Western Standard - April 10, 2025


VINDICATED: COVID-era protest ban ruled unconstitutional

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
It starts with Gold 'Canada will fold...' and they know it, tough talk just for election, Part 1

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

128.99

Word count

3,077

Sentence count

144

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Randy Hillier served as the MP for Lanark, Frontenac and Kingston in the Ontario PC caucus from 2007 to 2022. He was kicked out of the caucus by Premier Doug Ford in 2019, for his opposition to the government's anti-lockdown laws during protests.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Mark Carney backed Bill C-69, Trudeau's No More Pipelines Law.
00:00:09 It's killing energy projects right here at home.
00:00:13 But guess what?
00:00:15 While Canadian workers get left behind, Carney's company, Brookfield, is busy buying pipelines in the U.S., in Brazil, around the world.
00:00:26 Shut down Canadian energy. Profit off everyone else's.
00:00:32 Mark Carney. Blocking Canadian jobs and banking foreign billions.
00:00:56 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:01:09 Just yesterday, there was a historic court ruling from, I believe it was the Superior Court of Ontario,
00:01:16 Ontario's Supreme Court, for lack of a better term,
00:01:18 that ruled that the Doug Ford, Ontario PC government's anti-lockdown rules,
00:01:26 sorry, anti-protest rules during COVID lockdowns were unconstitutional.
00:01:33 Many people were charged, fined, imprisoned unjustly under these laws,
00:01:40 restricting the right of Ontarians to demonstrate freely during the COVID lockdowns.
00:01:45 Funny enough, these laws seem to not have been applied to Black Lives Matter protests taking place at the time, but towards people protesting the laws themselves.
00:01:54 The face of many of these protests and the government's prosecutions against their anti-protest laws during lockdowns was Randy Hillier.
00:02:08 Randy Hillier served as the Ontario Member of the Provincial Parliament from 2007 to 2022
00:02:14 as the MVP for Lanark, Frontenac, and Kingston in different variations of that constituency.
00:02:21 He was kicked out of the Ontario PC caucus by Premier Doug Ford in 2019.
00:02:29 There's paper reasons for it, but it was very clear the reason he was kicked out was his opposition
00:02:33 to lockdowns, mandates, and other COVID measures.
00:02:37 So it's my pleasure to welcome to the program, Randy Hillier, coming to us from some undisclosed location in the Ottawa Valley.
00:02:46 From beautiful downtown Lanark County.
00:02:49 Pleasure to see you again, Derek, and pleasure to be on the show with you.
00:02:52 My pleasure.
00:02:53 And you're going to live with Cobb with Western Standard.
00:02:56 Oh, thank you.
00:02:57 Lanark County, I've got a lot of family history in that area.
00:03:00 It is a beautiful place.
00:03:01 And for the Albertans who might hold it against me for having roots in that area,
00:03:05 It is the closest thing to Alberta, uh, east of Saskatchewan.
00:03:09 If Alberta is ever its own country, I'm going to make sure that Lanark County is, uh, one
00:03:14 of our colonies.
00:03:15 All right.
00:03:16 Uh, Randy, um, maybe just, uh, briefly give us just a summary of, uh, you know, maybe
00:03:24 a bit beyond what I did in the introduction of what it is that happened with the charges
00:03:29 against you, what it is you were fighting against.
00:03:31 and uh and then we'll go kind of into the court battles from there yeah so this was all in
00:03:39 in 2020 i began to publicly oppose with rallies demonstrations public rallies and demonstrations
00:03:49 the lockdown measures that the doug ford government had imposed
00:03:55 And during 2020, 2021, leading up to the truckers' convoy in February 2022, these rallies became bigger and bigger and more frequently.
00:04:12 As a result, I received 25 provincial offense notices for organizing these rallies.
00:04:19 Each one of the offenses carried a maximum fine of $100,000 and up to a year in jail.
00:04:28 Eventually, 20 of them would be withdrawn, but there remained five prosecutors who were absolutely determined and vicious and wanted to get their pound of flesh from me.
00:04:39 There. And we argued this in the constitutional court. So yesterday's decision was in the Ontario Court of Appeals, the highest court that we have here. If the Crown seeks to appeal that decision, they will have to go to the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:04:57 So the appeals court ruled, without question, the measures that Doug Ford did during the Reopening Ontario Act were constitutionally invalid.
00:05:12 He did not have the authority to prohibit and ban the outright, the protests and the peaceful assembly.
00:05:23 So it's been four and a half years since those charges started.
00:05:29 And it has now come to an end unless the government, the Crown, decides to seek leave of appeal to the Supreme Court.
00:05:42 And do you have any idea, Randy, if the Crown is intending on appealing this to the Supreme Court?
00:05:47 Because this is a major curtailment of, and this sets precedent right across the country.
00:05:53 I know many provincial governments would be unhappy about this ruling with the precedent set.
00:05:57 Is there any indication that the federal or Ontario governments are intending to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada?
00:06:04 Not yet.
00:06:05 They have 30 days.
00:06:06 And there is still a remedy stage here.
00:06:08 We still have to, you know, will the law be struck down?
00:06:14 So when a law is found to be invalid constitutionally, Derek, then the question becomes, what do you do?
00:06:24 Do you read something else into the law to make it constitutionally valid, or do you strike down the law?
00:06:33 So over the next month, we'll be having further hearings about the remedy.
00:06:39 um um and i don't want to jump the gun or jump the shark here um and release anything but we'll
00:06:49 be i'll be going very strong that there can never be limits on peaceful assembly
00:06:56 in a free and democratic society if you prevent or prohibit peaceful assembly you are no longer
00:07:07 in a free and democratic society.
00:07:09 So there's that element to come, and then it will be the crown
00:07:14 will have 30 days, but they don't have an automatic right of appeal
00:07:18 to the Supreme Court.
00:07:19 They would have to make a strong case that this is a national
00:07:24 pressing concern that it should go to the Supreme Court.
00:07:28 But yes, many other provinces will be with trepidation on this
00:07:33 at other, you know, charges that are still before the courts
00:07:40 over the lockdowns, people that have been convicted of these.
00:07:44 We could see a significant number of successful appeals, et cetera.
00:07:54 So we'll have to wait and see, though, what comes up.
00:07:58 Yeah, this could have a domino effect for many people
00:08:01 who've been convicted under both Ontario
00:08:04 and other provincial anti-protest laws
00:08:09 during lockdowns.
00:08:12 Most things have been thrown out,
00:08:14 but some have stuck thus far
00:08:16 until your victory here.
00:08:18 Do you think there could be a domino effect
00:08:20 from your ruling?
00:08:22 Well, I think there's a few things.
00:08:24 So this is the first time the court has ever ruled.
00:08:28 Yeah.
00:08:29 Well, there's two things.
00:08:30 This is the first time that we've actually won against the lockdowns on a constitutional question.
00:08:37 There's been some successes like in Alberta.
00:08:41 Remember the courts ruled that the Alberta Health Services did not have the statutory authority.
00:08:49 Yeah, those were statutory victories, not constitutional.
00:08:51 Yours was constitutional, making it much more important nationally.
00:08:54 Absolutely.
00:08:55 And this is also the first time that a court of this stature has, in its first time a court, has ruled on the provisions of peaceful assembly as a protected right.
00:09:12 So the decision is quite powerful, very unique, and the judges, the three judges at the appeal courts recognize the significance of what peaceful assembly is in a free and democratic society.
00:09:31 So, and I think this coupled with the Mosley decision from January of, was it January 24 or 23, I forget now, but the Mosley decision that ruled the Emergency Act as ultraviolet or as unconstitutional, that coupled with this, I think will, can be utilized substantially by
00:10:01 any remaining uh individuals in front of the courts in ottawa on the on the truckers convoy
00:10:07 so this has been going on uh what about four years now four and a half years on this particular ones
00:10:12 i still have some other charges uh from the truckers convoy but uh we we won't confuse or
00:10:19 muddy the waters with those ones right today yeah uh yeah yeah you uh i mean you you've been racking
00:10:25 them up, uh, doing God's work, racking up these, uh, these COVID related charges.
00:10:29 Um, like what's been the cost you personally, uh, lawyers ain't cheap.
00:10:34 So I've been, um, so I've been very fortunate.
00:10:38 I, you know, you have to give a big thank you to, uh, uh, John Carpe and the Jason CF and
00:10:43 the charter advocates who have been handling these provincial offenses for me.
00:10:48 Uh, I am representing myself.
00:10:50 The cost of lawyers on the criminal charges was bankrupting me,
00:10:55 so I dispensed with my legal counsel on the criminal charges
00:11:00 about a year and a half ago.
00:11:04 So I've been able to keep my head above water
00:11:07 representing myself on that one.
00:11:09 That's dangerous, representing yourself in court,
00:11:13 especially on a criminal matter.
00:11:15 It wasn't, Derek.
00:11:17 Like it was, you know, my lawyer, I'd already given him over a hundred grand for the initial part of the defense.
00:11:28 And, you know, like I'm not a wealthy man, but regardless, I'd already given him a hundred grand.
00:11:35 He wanted another hundred grand to keep the defense going.
00:11:41 And I said to him, I said, you know, what's this going to cost in total?
00:11:47 And he said, well, you know, budget 500,000 bucks.
00:11:51 And, you know, it's not like I'm some Ottawa politician that has the nice gold-plated pensions.
00:11:58 Provincial politicians in Ontario don't get any pension at all.
00:12:02 So, you know, and I just said to him, so there was no risk to me, Derek.
00:12:08 It was either I went bankrupt and lost my home and put my family out of a home.
00:12:15 and still possibly get put in jail
00:12:19 because the Crown wanted three and a half years on that charge
00:12:22 or represent myself.
00:12:25 And at least then, you know, I knew I could keep my house
00:12:29 and my family wouldn't be homeless.
00:12:31 So, but anyway, I think, you know, the other,
00:12:34 what I want to tell you as well, which I find very unique,
00:12:37 this is a major, major constitutional win.
00:12:42 The first constitutional win, uh, from the COVID mandate, uh, Derek, um, uh, has a powerful
00:12:49 impact, not just in Ontario, but across the country.
00:12:52 Uh, and not one premier has mentioned it.
00:12:57 Uh, certainly Doug Ford, the premier in Ontario has not mentioned it.
00:13:01 Not one opposition member in any legislature has mentioned it.
00:13:06 Well, to be fair, we haven't even had question period in any provincial or federal
00:13:11 legislature since your decision i mean it it came down yesterday i think in the afternoon
00:13:16 so to be fair there hasn't been a chance for anyone to yet even in the scrum or even in a tweet
00:13:23 yeah not it yeah uh and polyev and carney have not mentioned it uh nobody nobody has mentioned
00:13:33 it but not only the political class has not mentioned it um the toronto star has not mentioned
00:13:39 it global news has not mentioned it um the national post has not mentioned it that you know
00:13:46 the global mail whatever you want the mainstream media has run away from this major constitutional
00:13:54 victory as if it never existed so uh you have a bit of a history with doug ford uh you know
00:14:03 like i don't know how you felt about him but when he first won the pc leadership uh i was
00:14:08 you know coming after rob ford i was uh kind of optimistic that ontario would actually maybe have
00:14:15 some solid conservative leadership uh he very quickly threw most of that under the uh off the
00:14:20 under the bus especially once he was elected premier uh you had your differences with him
00:14:26 you you've i've known you a long time you're a very outspoken guy like me you might not be suited
00:14:31 to political longevity uh for that reason but um you know doug ford was extremely upset with you
00:14:39 when you were uh leading much of the resistance in ontario against his covet lockdowns and mandates
00:14:44 those kinds of things uh has he called to apologize not yet um yeah you know uh like this is this is
00:14:57 vindication for many people Derek and you know it's not just vindication for me it's many many
00:15:02 people uh that who spoke out and said these mandates for were unconstitutional and um you
00:15:10 know but I you know we see this it's all our political class and the mainstream media class
00:15:17 um are just hoping that nobody notices the truth um you know I was thinking about this
00:15:26 the other day as well, like when I was reading the USA Congress final, their congressional
00:15:34 final report on COVID. And it is even somewhat harsher than, well, significantly harsher
00:15:41 than the Alberta government's review on COVID. You know, like, but they've released it. You know,
00:15:48 this was not a naturally occurring virus. This was done by gain of function. The vaccines were
00:15:55 neither safe nor effective and they caused significant harm and injury the masking the
00:16:04 social distancing the lockdowns were all harmful not dissimilar but stronger language than the
00:16:12 alberta review but once again nobody in our media our mainstream media and nobody our premiers our
00:16:20 opposition leaders, our political leaders are all hoping that nobody notices the truth and that
00:16:28 nobody will notice that the COVID emperor indeed had no close. So as mentioned, you've been fighting
00:16:36 this for four and a half years. You had a major, major victory yesterday, but there's still more
00:16:43 on the table. They're still coming for you. They're not done with you yet. What's next?
00:16:48 So I have these nine other criminal charges that I was, uh, that I was
00:16:52 representing myself on, uh, and I-
00:16:55 You are just a mafioso of, uh, of COVID, uh, breaking COVID laws, aren't you?
00:17:01 Those nine are from, uh, the horrible, um, and outrageous and audacity, uh, 0.54
00:17:09 audacious moves of me to go to Ottawa in the cold of February, 2022.
00:17:17 And, um, but I was successful in November of last year to, um, I brought up a Jordan application and the judge ruled in my favor that, uh, the crown had delayed foot drags and had been, uh, uh, too long in prosecuting me.
00:17:37 Uh, so she stayed all the charges against me.
00:17:40 Uh, later in December, uh, the crown, uh, appealed.
00:17:47 or they gave me notice of appeal on that application.
00:17:52 So I'm back in the appeals court on my Ottawa charges.
00:17:59 And this week, I just filed a notice of motion.
00:18:02 I'm sorry, my Ottawa charges, you're talking about Freedom Convoy, right?
00:18:05 Yeah.
00:18:05 And then yesterday, I just filed notice of motion to quash the appeal.
00:18:12 so um so these are uh uh you know i spend a lot of time doing legal stuff um uh rather than um
00:18:23 cutting and splitting my firewood that i should be doing right about now
00:18:26 but um you know it's um that's what we have to do uh to to defeat this legal machine and this
00:18:34 legal monster and its close brother or twin brother, the political machine and the political
00:18:43 monster.
00:18:44 Well, you've been quite the prison study lawyer so far.
00:18:48 You've done a heck of a job.
00:18:51 I'll just wrap up with this question.
00:18:54 It's a federal election happening right now.
00:18:58 What is it you're hoping to see from, I won't even ask about the liberals or NDP,
00:19:03 uh because they're sort of hopeless on the topic but what are you hoping to do at least see from
00:19:08 the conservatives uh you know in commitments they might make around the fall from covid and
00:19:15 protection of freedoms this kind of thing what are you hoping to see from polyev and the conservatives
00:19:19 well my expectation is zero uh so it's not um you know as you know derek i've been
00:19:27 intimately involved with the Conservative Party for a long time, and with the reform before that.
00:19:36 So, you know, I have seen the insides of the Conservative Party, and I don't,
00:19:47 I see them just as another Central Canada globalist entity, just like the Liberals,
00:19:56 And that has always taken advantage of the eastern and western extremities of Confederation.
00:20:07 They've consolidated and they ensure that central Canada always is well taken care of to the detriment of others.
00:20:16 Um, and I think, you know, what we've saw, uh, uh, this complete fraudulent, uh, narrative
00:20:25 that has been accepted across the country, uh, that this is a, an election to defeat
00:20:31 Trump, uh, and, and both parties have accepted that narrative and have promoted that narrative.
00:20:39 um and of course this is um if we were halfway intelligent if we were truthful in in canada
00:20:48 we would be saying to ourselves look at here last week the march employment numbers came out of the
00:20:55 u.s there was 228 000 new jobs created in um in the united states and in the same month we lost
00:21:03 another 33 000 jobs um yeah that maybe we should be thinking along trump's line that um that maybe
00:21:12 we should have manufacturing back here in this country maybe we should have an industrial base
00:21:17 maybe we should be able to exploit utilize and harvest our our natural resources uh and turn
00:21:25 them into wealth uh and and maybe in canada that there's only men and women as well and 0.72
00:21:32 and nothing in between and nothing beyond.
00:21:36 Maybe we should be promoting freedom rather than an attack
00:21:44 and being a hostile neighbor
00:21:46 to the largest economy in the country
00:21:49 and our greatest customer.
00:21:54 I don't see either party having the gonads and the stones
00:21:59 and the stones to be truthful with Canadians.
00:22:02 And I think they're leading us into a very, very dark economic time.
00:22:07 All right.
00:22:07 Well, you know, if you just get tired of fighting in the courts
00:22:12 for your basic freedoms in Ontario,
00:22:16 maybe I should just invite you to come to Alberta and declare asylum. 0.95
00:22:20 And we'll just grant you asylum here in the Wild Rose Republic. 0.89
00:22:25 and you could just live out your retirement
00:22:28 in a bit of peace.
00:22:30 There's a great many lovely, lovely Albertans
00:22:33 and it's been a great pleasure meeting
00:22:37 and talking with so many of the great people
00:22:41 that have over the years,
00:22:43 but also now with the referendum discussions
00:22:47 and the 51st state discussions,
00:22:49 you've got a lot of good people out there
00:22:51 and any normal redneck would love to live in wild goals. 0.57
00:22:59 Amen.
00:23:00 Thank you very much, Randy, for joining me today.
00:23:03 It's been a pleasure, and good luck in fighting the next nine dozen,
00:23:07 whatever you've got, charges in front of you.
00:23:10 Best of luck.
00:23:11 Thank you very much.
00:23:12 Thank you, Derek.
00:23:21 Transcription by CastingWords