00:00:00Hello, Malcolm. I'm so glad to be speaking with you today because we're here for another episode
00:00:05of Women Are Terrible, in which we are asking the question, why do women think they can get away0.52
00:00:12with abuse? And this question is cropping up because once again, we have-
00:00:17A woman who should have known that it would come out.
00:00:20Yes. Basically, the 22-year-old son of a reality TV star whose entire public identity revolved
00:00:27around being a parent of eight kids recently came out with a tell-all book detailing his abuse
00:00:32this is the one from like kate of eight where the woman had was pregnant with six kids at a time and
00:00:36like a bunch of companies gave her free stuff and then she got divorced and yeah anyway continue
00:00:41his his account includes being systematically isolated from his siblings zip being zip tied
00:00:46and beaten uh being locked for 70 of his time in a basement with no bathroom i've never thought of
00:00:52doing that with our kids that's a great malcolm no no no no no no no no no um and also being
00:00:59heavily medicated against his will and somehow this very famous woman thought she could both
00:01:05be toxic on and off camera and get away with it why and and that's what we're going to explore
00:01:11today and uh not just that but we're going to be exploring it through the lens of a phenomenon that0.67
00:01:16we saw with her that i've seen with my mom that i've seen as many other psycho boomer mothers
00:01:21are like post boomer mother like just post of like just thinking that you can give your kids
00:01:28tons of medication to make whatever you don't like about them go away yeah like they're acting
00:01:32out and therefore you're going to maliciously medicate them or institutionalize them yeah
00:01:38you can just hit them i'm gonna hello i'm dr richard shea here to tell you about my exciting
00:01:48new drug free treatment for children with attention deficit disorder treatment is fast
00:01:54and effective and doesn't use harmful drugs watch closely as i apply treatment to the
00:01:58first child i want a horse i want a big brown horse with a fluffy black tail with a diamond
00:02:02sit out and study sit out and study stop crying until your school work
00:02:14you just wish you were beaten rigorously as a children a child weren't you uh it would have
00:02:21been a lot easier than my parents just hit me the way i hit our kids it would be so much nicer than0.95
00:02:25what they did like actually yes so if if she just hit her kids um just like well she did malcolm1.00
00:02:34and we'll get into that um of course she zip tied and beat them but she did other things
00:02:39we'll talk clearly not correctly no no definitely not correctly you know like we we talk about this
00:02:45in our corporal punishment episode but uh if you do if you engage and generally we are against
00:02:51the concept of quote-unquote spanking or corporal punishment anything that is that is delayed that
00:02:57is not basically um only when you know communication is clearly impossible with a child so like older
00:03:02children it's not appropriate uh it's sort of like you know if a if a kid who is incapable
00:03:07of understanding you is doing something that is dangerous to themselves or others you know
00:03:11immediate like sort of jolting not not painful not um in anger a physical correction can be very
00:03:18helpful like you know kids like shoving a knife into an outlet slap like that's gonna hopefully
00:03:24like get everyone a little bit like okay what's going on here which was just the other day
00:03:30i see one of our children with a screwdriver going straight toward an outlet do you think
00:03:37that they would know but anyway there are instances where sometimes this makes sense
00:03:42she was not doing that it was it was all delayed it was like highly ritualized it was with you know
00:03:47weapons like spoons and zip ties and things like that um but but also just her hands anyway we're
00:03:51gonna get into it um and um it it is uh it's horrifying for context um this is we're talking
00:03:58about kate goslin she became famous through the tlc realities tv series called john and kate plus
00:04:04eight and then later kate plus eight because she divorced john in which her life was being
00:04:09documented as as a mother raising and she was clearly the bad guy in the relationship oh yeah
00:04:14no i'll show you a clip um she had first twins who were born in 2000 and then sextuplets who
00:04:20were born in 2004 via fertility treatments with her then husband john goslin she made tons of
00:04:26money through this by the way first she was making about two thousand per episode and then it went up0.91
00:04:31to twenty two thousand five hundred per episode by later seasons of john and kate plus eight
00:04:35she made around two point five million dollars for the first five seasons actually not including
00:04:41extras and then after her divorce when the show became just kate plus eight she was making up to
00:04:46two hundred and fifty thousand dollars per episode though most were like a little over forty thousand0.99
00:04:51per episode, but that's still insane amounts of money. Um, and you can already tell that she was0.99
00:04:56unethical just for having sex tuplets because that puts these unborn children in incredible danger.0.99
00:05:02Like most IVF clinics won't even transfer twins because just a twin pregnancy is more pregnant,
00:05:08is more dangerous. She was a nurse by the way, she knows better. We don't do twins. We could0.98
00:05:15do twins and be having kids much faster when Simone is younger, but it's not good for the
00:05:18I mean, it puts the mother at risk. I should care more about that. I don't care as much about that. I care much more about the babies and it does put the babies at risk. And she chose to transfer six. I mean, one, like there are huge ethical issues with the doctor who did this. I've seen very detailed gynecological, like from gynecologists doing big rundowns of the whole, like, how did this happen? Who could have done this? There was a whole lot of like lying and stuff that was going on. So very unethical woman already to start. Anyone who is having sex tablets via an IVF procedure is an extremely unethical person.
00:05:48it makes it even worse that she was a nurse she knows better and she did it anyway um and this is0.98
00:05:53something that will have a permanent effect on the kids yeah intelligence growth everything messed
00:05:58up super messed up um but then you can also guess she's going to yield issues when you realize that
00:06:03images of her haircut um have have literally been used as sort of the um the the the picture
00:06:12the poster child of the karen haircut so malcolm look at your screen okay oh my god
00:06:18that is the karen haircut that is the i will i will speak to your manager haircut that is kate
00:06:24goslin i didn't know when i saw pictures of this i thought this was just like an example of like
00:06:28someone out like in the wild taking a picture of some random woman and being like this is the0.83
00:06:33karen haircut no this is kate goslin um and this how did her show get that popular is she that
00:06:40entertaining uh i guess people really actually i found it incredibly hard to even watch clips of0.98
00:06:45her show because she's so cruel to her children and to her husband let me give you an example1.00
00:06:51actually because it's here's the thing is even in the show she's just so mean to everyone including
00:06:56her husband watch this sorry can you stop breathing so loud honey he's like
00:07:01breathe quietly so i consider them sick anyone sick for do you hear yourself breathing oh that's0.97
00:07:11just gross i want this woman's life destroyed does anyone hear him breathing i'm sorry for0.98
00:07:17breathing she's so mean now i mean you malcolm you get mad at me for like not being like nice0.93
00:07:24enough when the documentary film like filming is happening i'm not that mean to you i love the
00:07:29sound of you chewing like i i i actually quite love you so now you can always remember there's
00:07:37someone who's worse on camera around their spouse than me. And I admit that I'm not great on camera
00:07:43around you because I'm so stressed out about the cameras. But there are levels that, you know,
00:07:47go even beyond. And I think part of that is the reason why she ended up being so abusive towards1.00
00:07:53her kids. You can tell that she hates her husband, like from that clip. And if you hate your partner,0.99
00:08:00you're probably not going to like your kids very much because you're going to see so much of them
00:08:04in your kids and i think that is a big factor that plays into this episode i can really clearly
00:08:10see you not paying attention and the screen sort of flashing on your face okay okay you can watch
00:08:15moa comics but you need to turn down your i'm not watching moa comics i was going through to do
00:08:19items i had an open thing and i thought a vibe coding software was stopped okay great well
00:08:26anyway you can tell how you feel about me on our podcast apparently um is this the new
00:08:32stop breathing um anyway but to do items yell at me they were they're open on the screen
00:08:41i know i know i'm so sorry but anyway i love the sound of you eating she can't she can't stand even
00:08:48the sound of him breathing but this is this is why you can tell like she's she probably hated
00:08:52her kids because she also hated her husbands and also she she hated them from the beginning she1.00
00:08:56was willing to have sextuplets, which is abusive. So let's talk about the allegations made against1.00
00:09:02this mother in The Shadow of Eight, which is the book that came out. It is doing gangbusters
00:09:10on Amazon. I think it already has over 3,000 reviews and it just came out, Malcolm. Like,
00:09:15that is a level. And I learned about this because my favorite snarky YouTuber,
00:09:19Cheer Denise, is doing a live reading. I'm going to link to her playlist of her reading this book
00:09:25with her snarky annotation uh and and actually there's a good clip from her show that's included
00:09:30in her um her introduction to this book so i'll just play it right here for a sec
00:09:35this bear away i'm not i'm not dealing with it i'll teach him to get done
00:09:40this is so mean that's the author of this book kiss him goodbye can you imagine me doing that
00:09:50to Mr. Bear? Mr. Bear who our kid loves, yeah.
00:42:40when they were like filming something for one of the shows,
00:42:44and they were sitting in a car while kate went into some store with her bodyguard and um who
00:42:52she was probably having an affair with i guess and at one point he starts fighting with one of
00:42:57his sisters and his sister just starts clawing at his face oh my god his face gets like literally
00:43:03all cut up and bloody and he remembers how hot his face felt with all the blood on it
00:43:07and he and there i think there were two nannies in the van at this point she comes back to the
00:43:13car and they're like oh he just started going crazy and scratching his face and his sister's
00:43:17like yeah he's being crazy and everyone just piled in on him blaming him for clawing his own face and
00:43:24he's like look how i do i don't even have long nails like and his sister had clearly long nails
00:43:29i'm like i didn't do this and you can even tell in later footage of the episode where this all
00:43:35happens on this vacation there's some scene on the beach where he's separate and distant from
00:43:40the rest of them uh kind of milling about by himself while everyone else is playing in the
00:43:44foreground and he her kate's own makeup artist had like plastered foundation over his face to try to
00:43:52hide the scratch marks oh so the reason why they all blamed it on him and not the sisters for the
00:43:57film crew they didn't want the film crew to be like i don't know i don't know it does seem that
00:44:01the most the people who are most familiar with the abuse that was taking place were the nannies
00:44:05and tutors they they did know what was going on because they're carrying around the camera showing
00:44:10him in his cell as he begs to be let out to go pee and they're the ones who are sitting in the van
00:44:15whereas the camera crew was forbade they she forbade them from entering the basement and all
00:44:20these other things so i think they knew less of what was going on though they probably had their
00:44:24suspicions but they were making so much money they probably just didn't care which which is insane to
00:44:29me because like even with i mean if you're familiar with hollywood kids the camera crew here
00:44:34you know maybe no no because no hollywood kids even at that period when they were filming all
00:44:39this stuff in like the 20 or the naughties or whatever like 2010s there were heavy heavy
00:44:43regulations around how much kids could work maybe less with reality tv i know there's more laws now
00:44:47but like the documentary crew that films with our kids here they're all parents uh or most of them
00:44:53are they love our kids our kids hang out with them our kids love everybody who meets our kids
00:44:58loves our kids we have like but like they care like if they thought that we were abusing our
00:45:03kids i'm pretty sure they would like do something you know i mean i think they they don't think
00:45:08we're perfect and i don't know what's going to happen to us when this thing comes out but like
00:45:11they it's it's bizarre to me that this film crew who i could only imagine have getting getting
00:45:17attached to the kids would be okay with any of this um but somehow they let it happen i hold on
00:45:23so i'm gonna push back here it's a film our film crew gets attached to our kids specifically
00:45:29because our kids are very pro-social very confident our kids have almost severely injured
00:45:39several of them true and that's part of this this kid may have simply not interacted with
00:45:45the film crew much oh just been very distant you think yeah some kids are just you know timid and
00:45:50you're not gonna build the same sympathy for a timid kid a lot of what got him in trouble
00:45:54initially like what was seen as behavioral problems is he was very reticent to get involved
00:45:59in the documentary he really didn't like like being interviewed he he described her as he was
00:46:04being interviewed you know on like the confessional chair um her sitting you know right behind the
00:46:09cameraman being like like you have to smile like putting her her fingers you know at the sides of
00:46:14her mouth and like pointing upwards to like yeah like you had to smile uh which is terrifying and
00:46:19there's all these shots of him um in the show just looking so listless and sad he like his father
00:46:24john really didn't want to be a part of this and was very reticent i think that's part of like what
00:46:28initially made her be like i need to medicate him he's not acting the way i want because you know
00:46:32she this was her livelihood they didn't have jobs after they had these kids they just made
00:46:36tlc they're gonna be very hard to i guess yeah you can't if she was a nurse you can't support
00:46:43no well i mean no and the way that she wanted like i said they're like the classic combo nurse
00:46:49and fireman there's always a parent home it's the perfect career combo anyway whatever uh two of my
00:46:54cousins ended up in arrangement the two of my cousins became nurses they were girls our girls
00:46:59and married firemen how many of our watchers are nurse firemen combinations i wonder yeah i wonder
00:47:05this is like this secret pronatalist combo that allows for we have like a bunch of like somebody
00:47:09was like oh my god watching malcolm struggle was like a basic like screwing something together he's
00:47:14like i could do that in my sleep and yet he has no problem with all this ai coding stuff
00:47:18and i'm like easy your farmer nonsense is hard i don't know how anyone could find that easy
00:47:24well yeah it's uh but we have we have a lot of like a traditional men0.94
00:47:29here's to all the man men who are firemen and policemen and shoot bad guys
00:47:39great oh yeah it was a policeman one married a policeman and one married a fireman you know
00:47:46got me on the show i was just i was recently on um archcast great guy love him anyway so he uh
00:47:53like people could be like malcolm you have such a gay voice it's so gay your voice and i'm like
00:47:59whatever man i got the voice i got okay i'm not gonna i'm not gonna present myself with anything0.91
00:48:04other than what i am yeah we're just gonna have to go down on the internet is that that cute
00:48:07lesbian i want to be like look if i'm same-sex attracted i've got a wife and five kids okay so
00:48:13like clearly i on a harder difficulty setting than you beat you with the morality game okay i guess0.57
00:48:21yeah who has more kids in the end uh you know what i'm not just even from a christian morality
00:48:25framework right you know wife and five kids that the bible doesn't say don't be same-sex attracted0.99
00:48:31it says don't be gay right yeah i just i just think your slutty background doesn't imply that0.98
00:48:36you're same-sex attracted your body count doesn't imply that but like i'm not a parade of people0.98
00:48:42thinking i'm saying i know i well no that's look okay context some griper clip maker uh put some
00:48:49clip up of malcolm ranting against nick fuentes and me defending him and malcolm drink milk during0.97
00:48:56this clip and everyone's just like who are these ugly lesbians and why is he drinking milk and0.97
00:49:02like how dare he this is the thing of of of all of us there are i agree that i look effeminate and0.99
00:49:11i sound kind of gay sometimes but if you are standing one person on earth who unilaterally0.86
00:49:20looks more effeminate and talk gayer than me it's nick stop no we we want to have him on it would0.89
00:49:27be great for nick fuentes to come on the show why are you being so mean i think so a lot of other
00:49:32people have asked us explicitly not to have him on the show why yeah that's true that is true
00:49:38Because we are seen as the pro-natalist figureheads, and having him on the show, even though we don't like this framing and this way of doing things, could end up as other people seen as associating the pro-natalist movement with Nick Fuentes or the Gropers.0.85
00:49:53Yeah, I just, I strongly, I strongly am against the whole we don't talk to them thing.0.79
00:53:20therefore if my kid is acting in a way that is out alignment with my own emotional state
00:53:25then there's something wrong with the kid even if their own emotions are fluctuating wildly or
00:53:29not coherent with reality yeah yeah i will say if i'm going to point out anything sus about this
00:53:35i'll point out a few sus things that could make me one the fact that everyone in the car blamed him
00:53:42now there are cases of abuse in families and stuff like this but this also sounds a little
00:53:47suspicious like there's more to that story than he's letting on oh he was no he admits in the
00:53:52book to being an obstinate child and and the second one is the tutor who he said he trusted
00:53:59thinking it was safe to lock him in his room that that was the safer option that almost indicates
00:54:05to me that he had demonstrated something to that tutor that made the tutor cohere with the mom's
00:54:10belief that it was safer to lock him up even when he vouched for that tutor's morality
00:54:17and logical coherence i mean up until then but also he's a kid you know and if this is one person
00:54:23who shows you a little bit of kindness but yeah i mean i he he does not glaze over the reality that
00:54:30he was an obstinate kid and that he didn't get in trouble a lot obstinate to justify this but
00:54:38dangerous to justify this and that's where yeah there there is no there is no clear evidence of
00:54:44that but on days she would have coming here here's what i can see something like this happens
00:54:48we've had some children that some days just spaz out and act terrible during filming and it makes
00:54:54us look terrible because if you're forcing a kid to do something people are like oh that's the scene
00:54:58and so uh if you didn't care and you had cameras in your house every day
00:55:04it may make sense just to lock a kid in the basement where filming isn't allowed to happen
00:55:09uh to allow you to get the shots you need that yeah but like just don't do it i mean throw him
00:55:16one of our our there are various ai backslash os we have a wonderful android operating system that
00:55:22could have uh allowed him to educate himself while he was locked up specifically mudpuppy.ai
00:55:29backslash os um and it allows you to flush like old android tablets and phones and stuff like that
00:55:35with a operating system that allows kids to watch all you know documentaries and cartoons from the
00:55:4290s and they get points for watching documentaries and talking about them with an ai and then
00:55:48they spend the points on cartoons it's pretty good it's pretty good our kids love it yeah no
00:55:53if she could just like have made his his cell a little bit more comfortable but yeah she could1.00
00:56:00not do that but i think the bigger question here and the larger theme of this women are terrible1.00
00:56:05episode is why do women think that they can do this um and and what doesn't make sense to me1.00
00:56:12again is that the film crew probably knew about this even though they weren't allowed to enter1.00
00:56:15the basement because she wasn't able to do it she got her bag she's not even making money anymore0.92
00:56:19well no here's the thing though is i actually think she just she she she got away with it like1.00
00:56:26she she did get it she the women think they can do this because they do and can and and they get1.00
00:56:34away with this. When we did the, when we talked about the woman who strangled her children in her0.99
00:56:41basement, whatever her name was, there were people who came forward and told us of similar things
00:56:47that had happened with their families who then got off really easy, like basically didn't really
00:56:55serve time. And I think we live in a society that gives way too much leeway for abuse and crimes
00:57:03probably for complicated reasons i think for one reason like there isn't much of an alternative
00:57:09you know like where are the kids going to go the state for example doesn't want to pay for more
00:57:15kids like that they have to handle through child protective services and stuff and it costs a lot
00:57:21of money for even for kids to be fostered um even though we don't have orphanages anymore
00:57:26so i mean yeah he's still probably better with his family than he is in the system
00:57:31Yeah, I think that's the key problem is we're sort of at this horrific impasse where the government and society at large acknowledges that there is kind of nowhere to, there's nowhere to go.
00:57:46and so i think especially mothers get away with this horrific abuse because what else is going
00:57:53to happen to the kid there is no orphanage system there is no benevolent like adoption system there
00:57:58is no fostering system that doesn't cost the state a ton of money and so they're like well kid like
00:58:05sorry yeah like what are we supposed to do yeah like whatever i mean like the mother had you and
00:58:11also just considering to the way that my body my choice seems to extend to live children now
00:58:18um we just live in this toxic culture where that's not punished and it hasn't been punished
00:58:24historically as you pointed out when you talked about all the atrocities that mothers commit
00:58:28what was interesting is we get punished for very light things with our kids they get not punished
00:58:34for very heavy things and it's because well she was criticized heavily but she also just
00:58:38internalized it as her identity she's like yeah i'm a tough mom i mean she just identified as a
00:58:42karen she's like that's just how i am i'm just strict i get angry whereas we we do not identify
00:58:51yeah you would be embarrassed to treat me that way on camera presumably right like i would be
00:58:56humiliated whenever i know whenever i like accidentally say something that makes you look
00:59:02bad which always happens and i really hate that on camera i beat myself up for weeks i'm still
00:59:08beating myself up for it and yeah that she just like i leaned into the end but also that like she
00:59:15she clearly hated him and this is another thing i just wish people that hated each other would
00:59:20not have kids because then they're just going to hate their kids and then those kids are going to
00:59:24be mistreated just like he was and i this again dark cronadolism only people who deeply love each
00:59:29other and who deeply want to invest in in giving kids an amazing life should be having kids this
00:59:37is all very depressing and this is one of those terrible there is no justice in the world we have
00:59:42to build a better world because i want a world in which only the most well-resourced loving people
00:59:49are left on this planet and having kids i can't deal with this i can't deal with and here's where
00:59:56i struggle is on the surface of it kate goslin is a pronatalist like she you said from like some
01:00:04interview or something she's she i just so wanted to be a mother yeah and yet she seemed to hate
01:00:10every second of being a mother there's all these clips i really like being a dad having the kids
01:00:17with us is a lot of fun i love it too i love them so much and i i am not a natural mother i never
01:00:23saw myself as a mother i i never liked kids i'm not a kid person i'm just like i'm gay for our
01:00:30kids i love our kids um i i'm a kid person for our kids and i i don't know i don't i don't have
01:00:37a like solution for this and i desperately want a solution for this because i i hate that this
01:00:40happened to colin i i it feels so bad looking at these clips of him as this kid just like
01:00:49constantly having things taken from him um yeah i don't know there's no justice in this world
01:00:57we have to build a better one and love you uh i am excited for the case case and i have decided
01:01:05that i'm going to sort through everything in my room and completely clean it up so there's nothing
01:01:09on the floor or anything like that really all right i might need some more boxes but i think
01:01:17i can do this okay what inspired this change of heart well i was looking at how nice my new bed
01:01:25setup is yeah i thought it would be a good narrative for the documentary on us oh but like0.97
01:01:31he's making jewelry now he's got to get this shit together yeah yeah wow what do you think0.96
01:01:37i mean i would love that especially because the kids want to spend more time with you in your room0.99
01:01:41these days um they just want more daddy time because they want to be away from the hag witch1.00
01:01:46that is their mother uh i think that um you can be their safe place and they would really like that0.99
01:01:52Oh, and I can get a nicer lamp because I've got this cheap one that's like a freaking bulb on a stick.0.96