Western Standard - August 27, 2025


Will Alberta's new insurance model cost more than it pays?

Topics
Mentioned
Exposing the Residential School Grave Hoaxes: Government Funds & Media Missteps Where the f*** is Nenshi’s NDP?!

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

188.08

Word count

2,261

Sentence count

149


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Bill 47, also known as the Care First Insurance System, which will be implemented by 2027, will regulate Albertans' right to sue at-fault drivers, having to instead answer to a tribunal funded by the insurance industry and appointed by the government. This will mean that someone injured in an accident will lose their rights to sue and seek compensation should they be injured by a bad driver.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day everyone. My name is Leah Muschett. I am a reporter here at the Western Standard.
00:00:05 Today we're going to be talking about Bill 47, also known as the Care First Insurance
00:00:10 System, which will be implemented by 2027. This system will regulate Albertans' right to sue
00:00:17 at-fault drivers, having to instead answer to a tribunal funded by the insurance industry and
00:00:23 appointed by the government. How will Albertans be impacted, you may ask? Well, today I have Ricky
00:00:28 Bega here with me, CEO and Managing Partner at Crash Lawyers, who will help me answer some of
00:00:34 these questions as well as others. Ricky, what will you, what do you think will be the biggest
00:00:39 impact on Albertans if this system were to be implemented? Well, good afternoon Leah. Thank
00:00:45 you very much for having me. So Care First is a no-fault system which will be delivered by a
00:00:50 private insurance company. This will mean that someone injured in an accident will lose their
00:00:55 rights to sue and seek compensation should they be injured by a bad driver. There will be zero
00:00:59 accountability for bad drivers causing us harm and all the power under the Care First system will
00:01:05 be on behalf of auto insurance companies. Okay, well I guess following that, how is like the current
00:01:14 system Alberta different from the All Care system and what is like the market like right now in Alberta
00:01:20 for auto insurance? Yeah, so I think you probably mean the Care First system. So the current system
00:01:27 is basically a tort system which means if someone wrongs you and causes you injury, you have the
00:01:32 right to seek compensation against them or sue them to make you whole. Things like pain and suffering,
00:01:38 loss of income, future cost of care are all things under the current system we're able to obtain for
00:01:43 our clients. And under the new system, the Care First system, it's going to be a private insurance
00:01:48 company that will get to decide if you get to be, if you get any compensation at all,
00:01:53 how much treatment you get and how long you get the treatment for. So essentially the insurance
00:01:57 company will get to be the judge, jury and executioner on how Albertans claims are ran.
00:02:02 And, you know, I think everyone can say, you know, if you ever had an experience with insurance,
00:02:07 you know, you'll note that they love accepting premiums month over month, but the second that they need to
00:02:12 pay out or you need them for something, they're nowhere to be found. So it's a bad system for Albertans.
00:02:17 Hmm. Okay. Well, the next question I would have for you then is,
00:02:22 what is the, like, why is the provincial government trying to do this system? And
00:02:28 is it, like, will it be effective? Is there examples in other provinces of implementing this?
00:02:34 And was it?
00:02:35 Well, that's a good question. Well, you know, I think to speak about the last question there, you
00:02:40 mentioned, you know, how is the market really like for auto insurance companies? And the best way I can
00:02:45 describe it is that they're thriving. There's a falsity going around that that insurance companies
00:02:50 are leaving Alberta, and that they're hurting and that they need help. But this is so far from the
00:02:54 truth. You know, I asked anyone, why is it that Saskatchewan General Insurance, which is a government
00:03:00 run insurance company from Saskatchewan, it's a no fault province as well, they have elected to come
00:03:06 to Alberta since 2006 to sell premiums, and have never left. You know, I tell anyone that if it
00:03:12 was so bad, why would a no fault province insure come to our province to sell policies? You know,
00:03:18 I also say that, you know, if the state of affairs are so bad, in May of 2027,
00:03:24 DFINITY Insurance bought travellers insurance for $3.3 billion. Is it because they want to lose money?
00:03:32 I don't think so. Hmm. Okay, yeah. Interesting. Then, uh, then the touch on basically that,
00:03:39 you know, your, your, your all of question, which was, you know, why is the provincial government
00:03:42 trying to do this with our system? Um, I think it's simple. They're, they're trying to bring in
00:03:46 a no fault system where, you know, Albertans rights to their own property will be lost. Um,
00:03:51 they were initially telling us that they want to bring in this new system, because it will come with
00:03:55 savings of up to $400 a year for the average Albertan. Um, but we realize now that that's
00:04:01 false, you know, Aaron Sutherland, who's the vice president of the Insurance Bureau of Canada,
00:04:06 has publicly come out and said that this plan will save no money for Albertans.
00:04:10 So now Albertans are essentially stuck with a lose, lose, lose, uh, situation where we're losing our
00:04:16 rights. Insurance cream room is going to go higher. And now there's no savings to be had at all.
00:04:20 It really begs the question why the UCP is doing this in the first place. Um, you know,
00:04:25 I think there's also a ton of history from, from other provinces and states in America that have
00:04:29 implemented no fault insurance. It is very, very short term savings. Um, as we know, an obliteration
00:04:35 of, of our rights, uh, only for premiums to go back up. So it's just, it's just a bad plan altogether.
00:04:41 Okay, Ricky. So another question I have for you is, are there similar systems in place in other
00:04:47 provinces and were they at all effective? Yeah. So, uh, Saskatchewan and then Manitoba both
00:04:54 have, uh, no fault systems as well. Uh, BC's no fault system, I think is probably the one that was
00:05:00 the most newly implemented in this country. Um, and I, and I tell everyone, all you got to do
00:05:05 just Google no fault insurance, British Columbia. Uh, you will see hundreds, if not thousands of
00:05:11 horror stories coming out of that province. Uh, in BC, the no fault system, they called it enhanced
00:05:17 care in Alberta. They're calling it care first, but they're all fancy terms for the same awful policy
00:05:23 of no fault insurance. Okay. Yeah. It makes sense. Um, okay. The next question I have for you then,
00:05:30 it sounds from what you're saying, like kind of takes away, um, Albertans rights in a way.
00:05:39 So elaborate further on that. Is that the case? Yes. So for 99.9% of people, their rights will be taken
00:05:47 away. You know, the government is trying to slide this, this little unique wording into the
00:05:52 legislation, which says that, you know, someone will still retain the right to sue only if the
00:05:59 at fault driver is convicted of the criminal offense. And this is, if you really think about
00:06:03 it, a very odd condition. Um, you know, this threshold has no connection to how badly you hurt.
00:06:10 If you're paralyzed, for example, by a distracted driver who wasn't charged, you're out of luck.
00:06:15 You're not, you're not getting any compensation and your rights are gone. But if you suffer a
00:06:19 minor scratch on your hand in a DUI, for example, in the person's charge, then you might retain some
00:06:24 rights. You know, victims are compensated, not based on their injuries, but on whether the offender
00:06:29 faces charges. You know, the example I can give you is, is what happens in the very snow months,
00:06:34 uh, the snowy months, sorry, of Alberta. There's, there's hundreds of accidents a day.
00:06:38 You're telling me that just because a cop doesn't show up to the scene, to the accident and issue a
00:06:42 ticket, my right to see compensation from a bad driver are gone. Um, it doesn't make sense.
00:06:47 Hmm. All right. Okay. Well, um, so will this all, not all care, but, um, anyways,
00:06:57 will this system bypass, like, how did it bypass, like, cause it's in a tribunal now,
00:07:03 like it'll be answering to like a private tribunal. So how did it like bypass, like,
00:07:08 how is this allowed so easily to be implemented? Basically is my question.
00:07:13 Yeah, well, you know, uh, I'm not a constitutional lawyer, so I can't really comment on the legality
00:07:18 of what the government is doing, but I can say that it is, you know, something that's morally wrong
00:07:22 and an unconservant methodology. Um, you know, every province which has adopted no-fault insurance is
00:07:28 usually adopted when a socialist party is in power. You know, I, I guess our government can make this
00:07:33 change so easily because they have a majority government and they can put through whatever plan they want,
00:07:37 no matter how good, bad, um, they can just push through whatever they like. If you look at the
00:07:42 legislation bill 47 itself, um, it says, you know, it says that you're not allowed to go to court.
00:07:48 You'd have to go through their care first tribunal. That tribunal does not have to follow normal court
00:07:54 rules, court processes, and the decision cannot be reviewed or reversed in court. Um, you know,
00:08:00 I think there's, there's already, you know, an article that came out that says British Columbia has a
00:08:05 similar tribunal and 91% of the time that tribunal just sides with the insurance company. So,
00:08:12 you know, a regular Joe would have to appeal the tribunal's decision and come up with all
00:08:17 the paperwork and, and, and try to go through this tribunal without a lawyer's help. And that's why
00:08:22 they lose 91% of the time in British Columbia. So, um, it's just unfair. And in, you know, I feel like
00:08:29 they need to backtrack what they're not. So, um, um, as you were saying, like, uh, those cases in
00:08:34 British Columbia, so you like in the text that you gave me, you were talking about how like it's
00:08:41 funded, it's going to be funded by the insurance companies, like the tribe, you know, so that's the
00:08:46 case also in British Columbia, like it's funded by the insurance companies as well.
00:08:51 Uh, correct. So British Columbia is a, is a, it's a public insurance company, which is the ICBC.
00:08:58 So British, that's a, that's a public insurance company. Uh, you know, if anything, Alberta's
00:09:03 system that they're trying to implement is worse because it's a private for-profit insurance company
00:09:09 that's going to get to be the judge, jury and execution on how your claim is read.
00:09:13 So, you know, obviously private insurance companies care about the dollars and cents.
00:09:17 They care about their shareholders. They care about profits. They will have every reason to cut you off
00:09:22 before you're, before you're healed. They'll have every reason to deny your treatment.
00:09:26 And, um, you know, because they have exclusively taken, you know, your, your rights to counsel out
00:09:31 of the system, you'll have no one in your court to fight for you. You know, I, the best example
00:09:36 I can give you is, is I currently have a client who was a doctor who's an ophthalmologist and within a
00:09:42 year, he was cut off by the insurance company. Luckily he had need to fight for him, fight for
00:09:47 his rights. And I was able to get his treatment reopened up again or opened up again, I should say.
00:09:53 And, um, if the second you take counsel and lawyers out of the picture, then it's just going to be,
00:09:57 you know, regular joke going against a billion dollar, uh, insurance companies and billion
00:10:01 dollar lawyers of the insurance company, which is just a, it's an unfair balance of power.
00:10:05 Hmm. Okay. Yeah. So basically what you're saying, what I got is it might be worse. Yeah. Then like
00:10:12 the BC system, just because now it's even like they have more interest in like saving more money,
00:10:17 their private companies. I anticipate that it will be worse. Yes. Okay. Well, also I have another
00:10:25 question for you, which is if Albertans don't want this to come to pass, what can they do to help stop it?
00:10:32 Yeah. So, um, you know, I'm, I'm a member of a group which is called Albertans Against No Fault
00:10:38 Insurance. Uh, the, the acronym is ANFI, A-A-N-F-I. Uh, there's a website that you can go to, it's called
00:10:45 ANFI.com. And, uh, under that website, you can contact your MLA, voice your concerns. Uh, we have a
00:10:51 petition with close to 6,000 signatures already as well. So just hoping that we can show the government
00:10:57 that this is a bad plan. Albertans don't want it. They want to, they want to keep their rights. Um,
00:11:02 you know, should they be injured by a bad driver in an accident? And, um, you know,
00:11:06 the, the best thing you can do is just, you know, reach out to government, reach out to MLA and tell
00:11:10 them that you don't like this plan. And, and, and I feel like with enough pressure from the regular
00:11:15 public, um, we can make a change of the space. Okay. That makes sense. Well, um, thank you very much.
00:11:22 That's all the questions I have for you today. I really appreciate you being with us today and joining.
00:11:28 And yeah. So if you guys liked this video and you would like more, we have a lot more on our channel,
00:11:35 so you can definitely subscribe to the Western standard YouTube channel, as well as subscribe
00:11:42 to our, obviously our actual website, which is $10 a month. So thank you very much again.
00:11:48 And yeah. Goodbye. Thank you for your time. Bye-bye. Thank you.