Western Standard - November 20, 2021


Uncensored: Live from the UCP AGM 2021

Mentioned
The Pipeline: Devastation in BC and Conservative Chaos Jason Kenney's Keynote Address live from the UCP AGM 2021

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

184.1

Word count

3,380

Sentence count

113

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us live from the floor of the United Conservative Party AGM where our panelists Danielle Smith, Rob Anderson, and Bruce McAllister discuss the premier's speech on the eve of the AGM. Topics covered include: What is the real problem Alberta is facing right now? Why is it so important to have children in school? Why should they play sports in public schools? What s the best way to deal with the growing opioid crisis?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Good afternoon and welcome to Uncensored on Western Standard.
00:01:56 We are live on the floor of the UCP AGM here at Gray Eagle Casino.
00:02:01 I'm your host, Bruce McAllister, and I'm joined, as always, by our two esteemed panelists.
00:02:06 First, on my immediate right, Danielle Smith, the president of the Alberta Enterprise Group,
00:02:10 former leader of the Wild Rose Party, and common sense conservative commentator.
00:02:14 Danielle, good to see you.
00:02:15 Good to see you, Bruce.
00:02:16 Rob Anderson, practicing litigator, former Airdrie MLA, and author of the Alberta Enterprise.
00:02:23 No, the Free Alberta Strategy.
00:02:25 Mix them up.
00:02:26 Rob thanks for being here. Thanks for having me. It's been a long day and a long night uh for those
00:02:31 that haven't been here uh we can tell you that the premier just finished his speech uh people
00:02:35 behind us you may see having lunch now why don't we start on the premier's speech uh what did you
00:02:40 think of it? I loved about uh 45 percent of it I think part of the problem that he has is that he
00:02:47 he's hitting all the right points like all of the great things he's doing with the economy
00:02:52 all of the business investment if that was the kind of thing that moved votes then i think he
00:02:57 would be doing just fine the problem is that he had to begin with the very contentious issue of
00:03:02 how he's managed the covet crisis and this is a very divided room and i didn't hear what he needed
00:03:08 to say was something that would either win votes back from where they're landing with the ndp
00:03:15 or win votes back from where they've drifted to the wild rose and other political parties and i
00:03:19 I think that that was a missed opportunity for him, quite frankly.
00:03:22 Maybe a reason for that.
00:03:24 But before I follow up, Rob, your thoughts in general on the speech.
00:03:27 Kind of the same feeling.
00:03:29 You know, the two, the Premier's doing quite well on some of the files.
00:03:34 If you look at his work on the education file, on the diversification file, they're doing well.
00:03:39 The problem is the two biggest issues in Alberta right now are, well, obviously COVID's one.
00:03:45 And closely behind that is Alberta sovereignty, our place, and confederation.
00:03:49 And he's utterly failing in those areas.
00:03:51 And even in the speech today, his discussion about those two issues
00:03:55 is extremely weak and defiant, and he just isn't getting it.
00:04:00 So he can do well in those other areas, and that's great.
00:04:02 Those are important files, but he's missing the point.
00:04:06 He needs to address the elephants in the room,
00:04:09 which are those two issues, which right now he's failing on.
00:04:11 Okay, what should he have done?
00:04:13 Well, I think there's a feeling out there that maybe it's time for a mea culpa.
00:04:17 you know you say look i i haven't done this you know we've been obviously distracted by the
00:04:23 the covid crisis and all those sorts of things but it's time to turn the page and be strong on
00:04:28 these issues particularly the alberta sovereignty and albert's place in confederation and and and
00:04:33 reese probably apologize for some of his um uh indecisions with regards to dealing with covid
00:04:41 back and the forth and the flipping and the flopping and the demonizing of his base and so
00:04:45 forth and move forward but he didn't do that daniel you've been on that stage maybe not the
00:04:49 one here at great eagle not as premier but certainly as leader of the official opposition
00:04:52 in front of hundreds of people you know what it's like to try and balance uh competing interests
00:04:58 and obviously he was trying to do that so playing the devil's advocate what what would you have
00:05:02 done differently what would you have liked you know i felt like the room was really on his side
00:05:06 certainly when he got past the discussion about covid i don't think i think his real problem is
00:05:11 we're heading into a fall respiratory virus season. And I don't think people trust that
00:05:16 when he says we're going to do it this way, that he's going to stick with it. I think we've seen
00:05:20 the flip-flopping. And I'll just give a prime example. In the past couple of days, we've seen
00:05:24 that vaccines have been approved for age 5 to 11. And he initially said, we're not going to
00:05:31 mandate that kids have to have vaccines to go to school. But you know what? Kids still have to be
00:05:35 vaccinated to play sports and to be in band and to play soccer and to go to arenas. And I
00:05:41 guess i'm thinking so what's the rules going to be are we going to start having five and six and
00:05:46 seven year olds banned from those kind of activities i just don't know where he's going to go because
00:05:51 it seems like every time he comes out strong on an issue he gets pushed back by mainstream media
00:05:57 he gets pushed back by docs gets pushed back by teachers then some kind of poll result comes out
00:06:02 and he completely flips and i think that's the problem that he's going to have is that he can't
00:06:06 quite get past that because it doesn't sound like he thinks he's done anything wrong okay
00:06:11 So I want to follow up on policy debate and all those things,
00:06:14 but because you raised it, COVID vaccines for kids.
00:06:18 My fear and the fear of a lot of parents is right now you say they're not mandatory.
00:06:21 What happens, Danielle, when the mainstream media, when the docs,
00:06:26 when the NDP come out and say, you should mandate these,
00:06:29 and the pressure starts to build publicly?
00:06:32 Will we see an about-face and a foot-flop one?
00:06:35 This is what I'm worried about is so much of what is happening
00:06:37 around the vaccine policy is social pressure.
00:06:40 and my own dear niece she ended up getting vaccinated because she was getting taunted by
00:06:45 her kids by her classmates and I just don't want to see six and seven and eight and nine-year-olds
00:06:50 feeling that kind of ostracism and bullying because that that lasts a lifetime and for the
00:06:55 comfort of adults putting that on children who don't have the maturity to be able to handle that
00:07:00 that uh that kind of pressure it's not fair it's not right especially since we know now that we
00:07:06 have had almost two years of experience with this virus it is very clear most at risk is over the
00:07:12 age of 70 multiple pre-existing conditions especially those who are living in congregate
00:07:16 care either because they're in hospital or in nursing homes there really is no reason to be
00:07:21 putting that kind of pressure on kids and that's what I'm worried about is that the premier has
00:07:24 unfortunately demonstrated one too many times that whenever Rachel Notley takes the lead on an issue 0.99
00:07:30 manages to rally some public opinion behind her then he ends up going the exact opposite direction
00:07:35 that's exactly the opposite of what his members want to see him do i'm going to guess you'd probably
00:07:39 say the same thing um this is one i think there'll be significant backlash in though if we do see a
00:07:45 flip-flop yeah no absolutely the the way that that uh he'll be quick to say the premier will
00:07:52 be quick to say that it's not mandatory right he'll say no no you've got you've got a choice
00:07:57 you've got a television folks you've got you've got a choice you're able to you're able to uh
00:08:03 decide whether or not to get it but you don't you either get it or you lose your job you either get
00:08:08 it or for your kids or you don't your kids don't play sports which i think is frankly abusive to
00:08:13 children like that is part of their lives and and it shouldn't matter if you're if you're living in
00:08:19 calgary and you can't play sports if you're a kid or you live in an air dream you can't i mean it's
00:08:22 just insane let me let me ask you both to park this one i think we could talk about this potential
00:08:27 COVID policy, and we should mention maybe for a future episode of Uncensored, let's have
00:08:33 this discussion more in depth, but I want to get back to the convention.
00:08:38 It's like there's a, I mean, it's the United Conservative Party, it feels anything but
00:08:44 united.
00:08:44 Let's talk with the policy debate and the motion that came on the floor first with you,
00:08:49 Danielle, to increase from 22 to 29 the amount of constituency associations that have to
00:08:55 vote for leadership with you.
00:08:56 didn't get support enough support but it didn't get 57 support it was a weird i was here last
00:09:02 night it was quite strange to start off with a constitutional discussion in the evening when
00:09:08 people were still trying to file through i gather there was a protest outside that prevented as many
00:09:13 as 150 delegates from coming in and so and because of just the the way policies are voted on that one
00:09:19 needed a particularly high bar 75 percent it ended up getting 57 and so it ended up failing just
00:09:25 because of that. But that gives you some sense of where the room is at. To have 43% on a vote like
00:09:32 that say, no, we want to be able to keep with the rules, knowing that that bar, I guess, has already
00:09:37 been reached. There already are 22 presidents who want to call for an early leadership. It was quite
00:09:42 clear that there was some pressure being put on to manipulate the membership into passing a higher
00:09:50 bar, and the membership was having none of it. That's what I got the sense of last night, is they
00:09:54 They said, don't try to change the rules on us because virtually every other policy after that failed.
00:09:59 I got the real impression that because of the way that was handled, the membership just said, we're not going to trust any of these rule changes.
00:10:08 And so they just voted them down.
00:10:09 Okay.
00:10:10 So just, again, if you're not clear, and I think you explained it very well, for the motion to pass, it needed 75% of the membership vote.
00:10:18 It got 57.
00:10:19 still 57 was if that's a vote on if that's a leadership vote for the premier it's closing in
00:10:25 on 60 i mean what did you think of the number well first of all it's a stacked vote right
00:10:29 so so the premier's his people are paying for memberships getting people out here in droves
00:10:35 and they still only got 50 percent seven percent that's not good isn't the other side doing the
00:10:41 same thing they're not the other side isn't as organized and they don't have as much money at
00:10:44 their disposal there's just no way but aside from that i think there's this almost denial in the
00:10:50 room that i'm here that i'm seeing right now i think there are some people in here the premier's
00:10:55 people that still think the man can win and i'm telling you i i have at this point i don't see a
00:11:02 way that he can win the next election i don't see a path and so it's very interesting because you
00:11:07 got a party here that's basically engineering its own self-destruction that's what it feels like in
00:11:11 the room they are not going to win they are going to lose with him at the helm and i think people
00:11:16 that's the conversations in the hospitality suites that's the conversations if you get people one-on-one
00:11:21 but when everyone comes to vote and everyone's got to stand and pay homage to the great leader
00:11:27 and so forth it's a really odd uh dysfunctional tone here right now you know and part of the
00:11:32 reason for that is that the premier gives a really good speech i was i had the teleprompter right
00:11:38 behind me and i was turning around to see how much he was reading off of it very little he has
00:11:43 a one bullet point and then he just drives it home because he's a really smart guy and he gets
00:11:49 right into the details and he can give a barn buster of a speech and so i think people give
00:11:54 the get the impression that that's going to be enough to rally support to win in the next election
00:11:58 problem is it's a big province 4.4 million people you can't cram all of them into a room like this
00:12:03 not all of them are going to see a speech like that and so they're going to make their judgment
00:12:06 based on different things, based on what he does.
00:12:09 And as Rob pointed out, especially for rural Alberta,
00:12:13 the free Alberta strategy,
00:12:14 all the things that we need to do to assert Alberta sovereignty,
00:12:17 it's not acted on that.
00:12:19 And now these very, very divisive policies
00:12:21 that were still not past COVID,
00:12:23 that's going to be a continued problem for him.
00:12:25 Okay.
00:12:27 I'm going to try and play devil's advocate with some of this.
00:12:30 So if you're the premier, I mean, you've got to say,
00:12:33 When do the headlines start focusing on all of the positives that we're doing in Alberta, jobs, jobs, jobs, the economy taking off, all of the good things we're doing, instead of this self-destructing party debate?
00:12:48 What I'm trying to ask, I guess, if we gave the guy a break and started to report on the news of the day and not necessarily the forces that are trying to divide the party, would he stand a chance to pull this back together? I'll start with you.
00:13:01 i follow his twitter feed and i love it when he's tweeting about the latest business investment or
00:13:06 some new job creation effort i think that that is when he's at his best that's what he loves
00:13:12 talking about however my observation is that people are prepared to take a risk on changing
00:13:18 government when the economy is going well it's sort of counterintuitive that politicians don't
00:13:23 necessarily get their credit when things are going well that's when people say you know what even the
00:13:27 the next guys couldn't screw this up because it's going so well so in some ways i think that
00:13:31 actually plays to rachel notley's favor i don't know that that will be a barrier to people making 0.54
00:13:36 that decision to go back to her in 2023 okay pick up on that but also this brian gene is here
00:13:43 shaking hands and meeting delegates and there's there's a guy wading into wings i'll tell you
00:13:50 what i'm hearing from a lot of people is that's not the answer so i mean i i don't know where
00:13:54 you are on that but touch on both of those questions well first of all every every failed
00:13:59 leader always blames the media for not getting their positive message out okay so that's not an
00:14:04 excuse you he's he's the premier he has to he has to generate support and he's just done a poor job
00:14:11 in a couple of key files and that's just the way it is so you're you can't complain oh that the
00:14:15 media is doing this and that it's just especially for a conservative leader that's life get used to
00:14:19 But with regards to the other leadership candidates in the wings and so forth, I do think that that's a bit of concern for people.
00:14:27 I think that they're saying, okay, if we get rid of them, who's going to be next and so forth.
00:14:35 But again, that will take care of itself.
00:14:38 There's always going to be someone that is going to step up, the right person at the right time.
00:14:42 That is going to happen.
00:14:43 So I'm curious to see if the caucus in particular, because I don't personally feel that the leadership vote is going to result in Kenny having to step down.
00:14:53 I think that the only way this is going to work is if MLAs, 10 to 15 of them, go sit as independents and demand that he step down.
00:15:01 And I think that's either going to happen in the spring or it's not.
00:15:04 And if it doesn't, we're going to have an NDP government in 2023.
00:15:07 and rob's being too modest because he would be one of the names that would that i think people
00:15:12 would ask to step forward to put his name into you know i i would feel like if the position was open
00:15:18 that i'd have to run just because i believe in unity and this is the real issue is that let's
00:15:23 throw some names on the table because there's some good cabinet ministers um i i believe jason
00:15:28 nixon has demonstrated that he's got leadership potential doug switzer has demonstrated leadership
00:15:33 potential. Leila here is clearly interested. Rajan Zani is clearly interested. Casey Madhu,
00:15:39 the justice minister, would be a good candidate. And then on the outside, those who were involved
00:15:44 in World Coast politics, Rob Anderson, Bruce McAllister, maybe me, Brian Jean, they're talking
00:15:49 about federal names, Michelle Rumpel-Garner, Ronna Ambrose. Here's the point. If you had 10
00:15:53 strong leadership candidates, each selling 20,000 members to win, now you have a party of 200,000
00:16:01 people going into the next election that is a force that can turn things around and that's the
00:16:06 kind of rejuvenation that happens with the party leadership but if we continue on this path i think
00:16:12 you're going to see struggle in not in motivation not only the fundraising numbers but the membership
00:16:19 numbers the willingness of people to come out do or not and that's what lends itself to the
00:16:23 ndp winning okay um we're going to wrap in a couple of minutes so why don't we go this way
00:16:29 Where do we go from here?
00:16:30 Where does the UCP go from here?
00:16:32 And what's next for the Premier?
00:16:34 Well, I think, again, I think we're going to know in the spring.
00:16:37 And I think that I'd be surprised.
00:16:40 There'll be a leadership.
00:16:41 He made that clear, at least, in his speech.
00:16:43 There's going to be a leadership.
00:16:44 My guess is he will survive it.
00:16:46 He's an excellent organizer, the Premier.
00:16:48 Excellent organizer with regards to getting delegates out.
00:16:50 That's his wheelhouse.
00:16:51 He'll make sure he gets his over 50%.
00:16:53 I think that'll be good enough for him.
00:16:56 And then it's up to the MLAs.
00:16:57 At the end of the day, will his caucus, will 15 to 20 of his caucus have the guts to do what's necessary and do what, frankly, happened to Stockwell Day back in the day where the 10 MPs went and sat, sit as independence and ask the Premier to do the right thing.
00:17:13 And if not, then I think 2023 is going to be a tough one.
00:17:16 The only other option would be that I think Brian Jean clearly wants to run for UCP leadership.
00:17:22 I mean, he's as much an architect of unity as the Premier is,
00:17:26 so I think that that would be his first option.
00:17:28 But clearly, if he doesn't get that chance,
00:17:30 he, I think, believes that it's his job to break the bottleneck.
00:17:33 And so I think you'd see him starting rebranding himself
00:17:37 and the party under a brand new name,
00:17:39 running 87 in 87 constituencies,
00:17:43 and I think he'd have a pretty good chance
00:17:45 of winning a lot of them in rural Alberta.
00:17:47 That isn't a winning strategy for Calgary and Edmonton.
00:17:50 So that road also probably leads to a Rachel Nobby victory.
00:17:54 Well, we expected a lot of drama at this convention.
00:17:58 I'm not sure that we've got all that we expected.
00:18:00 But what I'm hearing is expected at the next one and over the next year.
00:18:04 Completely.
00:18:05 All right, guys.
00:18:06 Thanks, as always, for your time.
00:18:08 Thank you.
00:18:08 Danielle Smith and Rob Anderson, Uncensored on the Western Standard,
00:18:11 live from the floor of the Great Eagle Casino at the UCP AGM.
00:18:16 We'll be back with more episodes of Uncensored on the Western Standard.
00:18:19 Thanks for watching