Western Standard - October 13, 2021


Western Standard: Uncensored

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The battle continues between Without Papers Pizza and the city Family says Alberta government & NDP spreading ‘fake news’ that Nathanael’s death was from COVID

Episode Stats


Length

59 minutes

Words per minute

179.29

Word count

10,730

Sentence count

379

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this inaugural episode of Western Standard Uncensored, the panelists discuss the Equalization Referendum, and how Albertans should view it. The panel is: Bill Buick Danielle Smith Rob McAllister

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Good evening.
00:01:21 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:01:25 And you're watching the inaugural episode of Western Standard Uncensored.
00:01:29 Uncensored. This is a new political panel that we've put together of some of the veterans of
00:01:35 Alberta conservative politics. I'm joined in the studio today by Bruce McAllister. Bruce and I go
00:01:42 back a bit, as do some of the other panelists who will be joining us. Bruce was a wild rose in LA
00:01:48 back in the day, still very busy fighting the good fight, and he's going to be the moderator of
00:01:53 this show, Western Standard Uncensored. Before we get to that, though, I want to thank all of
00:01:58 our Western Standard members for your continued support. Without you, we cannot continue to do
00:02:02 the work we're doing. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, however, I'd like you
00:02:06 to go to westernstandardonline.com, click on membership, and you can try it free for 15 days.
00:02:11 It's only $99 a year or $10 a month for uncensored, independent, government bailout-free media
00:02:19 focused on the issues that you're not going to see in a lot of the other mainstream media,
00:02:23 which is exactly what we're doing here today.
00:02:26 Western Standard Uncensored is about talking about the issues with people
00:02:31 that you're just not going to see in many other media outlets.
00:02:35 So with that, I'm going to put it to Bruce here, who will take it away,
00:02:38 tell you a bit more about the show, and introduce the panelists we've got tonight.
00:02:42 Good stuff. Derek, thank you. Always good to work with you.
00:02:44 Pleased to be in your TV studio.
00:02:46 It's been a while since I've been in a TV studio.
00:02:49 It's hot, isn't it?
00:02:50 It's hot. It's warm. Good evening to you at home.
00:02:52 Thanks for joining us. Welcome to Western Standards Uncensored. This is a political
00:02:58 panel with a punch, and it is our inaugural episode. As Derek mentioned, we're going to
00:03:03 talk about everything under the sun that matters to Albertans, frankly, and Canadians for that
00:03:09 matter. And it's clear that a lot of issues that make the mainstream media maybe aren't discussed
00:03:15 as they should be, or you could say there would be a left-leaning narrative that accompanies them.
00:03:20 we're going to try and break that down this panel will ask tough questions we will ask real questions
00:03:26 and it will be a thoughtful and thorough debate some of the things we'll talk about in upcoming
00:03:32 episodes vaccine passports your personal freedoms we will talk about the free alberta strategy
00:03:39 launched by one of our panelists tonight but tonight we're going to talk about the upcoming
00:03:44 equalization referendum we go to the polls on october the 18th in a municipal election
00:03:50 One of the questions that we're going to be asked, we're going to put up on the screen for you, concerns equalization and how Albertans should view it.
00:03:58 And when you get my age, you need to put these glasses on. I want to read this correctly.
00:04:03 Should Motion 36.2 of the Constitution Act, 1982, Parliament and the Government of Canada's commitment to the principle of making equalization payments be removed from the Constitution?
00:04:15 Let's meet the panelists that are going to discuss this tonight. I want to start with Bill Buick.
00:04:19 Bill is the executive director of Fairness Alberta.
00:04:22 He was the lead on policy for the Wild Rose from 2010 to 2017.
00:04:27 Guy we always describe as a big brain and a deep thinker.
00:04:30 Bill, thanks for joining us from Edmonton.
00:04:35 Bill is muted.
00:04:36 Bill's muted.
00:04:37 My pleasure.
00:04:38 He's a big brain and a big thinker.
00:04:39 Got it.
00:04:40 But he was muted.
00:04:41 And that's your tip, Danielle and Rob, to be not muted when I throw it to you.
00:04:46 And we'll go to Rob next.
00:04:47 Rob, you'll know, was an Airdrie MLA for a couple of terms.
00:04:51 He was the finance critic for the Wild Rose Party,
00:04:55 and he is a practicing litigator and the author of the Free Alberta Strategy.
00:05:00 Joining us from Airdrie, Rob, thanks for being with us.
00:05:03 Thanks. It's like getting the old band back together here.
00:05:05 This is fantastic.
00:05:07 It's an interesting old gathering, isn't it?
00:05:10 And last but not least, I'd like to introduce Danielle Smith,
00:05:13 the lady who probably doesn't need an introduction. 1.00
00:05:15 Danielle, your CV is growing by the day.
00:05:19 What would I say, former school board representative,
00:05:22 former leader of the official opposition,
00:05:25 broadcaster, columnist, executive director of the Alberta
00:05:30 Enterprise Group, and so much more.
00:05:33 And a lot of Albertans follow you these days on Locals,
00:05:36 your app, and thank you for joining us tonight.
00:05:39 My pleasure. Nice to see you all.
00:05:41 Great to see you.
00:05:42 Why don't we just stay right with you for the first question?
00:05:45 okay you've seen the question on the screen what do you make of it why should Albertans be voting
00:05:50 yes you know the first time I heard about this strategy I didn't think it was going to be
00:05:55 successful I think Brian Jean was actually the first person to mention the idea of voting on
00:05:59 the question of equalization and I didn't think it would be successful because here we are in
00:06:04 Alberta voting on what is essentially a federal spending program but I think the way the question
00:06:09 has been designed is very clever I've had a chance to talk with Professor Ted Morton about it
00:06:14 And because of various constitutional decisions that have gone through the courts in the past, my understanding is that by asking Albertans if they want to take a section out of the Constitution, it initiates a process that causes the federal government to have to take this seriously.
00:06:29 And it starts the national discussion.
00:06:31 I don't know that we'll be successful in getting equalization eliminated, but you know what?
00:06:36 We may be successful in getting it reformed.
00:06:38 All I know is if we vote no to this, we'll never even start the conversation.
00:06:41 That's why I am encouraging everyone I know to vote strongly yes in favor of this, because I think we do need a strong mandate for the Premier to pursue it.
00:06:51 Rob, you want to pick up on that? What will you say to the question in general?
00:06:55 Well, I mean, I think that I think it's important and I will be voting yes, obviously,
00:07:03 and we'll be encouraging everyone that is voting in the municipal election next Monday to tick a
00:07:12 box by the yes column because obviously equalization is a disaster. It's a terrible policy.
00:07:18 It specifically rewards poor government. It penalizes good governance. It penalizes provinces
00:07:30 that are full of hardworking workers that are contributing to society and to the economy and
00:07:41 so forth. It is literally one of the most ineffective and ridiculous programs that one 0.90
00:07:48 could conceive of. And yet we've somehow have this beast enshrined in our constitution. So we need 0.98
00:07:54 to vote yes on it. Now that said, though, I don't believe that whether we get 60% or 50% or 70%
00:08:04 or whatever, is that important here. And for me, this is more of a symbolic question. I think there
00:08:10 are more substantive things that Alberta can do to end equalization and federal transfer payments
00:08:16 and so forth that go far beyond this question.
00:08:20 But to Daniel's point, there are some legal reasons for doing this.
00:08:24 Will they be successful?
00:08:27 We'll see.
00:08:28 So yes, vote yes, for sure.
00:08:30 But, you know, there are more important things we should be doing.
00:08:34 Right.
00:08:34 And we're going to get to some of those questions.
00:08:36 I'm going to put you on the spot with some of that and ask you to outline some of the
00:08:40 in-depth analysis, I guess you could say.
00:08:43 Bill, do this for me.
00:08:44 For somebody watching tonight that maybe isn't overly familiar with it, why is this so significant?
00:08:49 Can you put it in layman's terms as to why Albertans should be on side with the yes vote?
00:08:55 Yeah, it's a rare chance for the general public to show their feelings about a specific topic.
00:09:02 I mean, I know a lot of people have different opinions on direct democracy.
00:09:07 But to my mind, when you have a chance to speak up and make your feelings known, you should take it.
00:09:13 and it's it's I think we can't rely on the political class to get this done for for lots
00:09:20 of reasons it's it's pretty easy for the federal government to ignore Albertans and it's pretty
00:09:27 easy for them to ignore the pre it's a chance to say no this isn't okay we're tired of of paying so
00:09:38 much getting so little in return and lately getting you know uh negative uh scorn and ridicule
00:09:46 and policies that are going to kill our uh our energy sector which is the lifeblood of our 0.82
00:09:52 economy so it's it's time for us to to say no this is not okay and we insist that this be addressed
00:09:59 i mean there's so many uh issues at the federal level that that politicians would prefer to try
00:10:04 and tackle before this one and so it's up to us to kind of put our foot down and say no you need
00:10:10 to fix this okay so we're in agreement that obviously we're sending a message to albert
00:10:15 pardon me to ottawa with this and albertans should send a strong message quebec obviously has
00:10:23 a lot of things going in its favor that alberta would like to see frankly done here
00:10:27 Is there a number on this, Rob? You kind of touched on it, 60, 70%. Does it matter to you
00:10:35 to send a strong message to Ottawa? Well, the higher percentage, the better,
00:10:42 obviously. I mean, if it's 70, 80%, that's going to send a stronger message than 50, 60, obviously.
00:10:49 But, you know, I think to Bill's and Daniel's point, I think it is important for the, I'm
00:10:56 assuming the legal process that's going to be commenced after the vote,
00:11:02 assuming that we get an over 50% vote,
00:11:06 to challenge whether this flawed program should be left in our Constitution.
00:11:12 I think for those purposes, it's important to send a good message.
00:11:16 Of course, we can get into whether the current premier's approval ratings
00:11:25 and whether whether these these other factors the wording of the question and so forth uh is such
00:11:31 that it's going to um be whether or not this vote will be a real indication of how of how albertans
00:11:38 um view equalization but that said a yes vote is is important uh but again you compared alberta to
00:11:47 quebec and and it's a very apt comparison because one has to ask how has quebec been so successful
00:11:54 in obtaining so much equalization over these years and making sure the formula is so rigged
00:11:59 which it is it's rigged to to favor them um and you know the reason one of the reasons is is that
00:12:05 they if they you know first of all their leaders have have guts and they they stand up for their
00:12:10 province and they do what needs to be done for for their for their people in that regard and uh and
00:12:16 and they made it in ottawa's best interest to capitulate to to their demands and uh
00:12:22 Alberta has not done that.
00:12:24 We have not had leadership in that area.
00:12:26 We don't have a viable walkaway position
00:12:28 that strikes fear into the hearts of Ottawa politicians.
00:12:32 We've been pushovers.
00:12:33 So hopefully this is a first step
00:12:35 in showing that we're not going to be pushovers
00:12:37 on this issue anymore.
00:12:39 Well, lots there to follow up on, Rob.
00:12:42 Pretty strong language,
00:12:43 and I think a lot of Albertans would share it.
00:12:45 Danielle, we'll go to you on some of what Rob said.
00:12:48 How has Quebec been so successful,
00:12:51 frankly in getting what they want where we have not? Isn't that the great question? Let me
00:12:57 reverse the answer from what you'd asked earlier as well though about how large a mandate this
00:13:03 needs. Let's think of the alternative is that if it doesn't have a strong mandate that'll send a
00:13:08 message to the Premier that this is not something that Albertans care about. I think we've all been
00:13:13 worried that the Premier has only tepid interest in some of the Fairness Alberta priorities whether
00:13:18 it's an Alberta pension plan or provincial police, you're collecting your own provincial
00:13:22 income taxes. And that's what I'm worried about, is that if there isn't a strong vote for this,
00:13:27 then there wouldn't be any motivation to go on to the next ones. And I mentioned those ones in
00:13:31 particular, because Quebec has looked at its powers under the Constitution. And they've been
00:13:36 a grown up province, they said, we're not going to have Ottawa take money from us and deliver
00:13:40 these services, we're going to do it ourselves. So they have their own Quebec pension plan,
00:13:44 they have their own provincial police, they do collect their own personal income taxes,
00:13:48 they have their own immigration system and i think what that's done is it's created the architecture
00:13:54 so that when quebec saw a sovereignty from time to time say you know what if we don't get what we
00:13:59 want we're out of here they actually have the structure in place that you have to take it
00:14:04 seriously how come alberta even if there is that question on the table why would ottawa take them
00:14:10 take alberta seriously if not only we don't collect our own taxes we don't have our own police
00:14:16 we aren't self-sufficient on pension. I think that this is really the first step of a series
00:14:23 of things that need to be done. But if we don't get to this first step, we're not going to be
00:14:26 able to follow down in the path of Quebec. And look, I'd love to see Confederation work. I'd
00:14:30 love to see Alberta and Quebec work together so that we both have the ability to maximize our
00:14:37 economic prosperity. But I will tell you this, I know the precise day that Albertans said they'd
00:14:44 they'd had enough with Quebec. And it was the day that Francois Legault, shortly after being elected,
00:14:49 said, we don't want your dirty oil. And then within, I think, a 48-hour period, there was
00:14:53 extra money in the equalization fund. So Quebec got an extra billion dollars. At that point,
00:14:58 I was still on the air, and my audience said, forget it. If they don't want to allow us the
00:15:03 opportunity to develop our own resources, we can't just have a pipeline of money going to Quebec.
00:15:08 We've got to have the question of whether we should stop this program in the first place. So
00:15:12 they started it but i think we have to to answer to it by saying that we've got to do something
00:15:16 differently yep very well communicated and i can feel people's blood boiling listening to your
00:15:21 answer um bill is there a number for you that's significant and do you want to pick up on the
00:15:26 quebec chatter no i i think given uh the you know side swipe by covid and the premier's pop
00:15:35 you know the turnout of what will end up be showing up for municipal polls winning it is
00:15:42 what's important a loss would be something that the people not interested in in our issues would
00:15:47 use a club to beat us over the head for the next 10 years but going back to the quebec one not to 1.00
00:15:55 risk the blood boiling right over but i wrote a piece in the herald a couple months ago showing
00:16:00 how the three biggest flaws in the program are totally stacked in quebec's favor uh the the one
00:16:06 is that there's this gdp growth rule so that uh as danielle noted you know that they have to spend
00:16:12 a certain amount more every year in the payments regardless of need regardless of how unequal we
00:16:17 are uh the second issue is that quebec hydro isn't properly accounted for so because quebec
00:16:23 subsidizes their hydro rates it makes it look like quebec hydro is much deflated and how what kind of
00:16:29 taxation you could get from that entity if you just bring them up to the same as toronto's prices
00:16:34 quebec's payment drops from 13 billion to 5 billion and the whole program shrinks about two
00:16:39 uh by about a third so that is a something that is an obvious thing that needs to be addressed
00:16:44 just treat quebec hydro as if it were charging market do what you want with the actual uh
00:16:50 subsidies but we're not going to pretend you're not subsidizing it when we do our formula
00:16:54 and uh the third one is the no accounting for difference in uh prices in each province you
00:17:00 can't hire a nurse in toronto or calgary for what you can hire a nurse in montreal or moncton
00:17:06 uh the cost of living there is so much cheaper that it the number one driver of costs and public
00:17:12 services is salaries and you just don't need to pay people as much in those provinces so why would
00:17:17 you need the same fiscal capacity to afford the same services so that's a major flaw as well you
00:17:23 You put those three things together and Quebec's payment goes from 13 billion to about 300 million.
00:17:28 It basically disappears and suddenly, oh, look, Quebec actually isn't a have-not province.
00:17:33 They're right around the national average.
00:17:35 So if we could just fix that program, get this ridiculous giant payment to Quebec out of it,
00:17:40 suddenly everybody's saving at least $10 billion and we're not having to fork over that kind of money
00:17:46 for a province who has better services than anyone else in the country.
00:17:50 That's good stuff, Bill.
00:17:52 it's actually troubling what you give us but it's good information and there are people listening
00:17:57 out there i think that i think we should keep in mind we'll have a lot of uh political types like
00:18:02 ourselves out watching our program here tonight and hopefully there's some people that aren't so
00:18:06 political geeks like us and maybe not married to the coverage of this stuff every day and we can
00:18:12 help them with some of this information and help make an informed division uh decision pardon me
00:18:18 let's put the question back up on the screen james if we could one more time this is the
00:18:22 question you're going to be asked on the ballot in the upcoming municipal election next Monday.
00:18:27 It's October the 18th. I guess it's this Monday. Rob, you mentioned that the system is rigged.
00:18:33 And I think from what Danielle and Bill said, they tend to agree. Do we have to focus on
00:18:40 educating more Albertans to exactly how this works and how much better our province might run if
00:18:46 this formula were straightened out? Very good point. I mean, obviously, this just deals with
00:18:51 equalization formula itself and of course the when you hear these numbers such as alberta has
00:18:57 transferred uh 600 billion dollars more in tax revenues to ottawa than it's received back from
00:19:03 ottawa government's services over the past 60 years and we're talking about that number we're
00:19:08 talking about not just the equalization formula but also just the federal transfer scheme whereby
00:19:13 we all pay our taxes to ottawa and they just continually find more and more interesting ways
00:19:19 to uh to take that the majority of those monies and and put them into uh into quebec and uh for
00:19:25 various boat buying schemes and things like that so so it's a big it's a huge issue um i personally
00:19:31 uh you know i think that albertans um understand that we're getting host they understand that we
00:19:39 are getting the short end of the stick in confederation um in in a big way uh what i
00:19:45 think is really alarming to them is that um you know there's i call it the tale of two trudeaus
00:19:52 the first trudeau he he actually the national energy program people don't know this but it was
00:19:56 actually it was actually the mission of it although it didn't really have the intended
00:20:01 effect was to grow the energy industry for energy security in canada and to of course milk alberta
00:20:07 for all it was worth uh while that was happening uh not a popular program had all kinds of
00:20:12 unintended poor consequences but that's very different from the second trudeau justin trudeau
00:20:17 whose stated goal is not just to suck us dry with with these continued equalization payments and
00:20:24 and this law transfer program but it's also to actually phase out of existence our primary
00:20:31 industry in the hundreds of thousands of jobs that that creates in this province and across canada
00:20:37 So we're looking, so on that backdrop, I think it's important to note that, you know, this question is just, we're talking about one piece here.
00:20:49 We're talking about kind of the sucking Alberta out of its resources dry piece.
00:20:54 That's an important piece.
00:20:55 But what Albertans, I think, are starting to wake up to and what they should be waking up to now is the realization that we have a bit of an existential crisis on our hands.
00:21:03 We are not going to be a fiscally viable province, a financially economically viable province, if we do not push back on the intention of the current government, which is to eliminate our most important industry and the hundreds of thousands of jobs that it creates.
00:21:19 Danielle, does the question go far enough?
00:21:21 Well, I think Rob is dead right. I mean, we need to go much further. We need to realize what the existential crisis is for Alberta, because I think we thought, well, after the NEP, we'll just keep our heads down and they'll allow us to keep on making money.
00:21:37 They'll siphon some off. But as long as we're wealthy and we can take care of our stuff, it's all right.
00:21:42 But as soon as they start attacking our principal industry, we have to ask where it ends.
00:21:46 So we thought initially, OK, well, they're going after coal. Fine. We'll phase out coal and we'll adopt natural gas at our electricity power plants.
00:21:54 And then it was, oh, well, now they're going after the oil sands. OK, well, let's figure out how we can do carbon capture on the oil sands.
00:22:00 Well, now they're going after natural gas. And I don't think that we should be cavalier about what's happening in Quebec.
00:22:06 They have passed a policy essentially making it impossible to extract any oil and gas resources from their province.
00:22:14 And when you look at how much natural gas assets they have, and it's significant, the very idea that they would hamstring a sector of their economy and then turn around to the rest of the country and say, oh, by the way, we find ourselves a little bit short.
00:22:27 Can you just transfer money from the rest of the country?
00:22:29 is appalling, number one. But the second part is that if that is what they're going to do in Quebec,
00:22:34 is pass policies that they can tell the world that the Glasgow COP26 conference is coming up
00:22:40 in a couple of weeks' time, that this is the direction Canada is going, you better believe
00:22:45 that Justin Trudeau is going to look at ways of putting pressure on other regions to cancel
00:22:50 exploration and development permits as well. So Quebec has always led the country in this
00:22:55 discussion. It's one of the reasons why we have such a huge divide between the public opinion in
00:23:01 Alberta and Quebec. We fundamentally disagree on how we develop our energy resources, and they have
00:23:07 always had the upper hand politically, they've had the upper hand financially, and now they're
00:23:11 taking it one step further. So Rob is absolutely right. We need to push back. This is the first
00:23:15 step, but there's so many more reasons why we have to make sure that this conversation
00:23:18 advances from here. All right. You're watching Uncensored, a political panel that gets straight
00:23:25 to the punch on western standard what i just heard from you danielle was a yes vote is absolutely
00:23:31 necessary while it won't get us where we need to be it'll at least get us moving in the right
00:23:35 direction bill would you concur yeah i uh i mean a lot of people fixate on the the constitutional
00:23:43 side of this and you know uh i have a plan to hopefully get five provinces with 70 of the
00:23:52 population on board with this because they're all paying into it and getting nothing. But there's
00:23:56 no way we're getting seven provinces on board, given how much some of them are used to getting
00:24:01 those no-strings-attached checks. But the point of it is just that when the Supreme Court was
00:24:08 clear in 1998 that when one individual province expresses that they want to see constitutional
00:24:15 change. The quote said, there's a corresponding duty on the participants to Confederation to
00:24:23 engage in constitutional discussions in order to acknowledge and address democratic expressions of
00:24:28 a desire for change. So to my mind, it's the key that, you know, they could have had an easier
00:24:33 number or a higher result, probably if they just said, do you think equalization is unfair,
00:24:37 but it wouldn't meet that threshold. Once we do meet that threshold, those negotiations can
00:24:42 sort of put everything on the table including some of these other issues you know one of them
00:24:48 is why did the federal government need to take so many tax dollars compared to the provinces
00:24:53 why are provincial taxes half the size of our federal taxes that's just the way that the federal
00:24:59 taxing power and the tax room that the federal government has means that the provinces all have
00:25:04 to beg and plead to get the funding they need to provide their services when as a taxpayer i would
00:25:10 much prefer, you know, be switched and have double my money going to the provincial government
00:25:15 where health and education and the justice system and all the things that actually cost
00:25:19 money are, compared to the federal government where they just use it to basically slush
00:25:24 money around and follow political pursuits that are extra constitutional.
00:25:29 Bill, I want to stay with this for a minute. You've been debating academics, frankly, on
00:25:34 this issue for the last couple of months as we lead up to the vote the academic argument and
00:25:41 some would say the liberal argument is that uh this question isn't right it's not going to get
00:25:46 us where we need to be uh the emotional argument and the one that most albertans get when it's
00:25:53 presented to them is that we need to go in this direction did you do anything you want to address
00:25:57 that you're hearing from some of the critics uh on this debate they seem to be bending over
00:26:03 backwards to be either uh purposely uh misleading folks or just being utterly obtuse because i feel
00:26:11 like a lot of them it's not so much that they're they're partisan it's not their partisanship it's
00:26:15 that they just don't trust uh people to get it uh they think they're afraid of people getting
00:26:22 emotional and and acting on something without you know having a phd level uh of understanding on it
00:26:28 and i'm you know i'm sorry but that's the world and and so i think this is important because i
00:26:33 think albertans get it more than these guys give them credit for uh and so whether it's this you
00:26:39 know some of them are niggling over this 1998 uh court ruling and pretending it was only about
00:26:44 secession but the court was clear that there's a more general principle on this but who cares
00:26:48 about the court it's just common sense that if a if a province has a vote like this to express
00:26:54 dissatisfaction about something in the in the country you have to respect that and do something
00:27:00 about it and you can't just sort of write it off as uh and utterly ignore it uh as you might be
00:27:05 able to do with a politician who's of a different party that you don't like i'd love to hear an
00:27:10 academic uh talk in plain language i should point out you are dr bill dr bill buick so we appreciate
00:27:18 that rob you mentioned a little bit uh about um the premier's popularity possibly factoring into
00:27:25 this vote we should address it i don't think there's a less popular premier in the province
00:27:30 right now do you think that will impact albertans yes or no vote at the polls uh yes i think both
00:27:37 directly and indirectly it'll it'll affect the vote so anyhow to bills dr maybe dr buick dr buick
00:27:48 Bill's point earlier, you know, just a victory, just over 50% would be a victory.
00:27:54 And the reason is, is because of the Premier's unpopularity.
00:27:58 We don't need to get into the reasons for it.
00:28:00 But, you know, I've seen polling ranging anywhere from 18 to 22% approval rating.
00:28:05 That is abysmal.
00:28:09 Those are terrible numbers.
00:28:11 Whether he can survive them, who knows.
00:28:12 But the problem is, because he's so unpopular, it directly affects the vote in that some people, rightly or wrongly, are going to tie their view of this question and how to answer this question based on how they feel about the premier who's responsible for putting it on the ballot.
00:28:31 day and if people aren't thinking and they're thinking emotionally about it they might want to
00:28:35 try they might think that this is punishing uh him by by voting no on the issue well of course
00:28:40 that's not punishing the premier it's punishing albertans so that's the direct way it affects it
00:28:45 and then the indirect way is that he hasn't been able to advocate for it uh what what should be
00:28:51 happening in a situation like this if you had if he had the popularity of a of a scott of a premier
00:28:56 Moe or, you know, another one of the more popular premiers across the province right
00:29:01 now, he would be out actively campaigning for a yes vote, but he can't because he knows
00:29:08 as well as anybody else that by doing so, he actually harms the initiative.
00:29:13 So we're kind of in a difficult bind here.
00:29:16 And frankly, if we get, you know, say 50, 60, anything above 60% would be actually kind
00:29:22 of a remarkable vote in favor of ending the program just because, frankly, we've kind of had
00:29:29 one hand tied behind our back by having the most unpopular premier in the country.
00:29:36 Danielle, is the premier's heart on this, you think?
00:29:39 That's the question, isn't it? I think Rob's right. I think if he has strategists around him
00:29:45 asking whether he would add value to the debate, most people would probably be saying,
00:29:49 if you go out and actively campaign for this, you might end up creating the opposite result.
00:29:55 So I want to assume that he does want the, he is engaged, he does want it to pass, he did put it
00:30:00 on the ballot. Let me just put something out there that I'm surprised that I haven't heard
00:30:04 more mayoral candidates mention this, because it does strike me that if you're going to make
00:30:10 the argument that we shouldn't have equalization between the regions, it seems like a pretty
00:30:14 powerful argument you could make if you're in Calgary or if you're in Edmonton or if you're in
00:30:19 the regional municipality of Wood Buffalo. We've got a lot of equalization that happens in this
00:30:24 province too. And this is, I guess, the nature of the problem is that municipalities are feeling
00:30:29 resentful that this ballot question is out there, whereas I think municipal leaders should be
00:30:36 looking at it as a way of starting a conversation about maybe we need to take this principle of
00:30:42 allowing different regions to benefit from the revenues that are generated within their territory
00:30:48 so that they can pay for their own services. We've got the same kind of strange tax and transfer game
00:30:52 happening within our own province. So to me, having it on the municipal ballot is the exact
00:30:57 right place for it. It could start a broader discussion. But sadly, we just haven't had very
00:31:02 many champions for this at all. We've got the academics who are against it. We've got the
00:31:06 municipal leaders sort of resentful that it's there. We've got at the municipal level, largely
00:31:11 those who are employed at the municipal level of office the unions are the ones who tend to come
00:31:16 out and vote and I don't I haven't heard very very much enthusiasm for it there so that's the only
00:31:22 thing reason I'd be very concerned about the the lack of the premier's popularity and ability to
00:31:26 weigh in on this because he should be the principal voice championing it and I think Rob's right that
00:31:32 if he if he did end up taking a lead on it we might get the opposite result. Going to stay with
00:31:37 you danielle before i do i just want a shameless plug for what we're doing here grateful that
00:31:42 you're watching us tonight you're watching uncensored and it's a political panel with a
00:31:46 punch we've decided to work with the western standard and uh talk about the things that
00:31:51 matter to albertans and give you a platform and hopefully uh some common sense discussion on the
00:31:56 issues that matter we're doing it tonight on the equalization referendum that's coming up on the
00:32:00 municipal election ballot this coming Monday. Danielle, does Ottawa care? What happens?
00:32:08 Well, they should, but I guess it doesn't do much good if you just saber rattle and you don't follow
00:32:13 up with any meaningful action. And if they start a consultation with us, I think we have an idea
00:32:22 of where that's going to end up. If you put it to a vote, seven out of 10 provinces representing
00:32:27 50 percent of the population is i think the vote that you need to be able to change the constitution
00:32:32 for the reasons bill and rob have suggested we might end up losing that one the only way we
00:32:36 really can start taking our tax dollars back is by having our own alberta pension plan because we pay
00:32:43 about 30 of the premiums but we only get back 10 of the benefits that are paid out if if we
00:32:50 repatriated that program and we developed the investment principles around the values and
00:32:55 principles that Albertans care about, they would pay attention to that. We already know they're
00:33:00 paying attention to that because as we were beginning this discussion, the CPP Investment
00:33:05 Board was doing advertisements out here saying, oh, your CPP Investment Board is doing a great
00:33:10 job on your behalf. We also know that if we decided not to keep the RCMP and went with our
00:33:16 own Alberta Provincial Police Force, that would also catch their attention. How do we know that?
00:33:20 the RCMP union has already started taking out ads and doing campaigns to try to get Albertans
00:33:26 persuaded not to go down that track. So I do think that there are other steps that need to
00:33:31 be taken after this one that'll be more powerful, that will cause Ottawa to pay closer attention.
00:33:37 But I don't think that they can because of the legal way in which this is structured. They can't
00:33:42 ignore it, but they can override it. They can do political maneuvers to make it ineffectual,
00:33:47 But there's other things that we can do in retaliation.
00:33:50 Well, let's go to the lawyer in the group.
00:33:52 Mr. Anderson, what do you think?
00:33:53 Is Ottawa watching?
00:33:57 They're watching.
00:33:58 I don't know if they care at Hill of Beans what happens here.
00:34:01 We haven't done anything to defend ourselves.
00:34:05 We haven't done anything to push back.
00:34:08 Whenever something outrageous happens with Ottawa attacking our interests,
00:34:14 um we launch a press release and say we're disappointed uh and that seems to be it we
00:34:23 buy billboards okay uh we need to do we need to be more substantive than that and and everything
00:34:30 danielle just said uh is absolutely correct the creation of the uh alberta pension plan to replace
00:34:36 the cpp is an absolute 100 no-brainer our seniors win our workers win with lower premiums seniors
00:34:43 with higher benefits and the taxpayer wins here in alberta so that is a no-brainer but there's
00:34:48 many others there's the police forces was mentioned um setting up our own uh unemployment
00:34:53 insurance program which we also over contribute to um and then there are i would say more aggressive
00:34:59 things that we can do uh ottawa is still not listening um frankly i i just think alberta
00:35:04 needs to change the dynamic here and understand look the rules of confederation as they stand
00:35:10 right now and as interpreted by the supreme court are rigged against alberta period full stop like
00:35:17 let's not pretend it's not that way they're rigged and they're always going to find in favor of the
00:35:23 federal government they're always going to lean towards vote buying in quebec and satisfying
00:35:27 that mass that large voting block and we have to take a look at ourselves and say okay what are we
00:35:33 going to do different because it's insanity to keep doing what we've been trying to do for the
00:35:37 last 50 60 years to absolutely no avail so you know my my you know view on it is uh you know
00:35:44 someone as a co-author of the uh of the free alberta strategy is that um that we need to
00:35:50 start looking at ways to um declare ourself a sovereign jurisdiction and act as a sovereign
00:35:57 jurisdiction within canada um so that we are able to take control of our autonomy on various different
00:36:04 governance pieces and ensure that we can stand up to Alberta or to Ottawa, get their attention
00:36:12 and actually have some meaningful change.
00:36:14 Okay, listen, I was going to give you a chance to give a free plug to the Free Alberta Strategy.
00:36:19 You just kind of half did.
00:36:22 Daniel, let's give him a little more time.
00:36:23 I know he's itching to get this out there.
00:36:25 The FreeAlbertaStrategy.com is the website.
00:36:29 Cole's notes, Rob, what are you telling Albertans in this paper?
00:36:33 Well, I'll just say there's two foundational principles of it. Number one, there's the
00:36:38 Alberta Sovereignty Act, which we propose the provincial government pass. And all it says,
00:36:43 think of it as a notwithstanding clause on provincial rights. So, of course, the charter
00:36:49 has a notwithstanding clause, and it says that a province can still do something even if it's
00:36:53 found to be an infringement of Section 15, the equality provision and other provisions of the
00:37:00 charter if it invokes this notwithstanding clause. Well, we don't have a notwithstanding clause for
00:37:06 section 91 and 92 of the constitution, which deals with provincial and federal jurisdictions.
00:37:11 And Alberta, in my view, needs to take action on this and say that, look, we are a sovereign
00:37:19 jurisdiction within Canada. And when Ottawa passes laws that attack our province's economy,
00:37:26 attack provincial jurisdiction and provincial rights.
00:37:30 Which they do all the time.
00:37:31 Which they do all the time, from the carbon tax to different weapons legislation
00:37:37 and restrictions to, you name it, the oil tanker.
00:37:40 You can just go on and on, environmental regulations on our oil and gas sector.
00:37:45 All of these things, which should be a provincial jurisdiction,
00:37:48 all of these things are clearly not within the role of the federal government.
00:37:53 And the passage of the Alberta Sovereignty Act would say,
00:37:55 look, we are not going to enforce unconstitutional infringements of our provincial rights or attacks on Albertans within the boundaries of Alberta.
00:38:05 So, for example, you can pass your carbon tax, fill your boots, but we're not going to enforce it here, period.
00:38:11 And you can scream and yell all you want, but we're not enforcing it within our boundaries.
00:38:15 And that's the type of action that I believe will get results long term on equalization, as well as on many of the issues that are that are hurting Alberta right now.
00:38:25 All right. We could devote an entire program to the free Alberta strategy, and I think we probably will. Right now, let's kick it back to the debate on, or the discussion, pardon me, on the upcoming referendum on equalization. Bill, you didn't get a chance to weigh in on the last question I asked. Did you want to go there?
00:38:43 yeah i i uh think there's equalization in particular is not an alberta problem it is a
00:38:52 problem for uh like i said roughly 70 percent of the country pays a significant amount into it
00:38:59 albertans pay probably about 650 dollars per person but if you go to ontario saskatchewan bc
00:39:06 even Newfoundland, they pay about $500 per person. So it's $2,200 for a family of four in those
00:39:15 provinces is going directly to fund provincial services in Quebec and the Maritimes. So I feel
00:39:21 like we have an opportunity here. Ottawa might not want to listen to Alberta and they might be able
00:39:27 to wave their hand about Alberta getting upset again. But if we can get people in Toronto or
00:39:34 police people in the greater toronto area and all those target seats saying wait a second how come
00:39:39 we aren't getting more of our tax dollars back to pay for our provincial services in metro vancouver
00:39:45 saying the same thing uh that is something no party in ottawa can ignore and so what we're
00:39:51 trying to do at fairness alberta and i encourage everybody to go uh to go see our equalization
00:39:56 referendum.ca website to see we have a section right there to bc and ontario people that might
00:40:02 be paying attention to this. This is an opportunity to get a ball rolling from which you guys can
00:40:09 benefit a great deal as well and once you got 70% of the country with all those target seats in
00:40:14 those places, Ottawa will have to pay attention and that's what we're focused on in the short term.
00:40:19 Bill, we've discussed this before and I've challenged you on it and I'll
00:40:23 do it again and I know you've got a good answer but it's tough to sell the emotion of this in
00:40:28 other provinces do you find that or are you are you getting a good response i've i you know i
00:40:36 it's no it is albertans uh tend to be more uh conditioned i would say to to expect uh unfair
00:40:45 treatment from ottawa i think it's going to take a little bit more work in in british columbia and
00:40:51 ontario to get them thinking the same way but but this country to me has a great deal of potential
00:40:57 if we can just stop thinking about it as a sort of a giant welfare experiment and everybody's
00:41:04 just here to hold each other when the times are tough uh when this country was founded for two
00:41:09 reasons one was mutual defense against the united states because they have the biggest standing
00:41:14 army in the world and we're starting to look for something to do and the second one was to have
00:41:19 strong economic partnerships so that we could freely trade and cut down all these tariff walls
00:41:25 that were preventing us from all of us from making the most of our economies and achieving
00:41:31 our potential and so if we can get canada thinking again as a place where we are striving to be the
00:41:36 best and the most productive and the freest place in the world i think that can make a huge
00:41:42 difference and the key to that in my mind is get ontario to stop thinking of quebec as the big
00:41:47 political issue in in uh in canada and start seeing that bc and alberta have just as many
00:41:53 people and a much bigger economy than quebec does and it's building a bridge from ontario which is
00:41:59 a productive uh have province that pays in as well getting that bridge and that mentality from the 0.99
00:42:05 ottawa river kind of being something to just kind of turn away from and look for the potential in
00:42:11 the western part of the country and if ontarians can understand that we can all be stronger
00:42:15 including the eastern part of the country by having all of our economies firing on all cylinders and
00:42:20 ending some of this dependency, to me, that's the recipe for long-term success in Canada.
00:42:27 We've covered a lot of ground. We've got some time left. Danielle, I want to go back to you
00:42:31 with kind of an open-ended question. You're just joining in the debate or discussion here tonight.
00:42:36 People recognize we're talking about the upcoming equalization referendum.
00:42:40 What do we need to know ahead of Monday? Well, there's a couple of things that I just find
00:42:46 outrageous that really persuaded me that equalization needs to be eliminated and one of
00:42:53 them is i think bill alluded to it earlier quebec receives 13 billion dollars out of this fund and
00:43:00 it's a total of 21 billion dollars and newfoundland and labrador doesn't qualify for any equalization
00:43:06 transfer now think about that and what we've seen over the last year and a half newfoundland labrador
00:43:10 is on the brink of bankruptcy they're not able to support their own programming but we're basing
00:43:15 their allocation this year based on previous year's levels of wealth. Meanwhile, Quebec keeps
00:43:20 bragging that they have balanced budgets and surpluses and putting money away into their
00:43:25 prosperity fund and paying down debt, offering subsidized daycare, subsidized post-secondary.
00:43:32 And you have to look at that and you say, how can that be? How can we create a program that is so
00:43:37 biased in favor of Quebec and so imbalanced against clearly a nation or a jurisdiction
00:43:46 that's in need like Newfoundland and Labrador. And that I think is the fundamental unfairness.
00:43:50 So when we're talking about equalization, I think what we're talking about is rebalancing the
00:43:54 discussion so that the entire program isn't geared towards Quebec. I think we have to be
00:43:58 honest about that because if we were, I mean, I must tell you, I don't get too bent out of shape
00:44:04 by thinking that we might need to top up Prince Edward Island because they're a very small
00:44:09 island jurisdiction, what, 150,000 people? They may have a higher cost of service. It may make
00:44:14 sense to give them a bit more of a transfer so they can have roughly equal programs with roughly
00:44:20 equal tax rates. But Quebec should have never been able to qualify for this program. We never
00:44:25 should have had a program that causes tiny jurisdictions like Newfoundland and Labrador 0.88
00:44:30 and Saskatchewan to be paying for platinum level services in Quebec. And that's what it comes down
00:44:36 to for me, is that we may end up with some kind of top up for some of the other regions, the smaller
00:44:41 regions on a conditional basis or temporary basis, but this permanent transfer of dollars to Quebec
00:44:48 as they find ways to crater their own economy by either not developing their own natural resources
00:44:53 and creating a new revenue stream, or by subsidizing their electricity rate so that
00:44:59 They're not getting an appropriate dividend.
00:45:01 That's got to stop.
00:45:01 That's a hard line for me.
00:45:03 Rob, you want to jump right in there?
00:45:06 No, Daniel could not have said it better, frankly.
00:45:08 Frankly, Alberta, D.C., Quebec, Ontario should never qualify for equalization, period.
00:45:16 We're all big boys and girls.
00:45:18 We've got large populations capable of taking care of ourselves, capable of having the economies of scale necessary in our tax base and so forth to build the hospitals that we need.
00:45:29 and employ the people that we need there's no reason these four provinces should ever receive
00:45:34 equalization saskatchewan manitoba perhaps a little nova scotia perhaps a little bit of
00:45:40 equalization would be warranted there in uh in lean times but not a lot and then it should be
00:45:45 reserved as daniel said for the very smallest uh populations where economies of scale just
00:45:51 in the tax base just do not make it possible to provide proper health care and and education and
00:45:57 and so forth so we're talking about a 21 billion program 21 billion dollar program it should
00:46:02 probably be about two billion dollars that's what it should probably cost and it should go primarily
00:46:07 to two or three provinces in the highest need uh if any depending on how on how things are
00:46:13 that year in that province but it has turned into a giant vote buying scheme by sucking dollars out
00:46:20 of Alberta, redistributing them into Montreal, Quebec, and the Maritimes as well, all for
00:46:29 the purpose of electing Liberal government.
00:46:31 It's a joke.
00:46:32 It needs to change.
00:46:33 Okay, so I want to pick up on that, and just let me be the elephant in the room, or maybe
00:46:38 not even.
00:46:39 If you're going to get elected as Prime Minister in Canada, you're going to have to win in
00:46:44 Ontario, and you're going to have to win in Quebec, and Western Canada doesn't matter,
00:46:49 it's often decided before it gets out here in fact it's disappointing but anybody that can do
00:46:55 general mathematics not skip counting but standard algorithms which is what we prefer for our kids
00:47:00 can see that the numbers add up for Ontario and Quebec so until we change that I don't know how
00:47:06 we're going to change equalization but what I'm hearing from the three of you tonight is that this
00:47:11 has to be the start of the conversation bill agree or disagree disagree um i i too grew up in a time
00:47:20 where we did uh solid fundamentals of math uh in our school system and and it's it's not really the
00:47:27 case anymore that you need quebec uh harper won a majority in 11 with hardly any was it 10 quebec
00:47:34 seats and a few in the maritimes uh bc and alberta are bigger than quebec bc and alberta have almost
00:47:41 the same amount of seats but hopefully we can get that remedied soon and uh and and and if you can
00:47:48 win over and moreover it's it's all you know there's those 50 seats in the in the greater
00:47:52 toronto area and uh if you can get them thinking about do we want a productive country do we want
00:47:58 a prosperous country do we want a free country or do i want to keep sending uh two thousand dollars
00:48:04 to quebec's government to have cadillac services just over the ottawa river that we don't have
00:48:09 have here in ontario i i feel like you can make it awkward you know and have the people in toronto
00:48:15 saying we're kind of fed up with this what are you going to do about this problem and like i said
00:48:20 when that happens no party can ignore it and you can win governments based on ontario and the west
00:48:26 it's very logical and it's not only possible it's logical thinking your closing comments bill because
00:48:33 we're going to come back to you for those once i give rob and then danielle a chance to respond to
00:48:38 that rant of mine throwing to Bill. Rob, you first.
00:48:44 Well, I understand the logic that Bill was going with there. I do disagree with it from the
00:48:53 standpoint of, I don't think there's a difference in the amount, the per capita amounts that are
00:49:02 being taken from Albertans as opposed to people in Ontario. And people in Ontario, the voters
00:49:10 in Ontario, they know full well that the jurisdiction that's footing most of the bill
00:49:18 here is Alberta on a per capita basis. And so to me, I think it's just, to me, I just
00:49:26 don't think you're going to be able to find, you're not going to be able to wake up the
00:49:30 people of Ontario to that inequality, just because it's not hurting them as much. I mean,
00:49:36 sure, it's a bit of a pain, but government wastes money all the time, they think. So what's the big
00:49:41 deal? In Alberta, it's a massive problem. I mean, if you just look at our deficits right now,
00:49:49 $20 billion a year, it's insanity. I mean, unbelievably, Quebec's got balanced budget
00:49:56 using our deficit essentially using the amount of our deficit to pay for their programs i mean yeah
00:50:02 this is a big issue here and i don't think i think it's always going to be in ontario's best
00:50:08 effort or best interest in their minds to placate quebec with alberta's money and i think the only
00:50:15 way that changes if we is if albertans assert their sovereignty and said game over guys we
00:50:21 We either change this, or you're going to have to find yourself another sugar daddy. 1.00
00:50:26 All right.
00:50:28 Hadn't heard it put quite like that, but I like it.
00:50:31 Danielle, I'll leave it to you to break the tie on this one.
00:50:34 There's a couple of things.
00:50:35 I remember reading an Andrew Coyne column years ago.
00:50:37 It got me thinking about the dynamics in Ontario.
00:50:40 And there's a strange dynamic in Ontario.
00:50:43 I don't pretend to understand it.
00:50:44 But to be able to win votes in that greater Toronto area,
00:50:48 you have to demonstrate that you can win votes in Quebec.
00:50:50 Maybe it just goes back to the idea that Ontario, maybe they feel like they've got to be the healer of the nation or something and keep everyone together.
00:50:59 But that's why I don't think a political party can win by writing off Quebec completely, even though, as Bill points out, the math works.
00:51:06 I think the bigger issue that we have to get to is when you look at all of the different transfers that we have in provincial areas, we've got the Canada Health Transfer, the Canada Social Transfer, and equalization.
00:51:18 I just looked up these numbers on the weekend. It's over 83 billion dollars that the federal
00:51:24 government launders. They take it from the provinces. They take their cut through the
00:51:28 federal bureaucracy. They divvy it up. At least the Canada Health and Social Transfers are done 1.00
00:51:35 on a per capita basis. But the reason why everybody keeps dancing to Ottawa's tune is because of the
00:51:40 unfairness of equalization. Now, my favorite approach would be just take that 83 billion
00:51:47 dollars and turn it all into a single transfer on a per capita basis. And the reason you'd want to
00:51:54 do that is pretty soon you'd have the provinces start saying, hmm, why is Ottawa taking this money
00:51:59 in the first place? If they want to have meaningful decisions on health care and long-term care and
00:52:06 daycare, why don't they run for provincial office? Why do federal politicians run for federal office
00:52:13 knowing that it's actually a fairly limited role, and then take money from the provinces so that
00:52:19 they can have some way of influencing policy. That's the thing that I object to. But I don't
00:52:24 think we get to that conversation without eliminating equalization first, because look
00:52:28 what's already happening. We already have the provinces lining up to say, how can we get more
00:52:33 money from Ottawa and health transfers? I would far rather for our provinces to say, stop taking
00:52:39 it in the first place. Let's convert all of those transfers into a change in tax points. Let's get
00:52:44 rid of equalization as it stands, give tiny top ups to those provinces that need it on a different
00:52:49 type of basis. And then let's start taking care of our own business. But I don't think that you
00:52:53 can have that conversation until you deal with the equalization problem. Well, you may have
00:52:59 effectively wrapped for us, Daniel, but I'd like to give everybody a chance, maybe 60 seconds or so,
00:53:05 to kind of throw their thoughts together, wrap this up.
00:53:09 And again, to those of you at home, thank you for being with us.
00:53:11 This is our inaugural edition here on the Western Standard of Uncensored,
00:53:15 and we're going to straight talk on some of the things that matter to Albertans and Canadians.
00:53:20 Bill, we'll go to you to close first.
00:53:22 The upcoming equalization referendum, why should Albertans vote yes?
00:53:27 because a voting no is a terrible step backwards for everything that albertans should be concerned
00:53:36 about on the federal scene in terms of getting a better deal for albertans uh but b equalization
00:53:42 program is extremely flawed and and no this vote won't uh cancel it tomorrow but it'll start a
00:53:49 renegotiation and a conversation on equalization which on its own merits needs serious overhaul if
00:53:54 not elimination and then c once that negotiation starts other things come out of the table like
00:54:01 the health transfers like tax points like trying to adjust the imbalance between the federal spending
00:54:05 power and the provincial needs to spend and so please don't be complacent there's not going to
00:54:11 be a huge turnout on this vote uh please uh you know follow fairness alberta on facebook we'll
00:54:16 be posting things all week come to our uh equalization referendum.ca website and point
00:54:21 your friends there and please encourage everyone you know to go out and check yes on that ballot
00:54:26 even if they have no other reason to show up to the polls but while they're at it they should
00:54:29 probably do a little research on their municipal candidates and make sure we get some responsible 0.93
00:54:33 politicians put into place there as well bill buick from fairness alberta thank you for being
00:54:39 with us tonight thanks all right rob we'll throw it over to you why should we be voting yes well
00:54:47 uh first off i think uh bill uh deserves a lot in fairness alberta deserve uh you know heartfelt uh
00:54:54 gratitude for at least getting this into the uh the public sphere a little bit more than it has
00:55:00 been because it has been uh the the ucp particularly the premier been completely missing an action on
00:55:06 it so uh thank you bill for doing that um vote yes because it's it's the obvious answer to this
00:55:13 question. Equalization is a terrible program for Alberta and for Canada, frankly, and it needs to 1.00
00:55:21 be eliminated. But also, aside from that, Albertans need to think, okay, what's next? Yes, equalization
00:55:29 needs to be eliminated or fundamentally changed, but we have to do more than that. And we have to
00:55:35 start thinking about how we can assert our sovereignty as an independent jurisdiction
00:55:39 within canada in order to make that happen and i hope people will will start thinking in those
00:55:45 terms a little bit more going forward and if we have some ideas of course on freeolbertastrategy.com
00:55:50 you can check out thanks and we'll probably have that another night on this program rob thank you
00:55:56 for joining us tonight you bet thank you all right danielle we'll leave you the last word on this
00:56:01 subject why should we be voting yes to end equalization well let me tell you why i think
00:56:06 all the reasons to vote no are bad reasons. One reason to vote no, I'm mad at the premier. So what?
00:56:12 Put that aside because this isn't about the premier. Another reason to vote no, well, I feel
00:56:16 sorry for the small provinces and we should help them out. That's okay. We can change the approach
00:56:21 so that we can address some of those small province issues. Voting no on this one is not the reason to
00:56:27 do it. Vote yes to have the conversation about how you're going to change it. Some people say it's
00:56:31 the wrong time. Well, when else are we going to do it? Going to wait another two years to have it
00:56:36 conjunction with a provincial election this is absolutely the right time to have it as well
00:56:40 being engaged on it as well means that we can have more votes on more things so if you vote no
00:56:45 you're telling the premier that you don't care about these issues enough to vote one way or the
00:56:49 other that you don't care to have the next step of the conversation which we need to have which is
00:56:53 how to get more fairness in alberta how to imp how to how to address some of the issues from the fair
00:56:58 deal panel so i i look at all of the objections the only reason why you would vote yes or vote
00:57:05 vote in favor of keeping the program the way it is is that you're fine with alberta continuing to
00:57:09 be a doormat that you're fine with alberta continuing to be the whipping boy you're fine
00:57:14 with not wanting to upset the apple cart because quebec might get upset and that's not a good
00:57:18 enough reason to to vote yeah to vote no to to defeat this this referendum vote i think
00:57:24 we need to have the conversation we need to tackle the challenges we're facing with quebec 1.00
00:57:29 head on we need to let them know we know what you're up to we know how you're gaming this
00:57:34 program and we're not gonna let you do it anymore because if you want to have a constructive
00:57:38 conversation about this country how this country works you want to have a construction or constructive
00:57:42 conversation about unity then this brings everyone to the table if Quebec would stop standing in the
00:57:49 way of our ability to achieve our own economic prosperity then we might not be having this
00:57:54 conversation but it's kind of hitting them where it hurts this is where it hurts and then we can
00:57:58 have the conversation about all the other things we need to do to fix confederation and bring some
00:58:02 community back. So that's why I say vote yes. Love it. One more, one more question for you,
00:58:07 Danielle. Both Rob and Bill have been rightfully plugging the organizations they're with. You're
00:58:12 the executive director of the Alberta Enterprise Group. You also have an app called Locals. And
00:58:17 if people want to see the content you put out, the discussions you have from a conservative
00:58:21 perspective, how do they go about doing that? You bet. I should mention, it's so funny, I was
00:58:25 going back looking at some of the old records for the Alberta Enterprise Group. And in 2012,
00:58:29 I had a debate with Michael Ignatieff on this exact question of whether or not we should continue to support equalization.
00:58:36 I bet you can probably guess from what I'm saying the position that I took at that time.
00:58:40 But I do talk about this along with a whole pile of other issues.
00:58:45 DanielleSmith.Locals.com
00:58:46 Awesome. Danielle, thank you.
00:58:49 And our thanks to Rob and Bill, of course, and to all of you for joining us tonight on Uncensored.
00:58:55 This is Western Standard's version, Uncensored, a political panel looking at the issues of the day.
00:59:01 We're going to continue to do this.
00:59:02 Tonight, we talked about the equalization referendum coming up in the next civic election, which is coming up Monday.
00:59:08 We will be talking about our personal freedoms, vaccines.
00:59:12 We'll be talking about all kinds of things that matter to Albertans and Canadians.
00:59:16 Reminder, Derek would want me to let you know that you can go to westernstandard.com and become a member.
00:59:20 and I think he'd probably be able to guide you through how to do that better than I can
00:59:25 but if you go to the website you'll see it'll walk you through how you can and obviously drop a few
00:59:32 bucks and support a good cause. Organizations like this are doing their best to take the issues of
00:59:37 the day present them to you unfiltered and frankly not the narrative that we're used to getting in
00:59:43 the mainstream. So thank you so much for tuning in tonight it's been a pleasure to bring you our
00:59:47 first inaugural edition, and we hope to see you again. Good night.