Western Standard - October 31, 2023


'Trudeau's Liberals are desperate'

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Oct 30, 2023 Flames’ coach thinks NHL will follow through on mandating neck protection

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

164.95

Word count

2,495

Sentence count

182

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Learn English with Justin Trudeau. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has been in office for eight years and has failed to deliver on his promise to get rid of the carbon tax, which was supposed to be a temporary measure to help fight climate change. Instead, he has increased the price of heating oil and increased the cost of housing.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 On Thursday, the Prime Minister admitted he's not worth the cost. He found out that I was
00:00:07 holding a monster rally in a Liberal stronghold, and he panicked. His phones lit up as Atlantic
00:00:15 Canadian Liberal MPs, bawling their eyes out, pleaded with him to relent to the pressure
00:00:23 that the leader of the opposition was mounting to axe the tax. The Prime Minister said he was stiff
00:00:31 in spine and he would never back down. And the Liberal MPs from the Atlantic caucus said,
00:00:36 well, then we'll oust you as leader and you'll lose your job. How will that do for your ego?
00:00:42 The Prime Minister said, in that case, we'll pull together a press conference this afternoon.
00:00:46 We'll try to time it right before the Conservative leaders' great rally in Windsor, where 1,000
00:00:53 people were scheduled to rise up against the tax. And we'll promise to pause the tax until
00:01:02 after the election. So now Atlantic Canadians know that if they elect this Prime Minister,
00:01:10 they will get a massive tax hike on their home heating oil. And if they elect the common sense
00:01:17 Conservatives, they will have tax-free heat. Pretty simple choice. Pretty simple choice. The 0.61
00:01:26 Prime Minister has just defined the issue of the next election. Vote for him and have a massive home
00:01:33 heating tax. Vote for common sense Conservatives and we will axe the tax for everyone and forever.
00:01:40 What do you think, Mr. Speaker? Who would you vote for?
00:01:48 But he sent out one of his Newfoundland MPs to say that the reason why only some Canadians were getting
00:01:55 a pause on the carbon tax is because other Canadians didn't vote Liberal. So soon they'll have
00:02:01 a new income tax rate for provinces that don't elect Liberal MPs, a new sales tax rate, new tax rates
00:02:09 everywhere else. But the problem with this bloody-minded divide-and-conquer tax strategy is that some
00:02:17 Liberals seem to have failed to win over the Prime Minister's hearts. The Liberal MP for Sudbury
00:02:23 has not got a carbon tax exemption. The two Liberal MPs in Thunder Bay, a very cold climate,
00:02:30 they don't get a carbon tax exemption. The Liberal MP for Nickel Belt did not get a carbon tax exemption in
00:02:38 those harsh, cold Northern Ontario communities that use gas and propane. The extremely ineffective Liberal
00:02:46 MP for Edmonton Centre has not got a carbon tax exemption. The loquacious and loud and never quiet
00:02:58 member for Winnipeg over here. They call it Winterpeg, cold in Winnipeg. And yet the Liberal,
00:03:04 what is this writing again? Winnipeg North, a man of many words but few actions, has failed to get a
00:03:13 carbon tax exemption for Winnipeggers. Apparently those people are forced to pay higher prices for
00:03:19 their heat because their MPs are so ineffective that they could not mount pressure on the Prime
00:03:25 Minister to back down. Mr. Speaker, it is proof that he's not worth the cost, just like he has not been
00:03:30 worth the cost for housing. After eight years, this Prime Minister has doubled mortgage payments, doubled
00:03:36 the rent, doubled the needed down payment for a home. Let's just review the housing hell he has caused since he
00:03:42 promised to lower housing costs. Let's go through it. It now takes 25 years to save up for a down
00:03:50 payment in Toronto before this Prime Minister you could pay off a mortgage in that time. Families are
00:03:55 now stretching out their mortgage terms to 90 and 120 years because interest rates on their exorbitant
00:04:04 mortgages have stretched out the amortization. That means that not only, you know, you used to pay off
00:04:09 your entire mortgage by, you know, 25 years in and then you could retire mortgage-free. Now, not only
00:04:16 will you never be able to pay off your mortgage in your entire lifetime, even if you hand the house
00:04:20 and the mortgage to your kids, they might not be able to pay it off in their lifetime. They would
00:04:24 then have to hand the house to a third generation who would still inherit a mortgage. So much for the
00:04:30 government taking on debt so that Canadians don't have to. Under this Prime Minister, homes cost 50% more
00:04:37 than they do in the United States. And you can buy a castle in Sweden for the price of a two bedroom
00:04:43 in Kitchener. Toronto is now ranked the worst housing bubble in the world by UBS Bank. Vancouver is the
00:04:50 most unaffordable, the third most unaffordable housing market on earth when you compare housing costs to
00:04:58 income. And Toronto is the 10th. Vancouver is now more unaffordable than New York, London, England,
00:05:05 Singapore. Singapore being a tiny island with 2,000 times more people per square kilometer than
00:05:12 Canada. Canada used, Canada should be the cheapest place in the world, Mr. Speaker, because of course,
00:05:18 we have more land per person than all but four countries on the planet. In other words, we have
00:05:24 lots of space, just not a lot of homes. In fact, we have fewer homes than per capita than all other G7
00:05:34 countries, even though we have by far the most land to build on. In fact, we have fewer homes per capita
00:05:39 today than we did eight years ago when this Prime Minister took office promising more homes and more
00:05:46 affordable homes. And if you want the best all-in-one measurement of this Prime Minister's performance on
00:05:52 housing and housing, look at the OECD, which compared housing costs to income starting in 2015 to present
00:06:04 among all 37 OECD countries. So how have the pace, the ratio of home prices to family incomes grown in Canada
00:06:16 relative to the other 36 OECD countries? We are the second worst. In other words, housing costs outgrew
00:06:26 incomes in Canada at a faster pace than in all but one of the other 36 OECD countries. In other words,
00:06:36 this is a new problem that occurred after this Prime Minister took office and it is a problem that is
00:06:44 unique to Canada. He cannot blame some prior government and he cannot blame other countries
00:06:49 because he is worse than Canada has ever been and worse than almost anywhere else in the world. This
00:06:56 is a made-in-Canada problem unique to this Prime Minister. Why? Because he has spent the last eight
00:07:04 years building bureaucracy rather than building homes. He brags that he has the most expensive housing
00:07:12 programs. He complains that when I was housing minister, my programs did not cost as much. And he
00:07:19 is absolutely right about that. I had far more affordable housing programs. In fact, there were far
00:07:27 few billions in my housing programs than there are in his programs. But we don't measure the success by how
00:07:34 expensive we can be. We measure success by how affordable we can be. He even made up a fact. He looked at a
00:07:41 CBC headline, which is always a dangerous thing to do. And he said that when I was minister that we
00:07:46 we only built 99 homes with 300 million dollars. I said, what the heck is he talking about? I have a
00:07:50 mind like a steel trap I would have remembered if I'd announced a 300 million dollar housing program.
00:07:55 So I checked into it. But here's what actually happened. First of all, the program was created in 2008,
00:08:00 a half decade before I even became the minister. Second of all, it didn't spend any money. The program was
00:08:06 designed to encourage private home ownership by First Nations. It invested capital of 300 million
00:08:12 dollars and didn't spend a penny because the money was invested commercially. It actually grew to 380
00:08:18 million dollars. And it wasn't 99 homes. There were 7,000 homes built, purchased, or renovated for First
00:08:26 Nations people. So it didn't cost any money. It made a profit and it built, renovated, and bought 7,000 homes.
00:08:34 Oh, and by the way, the entire thing is run by First Nations themselves. No wonder the liberals
00:08:38 don't like any of that, Mr. Speaker. But forget the facts. If I had to deal with their body of facts
00:08:44 in litigating the housing file, boy, I don't know what I would do. You might have to hallucinate to
00:08:49 come up with some other facts too. I might even get desperate enough to read CBC headlines as well.
00:08:54 But Mr. Speaker, in the meantime, let's talk about a real common sense plan to bring homes Canadians can
00:09:03 afford. Let's talk about my bill. The Building Homes Not Bureaucracies Act. Now, principle number one,
00:09:12 it will require cities boost home completions by 15 percent per year or they'll lose federal
00:09:19 infrastructure money. We give them five billion a year in direct transfers. They can pretty much do
00:09:24 whatever they want with that money. I'm saying this is going to be a housing incentive. We're going to start
00:09:28 paying city bureaucrats the way real estate agents get paid on volume. You get housing completed,
00:09:35 you get more money. You don't get it completed, you get less money. So the bureaucrats will have
00:09:39 to wake up every morning and say, how can we approve as many permits as quickly as possible so Canadians
00:09:44 have a place to live? And it's going to be very mathematical. I require you hit 15 percent more home
00:09:51 building per year. If you beat that by say 10 percent, you get 10 percent more money. You miss
00:09:55 it by 10 percent, you get 10 percent less money. Maybe then the bureaucrats will wake up and the 0.99
00:10:00 mayors will wake up every day and say, how can we get this done quickly? Mayors would then be forced to
00:10:06 move their offices right into the permitting room, have a big open room. Imagine that with big screens
00:10:10 that say permitting times would be on one wall, number of homes waiting, how many people are on hold
00:10:15 right now? How many homes are being held? Imagine if you had big screens in the city hall and all the
00:10:21 bureaucrats were busy motoring away trying to get to yes and get things done. Wouldn't that be 0.98
00:10:28 incredible if we actually focused on results rather than building more bureaucracy, Mr. Speaker?
00:10:34 That's what my bill will incentivize. Right now, by contrast, the current housing minister has come up
00:10:40 with a program. It works very simple. He calls up the mayor. He says, everyone knows housing is hell
00:10:46 after eight years of our government. Can I come to town and take credit for homes you were already
00:10:51 going to build? And I'll write you a big check if you do it. So he shows up. The city says, yeah, yeah,
00:10:55 there was already a subdivision going in over there. Let's give the minister credit for that. And in
00:11:00 exchange, he'll stroke a big check for 40 million dollars with which we can build more bureaucracy.
00:11:04 And then the bureaucrats will be happy, the politicians will be happy, and everyone else will be miserable.
00:11:09 And so that's what he's been doing. We know that this is not leading to more housing construction
00:11:14 because housing starts this year are down 9%. So yes, he can show up and say, oh, look at these
00:11:20 24,000 homes that were already going to be built. But the overall housing starts, the number of shovels
00:11:27 put into ground, down 9%. Two years after this so-called housing accelerator was created, not a single
00:11:34 solitary new house has been completed. A $4 billion housing program that doesn't build housing. My plan
00:11:43 creates a strict mathematical formula that pays for results. Second principle, we're going to require
00:11:50 every federally funded transit station be surrounded by housing so that you can live right next to the bus
00:11:56 or train. Countless stations that I've been to right across this country don't have housing. In fact,
00:12:02 in Winnipeg, the gatekeepers there actually stepped in to block 2,000 new homes right next to a transit
00:12:09 station that was built for those homes. They had to get slapped down in the courts. And what did the
00:12:15 Liberals do? They gave more money to the incompetent politicians at Winnipeg City Hall to block housing
00:12:21 for the people who need it. Well, I'm going to put all the federal funds for transit stations
00:12:26 into a trust. And the city will not get the money for the transit station until there are apartments
00:12:32 occupied all around the station. And that way, they will have to hurry up and approve the housing if
00:12:37 they want to get the money. We will again pay for results. Next, this bill will require that the
00:12:44 Federal Minister of Public Works do a full inventory and come to this house within months to
00:12:50 announce all the buildings that will be sold in order to build housing. The Prime Minister promised
00:12:57 this eight years ago. And in eight years, with all the 37,000 federal buildings and 6.2 million square
00:13:07 meters of office space and the thousands of acres, how many homes has he managed to build on federal
00:13:13 land and in federal buildings? How many? I asked him. Don't worry. He didn't know either. 13.
00:13:20 Not 13,000. Not 1,300. 13. My bill will make it mandatory by law that the Minister come here with
00:13:26 a plan to sell off 15% of all federal buildings, thousands of acres of federal land, so that we can
00:13:33 build, build, build on that land that's being used for nothing. And federal bureaucrats, on the fourth 1.00
00:13:38 principle, are going to have to get their act together as well. I was speaking with a builder who
00:13:43 builds beautiful, environmentally friendly homes and apartments in Atlantic Canada. He's in the
00:13:49 process of building a carbon neutral home right now. It'll be the greenest apartment complex in the
00:13:56 world. He had to wait two years for CMHC to approve the financing on that home. The benchmark is supposed
00:14:03 to be 60 days. So here's how life is going to work around here when I'm Prime Minister and in this bill.
00:14:07 The CMHC bureaucrats will have to hit the 60-day target within six months. If they don't, I'm cutting
00:14:13 their pay in half. And if they don't do it within a year, I'm firing the entire executive. It's right
00:14:19 in the bill. That's life. You're a barber, you don't cut hair well, you get fired. If you're a mechanic and
00:14:26 the engine block falls out, you get fired. In the real world, when people don't do their job, they don't get
00:14:30 bonuses. That's how life works under this Prime Minister for the senior six-figure bureaucracy. This bill puts an
00:14:37 end for that. We're going to pay for results, not for bureaucracy and the privilege of incompetent
00:14:44 bureaucrats who make life miserable and costly for everyone else. Mr. Speaker, the Building Homes,
00:14:52 Not Bureaucracy Act is common sense. The common sense of the common people united for our common home.
00:14:58 Your home. My home. Our home. Let's bring it home.