Juno News - August 16, 2019


Trudeau’s excuses for #Lavscam keeps changing

Topics
Mentioned
Justin Trudeau blocked access to key information on SNC-Lavalin affair Canada has an ILLEGAL gun problem

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

181.48

Word count

962

Sentence count

57

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Justin Trudeau has been found guilty by the Ethics Commissioner of violating section 9 of the Conflict of Interest Act, but what does that mean for the rest of his political career? And what does it mean for his chances of re-election?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Let's talk about why the latest news in lab scam matters. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
00:00:13 being found guilty by the Ethics Commissioner of violating Section 9 of the Conflict of Interest
00:00:20 Act. Now that is a law. So Justin Trudeau was found to have broken a law. Now this was not a
00:00:26 law that was administered in a criminal court say that he's been found guilty of something that
00:00:30 comes with jail time. The repercussions are pretty minimal. The office is pretty toothless. But he
00:00:36 broke a law nonetheless. If you want to read the Conflict of Interest Act you find it up there on
00:00:42 the Justice Laws page alongside other documents like the Criminal Code. It is a very serious matter.
00:00:49 And the difference now between the conversation we were having months ago is back then a lot of it
00:00:54 was well what would the political consequences be and what's the spin going to be? How will Trudeau
00:01:00 turn the page on this? How will he get a new message out on this? And so forth. Now very different. This
00:01:06 isn't Andrew Scheer calling on him to resign or what have you which is well a valid take I guess to have 0.59
00:01:12 and one that a lot of people are putting forward that's still one politician saying something else
00:01:17 to another politician in a partisan arena. No this is a quasi-judicial body. This is a commissioner,
00:01:22 ethics commissioner saying you broke these rules. So that takes us into new terrain in the first
00:01:29 place and we've learned that the RCMP has said they are keenly watching this and they will do any
00:01:33 actions that are appropriate which is a very interesting statement because a lot of times
00:01:38 they don't comment. Here they're offering well they're offering something and we shall see where
00:01:43 that takes us. Another thing that's changed is how Trudeau is responding to all of this and it's
00:01:50 changed perhaps not in the way it should have. Now you remember when the story first broke way back
00:01:55 in the beginning of February Justin Trudeau said fake news. He sounded like Donald Trump. False. Nothing
00:02:00 to see here. He said this story is false. The allegations in the Globe story this morning
00:02:06 are false. Neither the current nor the previous Attorney General was ever directed by me or by
00:02:15 anyone in my office to take a decision in this matter. Then a few weeks later Jody Wilson-Raybould
00:02:22 gave her damning testimony at committee where she provided documentary evidence. She gave exact quotes.
00:02:28 She gave timelines and dates and Trudeau had to say well okay fine. I mean it happened but it wasn't
00:02:34 improper pressure. We did not break any rules or laws and it was all about jobs. Now that doesn't
00:02:40 even hang anymore. Now he said to say okay well we were found to have broken a law well it was still
00:02:47 all about saving jobs and that leaves a lot of people scratching their heads going well what what
00:02:52 other laws would you be willing to break in this pursuit of saving jobs? Is everything justified
00:02:58 for one policy proposal for one job campaign for one company and so forth? I mean is that really
00:03:05 the right way to focus on all of this? Is that the right thing to say? Trudeau also said some other
00:03:10 things in how he quibbled with the ethics commissioner Mero Dion. I want to read to you
00:03:14 some of his remarks he gave in response after this news broke. He said even though I disagree with some
00:03:20 of his conclusions Mero Dion's conclusions I fully accept this report and take responsibility for
00:03:25 everything that happened. How he actually takes responsibility for it is still unclear. Nothing
00:03:30 has changed but he says where I disagree with the commissioner amongst others is where he says
00:03:35 and takes a strong perspective that any contact with the attorney general on this issue was improper.
00:03:42 What do you mean you disagree with what the ethics commissioner says? This is you're not at you're not like
00:03:50 at the bar talking to a guy and he has one opinion and you have another. This is not Mero Dion saying
00:03:56 something. This is not him voicing an opinion. This is a ruling by the ethics commissioner. It's not really
00:04:03 something for you to to disagree with. I mean you can say you don't like that you've been found guilty like
00:04:09 I'm sure a lot of people who are found guilty by a judge a jury or even you know an ethics commissioner
00:04:14 or someone like that they may not like the outcome but this is not a debate parlor. This isn't two guys talking
00:04:18 at the bar. You can't really legitimately expect people to buy that and the framing of it is very
00:04:25 troubling because Justin Trudeau is almost suggesting that the ethics commissioner is someone who
00:04:31 well it's just some guy on equal or even lesser footing than Justin Trudeau and it's not so much that
00:04:37 it's the ethics commissioner's job to judge Trudeau but that it is Trudeau's job to judge the ethics
00:04:44 commissioner. Is that the case? I don't think so and it's very alarming to see him take that tone. One
00:04:50 would think that maybe he would offer just a little bit of contrition now that the RCMP has come even
00:04:56 closer to knocking on his door vis-a-vis obstruction of justice issues. Instead doubling down tripling down
00:05:02 that not only is there nothing to see here but that one must discredit the entire office of the ethics
00:05:09 commissioner. So the lab scam story has changed quite a lot since when we talked about it last
00:05:14 and it has not changed at all for the better.