Western Standard - August 14, 2025


Why is the PPC supporting Alberta independence?

Topics
Mentioned
The EU's climate narrative — As scary as it sounds? How Alberta teachers' strike may sway school board trustee election

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

165.04

Word count

8,283

Sentence count

440

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

28

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford returns after a long weekend to talk about the People's Party of Canada and the upcoming Alberta referendum on independence from Canada. Plus, why is a federal political party, ostensibly dedicated to Canada, supporting a referendum on a part of that country?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day and welcome to the Pipeline.
00:00:28 Today is August 13th, 2025.
00:00:31 I'm Derek Phil DeBrant, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:36 I'm joined, as usual, by Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:41 And already back out of retirement is former Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:47 Just couldn't stay away, Derek.
00:00:49 No, we had your retirement party on Friday.
00:00:53 It's Wednesday, and you're back already.
00:00:55 So you just kind of had a long weekend, and you're already out of retirement.
00:00:59 Well, it's going to be a lot of long weekends, isn't it?
00:01:02 Because I'm just coming in to do pipeline every now and then, so every week, actually.
00:01:06 Yeah.
00:01:07 Confirmative to the auto article.
00:01:08 So good to be back.
00:01:09 We couldn't let you go completely.
00:01:11 So, yeah, you're going to be back, still doing the pipeline with us.
00:01:14 Your show, Hannaford, is going to continue on,
00:01:16 and your passionate pen will continue to grace our pages with your column at least once a week here.
00:01:23 Since we're talking about the passionate pen and the column,
00:01:28 don't forget to check in with Hannaford tomorrow,
00:01:29 and we've got Jaroslav Baran explaining some of the nonsense in Eastern Canada.
00:01:35 There's always a lot of material there.
00:01:37 Never fails.
00:01:38 Okay.
00:01:39 Well, we're going to be talking about why the People's Party of Canada,
00:01:46 note the last part of the name on that party,
00:01:48 The People's Party of Canada has endorsed the yes side in the expected upcoming, at some point, not yet set, Alberta referendum on independence.
00:01:59 So why is a federal political party, ostensibly dedicated to Canada, supporting a referendum on a part of that country, leaving it?
00:02:10 It's a head-scratcher. We'll talk about it.
00:02:12 uh everyone already knows i'm sure uh everyone listening watching knows about uh nova scotia's
00:02:20 ban on walking in the forest or going fishing uh but there's been a new development on that front
00:02:29 uh the fire the ban on hiking and fishing because fishing on the water might create a forest fire
00:02:38 uh that ban no longer applies uh as long as you they ask first to first nations natives so now
00:02:49 i guess the ban on fishing and hiking in nova scotia is going to be racially based we'll talk
00:02:55 about it uh but first we're going to start with mass migration mania uh the floodgates of mass
00:03:05 migration have been thrown wide open in Canada. Over the last five years, we already had mass 1.00
00:03:11 migration to quite, yeah, we already had mass migration for a long time before it, but then the
00:03:16 gates were just thrown completely open five years, five, six years ago. Mark Carney, as a part of his
00:03:24 campaign to reassure the Canadian people, said that he is not Justin Trudeau, said he's going to bring
00:03:30 those numbers down we have a report from black locks reporters on our pages today that um the
00:03:38 cap he has put in is uh well they're not really living up to the cap the the borders continue to
00:03:45 be porous mass migration continues unabated night they don't even know how many people they've got
00:03:50 you know a lot of people have uh just sort of you just intuitively know if the immigration is
00:03:56 taking off like a rocket or what what's the sense of that there was a time when you had to be highly
00:04:01 qualified to come to canada at all that's 50 years ago 25 years ago we've got a lot of family
00:04:08 reunification again you could see why you could make the case somebody wants to bring members of
00:04:14 their family and so they can enjoy the benefits they've uh they've been experiencing themselves
00:04:19 in canada all of those things made sense and around about 200 000 people a year would come in
00:04:25 Then it just took off, and I think after a lot of years,
00:04:30 when it was 400,000 and 500,000 during the first years of Mr. Trudeau's reign,
00:04:36 we hit a million new people in Canada.
00:04:40 Not a million new Canadians who had all gone through the sausage machine, 0.70
00:04:44 but just people here.
00:04:46 They were either students on working visas or people brought in to work. 0.62
00:04:51 And the numbers just shot at me.
00:04:54 think well why would they do that the answer is that nothing else that mr trudeau was doing
00:05:01 economically was working but having all these people coming in finding a place to live buying
00:05:08 food buying cars buying gas gave the false impression of a prosperous growth within
00:05:15 canada but of course the downside of it as we all know uh at the housing market first the rental
00:05:22 market. And people started asking questions. Now, Mr. Carney was asked a question during
00:05:29 his campaign. He said, look, we've got to get a grip on this thing. But the story this
00:05:33 morning is we haven't got a grip on it. Let's just read you what we said. The immigration
00:05:37 levels in the first third of the year, this year, outpaced Prime Minister Mark Carney's
00:05:45 promised cap on quotas, figures released by the Department of Immigration for the first
00:05:50 120 days of this year
00:05:53 Indicate that we will
00:05:55 Exceed 400,000 immigrants
00:05:57 In 2025
00:05:58 That's more than Mr. Carney
00:06:01 Promised
00:06:02 So the system is not working
00:06:03 And the why of it
00:06:06 I don't think it's changed
00:06:08 I think it gives the federal government
00:06:10 The illusion of prosperity and busyness
00:06:13 They like that
00:06:14 I partially agree with Nigel
00:06:17 On the why
00:06:18 Partially
00:06:20 But I think it's, and we see this in Western countries everywhere, I think it's more than just trying to juice the overall gross national product, gross national product here.
00:06:37 I think it's trying to stack the electorate, because the progress of this worldview is that so-called old-stock Canadians are reactionary, they're not sufficiently progressive, they're racist, gun-owning, vaccine-hesitant, etc.
00:06:56 You know, add whatever epithets you want to it.
00:06:59 I think it's, in their view, a way of also, in the long term, intentionally changing the demographic and therefore electoral makeup of the country.
00:07:10 I mean, that's a bit more taboo to get into, but hell, for at least just standard, we can say what we want here.
00:07:18 I think it's both.
00:07:19 I don't think it's just artificially juicing the GDP numbers.
00:07:23 it's, I think it's an
00:07:25 intentional
00:07:26 policy, intentioned
00:07:30 and designed to change the
00:07:31 makeup of Canada. No, I agree.
00:07:33 It's both. I think
00:07:35 I'm thinking this began more, though, is that juicing
00:07:37 of the economy. It's a lazy way to do it.
00:07:39 I mean, they only ever had one economic
00:07:41 measure they could keep pointing to. Look how our GDP
00:07:43 is growing. Never GDP for capital.
00:07:45 Not GDP for capital, because yeah, your pie
00:07:47 is growing, but the people eating it are outpacing
00:07:49 the growth of the pie.
00:07:51 But the political ramifications
00:07:53 absolutely. I mean, we look at a recent
00:07:55 thing, too, where the government put out a big invitation
00:07:57 when he's saying he's going to be controlling
00:07:59 this, and he's saying, oh, by the way, everybody
00:08:01 invite your grandparents and your parents to
00:08:03 come over now. We know what kind of economic
00:08:05 benefit is that? That's going to pressure the healthcare 1.00
00:08:07 system further. That's going to, you know, all of our
00:08:09 systems are housing the rest.
00:08:11 But what it will do is make
00:08:13 some of those new Canadians very happy. They're
00:08:15 reunited with their family, and they're hoping
00:08:17 anyways that gratitude is going to be expressed at
00:08:19 the ballot box. So
00:08:21 So I think there's very much a political element to it.
00:08:24 I mean, the new Canadians coming over might not have citizenship and time to vote, 1.00
00:08:28 but the families they're reuniting with will, and they want to keep that block.
00:08:34 I mean, they were pretty blunt about that.
00:08:36 I can't remember which minister it was or which liberal it was
00:08:38 when they were asked about why are you taking this particular stance
00:08:41 on, again, one of the things in the Middle East.
00:08:43 This is, well, you know, how many Jews there are in my riding
00:08:45 versus how many Muslims are in my riding.
00:08:47 Yeah, you know.
00:08:49 So, unfortunately, it ties very much into their electability and building the demographic they think they need to build to win.
00:08:57 Well, as you're saying, I mean, like now, Canada's foreign policy is not dictated by what is in the Canadian national interest.
00:09:05 It is, and foreign policy in all democratic countries has to keep an eye on domestic opinion.
00:09:10 But domestic opinion is changing with mass migrate, unrestricted mass migration from around the world.
00:09:16 And that means even more so than in a normal country, you know, our foreign policy is dictated by, you know, which diaspora population are we able to please or not aggravate, etc. 0.54
00:09:34 A diaspora politics is in large, pretty much runs our foreign policy at this point.
00:09:40 it has nothing to do at this point
00:09:45 with what's in the national interest now
00:09:46 yeah I think that's a fair comment
00:09:48 and I think that's been going along for a long time
00:09:50 to your point about
00:09:52 bringing in people
00:09:55 who can be relied upon to vote liberal
00:09:56 that is
00:09:59 probably what the liberals are
00:10:00 thinking because the liberals
00:10:02 like to work through community
00:10:04 organizers and they talk to one person
00:10:07 and he goes out and tells
00:10:09 the community which doesn't speak english very well these are the people you need to vote for 1.00
00:10:13 the liberals like to do it that way i don't think put these people in the conservatives play that
00:10:17 game too all parties do but and here's the thing uh during the the harper years what we discovered
00:10:24 was that a lot of immigrants come from socially conservative countries the philippines pakistan
00:10:31 um india and they're not coming here because they like the social policies that the liberals are
00:10:39 pushing that's very much the business of white atheists to to promote those policies if they 0.50
00:10:45 vote liberal it's in spite of those policies not because of them what they're coming here for is a
00:10:49 better life and the fact that they can bring their their parents so it's not quite as impenetrable
00:10:55 as I had assumed before I went to Ottawa.
00:10:59 I mean, it's...
00:11:01 Jason Kenney did very well
00:11:04 at what you're calling diaspora politics.
00:11:06 Well, there really was that one election
00:11:09 with the Harper majority in 2011
00:11:11 where they were successful in diaspora politics.
00:11:15 At least in negating the liberal advantage in it.
00:11:18 They had to do a lot for it.
00:11:21 But that was kind of a one-off.
00:11:22 In general, it does trend to progressivist, leftist parties,
00:11:25 and i think you know big part is you know they're relying on leftist identity politics
00:11:36 victim hierarchies saying okay well you might come from country xyz where you may have a more
00:11:42 traditional view of the family unit etc but here in canada you're a victim uh and here here's you
00:11:50 know add up your different here's your point system add up your victim level um and therefore
00:11:55 you belong with us and i mean it doesn't work on all obviously there's not always french fries
00:12:02 isn't it yeah but but it does work to a pretty extensive degree especially um beyond just the
00:12:09 social policies you know like if you have a traditional view of family etc it uh you know
00:12:15 diaspora politics is also money we're going to give you know some money for you to help build
00:12:21 xyz cultural center for your people and that that has created a bidding war in all of the parties
00:12:27 on the left and the right the right does this too now because they have to politically to to be
00:12:31 competitive at all in many constituencies in alberta uh and anywhere in canada to be competitive
00:12:37 you have to engage in this bidding war of diaspora politics you got to show up and eat the food do
00:12:42 the dance, bow to the right thing. It's a dangerous dance too, though. And we're starting to see that
00:12:48 now that we're hitting a tipping point of such large segments of these populations. Diaspora,
00:12:53 again, yeah, they're escaping those areas. But look at the Kalistani Hindu mess going on. And 1.00
00:13:00 there are very large, significant, politically active populations on both sides of that issue.
00:13:06 And it's very politically dangerous waters to wade into. And the liberals have been good at
00:13:11 kind of playing both sides, but
00:13:13 it can blow up really badly on you with that
00:13:16 It dictates our foreign politics 0.82
00:13:17 our foreign policy, like our entire relationship
00:13:20 with India has nothing 1.00
00:13:21 has very little to do with what's in our national
00:13:24 interest on trade, on security, etc
00:13:26 It has to do with
00:13:27 diaspora politics between the Sikhs and the Hindus
00:13:30 That's the whole thing
00:13:31 Like, you know, giving a cold shoulder to Modi
00:13:33 This is a massive trading partner
00:13:36 for us, this is a great new
00:13:37 developing market
00:13:38 The liberals have come to the realization that
00:13:41 within Canada, the Sikh
00:13:43 voter base
00:13:45 is significantly more important than the Hindu 0.98
00:13:47 voter base. Therefore,
00:13:50 you're going to take shots at Modi, who's a
00:13:52 Hinduist, you know,
00:13:54 not perceived as that friendly towards the Sikhs.
00:13:55 And meanwhile, we lose out on
00:13:58 potentially billions in trade. They're sacrificing
00:14:00 our economic well-being for their bloody
00:14:01 partisanship. I mean, that's...
00:14:04 Meanwhile, we don't actually
00:14:05 know with any certainty
00:14:07 how many immigrants 0.56
00:14:09 we have in Canada
00:14:11 and what their status is.
00:14:13 How many have come in?
00:14:14 We don't even know how many.
00:14:15 We know how many have come in,
00:14:17 but we have no idea if they're still here.
00:14:20 There they are.
00:14:20 Once they're here,
00:14:21 there's the honor system when it's,
00:14:22 oh, your visa's up,
00:14:23 we expect you just purchased a ticket
00:14:25 and went home, right?
00:14:26 Yeah.
00:14:27 Don't think many do.
00:14:28 No, it's not looking that way.
00:14:30 And that's part of the problem
00:14:31 when you have insular communities like that,
00:14:35 actually, when it comes based on that,
00:14:38 because that's how undocumented 0.89
00:14:39 or people who aren't legal
00:14:40 can manage to maintain within a country
00:14:42 because if they stay in the tight community, you can find
00:14:44 ways to keep working.
00:14:46 It's complicated.
00:14:47 So we've put this cap on, or Carney's put this cap
00:14:50 on, which was still an extraordinarily
00:14:52 high cap.
00:14:54 I mean, to be fair,
00:14:57 Pryor Polyev in the election
00:14:58 called for a cap as well,
00:15:00 lowering our cap.
00:15:03 But it was still also
00:15:04 extraordinarily high.
00:15:07 Neither party
00:15:08 seemed particularly interested, probably
00:15:10 for reasons of diaspora politics to get serious about controlling mass unrestricted mass migration
00:15:17 well uh to be fair we've now missed even the cap there's one other area though and there are
00:15:22 elements of the business community particularly say in the service area and such where they
00:15:26 wanted temporary foreign workers because they've been having a difficult time finding affordable
00:15:31 local business loves this and it drives down the cost of labor uh you know below levels that you
00:15:39 Otherwise, lower-income, working-class Canadians are willing to do. 0.97
00:15:42 You're going to bring in people who are happy to work at that level,
00:15:45 and it undercuts our lower working class.
00:15:47 This loves it.
00:15:49 It's another aspect of the incentives for the Liberals to continue to talk big
00:15:53 but do nothing when it comes to this.
00:15:55 You know, there's more to be said on that subject.
00:15:58 People say, well, you know, they take the immigrants 1.00
00:16:01 because the immigrants have a higher work ethic than, you know,
00:16:04 the Canadian-born kids of whatever race they may come from.
00:16:08 and there's some truth to that however there is also a very strong ethnic
00:16:15 preference in hiring so if you have somebody from this community who's got a
00:16:20 business he tends to look for people of his own kind for them to work and it is
00:16:25 resulting in Canadian young people born in Canada having much more difficulty
00:16:32 in finding part-time work summer jobs and things like that because they're all
00:16:36 the jobs are all going to like little hiring halls that are ethically based yeah and i can
00:16:43 understand that i mean you're you know you're you're you know say new or relatively new to
00:16:47 here you establish a business part of your your social support network maybe yeah there's government
00:16:54 stuff but no one cares about that that's you you're you're you know you're doing a favor to
00:16:59 your your your friend you hired his kids you've now built uh you've put some mortar in between
00:17:06 the bricks of your social structure there it's holding that community together and so that's a
00:17:10 perfectly natural and normal it's understandable and there's not helping with people who are
00:17:15 already here who are supposed to be benefiting from immigration there is a wider thing with
00:17:20 i guess spoiled western work ethic in my view like owning a pub service industry i would try to hire
00:17:26 local kids but boy they don't show up on time they don't care i mean not for everyone there's
00:17:31 exceptions but i tell you and when you start that route and i started getting filipino workers in
00:17:35 my kitchen. They were fantastic. They would reach out to the community to find other people who
00:17:39 wanted to work in there. They were never late. They didn't complain and they were just made
00:17:43 fantastic staff. So it's hard to, and I, you know, this isn't a guy starting as a Filipino 1.00
00:17:49 employer. That's just the way it worked. So whose fault is that? Uh, you know,
00:17:53 our show is Filipino and I'm convinced of their work ethic. The guy running the show right there,
00:17:57 John, so, you know, and arguably the hardest working guy here, but either way, I, you know,
00:18:02 I just always get a laugh out of some of the people.
00:18:04 They're coming to take our jobs.
00:18:05 Well, did you apply for any of those jobs?
00:18:09 Where I want to know is, where are the unions?
00:18:13 Unions, which are supposed to, in theory,
00:18:16 represent the interests of the organized labor working class.
00:18:21 Now, most unions now tend to be the government sector
00:18:25 working in very often white-collar office jobs.
00:18:29 But, you know, even the private sector unions, you know, where you're supposed to be able to go get a job, not have to necessarily have a bunch of post-secondary degrees to do it and support the broader interests of the working class.
00:18:43 The single working class voters are voting more on the right now. Working class voters are very conscious of the problems around mass migration. But the union leaderships themselves are definitely silent on mass migration, which brings in people willing to work cheaper than someone who's maybe grown up in Canada and undercuts their wages.
00:19:10 it's the single biggest threat
00:19:12 to the working class in Canada
00:19:14 and they're
00:19:16 utterly silent
00:19:17 you know I never thought I'd hear Derek saying
00:19:20 where the hell are the unions
00:19:21 the unions have changed you
00:19:24 the unions have changed though
00:19:26 I mean it used to be the lunchbox carry and trade unions
00:19:28 now it's the
00:19:30 teachers lounge unionists
00:19:31 they're the ones dominating
00:19:34 the political class anyways
00:19:35 they've gone more into the woke politics
00:19:38 The Gil McGowans even aren't as big on the old school, you know, we're going to stand up for the worker thing.
00:19:43 They're tying themselves into woke causes instead.
00:19:46 I think that union block's still there, but nobody's speaking for them right now.
00:19:52 We need better unions.
00:19:55 If we're going to have them.
00:19:56 If we're going to have bloody unions, you get ones that at least speak to the single biggest issue facing the working class.
00:20:04 I was going to actually ask Gil McGowan to call on the Hannaford Show.
00:20:07 What do you think about that?
00:20:08 uh yeah i mean if you bring if it's in person we probably have to bring security in for it
00:20:14 so i know it won't come in mind all right but you know you you should invite him i you know i think
00:20:21 that'd be great i'd like to see what you know the union bosses have to say on these issues
00:20:26 probably disagree on everything but they should theoretically agree with us on this
00:20:31 This is, as we were saying, big business is the ones that like cheap, unrestricted mass migration.
00:20:39 They get to completely flood out the wage force.
00:20:46 That's one of the reasons why unions like minimum wages applied even outside them is it sets a floor.
00:20:53 Yeah, it still pushes all the way.
00:20:55 It creates general pressure.
00:20:56 That creates upward pressure.
00:20:58 It still messes with the market.
00:20:59 it's probably a bad idea, but at least it is
00:21:01 technically upward pressure. Some people who
00:21:03 aren't worth the minimum wage, well then they just
00:21:05 fall on social assistance. And
00:21:07 you can argue about how good a trade-off
00:21:09 that is or not. But okay.
00:21:11 But this creates
00:21:13 downward pressure on wages.
00:21:15 Massive downward pressure. And people
00:21:17 doing pretty well,
00:21:19 they're not all
00:21:21 that affected by it. Because it's at the lower levels
00:21:24 where this pushes down. The entry levels.
00:21:26 Entry-level jobs, low skill,
00:21:28 you know, that kind of thing.
00:21:29 Well, the ones are going to lose out to artificial intelligence.
00:21:34 Artificial intelligence is going to kill upper class jobs.
00:21:36 It's just artificial intelligence won't unplug my toilet.
00:21:40 Yeah.
00:21:41 Not yet.
00:21:42 Skills.
00:21:43 Blue color skill makers are going to be left with jobs soon. 0.62
00:21:49 Okay.
00:21:52 Let's move on to the wildfires in Nova Scotia.
00:21:55 So this has got everyone on both sides in a tizzy.
00:21:59 Um, you know, I, I saw, uh, was it Steve Marr?
00:22:03 Uh, no, no.
00:22:05 Was it Steve Marr?
00:22:06 Uh, the Golden Mail columnist?
00:22:08 Yeah.
00:22:08 Steve Marr, yeah.
00:22:09 Um, you know, you've seen him kind of defending this, uh, we, I'm not gonna explain the situation
00:22:16 itself, but everyone's, everyone already knows about it, but, you know, he, he was defending
00:22:20 it saying, well, you know, most of the critics of this, they're all coming from, uh, points
00:22:24 West, as he put it.
00:22:26 Uh, these Westerners, I don't think he actually put it very rudely.
00:22:29 I don't think he's actually incorrect when he says it's, you know, these Westerners are more libertarian and, you know, they're and I don't like it when he's sort of piping about how we were doing our business.
00:22:39 So, OK, it goes both ways. I get it. But he's saying, you know, we're more communitarian out here. I take issue with that.
00:22:46 I think that actually in many ways we're more communitarian. We just rely less on the state to do it.
00:22:51 I cooperate. I'm I'm building a I'm building stuff around my property with my neighbors, doing things that are kind of almost quasi municipal.
00:22:59 We don't bother asking a government. We just
00:23:01 come together, pool our resources, pool our
00:23:03 labor, do it ourselves. We're communitarian
00:23:05 just on a more private, voluntary
00:23:07 level. But okay, I guess what he's
00:23:09 saying is the more communitarian
00:23:11 may be on the state level, state enforcing it.
00:23:17 So if
00:23:19 everyone's admitted, including the government officials, that
00:23:23 yes, walking in the forest or going
00:23:25 fishing isn't going to create a fire, but some other people 0.56
00:23:27 will go there and do some dumb things, so we have to do this. And I'm willing to actually grant
00:23:32 the theoretical possibility they could be correct. In an emergency, rights do get curtailed. All
00:23:38 governments do is curtail rights, and sometimes that can be justified. But I'd say after the last
00:23:45 decade we've had, there's very little reservoir of goodwill that we trust the government to know
00:23:51 where to draw the line in the curtailment of rights in an emergency. We went through COVID
00:23:56 where rights were stripped away without any evidence
00:23:58 or often in the face of contrary evidence
00:24:01 where people were legitimately oppressed
00:24:06 and discriminated against
00:24:07 for no discernible actual public good outcomes.
00:24:13 So yeah, we don't have a very big reserve of goodwill
00:24:16 to trust the state on these things.
00:24:19 Okay, so that's the argument going on there.
00:24:22 But what really just made this chef's kiss on me
00:24:25 was when the Nova Scotia government created an exemption for First Nations.
00:24:29 So, you know, going for a hike in the forest, going fishing,
00:24:35 these things could inadvertently start a forest fire. 0.58
00:24:40 But if you happen to belong to a First Nation,
00:24:45 then the risk might not be so great.
00:24:48 I don't know.
00:24:50 Is this the difference?
00:24:51 I'm going to get in trouble on this one.
00:24:52 Is this the difference between an Indian fire and a White Planned fire? 0.94
00:24:55 I don't know where to go with the answer
00:24:57 with that one. But I mean, they're
00:24:59 inviting this kind of discussion because the absurdity
00:25:02 of this. They're just getting so bold
00:25:03 and blatant and showing that this
00:25:05 has absolutely nothing to do with the fire risk.
00:25:08 What's it about? What is it
00:25:09 about then? I don't understand. Because it's
00:25:11 clearly not a fire risk.
00:25:13 It's control. I mean, I brought
00:25:15 many, many safety guys to tears
00:25:17 during my 20 years in the oil field.
00:25:19 You were the safety guy? No.
00:25:21 I was the surveyor who defied the safety guy
00:25:23 who fought with the safety
00:25:25 guy who would battle with him I like smart safety policies I like to see the
00:25:31 guy who shows up in his pickup truck drunk fired I like to see the guy who's
00:25:35 blasting down the cut line on a quad with no helmet on and jumping off the 1.00
00:25:39 stumps disciplined I don't like the twits and morons though who start imposing 1.00
00:25:44 stuff where there really wasn't a risk to begin with like first they started 0.99
00:25:50 with ATV bands of the woods and things like that chainsaws okay those are
00:25:53 Those are hot items that could start a fire and there could be a problem.
00:25:58 No problem.
00:25:59 But when you start to ban hikers, that's safety guys gone wild where they just go to the length of the absurd.
00:26:06 And then it also shows that they tend to be also the ones who are woke to the max as well.
00:26:11 Well, oh dear, we've got a First Nations play that's coming up and they're going to be very upset if we cancel this.
00:26:17 If it had been any other play or heaven forbid a Christian Singer. 1.00
00:26:21 It was Shakespeare actually.
00:26:22 It was an indigenous interpretation of Shakespeare, which I think is cultural appropriation.
00:26:29 It is, which I think most of us don't mind or care, but the irony is hilarious, though.
00:26:35 And they're just scared of canceling that to upset them.
00:26:37 It's that bizarre double standard.
00:26:40 There's no race less likely to light a fire than another. 1.00
00:26:44 Or if we wanted to dig down into some stats, we might find some stuff they really don't want to find out.
00:26:48 We're going to have to cap our spiciness right there. 0.99
00:26:50 yeah but it's just bureaucrats gone wild and and they've they've got the authority they enjoy using 0.75
00:26:57 it and it's it's ridiculous and and i'm glad this happened with this because it exposed 0.99
00:27:02 just how stupid it is one more thing about that story there is now a snitch line oh yes yeah now 0.99
00:27:09 snitch line that takes us back to covid yep and we're gonna do your point about um 0.99
00:27:16 about control there there is the thing that locks that into place
00:27:23 it's when governments don't have any imagination
00:27:26 then they start restricting people uh it's simplistic they won't do the hard
00:27:32 work of enforcement and it is hard work but then but they
00:27:37 want you to become a partner with them in enforcement uh it's
00:27:42 not a way to build a society i'm just amazed that people will even
00:27:46 tolerate it for a moment when real safety is difficult but bands are easy yeah you know if
00:27:51 but it's funny that most often at least we could do a bit of a cost benefit i mean how many children
00:27:55 die in swimming pools every year across the country a handful if we wanted to reduce it to
00:28:00 zero there's only one way you'd have to ban every swimming pool you make reasonable mitigations like
00:28:05 white garden fencing around the pools training lots of things trade-offs but you do have we
00:28:10 have accepted that as it sits right now a number of children are going to die in those swimming
00:28:15 pools. To be honest,
00:28:18 I won't be shocked if it gets to a point where they
00:28:19 start banning the bloody things. If you're going to ban people from
00:28:21 walking in the woods, because that's the only way
00:28:23 they think they can reduce the human ability to light
00:28:25 a fire to zero,
00:28:27 as ridiculous as that sounded 10 0.52
00:28:29 years ago today, apparently it's just a shrug of the shoulders. 0.95
00:28:32 Well, it'd be the same with
00:28:33 the only way to eliminate auto accidents
00:28:36 is the ban. Of course, yeah.
00:28:37 We've decided
00:28:39 that that is not reasonable.
00:28:41 There's things we can do to mitigate things,
00:28:43 but people are still dying
00:28:45 every single day, and auto crashes.
00:28:48 I think this is actually,
00:28:51 this kind of government overreach
00:28:52 actually creates danger.
00:28:55 You know, I remember saying during COVID
00:28:57 that I hope to God we don't actually get the big one.
00:29:02 Like, if we got a real, you know,
00:29:05 like, you know, one of these movies
00:29:06 where it's like, it's the Black Death,
00:29:09 and it's a genuine crisis,
00:29:11 You know, I mean, a restriction of your freedoms can, in some circumstances, be justified if the tradeoffs are appropriate, if you're not going intentionally too far.
00:29:27 There is a circumstance under which lockdowns could make sense, theoretically.
00:29:32 um but the abuse of government power by virtually nearly every government around the world
00:29:42 uh and especially in canada uh during covid make sure that it destroyed our trust in institutions
00:29:50 it destroyed social trust to the point where if we got the big one if we got you know black plague
00:29:57 coming um so many people uh if it happens within i think 15 years of covid here people are going to
00:30:06 say ah you got you got us last time yeah we've been through this i'm not going yes yeah people
00:30:11 are people will not follow uh reasonable recommendations or reasonable restrictions
00:30:16 uh you know you do have to curtail some activities during a forest for high risk of forest fire like
00:30:24 I ride my quad every single day
00:30:26 around my own land here, but if we were under
00:30:28 a fire watch, I understand
00:30:30 that, okay, maybe that could create a grass fire
00:30:32 on my land. You got a manifold outside, tall
00:30:34 dry grass, okay. It can happen.
00:30:36 It doesn't happen a lot, but it happens. That would be
00:30:38 a reasonable restriction, but if the government's
00:30:40 always, and if the government's going around
00:30:42 banning me from hiking
00:30:44 or fishing, clearly things that have no
00:30:46 impact whatsoever, I'm less
00:30:48 likely to trust the more reasonable
00:30:50 restriction that, hey, right now
00:30:52 you probably shouldn't ride your quad
00:30:53 because it could cause a spark well the measles resurgence I'm blaming to a degree total overplay
00:30:59 of the COVID vaccines when they got in people's faces they caused this trust we had everybody
00:31:04 you know a tipping point of people taking up the measles vaccine for decades and we've
00:31:09 virtually eliminated and suddenly now there's people are saying I don't trust vaccines for
00:31:13 measles and I'm not going to have my children vaccinated look what happened now we're seeing
00:31:17 weasels popping up on the scene again. That was the fault of them breaking the trust with COVID.
00:31:25 Yeah, you know, it's as old as history itself. Governments always try to gather power and it's
00:31:31 sort of the unique achievement of the governments of the Anglosphere in the last couple of hundred
00:31:37 years, inspired by liberty-minded philosophers who actually step back and say, no, people should be
00:31:43 free to do what people can do safely um but now we're seeing uh what we're seeing the kind of
00:31:51 overreach you're seeing in melvis coast and in new brunswick and newfoundland and and and people
00:31:58 have lost confidence in the old liberty idea and i say yeah sure here's my wrist put the handcuffs
00:32:04 on or just make me safe you were you have written in the past cory morgan that there's a war on
00:32:13 motor cars the secret plan is have a lot less motor cars and people to be a lot less mobile
00:32:23 keep them in 15 minute seats and if they have to go somewhere let them rent a golf cart well or if
00:32:28 it's public transit and then then boy it's much easier to kind of yeah but then you kind of got
00:32:32 people literally where you want them yes and uh i would make this proposition to you and it sort
00:32:39 of it relates back to
00:32:40 the forests.
00:32:43 The ability to go where you go
00:32:45 is the true definition of freedom.
00:32:47 It's more important than having a vote.
00:32:49 If you can go where you want to go
00:32:51 and you don't have to get your
00:32:53 sign-off or a permit from a government
00:32:55 department first, that's reason.
00:32:57 They don't like that.
00:33:02 Yeah.
00:33:03 And this can lead us to
00:33:07 seeing conspiracies
00:33:09 And sometimes we'll see them because maybe they are there, but it'll also lead us to see things that are not there because our trust in institutions, our formerly high trust society is no longer a high trust society.
00:33:21 um and so we've lost um and this might rub off on otherwise institutions that otherwise still
00:33:29 actually do a good job um i generally trust my doctor generally um but i'm probably just
00:33:39 naturally more suspicious of you know the medical institutions in general because they threw their
00:33:46 lot in and got political uh i mean you can't trust some wings of of even the scientific
00:33:52 community now because they've made themselves explicitly political be it on global warming
00:33:56 on vaccines uh and so but this is going to rub off then on people who have not violated our trust
00:34:03 um yeah so to your point about the scientists many fit the description that you've given them
00:34:12 But here is another illustration of where the central government moves in and creates the opinions that it wants, because scientists need money to do research.
00:34:23 They don't much care what the research is, but they do need the money. That's what pays the bill.
00:34:29 So the government sets up the guidelines for giving grants that you have to think certain things.
00:34:36 So prove the point, try and get a grant as a climate scientist that says no, all this stuff about global warming is way, way overrated. You will not get the grant. It just won't happen.
00:34:51 But if you take the other view, then you will. Much better chance anyway. So again, yes, some of our friends have let us down, but you can see why in the behest of the government.
00:35:06 So just giving a pat on the back to the honest scientist.
00:35:13 Yep.
00:35:13 Okay.
00:35:15 Well, we'll switch gears a little here.
00:35:19 Corey, I'll let you set it up.
00:35:21 But Maxime Bernier did a live stream the other day.
00:35:25 We covered it.
00:35:30 As both of us, as people who have led small, fringy parties before,
00:35:36 Both on the independence issue, we both, I think, are particularly well positioned to be able to speak to this.
00:35:43 Small parties have to do bold, sometimes even outrageous things to get attention, to get some traction.
00:35:50 um but the people's party of canada a populist right-wing um but ostensibly still canadian
00:36:01 nationalist and federalist party has now endorsed the yes side of the likely still
00:36:07 coming referendum at some point on alberta independence
00:36:10 curious well speaking of putting party interest ahead of national interest here's a fine example
00:36:19 of it on a more micro level, I think.
00:36:22 I mean, the
00:36:23 PPC under Maxime Bernier sort of
00:36:25 has a base of
00:36:27 support that's very small. It hasn't grown,
00:36:29 but it hasn't really shrunk either.
00:36:31 It shrunk from the high point they had in COVID.
00:36:33 Oh, at least from back then. I'm just saying, speaking
00:36:35 more in the last couple of years.
00:36:37 But they need money. They need
00:36:38 a degree of support. And I'm only guessing, but I would
00:36:41 bet a bulk of their supporters are concentrated
00:36:43 in Alberta. And of all
00:36:45 parties where the bulk of the supporters would be
00:36:47 independence-minded supporters, his
00:36:49 Alberta members are probably 90%
00:36:51 independent. I would imagine, yeah.
00:36:53 And he's donors. He
00:36:54 wants to keep them happy.
00:36:57 Let's put that out there because it is
00:36:58 counterintuitive to a federal party.
00:37:01 I mean, he did put out other things talking about
00:37:02 reducing, you know, federal incursions into
00:37:04 provincial jurisdiction and other
00:37:06 policy moves. But to be an
00:37:08 ostensibly federal party
00:37:10 to say that you support the
00:37:12 dissolution of the federation through a vote
00:37:15 in another province,
00:37:16 it's just bizarre. I mean, seeing the bloc do so.
00:37:18 I mean, we'll take all the help we can get.
00:37:19 Oh, sure.
00:37:20 I mean, we've sort of been saying it for quite some time.
00:37:23 I mean, I just, I think his motivations are just purely driven on trying to keep that base inflamed and happy and donating.
00:37:32 I mean, is he going to gain any of his support in Ontario or Quebec or anywhere else?
00:37:36 But he's not looking there.
00:37:37 He's just looking to pay the bills.
00:37:40 Fortunately, I think you're right.
00:37:41 But, you know, he could use this excuse if he wanted to.
00:37:45 let's get a strong pro-independence vote in alberta and then we can maybe extract a better
00:37:52 deal out of the federal government which i still support that is what he's argued here uh and he
00:37:57 said like in the 1995 quebec referendum on independence he voted yes uh because he felt
00:38:03 that you know after charlatan and michelag things have been frozen the ambitions of quebec
00:38:07 nationalists had been thwarted that was the only way to obtain reform i think most people who voted
00:38:14 for independence in the Quebec, well, whatever
00:38:15 they were voting on was a convoluted question.
00:38:18 But most people voted yes, I should
00:38:20 say, voted for independence, but
00:38:21 a sizable minority of them wanted to
00:38:24 push, to use this
00:38:26 as a gun to the head of Canada to obtain
00:38:27 reforms.
00:38:29 But, I mean, if
00:38:31 we got a yes vote on independence
00:38:33 in Alberta, like, our proposed question is
00:38:35 not ambiguous. It's not the Quebec one 0.89
00:38:38 where it's, what does yes
00:38:39 mean? Yeah,
00:38:41 it's not ambiguous. It's clear. If we get a yes
00:38:44 vote we expect independence the time for reform is before that vote it's not after that vote after
00:38:51 that vote the only discussion needs to be okay uh i'll take the kids uh monday to friday you
00:38:58 take them on the weekend and who you get the house i get the car that's the discussion who
00:39:02 gets quebec well they get quebec you can have it and we're not paying child support anymore
00:39:09 this is about ending child support
00:39:10 so I get what he's saying
00:39:13 but perhaps he's approaching this
00:39:15 from the view of a Quebec
00:39:17 of at least many Quebecers who saw
00:39:19 a yes vote for independence
00:39:21 in Quebec as a way of
00:39:23 extracting more from the federal government
00:39:25 getting more decentralization in the kind that they want
00:39:27 or asymmetrical deal etc
00:39:28 many Quebecers do view
00:39:30 the independence movement as a way to do that
00:39:33 and I'm sure some
00:39:35 Albertans do but
00:39:36 not many
00:39:37 Something Ted Byfield mentioned a couple of times, I remember back when I was leading the AIP too, though, was it was refederation.
00:39:44 And it was more along the premise almost, though, that, yeah, I guess if the federation fell apart, we could redraft it with a new contract.
00:39:52 And province leaving could be the catalyst that leads to that.
00:39:56 So the negotiations begin, but now we're at the beginning of the negotiations as independent nations, and we're going to try to come together under a new agreement.
00:40:03 Well, I've argued before, like, sometimes I've asked people the question rhetorically, if Alberta was an independent country right now, would we join Canada under these terms?
00:40:15 No one, no one, whatever, even the most hardcore Federalist, they have to admit, no, I probably would not.
00:40:22 But, you know, we've, you know, Alberta independence has thought of the other question of broader Western independence.
00:40:27 If Alberta went, there's a very good chance, Saskatchewan would follow, probably start a domino effect.
00:40:32 Quebec is then gone because Quebec would have to pay into Canada. They'll never do that. And that means at that point, then BC, maybe Manitoba and territories come along. And then it raised the question, would Canada just be refounded under the new constitution? Because I fundamentally, you know, I didn't grow up not liking Canada. I grew up as a passionate Canadian nationalist. And I, if it was possible to save Canada, that would be my preference. I think it's the preference of most even hardline Alberta nationalists.
00:41:00 I no longer want to be outvoted by the East all the time
00:41:02 because they have crazy ideas
00:41:04 I think we just have very separate
00:41:06 conceptions of the role of government
00:41:08 how we want to govern ourselves
00:41:09 but yeah
00:41:11 so I think that's kind of what
00:41:14 Bernier is arguing, not to actually recreate
00:41:16 the country again, but that it would
00:41:17 create a political
00:41:20 circumstance, political facts on the ground
00:41:22 that would lead to broader reform of Canada
00:41:24 fine
00:41:26 but that's not what would happen if we got
00:41:28 a yes vote
00:41:29 We've got a yes vote. It's done.
00:41:31 Yeah. Or at least
00:41:32 that's pulled the string on the sweater
00:41:35 that made it unravel. You know, whatever happens
00:41:37 after that. I think if any one
00:41:39 province leaves the Federation, the Federation's done.
00:41:41 Whether it's Quebec or Alberta or
00:41:43 Saskatchewan. No, no, no. I think Quebec
00:41:45 could leave and everything.
00:41:47 Our reason for leaving would more
00:41:49 or less go away. Not entirely,
00:41:51 but we could then probably reform
00:41:53 the Constitution. We could probably make
00:41:55 Canada work without Quebec. Well, perhaps. 0.99
00:41:57 Leaving would strengthen Canada. That chunk
00:41:59 The problem with Quebec is we're going down a rabbit hole, you know, but it is a geographic problem.
00:42:04 They have an interest when you free trade, but the country such where the Maritimes are subtly isolated and then we've got some other issues to deal with.
00:42:12 Yeah, but they're not exactly going to be a Danzig corridor.
00:42:15 Like, I doubt they're going to arm it.
00:42:16 No.
00:42:17 To stop us from rolling through.
00:42:19 The Nufi's are rolling up from that. 1.00
00:42:21 The Nufi's coming from East Russia. 1.00
00:42:23 No, I think they, it would be in everyone's interest if Quebec left.
00:42:27 Quebec needs to trade with Canada.
00:42:30 I think we'd probably come to some kind of
00:42:32 anything other than pipelines
00:42:33 we could probably get through.
00:42:35 Actually, we might have more leverage to get pipelines through Quebec
00:42:38 at that point. You won't hear an argument out of me.
00:42:40 We're pretty much converted on this.
00:42:43 The question is whether we should
00:42:45 even waste much time talking about the
00:42:47 People's Party. I mean, a lot of people
00:42:49 like Bernie. He's charming his
00:42:51 old get-out, charming
00:42:52 wallpaper off the walls, but
00:42:55 you know, nobody's voting for him.
00:42:58 Was it less than 1%
00:42:59 in the federal election?
00:43:01 Yeah. I mean, they had their high point
00:43:03 during COVID.
00:43:06 Because there was a very real
00:43:07 reason for it. They were the
00:43:09 only party not in on vaccine
00:43:11 passports. Like Aaron O'Toole ran on
00:43:13 pro-vaccine passport,
00:43:15 pro-carbon tax, all of
00:43:17 these things. There was a real purpose for the PPC
00:43:19 then. Polyev
00:43:21 largely changed that. But
00:43:23 I think the big risk for the
00:43:25 Federal Conservative Party
00:43:27 now is on immigration, and
00:43:28 their language is getting
00:43:31 tougher on it, but I
00:43:33 think people are... I think
00:43:35 the Canadian public in general, and Conservative voters
00:43:37 in particular, are well to the right
00:43:39 of the Conservative Party on
00:43:41 immigration right now. I think if the PPC
00:43:43 is to get traction on any major
00:43:45 issue and try to have some life
00:43:47 come back into it, it's going to be on that.
00:43:49 It could be one for them to know, and yeah.
00:43:51 Okay, well, let's put a pin in it and go to our parting shots.
00:43:56 Start with Corey today.
00:43:57 Sure, the Toronto International Film Festival, and it's a big one.
00:44:00 It's worldwide known with all those movies coming out,
00:44:03 but they had a documentary that, well, documented an Israeli man
00:44:08 saving his family from Hamas on October 7th,
00:44:11 and they've booted that documentary from the festival.
00:44:13 Of course, they won't show it, but the weakness of their excuse
00:44:17 in kicking that out is that it used a bunch of the footage
00:44:20 that Hamas had taken, you know, with their 0.96
00:44:22 body cams while they were on their orgy of murder 0.98
00:44:24 and rape. And the 1.00
00:44:26 documentarian hadn't gotten permission from
00:44:28 Hamas to use the footage. Oh, so it was copyright! 0.69
00:44:31 Yeah!
00:44:34 I wish I was making this up.
00:44:36 You've got to be... I didn't see that.
00:44:38 So that's when their excuse
00:44:39 has been... So, I mean, you know,
00:44:42 the reality, they didn't want to show it in Israel's
00:44:44 sympathetic documentary, but that was the best
00:44:46 excuse they could find for kicking it out,
00:44:47 is the terrorist group didn't give us
00:44:50 permission to use the footage they took while
00:44:52 they were committing terrorism and shared on social
00:44:54 media. Well, at least they didn't say
00:44:56 it was a safety issue. No, no, good.
00:44:58 Fair enough. They changed the narrative.
00:45:00 That
00:45:00 is gloriously Canadian.
00:45:05 Gloriously Canadian.
00:45:06 They didn't get copyright
00:45:08 from Hamas. Yeah.
00:45:10 I'll top that. I do all I can't.
00:45:12 I mean, that's it.
00:45:13 You dug that when I brought a
00:45:16 court. I did think, though, it
00:45:18 was very significant
00:45:19 of what Parks Canada did this week.
00:45:22 A couple of weeks ago, they kicked Sean Fucht,
00:45:25 the American Christian rocker, off a Parks Canada site
00:45:30 saying that he didn't conform to their values.
00:45:33 They had values, you know.
00:45:35 Well, wasn't that nice?
00:45:37 Well, yesterday, I think it was,
00:45:40 there was the unveiling of a plaque
00:45:43 in a Manitoba residential school.
00:45:47 And Parks Canada, in pursuit of its values, has been very strong.
00:45:51 They'll say, oh, you know, the residential school system was cultural genocide.
00:45:55 And they would put that on the plaques when they were designating some of these schools as historic sites.
00:46:01 Well, let's just say that they really do have values.
00:46:05 What are we to make of the fact that on this one, there was no reference to cultural genocide?
00:46:10 Is Parks Canada, which takes his marching orders directly from the federal government, starting to go, I think, more moderate view of what the residential school was, were about, could it be anything to do with the fact that Mr. Carney's father actually ran a residential school in the North Estuary?
00:46:32 There's no evidence that he was a genocidal.
00:46:35 No, no.
00:46:35 There's no evidence.
00:46:36 And was a very reputable public administrator.
00:46:39 I love the idea that maybe some truth will start sneaking back into that story.
00:46:45 Here's to hope.
00:46:45 But Parks Canada, whoa.
00:46:48 Yeah.
00:46:49 All right.
00:46:51 Well, I want to give tip of the hat, wake of the finger here for China. 1.00
00:46:58 um china not uh not a state which i'm normally sympathetic with but uh they did what you would
00:47:09 naturally expect there was already a big tariff on canadian canola in retaliation for canadian
00:47:16 tariffs against chinese-made electric vehicles this was designed to artificially prof up
00:47:22 Ontario's
00:47:24 mega-subsidized
00:47:26 EV industry. You can get it going.
00:47:29 Kind of like what Trump's doing for the American
00:47:30 oil industry. Yes. But
00:47:32 ever since Trump pulled the
00:47:34 EV mandates and subsidies in the States,
00:47:37 it has pretty much flat-lined
00:47:39 the whole industry.
00:47:40 Very few people
00:47:42 actually want EVs, unless you have
00:47:44 small little drives around a city or something.
00:47:47 Maybe then. But for
00:47:48 huge portions of people who live in a place like North
00:47:50 America, it's wildly impractical.
00:47:52 especially in canada where it's cold batteries don't do too well uh the whole industry is
00:47:57 cratering anyway the liberals have stood by their ev tariffs on chinese vehicles and the chinese
00:48:03 have just increased by like 76 78 76 76 uh percent on top of the 100 that was already there
00:48:11 against canadian canola so and who does that primarily affect uh i don't think ev manufacturers
00:48:19 in Ontario are also in the canola business, it affects primarily Western farmers in Alberta
00:48:25 and Saskatchewan and Manitoba, who have one of the biggest market in the world, effectively
00:48:33 completely closed to them now. And that's all done to prop up Ontario's, I can't even say
00:48:40 zombie because zombie implies was actually alive at some point. It's never been alive.
00:48:44 It never will be alive.
00:48:46 Propping up Ontario's Frankenstein.
00:48:49 That's probably better analogy.
00:48:51 Frankenstein EV industry.
00:48:53 So I'm just glad that we could do our part
00:48:56 for Ontario's subsidized EV industry.
00:49:01 We're just doing our part for the country
00:49:02 because we never do.
00:49:04 All right, Corey, Nigel, thank you very much.
00:49:09 Always a pleasure.
00:49:09 Hopefully we have Erica back next week. 0.99
00:49:11 I thank all of you for joining us today on The Pipeline.
00:49:15 Remember, we are supported by people like you.
00:49:18 We, to keep doing the work we're doing as Western Canada's largest independent media outlet,
00:49:28 we need you to support us by becoming a member.
00:49:31 Go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:49:33 Click on subscribe.
00:49:34 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content,
00:49:39 getting past the paywall and supporting the work that we do.
00:49:42 Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:49:44 God bless.
00:50:09 You