00:00:00U.S. Border Tsar Tom Homan says it's time for America to shift its border security focus north
00:00:11to Canada. Now that America's southern border is secure, Homan describes Canada as a huge
00:00:18national security vulnerability. It's another sign of just how far Canada's relationship with
00:00:24the United States has fallen. Ian Lee is an associate professor at the Sprott Business School
00:00:30at Carleton University. He has co-authored a book, a new one, with Larry O'Brien. It's called
00:00:37Trapped in the Shadow of Trump's America and How We Escape. The book doesn't just diagnose the
00:00:44problem. It offers some solutions, five of them. Professor Lee joins us now from Ottawa. Welcome,
00:00:51sir. Thanks very much, Mark. Thanks for inviting me. Let's talk a little bit about the book and
00:00:57what brought you to writing it. I think it's a very timely one, obviously, and you've
00:01:03written it along with Larry O'Brien at a time when a lot of Canadians are concerned about our
00:01:09relationship with the Americans. Maybe you could talk about how that came to be, the book.
00:01:14Sure. I mean, I've known Larry for quite some time. Full disclosure, I supported him when he
00:01:19he ran for mayor in 2000. Larry is a technology entrepreneur. He's lived in Ottawa all his
00:01:25life like I have. And he started, he was the founder of Callion Technology, which is a
00:01:31very well-known and successful Canadian startup. It's now listed and has been for years on
00:01:36the Toronto Stock Exchange. He ran for mayor, sold out all his shares, so he wasn't in a
00:01:40conflict of interest. And he ran on a, you know, a campaign at the time of bringing taxes
00:01:46under control, you know, a prudent, small c, fiscal conservative government. And that's when
00:01:53I first really got to know him. Over the years, we've stayed in touch. We've talked. And it became
00:01:59increasingly clear that our views were very, very similar, and especially on the whole question of
00:02:05the Trump government. We don't agree with Donald Trump on terrorists. We don't agree with just
00:02:11about anything he's doing. But we didn't agree with people who, many Canadians, who are saying
00:02:16that Trump had caused our problems. And because we just knew that wasn't true. Trump did not cause
00:02:24the $200 billion of interprovincial trade barriers, which have emerged over very long decades
00:02:32by premiers of Canada's provinces. Trump didn't create the dependency that Canada created for
00:02:40itself in betting everything on the U.S. and not diversifying its economy by developing
00:02:48resources and exporting them to other countries around the world.
00:02:51In fact, successive governments expressly tried to restrict the resource development.
00:02:59Mr. Guibo, the former environment minister, said resources should be left in the ground.
00:03:02And so it was this, and I think it was the high watermark was the last 10 years of the Justin Trudeau administration.
00:03:12And so this book is not partisan. It is not about Justin Trudeau. It's not about Donald Trump.
00:03:17What we do is we look at the mistakes of the last 60 years in Canada, at the various mistakes we made that did things like develop the provincial tariff barriers and protectionism that kept out foreign competition and so forth.
00:03:36And we documented these in the first half of the book.
00:03:41That's like going to the doctor and the doctor says, well, I've got to diagnose the patient to see what's wrong.
00:03:46And we produced lots of data, by the way, lots of data sourced from Stats Canada, trend data, showing our productivity going down very dramatically over many years.
00:03:58So it's much lower today relative to the United States.
00:04:01So then we said, OK, what Trump, we didn't deny what Trump is doing.
00:04:05What we said is in the book is Trump exploited our weaknesses.
00:04:09He saw our weaknesses and he mercilessly exploited the weaknesses that we had done to ourselves and that gave him the opportunity to go after us.
00:04:36The OECD ranks us with a very, very poor record compared to other countries with excessive regulation.
00:04:43We used these various statistics from OECD or from StatsCan showing these problems that exist in Canada.
00:04:53And then in the final third of the book, we've got our solutions, which is to address and eliminate these weaknesses to make us independent and able to resist the demands and the pressures from the Trump administration.
00:05:10If you're going back 60 years, then obviously there were agreements made.
00:05:14I mean, I can go back to the free trade agreement that was negotiated between Brian Mulroney and Reagan.
00:05:21And at the time, you'll recall the election that really set the stage for that.
00:05:28Mulroney said, you know, this is going to be great for Canada.
00:05:31We're going to be able to deal with the Americans at a level that will enrich our country.
00:06:35I'm not this isn't a partisan book where we're saying those people that believe that, you know, we should be closing down the economy and restricting it and we shouldn't develop our resources with the mistake we made was in saying we're going to put lots of restrictions around resources.
00:06:51We're going to have the no pipeline bill, the tanker ban bill, and said, even though
00:06:56we've got trillions, literally trillions of dollars of resources, not just oil and
00:07:02gas, we have trees like no tomorrow, timber, we have potash.
00:07:08We have uranium for the nuclear fuel for nuclear reactors.
00:07:13We have fish, we have seafood, we have canola, we have the resources that the world wants.
00:07:18The Germans have said they want it, the Europeans, the Japanese, the South Korean country, Prime Minister, excuse me.
00:07:26And so what we did, the mistake was not in doing the free trade agreement.
00:07:30It was embedding the farm and saying we will basically only deal with the United States when we should have been simultaneously expanding and diversifying, yes, the United States,
00:07:43but we should never have done what we did, which made us so overly dependent on one country.
00:08:11The mistake was closing down our resource sector by people like Mr. Guibo, who said that this was a terrible thing to develop our resources.
00:08:20And so we're criticizing these kinds of decisions over the last 60 years that trapped us and then drove us into the arms of the United States when we should have been diversifying at the same time we did these trade agreements with the U.S.
00:08:35Now, since Prime Minister Carney came into office and he has moved, I would suggest tentatively towards opening up the resource sector more with an MOU, I know you're very well aware of, is this enough?
00:08:55Is he moving fast enough in your view, considering all of our issues with the United States?
00:09:01I mean, you know, it's still going to, even with the MOU, it's still going to take a long
00:09:06time to develop these resources and to build out the kind of infrastructure which you're
00:12:09What they're doing is they're playing games
00:12:11with absolute emissions which go up every year for a very obvious reason yes the population is
00:12:17growing that's right and no i'm not blaming and before someone goes and throws a cheap shot at me
00:12:21that i'm blaming immigrants no everybody uses energy everybody and because 70 of the energy
00:12:28in canada is natural gas and oil which does have carbon the absolute emissions go up because
00:12:34there's more people every year every year every year that's not the issue it's like saying it is
00:12:39The real issue is just like we talk about GDP per person, you have to talk about emissions per person, and we have an absolutely strong record.
00:12:49We have some of the cleanest and highest and most stringent standards in the world for mining and oil and gas and so forth.
00:12:57So my point is that this was used. We have a chapter on this, how the environmental regulations and restrictions were used to stymie and block the development of our resources, which then ironically drove us into the arms of Donald Trump.
00:13:13I mean, does everybody listening understand what I just said?
00:13:17These policies made us more dependent on the United States.
00:13:21Instead of saying, no, no, no, we've got to diversify and send our potash abroad,