Western Standard - December 19, 2024


Trudeau out. Trump in?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Incompetent! Arrogant! Out of control! Trudeau must go! HANNAFORD: A walk through Trudeau's mind

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

173.16

Word count

8,318

Sentence count

532

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

32

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Nonniford and Editor-in-Chief Derek Fildebrandt join host Cory Morgan and Senior Editor-In-Chief Neil MacGregor to discuss the latest in the Trudeau government's meltdown, and the question of whether or not Justin Trudeau will survive the election.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Today is December 18th, 2024. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western
00:00:28 standard and you're watching the pipeline this will be our last episode before the christmas break
00:00:35 uh but don't worry we'll be right back to you early in the new year i'm joined as always by
00:00:40 my colleagues and good friends western standard opinion editor nigel henniford it's good to be
00:00:45 here and western standard senior alberta colmas cory morgan happy holidays uh geez uh you know
00:00:53 know we do three topics we're just doing two today because there's just uh has there been
00:00:58 anything in the news can't think of a darn thing you have to turn it on wait a minute didn't miss
00:01:05 did trudeau resign no no must be thinking trudeau's government's in complete meltdown crisis and
00:01:11 trump is talking about annex in canada maybe we should talk about those things
00:01:16 well if we ran out of things rachel gilmore got fired again too oh you know what at least someone 1.00
00:01:20 did lose a job okay well uh that's what we'll be talking about um donald trump
00:01:29 beginning as just i could begin over dinner at mar-a-lago with justin trudeau
00:01:33 ribbing him about uh kind of becoming the 51st state and he can be his governor
00:01:39 that is seemingly escalated is this a thing is this actually a thing or is this trump's just 0.93
00:01:45 bullshitting. He's a bullshitter. And he likes to troll. But I'm starting to wonder now. 1.00
00:01:53 I got an eyebrow up. So we're going to talk about is, is Donald Trump just joking about
00:02:00 Canada joining the United States? Can't believe I'm even saying it. We're going to talk about
00:02:06 it like it's even a half serious idea. But before that, we're going to talk about Justin
00:02:12 Trudeau on death watch. His prime ministership has entered its final terminal phase. He is sitting
00:02:21 in hospice at this point. The government is circling the drain. I don't know how many more
00:02:27 metaphors I could fit into this, but each of them is a pleasant thought at this time. It began
00:02:33 early Monday morning. Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, his right-hand
00:02:41 woman abruptly and shockingly tendered her resignation. You all know, everyone already
00:02:49 knows the story by now, so just leave it at some absolutely gargantuan political miscalculations
00:02:56 and arrogance from Justin Trudeau has led to this point. And, you know, at this point,
00:03:04 you're wondering if he can last longer than a head of lettuce.
00:03:11 Is that what that lettuce is doing in our canteen? It is. Okay. It is. I haven't decided if we do
00:03:16 a live stream with it yet, but we have a fresh head of lettuce in there with, you know, some
00:03:20 tomato eyes and a pepper mouth. That is what it is doing there, staring at you. I'll start with you,
00:03:28 Nigel. Trudeau has had some disasters before. He has had career ending scandals that would end
00:03:37 anyone's career. Blackface, SNC-Lavalin, and Jody Wilson-Raybould, Aga Khan.
00:03:52 The list is so long, and he always survives.
00:03:58 Possibly because he just holds on long enough until Canadians see a squirrel and focus on something else.
00:04:06 And we don't forget about it, but enough Canadians seem to forget about it.
00:04:11 And he just goes on.
00:04:13 Is he going to survive?
00:04:15 And I'm not talking about the general election.
00:04:16 We already know he's done.
00:04:18 The ballots have effectively already been counted.
00:04:21 He is done.
00:04:22 He is going to be out of power, and he's going to be out of power in a spectacular way, at a minimum, by the next election.
00:04:27 can he survive does justin trudeau make it to the election depends really when the election
00:04:36 comes and if you were to let's just sort of back up to october they just lost a safe seat in
00:04:43 montreal just lost another one in bc on monday same day as all this was happening so you have
00:04:50 us a parliamentary session book ended as somebody said uh by election losses now in the first one
00:04:59 there were people in the party starting to question his leadership and uh
00:05:06 i think they may have been able to get 20 or 30 mps liberal mps to say mr trudeau
00:05:15 it's time to consider your future outside the liberal party so um that number he managed to
00:05:24 just dismiss and carry on now the inside scoop is that it's more like half his caucus
00:05:31 are calling for him to resign now they have no mechanism to do it there isn't one uh no
00:05:38 the constitutionally can but it's they didn't take the reasonable route of invoking the reform act
00:05:44 They took away their easiest route, but they can constitutionally remove them.
00:05:50 It's just a lot more bloody.
00:05:52 I'm not sure any of them realize that that piece of British tradition is still available to them.
00:05:58 Certainly the charter route, which the Conservatives adopted, the NDP adopted,
00:06:03 which allows the caucus to get together and say we've had enough of these guys or this guy,
00:06:09 that's not available.
00:06:11 So, the question comes, can he stand being faced in some sort of quarantine
00:06:19 where nobody answers his phone calls, nobody speaks to him, nobody smiles at him,
00:06:26 nobody claps when he gets up to answer questions and ribbing from Pierre Poulyev,
00:06:33 basically being sent to Coventry, as we used to say.
00:06:36 And at any rate, that is the most uncomfortable situation to be in.
00:06:43 No government business gets done, not that there's much getting done anyway.
00:06:47 And it just becomes a matter of waiting for Mr. Singh to say,
00:06:52 all right, I've had enough of being teased about keeping this guy in power.
00:06:57 When the budget comes up, I'm going to vote no, and then it'll all be over.
00:07:02 So I think that unless Mr. Singh has got a different agenda, and a highly cynical one, this can't go on past the next budget.
00:07:14 But it could go on that long, especially if he were to prorogue, in which case he wouldn't have to show up and he wouldn't have to look at these people or listen to them.
00:07:22 So, Corey, so Jagmeet Singh has finally, he ripped up the agreement, remember, he ripped it up, he said, in the fall when he realized that being tethered to this corpse was very, perhaps bad for his political prospects.
00:07:38 He ripped it up, but then continued to vote along, vote confidence in the Trudeau government.
00:07:43 And the day of Christian Freeland's resignation, he comes out and says, now I'm serious.
00:07:51 Justin Trudeau should resign.
00:07:54 He seemingly did not predict what the very first question and every single subsequent question to that would be, which is, well, are you going to vote non-confidence in him now?
00:08:02 And it was like watching a Vietnamese torture chamber.
00:08:08 They're pulling his nails back, and he still won't say, I'll vote non-confidence in him.
00:08:11 They sent one of his, I think their house, the NDP house leader, Peter Julian, who, after much fingernail prying, said, well, you know, if Trudeau is still prime minister and hasn't resigned, and we're still in this bad situation by, I don't know, February or March, then all options are on the table.
00:08:36 Well, what happens in February or March?
00:08:39 There seems to be some sort of pension change, if I recall.
00:08:42 What is it that happens in February and March?
00:08:45 February the 25th, I think, isn't it?
00:08:46 Yeah.
00:08:47 Right between February and March, Jagmeet Singh's pension vests,
00:08:51 and he becomes eligible for that lifetime pot of money.
00:08:55 I mean, he is pretty much admitting it at this point.
00:08:58 He is not going to bring down the Trudeau government until he gets his pension.
00:09:03 I actually think we should just change the pension rules.
00:09:05 You get a pension no matter how long you serve,
00:09:07 because you just get it gets bigger the longer you serve just make everyone instantly vest
00:09:11 because i mean this kind of stuff has played a role in the past but it hasn't been so naked and
00:09:17 now just now jake meeting is admitting it so i don't i don't think jake meeting is actually
00:09:23 going to bring down this government until his pension vests uh but it seems to me um
00:09:29 regardless of what happens resign or stay uh corey his best prospect is probably to just
00:09:35 prorogues at this point prorogues for those of you who don't speak parliamentaries at home
00:09:41 is just essentially it suspends parliament everything ends committees and they can't
00:09:46 investigate anything it's just a hard reboot it's a hard and all bills restart so if you prorogues
00:09:53 that means parliament's actually not going to be coming back at any time it's just it's a play
00:09:57 it's a play for time um if he's going to resign and have a leadership race um to replace him
00:10:03 he's got a prorogue or if he doesn't want to get defeated immediately he's got a prorogue what's
00:10:11 true to do here I don't know anymore I don't I mean he I question his sanity to a degree I really
00:10:19 do I think the pressure's gotten to me he's not thinking rationally he's not acting rationally
00:10:23 I really thought when all the year-end interviews were canceled okay here we go because if you were
00:10:28 trying to hold on for your political life well here's your opportunity to give your heartfelt
00:10:32 plea to everybody on why you're going to be better. And you got rid of those. But then I watched him
00:10:36 at the Christmas party for caucus. And he was just all smiles and pretending nothing happened.
00:10:43 I, if he leaves, it's not going to be on his own accord. He has to be kicked out. His caucus has
00:10:49 to do something as bloody as it may be. And I think they're finally starting to realize it.
00:10:53 Like with Freeland, this was his most loyal supporter. He had not only tried to humiliate
00:11:00 her with a ridiculous firing and then expecting her to still present his, as you've said, a steaming 0.91
00:11:07 pile of a budget before leaving. So make you wear all that crap that you took on on my behalf. 1.00
00:11:12 And then I'm going to still have you fired. It also signals to every caucus member and every 0.99
00:11:17 cabinet member, he thinks nothing of you. He doesn't care about your loyalty. He will not
00:11:21 reward you. He doesn't appreciate your loyalty. If he will do that to her, he will do that to any
00:11:26 of you. He is not a man worth following. He is not a man who values your effort, your time,
00:11:32 your sacrifice. They've got to be having those discussions now and saying, this is it. This
00:11:36 has got to stop. Well, I think they've been having those discussions for a long time,
00:11:39 Corey. Oh, certainly. But this displayed it in full length. I mean, he didn't even meet her face
00:11:45 to face. He did it over Zoom. They were in the same city. Like that's cowardice and disrespect
00:11:49 of a level that is beyond I even thought he was capable of. I mean, you'd think he sent a text
00:11:54 Yeah. No, but I mean, what would be the mechanism by which they would, short of 150 MPs walking into his office and saying, you've got to go?
00:12:06 Yeah, because they didn't sign on to the Reform Act. So the easy route is not immediately available.
00:12:11 But I mean, they can, as you kind of said earlier, he can be neutered.
00:12:15 You know, you can, you can.
00:12:18 There is a way. And so the media has been totally missing this.
00:12:21 Now, there's generally two ways the leader of a party is removed, federally and to an extent provincially.
00:12:29 One is the way, say, Jason Kenney was removed, a vote by the members.
00:12:32 But that's often not available.
00:12:35 The Liberal Party's constitution, the members don't even get to vote on removing the leader of the party if the leader of the party is the head of the government.
00:12:43 They only get to vote if they're in opposition.
00:12:48 That's not a very good idea.
00:12:49 There needs to be a peaceful and relatively bloodless way to remove a party leader by the grassroots.
00:12:54 And it also needs to be a way to remove a leader at the caucus level, which is the root of responsible government in the Westminster parliamentary system.
00:13:04 The leader of a government or the leader of the government has to have the confidence of the House and of the governing caucus.
00:13:12 Opposition caucuses can do this, too.
00:13:14 So we talked about the Reform Act piece of legislation that merely codified powers that MPs have always had as long as there's been a House of Commons in old England.
00:13:25 And but they still have the power to do this.
00:13:29 And the media, I think, has been completely missing the point on this.
00:13:32 It's more complicated. It's a lot more bloody because the liberals were too cowardly to vote to give themselves this power after the last election. 0.74
00:13:40 Every caucus votes on it after the election. They were too cowardly to do it. 0.99
00:13:43 They're on Team Trudeau, not Team Canada or Team Liberal. 0.81
00:13:48 But there is a way to do it, and that would be to get a letter or, for lack of a better term, a petition signed by a majority of the governing Liberal caucus.
00:14:00 And it would have to state in that letter that they've lost confidence in the prime minister.
00:14:05 And here is a nominated successor.
00:14:08 That could be an interim person, and then they could hold a leadership race.
00:14:11 But here is a nominated successor. Here is, I don't know, Stephen Gilbeau. Stephen Gilbeau will be an interim prime minister, and he has the support of a majority of the caucus.
00:14:22 If they take that to the Governor-General, the Governor-General would at least have to give it serious weight to appoint that new Prime Minister, removing Justin Trudeau, or else go to Justin Trudeau and say, you need to immediately test the confidence of the House of Commons or dissolve Parliament.
00:14:43 Those are your options.
00:14:45 That is the way the Liberals could do it.
00:14:46 Justin Trudeau's way around it would be able to say, as soon as I smell anyone signing that letter, I'm calling an election.
00:14:53 And he retains that right.
00:14:56 Either way, there's no good options for any Liberals, Trudeau, Freeland, backbenchers.
00:15:00 They're all screwed no matter what they do because they waited too long.
00:15:03 But it is not true that the Liberal caucus has no way to remove him. 0.96
00:15:06 That is the way to do it.
00:15:08 Just Justin Trudeau retains the right to press the big red button and nuke them all.
00:15:12 Yeah. Well, I mean, if I were in his shoes, you know, assuming even that vanity and self-interest and whatnot, the closest I could see him coming out of this with a shred of dignity and pride would be maybe to negotiate with them and say, fine, I'm going to do it.
00:15:25 But I want to stay on until the new leader. Then you get to point your buddies, do your things, you know, have your patronage and step out.
00:15:32 But again, I don't think he's rational anymore. I don't think he sees that out as a reason.
00:15:38 Well, to the point about pride, this is really, you're zeroing in on the heart of the problem.
00:15:44 Mr. Trudeau does not see himself as a liberal.
00:15:47 As far as he's concerned, this is a Trudeau government.
00:15:50 It is not a liberal government.
00:15:53 He is not invested in the history and the future of a party.
00:15:57 So, in actual fact, he could be evicted from office and walk out of there still with his head high,
00:16:04 thinking, they weren't worthy of me.
00:16:06 I can believe that.
00:16:08 Because he has such an incredible sense.
00:16:10 Like, we don't agree with his mission, which is all about changing the nature of Canada and climate change
00:16:15 and a number of things that go into at another time.
00:16:19 But that's where his head is at.
00:16:20 He thinks he's the hero here. 0.69
00:16:23 And finally, the people have just shown their cowardice.
00:16:30 Didn't know what they're good for them.
00:16:31 And, you know, if he leaves, he leaves a destruction.
00:16:36 You know, but that's I think that's the nature of the man.
00:16:43 Yeah, it's as good as an explanation as I can see.
00:16:45 Like I said, that's been the hard part I've been having with this this last couple of days is I keep trying to apply reason where reason isn't existing.
00:16:54 And so I'm never going to find a satisfactory conclusion.
00:16:58 I'm never going to be able to predict what this guy is going to do because I can't put myself into that mind.
00:17:04 I can put myself into the mind of a leftist and so on, assuming that they're still rational.
00:17:08 But he just doesn't seem to be behaving.
00:17:10 Well, just a moment ago, you actually stole my parting shot when you made the remark about how he dismissed Christia Freeland.
00:17:21 That's all right. I'll think of another one.
00:17:24 But, I mean, the fact of the matter is that that tells you that he lacks basic judgment.
00:17:29 because you just don't give somebody a job to do on monday and say by the way once you're done
00:17:36 you're fired what did he think you know i think was um robin urbach had the best analogy that
00:17:44 uh you know it's like when you break up with someone let's say can you please still come to
00:17:48 christmas dinner and act normal in front of the family yeah then you know then we'll part ways but
00:17:52 you got to come and act normal in front of the family in the meantime and she wasn't willing to
00:17:56 eat that turd sandwich uh i'll just come back this thing just just a little bit i think at this point
00:18:02 singh has removed himself from the calculation i there is a very very good chance singh will never
00:18:09 actually have voted non-confidence in justin trudeau once for this iteration of this entire
00:18:14 parliament because i think there's a good chance trudeau is just going to prorogue he has to prorogue
00:18:22 But then again, we come against the budget.
00:18:24 We might thankfully get an election before October next year, the scheduled election date, if this was a majority government.
00:18:32 Well, the first thing after prorogation is a speech from the throne, which is a confidence.
00:18:37 Yeah, but you can prorogue for a long time.
00:18:38 Yeah, you can keep it up for quite a long time.
00:18:42 You'd see marching on the hill, I think, finally, if he tried to drag it beyond spring.
00:18:47 Yeah, but at that point, no one could vote non-confidence.
00:18:50 His own caucus can't really vote non-confidence. Singh can't vote non-confidence. And I don't think Singh will. And actually, I think this is what Singh wants. Singh doesn't want to have to stand up again when the House would come back in late January and continue to vote confidence in Trudeau even now when his own caucus has lost confidence in him effectively.
00:19:11 He doesn't want to have to do that.
00:19:13 Trudeau will be doing Singh a favor for his pension if he prorogues,
00:19:17 because then Singh doesn't have to stand up every day and say,
00:19:20 Trudeau should resign, but I'm going to vote to keep him in office.
00:19:23 Well, it goes beyond a pension, I think, too.
00:19:25 I mean, I know that bugs Singh the most when people point it out,
00:19:27 but he also drives a Maserati and wears a watch that's worth a year's salary for most of us.
00:19:31 Yeah, but it's a nice chunk of cash for the rest of his life.
00:19:34 It certainly is.
00:19:35 But I mean, it also is his party's broke, and they're low in the polls.
00:19:39 I mean, if he was, you know, if their party had a couple million in the bank and they were sitting up looking like they're going to win a bunch of seats, he'd be willing to go.
00:19:47 Because even then, then you're thinking you're going to renew his own seat.
00:19:50 Exactly. So there's more to it than just the pension.
00:19:53 They're facing just as much obliteration as the liberals if they go to the polls.
00:19:57 How do you run a campaign on 200,000 bucks?
00:19:59 It's not going to go well for him.
00:20:02 Well, you have to do what the liberal government would do is borrow money.
00:20:05 Yeah, they just paid off their debt for the last election.
00:20:07 Well, let's turn to some of the fallout from this whole Shaisa show.
00:20:14 Some of it's actually been pretty good.
00:20:17 So just yesterday, word came in that the Liberals, out of nowhere it seems, gave up on their emissions cap.
00:20:26 The emissions cap in the electricity grid, you know, I think they were, you know, they've been trying to get all the,
00:20:32 heard the cats of the premiers together for a team candidate approach.
00:20:36 And then you've got Daniel Smith and Scott Moe sitting at the table.
00:20:40 The first word's out of their mouth is, F you. 0.98
00:20:42 You're screwing us worse than Donald Trump ever could. 0.98
00:20:45 We're not on your team. 0.79
00:20:46 We're not going to pull your chestnuts out of the fire.
00:20:49 Put some cash on the table.
00:20:51 We need some table stakes here. 1.00
00:20:52 We need to see you're serious before we're going to get on board.
00:20:55 And I liken this to, I think, I don't know who I was talking with yesterday on the news
00:21:00 about it, but this is a hostage negotiation.
00:21:03 So when someone's got a bunch of hostages, the hostage negotiator from the FBI comes out and says, OK, well, before we negotiate, you've got to release one hostage.
00:21:12 Just go, you're serious, go a little goodwill.
00:21:15 Now, liberals still have a ton of hostages on Alberta, a ton of Alberta hostages.
00:21:20 But they released the hostage yesterday in lifting the emissions cap.
00:21:24 I think that comes from a combination of the crisis facing the government from the pending Trump tariffs and the meltdown of this government that they need to buy some breathing room from two premiers who are ready to cut this government's throat.
00:21:38 At the same time, I think there could be political follow-up in this, because I know one guy who's probably not very happy, and that's Stephen Gilbeau, who is, I mean, he's loony.
00:21:49 He's totally loony tunes, but to his credit, in a weird way, he is a principled politician in that he actually believes what he's doing.
00:21:56 He's not just there for a pension.
00:21:58 That guy, I trust him.
00:22:01 I believe him when he says he thinks the world ends if he doesn't tax my drive to work in the morning.
00:22:07 I think he generally believes that.
00:22:09 His emissions cap was dearly important to him.
00:22:13 This is a pretty big climb down for the government, Corey.
00:22:17 Oh, yeah, the green Jesus is going to be very upset.
00:22:19 I mean, as you said, he's a true believer.
00:22:21 He's an ideologue.
00:22:23 The pragmatism on the part of the government, yeah, they're scrambling.
00:22:25 They've got fires in every direction.
00:22:28 If they can at least just pacify a couple of premiers, it's a couple less things on their plate while they try to figure out what the heck they're doing on anything else.
00:22:34 but then infuriating a loyalist like Gilboa could also backfire on them.
00:22:38 You know, this is an ideologue.
00:22:39 He doesn't care about the pension.
00:22:41 He doesn't care about staying in longer.
00:22:42 And that's all Trudeau needs is Gilboa now turning on him,
00:22:45 which potentially could happen.
00:22:47 What do you make of the fact that it was Wilkinson,
00:22:49 the Intercam minister, who actually came out and made the announcement?
00:22:52 Well, it's because, of course, there's no way Gilboa was going to do it.
00:22:56 So I guess the question is, does Gilboa go next?
00:22:58 So as soon as I heard this, my first thought was, ooh, Gilboa could go.
00:23:03 But I haven't heard it, but in our newsroom, I was told that Gilbo has been on the radio saying, oh, well, you know, I guess.
00:23:14 But is his pension best?
00:23:16 I think he's a good question.
00:23:17 He's been in a while.
00:23:19 No, but he wasn't from, he didn't come in for his original majority.
00:23:22 He was recruited later on.
00:23:24 I'm not sure.
00:23:26 Now, he has a better chance of keeping his seat than even J.B.
00:23:28 He's an island of Montreal liberal.
00:23:30 If you're one of the ten.
00:23:31 That is, if the Liberals have 10 seats left in Canada, seven of them will be on the island.
00:23:37 Now, his seat is probably still, like, he's supposed to be in a seat that is just not even in contention.
00:23:43 It will be in contention.
00:23:44 He could lose his seat.
00:23:45 The Liberals are looking at a 1993 Kim Campbell-style apocalypse.
00:23:51 But there'll be a few.
00:23:52 He might be.
00:23:53 But also, who wants to serve at that point?
00:23:55 I remember after the 2015 election in Alberta, the poor PC sitting in the corner reduced to a small third place. 0.61
00:24:03 God, they looked miserable.
00:24:04 Now, there was still a path, though, because eventually we united those parties with Wildrose and came back. 0.93
00:24:09 But, man, they were an unhappy bunch.
00:24:11 No one wants to serve in that.
00:24:13 You know, Elsie Wayne and Jean Charest in 1993 was a bad existence.
00:24:18 But anyway, that's ways around.
00:24:20 And Nigel, I know you have no great insight into the warped mind of Stephen Gilbeau.
00:24:29 But do you think there's now a risk that Gilbeau or others could jet?
00:24:32 Nigel, I have an insight into his warped mind.
00:24:35 We are yin and yang, the reverse and the obverse.
00:24:40 We're just as deeply principled as each other, just believing completely different things.
00:24:45 I think that Mr. Gilbill will accommodate himself to the situation for as long as it makes sense in his mind to do so.
00:24:57 But ultimately, he has seen the writing on the wall.
00:25:02 This government is turning its back on what he is for.
00:25:05 for carbon capture, there's, excuse me, you know, clean fuels, a cap on emissions in the
00:25:16 national grid, everybody driving electric cars, that's not going to happen. So I think
00:25:22 he's probably just, well, I'll make my exit when it's a good time and not at a time when
00:25:29 I cut my own throat doing it. So he can't be happy. I'm actually surprised that we haven't
00:25:34 heard something from his office already, but maybe he's just a more thoughtful guy than I gave him
00:25:39 credit for. Politics is not quiet in Ottawa right now. Parliament may be finally done for the year,
00:25:47 rest in peace, but I don't think the politics are done. Some of us have a little Christmas
00:25:54 vacation here i fear we may be back in at some point over the break one a one thing about which
00:26:05 may cause mr gilbo to stay his hand it concerns me that in celebrating the fact that oh we don't
00:26:12 have to meet zero emissions by 2035 we still accept the fact that we're going to apparently
00:26:20 meet them in 2050, so his idea remains intact. It is the details that have changed a little bit.
00:26:28 Well, let's keep in mind, all of these things the liberals are announcing, none of them matter.
00:26:32 None of them matter. I mean, it's like me declaring myself a prophet for a religion I
00:26:37 know nothing about or something. These guys can announce anything they want. They announced
00:26:41 another big gun ban the other week. You know what gun owners did? They drove their shoulders. 0.99
00:26:45 The government's not just lame anymore. The legs have been cut right off.
00:26:49 I mean, it's not going anywhere.
00:26:52 Yeah. As I put in my column today, related to our next discussion,
00:26:59 Trump isn't even sworn in as president yet, but he's calling all the shots.
00:27:04 And Trudeau isn't even an ex-prime minister yet.
00:27:06 And he's already not calling any of the shots.
00:27:09 He has no power. He is done.
00:27:11 We essentially don't have a government, which in a sense is kind of a good thing.
00:27:14 nobody moves nobody gets hurt well that's I think that's a good segue to our
00:27:19 next topic I don't know how to treat this topic but I think we got to talk
00:27:28 about it this began with you know Donald Trump's tweets that he's gonna slap a
00:27:35 big 25% tariff on Canadian and Mexican goods unless some things got fixed with
00:27:41 the borders and illegals and drugs and things not mentioning some of the other
00:27:44 big issues. He's got like defense. Defense is a huge one that could very reasonably see a tariff
00:27:51 slapped against us. And we really wouldn't even have anything legitimate to say in response. We'd
00:27:55 be like, yeah, kind of our free riding. So we would have no defense, no pun intended, but we
00:28:00 have no defense against his arguments against our defense spending. Began with that. Trudeau flies
00:28:06 down to Mar-a-Lago. They have dinner. It's apparently nice. But Trump kind of teases Trudeau
00:28:12 saying, hey, if you can't take the tariff, maybe you should
00:28:14 just become the 51st state, and
00:28:16 hey, you can be its governor. That was a joke.
00:28:19 Someone from the
00:28:20 liberal or the Trump side leaked that out.
00:28:22 I'm starting to think it was the Trump side.
00:28:24 First, I thought it was maybe the Trudeau side, trying
00:28:26 to rile up anti-Trump stuff.
00:28:28 I'm starting to think it was, now I'm starting to think it was
00:28:30 the Trump side, because
00:28:32 soon after that,
00:28:34 after that became news
00:28:36 that you saw Trump
00:28:37 tweeting, making fun,
00:28:40 trolling, teasing, and
00:28:42 in particular, denigrating and disrespecting Justin Trudeau.
00:28:46 You know, he posted a picture of himself of himself standing beside a Canadian flag
00:28:51 looking like a conqueror overlooking the Matterhorn.
00:28:54 Now, that's not the famous mountain in Switzerland.
00:28:56 I think it was meant to be the Rocky Mountains.
00:28:58 The Assiniboine, similar looking.
00:29:00 Yeah, but I think that was the Matterhorn.
00:29:04 It was. Yeah.
00:29:05 But I think, you know, looking out over what I think they thought was the
00:29:08 A.I. thought was the Rockies. And then other tweets calling him Governor Trudeau and you talk about the 51st state.
00:29:19 And this has gone on. Eric Trump joining in. Hashtag Canada 51st state.
00:29:25 And, you know, at first, I think, was just kind of a mega trolling, posting kind of thing.
00:29:31 having fun rah-rah america let's it's that's continuing on and it even continued on i think
00:29:39 it was like maybe i'm mistaken i think it was like 3 a.m last night trump goes on truth social
00:29:43 and that auto post to twitter x um but you know the he chimed in on the christian freeland thing
00:29:50 uh saying you know good riddance she won't be missed uh fired by governor trudeau
00:29:55 um again talking about 51st and then last night tweeting again uh there's many canadians who want
00:30:01 to join i think he's talked to many canadians i don't think this is very top of mind canadians
00:30:05 clamoring to join the united states but uh you know they're unhappy canadians will pay less taxes
00:30:11 and have better defense we'll have first and second amendment rights that's what we want
00:30:15 yeah yeah i mean uh those those would be pretty nice like a 25th amendment yeah so anyway there's
00:30:21 There's like five or six statements now from Trump talking about Governor Trudeau and 51st state stuff.
00:30:30 And look, the Trump haters, people with Trump derangement syndrome, the problem is they take everything he says literally.
00:30:37 If he says something that's not true, they think it's a lie. 0.99
00:30:40 They say something that is true, it's a threat, when in fact this man is just, he's a bullshitter. 0.97
00:30:44 And he's ribbing, he's trolling. 0.98
00:30:47 But sometimes he does troll, or the analogy I was using, he's a bullshitter. 0.99
00:30:52 Sometimes he throws bullshit against the wall to see what sticks. 0.99
00:30:55 That's probable. 1.00
00:30:57 And yesterday, I was 100% sure this is just Trump bullshitter. 0.89
00:31:01 He's trolling. 0.71
00:31:03 Now I'm only 99% sure.
00:31:06 Start with you, Nigel.
00:31:07 is there and do you think there is anything at all to this beyond purely just weakening
00:31:17 trudeau's hand because he knows trudeau's weak oh derek i actually don't think there is anything 0.61
00:31:22 to it i do think that uh trump is uh you call him a bullshitter a lot of people call him a bully
00:31:29 I think he has detected weakness in Justin Trudeau, and heaven knows, we saw it first.
00:31:37 So he is doing some psychological warfare here to, as you put it, weaken him prior to the negotiations.
00:31:46 And he's having fun doing it.
00:31:48 now the only thing about that which could backfire and may in fact have sad consequences
00:31:56 here in sanada canada is much as i have enjoyed the persiflage and the teasing because i don't
00:32:05 care for mr trudeau very much and i do kind of like trump so i'm happy to see that there comes
00:32:11 a point at which even somebody like me is going to say okay fine got the joke that's enough
00:32:18 We are a country. We're a serious entity, and you don't get to have my sympathy in making those kinds of jokes anymore.
00:32:27 It was great for the first week.
00:32:29 And what the sad consequence that I'm referring to is that if it gives Mr. Trudeau a chance to step forward as a champion of national Canadianism, Canadian nationalism, he actually has something good to go to the public with in an election.
00:32:56 I am your protector against Mr. Trump.
00:33:00 I'm not saying it'll work, but it's something that he could use.
00:33:03 So I think Mr. Trump would do us all a favor if he changed the channel.
00:33:08 I get what Nigel's saying, Corey.
00:33:10 But first of all, I don't think Canada is a serious national entity at this point.
00:33:15 Canada is an international laughingstock among friends and foes.
00:33:19 um i i get you know that he's wanted to play the anti-trump card that's what they were planning
00:33:27 on but now they're so weak i don't think the liberals can because if they do trump he might
00:33:32 be a bullshitter but he but you can also sometimes tell when he's serious and and he can't bite back
00:33:38 that hard i i'm inclined to generally think this is uh this is a joke that maybe he's pushing a
00:33:44 little far but as he's pushed far now we're over a week of the actually the original joke was like
00:33:49 December 2nd or 3rd when this first started. And this has gone on and on and on. And I'm going to
00:33:56 be like, okay, is he taking a joke too far now? Or is he planting a flag here? So I'm going to
00:34:05 pretend to take this seriously for a moment. I take it 1% seriously now. I took it 0% seriously
00:34:10 a day ago. But I take 1% seriously right now. Trump is in his last term. So any electoral
00:34:18 follow-up that would come from hypothetically a super mega country of also let's say like in this
00:34:24 crazy world canada would not be a state it would be five six or ten states or something there's
00:34:30 just no way it would come in as one but either way it would it would alter the electoral math
00:34:34 that for a few cycles would probably advantage the democrats but trump is done his legacy doesn't need
00:34:40 to be another republican elected this gets your face on mount rushmore the uh the louisiana
00:34:46 purchase was previously the largest increase in American territory, doubling its size.
00:34:51 And Canada is how many dozens of times bigger than the Louisiana Purchase?
00:34:57 It would, you know, so in my column today, you know, I talk about him as a bullshitter. And,
00:35:02 you know, he's gone around saying, I'm the greatest president, better than Lincoln,
00:35:07 better than Washington. I don't think actually means that that's just him being him. But if he
00:35:13 did hypothetically pull off something this crazy that's Mount Rushmore worthy that gets you in the
00:35:20 pantheon of the greats yeah I just I mean maybe in his kind of weird mind he could see that as a
00:35:26 coup but that's what I'm asking for not the feasibility of this but do you think there
00:35:32 is anything in Trump's head that's actually seriously contemplating this at all maybe
00:35:36 daydreaming in the bathtub but he's still enough of a realist to know that he's got enough irons
00:35:40 in the fire before doing that, that, you know, he would actually move on. And I think some of it is
00:35:46 a bit strategic. It's really destabilizing an already unstable country when you're looking
00:35:50 for a whole new negotiation on a new deal. But there's consequences that are going to start
00:35:55 coming. And it's as Nigel said, eventually, people find it's one thing to disrespect Trudeau.
00:36:00 But now we're getting nation to nation, you're starting to disrespect Canada. And that can sour
00:36:05 a relationship that's been a good, peaceful, prosperous one for both of us for a long,
00:36:10 long time. Another part of his tweet that not enough people mentioned, and he's been said a
00:36:13 few times too, is we're subsidizing Canada a hundred billion a year, which is a load of crap. 0.99
00:36:18 It is. But I've been attacked on X, so that's nothing new for me, but by American followers 1.00
00:36:24 and such, oh, you parasites, we're sick assuring you Canadian does. You got to remember some of 1.00
00:36:28 Trump's followers and they're taking this on thinking, you mean I'm paying tax dollars to
00:36:32 those Canadians? They take his crap seriously. They are subsidizing us with our defense. 1.00
00:36:38 But that's not what he's talking about. He's not even talking about that.
00:36:41 He's taking what we're talking about as a trade deficit, and he's expanding even beyond that and bloating it.
00:36:47 I'm just saying these, what it was lighthearted teasing, as some are dismissing it as, are starting to cause actual rooted divisions.
00:36:55 And that can be problematic even once Trudeau is gone, and it's not good for relations between our countries.
00:37:02 And I worry about that. That's a consequence that I don't think maybe even he's thinking about that might come from this.
00:37:08 But, you know, the Trump following, the MAGA bunch, they take his stuff as gospel. 0.98
00:37:13 And if they think that those darn dirty Canadians are going to, you know, blow up the Baldwin's house and they are actually, you know, taking money out of the pockets of American taxpayers, it hurts us. 0.98
00:37:26 So, again, just amuse me with this wild hypothetical that this, say Trump was serious. 0.99
00:37:35 the Republicans would be
00:37:38 electorally disadvantaged by it for a few cycles
00:37:40 until things reorient and then
00:37:42 probably come back to the 50-50 split that America
00:37:44 is in
00:37:45 but Republicans would
00:37:47 back it because it's manifest destiny
00:37:50 it's making America super great
00:37:52 again, greater than it's ever been
00:37:53 and Democrats would support it because
00:37:56 they'd bring in a bunch of voters
00:37:58 that are to the left of the current
00:38:00 American center, so that'd be good for them 0.99
00:38:02 so America would go for it
00:38:04 And I just don't think Americans really thought about it very much until the last week or so.
00:38:10 Let's talk about on the Canadian side.
00:38:13 Poll show there's like 10 or 15% of Canadians that favor it.
00:38:16 That's higher than I would expect.
00:38:19 It's higher than real.
00:38:20 Last year I went on a speaking tour.
00:38:22 I hit a couple of dozen pounds of filling books and speaking to independence-minded crowds.
00:38:27 These are people as this is the most curated group of non-confederation type people you're going to find.
00:38:34 And one of the things one of the other speakers would do at every one of those meetings is actually pull the room by hands.
00:38:38 You know, which would you what would you like to see if you left Canada?
00:38:41 An independent Alberta, West with five provinces or four provinces or joining the USA.
00:38:48 You're lucky to get one percent wanted to join the United States.
00:38:51 So even in that room, I mean, I know people being reactionary right now and we're seeing some of those larger numbers.
00:38:56 Yeah, there's not a realistic. But I'll keep in mind, this is not just the West or Alberta here.
00:39:00 This is Ontario. Oh, yeah, it would even get weaker. No, no. But now the numbers do include up there.
00:39:05 Either way, it's very small. It's higher than I would expect. Yeah, but it's small.
00:39:10 Trump's saying great numbers. That's just it's not the case.
00:39:14 But could he force it if he wanted to? And I do think he could.
00:39:19 If he decided he wanted to do this and he got the probably get both parties to the states to get on.
00:39:25 The only things that stop any U.S. president could force union between these countries if they wanted to without military force.
00:39:34 It would be entirely unnecessary and unproductive to use military force.
00:39:38 They don't need to.
00:39:40 They could bring in massive tariffs and other measures.
00:39:44 They could bring us down to a Great Depression-level economic apocalypse.
00:39:49 They could do it tomorrow if they really wanted to.
00:39:51 The only things that stop them is it'll hurt them too, but it'll hurt them a hell of a lot less than us.
00:39:56 But it'll hurt them.
00:39:58 And diplomatic niceties.
00:40:02 Diplomatic niceties is not a term I really associate with Donald Trump.
00:40:07 If he wanted to do this, and even if Canadians wanted no part of it,
00:40:12 how long would the Canadian public be willing to endure a Great Depression?
00:40:18 the bankruptcy of the federal government
00:40:21 and then the end of the welfare state that comes from that.
00:40:24 They're saying, well, we want our universal health care.
00:40:26 You don't get universal health care if the federal government goes bankrupt.
00:40:29 You don't get any of that stuff.
00:40:31 The American welfare state all of a sudden looks a lot more generous than the Canadian one.
00:40:34 If a U.S. president was truly determined to,
00:40:37 they could do this without firing a bullet.
00:40:41 Nigel, do you think a determined U.S. president could force this if they truly wanted to?
00:40:49 40 million illegal aliens to go with the 20 they've already got they're trying to get rid of 0.99
00:40:53 well i don't think we'd be considered aliens but i we might consider ourselves ourselves
00:41:00 illegal aliens you know derek i mean it's a fun it's a fun idea to play with uh i don't buy it
00:41:08 myself i don't have the same sense of i take it one percent seriously i take it i give it a one
00:41:14 percent but i'm saying a u.s president if they're truly determined to well i i just don't see
00:41:19 anything look you've got a country of 360 million people against a country of 40 even in the end
00:41:24 they can do whatever they like of course they can but i don't think they would have the domestic 0.93
00:41:29 support for it the republicans would not be as i mean they might like to have alberta and maybe
00:41:35 be Saskatchewan. I don't think they're going to want Quebec. I don't think they're going to want
00:41:40 Quebec. Cut those guys loose. They would know that all they would be getting would be 40 million
00:41:52 people who didn't really want to participate in this. That's not what I'm asking. I'm not asking
00:41:58 that. I'm saying if they were truly determined to, could they do it? Well, I mean, of course.
00:42:03 without firing a shot. That's, well, that's, that's, that's the question. Well, how long would
00:42:09 how long would we be willing to accept bankruptcy and depression level economy
00:42:15 to withstand it? But I mean, that would be an act of economic war to have gone down the road of,
00:42:20 you know, speculation. And there are other nations on the planet stronger than Canada. I mean,
00:42:25 if he's getting that insular, you better be ready for trade sanctions to come from everybody in 1.00
00:42:29 Europe, possibly parts of Asia.
00:42:31 You think anybody's going to stick their neck out to help
00:42:33 Canada?
00:42:35 If you see expansionism on the part of the United States,
00:42:37 yeah.
00:42:39 China would come up with a loan for us.
00:42:41 They'd want a lot in return. 0.83
00:42:44 Sign your soul to the devil there.
00:42:45 And there are
00:42:47 certainly Canadian leaders who would rather
00:42:49 do that than
00:42:50 reverse the results of the war of
00:42:53 1812.
00:42:56 This is what happens though
00:42:57 when I think as the post-war liberal international order
00:43:01 collapses, and Trump is eager, I think,
00:43:03 to bring about that collapse, is that we're now back
00:43:07 to kind of old school power politics.
00:43:09 And Trump recognizes that historically,
00:43:13 the great powers have a backyard.
00:43:14 They have a sphere of influence and they get to do
00:43:16 what they want in that sphere of influence.
00:43:18 Ukraine is in Russia's sphere of influence,
00:43:23 Taiwan is in China's, and guess what? 0.98
00:43:26 We're in America.
00:43:28 They can already do whatever they like up here anyway.
00:43:31 So I felt the Alaska Highway.
00:43:33 They got the dew line.
00:43:34 They do what they need to do.
00:43:36 Okay.
00:43:36 Well, that was enough speculative craziness for today.
00:43:41 Let's see what happens.
00:43:42 Well, you know, we actually got, we have the break coming up.
00:43:44 So let's see if the Stars and Stripes are flying over Ottawa by January.
00:43:51 Okay.
00:43:52 Let's go to our parting shots.
00:43:53 Let's start with you, Nigel.
00:43:54 So now that Mr. Moran there has stolen me, it occurs to me to remark that much as we feel sorry for Christia Freeland and as much as we feel sorry for any woman who has been outrageously treated by a cad, she still was not actually the best finance minister that we have ever had.
00:44:17 And, quite frankly, her presiding over endless deficits that have taken our accumulated deficit all the way to $1.2 trillion, plus another $60 billion under her own signature here.
00:44:38 You know, maybe Trump was right.
00:44:40 Maybe she wasn't so great.
00:44:42 Good riddance.
00:44:43 She won't be missed, as he said.
00:44:44 She won't be missed.
00:44:44 Just kind of further to what Nigel was saying, I don't want to get, you know, what's lost in the mix of this insane news cycle. We have a $62 billion deficit. Our debt servicing charges are over $52 billion a year. Now that's money flushed down the toilet. I worked that out. If you take it just per taxpayer, $1,700 per person per year, just to service the debt.
00:45:12 now. If you're having trouble making ends meet, well there's a hundred and some a month per person
00:45:16 working in your household that's paying the interest. Going to nothing. No health care,
00:45:21 no daycare, none of that stuff. That. Don't lose the numbers while all this political intrigue goes
00:45:26 on. Hey, keep in mind, that's just the federal debt. Oh yeah. That's not including the provinces.
00:45:30 No, I could go a lot deeper. All right. Well, my parting shot is the measures that the Alberta
00:45:38 government is taking in response to uh to trump albert is taking a very different approach than
00:45:43 the fed well the feds have had no approach essentially they're they're caught chasing
00:45:47 their own tails with their own games then you've got ontario premier uh doug ford promising trade
00:45:52 war with america oh they're so afraid uh yeah ontario does export energy but it also imports
00:45:58 a lot of energy it's actually not a particularly large energy exporter doesn't really have much
00:46:03 to say so albert has taken a more conciliatory approach i'm not sure there is a good approach
00:46:08 But I think, at least in Alberta's case, that's probably best for Alberta, because we do export a lot, and if we can't, we're toast.
00:46:15 So Alberta has gone ahead and put forward $20-odd million into essentially setting up our own border patrol, particularly along the Montana border there.
00:46:26 I think, what is it, a 10-kilometer, is it a 5- or 10-kilometer zone?
00:46:31 Two kilometers back from the border to be in patrol, yes.
00:46:34 I mean, there's not a lot there.
00:46:35 Corey, you've worked along there.
00:46:37 I've been along there.
00:46:38 There's just some corn and dirt roads and the odd kid flying around in a Mustang.
00:46:43 Pretty bleak down there.
00:46:44 Yeah, there's not much there, but Alberta setting up its own border patrol and whatnot,
00:46:48 and that seems to have been pretty well received in the United States.
00:46:52 My only problem is that this shouldn't be the job of the Alberta sheriffs.
00:46:57 This should be the job of the Rat Patrol.
00:46:59 We've already got the Alberta Rat Patrol that patrols, already patrols the B.C., Saskatchewan,
00:47:05 and Manitoba borders looking for vermin to come in past our borders and they're very efficient at exterminating them.
00:47:11 So I just think we should have given the rapid roll some some missile drones to control the borders with.
00:47:18 I think that would have been a bit more efficient.
00:47:20 More fitting anyway.
00:47:21 See, I'm living in a fever dream today.
00:47:23 OK, gentlemen, thank you very much.
00:47:25 I thank all of you for joining us on the pipeline today.
00:47:28 Remember, if you're not a member of the Western Standard, you really should be supporting one of the only independent media left in Canada.
00:47:34 media left and candidate not taking the Justin Trudeau's federal media bailout subsidies.
00:47:40 We exist because of people like you that are willing to pay for real independent journalism.
00:47:45 Go to westerncenter.news right now, click on subscribe. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year
00:47:50 for unlimited access to get past that pesky paywall. Thank you very much for joining us.
00:47:55 Merry Christmas, and we'll see you in the new year.