Western Standard - September 17, 2025


Who has the power in Alberta's school board system?

Topics
Mentioned
Conversation on trans ideologies, free speech and Charlie Kirk Canada can’t afford free housing

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

135.98

Word count

3,399

Sentence count

276

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we talk to John Hilton O'Brien, Executive Director of Parents For Choice, an advocacy organization dedicated to informing parents about Alberta's education system. We discuss a recent report by the Parkland Institute, which challenges parental rights, as well as the book ban that has been implemented in Alberta schools.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, my name is Leah Muschid. I'm a reporter here at the Western Standard and today we have with us
00:00:05 John Hilton O'Brien, Executive Director of Parents for Choice, an Alberta-based advocacy organization
00:00:11 dedicated to informing parents about Alberta's education system. Today, John is going to comment
00:00:17 on the recent report by the Parkland Institute, which is talking about challenging parental
00:00:23 rights, as well as the book ban that has been put in place in Alberta schools. So John, today why
00:00:32 don't we start out by discussing the book ban and you can tell us more about that. So let's start at
00:00:37 the beginning. A dozen years ago, parents came to us with concerns about books in their children's
00:00:43 schools. So we raised some alarms about it, we tried to talk to ministers and so forth, and
00:00:49 school officials told us they weren't there. Turns out this was false. Parents finally ran what we
00:00:57 kind of call an intelligence operation, and they got into school catalogs and pulled call numbers.
00:01:03 And that happening last year is what convinced the minister to investigate and then to act.
00:01:10 So right now what's happening is Edmonton Public Schools has been cosplaying as the rebel alliance
00:01:16 against the government's empire. But let's be clear, this is not a war on ideas. The government always said
00:01:25 that classic literature would stay. If you read the original order, it specifically exempted any
00:01:33 cases where sexual activity was implied but not clearly described. And so EPSB had no call than any of
00:01:42 the books they did. But today, with the government's announcement yesterday and the revised order,
00:01:49 what's being removed is specifically graphic sexual imagery. Child abuse, penetration, sex toys. 0.81
00:01:58 No reasonable person thinks kids need that in a school library. Just the same. I had an interview last 0.99
00:02:06 week where a librarian or someone from the library association was defending having these books in
00:02:12 schools. So that's been kind of entertaining. But this morning I had an interview on CHED where the
00:02:22 interviewer told me I was just an activist so I shouldn't have a say by implication. So what gives here?
00:02:30 Whether I'm an activist or a professor doesn't change the facts. Parents produced catalog call numbers
00:02:37 after 12 years of denial. That evidence is why the minister acted. Truth doesn't depend on job titles.
00:02:45 And professionals like librarians, real professionals know their limits. They inform and they advise parents.
00:02:54 They do not overrule them. So why exactly are left-wing media and activists starting to make this about me?
00:03:04 Who I am has no bearing on whether sexualized material exists in school libraries or whether
00:03:10 we should protect kids from it. The catalog numbers tell the story. The research studies that I've cited tell the story.
00:03:18 Facts don't change depending on who says them. So what is going on here? Well, last Wednesday, Parkland Institute
00:03:31 issued a report about who is really behind parental rights. And that's being used as a talking point on the left.
00:03:40 And they named me personally. They even got a key fact wrong to the point of honestly being pretty much slanderous.
00:03:49 They said that in an article I wrote for the Western Standard, I had said that teachers were allowed to make
00:03:57 referrals to the child gender identity clinic in Alberta without parental consent.
00:04:05 They claimed that I had produced no evidence for this.
00:04:08 But if you read the article, whether it's on our website or I think on the Western Standard,
00:04:13 in the sentence that talks about it, there's a link to documentary evidence.
00:04:19 I found a presentation being made internally at Alberta Health Services saying precisely this.
00:04:30 So, you know, there's a saying in politics that you shouldn't punch down. And for goodness sake,
00:04:37 if you do, don't miss. So why would Parkland Institute do this?
00:04:42 Yes. Well, what's happening here is the empire wants to claim equal moral ground with the rebel alliance.
00:04:50 And when you don't have the truth on your side, you resort to character assassination.
00:04:56 But look, Parkland is not a neutral think tank. It does not disclose who their donors are. They don't
00:05:06 disclose what their budget is. And the reason for this is that they operate as part of the University of Alberta's
00:05:15 574 million dollar research umbrella. At the same time, they hide their own budget.
00:05:24 Now, its board does include some professors, but it does something that no other think tank does,
00:05:31 or at least not attacks to a university. They have reserved seats for the major public sector unions.
00:05:39 AUPE, AFL, ATA, Health Sciences Union, United Nurses of Alberta. For decades, this has been known as
00:05:49 Alberta's unofficial opposition to conservative parties. Is that really scholarship or is that a
00:05:56 political machine and academic clothing? But look, it's a little bigger than Parkland, okay?
00:06:05 If you go to Public Interest Alberta, they shared the same unions on the board, plus the Canadian Union of
00:06:12 Public Employees. And these unions that are on the board of this organization spent a lot of money during
00:06:21 the last election as third party advertisers. Sorry, I mean during the last trustee election. The ATA alone,
00:06:29 the Alberta Teachers Association, spent $1.1 million as a political third party advertiser. When you add up
00:06:37 the spending from these unions, $2.7 million was done officially at the provincial level in 2021,
00:06:46 and $1.7 million was done specifically as a campaign advertiser during the municipal election. A PAC called
00:06:57 Calgary's Future was funded to the tune of almost $2 million by CUPE, and they endorsed spots on every
00:07:06 seat on Calgary City Council and every seat on the public school board. They're not alone in this. In
00:07:14 Edmonton, the Labour Council endorsed eight candidates who were, I think it was for trustee, and five of
00:07:22 those won. The net result is that both city boards are effectively captured by union-backed slates.
00:07:30 And we're talking $2.5 billion in education budgets. This is not the rebels versus the empire.
00:07:39 That's a machine running billion-dollar boards. So what I'm telling you is that the board of the
00:07:47 Parkland Institute is the empire. They are not the rebels. And EPSB is part of that discussion on their
00:07:57 side. So this election, the ATA announced that they're going even further. The government has tried to
00:08:06 attempt this down a little bit by announcing restrictions on third-party advertisers.
00:08:11 But the first job of any campaign manager is apparently to get around spending limits and so
00:08:18 forth. So last March, they declared war with their Stand for Education campaign.
00:08:25 I'm not sure if they're buying TV or radio ads, but we are starting to see lawn signs from the ATA,
00:08:32 at least in Calgary. And we expect to see the full blitz. They have their own candidate website that they
00:08:41 refer people to. They're putting up ATA broth lawn signs. They're also handing out an 88-page campaign
00:08:48 handbook, very professionally written, probably cost a substantial amount of money, and it would do credit to
00:08:57 either UCP or the NDP during a provincial campaign. And they're giving that out to their people for free.
00:09:06 It gives step-by-step instructions on messaging, canvassing, organizing, and tells ATA locals how to
00:09:13 get involved. It's not a union helping members. This is a parallel political party trying to capture
00:09:20 school boards or keep the control they already have. And when I say that during the last election,
00:09:28 unions spent $4.4 million at the trustee level, admittedly as political advertisers mostly rather
00:09:37 than direct election campaign advertisers, I'd like to remind you for scale that during the last
00:09:44 provincial election, UCP only spent $4.2 million. So the union spending during the course of the last
00:09:54 school board elections was bigger than a winning provincial election campaign. So the ATA's agenda
00:10:03 is not neutral. They open a campaign only for so-called public schools. They leave out Catholic boards.
00:10:10 They leave out independent schools and they leave out homeschoolers. Why? Because if they close down
00:10:17 the alternatives, they can force every teacher from the independent schools and homeschoolers to pay ATA
00:10:24 dues. And they have a political ally with the Public School Boards Association of Alberta. They're aligned on
00:10:33 that. They fold in SOGI-123 activism, promising to mobilize opposition to government policies.
00:10:40 And their tactic crossed the line, right? An ATA staffer personally phoned Canyon Meadows Cinema last
00:10:47 year to cancel a UCP event, or sorry, to cancel their ATA event because they said the cinema had dared to
00:10:59 host an event by a UCP constituency association. They went to the extent of calling the UCP a hate girl.
00:11:06 So this is not education advocacy. This is political warfare. Now compare that with transfer choice and
00:11:15 education. We really are grassroots. We've trained about 300 parents, community members and potential
00:11:21 trustees. We don't have a multimillion budget. We don't have a free campaign manual. We're not providing
00:11:31 lawn signs from HQ. When we provide a service, we charge for it so that there's no even appearance of
00:11:40 collusion. If we train people, they'll pay a fee to take our workshop. It's not done for free.
00:11:46 And what we see here is ordinary people stepping up. It's not driven by big money from somewhere.
00:11:57 We're run by tiny, tiny donations from ordinary people. It's like we're looking at David and Goliath here,
00:12:06 and Goliath is pointing at David before the battle and yelling, he's too tall. So what's the bottom line
00:12:13 here? When you draw a government paycheck, you are not Luke Skywalker. You are a storm trooper. And if you
00:12:23 are like the Parkland Institute, you probably have the same aim from the looks of it. Parents are the
00:12:31 citizens here. They're the ones paying the bills. They're the ones raising the kids. And they deserve
00:12:37 a save. Trustee elections are coming next month. And I hope that parents will ask every candidate one
00:12:44 single question. Will you keep sexualized books on school shelves? Or will you stand with parents?
00:12:51 Beyond that, we are sending out the survey to every trustee candidate. And we will be asking
00:13:00 everyone possible to answer 10 simple questions that will help parents get a better sense of where
00:13:06 they stand on things. So I think that's, as Forrest Gump said, all I've got to say about that.
00:13:16 Okay, well, that's pretty interesting. That covered some of my questions on the report, definitely.
00:13:22 Because you're basically saying it's kind of all connected. And trustees are have like a big fund
00:13:30 for like, keeping things going in the direction they want to go with like the ATA with all of that. So I
00:13:38 guess my question also, because the report itself was called, what was it called challenging
00:13:46 independent education, challenging parental parental rights. Oh, my bad. Okay. Yeah. So it's challenging
00:13:52 print. Like, but I'm just confused. I don't know if you can explain this to me. Why do they want to
00:13:58 challenge parental rights so badly? Like, it's their kids. I just don't get it. Well,
00:14:06 it's not about parents. It's not about voters. This is about a group of political elites, right?
00:14:13 Union members of these public sector unions may not even be aware that their managers have a seat at
00:14:20 Parkland Institute and Parkland, sorry, not Parkland, but Public Interest Alberta. They probably don't
00:14:28 know they wouldn't approve. This is a management side project. And what it does is help these and
00:14:34 these people on these boards keep power. And make no mistake, they've got a lot of power and prestige.
00:14:41 And that is definitely worth something. They've got a lot at stake. Right. Yeah. I guess. Yeah. It
00:14:49 doesn't make sense then. The key difference between now and last time is that the province is trying
00:14:58 to rein in spending by third party advocacy groups, right? They want restricted to $5,000. And they're
00:15:07 trying to say, no, no, every local doesn't get to spend $5,000 as a third party advertiser. Your whole
00:15:14 union gets to spend $5,000. And right now, these guys are trying to find a way around that. And this
00:15:22 is one of the ways they're doing it. So consider that report. That report was prepared for the Parkland
00:15:29 Institute by the research director for a group called Support Our Students. They're an activist group
00:15:39 on the left. And they push for very progressive agendas. But what's happened is Parkland Institute
00:15:50 may have paid the money to produce the report, possibly more than you would think reasonable. We will never
00:15:58 know because their reporting is completely opaque. There is no way to access that information.
00:16:05 However, that would fund support our students. So that would get money into the hands of an activist 0.99
00:16:12 group. That's one more group to spend $5,000 as a third party advertiser. And that's one more
00:16:18 group that can donate money to candidates. Wow.
00:16:23 So you're seeing workarounds here. Yeah, definitely. Well, okay. Other than that,
00:16:32 I guess you also in the Parkland Institute report, they were talking about how your organization,
00:16:42 they said they're you're trying to influence public education by approach school trustee
00:16:49 workshops that you guys do. So why don't you tell us more about these workshops? Like,
00:16:54 what do they entail? And how is it going to help like parents and students and like school boards and
00:16:58 stuff? So we are planning to do another workshop in Calgary towards the end of this month. But we have
00:17:06 already been running workshops for the last four years. Part of the reason why the unions are worried is that
00:17:15 we did this during for the first time during the last school board elections. Out of the people we
00:17:23 trained, a dozen people ran for office, and four of those apparently got their seats. Since then, we've
00:17:31 trained over 300 people. So we could look forward to more independent minded people getting seats.
00:17:39 Not all of the people that we train are necessarily conservative. We train whoever comes in the door,
00:17:47 because simply put, having a healthy political process at the school board level would be a
00:17:53 wonderful thing. Because right now, most of us don't know who's running. And more than half of us don't
00:17:58 know who our local school board trustee is. We would like to fix this.
00:18:02 But to the union, this is a terrible threat to their control. When I say that those school boards
00:18:11 control 2.5 million dollars in spending, if you can get a friendly superintendent installed at one,
00:18:19 if you can get policies that favor hiring your own people in administrative positions,
00:18:27 that's a key bit of political patronage. And so there's a lot on the line here.
00:18:33 2.5 million dollars, just the leavings from that, involve a considerable amount of power.
00:18:41 Yeah. Now I'm wondering if I actually answered your question.
00:18:48 So what are the workshops? So the workshops themselves are usually a day and a bed. I start on Friday night.
00:18:56 And first I do a workshop on how to be an effective trustee. And I'm covering things like how to avoid
00:19:03 groupthink, how to get through interpersonal issues, how to work with a work plan, and how to actually get
00:19:14 things done. It's good advice for anybody on any board, honestly. And it's hard learned from me being on
00:19:21 far too many boards, geeked out with the fact that I was trained as a social worker, and all of those
00:19:27 group work classes come in really handy. Friday morning, or early Saturday afternoon, if we're
00:19:36 trying to jam this into a single day, we cover the nuts and bolts of campaigning. How is it actually done?
00:19:43 Concrete examples, right? Occasionally a role play if we have time. So all the things you need to know
00:19:52 about how to do the acts of campaigning. Because strangely, not a lot of people actually understand
00:19:59 them. Then in the afternoon or late afternoon and early evening, if we're jamming it into a single day,
00:20:07 we talk about messaging and issues. We talk about things like, how many issues do you actually get
00:20:13 to talk about? How are those connected to what you can actually do as a trustee? How do you
00:20:20 turn this into statecraft rather than mere politics? And then we talk about how you pick issues that reflect
00:20:28 your agenda, and how you go about choosing them. So we go through possible issues at different levels,
00:20:37 and we perhaps do a little role playing for a team trying to figure out what to run. Because after all,
00:20:44 school board trustees and municipal councillors have to pick their own issues. They're not chosen by any
00:20:50 party. So that's pretty much the whole workshop. We have written a textbook for it that comes as
00:20:57 part of signing up for the workshop. We have generally positive reviews from the workshop,
00:21:04 people praise it. And we do it as a straight through consistent thing. So you've got a clear
00:21:11 idea of what you're enlisting for. But here's the key problem, Leah, and this is what we're really
00:21:18 trying to address. For 45 years, Alberta had a conservative government, well, progressive
00:21:25 conservative. And we got used to the idea that politics was taken care of, so we didn't need to
00:21:31 worry about it. And we got out of the habit of doing competitive campaigns. And what's happened with
00:21:41 unions and progressives taking over our school boards and making such an effective bid for provincial
00:21:49 government is that conservatives aren't very good at campaigning. When I started on the original board
00:21:58 of the Wild Rose Party and we went into our first election, I found out that none of us had actually
00:22:04 had a meaningful role in an election. Those who had had been board members and hadn't done any actual
00:22:10 campaigning. So I set about trying to change that. What we want people to do is start treating politics
00:22:17 as a hobby. This is not the most important election ever. You don't go for this election and then never
00:22:27 again. You have to plan to be involved more than once. Treat it like a hobby, like fishing or boxing.
00:22:35 And you train, you get your original equipment, you try it out, you get your feet wet a little,
00:22:45 you come back, you get a little more training, and you try it again. That's what we need to do for
00:22:51 conservatives to be effective in political campaigns. And that's a culture shift that we're trying to
00:22:57 accomplish here. Because when that happens, parents have a more meaningful voice in politics and deciding
00:23:06 what's happening at those schools, at the levels those decisions are made.
00:23:10 Well, thank you very much, John. I feel like it was very informative.
00:23:15 I really appreciate you going into more detail on like the Parkland Institute, what it actually means,
00:23:21 why they're writing the report to begin with. Yeah, I really appreciate it a lot. And sorry,
00:23:27 is there something you want to say? Go ahead. This is very, very long. I'm not sure if you'll be able to
00:23:32 use all of us. But if you need to ask any questions while you're constructing the story, I'll be happy to
00:23:39 hop on a brief call like this. Okay, yeah, no, no problem. I feel like maybe I'll just like,
00:23:45 because you said you wanted to send a survey. So maybe I'll link it in the article as well.
00:23:50 Like you're still constructing it. It won't really be done. It won't be complete, probably until
00:23:58 the last day to declare as a candidate, which is something like the 19th or the 19th.
00:24:04 We will be starting to send it out as we go. If people were, if people want to help make that
00:24:13 survey come, they could send an email to us at admin at parentchoice.ca. Okay, yeah. Okay,
00:24:20 then we'll just do that. We'll tell them about that. Maybe like link it either in the YouTube
00:24:25 description or in the article. Yeah, that would be great. Sweet, sweet. Okay, well, thanks again.
00:24:33 And if you guys enjoyed this video, then you can subscribe to the Western Standard YouTube channel,
00:24:40 as well as check out our website at Western Standard, where you can subscribe for $10 a month.
00:24:47 Yeah, that's all we have for you guys today. So thank you very much. And bye bye. Thank you.