Western Standard - November 12, 2024


Will Donald Trump be good for your RIFF?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trump wins, what will the Democrats do? Investigative journalist Sam Cooper on his years of work with the foreign interference issue

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

154.66

Word count

3,802

Sentence count

134


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On November 6th, the Dow Jones Industrial Index surged 1,500 points, closing at a new record high of 43,730. Some question whether this surge was an endorsement of Trump, or a gasp of relief at a clear result in a controversial election. To make matters clear, we speak to Peter Piovic, a Calgary-based senior portfolio manager at Wellington Altus Private Wealth, to find out if the surge was in response to a Trump victory.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 After it was clear that Donald Trump had won the U.S. election last week,
00:00:25 the stock market roared. The Dow Jones Industrial Index surged 1,500 points, closing at a new record
00:00:33 high, 43,730. So regardless of whether they liked Trump or not, a lot of people made a lot of money
00:00:41 on November the 6th. My question then is whether this surge was an endorsement of Trump or a gasp
00:00:48 of gratitude for certainty and a clear result in a controversial election. Here to make matters
00:00:54 clear is peter piovic he is a calgary-based senior portfolio manager at wellington altus private
00:01:02 wealth canada i know what he drives so i think he's qualified to have an opinion what about it
00:01:08 peter does the market love trump well thank you nigel it's great to see you as always and i'm
00:01:15 really pleased to be on your show and uh regarding qualifications although i'm not a political
00:01:20 scientist or pundit i have been managing money for 27 years now and following global macro economic
00:01:28 trends and that's a foundational attribute for us here at wallington altus private wealth so
00:01:34 i hope i can answer all your questions and share some knowledge with your viewers
00:01:38 and great to have you here peter thank you what do you think what happened yesterday
00:01:44 yeah well you know i'll just answer bluntly uh yes so uh short answer is yes although many
00:01:51 see trump as a controversial figure the reality is is that his victory opens the door to a new
00:01:56 economic vision and part of that vision includes a policy of deregulation and that's that's a big
00:02:03 one there and markets appreciate that so as we witnessed this week both pre and post election
00:02:11 with the large gain seen in the North American stock markets, as well as other risk assets such as Bitcoin,
00:02:17 both of which now set at all-time highs.
00:02:20 Now, some people say that it was just the market responding to certainty.
00:02:28 Had Vice President Harris actually won, would we still have had a surge like that?
00:02:34 probably not the the certainty aspect of it does matter certainly I know from our perspective as a
00:02:44 money manager we try not to be let's just say take one side or the other we just need to know
00:02:50 and understand what the policy will be of that administration and as long as we know and
00:02:55 understand what the policy will be we know what to do next in terms of how we align our portfolios
00:03:02 you know, to meet that policy. But what we have here really is an opportunity for the White House
00:03:07 executive branch policy to better align with a more proactive monetary policy from the U.S.
00:03:13 Federal Reserve, which may have a profound impact on risk assets and financial markets
00:03:19 in the coming year. So, yeah, I mean, with Trump as president and his team featuring figures like
00:03:25 rfk jr and elon musk he claims to implement essentially a bold economic agenda which he
00:03:33 dubs uh american system 2.0 and the market likes that it's so you you talk about a bold economic
00:03:41 agenda now there's a graph that we see that shows that the market improved under mr trump's first
00:03:52 administration 2016 to 2020, I think it went up about the notes here, something like 15,000,
00:04:01 so I beg your pardon, yeah, about 15,000 points. But then it went up about that in the Biden
00:04:06 era as well. So does it actually matter who's president?
00:04:11 Historically, if you run the regression analysis, short answer is no. In most cases,
00:04:17 the answer would be no however there can be differences in policy agendas which during
00:04:23 certain market environments or call it macro environments may actually have an impact and
00:04:29 i believe this is one of those times you see we're we're at a time of essentially near unprecedented
00:04:38 fiscal deficit and obviously the highest levels of government debt we've even if adjusted for
00:04:46 for inflation, the highest levels we've seen really
00:04:49 since post-World War II era.
00:04:51 And that's got a lot of people concerned.
00:04:54 So the policy of this next administration
00:04:57 and how they handle that fiscal deficit
00:05:00 will be a huge clue to how money managers such as us
00:05:07 position our portfolios for the coming next four years.
00:05:11 So what are their alternatives?
00:05:14 In other words, what are you going to be looking for that's going to drive your decisions?
00:05:19 Yeah.
00:05:20 So this is going to be essentially very tricky for them to navigate, but it is possible.
00:05:26 It's been done before.
00:05:28 So if you look at the era post-World War II, we had actually a very similar environment
00:05:33 to we had now.
00:05:34 We just had a major war.
00:05:36 There was massive fiscal deficits.
00:05:38 There was massive amounts of debt.
00:05:40 um so um that has to be corrected for uh and if it's not then that can create a fiscal crisis
00:05:47 or massive recessions um so um so what are they gonna what do they need to do in the next coming
00:05:53 years and what are we going to look for is is essentially this they need to bring down the
00:05:57 fiscal deficit first and foremost um it's just too high and it's and it's at a level that's
00:06:03 wholly unsustainable for for the future our future and the future of our children um so um
00:06:11 trump did hire or he plans to hire elon musk as an example um and uh his primary role at least
00:06:18 what's been stated so far from what we know is to cut two trillion dollars um out of the
00:06:24 us fiscal deficit and um and that that in and of itself is going to go a long way uh to uh to give
00:06:32 give the market confidence that there will not be a fiscal crisis in the next coming years.
00:06:38 If that deficit's not cut, then people are going to start to get worried.
00:06:43 Now, that's a huge amount of money to take out of a budget, out of a government plan for expenditure.
00:06:52 Yes, it is.
00:06:54 Yeah. I mean, it was also a huge amount to inject.
00:06:58 but now that the people who were earmarked to receive it have got it they're going to expect
00:07:04 to get it again they've made plans on this basis what are the options say it's Mr. Musk
00:07:13 what options does he have to to do that just take money away and brush everybody off how does it go
00:07:20 No, definitely that's not the way it needs to go. So this is the tricky part that can also be
00:07:29 dangerous. Yes, there's a huge fiscal government deficit. However, that fiscal government deficit
00:07:36 is essentially financing most of the growth that we have in the US currently. So typically,
00:07:42 it's difficult to take that amount of money out of the fiscal deficit and out of the economy
00:07:47 without also impacting growth and if you if you impact growth you could end up with a growth scare
00:07:55 and a growth scare could end up leading to a recession could possibly and so that's one of
00:08:01 the major risks so the plan that they have at least from what we know is uh they they wish to
00:08:08 take it primarily out of um oh what they've used the word fraud essentially so they've actually
00:08:15 used word fraud uh and i'm not i'm not saying that but that's that's the word that they've used
00:08:20 um uh where they believe that there's a lot of um slush in the budget where money is basically
00:08:28 not going to where it's supposed to be going and they're not even quite sure where it's going in
00:08:32 some cases again according to to them um so they believe that they can take their words hundreds
00:08:40 of billions of dollars um out of the deficit simply by uh doing a more careful accounting
00:08:46 of where money is going to so that's kind of step number one step number two
00:08:52 i mean they've also campaigned on the prosperity for peace and uh and to end the wars uh whether
00:08:59 it be in ukraine or the middle east and certainly if um if if that's done uh that uh that could
00:09:07 result in less money essentially um uh being used for those purposes although the uh the the war
00:09:16 money if you want to call it's a bit tricky because a lot of that money actually does stay in
00:09:19 the u.s meaning that you know u.s might create bombs and planes and tanks and so forth and then
00:09:26 ship them off but the proceeds of that often do stay in the u.s so they need to in summary they
00:09:32 They need to reduce the deficit, but in a way that will impact growth as little as possible
00:09:38 to bring sanity back to the budget and achieve a prosperity for the future.
00:09:47 In the earlier Trump administration, 2016 to 2020, I think all of us recall that as
00:09:55 a time of prosperity and growth.
00:09:58 Is that something that was a consequence of what President Trump did at that time?
00:10:07 Can we expect the same kind of policy triumph in the four years to come?
00:10:16 So yes, but partially.
00:10:19 One of the things that he did in his first term was he reduced taxes
00:10:23 and he reduced as well regulation
00:10:28 or he proceeded upon deregulation.
00:10:30 So that's going to be an integral part of his plan
00:10:32 from what he has stated so far in his policy documents
00:10:35 that he does wish to reduce taxes,
00:10:38 which is a double-edged sword.
00:10:40 It's good for the economy and it's good for growth,
00:10:42 but it's bad for the fiscal deficit
00:10:45 unless done very carefully.
00:10:48 And then the other part of it,
00:10:50 and this is probably where he's going to
00:10:51 put his largest level of focus on is deregulation.
00:10:56 He plans on essentially doubling down on deregulation
00:10:59 and making it much easier for, say,
00:11:03 banks to lend money through deregulation,
00:11:07 which he would hope would spur the economy
00:11:10 in the coming years to come.
00:11:13 And I believe if it's done properly
00:11:16 with a balance of reducing the fiscal deficit
00:11:19 and deregulation and freeing up capital from the banks
00:11:24 to put into the general economy, he might be able to pull it off,
00:11:28 and that's what's got markets excited.
00:11:31 I think that's the key point.
00:11:32 So you're saying that it's his plans to deregulate
00:11:37 that are going to drive the economy, and that's what's got the market excited?
00:11:41 That's the plan.
00:11:45 Execution risk is always there, though.
00:11:48 As always.
00:11:49 I face that every day when I come to work.
00:11:53 I'm sure you do, too, in your own way.
00:11:56 So that's the plan.
00:12:02 You can't foresee the unforeseeable,
00:12:05 but what are the risks that he would be very well aware of as he sets forth on this?
00:12:11 Yeah, so some of the risks may have been reduced here
00:12:15 since it appears, at least, that the Republicans have a clean sweep.
00:12:20 They have both the House and the Senate as well as the executive branch.
00:12:23 So there might be less opposition to him being able to actually execute on his policies,
00:12:30 depending on how much opposition might actually still exist within his own party.
00:12:36 But the main risk would be, well, there's a few of them.
00:12:41 so um you know with uh increasing the amount of capital that's coming into the economy
00:12:48 uh future inflation is always a risk if again if it's done improperly uh because when you create
00:12:54 new money you know there is always a chance uh if if not done properly that that leads to inflation
00:13:00 which was would not be good if we return to that again uh the the bigger risk though i would say
00:13:06 is fiscal fiscal crisis uh so if if he cannot properly cut the deficit without um necessarily
00:13:15 harming growth we may end up possibly uh with the fiscal crisis by this time next year or early 2026
00:13:24 where essentially the bond market or the and or the currency markets you know might look at the
00:13:30 deficit. I mean, if he's cutting taxes, but he hasn't necessarily cut enough, you know, out of
00:13:36 the budget, where they just essentially balk. They say, no, no more. You know, we cannot continue to
00:13:43 finance this. It's too much, too much debt, too much deficit spending. And that could lead to a
00:13:50 fiscal crisis and possibly a recession as well. This is not something that he would be unaware
00:13:56 of or the people around him who are advising would be unaware of I would
00:14:01 hope not and I'm I would I would have confidence that he he has enough people
00:14:05 around him that he would be aware of this so I'm sure I'm sure the question
00:14:13 that everybody has who has anything to lose and a hope of gain is that's very
00:14:18 interesting peter what do i do as an investor so uh i there's there's probably a couple two-pronged
00:14:29 approach first of all uh it's it's important to have as many tools in your toolbox so to speak
00:14:34 as possible most people might have potentially either all their money in the stock market
00:14:43 you know that of course then makes you beholden to what happens in the stock market
00:14:47 some might have a balance of stocks and bonds which gives them a little bit more diversification
00:14:52 but even that might not be enough in a low interest rate environment to give you adequate
00:14:56 protection what we would advocate for is a much broader and diverse asset base where
00:15:04 clients have a portfolio of good quality stocks good quality bonds but also alternative assets
00:15:12 such as silver bullion or other precious metals and other alternative assets essentially that are
00:15:22 not correlated to either the stock market or the bond market. And if you can structure a portfolio
00:15:29 where you have a different group of assets that's not correlated or not similar to each other,
00:15:35 that'll give you a lot of protection depending on whether, say, Trump is successful in his
00:15:41 endeavors over the next four years or if he's unsuccessful or what's probably most likely the
00:15:46 case something in between. I noticed that when you began that answer you initially said gold and
00:15:52 then you caught yourself and switched to silver. Was that just to be inclusive or were you thinking
00:15:58 that silver's got more upside than gold? We have gold bugs who follow us so I have to ask the
00:16:04 question no it's a good question uh and um i i grew up uh with a father who's a geologist so i
00:16:13 grew up around gold and silver my entire life and this uh this topic is is you know very familiar to
00:16:20 me so uh i would suggest that uh there's probably a couple different reasons to own gold and silver
00:16:26 uh and probably silver does have more upside just to answer your question uh quickly at least in the
00:16:31 short term long term it's a little bit harder to say uh but short term silver has lagged gold
00:16:37 and there's a lot of people that believe myself included uh that at some point uh here there's
00:16:42 a reversion to the mean and silver plays catch up the gold and to play catch up the goals it
00:16:48 probably has quite a bit of runway room here to go uh to the upside uh it's also looking very good
00:16:53 it from a technical uh or charting uh perspective um but beyond potential upside i i think the main
00:17:01 there's two main reasons to own the the metal that's not quote-unquote speculative uh one would
00:17:07 be uh its uh correlation to both the stock market and the bond market especially gold uh gold is not
00:17:15 correlated uh to either the stock market or the bond market meaning that the stock market and the
00:17:21 bond market or do what they're going to do. And the gold market for what it's worth is going to
00:17:27 do what it's going to do. And it's not necessarily wholly related. So when you blend the two together
00:17:32 in a portfolio, you essentially get almost a magical outcome where volatility overall in the
00:17:38 portfolio greatly decreases, as long as it's blended in the appropriate amounts, where returns
00:17:44 do not go down. And they may even increase over time. So correlation is one reason to own gold.
00:17:51 The other reason is essentially insurance.
00:17:53 And that's another large reason why we own gold is insurance in case of any sort of major calamity,
00:18:01 whether it's war or whether it's a fiscal slip up, let's just say like we've been talking about.
00:18:09 It's good to know that one has gold as a backstop to give insurance to the overall portfolio.
00:18:16 Well, does it actually support your point there that as the stock market surged yesterday, when the news of the Trump victory was incorporated, as it surged, gold went down? Is that the kind of correlation that you're talking about?
00:18:32 So when I say it's not correlated, I don't mean that it's opposite. I don't mean that if stocks are up, gold is down, and if stocks are down, gold is up. That would be essentially like an opposite effect.
00:18:45 non-correlated meaning that it's very difficult to discern a pattern between gold being up and
00:18:50 stocks being down both can be true in a positive way an opposite way and anything in between which
00:18:57 which is why it has such a such a wonderful property when blended with with with stocks
00:19:03 but yesterday did not surprise me with gold going down essentially if you think of it this way
00:19:08 you know there was probably a moment there where there's a lot of investors in the sidelines that
00:19:13 were thinking about putting money back into the stock market. They were thinking about it. They
00:19:18 weren't sure. They were worried. They didn't know who was going to win the election. And then all
00:19:21 of a sudden, Trump wins the election. And they're like, oh, I got to get in. I got to get in like
00:19:26 yesterday and like right this very second. But to get in, you often need to sell something to get in.
00:19:32 And if you look at the performance of gold this year alone, I mean, it's up tremendously. So,
00:19:38 you know, why not sell a little bit of gold and put it into stocks at that point in time and take
00:19:42 some profits so that was essentially profit-taking on gold I see we're
00:19:47 getting close to time Peter but two questions to ask any thoughts on
00:19:52 Bitcoin under a Trump presidency and then we need to talk about the TSX so
00:19:58 Bitcoin first yeah now and I'll be brief since we're short on time Bitcoin has a
00:20:05 lot of things going for it right now typically it tends to do well post
00:20:09 election. So once an election has occurred and it's over, historically, it's almost always done
00:20:14 well right after the election. Secondly, Trump is considered to have a very, very favorable view
00:20:22 to cryptocurrencies. I mean, he's even suggested and the RFK has even suggested that maybe the
00:20:29 Federal Reserve should even be using Bitcoin as a reserve asset, which I'm not suggesting that
00:20:36 they will do. But if they did, that would certainly be extremely bullish for Bitcoin.
00:20:43 But also, Bitcoin is in its current seasonally strong period for the next, I'd say, nine months
00:20:50 or so. So overall, the prospects for Bitcoin look wonderful. And I believe you want to talk about
00:20:57 the TSX next? Yes, please. We've spent all this time on the American Stock Exchange. What's the
00:21:05 what difference did the Trump election make to the Toronto Stock Exchange and what are the linkages
00:21:13 there? Quite a bit. So first of all, the Toronto Stock Exchange has radically underperformed
00:21:22 all major U.S. indices, whether it's the Dow or the Standard & Poor's 500 and especially NASDAQ
00:21:28 during the Trudeau era, so it's already been a very huge laggard in terms of performance.
00:21:37 With a Trump presidency, it has the potential to even possibly make that worse unless things
00:21:45 change and change quickly here in Canada. But essentially, if the U.S. was already a more,
00:21:52 call it a free market type system than Canada, which is one of the reasons why
00:21:57 It had its own performance. If Trump comes in here and starts deregulating and also another one of his objectives is to boost innovation, particularly in the tech space, i.e. artificial intelligence and blockchain data centers in the U.S., that could further the gap between Canada and the U.S.
00:22:19 unless Canada also, quote-unquote, joins the party
00:22:23 and embarks on tax cuts, deregulation,
00:22:28 and basically an effort to spur productivity growth,
00:22:31 which is also something that's been lagging in Canada
00:22:34 for really the last decade.
00:22:36 Have you observed that kind of policy agility
00:22:39 in the government of Canada, in the Bank of Canada?
00:22:43 Oh, I mean, look at history.
00:22:45 I mean, during the Harper era, Harper, I believe,
00:22:48 We've had a set of policies that made Canada very competitive during the 2000s, and the Canadian stock market during the 2000s actually radically outperformed the U.S. stock market during that decade.
00:23:03 But unfortunately, the reverse has been true over the course of the last decade or so.
00:23:08 So it is fixable, but we do have to change policies, in my humblest opinion, here in Canada in order to remain competitive with the United States.
00:23:21 Peter, unfortunately, we could talk for a long time, and unfortunately, that's all the time we have.
00:23:28 Perhaps we can end on an optimistic note.
00:23:31 The U.S. Fed has cut interest rates by a quarter point.
00:23:35 I think that's good for us going forward, is it not?
00:23:37 well it's it's going to depend on how how much we cut interest rates next there's there's
00:23:46 certainly a lot of reason to suggest that if we are less competitive than United States that we
00:23:53 may actually need to cut interest rates more than they do in the United States in order to try to
00:23:57 bridge that gap so I do await to see the policy response in the Bank of Canada over the coming
00:24:04 weeks. But overall, we do believe very strongly that interest rates will be coming down in both
00:24:10 Canada and the U.S. in the coming months. Well, there's a lot of us who will take much
00:24:14 satisfaction from that. Thank you very much. That was Peter Piovic from Wellington Altus
00:24:23 Private Wealth Canada, giving us his insights on what the Trump presidency is going to mean
00:24:30 And in the years to come, for the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.