Western Standard - August 29, 2025


Your non-existent right to defend your home

Mentioned
Where the f*** is Nenshi’s NDP?! HANNAFORD: Your non-existent right to defend your home

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

152.63

Word count

3,401

Sentence count

86

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A homeowner in Ontario was charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon after he defended himself and his home against another man who had broken into the same home. Does this case suggest that Canadians don t have a right to self-defense in their own homes? In this episode, we talk to constitutional and criminal lawyer Hattie Keir to find out.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, August the 28th. Last week, an Ontario man
00:00:26 was charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon after he defended himself and his
00:00:31 home against another man who had broken in. This famous case involves an intruder who was
00:00:37 allegedly stabbed and remains in hospital. Canadians, coast to coast, are deeply concerned
00:00:44 that the homeowner was charged. Do Canadians not have a right to defend themselves and their homes
00:00:53 against intruders. With me today is Hattim Keir, a constitutional and criminal lawyer whose work
00:01:01 is funded by the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms. Welcome to the show, Hattim. 0.99
00:01:07 Hi, thank you for having me.
00:01:09 Hattim, let's cut to the chase. There are two questions here, it seems to me, that need to be
00:01:15 dealt with first. One, it seems like the message is that Canadians don't have a right to defend
00:01:21 themselves and their homes? And who actually says so? Is not the police messaging that? Is that the
00:01:28 accumulated wisdom of the courts, or is it Parliament itself? And then the second question
00:01:34 is, to me, something seems to have changed. I can't imagine this case coming forward at the time
00:01:43 that I started my journalism career a very, very long time ago. So what's your sense of
00:01:51 what is going on? What is driving this apparently bizarre situation?
00:01:58 Well, to start with your first question, I think you're right to say that the message is Canadians
00:02:03 don't have a right to self-defense. And that is the state of things. As for who's making it that
00:02:10 way it's a uh well it starts with parliament because the criminal code is is their legislation
00:02:16 uh criminal laws under the federal jurisdiction um and then more broadly than that you could you
00:02:21 could attribute it to the the justice system as a whole um in terms of what's changed uh
00:02:31 it's a combination of factors so the the criminal code was amended back in 2012
00:02:37 12 to make the current rules for self-defense as they are and the rules turn on reasonableness
00:02:45 it's an assessment of reasonableness and that decision is ultimately going to be made at a
00:02:50 trial by the jury the jury is made up of 12 regular people and so what is reasonable ends
00:02:58 up turning on what people tend to think is reasonable taken more broadly though it it's
00:03:05 It's affected by the judge's jurisprudence on what's reasonable. And then even, you know, going right back to the beginning of one of these charges, it's affected by, or it's at least the fact that situations like this arise turns on the fact that there's police who are laying the charges in the first place.
00:03:25 So they show up to the scene, they assess what happened, and in their view, it makes sense to lay charges against this individual whose home was just broken and entered.
00:03:38 And then it's in the hands of prosecutors who choose to prosecute those offenses as opposed to diverting them or withdrawing them.
00:03:46 And then that leads to it falling into the hands of the court and then ultimately the jury.
00:03:51 but you know i think so many of us feel that there is something about somebody invading your
00:03:58 property your space that's deeply offensive it's out of improve out of all proportion to the actual
00:04:05 loss that you might incur it's it's sort of dishonoring and it makes people angry and it
00:04:13 seems that the legal system is saying no no you shouldn't be angry you've got to be reasonable
00:04:19 about this and i wonder where that line of uh well perhaps you disagree that but with my analysis but
00:04:27 if you do agree then how how did that line of reasoning enter the legal system
00:04:33 who did it serve well to to go to your your point about the the offense of having someone break and
00:04:43 enter into your house the law historically taking a broad view isn't uh isn't ignorant of that fact
00:04:50 when it comes to search and seizure law the court recognizes that a man's home is his castle 0.58
00:04:57 when it comes to um uh let's say sentencing someone for breaking and entering the court
00:05:04 will absolutely recognize the the harm caused by that sort of violent intrusion into a person's
00:05:10 space. And then when it comes to self-defense, historically, the court has recognized that a
00:05:16 person isn't obligated to retreat within their own house. Now, that said, I don't completely
00:05:24 disagree with the premise of your question. I think you're right to point out that there seems
00:05:28 to be a disregard for that when you see a case like this come through the court system. And this
00:05:33 isn't the only one. There have been others in recent years. I think part of what's happening
00:05:39 is a an overwillingness on the part of police to charge and then let the courts figure it out
00:05:49 and so you know they see a person who who did commit by the letter of the law they did
00:05:56 use force against another person so if it's not self-defense he would be guilty of let's say it's
00:06:02 assault or assault with a weapon and so so they lay the charge and then if he has a defense they
00:06:07 leave it to the courts to sort that out. The problem with that, and I think what offends
00:06:13 the sensibilities of probably a great deal of Canadians, is that there's a punishment in the
00:06:18 process. If you're charged with a criminal offense, it'll take years. Perhaps it can range
00:06:26 from a year and a half upwards to three years, depending on the nature of the charges and the
00:06:30 procedure used, but it can take years to resolve. In the meantime, a person is dealing with the
00:06:36 stress of the potential criminal conviction that results the criminal uh you know the possibility
00:06:42 of a criminal uh a criminal record the the potential of jail time in situations where
00:06:48 the self-defense ends in a homicide there's a pretty stark reality that's facing this person
00:06:54 where they could either walk free at the end of this trial or face life in prison
00:06:59 uh and then even even if they get acquitted uh they'll have spent thousands and thousands of
00:07:05 dollars in their own defense and i think people see that and probably rightfully think that that
00:07:12 should that that entire process should have been avoided if the situation clearly appears to be
00:07:18 self-defense now you say that the discretion rests with the police and that of course is the case
00:07:27 but and there seems to be a willingness to just throw the book around and let the court sort it
00:07:33 out don't think the police always thought this way is there is this anything at all to do with
00:07:40 the fact that the police have had bad press over the last years often in the hands of woke canadians
00:07:47 and they just don't particularly want the aggravation so instead of making a decision
00:07:53 to not charge for which they might be criticized by all the usual suspects
00:08:00 they take the approach you've described give it to the courts let them sort it out too bad for
00:08:06 the fellow but it's not my money is that is that how it works i'm not a police officer i don't know
00:08:13 exactly what the cause is but my suspicions align with yours i i think it is if they lay the charge
00:08:19 i i think it's arguably out of their court at that point they can uh they can direct the
00:08:27 responsibility to other parties in the justice system the prosecutor and ultimately the court
00:08:32 and perhaps it makes it harder to fault them for the decision whereas if they do decide not to lay
00:08:40 a charge the buck stops squarely with the police no one else in the justice system has the authority
00:08:46 to then intervene and lay that charge well it has always been my understanding that the police are
00:08:54 very responsive to political direction. For example, if a politician holding office is very
00:09:04 concerned about drunk driving, then the police will get that message and they will be tough on
00:09:10 drunk driving. But it might be something else, in which case they'll be tough on that. This is not
00:09:16 to say that police routinely ignore offenses that are not politically motivated, or I should
00:09:23 rephrase that that are some politicians pet project but they certainly will respond if
00:09:31 somebody makes a point of saying we really want you to care about this so is perhaps the way to
00:09:40 deal with this kind of thing to put politicians in place who actually have an understanding
00:09:49 of what it means to be awoken in your own home
00:09:55 to find an intruder there
00:09:57 and that you do the reasonable thing.
00:09:59 I mean, Danielle Smith, Premier of Alberta,
00:10:02 commented at one of her town hall meetings
00:10:04 that if you don't want to get a...
00:10:06 This is a paraphrase.
00:10:08 She didn't say these very words,
00:10:09 but this was the gist of it.
00:10:10 But if you don't want to get beat up,
00:10:13 don't break into somebody else's house.
00:10:15 Well, that seems reasonable.
00:10:16 Now, a politician who feels like that, does she have any power to influence the way the police handle these cases? 1.00
00:10:24 There is a level of independence between police and the political sphere.
00:10:30 That said, I think police forces, generally speaking, don't want to be the subject of negative press or negative public attention.
00:10:38 so i think a shift in the the public's view the way public pressure gets directed is an important
00:10:47 part of of shifting the culture at the level of the police at the level of prosecutors
00:10:53 um and politicians are a part of that they're a part of that that general um climate that will i
00:11:01 think nudge police in the right directions uh but then more importantly than that if we're discussing
00:11:07 the responsibility of politicians and all this, they should exercise their political
00:11:12 power to align both the letter of the law and its implementation in a way that aligns
00:11:18 with a defense of people's rights to life and to defend their own lives.
00:11:25 Okay, well, I'm going to come back to that point in a moment, because really, when you're
00:11:29 getting down to that level of detail, you're talking about the provincial governments,
00:11:33 the canadian code criminal code is what it is but it's it's administered in at the provincial level
00:11:40 um but first i want to come back to what you said about a proportional response and i wonder what
00:11:48 is actually possible let's say it's you who's awakened in the middle of the night to find
00:11:54 somebody in your house going through going through the drawers or they've got the tv in their hand
00:11:58 and they're on the way out the door you don't know who they are and you don't know what they want
00:12:06 or how much they want you don't know if they're going to run away when confronted
00:12:11 or whether they will come at you in the kawartha lake case that's making the headlines the intruder
00:12:17 was supposedly on his own but he was wanted for other offenses so there's a dangerous man
00:12:27 in the house as the person who is seconds away from being fast asleep and is just trying to make
00:12:34 sense of this how would you know that how would you know to think about it is there somebody else
00:12:39 with them do you know are they by the door to your children's bedroom what will they do next
00:12:44 you don't know in other words you're supposed to make a response apparently that's proportionate
00:12:50 to all these things that you don't know and your life and the lives of others who depend on you
00:12:56 for protection depends upon you getting it right in a split second so what do the police advise
00:13:07 call cower and wait i've heard it expressed to me that seems to place a tremendous
00:13:15 onus of forbearance upon the homeowner. And you say?
00:13:23 I think you're right with maybe a couple of qualifications. So in terms of the ultimate
00:13:29 resolution by the court, I do place a deal of trust in juries to make the right call. It's
00:13:36 regular people who are tasked with deciding whether or not the use of force was reasonable
00:13:40 in all the circumstances um and for the most part i think juries are capable of getting it right
00:13:46 that said um the uh the court or i should add the court has directed also that people
00:13:54 uh fate in a self-defense scenario aren't required to weigh to a nicety that's the term used by the
00:14:01 court uh the amount of force that they use um the problem with with cases like this uh again or or
00:14:10 But to use an example that's actually run its course through the courts, there was an
00:14:16 individual in Hamilton named Peter Kill who engaged in lethal force when someone had entered
00:14:24 his property.
00:14:25 There was also an individual in, I believe, Manitoba, Stanley, who used lethal force.
00:14:31 He was ultimately acquitted.
00:14:33 So in those cases, take the Stanley case, the individual was acquitted at the end of
00:14:37 all of it.
00:14:38 So you could say the law got it right, but perhaps he shouldn't have been charged in the first place. And at that level, the message that is being sent, if he is in fact being charged, is that perhaps he shouldn't have used the force or he should have been more restrained in using it, or else just be prepared to be put through the wringer of the legal system after he does use it to defend his own life.
00:15:04 Well, I guess there's a slight difference.
00:15:07 The Manitoba case, was it Manitoba or Saskatchewan?
00:15:11 It might have been Saskatchewan.
00:15:12 Yeah.
00:15:13 I'm not sure either, but there was a case anyway.
00:15:17 In that situation, I don't believe that the homeowner or the person doing the defending of his property was actually awakened from sleep.
00:15:26 and it's a different thing to my point about the ability to make a decision to offer a
00:15:35 proportionate response if you've just woken up and it's all over in a second you have to decide
00:15:42 in a second what you're going to do it's a rather different thing even than when you are looking out
00:15:49 of your your kitchen window and see somebody interfering with property on your on your farm
00:15:54 which I think was the situation.
00:16:00 These things seem to me to put a tremendous onus on the homeowner,
00:16:07 one that the homeowner as the entirely innocent party shouldn't have to bear.
00:16:11 And I suspect that you're not going to dispute that with me.
00:16:14 But what I would ask you is how can the provinces,
00:16:20 the actual administrators of the justice the people who pay for the policing how can they
00:16:26 actually deal with this so that this kind of situation if it happens doesn't happen very
00:16:34 often and it's not something that the homeowner has to sit there worrying about well we've uh
00:16:41 you know in response to this lindsey situation we've heard comments from both uh the ontario
00:16:46 and alberta premiers expressing criticism of how this was handled and so those provinces and any
00:16:54 others can take the responsibility to change how the laws are actually implemented and enforced
00:17:01 now local police forces will have a measure of independence and so it's it's up to them
00:17:07 to take responsibility for laying charges in a more uh restrained responsible manner
00:17:13 but with respect to the provinces it the ball goes into their court after the police lay the
00:17:20 charges so once police lay the charges the discretion is out of their hands it then goes
00:17:26 into the hands of provincial prosecutors who are responsible for the administration of criminal
00:17:30 justice and it each for every province this is going to be true there are policies that guide
00:17:37 the use of prosecutorial discretion. Prosecutors are necessarily tasked with making a call whether
00:17:45 or not a charge is worth prosecuting. And if it's not, they can withdraw it, which leads to
00:17:51 it evaporates, essentially. Prosecutors will withdraw charges if there's no reasonable
00:17:59 prospect of conviction, which makes intuitive sense. But they're not limited to that assessment.
00:18:05 prosecutors also are tasked with considering
00:18:07 whether it's in the public interest to prosecute.
00:18:11 The classic example might be someone who commits a crime
00:18:14 but really is having more of a mental health issue
00:18:18 that can be treated.
00:18:19 And so, for example, it can be diverted
00:18:21 to a mental health route rather than a criminal route.
00:18:26 And there's policies that the attorney generals
00:18:29 will implement and distribute internally
00:18:31 that then guide the application of that discretion
00:18:34 for for every prosecutor and prosecutors have to work within those policies so for example uh the
00:18:40 the province can set a policy determining when to uh when it's acceptable to offer a plea deal
00:18:49 on a charge of impaired driving you know for if a person breathes over a certain amount or if they
00:18:56 maybe if they've had multiple offenses a plea will be off the table so in that same vein
00:19:03 It's open to a province to make a policy decision and say it is not in the public interest to vigorously prosecute people who are making those difficult calls, those difficult decisions at three in the morning when they've been awakened, awoken by an intruder and use force to defend themselves.
00:19:24 So the province can implement standards that they could ask prosecutors to look at and to make a decision in cases where someone's home has been entered in the middle of the night, whether prosecution is really in the public interest and if not to withdraw the charges.
00:19:41 So that would rest with the office of the attorney general in each respective province.
00:19:46 That's right.
00:19:47 And so then the political heat that the police are trying to avoid
00:19:51 would land right there on that elected individual
00:19:55 who has his own incentives for dodging it, I guess.
00:20:00 Or incentives for claiming the praise, right?
00:20:04 If people really are upset at this,
00:20:05 then there's an opportunity for a politician to do something popular.
00:20:11 So, well, that's actually a good point.
00:20:16 uh in respect to the are we worrying about something that doesn't happen very often or are
00:20:24 there actually a lot of cases that we don't hear about where people have defended themselves and
00:20:30 have in fact gone to jail or been fined or paid some penalty how often does this situation crop
00:20:37 up we should worry about it i i'm not able to to speak to how common it is uh you know i i'm not
00:20:45 aware of the stats on this but i will say that the the effect goes beyond the individual case
00:20:50 there's a chilling effect at the start of this interview you asked me about the message being
00:20:54 sent to canadians about whether or not they have a right to self-defense and i think for a lot of
00:20:59 people who see a case like this come into the news the message they receive loud and fear is
00:21:04 i i should be very hesitant to to engage in self-defense when i'm making that decision i'm
00:21:09 choosing between trying to defend my life or trying to avoid criminal the possibility of
00:21:16 criminal liability so really the man who decides to throw the intruder right before he comes near
00:21:24 his wife and his children will act they will be the hero because he's not only facing the intruder
00:21:30 he's facing all the possible consequences that come later right what a sad situation
00:21:37 our team thank you very much for shedding your wisdom upon this um we i i won't ask you to guess
00:21:47 what's going to happen in the lindsay case there are still too many details that have not been
00:21:53 made public but certainly my sympathies are with the gentleman who is uh has been charged with
00:21:59 defending his his home and i think a lot of people watching this program will probably feel the same
00:22:07 way so thanks for explaining what's really behind this thanks for having me on you're very welcome
00:22:12 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hatterford. Good night.