Making Sense - Sam Harris - November 19, 2026


#503 — More From Sam: AI Takeover Odds, Podcast Bros, Spidey Sense, and More

#502 — The Rebuke

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

180.75

Word count

3,912

Sentence count

165

Harmful content

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 You're listening to Making Sense with Sam Harris.
00:00:04 This is the free version of the podcast, so you'll only hear the first part of today's
00:00:07 conversation.
00:00:09 If you want the full episode and every episode, you can subscribe at samharris.org.
00:00:14 There are no ads on this show.
00:00:16 It runs entirely on subscriber support.
00:00:18 If you enjoy what we're doing here and find it valuable, please consider subscribing today.
00:00:25 Welcome back to another episode of More from Sam.
00:00:27 Hey, Sam, how are you?
00:00:28 Hey, good to see you.
00:00:30 Good to see you as well.
00:00:30 Been a while.
00:00:31 Yeah, been too long.
00:00:32 We got lots to cover on this episode, so we'll jump right into it.
00:00:35 Paul Cristiano was recently on the Dwarkesh podcast, and he put the odds of an AI takeover
00:00:40 in the next year at about 10% and gives us a 75% chance it all turns out okay in the
00:00:46 end.
00:00:46 How are we just rolling into this with a 25% chance now of catastrophe?
00:00:51 Yeah, well, this is something I've been talking about both on my podcast and those of others.
00:00:56 Just whatever is real, I mean, I don't know what if any of these percentages are remotely plausible, but the fact that the people closest to doing this work that is actually doing it, I mean, from the CEOs on down, not one of them gives us odds of catastrophe that are reassuring, right?
00:01:17 I mean, it's not like you have a radical difference of opinion between, you know, Dario Amadei
00:01:22 and Sam Altman and their chief science officers.
00:01:26 And I mean, they're all giving double-digit percentages of extinction on some level, right?
00:01:33 So it's, again, I don't know what one should believe about this, but the fact that the
00:01:39 people who are doing the work purport to believe this about their own work, right?
00:01:44 I mean, people are alleging that this is a marketing tactic.
00:01:48 That doesn't make any sense.
00:01:49 I mean, think of how much better the marketing would be if, you know, one of these guys,
00:01:54 let's say Dario, could say, I don't know what Sam Altman is talking about over there.
00:01:59 I mean, if he's behaving that recklessly, maybe OpenAI should stop their work.
00:02:03 But over here at Anthropic, we have safety well in hand and we put the chance of anything
00:02:09 going totally haywire at one in a million, right?
00:02:12 I mean, that would be good marketing.
00:02:14 the we might kill your kids line and their kids and extinguish the future is not good marketing
00:02:21 right so i mean this is just a uh it's totally inscrutable to me that you can have 0.94
00:02:26 these people say this about what they're doing and to claim to be in a some kind of suicide race
00:02:33 toward the brink and for the next thing to happen is just confused silence on the part of everyone
00:02:41 I mean, like, how are we not having congressional hearings immediately in response to these kinds of utterances?
00:02:48 And so, I mean, this has been a mystery for, I don't know, at least two years.
00:02:52 But it's increasingly bizarre that words seem to have no consequences.
00:02:58 Yeah, why are we sleepwalking through this?
00:02:59 I mean, I feel like I keep waiting for the adults to stand up.
00:03:04 And then I wonder, wait, are we the adults?
00:03:05 Are they waiting on us?
00:03:06 Who's going to come forward?
00:03:07 And do you think we're just going to roll into this next year without slowing down?
00:03:12 Well, I would imagine the Democrats in Congress are going to do something.
00:03:16 I don't know how much they're going to attempt to pull the brakes and what sort of regulation
00:03:20 conversations are going to happen.
00:03:22 But I got to think they're going to have a different posture than the Republicans have
00:03:26 had and certainly the Trump administration has had.
00:03:29 It's more, you know, what's happened with NVIDIA and the obvious conflicts of interest
00:03:34 there.
00:03:34 You've got Howard Lutnick and his kids directly benefiting from apparently the leakage of our technology to China.
00:03:44 I mean, it's just the level of corruption and incompetence that this administration has advertised about itself is fairly astounding.
00:03:53 So I got to think the Democrats are both going to investigate all of that as they're threatening to and that they'll have a different posture with respect to regulating the industry.
00:04:02 But again, it's not like, I don't even understand how this is controversial. I mean, I know there's some people who think alignment risk is not a thing. I mean, you've got people like Marc Andreessen and Jensen Huang and others who have, I guess, Jan LeCun, I mean, people who are reasonably close to this work who think that all of these fears are overblown and that there's some kind of quasi-religious cult of effective altruists who've gotten into the frontier labs and terrified everybody.
00:04:32 But even if you want to bracket all of this as, you know, who knows what's real, the people closest to doing the work, the people who are deciding whether to release the next version of their model are the ones who are most worried, right?
00:04:47 I mean, it's just, it's every bit as analogous to the Manhattan Project scientists saying, one asked, I don't know, this seems like a pretty good chance we might blow up the world when we run this test at Trinity.
00:04:59 And the fact that they didn't say that, right, they ran calculations that assured them that the risk of igniting the atmosphere was minuscule.
00:05:09 I mean, that is the reason why they went forward.
00:05:11 I mean, there's no way they would have gone forward and run the Trinity test at Alamogordo if they thought the chance of igniting the atmosphere and destroying all life on Earth was 10% or 25%, much less 50%, which is a number you get from some of these guys.
00:05:25 So it's just a very weird world we're living in, which seems to be engineered by what social media and Trumpism have done to our brains, that we're all just spectating upon this much-discussed possible apocalypse, and words seem to have no meaning.
00:05:48 So why do you think they keep pushing forward? I mean, this guy goes on the podcast, and then he goes back to work on Monday.
00:05:54 I have, well, it's what the principals claim is that they're in an arms race and they can't afford to stop because someone's going to get there and it would be much better if they're the ones to step into the end zone first, right?
00:06:06 And each of the frontier labs apparently believes that about themselves and certainly all of American work on this front believes that about China, that China is, if China got there first, that would objectively be bad. 0.86
00:06:21 I agree with that. Paul Cristiano's conversation with Dwarkesh was very interesting. I think that 0.93
00:06:27 people should just go watch that podcast. Again, he's on the worried end of the worried spectrum,
00:06:33 but his specific concerns about how hard it would be to pull the brakes and about what,
00:06:39 you know, just the espionage risk and the catch-up risk from China, like all the details
00:06:44 there are pretty interesting and I haven't heard anyone express them quite that way. So it's worth
00:06:50 listening to him on that podcast did you still worry that if congress can't get around this
00:06:56 that we're going to have to have some minor catastrophe at least before we all get our
00:07:00 heads together get our heads around this well i think that's extremely likely i think we will
00:07:04 have some catastrophes you know whether minor or major but something i mean all of the infrastructure
00:07:12 outages we've had in the last week or so which some people have speculated are not all coincidentally
00:07:19 arriving at the same time, but that there's some kind of coordinated attack from cyber criminals
00:07:26 or cyber terrorism, or that rogue AI has gotten out and is corrupting our systems, or just the
00:07:33 frenzied work that's going on behind the scenes to patch our systems in anticipation of cyber
00:07:40 attacks or rogue AI, that that is, you know, the patching process is causing all these outages.
00:07:46 I don't know what's true there, but on our present course, again, from what I'm hearing these guys say about their own work, it would seem like a miracle if we don't have a series of bad outcomes that get our attention.
00:07:59 how bad is is anybody's guess but i mean the fact that hugging face happened and that we still don't
00:08:05 totally understand what happened you know it's very easy to see that we could have a an event
00:08:10 that's you know 100x worse than hugging face and more or less has the same dynamics of you know ai
00:08:15 getting getting out and doing things that we didn't intend and it becomes very difficult to
00:08:21 put it back in the box are you um in light of the recent events you just talked about are you doing
00:08:26 any uh prepping i mean if uh the power goes out do you have any i haven't uh i mean what are you
00:08:32 doing what is there was just an article in the atlantic on just on what sort of prepping people
00:08:37 recommend i can't say that i have gone down that rabbit hole yet but i don't know that i won't i
00:08:44 mean it's you know being prepared for any kind of um you know public emergency or natural disaster
00:08:50 seems like a prudent thing to be and so i i you know i should do more than i i have you know that
00:08:55 there was a period where I was fairly prepared. I mean, there was one period where I had like
00:08:58 three months of food. I forget when that was, it might've been before COVID, but I'm not currently
00:09:04 in that posture. So I need to rethink that. How many days or weeks do you think you,
00:09:08 three months sounds like a lot. I mean, that's like nuclear disaster. At that point, you might
00:09:13 as well just go down with the ship, maybe a week or two. I've got more than three months worth of
00:09:17 firearms. So I'm prepared for some things. All right. Switching gears. We got rid of
00:09:25 measles in this country 26 years ago, and this week we officially lost that status. Hooray.
00:09:30 The vaccine still works, but fewer people trust it. How do we win that trust back?
00:09:34 Well, I mean, we have a lunatic in charge of our health services. I mean, it's just the fact that
00:09:40 we have RFK Jr. running the show over there and deciding what is science and what is not and what
00:09:48 is prudent and what is, you know, worth rolling the dice on. I mean, it's just, it makes no sense.
00:09:54 the people who brought us this Maha bullshit are culpable for it, right? I mean, measles is bad. 0.99
00:10:01 Things can get a lot worse than measles. But I mean, I just, I think we're now right to be
00:10:05 worried. I mean, ironically, the people who don't trust the government and don't trust the CDC and
00:10:10 don't trust science are the people who edged us here toward the brink. And now it's reasonable
00:10:16 not to trust the government and not to trust the science as it's communicated by people who don't
00:10:22 trust the science. I mean, it's just, we are destroying the credibility of our institutions
00:10:28 by bringing these iconoclastic know-nothings into the institutions themselves and putting
00:10:35 them in charge. You know, it's a disaster. How big a disaster it is, I don't actually know. But
00:10:40 yeah, I mean, when the next, you know, food pyramid comes out and it's all, you know,
00:10:46 wild game, you know, from top to bottom, you know, we'll know that somebody from Joe Rogan's podcast
00:10:53 got control of that part of the FDA. I mean, it's just, it's insane. I mean, like, again,
00:10:59 nobody even seems to want adults in the room at this point. And just how we get back to something
00:11:07 recognizably normal, I think only political changes can accomplish that. And, you know,
00:11:13 I think 2028 is the first moment where that can, you know, where there can really be a radical
00:11:19 change from top to bottom there. But you don't think with the midterms now, the Democrats taking
00:11:24 back Congress, that they'll be able to at least... Well, I think there'll be a lot of noise. There'll
00:11:30 be many investigations. There may be subpoenas. There may even be charges, but I think there'll
00:11:34 be lots of resistance from the Trump administration. But there'll be people who won't answer their
00:11:39 subpoenas, right? There'll be contempt of Congress. There'll be, you know, whatever Trump can do to
00:11:44 stifle any kind of rational process of trying to figure out, you know, how this can never happen
00:11:49 again at the level of our federal government, right? So I think much of the efforts of Democrats
00:11:55 should be very well targeted and, if possible, forward-looking, right? So like the desire for
00:12:01 vengeance, I completely understand, but I think it should be resisted, or at least that shouldn't be
00:12:07 the lens through which most of this is first looked at, right? I mean, let vengeance be a,
00:12:13 and its satisfactions be a byproduct of a far more pragmatic and calculated approach to
00:12:22 figuring out how not to do this again, right? What we've revealed to ourselves is that we don't have
00:12:27 a system of government that is impervious to the rampages of a charismatic psychopath, right? I mean,
00:12:32 that's the world we're living in. We elected a creature of the internet, you know, I mean,
00:12:37 basically the a a you know a comment thread that gone wrong is running our government and has been
00:12:44 you know deranging our politics for something like 10 years and um we have to figure out
00:12:50 how not to let this happen again right so where we had only norms i think we want laws where we
00:12:56 had the wrong laws we want the right ones i'm fully expecting that some people should go to
00:13:03 jail for the level of corruption we've seen. I don't know how high that reaches. I'm also fully
00:13:08 expecting Trump to pardon everyone in sight and for actually no one to be effectively prosecuted.
00:13:15 So it's not, the idea that we're going to see somebody like Stephen Miller in an orange jumpsuit
00:13:22 as much dopamine as that would produce, I just don't think that's likely to happen, whatever
00:13:28 is true of this administration. And I think, again, that the level of corruption has got to be
00:13:34 totally unprecedented in American history. I mean, it's just, we've seen too much just
00:13:40 spill out into public. And you can only imagine what we haven't seen is even worse. But again,
00:13:47 I do think pure retribution as the motive here is going to be, or even if retribution is just
00:13:56 framed as justice. It's going to be easily spun by Republicans, those that have survived the
00:14:02 implosion of the party, as just pure lawfare and cynicism and partisan overreach and Democratic
00:14:08 awfulness and used to rally their base. So I really think the Democrats have to be careful.
00:14:16 I mean, this is a high wire act and they should target things that even the Republican base
00:14:20 want investigated which may be corruption it's certainly the epstein controversy right so like 0.75
00:14:27 give give some red meat to the lunatics over in trumpistan so as to give them uh at least
00:14:34 cognitive dissonance around what's happening with with a change in congress yes i wasn't talking 0.96
00:14:41 about actually going after them as much as slowing down the progress in the wrong direction
00:14:45 but since you brought up epstein oh you're talking you're talking narrowly thinking about ai no no
00:14:50 i was just talking about stopping well i meant around the measles i meant around rfk jr and all
00:14:54 the bad ideas once you know they they they don't need to prosecute him but they could slow down
00:14:58 some of the bad ideas and maybe restore some sanity around all that we i'd be in a perfect
00:15:03 world almost every one of the everyone you could name is probably somebody who should be prosecuted
00:15:10 I mean, I just cannot believe what we have let happen to America's place in the world,
00:15:16 right?
00:15:16 I mean, we have just vandalized our own house.
00:15:20 So this includes, you know, Elon and probably a bunch of other oligarchs, and certainly
00:15:26 everyone in the administration should be investigated. 0.95
00:15:29 I mean, it's just that this is a clown car of corruption. 0.56
00:15:32 I mean, everyone there is a loyal cultist, perhaps with a couple of exceptions, or at 0.88
00:15:39 a couple of minds that are at least split, right? So, I mean, whether Marco Rubio retains the
00:15:44 capacity to be a normal Democratic politician, I guess, remains to be seen. But most of these
00:15:49 other guys and gals are deeply compromised. And so I just think we need to get to the bottom of it,
00:15:57 but we have to be aware that those efforts can be easily spun as every bit as self-serving and
00:16:05 corrupt as the way in which trump himself has weaponized the justice department we can't fall
00:16:11 into that those optics even if they're illegitimate so you mentioned jeffrey epstein i want to talk
00:16:15 about him but but actually given what you just said i want to jump to something else i was looking
00:16:19 at the comments on your recent trigonometry episode and nearly every one of them all all
00:16:24 said the same phrase right those guys love me no tds how i i totally understand how somebody could
00:16:30 have accused you of that at some point but given all that we now know that everybody knows how is
00:16:36 that still a thing like honestly i just don't understand the audience i mean i averted i avert
00:16:43 my eyes almost immediately i spent about five minutes looking to see what's happening and you
00:16:48 know i don't know what's a human and what's a bot they don't really have there's probably no
00:16:53 difference in terms of the actual um legitimacy of the criticism but again my my line here is that
00:17:00 the real TDS is to think that none of this stuff matters, right? The character of the president
00:17:05 doesn't matter. What he's done to our alliances doesn't matter. His glad handing of our enemies
00:17:12 doesn't matter. His corruption doesn't matter. The change in our political culture doesn't matter.
00:17:16 None of it matters, right? That's TDS, right? It's not to be concerned about the unraveling of
00:17:21 America's role in the world or the health of our, the degraded health of our political conversation.
00:17:28 i mean that's that is obviously very important and we've never seen anything like this in our
00:17:35 lifetime yeah all right so i want to get back to epstein you've mentioned a number of times
00:17:39 on this show that jeffrey epstein almost certainly killed himself and now monday's new york times
00:17:44 story seems to have changed your mind can you tell us what happened yeah well i mean i don't
00:17:50 so you've said it a number of times on this podcast it's just you know i'd be surprised
00:17:54 So, you know, I'm allergic to conspiracy theories, as you know, and I think I have, I forget how dismissive I've been about any conspiracy around Epstein killing himself.
00:18:08 I'm sure I've said something disparaging of people who were sure he didn't kill himself.
00:18:12 And it always seemed to be quite plausible that he would kill himself.
00:18:16 I mean, he had every reason to kill himself, given what he was looking at.
00:18:18 At least that's my intuition about it.
00:18:21 I mean, I don't have any inside information.
00:18:22 But, you know, I can imagine somebody who's been successfully prosecuted for sex crimes, in some cases against, you know, underage girls, you know, looking at the rest of his life in prison, you know, it's very easy to see he's just being flung into hellfire on some level.
00:18:42 And so I would not be at all surprised if he killed himself. And the idea that someone allowed him to be murdered, you know, when he's a very high-profile criminal, I mean, it's just, that seemed far-fetched.
00:18:57 I mean, obviously, there were all these kind of anomalies around, you know, the video not working and the guards being asleep or, you know, shopping for stuff on restoration hardware or whatever the final story was.
00:19:07 You know, all of it's a mess.
00:19:09 But again, I think the adage never attribute to malice or evil or whatever or conspiracy, what can be explained by incompetence.
00:19:19 I think that covers a lot.
00:19:20 But then, yeah, the New York Times published a story the other day and casually linked to what they claimed were the full autopsy photos.
00:19:32 And I just as casually clicked that link.
00:19:35 And then I think you have to click another link.
00:19:37 I mean, you're given a directory of folders.
00:19:39 And then I clicked the link to the folder that said whatever, autopsy photos.
00:19:43 Not thinking much of it.
00:19:44 I mean, I don't know what I was expecting to see.
00:19:46 but I can just tell you that anyone who does that will see more of Jeffrey Epstein than perhaps they
00:19:52 want. It's quite a sight. I mean, it's really, I hadn't, you know, I guess I'd seen autopsy photos
00:19:58 to some degree and in some context before, but I mean, all I can say is that the guy clearly had
00:20:04 injuries that, again, I'm not a pathologist. This is not my wheelhouse, but I have a set of
00:20:10 intuitions about what would happen if a person simply hung himself in kind of the orderly manner
00:20:17 of committing suicide. And that's not what the pictures look like to me. And this looks like
00:20:23 a guy who has other injuries to his body. I guess it's possible that somebody beat him up and then
00:20:30 he killed himself, right? I mean, I guess that sequence of events is possible, but no one has
00:20:34 said anything about that. This is, it just does not look like what I would expect a suicide by
00:20:41 hanging to look like. So there's, I mean, again, I'm not a pathologist. I don't have an alternate
00:20:47 explanation, but given that there's so many glitches in the way this was investigated and
00:20:54 the way that the evidence was gathered, I mean, apparently there's, you know, there, there's not
00:20:58 even, you know, photographs of things that you would, you would have thought anyone would
00:21:02 photographed and if it was possible that it was a crime scene i don't know i mean just it just does
00:21:07 not it's it was a surprise to see that and so yeah i have i've got no criticism of anyone who
00:21:12 thinks that he didn't kill himself at this point i mean i you know i was i think far too confident
00:21:17 about that given what i knew at the time so what do you put it at most likely he was killed now
00:21:24 would you say 90 or well i i would put it given what i saw in those photos members can hear the
00:21:31 full conversation by subscribing at samharris.org. Subscribers get a private RSS feed you can use
00:21:37 with your favorite podcast player.