Western Standard - May 14, 2026


When the ethnic vote votes ethnic

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Alberta’s humiliating negotiations with Carney have gone on long enough Once, we did immigration right – and we can do it right again

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

161.81

Word count

7,910

Sentence count

270

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

25

sentences flagged

Hate speech

34

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard editor Dave Naylor, senior editor Corey Morgan Morgan, and editor-in-chief Nigel Hannaford discuss Alberta's carbon tax sellout, and the growing problem of ethnic politics in Canada's political class.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:27 Today is May 13th, 2026, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:31 I've got our normal crew of misfits here, our former opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:37 Former because I'm a misfit, I guess.
00:00:40 Nah, you retire.
00:00:41 I retire. 1.00
00:00:42 I'm still here because you're a misfit. 0.97
00:00:43 Yeah, that's too fit. 0.98
00:00:46 Senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:47 And news editor, Dave Naylor. 0.86
00:00:51 Head misfit. 1.00
00:00:52 Head mistress.
00:00:53 all right you know sometimes it kind of fits with the business right uh we are going to talk
00:01:00 about uh alberta's big carbon tax sellout uh confirmed today that uh the alberta ucp government
00:01:10 has agreed to pay a carbon tax of 130 per metric con getting to that by uh 2040 in exchange for
00:01:20 Well, we'll get the details of it tomorrow, unless it leaks out earlier.
00:01:24 But we'll get the details at least officially tomorrow.
00:01:27 Friday.
00:01:28 Oh, yes.
00:01:28 Friday.
00:01:29 Not tomorrow.
00:01:29 I'm ahead of myself.
00:01:31 But Friday at a press conference between Premier Danielle Smith and Prime Minister Mark Carney,
00:01:37 where I guess there'll be some kind of announcements of a pipeline or towards pipelines.
00:01:42 We'll see.
00:01:44 But either way, Alberta has had to sell the farm to get this.
00:01:47 So we'll talk about it.
00:01:48 um the canada haters are rallying to save canada from alberta the only uh the only thing the canada
00:01:59 haters hate more than canada it seems is alberta uh efforts by some in the foreign-owned and eastern
00:02:08 owned uh mainstream media press to paint every every alberta independent supporter as a hater
00:02:16 of canada while conveniently overlooking the people who genuinely hate canada people who topple
00:02:22 statues of our founders people who change the lyrics of oh canada people who denigrate the
00:02:27 military that kind of thing so we're going to get into kind of the hypocrisy around that
00:02:31 but uh first uh what happens when the ethnic vote votes ethnic um you know we've had uh it's it's a
00:02:41 thing not just in canada or alberta it's it's really everywhere in the western world that has
00:02:45 mass migration, you get kind of balkanized pockets of people from different ethnicities,
00:02:54 and they'll often vote, normally vote for someone of their own ethnicity once they reach a critical
00:03:01 mass of the voting public. But there's a very interesting case we want to zero in on from
00:03:08 Ontario, I think Scarborough, so you know, in the GTA, where Nate Erskine-Smith, he is a member of
00:03:15 a Liberal Member of Parliament, and he's trying to become a Liberal Member of the Ontario Parliament
00:03:20 because he's seeking the leadership of the Ontario Liberal Party. He has spent his entire political
00:03:24 career supporting open border, virtually unlimited mass migration, Dave. There's video clips of him
00:03:32 going back a decade and a mile long of him pandering to that local ethnic community,
00:03:38 which is Bangladeshi primarily.
00:03:41 And I guess he was expecting a little gratitude
00:03:44 for the support he's given them.
00:03:47 And it didn't pan out so well
00:03:49 when he was running for the Liberal nomination,
00:03:50 which is kind of a precursor for him
00:03:52 to become Ontario Liberal leader, right?
00:03:53 Yeah, be careful what you do 1.00
00:03:55 in case it comes back and bites you on the ass, 1.00
00:03:57 I guess is the way to look at it. 1.00
00:03:59 Yeah, he, in the nomination race for Scarborough,
00:04:04 he lost to a gentleman called Ashenol Hafiz,
00:04:07 who is a local Bangladeshi businessman, owns 15 Domino's pizza outlets.
00:04:15 And he lost, Erskine Smith lost by 19 votes.
00:04:21 And it was just, it looked like a mess.
00:04:24 I mean, it looked like Northeast Calgary politics at its worst.
00:04:29 They were handing out Bangladeshi voting cards and telling them,
00:04:33 You know, basically having these people, I don't mean these people like that, but not in a Don Cherry way.
00:04:40 But, you know, he got the Bangladeshi community motivated and they came out and supported their Bangladeshi client, you know, or candidate.
00:04:52 So, yeah, liberals all for mass migration. 0.96
00:04:55 But now it's turning into, you know, hey, we can't even get elected in Toronto right now because of the ethnic group. 0.95
00:05:02 And apparently he doesn't speak very good English, so I'm sure he'll be a worthwhile member of the Ontario Parliament. 1.00
00:05:10 I think there's a good headline in there about the dominoes falling or something along those lines. 0.98
00:05:17 Corey, you know how ethnic politics works.
00:05:23 We've got our pockets here in Alberta.
00:05:25 Northeast Calgary is one spot.
00:05:27 Southwest Edmonton is another.
00:05:29 And those enclaves continue to grow into other quadrants of both cities, even areas outside of both cities, increasingly.
00:05:38 And all parties play this game.
00:05:41 The Conservatives are absolutely no better on this.
00:05:47 You know, Conservatives often...
00:05:49 Doug Ford just the other week saying, hey, I wish I could snap my fingers and you could all stay and then become citizens.
00:05:57 Everyone plays this game.
00:05:58 I think the Liberals probably lean into it the hardest, but the Conservatives do it pretty well.
00:06:04 They don't get any pass on this kind of thing.
00:06:08 But the assumption has generally been you're going to support the politician that lets you in.
00:06:17 Our party has been in power for 10 years.
00:06:20 We let you guys in.
00:06:21 We let your cousins and your uncles and your grandparents and all of these people in, and we've provided generous benefits.
00:06:27 I'm such a good guy, I show up to the
00:06:30 cultural events, I put on the costume, I do
00:06:32 the dance, I eat the food
00:06:34 and
00:06:36 they expect an electoral reward
00:06:38 for that. Well, they might still be willing to vote for the party
00:06:40 but they still want their
00:06:42 guy in
00:06:44 and that seems to be the lesson of
00:06:46 Nader's Smith here
00:06:48 His campaign put out a video
00:06:51 detailing what, it sounds pretty fraudulent
00:06:54 but none of it sounds surprising
00:06:55 you know they got people voting without proper id they're like the flimsiest of stuff that they're
00:07:01 allowing to take place sounds like people got to vote more than once it sounds totally fraudulent
00:07:07 but it's kind of a what else did you expect when you're playing this is tammany hall
00:07:13 politics just in 2026 what else did you expect yeah well that the ethnic game is totally different
00:07:20 as we've all suffered through it i'll just kind of quickly go back to a past story we had
00:07:24 a nomination in northeast calgary with the wild rose party when it was up and coming
00:07:28 we had five people four people running in it three were of ethnic minorities and one wasn't
00:07:33 the three who were running immediately submitted thousands and thousands of brand new memberships
00:07:38 and it's determined we quickly determined that actually all three had sold to the exact same
00:07:42 three members over and over the duplicates were out of control so our executive director actually
00:07:48 went door knocking and documenting and checking on these we had households with supposedly 20 people
00:07:53 in them uh things like that and we disqualified all three of the others and kept the white guy
00:07:57 i tell you the backlash looked awful but what are you supposed to do they play politics differently
00:08:03 in blocks and they play the nomination game heavily so on the liberals well it looks good
00:08:08 on you you back towards it you didn't put in the controls and you learned another hard lesson
00:08:14 it's also a symptom though i think of not having good policies of multiculturalism but when these
00:08:20 blocks and these enclaves are starting to turn so predominant for one group or another group or
00:08:25 another. We're going to see more of that, whether it's conservative or liberal, because you don't
00:08:28 play based on policy any longer. You've got to play based on finding community leadership and
00:08:33 whatever that particular ethnicity that dominates a riding is. And I don't think it's healthy for
00:08:38 Canada democracy, but we're just seeing it starkly with the liberals now having it happen to them.
00:08:43 And we're going to see more. So a ton of people voting in this, it's claimed we're not citizens,
00:08:50 which is allowed under the Liberal Party, but many of them were even temporary foreign workers,
00:08:54 like they're not even permanent residents. But the Conservatives really can't get on their high
00:08:59 horse here. The Conservatives don't at least officially allow temporary foreign workers to 0.99
00:09:03 vote, but the Conservative Party voted against limiting membership and therefore voting in the
00:09:09 Conservative Party federally to Canadian citizens at their most recent convention here in Calgary.
00:09:13 The Conservatives voted against it. So they've got, they don't really have any high horse to
00:09:18 stand on here themselves um but i think one of the lessons here is i don't know how to put it
00:09:26 um in a way that's not going to get in trouble so i'm just going to get probably some trouble
00:09:30 here i'll have to discipline myself um you know regular proviso not all migrants are cheats and 0.74
00:09:36 engage in tammany hall style uh dirty politics but a lot do if you import people from the third
00:09:45 world, you cannot act surprised and shocked when you get third world politics. Some people do leave 0.59
00:09:53 that behind, and they want nothing to do with it here. But a lot don't. I mean, these are
00:09:59 multi-generational habits. Democracy is not just the flip of the switch. You know, everyone sounds
00:10:04 nice on paper, but it's a culture. It's a practice. It's something that often takes generations to be
00:10:10 truly inculcated with. And then there's the other side, which is where I probably get in more
00:10:19 trouble for saying that every other group in the world plays tribal politics. In the West,
00:10:28 white people, we've generally been told that's a bad thing. We don't play tribal politics.
00:10:33 We're colorblind. You know, a brown guy could represent a white riding, an Asian guy could
00:10:39 represent a black riding, and none of it should matter 0.96
00:10:41 because it's, you know,
00:10:43 we're not playing tribal politics.
00:10:45 But the fact is, that is a
00:10:47 uniquely 0.99
00:10:48 European
00:10:50 idea among European descended peoples,
00:10:53 that we don't do that. 0.98
00:10:55 The rest of the world didn't get
00:10:57 the memo. So Nader,
00:10:59 Skinsmith,
00:11:01 you know,
00:11:03 color him surprise, no pun intended,
00:11:05 that his
00:11:07 opponent showed up playing
00:11:09 tribal politics
00:11:11 I don't know where this leads
00:11:14 I don't know how we get
00:11:15 other groups to stop playing tribal politics
00:11:18 without eventually
00:11:19 everybody playing tribal politics
00:11:21 and when we get to that, that's a bad spot to meet
00:11:23 This is the triumph of everything
00:11:25 that the liberals have done since Pierre Trudeau
00:11:27 father of the
00:11:29 father of the
00:11:31 unfortunate Justin Trudeau's
00:11:33 first started opening
00:11:34 immigration offices
00:11:37 in non-traditional areas
00:11:38 back in 1967 they have always tried to play the race card play the cultural card in order to
00:11:47 weaken conservative holdings we go back to the 1970s when joe volpe prominent liberal mp at the
00:11:53 time uh basically stole the the uh ridings along the the shore of the lake there by importing
00:12:02 portuguese immigrants and eventually they managed to get the the the majorities that they needed
00:12:08 he was italian okay well he was but he used the portuguese and immigrants so uh yeah like
00:12:17 everything they have done has been to expand the influence of immigrants as at the expense of the
00:12:23 the conservatives lord knows jason kenny did a hell of a fine job trying to reverse that for
00:12:29 for the time that he was in office you know mr curry in a hurry was the was the joke around the
00:12:34 hill but uh you know it didn't stick so what we got we have got the full we are now seeing the
00:12:41 start of the full flowering of all of those policies over a period of some 60 years and
00:12:47 you get somebody like erskine smith who by the way is not a particularly sympathetic character
00:12:52 for people like us i'd say no more i went through the how many stages of grief is it five i you know
00:13:00 three seconds i was done and so so there you are the thing is this is a little bit unique in the
00:13:10 sense that after the war we had a lot of ethnic communities from europe displaced dps displaced
00:13:16 persons uh coming here germans austrians italians uh they didn't get into politics they showed up
00:13:26 they got the job they did it uh took the paycheck went home to their families what's different is
00:13:32 that the uh this particular group of uh immigrants from bangladesh and others like them do get into
00:13:39 uh into politics because they have actually bought the package they think that this is a good thing 0.61
00:13:45 this is how you get influence this is how you make things happen so let's play the game it's just
00:13:49 and they play dirty.
00:13:52 I forgot, we should have shown it earlier.
00:13:55 We've got to show that picture.
00:13:57 Someone captured this picture. It was on social media
00:13:59 and it really just, it captioned
00:14:01 both Nate Erskine-Smiths
00:14:02 and perhaps the Liberal Party, maybe even
00:14:05 Western Civilizations
00:14:06 predicament
00:14:09 here perfectly.
00:14:11 You'll see it's Nate
00:14:12 walking out of the hall, the building where
00:14:15 the nomination was held. There's trash 0.94
00:14:17 all over the ground it doesn't look like a first world country it's gloomy out in the distance that 0.99
00:14:23 he's walking to and there is a with the Canadian flag flying there's the weird uh trans pride
00:14:32 progress flag flying at the same time like it uh whoever captured that photo I don't know if they
00:14:39 that was intentionally meant but it was it's almost like a renaissance painting in its significance
00:14:45 and the symbolism captured right there.
00:14:49 I'll tell you one thing, Derek. 1.00
00:14:50 I bet it wasn't the Bangladeshi community 1.00
00:14:53 who put the trans flag there.
00:14:55 No. 1.00
00:14:57 I think that's a fair...
00:14:59 You might be prejudging things here,
00:15:02 but I think it's probably a fair prejudgment.
00:15:05 Yeah.
00:15:06 You know, the thing is, I would actually...
00:15:08 Maybe I'm just being very British about this,
00:15:11 but I would rather have somebody like Shothmajumdar.
00:15:15 or giovanni who are respectively of south asian origin and jamaican origin who are true conservatives
00:15:23 i would rather have them representing me in ottawa than i would have somebody
00:15:30 who is of the same persuasion as mr erskine smith who has totally unconservative ideas and is
00:15:38 actually part of the problem of how this country is going down to the point we can come out of a 0.90
00:15:44 nomination meet and see you trash on the ground on a trans flag that's give me the give me the
00:15:51 guy with the right ideas every time yeah but as we're quickly discovering though uh 0.98
00:15:59 the rest of the world didn't stop playing tribal politics just because you know we kind of
00:16:03 collectively decided as european societies some did break out i guess you could see like shoo he's
00:16:08 in calvary heritage i think yeah i mean he's not going to get a block of south asian voters that's
00:16:13 not an ethnic right he's he's won it based on his own merit and campaigning and uh he's a very
00:16:17 popular member of parliament down there so we can we can break out of that that that thing and to be
00:16:21 fair i think if shu ran in northeast calgary he would probably collect some of your support based
00:16:26 on your your ethnic community but but shu've won a non non-ethnic rotting yes i said you want to
00:16:33 well he's actually harper's right yeah it was harper's old right preston manning's running at
00:16:37 at one point,
00:16:38 for lack of a better term, he wanted a white rotting
00:16:41 based on values. 0.96
00:16:42 People liked what he stood for, he won the nomination,
00:16:44 he won the general. A bunch of people like us voted
00:16:46 for him. Yeah.
00:16:49 But I don't
00:16:51 think, even if we shared the
00:16:52 values, I think it's highly improbable
00:16:54 any one of the four of us at this table
00:16:56 would get elected in Northeast Calgary.
00:17:00 I'm willing to say
00:17:01 that with a fair bit of confidence. Well, part of the way
00:17:02 that game works is if we did, it would mean we
00:17:04 would have had to get some endorsement from some community
00:17:06 leaders in those ethnic
00:17:08 it gets into that
00:17:11 whole intricacy of northeast Calvary politics
00:17:12 we would owe them a favor
00:17:14 and you know I know some people
00:17:19 are going to watch this and they're going to try and play it back
00:17:21 to us at some point and lord it over us
00:17:23 and they're going to say this is so awful
00:17:24 how do you keep saying it
00:17:25 maybe some know nothings will not know better
00:17:29 but political operatives
00:17:31 in left wing parties
00:17:32 you might condemn us for saying this but you
00:17:34 know what we're saying is true
00:17:36 you play these games, you know
00:17:39 it's true, you know that
00:17:41 this is just the way it works
00:17:43 so, you know, save us
00:17:45 the self-righteous condemnation
00:17:47 when it comes for
00:17:49 saying the truth out loud that
00:17:50 you know, until very recently
00:17:53 people only said in hushed tones
00:17:55 Okay, well, I mean, that's a
00:17:59 sort of... Derek's never said
00:18:01 anything in hushed tones, has he?
00:18:03 Never, yeah
00:18:03 Touche
00:18:06 All right. Fairly decent segue then, I think, into our next segment here.
00:18:16 The Canada haters rallying to save Canada against Alberta.
00:18:20 So I don't mean to pick on him. He's actually a decent writer. I don't often agree with him.
00:18:24 But the Calgary Herald's Don Braid wrote in his column,
00:18:30 The Alberta independence people hate Canada. They have to show hatred and contempt for Canada.
00:18:35 He quotes some people saying, I don't think anything really hate, I don't know how in front of me, but, you know, that, you know, an independent Alberta would probably seek American recognition, which, I don't know, any country in the world seeking independence seeks American recognition, all the more so one that borders it.
00:18:52 So I don't know how that's a newsy thing, but he says, you know, these people hate Canada.
00:18:57 They have hatred and contempt for Canada.
00:18:59 and that got me thinking
00:19:06 Nigel
00:19:08 the Canada haters
00:19:10 I'm sure there are a few
00:19:12 but it's a vanishingly small number
00:19:14 when I think of Canada haters
00:19:16 I think of people who topple the statues
00:19:19 of Sir John M. Macdonald
00:19:20 I think of the people who changed the lyrics of
00:19:22 Old Canada to make it gender neutral and politically correct
00:19:25 I think of the people who either
00:19:26 cheered or stood by as 112
00:19:28 churches were burned to the ground or significantly
00:19:31 vandalized. I think
00:19:32 of the people who
00:19:33 kneel ritualistically for Black Lives Matter,
00:19:37 people who lowered the flag on Parliament
00:19:38 Hill for five months, people who
00:19:40 put down the
00:19:42 history of Canada as a 0.99
00:19:44 genocidal state founded on stolen 0.52
00:19:46 native land. When I think of Canada
00:19:48 haters, those are the
00:19:50 people I'm thinking of.
00:19:52 Not people who, for
00:19:54 the most part, have been
00:19:56 patriotic Canadians their whole life. They might be
00:19:58 born in Alberta or born elsewhere, loved Canada, loved what it stood for.
00:20:04 They don't hate Canada, at least as they were born into,
00:20:07 but they might hate what Canada has become and what Canada is becoming.
00:20:11 Well, I've had 50 years plus to observe the difference between Canada that was
00:20:16 and the Canada that it has become.
00:20:19 And so I can 100% see where you're coming from that on, Derek,
00:20:23 and actually agree with you.
00:20:24 But, you know, people are always going to put the best, go into a back room.
00:20:31 Well, what are we going to say now?
00:20:32 Obviously, somebody like Mr. Nenshi, a one-time mayor of Calgary,
00:20:37 now a leader of the opposition.
00:20:39 Well, how are we going to fight Daniel Smith on this one?
00:20:41 Well, we'll be very pro-Canadian.
00:20:43 Well, this is the same guy who tried to take one of the Canada Day celebrations
00:20:47 and then turn it into a provincial lament for all the sins of racism,
00:20:53 colonialism i don't know there was a long list and he didn't want to do canada day he wanted to
00:20:59 he wanted to make it a day of protest so when you got people like that you have to wonder about the
00:21:04 sincerity of it and you know because this came up i ended up looking around uh to see where where we
00:21:11 were going with this and um you know there's something on facebook i'm sorry instagram from
00:21:19 one court ellingson he's a an mla and this is the kind of ndp oh yeah very ndp so he says a few weeks
00:21:29 ago this would be last week a few weeks ago the alberta ndp organized a day of action to fight
00:21:34 against alberta separation here's what they got 75 people in calgary and 200 people across our
00:21:43 province showed up on a snowy april day to talk to neighbors about why alberta is better leading
00:21:50 canada than leaving it so you know after all the sound and fury and all the frankly the bs
00:21:57 they managed to get according to this individual 275 people out so i don't think the tide is
00:22:05 flowing their way because i think the what derek has just said about who it is who actually really
00:22:13 hates canada and the kind of things that the ways that they choose to express it don't fit well in
00:22:20 alberta um i think yeah sure go on take it from there but dave um you know i i uh i wrote a column
00:22:30 on this and you know
00:22:32 I kind of very broadly try to put
00:22:34 Alberta nationalists in two camps
00:22:36 one is
00:22:38 probably disproportionately Alberta born
00:22:40 that
00:22:42 understands the very long history of Alberta
00:22:44 struggle with Ottawa
00:22:45 structural constitutional issues
00:22:48 going back forever
00:22:49 all of these things
00:22:52 and that's one group and the other one
00:22:54 I called readout 0.91
00:22:56 Canadians
00:22:57 my guess is they probably come disproportionately 0.99
00:23:00 from other provinces uh because those other provinces are going to hell and they came to
00:23:06 alberta for an opportunity they come to alberta because of what it stands for um and they're
00:23:12 they're not anti-canadian at all they they're patriotic canadians but they see that canada
00:23:17 has gone to hell and it's continuing to go further down into hell and there does not appear to be
00:23:23 any real sign that that is being reversed 0.67
00:23:27 right now. And so the idea is that
00:23:31 you're actually able to save a slice of Canada
00:23:34 by leaving it, essentially. The rest of Canada is irreversibly
00:23:39 I think it's roughly 125-127%
00:23:43 debt to GDP, $4 trillion of debt.
00:23:47 These things are never, ever getting paid by us, our children, or even our
00:23:51 grandchildren.
00:23:53 We're still literally paying debt
00:23:55 taken out by Pierre Trudeau
00:23:57 before I was even born.
00:24:00 The idea
00:24:01 is to save a piece of Canada
00:24:03 by saving at least a little
00:24:05 piece of it.
00:24:08 I don't
00:24:09 see this being a deeply anti-Canadian
00:24:11 movement the way they say that
00:24:13 even Quebec would be. I'm not even sure Quebec is
00:24:15 necessarily anti-Canadian. It just wants to be its own 1.00
00:24:17 thing. I don't know.
00:24:19 You used to work with these guys.
00:24:21 So what plan are they living on thinking that this is somehow a Canada hate fest?
00:24:28 Well, you've got to remember Dawn, who I consider a friend.
00:24:31 He's a very left-wing, very left-wing writer, has been for decades.
00:24:36 But just look, I mean, the facts tell the story.
00:24:39 People are moving to Alberta en masse.
00:24:42 Thousands of people from B.C. are fleeing the wacky government of David Eby.
00:24:47 thousands of people are leaving
00:24:49 Ontario, Waikiki
00:24:51 government of Doug Ford
00:24:53 and where are they going? They're going to Alberta
00:24:54 which is causing stresses for us in terms
00:24:57 of education and
00:24:58 school building and getting enough teachers
00:25:01 and stuff like that but I don't think all the
00:25:03 people coming here are coming
00:25:05 here as okay Alberta is going to
00:25:07 separate, let's go to Alberta
00:25:09 you know they're coming here
00:25:10 you know to try and get the best quality
00:25:13 of life for their families
00:25:14 and you know
00:25:16 I'm sure some of them would probably vote for independence, but I think most of them would still be happily Canadian or happily say they're Canadian.
00:25:30 Okay, Corey.
00:25:36 It makes for, I mean, neither the nationalist camp or the federalist camp are homogenous, as you and I well know.
00:25:43 who we can't agree on much really often,
00:25:47 even within the nationalist camp.
00:25:49 But the Federalists, there's odd bedfellows.
00:25:54 I mean, we'll give the devil his due here.
00:25:59 Jay Zkenny, I don't consider to be a Canada hater.
00:26:02 He's Canada first, not Alberta first.
00:26:04 And that's a legitimate position to take.
00:26:06 That's fine. That's his choice.
00:26:09 But he's not a Canada hater.
00:26:10 but he has to share
00:26:12 a campaign
00:26:14 and a stage essentially here
00:26:16 with people who do hate Canada
00:26:18 or at least demonstrate
00:26:20 contempt for them
00:26:21 you know you've got
00:26:25 you know depending on the poll
00:26:26 we look at we'll say 35%
00:26:29 of Albertans support independence
00:26:30 30% at the low end, 38% at the high end
00:26:32 depending on the polls you're looking at
00:26:34 we'll say 35% split the difference here
00:26:36 So among the roughly two-thirds that are currently opposed to independence, a majority of those are on the left, and they're backing parties that stood by as churches were burned down.
00:26:50 They vote for politicians that wanted to change Canada Day from a celebration of Canada into a ritualistic self-flagellation of national guilt.
00:27:00 voted for politicians that kept the flag
00:27:03 at half-mast for five months
00:27:05 for a genocidal hoax.
00:27:09 I don't know, maybe I'd like your thoughts
00:27:12 on how can those people
00:27:17 now drape themselves in the flag
00:27:19 as the patriotic defenders of Canada
00:27:22 when two, three years ago
00:27:25 they were calling Canada
00:27:28 an illegitimate settler colonial slave state founded on stolen native land it's hypocrisy
00:27:34 and a purposeful cognitive dissonance i you know i like stirring things up when i get bored on x if
00:27:40 i just wanted to get things worked up and that still works now i've took i've posted that about
00:27:44 five times over the years i just a simple canada is not a genocidal country and the hornet's nest
00:27:50 is poked i'm a racist i'm a denier i am you name it this and that the people who get so upset for
00:27:57 me daring just to say that the country isn't genocidal. Their idea of where we're supposed
00:28:03 to be sitting and where we're supposed to be thinking is we're always staring at our shoes.
00:28:07 Canada is an awful place that did terrible things that probably shouldn't exist. It's a post-national
00:28:11 state. We're settlers. We're colonialists. And then when we see independence movements blossoming
00:28:17 on each side of the country, all I had tried to ask these guys, what the hell did you think was
00:28:22 going to happen. You've been undercutting any sense of pride or identity or unity in this country for
00:28:29 years. And lo and behold, some people said, well, I'm not about to stand up and hand it all off to
00:28:34 the indigenous bands, but I don't feel any connection to this god awful state. So yes, 1.00
00:28:37 I won't feel bad for a second saying, you know what, I might embrace an independence movement
00:28:41 because you guys told me this country is not worth saving anyways. So yes, it's not helping
00:28:45 them when they suddenly have cloaked themselves in this flag that they were so recently burning
00:28:49 and pissing on and i got no use for them as samuel johnson said two centuries ago patriotism is the
00:28:55 last refuge of a scoundrel he was of course speaking of the americans but uh it applies 0.67
00:29:01 equally today well i think it's contextual i think uh the scoundrel can uh rely on patriotism to
00:29:09 cloak his actions but i i would reject that patriotism is uh is a negative thing to begin
00:29:17 with you know i believe in nationalism i believe patriotism uh it is often a force for good people
00:29:23 doing bad yeah you can fall back and you use it as a cloak that's exactly what johnson was talking
00:29:28 about and that people with dishonest or selfish motives will often use patriotic further to cover
00:29:34 their tracks it's a tried and true method yeah i you know i i guess it doesn't need to be said
00:29:41 but I'll say it anyway to be fair
00:29:43 not everyone in the Federalist camp 0.98
00:29:45 is a hypocrite here
00:29:47 not everyone in the Federalist camp is a hater 1.00
00:29:49 that would be less ridiculous 0.60
00:29:51 than I think what Don Braid
00:29:53 was arguing that the Alberta nationalists
00:29:55 hate Canada
00:29:56 there's just not particularly much evidence to support that
00:29:59 you know there are plenty
00:30:01 of people in the Federalist camp
00:30:03 who
00:30:05 are not self-loathing, self-flagellating
00:30:07 who think Canada is an illegitimate state
00:30:09 but
00:30:10 what i am saying is it makes for awkward bedfellows when your goal is to save save canada uh i'm not
00:30:18 sure what canada they're trying to save it seems to be the canada i i was born into was just long
00:30:23 gone but yeah let me just say this what i notice about the people who i encounter in the alberta
00:30:30 independence movement is that there isn't some culture or language that binds them together as
00:30:37 be the case with quebec it is a set of values that they hold and all seem to hold which is
00:30:47 what where we entered this discussion talking about the people who say that patriots for canada
00:30:53 are the ones who have said everything about canada is wrong but those things that they
00:30:58 say about canada being wrong are the things that uh alberta patriots if i can use that expression
00:31:05 they're the ones they're trying to hold on to uh fair play decency parliamentary democracy
00:31:11 you know this is a uh they're rejecting the socialists so okay you know we got a nice flow
00:31:19 one topic's actually going to another fairly well today um we're going to talk about alberta's
00:31:24 carbon tax sellout um so in november i think was the day before the ucp convention
00:31:33 Daniel Smith and Mark Carney signed an MOU, Memorandum of Understanding,
00:31:38 about working together if some give and take on environmental policy
00:31:42 in exchange for fixing the situation around pipelines
00:31:46 and possibly tanker access on the West Coast and things like that.
00:31:51 I had a pretty open mind to it, Corey.
00:31:55 I was actually shocked when we all showed up to the UCP convention covering that there. 0.85
00:32:00 And I, in a very awkward moment, found myself to be the squishy moderate in the room.
00:32:06 Most people were very much opposed to it.
00:32:09 But I said, you know, I mean, we should encourage the premier to make a good faith effort on these files.
00:32:18 I mean, it's just an MOU.
00:32:20 Let's see how it goes.
00:32:21 Negotiate in good faith.
00:32:23 Maybe she can make some progress. 1.00
00:32:25 But, I mean, she can't sell the farm to do it.
00:32:27 this Friday 0.53
00:32:30 there's going to be a press conference
00:32:33 I believe here in Calgary
00:32:34 that's what we understand
00:32:35 we'll be covering that live
00:32:38 where I guess the results
00:32:41 of this will be put forward
00:32:42 we don't yet know is there going to be a pipeline
00:32:45 built is it just fixing the
00:32:47 process to potentially get to a pipeline
00:32:49 I don't know one thing we do know
00:32:51 that's come out early
00:32:52 is that the Alberta government
00:32:55 has now signed on
00:32:57 the dotted line, it's agreed firm that Alberta will agree to increasing the industrial carbon
00:33:02 tax to $130 per metric ton, elevating up to, uh, into 2040. Um, Corey, I, I went into this with an
00:33:14 open mind. I took some guff for being too soft, which is a pretty rare thing for me to have and
00:33:21 take, but
00:33:23 I don't think it was wrong to keep an
00:33:25 open mind, but I think
00:33:27 we know enough now.
00:33:30 Alberta has now agreed to
00:33:31 completely capitulate on the carbon
00:33:33 tax, and we are going to accept the legitimacy
00:33:35 of Ottawa dictating our own
00:33:37 internal environmental policies.
00:33:40 To me, this
00:33:41 looks like a total salad.
00:33:43 I'm not going to celebrate this.
00:33:44 I understand in the role of Premier,
00:33:47 your job isn't to walk right into a room with
00:33:49 the Prime Minister and just give him the finger right off the bat.
00:33:51 you know okay well let's see what we can do to potentially find mutually beneficial agreements
00:33:56 for the country and for the province but the carbon tax I mean come on we've talked about
00:34:00 this for a decade it doesn't do a damn thing to save the environment it never will it's a tax
00:34:06 that's all it is is something Premier Smith has always been very clear about whether it's the
00:34:09 consumer one or the industrial one and it puts Canada at a disadvantage around the world and
00:34:16 trying to sell its products. Now, it puts Alberta at a disadvantage. The baloney we're seeing from
00:34:22 guys like Corey Hogan, you know, that lone liberal MP, talking like the rest of the world is 0.99
00:34:28 demanding decarbonized oil, this fictional imaginary crap. No, they aren't. And in fact, 0.97
00:34:35 Canada isn't demanding it as they get Venezuelan, Russian, Saudi Arabian, and every other tanker to
00:34:40 the East Coast they could possibly can get. But Alberta is the one and only beacon that apparently
00:34:45 has to decarbonize its oil she capitulated i think she should have told him to go to hell
00:34:51 it'll be interesting to see on friday i imagine they got something else but let's see where this
00:34:55 proponent is then do you have a proponent have you got rid of the tanker ban have you said that
00:35:00 the indigenous don't have a veto there's a whole lot more things i expect out of this if you're
00:35:04 going to call it a victory so maybe she's letting something out and has a big announcement coming i
00:35:09 don't know but i gotta see more there there is reporting now coming out of ottawa that
00:35:13 Prime Minister Carney will declare this
00:35:15 a project of national interest
00:35:17 which basically means the Indigenous
00:35:19 lose all their rights to complain 1.00
00:35:21 and bitch and block it. 1.00
00:35:23 But that's what in theory is going to happen. 1.00
00:35:25 But it's going to unleash
00:35:27 a tidal wave of protests
00:35:29 and we're going to have highways
00:35:31 blocked and railways
00:35:33 blocked.
00:35:34 But hopefully at the same time
00:35:37 it's getting built.
00:35:39 But obviously still years away
00:35:41 from uh uh being constructed and and and completed so the whole thing about the uh you know the
00:35:49 shipping bans and and whatnot can be dealt with at a bit of a later time because there is
00:35:55 because nobody's going to invest a nickel that's true unless they know it's gone that's the fair
00:35:59 that's that chicken and egg game that's been great though now that would be a relatively easy thing
00:36:03 for him to do now and say look we're making progress you know we've got rid of the tanker
00:36:07 Tinkerban, there are no pipelines, we've eliminated that legislation, you've still got the promises
00:36:13 you have hinted at to the indigenous peoples to deal with, but the things that we could
00:36:17 do now and that we could do easily, we're doing. 1.00
00:36:20 So this is the way it's going to, but we don't see that.
00:36:23 Well, Nigel, even if, let's say there's a bunch of victories on those fronts, the West
00:36:29 Coast Tinkerban gone, it's a project of national importance, all of these things. 0.98
00:36:37 I know, and it looks likely, okay, we could get a pipeline of this. 0.55
00:36:41 I don't care if we get a dozen pipelines or if they build them to the moon.
00:36:44 Alberta will have signed away its sovereignty.
00:36:47 What happened to, you know, Premier Daniel Smith has said she's not backing independence for Alberta.
00:36:54 She's backing a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada.
00:36:57 This doesn't sound like a sovereign Alberta.
00:37:00 The carbon tax is a matter for Alberta to decide.
00:37:04 This is an Alberta carbon tax, yet it's being dictated in terms of these negotiations to buy Ottawa.
00:37:10 That doesn't sound like a sovereign Alberta with any United Canada to me.
00:37:13 No, and you know, if I were Danielle, I don't know whether I'd be doing that.
00:37:17 But I have to go back to where Corey started in this segment when he said, 0.96
00:37:23 oh, she can't go in there with boxing gloves.
00:37:26 And you've got to try to make it look like you're working along.
00:37:31 but she has the really has the world against her on this one for all the reasons we've just talked
00:37:36 about the cost of burying carbon dioxide to make decarbonized oil is going to put 50 a ton or two
00:37:44 onto oil this is what they tell me but people who know more than i do 50 a ton and you're going to
00:37:50 go out and try and sell this overseas what exactly you know how long do you think the round war is
00:37:55 going to last it's uh this is not going to work but she goes in and says what she has to say
00:38:01 i've got a feeling that the thought may be by 2040 carney will be gone somebody else will be in
00:38:10 charge it is inconceivable that the liberals should govern for another you know 14 years
00:38:17 they've done it before we'll get well that would be a 24-year run you're starting to get back in
00:38:22 mckenzie king territory but anyway you know this can't possibly last we've even got al gore saying
00:38:27 like global warming which is the foundation of all this is going to be replaced by global freezing
00:38:34 i mean i don't know who takes al gore seriously anymore but al gore is prepared to stake his
00:38:39 reputation on being wrong this this i think is going to go away meanwhile as long as he's talking
00:38:47 The Western, you know, the Alberta independence crowd cannot use that as a wedge against her.
00:38:54 I don't know. I do agree that she, you know, can't walk into a meeting with Carney and just punch him in the nose.
00:39:01 As good as that would all make us feel that is not what she should do, she should be negotiating in good faith.
00:39:10 The problem is she's negotiated us $130 on carbon tax, and maybe Carney has gone by then.
00:39:18 Maybe he is replaced by a more radical liberal.
00:39:22 Maybe he's replaced by a crappy conservative because many conservatives won't take a standing even against the industrial carbon tax.
00:39:30 They're, you know, they're going to hem and haw and they got they got a they don't want to rock the boat too much to win votes in central Canada.
00:39:37 But also, I don't think we can rely one bit necessarily on the Conservatives being committed to repealing the carbon tax.
00:39:43 Conservatives changed their mind about a bunch of things in the last two weeks of that last campaign when they thought it would maybe save the election for them.
00:39:49 Didn't.
00:39:51 So she has then agreed to the principle that Ottawa has legitimacy in dictating this to us.
00:40:02 That is a moral loss.
00:40:06 That is a loss on an important principle.
00:40:09 So, you know, yeah, it's 2040 is, I guess, a ways off.
00:40:16 Maybe Carney's gone by then.
00:40:17 Maybe things change, but I wouldn't bet on it.
00:40:20 I mean, we're still dealing with the disastrous policies of Justin Trudeau 10 years ago.
00:40:26 You can't really bet on this.
00:40:28 I think this is a strategic mistake.
00:40:31 I don't think it's going to appear.
00:40:32 I think this is,
00:40:34 Carney needs this to keep the Stephen Gilboa wing
00:40:36 of the Liberal Party in the tent,
00:40:40 keep the NDP down,
00:40:41 keep the Greens down.
00:40:44 But this is, in Alberta,
00:40:47 I have a feeling that
00:40:48 there's going to be a lot of people on our side
00:40:51 who are upset about this.
00:40:54 I think this should be on the ballot in October.
00:40:57 There should be a referendum question at this point.
00:40:59 we have uh five questions on constitutional reform which i generally more or less agree
00:41:05 with but that are never going to go anywhere because the rest of canada will not say uh
00:41:09 yes to it we've got i think four questions on immigration what one's four one's five
00:41:13 uh that's fine so and then probably independence as well let's put this one on let's let's see
00:41:21 where albertans stand on this maybe i'm wrong but uh i this is not a deal i think i would vote for
00:41:27 so look i think that mr carney has an incentive to to at least appear to offer a pipeline because
00:41:37 if enough people believe that it's a real prospect that is going to subtract from the independence
00:41:45 movement so he is not totally unmotivated to do something good or at least appear to do
00:41:51 something good for daniel smith on friday that would have an impact now whether it's real
00:41:58 that's a whole different discussion for next week but um i wouldn't write it off just yet
00:42:05 all right all right uh party shots dave uh very disturbing video this week of uh gang of girls
00:42:14 and uh yeah we'll show some of the video very disturbing uh uh poor girl in red deer beaten
00:42:22 senseless swarmed kicked in the head repeatedly elbowed in the face repeatedly and then when she 0.69
00:42:28 was unconscious she was dragged to a group of nearby trees and and dumped um disgusting behavior 1.00
00:42:36 our linda slobodian wrote about it today you know nothing's stopping these miscreant teens
00:42:41 uh nothing will stop because there's no justice no justice for them so uh rcmp under great pressure
00:42:49 to make some arrests i think it'll be quick but uh yeah go go and check out the video because it
00:42:55 really is really is disturbing you know i i got to my share of scraps as a teenager and uh we fought
00:43:02 one-on-one and when someone lost it was over and if someone didn't stop your own friends dragged
00:43:10 you off uh i i forget even the law here uh there's just doesn't see maybe there's just no code of
00:43:18 how to have a proper scrap in high school anymore there's always going to be people fighting in high
00:43:21 school it happens it's never going to go away but uh yeah we just there seems to be no common
00:43:27 sense about how to have a proper scrap now no no cory uh so i guess due to good marketing and
00:43:34 good branding tim horton's got practically a monopoly in the donut and coffee industry in
00:43:39 Canada, and then devolved into what I think was one of the most overrated institutions in the
00:43:43 country. So we're seeing that getting withered away with Dunkin' Donuts moving in and some
00:43:48 others moving into the country. I'm just enjoying seeing competition come back. And I just want to
00:43:53 say, I miss Robin's Donuts. I guess they still exist in other parts of the country, but they
00:43:58 aren't in Alberta anymore because they just couldn't compete against Tim Hortons that really
00:44:02 just kind of took everything by wave. But maybe we were reversing things. I want to see some
00:44:06 competition in the donut and coffee world so come on back robbins we missed you so more more work
00:44:11 for temporary foreign workers oh well you know you guys have a donut shop actually hired canadians
00:44:17 that that's a bigger debate but i tell you as a serious industry owner put out an ad and see how
00:44:23 many show up for it yeah fair enough but yeah tim hortons really is uh the canadian health care of
00:44:29 uh of buddhist service delivery in canada where it's something where uh we have no right to be
00:44:34 very proud of at this point. 0.99
00:44:36 Nigel.
00:44:36 Yeah, so I couldn't help noticing that story
00:44:40 that we picked up out of Black Locks.
00:44:42 Black Locks does the research and puts it out,
00:44:45 and we're happy to pass it on to everybody else.
00:44:48 But on World Press Freedom Day, Prime Minister Carney
00:44:52 praised a strong independent press.
00:44:55 What Black Locks revealed was that just about 10 days before,
00:44:59 officials in all of the most powerful ministries have got together
00:45:04 and we're trying what they were trying to do is work out who's a real journalist who should be
00:45:07 allowed to go into me and i i'm just touting ahead i think we're going to put this out on friday uh
00:45:15 i did a little rap this morning because i was kind of mad so watch out for it on friday talking
00:45:19 about the hypocrisy of uh somebody who will stand up and say on one day that uh press matters and
00:45:27 freedom press freedom matters and meanwhile is trying to sort of ways find ways to exclude
00:45:32 people like us people like rebel news juno from being able to ask questions at government meetings
00:45:40 uh mine i've got uh call them up now uh we don't report on rumor here but we ended up in a weird
00:45:49 kind of twilight zone of information uh i've had some very good sources tell me that alberta
00:45:55 finance minister nate horner uh not sure the reasons around it but he'll be stepping down
00:46:02 or something to that effect in the coming weeks,
00:46:05 and he will be replaced as Alberta's finance minister by Jason Nixon.
00:46:10 So I've got pretty good sources tell me that.
00:46:13 But there's also pretty good sources in the government who deny it to me.
00:46:17 And I've got other sources in the government who deny it, but unconvincingly.
00:46:22 So you read it here first.
00:46:25 You read it here first.
00:46:26 the column, if you read it
00:46:29 you'll see
00:46:30 I make, I unambiguously hedge 1.00
00:46:33 and try to cover my ass 0.99
00:46:35 this is not gospel 1.00
00:46:37 you can't take it to the bank because I've got
00:46:39 official government sources denying it
00:46:41 but I've also got some
00:46:43 pretty good sources in the government
00:46:44 confirming it, and then others who
00:46:47 denied it, as I said, very
00:46:49 unconvincingly, so
00:46:51 take it
00:46:53 for what it is
00:46:54 if this is on poly bet
00:46:57 it's a good bet that this is happening
00:46:59 Jason Nixon is going to be the next finance minister
00:47:02 of Alberta and Nate Horner is either
00:47:03 retiring or moving out of the portfolio or something
00:47:05 I don't know what's happening on that side
00:47:07 it's probably a good bet
00:47:11 to roll the dice on
00:47:12 but it's a roll of the dice
00:47:13 I hate to have an unconfirmed story
00:47:16 we don't do rumor
00:47:17 but in this case
00:47:18 we're reporting what some people confirm
00:47:21 and we're reporting at the exact same time
00:47:24 that others are denying it, such
00:47:26 as it is. So
00:47:27 we'll see.
00:47:30 I think I'm right, but we could have
00:47:32 I could have egg on my face.
00:47:33 Time will tell.
00:47:35 Such is the world of political
00:47:36 sometimes.
00:47:39 Okay, Dave, Corey,
00:47:41 thank you. Thank you, John, running
00:47:43 the studio and all of you who joined
00:47:45 us, give us your precious
00:47:47 time today. Thank you for your support.
00:47:49 If you're not yet a subscriber to the
00:47:51 Western Standard, and by subscriber, I don't mean just getting
00:47:53 our emails, I mean you have a paid
00:47:55 subscription for all access to
00:47:57 Western Standard content. Please go to
00:47:59 westernstandard.news, click on subscribe
00:48:01 at $10 a month or $100 a year
00:48:03 to get unlimited access to
00:48:05 Western Standard content and
00:48:07 support the work we do. Thank you very much
00:48:09 for joining us today and God bless.
00:48:23 We'll be right back.