Ali Dawah - March 10, 2023


LGBQT IN MECCA!! - HALAL OR HARAM？


Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

206.7302

Word count

2,314

Sentence count

132

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

30

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jummah Kutbahayah on the issue of hermaphrodites and the ruling in Islam regarding them. Is it haram for them to perform Umrah? Is it halal for them? What does the Quran say about them?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 I saw that, I went into this individual's profile, and if I'm not mistaken, this individual was even involved in Tabligh Jama'at.
00:00:06.640 Are you ready to reach your ultimate potential? Are you looking for long-lasting relationships and ultimate financial freedom?
00:00:13.220 It's time to join the Muslim Alpha program, the ultimate guide to masculinity based on the Quran and Sunnah. 0.99
00:00:19.480 Sign up today. Use code ALI25 for a 25% discount.
00:00:22.860 So there is this new phenomena happening by individuals who are going to the Kaaba, some of them who identify as being queer from the LGBTQ community,
00:00:32.660 some of them who have feminine, very strong feminine-looking features, and they are going to the Kaaba and doing videos.
00:00:39.000 We're going to be talking about if what they're doing is halal, haram, and we're going to go to the issue of hermaphrodites. 0.75
00:00:45.940 I think that's what they're called, forgive me. Hermaphrodites, yeah?
00:00:48.100 Who are individuals who are born with both male and female genitalia, and what is the ruling in Islam pertaining to these individuals?
00:00:54.860 Let's watch these two videos and come back, inshallah, because there are important lessons to be learned,
00:00:59.300 because some people are deriving Islam and their rulings from their aql, from their logic.
00:01:04.420 We don't follow your opinion or your logic. We follow Islam. Let's go.
00:01:07.680 Now, when I saw that, I went into this individual's profile, and if I'm not mistaken, this individual was even involved in Tabligh Jama'at,
00:01:15.040 meaning they give Dawah to Muslims, yeah? The Qura people give them the Nasir, etc.
00:01:19.680 I did my research as much as I can, and I came to the conclusion that I do not know, and I cannot clearly see,
00:01:25.680 if this is a man or if this is a woman. 0.82
00:01:28.360 I don't know if this individual is a hermaphrodite, I hope I pronounced that right, yeah? 1.00
00:01:33.000 That if they're born with both the genders. 0.74
00:01:36.140 Now, let's quickly tackle the one who says that he is or she is a queer.
00:01:40.780 Now, this individual in Islam, number one, is it haram for this individual, who might be a homosexual, 0.98
00:01:47.980 who might be a queer, who might be a whatever it may be, yeah? 0.79
00:01:52.680 Entering the haram, or doing, um, arguments say, coming and doing umrah?
00:01:57.580 There is no evidence from Islam in the Quran or the Sunnah to say that such an individual who's indulged in these sins, yes?
00:02:05.500 Is it haram for them being Muslim? No, it's not. They are still a believer.
00:02:09.600 As long as they do not say that their action, what they're doing is, or themselves having this is halal,
00:02:16.820 or them acting on it is halal.
00:02:18.340 If they deem it to be haram, and they say that this is something that, this is how they are,
00:02:22.860 okay, they can say, I have these desires, but to say that desire is halal makes you a kafid. 0.90
00:02:27.580 If you say this desire is haram, you're a believer that's sinning.
00:02:31.200 It's as good as seeing somebody who commits adultery, drinks alcohol, involved in riba,
00:02:35.780 which can be classed as worse in the context of his waging war against Allah and his messenger.
00:02:40.260 And how many people are involved in riba?
00:02:42.100 How many people are doing adultery and alcohol?
00:02:44.440 Yes, that's the point there.
00:02:46.840 Do we say they cannot come to umrah?
00:02:48.400 No, this is jahil. This is being ignorant. 1.00
00:02:50.680 I mean, I'm hearing some Medina students, which I'm not going to mention, 0.91
00:02:55.160 who are sitting in their home, they have no experience in the dawah, they have no knowledge.
00:02:58.160 They come with this attitude of just because something looks abnormal,
00:03:01.600 or they deem that it looks haram, it is haram.
00:03:05.440 All that time you studied in Medina, did you not?
00:03:07.360 Wallahi, mind blown. I'm Ali needs dawah. I'm Ali jahil.
00:03:11.980 When I see these individuals who have zero experience in the dawah,
00:03:15.400 and they studied in Medina, when they come with this stuff, it blows my mind.
00:03:19.920 Did you not learn anything? Simple principles of Islam, did you not learn? 1.00
00:03:24.540 Anyways, digressing. The point is what?
00:03:27.180 That, that doesn't make them a disbeliever.
00:03:29.940 Neither can we say it is haram for them to come and perform umrah.
00:03:32.620 However, if somebody does a video, if I do a video and go to them and go,
00:03:35.860 I'm an adulterer.
00:03:36.780 I'm involved in riba. I wage war on Allah and His Messenger. 0.99
00:03:41.620 I drink alcohol.
00:03:43.480 Now you are openly publicizing your sin.
00:03:46.160 And the Prophet ﷺ said,
00:03:48.080 Every son of Adam will be forgiven except those who publicly publicize their sin.
00:03:53.840 Yes?
00:03:54.020 Now, if people are coming and bullying and saying they shouldn't be allowed and this, that, 1.00
00:03:58.760 you are a five-star, grade A, jahil, ignorant. 1.00
00:04:03.040 How could you say somebody who's indulging sins, whatever it may be, cannot come to the haram? 0.99
00:04:07.860 If you are someone who commits zina, adultery, riba, alcohol, drink, whatever, murder, whatever it may be,
00:04:12.640 does that mean you cannot come to the haram?
00:04:14.360 So let's be balanced.
00:04:15.700 There are two extremes.
00:04:17.220 One, woo, ooh, girls. 0.99
00:04:18.860 You queer, whatever you do, you act upon it, khala, no problem. 1.00
00:04:21.560 One, no. 0.96
00:04:22.500 So the point is that addressing the queer. 0.98
00:04:25.540 Because you are openly propagating.
00:04:27.160 Islam deals with this, you know, as we know, don't go into detail,
00:04:30.620 to openly publicize your sin.
00:04:32.480 Number two.
00:04:32.940 Now let's deal with the other individual who has feminine features. 1.00
00:04:37.060 I don't know if that's a filter.
00:04:38.240 I don't know if we can't say it's wearing makeup, but it might be a filter.
00:04:40.920 Yeah?
00:04:41.480 This person, I went through their videos.
00:04:44.220 I genuinely, wallah, I do not know if it's a man or a woman.
00:04:47.060 I do not know.
00:04:48.740 They might be a hermaphrodite.
00:04:50.280 Yes?
00:04:51.300 But the point is what?
00:04:52.360 What is the ruling?
00:04:52.980 Shaykh ibn Rufaymin says that the one who is born with two genders, yes, they are not 0.91
00:04:58.320 allowed to get married until it is decided what they are. 0.93
00:05:02.140 Usually the Sharia says that the active genitalia, which they pee from, yeah, or ejaculate from, 0.98
00:05:08.020 or whatever it may be, it is there. 0.86
00:05:09.720 That is the determinant factor of you being a male or a female.
00:05:12.840 Or some scholars even say, which is a different opinion, that we look at the certain features.
00:05:17.920 If this person can have intimacy, they can impregnate, then it's a man.
00:05:21.160 If they can fight like a man, like war, they can fight like a man, there's some masculine
00:05:25.360 traits that are there, then the decision will be that it's a man.
00:05:28.040 If it's a female, they have very, very feminine features and other factors, et cetera, you know, signs 1.00
00:05:35.440 of period or whatever it may be, then they are a woman. 0.62
00:05:38.080 But Shaykh ibn Rufaymin says that they cannot get married.
00:05:41.820 Why?
00:05:42.620 Because if they are not known, is it a male or a man or a woman, then marrying, imagine
00:05:47.480 marrying a man and them themselves are a man.
00:05:50.380 It's haram for a man, a man to marry, it's haram, the bichay is not valid. 1.00
00:05:53.600 If they are a woman which they don't know and they marry another woman, then it's again 0.99
00:05:58.520 not permissible.
00:05:59.700 So that's why it is said that they should not be married until the decision is made clear.
00:06:05.400 I'm going to leave a link from Islam Q&A, you can read in detail, more in detail about
00:06:08.820 this.
00:06:09.040 But the point is what, such individuals, which again goes to my point and I'm going to wrap
00:06:13.640 up on this, we think just because something looks wrong, it must be haram.
00:06:18.740 Just because we have a way of looking at Islam and we believe our Islam is the only Islam, 0.84
00:06:22.780 yeah, like these jahils, like these so-called Medina students, jahils, people are telling
00:06:27.680 me, unbelievable, that we think, for example, I'll give you a fine example of the Bitter Truth
00:06:31.740 Show.
00:06:32.480 Some people will come in and say, this is free mixing.
00:06:35.180 What?
00:06:35.900 Allah, it's unbelievable.
00:06:36.980 These are coming from people's student knowledges.
00:06:39.800 Is there bil-ijma, that free mixing? 0.98
00:06:43.240 For example, doing hajj, umrah, free mixing, going to the restaurant, going to university,
00:06:48.180 going to work.
00:06:48.940 There are Muslim men and women who go to work where they have to work with opposite gender.
00:06:53.000 Is this free mixing?
00:06:54.520 The Sharia has specific rules.
00:06:55.980 And I'm going to put a video of Mufti Munir, which explains the balance view, not the extreme
00:07:01.280 one, which is the Saudi, our super, super Salafi brothers, not all of them, who think 0.96
00:07:06.280 their Islam is the only way Islam. 0.91
00:07:08.200 You don't do this?
00:07:08.900 Khalas, you're a person of Hawa, a person of desire.
00:07:11.760 There is a balance.
00:07:13.400 When it comes to the Bitter Truth, people make comments.
00:07:16.420 What ignorance you have to have.
00:07:18.620 Number one, is it haram in any circumstance for a man or woman to talk to each other? 0.88
00:07:23.940 No.
00:07:24.820 Is it haram for a man or woman to come in a specific setting?
00:07:28.360 Totally haram?
00:07:29.180 No.
00:07:30.220 In the Dawah, when we give Dawah to the opposite gender, sometimes I speak to three, four girls. 0.99
00:07:34.020 They are there?
00:07:34.780 Yeah?
00:07:35.540 Number one, is it in public?
00:07:37.260 Yes.
00:07:37.820 Number two, number two, is it pertaining to Dawah?
00:07:40.460 Yes.
00:07:40.940 When the Dawah conversation ends, Khalas, these are the conditions we follow. 1.00
00:07:44.640 With the Bitter Truth, it's the same thing.
00:07:46.160 People look and think, just because this looks wrong, must be haram.
00:07:50.060 The more everything is haram, it means the more Islam is truth. 0.99
00:07:54.100 The Prophet, peace be upon him, said, nobody overburdenes them with their religion,
00:07:56.720 thinking everything is haram, haram, haram, except that overtakes them.
00:07:59.820 Yeah?
00:08:00.180 It becomes a burden on them.
00:08:01.960 In the Bitter Truth, alhamdulillah, and I'm making a correlation here,
00:08:04.540 it's because you look and be like, oh, he looks feminine, etc.
00:08:07.520 They should have banned him.
00:08:08.640 Why should they ban him?
00:08:10.140 If he has that, he's born like that, and he's not putting makeup on,
00:08:13.300 and he's a man, but he has very, very feminine looking features,
00:08:18.280 how could you stop him from the haram praying?
00:08:21.320 I mean, maybe he could even give dawah, because it's not his fault he was born like that,
00:08:26.560 and he's got feminine features, he looks feminine.
00:08:29.220 Yeah?
00:08:29.580 I've seen videos of this guy where other men in beards are hugging him,
00:08:32.440 so he must be a man maybe, I don't know.
00:08:34.300 Yes?
00:08:34.980 So the point is what?
00:08:36.720 Alhamdulillah, when we do the Bitter Truth show,
00:08:38.960 the sisters that come observe hijab modestly, alhamdulillah. 0.53
00:08:42.080 We have, we sit on separate sofas, alhamdulillah.
00:08:44.440 It is in public, alhamdulillah.
00:08:46.220 And it is for the sake of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala, 0.94
00:08:49.100 and it is pertaining to dawah to prevent the biggest fitna in our time, divorces.
00:08:53.640 Yeah?
00:08:54.320 And that is all I'm going to say.
00:08:56.100 And anybody that doubts that and says,
00:08:57.820 no, you're doing it for this and this, that,
00:08:59.360 let's take the curse of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala on the layah. 1.00
00:09:02.020 Let's take the kitab of Allah and say, 0.89
00:09:03.740 you ask Allah's curse if I'm doing this for clout and fame and views and money,
00:09:07.900 no problem.
00:09:08.800 I will also take you,
00:09:10.480 I will never be sure that I'm doing this genuinely for the sake of Allah, 0.99
00:09:14.720 genuinely for this, genuinely for that.
00:09:15.860 No.
00:09:16.520 I ask Allah, inshaAllah, I'm doing it for that.
00:09:18.940 But since you are so certain I am doing it for those reasons,
00:09:22.120 ask Allah's curse upon you then. 0.99
00:09:23.900 It's as simple as that.
00:09:24.820 So the point I mentioned with the bitter truth,
00:09:26.780 and this and other elements,
00:09:28.100 is we have a group of Muslims who are jahil,
00:09:31.500 who don't have ingruth.
00:09:32.140 Now, can there be a difference of opinion?
00:09:34.060 Can there be scholars,
00:09:35.380 like Sheikh Uthaymin, Sheikh Salih Fawzan,
00:09:37.220 who can come and look at the bitter truth show and say,
00:09:39.000 this is not permissible.
00:09:40.800 100% we respect the opinion.
00:09:43.340 But to say that is the opinion,
00:09:45.560 and there is no opinion,
00:09:46.800 you are a five-star grade A jahil.
00:09:49.840 Jahil to say that one scholar's opinion,
00:09:51.880 because some scholars deem one an innovator.
00:09:53.620 Another scholar says,
00:09:54.280 no, he's not an innovator.
00:09:55.400 Which one do you take in that instance?
00:09:56.880 There are rulings to that,
00:09:57.600 which go into detail.
00:09:58.580 But the point I'm seeing in the right show is the following, guys.
00:10:01.060 Just because something looks wrong to you,
00:10:03.940 doesn't mean in the Sharia it is haram.
00:10:06.260 I can give you examples from the Prophet Muhammad,
00:10:08.280 peace be upon him,
00:10:08.720 that if I mentioned to you,
00:10:09.840 I would have been like you would fall into kufr by saying,
00:10:12.180 whoever did this, this man is,
00:10:13.340 and I brought up the Prophet,
00:10:14.480 and I said this,
00:10:15.560 and Abu Bakr said this,
00:10:17.440 your jaw won't drop.
00:10:19.480 Yeah?
00:10:20.300 So, we even have a fatwa when it comes to,
00:10:22.920 from Sheikh Salih Al-Fawzan,
00:10:24.600 Sheikh Bin Baz,
00:10:26.080 when it comes to women doing dawah on camera. 0.95
00:10:29.460 So, the point is this,
00:10:31.360 don't take your Islam from your aql. 0.68
00:10:33.320 Take it from the naql,
00:10:34.260 which is the Quran and the sunnah.
00:10:35.920 Don't think this looks weird,
00:10:37.040 oh, Ali dawah goes and does videos in this way,
00:10:40.940 I think it looks haram,
00:10:42.360 it must be haram.
00:10:43.380 Oh, this looks weird,
00:10:44.100 that guy going and doing umrah,
00:10:45.140 he looks feminine,
00:10:46.000 it looks haram,
00:10:46.700 it must be haram.
00:10:47.340 Fear Allah.
00:10:48.380 Because when you're saying it's haram,
00:10:49.380 you're saying something that Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala has said.
00:10:52.820 That's all I'm going to say,
00:10:53.680 brothers and sisters,
00:10:54.240 may Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala bless you,
00:10:55.300 inshallah,
00:10:55.840 and may Allah make us among those
00:10:57.080 who are on the balanced path,
00:10:58.200 inshallah.
00:10:58.440 please watch the video from Muftim Munir
00:11:00.120 when it comes to pertaining to free mixing,
00:11:01.720 and inshallah,
00:11:02.720 the matter is clear
00:11:03.660 with the Islam Q&A link
00:11:04.780 when it comes to such individuals.
00:11:07.820 And yeah,
00:11:08.240 that's it.
00:11:08.620 May Allah bless you guys.
00:11:09.520 Asalaamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuh.
00:11:11.280 Take care.