Western Standard - November 05, 2021


Uncensored: COP 26 - Climate Change Hypocrisy

Topics
Mentioned
Jean to seek UCP nomination in Fort McMurray Hillier announces bid for Ontario premiership under PPC banner

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

175.73

Word count

8,700

Sentence count

202

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Our panel will weigh in on our Prime Minister with a new cap on oil and gas emissions, the fallout already being felt in Alberta, and a new federal environment minister, a former Greenpeace activist and anti-oil and gas advocate. We ll ask our panel about that, also a giant wind farm planned for Alberta, no one is talking about it, and is there a giant hypocrisy in it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 Alton
00:01:10 Thank you.
00:01:40 good evening and welcome to uncensored i'm your host bruce mccallister thanks for being with us
00:02:07 tonight. We have a lot to unpack. Just before we get to our panelists and introduce them, let's
00:02:13 tee up the subject material tonight. We'll talk about COP26, 400 jets on the tarmac over in
00:02:20 Glasgow, and countless limousines and cars idling nearby. What's it all for? And is there a giant
00:02:27 hypocrisy in it? Our panel will weigh in. Our Prime Minister with a new cap announcement on
00:02:33 oil and gas emissions, the fallout already being felt in Alberta. What does it all mean? We will
00:02:39 weigh in on that also. And a new federal environment minister, a former Greenpeace activist and anti-oil
00:02:46 and gas advocate. We'll ask our panel about that. Also, a giant wind farm planned for Alberta, 18,000
00:02:54 acres. Nobody's talking about it. One of our panelists is. She knows all about it. We'll get
00:03:00 to the bottom of it including details on the german investor who stands to profit and we will
00:03:06 conclude this evening with this what can albertans do about the situation we are in one of our
00:03:11 panelists the author of the free alberta strategy we will talk about that and the path going forward
00:03:17 now let's meet our panelists starting with danielle smith danielle the executive director
00:03:22 of the alberta enterprise group the former leader of the wild rose party and a common sense
00:03:27 conservative commentator. Danielle, always good to see you. Thanks for being here tonight.
00:03:31 Hello, Bruce.
00:03:33 Rob Anderson, practicing lawyer. Rob, also former Wild Rose member, former finance critic and author
00:03:38 of the aforementioned Free Alberta Strategy. Good evening, Rob.
00:03:42 Hey, Bruce.
00:03:43 And Donna Kennedy-Glans joining us tonight, a face you'll probably recognize. Donna's been doing a
00:03:48 lot of political commentary of her own. An author, a former energy analyst, and Donna, a quick plug 0.98
00:03:54 for your book coming up here it is um teaching the dinosaurs to dance coming out in the spring
00:03:59 correct that's right thank you bruce okay well we'll get we'll we'll talk more about that maybe
00:04:05 at some point during the show because everybody says it's a great title what's the book about so
00:04:09 we we will i promise leave some time for that want to start with the summit though uh everybody this
00:04:14 is what uh everyone is talking about in canada uh danielle let's begin with you what do you make
00:04:19 of it are we getting anywhere we've got 30 000 people over there what's what's the result well
00:04:25 i think we were all waiting to see what the prime minister would do in response to the equalization
00:04:29 referendum which gave a strong mandate to premier jason kenny to pursue taking uh equalization out
00:04:35 of the constitution and i think appointing stephen galbeau is the big uh middle finger that he gave
00:04:41 us in response because i i think there's no other way to interpret the fact that we now have a
00:04:47 a radical Greenpeace environmentalist in that position,
00:04:51 who when he got elected a few years ago,
00:04:53 said he would make it his mission
00:04:55 to address the issue of fossil fuel use.
00:04:57 The other thing that has me quite concerned
00:04:59 is that when the premier was asked
00:05:01 about this oil and gas cap on emissions,
00:05:04 he said, yeah, well, I tried to talk to the prime minister
00:05:07 about this after I got elected in April, 2019,
00:05:10 but he didn't see that interested.
00:05:11 And that says to me that there has been practically no
00:05:15 or definitely zero cooperation and collaboration
00:05:19 on some of the great things
00:05:20 that our energy companies are doing in Alberta.
00:05:22 And I really fear what it means is that
00:05:25 we're seeing the prime minister set to go down the same path
00:05:28 as we're seeing in Quebec,
00:05:29 which has begun with a ban on oil and gas exploration.
00:05:32 It wouldn't surprise me if he's going to try to push
00:05:34 the same thing across the country.
00:05:35 Definitely not a positive step.
00:05:38 Yep, for sure.
00:05:40 And I want to come back to Guilbault, obviously Guilbault
00:05:43 and ask about him a little bit more in depth,
00:05:45 first I want to talk about the summit in general. Rob, you see, I think somebody had said 30,000
00:05:50 delegates over there, 400 jets on the tarmac, and here we are in the name of cleaning up the
00:05:58 planet. There's a hypocrisy to all of this. What do you make of it?
00:06:02 Well, I mean, there's huge hypocrisy, but the problem here is the climate alarmists. They
00:06:10 aren't being truthful about the urgency of the situation um that's well documented i mean the
00:06:16 temperature models over the last 20 years have grossly over exaggerated the actual temperature
00:06:20 change of the earth it's just one of a hundred of examples but because they're not being honest
00:06:24 the solutions they're forcing on us right now from these ridiculous summits
00:06:28 are very dangerous because these policies are causing energy prices and therefore inflation
00:06:35 on everything to soar which is especially destructive and harmful to those in poverty
00:06:39 or close to the poverty line and that results in actual damage and people actually dying of
00:06:45 starvation in certain areas increased violence drug abuse all kinds of social skills that really hurt
00:06:51 people um because affordable and reliable energy is the key to lifting people out of poverty and
00:06:57 these people at these conferences including our prime minister and his environmental minister
00:07:02 when they focus on shutting down alberta's oil and gas industry rather than harnessing it to develop
00:07:08 the technologies that will allow us to power economies more efficiently and sustainably
00:07:13 they actually worsen the very problem that they are trying to solve especially as poor energy
00:07:18 hungry countries look to burn coal and even wood in some cases to meet their needs so they're
00:07:25 completely backwards on how they're addressing this issue and of course the hypocrisy their 0.78
00:07:30 hypocrisy knows no bounds well we should mention one of our panelists has been to one of these
00:07:36 summits before dawn i know you um you were at one in paris i believe you can correct me if i'm wrong
00:07:41 but uh you know what did you learn from that and what are you taking away from this one
00:07:46 thanks bruce i i actually did go to cop uh 21 and i actually took my son one of my my sons came with
00:07:53 me i went on my own dime um i went economy just for the record and and i took with me um the
00:08:01 viewpoints actually 40 40 people had gathered before that summit and reached out across alberta
00:08:09 talked to 500 000 albertans and we took those viewpoints of albertans to not just the government
00:08:16 talks or the corporate talks but we actually took that into advocacy space and it was it it was it
00:08:22 was a bit like a carnival it was three stages one was for the diplomats and it was you know very
00:08:27 you know can you imagine coming together as that many politicians and coming up with language
00:08:33 everybody agreed on it's really it's really diluted discussion and then you had corporations
00:08:39 and they were trying to share best practices and frankly canada has a lot of best practices
00:08:46 coal like look what we've done in alberta on coal look what we've done on methane look what we've
00:08:51 done on conservation of land like we have some really really good practices to share and that
00:08:57 was pretty constructive space but i spent 90 of my time with the the advocates and and believe me
00:09:04 i i felt a little weird in that space at times because i was the target of criticism because i
00:09:09 was coming with viewpoints from people who were saying all over alberta we get it that we have to
00:09:16 do energy transition we understand climate change and and rob you know some people don't believe it
00:09:22 but lots of people believe it and i grew up on a farm and my farming family really understand that
00:09:28 climate change is happening so they just don't know they wanted to talk about how to transition
00:09:33 and they wanted to tell people in paris that these are the consequences of your choices like you can
00:09:39 say you know no more oil sands but this is the result and you understand that result so it was
00:09:45 kind of a human check-in bruce but it was it was a lot of drama i mean now today we've got you know
00:09:52 bill gates and we've got leonardo dicaprio i mean it's a it's a place it's like a davos for
00:09:59 the environmentalists and and it's a really hip place to be so it's not surprising people are
00:10:05 there but i i think a lot of the work gets done outside of those venues okay so let me stay with
00:10:12 you and we'll go reverse order this time donna so there's there's a lot of noise frankly about
00:10:17 who wasn't there our premier wasn't there um now when you were there premier notley was there
00:10:23 correct premier at the time yes um so so how do you view that should should premier kenny have
00:10:28 been there and what might he have accomplished if he was actually it was i i thought a lot about
00:10:34 that i know a lot of people are are really critical of him not showing up and defending our you know
00:10:39 the good stories and and and sort of being there is a bit of a foil to trudeau right now
00:10:45 But to be honest with you, I think it probably is a good idea for him not to have gone.
00:10:52 It's a stage where people want the drama.
00:10:57 And what would happen is, you know, Trudeau gets up and says,
00:11:00 we're going to put a cap on oil and gas emissions, which we all know.
00:11:05 I mean, to Danielle's point, I mean, this has been around since the NDP.
00:11:09 This didn't change.
00:11:11 It's been with us.
00:11:12 We all know that's what's going to happen.
00:11:14 So it's not really a surprise, but do we want to have that conversation between Trudeau and our Premier in a public space where, you know, there's a lot going on?
00:11:24 Carney, who is viewed as a really grounded player in all of this, you know, financial guy, trusted, and he's getting attacked by Greta right now.
00:11:32 So I don't know. I think maybe it was a wise move for Kenny not to go.
00:11:39 Well, I love, Donna, that you're with us tonight because I can already see some points that you're going to disagree with Rob on, with Danielle on.
00:11:45 Yes.
00:11:46 This is great for discussion.
00:11:48 And frankly, I'm with you a little bit.
00:11:51 I didn't see the need for another delegation going from Alberta, just wondering what they might accomplish.
00:11:57 That said, you want to be front and center where you can be.
00:12:00 Rob, what did you think?
00:12:01 Should the premier have been there?
00:12:04 That's a tough one.
00:12:06 I believe he should be there.
00:12:08 believe that there should be an alberta delegation there i i agree that that might have limited use
00:12:13 um but i think it's important like even in that in what donna was saying there and i find i find her
00:12:20 position to be extremely reasonable um uh it's very important to we we did this in covet too
00:12:29 you're either anti-vax or you're pro-vax you know you're either anti-science or you're pro-science
00:12:35 the issue that many people are taking and if you look at uh michael schellenberger for example and
00:12:41 other ipcc contributors and so forth what they have an issue with and what i have an issue with
00:12:46 is climate alarmism that to me is extreme it's not that these people are many of us are denying that
00:12:53 climate change is happening of course it's happening it's always happened and we have to
00:12:58 figure out how we can make sure that we're not affecting it in a way that is that is detrimental
00:13:04 to the human race i think everyone agrees on that but these the alarmism the absolute frothing at
00:13:09 the mouth of the at that you see at these at these uh at at these events and and and by trudeau and
00:13:17 by his environmental minister that says you know oh we're gonna you know this is gonna happen we're
00:13:22 gonna have runaway global warming by 2030 if we don't cut it back to such and such or 2050 but
00:13:26 these predictions have been shown to be wrong religiously for the last 20 to 30 years
00:13:33 I mean, you just got to look at the data. And so people are saying, look, we have an issue here to address. Let's address it. But let's use best practices. Let's think through these things. And the great example here is coal versus natural gas. I mean, China and India are literally firing up dozens of new coal fire plants monthly because they have to. Their people need the energy. And as everyone knows, these plants are literally double the emissions intensity of natural gas.
00:14:01 So if you're an alarmist or if you want to out of caution reduce CO2 emissions around the world, like perhaps Donna, myself and Danielle might want to do, and I'm not going to speak for them, but why would you not support fostering trade and pipelines and tankers that result in clean Alberta liquefied natural gas heading to Asia by the boatload so that some or all these coal-fired plants could become natural gas plants and then reinvesting a part of that wealth generating revenue into further technologies that work on bringing the burning of fossil fuels closer
00:14:31 to net zero and the reason why they don't is they either lack education vision or many instances in
00:14:37 my view they're bought off and paid for by certain special interests but free and clearing clear
00:14:42 thinking citizens need to stand up and speak out about this and that's why i think the premier
00:14:46 should have attended well you made a you made a very good case and some of those things rob
00:14:51 probably the premier uh should have could have said had he been there danielle pick up on that
00:14:55 and also the fact that you know rob mentions china and india and of course uh they're not even they're
00:15:00 not even at the table so i don't know how we're going to get them to move on anything when they're
00:15:03 not even participating well i would say the the premier definitely should have been there but he
00:15:08 has to be there with something more than a lame announcement which is what he did on the same day
00:15:13 that justin trudeau announced the cap on oil and gas emissions he said oh look at these projects
00:15:17 we're going to remediate or or or reduce emissions by seven megatons by 2030 that is nowhere close
00:15:26 to being part of the conversation if you talk if you pick up on rob's point about our lng being
00:15:33 exported to displace coal if we could get credit for that through the mechanisms that are available
00:15:38 in the paris accord that would get us towards a net zero target in alberta if we start looking
00:15:44 at bitumen and i've seen a number of proposals they i think people are familiar with bit crude
00:15:48 and canapux if you take that kind of approach that we won't use bitumen for combustion purposes that
00:15:55 we'll use it for asphalt or we'll use it for construction materials that gets us a well on
00:16:01 our way towards a net zero goal if you look at the capability of carbon capture storage and
00:16:07 utilization the ability to capture co2 turn it into useful products or buried underground we've
00:16:13 got so much poor space that gets us towards our net zero target hydrogen fuel of the future as
00:16:19 well we've already got projects on the go to to transform our long-haul trucking to hydrogen
00:16:26 that gets us towards the goal then add in our foresters who are planting more trees than anyone
00:16:31 else our uh ranchers who are sequestering uh co2 in in soils as well as our producers
00:16:37 or farm producers who are doing the same thing when when ifrancois blanchet decided to go on
00:16:42 his platform yesterday and challenge alberta that we shouldn't have an equalization program
00:16:48 we could have a green equalization program i say i'll take that bet because with the
00:16:54 the kind of technologies we're talking about we will get to net zero faster than anywhere
00:16:59 else in the country and quebec will be paying us for the benefit of capturing their soil we've got 1.00
00:17:04 direct air capture as another major initiative one smart company avatar innovations is partnered
00:17:10 with elon musk to develop that technology so i don't know why we run away from this i don't know
00:17:16 why we fear it if we believe in innovation then we should embrace innovation we should be there
00:17:21 to make the arguments and we should accept that challenge because i firmly believe that without
00:17:26 our energy sector taking the lead in this the world isn't going to create these kinds of solutions
00:17:30 without us and so we've got to have the confidence that we should be at the table i think the premier
00:17:34 could have been there with that message points points well made and uh it would be tough to
00:17:39 to debate with any of you frankly uh no matter what position you're taking they're both
00:17:43 communicated uh very well danielle when you mentioned uh carbon capture and storage i think
00:17:48 of the great work that enhanced energy is doing in alberta with the alberta carbon trunk line
00:17:53 more than a million tons uh sequestered annually with the capacity to do much more so you're right
00:17:59 we do have innovation here in alberta we need to talk more about it however when when quebec or
00:18:05 the prime minister seemingly give you the middle finger in alberta um and and appointing stephen
00:18:11 Yeboah as environment minister a lot would say just did they just did that how do we really
00:18:16 believe that they're interested in our innovation or is this indeed about shutting alberta's oil and
00:18:21 gas industry down and transitioning uh to other energy it's absolutely about shutting alberta's
00:18:27 oil and gas industry down and i don't think that we can we can sugarcoat that that's clearly what
00:18:32 the extreme environmental movement wants however what's interesting about it is that i think by
00:18:38 being so extreme they're actually alienating some who really want to solve this problem i've most
00:18:43 recently met two environmentalists paul stevers with a group called climate san and matthew
00:18:49 klibbenstein with the hydrogen association of canada both of them say they live on the left
00:18:53 both of them very concerned about co2 emissions but both of them realize that the only industry
00:18:59 that is able to roll out technology at scale is the energy sector that we have pioneered right
00:19:07 here in alberta you're not going to create a wind farm solution to this global problem you are not
00:19:12 going to create a solar panel solution to this problem you need the kind of technologies that
00:19:17 only our industry is capable of doing and so if you're serious about solving the problem then
00:19:23 you're not actually going to achieve it with what the greta thunbergs and the extreme environmentalists 0.92
00:19:27 are saying in fact when you look at the rollout of wind and solar the places where it's been the
00:19:33 most successful rolled out with the most penetration is a place where we have natural
00:19:39 gas as a backup because with intermittent power the only way you can work it into your grid is
00:19:44 you've got to be able to turn on base power in a an effective way as soon as that occurs so there's
00:19:49 no reason why the wind and solar industry should be oppositional to the natural gas industry they're
00:19:55 part and parcel they need to to coexist together and they need to grow together and the the message
00:20:00 that the extreme environmentalists have that it's going to be wind and solar and nothing else it's
00:20:05 been proven even by the leftists like michael moore in his documentary planet of the humans
00:20:10 it's been proven that can't possibly happen so i don't know why we continue to operate in the
00:20:15 fiction that somehow they have the upper hand on us they don't we've got the upper hand on this and
00:20:20 we need to be confident in asserting it well they're certainly uh pushing us down that road
00:20:24 aren't they with the cap announced by the uh the prime minister on oil and gas emissions um
00:20:30 Rob, is it even hidden anymore, the agenda, the message that appears to be coming out of Ottawa?
00:20:35 And how do the office towers in downtown Calgary deal with this?
00:20:41 It's not a hidden agenda anymore.
00:20:44 I mean, that's pretty clear.
00:20:45 I mean, the prime minister, I think, he tried to walk back some comments he made on previous campaigns about phasing out the oil sands and so forth.
00:20:56 But now it's pretty clear.
00:20:58 It's abundantly clear.
00:20:59 The stated objective of this government is to phase out and end the energy industry here.
00:21:06 And the way you do that is you let the current projects play out.
00:21:12 You let them gather what they're going to gather, produce what they're going to produce.
00:21:18 And then you just make it impossible for there to be more, for there to be new investment.
00:21:23 And right now, Alberta is seen as one of the most unattractive places in the world.
00:21:29 to invest new oil and gas money sure you can through fracking and some things there's some
00:21:34 existing plays of course the large oil sands plays that are already in the ground and operating
00:21:39 those will play themselves out and and and and there'll still be revenues generated from there
00:21:44 but this is just not a place that you invest right now and that's the goal that is the goal
00:21:49 of the Trudeau government that's the goal of Ottawa is to phase out the entire energy industry
00:21:54 over the next 10 to 20 years and the harms that that is going to cause this province the
00:21:59 devastation the loss of jobs the loss of revenue the effect that it'll have on health social
00:22:05 services education all of these things is is remarkably destructive and irresponsible in every
00:22:13 way of this uh this federal government um uh you know to to go down that road up the the solution
00:22:19 here. We all know that we're transitioning, but that transition is not away from oil and natural
00:22:25 gas, but that transition is not going to take 10 years worldwide. That transition is going to take
00:22:30 closer to 50 to 100 years worldwide. And we can either be part of that transition in a way that
00:22:35 where we have the revenues and we enjoy the bounty of our natural resources, or we can allow
00:22:45 venezuela saudi arabia uh iran etc to supply oil to the world uh with with cruddy environmental
00:22:54 records and you know obviously treating their their people in a in a in a not very good way
00:23:00 we can't allow that to happen we have a role to play and the federal government wants to end that
00:23:05 role and it's irresponsible uh donna you want to pick up on that oh yeah i'm an energy nerd so yes
00:23:12 Yes. I had the portfolio of electricity and renewable energy. I think it was the first
00:23:19 portfolio in Canada. I had that in 2013, 2014. And I come out of the extractive sector,
00:23:27 so I had to prove myself that I actually believed in renewables, and I really do. To Danielle's
00:23:34 point and to what rob's saying i i think i mean we have a we have such an abundance of energy
00:23:42 possibility in alberta we can weave together stuff that nobody else can do in most places in the
00:23:48 world it's quite amazing and and during this transition until we get batteries we are going
00:23:54 to need to do that that's just the reality we live in a cold country and we're gonna need natural gas
00:24:00 to back up when that's just a fact i wish it was different but it's not that's the way it is
00:24:05 so i i think it's what i ask myself all the time bruce is i follow the money and and right now yes
00:24:16 we have a lot of ideology coming out of federal government leadership and we have had for a long
00:24:21 time that has not changed that's been the same regardless of who is environment minister we
00:24:26 still know what's coming out of the prime minister's office that's been pretty locked in for a while
00:24:33 what's more interesting is who lends money to the energy sector so i've got lots of friends and
00:24:41 one of my sons was cfo of junior oil and great company great little company doing well ethical
00:24:49 creative and the banks came to him last christmas and said you know what we love you guys we think
00:24:54 you're doing great but you know our policy is we're not going to loan to small players anymore
00:24:59 you're going to have to sell your assets to those guys over there and my son's gone into a different
00:25:04 business like that's the reality that's that's what's going on in alberta um we have to transition
00:25:10 but what i am watching really closely and bruce i hope we get to talk about this is what's going on
00:25:16 with who is funding renewables and and why are they come why are all these foreign investors
00:25:24 showing up i know we have great assets but i i'm back to follow the money okay look we can and uh
00:25:31 you know i i have an out an outline to follow but you guys all mess it up because you just continually
00:25:36 you continually raise the next topic before we get to it let's talk about it let's let's fine
00:25:41 let's just stay right here okay so donna let's let's let's let our our listeners and viewers
00:25:46 understand uh what you're following there is a hearing underway the last couple of weeks maybe
00:25:50 longer about a huge proposed uh wind farm near lomond alberta and you can give us some of the
00:25:57 details 18 000 acres i believe um 83 of these giant uh giant statues uh whatever they call them
00:26:06 this thing is immense nobody is talking about it it's a german investor that's here who who is
00:26:13 making all of the money and um tell us give us some insight okay well i'll try to not be unruly
00:26:19 bruce sorry about that um seriously i i am nerding out to watch an alberta utilities commission
00:26:28 hearing via zoom um on a renewable energy project is yeah it's it's not for the faint of heart um
00:26:37 i've it's been going on for the last couple weeks there's a there we've we've heard recently that
00:26:42 there's a lot going on in vulcan county there's a the biggest solar farm in canada is going on
00:26:48 in vulcan county and amazon's going to buy the electricity and green gate's doing the project
00:26:53 isn't that fantastic? And it is fantastic. In this same little community, I drove down there
00:26:59 on Sunday, in this same little community near Lomond, Alberta, L-O-M-O-N-D, a gigantic German 1.00
00:27:08 multinational is going to, wants to, if they get permission, construct 83 wind turbines that are
00:27:16 taller than the Calgary Tower and have a wide sweep. It's almost that tall. It is a remarkable
00:27:25 investment. It's going to be, if they are successful, the biggest wind farm in Canada.
00:27:31 I mean, gosh, we start to sound like Texas with all these big boots things going on.
00:27:36 So I'm curious, why are they coming here? Why are they coming to Alberta? They've never invested
00:27:42 here before so i i went deep i went really deep and they are investing here because yes and under
00:27:51 the ndp government we had you know iso the electricity um aso alberta electricity service
00:27:59 system operator oh system operator thank you i just called them aso they had a bid for three
00:28:06 wind farms and people bid and those projects went ahead good stuff now this government has
00:28:12 opened it up and if you bid on these projects you bid you know you get to construct generate the
00:28:18 electricity but not only do you just get the right to sell the electricity to albertans you also get
00:28:26 the green credits now even the ndp didn't do that so it used to be that you you know you have this
00:28:32 great big cake that was electricity that you could sell but and the icing this little sliver of icing
00:28:39 was the green credits today even the market surveillance guys who are watchdogs are saying
00:28:46 who cares about the cake all they need is the icing to make this thing go economically 0.94
00:28:51 credits are worth that much and if you're avio wind and you come in from germany and you invest
00:28:58 your money to build all these wind turbines in our land remote places where people get accused
00:29:03 of nimbyism for questioning this because green is good you get to sell those credits and the value
00:29:10 of those credits is going up by the day and so they will likely be sold to somebody like amazon
00:29:17 to offset their emissions in a place like california now i have a problem with that i want 0.66
00:29:24 albertans to get that money am i being ridiculous i don't think so i don't think so danielle you
00:29:31 were nodding away there and um do you want to weigh in on this subject i don't know if you're
00:29:35 familiar with this this particular farm i don't mind a discussion about wind but it seems to me
00:29:41 we don't talk about wind and the environmental impacts the same way we talk about any other
00:29:45 energy source so if we're going to do compare green with green let's talk about the migratory
00:29:50 birds that get killed with these turbines let's talk about the bats that get killed let's talk
00:29:54 about the fact that you can't build wind turbines with a wind turbine you need to have steel which
00:29:59 you need fossil fuels for. You need cement, which you need fossil fuels for. You need fiberglass,
00:30:03 which you need fossil fuels for. You need to transport it to site. Some of these, I don't
00:30:07 know how big this one is, but it's 1,500 or more trips in traditional combustion engine vehicles
00:30:12 to get it to site. So why aren't we talking about all of those carbon impacts? In addition,
00:30:18 as I understand it, we don't have an effective way of decommissioning and recycling all of the
00:30:23 products at the end of life for these for these installations. And so we do have an imbalance in
00:30:30 how we assess them. The other thing I worry about with when I was down in Montana, and one of the
00:30:34 things they do in Montana is if you're going to sell renewable into the grid, you have to be able
00:30:39 to firm it up. So if you say I have 100 megawatts of power to sell, you have to always be able to
00:30:45 sell 100 megawatts of power, which means you have to partner with something like natural gas to be
00:30:50 able to make it work. The fact that they are able to come in, get all of the different credits that
00:30:55 Donna's talking about, in addition not have the same scrutiny on the environmental side that we
00:31:01 would have on our traditional industries, and then at the end of the day mess up with the power grid 0.78
00:31:07 because they can't provide reliable energy. I've looked at this every single year when we get down
00:31:12 minus 30 in February, we have an air mass that sits on us and none of those turbines move.
00:31:19 When it gets cold and frozen, none of those solar panels are generating energy either. And so we
00:31:25 have to recognize these are not year round alternatives and we have to judge them from
00:31:30 a reliability standpoint as well. That's supposed to be what the electric system operator is
00:31:34 supposed to do. And it seems like if everyone's chasing after the green credits, they're just not
00:31:39 making the full assessment that they need to on the cost benefit right and we should also consider
00:31:44 how much government money uh is is thrown at these things and by comparison to the oil and gas
00:31:49 industry uh rob you're the only person that hasn't jumped in on this one go ahead uh well i just echo
00:31:57 everything that uh that i've heard here is that daniel's uh um outline of the environmental
00:32:04 impacts of these wind farms was is is very true um there's a great book out it's called apocalypse
00:32:12 never it's by michael schellenberger he's an environmental activist ipc contributor certainly
00:32:18 not a righty very much on the left side of things but someone who's actually truthful
00:32:23 about climate alarmism and the damage he believes it's causing both the environmental movement and
00:32:28 the environment he talks a lot about solar farms and wind farms and it takes for solar farms take
00:32:35 450 times 450 times more land than nuclear plants and wind farms take 700 times more land than
00:32:43 natural gas wells to produce the same amount of energy and we are literally sitting on an ocean
00:32:51 of clean burning natural gas and we're getting better and more efficient at burning it and using
00:32:56 it every day that will not only heat our homes but it could heat hundreds of millions of homes
00:33:00 around the world as as i talked about earlier in asia and africa and so forth if we if we got our
00:33:06 act together and didn't have a hostile federal government and we can use all of these profits
00:33:12 from the sale that gas to develop and innovate tech in alberta uh which is which is fantastic
00:33:17 we have to be smarter on this issue bruce like aside from i'm not going to repeat what danielle
00:33:22 said these things are just but ugly okay like let's just call it a spade a spade we have one
00:33:28 of the most beautiful pristine landscapes in the world here especially on the uh on the on the
00:33:34 eastern slopes i do not want and i'm i'm sure the residents i know in talking with several of them
00:33:40 over the last week because i knew we were talking about this issue they are absolutely horrified by
00:33:46 this it's destroying their entire view scape and landscape they're ugly and they don't you can't
00:33:53 just at the end of life here you don't just tear them down and reset throw them in the recycle bin 0.87
00:33:57 at the curb I mean this is this is ridiculous we're sitting on on an ocean of natural gas and
00:34:04 all this is is it's a scam it's a way that a German company has found to come in here and and
00:34:12 and use the the carbon credit process and and the funding that's made available to them from
00:34:17 government and so forth directly and indirectly to make a buck this isn't about the environment
00:34:22 it has nothing to do with the environment if they did they could make you know they can make a far
00:34:28 bigger difference by investing in lng and getting it over to asia if they wanted to actually work on
00:34:34 c reducing co2 levels um loud and clear i hear you it's just brutal and there's there's
00:34:41 there's we should show leadership here and kenny should be all over this i hate i hate to cut you
00:34:46 off rob these lights on our landscape especially when you're that passionate on it on an answer i
00:34:51 hate to cut you off but we've got a couple things we want to get to before we run out of time in
00:34:56 about 10 minutes don i want you to close this one off for us and let us know what's the status of
00:35:01 this hearing what happens going forward the every all the uh the proponent and all the objectors
00:35:08 have been heard from. The AUC hearing has finished. They will announce their decision within 90 days,
00:35:15 so we'll know by year end. The First Nations communities that are directly affected by this
00:35:22 Blackfoot in southern Alberta were objectors and pulled out at the very last minute,
00:35:28 all three groups. The Majerville Medicine Wheel, which is a very significant religious site,
00:35:35 a traditional site is within view scape of the this particular installation of
00:35:42 turbines so it was very controversial there's a lot at stake here and once you
00:35:48 put these things up they're gonna be with us for a long time so I just you
00:35:53 know I want us to hear these people and I'm not you know I get NIMBYism but
00:35:59 these people have a right to be heard and and I I'm just not sure how many
00:36:05 Albertans can and have keep keep nerding out keep nerding out and listening to these things and
00:36:11 we'll we'll keep having you back Donna to to chat about them okay so what do we do about what we're
00:36:16 dealing with in Alberta what can Albertans do well Rob has authored along with a couple of others
00:36:22 Barry Cooper and Derek Fromm the free Alberta strategy Rob tee it up for us and tell you what
00:36:29 tell us what you suggest that we might do in order to make Ottawa frankly hear the voices of
00:36:34 albertans well thank you for that um and i'm very interested to hear donna's uh view on this because
00:36:41 i know that she was obviously on the fair deal panel and right did the lion ship like a lot of
00:36:46 work on that obviously um and there were some very good recommendations which are in as are part of
00:36:52 the free alberta strategy virtually every almost every one of them um the i would say the main
00:36:58 concept because you know we're short on time but the main concept is alberta in my view bruce needs
00:37:03 to um declare itself a sovereign jurisdiction within uh within canada um much like quebec
00:37:11 has effectively done they have their national assembly um they pass laws that uh like banning
00:37:17 pipelines from crossing their borders that are clearly unconstitutional not in their purview
00:37:21 but they do it anyway in ottawa doesn't really have a choice but to respect that and alberta
00:37:26 needs to as you know we talked about before coming you know to air here alberta needs to 1.00
00:37:31 get its elbows up here like we are being attacked on every single side right now but mostly by by
00:37:38 ottawa and uh when we're talking about what's happening um in confederation here and what's
00:37:45 happening is not just sucking resources out of alberta that's definitely still a problem 0.66
00:37:49 equalization and transfer and so forth but this is an existential crisis we are talking about
00:37:55 the destruction of our most important significant industry not just in alberta but in all of canada
00:38:02 and like what country undertakes such a such a self-destructive course of action we have to say
00:38:09 look in alberta if you pass laws that interfere with our provincial jurisdictions such as natural
00:38:15 governance of our natural resources we are not going to enforce those laws within the province
00:38:21 so carbon tax we're not enforcing it here we're not going to put that burden on our people
00:38:25 and on our industry to enforce the carbon tax with any provincial agency or governed body we need to
00:38:34 start doing these things and yeah it's going to ruffle feathers and you know maybe a little mini
00:38:39 uh controlled constitutional crisis is what uh what a country needs from time to time when it's
00:38:44 become as dysfunctional as it is now but that's kind of the foundational principle of the free
00:38:49 alberta strategy we'll probably make more time for it in a future episode rob but um having said what
00:38:55 you just did danielle we'll start with you and then we'll go to donna and allow her to make a 1.00
00:38:58 comment and then wrap up um okay you hear a lot of talk about separation lately i think this is where
00:39:04 the rubber hits the road many albertans are frustrated but they about what they see but
00:39:09 don't want to go that far is this um is this a lever we need to pull do we need to be more
00:39:14 aggressive clearly we do there's two there's two things that i'll just jump off from what rob said
00:39:20 about how we assert ourselves i remember being on a panel a few years ago with um with a quebecer
00:39:25 and we talked about how confederation should work and it actually should work ironically
00:39:32 a little bit more like the european union instead of having ottawa collect all the taxes and shoot
00:39:38 the money back to us we collect our own taxes and we decide what we're going to shoot to ottawa 0.66
00:39:42 i mean the i don't know how it is that we gave up autonomy over that central tax collection role
00:39:48 because even if ottawa argues they have an entitlement to every penny that they're taking
00:39:54 from us i think it would be good psychologically for us to be able to see just how much we're
00:39:59 giving to ottawa that gets dispersed into quebec and the rest of the country right now it's
00:40:04 intermingled the other thing too is that we need to demonstrate that we have the capacity to do
00:40:10 all of the things that an independent sovereign within Canada jurisdiction can do. And we haven't
00:40:15 done that. So for me, collecting all of our own taxes first is the number one priority.
00:40:22 Second, I was recently talking to somebody who is trying to create a bio waste facility in Alberta.
00:40:30 They said it's mystifying. In Quebec, you only have to go through one environmental review process.
00:40:35 Quebec has the environmental authority. Once they've decided to approve it, it gets approved.
00:40:39 we have two layers here not only does alberta have an environmental review process but doesn't
00:40:44 get approved until ottawa approves it how come quebec has autonomy on environmental approvals
00:40:50 and we don't why is the federal government asserting that it should be able to approve
00:40:53 our sagd projects or the tech frontier mine or whatever other project we put forward the answer
00:40:59 is no we just have to assert ourselves in the same way that quebec has and those would be the
00:41:03 the two places I'd start. Okay. Donna, concluding thoughts, both on this subject and on what we've
00:41:10 discussed so far this evening. I'm going to be a bit of a dissent here. I actually think we should
00:41:18 put our elbows down a little. I was on the Fair Deal panel, and I was actually surprised that
00:41:23 Kenny asked me to be on that panel because I think it was a case of keeping your enemies close.
00:41:28 um i learned a lot because i like to listen to albertans and they had a lot to say and i think
00:41:35 we dug into what the legal framework is and and i think there's a better understanding of what our
00:41:40 legal rights are within within confederation and that has a value to what both danielle and rob
00:41:46 what you're speaking to we we need to know our rights so that we can you know exercise them
00:41:51 but you know british columbia has figured out a way to do the carbon tax in a way that's effective
00:41:57 And we could have done the same thing.
00:42:01 Our industry here and innovators, and I'm not just talking about oil and gas, are doing leading edge stuff.
00:42:08 AI out of Edmonton, like that's cutting edge.
00:42:11 Machine learning, lots of stuff coming out of all over the province, everywhere.
00:42:16 I think we just need to keep doing what we're doing.
00:42:19 and if we put our elbows down and stopped attracting all this drama because it's attract
00:42:26 we're like a lightning rod for it right if we could just say you know what we want people across
00:42:33 canada to thrive all of us we are only four and a half million people here in alberta
00:42:39 we contribute more than we take you know what for now that's the deal and and we acknowledge it but
00:42:46 But let's just move on and just allow us to be able to whatever it takes.
00:42:53 We might have to dig a little bit differently and we might have to shoot from behind the neck from time to time to throw in a hockey metaphor, Bruce.
00:43:02 But it's it's we have to learn how to do it and we have to be smart.
00:43:07 And I think we're capable of it. But elbows up all the time.
00:43:10 I just think it's a game that gets tired and it's distracting and it's distracting us from
00:43:15 doing what we are capable of doing, which is a heck of a lot more. And I want us to spend our
00:43:21 energy on that. Well, I can tell you more people are shooting from behind the net for what it's
00:43:25 worth. The lacrosse move is making its way into the NHL. Dawn, I know you've got a jet, so thank
00:43:31 you for your time tonight. I know Rob and Danielle are both going to probably disagree with some of
00:43:35 what you said, but really appreciate you joining us. One more plug for your book, okay?
00:43:40 Thank you. OK, the book, the book, one more time, teaching the dinosaur to dance.
00:43:47 That's right. And it's due out in in the spring. Donna Kennedy, glad. So good to have you. Thank you.
00:43:53 Thanks. Boy, boy, Donna packed a lot in there. And, you know, I think, to be fair, much of what she says is reasonable.
00:44:01 But a lot of people are at the point where they said we've been trying that strategy.
00:44:04 We've been trying to do it that way. And it's not working.
00:44:07 I mean, what would you say, first of all, to what Donna said and concluding thoughts on what we've discussed so far this evening?
00:44:13 Well, anybody who knows hockey knows that you don't you're not going to win too many games if you don't bang, crash and get your elbows up in the corners from time to time because you won't be respected and your space won't be respected.
00:44:23 So I think that it is important. And I think that, frankly, we haven't, we've had our elbows down for several decades now where we basically just allowed Ottawa to run roughshod over our provincial jurisdictions to rob us blind, frankly, $700 billion over six years in net equalization and transfers.
00:44:45 we can't allow this to happen anymore where we're going to be a has been and have not and uh that's
00:44:52 not the alberta that i want to live in uh the alberta i want to live in and i want to see kids
00:44:56 live in and and friends and family it's a strong prosperous economically powerful province that
00:45:04 you know that is able to create the technologies to deal with some of these big world environmental
00:45:08 issues and do so on our terms with our people and our money and uh we need to start we need to stop
00:45:15 being so deferential to the authority of ottawa in order to get there because if we don't i'm
00:45:21 telling you it's uh we're going to bleed out as a as a province and you can if you want to look to
00:45:26 what we'll look like um you know people aren't going to move here for our weather that's for
00:45:30 sure uh it's going to look we're going to look a lot like you know who knows um other places that
00:45:36 are far less prosperous and that we don't want to be like so i think the strategy is is a key
00:45:41 piece of that and i'm glad to see that uh or hear that danielle um uh is uh understands so much of
00:45:47 it and is supportive of it so maybe we're about to get an endorsement from you danielle uh well
00:45:53 well said rob listen uh thank you and uh why don't we leave the last word to danielle tonight on what
00:45:59 you've heard from donna and rob on this subject danielle and just just in general um you know
00:46:04 our our conversation this evening well let me let me tell you the problem that i have in the
00:46:09 position that I'm in is because I talk to innovators all the time, and I know that the
00:46:13 innovators have taken the net zero challenge seriously, and they think they can do it.
00:46:17 They think that not only this race to net zero is one that we should run, but it's one that we
00:46:22 can win. But I feel like the polarization has gotten in the way of the conversation. So with
00:46:28 Premier Kenney, he spent so much time fighting the carbon tax that I don't think he wants to talk
00:46:32 about the things that I'm seeing about this type of innovation. And then on the other hand, if you
00:46:37 believe the polls, it looks like Rachel Notley might be our next premier. Well, last time she
00:46:41 got elected, she completely froze out the business community and wasn't interested in hearing what 1.00
00:46:45 they had to say. So if you end up with our two political leaders not hearing from the innovators,
00:46:50 and at the same time, you've got a mayor in Calgary, Jody Gondek, that doesn't know what's
00:46:54 going on in her own backyard. The same time you've got a prime minister who thinks that we've got an
00:46:58 industry that's stuck in the 1990s. I don't know how we move forward on finding that kind of
00:47:04 collaboration and that sort of solution. That's where I'm feeling some frustration is that it
00:47:08 does seem to me like we are the most entrepreneurial place in the entire country. We have the best
00:47:14 minds here. And what happens when we have downturn in our economy is everybody sits and thinks and
00:47:21 gets creative and then they come back even stronger. And I feel like we're on the cusp of
00:47:25 doing that. But I don't think that the politicians understand just how much the industry is prepared
00:47:31 to innovate, how quickly they're prepared to get there. And instead, we're setting up this
00:47:36 polarization and this fight. That's what I worry about is nobody's at the table. No one's talking
00:47:40 to each other. And if we don't get people talking to each other, I think that the inevitable is
00:47:46 going to happen. I don't know that this country can stay together. Well, talking about it is
00:47:50 exactly what we need to do. And that's what we try to do tonight and we'll continue to do. Danielle,
00:47:54 thank you. And Rob, thank you both for being with us. My pleasure. All right. Let me conclude with
00:48:00 this tonight to those of you watching at home. We're going to do this on Censored every week.
00:48:05 We're going to do a segment. If you have some thoughts on what you'd like to see us discuss,
00:48:10 some of the issues that you would like to see covered, send us an email. We'll certainly take
00:48:13 it into account. Rob and Danielle will be regular panelists and we'll bring a third in depending on
00:48:18 the subject material. But frankly, Alberta is in a situation where many of these things are not
00:48:24 getting the publicity that they need to. And we're going to do our best to give that to them and to
00:48:28 bring some perspective and some insight on this political panel called Uncensored.
00:48:33 Thank you for being with us tonight. We'll see you next week.
00:48:58 .
00:49:28 You