Western Standard - August 31, 2022


UCP Leadership Debate

Topics
Mentioned
BC's unvaccinated doctors want to get back to work Trudeau responds to allegations Canada smuggled British teens

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 11 minutes

Words per minute

173.76

Word count

22,817

Sentence count

1,204

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The United Conservative Party has seven candidates in the running to become the next Prime Minister of Alberta. They are: Leela Ahir, Dan Smith, Daniel Smith, Travis Taves, Rajan Sani, Rebecca Schultz, Brian Jean, and Todd Lohan.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 You
00:02:00 baby
00:02:18 so
00:02:30 so
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 One heart beat, strong and free.
00:04:07 One choice for better, one voice together, strong and free.
00:04:15 We'll be right back.
00:04:45 Strong and free, how better we can be, strong and free.
00:05:01 so
00:05:31 Good evening, good evening and welcome to our second and final
00:06:01 I am Cynthia Moore, President of the United Conservative Party.
00:06:09 We are here in the beautiful MacLab Theatre, part of the Citadel Theatre Complex.
00:06:15 The Citadel is one of the largest non-profit theatres in North America and a leader in
00:06:21 both Edmonton and Alberta's performing arts, with more than 250,000 people coming into
00:06:28 these spaces each season.
00:06:30 On a personal note, growing up, I attended many productions here as well as the Citadel
00:06:36 Theatre School.
00:06:38 We salute those whose vision created this remarkable artistic company.
00:06:44 We also acknowledge that we are located on Treaty 6 territory and within the Métis homelands
00:06:51 and Métis nation of Alberta Region 4.
00:06:54 This land is the traditional territory of many First Nations, such as the Cree, Dene,
00:07:01 Stoney, Sawtoe, and Blackfoot.
00:07:07 123,915.
00:07:11 That's a big number.
00:07:16 That is the number of UCP members eligible to vote in this leadership election.
00:07:24 123,915 dedicated Albertans, like you, who recognize the importance of this election,
00:07:39 not only to our party as we elect our new leader and premier, but more importantly,
00:07:45 to the future of this province.
00:07:49 A substantial number of you have bought three-year memberships and donated.
00:07:54 I want to thank you for your overwhelming support of the United Conservative Party.
00:08:00 We take the will of the membership very seriously.
00:08:03 That's what this leadership contest is all about, listening to you, discussing the future
00:08:10 of this province based on our shared Conservative values.
00:08:15 The questions here tonight are inspired by input from our membership.
00:08:19 But with membership comes responsibility.
00:08:24 You need to vote.
00:08:27 Your vote matters.
00:08:29 You can cast your ballot by using our mail-in option.
00:08:33 Ballots will be mailed to you this Friday to arrive after the long weekend.
00:08:39 So watch for them.
00:08:41 Or you can vote on October 6th at one of five in-person voting stations located around
00:08:46 the province.
00:08:49 This has been a very thorough process, and whoever becomes the leader on October 6, let's
00:08:55 give them our support and move forward.
00:08:58 Move on to focus on winning the 2023 provincial election.
00:09:03 Albertans have told us that they want to see this government re-elected.
00:09:08 We are a team, so let's work together.
00:09:12 I know you're excited to hear from the candidates, so let's get on with the show.
00:09:17 I'll be back after the debate
00:09:18 to give you important voting information.
00:09:21 Now, back by popular demand
00:09:24 from our first official debate in Medicine Hat,
00:09:28 our moderator, Jeff Davison,
00:09:31 CEO of the Prostate Cancer Center.
00:09:34 Take it away, Jeff.
00:09:38 Well, thank you, Cynthia.
00:09:41 Thanks so much for having me back.
00:09:42 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome and good evening.
00:09:45 Welcome to the second and final UCP 2022 Leadership Debate.
00:09:51 Thank you for joining us as we broadcast you from Edmonton, Alberta.
00:09:54 Edmonton, give yourselves a round of applause.
00:10:00 That's, by the way, the last time you'll probably want to applause tonight.
00:10:04 I do police the audience a little bit in this.
00:10:07 Tonight, we'll have the seven leadership candidates on stage to give us their position on a series of questions
00:10:14 submitted by UCP members from across the province.
00:10:17 Each candidate will be given an equal opportunity
00:10:19 to speak over the next two hours
00:10:21 in order to provide all candidates
00:10:23 a reasonable opportunity to speak to you,
00:10:25 the UCP members, and of course to all Albertans
00:10:28 because we're broadcasting across the province.
00:10:30 This evening, candidates will be asked for their views
00:10:32 on the future of the United Conservative Party
00:10:35 and a government led by them as premier of this province.
00:10:39 But before we can get into the questions,
00:10:41 let's first meet the candidates.
00:10:42 So, audience, I'm going to ask you to just hold your applause until the end, but allow me to introduce Leela Ahir, Daniel Smith, Travis Taves, Rajan Sani, Rebecca Schultz, Brian Jean, and Todd Lohan.
00:10:53 Go ahead, give them a round of applause, everyone.
00:11:08 All right, go ahead and get comfortable there.
00:11:10 I mean, I know you're all ready for a photo, but we'll do that after.
00:11:13 You know, it's nice, though.
00:11:14 That's the political smile I want to see in all of you.
00:11:17 All right.
00:11:17 First of all, I want to say to all the candidates here, thank you.
00:11:20 You know, I can tell you as a recovering politician, it's not easy being in the hot seat.
00:11:24 And it's certainly not easy circling the province day after day.
00:11:28 And I want to let you know, I think you've all worked incredibly hard and earned the right to be here tonight on stage to speak to your fellow Albertans.
00:11:34 And although only one of you will be selected as our next premier, on behalf of UCP supporters
00:11:41 and all Albertans, I want to thank each and every one of you for putting your name forward
00:11:45 in service to Alberta.
00:11:46 Give them another round of applause.
00:11:54 All right.
00:11:55 Okay.
00:11:55 So tonight's debate is about ideas, and it's about presenting a vision for Alberta's future.
00:12:01 So it's only right that tonight's debate is about putting the candidates in the driver's seat.
00:12:05 With seven candidates seeking leadership of this party, it's about giving each of them an opportunity to detail their plans to you, the members.
00:12:13 So let's cover the process we're going to go through here tonight a little quickly.
00:12:16 First, I'm going to invite the candidates to each give a one-minute opening statement.
00:12:20 After opening statements, each candidate will be given one of seven questions with two minutes to respond.
00:12:26 Following the completion of their two minutes, I'll put one more question to each of them and
00:12:29 that question will be the same for all of you. That question is who would you like to debate
00:12:33 on this topic? I'll then invite fellow candidates chosen to provide a one and a half minute answer
00:12:39 to the question I asked, which will position us for a head-to-head debate between those two
00:12:43 candidates. Then open debate will go for three minutes before we move on to the next question
00:12:49 and the next candidate and I'll remind all the candidates that the audience is looking for plans
00:12:53 and solutions not just a bunch of yelling at one another over top of each other that works in
00:12:57 ottawa it doesn't work here we're going to do this seven times in total once for every candidate
00:13:02 and there's no limit to how many times a candidate may be chosen in one-on-one debate so to keep
00:13:07 things a little more interesting each candidate is also given five 45 second rebuttals that they
00:13:13 can use over the course of the debate so a head-to-head debate could look like it's head to
00:13:17 head to head or head to head to head well you get the point but that's how this could look
00:13:22 my only rule for the rebuttals is that candidates cannot use them all at once
00:13:26 so to keep things fair if a candidate by the way is named in any debate that they're not
00:13:31 an active participant in i will bring them in and allow them some time to respond and
00:13:35 just a reminder to all of the candidates we've got a lot to get through tonight and
00:13:39 we will be keeping a sharp eye on the clock i think we learned that lesson last time right
00:13:43 so if you go over time i will ask you to stop talking but if you choose to keep talking we'll
00:13:48 just cut your microphone off and as i've said many times that's much more embarrassing for
00:13:51 you than it is for me at the end of all of this i'll ask each candidate in order of random draw
00:13:56 remember folks this is all random drawn how we're approaching the questions to give a two minute
00:14:00 closing statement which is their final pitch of the night to you the ucp members across alberta
00:14:06 last request all right members of the audience this one is for you i asked one thing from you
00:14:11 and that is that you refrain from reacting to answers from the candidates please no clapping
00:14:16 or cheering or booing let's all be respectful we're all on the same team time is tight and we
00:14:20 and we will not be stopping the clock.
00:14:22 All right, everybody ready?
00:14:24 We're going to kick things off with opening statements.
00:14:27 Mr. Lowen, you drew first.
00:14:30 Come on up to the podium.
00:14:31 You'll have one minute once you hit the podium.
00:14:34 The floor is yours.
00:14:35 Thank you very much.
00:14:36 Tonight people are looking for new ideas and a solid plan.
00:14:39 They're looking for someone who wants to make a change.
00:14:42 They're looking for someone they can trust
00:14:44 and who will stand up for them.
00:14:46 Not more of the same,
00:14:48 We are not reusing the same failed tactics of the past
00:14:51 and not someone who sat idly by while Albertans suffered
00:14:54 and watched our party in our province slip into despair.
00:14:57 Folks, I am here to bring you hope and to share my vision
00:15:01 to inspire the people of our province to once again
00:15:04 get behind our movement that just three short years ago
00:15:08 sent the NDP packing to help restore the Alberta advantage.
00:15:11 We have a long ways to go yet.
00:15:14 If we are going to succeed, we need to reconnect and rebuild
00:15:16 We are proud to have a full trust with folks in all four corners of our great province.
00:15:19 Folks in Edmonton, Edson, Calgary, Carsten, Balliview, Vulcan.
00:15:23 As Conservatives we are supposed to believe the government's first duty is to listen to you
00:15:26 and respect your ability to make the right choices for your family and community.
00:15:30 I'm running to give this party back to its members but more importantly I'm running to
00:15:34 give Alberta back to Alberta.
00:15:36 Thank you.
00:15:37 One minute on the dock.
00:15:39 Great job.
00:15:40 All right.
00:15:41 Mr. Jean, come on up.
00:15:42 You will also have one minute once you hit the podium.
00:15:45 Hello everyone, I'm Brian Jean and I'm running to renew a party that so many of us worked
00:15:54 so hard to create.
00:15:56 I'm running for the leadership of our party because I want to make Albertans the happiest,
00:16:00 the healthiest, the most free and the most prosperous people in Canada and the world.
00:16:06 I want to be your premier to help you have more autonomy in your life, to help you have
00:16:09 the opportunity to have more free choice for your future.
00:16:14 As a lifelong Albertan, I've strived to serve my community and my neighbours, whether as
00:16:18 a business owner, a lawyer, a community volunteer, a member of parliament, an MLA or a party leader.
00:16:25 I believe that the United Conservative Party has the best ideas, the best principles and
00:16:30 the best people.
00:16:31 If the UCP is led in a way that connects with everyday, ordinary Albertans, we will have
00:16:36 success.
00:16:37 We will serve and lead Albertans to prosperity for many years to come.
00:16:42 want the ucp to be a party that listens they want it to succeed that is what i plan to do with your
00:16:49 help thank you thank you mr jean all right miss schultz come on up to the podium
00:16:59 you have one minute for your opening remarks please go ahead
00:17:03 some of you believe that this race is a two horse race where we are making a decision
00:17:09 between poor political judgment losing elections making promises we can't keep or the status quo
00:17:15 the same old people same old places doing the same thing saying that we're going to get a different
00:17:20 result if that is the case i sure hope me included i hope we bought three-year memberships because
00:17:26 we will be back here again in one year or two and i don't want to see that i know you don't either
00:17:33 i am not ready to say goodbye to my calgary mlas being completely shut out of edmonton
00:17:38 or being a divided party so ask yourself this not just who are we going to choose right now
00:17:45 but who are your neighbors going to vote for in 2023 your kids your daughters we need a leader
00:17:51 who albertans can see themselves in who will defend our rights and resources who can beat
00:17:56 rachel notley and earn the trust of albertans in every corner of our province we need a fresh
00:18:00 perspective leadership for the next generation and a leader that albertans can be proud of
00:18:05 all right that's one minute thank you all right what are we talking about no clapping i get it
00:18:12 we're all excited but here we go all right miss sonny come on up one minute is yours when you're
00:18:19 ready thank you good evening everybody sasriaka namaskar aslamu alaykum ladies and gentlemen
00:18:26 danielle smith says she will pass a painful sovereignty act and brian gene wants to open
00:18:32 of the constitution these are the kind of things that require a mandate from albertans before moving
00:18:38 on an election of all albertans i also ask all mlas to commit to waiting for that vote i would
00:18:46 approach this differently one issue that we all talk about is equalization we don't need to amend
00:18:53 the constitution or ignore any laws the formula is up for review in 18 months i would start today
00:19:01 to draft an alternative formula
00:19:03 and talk to the other premiers,
00:19:05 starting with the six other conservative premiers.
00:19:08 Quebec Premier Legault said he wants Quebec off equalization.
00:19:12 He calls it embarrassing.
00:19:13 I agree.
00:19:14 Let's help them.
00:19:15 No laws broken.
00:19:17 No lengthy constitutional battles.
00:19:19 And only time to build strong families,
00:19:22 strong communities, and strong Alberta.
00:19:24 I know, it's tough.
00:19:25 It's one minute.
00:19:25 All right.
00:19:26 We just talked about clapping.
00:19:28 What is it?
00:19:29 All right.
00:19:30 mr taves come on up here i mean this is like policing my children come on folks all right
00:19:36 mr taves you ready one minute opening remarks the floor is yours i got into politics and sought
00:19:42 public office in 2019 for one reason we had an ndp government i was concerned that the prosperity
00:19:48 and the opportunity the freedoms that we had enjoyed may not be afforded to the next generation
00:19:53 to our children and grandchildren i believe the most important question in this leadership race
00:19:59 is who can which leader can unite the party and movement and go on to win the election in 2023
00:20:05 friends leadership matters track record matters and if you want to see how somebody will lead i
00:20:12 would suggest take a look at how they've led together we rebuilt this movement we formed
00:20:17 government and i had the privilege of serving albertans as their minister of finance through
00:20:22 some of alberta's darkest days we brought this province to fiscal responsibility with a balanced
00:20:27 budget and we positioned our economy to lead the nation in economic growth i will provide strong
00:20:33 principled leadership leadership that unites this movement and can win the election in 2023
00:20:40 thank you mr caves are we going to make this a thing honestly are we going to make this a thing
00:20:45 come on they said yes okay come on all right miss smith one minute the floor is yours go ahead
00:20:54 good evening everyone i think that what we are looking for in a leader is someone who will stand
00:20:59 up to ottawa someone who will beat rachel notley and someone who will restore our freedoms is the
00:21:04 reason why i pledged that we would have no lockdowns or mandates why i led with a proposal
00:21:09 on health reform and why i led with the idea of an alberta sovereignty act and what is the sovereignty
00:21:15 act it just says we want to be treated just like quebec some will say it's about separation but it
00:21:20 absolutely isn't. It is simply about defending our constitutional areas of jurisdiction and the
00:21:25 rights and freedoms of our citizens, just like Quebec. Some will say we don't need it. I'm going 0.64
00:21:30 to tell you that we do. We might be facing mandatory vaccination. We will say we will not
00:21:35 enforce that. If there's an emergencies act that wants to jail our citizens or freeze their accounts,
00:21:40 we'll say we will not enforce that. Arbitrary fertilizer cuts, arbitrary phase-out of our
00:21:46 natural gas for electricity and power, arbitrary caps on our energy industry, and perhaps even a
00:21:52 federal digital ID. We have the Alberta Sovereignty Act. We will not enforce that. We'll put Alberta
00:21:58 first. All right. That's one minute. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Ms. Smith. All right. Missa here.
00:22:06 We're going to have a talk about this after.
00:22:08 the floor is yours good evening i'm leela here and i'm here tonight to earn your vote i'm a rural
00:22:15 albertan born and raised and in 2015 i ran with the wild rose against the government that had
00:22:19 lost its way in 2019 i helped rebuild our party to return conservatives to government
00:22:25 i stood up to premier kenny when he put himself above everyday albertans and for that he threw me
00:22:30 out of cabinet you've seen me grab a bull by its horns and also stand my ground in the face of
00:22:35 unprecedented attacks against myself and my family. I will not back down and I will stand
00:22:40 up for what's right. Now we've mentioned the bull, so let's talk about the crap. The 0.99
00:22:44 Sovereignty Act is an attack on our Canadian and Albertan values. It's an excuse to leave
00:22:49 Canada when we should be looking for ways to leave Canada. We need to stand up for what's
00:22:54 right and work together for Albertans. We lost our way because Premier Kenney put himself
00:22:59 first and we cannot afford to choose a government of just one person a second time. If you
00:23:05 choose me as your next premier i will work hard every day to serve you to listen to you and to
00:23:10 bring albertans back together thank you all right give them all a round of applause get it out of
00:23:15 your system now hoot holler cheer whatever you want to do are you good you got that out yeah okay
00:23:25 all right okay we're going to start with our first debate question of the evening and miss schultz
00:23:30 This question is for you and I'll remind you, you have two minutes for your answer.
00:23:35 The question is on leadership and unity.
00:23:38 This first question is top of mind to all our members.
00:23:41 Unity.
00:23:42 Five short years ago, over 95% of members of the Wild Rose and PC parties voted overwhelmingly
00:23:47 to merge into the United Conservative Party.
00:23:51 The UCP formed government and Alberta is now leading the country in job growth.
00:23:56 We've got our first surplus budget in seven years.
00:23:58 Pipeline capacity has expanded and we're now shipping more product to the world than ever before.
00:24:04 What specifically, and I'm looking for specifics, will you do as leader to ensure this party stays united and moves Alberta forward?
00:24:12 You have two minutes.
00:24:14 Thank you, Jeff.
00:24:15 I mean, when you talk about where our province is right now, I look at the spring and the step of Albertans.
00:24:20 This is excitement that we haven't seen in a number of years.
00:24:23 Things are going well economically.
00:24:25 we've been talking about diversification for so many years and we're finally seeing it happening
00:24:30 yes things are great in oil and gas we're seeing investments in agriculture technology manufacturing
00:24:36 hydrogen film and television this is an exciting time and i'm grateful for my team and the hard
00:24:42 work that we all put in to getting where we're at today we did a lot of things right now did we get
00:24:46 everything right obviously not or or we wouldn't be here tonight i think albertans are looking for
00:24:51 a different tone and approach and i think that that will help with unity um i think what i bring
00:24:56 to this table that is unique is i know that it's not just about me there is no one person who is
00:25:01 going to make sure that we can win the next election and keep our party united this is about
00:25:06 all of you in this room all of our members right across the province our team of exceptional mlas
00:25:11 we have to put the decision making table back to mlas mlas have a very important job of representing
00:25:17 the diverse views of constituents right across the province uh ralph klein did that here i think we
00:25:23 can do that here again that's going to matter i think we need to focus on listening to our
00:25:28 grassroots party members my first commitment was actually to doorknock in all 87 constituencies
00:25:32 right across the province i'm working on it and keeping track uh meeting with every single one
00:25:38 of our constituency association board presidents and our boards why because we need to hear the
00:25:43 voice of the grassroots but we also need to do that work to win to campaign to beat rachel notley
00:25:48 in the ndp in 2023 now you know i would just say this that in knowing that it's not just about me
00:25:55 i i do think we've got to respect the views of our team i don't think we can go into our
00:25:59 the very first legislative session with a bill that other candidates on this stage don't support
00:26:05 i don't think that's good for unity we've seen that before we don't want to read it in the paper
00:26:08 we need to focus on our team and all of you our members right across this province and build that
00:26:14 into the way we do what we do all right well thank you no no don't do it don't do it i'll
00:26:20 get out of this chair all right the next question for you ms schultz who would you like to debate
00:26:26 on this topic uh travis tapes mr taves all right i'll remind you the question is what specifically
00:26:32 will you do as leader to ensure this party stays united and moves alberta forward you have a minute
00:26:37 and a half sure good you know what i appreciate being able to weigh in on this issue because i
00:26:42 believe again unity and leadership are the most important issues facing this party and movement
00:26:47 you know again i i got involved in politics for one reason we had an ndp government and i believe
00:26:53 there was two fundamental breakdowns that led to an ndp government both of them uh involved unity
00:27:00 and uh leadership in terms of unity we know what happened in 2019 we had a fractured conservative
00:27:06 movement and that fracture ultimately resulted or contributed to an ndp government but there
00:27:12 was also a breakdown of leadership because a mere mere months before the 2015 election
00:27:18 the leader of her majesty's official opposition the then leader of the wild rose party walked
00:27:24 the floor and i believe it was those two events that ultimately contributed to an ndp government
00:27:30 again leadership and unity matter i believe i can i'm very confident i can unite this party
00:27:38 in this movement and leadership style and tone matters my leadership style has been informed
00:27:43 by previous leadership experience and i know this that every voice around the table matters
00:27:50 that's the way we make better decisions that's the way we make best decisions that's the way you bring
00:27:55 unity to an organization friends i will bring strong principle proven leadership to unite this
00:28:01 movement this party and win the election in 23. all right thank you okay let's move into three
00:28:06 minutes of open debate ms schultz kick us off so i do agree with with much of what you said um
00:28:12 travis and i do think that our team matters and i know that we are aligned on that i also know
00:28:16 that you are a person of great integrity um somebody who i have really enjoyed serving
00:28:22 alongside over the last three years but when I listen to what I hear from
00:28:25 Albertans I do have a couple of questions one thing I hear all of the
00:28:29 time whether it comes to investment attraction or some of the changes that
00:28:32 we need to see in health care how are we going to how are you going to break
00:28:37 through some of the bureaucracy when we have decisions where bureaucracy ran the
00:28:42 show led the charge and we were left to clean up the political mess later or we
00:28:46 didn't enter the fallout with things like the teachers pension yeah or a two
00:28:50 All right, let's give him a couple seconds here.
00:28:53 So a few things there.
00:28:55 Here's the reality.
00:28:57 Unless board members, directors, and department heads within the bureaucracy are completely and totally aligned with government's mandate, we will fail to deliver on that mandate.
00:29:10 We've seen that.
00:29:11 The government made errors in not ensuring, not requiring that there was full alignment within department heads, within directors of agencies, boards, and commissions, including AHS, in the first month that we took office.
00:29:27 There were mistakes made, and we can never make those mistakes again, because we have a responsibility as elected members to deliver on the mandate that we promised Albertans during the campaign, and that means full alignment with senior bureaucrats.
00:29:41 in here well and i would say it does require full alignment of senior leadership within the
00:29:45 bureaucracy i was lucky to transform every area of our ministry not because i had all the best
00:29:50 ideas because i had some exceptional leadership that was absolutely on board with transformational
00:29:55 change and looking at how we do things differently i don't think we always saw that in government
00:29:59 and and the other question i would ask is there was something you know i get asked quite often
00:30:05 is are you in this for the long haul what happens if you don't win are you going to stay are you
00:30:11 going to continue to fight for our party i know that the answer for me is you know what i hope
00:30:16 to win this race i do because i do believe that albertans deserve a fresh type of leadership a
00:30:21 different approach humility creative thinking i have a question for miss schultz she's asking
00:30:28 a lot of extremely important questions one is a question of unity what's going to happen after we
00:30:33 win the election i can tell you this and i believe this for every member up here that i will remain
00:30:38 committed to this movement full stop a question for miss schultz you know she talks about making
00:30:44 progress in her department and she negotiated certainly some more favorable things in the
00:30:49 child care agreement with ottawa but she didn't fully negotiate an ideal outcome for child care
00:30:54 providers i would ask miss schultz what she would do different next all right let's give her the last 1.00
00:30:58 few seconds yeah i would say it was unfortunate that that negotiation is still happening until
00:31:02 the end of November but I felt like I had something to offer in this leadership race and I sure hope
00:31:07 that the minister who's doing that now is going to carry that final negotiation all right that's
00:31:11 debate all right thank you folks I know three minutes it goes by tight right okay so now we
00:31:16 offer 45 seconds worth of rebuttals I have Mr. Jean first then I have Miss Honey is there anybody
00:31:21 else is it here and Miss Smith all right Jean go ahead unity is received by how you treat people
00:31:31 by treating them with respect, by treating them to make sure that they actually have a voice around the table.
00:31:37 I have almost 15 years of experience in politics, leading federal teams and provincial teams.
00:31:43 I have led a caucus, and I would remind people that during that period of time,
00:31:47 I never had anybody actually quit my caucus.
00:31:49 We never actually had to kick anybody out of caucus.
00:31:52 That's what unity is about, because we listen to the grassroots,
00:31:54 and we make sure that caucus and the grassroots are in charge of that.
00:31:57 I have a track record of listening and consulting with people,
00:32:00 and making sure that they are heard.
00:32:02 And I may not be the flashiest person,
00:32:04 I may not be the best speaker,
00:32:05 but I can form great teams,
00:32:07 I can get the job done
00:32:08 and I can make sure that the people that are in charge,
00:32:11 the members of the party and Albertans
00:32:13 always have the last say.
00:32:14 All right, thank you.
00:32:15 All right, Missani, 45 seconds.
00:32:17 Thank you.
00:32:17 When a leader listens and respects their caucus
00:32:20 and when caucus can see their values and perspectives
00:32:24 incorporated into policy and regulations,
00:32:28 that is unity.
00:32:29 And true leaders also have a track record of success, more success and failures.
00:32:35 And I will remind you that past behaviour is a good prediction of future behaviour.
00:32:41 Choose stability, knowledge and experience over turmoil, recklessness and constitutional quagmires.
00:32:48 All right, there we go.
00:32:50 Ms. Ahir.
00:32:51 Thank you so much.
00:32:52 I've been elected for seven years and I got into politics because of floor crossing.
00:32:56 That's how I was elected.
00:32:57 That's how I got here.
00:32:59 And I just wanted to say to what Rajan was saying, being able to listen to your caucus is one of the most important things you can ever do.
00:33:06 These are people who have given up their lives, their families, birthdays, anniversaries to be there to be able to advocate for their constituents.
00:33:13 They are the gem of our caucus because they know what's going on in their communities.
00:33:17 When things started to fall apart, Todd Lowen was kicked out of our caucus.
00:33:23 I was one of the few people in that caucus who stood up for him to try and bring him back.
00:33:28 That's what leadership is.
00:33:29 Leadership is standing up against bad bills like Bill 81 against the best interest of what's happening at that moment for the people of Alberta, not the caucus.
00:33:37 Thank you. Thank you very much.
00:33:39 Ms. Smith, five seconds.
00:33:40 I just want to point out, I think what Rebecca was trying to get out of Travis is that he's not going, he hasn't committed that he'll run in the next election if he doesn't win.
00:33:48 He may support the movement, but I think people want to know whether or not you'll commit to running.
00:33:51 I would say that leadership is important because two long conservatives have been leading and
00:33:59 governing by opinion poll. Leadership by fellowship is not leadership. As you've seen during this
00:34:06 campaign, I've taken some bold positions. I've taken a position on the Sovereignty Act. I've
00:34:09 taken a position on lockdowns. I've taken a position on health reform. And you'll see
00:34:13 that every other candidate on the stage has followed my lead. That's what leadership looks
00:34:16 like. You take a bold position, you bring people around, you consult, you get feedback,
00:34:21 you modify, and then you allow people to disagree. That's the kind of leadership style
00:34:25 that I have. All right, 45 seconds. Mr. Taves, you were called out a few times there on whether
00:34:29 or not you're going to stick around. Maybe you want to 30 seconds to answer. Well, absolutely.
00:34:35 Number one, I'm absolutely committed to this movement, regardless of who wins this leadership
00:34:40 race. Unity in this movement and the success of the Conservative Party in the spring of 23 is
00:34:46 essential. In terms of my decision to run again, I would reserve the right. I will not be
00:34:51 disingenuous with Albertans. I would reserve that right after the leadership, but I will be
00:34:56 supportive of this movement going forward. All right. Thank you very much. Okay. That wraps up
00:35:02 question one. Let's move on to question two. Just a second here. Sorry. Oh, I'm sorry. I apologize. I
00:35:07 had you on the list and I'm not doing my job here. Please go ahead. No problem. Thank you very much.
00:35:11 Obviously, unity is really about trust.
00:35:13 It's about uniting around principles that we all share as conservatives.
00:35:17 I just want to tell a quick story.
00:35:19 When I was kicked out of caucus, the MLA that made the motion to kick me out of caucus,
00:35:23 I reached out to him several months afterwards, and we had a good chat.
00:35:26 It was maybe a little awkward and uncomfortable at the beginning.
00:35:29 But since then, we've actually become very good friends
00:35:31 and have been able to actually associate a lot with each other
00:35:35 and be able to bounce things off back and forth.
00:35:37 And I think that's what leadership is about,
00:35:39 being able to reach out to those that maybe have wronged you in the past and be able to patch
00:35:43 things up and make sure that there's unity going forward. I've kept a good relationship with much of
00:35:49 caucus and the cabinet going forward. And leadership is about surrounding yourself with good
00:35:54 people. And I think that's what we have to remember when it comes to leadership. Thank you.
00:35:57 All right. All right. Thanks, Mr. Lohan. Sorry I missed you there. I had you written down, but
00:36:01 not too much shuffling here. All good. All right. Question two. Okay. And a reminder, everyone,
00:36:06 The question is on crime and policing.
00:36:08 Tonight we're in downtown Edmonton,
00:36:10 just a short walk from Chinatown
00:36:12 where there has been an outcry in the community
00:36:14 over petty and violent crime.
00:36:16 Calgary's downtown is also at a crisis point
00:36:18 as people feel overwhelmingly unsafe,
00:36:20 in particular on transit,
00:36:22 due to escalating rates of opioid addiction.
00:36:24 Likewise, crime rates in our rural communities
00:36:26 remain stubbornly high,
00:36:28 and many are concerned with slow emergency response times.
00:36:30 What is the impact of crime and crime and crime?
00:36:33 with slow emergency response times.
00:36:36 What will you do to address crime issues across the province
00:36:39 and what specific solutions would you bring forward as leader
00:36:42 to make our community safer for all Albertans?
00:36:45 You have two minutes.
00:36:47 Thank you for that question.
00:36:48 First of all, we can all agree that crime is an issue
00:36:51 in both urban communities and rural communities.
00:36:54 Certainly, what we're hearing in the rural communities
00:36:57 is an escalation of crime.
00:36:59 I know that there are some communities
00:37:01 who believe that the RCMP is serving them to the maximum extent,
00:37:07 but there are other communities who felt that the RCMP has let them down.
00:37:11 And we have not gone to the issue, to the crux of the problem here.
00:37:16 In fact, government and some of my colleagues have jumped straight to the solution
00:37:19 without actually defining the problem.
00:37:22 Why is there a disconnect?
00:37:23 I think it's important to bring people back to the table.
00:37:26 and certainly Alberta municipalities and rural municipalities have all objected to the Alberta
00:37:32 Police Force proposition that is coming from the government. And we need to understand why.
00:37:38 Some of the comments made are that they're worried that the cost will be downloaded to them. And even
00:37:43 if they're not, it's still not acceptable because there is only one taxpayer. So I think it is time
00:37:49 to get back to the table to understand why is there a discrepancy and work together to find
00:37:54 the solutions now in the urban centers it is definitely a complicated situation because we
00:37:59 have the opioid crisis we have the numbers of those experiencing homelessness those numbers
00:38:04 have increased and of course crime has increased as well and i think there is a tremendous opportunity
00:38:10 for everyone and particularly in edmonton everybody's blaming each other and pointing
00:38:14 fingers at each other but when was the last time that the social service agencies sat down with
00:38:20 the municipalities and police
00:38:21 services and all recognize
00:38:23 that we have a problem.
00:38:24 And instead of pointing fingers,
00:38:26 and this includes the province
00:38:27 as well, the infighting
00:38:29 actually is disgusting.
00:38:30 It's time for everyone to come
00:38:32 together, sit down, and look
00:38:33 at who owns the expertise.
00:38:36 Social service agencies can do
00:38:37 a lot to help those who are
00:38:39 vulnerable and experiencing
00:38:40 addictions.
00:38:41 Let them take a larger role.
00:38:43 Give police services more
00:38:44 resources as well.
00:38:46 All right.
00:38:47 Thank you, Ms.
00:38:48 Sunny.
00:38:49 Okay, the big question.
00:38:50 policing and crime?
00:38:51 I would like to debate Danielle.
00:38:53 All right, Ms. Smith, you have a minute and a half.
00:38:55 The floor is yours.
00:38:56 The question again, just so you have it,
00:38:58 what will you do to address crime issues
00:39:00 across the province and what specific
00:39:02 solutions would you bring forward as leader
00:39:04 to make our community safer for all Albertans?
00:39:06 I think we need to begin with an Alberta
00:39:08 provincial police.
00:39:09 Number one, our members gave us direction
00:39:11 by voting in favour of an Alberta provincial
00:39:13 police at our AGM and they voted
00:39:15 in favour of adopting it to either
00:39:18 augment or replace the RCMP.
00:39:19 So let's start with augmenting, because I can tell you a few of the areas where we have
00:39:24 deficiencies. Number one, of course, is rural property crime. I think we all know that
00:39:29 our rural neighbors feel like they have to take matters into their own hands sometimes,
00:39:34 because we end up having the RCMP not close enough to be able to respond to a call. It's
00:39:39 terrifying for them. We've got one of our main communities in Alberta, Hardesty, has $110 billion
00:39:45 dollars worth of value going through it in those tank farms doesn't have a police an rcmp detachment
00:39:50 within 45 minutes these are the areas that we can plug the holes also in calgary and edmonton we have
00:39:56 a severe homelessness and mental health and addictions crisis i believe that we can train
00:40:01 our alberta provincial police in being able to respond to those mental health and addiction calls
00:40:06 so they can be an augmentation to calgary and edmonton and a point of access into the health
00:40:10 care system so that those who are struggling with addiction can get the health care that they need
00:40:15 I think that's a critical link that is missing in our current police services.
00:40:19 The RCMP should be focused on the crime that they can police best.
00:40:23 Cross-border gun smuggling, those guns getting into the hands of gangs in Calgary and Edmonton,
00:40:29 human trafficking, organized crime.
00:40:32 And let's leave the other types of rural policing and community policing to an Alberta provincial police force.
00:40:38 All right. Thank you.
00:40:39 Okay, so we're going to get into three minutes of open debate here.
00:40:42 No, no, no, we're not done with this question yet.
00:40:43 Three minutes of open debate.
00:40:45 Ms. Sonny, I'll have you kick us off. 0.98
00:40:47 Thank you, Jeff.
00:40:48 And there is much that I disagree with that.
00:40:50 But I do have a question.
00:40:52 Danielle, the Sovereignty Act will upend crime and policing in Alberta.
00:40:57 If you become premier, will you commit to holding off on passing the Sovereignty Act
00:41:02 until you get a mandate from the people of Alberta in a general election?
00:41:07 I believe that we have a mandate from the people of Alberta
00:41:10 to make sure that we get tough with Ottawa.
00:41:13 we've been looking for different ways to do that we've got a mandate through the equalization
00:41:16 referendum and i believe that uh having a bill which would simply state we have rights under
00:41:22 the constitution that are provincial sovereign rights to legislate we're going to enforce that
00:41:26 we've got as a signatory to the charter of rights and freedoms we're going to protect the rights of
00:41:30 our citizens we're going to enforce that there's nothing really unusual about that quebec already 0.80
00:41:35 does it saskatchewan and quebec have both declared themselves nations within a nation so i believe
00:41:40 that we do have a mandate from the people to do that by virtue of the fair deal panel and by
00:41:45 virtue as well of the equalization referendum i would i would completely disagree such a
00:41:49 consequential piece of legislation does require a mandate of all albertans in a general election
00:41:56 and equating the equalization referendum to a mandate for the sovereignty act is ludicrous
00:42:02 and uh just going back to what was being said about um crime and policing when alberta
00:42:07 municipalities in rural municipalities resoundly reject the idea of an alberta provincial police
00:42:14 force we have to listen that's been the whole criticism of government that we have not been
00:42:19 listening danielle you are not listening when you are enforcing the idea of an alberta provincial
00:42:24 police force without effectively engaging with those who are saying no i think rajan you've just
00:42:29 said that you don't accept the wisdom of our ucp members because our ucp members have voted on this
00:42:34 and given us direction and i would just uh borrow from uh from brian gene when brian gene talked
00:42:39 about the equalization referendum that was initially his idea and part of the reason he
00:42:43 talked about putting that forward in the first place was to initiate a process that would open
00:42:47 up the constitution so that we could have a conversation about all the things we need to
00:42:51 fix in our relationship with ottawa so that's why i would draw a connection that absolutely i think
00:42:56 we do have a mandate to make those changes yeah i would and we also all right let's let miss
00:43:00 I would completely disagree and let's get back to you know putting this legislation to Albertans so that they can actually reflect on it and which part which sovereignty act are we talking about the unconstitutional one or the constitutional one because when I'm out there talking to Albertans all across the province there is much confusion about this particular issue so I would like to ask you once again why is it that you won't consider bringing this to Albertans in a general election
00:43:30 So Albertans can weigh in on this consequential piece of legislation that will cause chaos.
00:43:35 All it really does is put Ottawa on notice that we will be defending our rights as defined by sections 92, 93, 94, 95, and 92A of the Constitution,
00:43:45 as well as defending the charter rights and freedoms of our citizens.
00:43:48 That is establishing a new relationship with Ottawa because we haven't done that in the last 30 years.
00:43:54 Okay. So we're going to move on. All right.
00:44:00 dial it back a minute all right so we've got we've got more on this question so mr taves i have you
00:44:06 for a rebuttal mr loan have you got yours up anybody else ms schultz uh is it here okay all
00:44:14 right mr taves 45 seconds is yours all right i a couple of comments um on on the rcmp and
00:44:22 enforcement and provincial policing as i've traveled around the province i've been deeply
00:44:26 troubled by the stories of crime rural crime for sure but what's going on in chinatown here in
00:44:32 edmonton is absolutely tragic we have to take action as a government to ensure that our streets
00:44:38 are safe that's absolutely critical i believe an alberta police service could be part of that
00:44:43 solution i believe the rcmp have been hampered by a culture of deep culture of risk aversion
00:44:49 and heavy bureaucracy from ottawa that's why i believe in alberta police service could well be
00:44:54 part of that solution, I would commit to working with municipalities to bring them along to
00:44:59 demonstrate the value proposition.
00:45:01 All right, thank you. Mr. Lowen, 45 seconds.
00:45:04 Yes, thank you. In rural Alberta, we definitely have a problem with rural crime.
00:45:09 With the pandemic, it's increased the use of drugs and, of course, drug-related crime.
00:45:14 We have to stop the catch and release in the court system right now. The police work hard,
00:45:19 they catch people, and then they're back out on the streets before they know it.
00:45:22 And so as far as what we'll do, what we need to do is we need to have our property rights, for instance, enshrined in our own provincial constitution.
00:45:30 I've committed to that.
00:45:31 We need to make sure that we have something that Ottawa doesn't have in the constitution and that is the property rights.
00:45:36 And as far as the provincial police, we need to work with municipalities, make sure they know that they're not going to be responsible for paying for the provincial police.
00:45:43 And we need to have that provincial police to set that a little bit more of a barrier between us and Ottawa.
00:45:47 And then we have a police force to respond to Albertans' needs.
00:45:50 All right. Thank you, Mr. Lowen. Ms. Schultz.
00:45:51 Yeah, and my thoughts on the provincial police are that, much like Rajen, what is the problem that we're trying to solve?
00:45:57 Are we trying to address rural crime, where rural crime response times is a top concern?
00:46:02 As is catch and release, as Todd has raised, those are the two biggest concerns.
00:46:06 Downtown Edmonton, Chinatown, I hear about the impact on investment attraction that the downtown has.
00:46:12 Employers concerned about their employees' safeties when they're walking through the downtown.
00:46:15 So what's the problem we're trying to solve?
00:46:18 We have the vast majority of municipalities against a police force.
00:46:21 I know that our municipalities are one of our biggest partners in addressing many of the challenges that we are trying to address right now.
00:46:28 So I think we have to look at investing those dollars maybe instead of changing the stripe on the side of the pants or the sticker on the side of the car to put additional boots on the ground and have the right conversations at the right time about the right problems to try to solve.
00:46:40 Thank you. I know it's tough. 45 seconds is fast.
00:46:42 Thank you.
00:46:44 Every single conservative knows that job number one is ensuring public safety.
00:46:49 And changing the name is not going to change the systemic and structural issues that we have in policing at this time.
00:46:57 Speaking with municipalities is one piece of it.
00:46:59 But there's an entire consultation across this province that has to happen.
00:47:03 Nobody speaks about cultural sensitivities, the engagement with people, domestic violence, sexual assault.
00:47:08 The fact that women who are being sexually assaulted, or anybody for that matter, in a rural area has to travel three hours in order to have the system be able to input her data after the assault has happened.
00:47:22 We have bigger issues to deal with here, and those systemic issues can be dealt with as long as we work on this together.
00:47:29 All right. Thank you. Mr. Jean, wrap us up on this. 45 seconds, Steve.
00:47:32 I agree with the idea of a provincial police force over the long, long run.
00:47:37 But anything that will see fewer police officers on the street is an unstarter for me.
00:47:42 With over 70 communities, rural communities in Alberta, say, no, don't take the RCMP away from us.
00:47:48 We're talking about bringing them along.
00:47:50 Why don't we talk about giving them more choices?
00:47:52 My campaign is all about autonomy.
00:47:54 Choices for people, choices for communities.
00:47:56 If they want the RCMP, let them have the RCMP.
00:47:59 It's a premium police force.
00:48:00 In the meantime, let's work towards a provincial police force.
00:48:03 We have the city of Edmonton, the city of Calgary, Lethbridge.
00:48:05 We have different police forces across this province that give good policing.
00:48:09 We need to integrate the communication.
00:48:11 There's no question at all.
00:48:12 But we need somebody who understands policing and crime.
00:48:15 And, you know, folks, I spent three years in the Justice Committee in Ottawa
00:48:18 and ten years as a litigator in Patrick Murray.
00:48:20 All right, that's time.
00:48:21 I understand it.
00:48:21 All right, give them all a round of applause for the question,
00:48:23 because I know you want to.
00:48:26 All right.
00:48:26 Okay, Mr. Jean, we're coming back to you for question three, and the question is on agriculture,
00:48:32 and I'll remind you, you have two minutes for your answer. Alberta's agriculture sector 0.65
00:48:37 is thriving, with farm cash receipts at their highest levels ever. This despite input costs
00:48:42 like fertilizer and fuel significantly increasing. Since 2019, there's been more than $1.5 billion
00:48:49 in new investment into the agri-food industry, creating thousands of new jobs and putting
00:48:54 high-quality food on our tables.
00:48:57 This progress, however, is now threatened by the Trudeau government's fertilizer emissions
00:49:01 targets that many say will drive up food prices, limit crop yields, and hurt every Albertan
00:49:08 looking to access affordable solutions to feed their families.
00:49:13 What specifically will you do to defend our agricultural sector from yet another
00:49:17 harmful policy from Ottawa?
00:49:19 You have two minutes.
00:49:21 Well, thanks very much.
00:49:22 agriculture is a big topic and there's so much to cover on this and it's such an important thing
00:49:27 for our future and our present. I will tell you this first of all that I put forward a detailed
00:49:31 suite of agriculture policies. I think the most detailed suite of agriculture policies that we've
00:49:36 seen in a long time from any contestant in a leadership race. Things like establishing across
00:49:41 commodity advisory board of grassroots farmers and ranchers. That would mean that they would give
00:49:45 the opportunity to give information to the minister and the premier firsthand and we would
00:49:50 make sure that that's across the province so we wouldn't get to this point in the first place.
00:49:54 In relation to fertilizer in particular, what I would do in this particular case is make sure that
00:49:58 we have a made-in-Alberta solution. You see, agriculture is actually a joint jurisdiction.
00:50:03 It's jointly shared by the federal government and the provincial government, so we have to make
00:50:07 sure that we have a made-in-Alberta solution, fertilizers in particular for fertilizer companies
00:50:11 in Alberta. We make it here with Alberta products, and then we have the jurisdiction to manage it
00:50:16 going forward, and I think that's one of many interesting ideas that we can do, and
00:50:20 we can do that to withstand the constitutional challenge, but we can also do it to make sure
00:50:25 we have the proper facts for the proper constitutional challenge, because we have to win that constitutional
00:50:30 challenge.
00:50:31 It's obvious why grain farmers are worried, because what this means is ultimately less
00:50:37 grain, less diversity in grains, less barley, less opportunities for feedstock for cow-calf
00:50:43 producers less opportunities for frankly for Alberta and Canada to continue to
00:50:49 feed the world people don't know this but we have a huge part in feeding the 0.99
00:50:53 world and these stupid moves by Justin Trudeau are going to starve the world 0.99
00:50:57 and Alberta has the opportunity to provide so much more so I say to you 0.99
00:51:01 this that we have to find every opportunity to challenge the
00:51:04 jurisdiction but if we go wrong the courts will rule against us and we can't
00:51:08 do it wrong that's why we have to do it right we have to set up the proper facts
00:51:11 make sure it's a made-in-Alberta solution that will withstand the constitutional challenges that
00:51:16 will come and will in turn have a constitutional challenge. We need to open up the Constitution.
00:51:20 We need to get there in order to change things for us for the better.
00:51:23 All right. Thank you, sir. All right. Next question. Who would you like to debate on this topic?
00:51:27 Todd Lowen. Mr. Lowen, I'll remind you the question. What specifically will you do to
00:51:33 defend our agricultural sector from yet another harmful policy from Ottawa? You have a minute and
00:51:39 I think the first thing that we need to say to Ottawa is no for once we need to say no to Ottawa
00:51:45 and actually stand up for Albertans and stand up for Albertans rights when we look at the 30% 0.70
00:51:50 fertilizer reduction that the federal government wants to impose on Alberta farmers that's not a
00:51:54 that's not a environmental policy it's a starvation policy we need to stand with our
00:51:59 hard-working farmers and ranchers and the best thing we can do is to keep government out of their
00:52:04 business. We have carbon taxes that our farmers have to put up with. Carbon taxes on grain drying
00:52:10 when they're using natural gas to dry their grain. That's totally unacceptable. We see a war on beef
00:52:16 now. I guess they want to see us eating crickets instead of beef. I'm not sure why anybody would
00:52:21 want to do that, but I guess that's the direction our federal government wants us to go. We need to
00:52:27 defend ourselves from Ottawa. We need to be able to stand up and protect our own property rights
00:52:33 here. And another thing I think we could use here is a right to farm act. An act in the legislature
00:52:38 that actually protects farmers so that they actually have a right to do their business and
00:52:42 do their business the way they feel is right. And so again, we need to say no. We've seen the
00:52:47 Saskatchewan Premier, Scott Moe, is saying no to Ottawa. I think he's been listening to me because
00:52:51 I've been saying this for quite some time now. And we need more people to say no, more of our
00:52:56 political leaders to say no to Ottawa and make sure that we stand up and protect our agriculture
00:53:01 Thank you, Mr. Lohan.
00:53:03 We will move into three minutes of open debate now.
00:53:06 Mr. Jean, kick us off.
00:53:08 First of all, I would like to say how much I appreciate my
00:53:10 friend Todd Lohan and how much I appreciate the
00:53:12 opportunity for him to get back in caucus.
00:53:14 I would like to see that done as soon as possible.
00:53:16 I don't understand why he left in the first place.
00:53:18 I hope that I can get the commitment from everybody here
00:53:20 on this stage to make sure that Todd has the opportunity
00:53:23 to get back there as soon as possible.
00:53:25 Like this particular issue, I really value his opinion
00:53:27 as I think most Albertans do.
00:53:29 As far as Albertans and agriculture, I'd like to do a couple other things.
00:53:34 And Todd, I'm wondering what you think about this.
00:53:36 And in particular, I'd like to make sure that Albertans are the only ones that have Alberta grazing leases.
00:53:40 I'd like to make sure that we have a develop a made-in Alberta solution and take back our immigration from the federal government 0.98
00:53:46 so we can have proper agriculture workers in Alberta that actually do what Albertans need on our farms. 0.99
00:53:51 All right. A couple things to throw in there, Mr. Lohan. What do you think?
00:53:54 Yes, thank you very much.
00:53:55 Yeah, when it comes to grazing leases, there's a lot of contention with grazing leases with public land, private land, and that relationship with the public.
00:54:02 And there's a lot of work that needs to be done there.
00:54:04 But I think when it comes, you know, I guess I kind of want to go back to the fertilizer issue.
00:54:09 And I actually think that if we used Justin Trudeau's BS, we could probably fertilize the crops with that.
00:54:15 But unfortunately.
00:54:21 All right, all right.
00:54:22 We're cutting into his time here.
00:54:23 Maybe the world couldn't handle the crops with all that fertilizer, but I think we have a long ways to go in our relationship with Ottawa and being able to defend against the incursions on our rights here in Alberta.
00:54:38 And again, we see it over and over again.
00:54:40 We've seen a federal government that's not just tried to destroy our oil and gas industry.
00:54:46 They're actually destroying it right now.
00:54:48 And now, of course, they're going for agriculture.
00:54:51 All right. Keep us on agriculture.
00:54:52 I disagree with Todd on this.
00:54:54 I think the worst thing to use would be BS from Trudeau
00:54:57 because we don't know what we're going to get
00:54:58 except for a lot of hot air,
00:55:00 and frankly, the end crop would be a big, big problem.
00:55:04 You guys are writing my jokes for me.
00:55:05 Listen, I think the best thing we can do for Trudeau
00:55:08 is to keep him out of Alberta.
00:55:09 I think that's the best thing we can do
00:55:11 for a prime minister that's not going to stick up for us.
00:55:13 I think it doesn't matter whether it's agriculture,
00:55:15 whether it's policing,
00:55:17 whether it's the opportunity
00:55:18 to keep their environmental cops out of Alberta.
00:55:20 We have to do that.
00:55:21 I don't know how we're going to do specifically everything we need to do
00:55:23 because we need to do it within the Constitution.
00:55:26 We need to make sure that our agricultural industry thrives
00:55:28 with made-in-Alberta solutions that can withstand it
00:55:31 because all of the solutions up here, folks,
00:55:32 every solution you hear has to go through the same path.
00:55:35 It has to go through the Constitution in order to make changes.
00:55:39 That's called the rule of law, and that's what we are under.
00:55:42 All right, final 30 seconds, Mr. Lone.
00:55:43 Okay, yeah, I don't think we need another advisory board on anything.
00:55:46 We need to just get government out of the way of farmers and ranchers. 0.99
00:55:49 And one thing is we can't apologize for our oil and gas industry or our farmers or our forestry industry here in Alberta.
00:55:57 We're doing the best job right here in Alberta right now.
00:56:00 And I think the rest of the world needs to catch up to us.
00:56:03 But to punish our farmers and agriculture sector by more restrictions and more regulations, I think is unfair.
00:56:10 We need to stand up.
00:56:11 We need to say no.
00:56:12 I agree.
00:56:13 Okay.
00:56:13 So for rebuttals here, I have Mr. Taves.
00:56:16 Anybody else?
00:56:18 Ms. Ahir?
00:56:19 Ms. Smith?
00:56:20 All right, Mr. Taves, 45 seconds.
00:56:22 All right.
00:56:23 Agriculture really is the backbone of rural Alberta.
00:56:26 It makes a tremendous economic contribution to the province.
00:56:29 We have world-class farmers and ranchers in an incredibly competitive industry.
00:56:33 We need to push back on Ottawa when they step into Alberta to look to limit production.
00:56:38 Right now, the world needs more responsibly produced Alberta agriculture production.
00:56:44 we have to ensure that we're giving Alberta farmers and ranchers the tools to do just that.
00:56:49 Look, I was pleased when farmers, ranchers, industry leaders,
00:56:53 our own Minister of Agriculture, Minister Horner, and others,
00:56:56 pushed back successfully on the ridiculous ground meat labeling laws that came down from Ottawa.
00:57:02 That's the approach we need to take.
00:57:04 I will push back and defend agriculture every day of the week if I serve as Premier.
00:57:08 All right.
00:57:09 Miss Ahir.
00:57:10 Thank you.
00:57:11 first farmers feed Alberta and Alberta feeds the world and the federal government can't have it
00:57:16 both ways you can't put forward a carbon tax not show your work and show that there's been any
00:57:21 emissions reductions and then go after another sector it doesn't work that way so they need to
00:57:26 show their work but quite frankly if they're going to do this they need to subsidize our farmers out
00:57:30 here for their field monitors I really believe that our farmers probably know how much nitrogen
00:57:34 is in the ground at any given time because it actually costs a lot of money to put fertilizer
00:57:39 are on the in the entire product is being is about food production we have food insecurity right now
00:57:45 and anything that attacks that is a very very serious concern regardless of the government
00:57:50 regardless of the situation so how about we talk to our experts let's talk to our farmers pretty
00:57:54 sure they could tell you right now how much nitrogen is in the ground all right miss smith 45
00:57:59 seconds i've been spending a lot of time reading the constitution as you can imagine and section 95
00:58:04 does talk about how the provinces take the lead right in my reading on immigration and agriculture
00:58:09 because it says that the federal government may from time to time pass legislation in this area
00:58:15 this is the reason it's important to establish the alberta sovereignty act so that we can go
00:58:19 back to the original relationship that we had with with the federal government and push back against
00:58:24 them in a meaningful way when they come through with a dumb rule like labeling our ground beef
00:58:29 is unsafe or by trying to force an arbitrary reduction in fertilizer use, we would just say
00:58:35 we will not enforce that. We've got a number of companies here in the natural gas business who
00:58:40 can very easily help to make fertilizer. We have the ability to support our farmers by approving
00:58:45 those projects so they are never left short. 45 seconds is tough. Any other takers? We're moving
00:58:51 on. All right. Get it out. Give them a round of applause.
00:58:59 all right question four mr lowland we're coming back to you and the question is going to be on
00:59:03 inflation the cost of living in alberta and around the globe is getting more expensive
00:59:09 significant price increases for gas food eating our homes and electricity coupled with skyrocketing
00:59:15 inflation have all negatively affected alberta families and in particular our seniors first
00:59:20 nations and other vulnerable communities if alberta's primary value proposition is an affordable
00:59:26 high quality of life? How will you work to ensure this for everyone? And what specifically would you
00:59:31 do to limit the negative inflationary pressures put on Albertans? Two minutes.
00:59:36 Yes, thank you very much. We've seen inflation, of course, rise across, well, around the world,
00:59:42 but particularly here in Alberta, we've been in a real tough position. We've seen the price of fuel
00:59:48 rise up. We've seen the cost of everything rise here in Alberta. And it's always easy to point our
00:59:52 We have $1.3 trillion of debt in Ottawa and they are printing money like it is going
01:00:00 out of style.
01:00:01 We always look at Ottawa and point our fingers at them.
01:00:04 Right here in Alberta, we have $112 billion worth of debt.
01:00:07 We are paying $2.7 billion a year in interest on that debt.
01:00:11 Interest rates are rising.
01:00:13 We have a situation right here in Alberta where we have been spending way too much money.
01:00:18 We have always complained about the NDP and when we look back at the last NDP budget,
01:00:22 I know conservatives were lighting their hair on fire, how much it was and how much was being spent.
01:00:26 But when we look at our own budget now, 10% more than the NDP did in their last budget.
01:00:32 And so we're seeing this excessive growth in the economy, or sorry, in debt here in Alberta.
01:00:39 And that's growing and growing.
01:00:41 And that's affecting the cost of everything right here.
01:00:43 So we need to take the surpluses that we have.
01:00:46 We need to pay down that debt as soon as possible.
01:00:48 We all look at Ralph Klein's days when he held the sign paid in full up and how proud we were to actually pay off our debt and get our province back under control.
01:00:57 But we've slipped since then.
01:00:59 We've slipped and we've watched that debt grow and grow.
01:01:03 And even our sustainability fund has been spent.
01:01:05 It's gone.
01:01:06 We look at the Heritage Trust Fund account.
01:01:09 We've spent the interest off it every year since it was first started back in Lougheed days.
01:01:13 Now, if we had just left that interest in the heritage savings account, we'd probably
01:01:18 have about $100 billion in it, but we siphoned it off every year.
01:01:23 And so we're great at spending, not very good at saving, and now we need to get back
01:01:27 on track so that we can start paying down our debt and make Albertans proud again and
01:01:32 get things back so we can start spending that money on things Albertans need instead
01:01:36 of on interest.
01:01:37 Thank you.
01:01:37 All right.
01:01:38 Okay.
01:01:39 Who would you like to debate on this topic?
01:01:41 Travis Davies.
01:01:42 All right, Mr. Taves, you'll have a minute and a half to answer the question.
01:01:46 If Alberta's primary value proposition is an affordable, high quality of life, how will you work to ensure this for everyone?
01:01:52 And what specifically would you do to limit negative inflationary pressure on Albertans?
01:01:57 Yeah, that's a great question.
01:01:59 I appreciate Todd choosing me to debate this issue because this is a question on so many Albertans' minds.
01:02:04 Look, as Minister of Finance, I was really clear.
01:02:07 in terms of fiscal policy from the government,
01:02:10 the best thing governments can do,
01:02:12 the most beneficial and durable thing governments can do
01:02:14 during times of inflation is spend less, borrow less, and tax less.
01:02:18 That's ultimately what we need to do.
01:02:20 That's what I did as the Minister of Finance on a couple of fronts.
01:02:23 Firstly, I had the privilege of suspending our fuel tax in this province,
01:02:27 saving Albertans $1.3 billion on an annualized basis.
01:02:32 I would make that fuel tax suspension program permanent
01:02:35 by the privilege of serving Albertans as premier.
01:02:38 Here's the other good news about that piece.
01:02:40 On an annualized basis, because the federal government collects GST on the total fuel bill,
01:02:44 we keep about $65 to $70 million right here in Alberta in terms of federal transfers
01:02:50 when we suspend the fuel tax.
01:02:52 That's a bonus.
01:02:53 The other thing we need to do, and I agree with Todd on fiscal sustainability
01:02:57 and fiscal responsibility, it truly matters.
01:03:00 What I disagree with him on is spending.
01:03:03 We held operational spending flat for the first three years of our mandate.
01:03:09 That's how we got to fiscal discipline.
01:03:11 That's how we got to a balanced budget.
01:03:13 We balanced the budget on $70, $69, and $66 oil.
01:03:18 Fiscal discipline will continue to matter.
01:03:20 Reinvestment in the Heritage Saving Trust Fund will matter,
01:03:23 but debt repayment is priority number one.
01:03:26 All right.
01:03:26 Okay, Mr. Lowen, kick us off.
01:03:28 Three minutes of open debate.
01:03:30 We'll start with you.
01:03:31 Yeah, thank you very much.
01:03:31 So, yeah, Mr. Taves, I guess I just want to maybe challenge a little bit on that.
01:03:36 You kind of said, well, we kept the line flat on operational spending.
01:03:41 But still, the NDP's last budget was $56 billion, and our last budget was $62 billion.
01:03:46 That's over a 10% difference, and so we're obviously spending more than the NDP did.
01:03:51 I would like to jump in here.
01:03:55 Sure, I'm going to jump in on this one because misinformation is not helpful for Albertans.
01:04:00 There was additional costs related to the pandemic that were health related.
01:04:05 I asked my department early days, break anything COVID related out of operational spending for two reasons.
01:04:11 Number one, we couldn't monitor our progress on bringing down operational spending and bringing discipline to our departments.
01:04:18 Number two, I was certain department heads would want to build in that additional spending into their baseline budgets.
01:04:24 So we broke that out.
01:04:26 Operational spending did remain flat over the first three years of our term.
01:04:30 Had we continued on the NDP track, had we continued...
01:04:34 It's pretty easy, like I say, to separate just one little thing of the budget.
01:04:38 But again, the budget overall went from $56 billion to $63 billion.
01:04:42 And you want to take credit for the taxes reduction on fuel,
01:04:45 but that was Matt Jones's idea, actually, and he brought that one forward.
01:04:49 Now, how about de-indexing income tax?
01:04:52 You de-indexed income tax, and that's cost taxpayers of Alberta
01:04:54 more every single day since you've done that in 2019.
01:04:59 And so that's something that needs to change.
01:05:01 All right, let's let him match.
01:05:02 So yes, we held operational spending flat for three years.
01:05:07 Had we continued on the NDP course,
01:05:09 we wouldn't have projected a $500 million surplus.
01:05:12 It would have been a $6 billion deficit.
01:05:15 That would have been the result
01:05:17 had we not taken office and made the hard decisions.
01:05:20 We inherited a fiscal train wreck, friends,
01:05:23 a fiscal train wreck.
01:05:24 We worked hard to bring fiscal discipline to our spending,
01:05:27 setting a fiscal anchor of aligning our operating expenditures
01:05:30 with that of other provinces, which by this year, fiscal year 22-23,
01:05:35 we will have arrived at eliminating a $10 billion differential.
01:05:39 That was job number one in getting to a balanced budget.
01:05:42 Absolutely critical.
01:05:44 What you did inherit was high oil prices,
01:05:46 which of course has been very beneficial to the Alberta government.
01:05:49 And that's great.
01:05:50 All right.
01:05:51 That's great.
01:05:52 I need to jump in here because our budget was balanced, Todd, on oil prices of $70, $69, and $66.
01:06:02 We're in $100 oil right now.
01:06:04 That's going to leave Alberta with large surpluses, provided we can deliver fiscal discipline, which will be essential.
01:06:10 We will have to use those finances, those surpluses to pay down debt.
01:06:14 I'm trying to figure out where the fiscal discipline has happened since the NDP's budget.
01:06:18 Where did that fiscal discipline come in?
01:06:20 I haven't seen that.
01:06:21 i would i would ask mr lowen to actually read the financial statements in detail it's very
01:06:26 clear he's not done that he needs to go and do that dial it back come on folks we got to get
01:06:32 through debate here you haven't responded to the 56 billion versus 60. all right that's it folks
01:06:36 okay all right just a reminder audience we don't stop the clock so we got to keep going here right
01:06:41 we'll save the clapping all for the end i'm giving you that all right okay so do we have
01:06:46 anybody who wants to use their rebuttals on this okay i'm gonna go left to right miss it here start
01:06:50 Thank you so much.
01:06:52 I would like to talk about the operational
01:06:54 spending that was flat.
01:06:56 You balance the budget on the backs of our
01:06:58 children, their education and our vulnerable.
01:07:00 These are the things that got turned back just so
01:07:02 you understand where those dollars came from.
01:07:05 It didn't come just from fiscal responsibility.
01:07:08 It came from the government not keeping pace with
01:07:11 inflation as Todd was talking about.
01:07:13 I would like to apologize for that because we
01:07:14 used it as revenue in order to reduce the cost
01:07:17 of government.
01:07:18 We did not re-index AGE because we had promised
01:07:20 that we have to do immediately as well as alberta seniors benefits and catch up and be able to move
01:07:24 forward the dollars in this province that you spend your hard-earned tax money belongs with you
01:07:30 and helping you to build your province and make things move forward for all of us
01:07:35 this is not in a moment where you look at the bottom line all right now it's 45 seconds miss
01:07:40 smith 45 seconds to you uh i have read the financial statements in detail as i have since
01:07:45 1995 and i can tell you what they do say is that we had 16 billion dollars worth of resource revenue
01:07:51 last year and we spent 12 billion dollars of it so we have not gotten off the royalty revenue
01:07:59 roller coaster and more work needs to be done there i'm pleased to see just before we came on
01:08:03 that we're announcing an even larger surplus glad to see that we're going to start putting some more
01:08:08 in the savings plan i would have liked to have seen a dedicated debt repayment plan a dedicated
01:08:12 savings plan but on the issue of affordability i would say that i think that both travis and
01:08:17 and brian have come up with some good ideas for how to reduce electricity and energy costs the
01:08:22 next thing big thing we have to tackle is affordable housing and one of the all right
01:08:28 we're not going to get it we'll come back to that later yeah 45 seconds is quick i know miss sonny 0.82
01:08:33 well i do agree that inflation has made life difficult for many albertans and canadians it's
01:08:38 It's a global phenomenon brought on by higher commodity prices, supply chain issues, lockdowns
01:08:43 in Shanghai, and we have an opportunity, particularly now that we're recording such great surpluses,
01:08:48 to make sure that we invest in Albertans.
01:08:52 Now, Jason Kenney announced that he was indexing tax brackets today.
01:08:55 That's a good first step, but I would also assert that we do need to index seniors' benefits
01:09:00 and index benefits for AISH as well, because it's important when we're a wealthy province
01:09:05 and we're a government and we have surplus revenues.
01:09:08 If we can help, we absolutely should help
01:09:11 those Albertans who need it the most at this time.
01:09:14 All right, thank you.
01:09:15 Ms. Schultz.
01:09:17 Yeah, and absolutely, affordability is one of the top issues
01:09:19 that we hear wherever we go,
01:09:21 and I think many of the candidates do agree with that.
01:09:23 I mean, when people are talking about the cost of gas
01:09:25 or a gallon of milk or staying awake at night
01:09:28 wondering how they're going to put their kids in activities
01:09:30 to benefit their mental health and well-being,
01:09:33 this is something that matters,
01:09:34 And I would continue to suspend the fuel tax and take advice from some of my colleagues like Brian on some of his plans for looking at how we can make utilities more affordable for families as well.
01:09:44 I was also happy to see the government re-index personal income taxes.
01:09:48 I also put forward as bill number one being a plan to get us off of that energy roller coaster that we can invest in our future.
01:09:55 We can put 35% of the surplus away to save, 30% to invest in things like affordability measures, and 35% to paying down the debt.
01:10:03 All right. Mr. Jean, last 45 seconds. Over to you.
01:10:06 I'd like to thank the hardworking men and women in our agricultural sector and our oil and gas sector because they actually balanced the books.
01:10:12 They gave us the surplus, and they should be thanked for that.
01:10:15 Inflation is the biggest issue we have to deal with over the next few years, and that's why I suggested one of the first things I did was say,
01:10:22 you own the oil and gas here in Alberta. Why would you pay royalties on oil that you own?
01:10:27 So anything you consume as an Albertan, the 380,000 barrels a day that we consume as Albertans would be royalty-free.
01:10:33 That would save us 15 cents or so a litre.
01:10:35 That would give us some of the cheapest, most inexpensive gas, fuel, all across Canada.
01:10:40 Make us transportation hubs.
01:10:41 I'd also reduce the transmission and distribution charges on your home bills.
01:10:46 Make sure that comes down by a third, just through surpluses, but one thing I wouldn't
01:10:49 do is I wouldn't bring in net zero that would bring 12 times more expense, net zero.
01:10:56 I would not force companies to bring their emissions to net zero because folks, that
01:11:00 is dangerous.
01:11:01 $600 a ton. We can't afford it.
01:11:03 I know. It's 45 seconds. It's tough.
01:11:05 All right.
01:11:06 Okay, give him a round of applause, everybody.
01:11:08 I know you got it in you.
01:11:10 All right.
01:11:14 Okay, question number five.
01:11:16 Miss Ahir, this one is for you.
01:11:17 You'll have two minutes for your answer.
01:11:19 And the question subject is education.
01:11:22 Education, and equally, the opportunity for choice
01:11:25 within the public education system,
01:11:27 are a cornerstone of conservative politics.
01:11:29 post-secondary education is the natural next step in the 21st century economy.
01:11:35 Share with us your specific thoughts on education and feel free to talk about the entire continuum
01:11:40 or pick a specific area you think needs attention, but please give us solutions to what you see
01:11:46 are challenges within education today. Thank you very much and thank you for the question.
01:11:51 All of us in this room, and all of us actually on this stage, are a product of teachers.
01:11:57 And anyone who has grown up in Alberta, raised your kids here, and have gone through the public system like I did, understand the importance of our teachers and understand the importance of our system and our educators.
01:12:11 I absolutely believe in school choice.
01:12:13 And I also am a huge believer in our public system.
01:12:18 This is about strong education systems, and especially whether you were born here or whether you are an immigrant and you just arrived yesterday.
01:12:25 we just need to make sure that there's an even playing field for everyone so some of the things
01:12:30 that we hear about pretty regularly is about letting our teachers teach right now as you can
01:12:35 imagine in our education system there are multiple issues that are going on we have extreme complexity
01:12:40 in the classrooms between new people that are coming in with english as a second language
01:12:46 children like my own that are neurodiverse to the inclusion within classrooms and especially
01:12:51 and particularly coming out of COVID.
01:12:53 We have so many
01:12:55 issues that teachers are dealing with
01:12:57 and I think if we could just give a huge
01:12:59 shout out to our teachers, our administrators
01:13:01 and organizers, and when
01:13:03 you do a round of applause, make sure that that's
01:13:05 for them because of everything that they've
01:13:07 been through, but more than that, the resilience
01:13:09 that they have shown throughout this entire process.
01:13:12 When we talk about
01:13:13 education, the next word that has
01:13:15 to come in is funding.
01:13:17 We cannot be balancing our
01:13:19 budgets on the backs of our children
01:13:20 and their education regardless of whether we are in a surplus or if we are in a space where we are
01:13:28 lacking dollars in this province our children may not ever suffer from austerity teachers are our
01:13:34 partners they're not our adversaries and we need to trust our school boards to be able to make the
01:13:39 right decisions and alberta is competing competing with quebec and bc right now for international
01:13:43 ratings in math science and language and they have never cut their funding in the 21st century
01:13:49 All right. Thank you. Right on time. All right. Who would you like to debate on education?
01:13:54 I would like to debate Rajen, please. All right. Miss Ani, you have a minute and a half. Again,
01:13:58 the question is share with us your specific thoughts on education and feel free to talk
01:14:03 about the entire continuum or pick a specific area you think needs attention, but please give
01:14:08 us solutions to what you see are some of the challenges within education today. Yes. Thank
01:14:13 So, first of all, I've already spoken about my commitment to restart the curriculum review.
01:14:19 I do believe that it has been controversial from the beginning.
01:14:23 There are good elements to it, but obviously it hasn't been rolled out properly.
01:14:27 And we need to ensure that those who are intrinsic to the system, I've said this many times before,
01:14:32 and that includes teachers and academia and superintendents,
01:14:36 that they are on board with curriculum changes.
01:14:39 changes. Now let's talk about post-secondary education. I was talking to somebody recently
01:14:45 who pointed out to me that when you have a jurisdiction where you have high tuition,
01:14:50 you should also have high student aid. Right now in Alberta, that is not the case. We have
01:14:55 high tuition and low student aid. So one thing that I would like to do is to strategically
01:15:00 inject some funding into student aid so we can help students at a time when inflation
01:15:05 has hit them in so many different ways. The other program that I'm quite proud of in
01:15:09 government and it was in the 22 23 budget is a program that encourages health care workers
01:15:16 to work in rural communities in exchange for forgiveness of some of their student debt i
01:15:21 think this is an excellent program rural communities need more health care workers
01:15:26 that's a reality and to incentivize young people to choose a career in health care and serve those
01:15:32 communities that need it the most is an excellent way to ensure that we address that labor shortage
01:15:37 i think we need to double down on this particular program all right ready for debate we've got three
01:15:43 minutes is here why don't you kick us off yeah thank you so in speaking and we were a few of
01:15:49 us were at the i think most of us were there at the panel at the um with the ata one of the things
01:15:55 that became very apparent was the lack of consultation on our curriculum and when you
01:16:01 think about how important that is and if you talk to school authority school boards all of us in
01:16:05 here know we have kids, we have grandkids, we have families that are being impacted by this.
01:16:10 The biggest concern that came out from this was the inability for us to actually be able to not
01:16:14 only market what we were doing, but to share that information and to bring teachers and curriculum
01:16:19 advisors and school authorities on board. But one of the main things that came up and what we have
01:16:25 to be able to commit to is to grow funding based on population growth, inflation and enrollment
01:16:30 growth and i know that rajan was talking about inflation but all right well let's let's let her
01:16:34 talk about that thank you i don't think there's anything that leela is saying that i don't uh
01:16:39 agree with absolutely there wasn't enough consultation on the curriculum we have heard
01:16:44 that from from many folks and i had set up a working group actually in my constituency
01:16:49 comprised of teachers and conservative teachers they supported me in my nomination and they came
01:16:53 back with a series of recommendations and one of the biggest recommendations obviously was to start
01:16:59 from the beginning but i do want to go back to the importance of advanced education because we've
01:17:04 talked about k-12 there's a lot of agreement on that we want to ensure that we keep our kids here
01:17:10 we're having a problem with brain drain that is something that is going to impact how we can grow
01:17:15 our economy and i don't disagree with anything that rajan is saying education right across the
01:17:23 the board not only that do we need to look at what Roger is talking about with
01:17:29 advanced education but we have to consider the supports that are in the
01:17:32 classroom as well too and this is one of the things that we don't talk about
01:17:35 enough our teachers are not able to teach they are dealing with multiple
01:17:40 issues and the complex classrooms in particular that were underfunded not
01:17:45 only by our government but were used as an ability to be able to balance the
01:17:49 budget. When you have a school authority and you have reserve funding, you hear all about the
01:17:55 reserve funding throughout the province and all of the school authorities, why are they not being
01:18:00 given the flexibility to use those dollars as they need to? Instead, there's this dictatorship
01:18:05 coming from on high telling them that you have to use this particular dollar for this. I think,
01:18:10 again, we're all in agreement, or most of us are, in terms of the funding that is required to be
01:18:15 re-injected back into the education system and a concerted focus on reviewing the curriculum
01:18:21 I just do want to go back to the importance of post-secondary education once again because
01:18:26 and I'm just going to tie this all back to one of the worst things that could possibly happen
01:18:31 is if we have this thoughtless legislation that is brought forward that is going to cause
01:18:36 additional chaos that's going to prevent people from wanting to move into our province you know
01:18:41 So livability is something that people look at when they want to move into this province.
01:18:46 And education is one of those.
01:18:47 Okay, let's move on to our 45-second rebuttals.
01:18:50 Mr. Lowen, anybody else here?
01:18:52 Mr. Taves, Ms. Smith.
01:18:53 All right, Mr. Lowen, go ahead.
01:18:54 Yes, thank you very much.
01:18:55 I think one of the main things we do need to realize with our education system,
01:18:58 we need to respect the choice in education that we have in Alberta.
01:19:03 And we need to have our education focused on the basics
01:19:05 and not so much on the social values and family values and things like that.
01:19:09 It is interesting when we talk about the curriculum, the curriculum has been going along
01:19:14 for quite a while, now it's been announced and made on the table, and now we see a lot
01:19:18 of the cabinet ministers backpedaling on the curriculum when they never said anything
01:19:21 about it before, so that's interesting to see, but one of my main concerns right now
01:19:26 is our post-secondary education system, where it's not graduating the professionals that
01:19:30 we need, for instance in health, we have to bring doctors and nurses from all across
01:19:35 the world and we're running short right now but our post-secondary education system isn't keeping
01:19:39 up that needs to change all right mr tach 45 seconds all right first principle parents are
01:19:45 the individuals primarily responsible for their children's education full stop no it's only 45
01:19:52 seconds don't jump in now i support choice in education and if i serve albertans as premier
01:19:57 i will bring in transportation funding for independent schools i support curriculum reform
01:20:03 a focus on core disciplines of numeracy, literacy, and a fact-based education.
01:20:09 Activist ideology has no place in a curriculum.
01:20:12 It has to be removed.
01:20:13 All right, all right, audience.
01:20:15 Come on.
01:20:16 Let's dial it down, folks.
01:20:18 Remember, we got 45 seconds.
01:20:19 These are quick answers.
01:20:20 Clap at the end.
01:20:21 Lastly, we didn't cut education funding.
01:20:23 I'm sorry.
01:20:24 That's reset now for Ms. Smith.
01:20:26 They seem to like what you had to say, but, you know, we got to move on.
01:20:28 Well, the thing about K-12 education is it may be the only area that Ottawa hasn't interfered in to try to tell us how to run things.
01:20:36 That's how every single one of our social programs should be run.
01:20:39 And that is the reason why we have an Alberta Sovereignty Act, is to push them back into their lane so that we're able to deliver our programs the way we want to deliver them.
01:20:48 Where I'm worried the most about in the fall session is that we've seen in Western University,
01:20:53 that university make the decision that they're going to force their post-secondary students to
01:20:58 be vaccinated to attend classes if i'm elected we will not do that not in post-secondary not in k-12
01:21:05 no more masks no more lockdowns no more taking kids out of their activities and we have to
01:21:11 be sure that we test every child and give them the tutoring support to bring them up to grade
01:21:15 level and the learning loss they've had all right we got to catch you there mr g
01:21:18 well 45 seconds is not very long um but i just don't understand and one of the questions i had
01:21:26 for the cabinet ministers is why did the relationship get so bad with our teachers
01:21:29 and administrators it just doesn't make sense to me so talking about what we need to solve we need
01:21:33 to solve the relationship and that means it's all about communication it's all about meeting with
01:21:37 them i couldn't believe that ministers wouldn't meet with the ata to have discussions it's about
01:21:42 looking for outcomes looking for opportunities to find common ground to bring people together
01:21:46 To be less divisive in our education system, I think that's pretty easy to do,
01:21:50 especially if we take politics out of the education system.
01:21:53 We didn't like it before.
01:21:54 Why would we like it now?
01:21:55 It's not good for our kids.
01:21:56 I have a three-and-a-half-year-old.
01:21:57 I can't imagine anything more important than getting our education right.
01:22:00 We need to make sure that our post-secondary is there for Albertans,
01:22:04 and I would make sure that Albertans get our post-secondary spaces first.
01:22:07 That's it.
01:22:07 Okay, Ms. Schultz, 45 seconds.
01:22:09 Yeah, and I would agree that parents know what is best for their kids.
01:22:12 That's why I am a supporter of parent choice,
01:22:14 And I think when we talk about opposition to parent choice, the question is actually usually about funding.
01:22:19 So what I hear in my constituency, what I hear across Alberta is teachers saying, you know, I have a number of complex kids in my classroom.
01:22:26 Parents saying my kid is in that classroom and they need support.
01:22:29 Meanwhile, government is saying school divisions make the decision.
01:22:32 School divisions saying government's not giving them enough money.
01:22:34 We have that conversation instead of actually trying to solve the problem that we've got, which is class size and complexity.
01:22:40 and making sure that tax dollars are, in fact, going to kids and teachers in the classroom.
01:22:45 I do believe in the importance of mental health, supporting mental health and true wraparound supports in schools.
01:22:50 And post-secondary is important.
01:22:51 We need to continue to incentivize innovation, research, and value for tax money.
01:22:56 All right. Well, thank you.
01:22:57 I'm being told by the people in my ear, Mr. Taves, we did reset the clock quick,
01:23:00 so you have 15 seconds if you want to say anything last minute on education.
01:23:03 I do. We held education funding flat for three years,
01:23:07 but we honoured our commitment and we didn't cut education funding that's an ata fallacy all right
01:23:12 okay there we go all right give them a round of applause and you know
01:23:21 okay before we get into question six just to remind all the candidates missa here you only
01:23:26 have one rebuttal left uh as does mr gene okay we've got two questions to go the first question
01:23:31 here question six is on arts and culture and it's for mr tapes all right tonight we find ourselves
01:23:38 at the citadel theater in an excellent example of arts and culture thriving in alberta festivals
01:23:44 cultural heritage events and even movie production is enriching all of our lives across the province
01:23:51 conservatives are often criticized for not doing enough for the arts yet the ucp government for
01:23:56 instance has done more to advance film and television production in alberta than any
01:24:01 other government in our province's history resulting in a soon-to-be billion dollar a year
01:24:05 business whether it's live festival performances or the value created by creative industries
01:24:12 help us understand your vision and perspective on the future of arts and culture in alberta
01:24:17 you have two minutes all right i mean firstly i find it ironic that an individual who's an
01:24:21 accountant a rancher and a previous finance minister gets the arts and culture question
01:24:26 You know, when it comes to culture, I often think agriculture right off the bat, but seriously, seriously, I recognize the importance of a strong arts and culture sector.
01:24:38 I know that tens of thousands of Albertans absolutely thrive on a strong sector, thrive going to theater, pursuing disciplines in the arts, and it is critically important.
01:24:52 You know, at a time when we're looking to attract other people from Canada and around the world into the province of Alberta, it's critical that we have a very robust arts and culture scene, and I recognize its importance.
01:25:05 And, you know, arts and culture are quite broad.
01:25:09 Arts and culture include going to the opera at the Jubilee.
01:25:13 It also includes protecting our history and ensuring that we can protect our heritage at our museums, such as the Glenbow or even the Sam Center at the Calgary Stampede.
01:25:24 But it also includes ensuring that our youth have an opportunity to take dance lessons, play an instrument, learn an instrument, and even pursue a love of theater.
01:25:34 We've done much for the film and television industry.
01:25:37 We brought in a renewed reinvigorated tax credit that has worked.
01:25:41 We've taken a film and television industry that was about $100 million a year
01:25:45 and moved it to an industry that is getting closer to a billion dollars a year.
01:25:51 Friends, if you are passionate about theater, drama, and the arts,
01:25:55 right now is a great time to pursue a career in Alberta.
01:25:59 That time is now.
01:26:01 Look, the best thing we can do for a thriving arts and culture sector is ensure that we have a robust economy.
01:26:08 So Albertans with high-paying jobs can go out and pursue their passions, go to the entertainment they want to, and support the arts and culture scene.
01:26:16 Businesses and individuals also support capital projects when we have a strong economy.
01:26:21 All right. Okay. So who would you like to debate on arts and culture?
01:26:24 You know, I'm going to go to a previous culture minister, Lila here.
01:26:31 All right, Miss Ahiri, you have a minute and a half, whether it's live festival performances
01:26:35 or the value created by creative industries.
01:26:38 Help us understand your vision and perspective on the future of arts and culture in Alberta.
01:26:43 Go ahead.
01:26:43 Thank you very much.
01:26:44 Arts and heritage and cultural industries, recreation and sports contribute.
01:26:48 Just so you know, the culture industry is part of a strong economy.
01:26:54 It's not as a result of one.
01:26:56 It's actually part of the entire economy.
01:26:59 $6.1 billion in our economy and creates more than 65,000 jobs a year.
01:27:08 And those are older statistics.
01:27:10 It has grown immensely, especially post-COVID.
01:27:14 Just to give you an idea as well, too, in our province, for the 4.3 million people we have,
01:27:20 1.3 million of them are volunteers and many of them are in that sector because, as Mr.
01:27:26 Taves was saying, people are driving to ballet and to hockey and all of those parents and everybody
01:27:31 who contributes, thousands of ours, I'm sure many of you have, contribute to that economy. I'd also
01:27:36 like to bring up that when arts and culture thrive in our province, Alberta thrives. And not only are
01:27:44 we seeing that homegrown talent here, and I wanted to talk a little bit, just for a few seconds,
01:27:48 about the film tax credit. I remember, and you know, Mr. Taves, you can probably talk about this
01:27:54 little bit when we first came to you to talk about that tax credit and that tax credit was turned
01:27:59 away because they didn't believe in a tax credit they didn't believe that for every dollar that we
01:28:03 put into the film industry that five would be created i'm really glad that the tone has changed
01:28:08 and that that came around but boy oh boy was it ever hard to convince a conservative finance
01:28:13 minister to invest in film we're gonna we're gonna stop there before we get into open debate here
01:28:19 miss smith i should have reminded you you have one rebuttal left as well should you choose to
01:28:22 it for this question all right open debate mr davis kick us off you know i i won't apologize
01:28:28 for having to see the value proposition on a filament and television tax credit because i
01:28:34 believe handling alberton's taxpayer dollars needs to be done very responsibly and carefully
01:28:40 but there was a value proposition and when that was adequately demonstrated we went forth and
01:28:45 approved the funding in the budget and it proved to be the right decision because right now we're
01:28:49 We're seeing, again, not only hundreds of millions pushing almost a billion dollars of film and television productions in Alberta annually,
01:28:58 but we're seeing permanent studios and infrastructure built, investment coming back to Alberta.
01:29:03 So it's interesting that we're having this conversation because when we were having the discussions originally with the sector,
01:29:09 when they came here, when the sector is moving, imagine that all over the world, everybody is competing for these dollars right now, everyone.
01:29:16 And there are things that are changing in the United States right now where they're changing their tax laws and everything.
01:29:21 In fact, even rolling back human rights in certain states in the United States.
01:29:26 People are leveraging that and coming to Alberta.
01:29:29 It is now a billion-dollar industry.
01:29:31 And we did show our work.
01:29:33 We did prove that this was possible.
01:29:35 We did bring that forward.
01:29:36 I'm very grateful that we actually had the ability to find this as we came forward.
01:29:40 But having said that, how many billions of dollars did we miss out on by not jumping in at the very end?
01:29:45 With all due respect, your first business proposition, the valuation you provided did not cut it.
01:29:52 And that's why it simply wasn't perfect.
01:29:53 You see the eye rolling?
01:29:54 That's exactly what we saw when we brought in the value proposition the first time.
01:29:58 So here's my premise.
01:30:01 I believe in the value of a thriving arts and culture sector.
01:30:06 And we know that's a broad spectrum.
01:30:08 Everything from opera to ensuring that families have opportunities to enroll their children in drama, dance,
01:30:14 or play an instrument, you name it.
01:30:17 It's broad, it's important to the province.
01:30:19 But this is my other observation.
01:30:22 You know what?
01:30:22 That sector thrives when we have a strong economy
01:30:25 for two reasons.
01:30:26 Number one, when we ensure that we have
01:30:28 a very competitive business environment,
01:30:30 it attracts investment.
01:30:32 It attracts investment into areas of the arts
01:30:35 and entertainment, which grows in the economy.
01:30:37 When you're talking about a competitive environment,
01:30:39 particularly for the film industry,
01:30:41 they actually come to you with their value proposition,
01:30:43 what they're looking for.
01:30:44 They're just looking for an even playing field that is not only here, but across the United States.
01:30:49 Talk to any Bollywood film organizer that wants to come to Alberta.
01:30:52 They all want to come here because of our beautiful, beautiful areas that they're able to do all of this.
01:30:57 And it's billions of dollars that are possible to be able to come in.
01:31:00 But we weren't willing to look past that until the – I'm not really sure what –
01:31:05 There are –
01:31:06 originally there are lots of people who will come to alberta if you pay them to come
01:31:17 what we need is a valid business isn't that what we did with oil and gas
01:31:24 i'm sure the sector will be happy to hear that the minister paid them to come all right all right
01:31:29 all right yeah well it's like we've all learned how to debate hey all right 45 second rebuttals
01:31:37 miss sonny i have you are there any other takers mr lowen miss schultz miss smith all right miss
01:31:43 sonny kick us off hey thank you so several weeks ago the city of calgary was recognized as the
01:31:48 fourth best place in the world to live and this is based on livability indices and those livability
01:31:54 Indices include education, healthcare, infrastructure, entertainment, and culture.
01:32:00 So investments in culture are not frill or frou-frou.
01:32:03 There is definitely a valid value proposition there.
01:32:06 Absolutely.
01:32:06 And there's more expenditure done by companies like Amazon, on Google, on investments in culture.
01:32:13 And when you're looking to attract investment, especially now that our film industry is growing,
01:32:18 people who can live anywhere in the world, like San Francisco, Tokyo, London,
01:32:22 they will choose to come to Alberta
01:32:24 because of our livability index
01:32:26 and that includes investments in culture.
01:32:29 All right, Mr. Law, 15, 45 seconds.
01:32:32 Yes, thank you very much.
01:32:33 When it comes to culture,
01:32:36 I think it needs to come from the people
01:32:37 and not from government.
01:32:38 So I don't know how much government
01:32:40 should be involved in deciding
01:32:41 what needs to be done for arts and culture.
01:32:43 But one thing I see that was frustrating
01:32:45 over the last couple of years
01:32:46 is we had a lot of our kids
01:32:48 that were stopped from going to dance lessons
01:32:49 and music lessons because of the COVID response.
01:32:52 And I think that was a horrible shame.
01:32:54 Now, my brother's a music teacher,
01:32:56 and so I got to hear it firsthand almost daily
01:32:59 while he was without business for months and months and months
01:33:02 because kids couldn't do that.
01:33:04 But also when it comes to culture, we have to think about religion too.
01:33:08 And again, we had churches shut down.
01:33:09 We had pastors jailed.
01:33:11 And this government and these ministers were involved in that.
01:33:13 And we even had the Minister of Justice
01:33:15 actually endorse one of the candidates too.
01:33:17 And so that was frustrating to see.
01:33:20 Ms. Schultz, 45 seconds. 0.76
01:33:22 You know, I agree that this is absolutely an important aspect that brings people here to Alberta, quality of life.
01:33:29 People come for opportunity and jobs and that hope and optimism, that promise of Alberta that if you're willing to work hard, you can be who and whatever you want to be.
01:33:37 But it's great to know that we have a thriving theatre and music and dance and cultural sector.
01:33:44 That helps not only keep people here, but attract people here as well.
01:33:48 So, yes, the film and television tax credit, it really did change the game for us.
01:33:51 And I was grateful for those on this stage, but also those like Minister Schweitzer, the Premier, who supported those changes.
01:33:58 It put us back on the map, whether we're talking about Ghostbusters, The Last of Us, Fargo.
01:34:02 But it's also about fishing, hiking, museums, history.
01:34:05 And we have a great story to tell.
01:34:07 We need to continue to tell that story as it's a huge economic driver for us.
01:34:10 Thank you very much.
01:34:11 Ms. Smith.
01:34:13 Oh, thank you.
01:34:14 I should probably set the record straight about where the tax credit idea came from.
01:34:18 It was Blake Peterson, one of our MLAs, but I was Wild Rose MLA.
01:34:21 It got a unanimous approval in the legislature.
01:34:25 I'm quite pleased that the government finally implemented it.
01:34:28 One of the things I find interesting about how we're talking is that we're talking about
01:34:32 culture as an import rather than an export.
01:34:35 We're talking about people coming here to tell their stories.
01:34:38 To me, and this idea was planted with me by Todd Babiak, one of our novelists in the Edmonton
01:34:43 area we need to think about culture as an export we have so many great stories to tell from our
01:34:50 muslim community coming here to fur trade with our first nations from the the sikh men and women 0.96
01:34:56 who helped recover after frank slide to the chinese immigrants those are the stories we
01:35:02 need to be lots of things on 45 seconds all right okay so we've now got mr lowen mr gene
01:35:08 Ms. Schultz, Ms. Sani, Ms. Smith, you've used all yours, and Ms. Ahir, everybody has one left,
01:35:14 so this is it, question seven, the final question. But before we do that, get it out of your system,
01:35:18 go on. Okay, question seven is a big one, and the question's for Ms. Smith. All right,
01:35:29 you'll have two minutes to answer this question. It's on energy and the future economy. We're all
01:35:36 incensed by Ottawa's recent comments about no business case for gas to Europe as if Ottawa
01:35:41 knows anything about the energy industry. I think all candidates would agree that this is an
01:35:47 outrageous position for our federal government to take and you've all expressed your plans with
01:35:52 respect to relations with Ottawa. Let's talk then about how you see our world-class energy industry
01:35:59 contributing to the future economy and how will you ensure greater diversification of energy in
01:36:04 order to grow the Alberta Advantage. Ms. Smith, you have two minutes. You're going to be even more
01:36:09 outraged when you realize just how badly we were treated by Justin Trudeau. I knew that the
01:36:13 Chancellor was coming and I had some people trying to work on getting me to meet with them while he
01:36:18 was visiting Alberta. They cut out the Alberta part of the trip. They made sure that it was only
01:36:24 in Eastern Canada. They did a token press conference talking about how we might in the
01:36:31 future use wind turbines to create green hydrogen. This was an absolute slap in our face. And we have
01:36:37 to remember this, that every single time we try to ask Ottawa to engage with us, they push back
01:36:44 against us. Heck, when we passed the equalization referendum saying that we wanted to start a new
01:36:49 relationship, what did they give us? They gave us Stephen Gilbeau, the most anti-oil and anti-fertilizer
01:36:55 and anti-natural gas minister we could possibly ever have. So this is why the Alberta Sovereignty
01:37:00 act is important it gets us in a sovereign frame of mind and what would happen is if we were in a
01:37:05 sovereign frame of mind well you know what would happen we would stop expecting ottawa to come in
01:37:10 and build economic corridors for us we would build them ourselves we've been out talking about this
01:37:14 since the 1930s ernest manning raised the idea let's start doing it let's work with our friends
01:37:19 in saskatchewan and manitoba let's work with our first nations partners there's 14 of them
01:37:23 that want to work with us on a corridor that would go to churchill we could do another corridor
01:37:27 Thunder Bay, another corridor to Tuktoyaktuk, and another corridor to Port-au-Prince-Rupert,
01:37:31 we would be able to build rail lines, we would be able to build pipelines, we would be able to
01:37:35 build transmission lines, broadband internet infrastructure. And we turn the table on Ottawa.
01:37:40 Do you see what Ottawa does to us? They invade our jurisdiction time and time and time again.
01:37:45 They make us go to court, spend lots of money, and also take years of time keeping their law in
01:37:52 place where we try to overturn it. I would double dog dare them to take us to court if we were
01:37:58 starting to build pipelines with our First Nations partners and bringing our, not only our product to
01:38:02 market, but also bringing good paying jobs and prosperity to those communities, because I tell
01:38:07 you, we would win it. All right, that's two minutes. Hold it to the end here, folks. Hold it
01:38:13 Until the end, let's hold it to the end.
01:38:16 Double dog dare, I haven't heard that one in a while.
01:38:22 Who would you like to debate on energy
01:38:24 and the future economy?
01:38:25 I'd like to debate Travis.
01:38:27 All right, Mr. Taves, the question again.
01:38:29 How do you see our world-class energy industry
01:38:32 contributing to the future economy
01:38:34 and how will you ensure greater diversification of energy
01:38:36 in order to grow the Alberta advantage?
01:38:38 You have a minute and a half.
01:38:39 Sure, I appreciate being able to contribute
01:38:42 and debate on this question.
01:38:43 It's a very important question.
01:38:44 Firstly, with respect to our world-class energy industry,
01:38:48 I don't believe that economic diversification,
01:38:51 whether it's within energy or whether it's more broadly in the economy,
01:38:54 and a robust energy industry are mutually exclusive.
01:38:57 I believe that both can thrive.
01:39:00 In fact, we're seeing that now.
01:39:01 We're seeing the energy industry start to get its legs under it again
01:39:04 after really seven really, really tough years.
01:39:07 At the same time, we're seeing economic diversification
01:39:10 in this province at rates I've not seen in my lifetime.
01:39:13 So that's incredibly good news.
01:39:16 But we do have a federal government who is completely blind to the realities globally right now.
01:39:23 You know, when I was as finance minister, I was in New York about four or five months ago.
01:39:27 Every conversation I had with the investment community morphed to energy and food security.
01:39:33 It was amazing.
01:39:35 Every conversation morphed there, and I didn't do it.
01:39:38 The sad part was on my way home, I stopped and met with bond rating agencies, even some bank leaders in Toronto, a completely different conversation.
01:39:47 It's like they hadn't read the news. It was ridiculous. 0.87
01:39:50 Friends, we have to lead on energy. There's ways we can do it. 0.68
01:39:54 It's about bringing a Senator Joe Manchin to Alberta to demonstrate the value of this province and this industry on North American energy security.
01:40:01 I agree with resource corridors, absolutely critical, but we can't wave a magic wand and get rid of federal law.
01:40:08 That is simply a fallacy.
01:40:10 All right. There we go.
01:40:13 Okay. So we're going to move into open debate now.
01:40:15 Ms. Smith, why don't you kick us off? 0.80
01:40:17 I'm happy to.
01:40:18 I'm always surprised when I raise this issue because Travis has criticized my Alberta Sovereignty Act in almost every forum I've been with him.
01:40:24 But he doesn't promote the idea that he's advancing, which is to violate the Constitution, Section 121.
01:40:31 and impose tariffs on other companies and other jurisdictions
01:40:36 to punish them in retaliation for the decisions Ottawa makes.
01:40:40 Now, I would love for him to explain that policy, honestly,
01:40:43 because if you think that that's a better policy,
01:40:45 then you at least know that there are two people who have different ideas.
01:40:47 I would absolutely like to jump in.
01:40:50 And you know what?
01:40:51 One thing I don't do with that piece on my plan to strengthen Alberta
01:40:55 is over-promise and under-delivered.
01:40:56 The Sovereignty Act, friends, is a false bill of goods.
01:40:59 If it's implemented as it's been envisioned by the Free Alberta strategy, it will create chaos within this business environment.
01:41:07 It will send tens of billions of dollars packing out of this province.
01:41:11 It will undo all of the gains that we've made in the last three years.
01:41:15 If it's implemented in a soft way, not in the way it was envisioned by the folks at Free Alberta, it will be completely benign.
01:41:24 It will do no good.
01:41:25 It's a false bill of goods.
01:41:27 I would ask Danielle, what Sovereignty Act are you talking about today?
01:41:31 The one that chases tens of billions of dollars out of this province or the one that's completely benign, over-promising and under-delivering?
01:41:39 Because that matters. That truly matters.
01:41:40 All right, Ms. Smith, let's see what you have to say on that.
01:41:42 I think the only one who created chaos was the ministers who were involved in the Priorities and Planning Committee that shut down businesses arbitrarily, that shut down our economy arbitrarily.
01:41:53 Don't cut into time, folks. Don't cut into time.
01:41:55 that punished Jim's for no reason.
01:41:57 And we've seen it in court.
01:41:58 There was actually no reason to do it.
01:41:59 It was all political.
01:42:00 They have the ability to do that.
01:42:01 They created chaos.
01:42:02 But you see that Travis didn't answer the question,
01:42:05 and he always does that
01:42:06 because he wants to violate the Constitution, Section 121.
01:42:09 I just want to enforce the Constitution.
01:42:11 He wants to punish businesses
01:42:13 who want to invest in this country.
01:42:14 I'm happy to deal with that question.
01:42:16 I'm absolutely happy to deal with that question
01:42:18 because I would.
01:42:19 I would ensure, I would bring in legislation
01:42:22 that ensures that Alberta,
01:42:23 if pushed into a corner,
01:42:24 can come out with a response and it would be a response that would include both tariff and
01:42:31 non-tariff pushback options again we would calibrate our response there are about 13
01:42:37 provisions in terms of the Canada free trade agreement where Alberta is out ahead we could
01:42:42 immediately cancel any one of those or all of those and we would not be violating the Canada
01:42:47 free trade agreement and there might be a time where Alberta would have to push beyond that
01:42:53 all right last 20 seconds i just want to be clear that section 121 of the constitution says that we
01:42:58 cannot stop the free flow of goods with tariffs between our jurisdictions so i know that travis
01:43:04 likes to say that my plan would create chaos i'm telling you that plan would create chaos
01:43:08 it would create chaos they would not know which industries are going to be targeted
01:43:13 and for what reason and you know what if you if you got a fight with ottawa pick the fight with
01:43:17 Ottawa. All right, that's it. Give him a round of applause.
01:43:22 Okay, going into rebuttals here, Ms. Soni, you do have two open, but you can't use them back-to-back,
01:43:27 so you get one now. So we're going to start with you, Ms. Ahiri, then you, then Ms. Schultz,
01:43:32 Mr. Lewin. Okay, all right, Ms. Soni, 45 seconds. Okay, so when it comes to energy,
01:43:37 we do have a great story to tell. Obviously we have challenges, but we've done so much in this
01:43:42 space and the transition to energy is underway when we're talking about carbon and we're talking
01:43:47 about hydrogen as well. But one of the ways to protect the energy industry is from protecting
01:43:54 it from damaging government policies. Let's go down memory lane. Think about the National Energy
01:43:58 Program. Think about the Royalty Review. And now we're talking about legislation that is going to
01:44:03 bring additional constitutional kegmire and turmoil into Alberta. And I've got to tell you,
01:44:09 Danielle, that a sovereign frame of mind does nothing for those on Bay Street and Wall Street
01:44:14 when they're doing their analysis and trying to convince investors to bring their investments
01:44:18 into a stable and predictable environment. It's not going to work. I don't even know if that is a
01:44:23 sovereign frame of mind. All too often the debate about energy gets reduced to a yelling match over
01:44:30 pollution and profits and Albertans know that the importance of their clean earth, air and water
01:44:35 and successful economy have to be aligned because Alberta energy powers,
01:44:39 Albertan and Canadian families and could possibly fuel the world
01:44:43 if we should get these things figured out.
01:44:45 But it is really, really hard to negotiate new trade agreements
01:44:49 when you are starting a bar brawl in the middle of confederation.
01:44:54 We need to actually be able to figure this out and have a conversation,
01:44:56 build some relationships here.
01:44:58 Has anybody ever asked why?
01:45:00 Do we know why?
01:45:01 Or are we just yelling into the spaces,
01:45:03 trying to maybe assume that something will stick
01:45:05 and at some point in time we'll be able to push back enough.
01:45:08 Let's build some relationships and let's get some stuff done.
01:45:11 All right, thank you.
01:45:12 Ms. Schultz.
01:45:13 Yeah, and I would echo what many of my colleagues on stage have said.
01:45:16 What our energy industry does not want is any legislation
01:45:19 that is going to drive people, jobs and investment
01:45:22 out of our province at a time like this.
01:45:25 I am curious, though, for Danielle,
01:45:27 if you are so against Justin Trudeau
01:45:29 and so for doing things on our own terms,
01:45:31 Why did you accept his net zero policies?
01:45:35 Yes, we need a credible climate plan.
01:45:37 Yes, we need to work on industry with what that looks like.
01:45:40 But buying into Trudeau's net zero plan is very confusing for those of us,
01:45:45 especially when you're saying that you want to do things our own way.
01:45:49 It doesn't make sense.
01:45:51 All right. Thank you. Mr. Lowen.
01:45:53 Yes, thank you very much.
01:45:54 Trudeau isn't trying to destroy the oil and gas industry.
01:45:57 He is destroying it.
01:45:58 You know, we don't need to apologize for our oil and gas industry.
01:46:02 There's no way I will ever do that.
01:46:04 The rest of the world needs to catch up to our oil and gas industry
01:46:06 instead of standing back and pointing fingers at us.
01:46:10 But for those that just want to talk to Ottawa
01:46:11 and just think that we can have this collegial conversation with Ottawa,
01:46:15 when is it going to get to the point where they actually want to do something?
01:46:18 We need to do something.
01:46:19 We need to build a firewall between us and Ottawa.
01:46:22 We actually have to start doing things like our own pension plan
01:46:24 and send Ottawa a message.
01:46:26 But they've already driven away so much investment here.
01:46:30 We've seen so many harmful actions from Ottawa.
01:46:32 And some of the candidates here, I think, are just willing to sit back and wait for things to happen,
01:46:37 and there'll be no change.
01:46:38 And that's unacceptable.
01:46:40 All right. Thank you, Mr. Lohan.
01:46:43 Okay. Mr. Jean.
01:46:46 Yes, I think Travis, Danielle, and Rebecca are right.
01:46:49 Danielle said that the Sovereignty Act is in the Constitution.
01:46:52 She's right.
01:46:52 we don't need the sovereignty act because everything she's suggesting should be in there
01:46:55 is already in the constitution which we actually have to go through to challenge ottawa if we're 0.99
01:46:59 going to challenge ottawa folks every single situation here today travis danielle rebecca
01:47:04 all of the options they have for constitutional challenges all have to go through the constitution
01:47:09 has to go through section 46 has to go through paragraph 69 it has to be challenged that way
01:47:14 and that is the only way we are going to get any attention from ottawa and get any resolution to
01:47:18 to what's bothering us.
01:47:19 There's more than just equalization.
01:47:21 There's more than getting our products to Tidewater.
01:47:23 There's the Senate.
01:47:24 There's the House of Commons.
01:47:25 There's making sure that we can go forward
01:47:27 and actually have our say and be treated fairly.
01:47:29 The only one that has a solution for economic woes is myself.
01:47:33 Please, take a look at it.
01:47:34 Let's stop there.
01:47:35 Okay, Mr. Taves, you had one rebuttal left.
01:47:37 Do you choose to use it?
01:47:38 I choose.
01:47:39 I choose to use it.
01:47:40 Look, we have the most responsible forestry,
01:47:43 agriculture, and energy industry in the world.
01:47:46 all of those sectors right now are working ahead at reducing emissions intensity per unit of
01:47:53 production. We need to continue to support them and not derail them. But, you know, when Danielle
01:47:58 noted here a number of weeks ago, in fact, in the first debate, that she has a plan to accelerate 0.57
01:48:03 to net zero. To accelerate to net zero will undermine our competitiveness as an industry
01:48:09 and an economy, undermine future prosperity. We cannot get ahead of technology solutions.
01:48:15 we cannot get ahead of competing
01:48:17 resource-based economies
01:48:19 I will not parrot Justin Trudeau's
01:48:22 nonsense about net zero
01:48:23 alright, okay, that ends it all
01:48:26 give him a round of applause, everybody
01:48:27 you know you want to
01:48:30 don't the rules allow me a response
01:48:34 since I've had three people attack me
01:48:36 well, they didn't call you by name
01:48:38 so, and your rebuttals are done
01:48:40 I thought they were attacking me
01:48:41 Rebecca, I'm going to go to the jury on this
01:48:45 did rebecca call her by name all right 45 seconds sorry 30 seconds all right i would i would just
01:48:51 say that i notice as well that rebecca doesn't talk about her alternative to the to the sovereignty
01:48:56 act she would like to turn off the taps and i've talked to energy industry leaders especially those
01:49:01 who feed into line five if you want to talk about chaos talk about turning that tap off i don't
01:49:07 think they'll ever allow us to let it back on look we've got to stop letting ottawa define the terms
01:49:12 We know that we can do emissions reduction.
01:49:14 We could do emissions reduction globally by exporting more of our LNG
01:49:18 so we can reduce the amount of wood, dung, and coal being used around the world.
01:49:22 That's a proper environment.
01:49:23 That's time. That's time.
01:49:24 You already got to clap on this question.
01:49:27 All right.
01:49:28 Okay, so what we're going to move into now is closing statements.
01:49:31 And we're going to have 90 seconds now for closing statements, not two minutes.
01:49:34 That's what happens when we cut in.
01:49:36 Sorry.
01:49:38 Oh, I'm sorry.
01:49:39 We were increasing it to 90 seconds.
01:49:40 All right.
01:49:42 you're all throwing me off here okay so mr lowen you have drawn we're gonna bring the podium back
01:49:52 on stage here for anybody who wants to use it i think that's coming up
01:49:56 oh well you get two jobs this way give him a round of applause that's great
01:50:04 all right 90 seconds mr lowen you have the floor thank you very much and thanks to the organizers
01:50:09 and the people have taken time to watch here tonight i'm not a smooth talking politician i
01:50:14 don't have all the flashiest policy announcements and i'm not promising to shower everyone in cash
01:50:19 i'm running on my record as a conservative in a time when real conservative politicians seem
01:50:24 to be hard to find people ask why did i do this and it's so i could walk down the street in my
01:50:30 hometown and look people in the eye and say that i did everything i could i'm the only candidate
01:50:34 on this stage who has stood for alberton's freedom and prosperity without ever once
01:50:38 compromising or capitulating for personal or political gain in fact when albertans needed
01:50:43 strong leaders i chose to stand no matter how great the personal cost because the well-being
01:50:49 of albertans is my highest priority the provincial election in 2023 will be fought on trust we need
01:50:56 this leadership election to be a referendum on trust and accountability let's give alberta
01:51:02 a united conservative party that puts principle before politics so tonight i'm asking you to give
01:51:09 me your number one vote to stand with me as i have stood and continue to stand for you
01:51:15 uncompromising and unwavering for a free and prosperous alberta this government belongs to
01:51:22 you this province belongs to you this is your alberta and i'm committed to doing it your way
01:51:28 thank you thank you mr lowen all right moving next miss ahir come on up you're going to have 90 1.00
01:51:36 seconds for your vision and final statement to the members and albertans thank you for those
01:51:43 of you who know me you know that i will always try to do it right and that i'm not afraid to
01:51:48 stand my ground and for those of you who are just getting to know me i hope that you understand that
01:51:52 i will always put alberta and albertans first tonight you've heard what makes me different
01:51:57 from my colleagues on the stage i've risked my political career and my own safety in order to
01:52:01 do the right thing more than once and i want to remind our membership that doing the right thing
01:52:06 means you voting for the right leader for our party in our province a leader who can fight
01:52:12 and win an election in less than 39 weeks a leader who can bring everyday albertans back to the table
01:52:19 and be a champion for them in confederation and get our province back on track instead of looking
01:52:25 for reasons to leave. We need to find, be finding ways to lead Canada. And that means getting our
01:52:33 oil and gas to tidewater. That means leading global energy markets. That means standing
01:52:37 shoulder to shoulder with our farmers. And that also means taking care of our seniors and our
01:52:41 vulnerable. And that means ending pointless fights with our doctors, lawyers, teachers, nurses, and
01:52:48 first responders. That means making Alberta the best place in Canada in the world to build a
01:52:52 business and to raise a family.
01:52:55 So tonight, while my colleagues try to tell you
01:52:56 why they should be first on the ballot, I'd like to leave
01:52:58 you with one thing. If I'm not your
01:53:00 first choice, Mark Leela here
01:53:02 second, because I've
01:53:04 shown that I will always put Alberta
01:53:06 and Albertans first. Thank you.
01:53:09 All right. Thank you, Ms. Aheer.
01:53:11 We're going to go down
01:53:12 to Ms. Smith.
01:53:14 Come on up for your 90 seconds
01:53:16 to address the membership
01:53:18 at all Albertans.
01:53:19 you know the NDP is to stick up for the little guy but they don't do that anymore they choose
01:53:28 big bloated bureaucracy every single time they put ideology ahead of affordability
01:53:35 they couldn't push far enough or fast enough or hard enough to lock you down and to put
01:53:41 restrictions on our economy and what are the consequences of that we've seen kids not able
01:53:48 get surgery heard about one child who wasn't able to get cleft palate surgery at age three
01:53:53 imagine that child's going to be impacted by life for that i've heard about an rcmp officer
01:53:59 at edmonton who not only lost his job he wasn't able to watch his kid play hockey because he
01:54:03 chose not to be vaccinated we had people all over this province who couldn't say a proper goodbye
01:54:09 to loved ones and i talked to a man in cardston who teared up talking about how his 80 year old
01:54:14 parents were dying of loneliness in long-term care we're in a leadership
01:54:19 race because we made these decisions we our government caused this reaction they
01:54:26 allowed themselves to be bullied and pushed around by the NDP they didn't
01:54:33 stand up for the little guy now you know me I sometimes make mistakes but you
01:54:38 know I'm a fair person because if you heard me on radio for so many years I
01:54:42 I may make mistakes from time to time, but I won't be bullied, and I won't be pushed around.
01:54:48 I will stand up for you, and I will always put Alberta first.
01:54:51 Please vote for me. Go to DanielleSmith.co.
01:54:54 All right. Thank you, Ms. Smith.
01:54:56 Okay, okay, okay.
01:54:58 All righty, folks. All righty.
01:55:03 The next person who claps owes me a drink after this. Why don't we start with that rule?
01:55:08 You're in. All right. Thank you, Ms. Smith.
01:55:10 Ms. Schultz, you're up to the podium.
01:55:13 You have 90 seconds to address Albertans.
01:55:15 Please go ahead when you're ready.
01:55:17 Well, thank you.
01:55:18 Alberta is on the edge of being a world leader in every sense, but we're not there just yet.
01:55:23 And we absolutely can't risk losing that momentum.
01:55:27 Alberta needs a Conservative government to be an economic powerhouse that also strives to have the best health care, education, and supports for the most vulnerable in the country.
01:55:37 Because this leadership race, it's not about me.
01:55:40 it's not even about anyone on the stage it is about you it is about Kyle and
01:55:45 two hills who's probably not even watching this debate right now because
01:55:48 he's on his combine feeding Alberta and the rest of the world it's about
01:55:52 teachers like Robert and sundry who are doing their best to get ready to get
01:55:56 kids back in the classroom this week it's about the entrepreneurs and the
01:56:00 innovators the risk takers it's also about the parents tonight sitting in an
01:56:05 emergency room with their kids wanting peace of mind that their kids will have
01:56:09 quality health care and be able to see a doctor and it's about doctors like suri paramedics like
01:56:15 stew nurses like rosa who have the ideas on how we're going to fix this health care system 1.00
01:56:21 together i am in this for you for albertans and for you i will represent the values of
01:56:27 all of us in this big tent party with humility and with common sense so in this leadership race
01:56:34 vote for a leader who has a vision of hope and optimism for our future vote for a leader that
01:56:41 all albertans can get behind vote for a leader that you can be proud of please join me vote for
01:56:48 me all right thank you thank you michelle mr tapes are you ready 90 seconds to you when you're ready
01:56:58 go ahead and give your closing remarks to all alberts all right um firstly i would like to
01:57:05 appreciate all the candidates on the stage tonight i appreciate their commitment to this movement and
01:57:11 thereby their commitment to the province and i've appreciated the many ideas that have come out of
01:57:16 this leadership race all of that is of value but tonight i want to go back to the ballot question
01:57:22 What I believe is the most important question, and that is, who, which leader can unite this party and movement and go on to win the election in 2023?
01:57:32 Leadership matters, and leadership track record matters.
01:57:37 We've made great progress as a province in the last three years.
01:57:40 We've got a balanced budget.
01:57:41 We have an economy that's leading the nation this year and next.
01:57:46 Folks, we have economic diversification at rates probably not seen in my lifetime.
01:57:51 we've made great progress and I'm incredibly optimistic about the future
01:57:57 of this province and the future for the next generation your grandchildren and
01:58:02 mine but we have a lot of work to do now is the time for stewardship humility
01:58:09 and stability now is the time for strong principled proven leadership future
01:58:16 generations of Albertans are depending on us. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Taves. All right.
01:58:24 Mr. Jean, we're going to go to you next. Come on up to the podium. 90 seconds when you're ready to
01:58:31 address the membership in all Albertans. Thank you for listening tonight. And I would say that
01:58:36 there are many good people on the stage who want to lead our party. That's why they would all be
01:58:41 a Brian Jean cabinet. But I'm the only person who is actually talking about renewing the party
01:58:48 and returning it to what it was meant to be. A party that represents the vast majority of ordinary
01:58:54 everyday Albertans who want good conservative government that respects their autonomy,
01:58:59 their freedoms, their ability to choose for themselves. I want this party to make Albertans
01:59:04 happier. That involves changing the way we treat each other. Yes, it means returning to civility
01:59:09 for Albertans. I want to make this party for Albertans more healthier. And that means we have
01:59:17 to work with the good nurses and doctors to fix our health care system and make it the best in
01:59:21 the world. That's what I want to do. I want to make Albertans freer. And that means correcting
01:59:26 the mistakes of the last two years and making sure that our rights are actually protected going
01:59:30 forward. I'm the only one with a plan for that. And I want to make Albertans prosperous. That
01:59:35 That means fighting the Trudeau Liberals, fixing the Constitution, growing our economy
01:59:39 and taking advantage of the can-do spirit of Albertans.
01:59:43 If we do these things, we can renew our party and win the next election and win the next
01:59:48 election big.
01:59:51 You know that I've always been there for Albertans.
01:59:53 I always will be there for Albertans because I believe that they make the best decisions
01:59:57 when they're put in charge of their own decisions.
02:00:00 Please go to briangean.ca, join my team, vote for me number one, vote for me number two,
02:00:04 But please, vote for me in the top.
02:00:06 Thank you very much.
02:00:07 Thank you, Mr. Jean.
02:00:12 All right, Ms. Sonny, come on up. 0.99
02:00:15 90 seconds for you to address Albertans, the membership.
02:00:21 Okay, thank you everyone for joining tonight.
02:00:23 Reckless and distracting constitutional turmoil is not the top priority of Albertans,
02:00:29 and it's certainly not my top priority.
02:00:32 While some are out selling their schemes,
02:00:34 I've been talking to Albertans and I'm hearing that there are helpful things that they need
02:00:38 government to do, which I will do. Southern Alberta farmers need us to twin Highway 3.
02:00:44 Cattle ranchers need a second border crossing other than coots. The border blockade had a real
02:00:50 impact. There were real costs associated with it and ask the cattle ranchers. Northern Alberta
02:00:55 needs us to build a Fort Buck-Murray Peace River Highway. Students need us to strategically invest
02:01:01 and aid so they can afford to become the medical researchers, the electricians, and the code
02:01:05 writers that our economy needs. The healthcare system needs more healthcare workers. Municipalities
02:01:11 need us to ensure oil and gas companies pay their taxes. Rural Alberta needs broadband. They need
02:01:18 us to address crime and safety. And I'm not interested in going backwards and delving into
02:01:24 old grievances. I want to take Alberta forward. And finally, I do want to say this, that the
02:01:30 The politics of anger has caused a recent state of attacks on politicians and journalists.
02:01:36 And for those who spoke up and condemned it, I thank you.
02:01:38 And for those who didn't, I ask why.
02:01:41 We can't let the politics of anger win.
02:01:43 Instead, we must choose hope, progress, and most important of all, we must choose unity.
02:01:49 Please vote Rajan as your number one choice.
02:01:51 Thank you.
02:01:52 All right.
02:01:53 Thank you, Ms. Tawny.
02:01:54 Okay, folks, so the candidate's closing remarks ends the official debate
02:02:00 for the evening and folks before we do anything give these give every candidate here a round of
02:02:04 applause please it's it's tough sometimes we have to remember we're all on the same side here so
02:02:18 on behalf of ucp members i want to thank all the candidates for being here tonight this is uh this
02:02:23 has been fantastic i want the candidates to actually just stay seated for a minute and i
02:02:26 the audience to stay seated i do want to thank party president uh specifically cynthia moore
02:02:31 uh for putting this on and the entire the entire ucp team who uh who makes this all happen and a
02:02:37 huge thanks to the people of edmonton and all the staff here at the citadel theater for having us
02:02:41 tonight i think give them a round of applause too all right i am uh before we get a family photo at
02:02:50 the end here so none of the candidates are allowed to run away i want to call party president cynthia
02:02:54 Cynthia Moore back to the microphone to talk about a couple of key dates for our members. 1.00
02:02:58 Be sure to get your vote in on time to be counted for October 6th.
02:03:01 I want to say thank you.
02:03:01 Cynthia, over to you. 0.56
02:03:03 Well, when we planned this, we knew this would be exciting and it certainly was.
02:03:08 And what a privilege to hear such thoughtful discussions of the issues that matter to Albertans.
02:03:14 First of all, I want to thank Jeff.
02:03:16 Now, Jeff is a volunteer who I think I might have voluntold to do the first debate in Medicine Hat
02:03:23 and through your interest and support of his the job he did there he came back to help us
02:03:30 out tonight so let's give staff a round of applause thank you thank you
02:03:38 and then to the candidates um i i don't know about you but i'm very proud to sitting in
02:03:43 the audience tonight listening to these these conversations this has been an incredible
02:03:48 experience for our party i think this has contributed greatly to unity so i want to thank
02:03:53 them for for the job they've done now what i have to tell you is not quite as exciting but we are
02:04:03 moving on to the ballot phase of this uh this exercise and so as i said earlier um ballots
02:04:12 will officially begin um going out in the mail on friday to all 123 915 eligible united conservative
02:04:22 party members i love that number um your ballot must be returned so that it is received by the
02:04:31 independent accounting firm overseeing the leadership vote by monday october 3rd at 5 pm
02:04:38 and those of you who participated in the leadership review will remember we are very strict with
02:04:43 deadlines 5 p.m on monday october 3rd now their address will be on the return envelope enclosed
02:04:50 with your voting package so you don't have to worry about the return address more information
02:04:56 will be provided shortly about the locations and times of the in-person voting option
02:05:01 And because we're giving you two options to vote, we want you to be confident that our system ensures that only one vote is counted per eligible voting member.
02:05:13 Now, for those of you who haven't participated in a preferential ballot before, let's talk about the count.
02:05:21 In order to be elected leader of the United Conservative Party, a candidate must receive more than 50% of the valid votes cast.
02:05:31 Our rules state that we use a preferential ballot.
02:05:36 That means you will receive a ballot with all seven names on it,
02:05:41 and you will be asked to rank the candidates in the order of your preference.
02:05:46 You may rank as many or as few as you like.
02:05:51 On October 6th, volunteers will count the first choices on every ballot.
02:05:57 if no candidate receives more than 50 percent the person receiving the least number of first
02:06:03 place votes will be dropped from the race their second choices will be counted and so on this
02:06:11 process is repeated until a candidate gets over 50 percent you will receive detailed instructions
02:06:18 so don't worry if that doesn't make sense to you you'll have deep detailed instructions in your
02:06:23 ballot package and they can also be found on the ucp website on october 6th we will announce the
02:06:31 results and present our new leader and premier to the people of alberta at an event being planned
02:06:37 at the bmo center in calgary please join us if you can in person or the show will be accessible
02:06:45 to all albertans on our website as this event tonight was as well in addition we encourage
02:06:52 you to register for our 2022 ucp agm at river cree resort in enoch or here in edmonton
02:07:01 being held on october 21st through 23rd where the new leader will have the opportunity to make their
02:07:08 first major address to party members and kick off our 2023 election campaign you won't want to miss
02:07:16 that. Now, thank you all of you for being here tonight. This has been an historic process.
02:07:25 Good night, and we'll see you again on October 6th.
02:07:36 Thank you so much. Thanks.
02:07:46 Thank you.
02:08:16 Thank you.
02:08:46 .
02:09:16 .
02:09:46 .
02:10:16 .
02:10:46 .
02:11:16 You