Western Standard - April 12, 2025


Trump's tariff game exposed

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
'Canada will fold...' and they know it, tough talk just for election, Part 1 Where the Sun Don’t Shine: Rural Alberta rises up against solar farms

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

152.66

Word count

4,444

Sentence count

176

Harmful content

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Peter Piovic is a Calgary-based senior portfolio manager at Wellington Altus Private Wealth Canada and a regular contributor to the Western Standard. In this special edition of the show, he talks about the impact of President Trump's latest trade war with China and why he thinks there's still hope.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 China's killing our canola, $45 billion gone, Western farmers bleed, Mark Carney silent,
00:00:14 made millions off Beijing's dime, he won't fight, he's Beijing's banker, not our prime
00:00:21 Minister.
00:00:45 Good evening Western Standard viewers and welcome to this special edition of Hannaford,
00:00:50 a weekly politics show. I'm Nigel Hannaford. It is Friday, April the 11th, and my guest today
00:00:56 is Peter Piovic, a Calgary-based senior portfolio manager at Wellington Altus Private Wealth Canada.
00:01:04 Welcome back to the show, Peter. Thank you, Nigel. Pleasure to be back.
00:01:09 Peter, we're doing this special edition because we're normally Thursdays, but we're doing this
00:01:12 special edition tonight, Friday, because thanks to President Trump this past week,
00:01:16 has been dramatic on the markets and a lot of people are frightened as somebody who looks after
00:01:22 other people's money you must have had your phone ringing off the hook this week so here's the one
00:01:28 thing everybody wants to know is there any hope nagel you know there's always hope and things are
00:01:35 not always as bad as they seem at least that's the way it seems to work out you know for me longer
00:01:40 term. But no, there's hope. And yes, the phones are ringing off the hook because anybody who
00:01:47 turns on the news these days, they'll get a very healthy dose of fear. So if you could put it in
00:01:55 just one sentence, do you buy and hold or do you lock in your losses now before they get any worse?
00:02:01 the first thing one needs to do as always is the case is is is remain calm and um sit down
00:02:09 and look at everything that is occurring objectively uh with as little emotion as possible
00:02:15 the way we see it uh is is that there is a lot of statecraft being employed by the u.s administration
00:02:24 and statecraft is is when essentially you don't show all your it's kind of like a poker game you
00:02:30 don't show all your cards as a politician or as an administration right up front.
00:02:34 You have an end goal and you want to achieve that end goal,
00:02:38 but you've got to be careful how you get there
00:02:40 because if you overexpose yourself on that path, you may get derailed.
00:02:46 So a lot of what you're hearing, a lot of the fear that you're seeing,
00:02:49 some of it's real, but some of it is meant to achieve a means to an end.
00:02:56 So we can definitely talk more about that.
00:02:59 Well, let's do that. 1.00
00:03:00 The popular narrative is that President Trump is an idiot and is like an out-of-control 1.00
00:03:04 bulldozer in world markets, or my more kindly way of putting it, that his laser focus on 1.00
00:03:10 what he thinks are America's best interest is doing untold and irreparable damage to
00:03:15 the rest of the world.
00:03:16 So, statecraft, China, bond markets, refinancing of the U.S. debt.
00:03:26 can you put all that together in a way that makes sense of what he has done in the last two weeks
00:03:32 first imposing uh extra tariffs and then taking them off for everybody except china which now has
00:03:41 is it 104 or 140 i it moves so fast i lose track of it you have to check your tweets every five
00:03:49 minutes to know what the exact number is you know for that moment um but uh no that that that is all
00:03:55 That is all statecraft. 1.00
00:03:56 So, you know, when talking to people, if I took the approach that, you know, Trump doesn't know what he's doing, Trump's an idiot and so forth, then I would probably become even more popular. 0.99
00:04:07 However, that may not be the case. 0.99
00:04:10 You see, you have to almost just rewind here and see, you know, what are they trying to accomplish and why?
00:04:17 So, you know, so first of all, and this is a very complex topic, but at the end of the day, the crux of the problem are deficits.
00:04:25 So a couple of deficits in particular, you know, one is the fiscal deficit.
00:04:31 So if you have a fiscal deficit of, say, $2 trillion on a $37 trillion debt, that would mean that the national debt is growing by $2 trillion a year.
00:04:43 And that is unsustainable.
00:04:47 That's just the end and the be-all of it.
00:04:50 It is absolutely unsustainable.
00:04:51 And then when you look at the interest payments on that debt now basically approaching, and if you extrapolate its growth rate, possibly exceeding $1 trillion a year by the end of this year, then you've got a real problem on your hands because now that starts to, say, exceed the budget of the U.S. military in terms of interest expense.
00:05:15 So that's one deficit that they wish to reduce.
00:05:20 And then the other one, which is contributory to that, would be the trade deficit.
00:05:26 And that's what we've been hearing a lot of recently in terms of the trade deficit of the U.S. to China and to the rest of the world, which is where the statecraft comes in.
00:05:36 So, Nigel, do you want to talk a little bit more about the trade deficit and how that might work?
00:05:42 Well, let's do that.
00:05:44 So the trade deficit and also the Department of Government Efficiency, and it does sound comically bureaucratic, but in actual fact, that's an agency of government with a limited span or sunset clause in it, and it is actually uncovering enormous and ridiculous expenditures.
00:06:03 again if you take your eyes off it for a day you lose it but the last time i heard they'd
00:06:09 identified something like a trillion dollars that is just foolish expenditure so are you
00:06:17 are you saying that taking the sum total of what the u.s administration is doing and not just being
00:06:27 focused on tariffs they are in fact seeking to save money in government and appear to be succeeding
00:06:35 that they have um that they are working on the trade deficit through tariffs
00:06:44 and that of course when you apply a tariff anything that does come in is revenue to the
00:06:49 the government. And then I recall that we were speaking a while ago about the import of gold and
00:06:57 the possible revaluation of gold as a way of reducing the severity of the national debt,
00:07:08 the total national debt. I think you use the analogy of if you have a house that's a million
00:07:15 dollars and you're worth a million dollars and you have a hundred thousand dollars in the bank
00:07:19 uh a debt of a hundred thousand dollars you don't worry too much but if the debt is a million and
00:07:24 the house is a hundred thousand then you've got every reason to be concerned so the so taking
00:07:30 all of these things together can you place the tariff actions within the overall u.s approach
00:07:37 and maybe rate how well it's working for them yeah so it's it's going to be too early to say
00:07:44 how well it works, although they've been in these similar places before, and similar policies have
00:07:50 worked historically, post-World War II, post-World War I, and also post-Civil War. Now again, it's
00:07:56 just important to almost kind of refocus on what the main goal is, and that is to reduce the deficit,
00:08:02 the fiscal deficit, and to reduce the trade deficit. So now going back again to the fiscal
00:08:07 deficit, you know, very simple, if you have a deficit, if you're running a deficit, say in your
00:08:11 household. And what does that mean? It means you're spending more money than you're making.
00:08:16 So how do you fix that? You know, it's difficult, but simple. Obviously, you need to make more on
00:08:22 one side, so increase your revenue. And you need to spend less on the other side, which is decrease
00:08:28 your expenditures. And that's exactly what the US administration is trying to do. So on the revenue
00:08:34 side, you already mentioned it, Nigel, you know, tariffs increase revenue. And, you know, currently
00:08:40 they're targeting anywhere from $300 billion to $600 billion of increased revenue through tariffs.
00:08:49 And then on the expenditure side, you already mentioned Doge. So that's one way they're trying
00:08:55 to reduce the expenditure. But then the other way is going to be to reduce the interest expense
00:09:01 that I referred to earlier. And how do you reduce interest expense? And there's really only a couple
00:09:06 of ways. One is to reduce the national debt, which they're nowhere near accomplishing at this point
00:09:13 in time. They'd be happy if they can just reduce the deficit before they could even begin to think
00:09:18 about reducing the debt. But if they can get interest rates down, so if they can somehow get
00:09:25 interest rates down, which they have been coming down, and when I say down, I mean, and when I say
00:09:31 interest rates, I mean the bond market. You see, the Federal Reserve tracks the two-year
00:09:36 treasury bond as one of its main targets in terms of how to set their overnight interest rates.
00:09:44 And currently, that two-year treasury bond is hovering just under 4% and has been trending
00:09:50 downward now for weeks. So one of the ways, one of the reasons it's been trending downward,
00:09:56 ironically, is all this uncertainty that we've been seeing. So in a very strange way, and this
00:10:02 now again goes back to statecraft, in a very strange way, all this uncertainty, all this fear
00:10:08 and so forth that we've been seeing is bringing down interest rates in the bond market. And as
00:10:14 those rates come down, when treasury bonds come due, and the US government needs to renew those
00:10:21 treasury bonds, and there's trillions that need to be renewed this year. They've six trillion in
00:10:27 June, and there's more towards the end of the year. Those bonds get renewed at a lower interest
00:10:33 rate. And when they get renewed at a lower interest rate, the US federal government saves
00:10:38 money. When they save money, they reduce that fiscal deficit. So is that an accident or is that
00:10:46 planned. Well, if it's not an accident, then Trump is obviously a superior intellect to most of us
00:10:55 because sometimes it's hard to follow, even when you have it explained to you. Especially in the
00:11:00 last couple of days, there's been quite a few articles, mostly from the left-wing media,
00:11:05 emanating from the United States. Like I noticed that the lead article on this yesterday on the
00:11:10 National Post came from an American author. I don't know where they stand politically, but they
00:11:16 certainly were delighted to write that Trump had blinked when he suddenly removed these tariffs.
00:11:24 And I've had the argument advanced as recently as yesterday that, in actual fact, bond rates
00:11:29 are going up. So just because of those uncertainties and the different things we're being told,
00:11:34 are bond rates going up? You just said they were going down. That sounds better.
00:11:39 And did Trump blink? Okay. So just to answer the question on bond rates, first of all,
00:11:45 it depends on the time frame you're looking at.
00:11:47 Did they blink up this week?
00:11:49 Short answer is yes, slightly,
00:11:52 but they're still quite significantly down
00:11:54 from where they were last month and in February.
00:11:57 So nothing ever goes up or down in a straight line.
00:12:00 It goes up, it goes down, it goes up, it goes down.
00:12:02 So you have to look at the overarching trend
00:12:06 and the overarching trend is down
00:12:07 until proven otherwise.
00:12:10 But at this point in time, it's still down,
00:12:11 although this week, yes, it did tick up.
00:12:14 So then back to statecraft. So, you know, once again, it'll be very popular if I, you know, said that he blinked. And who knows, maybe he did blink. But here's the thing that I've been thinking about for several weeks now with respect to these tariffs.
00:12:30 So let's just kind of back up again and take a bird's eye view of the trade deficit, first of all, which is one of the reasons we're going to tariffs.
00:12:42 So if you look at, if you just look at goods and not services, the U.S. trade deficit to the world is something like $1.2 trillion, which is, by the way, is a colossal number.
00:12:57 Now, if you include services, because the U.S. does a lot of services, that number drops probably from $1.2 trillion to somewhere around $800 billion.
00:13:09 It's still a very, very big number, even when you include services.
00:13:13 Their trade deficit to China, on the services side, the data is really not clear.
00:13:19 It's very poor data on services with respect to China.
00:13:22 But on the good side, it's a little bit more clear.
00:13:25 it's probably just a little bit under 300 billion dollars so so net net if you're looking at goods
00:13:31 about one quarter of the u.s uh trade deficit um is with china and then three quarters is with the
00:13:39 rest of the world so and china is also um you know the uh the competitor let's just say to the u.s
00:13:47 with respect to economic and political power.
00:13:50 So I've always suspected that really the main target
00:13:55 in these so-called trade wars really is China
00:13:59 and always was China.
00:14:01 Sure, everybody else is involved as well,
00:14:04 but if you start with tariffs on everybody
00:14:08 and then you slowly reduce those tariffs
00:14:12 on most countries with the exception of China,
00:14:15 you might what might be happening here is you might be left with essentially uncovering the
00:14:22 the main target all along and and that could be an element of statecraft right there well that
00:14:28 okay so because I'm old I remember this happening in real time but back in the in the last century
00:14:37 at the at the end of the 80s at the end of the Reagan area it was deemed that it would be a good
00:14:43 thing for the world if china were brought which had been sort of excluded from a lot of things
00:14:49 was actually brought into the mainstream exposure to the the world trade uh organization and
00:14:56 international trade would be good for them it would raise their raise their hopes raise their
00:15:01 standard of living they would become more peaceful and less dangerous and as it was written so it was
00:15:07 done. Well, they didn't play by the rules. This is the sort of the conservative view of history
00:15:14 here. Obviously, if you're a leftist, you won't think like this. But the Chinese didn't play by 1.00
00:15:18 the rules and instead, aided by unpatriotic business owners in America, they offered
00:15:25 America offshore production to China and is now in a vulnerable position, both militarily and
00:15:31 economically and president trump was saying has decided that he is going to do to china what
00:15:38 reagan did to the ussr with star wars and tariffs are part of it and so are the other things that
00:15:45 we were talking about so there you are there's a there's a sort of a little potted history
00:15:51 uh and an explanation for all things uh which may be completely wrong but is there any truth in any
00:15:57 of it there the short answer is there may be uh truth truth in that we don't know yet but certainly
00:16:03 we'll be paying attention to how that progresses uh over time and but let's back up again and just
00:16:08 say how we got here um you know why did uh the united states offshore production uh to china
00:16:14 you know back in the day let's call it in the 70s and the 80s uh to start and there are many reasons
00:16:20 uh but one of them was um you know in the united states we had very high inflation like very very
00:16:26 high inflation, which led to very high interest rates, which were causing all sorts of problems.
00:16:32 You may remember that. I was pretty young at the time, but even I remember that as it was occurring.
00:16:39 Kissinger and the US administration at the time had this grand idea with costs. It was
00:16:47 no idea is not without consequence. The idea was essentially to export the inflation outside of
00:16:55 the United States essentially to China by exporting production of goods and factories
00:17:03 and manufacturing and so forth outside of the United States to China in the effort to bring
00:17:08 down interest rates by bringing down inflation. And to a large degree, it did work. And again,
00:17:16 just a quick little mechanism. Obviously, if jobs are being exported overseas, there's less
00:17:22 money in the US system after that is complete, which means less demand for goods and services
00:17:30 as there's less money to chase those goods and services. Furthermore, if China is exporting
00:17:36 goods into the United States, that means we are exporting money outside of the United States
00:17:41 and Canada. Canada wasn't all that much different. And when you export money out of a country,
00:17:48 That means that wealth is essentially being taken out of that country and sent over to the exporting country, in this case, China, which long, long, long term makes the Chinese obviously very wealthy and slowly but surely, you know, makes, you know, the average middle class American poor over time. 0.73
00:18:08 So that is what Trump is now targeting because fast forward now several decades, what has occurred is essentially too many, there's too many people in the United States that are not doing well as a result of all this.
00:18:23 They don't necessarily have as many good quality, high paying jobs as they would like.
00:18:29 And there's now a concerted effort to bring that production back into the United States, to bring those jobs back into the United States.
00:18:37 and then to have more wealth accumulate
00:18:40 and reinvigorate the middle class,
00:18:44 which I don't know if that's maybe being communicated
00:18:46 as well as it should be.
00:18:49 But if you definitely listen to and read
00:18:53 the actual policy of the U.S. administration,
00:18:56 that does appear to be their goal,
00:18:58 which by virtue means that the trade deficit
00:19:02 needs to come down.
00:19:04 And tariffs are a tool to achieve that means.
00:19:07 you it's complicated button it is complicated and you know well it is it is and i i the purpose of
00:19:17 this discussion is actually to be helpful to people who are trying to look at their own lives
00:19:24 make their own decisions and think what's going on how is this going to affect me
00:19:28 am i going to be living on the street now let's just talk about inflation as it affects us today
00:19:38 april you know 2025 if a person is thinking about making a large investment whether it's
00:19:47 in a motor car or a home renovation or whether they're moving thinking about moving house
00:19:52 all the big decisions that people have to make they know what the price is today
00:19:58 do you think inflation is something that they need to be concerned about if they were needing
00:20:06 to make these purchases in the next year a short answer is no nigel um so which i know is again a 0.65
00:20:14 contrarian opinion uh to what is typically being disseminated you know uh you know by a lot of
00:20:20 pundits in the media, and I'll explain why. So you have to, again, back up and see how do tariffs
00:20:28 historically, how have they worked with respect to inflation? Obviously, if taken at face value,
00:20:35 it would make complete sense that tariffs would be inflationary because you think, well, if you're
00:20:40 tapping, adding a 10%, 20% tariff on something, surely the price of that item must go up. And
00:20:47 And surely if that happens everywhere, it's inflationary.
00:20:50 But wait a minute, you just need to back up just a bit and look at the totality of circumstance.
00:20:56 So let's just say we're talking about a 10% tariff.
00:21:00 So historically, if you look at how this has worked in years past, because, you know, we've had tariffs forever.
00:21:07 You know, in one way, shape or form, we have a lot of experience with tariffs and how they ended up working.
00:21:12 So on a 10% tariff, typically the consumer does not absorb the totality of that increase.
00:21:24 So you might say, and these are rough numbers because it can be different in different circumstances,
00:21:30 but possibly two, two and a half percent, let's just say a quarter of that 10% tariff
00:21:35 is a one-time price adjustment to the consumer, which then begs the question,
00:21:41 what about the other three quarters, the other 7.5%? Well, there's typically and very often a
00:21:48 foreign exchange adjustment, which the foreign exchanges will adjust to reduce the impact of
00:21:54 that tariff. Next, the supplier typically will absorb some of that tariff, sorry, the exporter.
00:22:02 And then the importer will also absorb a portion of that tariff. And even if you look at a 10%
00:22:08 tariff and say well even if it's only two two and a half percent or so that's still that's still an
00:22:14 increase but wait a minute you have to look at the definition of inflation for something to be
00:22:19 inflationary that inflation has to be perpetual and it has to continue rolling forward meaning
00:22:26 that you have to continually get a price increase on that product for that reason and that's not
00:22:33 the case in this and in this instance um it's a one-time price increase so the price goes up
00:22:38 one time one day one month and then that's it unless tariffs go higher then that then that
00:22:44 changes the equation a bit but if it stays static at that point time that's just the so-called new
00:22:49 normal um it doesn't necessarily progress from then on um for inflation to be progressive it
00:22:56 needs it needs to continue um and then and then the flip side of that as well is because again
00:23:02 this is this is complicated stuff um the you know the there's demand destruction when the price of
00:23:09 that item goes up so for example if we're talking grapes and the price of grapes goes up to a price
00:23:15 that maybe you or i just you look at that price and we go you know i don't need those grapes that
00:23:19 bad um but hey those blueberries are on sale so i'm gonna i'm not just not gonna buy those grapes
00:23:24 i'm gonna buy this group those blueberries but what happens if everybody that's walking by the
00:23:28 the grape aisle does the same thing and says, yeah, I'm going to pass on the grapes.
00:23:33 The price of those grapes will actually come down, you know, at, you know,
00:23:37 kind of back to where the consumer is actually willing to buy those grapes at.
00:23:41 Otherwise, substitution occurs.
00:23:44 And beyond that, even if the price did perpetuate higher,
00:23:47 eventually we might just figure out ways to grow grapes more locally,
00:23:52 say in Kelowna, for example, and avoid the tariffs outright.
00:23:56 Yes, you look like you might have vineyards behind you, actually.
00:24:04 Yes. Well, I mean, that's certainly the way that they taught me economics at university.
00:24:10 In practical terms, I'm still waiting for the price of Marmite and certain other British 1.00
00:24:14 specialties to come down in just the way that you have described, and I will take hope from
00:24:21 what you've just said. It's just theoretical, of course.
00:24:24 Yeah, life happens. You in the past recommended hard assets. Do you still recommend hard assets
00:24:35 for people who are looking for a safe place to put their money?
00:24:38 Yeah, no, absolutely. You mentioned earlier about the potential of gold becoming something bigger,
00:24:45 possibly in this financial system. And that's always been the case. And that's still the case
00:24:50 today. For example, we talked about trade, we talked about deficits. At the end of the day,
00:24:59 the goal is to reduce the deficit, to manage the debt better, because if it continues on,
00:25:05 then the interest expense simply gets too high in the long run, and that could lead to a far,
00:25:10 far worse situation than we see currently here today. As much as none of us particularly like
00:25:17 what's happening. The reality of it is there is an effort to fix certain problems that exist in
00:25:24 the system, the financial system, to avoid a much larger problem down the road.
00:25:30 And one of the ways to fix this, so to speak, is gold at some point may, we don't know,
00:25:39 we don't know for sure, but it may play a much larger role in the financial system.
00:25:44 It's already a reserve asset at multiple, you know, multiple central banks around the world and Treasury departments.
00:25:52 If the debt situation at some point becomes a little more untenable, let's just say, one option is always going to be to simply take those take that gold that's sitting on the balance sheets of different central banks like the U.S. Federal Reserve or the Treasury Department and revalue it at a higher price.
00:26:12 And if you revalue it at a higher price, then all of a sudden the debt that that country has may not seem so big in relation to the value of gold that's being held in reserve.
00:26:25 So for that reason and many other reasons, we've always held a broad-based portfolios that yes, have equities, stocks, yes, have fixed income bonds, cash and cash equivalents for liquidity.
00:26:41 and then some precious metals, mostly gold,
00:26:44 possibly a little bit of silver and other commodities as well
00:26:48 to round up a much more balanced mix
00:26:50 that's able to weather a wide variety of storms
00:26:55 better than if one had only equities alone.
00:26:59 Peter, that's a beautiful segue to the word from our sponsors
00:27:03 that I'm going to deliver now.
00:27:06 This episode of Hannaford is sponsored by New World Precious Metals
00:27:10 based right here in Calgary.
00:27:13 Years of inflationary money printing
00:27:15 and rising debt have decimated
00:27:17 the savings of the average Canadian.
00:27:20 Gold and silver are the only currencies
00:27:22 that have held their value
00:27:23 for thousands of years.
00:27:25 Last year saw 30% gains.
00:27:27 New World Precious Metals
00:27:29 offers unique platforms
00:27:30 to help protect and grow
00:27:32 your hard-earned wealth
00:27:33 with gold and silver.
00:27:36 Check them out at newworldpm.com.
00:27:40 Peter thank you very much for your insights today they're always valuable and for the Western
00:27:49 Standard I'm Nigel Hannaford what does success mean to you peace of mind financial freedom
00:27:55 generation of wealth what do you see in your future investing in gold and silver can help
00:28:01 you get there through our trading partners New World Precious Metals offers safe affordable
00:28:06 secure international accounts to help you meet your unique financial goals.
00:28:12 Connect with one of our experienced team members.
00:28:15 Invest in gold and silver today.
00:28:36 Thank you.