00:04:56And certainly I was forming the belief that a campaign was underway, but it wasn't until the final summer of Joe Biden's presidency when his national security advisor, who is the person who has more knowledge about intelligence matters and security matters than anybody in the world.
00:05:14She came out and she said that, this answers the second part of your question, the entity who is the campaign manager that was paying for protesters in Western democracy that is organizing protests was Iran.
00:05:29Iran was overseeing, basically as a campaign manager, to answer your question, they were taking on that role for themselves.
00:05:37The banker was Qatar, so people were being paid to protest. Not all the time, but a lot of the time. Like, for example, at Columbia University, which was the epicenter for a lot of this anti-Semitic campus activity, if you put in eight hours a week training people how to do these protests, you could get as much as $4,000 US a week.
00:06:01In the university at Victoria, there was an entity called the Plenty Collective that was funneling out $20,000 a month.
00:06:11They were quite open about it for people to show up at protests.
00:06:15And some of that money was coming from government.
00:06:17So this stuff was happening right from the start.
00:06:20And the campaign manager, as the U.S. security advisor, national security advisor confirmed, was Iran.
00:06:27Is that where we're talking about, um, bot farms being used, uh, on social media, pushing the graphics, the narratives over and over again?
00:06:41For example, so basically around 18 months, exactly before October 7th.
00:06:46So the spring of 2022, hundreds of profiles started popping up around the Middle East, Europe, and North America.
00:06:53And these profiles, Brian had, uh, you know, 70 or 80 followers. They post photos of it, their
00:07:00kitten or a boyfriend or a celebrity or whatever. And they were pretty static. They didn't have a
00:07:06lot of activity. Then on the morning of October 7th, they sprang into life and there were about
00:07:13200,000 of these profiles and a large number of them were fake. It was later determined. And,
00:07:19you know, somebody that had 70 followers was suddenly getting half a million viewers. Like
00:07:25there were, there were about 50,000 of them, for example, that put out about 312,000 posts and
00:07:32comments. They were seen more than half a billion times in 48 hours. So like that kind of stuff
00:07:39doesn't happen or it doesn't happen organically. You need the support at the state level. And I
00:07:44think that's the role that China and Russia play. So it's literally just computer servers
00:07:50pumping this stuff out, providing an echo chamber to get it out to the largest number of people.
00:07:57And it was so sophisticated, Brian, the messages in Arabic were different than the messages used
00:08:03in the English language or French or German language. So on the 7th, these profiles came
00:08:11to life, as I say, in Arabic, pushing out a message that there'd been atrocities at the0.68
00:08:16Dome of the Rock, you know, a solemn, a holy place in Islam, that Israel was going to have
00:08:22a hostage exchange, that Israel was committing atrocities. About three days later, different
00:08:28messages started to come out in the English language, in places like Canada, saying that
00:08:34there'd been no atrocities. And if something did happen, Israel did it to itself. And they did it0.65
00:08:40themselves in order to justify their genocide against the Palestinian people so it was a very
00:08:46sophisticated segmented campaign just like political parties do during elections all right
00:08:53that there was an incident early in in the war as israel starts responding when it came to uh
00:09:03the bombing of a hospital and and that is it started out with regular media and then
00:09:10it became a huge issue in um in social media and was carried out there tell us about the uh
00:09:19al-hali arab hospital in gaza i believe was mid-october and the claim was that israel had
00:09:27bombed it and killed 500 people and the media ran with it it New York Times BBC it was everywhere
00:09:35it's you know it's important to know that we've just been talking about how the bad guys Iran
00:09:42and China and Russia and Hamas were active on social media and they were very effective on
00:09:47social media but they weren't just doing it there they were doing it in mainstream media as you
00:09:51point out. So Joe Biden, when he was president of the United States, was one of the G7 leaders who
00:09:58came to Israel to show solidarity with the victims of October 7th. And actually there's only two G7
00:10:04leaders who have never done that. And that's Justin Trudeau and Mark Carney, but leaving that
00:10:09to one side. So Biden shows up shortly on October 10th, 2023 to show solidarity with Israel. And as
00:10:18his plane is landing as air force one is landing headline in the new york times above the fold
00:10:23hundreds killed at gaza hospital israel to blame palestinians say and it was and you know forgive
00:10:33my use of this language it was bullshit the hospital is still standing 500 people were not0.58
00:10:38killed it's actually likely that nobody was killed a missile did hit the parking lot not the hospital0.89
00:10:45And the missile was not sent by Israel. It was sent by Palestinian Islamic Jihad. But to this day, Brian, just to show how effective this propaganda campaign is, our then global affairs minister, Melanie Jolie, Melanie Jolie posted on her official social media account that Israel was to blame for that.
00:11:06That, if you go and check right now, that post is still up and it is shameful and it is dishonest and disgusting, but it is an example of how effective this campaign was, not just in social media, but also in mainstream media.
00:11:20One of the people that you talk to for both the book and the documentary is Talor Cohen Montemayor.
00:11:29She runs a group called CyberWell that tracks anti-Semitism online.
00:11:35I want to play a clip here because she describes how effective the campaign was specifically after this incident.
00:11:43What was interesting to see is not only that this traditional media ran with this headline,
00:11:48but that specific piece of misinformation and disinformation that made it to social media
00:11:52caused a clear trigger of elevated levels of anti-Semitism online.
00:11:57That's the first time in the conflict that hashtag Hitler was right started trending on Twitter,
00:12:03went up by 1,600% in Arabic, reaching a potential audience of over 25 million people.
00:12:11So this is a direct example of how misinformation and disinformation can create a response that actually causes to support hate.
00:12:20So Warren, she tracks this, she documents it, but how do you fight back against something like that?
00:12:27How do you push back? Because there are still people that believe this, even after the facts come out.
00:12:33Yeah, so they were assisted by two things. On the one hand, they had state-level support.
00:12:38So you had Iran, who's very proficient in internet manipulation, but also Russia and China.
00:12:45Russia and China, you know, using that campaign flowchart that you referred to earlier, if the campaign manager was Iran, the campaign co-chairs were China and Russia.
00:12:55So there was state-level support for getting out this anti-Semitic content.
00:13:00But also, you know, it's not enough just to do that.
00:13:04And very early on, polling in Canada and the United States and Europe showed that young people were quite susceptible, unfortunately, Gen Z and millennials, to this anti-Semitic messaging that had been going on for some time.
00:13:19So they actually narrow cast it. They didn't broadcast their anti-Semitic message. They narrow casted it at certain demographics they knew would be very receptive to these terrible examples that Talor talks about in the clip that you just showed. And it really started to move public opinion within those demographics.
00:13:40Well, we saw the Osama bin Laden was right issue, uh, pop up in that demographic and on social media. We saw Hitler is right trend. This is, it is remarkable to me the impact that this has had.0.98
00:14:01It is. And, you know, some of the messaging was horrible.
00:14:06What the Anti-Defamation League, the B'nai B'rith in the United States, has been doing polling for many, many years, 60 years, about anti-Semitism and racism.
00:14:15And they found that if you were concerned about racism, you were also concerned about anti-Semitism.
00:14:22And around the time of the pandemic, when young people had to retreat into this online world, you started to see them embracing conspiracy theories.0.91
00:14:34You know, the Jews own pharmaceutical companies and Jews invented COVID.0.87
00:14:39But also they started to get into conspiracy theories like the Holocaust didn't happen.0.81
00:14:45And so when Iran started narrowcasting their hateful message about Israel around the time of October 7th, they were aiming right at those audiences.
00:14:57And so this is why you were seeing protests in the street almost entirely populated by young people.
00:15:03This is why you were starting to see encampments at virtually every major university across North America.
00:15:09And then we were finding out there were groups like Students for Justice in Palestine, who have budgets of untold millions, actually providing support for these encampments, providing talking points.
00:15:22They were even, Brian, they were saying to these students, if you get arrested, we will provide you with free legal representation.
00:15:30I can tell you as a lawyer, lawyers don't work for free very often, but in the case of this anti-Semitic global campaign, that's what was happening.
00:15:39The universities have been targeted for a long time. We'll get into how long this campaign's been going on in a bit. But Qatar, we had Harris Rafikon from ISGAP and Secure Canada a while back talking about how Qatar has been funding this. Have Western governments just been asleep at the switch and letting this sort of thing fester on campuses?
00:16:04Yeah, for sure. If you look at Carnegie, ISGAP found out that Carnegie Mellon in Pennsylvania, a prestigious Ivy League university, received billions with a B from Qatar over a period of about a decade.0.52
00:16:19And if you look at that decade, anti-Semitism on that campus started to explode. So there was a correlation between this funding that was taking place with universities and anti-Semitism.
00:16:31And here's the big problem. It was illegal. It was illegal for Carnegie Mellon and Harvard and Yale and these other universities to accept these billions from Qatar and other places. They were supposed to disclose that to the government and to the public, and they weren't doing that.
00:16:49And of course, here in Canada, we have the involvement of SJP at every single major university in this country.
00:16:59And so we had terrible things taking place at campuses like the University of Toronto, where there was an encampment there for months in the middle of King's Circle.
00:17:09There was one just beyond the Roddick Gates at McGill.
00:17:16They had food, they had drink, they had transportation, they had legal representation.
00:17:23It was organized like a military occupation, and that's how it conducted itself as well.
00:17:30And you saw the same organizers, people that have targeted you and I over the last several years, the same organizers showing up at the University of Toronto, showing up at McGill, showing up in Ottawa.
00:17:43They would travel a circuit handing out flags.
00:17:46How many Palestinian flags can there be in Canada? And yet you would go to a protest. And again, this is days after everyone's got a brand new shiny Palestinian flag. Everyone's got the same just printed placards to, you know, call for their support for the entire time.
00:18:07yeah and you know early on when the these campus protests are taking place you saw a place like
00:18:13columbia where all of these kids had identical tents and you know i had people say to me that
00:18:19can't be a coincidence and i said well it could be maybe there was a sale at amazon who knows
00:18:24but then there started to be more and more evidence of coordination like those signs that
00:18:29you refer to you know those professionally rendered signs that political parties use in campaigns
00:18:35like some of those Brian like those banners and so on they're professionally made they're like 50
00:18:41or 100 bucks they're not cheap you know I've helped run campaigns over the years you got to
00:18:47find money to pay for that kind of stuff and money was just falling out of the trees onto these anti
00:18:53Israel anti-western protests and now we know because it's been confirmed by intelligence agencies
00:18:59around the world, but a lot of the money was coming from Iran and Qatar, and this alphabet
00:19:05soup of non-profits and NGOs and so-called pro-Palestinian charities that have been allowed
00:19:13to operate with impunity in places like Canada and the United States.
00:19:18Okay, when we come back, we're going to take a quick break, but when we come back, we'll
00:19:22talk about how long the planning for this has taken.
00:21:24This is Tristan Hopper, the host of Canada Did What?, where we unpack the biggest, weirdest, and wildest political moments in Canadian history you thought you knew, and tell you what really happened.
00:21:35Stick around at the end of the episode to hear a sample of one of our favorite episodes from Season 2.
00:21:40And if you missed it, there are even more episodes from last season, so make sure you subscribe to Canada Did What? everywhere you get podcasts.
00:21:48these spontaneous protests Warren they did not just come out of nowhere this was years in the
00:21:55making you talked about the social media accounts popping up uh 18 months before the attacks
00:22:02happened one of the people that you spoke to again for both the book and the documentary was a
00:22:07former advertising executive named Gary Wexler um tell us what he's talking about here with
00:22:15finding out how long this had been in the works, the planning, how deep it was.
00:22:22You cannot put together a campaign at the municipal level, Brian, overnight. And you
00:22:29certainly can't do it at a global level, as we were seeing from the earliest moments after October
00:22:357th. You can't do that overnight. Procter & Gamble can't do that. Apple can't do that.
00:22:40It requires money. It requires people. It requires organization. It requires structure. And so it didn't happen right after October 7th. It had been in the works for a long time. So we started to see them targeting young people back in the pandemic, but it went back even further than that.
00:22:59And what Gary is talking about is the experience he had when he was working for an NGO in Israel and was interviewing people in Gaza and the West Bank and asking them about what they should be doing in the future.
00:23:14And he met this guy who said, basically, and this is what I've received, the people I've interviewed, is they've learned from the Jewish organizations.0.54
00:23:23They're going to create their own foundations.
00:23:25They're going to create their own social media.
00:23:27They're going to infiltrate the mainstream media.
00:23:29They're going to do their own fundraising. They're going to create their own campaign structure so that when they decide to move, they're going to be ready.
00:23:37And what's amazing is, you know, they always knew that they would be defeated by Israel on the battlefield.0.94
00:23:44They always knew that they would lose.0.82
00:23:46But what they were always doing, and what Hamas is the expert at, is attacking civilians, inviting a military response, and then using that as propaganda, using that military response as propaganda.0.67
00:24:01And what Gary found 30 years ago is a guy who was willing to talk about what was about to take place.0.60
00:24:09Unfortunately, nobody in Israel or the West believed him.
00:24:12When you get to Haifa and you start to interview a man named Amir Machul,
00:30:07You know, when Joe Biden went to Ireland just this week and came under physical attack by protesters, they were pro-Palestinian protesters.
00:30:18When we see it in the city of Toronto, every single weekend at the corner of Bathurst and Shepard, terrible things being said about Jews in a Jewish neighborhood, being permitted by the mayor of Toronto and the chief of police in Toronto, that is a coordinated campaign against Jews.0.61
00:30:36You see the Palestinian flag. It's like the default for every protester. It was showing up in those riots that were happening in France recently that were supposedly about high school student school conditions. And suddenly it's overtaken with the Palestinian cause.0.58
00:30:56What's happened is there is my very first book on a related subject was called Unholy Alliances.
00:31:03And what I found, and this was 30 years ago, you had forces on the far left coming together with forces on the far right and extremist and terrorist groups from the American Indian Movement, Nation of Islam, the White Aryan Resistance, and also far left groups.
00:31:24Marxist-Leninist groups coming together as an unholy alliance to attack Israel and attack
00:31:30Western democracy. 30 years ago, they weren't as successful. Now they are much more successful.
00:31:36You can see it in public opinion. You can see it in the polling. They've moved a lot of people
00:31:41against Israel. And it's not just young people and on the left. You know, just this week,
00:31:47we had the vice president of the United States saying one of the reasons why his party lost
00:31:51the midterms was was israel it was a shocking and appalling thing to say but again it's an
00:31:57indicator of how successful this propaganda campaign has been because now we're seeing0.89
00:32:02trouble not just on the left we're seeing it on the right as well who's who's part of the alliance
00:32:09now then you described who was there 30 years ago i i often hear it called the red green alliance
00:32:17The people who make it up now come across, you see them wide range of society.
00:32:23So you have public sector unions, you have it in academia.
00:32:28You certainly obviously have it in social media, a huge problem there.
00:32:31You have it in mainstream media at institutions like the CBC or the BBC or PBS or, you know, sometimes even coming out of editorials in the Toronto Star.
00:32:43You have it taking place in governmental institutions, but principally the problem is, I say, we're seeing it on social media.
00:32:52And the social media platforms, whether they are X, Twitter, TikTok, the meta properties like Facebook or Instagram, certainly Telegram, all of them are completely indifferent.
00:33:03As Talor Cohen Montemayor was saying earlier in your show, is her job, what she does is she brings these examples of extreme anti-Semitism to the Mark Zuckerbergs or the Elon Musk's to say, you need to deal with this.
00:33:22And unfortunately, too often, they're just leaving it up.
00:35:52We've seen the same thing with politicians across Western democracy, where they'll say all the right things.
00:35:59And then you have terrible events like Bondi Beach, where 16 people were slaughtered as they gathered to celebrate Hanukkah less than a year ago.
00:36:08You had events like in Belleville, 20 minutes from where I am at this moment, where 25 people were within a minute of being slaughtered here in Canada, here in Ontario, for being Jews, and only because of the intervention of two brave police officers, that didn't happen.
00:36:26It is happening. Propaganda is always, if it's effective, accompanied by violence. That is the objective, is to move people from a hateful thought to a hateful deed. That is what is happening.0.50
00:36:41So the answer to your important question is the Mark Carney's, the Doug Ford's, these other levels of government, the J.D. Vance's, they need to get off their asses and act.0.99
00:36:52We have no shortage of laws to deal with this problem.0.99
00:37:38But getting your message out that is sometimes a pro-Israel message is pretty difficult outside of the pages of the post-media newspapers or the New York Post or the Wall Street Journal.
00:37:50It's a pretty hostile environment out there.
00:37:53You know, for example, my book has not been mentioned anywhere by any mainstream media organization other than this one.