Western Standard - November 19, 2026


Why your next car could cost $12,000 more

Danielle Smith Defends the UCP's Independence Pledge Carney Talks Energy—But Where Are the Pipelines?

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

178.61

Word count

3,789

Sentence count

111


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Because of U.S. tariffs, the cost of everything is going up, including vehicles in Canada. So it's
00:00:04 estimated that U.S. tariffs are increasing new vehicle prices anywhere from $4,000 to $12,000.
00:00:10 And the reason for that is because that's on average. Yeah. The Americans are tariffing
00:00:15 everything, right? It's not just vehicles. They're tariffing components, parts, steel, aluminum.
00:00:19 And because we operate in this integrated North American supply chain, when they put tariffs
00:00:24 on products, tariffs or taxes, ultimately it raises the cost of production, which means that
00:00:29 consumers pay more. I'm joined with Brian Kingston, the President and CEO of the Canadian Vehicles
00:00:43 Manufacturers Association, to discuss the current affairs and future of Canada's auto manufacturing
00:00:49 industry. Brian, thank you very much for the time to speak to the Western Standard today.
00:00:54 Yeah, thanks for having me on. I appreciate it.
00:00:55 There is this news of the slant disclosure. What do you make of current state of affairs in terms of jobs and job losses?
00:01:03 The auto industry is under great pressure because of U.S. tariffs right now.
00:01:08 The total tariff bill on Canadian auto manufacturers is in excess of $7 billion.
00:01:13 And so manufacturers are trying to find a way to continue to operate, continue to build 1.3 million vehicles a year in light of those challenges.
00:01:22 And so we've seen companies that in some instances have had to either slow some production, retooling underway, but until we get those macroeconomic factors right, it will continue to be a really tough environment for building cars in Canada.
00:01:37 so there is some you could say a mixture of news i do want to highlight potentially some good news
00:01:45 on one front is honda announced their expansion of their facility i believe that's in alliston
00:01:50 ontario um in terms of of course the crv hybrid um at the crv as a consumer i know it's perhaps
00:01:59 the second most popular suv in the subcompact crossover area but i mean second only to the
00:02:07 RAV4, of course, but if such a very high-performing market vehicle is seeing expansion, but everywhere
00:02:13 else is seeing shrink closures and downsizing, what does that really mean?
00:02:20 Yeah, well, look, the basis of this industry, and it's been this way since really the auto
00:02:25 pack, so you're talking about over 60 years, we've integrated our market with the United
00:02:29 States.
00:02:30 And so what that means is that 90% of the vehicles that we built here go to the United
00:02:35 States.
00:02:36 So every single plant, regardless of what it's building, some of that production will stay in Canada for the smaller Canadian market.
00:02:43 Canadians buy about 2 million vehicles a year, and then the majority of that production will go to the United States.
00:02:49 So regardless of what a company is building in this country, they need U.S. access or it doesn't make commercial sense.
00:02:56 And that's why we've been making the case to the government to get to the negotiating table, find a mutually beneficial trade agreement that restores our access into the U.S. market, because Canada, while it's a sizable market, it's not big enough to justify five global manufacturers and the plants that they have here.
00:03:14 a typical auto plant will build about 200 to 300 000 vehicles a year there's no single model in
00:03:20 canada that sells in those volumes so that's why you need that access to other markets so that you
00:03:26 can actually justify the manufacturing scale that we have here so that is the number one priority
00:03:31 for all manufacturers is get that access restored so that we can continue to build the 1.3 million
00:03:37 vehicles or more that we do in canada right now i want to speak from the consumer buying angle here
00:03:43 because we are mentioning new vehicles that are being produced of course so on the new vehicle
00:03:48 end i mean with a few exceptions in north america and united states being the bigger market here
00:03:54 a lot of lot of dealerships have plenty of used uh sorry of new vehicle units on the lot still
00:04:02 that are just occurring costs and markoffs are happening but the demand just doesn't seem to be
00:04:08 there in certain classes in certain areas the rav4 again is a unique exception because people
00:04:12 are waiting months and months and months to get one depending on what area they are um so what
00:04:18 do you make of the effect of just the current market state from the consumer perspective on
00:04:23 new vehicles that could have any effect i know it's maybe a shorter term but just inform me about
00:04:28 that situation as well yeah well there's a couple things going on first of all because of us tariffs
00:04:34 the cost of everything is going up including vehicles in canada so it's estimated that u.s
00:04:39 tariffs are increasing new vehicle prices anywhere from four thousand to twelve thousand dollars and
00:04:44 the reason for that is because that's on average yeah the americans are terrifying everything
00:04:49 right it's not just vehicles they're terrifying components parts steel aluminum and because we
00:04:53 operate in this integrated north american supply chain when they put tariffs on products tariffs
00:04:59 or taxes ultimately it raises the cost of production which means that consumers pay more
00:05:03 Now, despite those challenges in the Canadian market, vehicle sales are still showing signs
00:05:11 of strength. And so we're on track through this year to be about 1.91 million vehicle sales,
00:05:18 and that'll be consistent through 2027. So those are good sales figures. We're not seeing a big
00:05:24 contraction of the market and inventories are right at healthy levels, what you would expect
00:05:30 with with any auto dealer now some models of course depending on the model and where the
00:05:36 the market is some models will be more popular and therefore inventories will be tighter and others
00:05:41 not so much but that's really just you know that depends on the market and what consumers want in
00:05:45 that part of the country but overall the market has been relatively robust despite all of the
00:05:51 challenges that we're seeing so just to get back to that fact i personally went a little bit blown
00:05:57 away you mentioned four to five thousand dollars is that like msrp in terms of out the door what
00:06:03 people are paying more under the current tariff regime four to twelve thousand dollars is the
00:06:09 estimate yeah because of u.s tariffs so looking at for example a compact sedan or a scv in the
00:06:16 beginner middle class and crv rav4 you're looking at four thousand couple thousand dollars overall
00:06:22 in cost difference yeah well just to give you a sense of uh of the total cost here and why it
00:06:28 ultimately is putting uh pressure on manufacturers and then consumer prices the americans have
00:06:33 collected 52 billion dollars us dollars in total tariffs on finished vehicles and auto parts that's
00:06:41 in just the past year and a half since they implemented in section 232 tariffs so uh this is
00:06:46 you know akin to the largest tax hike that we've seen in in decades in the united states and of
00:06:52 And of course, this is putting raising costs on manufacturers across North America and therefore raising vehicle prices.
00:06:59 So $52 billion, of course, that money is mostly coming out of the pockets of American consumers.
00:07:04 You can imagine since companies are paying them, rising their prices on parts and autos.
00:07:09 And then, of course, the consumers at the door are paying more.
00:07:13 But in terms of that $52 billion figure, is it kind of convincing, in your view, politically speaking,
00:07:19 from the american angle to keep these auto tariffs they steal tariffs on if you can indeed raise
00:07:24 money for things like subsidies or government revenue going to other areas that are key that
00:07:28 can affect the industry even on a temporary basis because as we know uh politicians tend to think
00:07:33 in two to four year intervals so is there any defense from that from their angle you think or
00:07:37 you think they're really just uh screwing no i think uh yeah no i i think i think the midterms
00:07:43 are probably your your best recent evidence of the impact of tariffs i mean tariffs initially
00:07:48 when they were introduced by the Trump administration, didn't cause a significant
00:07:52 amount of blowback because they take time for it to pass on. But now that they've been in place for
00:07:57 almost two years now, consumers are feeling it. And so much so that people were talking about
00:08:04 terrorists, talking about Canada in the context of the midterms, which is rare. Typically trade
00:08:09 policy doesn't factor in heavily into U.S. electoral cycles. So I think people are starting
00:08:15 to feel the pain. And they're starting to wonder why they are having to pay extra to import these
00:08:21 products that they didn't have to pay for in the past. Now, from a government perspective,
00:08:25 it's generating a lot of revenue for the U.S. Treasury. And that's always the challenge,
00:08:30 right? If they were to get rid of those tariffs, what would they replace it with? How would they
00:08:33 find other sources of revenue? But look, the voters in charge here. And eventually,
00:08:38 if they feel like they're paying too much and they're not seeing the benefits of this,
00:08:41 then I think you'll see a change in stance in the States.
00:08:45 A lot of cars that I've been seeing in the last couple of years look very
00:08:48 different than their same counterparts from 10 years ago,
00:08:51 from integrated dashboards to a greater emphasis on digital technology to
00:08:56 different kinds of engines, cylinder disactivation is more common,
00:09:00 EV, mild hybrids, hybrids.
00:09:03 Those cars weigh and are built differently.
00:09:07 In terms of our industry expertise, given that 60 year history,
00:09:11 kind of what are we prepared for we're not prepared for from an industrial angle in terms of
00:09:16 the future of vehicles moving more to evs mild hybrids hybrid systems are we ready for that
00:09:23 transition in terms of what the market is going to be demanding yeah i think the biggest uh
00:09:29 transformation we're seeing right now in auto is is to electrification as well as connected vehicles
00:09:34 i mean if you compare a vehicle on the road today to something even 10 years ago the amount of
00:09:38 technology that's available in the dashboard is phenomenal. In terms of preparedness for that,
00:09:44 well, the big challenge with electrification, and we saw this play out in Canada. Remember,
00:09:48 the federal government set a 100% EV target by 2035 a couple of years ago. That was clearly not
00:09:56 going to be met, and we saw sales collapse last year to below 8%, recovered a little bit to 11%,
00:10:03 but that'll be the big challenge manufacturers are electrifying we're seeing more and more EV
00:10:08 product but we're still not at a point where you have mass demand to support some of these ambitious
00:10:13 targets and it's a number of reasons but uh you know we've surveyed Canadians regularly on this
00:10:19 first of all EV technology is still more expensive price is coming down but it still is more expensive
00:10:24 so until you get price parity that will remain a challenge for a lot of families and households
00:10:29 and secondly uh canada's big and it's cold so people drive a lot and they drive in cold weather
00:10:35 batteries still have performance issues in extreme cold weather so until we address the
00:10:40 charging infrastructure issue battery performance needs to improve getting to mass adoption as in
00:10:46 you know 60 plus levels of uptake will be a real issue so we do have some readiness challenges
00:10:53 there on the horizon good news is these are all solvable problems but ultimately for a consumer
00:10:58 to switch to a new technology it has to be cheaper it's got to be better and we haven't
00:11:02 achieved that yet with electrification so i think in terms of battery production i think
00:11:08 perhaps would i be wrong in saying that the real short-term feature is the hybrid angle because
00:11:14 that's where a lot of high-performing suvs that have strong reliable battery systems are doing
00:11:20 very well and the market is i mean people are going after these these these suvs the crvs the
00:11:25 the RAV4s. I know the CX-5, which is one of the top six selling SUVs in Canada, will have a new
00:11:32 Mazda-engineered hybrid system next year. And a few other manufacturers have gone into that angle
00:11:37 as well. So do you think hybrids are really kind of the short to longer term feature before we ever
00:11:43 get to that full EV zero emission vehicle target whenever that year is set down the line?
00:11:50 Yeah, I think, look, hybrids are a transition technology. What we find is that once people
00:11:54 go to electric, they stay electric. But for those that aren't willing to make the switch,
00:11:58 sometimes a hybrid is a nice interim step. So I think it's something that you'll see in the
00:12:02 short to medium term. You won't see it over the long term. Where hybrid technology makes sense
00:12:08 on a longer term horizon is more in the pickup truck segment where you have to do a lot of towing.
00:12:13 So we're seeing some really innovative technologies there where companies are introducing variations
00:12:19 of hybrid engines, which give you the benefit of having an electric motor, reduce your fuel
00:12:23 consumption but still allow you to have the range necessary when you're towing for example
00:12:29 so i think we're going to see a mix of technologies but this is the point you can't mandate
00:12:34 ev sales because we don't know which technology will be most compelling to consumers
00:12:39 the objective shouldn't be on picking a specific technology it should be about emissions reduction
00:12:44 we all agree that we need to reduce emissions of the vehicle fleet so how do you do that in
00:12:49 the most efficient way possible and it's going to be a range of technologies hybrids plug-in hybrids
00:12:53 more efficient gas-powered engines and electric vehicles so what actually saves the Brampton plant
00:13:00 or gives life to jobs in that area in the near future if things can go in an ideal fashion
00:13:06 because again there are mortgage paying jobs in the line of course unions and other people have
00:13:11 been speaking up concerned about the well-being of those in Brampton but also at other facilities
00:13:17 in ontario since ontario hosts canada's auto industry um what i mean we talked about the
00:13:23 tariffs already any other specific industry related items that are causing this job less
00:13:29 pressure on for example stelantis and brampton and other facilities that have closed or have
00:13:34 downsized in the recent history yeah so there's a few things that are within our control that
00:13:41 we could act on and should act on immediately so tariffs of course that's the big cost that
00:13:45 that requires negotiation with the Americans. Outside of that, we need to make Canada ultra
00:13:50 competitive for automotive manufacturing. So one issue, let's get our environmental
00:13:55 regulatory environment right. I mentioned the EV mandate that federally is being repealed.
00:14:00 We have extremely stringent emissions targets that are still very costly for industry.
00:14:04 We have EV mandates in BC and Quebec that need to be fixed because they're putting costs on
00:14:10 manufacturers. You have to view this through the perspective of a global company. Why would a
00:14:16 global company invest and build cars in Canada when the cost of doing so here is so high? They
00:14:21 could service the Canadian market using purely imports. And so that's what we need to adjust
00:14:26 here and make sure that our regulatory environment is second to none. And then secondly, the
00:14:32 government's opening the market to China and that's extremely challenging right now for
00:14:36 manufacturers you can't compete with china because they are not playing on the same level playing
00:14:43 field they're heavily subsidized they have a whole different standard of environmental and labor
00:14:48 regulations which are far below what a manufacturer in canada has to comply with so we're giving
00:14:54 market share to non-market actors so i think if we manage some of those issues we can make canada
00:14:59 more competitive for manufacturing while of course dealing with the u.s tariff issue what do you
00:15:05 think is going to happen in terms of the chinese vehicle because i i i heard you know that 40 000
00:15:10 49 000 figure doesn't necessarily involve purely byd and other chinese companies and also can
00:15:16 involve other companies that are manufacturing in china like tesla at a cheaper rate and importing
00:15:21 to canada with vehicles that are relatively familiar to the canadian market already in the
00:15:25 electric vehicle sector uh but if byd actually puts its wheels on the ground uh gets a few
00:15:30 vehicles approved by the regulatory bodies and are starting to send out cars to consumers what
00:15:36 kind of impact you think that would have if they had even half of that 49 000 figure which i think
00:15:41 is still relatively ambitious for the short term yeah so the 49 000 is a relatively small amount
00:15:48 when you compare it to the overall vehicle sales in canada it's around three percent but it's about
00:15:53 one-third of the ev market so it's not insignificant uh right now the quota is being filled largely
00:15:58 by Tesla. They built Model 3s in Shanghai, and so they're using that plant to service the Canadian
00:16:04 market. But we do expect some other Chinese OEMs to receive certification very soon, and we'll
00:16:12 start to see those vehicles on the road for sale here probably in the first quarter, second quarter
00:16:17 of 2027. So the question is really, is this the Trojan horse for other Chinese vehicles? We've
00:16:24 seen this strategy in europe and the uk in particular start with evs roll out a dealership
00:16:29 network but then bring in gas-powered vehicles hybrids plug-in hybrids which don't fall under
00:16:35 the quota so that will be something that we need to watch the impacts could be quite severe if you
00:16:41 look at the european example they open the door too wide to china and the european auto industry
00:16:48 has been devastated right now. 104,000 jobs lost in the past two years. In Germany,
00:16:54 first six months of this year, 42,000 jobs have been lost in the auto sector. Big manufacturers
00:17:00 like Mercedes just announced that they won't be investing any further in Germany as they try and
00:17:05 manage this situation. So we have to be very careful. What the government has done is a
00:17:09 relatively small quota, but we've seen how the Chinese play this. They've got their foot in the
00:17:13 door and they're now going to try and uh blast that door as wide open as possible to gain more
00:17:19 market access at the expense of domestic manufacturers perhaps one of the more rapidly
00:17:23 growing um you know marketplaces for for example byd and i think their flagship vehicle that's
00:17:31 popular down south of this continent in south america would be their byd dolphin model which
00:17:37 comes down relatively even cheaper than uh the average hatchback comparable in brazil that's
00:17:42 even with high import tariffs in Brazil remains in China, but of course, you know, the greater
00:17:47 amount of them are imported overall. We haven't seen them on our streets, and likely the kinds
00:17:51 of vehicles will come down to a very different kind of market. So I imagine larger Sudans and
00:17:56 of course SUVs would be some of the vehicles that a company like BYD would want to, you know,
00:18:02 bring to Canada in order to compete in that vehicle space. You mentioned that they can,
00:18:06 you know, 49,000 can go up to one third of electric vehicles sold. So like I said, if they
00:18:11 got even close to half of those permits to bring the, you know, vehicles at tariff reduced
00:18:18 quotas, kind of what really impacts do you see? Because what I'm really trying to understand
00:18:24 here is, you know, obviously Tesla's well-established, well-trusted as a brand, doesn't have as
00:18:29 much of the, you know, overarching physical scrutiny as, for example, Chinese EVs have.
00:18:34 As you know, Ontario Premier Doug Ford and others have also mentioned how there's spying,
00:18:38 espionage, security, you know, concern around Chinese-made EVs, given the technological
00:18:44 nature. So, you know, if Canadians do start getting a little bit attracted by the lower
00:18:49 price points, I think probably the low $30,000 is what we expect in Canadian dollars out the door
00:18:53 with some of these vehicles. Still relatively much, much cheaper than a Tesla from the cheapest,
00:18:58 I think it was Model 3. What kind of impact do you see if Canadians actually do start buying up
00:19:04 those vehicles in, let's say, $10,000, $15,000, $20,000 in the next couple of years?
00:19:10 Yeah, look, it really depends on what the quota holds at. Does China try and force a larger
00:19:16 amount of quota? And do the Chinese companies bring gas-powered vehicles in outside of the
00:19:20 quota? That's the big question. If you look at markets like Europe, Chinese automakers are on
00:19:25 route for 20% market share, and it's expected that that will grow even further. From an economic
00:19:31 security, cybersecurity perspective, really the federal government is the best and most
00:19:38 authoritative voice on what those risks are. But when the government put in place the tariff on
00:19:45 Chinese EVs two years ago, they were quite explicit in saying that these connected vehicles
00:19:52 are posing significant risks to the privacy of Canadians, their data, and to Canada's national
00:19:59 security interests. So as a consumer, you have to make that decision. Do you want to purchase
00:20:04 that vehicle and not know how your data is going to be handled? I'll give you an example. At Norway,
00:20:11 they have taken a NIO vehicle, Chinese EV. This was done at a university where they tried to
00:20:17 study the impact of the data gathered in that vehicle. Ninety percent of the data that's
00:20:22 gathered is going back to China, to servers in China. So we have to put guardrails around them.
00:20:28 if we if the government deems this to be a security threat and a cyber security threat
00:20:33 to Canadians then we should be putting in place some sort of legislative framework some sort of
00:20:39 regulations dictating how that information is handled and where it is kept just like what
00:20:45 auto manufacturers here now have to comply with there are very strict rules around privacy which
00:20:50 they abide by so China shouldn't get a free pass and something that Canadians want to think about
00:20:55 before they purchase any of those vehicles ryan thank you so much for your time today
00:21:03 thanks for having me great to chat