Western Standard - March 23, 2022


WATCH: Calgary lawyer, medical students discuss COVID vaccine loophole many are trapped in

Topics
Mentioned
LIVE - Triggered: Exclusive with Jean Charest. Is the UCP rigging the review?

Episode Stats


Length

59 minutes

Words per minute

181.66

Word count

10,888

Sentence count

212

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we speak with a host of students who have been impacted by the removal of the proof of vaccination requirement for medical students in post-secondary education. We discuss the situation and how they are dealing with it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening. I'm Melanie Rizdin with the Western Standard. Tonight we have a host of guests that
00:00:12 we're going to be speaking with on this strange story. It's kind of a strange situation that has
00:00:17 unfolded for a lot of medical students, not only in Alberta, but across the country.
00:00:23 We've got a bit of a loophole situation that has happened with a lot of these students. So
00:00:28 talking about post-secondary education, a lot of the post-secondary institutions have announced
00:00:35 that they are lifting the vaccine mandates, the requirement for proof of vaccination.
00:00:41 So with those lifting, a lot of students that chose to remain unvaccinated are now being able
00:00:46 to return to their learning, whether it was online or in person, they can return to their studies.
00:00:53 However, when we're talking about medical students who need to do placements or they need to do a practicum or some sort of a residency, they're running into these strange kind of loophole roadblocks where they cannot access the facilities that are where they would be doing their placements.
00:01:14 Some of the facilities are under AHS, some are private facilities or clinics, and are choosing to keep a proof of vaccination policy in place.
00:01:23 And we know with AHS, they have lifted the proof of vaccination policy for current employees.
00:01:30 But anyone that begins to work with AHS after November 30th is considered a new hire, and they would need to show proof of vaccination for COVID-19.
00:01:40 that includes placement students from post-secondary institutions so you know really putting a lot of
00:01:49 students in a rough place because they have committed to years of study already spent thousands
00:01:55 of dollars spent thousands of hours towards their education to basically be hitting a wall now when
00:02:02 it comes to some of the completion of their training with placements and residencies so we
00:02:09 have joining us today a host of students as well as james kitchen which is a calgary lawyer who
00:02:16 deals with these situations through liberty coalition canada he is their chief litigator
00:02:23 first of all we've got a student from u of a who has asked to remain anonymous
00:02:28 so we're going to uh we're going to just refer to her as u of a student we also have will
00:02:33 tight grabber he is a dentistry student out of university of alberta jeff la franchise is a
00:02:40 dietitian student out of u of a and we've got monica martin who is a sonography sonography
00:02:48 sorry a student from sate uh so welcome everybody thanks for uh speaking with us today we just uh
00:02:54 want to get a good idea of uh of what you're facing so let's start with our u of a student
00:03:00 she is the one that first reached out to me and uh and filled me in on what she was facing and
00:03:08 other students in her school are facing that are following some medical training so why don't you
00:03:14 give me an idea of first of all what you're facing and the steps that you've taken to you know try
00:03:21 to get answers for the situation you're in thank you melanie for uh having me here today and giving
00:03:27 me the opportunity to have a platform to speak from because I think for months I haven't had that
00:03:35 opportunity because of discrimination towards students that are remaining
00:03:41 unvaccinated for their personal reasons and so early on in this there were again my own personal
00:03:52 choice to remain unvaccinated, I was quickly told that I may not be able to complete my program
00:04:00 based off of the placement hours that I would require for my program. And so this was
00:04:08 disheartening because I had worked so hard to get into the program and I come from a background
00:04:17 that is marginalized and so it it was a huge commitment you know i left my home i left uh my
00:04:28 job i left um and it was expensive it was it was uh you know i had to put up financing to to get
00:04:35 here so i was i felt very privileged i felt very um excited and you know going into something that
00:04:42 you've been working so hard to achieve for so long it was just kind of defeating being a couple months
00:04:48 in and being told we don't know if you'll be able to graduate and we you know and and i understood
00:04:54 like i was i was trying to see it from their side like this is new you know i'm respectful
00:05:01 to the things that are going on and um to be clear i'm not um anti-vax i just um at this time
00:05:09 and not vaccinated. So I think I tried to just look for answers to begin with, like, okay,
00:05:18 well, whatever solutions are there? What does this mean? Because at this time, too, you know,
00:05:23 you've already made that commitment, you've paid your tuition for the semester. So it was a lot of
00:05:30 emailing, as you had mentioned, where I'm reaching out and trying to find answers. But I was really
00:05:37 hitting like you've said a roadblock where you know no one was replying the answer was usually
00:05:43 a blanket statement saying get vaccinated there was no real dialogue or communication
00:05:50 regarding students that may be in a situation that required placement hours but remained
00:05:56 unvaccinated and so as mentioned this has been ongoing since the announcement in October now
00:06:05 with that the placements with ahs they kept kind of moving the goal post if you will to saying you
00:06:12 know um and i don't know the exact dates but to november and then to december and then um anyway
00:06:18 there was just like so many changes but it still held us back because they were not taking students
00:06:24 you know we've always been this kind of gray area as you've mentioned so um since then um
00:06:31 I have been able to, you know, get this far like in my program, but it really is still a lot of
00:06:43 hurdles and barriers and really just barriers to my own education. I like to talk to like refer to
00:06:51 it as my COVID class because I feel like I'm taking another class in my program because of
00:06:56 the emailing and researching and to find solutions and just to be heard and to come to some sort of
00:07:07 compromise. So as I had mentioned to you when I reached out, the AHS had in their policy, you know,
00:07:14 remote workers could be tested, like there were other solutions and there were other exemptions.
00:07:21 And shortly after that, they had some workers returning also with the testing. From my
00:07:26 understanding, the testing has been completely dropped. And then what you'll allude to later,
00:07:32 with Will's case, in January, you know, our students had heard that a student had received
00:07:40 an exemption. And I mean, that really instilled a lot of hope in us, and wanted to know like,
00:07:46 okay well i'm really not that much different from that student you know i'm in the program i'm
00:07:51 needing these hours at this location so now um what are the differences between you know between
00:07:58 that like why is there um differences let's say between schools or between faculties or
00:08:04 you know why hasn't there been kind of a consistent answer so i know they have now
00:08:11 release their statement and they're saying okay you know we we will accept them right but it's
00:08:18 been a long haul it's been a long haul to get to this point um with them saying that they will take
00:08:23 students who were enrolled you know previous to that november date but i guess what about all the
00:08:30 students who were doing an undergrad with hopes to get into this program you know like what about
00:08:36 the students who come after me so yeah and there are a lot of students as well who are in the midst
00:08:44 of their of their education their training but they haven't moved into their their placements
00:08:50 yet and so the statement from ahs was if they have not started their placement yet
00:08:55 they would they would need to be uh they would need to show proof of vaccination if they haven't
00:09:00 started their placement as of november 30th so i mean when you're talking about and and i don't
00:09:05 know how the how the years work for say a medical doctor uh student but i would assume there's a
00:09:12 there's a couple years of of uh schooling before you would even hit into a residency so so you
00:09:20 know there's there's students who have like you said invested time and a lot of money and you
00:09:27 know this is a dream of theirs i mean i would assume that this is something you're really
00:09:31 looking forward to doing along with all of these other students that we're going to speak with and
00:09:37 to hit this roadblock that says this is the only way this is going to work and it's something that
00:09:43 you don't agree with or you for whatever reasons have chosen not to to be vaccinated um you know
00:09:49 i i could see that being very frustrating and as you said uh even when i started asking questions
00:09:57 on behalf of students i must have sent hundreds of emails i was sending them to the to the
00:10:04 regulatory bodies whether you know college of physicians and surgeons collins of college of
00:10:09 nurses things like that the regulatory bodies sent it to uh the ministry i i sent it to ministry
00:10:15 of education sent it to the health ministry i uh contacted even some of the placement clinics and
00:10:21 facilities to find out what their policies were. And I can understand the frustration that you
00:10:28 students must be feeling because I never got a real solid answer as to who is in charge.
00:10:35 AHS says they are receiving direction from the ministry. The colleges, the regulatory bodies,
00:10:42 say they are receiving instruction and direction from AHS. The clinics, even private clinics,
00:10:49 are saying they are waiting for direction and instruction from the regulatory bodies so it's
00:10:55 like this this passing of responsibility and nobody's actually focused on the fact that we have
00:11:04 thousands tens of thousands across this country of medical students who are stuck in this purgatory
00:11:12 now and are not able to finish their education because of these placement issues so that's a
00:11:19 problem solutions need to be made and you know this is why we're talking about this today what
00:11:26 might be interesting is to uh let's let's chat with chat with will for a moment will uh tight
00:11:31 grabber he is in dentistry you have a student and will you actually face this as well you uh i'll
00:11:39 I'll let you explain a little bit.
00:11:40 But you actually are the student that went and got legal representation from James Kitchen through the Liberty Coalition Canada.
00:11:50 And tell me how that went.
00:11:53 James, you're welcome to contribute to this explanation as well.
00:11:57 So, Will, what were you facing?
00:11:59 Well, it was a long, drawn-out process, but I'll try to make it succinct.
00:12:03 Basically, at the beginning of the school year, AHS dropped a policy, which was about August 31st, I think, that said, okay, we're going to be bringing in a vaccine mandate.
00:12:14 And at that time, I didn't think I would be subject to it.
00:12:17 You know, I thought, okay, well, you know, I'm under the university policy.
00:12:20 I'm not an AHS employee because dentistry, we just lease out of AHS building, but it's all on dentistry's dime.
00:12:28 We're not AHS employees.
00:12:30 We just lease.
00:12:30 so anyhow um flip forward and you know the school of dentistry is taking orders from the u of a and
00:12:37 also from ahs and turns out that you know i am subject to this policy so i'm going wow
00:12:42 this is bad so let me go reach out to who's a lawyer who's a lawyer that i could have and i
00:12:48 you know i'm just kind of searching who's hot right now who's hot i'm kind of looking online
00:12:53 and stuff and you know i had heard about um james kitchen through uh the case about pastor coats
00:12:58 So, and I knew he, I knew that turned out well. So, cause I have some friends that go to Grace Life Church and stuff. So it's kind of how I got put on to James and just so happened that, you know, I got to him quickly enough that he was able to take on my case before he was overloaded with cases. Cause I know that he's, he's in high demand and I'm very privileged to have him. He's an awesome lawyer.
00:13:20 so anyhow um we did go through a series of um kind of back and forth to u of a and ahs and there
00:13:28 was really no movement uh going on it's kind of just you know u of a deferring to ahs ahs deferring
00:13:35 to u of a just like you uh had said melanie i i confirmed like nobody wanted to take kind of
00:13:41 control of the situation or be liable for a decision ultimately so they were all just trying
00:13:46 to kind of exonerate themselves from the situation just you know not have anything to do with it
00:13:51 and that's what leaves people in limbo um yeah so for the long for the longest time um like i was
00:13:57 just i was just jonesing for an answer i was like where we're like what am i going to do what's my
00:14:02 what's the status going to be time's ticking time's ticking for me um it was very critical
00:14:07 because uh you know this is a time sensitive matter um had things been pushed out any longer
00:14:12 i might not have been able to finish this year um thank god that you know he made it work um
00:14:18 ultimately what happened was it was christmas time and uh you know i was reviewing the ahs policy
00:14:23 that got like whatever um went through i think three revisions in december 2021 which was wild
00:14:31 that's when they really enforced the policy um i wasn't able to come on campus effective
00:14:37 december 1st so i was kicked out of the program uh went on hiatus um you know they redropped
00:14:45 their policy i think december 13th and then again just before christmas time when i looked at that
00:14:50 revision it was my uh well my fiance's dad he actually had me review the policy and i read it
00:14:56 and i go hmm this policy says that workers include students including post-secondary institute like
00:15:02 post-secondary students instructors going like hmm that should include me so i reached out to james
00:15:09 um put it in his wheel and in his wheelhouse and uh he reviewed it and he goes yeah legally you
00:15:15 are entitled to return so you know let me um let me reach out to ahs um you know see what they do
00:15:22 they responded um ultimately they weren't going to give a direct answer about it either they
00:15:27 weren't going to say hey well yeah you're cool to go back what they gave in return was okay this is
00:15:32 our policy yes you have rightfully interpreted the policy you are now responsible to go to your
00:15:38 post-secondary institution and confirm whether you're eligible according to our policy you know
00:15:44 you are eligible but that's not our decision to defer to the post-secondary institutions this is
00:15:48 not something that we're gonna we're gonna act on so again just continuation of not wanting to be
00:15:53 liable liable so so then what happened was I took it to the U of A you know they had a vaccine
00:16:01 directive at that time it was in fall and winter um you know i had a human rights based exemption
00:16:07 based on my christian faith i had drafted a nine-page document that's in fall time
00:16:15 and it granted me an exemption based on that and it was extended into winter term so in theory i
00:16:22 was eligible to return to my placement according to u of a's directive and the u of a school of
00:16:28 dentistry interpreted it and initially they wanted ahs to give you know the final final direction on
00:16:35 on the trajectory of my case would be but that's just not how it works jane just told me to go
00:16:40 back to the u of a and said hey this is what they they said you ahs has delegated this task to you
00:16:46 you have to ultimately make the decision so the onus for post-secondary institution instructors
00:16:51 or students is ultimately the post-secondary institution should be ruling on this it's not
00:16:57 ahs any longer the policy is in effect that does permit anybody with a human rights-based exemption
00:17:03 according to the post-secondary institutions policy to return what's perplexing to me is that
00:17:09 now they've dropped all these policies and there's still people barred from their programs that makes
00:17:13 no sense to me um you know i actually had to kind of hurdle through when when these things were in
00:17:19 effect now there are no there are no barriers and so who's still stalling my my colleagues my um
00:17:26 you know my perspective nursing and uh medicine and i'm i know a medicine resident who hasn't
00:17:32 been able to return to his residency and i'm just i just don't get it you know i'm i'm very
00:17:37 privileged to be in the shoes i'm in but i don't see why these other people can't also join along
00:17:42 with me um when i heard about uh our ufa friends case i was just astonished that this is still
00:17:49 being dragged out as it is um to make it really short and simple james and i basically just looked
00:17:56 at the ahs policy and acted on it and um you know the the problem in the matter is the people who
00:18:02 are supposedly behind these decisions to bar students they make right you know they make a
00:18:09 flip into or dogmatic statement and then they don't back it up and they don't respond to people's
00:18:14 inquiries just like you said so that's the full circle well let's james do you want to speak to
00:18:20 that a little bit because i think that's part of this strange purgatory is who's taking
00:18:29 responsibility who's not like what can you say to that well that's the bureaucracy for you right i
00:18:35 mean the the larger government gets the more bureaucracy there will be the less um human
00:18:41 compassion there will be the less morality involved in decisions the more robotic and
00:18:46 oppressive everything will become and the more somebody who you know doesn't have the doesn't
00:18:53 have the capacity to to hire a lawyer to advocate for them or you know can't advocate um in that
00:19:00 extreme stance for themselves is going to get lost in the bureaucratic mess right i mean it's hard
00:19:06 enough for people in their 40s to deal with this but i mean to be a student um you know
00:19:11 you get all this pressure um you're figuring out what it means to be an adult and you know you've
00:19:18 been told at least a good chunk of your life that people actually do you know care somewhat about
00:19:23 what happens to you or what happens to other human beings and so it's a bit of a it's a bit of a
00:19:27 mental shock to run into all this um you know complete and utter hypocrisy and lack of compassion 0.61
00:19:33 These people just don't give a damn what happens to you, you know, especially since you're, you know, you're one of the undesirables, you're one of the unvaccinated. 1.00
00:19:40 Well, I mean, you're just, you know, as far as they're concerned, of course, I'll never admit it, but they would just wish it would go away anyways. 0.58
00:19:45 So, yeah, it's a real mess.
00:19:47 And this is the human cost of embracing big government.
00:19:53 This is the human cost of the modern administrative state where the government controls everything through a bureaucracy and through people that have lost any sense of morality or human decency.
00:20:02 um you know and and i'm used to that i'm i'm rather cynical i mean every day i deal with with
00:20:08 with government treating people like dirt um that's just what i do as as a litigator so i
00:20:13 sometimes forget how shocking it is as a regular person and thought the world was a decent place
00:20:17 um to encounter that and to be stuck in it as as the victim um so you know with will's case i you
00:20:23 know i got involved and i did what i normally do in any in any case and you know i beat down doors
00:20:27 and I send emails and I send letters and I get very candid and sometimes rather nasty in the
00:20:35 things I have to say. And a lot of times that does eventually produce results, just sort of like
00:20:41 the old woman that kept going to the unrighteous judge. And there's an Old Testament story about
00:20:46 this. And eventually she got justice, right? Because she wouldn't leave him alone. And he
00:20:53 He was unrighteous as a judge, but he wanted to be left alone, so he gave her justice.
00:20:58 A lot of lawyering is actually like that, which is awful, really, but that is how our
00:21:03 world works.
00:21:05 So that's part of what happened in Will's case.
00:21:07 The other part, though, I want to make sure people know, Will and I benefited from a conglomeration
00:21:16 of efforts in the late fall to push AHS and eventually the minister to stop all this nonsense.
00:21:24 The constant lawsuits and threats of lawsuits and demand letters from various lawyers in Alberta
00:21:32 I think did have an effect. Mine was only one small effort amongst that. There was Jeff Rath
00:21:38 and the Justice Center and Leighton Gray and all the rest of them. Because Will wasn't the only
00:21:42 person that had went and hired a lawyer to do this. Probably one of the only students, of course,
00:21:46 because poor students, they don't have the means. And that's where I try to come in with somewhat
00:21:52 lower rates for people like that. I have had a lot of student clients, and that was actually
00:21:56 something I set out to do in the fall, was to help students because I knew pretty much nobody
00:22:00 else would or would want to. So, you know, when AHS, just to go back a little bit of recent history,
00:22:08 AHS moved their policy three times, the enforcement of it, sorry, back, right?
00:22:13 And I always tried to say, when I had an opportunity to say it in the media, like, look, this is politically how it works, right?
00:22:19 Are these deadlines being moved because of science?
00:22:21 Obviously not.
00:22:23 They're being moved because of political pushback, right?
00:22:25 So keep pushing.
00:22:27 You may have no impact, and sometimes we haven't, but sometimes we have, and that was an example of it.
00:22:32 the political pushback and the legal pushback through all the lawsuits worked together to
00:22:37 push NHS to move it back. And then eventually the political pressure was intense enough that
00:22:42 the minister said, okay, we can't keep doing this. Most of the people that are impacted by this and
00:22:47 are upset about this and are suing us are actually the people that might vote for us in the next
00:22:50 election. So we got to remove it, right? Completely political analysis, obviously not an analysis
00:22:55 about safety or science or anything like that. So the policy ultimately was lifted. And I think
00:23:02 very late December. And so, you know, Will was a benefit of that and of my advocacy. And so he was
00:23:09 able to get all set up. And, you know, obviously he had a human rights accommodation from the
00:23:16 University of Alberta, which he got all by himself. And the U of A has granted very few of
00:23:20 those. So I was very happy to see that. So that was already in place even when he came to me.
00:23:24 So, you know, things turned out better for Will than for most people, partly by chance,
00:23:31 partly by his advocacy. And, you know, that's how he got into a better position than a lot of these
00:23:37 other students. Now, I understand it now that one of the problems, maybe the only problem,
00:23:43 is that for, you know, AHS has chosen this arbitrary date of November 30th. And they've
00:23:48 said, look, if you were in a placement prior to that, fine, you can come back on, I think it was
00:23:56 March 10th was the date. But if not, you can't. And I just want to highlight that. As first,
00:24:01 you know, I think that might be one of the problems. But the fact that that is the problem
00:24:05 is really despicable, right? Because it's absolutely arbitrary. That's completely a
00:24:10 political position, right? It's an ideological position. It's got nothing to do with science
00:24:15 or safety, again, like everything else, right? Like almost everything with COVID. It's got
00:24:18 everything to do with ideology and politics and nothing to do with science and safety.
00:24:21 and so you know and again of course you got the lack of lack of human compassion and human decency
00:24:26 right well you know if you weren't in before November 30th to hell with you you know you're 0.81
00:24:30 not you're not we're not going to take you back again why right if it's not lawful um and we
00:24:35 should be able to easily say it's not but of course we can't you know seem to convince decision
00:24:39 makers that that all this nonsense is unlawful um so I'd like to think that if I don't have any
00:24:44 students right now that I'm dealing with this I'd like to think if I did I could I could help them
00:24:48 get past that i don't actually know because i haven't dealt with it certainly you know i would
00:24:51 say the same thing i've said here this is arbitrary it's unlawful it's ridiculous it's got nothing to
00:24:55 do with with your ostensible reasons for it let's all get on with our lives and stop treating people
00:25:01 like they're subhuman like they're like they're less than you because you know they didn't they 1.00
00:25:06 didn't run out like a coward and take the shot they stood there well can we get on with that
00:25:11 yeah and and i want to point out too because that makes a lot of logical sense we're talking about
00:25:16 you know say a facility where um you know uh perhaps dozens of people have returned and are
00:25:24 unvaccinated because they were previous employees so so again when you're talking about this the
00:25:29 logic behind the science you have unvaccinated people back in facilities and in clinics and in
00:25:36 practice um so so to ban students with this november 30th deadline or even even new hires
00:25:43 for ahs again the the science but the other thing james that is that has has come up in this and
00:25:50 one of the issues that these students are facing is that many of these clinics and placement
00:25:55 facilities are private and they've been instructed that you know and even the government of alberta
00:26:01 when they lifted the proof of vaccination policy and the reprogram they said you know we're not
00:26:08 going to tell private industry how they are going to set their uh you know their policy they that's
00:26:15 up to them so we've got private clinics now who in the onset were encouraged potentially
00:26:22 incentivized to bring in these policies but now that we've done a shift and the science has proven
00:26:30 that the shift is necessary there is no equal in pressure or equal um you know influence from the
00:26:39 government to these private practices to now lift these discriminatory mandates so that's another
00:26:48 problem that these students and and then the irony behind all of that again this mess of not being
00:26:55 able to get to a true answer is some of the regulatory bodies are saying well
00:27:01 we're waiting for instruction from AHS then I hear from the clinics that
00:27:06 they're waiting for instruction from the regulatory body however the
00:27:09 regulatory bodies in a statement released to me have said straight up we
00:27:15 do not tell private practice what their policy should be that is determined by
00:27:20 them I've even and I will tell you this as well I even spoke with placement
00:27:26 clinics under the AHS umbrella that were unaware of the new AHS policy with the
00:27:34 November 30th date so I I had to inquire art so are you telling me that there has
00:27:39 been no communication from AHS to you to your clinic as to what things need to
00:27:46 look like moving forward no they have not had communication so i think that that's a massive
00:27:52 issue too with this like where's the accountability if there's no communication we have to remember
00:27:59 that ahs is only doing uh is only is only insofar as they have lifted mandates only doing so because
00:28:04 they're being told to do it by the minister right which they begrudge which they um they they can't
00:28:11 stand that okay so it's like it's like a child being told by a parent that you you know you have
00:28:15 to clean your room well if that child is not actually you know wanting to be obedient and be
00:28:21 and be decent then it's you know instead of actually cleaning the bedroom we'll just shove 0.96
00:28:25 stuff where it can't be seen it's the same thing here right hs is ideologically motivated that's
00:28:30 their primary motivator above above all above everything else okay so when when a political
00:28:35 actor comes in and tells them to do something for for political reasons and they politically
00:28:39 disagree with it they hate that and so you know they're going to respond in a begrudging way
00:28:44 and they're not going to respond in a good faith way, right? So they're going to do what they
00:28:47 absolutely have to, to comply and no more than that, right? And so the lack of communication
00:28:52 and the lack of trying to help people and all of that is just reflective of their general attitude,
00:28:56 right? The general attitude of AHS is, you know, we are ideologically married to this. We will do
00:29:01 it as much as we possibly can, unless somebody who actually has the authority to tell us to stop
00:29:06 does. I mean, ultimately, that person is only the health minister, right? You know, and for better
00:29:11 or for worse, you know, politics actually went in our favor that way, you know, where
00:29:15 political decision makers who were actually supposed to make decisions based on what they
00:29:20 think is best for the people, stepped in and did something.
00:29:23 So yeah, no, the behavior of AHS since, you know, since almost since the beginning, I
00:29:28 wouldn't say at the beginning, there was a little while where AHS was actually operating,
00:29:33 you know, in good faith, but it didn't take long before the power went to their heads
00:29:36 and they became drunk on it and just acted like tyrants, you know, since probably about
00:29:41 the summer of 2020. They can't bring themselves to be humble and to actually care about people
00:29:50 and to actually follow the real scientific evidence. It has become ideology, it has become
00:29:56 control, and we're still seeing that now. And so you're going to continue to see obdication
00:30:02 and frustration on their end with people that aren't doing what they ideologically want,
00:30:08 even though the minister has told them to back off and this this is where you see it right and
00:30:12 it's it's it's frustrating well i'm used to seeing it but it is it is frustrating to watch and shocking
00:30:16 if you're not used to seeing it right well and you're right when you're talking about some of
00:30:21 these students i mean most students who we're talking to today are are young uh jeff la
00:30:28 franchise he is a dietitian student at u of a jeff why don't you tell us a little bit about
00:30:34 your situation and what you've faced through this sure well thank you for having me um so yeah kind
00:30:42 of like everybody else's story um uh doing trying to complete my placements um and only available
00:30:49 through alberta health services or so i've been told um and it's just been you know difficult
00:30:55 facing all these pushbacks you know i've been relatively patient with it and optimistic
00:30:59 um you know back in october um i was in lethbridge and you know uh during the end of the month didn't
00:31:06 know if i should expect you know tell my landlord i need to stay a month or if they're going to push
00:31:09 it back um so just really stressful but you know got my november uh placement done i was supposed
00:31:15 to have another three weeks in december but unfortunately when the mandates um came into
00:31:20 effect at the beginning of december i was unable to complete that um but luckily i was able to
00:31:25 come home um and uh spend some time with my wife and newborn child so that was kind of a blessing
00:31:31 in disguise um so i'm yeah so that's been kind of good uh that way but uh just difficult um wanting
00:31:38 to complete you know like my degree just like everybody else um spend lots of time and uh and
00:31:44 money you know trying to get this thing done i have three three uh three months left and that
00:31:49 three weeks i didn't finish in december was left to complete my um placement uh and my placements
00:31:55 and it's just been you know uh just relatively difficult to deal with all the pushbacks that
00:32:00 they're giving us and for no based uh no they're not based in any scientific reasoning like it's
00:32:06 kind of been stated um it's really just you know kind of just doubling down on their policies they
00:32:10 just kind of say face a little bit of cognitive dissonance perhaps they just don't want to you
00:32:13 know accept the the reality that faces them um and yeah just uh it's been very difficult um
00:32:20 that's good insight jeff though it really is you know this this idea that that um doubling down
00:32:27 on on a policy that that i think logically has shown that whether you are vaccinated or not you
00:32:36 are catching you are carrying and you are spreading covid19 so at the end of the day i mean if people
00:32:42 want to keep testing policies in place okay you know but but when we're talking about you know
00:32:49 sort of this discriminatory policy that says you as an unvaccinated student are unsafe
00:32:56 scientifically unsafe compared to somebody who is vaccinated you know the the the i think the
00:33:02 social construct the social responsibility behind the original idea of this of this uh the the
00:33:10 policies has has got to be reviewed at this point so jeff are you have you where are you at with
00:33:17 your placements then have you are you able to press through with them or where where are things
00:33:21 at for you well i've made contact with my program director my internship lead and you know unfortunately
00:33:28 they advocate very uh they don't advocate very much for us um you know going back to i had a few
00:33:33 meetings back in october with them and i pressed a question on what has you know the school been
00:33:37 doing for us what is you what have you the program directors you know or others been doing for
00:33:41 students in this case and basically the answer was that you know alberta health services calls
00:33:46 of shots you know they're their own business they can make their own policies and we're in no
00:33:49 position to make any demands of them and i i was you know i'm obviously yeah businesses can make
00:33:53 their own policies but you as uh should be advocating for us as students in some form
00:33:59 because you know we do provide them with you know workers and things like that so it is a
00:34:03 you know a relationship that goes both ways and you know the university was just very much not
00:34:07 willing to or that they were told me when i questioned them upon it they you know said they
00:34:13 had no right to question alberta health services and their policies in regards to
00:34:17 you know helping us out as students kind of we just were at their whim um but right now um
00:34:22 as of last week when i emailed my director she said you know we're waiting for alberta health
00:34:27 services to tell us more um you know they don't know what to do with students now just hang tight
00:34:31 be patient and i'll get back to you um and it's kind of also been frustrating because i've
00:34:35 questioned her there's been some placements that are through the university and not through alberta
00:34:38 health services and they refuse to answer my questions on if i can complete them through
00:34:43 the university because you know their mandates are have been dropped you know so um it's been
00:34:49 rather difficult um now i did reach out to uh i did reach out to u of a as well i'll just i'll
00:34:55 uh if you if you haven't seen it yet this was the statement that i got from u of a
00:34:59 uh we are working with students impacted by changes in health and safety regulations to
00:35:03 ensure that they can take part in the experiential learning component of their respective programs
00:35:10 students are subject to the rules of the organizations holding their practicums clinical
00:35:15 placements and residencies if an organization requires students to be vaccinated they would
00:35:21 need to either follow that rule or work with their home faculty to see whether their placement can
00:35:26 be held in a different location uh and and really yeah my my my request to u of a was
00:35:34 how are you how are you helping the students what what is the u of a doing to um to advocate for
00:35:41 the students because u of a is responsible um on their side of things for building these placement
00:35:47 relationships and partnerships with with private industry clinics and whatnot but also ahs based
00:35:54 clinics so so again it's this you know it often feels like this well it's not up to us right and
00:36:02 then it's and then it's dismissed or deflected and you know somebody at some point needs to stand up
00:36:10 and needs to recognize that yes you students you know an education i mean that's that's a right
00:36:19 like you have paid your time your effort your money your dedication to these to these studies
00:36:27 and to hit this roadblock i mean you know even if there was some sort of a grandfather clause for
00:36:33 when you started your studies but but even regardless my question too is we're we're
00:36:38 dealing with not only an alberta-wide but a country-wide shortage of medical professionals
00:36:44 in many disciplines i want to speak yeah yeah um the thing one of the problems with all this is we
00:36:53 don't speak plain language language we don't speak plain english we don't we're so polite
00:36:59 that we don't call it like it is i made a point of watching a lot of american media lately
00:37:04 and i i feel like you know i must be the the ugly duckling because i feel like i must be american
00:37:10 in my blood and i and i somehow was you know stolen and taken to canada or something when i
00:37:14 i was young because what what a lot of americans do is they actually speak their mind okay that's
00:37:18 what i've done in the last half an hour okay i've called uh ahs ideological there's there's not not
00:37:25 nearly enough canadians that are brave enough to actually say that even though they know it
00:37:28 there's there's more should know it but there's there's a lot that know it and don't say it okay
00:37:32 americans will say yeah this the cdc is ideological and that's awful i'm not scared to say it by the
00:37:37 way. And so here's the problem. And we need to be honest about this. The University of Alberta
00:37:44 doesn't want to help these students. Okay. University of Alberta is woke. It's drowning
00:37:49 in wokeness. Okay. And for whatever reason, the woke thing is to force people to take these things
00:37:55 and to treat them subhuman if they don't. Okay. That's where AHS and the U of A is at. They don't
00:38:03 want to help these people. They want to pretend like they will. They want to pretend that they
00:38:06 are. They want to put on the public face that they are, but they won't really. And let me give
00:38:10 you a tangible example of that. Will is a pretty resourceful, ingenious guy. And I am a little bit
00:38:18 too. And we put our heads together in the late fall, whatever it was, November probably. And we
00:38:24 said, okay, well, let's get you a placement in a private dental clinic. Since there's a ton of
00:38:29 dental clinics that have absolutely no control or oversight by AHS. I think Will found no less
00:38:35 than four or five dentists or dental student dental clinics that were willing to accept him
00:38:40 as a student so that he can complete his placement there okay we went we went to the u of a and we
00:38:50 said look we know ahs is screwing things around and that's not your fault you can't do anything
00:38:55 about that so by the way when a when u of a says like we can't do anything about ahs or what clinics
00:38:58 want to do that's largely true okay um but that's the good courses that's a deflected tactic
00:39:05 The U of A can do something about it if they really want to.
00:39:10 Not by controlling people they can't control, but they can control what they do.
00:39:14 So Will and I went to the U of A and we said, look, we got four or five dentists that are willing to take Will.
00:39:20 All you have to do is say yes.
00:39:23 All you have to do is let him do it.
00:39:26 Let him go to this clinic.
00:39:27 These dentists are willing to go through all the paperwork and go through all the procedures and satisfy you that they can complete his practicum.
00:39:34 By the way, Will is an exemplary student. So he's not some regular student. He's got a stellar
00:39:39 record. He's shown himself to be able to go into something that's a bit more challenging and
00:39:43 different and succeed at it. And U of A knows that. They have a record of that. They've even
00:39:47 made that known. So we went to the U of A and we said, all you got to do is accommodate him
00:39:52 by letting him do this. He'll take care of it. He's coordinating it all. All you got to do is
00:39:57 say yes. They hired a lawyer and wrote me back like an eight-page letter explaining why they
00:40:04 refuse to do this, okay? All they had to do was say yes, but they were determined not to because
00:40:11 they don't really want to help Will because they agree politically, ideologically with all of this
00:40:18 nonsense. They agree with oppressing people like Will. They don't want to help them. They just want
00:40:23 to look like they're helping them it's the same virtue signal crap with with all this other stuff
00:40:28 with helping uh you know minorities right well we'll help the popular minorities but not the 0.99
00:40:33 unpopular minorities right we'll help we'll help the blacks and we'll help the natives and we'll 0.99
00:40:38 help the gays and we'll help the transgender but unvaccinated no no no no we won't help them that 1.00
00:40:43 that minority we can be oppressed all we want because it's the woke thing to do right now is 0.75
00:40:48 oppress that minority and we don't we don't talk clearly enough we don't talk with enough moral
00:40:54 clarity about what these people really think and what they're really doing and what their actions
00:40:58 really mean and that's what's going on with the u of a and that's why they said no to will they
00:41:03 dressed it up in eight pages of legalese okay but that's that's where it was really coming from
00:41:08 that's the outcome they wanted because of their ideology so they told their lawyer argue it for
00:41:13 us because we've already decided this is what we want to do so and and speaking most of our
00:41:19 students today are from u of a but we do have one from sate right now uh monica martin you're uh in
00:41:25 sonography and you have also run into issues uh monica why don't you tell us a little bit about
00:41:31 your experience uh through sate yes for sure so um i'm a little bit different in terms of um i'm
00:41:38 a mature student i'm 42 years old and i'm a single mom and so to invest all the time and effort and
00:41:46 money into this program is is a huge thing for me um i've had a lot of health concerns and at the
00:41:53 start of the program i did get a vaccine exemption from the regular vaccines um but once covet hit
00:41:59 that was sort of thrown aside and so say basically when i've applied for the covet vaccine exemption
00:42:07 they've deferred to the college of physicians so the college of physicians of alberta have said
00:42:12 basically that no exemptions can be made you basically have to try the vaccine first to see
00:42:18 what happens and my doctors in terms of my doctor's recommendation he said that he does
00:42:25 not recommend it because i'm at a such an increased risk of a life altering or ending
00:42:30 adverse event because of everything that's been going on and so i've kind of got the run around
00:42:35 with that where um they won't approve it and they say okay you need to go see specialists which is
00:42:40 you know 18 to 24 months down the road before you can even see one um i was able to get in with an
00:42:46 allergist which we butted heads pretty hard um and i finally called him out and i said listen i
00:42:52 i know what the position statement is of the college of physicians um and he basically kicked
00:42:56 me out of the office after i said that so he didn't want to admit that there was a directive
00:43:01 and that they're not allowed to give exemptions my doctor has when i did ask for one he said you
00:43:07 know i know that this will damage you but i cannot give an exemption because i'll get in trouble with
00:43:13 the college of physicians so i understand that i mean he wants to save his job he needs to make a
00:43:18 living as well and so i've kind of gone the run around a lot with that so i don't have an exemption
00:43:24 on file for the covid vaccine um so i was told sort of from september to december that um
00:43:32 everybody at state was told if you're not vaccinated you're going to be withdrawn from
00:43:35 your program so i really just tried to stay motivated but it definitely affected my grades
00:43:40 and everything else um you know me wondering day day after day you know is this a waste of my time
00:43:45 and money but you know trying to stay positive and see what happens so finally at finals i was told
00:43:50 that they found one clinic that would take me for one of the specialties I need to rotate through,
00:43:55 so that's general ultrasound, and that they would get me started, but I still wouldn't be able to
00:43:59 graduate because AHS won't allow me to work at their sites, and I am required for other
00:44:04 rotations as well. So there's two rotations that I'm being affected by. So there's another one
00:44:11 that has a dominant clinic. They're pretty much the only clinic that really deals in volume with
00:44:16 it and their personal policy as well is to not accept unvaccinated people um so I did I I got 1.00
00:44:25 the run around a lot so I would never get an answer I'd say you know can I take a leave of
00:44:28 absence and come back when things settle down and you know again run around um time and time again
00:44:34 every time I tried to get information and details um and so finally I did put my foot down kind of
00:44:39 like what James said I put my foot down and I said listen like you're saying that you want to
00:44:43 help me but really it's just lip service because it's not really I'm not getting anywhere I'm not
00:44:48 getting my placements and you're saying I still won't be able to graduate at which time I was
00:44:52 told that was borderline academic misconduct and I'm unprofessional so I think they've kind of
00:44:58 pushed me to the limit and so I've been in my general rotation but I still like I said I still
00:45:04 have two other specialties I need to rotate through they are trying I think they said that
00:45:10 been contacting different clinics to see if they've changed their policies and so i've got a
00:45:15 meeting on tuesday um but they do say i still need to rotate through hospitals for one specialty for
00:45:20 sure um so that's going to be a bit big roadblock and then also in terms of my studies without
00:45:27 rotating through the hospitals i'm just not getting the well-rounded experience that i need
00:45:32 because you see different things in the hospital versus the clinic clinic um so that sort of you
00:45:40 know is affecting me as well right i'm just like i said you just see completely different pathologies
00:45:45 and stuff right and you know monica you you make this statement that you understand you understand
00:45:52 the position your doctor is in for not being able to but i mean um the the fact that we have gotten
00:45:59 to a point where we need to understand that is is also a travesty because it is doctors have never
00:46:05 ever been put in a position to not be able to pass directives on or or um you know medical
00:46:15 assessments onto their their patients that they feel are important and necessary and and in the
00:46:21 best interest of their patient i mean everybody's bodies are different and if there is something
00:46:26 that and i mean i know uh many lawyers i'm not sure about james but i know many lawyers have
00:46:30 have dealt with clients as well
00:46:32 who were looking for medical exemptions.
00:46:33 I know of, I believe it's, she's a anesthetic, 0.72
00:46:40 I'm probably not even gonna be able to pronounce it properly,
00:46:42 but yeah, yeah, Dr. Moser, who would also,
00:46:48 same situation as you, Monica,
00:46:50 would also be in a situation
00:46:51 where she would likely have a life altering
00:46:54 or life ending reaction to the vaccine,
00:46:58 but was not granted a medical exemption based on this idea
00:47:02 that, well, you need to try one first
00:47:05 in order to see if it will kill you.
00:47:09 I mean, I just can't put the logic behind
00:47:14 why anyone would want to take that risk
00:47:16 when at the end of the day,
00:47:18 we're talking about something with a 99.97% survivability.
00:47:25 And again, the science has pointed very clearly
00:47:28 the fact that vaccinated or unvaccinated we are um we are susceptible to catching and spreading
00:47:34 so it's it i think it is a travesty that we have to get to this idea that we have to be understanding
00:47:40 that our doctors don't want to lose their license from the college of physicians and surgeons and
00:47:45 be put in that position when that's sort of what they were supposed to do that's part of what their
00:47:50 job is and to me it's completely unethical and immoral for the college of physicians to put that
00:47:56 that statement out they don't have a client physician relationship with me
00:48:00 they don't know my medical history you can't just black blanket statement that
00:48:04 everybody has to try it it doesn't it doesn't make sense right so we you know
00:48:10 basically the the idea behind talking with you all and and having everybody
00:48:15 comment on this is to to really just grow an awareness I mean there is a lot
00:48:20 of talk right now that you know what's the big deal the mandates have been
00:48:25 lifted. They have been lifted in certain areas. And, you know, James, you and I were speaking
00:48:31 about this the other day. Yes, they have been lifted in a certain number of areas, very
00:48:37 publicized areas, but it's a tip of the iceberg. Yeah, yeah, that's right.
00:48:45 They, you know, the people, for the most part, who are in positions of authority, who are the
00:48:52 elites who have official capacities in our society. It certainly seems like the vast majority of them
00:48:59 personally agree with this. And if there's a large contingent that don't, they're too cowardly to 0.96
00:49:04 speak out about it. They're too cowardly to do something about it. You know, there's not nearly 0.99
00:49:08 enough of the Randy Hilliers or the Dr. Nagasi, I think his name is, you know, people who are
00:49:15 actually politicians bureaucrats physicians um elites um they're too cowardly to speak up if if
00:49:23 if there actually is a contingent that that disagree with all this and have the have the moral
00:49:27 uh clarity to see it for what it is and so here we are right um and it's it's the same thing across
00:49:33 the board with with most professions too and of course this goes back to the regulatory bodies
00:49:37 right um every time i i i speak out um and and a few other lawyers that also speak out we we have
00:49:43 to wonder where where is that um that threatening letter from the law society going to come right
00:49:48 how much can we actually talk about what we know is going on um this this is this is the problem
00:49:55 is that either either either the professionals themselves are don't don't want to speak up or
00:50:01 actually think this is good uh or they're just too scared of the regulatory bodies because the
00:50:04 regulatory bodies have way too much control which is something that we just don't talk about in this
00:50:09 country i've learned over the last six months there seems to be pretty much nobody besides
00:50:13 me and maybe a couple others that are actually talking about the problem we have with tyrannical
00:50:18 regulatory bodies that have way too much control and power that we've slowly unconsciously given
00:50:26 them through these huge pieces of legislation over the last 10 or 20 years and now you know
00:50:32 this crisis the civil liberties crisis comes along and you know almost nobody realizes that we've
00:50:38 We've given almost God-like powers to regulatory bodies and regional health authorities like AHS.
00:50:45 That's not okay.
00:50:46 You know, we look at all this oppression of minorities and this tyranny and the destruction of civil liberties.
00:50:53 Why? I can tell you why.
00:50:55 When you give more control, and I know this is very philosophical, 40,000 feet, but it's true.
00:51:00 When you give this much control to government, broadly speaking, not just cabinet, this is what you get.
00:51:06 you get less individual choice less individual freedom more purity more oppression of minorities 1.00
00:51:13 that's inevitable that's that's as predictable as you know when when you you see the chinook cloud
00:51:20 it's going to be warm like it's it's it's just it's that easy and yet we've we've just somehow
00:51:24 like no no no no no no big government's good big government is evil and and you're seeing the human
00:51:30 cost of it today okay and and on all the and more more significantly i would say the the people
00:51:38 who are dead right now because not because they willingly took a shot because they they believed
00:51:44 falsely that that that you know this that they had to have this and it was gonna be really good
00:51:48 and it was really safe but there are people who are dead right now who took that thing against
00:51:53 their will to keep their job and if that's not evil i don't know what is well and back to our
00:52:00 u of a student um the the one we're keeping anonymous at this point uh you tides are changing
00:52:08 we are starting to see some movement as as per will's case uh being being um successful in in
00:52:16 being able to move into and through his his placement um you were mentioning that uh you
00:52:23 know of a nurse that was able to get placement hours yes thank you uh melanie so the student
00:52:30 i know that's in the faculty of nursing received an email uh yesterday regarding the change in the
00:52:35 mandate and was told that she will be acceptable accepted into pardon me um her uh placement hours
00:52:42 with ahs so this was a huge relief for her and something that she's been really striving for
00:52:48 the last few months and uh you know we've been in contact uh regularly just to really support each
00:52:54 other you know and really uh be there for one another um through this stressful time she had
00:52:59 actually connected with me through another student because she just felt so alone and discriminated
00:53:05 against in her program so we really have been uh you know going through this together um i think
00:53:11 it's made us um very understanding empathetic to people who are going through this and i and i do
00:53:18 want to mention uh this just quickly is there are students too that um received the shot so they
00:53:24 didn't have to uh you know face discrimination um and really do feel like they were coerced
00:53:33 in a decision and i know this is a totally different topic but um there are people in
00:53:37 our programs that have said you know i wouldn't have done this otherwise but i really want to
00:53:43 graduate so it's just too bad to hear that and um anyway for this student specifically she has said
00:53:51 you know this is one small victory but she hasn't you know it's not a win necessarily because she
00:53:56 doesn't know what will happen uh down the road for her employment so it's just like a story that's
00:54:02 kind of ongoing yeah for sure absolutely and and you know every every positive step is is good and
00:54:09 uh i think provides a lot of hope yeah i agree and and hope is is what we all need right now
00:54:17 i think you should say something about the fact that this this university of alberta student i
00:54:21 don't think um she's paranoid by the way and in wanting to hide her identity um well i i can
00:54:28 understand why why somebody would want to hide their identity right now i mean she she is working
00:54:33 through trying to to get help from her post-secondary and trying to you know
00:54:42 the placement coordinators and whatnot and so so I can understand I can
00:54:48 understand that would feel a bit dicey and not wanting to make anybody upset or
00:54:53 angry or draw any negative light to it but but at the same time I mean if you
00:54:58 don't stand and be heard and and discuss these things then people really just
00:55:02 just don't know they're happening.
00:55:05 That's right, that's right.
00:55:06 Yeah, and that's just it, right?
00:55:08 You know, corruption festers in the darkness, right?
00:55:10 Life is the best disinfectant, right?
00:55:12 The only way you maintain a society
00:55:14 that's worth living in is by constantly scrutinizing it.
00:55:18 Yeah, exactly.
00:55:19 Well, and there has to be an accountability,
00:55:21 and let's be honest, the media has dropped that ball
00:55:25 a number of times for quite some time now.
00:55:28 So, I mean, there is movement happening.
00:55:30 Things are changing,
00:55:31 and they really must change because again, you know,
00:55:34 as mentioned many times, the science has changed.
00:55:36 So it's, you know, it's just, we have to hold on.
00:55:40 We have to, again, this is about awareness.
00:55:42 This is about, you know, bringing it into the light,
00:55:47 you know, and asking for accountability,
00:55:50 asking for who's going to take responsibility for this,
00:55:53 who's going to do something about this and not relenting.
00:55:56 And, you know, I can see James, why you are extremely busy.
00:56:01 with you know supporting students but also many others um tell me just a little bit let's talk
00:56:06 for just a second about liberty coalition canada which is the um which is who you work through to
00:56:12 support will uh and then we'll wrap it up because i know we're we're uh it's been it's been a good
00:56:19 long talk for everybody so just very briefly liberty coalition canada is um the organization
00:56:26 that basically like it sounds is trying to bring liberty back to life in in canada um and and
00:56:33 that's why that that word is specifically chosen because that word captures i think better than any
00:56:37 other word in the english language the idea of individual freedom and um you know human flourishing
00:56:46 that comes through that because if if we're apparently all about making the world a better
00:56:50 place then that means we're about human flourishing and that happens more in a context
00:56:55 of individual freedom than anywhere else. And that's ultimately at a grand scale what we're
00:57:00 all about. And so we do that through legal work that I do. We do it through Michael Thiessen and
00:57:05 a few people like him that do a lot of, I guess, alternative media. They do podcasts and they talk
00:57:10 about the types of things that don't get talked about. That's why I get along with them so much
00:57:14 probably. So basically, just like any other advocacy organization that's trying to keep
00:57:21 or to revive this as a free nation and defend individuals' liberties, right? And we have a
00:57:25 of those in this country not nearly enough which is part of the problem and so that's one of the
00:57:29 reasons that liberty coalition canada is doing this and uh i really like them and i really like
00:57:33 what they're doing um they obviously do come from a christian bent i'm not going to hide that um
00:57:37 you know there's secular organizations like the justice center that liberty coalition canada is
00:57:40 very much about liberty as part of the judeo-christian perspective right i mean you look at
00:57:44 america britain canada they're all based on this idea of political liberty that's actually rooted
00:57:49 rooted in christian theology and they're very much uh about that you know i i'm a christian and and
00:57:54 I believe in liberty for philosophical and theological reasons and so it's a good fit and
00:58:00 we've helped a couple of students like Will. We have a couple of just employees at places where
00:58:06 they've been fired for not taking the shot. We're helping Dr. Wall, the chiropractor who's facing
00:58:11 discipline because he didn't wear a mask even though he has a medical exemption. We're picking
00:58:16 cases where we can try to hold the advance of tyranny against people who aren't getting
00:58:23 represented right now, like students and professionals. Those are people that are not
00:58:26 getting enough attention, I would say, in the country as far as people defending them on a
00:58:31 pro bono basis. So that's what we do, right? We raise donations. That pays me. I charge a discounted
00:58:37 rate. And so we're able to help people like Will, who doesn't have $10,000 in the bank to litigate
00:58:42 a case, right? And that's a really, really, really important thing. If you don't have a public
00:58:47 interest lawyer doing discounted or pro bono work, you can say goodbye to your civil liberties and
00:58:53 your country unfortunately and that's one of the reasons why they're not losing it as quickly or
00:58:57 as badly in the United States is they have more people like me that are you know standing in the
00:59:03 gap against the the forces of tyranny. Well agreed and agreed that this is a situation where I think
00:59:10 a lot of people have not reached out for support because they don't feel they can afford it. They
00:59:14 look at the human side of this and how it's impacting people that are trying to get their
00:59:20 educations and move into an industry where we so need you where we so need people bodies we need
00:59:27 you know where we have a a shortage a huge shortage across alberta and the country for uh
00:59:32 for medical workers and so uh here's hoping that this helps thanks so much very much for all of
00:59:38 you joining us today to discuss this thank you thank you very much for holding this thanks to
00:59:45 you Melanie for trying to shine a light.