51 sorry to keep on going back at you but i just because i am curious about this advertising piece
03:36:55 because it i i hear you i hear what you're saying as an opportunity obviously to to support uh these
03:37:01 you know journalists and the work of these papers and broadcasters um but at the same time there has
03:37:08 been uh a decline in private advertising in newspapers certainly like that that's a fact
03:37:15 as well, right? Absolutely. So just for ballpark numbers, so advertising in Canadian newspapers
03:37:21 a dozen years ago would have been about three and a half billion dollars. Today, it's probably
03:37:26 900 million or so. Okay. So the private sector has also abandoned that route. I wouldn't say
03:37:34 abandoned. I'd say they've changed in terms of their spend, but we're still doing okay in terms
03:37:43 of a lot of community newspapers i mean if you pick up a community newspaper you're going to see
03:37:48 the ad from the chevy dealer you're going to see you know the ad from the remax agent like we we
03:37:53 still do okay it's but disproportionately we don't do well with government uh and in particular with
03:38:00 the federal government it's interesting and is it because they believe that this is where the
03:38:04 eyeballs are they should go where the eyeballs are is that not so the government has an agency
03:38:07 of record right and i think this dates back to the sponsorship era so or the sponsorship scandal
03:38:12 from years ago so the government has an agency of record that makes the decision it used to be
03:38:17 cosette it's now wpp i think that the those firms have done what is easiest and most profitable for
03:38:24 them which is programmatic advertising those ads that just sort of pop up everywhere you know you
03:38:29 you've developed much more of an impression if you take out a a full page ad uh in the killiel
03:38:35 de saintia sinth um bell example you're going to make much more of an impact than a little
03:38:40 programmatic advertising that pops up okay thank you appreciate you i know there's lots of individual
03:38:48 mps advertising in our local media but that's a different budget and i won't get into it uh uh
03:38:57 you have the floor mr shampoo two minutes thank you madam chair i didn't know i'd have this
03:39:01 additional two minutes i'd feel bad if i didn't give mr begelman the opportunity to respond to
03:39:06 my comments i thought we would continue our conversation
03:39:11 by email or otherwise but mr figelman i'll give you a minute to respond to
03:39:15 what i said earlier if you wish if you want to pick up
03:39:19 and hear your question when you first asked if you don't mind asking the
03:39:22 question forgive me the audio is terrible for me
03:39:26 yeah the question i just asked well i'm giving you the opportunity to respond to
03:39:31 what i said earlier we ran out of time for you to respond
03:39:36 Est-ce que la traduction, est-ce que vous avez la traduction en anglais?
03:39:39 Are you having the interpretation into English? Do you hear the interpretation?
03:39:43 Testing on the English channel. We want to make sure that our system is working properly.
03:39:50 Is it that you can't hear or that there's no translation? Translation.
03:39:55 English channel, if I speak, can you hear, can you hear the English? Is the English interpretation
03:40:00 coming through is there a problem testing on the english channel one two three testing one two three
03:40:09 can you hear me interpretation into english is this working for you can you hear okay
03:40:17 ah okay i didn't have my microphone on is it working now is it working better
03:40:23 okay go ahead mr shampoo my question wasn't really a question mr fegelman i was giving
03:40:34 you the opportunity to respond to what i said earlier we were interrupted we ran out of time
03:40:41 so i am proposing that you respond to my comments for a minute
03:40:46 rather than having this conversation later i was just giving you the floor to respond
03:40:53 I'll give you an example of some of the dialogue we had in recent days. We filed a complaint with
03:41:00 the Globe and Mail to their standards editor because they had published a column that had said
03:41:05 that Israel takes Palestinians hostage, which it does not do, which is a violation of international
03:41:10 law. We filed a complaint, they received it, they appreciated it, and they took corrective measures
03:41:16 to issue a correction. That's the kind of what we consider to be constructive dialogue that is
03:41:22 important and i would also say um with your comment about alleged harassment if any of our
03:41:28 subscribers we have about 80 000 subscribers from coast to coast if anyone engaged with a member
03:41:33 of the media in a way that we felt was unprofessional strident knee-jerk reactionary
03:41:40 we would be the very first to either try to sensitize them to our concerns uh and if they
03:41:47 weren't listening and were uncooperative we would take them off our list we don't think that that
03:41:51 is helpful we think it's actually quite counter-productive so if journalists told you
03:42:00 they were embarrassed they were bothered there's little time but if journalists told you we don't
03:42:11 agree with the way you're operating we'd prefer for comments criticism discussion of that nature
03:42:17 be done with the editors or the bosses of newsrooms rather than journalists directly you would be open
03:42:25 to that you would be open to that dialogue we're certainly open to any kind of dialogue with any
03:42:30 different leverage point in the canadian media landscape our challenge though is what we
03:42:35 oftentimes encounter is window dressing of accountability and evasive efforts on in terms
03:42:44 of implementation of journalistic standards meaning we could bring a grievance to a journalist
03:42:49 editor and they may not reply and are totally evasive and we think that that's quite problematic
03:42:55 so i think there is a necessity for an oversight mechanism i i think broadly speaking our goal
03:43:03 should be that look a very canadian response with civic engagement because i think that's
03:43:08 fundamentally constructive that's where we don't agree mr fegelman i think at a certain point
03:43:14 have to accept the processes in place it's not up to journalists or workers who didn't ask to have
03:43:19 that relationship to have that harassment directed at them i think there needs to be a line drawn
03:43:25 somewhere and i think the way you proceed with your call to contact journalists directly by email
03:43:31 i think you're crossing that line that's my opinion i think on that we can end and we can
03:43:37 talk about the motion yes exactly if you wish to begin mr shampoo you can introduce
03:43:46 no let's go ahead well we can continue five minutes oh if you'd like we're going to discuss
03:43:53 the motion that mr shampoo uh rose earlier today you don't have to leave you can stay at the end
03:43:59 but we have finished with our questioning of you i hope it was not too onerous we truly appreciate
03:44:05 all of your participation and keep in mind that you're welcome to send in any further information
03:44:12 or documentation i know mr dan raj you've been asked to supply certain documents to this committee
03:44:17 but we can take all of that or if there's something you forgot to say for example don't
03:44:21 hesitate to reach out to the committee and we can include all of that in our consideration
03:44:26 of our report thank you again mr shampoo thank you madam chair i read the motion earlier so
03:44:33 that it would be on the record i just want to give a little bit of context in quebec last week we
03:44:40 learned all right we are just coming out of heritage committee that's happening in ottawa
03:44:50 today that's where travis was testifying and telling uh folks there about his experience
03:44:55 inside of the cbc he has presented evidence um two binders he's calling the receipts um
03:45:01 and in the meantime we've been doing this show so i want everyone just to to to stay locked in
03:45:06 to stay tuned in because travis will be joining us as soon as he can get out of that room um in
03:45:12 the meantime someone's been helping me produce this show uh and i don't want him to be um
03:45:21 to be damaged by travis or my reputation because he is a solid journalist he's unlike travis and
03:45:27 myself this is wyatt sharp i want to introduce everyone to uh why it's been producing this
03:45:31 special with us and why it also has his own show it's called the white sharp show um wyatt i i
03:45:37 don't think i have to i don't think it embarrasses you to tell people to tell people that you're
03:45:43 young you are uh 17 years old right still in high school um but very politically engaged um you are
03:45:50 you consider yourself a journalist you interview newsmakers and um you have your own show and uh
03:45:56 You've been following along with this story. So you want to give me some of your initial thoughts
03:46:01 out of Travis's testimony? Yeah, I mean, just quickly, I know we have Travis who's getting
03:46:06 set up so we can go to him in a moment. I just like, as you point out, I try and remain as kind
03:46:10 of nonpartisan as possible. And I think the thing about this story is it is a very nonpartisan
03:46:14 story. There have been disruptions that people have raised on both sides of the aisle. We had
03:46:19 Sarbjit Karan earlier in the show who was talking about some of those issues as well. And this is
03:46:23 not, I mean, I think Travis was talking about this as well, but there is a case to be made for a
03:46:27 strong CBC and no one, at least Travis or otherwise, is saying that we need to, you know, completely
03:46:32 defund the CBC. And I think from my perspective as a young journalist, there are few people who
03:46:38 were willing to kind of step out and support me when I was 11, 12, 13 years old in the same way
03:46:42 that Travis was. I mean, when you're 12 years old in an industry that is otherwise occupied by people
03:46:47 40, 50 years old and even older, it can feel isolating at times. And I'll just give one
03:46:52 particular story i remember being out kind of in ottawa when president joe biden came to canada and
03:46:59 travis was there going to like the secure bus and the secure locations to get on everywhere and
03:47:04 travis was one of the few people who would actually kind of you know show me around kind of mentor me
03:47:09 and stuff so not to make it out as if he's a saint i'm sure he has his flaws but just he's kind of
03:47:13 i just yeah i just want to kind of make it out to people as if you know the case is that um he he is
03:47:20 someone who is a very nice person, has a great heart.
03:47:22 And I think he is not doing this from a position of, you know, partisanship so much as he just wants journalism to be good.
03:47:29 He wants journalism to be strong, as it should be, especially coming from the public broadcaster.
03:47:34 That's enough from me. We have someone much more exciting.
03:47:38 We want to bring in Travis. And Wyatt did not say all that just because you're coming on, Travis.
03:47:43 um okay yeah how'd it go i can fact check Wyatt on one thing yeah i well i'm definitely not a saint
03:47:50 so he said i'm not a saint but uh oh i already said that's okay yeah well you're well aware of
03:47:55 that listen i mean listen uh i i don't know you tell me but i think yeah i was disappointed that
03:48:04 the only one party asked about some of these really concerning uh issues right um i i think i
03:48:11 tried to highlight as much as I could in the short time that I had, but I do think that
03:48:18 this is one hearing. It's a committee hearing, right? I'm one voice. There are all these other
03:48:23 voices. This is a much larger conversation that we need to have as a country. This is bigger than
03:48:30 just one person. It's about staff members across regions, across time zones, across newsrooms in
03:48:38 this country that have similar concerns so if the cdc wants to put out a statement today
03:48:43 which i chuck thompson i'll help you write your statement right now uh you know we we we are
03:48:49 shocked by these false allegations that mr dan rej once again uh you know put forward today
03:48:56 at parliament this is an attack on our leaders and news okay whatever chuck just write it
03:49:01 storm put it out it it's not it's not these are these are these are stories that are real these
03:49:09 are real people's lives people should not be tokenized people should not have their voices
03:49:14 diminished right and so i i hope that this is able to start a conversation in terms of what
03:49:22 accountability looks like because the cbc left to their own devices we have seen this time and
03:49:27 again, do nothing because they are just funded. And there's really no oversight. Sure. Will the
03:49:33 president come here? Will it get heated a bit? Yeah. What happens after that? So what I really
03:49:39 want to see out of all of this, and as I said in the committee, Carmen, I'm willing to sit down
03:49:44 with them and have a discussion about some of the systemic issues at play here. I have a feeling
03:49:50 they're not going to take you up on that. I don't think Stevie's is going to take me up on that
03:49:53 either which is a shame though right because like you know this can be a midlife crisis for the cbc
03:49:59 or it could be an end of life crisis i mean executives can decide and as i said i i don't
03:50:05 need to destroy the cbc they're doing a great job of that uh at 250 front street and across the
03:50:11 street here on queen street in ottawa for themselves do you have a few if you have a few
03:50:16 minutes let's just go through some of this but tell me if you have to run and we'll wrap it up
03:50:20 I do. I'm being loud in the hallway, so I probably am going to have to go outside and reconnect with you.
03:50:25 But sure, yeah, I can ask someone a question.
03:50:28 Well, I just I actually want to get into it a bit.
03:50:30 But if you want to relocate and then we'll talk about it, that's fine.
03:50:34 But I wanted to talk about your actual testimony, the binders, some of the stuff that you brought forward as evidence and some of the new things that you talked about.
03:50:42 So do you want us to hold for that while you while you move yourself or you want to get into it now?
03:50:47 yeah let me let me go outside i want to have a dart which my mother is probably gonna 1.00
03:50:53 right now we need you on this live coverage no smoking and then i will and then i'll uh
03:50:58 and then i'll join you back uh well hurry up okay let me have five minutes okay okay everyone see
03:51:04 i'm so sorry he needs to go have a smoke and go outside but in the meantime uh maybe young
03:51:10 wyatt wants to join me once again uh white sharp is the host of the white sharp 0.56
03:51:14 a show um and a young person and someone who's been helping us behind the scenes produce
03:51:20 this special that you see um today and you know why we've had a lot of conversations leading up to
03:51:26 um to the testimony today with people who have talked about the future of journalism where does
03:51:33 this go um where are audiences like even you you are not i mean you do do network you do do
03:51:39 mainstream media but your show is broadcast on an independent channel you do a lot of podcasts you
03:51:45 do a lot of other things so um you know the bigger picture here really is where do audiences go and
03:51:52 are we seeing the slower decline the slow decline of traditional media yeah i mean i think so and
03:51:58 i don't want this to come from you know people assuming that i'm partisan and i'll even just say
03:52:01 in the committee and in the testimony from some of the other speakers one thing i really
03:52:05 appreciated with some of the people talking about the importance of local news. Because I do think
03:52:10 that while there is a strong case to be made for independent media and for what you and Travis are
03:52:14 doing, what I'm doing in a number of respects as well, it is still true, and you and Travis will
03:52:18 say this yourselves, that you're no longer journalists. You're contributing to kind of
03:52:21 the opinion ecosphere and the commentary ecosphere, which also fills kind of an important gap. But I
03:52:26 think there is still a need for that kind of journalism piece. And so I think what the kind
03:52:31 Committee and some of the testimony was talking about was prioritizing real factual and unbiased
03:52:36 journalism, which a number of local newsrooms do. So I think it's unfortunate in the US even
03:52:40 where we see layoffs happening at the Washington Post and elsewhere. And I think the question
03:52:45 starts to become, you can't make a meaningful case for upholding local news when there are,
03:52:51 you know, questions and skepticism surrounding how kind of factual the news and the reporting
03:52:56 coming from some of these so-called unbiased entities is actually being. And again, going back
03:53:00 to what I said before. I think there's a strong case to be made for, you know, a CBC. And I think
03:53:04 a lot of it is changing the medium as to how it is produced. I can talk to, you know, the perspective
03:53:10 of people who are my age and in my generation, because I think a lot of them, they're certainly
03:53:13 not sitting down watching the national or watching the six o'clock news on any station. And that's
03:53:17 not even just about CBC. That's just about an accessibility thing about the fact that young
03:53:21 people don't really want to kind of put the time in to do that. They want to get their news
03:53:25 in quicker ways. So I think in terms of the medium and, you know, how people consume their
03:53:30 news changing, a lot of that does come down to the fact that people are tuning into these platforms
03:53:34 like yours, like Travis's, and other kind of podcasting platforms out there, because it allows
03:53:39 them to get the news, but it also allows them to hear kind of a contrast of opinions. And like
03:53:44 Travis said, I think it's unfortunate that there are certain kind of facets within the media
03:53:49 landscape who are making it where we can't have multiple perspectives included. And I think having
03:53:54 multiple perspectives included can reduce the level of polarization that we're seeing in Canada
03:53:59 and the United States. Polarization that has gotten so intense at times that it feels as if
03:54:03 you can't even have a conversation with other people without it becoming just a shouting match
03:54:08 or, you know, a super intense kind of back and forth. I think also something like that I'm seeing
03:54:14 in the comments that I'm seeing as a reflection of what Travis is saying is a general distrust
03:54:21 in institution of journalism of media of mainstream media and the idea that um you know
03:54:30 there's a bias there that no one speaks about and so i think you know there is a role for journalism
03:54:37 there is a role for objectively reporting things but then you know we hear from people like brian
03:54:43 Lily or Travis where there there is sometimes a bias that isn't necessarily acknowledged and that
03:54:52 leads people to distrust the media to distrust those institutions and not believe them and
03:54:58 turning to other sources um and you know that's not always a good thing I think it's a I think
03:55:04 it's a good thing that we have like a diversity of of places where people can go but more often than
03:55:09 not when people go to those places they're hearing what they want to hear right they're hearing
03:55:13 the same things that you know uh the same it's group thing right it's like it's like you're
03:55:20 you're speaking in the echo chamber um but at the same time i think there are people out there
03:55:27 doing good work like you um who don't you know have that bias but i think what travis has presented
03:55:33 today about the cbc raises a lot of questions given that they take so much government money
03:55:40 right they are they are they are funded by taxpayer dollars almost 1.5 billion dollars
03:55:45 and therefore there needs to be a lot of accountability there and um the the issues
03:55:50 that travis has raised the issues we've heard from other people who work inside the cbc
03:55:54 those are legitimate ones that should be addressed and um so far we haven't seen
03:55:59 sort of a reckoning with that yeah and i mean to your point i mean the amount of money that cbc
03:56:05 receives i think a lot of people their criticisms about it is that it's wasteful no one's
03:56:09 not many people anyways, are disputing the fact that some government money towards a public
03:56:14 broadcaster can be a good thing. You see it in the United States with NPR, with PBS. And
03:56:18 these are outlets that have done a relatively good job in the US, at least at kind of maintaining
03:56:22 that level of neutrality. People from both sides of the aisle are willing to go on some of these
03:56:27 platforms. But when we look at it, and kind of what's happening in Canada, and what Travis
03:56:30 testified about today, it speaks to, I think, a broader problem. And that is when you're investing
03:56:35 so much money in a platform, that's one thing. But when you're investing that much money,
03:56:39 and as a result, it's become so polarized and so partisan that now half of the country feels as if
03:56:44 they can't tune into that platform and as if the platform doesn't represent their political
03:56:49 viewpoints, that's a problem. And I think, you know, we should be encouraging more dialogue,
03:56:52 we should be encouraging more conversation from people on all sides of the spectrum who have
03:56:57 differences of opinion, and bringing them together. And, you know, Brian Lilly was talking
03:57:01 about this when you were interviewing him earlier about how when he was on Travis's panel, the
03:57:05 intersection on Canada Tonight. He was brought on with Rachel Gilmore. He was brought on with
03:57:09 Sheila Copps. He was brought on with people who are at the complete opposite end of the spectrum,
03:57:13 and he felt as if being in kind of a more controlled environment with some of these
03:57:17 people who have political disagreements allowed for that conversation to kind of flow naturally.
03:57:21 He said he was on with Gertan Singh, a former NDP, MPP, and the Ontario legislature on Canada
03:57:26 Tonight with Travis, and he said that show and that appearance with Travis was kind of a medium
03:57:31 that then allowed him to maintain a friendship with Gertan Singh.
03:57:34 And so I think having the conversations with people from across the aisle,
03:57:38 it fosters a sense of dialogue that can reduce partisanship and reduce polarization.
03:57:42 And it's also just very much needed right now.
03:57:44 And I think people want to see respectful conversations.
03:57:47 You know, they want to see more solutions-focused thinking.
03:57:50 They want to see more practical thinking.
03:57:51 And they don't want to see those shouting matches and kind of the slogan-based politics
03:57:55 that so much of the political and media ecospheres have kind of, you know, come down to now.
03:58:01 Yeah. And, you know, I have heard, obviously, I know Travis's story. Well, I know some of the things that he went through. And I wonder, like some of the stuff that he presented today in committee, I don't think you've heard before. So I wanted to, you know, get your reaction as someone who's hearing that for the first time, like what you thought about some of the things that he brought forward.
03:58:24 Yeah. And I mean, in total transparency, like many of the people that he was talking about,
03:58:28 I don't know. They could be nice people. They might not be nice. I have no idea. I just am
03:58:32 hearing about it from Travis. And I don't have a lot of the people he was speaking about were
03:58:36 management. They were people behind the scenes. So, you know, kind of trusting what he's saying
03:58:39 on that in the sense that he knew them, I didn't. But I mean, I do think there are people who work
03:58:43 at the CBC who do great work. And I think there's people who work at the CBC who do very much care
03:58:48 about their jobs. And I don't want to take away from some of the good reporters who are working
03:58:52 there. But again, I think when you have a host who came from another network, this was not,
03:58:57 you know, a lot of people are trying to say that Travis was kind of inserted into this just to
03:59:01 make a political argument. He had a 20 plus career. He was at Bell Media. You guys worked
03:59:05 together at CP24. He was at Global. He was at all of these different platforms. And then he got this
03:59:10 opportunity to come to CBC. And I think when he went to CBC, it was his own show. He was expecting
03:59:15 that he could have some of these multiple perspectives included on his show. And then
03:59:19 when he was told that he couldn't do that, I think was the part that me as like a young journalist
03:59:24 who very much cares about, again, bringing all perspectives together was taken aback by a little
03:59:28 bit because I thought if it's the public broadcaster, if it's the, you know, seven or
03:59:32 eight o'clock primetime show every night, why wouldn't you want to have multiple perspectives
03:59:36 included? And that's something that I think regardless of partisanship, you know, you should
03:59:39 be able to at least identify multiple perspectives is a good thing. But we have Travis again. So
03:59:44 yeah okay white appreciate you thank you um travis you're back with us i i don't even want
03:59:51 to you shouldn't have told your mom you're gonna have a cigarette she's you're gonna get yelled at
03:59:55 um but oh i don't think we have audio on you you gotta unmute yourself there you go yeah
04:00:03 there we go yeah okay yeah sorry sorry i i i sorry i was be right i was being uh told that
04:00:09 i needed to come on right away so i came back to you as quickly as i could okay listen we're
04:00:13 gonna try to like let's let's let's do all this let's wrap it up let's give people like what they
04:00:17 want here um i want to address some of the comments we've been getting about you in cahoots with the
04:00:23 conservatives that you are you know you're doing their bidding so let's just get that out of the
04:00:28 way go and i'll tell you because i just i just ran into michelle ferrari in the uh the hallway 0.96
04:00:35 there and i ran to a couple of mps i thought i needed anand as i was coming out and michelle
04:00:39 for I pulled out her phone and we did a little uh a thing as I was walking out that'll be turned
04:00:45 into something partisan as well right so I mean listen I can't I can't dissuade some people
04:00:52 whatever I say some people will think that I am only doing this for partisan reasons
04:00:58 on the left and on the right I mean that is that is the conversation out there but I mean like
04:01:05 we have to look at the facts of the matter right that's what we have to do that's how we have to
04:01:09 judge things what happened inside what you know the what was said that case is before the canadian
04:01:17 human rights commission am i the only person saying this no there's a lot of people saying
04:01:23 this now there are more people coming out perhaps there will be more in the weeks to come and is
04:01:29 that what was in the binders travis like part of what was the evidence that you you submitted to
04:01:33 the committee today was some of that testimony um not testimony sorry some of the accounts
04:01:39 firsthand accounts from people who work at the cbc or had worked at the cbc and you know there's
04:01:45 their experiences that were not dissimilar to yours that was part of the evidence that you submitted
04:01:49 well i know so i have i have the letters that the folks have sent me we're submitting those to the
04:01:56 canadian human rights commission cbc knows who those people are the union knows who those people
04:02:01 are because there have been complaints right um but i i called actually the the committee to make
04:02:08 sure that i can get assurances in terms of confidentiality because i understand the real
04:02:13 concern that a lot of these folks have for professional repercussions and retaliation
04:02:17 for you know reputations being harmed i mean what what do you think is happening to me right now in
04:02:22 terms of this right so uh so there weren't those protections there so that's why it wasn't handed
04:02:29 over to them okay but but it will be handed over to the commission and i think you know
04:02:33 what is important here is that there are these ndas that are being used so if these okay ndas
04:02:42 are non-disclosure agreements and in your particular have been coming forward to me
04:02:49 and it's a growing list and these folks are not under these gag orders how many people are under
04:02:56 these non-disclosure agreements that can't speak out how much money has the cbc spent taxpayer
04:03:03 money on fighting cases like mine on grievances on systemic issues on hr consultants to come in
04:03:13 like we got to look at the fundamental problem here right we can put window dressing up all we
04:03:19 want we can paint the walls but if the foundation is crumbling we got an issue yeah okay so the
04:03:28 nda that they tried to make you sign was after what happened and what did it want you what did
04:03:35 it what did it say well i mean i i i said basically what it said in the in the committee room right
04:03:44 um that i was basically expected to to not speak at all that's problematic on on these issues
04:03:53 there's not a uh an issue related to somebody's human rights why is that a necessary clause to
04:03:59 put into an agreement right so i mean just on its face some of these things were very concerning and
04:04:06 And I mean, I don't know in what world I would sign a document like that.
04:04:12 Clearly, they felt emboldened to put that in front of me.
04:04:19 No, no, but people do because it's like you were up against a major corporation
04:04:26 with a ton of money, a ton of lawyers, and sometimes that feels a little helpless.
04:04:31 So people signed it because they have no choice.
04:04:33 They feel helpless about it.
04:04:34 and I get it like but yeah um anyway I do want to um I want to throw to this yeah
04:04:40 yeah I was just gonna say that this this this has been and I think that's important point that you
04:04:47 made Carmen it's it's been an isolating experience I mean now I'm able to to speak more and I you
04:04:53 know there I am thankful to all of the folks that have been uh supportive um and even the folks that
04:05:00 aren't that are just listening right uh but but when this was all going on at the cbc it was very
04:05:07 isolating i didn't have a lot of folks to talk to i mean i talked to you about things going on
04:05:13 throughout i remember you know my mother came to the set one day um she's from calgary you know my
04:05:19 folks are living calgary from turnidad but they live in calgary they've lived there since the 70s
04:05:23 and she came to toronto she doesn't come that often and i took her to the set and she thought
04:05:29 to herself wow you know she said to me all these folks here this is your show and all this stuff
04:05:35 had been happening i never really told them i said yeah yeah it's my show bold voice in journalism
04:05:41 that's that's what the job description said that's what the tagline of the show is bold
04:05:47 voice in journalism i was ashamed to tell my mother that essentially you know my voice was
04:05:54 diminished it was not equal to others so anyway yeah you know to that point you um talked about
04:06:02 how good people like yourself were forced out of the cdc and you talked about that in your
04:06:07 testimony and we want to play back some of that uh some of that so the canadian public is paying
04:06:15 for this to the tune of about 1.4 billion dollars and then of course the government also increased
04:06:20 set by an additional 150 million dollars at the end of the day then the public is the shareholder
04:06:26 and also the ones that are supposed to be benefiting from this news coverage in your
04:06:29 estimation what changes are needed to actually restore that trust i think that there needs to be
04:06:34 an overhaul when it comes to management i've you know you have my specific recommendations but i
04:06:39 will also say this i am not here as somebody who does not believe in public broadcasting
04:06:45 i was on jonavision i started as an audience coordinator when i was 19 years old at the cbc
04:06:50 I worked on the Air Force.
04:06:51 I worked on the Red Green show.
04:06:52 I then left.
04:06:54 I came back.
04:06:55 I worked at CBC Edmonton.
04:06:56 I worked at CBC Toronto.
04:06:58 Left.
04:06:58 Came back again.
04:06:59 I took a pay cut to come back to the CBC.
04:07:03 I used to walk around the CBC Broadcast Centre when I was 19 years old and sneak into the
04:07:07 newsroom, and I thought, I want to be at this place at some point.
04:07:11 This is the heart of this building, the news organization.
04:07:15 and and it has gotten so far away from what it was the cbc should not be a polarizing force
04:07:24 it needs to bring canadians together and it has the infrastructure to be able to do that
04:07:30 but until there's a recognition of the problem from management nothing will happen and they
04:07:37 fail to recognize this i i am willing i would be willing to sit down tomorrow with the new president
04:07:43 to talk about some of this stuff right but good people are leaving they're being forced out
04:07:49 and and their concerns are being dismissed because it's about protecting reputation well
04:07:55 here's you know some news i don't have to be wanting to destroy the cbc because
04:08:01 management and executives are doing a great job of that on their own
04:08:05 okay so uh that was you just a short time ago um
04:08:11 i yeah they're still gonna get they're still gonna get fun though right
04:08:15 i mean that's that's the thing about the whole thing like whoa i mean it's frustrating and i
04:08:22 understand why it's frustrating for so many canadians because it's like if these issues
04:08:26 are brought up and there's no accountability we're just discussing things it's like we're
04:08:30 on this endless merry-go-round and the gaslighting of Canadians saying nothing to see here you know
04:08:40 maybe there's a little tweak here or there that we need to do it I mean I get why people get
04:08:47 frustrated and I feel like you know I messaged you afterwards and I was like was I too hot
04:08:52 was I too passionate I'm passionate about this because like I believe that if we want this place
04:08:59 to survive and listen i know that there's a lot of folks that say goodbye but we're a big country
04:09:03 as i said right if we want if if there is a hope in hell of this place surviving
04:09:11 they got to start fixing some things they really really do and that starts with their staff and
04:09:17 the treatment of their staff where this committee hearing was about fairness in media there's not
04:09:23 fairness in terms of staff let's start with that that's the starting point okay i um
04:09:33 how much more do you got for me because i gotta run soon okay well what let's you tell me what
04:09:37 what else where are you going well i got i gotta fly back we're flying back i'm fine we have a we
04:09:44 have a thing tomorrow morning right okay great um yeah how i would just say like this is my
04:09:51 reflection on because i've heard you talk about this the last you tell me why don't you tell me
04:09:55 how you think about i just think like you've been sitting on this stuff for a long time
04:10:01 and sometimes stuff too there's a ton more stuff right there's a ton that um you know has to
04:10:09 yeah that has to um that has to wait sometimes for your legal your legal actions or you're
04:10:15 we didn't even get to this binder look look at the binder so i wonder if it's like
04:10:23 almost a huge relief to be able to say some of it now and um you know get out there because i
04:10:31 think you've mainly except outside of doing our podcast you haven't really given interviews you
04:10:35 haven't really talked about this with anyone um and today you got to talk about it a bit more
04:10:41 openly than you have before and uh how did how did that feel it felt okay but you know uh and
04:10:49 i'm gonna be doing more interviews i'm gonna start doing interviews now i thought you know to myself
04:10:53 i'll just say this and then move on um you know when we did the podcast but i think i have a
04:10:58 responsibility to keep sounding the alarm but it's it's like is anyone i know that there are people
04:11:06 listening but is anybody listening that will take some action here in terms of that at the at the
04:11:13 cbc which is one street over from where i'm standing right now i know that they're all
04:11:17 watching this but is there anybody in that building in terms of the management that wants
04:11:23 to take accountability and say okay maybe this kid's got a point right well i mean since you've
04:11:30 spoken out it's not just you right we've gotten just me so many people that have written in
04:11:35 written to you written to the show yeah and i've read some of those first-hand accounts um today
04:11:41 for the first time yep go ahead can i just say on that like like the portion where i was talking
04:11:48 about these other individuals i was able to read like a like a sentence or two because of time
04:11:55 these are detailed accounts right we got receipts i wonder how you how you and maybe like
04:12:03 when people like you talk about stuff like this how do you respond to criticism that
04:12:08 it's disgruntled employee it's um some of these people are current current employees
04:12:14 right it's just it's it's like this is this this is workplace stuff it's not
04:12:19 listen you you heard you heard the story of karen johnson is that is that you know yeah
04:12:25 wouldn't you be a bit disgruntled as well if you know those allegations are true right so anyway
04:12:33 um yeah i mean that that's thrown around so easily oh this person's bitter
04:12:37 i mean were the concerns legitimate right were they were they addressed what were the steps taken
04:12:46 like all of these are relevant questions before you just toss somebody's story aside and say
04:12:52 they're angry they're better they're this they're that no yeah no anyway i gotta i gotta run okay
04:12:59 travis thank you so much by the way folks if uh you know you're watching this carmen has been
04:13:04 doing this for several hours yeah because you made me well i mean listen it's like back to your
04:13:12 no listen it's my pleasure it's my pleasure and uh you know we started can't be censored because
04:13:17 we needed a platform to are you smoking again no no no there's a minister coming out of the
04:13:22 right here all right listen i'm gonna let you go uh and in the meantime i want to thank everyone
04:13:27 who has tuned in uh to this live broadcast of travis testifying um in ottawa i want to thank
04:13:34 wyatt who's been behind the scenes helping us to produce the show um and this is you know
04:13:39 it's not it's not the end it's to be continued so we'll see you soon