Western Standard - November 07, 2024


Trump wins, what will the Democrats do?

Topics
Mentioned
US Election Live Coverage No Production Cap Former Liberal Finance Minister Warns of Economic Risks for Canada

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

165.17

Word count

7,635

Sentence count

557

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Trump has won every single swing state, and now it s time to figure out who s going to be the next president of the United States. Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Columnist Corey Morgan join me to discuss the results, and the leadership review of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good day i'm derek vildebrand publisher of the western standard and you're watching
00:00:28 the pipeline. Today is October, November 6th, the day after the United States is a big general
00:00:37 election. It's, it's all mega. So much mega. I'm joined as usual by Western Standard opinion
00:00:45 editor Nigel Hannaford. Good to be here. And Western Standard senior Alberta columnist
00:00:51 Corey Morgan. Always a pleasure. I don't know for late night. Yeah, that was a very late
00:00:57 night, gentlemen. We were here till 1230. We pulled the plug. We were waiting for Donald
00:01:05 Trump to come on. We finally just gave up and said, watch it on the TV, guys. We're not
00:01:09 going to stream it. Ten seconds after we pulled our stream, Donald Trump comes out. But yeah,
00:01:15 quite something. We're going to be talking today as well about the leadership, resounding
00:01:21 leadership review results of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith. But before we get to that,
00:01:26 We're going to have just a double segment of mega.
00:01:30 Trump won bigly.
00:01:32 So big.
00:01:33 So great.
00:01:34 I've even got my Make Mongolia Great Again hat today.
00:01:39 Not quite mega, but I await the return of the great con.
00:01:45 All right.
00:01:45 Well, before we get into it, let's just kind of look at the results.
00:01:49 We have a pretty clear idea, very clear idea now.
00:01:52 Here, let's bring up the map here, Nico.
00:01:56 So, here's where we're at, using 2702win.com.
00:02:02 Everything has been solidly called, with the sole exception, of course, of Arizona.
00:02:09 Now, Arizona's going to go Republican.
00:02:11 I have a hard time seeing how it doesn't.
00:02:12 But that's 11 electoral college votes.
00:02:14 It's the only one outstanding.
00:02:17 But right now, they're only 67% reporting.
00:02:22 What is wrong with these guys?
00:02:24 It's Nevada and Arizona.
00:02:25 It's always, you know, where all the casinos are and they can't seem to count.
00:02:29 They just get fried in the desert, I guess.
00:02:31 Yeah, but you see here, this is a Republican-leaning state in any case.
00:02:37 I would be, Trump won every single swing state.
00:02:40 So let's quickly run through the swing states.
00:02:42 So we've got Nevada, swing state, Trump won pretty decisively.
00:02:51 We've got Wisconsin.
00:02:53 So this is the blue wall. Trump won by one percentage, not by a huge margin, but he's got Wisconsin. We've got Michigan. Donald Trump takes Michigan just a little over a percentage. Again, not a lot, but these are the blue wall states. Democrats need to win them. If they don't win them, they're pretty toast.
00:03:18 Pennsylvania. Trump winning more convincingly there. Still not huge margins, but 50.5 to 48.5. And Ohio. We'll show you Ohio here. Big win.
00:03:38 Like, Ohio's starting to look like a red state almost, 55.2% to 53.9%.
00:03:43 Ohio should not be that red.
00:03:45 When we saw Ohio going that red and early, I was like, yeah, it's going to be a bad night for the Democrats.
00:03:51 Could be a favorite sun effect.
00:03:54 It could be a bit of J.D. Vance, perhaps.
00:03:56 You've got North Carolina, swing state, 51.1% Trump, 47, 47% Kamala Harris.
00:04:03 And Georgia used to be a solid Republican state, but it is now, it's now a switcher.
00:04:10 It moves around.
00:04:12 We got Trump 50.7 to 48.5.
00:04:18 Solid night for Trump.
00:04:19 He won every single swing state up there.
00:04:24 So, you know, we had a late night last night, gentlemen.
00:04:27 But it looked pretty early, like it was looking good for Trump.
00:04:30 And there was no back and forth at all.
00:04:33 No state went back and forth.
00:04:34 They went red, and they got redder throughout the night.
00:04:38 Initial thoughts?
00:04:40 That was actually one of the most fortifying things, watching this thing through.
00:04:45 And in terms of what's it going to be like when it's all over, the whole thing was very definite.
00:04:52 It was very much, there was a mood and it was being expressed and it was being revealed as the results came in.
00:05:01 And this was important to me, at least, because it meant there was far less excuse for argument after it was all over.
00:05:09 If there'd have been backwards and forwards and more boxes coming in and, oh, gosh, we've got another pile over here,
00:05:16 that's the kind of thing that would have made a very uncertain election.
00:05:20 But it wasn't like that.
00:05:22 there definitely was a mood that's not to say that the country is together clearly they're
00:05:30 pretty much 50 percent by 50 percent divided between those who like the way trump does things
00:05:36 and those who would have preferred just about anything else but trump did win and it's not
00:05:44 arguable he even had the popular vote so first time a republicans actually got popular vote
00:05:50 20 years since George W. Bush against John Kerry, 2004.
00:05:54 So it's a strong result, and it should resolve things.
00:05:56 I noticed the stock market this morning just went straight up.
00:06:00 I'd like to say that was a Trump effect, but I think it was a certainty effect.
00:06:04 Possibly.
00:06:05 Now we know what the deal is.
00:06:08 I mean, this was, this was, I was expecting Trump, I was without a lot of certainty leaning
00:06:16 towards a Trump win yesterday.
00:06:17 I did not have in the cards a decisive Trump win.
00:06:20 I thought he, in probability, he was going to eke it out.
00:06:24 The polls tend to always underrepresent conservatives and Republicans, particularly with Trump, because it's not very nice at a fancy cocktail party to say you support Trump.
00:06:35 So people tend to, I think Republicans, especially Trump voters, are underreported.
00:06:40 But he won decisively.
00:06:42 Most likely he's going to come out of 312 electoral votes over Harris's 216 popular vote.
00:06:50 It's actually continuing to go up. He's at 1.5% over Harris.
00:06:57 The way the Electoral College votes is, you know, if the two candidates are tied in electoral vote, the Republican wins.
00:07:02 And he outright won the Electoral College, the popular vote too.
00:07:07 He's carried the Senate. He is likely, but not positively, but likely carrying the House of Representatives as well.
00:07:14 And he's already got the Supreme Court. Did Biden get the nominee to single justice?
00:07:19 No, that's all I can remember.
00:07:20 Oh, it's still Trump's court.
00:07:23 This is the most resounding Republican control of the United States government probably ever, Corey.
00:07:32 At least since Reconstruction.
00:07:34 Yeah, I'm not going to start digging anyway.
00:07:35 So, I mean.
00:07:36 You didn't go after Reconstruction, that's it. 0.53
00:07:37 And the stability in itself, that's the other part that I think, as Nigel was saying,
00:07:42 that the stock market's responding to.
00:07:43 We've got something that's definitely going to be predictable as far as who's in power,
00:07:47 and we're not going to be scrapping in the courts and messing around
00:07:50 and dealing with months of that sort of thing.
00:07:52 Well, let's hope not.
00:07:53 No, and we're not seeing indications of it.
00:07:56 Kamala Harris is making it clear she's going to concede.
00:07:59 It's not going to be a battle in that far.
00:08:01 There will always be some other individuals, I guess, but it's not realistic.
00:08:05 I guess the big question now is let's hope that we've got a party
00:08:09 that has an incredible amount of power now.
00:08:11 Let's hope they use it wisely in this next couple of years
00:08:13 and we see some positive changes.
00:08:15 That's what we've got to hope for at this point.
00:08:17 So let's talk about Kamala Harris. I think it was a real disgrace last night that she did not have the intestinal fortitude to stand up and say anything. 1.00
00:08:32 You know, she didn't even need to necessarily concede last night if there was a small glimmer of hope. I mean, by the time we called, so we're done. I mean, it was very clear.
00:08:43 But even if she didn't concede, she should have at least gotten up and thanked the people who voted for her and worked for her.
00:08:50 The people who knocked on doors for months, hammered in signs.
00:08:56 You know, she didn't have to do it through the winter because she didn't face a Democratic primary process. 1.00
00:09:00 But people who worked for her, who volunteered for her, donated money to her, they show up at her headquarters.
00:09:07 Don't underestimate the difficulties of pounding a sign into the hard packed
00:09:14 soil you know it hasn't seen water for a month. As I said last night I've won an election and
00:09:19 I've lost an election. You got to speak both times one is a lot more fun than the other one is but
00:09:25 when you lose it's actually even more important to speak at the very least to thank the people
00:09:29 who busted their butts for you and she just couldn't do it and it was the same with Hillary 1.00
00:09:34 Clinton. And I think this, it's not helping the cause of America eventually having a woman president 0.93
00:09:41 that you've now had two, both got trounced and both didn't have, you know, not that Trump
00:09:49 particularly graceful he lost last time he didn't concede, but at least he stood up and talked to
00:09:54 his people. And you can argue if that was a good thing or bad things that he said, but at least he
00:09:57 had the guts to stand up, as has every single defeated presidential candidate in American
00:10:03 history except for Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris. Neither of them as far as I know. I think
00:10:09 Gore never came out that night before. Okay but I don't know if he came out or not but that was
00:10:15 legitimately hanging in the air there was nothing. Oh I understand I'm just saying though he same
00:10:19 sort of thing as with Kamala though well I mean it was it was still technically could have been
00:10:24 he was not clearly defeated that night at all that was very much going to go to the courts that was
00:10:27 in the balance. We're saying the same thing he could have come out without conceding at least
00:10:30 I'm not sure.
00:10:31 Are you sure?
00:10:32 Because I was sitting up late that night.
00:10:33 I remember everybody, because everyone is waiting forever.
00:10:35 Is he going to come out?
00:10:36 And it was finally like an announcement.
00:10:37 Yeah, they decided they're not going to come out yet.
00:10:39 I don't remember.
00:10:40 Yeah.
00:10:41 Either way, it's very rare, though.
00:10:42 I don't want to understand.
00:10:44 So it's not a good look.
00:10:46 But Kamala Harris is going to be conceding.
00:10:49 I saw, oh, it was such a great, where is it?
00:10:54 I don't have it here.
00:10:55 It was such a great headline from the, I think was the onion. Trump calls Kamala Harris to congratulate himself. I thought it just summed up kind of both of them from last night very well. I don't know your thoughts, Corey on how she comes out of this and how the Democratic Party comes out of this.
00:11:19 I don't know. They've got a lot of introspection to do at this point.
00:11:22 They got four years to work on it. I mean, they're conceding. So
00:11:26 there's going to be a lot of changes. I mean, Kamala Harris is clearly a spent force. 1.00
00:11:30 She's not going to come out of the ashes like Trump, except which is a very exceptional case.
00:11:37 He is now the only the second non-consecutive two term president in American history,
00:11:42 the last being Grover Cleveland in the 1880s.
00:11:46 Yeah, so they've got to work on figuring out how they're going to be relevant in the next couple of years with such an overwhelming Republican control of every single part of the American system right now.
00:11:57 And just making a good showing for themselves as they figure out how they could change that circumstance four years from now.
00:12:06 So I'm fairly confident saying Kamala Harris will go down as the worst DEI hire in history.
00:12:13 Someone who was clearly never up to the task of the offices she held, who just managed by a combination of social grace and then checking off the right DEI boxes to be able to climb the ladder. 0.77
00:12:27 She didn't get a single delegate in the Democratic primaries when she ran for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2020.
00:12:36 Not a single delegate, but she checked the right boxes, so Joe Biden put her on the ticket.
00:12:40 Okay. And then you had the effective internal party coup, where she replaces Biden on the ticket. She faced no, she did not have to face the forge of a party nomination process. And she melted under the heat of a general election campaign, particularly against a ferocious opponent like Donald Trump.
00:13:03 But, you know, I think she did better than Joe Biden would have.
00:13:07 But that's because Joe Biden's brain doesn't work anymore.
00:13:10 The Democrats would have been so much better served having an open primary process.
00:13:14 DEI, you know, the idea of diversity hires is crumbling everywhere.
00:13:20 Major businesses that have been on board with it.
00:13:23 I think it's going to get a good press for a long time.
00:13:25 They're all getting out.
00:13:27 it is now the pendulum is swinging hard but Nigel do you think the Democratic Party
00:13:36 is going to maybe do serious reflection on the idea of constant identity politics that
00:13:42 everything is identity politics diversity hires uh Trump uh I think won the Latino vote.
00:13:50 Yeah he did and there there's some activists really shooting at I've seen some bizarre stuff
00:13:55 while it's online, we're going to see bizarre stuff, but some activists calling Latinos white
00:14:00 nationalists. And again, you guys, you haven't learned your lesson then if you're going to
00:14:05 pull these kinds of stunts. But I mean, this is just the day after 25% of blacks. 1.00
00:14:11 Trump did better with Latino voters than any Republican since Nixon in 1972, and better with
00:14:17 black voters than any Republican since the 1950s under Eisenhower. The great white nationalist Nazi 0.78
00:14:26 candidate seems to be doing better than any Republican in modern history with minority voters.
00:14:32 So do you think the Democratic Party is going to do a legitimate rethink on
00:14:38 their obsession with identity politics? Obviously, it did not work for them.
00:14:43 they will reflect on that and they will make changes the puzzle to me is that it took a defeat
00:14:51 like this to knock them off their high horse much as i deplore what the democratic party 0.99
00:15:00 has come to stand for i have never said that they were stupid people but now there is such a parade 1.00
00:15:08 of stupidity through this last four years but i'm starting to think well maybe i overestimated 1.00
00:15:16 their their intelligence and and their motivations because look at the things that they have done 0.99
00:15:23 never mind the dei just for a moment because i think that's actually a very big part of their
00:15:27 problem but how they managed to misunderstand what was on the hearts of what they thought
00:15:37 was their biggest pack of supporters, which was the women of America. 1.00
00:15:41 They thought abortion was the issue. 0.96
00:15:44 When you actually turn to the polls, abortion was, I think, about 14%.
00:15:50 What was the leading concern for American women was the economy, 1.00
00:15:54 because they're the ones who go to the grocery stores,
00:15:57 and they know what things cost, and they know that they don't bring as much home.
00:16:01 So the second thing was their habit of insulting their voters.
00:16:10 That comment made by one of their surrogates, I guess surrogate is the new buzz term for this.
00:16:17 If I go out and give a speech, I'm a surrogate for you, Derek, so there you go.
00:16:23 look it's um if you have somebody say there are no strong women around Donald Trump and then you
00:16:35 look at that stage last night when Trump came out and they all fell out and stood behind him
00:16:40 there were a bunch of women there who I would say were strong women and effective sure they 1.00
00:16:48 were beautiful that's expected but these are people that you can hand a big job to and say
00:16:53 willing to do it and expect it to get done. I mean, Melania, Trump speaks five languages and has a
00:16:59 little side business in high fashion, you know. It was a ridiculous thing to say, and you don't 0.96
00:17:05 bring people to yourself by shaming them, like Barack Obama. Okay, so with all those strikes 0.95
00:17:16 against them they then come in and and and emphasize that people are identified by this
00:17:22 marxist critique of of um it's all identity oppressors and oppressed you're you're not white 0.63
00:17:29 so you must by definition be oppressed uh then you have different degrees yeah because a latino
00:17:34 is still a white nationalist to a black uh and then jews who jews are now white nationalist nazis 0.95
00:17:40 yes so i i have a hard time keeping it straight if they don't rethink this they are doomed
00:17:45 to win let's uh beg your pardon they are doomed to lose again in 2028 you can't do this i i do
00:17:52 think that as you said there are many intelligent people in there i mean this is a shake up i i
00:17:57 suspect i mean right now we're seeing the hotheads speaking and and so on but the wise ones are being
00:18:02 quiet right now and they're thinking and i i think they're gonna they're gonna rebuild they're gonna
00:18:07 re-evaluate that approach i mean james carver will come on your show i was james carver was
00:18:13 The name I was thinking of is someone who was, he's been warning the Democrats that you're not going to win the votes of men by shaming men for being men.
00:18:22 You know, playing identity politics, maybe it'll work with those groups, but then you're going to alienate these other groups here.
00:18:30 In fact, but it didn't work with a lot of these minority groups.
00:18:33 Trump also nearly won with women.
00:18:37 I think Kamala had a minor edge, but Biden outperformed Kamala Harris with women compared to Harris here. 1.00
00:18:45 And, you know, both Kamala Harris and Hillary Clinton made making the first woman president of the United States such a key part of their campaign.
00:18:56 And that that appeals, I guess, to a certain segment of the Democratic Party, but it doesn't, I think, resonate with the broader American public.
00:19:04 And you'll see some of the hotheads in the Democratic Party right now saying, well, this just shows the American people aren't ready for a woman president. No, they weren't ready for Hillary Clinton, and they weren't ready for Kamala Harris. Those people were judged and found wanting. America surely will have a woman president at some point.
00:19:25 My best guess is that that person is likely to be a Republican, though, and we've seen this in other places.
00:19:32 We saw Margaret Thatcher in the United Kingdom.
00:19:35 Golda Meir in Israel.
00:19:38 Yep. What's her name in Italy? I can never remember her.
00:19:42 Georgia Maloney.
00:19:43 Yeah.
00:19:44 Indira Gandhi in India.
00:19:45 Yeah. Imperfect example, Angela Merkel in Germany.
00:19:49 She was a moderate conservative when she started. She left as a treasonous socialist by the time she was done.
00:19:54 the time she was done, but she started as a middling competent. She was competent, she's smart. Yeah, but she was a nominal nominally a conservative at least. The left doesn't tend to produce many. I mean, I guess New Zealand, what her name was, but for the most part, because I think they're making the argument, you have to elect this person because they're a woman. And that's not an appealing argument to a man. In fact, it's not an appealing argument to a lot of women either.
00:20:20 So I think America is going to eventually have a female president, but that is going to be a Republican. 0.95
00:20:27 The thing with DEI is that it is based on resentment.
00:20:31 You need resentment between classes and identities in order for any advantage to be conferred.
00:20:38 As a consequence, that's what the Democratic campaign projected was dourness. 1.00
00:20:46 Forget the joy stuff.
00:20:47 It wasn't much joy.
00:20:48 It wasn't much joy.
00:20:49 It was basically a complaint and a lament, whereas the Trump team certainly were pretty hard, but they knew how to have fun as well.
00:21:00 I mean, don't want to go back to talking about garbage trucks and McDonald's, but, you know, there's a playful side to that leadership team, which is very attractive.
00:21:12 And I think a lot of people said, oh, whatever, you know, they just kind of enjoyed it, voted for it.
00:21:19 D.I. is poison. Indeed. Okay, let's bring the map back up. I want to shift gears. It's not as exciting as the big headline Trump-Harris battle, but let's talk about Congress because it really matters. 0.99
00:21:35 So in addition to Trump's own win, Republicans have taken clear control of the Senate.
00:21:42 They were only down one seat, and they were defending a handful.
00:21:48 The Democrats were playing defense at a lot more.
00:21:51 For Canadians who aren't aware of how it works, only one-third of the Senate is elected every two years.
00:21:57 So it turns over roughly 33 seats at a time.
00:22:02 So it's not all up for election.
00:22:04 So, and just this cycle happened to be that the Democrats were on the playing defense a lot more.
00:22:10 And so the Republicans have easily taken control.
00:22:13 They're at 52 seats right now.
00:22:14 That could get up to 55.
00:22:17 It's going to be between 52 and 55.
00:22:19 Either way, they've got clear control of the Senate.
00:22:25 Then the House of Representatives, that one's a bit more complicated.
00:22:30 The Republicans already had a majority.
00:22:33 It'd be very odd for Trump to win on a Republican wave, the Senate to move on a Republican wave, then the House of Representatives to go the other way.
00:22:44 Now, local races, individual candidates matter a hell of a lot more in American politics than in Canada, because individual members of Congress and senators actually kind of get to vote as they want to.
00:22:55 There's pressure from their parties, but they can buck their party's trend because there's no party leader who takes your nomination away.
00:22:59 You have a primary instead, unless you're Kamala Harris. 0.99
00:23:03 The Republicans are at 210 seats in the House of Representatives right now. Democrats 194, 31 still up for grabs. Republicans are likely to maintain there. Although I would have thought they would have maybe made bigger gains in the House of Representatives. Doesn't look very likely that they will.
00:23:20 But and then Trump, as we said earlier, has the Supreme Court.
00:23:25 It's a pretty solidly conservative court at this point.
00:23:29 It looks at least for these two years before the next midterms, the Republicans can do anything they want.
00:23:37 They need to do it wisely.
00:23:41 And there is one of the strengths of the American system is that there is usually, even if you've lost the election, there is usually some place where you can take a little hope.
00:23:55 Well, we lost the presidency, but we got the House of Representatives.
00:23:58 Well, we lost the House of Representatives, but at least we managed to nominate a couple of Supreme Court judges.
00:24:05 And conservatives over the last four years have often found themselves thinking those kinds of compensatory thoughts, and it gives you hope, and it gives you confidence in the system.
00:24:17 Now, right now, if you are a Democrat, and if you're one of the kind of people who we like to caricature, where exactly do you take any hope and confidence in the system?
00:24:31 Well, the United States is a federation. They can still have some governor's mansions, some state houses.
00:24:36 But at the federal level, they're defeated.
00:24:39 They can move to New York or they can move to California.
00:24:42 But you see what I'm saying? Unless there is some place where you say, okay, that's a little bit of mine there.
00:24:48 And I'm holding on to it. And as long as it's there, the system is working for me.
00:24:52 Now, I wouldn't for a moment want to change any of the results that we reviewed last night.
00:24:57 But there is an onus on the governing party to remember that there are other people that they have to serve.
00:25:06 Not for a moment do I want them to take the eye off the ball and the things they promised to do.
00:25:12 But it's a matter of the style.
00:25:14 Like right now, I think a lot of us who were hoping for a Trump win, and I'm guilty of this myself,
00:25:21 are kind of taking the first 24 hours to gloat.
00:25:23 Okay, we have to go through that, and then we've got to put that on one side and say, what are the serious interests of everybody here?
00:25:34 Hopefully, that's all is already deeply embedded in the administration.
00:25:39 So, I'm not sure many Canadians know about this, but there's something called the Senate filibuster.
00:25:44 It applies particularly in the Senate, not so much in the House of Representatives, but it allows the minority party, as long as they've got more than 40 seats, I think,
00:25:53 And it's extremely rare that anyone's got more than 60 seats for a party in the Senate.
00:25:58 That just doesn't really happen much anymore.
00:26:01 But the minority party to stop the majority party from going too far and imposing its will.
00:26:08 The Democrats have been pretty hot about getting rid of Senate filibuster.
00:26:15 Because for a while they had the House of Representatives, the Senate, and the presidency.
00:26:18 They lost the House.
00:26:20 They still had the Senate.
00:26:20 They wanted to get rid of that.
00:26:21 I think they'll be quiet about that for a while.
00:26:23 I have a feeling that issue hits the back burner for now.
00:26:28 Now, the Republicans, to your point, Nigel, they could say, you know what?
00:26:33 Maybe you guys were right for the last four years.
00:26:35 Let's get rid of the filibuster.
00:26:37 But I think that would be quite un-magnanimous.
00:26:42 And it would be extremely short-sighted because no one gets to govern forever.
00:26:46 What was that great John Williamson quote that you had last night?
00:26:50 Someone else mentioned it.
00:26:51 And I was one who said with John Williams, it was, no defeat is permanent, no victory everlasting, or something like that.
00:26:59 You will eventually, now Oprah said that this could very possibly be the last election in America.
00:27:05 When I see the Enabling Act tabled, I'll reconsider her thoughts.
00:27:08 But until then, no, it's not.
00:27:12 Also, if you're going to set up a dictatorship, you should probably do it before you turn 80 years old.
00:27:16 There's not really much of a point in abolishing elections when he's not a spring chicken.
00:27:23 This is going to be his last term, obviously, constitutionally.
00:27:25 And it's just not going to come around. He's going to try and change it.
00:27:29 This is his term. But, yeah, I think it's the danger for the Republicans now is overconfidence.
00:27:39 They have a resounding mandate. They've got total control, but overconfidence now.
00:27:44 They probably should move aggressively.
00:27:46 They've got their two years before the midterms to make big, big changes, start deporting the illegals, cut the budget, build the wall, or finish building the wall.
00:27:58 I want your thoughts, Corey, though, on the unity ticket.
00:28:02 This was an interesting concept.
00:28:04 You had Kamala Harris.
00:28:06 She tried to balance her ticket by finding a frumpy white dude like Waltz.
00:28:09 Okay.
00:28:10 But then everyone at our rallies was just, it was Beyonce.
00:28:13 It's Taylor Swift is all celebrities, just a list celebrities.
00:28:18 Trump, by contrast, you know, he brings in RFK, Elon Musk, you know, these kinds of characters.
00:28:26 Do you want to speak first about how that involved the campaign?
00:28:33 But then I think more importantly, what role they're going to play in shaping this?
00:28:38 How is this going to be different from a previous Trump administration or other administrations in general?
00:28:44 Is it going to be a more decentralized hands-off?
00:28:47 Is Trump going to be the chairman president or is he going to be the CEO president?
00:28:52 Those are two different roles.
00:28:53 I hope he delegates because he's not a deep policy thinker, whatever he may be. 0.52
00:28:58 He's no fool, but he's a showman.
00:29:00 He's a politician. 0.99
00:29:01 He's a front man.
00:29:02 I don't like the thought of him drafting specific policy.
00:29:06 if you're going to talk about health care or cutting the civil service.
00:29:09 I hope, I mean, it was an interesting exercise, too,
00:29:13 of building different camps and bringing in support.
00:29:16 Likewise, RFK has some questionable views on medicine that I don't,
00:29:22 but since they don't have nationalized health care,
00:29:26 it's not as much of a concern.
00:29:29 He can promote the theories that he likes,
00:29:32 but it's not a control of what can or can't be done.
00:29:34 and it certainly would pacify the people with concerns about vaccinations.
00:29:38 What I'm most interested in is Elon Musk, though.
00:29:42 He showed how you can gut a large organization with a lot of bloat with Twitter.
00:29:47 And as much as everybody said, that's it, it's going to fall apart, it's going to die.
00:29:50 No, Twitter just proved itself more powerful than it's ever been.
00:29:54 Musk, whatever he might be, he gets things done.
00:29:57 He gets to the point, how much interest in time?
00:30:00 He's also an interesting character.
00:30:02 His interest is fleeting.
00:30:03 So if he wants to dedicate getting into and actually working on rebuilding that civil service, now is the opportunity.
00:30:10 You've got those two years before the midterms.
00:30:12 You've got the houses because it's going to be a battle.
00:30:16 So if you're going to take the knife to things, do it now.
00:30:20 Is he going to?
00:30:20 Is Trump going to give him the authority to?
00:30:22 Is he interested actually really in going further now that he's got better things to do?
00:30:26 He's making humanity interplanetary.
00:30:29 That's what I mean.
00:30:29 I mean, he's the picture of a genius kid with attention deficit disorder.
00:30:34 So, you know, the election is done.
00:30:35 I've got to work on my rockets now.
00:30:36 You know, we'll see.
00:30:39 But, I mean, it's going to be very interesting to see who he pulls around
00:30:41 and actually puts into those.
00:30:43 Because cabinets are different in the states.
00:30:45 Something to let our listeners realize as well.
00:30:48 We draw our cabinets exclusively, typically, from the elected individuals.
00:30:53 That's not the case in the United States.
00:30:55 You can pull some people into some powerful positions,
00:30:57 and they are not elected to them.
00:30:58 And that that's really where the opportunities are going to be good or bad for President Trump. So this next couple of months is going to tell a tale.
00:31:06 All right. All right, let's turn our attention closer to home here.
00:31:12 Bit of a smaller election or vote, but still, by far, it was the largest political convention in Canadian history in any province for any party, federal or provincial.
00:31:24 the Alberta United Conservative Party's convention in Red Deer.
00:31:29 Probably the biggest gathering ever in Red Deer.
00:31:31 I mean, maybe a concert thrived, but maybe.
00:31:34 I don't know.
00:31:36 And the big item on the agenda was her leadership review vote.
00:31:39 Now, all three of us were there.
00:31:41 A bunch of the Western Standard crew was there.
00:31:45 And I think we were all predicting she was going to be fine.
00:31:48 She was, I mean, you need, you know, 50% plus one is not enough to stay as leader. 1.00
00:31:54 It would open up, the knives come out hard for you then.
00:31:59 But I, you know, my prediction was 83.
00:32:03 She came in at 91.5, an absolutely triumphal result for Smith.
00:32:11 I'll start with you, Nigel.
00:32:13 I think at this point it's safe to say her leadership is unassailable short of an absolute atomic face plant on something.
00:32:22 So what we actually had was 50% plus 2,400 and what?
00:32:27 You know, I rest my case. That was enough.
00:32:31 So, you know, I sometimes wonder why we paid so much attention to those stories about the people who are there to undermine her.
00:32:42 I mean, there were people, there were 400 people who voted against her, yeah.
00:32:47 But, gosh, you know, did we fall for our own preconceptions?
00:32:55 It turned out there was nothing there, nothing to speak of.
00:33:01 Clearly, I mean, the wonderful thing about this, for the sake of all Albertans,
00:33:06 is that the Premier now is very clear that she has the total support of her party.
00:33:10 If there is any dissent within the caucus, they wouldn't dare raise their heads at the moment.
00:33:17 And she is about to go head-to-head with the federal government on their own lawsuit against the federal government,
00:33:28 telling them to back off on the emissions cap.
00:33:32 And also, we're heading into winter when this whole business of the secure supply of electricity is going to be on everybody's mind, even as the federal government continues to call for net zero by 2035.
00:33:49 So, it's good that whether you're a member of the NDP, whether you're a member of the UCP,
00:33:59 if you are living in Alberta, at this particular moment in Alberta's history, it is essential
00:34:08 that the leadership be strong in the face of what is really a predatory federal government.
00:34:15 I think we'll kind of continue with Nigel's point about, you know, why, why did we pay so much attention to those coming after her leadership? Those of us in the room, before you get in there, you never really know how many, how many people are they going to bust there? What are they going to do?
00:34:36 One of the groups was Take Back Alberta, David Parker, who, you know, and that organization, and he played a significant role in helping take down J.C. Kenney.
00:34:47 So there was some history there, thinking, okay, well, they were a part of it.
00:34:50 We know who these guys are.
00:34:54 You know, and, you know, then, you know, that organization played a role supporting Smith's election as UCP leader.
00:35:00 It's slate of candidates won in both the last two annual general meetings for their slate of candidates on the board.
00:35:07 So, you know, they had a track record.
00:35:10 But I just had a pretty strong feeling going into this that that train's run out of steam.
00:35:17 It doesn't have the heft anymore.
00:35:20 And then we saw the result. It had nothing. It was done.
00:35:25 It was done. And then there was also the so-called 1905 committee. There's really only two people publicly associated with it. I just wasn't seeing anything big around it. But, I mean, it is relatively unusual that you have organized groups trying to push a leader at a convention.
00:35:44 Normally these things are behind the scenes and it's kind of quiet and everyone smiles in public, but then quietly try to move people around.
00:35:52 That was not the case when Jason Kenney went down.
00:35:56 There was massive organized resistance against him and it won.
00:36:00 So I think maybe it was just kind of Jason Kenney syndrome from what happened last time that was projected on.
00:36:07 So, Corey, you know, we got the two organizations there, Take Back Alberta, 1905 committee.
00:36:14 They were absolutely destroyed by Smith's result.
00:36:20 Those of us watching things new, we really did.
00:36:22 I mean, I was confident before saying she's going to get 85% at least.
00:36:26 People watching from outside, they could point at and say, look how much impact Take Back Alberta had on Jason Kenney.
00:36:33 And that's absolutely true.
00:36:35 people saying conservatives are often pulled down by their own. Again, absolutely true. But they
00:36:39 haven't watched when that actually happens, or they're ignoring what was to be seen when that
00:36:45 happened. I mean, when you see the internal ones, those of us tied in, we'll still, we can smell the
00:36:50 whisper campaigns. We know what's going on. We don't necessarily know who, but you know what's
00:36:55 going on. And with Take Back Alberta, it was very transparent when they went after Premier Kenney.
00:36:59 There were dozens and dozens and dozens of well-attended meetings, a very aggressive
00:37:04 schedule, a very tightly organized get out the vote strategy to ensure that people voted against
00:37:12 Kenny. Absolutely none of that had happened. All we saw was David Parker speaking on social media
00:37:17 and a brochure campaign once the AGM hit. So that network just wasn't there. So there's no way they
00:37:24 could have been organizing to pull that together. There was no pile of 1905 meetings or even an
00:37:29 unknown group. You can't, especially when you've got a group of 6,000 people, you're trying to
00:37:33 influence, you're not going to do that in the dark. You're going to see the rumblings. You're
00:37:37 going to see these meetings. And I just didn't see, I just saw the usual characters and suspects who
00:37:42 like to organize around the peripheries, these things, you know, making noise, but never actually
00:37:46 getting anywhere. Smith should still take things seriously. I mean, the risk to a conservative
00:37:50 leader from within is always very real. She's gotten a pass and a strong mandate today. And
00:37:56 that can be very different two years from now. So she's still got, she's not going to face another
00:38:00 review before the next election. Well, no, she's not scheduled to, but let's remember Jason Kenney's
00:38:06 leadership review was not a scheduled one. It was effectively a recall. It can be. Constituencies
00:38:11 essentially called constituency associations had called a special general meeting, effectively
00:38:15 forcing a recall vote on them. Now these things are part of the UCP's constitution where they're
00:38:23 they're done every few years. But their strategy even at the event was strained. I mean,
00:38:32 they had these handouts with report cards claiming that Smith is weak on COVID stuff.
00:38:39 When in fact, she's probably the most radically anti-mandate leader of a head of government.
00:38:42 Good as they're going to get.
00:38:44 She's her only rival for the top spot is like Rhonda Santos. So I don't know what you're getting 1.00
00:38:50 at. These groups had, no, no one put their name on it. So we don't know who officially was behind
00:38:55 it. We have an idea. There was the one handout saying Danielle Smith is going to post Sharia law 0.78
00:38:59 on Alberta. You know, and I was like, how's that going to play? And I don't think, I think that
00:39:08 hurt them because it was so obviously over the top. And then they had no actual events there.
00:39:13 There was no visible, real presence of, we're the anti-Smith group, you know, here's a, we're having hospitality, come have a beer with us.
00:39:22 It was a flyer campaign is all it was.
00:39:24 Yeah, it was a paper tiger campaign, and it just had, there was no there there.
00:39:31 I guess the question, Nigel, is, is the media, and by media I mean Dwayne Bratt, going to continue to be quoted talking about people who they don't actually know ad nauseum here about this fake coup in the party that just never existed?
00:39:48 Well, the answer to that question specifically is yes, they will, because it is Dwayne Bratt's telephone number that they have.
00:39:56 If they were to ask around, they could probably get Barry Cooper's.
00:40:00 In fact, I would be pleased to forward it to my erstwhile colleagues at the Calgary Herald,
00:40:05 a bunch of telephone numbers for conservative academics and conservative thinkers
00:40:11 who would give them a different point of view than that offered by Dwayne Bratt.
00:40:16 But that's kind of, I don't mean any disrespect to Mr. Bratt either, Dr. Bratt.
00:40:22 He's entitled to his point of view, and when he's asked to give it,
00:40:25 sure he gives it but i do think that the the mainstream media would be doing everybody a favor
00:40:31 if they just asked a few more questions let me tell you one anecdote to that point the year was
00:40:38 2006 and at that time the premier premier daniel smith was still a columnist at the calvary herald
00:40:48 and both of us had to work late to comment on whatever was going to happen in the january
00:40:55 2006, federal election that was going to bring the Stephen Harper government to power.
00:41:04 And once the matter was settled, somebody came down to the caller and said, hey, guys,
00:41:09 do you have any conservative contacts?
00:41:11 We don't have anybody to ask for a call.
00:41:14 And obviously, we gave them what we had, and they went off and did their story.
00:41:20 That is very typical, unfortunately, of the media, that they have one point of view and one set of go-to people to support that point of view.
00:41:31 Selen do they get into the uncomfortable zone of where they get both sides of the story.
00:41:36 It's just these people, they don't actually know conservatives.
00:41:39 I try to be, you know, when we talk about internal NDP politics here, I try to be self-aware that I'm not a socialist.
00:41:48 I'm not a leftist progressive.
00:41:50 Now, I actually do know some and I can actually get along
00:41:55 and have a beer with these people, but I'm not one of them.
00:41:58 So while I might try to get in their brain, I'm very self-aware
00:42:03 that I'm not them, I do not think like them.
00:42:06 And I just don't think we see the same self-awareness on the other side.
00:42:11 We couldn't speak to the nuts and bolts that would go on in a union-backed sort of,
00:42:15 sort of organizing, I mean, organizing is organizing, but there's different intricacies
00:42:18 and things that they were immersed in for many years, and they would be able to speak to Gil
00:42:22 McGowan is as loony as he is, would be able to speak very well to what's going on behind the
00:42:26 scenes in the NDP. We're a lot more in tune to be able to speak to what happens in these
00:42:30 conservative organizations. But as Nigel saying, media doesn't call people like ourselves,
00:42:34 because they literally don't know who they are. Yes, they don't, they might know a couple of the
00:42:38 buzz name, you know, highlights, but they don't know the culture of it. They don't know who's
00:42:43 behind it. So yeah, you know, they had, there was a couple, there was TBA, and then there's two names
00:42:49 associated with 1905. And I just couldn't find anyone else involved. In fact, I knew a bunch of
00:42:56 TBA organizers who were aggressively handing out like pro Daniel Smith buttons and stuff at the
00:43:01 convention. I was like, yeah, you know, I'm just not smelling any rebellion. It was more of an
00:43:08 opposition for the sake of opposition at that point, I think. Yeah. On the TBA part, anyway.
00:43:13 Okay. Well, we're going to put a pin in it there and turn to our parting shots. Let's start with
00:43:19 you, Corey. Jeez, it was like a no huddle, you know, play between shows. I just came off mine
00:43:24 into here, so I hadn't dwelled on it. Parting shots, I just want to send my love in a sarcastic
00:43:31 way to Stephen Gilboa as he's gone and lobbed the nugget into the punch bowl out here with his
00:43:37 emissions cap, which is just clearly, I mean, again, modeled as a political play. I mean,
00:43:41 it's not, even if it came about, it's not going to come until after the next election.
00:43:45 I guess thanks for giving us lots of fodder to work on in the next few months, Mr. Gilbo,
00:43:49 and allowing regionalists like me to entrench even deeper in the West. Nigel.
00:43:54 As a longtime reader of Ayn Rand, I felt in the last few years that we were kind of living in
00:44:00 the last chapter of Atlas Shrubbed. I think something has changed there. Anyway,
00:44:05 There's something about the Trump team.
00:44:08 Musk is sending a man to Mars.
00:44:10 Ramaswamy built a high-tech empire,
00:44:12 and Trump himself changed the skyline of New York.
00:44:16 What did any of the Democrats ever do?
00:44:20 And it looks like Atlas is finally picking up the ball.
00:44:24 Maybe so.
00:44:25 For my parting shot, let's just bring up my screen here for a moment.
00:44:29 My favorite character of this election.
00:44:31 Peanut.
00:44:32 Peanut the squirrel.
00:44:35 I said it last night. I'll repeat it again. High school students in social studies are going to be taught 60 years from now how the government's execution of this poor, innocent, cute little squirrel changed America.
00:44:47 I don't know what degree he played a role, but it was a very last minute kind of cultural moment, emphasizing the excesses of the administrative state. And it's just the cutest little squirrel.
00:45:02 Here's another one. Peanut may have been executed by Democrats, but he lives on. He lives on in us, and I think there should be a memorial statue put up to him somewhere.
00:45:19 There's going to be a bust of Peanut the Squirrel in the White House in a few months. All right, that's it for me. Nigel, Corey, thank you for joining.
00:45:30 And thank all of you for joining us today.
00:45:32 Remember, if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, you really need to be.
00:45:35 The Western Standard is one of just a tiny, tiny handful of media left in Canada that do not take Justin Trudeau's federal media bailout money.
00:45:44 That is very, very expensive to us to not take.
00:45:47 So we need you to step up and become a member of the Western Standard.
00:45:49 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:45:52 You can do it quickly at westernstandard.news.
00:45:54 And being a member gets you past that pesky paywall that stops you from reading our stuff.
00:45:59 The Western Standard has got more reporters than even most of the big newspapers left in Canada.
00:46:04 So it's well worth your money, and you'll be supporting one of the last free press organizations left on this side of the border.
00:46:10 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.