Juno News - October 02, 2026


Professor blames Canada’s economic woes on ‘Laurentian elites’ who ‘restricted’ growth

Topics
Mentioned
The Court Fight Over Canada’s Trans Inmate Policy Canada’s Broken System: Criminals Get Coddled, Canadians Get Screwed

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

166.95

Word count

3,564

Sentence count

223

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 U.S. Border Tsar Tom Homan says it's time for America to shift its border security focus north
00:00:11 to Canada. Now that America's southern border is secure, Homan describes Canada as a huge
00:00:18 national security vulnerability. It's another sign of just how far Canada's relationship with
00:00:24 the United States has fallen. Ian Lee is an associate professor at the Sprott Business School
00:00:30 at Carleton University. He has co-authored a book, a new one, with Larry O'Brien. It's called
00:00:37 Trapped in the Shadow of Trump's America and How We Escape. The book doesn't just diagnose the
00:00:44 problem. It offers some solutions, five of them. Professor Lee joins us now from Ottawa. Welcome,
00:00:51 sir. Thanks very much, Mark. Thanks for inviting me. Let's talk a little bit about the book and
00:00:57 what brought you to writing it. I think it's a very timely one, obviously, and you've
00:01:03 written it along with Larry O'Brien at a time when a lot of Canadians are concerned about our
00:01:09 relationship with the Americans. Maybe you could talk about how that came to be, the book.
00:01:14 Sure. I mean, I've known Larry for quite some time. Full disclosure, I supported him when he
00:01:19 he ran for mayor in 2000. Larry is a technology entrepreneur. He's lived in Ottawa all his
00:01:25 life like I have. And he started, he was the founder of Callion Technology, which is a
00:01:31 very well-known and successful Canadian startup. It's now listed and has been for years on
00:01:36 the Toronto Stock Exchange. He ran for mayor, sold out all his shares, so he wasn't in a
00:01:40 conflict of interest. And he ran on a, you know, a campaign at the time of bringing taxes
00:01:46 under control, you know, a prudent, small c, fiscal conservative government. And that's when
00:01:53 I first really got to know him. Over the years, we've stayed in touch. We've talked. And it became
00:01:59 increasingly clear that our views were very, very similar, and especially on the whole question of
00:02:05 the Trump government. We don't agree with Donald Trump on terrorists. We don't agree with just
00:02:11 about anything he's doing. But we didn't agree with people who, many Canadians, who are saying
00:02:16 that Trump had caused our problems. And because we just knew that wasn't true. Trump did not cause
00:02:24 the $200 billion of interprovincial trade barriers, which have emerged over very long decades
00:02:32 by premiers of Canada's provinces. Trump didn't create the dependency that Canada created for
00:02:40 itself in betting everything on the U.S. and not diversifying its economy by developing
00:02:48 resources and exporting them to other countries around the world.
00:02:51 In fact, successive governments expressly tried to restrict the resource development.
00:02:59 Mr. Guibo, the former environment minister, said resources should be left in the ground.
00:03:02 And so it was this, and I think it was the high watermark was the last 10 years of the Justin Trudeau administration.
00:03:12 And so this book is not partisan. It is not about Justin Trudeau. It's not about Donald Trump.
00:03:17 What we do is we look at the mistakes of the last 60 years in Canada, at the various mistakes we made that did things like develop the provincial tariff barriers and protectionism that kept out foreign competition and so forth.
00:03:36 And we documented these in the first half of the book.
00:03:39 So that was the diagnostics.
00:03:41 That's like going to the doctor and the doctor says, well, I've got to diagnose the patient to see what's wrong.
00:03:46 And we produced lots of data, by the way, lots of data sourced from Stats Canada, trend data, showing our productivity going down very dramatically over many years.
00:03:58 So it's much lower today relative to the United States.
00:04:01 So then we said, OK, what Trump, we didn't deny what Trump is doing.
00:04:05 What we said is in the book is Trump exploited our weaknesses.
00:04:09 He saw our weaknesses and he mercilessly exploited the weaknesses that we had done to ourselves and that gave him the opportunity to go after us.
00:04:23 And so that's the framework of the book.
00:04:27 We document our structural problems, our structural weaknesses, declining productivity, protectionism, excessive regulation.
00:04:36 The OECD ranks us with a very, very poor record compared to other countries with excessive regulation.
00:04:43 We used these various statistics from OECD or from StatsCan showing these problems that exist in Canada.
00:04:53 And then in the final third of the book, we've got our solutions, which is to address and eliminate these weaknesses to make us independent and able to resist the demands and the pressures from the Trump administration.
00:05:10 If you're going back 60 years, then obviously there were agreements made.
00:05:14 I mean, I can go back to the free trade agreement that was negotiated between Brian Mulroney and Reagan.
00:05:21 And at the time, you'll recall the election that really set the stage for that.
00:05:28 Mulroney said, you know, this is going to be great for Canada.
00:05:31 We're going to be able to deal with the Americans at a level that will enrich our country.
00:05:37 And we should definitely move forward.
00:05:39 I can remember the debate, the hot debate over sovereignty in Canada.
00:05:45 Would there be a problem in terms of losing our independence if we aligned ourselves too closely with the administration of the day?
00:05:54 And then, of course, there was NAFTA that was negotiated with Stretien and Clinton.
00:05:59 Were those mistakes in your view?
00:06:02 No, no, we didn't.
00:06:03 We're not anti-free traders, by the way.
00:06:05 I don't want to leave you with the idea or your viewers with the idea that we're saying rip up the free trade agreement.
00:06:11 The mistake was not the free trade agreement.
00:06:14 The mistake was the Laurentian elites.
00:06:17 John Ibbotson, the former Globe and Mail journalist, uses this phrase, the Laurentian elites.
00:06:21 These are the political people in Ottawa, Toronto, and Montreal.
00:06:26 They're, I mean, quite, I'll be very frank.
00:06:28 We're not going to, you know, mislead or deceive.
00:06:31 They're largely progressive liberals, small-l liberals.
00:06:35 I'm not this isn't a partisan book where we're saying those people that believe that, you know, we should be closing down the economy and restricting it and we shouldn't develop our resources with the mistake we made was in saying we're going to put lots of restrictions around resources.
00:06:51 We're going to have the no pipeline bill, the tanker ban bill, and said, even though
00:06:56 we've got trillions, literally trillions of dollars of resources, not just oil and
00:07:02 gas, we have trees like no tomorrow, timber, we have potash.
00:07:07 I think we're number one in the world.
00:07:08 We have uranium for the nuclear fuel for nuclear reactors.
00:07:13 We have fish, we have seafood, we have canola, we have the resources that the world wants.
00:07:18 The Germans have said they want it, the Europeans, the Japanese, the South Korean country, Prime Minister, excuse me.
00:07:26 And so what we did, the mistake was not in doing the free trade agreement.
00:07:30 It was embedding the farm and saying we will basically only deal with the United States when we should have been simultaneously expanding and diversifying, yes, the United States,
00:07:43 but we should never have done what we did, which made us so overly dependent on one country.
00:07:49 We did look at the data.
00:07:51 All the other major countries of the world are nowhere near 70% of exports going to one country.
00:07:55 The only other country that has such a high dependency on one country is Mexico.
00:08:01 The G7, Germany, France, Italy, Japan are nowhere near 70% of all their exports going to one country called the U.S.
00:08:10 That was the mistake.
00:08:11 The mistake was closing down our resource sector by people like Mr. Guibo, who said that this was a terrible thing to develop our resources.
00:08:20 And so we're criticizing these kinds of decisions over the last 60 years that trapped us and then drove us into the arms of the United States when we should have been diversifying at the same time we did these trade agreements with the U.S.
00:08:35 Now, since Prime Minister Carney came into office and he has moved, I would suggest tentatively towards opening up the resource sector more with an MOU, I know you're very well aware of, is this enough?
00:08:55 Is he moving fast enough in your view, considering all of our issues with the United States?
00:09:01 I mean, you know, it's still going to, even with the MOU, it's still going to take a long
00:09:06 time to develop these resources and to build out the kind of infrastructure which you're
00:09:12 referring to, which is pipelines, right?
00:09:14 We had at one point an agreement to build a pipeline, west and east.
00:09:21 This is Energy East, Northern Gateway.
00:09:24 They did not have-
00:09:25 Which we need, by the way.
00:09:26 Sorry?
00:09:26 Which we need.
00:09:27 Which we need.
00:09:28 You're talking about reversing the policies of the last 10 years, I take it, 11 years, moving towards.
00:09:35 Yes, especially so.
00:09:37 Yes.
00:09:38 And I'm not, again, we're not being part of it.
00:09:40 We're just looking at the policies.
00:09:41 And the policies of the last 10 years, we're using data throughout.
00:09:46 We lost a trillion dollars of capital, capital flight, because the policies were so negative to the economy.
00:09:52 and the C.D. Howell Research Centre, which is staffed by a ton of former retired Bank of Canada
00:09:58 economists, okay, in Toronto, documented this. We're using stat scan data showing the productivity
00:10:05 was going down, down, down. And so we're showing that these policies of the past government were
00:10:10 very harmful to the Canadian economy. Mr. Carney and our ultimate evidence for our statements about
00:10:17 those policies is Mr. Carney is reversing a lot of them. We applaud him. We don't think he's doing
00:10:22 enough, although he's going in the right direction. So let's give him kudos for going in the right
00:10:27 direction. I mean, he's got to clean up the port of Vancouver. It's a mess. By the way, comes 398
00:10:33 out of 400 ports in the world by an independent nonpartisan organization that ranks the efficiencies
00:10:38 of ports in the world. We're terrible. The development, we have one of the worst records.
00:10:44 In fact, we have the slowest record in the world to open a new mine. 21 years from the time you
00:10:50 start to develop to the time you finish it. There is no country in the world with such a
00:10:54 bad record. We've been talking for 35 years about building a road, just a road up to the ring of
00:11:01 fire in Northern Ontario. 35 years later, we still haven't built the road. So there's a lot
00:11:07 of problems. And we talk about this in the book, you know, the red tape and the bureaucracy and
00:11:13 how the climate agenda was used not to address the climate. Actually, we argued it was used
00:11:20 to stop economic development of resources and i know we're going to get criticized on this mark
00:11:25 but i want to bring this up because people say canada is dirty and we're you know damaging
00:11:31 the environment natural resources canada which is part of our government table report on parliament
00:11:37 every year about energy metrics they have in there a very famous graph at least it's famous to me
00:11:43 that shows emissions, greenhouse gas emissions
00:11:47 per person per year have gone down
00:11:51 every last year from 1990 to today
00:11:56 under every government,
00:11:57 liberal governments and conservative governments,
00:11:59 under Kretchen's government,
00:12:01 under Mulroney's government,
00:12:03 under Trudeau's government.
00:12:04 And yet they say, oh my God,
00:12:06 you know, Canada's getting worse and worse.
00:12:08 That is just not true.
00:12:09 What they're doing is they're playing games
00:12:11 with absolute emissions which go up every year for a very obvious reason yes the population is
00:12:17 growing that's right and no i'm not blaming and before someone goes and throws a cheap shot at me
00:12:21 that i'm blaming immigrants no everybody uses energy everybody and because 70 of the energy
00:12:28 in canada is natural gas and oil which does have carbon the absolute emissions go up because
00:12:34 there's more people every year every year every year that's not the issue it's like saying it is
00:12:39 The real issue is just like we talk about GDP per person, you have to talk about emissions per person, and we have an absolutely strong record.
00:12:49 We have some of the cleanest and highest and most stringent standards in the world for mining and oil and gas and so forth.
00:12:57 So my point is that this was used. We have a chapter on this, how the environmental regulations and restrictions were used to stymie and block the development of our resources, which then ironically drove us into the arms of Donald Trump.
00:13:13 I mean, does everybody listening understand what I just said?
00:13:17 These policies made us more dependent on the United States.
00:13:21 Instead of saying, no, no, no, we've got to diversify and send our potash abroad,
00:13:25 our nuclear energy, our uranium abroad.
00:13:28 We've got to send our oil and gas.
00:13:30 We've got to send our timber abroad.
00:13:31 Oh, no, no, no, no, no.
00:13:32 We want to bet the farm and be completely dependent on the United States.
00:13:36 So along came this guy, Trump, and he thought, hey,
00:13:40 these guys have just shot themselves in the foot like multiple times. 1.00
00:13:43 And I am going to take advantage of the fact that they were so foolish with themselves. 0.99
00:13:48 And he exploited mercilessly our foolishness. 0.98
00:13:53 Is he trying to take us over, in your view?
00:13:55 I mean, there's different arguments about whether that is the case or maybe he wants Alberta.
00:14:00 He says he doesn't one day and then kind of hedges a little bit.
00:14:05 What is, in your view, his endgame as far as Canada goes?
00:14:11 Believe me, we've thought about this.
00:14:12 we've debated it endlessly, I mean, Larry and I and others, and I don't believe he wants to take
00:14:18 us over. I know people say he wants our resources, and I keep reminding everybody the Americans have
00:14:22 been buying our resources for 250 years. This idea that they can only get our resources if
00:14:28 they invade us is simply denied and contradicted by the factual, factual, factual reality. They've
00:14:35 been buying our oil forever. They've been buying our LNG forever. They've been buying our potash
00:14:41 forever. So it is just factually false to say that they want our resources. No, I think what
00:14:47 he, he, there's a list. The US trade rep has an annual report to the Congress. It's not a secret
00:14:53 document. Anybody can download it. And it's been tabled by every president since I believe I've
00:14:58 looked at it all the way back to Ronald Reagan. That's half a century ago. And they list all the
00:15:04 irritants by country. It's alphabetical. So you go down to the Canada part of the chapter of this
00:15:08 report. And they have a long list of irritants there. Supply management, protection of telecom,
00:15:14 not allowing foreign telecom like AT&T and Verizon to come into Canada. That list has been the same
00:15:21 for 50 years. But the issue was past presidents said, we don't like what you're doing to us,
00:15:26 Canada. We think you're being unfair to us. But, and it was always the but, and Barack Obama said
00:15:31 this to the Canadian parliament, we're not going to make a big deal out of it because we like you.
00:15:36 We've had this long relationship with you, so we're not going to, you know, blow the place up.
00:15:43 Along came Trump, and the difference between Trump and past presidents, he agreed with the
00:15:48 same list that all the other presidents had of all the things that we were doing that they didn't
00:15:52 like. Trump didn't create that list. There's all kinds of Canadians who think that he invented
00:15:57 this out of thin air. It's in the U.S. Trade Rep report tabled in the Congress that anybody with
00:16:02 the computer can download anybody just google USTR annual list of trade irritants and kaboom
00:16:08 it's in your computer what he did was he said unlike all the past presidents I don't accept
00:16:15 what you're doing I am going to punish you I'm going to penalize you until you change those
00:16:21 things that we don't like now we can say you shouldn't have done that but that's what he's
00:16:25 doing he's trying to get us to change those things that they it drives them crazy one of them is
00:16:31 supply management. It's right at the top of that list. So we're going to have to make a choice.
00:16:35 Do we want to have an agreement with the largest economy on planet Earth or do we want to compromise
00:16:42 on these things? We argue that the things we're fighting so hard are hurting us. Supply management
00:16:48 exploits low-income Canadians by doubling the price of milk and dairy and poultry. And I did
00:16:54 a paper on supply management. Many papers have been done. OECD show it exploits low-income and
00:17:01 modest income Canadians. We should be cheering at the top of our lungs to get rid of that 0.80
00:17:05 awful legislation, which I've characterized as the most immoral law of the Parliament of Canada
00:17:11 in the last 50 years, because it screws, milks, plucks, and shafts millions of Canadians.
00:17:17 Why do we want to hurt ourselves? I don't understand that. For 8,000 dairy farmers.
00:17:23 Obviously, there are political reasons why all the major companies support supply management.
00:17:27 But do you see the EU pivot as a possible way to begin the process of diversifying or not?
00:17:36 You know, I'm giving a presentation tomorrow afternoon on this very subject.
00:17:41 And I've read all of the major reports in the last two years called China Shock 2.0.
00:17:47 And first off, I agree we want to diversify.
00:17:50 I've said that over and over.
00:17:51 We must diversify.
00:17:52 And secondly, yeah, I mean, I'm not against diversifying to Europe.
00:17:56 I mean, 500 million people, roughly 450, 500 million people.
00:17:59 But what my point that I want to make, Mark, is Europe is in deep trouble, not because
00:18:06 Ian Lee said so.
00:18:08 Christine Lagarde, a very great, famous liberal in Europe, head of the European Central Bank
00:18:14 in January of this year in Reuters magazine said, and I quote Christine Lagarde, Europe
00:18:22 is in a profound existential crisis. It's economy. The Draghi report, which is on the European
00:18:30 Commission website, documents all of their problems. Actually, a lot of their problems
00:18:34 are a lot of Canada's problems, you know, declining innovativeness, declining competitiveness,
00:18:39 declining productivity. And they have, they're about to get annihilated in their high,
00:18:45 their most prestigious sectors, automotive manufacturing, high-end autos, electronics,
00:18:51 sophisticated machine tools. And China is targeting Europe. And the elites behind the
00:18:58 scenes are just terrified of China Shock 2.0. So what I'm trying to say is this,
00:19:04 any form of diversification is good. But if any Canadian thinks that we can pivot and basically
00:19:09 take all or most of our trade with the US and send it over to Europe, they have not studied
00:19:14 Europe. Europe is putting up all kinds of protectionism right now because they're trying
00:19:18 desperately to save the place, desperately to save Europe from being hollowed out like the U.S. was
00:19:26 under China Shock 1.0 that killed all those jobs in Ohio and in the Rust Belt that led to, oh my
00:19:34 goodness, the election of Donald Trump in 2016 because of China Shock 1.0. Now China Shock's
00:19:40 2.0 is coming, and it's going to hit Europe right between the eyeballs. And this is what 0.96
00:19:45 Mario Draghi is saying, for those who say that Ian Lee doesn't know what he's talking about,
00:19:48 go read the Mario Draghi report, former premier of Italy. And he is a friend of Mark Lalonde,
00:19:54 Mark Lalonde, I'm sorry, Mark Carney. You're getting old here. Mark Carney. In fact,
00:20:00 they both have PhDs in economics. Mario Draghi did his PhD in economics at MIT. And he was the
00:20:07 head of the European Central Bank. And that report he did is just filled with chock-a-block 1.00
00:20:12 with graphs and charts and data showing the decline of europe so sure let's diversify to europe but
00:20:19 they're not going to save us that's my that's my closing point they're not going to save us
00:20:25 we've got to save ourselves right the book is called trapped in the shadow of trump's america
00:20:32 and how we escape where do people find your book it's amazon um and by the way we don't get any
00:20:39 royalties so anybody who says i'm trying to make money here that we're getting no royalties well
00:20:43 this was a labor of love it's at amazon publishing so it's already got an isbn number and all that
00:20:48 good stuff and uh there's an eco uh uh what do you call it an electronic copy and a and a paperback
00:20:53 copy and they're not right they're priced very cheaply professor lee thank you lots of
00:20:57 running on the show lots of graphs and charts in this book so anybody who likes data it i've got
00:21:01 we've got the data there fantastic stuff thank you so much for coming on the show
00:21:05 thanks very much mark thank you if you enjoyed the show and appreciate independent journalism
00:21:10 please consider becoming a premier member of juno news by going to junonews.com
00:21:16 backslash straight up it helps us do what we do thank you so much for tuning in we'll see you next